New Culture Forum - December 11, 2020


News From The Front Line In The UK Culture Wars -- Save Our Statues Campaign Update

Julia Hartley-Brewer On The Culture Wars, Media Bias, Covid, Free Speech & Boris's Lame Leadership Peter Hitchens: The Left's Long March Through UK Institutions Is Complete

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

163.55

Word count

4,597

Sentence count

50


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now a few months ago we started the
00:00:18 Save Our Statues campaign you might remember many of you have signed up to it the issue obviously
00:00:24 was very much in the news then. It certainly hasn't gone away. Indeed it's not also based
00:00:29 just in London, it's all around the country. Of course culture warriors really don't sleep
00:00:35 so the assault on our heritage and history has been going on since we first started this
00:00:41 campaign. So today we're going to be looking at what has been good and bad in the months
00:00:46 since then. So to do that I'm joined by Richard Bingley who is the General Secretary of Save
00:00:52 Save Our Statues campaign, Robert Poll, who runs the very successful Save Our Statues
00:00:58 Twitter campaign, and Emma Webb from Civitas.
00:01:03 Thanks very much for joining.
00:01:04 I wanted to start, first of all, Richard, if I may, you actually have just been speaking
00:01:09 to a committee at the Welsh Assembly, haven't you, today?
00:01:14 Yes, the Welsh Assembly have had two, one committee and one
00:01:22 focus group so the committee was filmed this morning and they had a range of contributors
00:01:31 uh including ourselves i think we were the only ones supportive of sort of the status quo
00:01:38 and the cultural realm as it exists and um you know it was quite a pleasant friendly session so
00:01:45 I kind of feel I came out of that able to discuss the issues in a reasonably sensible way
00:01:53 and was grateful for the opportunity. But it does appear slightly different over in Wales.
00:02:00 They were saying the National Assembly has an overall purview of this and will be quite
00:02:07 instrumental in the decision making. They have carried out an audit of all of the statues that
00:02:12 exist in public space in Wales and so it seems to me a little bit different. In the rest of the UK
00:02:20 it's obviously the Town and Country Planning Act and the existing Statues Act and that you go
00:02:26 through local authorities. I'm not quite sure whether they're saying that that is not the case,
00:02:33 whether it's the National Assembly decision or not, but it certainly means that for our members
00:02:38 we should be putting on pressure communicating writing to these national assembly members
00:02:45 equally as we should be talking to the council leaders and local council representatives in
00:02:50 their ward um the main thrust of the concern i think they've just carried out an audit across
00:02:55 wales as i said is around the pexton memorial in carmarthenshire so that that seems to me to be
00:03:02 the one that's um sort of red rated in the wrist if you like uh and then probably sort of the henry
00:03:09 morton um statues up at denby and st asaph suppose in some ways you know it's encouraging that we
00:03:18 were all save our statues to go uh invited to go and and speak there but um robert what is the
00:03:26 situation with Picton that Richard mentioned there? Well, Picton has the monument in
00:03:33 Commardonshire, which is a large obelisk there that they're trying to, or they've consulted
00:03:40 on the future of, to know what to do with it. Picton was the hero of Waterloo, highest
00:03:46 ranked officer who died at Waterloo, but is controversial for some of his actions as a
00:03:53 governor of Trinidad I think and that's one of the most high-profile cases but
00:03:58 yes this report that the audit that Richard mentioned has just been released
00:04:04 and it came out with 209 instances of people who were commemorated to do with
00:04:12 slavery it was the headline although really if you looked just a cursory
00:04:17 glance at the names and the categories they put these people into it wasn't
00:04:21 really much directly to do with slavery at all there were I mean maybe a quarter
00:04:27 of those I think had any kind of connection a very small number actually
00:04:30 with slavery directly others may be benefited from plantation ownership but
00:04:37 actually a large number of these instances were people who they say were
00:04:41 maybe not abolitionists in Parliament people like Nelson who we've discussed
00:04:48 before have been the anti abolitionist letter has now been shown to be a
00:04:53 contemporary forgery so and there's also other names on there there's Wellington
00:04:59 Gladstone isn't Churchill on there too Churchill made an appearance didn't he
00:05:03 Churchill's on there and Gandhi is on there this this was really because they
00:05:09 had a category that included anybody who anybody has ever complained about so
00:05:13 without even investigating it's just these people require investigation but that that nuance is lost
00:05:20 and the headlines about it being about slavery and just the fact their names in the reports
00:05:25 obviously a slur on their character um people are judging them already never mind the further
00:05:32 investigation these sort of lists are being kind of drawn up everywhere aren't they yeah and it's
00:05:38 interesting and richard just sort of alluded to it there they've got this almost a guilt assessment
00:05:44 with the traffic light system with picton is red the worst offender of them all and i think francis
00:05:50 drake is on amber um and so they have been sort of ranked according to their guilt which is
00:05:57 interesting because before the black lives matter situation occurred nobody really knew i think who
00:06:04 Picton was unless they were a sort of history boffin um and i think the the sort of main
00:06:11 characteristic that of these lists and of this ranking um it came out uh recently with the
00:06:19 melville monument of henry dundas in edinburgh uh that a lot of these that the plaques and and
00:06:25 the inclusion of these people within the reports uh are based on complete historical ignorance i
00:06:33 I think it was the biographer of Churchill was described as completely ignorant and just based on absolutely nothing.
00:06:48 And so there's this sort of horrible toxic combination, as Rob's saying, of you have a very, very small minority of people
00:06:56 who are offended in a particular clique,
00:06:59 in the instance of the Dundas Monument,
00:07:02 a small clique of people who are offended by this
00:07:05 and pushing really hard and have managed to sort of
00:07:07 take control of the discussion around it,
00:07:10 combined with, you know, basing accusations on a forgery
00:07:15 with respect to Nelson,
00:07:18 and just generally on complete historical ignorance.
00:07:22 There was also another list that came out,
00:07:24 This is more, not actually statues, but it emanated from one of our institutions,
00:07:30 which even dragged a poet, Ted Hughes, into it.
00:07:34 Who did that list?
00:07:36 So that was a list put together by the British Library.
00:07:40 The British Library, huh.
00:07:41 And so Ted Hughes, he was, and this is actually part of a general trend
00:07:45 that there seems to be of dragging people through the mud
00:07:48 because of the most increasingly abstract relation that they have,
00:07:52 maybe the you know in this instance a relative from 300 years before ted hughes was actually
00:07:57 born somebody from the 1500s and ted hughes was born in the 1930s um and just because this this
00:08:03 ancestor of his had been involved in the london virginia company which had settled north america
00:08:08 um he was then put on this list as being in some way linked to slavery or colonialism and other
00:08:14 people who were on the list include george orwell because his great grandfather his great grandfather
00:08:19 I think owned a plantation in Jamaica even though Orwell was famously an anti-imperialist and all
00:08:24 of that money was gone by the time Orwell was born other people who have been listed by say
00:08:29 like the National Trust people like Coleridge poets like Kipling because of imperial themes
00:08:36 in their work and it just gets increasingly abstract even I think it was was it Oscar Wilde or Byron
00:08:42 um both of them but one of them had a uh it was because they were added to the list because they
00:08:48 had a great it was either a great grandfather or a great great grandfather that had benefited in
00:08:52 some way from um from slavery and an uncle by marriage who had been somehow benefited from
00:09:01 plantation owning something to that effect so just increasingly abstract you know you could
00:09:05 have a relative that from a thousand years ago i can imagine and you'd get dragged through the mud
00:09:10 for it i mean basically isn't it right to say richard that all of it all of you isn't it right
00:09:16 to say really that slavery is just a conduit isn't it slavery is just a way in to the outright
00:09:23 attacking of pretty much all of our culture you're talking about ted hughes and oscar wilde
00:09:31 i mean what what came out of the session this morning with the wales parliament was that the
00:09:36 overriding concern they had was around links to slavery and you know look the reality is
00:09:45 anything towards the west of the country whether it's Wales, Devon, Manchester, Liverpool is going
00:09:52 to have a lot of links if you want to use that word to the worst aspects of transatlantic and
00:10:00 and international trade in the 1700s and 1800s. We simply can't go back and repeal that or argue
00:10:09 the point from that. This has become a war of attrition with people wanting to remove our
00:10:16 statues and cultural heritage and so we have to kind of go about it in a legal way. There's a
00:10:22 very interesting case I came across where it was Basildon Council versus James, 2015,
00:10:32 and that the council had been attempting to change road names on a housing estate, and
00:10:39 it went ahead and did these, it imposed the road to change names, and the local residents
00:10:46 took the council to the magistrates' court, it went up into the High Court, and the High
00:10:51 court decided in the resident's favour because it said the consultation was fraud and it
00:10:57 did not take into account the emotions and upset of local residents and that it did not
00:11:04 adequately provide certain options, credible options. It kind of predetermined the case
00:11:11 before it took the action. So that gives us a lot of hope, that type of case, that if
00:11:19 consultations are not conducted and they are not rolled out fairly and they're not given
00:11:26 proper time scales for working people and for local residents local businesses then we should
00:11:33 and can take this forward to registrates courts and the high court and it actually doesn't cost
00:11:37 a lot of money it is very straightforward to do i suppose people a lot of people kind of get a bit
00:11:45 put off and intimidated when you start talking about courts and things but i mean that is
00:11:49 you're quite right that is the sort of the way isn't it i mean uh what we've also found out this
00:11:54 week on the statues front um is that which i think something you wrote about on twitter actually
00:11:59 uh robert was that in london sadiq khan's new is commission is costing the first phase a quarter
00:12:08 of a million pounds this was revealed in the budgets of city hall and you know this is the
00:12:14 first phase and therefore people are paying we are paying to see the possible removal of our
00:12:22 heritage aren't we we are yes and um i think up and down the country you and you hear about
00:12:28 the councils generally say people are not being paid directly perhaps or people who are coming
00:12:34 onto these committees but that doesn't mean there's not a cost as this clearly shows in
00:12:38 london uh there's a lot of consultants being brought in and researchers as well and workshops
00:12:44 and organisation. There's also opportunity cost of what these people could be doing
00:12:49 with their time and resources. Otherwise, again, councillors have real problems to solve
00:12:55 up and down the country. But yeah, we are ultimately putting the bill.
00:13:00 Do you think, I mean, we're talking about the cultural, as we said before, statues are
00:13:05 emblematic of it, the very particular part of it. But over the past, say, month, what
00:13:11 What has struck you as being a bit of a low or a new blow that's been struck in the cultural
00:13:21 war?
00:13:22 I think what I find most disturbing is that over the last month or so, it seems
00:13:28 to become increasingly clear that the source of this, in addition to all of the fire and
00:13:36 uproar around the Black Lives Matter and now that that has trailed away what we're sort of seeing
00:13:41 as it's sort of the curtain has been pulled back is that there is a huge gulf in the way that people
00:13:49 view art, public art and culture in general. I mean we've been talking about poets and literature
00:13:54 and as you say the statues are emblematic of that and it seems that you know this this gulf has
00:14:01 appeared between you know our way of thinking about statues and what statues are for and the
00:14:06 of historical element and then what is sort of embodied in you know the mary walson craft um
00:14:12 statue with this this idea that you know public art there was an article that was written about
00:14:18 this and i think you tweeted about it rob as well that this um idea that the that statues need to
00:14:25 sort of be forward-looking and inoffensive and universal and not particular because future
00:14:30 genera it has to be something that you know embodies everyone and all future generations
00:14:34 and is completely inclusive and then you end up with these horrible blob statues that are
00:14:38 absolutely meaningless and have no historical context and it brings us back to what we've been
00:14:42 discussing you know since june which is this sort of desire to sort of flatten the public space to
00:14:48 year zero and just to get rid of any kind of historical perspective from it whatsoever by
00:14:53 making these statues sort of inoffensive and that seems to be sort of summed up in um the art reviews
00:15:00 power 100 list this year that they put i think it's called the power 100 list and they've had
00:15:06 number one in that list um which is sort of ranked sort of the art moments of the year or
00:15:11 the those responsible for it and number one in the list is black lives matter for their
00:15:15 as they said um excel i think they said something like accelerating change within the art world
00:15:20 because of their iconoclasm so i think that what we're seeing is a kind of amongst the art elite
00:15:25 as well as you know the the political elite as we've seen in so many other areas of public life
00:15:31 there's this completely different view of the purpose of of art in the public space that just
00:15:37 jars completely with the views of normal patriotic brits and even not not patriotic brits and i think
00:15:45 that you know we saw that with the 25 mps who challenged the national trust over what they've
00:15:51 been doing with their own order of various different people and and those
00:15:57 MPs who are really standing up for normal people's voices and I think what
00:16:00 what really have we've seen is that this shift is probably far more
00:16:04 fundamental and and on a basic level than we previously thought I think so I
00:16:09 think if you can say there's been one thing I would say that's been good about
00:16:12 what's happened over the past few months is that the enemy for want of a better
00:16:16 word is in plain view would you say that you know we now before people could
00:16:21 dismiss what we talk about as somehow being oh come on you're being paranoid
00:16:25 but it's been quite clear hasn't it that the actual names of the people the
00:16:31 curators the directors of these things they're very very much in plain view I
00:16:36 think to an extent definitely and when it comes to the institutions perhaps but
00:16:40 there's again still the councils so stuff that doesn't really get the news
00:16:45 as much as pulling down statues does but there's still that threat to them so I
00:16:50 I would say one of the biggest concerns in terms of the trend recently is probably around plaques and the addition of plaques to statues, which sounds like quite an inoffensive compromise to some people.
00:17:03 But I think it's part of the double-edged sword, really, because I think some of the councils are realising now that removing statues is actually very hard, partly because they have to go through planning, which we obviously try and get lots of objections to and make life hard for them to do that.
00:17:19 so I think they're now thinking the easier route is to get these plaques but who decides what goes
00:17:25 on them as we've said before you know it's never really a balanced fair view of history
00:17:28 it's quite a distortion. I think the plaques would actually irritate me almost even more
00:17:34 because they're kind of going they're telling you what you know you you're meant to think I mean
00:17:39 would you would you say that's true Richard I mean are you a plaque man or not?
00:17:43 I like plaques but it's not the point you know there's no point of removing a fantastic
00:17:52 statue of drape or wellington and then replacing it with a tiny plaque that's probably been
00:18:00 contextualized in the corner you know so so it's all part of the same agenda which is
00:18:07 to delete ash care heritage um i think what's been depressing for me over this year really
00:18:19 um or the lack of engagement of local people i mean this has been kind of a media air war
00:18:26 you know i've done a committee this morning uh we've saved our statues and the welsh assembly
00:18:32 but at no point have i seen local residents involved yeah you know when when people are
00:18:37 talking of removing an obelisk that's been uh part of that community furniture for
00:18:44 dozens of years where people have walked past it traders have decided to set shops up near it
00:18:50 there's been no deliberate engagement by authorities and we know why that is because
00:18:57 Because when Leeds Council were forced to do a review, they got the answer back.
00:19:02 96% of people backed the status quo and loved their statues and loved that statue of Queen
00:19:09 Victoria and Hyde Park.
00:19:11 So whenever these authorities go out there and ask ordinary voters, ordinary people,
00:19:17 they will get a resounding vote of confidence in these beautiful statues and our exhilarating
00:19:22 history.
00:19:23 it's why they don't do it, it's why they speak to
00:19:25 subject matter experts
00:19:27 I think it's a very
00:19:29 important point because it's actually what you're
00:19:31 talking about as well, is that this huge
00:19:33 gap, you know, because
00:19:35 as you've shown as well, you know, when
00:19:37 people are asked, it's
00:19:39 a minuscule amount of people
00:19:41 who actually think we
00:19:43 should even worry about doing anything
00:19:45 with our statues, and it's an even smaller
00:19:47 amount who want them removed from what
00:19:49 I can gather, isn't that right? Yeah, and they don't seem to
00:19:51 have been some comparisons made between the way that they've been dealing with similar figures
00:19:57 in Canada, in Toronto, and their method of dealing with this and their community engagement and so on,
00:20:04 you know, they have an actual methodology to it, whereas here there tends to be just this rush,
00:20:10 and this is what happened with the Dundas statue, that, you know, they were going about it with a
00:20:14 relatively balanced committee, and then Black Lives Matter happened, and all of the sort of
00:20:20 pro-Dundas people were taken out and they did this plaque that was and I think this is what the
00:20:25 issue is that you know I think that putting a plaque for contextualization is preferable to
00:20:30 removing a statue but the issue is that they put this plaque on that said that you know however
00:20:36 many people that Dundas had been responsible for enslaving and that and this is something that's
00:20:43 disputed by historians so the things that they're putting on the plaques are disputed history and
00:20:47 there's no sense of nuance and it's sort of creating a fictitious within the local area
00:20:54 sort of fictitious understanding almost a mythic understanding of that location's relationship with
00:21:01 slavery or colonialism and so I think you know with the renaming of street names that that road
00:21:09 in Southall that they wanted to rename after Guru Nanak the what was it I think it was something
00:21:16 like 16 people out of 16 households out of 340 odd had replied and only seven of them wanted to
00:21:24 actually rename the road but that was i think rob you said that it was two percent um of the people
00:21:30 who should have been consulted were in favor of of this being renamed and yet they're going to go
00:21:34 ahead with it anyway so it's it's the in what on the one hand is a case of just simply not having
00:21:40 a good methodology for figuring out what people actually want because clearly there is a desire
00:21:45 to not do what people want but to as it seems to be the trend to educate the public into having the
00:21:52 correct opinions and they're sort of afraid to find out what they actually do believe and won't
00:21:56 go with what they what they want anyway and there's that on the one side and then on the other
00:22:01 side you know when they do air their views there's this tendency to go with the minority opinion
00:22:06 anyway yes either educate people or educate themselves you know this is the other thing
00:22:13 You know, all of our institutions now coming out with these particular pledges.
00:22:17 I saw one a lot perhaps, for example, recently, you know, it's all about we've got to educate ourselves.
00:22:23 And this is just very, very depressing.
00:22:26 I want to ask you, you know, finally to, you know, because it's not all bad news.
00:22:31 I want to hear about some good things that have been happening.
00:22:34 I mean, I would suggest, and it's a very bittersweet thing, this, that for me, it was the news that the National Trust has seen a massive fall in their revenue, simply because people have been cancelling.
00:22:49 And it seems to me that one of the few ways you can make a difference is actually by taking money away.
00:22:56 Go broke, go broke.
00:22:56 you know so that that would to me that was actually a good sign because sure enough they
00:23:01 then did come out and sort of start making noises about maybe we've done something wrong and all the
00:23:06 rest of what would you say has been good news what's good news on for example say like the
00:23:12 guy statue yeah that seems to have been a positive development this is thomas guy
00:23:18 thomas guy and sir robert clayton as well who between them built guys hospital and then
00:23:23 St Thomas's Hospital in London so they had submitted planning applications to
00:23:29 remove these because they're listed we helped generate 600 complaints each or
00:23:36 objections to the planning for each of these and now the result is or we hope
00:23:42 we contributed to this result is that they have withdrawn those applications
00:23:45 to remove the statues but without wanting to be premature I suppose it
00:23:51 doesn't mean the statues are safe they have said the hospital trust has said
00:23:54 that they will now do further research and consultation to come back with
00:23:59 another proposal which sounds like it may be a plaque again yeah the way they're
00:24:04 going so yeah we can't yet rest rest easy on it but it's positive it sounds
00:24:12 like they may hopefully not be taken down although in the meantime they're
00:24:16 still boxed up it's still boxed up for no reason 70 days or so now so now
00:24:23 hopefully that they've withdrawn the application and said as well that the
00:24:26 risk to the statues apparently there was is now significantly reduced they
00:24:32 should be unboxed yeah for people to enjoy Richard what about you what what
00:24:38 kind of have you seen anything on you know in the past few months that you
00:24:43 think he's actually been on our side of things a good thing um i have to say the central government
00:24:51 has been vocally very very supportive so again last week we saw a statement from the
00:24:57 equalities minister who was criticizing um moves to remove our cultural heritage and and and she
00:25:05 was sort of dismissing black lives matter as more as being sort of troublemakers as opposed to being
00:25:11 positively sort of contributing to any debate so you know that that with the
00:25:17 cultural secretary a few weeks ago talking about linking funding to protecting
00:25:23 and preserving a good things pretty Patel and then the mob behavior over the
00:25:30 summer so did Bryce Johnson I guess what to nuance that what we need now is
00:25:36 uh material support in terms of legislation and policing resources
00:25:41 to ensure that our public space is preserved and protected you know we
00:25:45 cannot keep seeing our very very precious memorials
00:25:49 including the sanataph being graffitied damaged uh
00:25:54 humbled and humiliated frankly and and the emotional damage that causes
00:25:59 we can't keep seeing that we see solid system
00:26:03 legal action and if it means protecting them with physical security you know cctv and security
00:26:11 companies then i think we need to invest in that as opposed to having these ridiculous reviews that
00:26:16 sleep can't quite how about you what do you what have you found i've sort of follows on from um
00:26:23 richard's point which is that not only is central government you know there are some good noises
00:26:28 coming from um from from you know the front bench but also from surprisingly uh within some of the
00:26:37 unexpected institutions so um i think for me probably the highlight is baroness stole chair
00:26:43 of the charity commission condemning the national trust for what they've been doing because and and
00:26:49 and what she said actually is a much broader point and sends a really good strong healthy message i
00:26:55 think to other charities which is a bit you know if you go go won't go broke but saying you know
00:27:01 don't involve yourself in the culture wars because you know charities you know that's not what
00:27:06 they're for your charity should be in some instances an escape from politicization and
00:27:13 that the organizations like the National Trust shouldn't be involving themselves in this way
00:27:17 and I think that and that sends a very strong message and I reckon that and you know that a
00:27:23 number of organisations museums and so on that do have charitable status will have to listen to the
00:27:30 chair of the charity commission so I think that's probably a bit of a sort of light shining in the
00:27:35 darkness well I mean we need them don't we we need encouragement and people need encouragement all
00:27:41 over the country but there are things moving but it's going to be a long it's going to be a long
00:27:45 battle isn't it this I mean Richard has said it before Richard thank you very much for joining us
00:27:50 from the West Country thank you very much Robert thanks Emma that's it for the
00:27:55 update this week on save our statues do please subscribe won't you and we shall
00:28:01 see you again on counterculture soon thank you