New Culture Forum - November 13, 2020


What Does It Mean To Be A Man & How Can Men Live More Meaningful Lives?

Navigating the New Political Divide - Matt Goodwin Were Trump & Cummings The Last Hope For A UK & US Conservative Pushback In The Culture Wars?

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

163.44

Word count

4,828

Sentence count

65


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittall. Now we are certainly living
00:00:28 in times where all masculinity appears to be toxic certainly men appear to be attacked from
00:00:35 many different sides but what does it really mean to be a man in the 21st century how can men lead
00:00:43 meaningful lives well that's the subject of a new book the seven ages of man how to live
00:00:49 a meaningful life the author is my guest today james innes smith who is a journalist for such
00:00:57 publications as The Guardian, The Spectator, The Times, numerous publications.
00:01:02 Thank you very, very much for coming in, James.
00:01:05 I found this fascinating and timely, but I wonder why did you decide to write it now?
00:01:13 Well, actually, it's been quite a long time in the making, actually.
00:01:17 It's gone through various stages. At first, it was called The War on Masculinity,
00:01:21 and that was about... I came up with the idea about two and a half years ago,
00:01:26 just around the time that Jordan Peterson was sort of making headway and it was very much of its time
00:01:33 I think that there was that there was all that stuff going on after me too and and I think
00:01:39 gradually it just sort of shifted really as that sort of blew over a bit and I thought well let's
00:01:43 broaden it out a bit to talk about well you know what what can men do to to improve their lot rather
00:01:51 than merely focusing on how things are going wrong or how masculinity has become toxic and
00:01:56 all these negative things how can men actually live more fulfilling lives and what do they need
00:02:01 to do in order to to to achieve that but you see yes and therefore it's being very constructive and
00:02:09 yeah positive but in a way why do you think we arrived at that situation i mean when you say
00:02:14 everything has been negative obviously it appears to me that it has but why did we arrive at that
00:02:20 situation how um i think we um i think we were looking for blame i think i think me too was
00:02:27 certainly a very important moment uh and and i but i think it was a very specific moment to do with
00:02:34 actual people doing actual harm and i think what happened is it broadened out it became very
00:02:41 politicized and i think um the feminist sort of side got on board and it all became a bit
00:02:48 sort of blamey and and men as a sort of as a sort of entity suddenly were under
00:02:58 the microscope and not very flattering I mean I don't I don't go along with this
00:03:02 idea that a poor old man you know they're under attack necessarily because
00:03:07 I think you know I think some of some of that stuff about Weinstein you know it
00:03:12 was needed to be called out and it was very timely and I'm glad that it was but
00:03:17 think what happened it sort of turned into something much more toxic to use a phrase
00:03:26 which i think has separated the sexes it's it's it's it's formed a barrier um which i think has
00:03:34 has opened up and it has divided the genders the sexes and i think it's very sad do you do you feel
00:03:41 it from men you speak to friends whatever do they do you feel that they feel they're in crisis
00:03:48 um yes quietly though they don't shout about it i think there's a lot of that sort of quiet
00:03:54 desperation amongst a lot of men of all ages actually we tend to think about young men and
00:04:01 mental health issues and all that but i think middle-aged men certainly and older men you know
00:04:06 know, the generations have become quite split, I think. And I think in the book, I try to
00:04:12 break it down into all the different sections of life. So I've got, you know, we start with
00:04:17 childhood, we go to adolescence, middle age, talk about work, and then old age and legacy.
00:04:24 So each act of life, I suppose, has its own challenges. So I wanted to try and, you know,
00:04:30 distill those and give men an idea of how they can sort of navigate their way
00:04:36 through all the trials and tribulations it's based actually on Shakespeare's
00:04:41 seven ages of man obviously the title suggests but as you were saying that it's
00:04:46 it's actually sort of almost it's like a hybrid of a self-help book would you
00:04:51 call it with that's a very derogatory thing isn't it yes I suppose I suppose
00:04:55 it is. It's more of a manifesto or something that you can refer to. It doesn't offer miracle
00:05:04 cures, it's not in that respect, but it's more of a sort of a gentle reminder of all
00:05:12 the sort of things that we have clung to in the past, institutions such as marriage and
00:05:18 the nuclear family, things which have now in themselves become politicised, which were
00:05:24 not political at all can you explain when you say they've been politicized
00:05:29 gives an example well for instance I think something like marriage or the
00:05:34 nuclear family for instance have very much become the domain of the right for
00:05:40 some reason that you know it's it's it's thought of as being reactionary if you
00:05:44 if you stand up for the nuclear family or for traditional marriage whereas that
00:05:51 was never the case before it was just it was it was a sort of good template by which you could
00:05:56 live your life and if you decided it wasn't for you then that was fine but I think it's important
00:06:01 to realize that you can you can you can be for something but not necessarily be against other
00:06:07 things so you can be for traditional marriage or the nuclear family but that doesn't mean you hate
00:06:12 single mothers or you you have it in for for same-sex marriage and I think the problem has been
00:06:19 that if you take a side you're automatically against the other side which i think in itself
00:06:25 is very difficult because it means people can't stand up for traditions or foundations which for
00:06:32 centuries have been the building blocks of our society but when you say they've been politicized
00:06:38 uh it's not they just didn't it just didn't happen kind of organically you could say it
00:06:43 was deliberate surely i mean when when you say people are you said that people aren't
00:06:47 are not necessarily put immediately into opposition with single-sex marriages,
00:06:52 but that's the way it's been framed, isn't it?
00:06:55 Yes, I think there was a case today, actually, of a chap who,
00:07:01 a Christian man, who said online or something that he was for,
00:07:08 that the best way to bring up children was within the nuclear family,
00:07:11 and he got pilloried and he's lost his job and various, you know,
00:07:14 he's been sort of demonized for holding that position interestingly he never at one point
00:07:20 at any point said i'm against same-sex marriage he said it was you know within his religion this is
00:07:26 these were the tenets of his religion that doesn't necessarily mean he's going to go out and you know
00:07:31 be cruel to same-sex couples or or single mothers so we've sort of we've got muddled up with
00:07:41 positions which
00:07:43 there should be no problem with holding
00:07:46 which have suddenly become
00:07:48 tied up with sort of right wing thinking
00:07:50 or left wing thinking which
00:07:52 there was no need for that I think
00:07:54 yeah
00:07:56 all of my perceptions over the past
00:07:58 three decades or so
00:08:00 that even though one
00:08:02 doesn't want to think in these left right terms
00:08:04 it was the left on the whole
00:08:06 who were sort of attacking these
00:08:08 things actually I mean you know
00:08:10 that when they were standing up for certain minority rights it was more about the attack
00:08:16 on the other things that mattered. Would you agree with that?
00:08:21 Yes, I think, well I suppose they wanted to bring about equality and in order to do that
00:08:28 they sort of got into the mindset that you had to somehow undermine the predominant culture
00:08:38 because it felt a bit like sour grapes
00:08:43 that maybe that predominant culture
00:08:45 had had it good for too long
00:08:46 and maybe it was time for a change
00:08:48 and that, you know,
00:08:49 why shouldn't minorities become
00:08:52 more of a dominant factor?
00:08:55 Which I kind of understand,
00:08:56 but it's a mean-spirited way
00:08:58 of finding equality.
00:09:00 And I think equality of opportunity
00:09:02 and that we allow people to flourish
00:09:05 in whatever field they want to
00:09:06 and in whichever sort of lifestyle they want to.
00:09:08 That has to be as far as it goes.
00:09:11 To then start to criticise or critique the dominant culture
00:09:15 feels to me, as you say,
00:09:18 like it's another toxic way of dealing with something
00:09:25 which should be about bringing people together.
00:09:28 Do you think that this kind of void,
00:09:31 you talk in the book,
00:09:32 because the point is you relate individual lives
00:09:35 to the culture outside of course do you think that the void in meaning which many people might
00:09:42 not even be conscious of uh they might be unconsciously aware of it is it mostly to do
00:09:48 with the decline or absence of religion do you think now i thought i think that's certainly
00:09:54 added to the problem for sure yeah um and even if you i mean i talk about in the book even if you
00:10:01 aren't, if you haven't bought into the Christian faith, we are imbued by its values as a society.
00:10:10 It's been the foundation of many of our institutions and our moral sensibilities for a long time,
00:10:17 for centuries. And I think when you remove that fundamental basis, people become confused,
00:10:28 they become lost they forget about what those foundations were and why they were important
00:10:34 and suddenly people are feeling unmoored from from things which only very recently were considered
00:10:44 as i said before they weren't political at all they were just merely the foundations
00:10:48 from which we could live our lives how would you say james what has given meaning to your life
00:10:56 well I was I came very late to marriage actually and to family I've just had a kid
00:11:03 and yes last week but yes in middle age and it's bringing me a lot of joy which I I've always been
00:11:10 slightly ambivalent about marriage and family and I'm absolutely thrilled it's it's it's give
00:11:17 it really does suddenly give you a purpose in life beyond the self and I think that is one of the
00:11:22 problems we've had in our society is we've become about about about me rather than the broader
00:11:29 society we sort of radical autonomy took over i think probably in the last 30 or 40 years whereby
00:11:36 it was all about the self self-fulfillment would bring us happiness and fulfillment as
00:11:42 happiness and meaning um which was never going to be the case i'm still i'm still amazed that we
00:11:51 follow that path to meaning because it's proved time and time again throughout
00:11:56 generations that it it never ends well if you just focus on the self at the
00:12:03 same time obviously we've had this sort of move to tribalism whereby we
00:12:07 identify as groups very sort of tight groups that I think is also made us lose
00:12:16 sight of that deeper sense of belonging and culture and society and that we're
00:12:22 all in this together and that life is fragile we're all terrified creatures
00:12:26 looking for purpose and if you start if you either go into the self and go well
00:12:31 it's just about me and I'm going to achieve what I need sod everyone else
00:12:35 that's one way and if you go into the tribal way that's also destructive
00:12:40 because you're saying well you know it's it's my tribe and the other tribes are
00:12:45 insignificant. It's about achieving a sense of pride for my little group. Now
00:12:53 Roger Scruton did talk about the little battalions where you know which I do
00:12:57 find is a good way to live a meaningful life if you know and that starts with
00:13:03 family. It starts in small communities where people are looking out for each
00:13:07 other and again I think we've lost that sense of looking out for each other on
00:13:13 on a small in a small scale but it it widens out into the broader community and and and gives us
00:13:21 all a sense of purpose and meaning and coming together i think the thing is it's interesting
00:13:27 that because i feel that you said we've lost it i mean i would say that on the part of some people
00:13:33 they positively rejected it there's this sort of feeling particularly you hit you get it in cities
00:13:38 yes um of sort of somehow i am so special that if i anchor myself in one particular place
00:13:46 that somehow is provincial it's it's going to restrict me do you recognize that as a
00:13:52 oh definitely yes i do and um i yeah it's a sort of terror of in cities of bourgeois
00:13:59 provincialness um and they but they forget that actually if you do go to the country or the
00:14:05 village life okay it's not as exciting as a city but it certainly has its benefits and as much as
00:14:12 people really do look out for each other i mean i've lived sort of half my time in suffolk on
00:14:18 the coast in a very small village and it's kind of a relief going back there after london because
00:14:23 you feel that you're sort of all there as a there's that sense of community and the word community is
00:14:31 chucked around a lot now and but it's i think it's lost a lot of its meaning because it's often used
00:14:36 to describe vast tracts of you know the the lgbt community or the bame community but i don't think
00:14:45 you can make those people into a homogeneous community they are well they would agree with
00:14:51 you i think yes yeah yeah yeah do you um do you sort of feel as well that some wider sense as you
00:15:00 put it like feeling passionate about something outside yourself or in fact you know something
00:15:07 outside yourself is meaningful to you whether it's your family or not do you think it can be achieved
00:15:13 by for example politics you know if you are very very i mean i've always found that it's people who
00:15:20 do things very very well and care about something outside themselves is always a very attractive
00:15:25 traits you know do you think politics can do that um possibly if you're if you're if your heart's in
00:15:32 the right place yeah um i'm not one of these people who dismisses all politicians as being sort of
00:15:37 psychotic you know um but but uh i think you you can veer off that path quite easily because of
00:15:45 the power but i think if you're if you genuinely want to change the world i mean there's not much
00:15:51 more meaning than that i mean to actually genuinely want to change people's lives for the better
00:15:56 to achieve a more equitable society in a realistic way not in any sort of utopian way
00:16:04 then i think absolutely and i and i also what you say about having something outside yourself
00:16:10 even just something as simple as a hobby when i talk about it in the book just just you know
00:16:15 to have something that you can focus your mind on that takes you out of the self because we get so
00:16:21 tied up in our own needs and wants and desires and it can drive us mad if we
00:16:27 don't have something other than that to to focus on I mean so in this you know
00:16:31 you you with each as you say you go through childhood adolescence
00:16:36 relationships middle age old age which I didn't read the thing is is the
00:16:45 throughout you give quite practical advice as well I mean like you just said
00:16:49 get a hobby this sort of did remind me rather Jordan Peterson's 12 rules you
00:16:55 know and he said to basically I was that actually aimed at men I think it was
00:16:59 aimed at people it was people yeah but but most of his audience was men I think
00:17:03 but it was like clear your room up wasn't it it was do those sorts of things
00:17:07 before you start telling people what to do yes and I mean would you say like for
00:17:12 example to an adolescent don't give in to say Instagram don't give in to
00:17:19 narcissism yeah I'm quite clear on that actually I advise parents just to not
00:17:25 give their children not allow their children onto social media and to avoid
00:17:29 giving them smartphones and and pads because for as long as possible because
00:17:36 I think they need to experience the real world before they start getting tied
00:17:40 into the sort of virtual world which is which although is on the surface very
00:17:45 wide because you can access the entire world is very narrow because you you
00:17:50 focus down and you kids especially they start to become very isolated I think in
00:17:56 a way and they don't see their friends as much they don't get outside they
00:17:59 don't breathe the fresh air and explore the world all those things that kids I
00:18:03 think it's absolutely vital for a healthy upbringing it all becomes focused
00:18:08 on one thing
00:18:09 and I also talk in the book
00:18:12 a lot about the sort of
00:18:13 coarsening of our popular culture
00:18:14 and I think
00:18:15 Yes, yes
00:18:16 I mean this is terribly important
00:18:17 in the adolescent section actually
00:18:19 Yes
00:18:20 Basically you're saying
00:18:21 that this is just
00:18:21 a lowering experience
00:18:22 isn't that right to say?
00:18:24 I think so, yeah
00:18:24 What are you talking about there really?
00:18:26 Well I just think
00:18:27 the sort of garishness
00:18:28 of so much popular culture now
00:18:31 it's sort of in your face
00:18:32 it's trying to get your attention
00:18:33 it's effectively shouting at you
00:18:35 It's a noisy, bright, I mean, I find it very difficult to look at most of it now.
00:18:42 It's actually sort of primetime TV.
00:18:44 There's something incredibly disturbing, the kind of sinister about it, I find.
00:18:50 It's trying to grab your attention in really quite coarse ways.
00:18:55 And I advise children, actually, and adolescents to explore the online world,
00:19:02 The long-form interviews, the long-form discussions, the Peter Whittle shows, obviously that sort of thing mentioned in the book.
00:19:10 Very flattered by the entry.
00:19:13 But there's so much out there.
00:19:14 There's such a rich vein of really thoughtful, decent-minded, honest debate that isn't partisan necessarily.
00:19:25 That broadens the mind in a really healthy way.
00:19:30 Whereas I think the mainstream has lost sight of that now. I think it's become too self-obsessed in a way. It's too conscious of its own incredibleness, that it feels too important to itself.
00:19:46 it's self-important and it's lost its ability to entertain inform all those gentle things which
00:19:53 the wreathian um structure avowed which was you know it was a sort of selfless way of spreading
00:20:02 good spreading the news spreading spreading the word spreading entertainment um rather than it
00:20:07 being a prescribed this is this is sort of this is what you will watch because this is what you
00:20:12 think we think will be you know sort of healthy for you and but it's it's it's it's become very
00:20:21 um yeah broad broadly coarse and and and unattractive i think and i don't think it's
00:20:28 healthy for for any of us really to to look too much of it it's it's it's the physical narcissism
00:20:34 as well that's striking isn't it yeah i mean on this instagram and social media it's quite
00:20:40 extraordinary it's all about the physical yes yeah which of course for vulnerable adolescents
00:20:46 is the worst sort of message to be told that you know that you know you in order to be light you
00:20:52 have to be attractive in order to be light you need to have a certain hairstyle and i think this
00:20:56 this goes across popular music as well i mean i don't want to sound like a boring old fuddy-duddy
00:21:02 because obviously there's a lot of good stuff out there but i think there's a cynicism that's taken
00:21:07 over a lot of popular culture which means that bands maybe who are who are talented and who may
00:21:14 need a lot of work to get out there are being denied whereas a sexy girl who's can shake her
00:21:21 booty will be sort of i don't know molded to a very sort of generic form of entertainment which
00:21:30 just feels just demoralizing and cynical rather than uplifting.
00:21:35 And I think it's that lack of feeling uplifted by the media
00:21:40 that I think is so missing, which people crave, actually.
00:21:45 You know, some people have remarked that the whole woke thing going on at the moment,
00:21:49 this sort of cult of woke, which seems to have taken over the culture,
00:21:55 has a religious feel about it.
00:21:57 i mean do you think that the people who indulge in kind of the more extreme versions of work are
00:22:02 in fact trying to find some sort of meaning oh they're hungry they're hungry for meaning and i
00:22:08 i don't i i don't have animosity towards them i i i feel that they are lacking meaning and that
00:22:16 there isn't there isn't a constructive meaning out there for them to latch on to so obviously
00:22:22 when that doesn't exist you go to the the closest thing and i don't think it's fulfilling for them
00:22:31 i don't think it's a long-term strategy for finding meaning or purpose and i think in the end
00:22:36 it's demoralizing and rather sad frankly one thing that's always said about love
00:22:43 is that love conquers all love gives us meaning do you think that's true for men do you think that
00:22:49 meaning can be got from just simply love i mean the way that we look at romantic things now is
00:22:57 we find our soul mate or we find our other half you hear this all the time gives us meaning do
00:23:04 you think that that is a successful aspiration for men to have i think it is but i think it's also
00:23:10 So, again, it's been over-romanticized and over-sexualized, a lot of it, so that I think, for instance, I talk in the book about online dating and how that's sort of coarsening the whole coming together of men and women and the entitlement and too much choice.
00:23:33 And all these things, I think, are moving away from that fundamental ability of love to bring us meaning.
00:23:41 And I think actually love is a very delicate balance of selflessness and giving.
00:23:49 And I think the selflessness thing, which comes with marriage, which comes with a deep, committed relationship,
00:23:55 that is so important
00:23:58 but it's been
00:23:59 forgotten about I think in this
00:24:02 selfish society
00:24:03 selflessness can offer us
00:24:06 huge amounts of fulfilment and meaning
00:24:08 and yet we rarely talk about it
00:24:10 as a way of
00:24:12 meeting
00:24:14 that sort of need for love
00:24:16 but it takes sacrifice
00:24:18 in order to find
00:24:20 true love and we don't like sacrifice
00:24:22 I think people
00:24:23 as you say feel entitled for it said you but also you know people you hear people say oh I'm
00:24:29 spiritual you talk about the dating game this is one of the old oh I'm yes I'm a spiritual person
00:24:34 so what actually do you mean spirit what do you mean and they've got this hazy idea what it
00:24:39 actually comes down to is they think about themselves a lot exactly have you ever been
00:24:42 on a yoga retreat I mean it's yeah yeah for all that talk of oneness and spirituality I've often
00:24:53 fan, I'm going to lose a lot of people here, but I've found some, not all obviously, but
00:24:58 some of that crowd, I think, are totally self-absorbed. And it's very ironic because their entire
00:25:07 raison d'etre, through yoga, is to get beyond the self. But I think there's a lot of vanity
00:25:12 there and narcissism. That whole yoga speak, I think, it feels a bit like woke speak to
00:25:19 it's a kind of meaningless jumble of words that sound interesting but actually don't mean anything
00:25:24 and of course if you press them on what they actually mean by their spirituality they'll
00:25:29 they'll run a mile if they if you mention the word religion because they they can't you know
00:25:36 to be truly spiritual you need to commit your life to something and believe in it wholeheartedly i
00:25:42 think what happens with that the spiritual lot you're talking about is they pick and choose
00:25:46 i have a bit of yoga they have a bit of buddhism there obviously not christianity because that's
00:25:51 old and boring and and you know what mum and dad used to do so christianity is usually the
00:25:56 the last thing on people's minds but it's a matter of picking and choosing things that
00:26:01 that make them feel important or it's a sort of virtue signal in a way i think some of the abs
00:26:08 totally absent of judgment as well yeah you can't make you can't discriminate or make any
00:26:14 form of judgment no of course that that's the route to success i think it's fascinating just
00:26:19 you know on a lighter note to me you know james i'm you know i'm going to be 60 in a few weeks
00:26:26 time um what should i be doing according to this well you're not in the old the old age
00:26:33 i'm teaching yeah well 66 is apparently that's where i started 66 is the official
00:26:38 where you can pick up your pension
00:26:41 and you become a senior citizen officially.
00:26:43 I think that's probably going to go up, actually,
00:26:45 as our time spans increase.
00:26:48 But I think as we enter the autumn years,
00:26:52 it's important not to get set in our ways, I think.
00:26:55 A lot of older people become grumpy and resentful
00:26:59 because they look back on their life and think,
00:27:03 God, what have I actually achieved?
00:27:05 Or what did it all mean?
00:27:06 And rather than being grateful for what they've got or what you've had or the incredible experiences that you've had, you tend to feel disappointed and let down.
00:27:17 I think that often also happens, I talk about this in the middle years as well, that midlife crisis point where you think, what the hell is this all about?
00:27:25 What have I done?
00:27:26 What have I achieved?
00:27:27 And you look back, the vast shipwreck of your life's esteems, to quote John Clare, the poet, and you think, God, what was that?
00:27:36 but i think that can also happen in an older age as well and we have to really watch for it because
00:27:41 it can it can make us make us bitter and twisted and resentful we start to fall out with our loved
00:27:49 ones we've all seen the bitter old men sitting on park benches shouting at ducks you know they you
00:27:56 know they they're turning over their lives and they they're not grateful for what they've achieved
00:28:01 you know we don't need massive achievements to to feel the sense of well-being at the end of our
00:28:05 lives. We need to know that we've treated other people with respect, we've put other people's
00:28:10 needs before our own, we've been selfless, we've loved, we've given, we've been generous. All these
00:28:18 things, they're not massive, you know, achievements necessarily. It's not, you know, curing world
00:28:24 hunger and it's not also not about the incredible journeys that we've made on traveling and all the
00:28:30 sexual conquests and and the experiences in that right all that stuff when you're
00:28:35 on your deathbed doesn't even cross your mind it's how you've been with other
00:28:40 people and what you're leaving to the world well I think what is quite timely
00:28:44 about this such as where we are now as this interview is going out in a in
00:28:50 another lockdown and this is the sort of time where people have been thinking
00:28:54 about this kind of thing what is this all about you know because they've been
00:28:58 stripped to a great extent haven't they of the kind of distractions yes so it's a good time to
00:29:04 read your book it's a seven ages of man how to live a meaningful life it's out now isn't it
00:29:11 so you can get it on on amazon thank you very very much james thank you very best for it and i hope
00:29:16 it does that's why it's an interesting book great thank you so much uh that's it for this week on
00:29:21 so what you're saying is um we will be back next week uh in the meantime please don't forget to
00:29:27 subscribe, won't you? Thanks very much, bye.