New Culture Forum - November 29, 2020


Were Trump & Cummings The Last Hope For A UK & US Conservative Pushback In The Culture Wars?

What Does It Mean To Be A Man & How Can Men Live More Meaningful Lives? Julia Hartley-Brewer On The Culture Wars, Media Bias, Covid, Free Speech & Boris's Lame Leadership

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

176.76

Word count

6,567

Sentence count

165


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture. I'm Peter Whittall. Now recently there have been a couple
00:00:17 of events, two big events, which would appear to be very discouraging for those of us who are
00:00:23 worried about cultural issues or the culture war if you want to call it that. First of all we have
00:00:29 apparently a new president in the United States, President Biden, who in fact has really barely
00:00:35 talked about things cultural during his campaign. And here we had what appeared to be a turnaround
00:00:43 at Downing Street and the adoption of what they call a less combative approach to cultural issues
00:00:49 in favour of a more woke environmental agenda. So what does this actually mean for those of us
00:00:57 who care about issues such as identity politics, free speech, and indeed the increasing dominance
00:01:04 of wokeism in our institutions. Well, to discuss this today, I'm very pleased we have the author
00:01:12 and emeritus professor of sociology at the University of Kent, Frank Farady, and from
00:01:17 the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator, Rafe Hadel-Manku. Thanks, Rafe. I want to start
00:01:24 by asking really one question and that is that before the election in America some people
00:01:31 were saying that actually Trump was the only person who was really there standing between
00:01:38 us and the complete collapse of Western culture. I mean was that pure hyperbole do you think
00:01:44 and do you think that really those people should be worried now?
00:01:49 I think it was a hyperbole, especially in the sense that Trump was often all talk and
00:01:56 no action.
00:01:58 You will recall that even in his last few years, despite demanding to be heard and speaking
00:02:05 up for Western culture, Trump was losing the war.
00:02:09 So for example, biggest setback as far as I can tell America was the way in which the
00:02:15 culture wars had become very pervasive in sports and you had this in football, American
00:02:21 football where suddenly everybody was taking the knee and suddenly all these sporting stars
00:02:28 were coming out on what I see as the wrong side of the culture wars.
00:02:33 This was a major defeat because sport was the one area where until very recently identity
00:02:39 politics, and political correctness was very, very weak, very, very feeble.
00:02:45 That's changed tremendously in the last year and a half, and Trump could do nothing about
00:02:50 it.
00:02:51 I could give you a lot more examples in America, the way in which Trump, although he appeared
00:02:56 to be on the right side of the angels, was nevertheless quite unable to do very much.
00:03:01 But nevertheless, having said that, I think what is a major problem is that having lost
00:03:07 the election, the people who are fairly woke and who are, in a sense, at the center of cultural
00:03:16 atheist politics are feeling supremely confident.
00:03:21 And not only are they feeling completely confident about what's going on in Britain, in America,
00:03:25 they're saying that they're going to teach people like us who are Brexiteers a lesson,
00:03:31 they're saying that they're going to teach the Poles and the Hungarians a lesson, they're
00:03:35 saying that Bolsonaro in Brazil is a cultural or an environmental outlaw and
00:03:40 they're gonna teach them a lesson so in that sense they really feel emboldened
00:03:44 they think that the populist moment has gone and that from here onwards things
00:03:49 are going to be easier I don't think that they're right but nevertheless the
00:03:53 balance has shifted in the wrong direction and I think the very fact that
00:03:57 in Downing Street there's been all these noises about being kinder and being
00:04:02 being softer and being more inclined towards dialogue is at least in part an attempt to
00:04:10 appease Biden as it is to do with the personality clashes that are taking place within Downing
00:04:16 Street.
00:04:17 MICHAEL KIRKLAND I see.
00:04:18 Basically, so you're saying it's almost a ploy.
00:04:21 It's not really real.
00:04:22 MICHAEL KIRKLAND No, it is real in the sense that it's a decision that they realize that
00:04:28 Britain needs to be on the right side of Biden.
00:04:31 To some extent, some of the changes kind of reflect that.
00:04:34 I think what's happening is wrongly interpreted
00:04:37 as kind of a group of women who are very sensitive,
00:04:40 winning against a bunch of bullying men.
00:04:42 I think that's a Netflix narrative rather than reality.
00:04:46 I think what you have is an accommodation
00:04:49 to the new reality on the part of Downing Street.
00:04:52 I mean, the reference to the role of sports
00:04:54 is interesting, isn't it?
00:04:55 Because only a year ago, people were suggesting
00:04:58 it was sports that was actually going to be the scene where the the pushback against wokery was
00:05:04 going to be most visibly seen because of the obvious ludicrous situation of men trans trans
00:05:09 women men actively engaged in female sports and winning prizes when they clearly had an advantage
00:05:15 and yet we've seen in the space of a few months how soon that changed with people taking taking
00:05:19 the knee but what we really have now is such a strange situation you know expect the unexpected
00:05:26 Oscar Wilde you know once quipped and that's never I think been more relevant than today
00:05:29 and by that I mean coronavirus because pandemics are very powerful you know the Black Death
00:05:35 you know led to an unexpected rise in workers wages because of a shortage of the labour force
00:05:41 and an unexpected casualty of the coronavirus has been the conservative pushback in the culture wars
00:05:47 because you know look back to January and February where even on this show we were discussing it and
00:05:52 I was very optimistic about the hopes for a conservative pushback in the culture wars
00:05:57 because Trump was riding high in the polls, the economy was going hammer and tongs,
00:06:01 you had very low unemployment.
00:06:03 In this country, Boris had just secured an 80-seat majority,
00:06:06 such a large majority that it was almost inconceivable that he wouldn't have won also in five years.
00:06:11 So we had 10 years here with Cummings, the mastermind behind Boris,
00:06:16 to put in place his agenda to try to reverse that long march through the institutions,
00:06:21 be it the bbc or the civil service and things seemed about as good as they could be for the
00:06:27 conservative side after a long time when things hadn't been and then out of left field we had
00:06:32 coronavirus and i think trump was actually doing very good things i mean the speech that trump
00:06:36 gave on dry the fourth at mount rushmore declaring war in the culture wars if i can say that was
00:06:42 exceptional and i think he understood what could be done there and unfortunately trump and cummings
00:06:48 have been the victims of coronavirus because they weren't prepared for this situation and i say trump
00:06:53 and cummings not trump and johnson because johnson has never been a conservative truly right he's
00:06:58 always been a liberal trump also was an old democrat liberal it was basically steve bannon
00:07:03 his advisor now gone and dominic cummings who were the architects of what could have been
00:07:07 the conservative fight back in the culture wars and banners long gone but trump never forgot his
00:07:12 lessons and now with cummings gone i see that that's that's completely evaporated and so
00:07:17 it's just it's a sorry state of affairs that we're in there as a result so basically you
00:07:21 you would agree with frank that they are supremely confident if you like the the woke karate for
00:07:26 one of a better because they see this a kind of vindication i mean i i i was fully prepared to be
00:07:34 really sort of down about the election i think what stopped it was that this this idea that
00:07:40 somehow it was closer for example than we thought but also that the idea of trumpism for one of
00:07:46 a better word uh was now something that existed in its own right isn't it well i think you're
00:07:52 entitled to feel a little bit optimistic in the sense that what the election revealed is that
00:07:59 the people that voted for trump and the momentum behind it was not just a momentary episode that
00:08:07 there is a substantial number of people a very large block of people who until very recently
00:08:12 felt they had no voice, who feel much more able and confident to express themselves.
00:08:19 And I think that the very fact that the polls proved to be so wrong, because they were expecting
00:08:24 such a big Biden landslide, indicates that even now, despite the fact that Biden has
00:08:31 won, not everything has been lost, because compared to five years ago, when these voices
00:08:38 do not exist, or at least were not heard, we now have a reality where people recognize
00:08:45 that you just simply cannot ignore millions and millions of people, not just in America
00:08:50 but throughout the world, who have very strong views about the denationalization of their
00:08:56 culture, the attempt to denature their human relationships, the attempt to alter every
00:09:04 single values that come from their ancestors.
00:09:08 People really are speaking out against that and that's been a very important development.
00:09:13 But I think it is interesting that in many ways the culture war is slowly shifting to
00:09:20 Europe.
00:09:21 I think the European Union and its decision to make what they call European values on
00:09:30 sexual relations of family life really important make it foundational and insist that everybody
00:09:36 abide on that it's far more provocative than anything that i've seen it's the first time i've
00:09:41 seen the eu demanding that unless you accept our values on family adoption unless you accept our
00:09:48 values on marriage then you are breaking the law and therefore you are you know outside the you
00:09:55 you should be. So I think in that sense the American situation has now been exported to
00:10:02 Europe and I think it's in Europe that we're going to see the really big battles in the
00:10:06 period ahead because in Europe the situation is much more finely balanced. There's a lot
00:10:14 of countries in Europe, Italy and elsewhere, where people are getting really, really angry
00:10:18 at being, in a sense, prevented from having their birthright being recognised as important.
00:10:27 But I think people are very, very angry here, aren't they?
00:10:29 I mean, the difference is it doesn't appear to be expressed, or rather it's expressed, we all hear it expressed,
00:10:37 but it doesn't seem to have a political outlet, does it, in the way that other European countries certainly...
00:10:43 No, and Boris Johnson has politically betrayed those people who elected him.
00:10:49 He was given a mandate by the working classes.
00:10:52 We've had a seismic shift in this country.
00:10:54 Every generation goes through a shift.
00:10:56 The Labour Party no longer represents the working class.
00:10:59 The Labour Party is now the party of the university-educated elites,
00:11:02 of the wokarati, of the urban classes.
00:11:05 And it's now, you know, what once was blue labour,
00:11:09 it's now the working classes who are the backbone of the Tory party
00:11:15 and yet its elite hasn't realised it yet
00:11:18 and you've got this almost sort of, you know, Louis XIV in Versailles
00:11:23 completely disconnected from the reality on the ground
00:11:26 and it was, as I've said for months on this programme
00:11:28 it was only Cummings who really understood that fully
00:11:31 the degree to which the Tory party is no longer the Tory party of yesteryear
00:11:35 and, you know, watching something like The Crown on television
00:11:38 you saw how Thatcher, when she came to power in 79, had to have a knight of the long knives
00:11:43 and against overwhelming obvs in the opposition of her cabinet and the Tory old guard,
00:11:47 you know, the establishment of the time, she brought in a huge shift and change
00:11:53 in terms of bringing in people who understood the economic necessity of change.
00:11:57 Johnson needed to do that with the cultural war that we're now facing.
00:12:01 The 2020s are about culture rather than the economy of the 1980s and he's fell miserably in that
00:12:06 and I don't think they understand fully the implications that that has
00:12:10 not only in terms of losing support to Labour
00:12:12 but now with the departure of Cummings
00:12:14 and anybody who actually understood the need to stand up for the family
00:12:18 to stand up for community, to stand up for democracy
00:12:20 to stand up for patriotism and old-fashioned values
00:12:23 they've now opened up once again a gap that they had sealed
00:12:26 for people like Farage or the Reclaim Party and others
00:12:30 and they've shot themselves in the foot over that.
00:12:33 it's interesting to me because when downing street came out with this oh we're going to
00:12:40 well they didn't officially but this is the message right somehow we're going to be less
00:12:45 sort of combative on these issues you sort of turn around how were you actually really confronting
00:12:52 them anyway i mean what were they doing that was so kind of upfront about it i mean it seems to me
00:12:58 that whereas, say, Trump did his speech at Mount Rushmore
00:13:02 and talked about taking away funding,
00:13:04 critical race theory and all of this,
00:13:06 Boris Johnson had to be kind of dragged
00:13:10 to say anything about the Churchill statue, didn't he?
00:13:12 Well, you know, the bar has been set very, very low.
00:13:15 So poor old Priti Patel is now the nation's bully.
00:13:19 And by that, all that they mean is that she basically said,
00:13:22 do this and do that.
00:13:23 You know, basically acting like any leader does in circumstance.
00:13:27 That's bullying.
00:13:28 Johnson, as you rightly suggest, has sort of talked a bit about doing stuff, and I think
00:13:36 Liz Truss was beginning to challenge some of the transcultural stuff that's being institutionalized
00:13:43 and was promoted by the May government, so that was a nice step, probably the only step
00:13:48 in the right direction.
00:13:50 But other than that, I was actually quite shocked by the way in which the government
00:13:57 in a sense adopted almost like a technically neutral language when they talked about this
00:14:01 Churchill statue and all these other things, I mean, you would have thought a conservative
00:14:05 government would have used that as an opportunity to stand up for the icon of the nation.
00:14:10 And they could have mobilized popular support around standing up for this is who we are,
00:14:16 this is what being British is really all about.
00:14:19 But instead of using that as an opportunity, they just kind of treated that as a kind of
00:14:23 mild public order issue that could be dealt with by the mayor of London or some of his
00:14:29 underlings.
00:14:30 So I think you're right to say that there was a lot of all talk and no action, and not
00:14:36 even a lot of talk about it, because I think what was very interesting about Johnson is
00:14:40 that even when it came to Brexit, you had this kind of performance, we'll get Brexit
00:14:44 done and everything else, but you knew in your heart of hearts that when push came to
00:14:50 to shove, Johnson wasn't going to say do or die, wasn't going to have a clear red line.
00:14:59 I think that to me has been a big tragedy.
00:15:01 I think the issue now, the most immediate issue to worry about or to discuss and to
00:15:06 argue about is Brexit, because I think that the scenarios that have been outlined are
00:15:13 ones that may well lead to the watering down of what Brexit really means.
00:15:18 I think we're living in this kind of new era where there's a lot of pressure to compromise
00:15:23 and to kind of fall in line with the EU wisdom of what really should be done.
00:15:29 And I think that a lot of the effort in terms of the kind of cultural concerns and conflict
00:15:35 has really got to focus in on this just to make sure that betrayal is off the agenda.
00:15:41 And of course the problem now is those key members from the Vote Leave team who were
00:15:45 embedded at the heart of downing street have now left you know dominic cummings and and and kane
00:15:50 um and if you think about it just in general just expand out beyond that look at the last
00:15:55 few months look at the opportunities as frank's quite rightly said the churchill statue you know
00:16:00 johnson wrote his biography of church right very bad book that it was as well as well um you had
00:16:06 the ban on royal britannia being sun in the royal albert hall you've got now these golden
00:16:10 opportunities of the hate crime bill that's coming in this is an opportunity for a free
00:16:14 speecher to really seize the mantle and yet and then you and then you have him you know basically
00:16:20 saying recently that it was devolution that was tony blair's biggest mistake that revealed his
00:16:24 true colors immigration everyone knows was the biggest failure of tony blair or the biggest
00:16:29 crime committed by tony blair and the fact that he said that it was devolution really shows that
00:16:33 he actually isn't a card-carrying member of the conservative brigade who want to see a reversal
00:16:39 in the culture wars and the fact that he has misstepped so often on all of these core issues
00:16:44 I think reveals his true colours and of course now what you have is you have the expulsion of what
00:16:50 was the one team in Downing Street who could have actually tried to steer the ship of the state
00:16:55 back onto a more sensible path and you've now got the old you know the old elites of the of the of
00:17:02 West London who basically are for green technology who are for trans rights who are in favour of
00:17:07 everything which basically is a dud as far as those people who voted in the red wall are concerned
00:17:13 i mean basically cameroons as we used to call them you you kind of reverted to that in a way
00:17:19 the thing about this is was when they talk about cultures when i speak to conservative or should i
00:17:23 say tories about them they see it and this came out in this kind of downing street uh report really
00:17:32 they see it as an issue a bit like devolution you know they they sort of see it as this oh
00:17:38 we're going to like go easy on that for a while um whereas people like us if you like or most
00:17:44 people i know see this in a far more fundamental way as something which is really seriously
00:17:51 happening before our eyes you know some people even talk now of a kind of quiet revolution going
00:17:56 on you know like a like a coup they don't seem to see it and do you think that they don't that
00:18:02 whether it's boris johnson or the toy party they see it in terms of the extremes of political
00:18:07 correctness that it's just nonsense that we've just got to get rid of do you think absolutely
00:18:12 i mean i've been collecting a lot of material on this and over the last 20 years the number of
00:18:18 times i've heard people say oh frank identity politics is finished it's now gone oh frank
00:18:25 Frank, you're exaggerating what you say about political erectness.
00:18:27 It's now gone.
00:18:28 Oh, Frank, this is just a temporary moment.
00:18:31 And I've done so many interviews where the guy shoves the mic in front of my face and
00:18:37 says, do you think this will be around in a couple of years?
00:18:40 The implication being that this is a momentary phenomenon.
00:18:43 And what they don't realize, and this is something that is quite surprising for people who call
00:18:48 themselves conservative, is that culture is not like something you buy in a candy shop.
00:18:54 I guess a bit of culture.
00:18:56 Culture is about a way of life.
00:18:58 And that way of life seeps into everything that we do.
00:19:01 Culture is about the stories you tell your children, it's what the young generations
00:19:06 are brought up on, the narratives about what it means to be British or what it means to
00:19:11 be a human.
00:19:12 They are kind of foundational, they are the basis on which our public and political life
00:19:18 is conducted.
00:19:20 And if that issue is not really addressed, an issue that pervades in every domain of
00:19:25 human experience, then what you're left with is a situation where you're occasionally reacting
00:19:31 to its most extreme symptoms.
00:19:33 So you hear a BBC commentator saying something really stupid and you kind of react against
00:19:39 that.
00:19:40 Fish people.
00:19:41 We had fish people this week, didn't we?
00:19:43 Not fishermen, fish people.
00:19:44 Exactly.
00:19:45 Fish fingers.
00:19:46 So you have this bizarre language games, and people know this is silly, and they kind of react against it,
00:19:53 and they think, well, I've done my bit in the culture war,
00:19:57 not realizing that those more irrational expressions of that are the least of our problem.
00:20:03 The real problem that we have is what is it that kids learn in schools?
00:20:08 What is it that students learn in universities?
00:20:10 What is it that the BBC communicates into our dining rooms and our bedrooms every single day?
00:20:16 What is Netflix all about?
00:20:18 These are powerful messages that motivate people and have important political consequences.
00:20:25 And if you're just sitting with your arms folded, completely indifferent,
00:20:28 and you're going on about green technology instead, then you're really missing the big picture.
00:20:34 And the problem here, of course, is that the long march through the institutions has been so successful
00:20:38 successful and that they are the people who are enacting all of these changes are now in such positions of power
00:20:45 and the entire bubble of Westminster and elsewhere is now so seeped in with with this
00:20:51 alternative culture that they can't see the fact that they are actually the culture warriors. They tend to regard us all as being
00:20:57 peculiar
00:20:58 silver-hatted, tin-hatted people who are reactionaries always banging on and obsessed by the culture wars. We aren't the ones obsessed by the culture wars.
00:21:05 we're really trying to defend the status quo for us we would like life to be business as usual
00:21:10 but when you have attacks on democracy when you have attacks on our culture when you have a
00:21:14 rewriting of our history when you're told essentially that the color of your skin means
00:21:18 that you are a racist without any without any personal intent on your part that's the reaction
00:21:24 it is actually you know the cultural war is being waged on us and we're not obsessed by it we're
00:21:28 simply reacting in an effort to try to bring some common sense back into the picture that's that's
00:21:34 That's a really important point because the number of articles published recently that
00:21:39 basically accused the right of starting the culture war, or basically The Guardian is
00:21:44 really good at this, Trump has initiated the culture war, and basically what they're really
00:21:50 saying is that the reaction to what has been started elsewhere is what the culture war
00:21:56 is, whereas what they're doing when they're, for example, saying that you've got to use
00:22:01 these pronouns when they're saying that this is a word you can no longer use, that's just
00:22:05 common sense.
00:22:06 But the reaction to the culture war, so the way they're kind of depicting it is that we're
00:22:11 the cultural warriors, whereas in fact all we're forced to do is to basically react to
00:22:18 a crusade against the customs that our parents lived by and the traditions that were part
00:22:24 of our heritage.
00:22:25 We're just standing up for them because it's being under attack.
00:22:28 And I think that that kind of reversal of reality is so powerful, it's so important
00:22:33 to expose for what it is in order to have a grown up discussion on the subject.
00:22:38 Do you think actually, actually you alluded to it about COVID earlier, it's not a conspiracy
00:22:46 or anything, but it does feel like this is being used as an opportunity to further certain
00:22:54 agendas.
00:22:55 I mean, the BBC, you know, actually said, didn't it, with the last night at the proms,
00:23:00 they sort of said, well, basically, the fact there's not going to be any audience
00:23:04 might be a good time to refresh everything.
00:23:07 And that's something you're sort of seeing, I feel, quite a lot,
00:23:11 you know, that somehow this is being used, people are atomised, aren't they?
00:23:14 Would you agree or not? Or do you think that's going too far, Wave?
00:23:18 I don't know. I'm not so sure, because they've actually had polls taken
00:23:22 where people's political spectrum
00:23:25 and their adherence to things such as masks and so forth
00:23:29 are actually pretty evenly split,
00:23:30 despite what one might think.
00:23:33 But certainly, in terms of things like the BBC,
00:23:35 there's a clear agenda where, if I can say it,
00:23:38 the face mask is a covering
00:23:40 to conceal a wider and broader agenda there,
00:23:44 where clearly COVID was being used
00:23:45 to try to expunge from the repertoire
00:23:48 parts of Britain's nautical heritage.
00:23:52 The way that I say it is that it's not a conspiracy but there are pre-existing
00:23:58 movements before the pandemic who are using the COVID situation to further
00:24:05 address. A very good example is the way the mental health lobby has never ceased
00:24:10 talking about the way in which there's going to be mental health crisis because
00:24:14 of the fact that people are locked up and and therefore their kind of
00:24:19 a therapeutic agenda of medical intervention medicalizing our life is really really really
00:24:24 strong similarly you have the environmentalist lobby going on about the fact that it's really
00:24:30 brilliant isn't it the fact that there are no cars being driven really shows you the future of what
00:24:35 life could be like in a you know sort of in a carless kind of a world so what's happening is
00:24:42 that you know pre-existing uh sort of uh causes are being piggybacked on the back of covid and
00:24:49 and that i think that kind of that's the way that i would see that and uh uh i think there's a very
00:24:54 genuine public health problem to which the response is very confused but underneath that all the
00:24:59 things that happened before the pandemic are getting in you know sort of intensified well
00:25:04 intensified and sort of speeded up you know like it's same thing as like shopping online it's a
00:25:09 cultural version of that isn't it i think the scariest thing that this has shown us really
00:25:12 though is the the degree to which the british public a vast majority of the british public
00:25:18 have been so docile and have acquiesced in and and willingly given away their liberties and freedoms
00:25:25 and in which they seem to be perfectly happy to see the police um overstep the mark and be
00:25:30 excessively um heavy-handed in terms of enforcing things and if anything it's really if there are
00:25:37 agendas out there and if there are institutions looking they're they're seeing and witnessing how
00:25:41 easy it is to actually remove from people that their ancient rights and freedoms i think actually
00:25:47 that one thing that connected to that you mentioned earlier about this law commission
00:25:51 these proposals these are just proposals but basically what is called some comment is that
00:25:59 the idea of hate crime being extended into the home either that you can be prosecuted for something
00:26:05 you say at home now a isn't it amazing the the law commission can even put this forward and b
00:26:15 isn't it extraordinary that no one prime minister downward sort of said sorry but just forget it
00:26:20 you know this is actually a thing that given a few months time we might be discussing on this
00:26:27 program isn't that extraordinary well i mean it is it's very worrying uh i'm not surprised because
00:26:32 Because public intervention in family life has accelerated year by year, and parental
00:26:40 rights have been circumscribed in all kinds of different ways about what you can and you
00:26:45 cannot do.
00:26:46 But I think the very fact that we now can no longer freely discuss whatever we feel
00:26:52 like in the previously our own home is something that even in a totalitarian system, they would
00:27:00 have been very careful.
00:27:01 I mean, basically, and I know this because I grew up in a totalitarian state, we used
00:27:07 to have a situation where there'd be all this propaganda saying the children can denounce
00:27:12 their parents, and they're encouraging them to denounce their parents.
00:27:16 But as it happened, very rarely occurred, because I think most communities, the families,
00:27:20 were very, very strong, and parents didn't really worry about their children denouncing
00:27:25 them to their authorities.
00:27:26 I'm much more worried about what's happening, particularly in Scotland, where they're handing
00:27:31 out these leaflets to children about what a good thing it is to do that.
00:27:34 They don't use the word denounce, but they basically, again, use this very neutral language,
00:27:40 sort of very sensible language of what you are having to educate your parents, basically
00:27:45 that's what we're saying, which I think is far more insidious than what used to exist
00:27:49 in the Soviet Union in East Europe, which was like a bull in a china shop approach.
00:27:55 It's a much more subtle approach.
00:27:57 i do think we have to really sort of put a lot of resources a lot of effort into combating this
00:28:03 because although it's becoming an accomplished fact in scotland it's also happening in wales
00:28:09 and it's only a matter of time before in england uh so you know this is going to become a major
00:28:14 cause and we have to be on alert and and combat this absolutely it's chilling it's dystopian
00:28:21 and it needs to be called out for what it is it's it's you know in terms of islam it's a
00:28:25 the reintroduction of blasphemy laws that we haven't had for for 20 odd years in this country
00:28:29 and you only have to actually think to yourself of what the the final stages in this are I mean
00:28:36 this was the land of liberty you know this is America was the inheritor of our freedoms and
00:28:40 traditions of liberty and how we can have a situation whereby if Salman Rushdie had published
00:28:46 the satanic verses in Scotland now he probably would have been charged with a crime can you
00:28:51 Imagine that, if Salman Rushdie, whom the British government and others belatedly got behind and defended and is upheld as being somebody whose rights to free speech should be championed, those same governments, conceivably, would be the ones now arresting and charging him and throwing him in prison.
00:29:05 It's an appalling state of affairs, you know.
00:29:07 And this is when someone like Macron is standing up there.
00:29:10 Surely, even with Brexit, you know, how grateful Brexit would it have been,
00:29:13 given that Macron is the one holding up the Brexit negotiations over fishing,
00:29:17 if Johnson had actually stood by Macron as a champion of free speech,
00:29:21 Macron might have been more inclined to be a bit more lenient
00:29:24 and compromise a bit more on the fishing issues.
00:29:26 I mean, there are just so many levels here on which Boris Johnson seems cack-handed and dishonest.
00:29:31 And as I said, it all amounts to a political betrayal.
00:29:33 I think it has been appalling with Macron as well. The way, as you say, Boris Johnson didn't even mention Islamism by name. It's all very, very sort of cloaked.
00:29:46 actually race point there about macron really brings me quite neatly to orban who when you
00:29:55 talk about you know free speech and the lack of blasphemy laws or whatever um orban is actually
00:30:00 trying to do many will say actually to protect the culture in its entirety uh you recently wrote
00:30:09 about this actually didn't you for spiked i believe actually for that in fact therefore he
00:30:14 is going to be completely demonized is he not or already has been by the eu well he's already
00:30:20 demonized i mean uh people often uh equate him to being you know like a hungarian hitler and hunger
00:30:28 is often seen as being this horrible place i mean the i mean the the fantasy picture of hungary in
00:30:36 the western press is just unbelievable the number of lies it's meant to be very very anti-semitic
00:30:41 whereas Budapest is probably the safest place for Jews to hang out in you know
00:30:46 I mean I always made the point that you know there are dozen there are loads of
00:30:50 Jewish restaurants in Budapest you don't have any policemen in front of them you
00:30:53 don't need them you got them in Brussels you got them in Paris where you know
00:30:57 there is a there are very major security issues yet hunger is presented in that
00:31:03 kind of way and and I just think what has happened is that you know Orban
00:31:07 because he actually stands up on the values issues that's the one thing that
00:31:11 he's very determined about, is regarded as a threat by the EU.
00:31:17 And the reason why it's regarded as a threat by the EU is not because of what goes on in
00:31:21 Hungary.
00:31:22 They don't care about Hungary.
00:31:23 What they really care about is that very often what Orbán says about Christianity or what
00:31:28 Orbán says about traditional values or about Western civilization, the judoic Christian
00:31:33 tradition, whatever Orbán says is something that a lot of people in the West also agree
00:31:38 with, but feel inhibited about expressing or voicing because they know it's going to
00:31:44 be demonized or criticized.
00:31:48 And I think that the reason why Orban in particular has got this incredible bad image is precisely
00:31:54 because he's regarded as somebody who's in a sense challenging the EU consensus on what
00:32:01 you can say and what you cannot say and what values you can celebrate and what values you
00:32:05 got to pathologize.
00:32:07 Here the sands are shifting slightly, however, in Orban's favour,
00:32:11 because it was inconceivable before that he would have had any support for the ideas
00:32:16 and the views that he's been espousing.
00:32:19 But because of what's happened in France, Macron is now more amenable to it.
00:32:22 Because of what's happened in Vienna, Sebastian Kurz is now more amenable to it.
00:32:27 And the same thing is the case in Italy.
00:32:28 And it looks increasingly as if it's Angela Merkel, who is isolated and alone now,
00:32:33 in terms of adhering to this old EU mantra what do you think is therefore the outlook and this is a
00:32:41 huge topic and we're winding up but I mean you know one doesn't want to be endlessly pessimistic
00:32:48 I find it very very difficult to be optimistic on these issues frankly when we're talking about
00:32:53 you know people being you know prosecuted for what they might say in their own home and things
00:32:59 But do you see any pushback in Britain at all on these issues?
00:33:08 In Britain, I think what I see in Britain is there are a lot of people who are fed up,
00:33:14 a lot of people who feel disappointed by the political system and the mainstream political parties.
00:33:20 One thing I encounter quite a lot where I live down in Kent is people saying,
00:33:25 you know, they use the expression, we need to have a new political party.
00:33:30 They don't actually say what that means,
00:33:31 but what they're really saying is that we need to have some other form of representation
00:33:35 that will express our views and our interests.
00:33:39 And I think there's a desire for something different.
00:33:41 I think what I'm really saying is that there's a profound legitimacy crisis in British society,
00:33:49 something that we don't discuss in the press, but it's there all the time.
00:33:53 And precisely because there's a legitimacy crisis, people in mainstream West Ministers
00:33:58 are trying to clamp things down a little bit.
00:34:02 But I'm reasonably optimistic in the sense that compared to 10 years ago, there are far
00:34:07 more voices.
00:34:08 I think that's the legacy of Brexit.
00:34:11 Whatever you think about Brexit and whatever is going to happen, I don't know.
00:34:14 But it's left one legacy, which is that a lot of people have discovered that they do
00:34:19 have a voice which can make a difference and that can matter.
00:34:22 and that's not going to go away anytime soon.
00:34:24 So in that sense, I do feel that there is a lot to play for.
00:34:29 You know, you're entitled to be pessimistic
00:34:31 about some of the things that we've just been discussing,
00:34:33 but at the end of the day, there is also the fact
00:34:36 that more than before, there's a sizable group of people
00:34:41 who are trying to find a different way
00:34:43 of dealing with the issues that we're doing,
00:34:45 who are seeing through what's happening
00:34:49 in mainstream politics and are therefore a very important resource or movement, potential
00:34:57 movement for something positive happening on the cultural front in the future.
00:35:02 There are reasons to have some optimism.
00:35:05 In America it's worth remembering that more people voted for Donald Trump than anybody
00:35:09 else in American history, apart from Joe Biden himself.
00:35:13 Trump actually increased his share of the vote amongst blacks, amongst gays, amongst
00:35:17 Hispanics. Biden didn't win that. People voted against Trump's personality, but the causes and
00:35:25 the issues that he stood for still remain even more relevant now. And this has been the shock
00:35:30 for the left, I think, in seeing how many people voted for Trump. And there's no reason to think
00:35:34 that Trumpism is here to stay, whether he'll be the next person to do it or Donald Trump Jr. or
00:35:39 somebody else. I think there's every reason to understand that had it not been for coronavirus,
00:35:43 his agenda would have won. That's the American scene. And in this country, certainly I would say
00:35:48 that it's the fact that you've got this new organisation of NRG, the Northern Research Group
00:35:52 in the Conservative Party, which hopes to hold the heels of the Prime Minister to the fire
00:35:57 over the Red Wall in much the same way that the ERG did for the European Union. And you have
00:36:02 another group of MPs in the Tory party called Common Sense, who are trying to stand up against
00:36:07 all of this wokery. And if they can finally, you know, smack the Prime Minister around the chops
00:36:12 and say, wake up to the reality of what's happening on the ground
00:36:15 and where our new centres of support are,
00:36:19 then there is hope there,
00:36:20 whether it's him or the next person to come along.
00:36:22 I think those are two reasons to be optimistic.
00:36:24 Well, I certainly hope so.
00:36:26 We're going to be talking about this obviously ongoing.
00:36:30 There's no question about it.
00:36:31 I would finish with one point,
00:36:34 which is at least things are out in the open in an odd way, aren't they?
00:36:39 People have played their hand.
00:36:40 so you know when you talk about institutions and how they're trying to change the way that they're
00:36:45 run and you now see the people you now see who's running them and i think that something's quite
00:36:51 new maybe but thank you very very much frank thank you very much uh that's it for this week we'll be
00:36:58 back uh next time and uh in the meantime please do subscribe won't you to counterculture out to
00:37:05 the channel, of course. So I hope you have a good weekend. Thank you. Bye.