New Culture Forum - December 07, 2020


Julia Hartley-Brewer On The Culture Wars, Media Bias, Covid, Free Speech & Boris's Lame Leadership

Were Trump & Cummings The Last Hope For A UK & US Conservative Pushback In The Culture Wars? News From The Front Line In The UK Culture Wars -- Save Our Statues Campaign Update

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

196.3

Word count

6,612

Sentence count

127


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittall.
00:00:24 now before I introduce my special guest today just a little message here we're
00:00:31 on about 9.5 million views now on the channel and over 90,000 subscribers but
00:00:38 if you want to give us a Christmas present which we would like very much
00:00:41 we'd like to get to a hundred thousand subscribers and the way to do that is
00:00:45 very very simple you just press on the subscription button and it's free and
00:00:49 then after that make sure that you press on the notifications because that way
00:00:53 you get the shows as they come up so please do that and make it a very happy Christmas for us
00:00:59 thanks now my guest today it was one of the very first on the show Julia Hartley-Burer is known to
00:01:06 you as the host of Talk Radio's breakfast show but of course she's been a journalist for many
00:01:12 many years and was on such shows as Have I Got News For You and indeed Question Time thank you
00:01:18 for coming very much I'm not sure I like the many many years oh many years just many just many
00:01:23 you started on on the um east london advertising i did my first local paper after journalism
00:01:29 training school yeah i was east london advertising bestmill green yeah but people
00:01:34 don't really do that so much now do you no i was yeah very much in favor of getting proper training
00:01:39 yeah i used to cover local council committees and then go to the fire station and the police
00:01:44 station the ambulance station to go and get stories and knock on doors and the tower blocks
00:01:48 yeah absolutely proper training richard madeley also uh trained there oh really yeah oh yes lots
00:01:54 of just very highly distinguished journalists it was really really really good days actually really
00:01:59 enjoyed that you've come actually uh straight from doing your show thank you uh it's doing
00:02:05 incredibly well isn't it we are doing very well our we can only see obviously if i've got a formal
00:02:10 listener they do these ridiculous rage hours where people sort of fill out a booklet about what they
00:02:14 they listen to but we can only see what's online but yeah our trajectory is basically doing that
00:02:19 and only this morning we go on video as well and this morning between eight and nine this morning
00:02:25 we had 48,000 people watching on Facebook not all the hundreds of thousands of listeners but 48,000
00:02:30 people watching the show because we do it it's basically all multimedia and very 21st century
00:02:35 now but yeah a lot of people are tuning in we are pretty much the only media organization right now
00:02:41 in the country who were questioning the lockdown and questioning a lot of the madness going on so
00:02:46 i think a lot of people are desperate just to get some sensible debate about the real facts and the
00:02:50 and the real arguments you see this is interesting because you say you're the only people really
00:02:54 questioning it which i think is right but your attitude if i if i'm right tell me if i'm wrong
00:03:00 but your attitude has somewhat changed hasn't it it's hardened over what six months yeah i'm yeah
00:03:05 i'm i'm old-fashioned when the facts change i change my mind i was uh certainly in favor of
00:03:10 lockdown early on it seemed the argument that were given you know by the prime minister and
00:03:14 chief medical officer chief scientific advisor sage they must know what they're doing right
00:03:19 got this terrible disease it's killing people body bags everywhere in italy and we saw what
00:03:23 happened in wuhan um it's the only way to deal with it we need to flatten the curve we're going
00:03:27 to have overwhelmed hospital we've got time to build everything up to cope to make sure people
00:03:31 don't get miss out on treatment if they've got the disease fine i already had covid i had i
00:03:36 I caught it on the 16th of March, so before we went into the formal lockdown
00:03:39 and was ill for three weeks at home with that.
00:03:42 Not very seriously, but certainly, I mean, knocked me for six.
00:03:45 And lots of my family had it. We all caught it at the same event.
00:03:49 So, yeah, I was fully signed up to it.
00:03:51 Very early on, though, I started questioning whether this was a good idea
00:03:54 and talking to people like Professor Carol Sikora
00:03:56 about the knock-on effects of a lockdown, saving COVID lives,
00:04:01 but costing cancer lives, heart disease and other people,
00:04:04 people not taking their children to A&E because they were so fearful of the disease and then
00:04:08 seeing the economic effects so within certainly a month or so I was thinking well hold on a minute
00:04:13 three-week lockdown it's turning into much longer lockdown and certainly by late spring early summer
00:04:19 I was saying hold on the cost of this is far too great and at that point I think the government
00:04:24 had got locked in to the lockdown and and the public had the British public signed up fully
00:04:30 to this idea and um ever since then yeah i mean totally opposed to the tears totally opposed to
00:04:35 the uh the lockdown two um and we'll be opposed to lockdown three which i think we're inevitably
00:04:41 going to be in because boris johnson said we won't have one and that's pretty much a guarantee
00:04:45 meaning we will come january because when we had last week you know this thing the new tears being
00:04:50 announced and everything i mean as you say it was effectively a lockdown by any other than 99 of us
00:04:55 I mean, if you can't have another household in your home,
00:05:00 if you can't go and sort of say hello to somebody
00:05:03 and meet them for a coffee or a cup of tea or a pint in a public place,
00:05:09 I'm saying that is a lockdown.
00:05:10 People being told to work from home,
00:05:12 yeah, you're allowed to get your hair cut,
00:05:13 you're allowed to go to a non-essential shop, well, go to the gym.
00:05:17 I mean, why weren't, if it's safe now, why wasn't it safe then?
00:05:21 It's either safe or it's not.
00:05:23 So which is it?
00:05:24 um this is a lockdown in all but name it's lockdown number three yeah how do you feel about
00:05:30 the way that generally people have reacted to it judo i mean because you know i know this is a very
00:05:35 wide question but you should take the take the british right you know this is okay a cliche but
00:05:41 nevertheless i always sort of felt that the british had this kind of truculent you're not
00:05:47 gonna you know boss me around yeah particularly about their liberties but it doesn't appear to
00:05:52 have been that way? No, I think it's fascinating how much we have behaved as many other European
00:06:00 countries have behaved. And one of the reasons why, for instance, we were Brexiteers, I think,
00:06:03 is because we do have a very different history. We haven't lived under totalitarianism. We haven't
00:06:08 lived under fascism, under police states. Our police are largely unarmed. It's policing by
00:06:14 consent. It's a very different, not just long term, but very, you know, our living history
00:06:20 is very different in terms of our relationship as individuals with the government and with the
00:06:24 police. So I was encouraged in the first lockdown that actually there was such a community spirit.
00:06:32 I was out there clapping, you know, for carers and felt quite, you know, quite moved by this
00:06:37 community spirit, this sense that we were all in it together and, you know, loved, for instance,
00:06:41 you know, the Rishi Sunak announcing all this help for businesses and things. I really felt,
00:06:45 wow you know this is the country coming together after all the horrors of brexit and not not brexit
00:06:51 but of the battles over brexit and i really felt that you know that this was like a new a new dawn
00:06:57 for us and and and this was this was a terrible thing that was happening that was going to have
00:07:02 good outcomes and then i realized that actually this this wasn't us coming together and doing
00:07:07 the right thing this was us sort of being sheep this were people being herded um even when the
00:07:14 evidence was clear that it was wrong and that the lockdown was doing more damage than it was doing
00:07:18 good. People were not only desperate to be scared, they were desperate to be told what to do. And
00:07:25 crucially, they were desperate for other people to be told what to do. So you awful, awful people
00:07:30 going out to a restaurant, how dare you kill a granny? You know, how are you killing a granny
00:07:34 by going to a restaurant sitting metres away from someone else outdoors, for goodness sake?
00:07:38 people it seemed were desperate to have more restrictions on not just theirs but other
00:07:45 people's lives and we can see this if we're going to trust the polling at all and I've really got
00:07:49 question marks about a lot of it that the people are really keen to carry on a lot of the restrictions
00:07:54 on our lives even after we've got a vaccine I mean that is terrifying and I feel that we are
00:08:02 as a nation we're not you or me I think and hopefully a lot not people watching this right
00:08:06 now are listening to my radio show we're willing to give away the freedoms for which our forefathers
00:08:13 quite literally laid down their lives what was the point of fighting nazi germany what was the
00:08:20 point of what was the point of the chartist what was the point of of women and fighting you know
00:08:25 the suffragettes to fight for their what was the point of it all if we are just going to give away
00:08:30 our freedoms at the drop of a hat but do you think that one of the reasons might be that
00:08:35 a lot of people maybe particularly young people actually just simply don't know about those
00:08:40 freedoms yeah they don't understand they don't even know what they're meant to be protecting
00:08:43 no indeed i mean people are going to talk about human rights everyone's obsessed with human rights
00:08:47 forgetting these these really sort of fundamental things not i'm not you know some of the human
00:08:51 rights people talk about are not really they're you know they're state-given rights we're talking
00:08:55 about really fundamental things like the right to protest the right to freedom of speech the right
00:09:00 the right to you know be with your family to be with your friends to to the right to work
00:09:06 you know really fundamental stuff um yeah i i think a lot of people don't understand how
00:09:11 important these things are and and how once you give them away and i'm not a conspiracy theorist
00:09:17 i don't come from that sort of background i don't view the state as a sinister body um well i didn't
00:09:23 until until more recently um once you give those rights away it's it's often very very hard to get
00:09:29 them back i think the next battle is going to be demanding dim i mean demanding those rights back
00:09:37 every single one of those rights we've given away in this emergency legislation i want every last
00:09:42 one of those back and i don't want them ever to be taken away again you see there there's this
00:09:47 view around that somehow or other april next year is when everything's off well if we're good
00:09:53 peter if we're good if we're good i mean the whole language of it is very much about we are
00:09:58 going to be allowed at christmas isn't it you say that you know we need to get these liberties back
00:10:06 what generally do you think julia's going to be the way britain looks after this i mean i know
00:10:11 that's a massive question but have you got any kind of gut feelings about it i i feel very
00:10:17 depressed actually about um god i try and look on the bright side i really do but um and then the
00:10:23 route out of here okay if it's the vaccine mass testing i don't think those actually are necessarily
00:10:27 the roots out of here because I think the root out of where we are right now isn't any of those
00:10:32 things it is actually it's a mindset it is I know I'm not calling for non-compliance with the law
00:10:37 I can't I'm a broadcaster I'm off com you know controlled um I can't do that I'm I'm fundamentally
00:10:44 someone who you know I'm a I'm a law-abiding citizen I I think it's important that we do all
00:10:48 whether the police officers or whether there's a camera on you you should do the right thing
00:10:52 but I think there needs to be a point where the British public say up with this we will not put
00:10:58 anymore I'm mad as hell I'm not going to take it anymore any version of that where they just say
00:11:04 no the evidence you're giving us of why we have to be this restriction or that restriction that
00:11:09 is not good enough we will not comply with laws which make no sense which take away fundamental
00:11:17 freedoms without being justified that emergency legislation I mean thank goodness we had the
00:11:21 the six-month sunset clause on it, thanks to people like David Davis. But again, it goes all
00:11:26 the way through to March again. First time round, that was emergency legislation, not having proper
00:11:32 debates in Parliament because we were in an emergency. We're not in an emergency. We're not
00:11:36 even in statistically worrying excess mortality right now, and yet we're told we have to give up
00:11:42 all these freedoms. I think the British public are going to have to have a really big wake-up call,
00:11:46 and I think they are going to have to realise
00:11:48 that a lot of the time you cannot trust
00:11:50 a lot of what we are being told from on high
00:11:53 and that the experts aren't very expert at all
00:11:57 and they're not being honest.
00:11:58 I think an awful lot is going to come out
00:11:59 in the public inquiry wash.
00:12:02 I think there are an awful lot of people
00:12:04 who are going to be named and shamed in the future.
00:12:08 I think people like me and others,
00:12:13 the MPs fighting against these measures,
00:12:15 I think history will look kindly on us.
00:12:19 I think it's going to be a wake-up call.
00:12:22 I think the British public need to literally one day wake up and go,
00:12:25 this is insane and we need to stop the madness.
00:12:28 I don't think any amount of testing or vaccines being rolled out
00:12:32 or anything else is going to provide enough of a wake-up call.
00:12:35 I think there will always be an excuse for the Sky News
00:12:38 and the BBC News at 6pm to say,
00:12:40 another two people have died of COVID, time to go back in your homes.
00:12:45 Have you been surprised by the way the media has handled it on the whole?
00:12:50 I mean, it just seems to me...
00:12:52 I spend every single press conference tweeting madly,
00:12:55 could one journalist please ask Prime Minister Griswitty or Patrick Vance
00:12:59 or anyone else who's giving that press conference
00:13:01 what the evidence is for the statement they are making?
00:13:05 Only this morning, I had Robert Jenrick on my show, the Housing Secretary.
00:13:09 And, again, people just give this, they make statements, as does Boris Johnson constantly, which are simply not backed up by the facts, not opinion facts.
00:13:20 They will quote things like we saw Boris Johnson talking about that 4,000 a day example scenario.
00:13:25 We have Patrick Vallance, the, you know, 50,000 a day infections.
00:13:29 None of these things ever likely to happen.
00:13:31 They knew that at the point they said that they weren't likely to happen.
00:13:34 But even when they talk about the past, mass testing is the reason why Liverpool was able to escape tier three,
00:13:40 because they had mass testing and that's what brought infections down.
00:13:44 There is clear evidence from government's own data showing that actually it was early October
00:13:50 when the peak of infections happened in Liverpool.
00:13:54 It plummeted, I mean, absolutely plummeted by half down, very, very, very steeply for the months
00:14:00 and before they brought in mass testing.
00:14:02 and indeed after mass testing was brought in, it plateaued.
00:14:05 It stopped going down for a bit, for goodness sake.
00:14:09 So unless the mass testers brought in a time machine
00:14:13 and went back and somehow fixed infection rates for the month beforehand,
00:14:16 it is a physical impossibility for mass testing to have been responsible for that.
00:14:20 And yet they make these statements and no one challenges them on them.
00:14:25 I think the media has been shocking.
00:14:26 Whenever the first question, it goes to the BBC or Sky,
00:14:29 the first question is always first question all 20 questions all the same lines oh are you sure
00:14:35 prime minister is it safe to come out of lockdown oh are you sure these restrictions are tight
00:14:39 enough what about all the people dying of covid my prime minister they're obsessed with this stuff
00:14:45 and that's not that it's not that deaths from covid don't matter of course they do i know people
00:14:49 myself who have died of covid um but it's about a proportionate response in 2018 we had a mass
00:14:58 flu outbreak 2000 we lost like 45,000 excess lives to a flu outbreak I was a
00:15:04 political editor of a national newspaper then I don't even recall writing about
00:15:08 that let alone the country being in lockdown the fact that there is no one
00:15:12 in the mainstream media asking what is your evidence why are you brought in a
00:15:17 policy without any evidence and and asking that again and again and again
00:15:24 until the evidence is produced and when the evidence is produced checking and
00:15:27 questioning the evidence this is this is journalism 101 but also it's parliament isn't it you you
00:15:33 mentioned that you were a political editor with the express and uh one thing that's been very
00:15:39 marked is the way in which parliament is entirely sidelined and indeed no one's actually seemed to
00:15:46 be that worried about it no and again we could understand in the early stages difficult people
00:15:52 were all locked up at home um but even when parliament's been back with a lot of people in
00:15:57 the chamber it there's only it's only really been the uh the the coveted group of tory backbench
00:16:02 mps who have actually been standing up to it and that's now up to 70 mps and and they're the ones
00:16:07 saying we need to see the evidence what amazes me is how many other mps say well yeah we need
00:16:11 to see the evidence and when the evidence isn't produced or is produced and doesn't back up what
00:16:15 the government says they need to do um they still allow it to happen so we had that 10 pm curfew
00:16:21 on pubs now extended to 11 p.m. for many areas that are allowed to have pubs open.
00:16:28 It's not that the evidence isn't very strong. There is no evidence whatsoever that a pub serving
00:16:33 alcohol without a substantial meal or a pub serving alcohol at one minute past 10 as opposed to 9.59
00:16:39 or people leaving at 11 or 10 makes any difference whatsoever. And yet these restrictions have been
00:16:45 allowed. If you are taking away fundamental freedoms from people, and yes, you know what,
00:16:50 going to have a drink in a pub is a fundamental bloody freedom for a lot of people it's actually
00:16:54 the only joy a lot of people have in their lives necessity for some of us yes um but if you are
00:16:59 taking and and at that point also the livelihoods of the people who work in the hospitality industry
00:17:03 the third biggest employer in this country by the way small point worth making um if you are taking
00:17:08 you should provide a bloody good reason for it and they haven't and the idea that we should have
00:17:13 policy made without any evidence without any justification and that our elected representatives
00:17:19 should just nod along and say okay i think it's shocking labor party i mean keir starmer saying
00:17:24 oh you know these measures should happen they whatever the measure is say it should be sooner
00:17:29 longer deeper harder more severe um there is no measure that is not tough enough for them but of
00:17:37 course the labor party is safe in the knowledge that you can always blame the government for
00:17:40 every covert death you can blame the government government for every non-covered death of which
00:17:45 there will be tens of thousands more of younger people who will die as a result also you get to
00:17:49 blame the government for all the economic fallout all the jobs lost all the businesses that close
00:17:54 and they will be the ones reaping the benefits come 2024 so they're on to an absolute winner
00:18:00 and the fact that the tory mps are going along with this insanity i mean they should do it on a
00:18:05 moral ground and on a philosophical ground but they should also be doing it just from pure
00:18:08 self-interest they should be questioning everything the government is saying on this
00:18:13 showed you we obviously concentrate mostly on kind of cultural matters I mean during this whole
00:18:18 period as well hugely important things have been going on which you do talk about on your show
00:18:24 again in the mainstream media not that much but there have been sort of various attacks or various
00:18:31 proposals for put forward on for example free speech yeah I wanted to start by asking you
00:18:37 first of all uh Darren Grimes for example does show a bit like this um we had that shocking
00:18:43 situation where he was hauled in or was going to be hauled in by the Met yeah for something that
00:18:48 somebody said David Starkey said on his show now you know you're a journalist and a broadcaster
00:18:55 these these things are extraordinary that they're sort of happening um and one again I'm not a
00:19:00 conspiracy theorist but it seems to me that people are being sort of materially tightened up if you
00:19:05 like yeah but then these psychological restrictions are coming on but this was happening long before
00:19:11 lockdown and covid yes but perhaps it's more exposed now yeah i mean yeah a young young man
00:19:16 being being told you know told he's going to be hauled in for a police interview under caution
00:19:21 uh because of something someone else said that i don't agree with david starkey on an awful lot of
00:19:26 things um i don't think he's a particularly nice person i don't think he should lose all of his
00:19:31 jobs because of his political views and his views on race on women or whatever i mean you know i i
00:19:37 personally think that you know we should allow for people to hold views we don't like i i i think we
00:19:43 should be able to challenge people's views and it's better that we know them but the idea that
00:19:46 a journalist should be prosecuted for something someone else has said to them um it's interesting
00:19:51 that we don't see that when no sky or bbc interview people i mean did we think about
00:19:57 questioning david dimbleby when he had a nick griffin from the bmp on um i think it's quite
00:20:02 bizarre and i always had a lot of sympathy for darren anyway i think he's a lovely bloke who's
00:20:06 been persecuted that's the only word for it persecuted uh from the the ramona side for
00:20:11 for years and years of his life since brexit referendum um and all allegations all have been
00:20:16 disproven against him um but um i can completely understand and i know this when i'm doing my show
00:20:21 it is perfectly possible for you know even if you're interviewing a cabinet minister and i've
00:20:26 been doing this for years someone is saying something but someone is saying something in
00:20:28 your ear or you you're just looking and you you know you're just realizing oh god i've got that
00:20:33 other interview and you're trying to find the pieces of paper for that and you're not actually
00:20:37 concentrating on what the person is saying and you're nodding along because you're on camera
00:20:40 and i think it's perfectly easy especially for a young new interviewer to be doing that um i know
00:20:47 darren grimes as you do not a racist boat in the boy's body absolute load of nonsense but it's the
00:20:52 It's this idea that we should be wary of talking to anyone who doesn't have, you know, acceptable views, bearing in mind that your and my views apparently are unacceptable.
00:21:03 I mean, we've been called far right for being Brexiteers, for goodness sake.
00:21:07 I've been called that on air by people, far right.
00:21:10 I mean, basically accused of being a Nazi for wanting to have an accountable, democratically elected government having the say over my country's rules and laws.
00:21:20 i mean that's mind-blowing but this is all about shushing us up this is all about controlling
00:21:25 what people can say and by doing so controlling what people can think and it is terrifying and
00:21:31 orwellian and everybody should fight for it and i don't care how much you dislike the person saying
00:21:36 something or how much you like or dislike what they say you should march in the streets for
00:21:41 their right to say it but this is all happening under a conservative government as well i mean
00:21:46 What was particularly interesting to me in this particular field of free speech
00:21:51 was we've had the situation in Scotland recently
00:21:54 where there is this attempt with hate speech
00:21:58 to bring hate speech prosecutions into the home, as it were.
00:22:02 Basically, you can be prosecuted for something you say in your own home.
00:22:07 Then we have the Law Commission here, Quango, proposing this.
00:22:12 Now, I don't know about you, Julie,
00:22:13 but why didn't Morris just sort of come out and say,
00:22:16 well, they can say that if they like, but forget it.
00:22:19 But no, they don't.
00:22:21 That's the thing.
00:22:22 And we had that also over, say, you know, the trans self-ID,
00:22:25 whereas Liz Truss was the one who sort of went,
00:22:28 no, absolute madness, we're not having that.
00:22:30 A man can't just say on a Wednesday that he's a woman
00:22:32 and we have to accept that
00:22:34 and then see a lack of safety for women and girls
00:22:36 in their safe spaces, like changing rooms and the like,
00:22:39 and indeed prisons as well.
00:22:41 I don't understand why the Tories don't do that
00:22:43 because we know that, you know, Dominic Cummings was focus grouping everything.
00:22:47 Surely this is really basic stuff.
00:22:49 This would be very popular stuff of the people who are aware of it happening.
00:22:53 And what I don't understand, again, is why the government isn't just saying,
00:22:58 no, we're not having any more of this.
00:23:00 And they should be getting rid of the hate speech laws themselves
00:23:03 because they're subjective.
00:23:04 There is no other crime where it is subjective that,
00:23:08 is it subjective that someone was murdered?
00:23:10 Is it subjective if I steal this bowl?
00:23:12 the bowl has either been stolen or it hasn't
00:23:15 and then we can have a court case
00:23:17 about whether or not I was the one who stole it
00:23:19 or whether something else
00:23:21 happened to it but the idea that
00:23:23 you just might think that it's been stolen
00:23:25 and accuse me of it being
00:23:27 stolen and I then have a record
00:23:29 which is that it was a non-crime
00:23:31 hate offence
00:23:32 that's genuinely what would happen
00:23:34 and that's crazy and that is
00:23:36 1984 Orwellian
00:23:38 lunacy
00:23:40 Crimes should not be someone's subjective opinion.
00:23:44 And they certainly, we shouldn't be trying to control what people say and what people think.
00:23:49 I believe in public as well as private.
00:23:51 I'm a great believer that you tackle bad ideas by offering a better idea.
00:23:59 There is no idea.
00:24:00 I mean, the conspiracy theories about vaccinations, about anything that's going on in the world right now,
00:24:09 the great reset and all of this um you can tackle all of these things i mean the trumpian claims
00:24:15 you can tackle them all by by giving facts by by airing proper debate by asking people to produce
00:24:22 a rationale produce evidence that is how you defeat bad ideas not by saying you can't say that
00:24:29 worst you can't think it this is a incredibly worrying uh thing if you say it has to be said
00:24:35 so many times that hate crime like the bowl here is basically something which requires
00:24:42 no evidence as you say it requires no evidence it could be sort of like that was a hate crime
00:24:46 i feel that was a hate crime even if you know not even if you feel um the bloke over there
00:24:50 could think that he thought it was a hate he thought that i said something to you that he
00:24:54 found offensible thought you might find offensive report that to the police and even if they find
00:24:58 no evidence of anything having happened it still goes on my record are we sorry are we living in
00:25:04 China because I mean that this is the sort of thing that would happen in China or North Korea
00:25:09 you know why don't we just drag everyone off to the to a detention camp at this rate um but this
00:25:14 does it isn't just happening to people in the public eye this is happening at a much lower
00:25:19 level scaled ordinary people who are told that your views are not appropriate not acceptable
00:25:24 even if they are giving perfectly reasonable common sense majority held views on issues
00:25:30 like you know they're not being keen on black lives matter because of the idea that defunding
00:25:34 the police is a insane idea um um or or that you know they don't believe that a man can also be a
00:25:41 woman at the same time as being a man i mean this is common sense after most of us that is now a
00:25:47 hate crime the thing is you see you brought us on to that quite quite well because during this whole
00:25:52 period of covert that we started with i think we've established we're not conspiracy theorists
00:25:56 but it does appear to me that many of our institutions have taken the opportunity oh yes
00:26:02 to put certain agendas through now the bbc were actually quite open about it when with the proms
00:26:07 business they sort of said well the fact that there's not an audience last night at proms
00:26:12 uh is a perfect opportunity to reset or to refresh or whatever they have but we see this through all
00:26:18 of our museums and institutions that this kind of ah right now is our time do you do you do you
00:26:26 think that that isn't just a coincidence absolutely taking advantage of it and again i think black
00:26:29 lives matter again i think exploiting the horrible murder of george floyd using that um absolutely
00:26:35 i mean the national trust all the museums i mean everybody the the the toppling of statues that
00:26:43 everything has just is just a great big excuse for people who frankly have got too much time
00:26:47 on their hands. Frankly, you need to have some real problems. You really do, people. I've seen
00:26:50 their laptops and their lattes at home. To try and just make this massive big cultural change
00:26:57 that no one has demanded, no one has asked for, most people don't think is needed.
00:27:02 This constant battering of our culture, our language, our freedoms, our values, our history.
00:27:12 This teaching us that everything we do is wrong. Driving a car makes you a bad person.
00:27:17 working from home makes you more susceptible to racism
00:27:20 yes apparently yeah you know we're all racist we're all we're all nasty
00:27:24 colonialists we're all we're all gas guzzling killing the planet we don't
00:27:27 get me we're just constantly it's it's you know venturing onto social media now
00:27:32 indeed onto you know bbc website or or sky news now you may as well just have
00:27:37 someone come up and punch you in the face because you're constantly told what a
00:27:40 terrible person you are i mean god forbid if you're white and straight i
00:27:44 I mean, you're a white, straight man.
00:27:46 I mean, God almighty, how dare you leave your house anymore, you know?
00:27:50 And I just think that most of the British public are saying, what's going on?
00:27:54 And it's really easy to say, oh, it's just happening on social media.
00:27:57 Oh, it's just happening on the Guardian website.
00:27:59 It doesn't matter.
00:28:00 Rubbish.
00:28:01 This stuff is permeating every aspect of our lives.
00:28:05 It's in your child's school.
00:28:07 It's in the universities.
00:28:09 It's into every workplace with unconscious bias training,
00:28:11 Which starts from the presumption that you're white and you're a racist.
00:28:15 Well, excuse me if I don't want to attend that.
00:28:18 The assumption that young men going to university need to be told not to rape.
00:28:22 Well, the men I was at university with managed to know that already, thank you very much.
00:28:27 This idea that we all need to be re-educated, that we've all got everything wrong so far.
00:28:34 Again, who decided this?
00:28:36 When did we vote for it?
00:28:37 When did we agree as a nation this was the case?
00:28:40 And who are these people who have put themselves in charge of our cultural values, our histories, our views, what it is to be British?
00:28:51 Who put them in charge? Because I don't remember that election.
00:28:55 What I do remember is a Brexit vote and I remember an election in December last year where I thought we were voting against a lot of that stuff.
00:29:04 and i thought we had an 80 majority of the tory party because people thought they were not signed
00:29:09 up to a lot of that madness i would really like boris johnson the tories to would give a very
00:29:15 very very strong preferably in legal terms uh signal that they are absolutely not signed up to
00:29:22 it but they're not doing anything are they really and i don't know who they're afraid of yeah i don't
00:29:27 know who they're afraid of because the vast majority and i don't mean 60 i mean like 95
00:29:32 percent of people even you know i grew up on the left and loads of friends and family members who
00:29:37 view staunch labor voters and like um they all think it's mad as well so where are these people
00:29:43 well they're all over twitter and they're in all of these quangos um and and ensconced in the media
00:29:50 as we know and um they are utterly unrepresentative of ordinary people they view ordinary voters of
00:29:57 all you British people with utmost disdain and contempt and I'm afraid we need to stand up to
00:30:05 them and we need to stand up to them very very strongly because you know I'll probably I'm going
00:30:09 to probably I would predict if I'm going to lose my job I will lose my job because of something
00:30:14 that is considered to be beyond the pale by this group of people even though I'll be speaking
00:30:19 words which would be echoed by 95% of the population they will come for the high profile
00:30:24 people as they already have and they'll work their way down and eventually no one's going
00:30:28 to be able to say or think anything that isn't the um accepted norm of the uh the twitterati
00:30:35 um i think the time to fight back is uh well about six months ago but certainly now
00:30:41 yeah no i think beautifully put it is a terribly worrying thing because there seems to be no
00:30:47 pushback i don't know when people call up your you know you get feedback there is a
00:30:54 palpable exasperation and also anger anger but also genuine sadness why are people why are people
00:31:01 attacking our history why are people attacking why do people think that everything that's happened
00:31:05 in this country is terrible you know we you know we're not the only country responsible for slavery
00:31:09 with but we are the only country that that led the the abolition of slavery i mean you know yes we
00:31:14 had an empire yeah so did lots of other countries um and every empire treated people badly and you
00:31:20 you know what if we're going to do reparations uh for you know slavery across the atlantic well
00:31:24 i'd like some reparations from the romans thank you very much i mean it's it's absolutely nonsense
00:31:30 most sensible people understand that until about 100 years ago probably less than that the world
00:31:36 was a pretty nasty place everywhere and everyone had it pretty rotten frankly unless you were the
00:31:41 top you know 0.1 percent of the aristocracy um and and life's got an awful lot better and i think
00:31:46 most people, I'm sure most people watching this would agree, we are living in a world where
00:31:50 infant mortality has gone down, maternal mortality has gone down, and people are living 20, 30,
00:31:56 40 years longer than they used to live 100 years ago. People are living at a level of
00:32:04 unforeseen riches in terms of people owning their own homes, cars, having enough to eat.
00:32:10 People are living better, longer, healthier, more fulfilling lives around the world than
00:32:15 they have ever done in their whole history of human beings. And this country I think has never
00:32:21 been a better place for people to live in, in terms of sexism and racism and homophobia and
00:32:26 things. We are absolutely in the right direction on all of those things. And yet we're constantly
00:32:31 told it's a terrible place. The world's a terrible place. Britain's a terrible place.
00:32:35 And I just don't think that echoes the reality for most people. I think most people, they love
00:32:39 this country. They want the best for this country and they love their fellow countrymen and women.
00:32:45 and want the best for them and i i would love us to get back to a place where we were sort of
00:32:49 you know all on the same side heading in the same direction instead of people trying to atomize us
00:32:54 and pull us apart and say you have to hate that person because they're a different color you have
00:32:58 to hate that person because they're a different sexuality um i i just don't think that's where
00:33:02 the vast majority of the british people are at and i really would like a government that that
00:33:06 represented and reflected that well i'm with you on that julia but i think we're going to have a
00:33:12 long wait but anyway look thank you very very much for coming back thank you for inviting me back
00:33:17 you were one of our very first guests as i said and in fact you hiked our views with your interview
00:33:23 right off so i'm very proud to be part of what is a fantastic fantastic podcast i'm very very
00:33:28 proud to be invited back thank you well thanks very much indeed thanks uh that's it for this
00:33:33 week and uh we'll see you next time so as i said at the beginning uh please do subscribe won't you
00:33:38 Thanks, bye.