New Culture Forum - August 02, 2021


Carl Benjamin (Sargon Of Akkad) - An Elegy For England & English Morality

Legendary Pollster Frank Luntz: The British Public Are Deeply Disillusioned A Journey Across Muslim Britain - Why Prof. Ed Husain Is Worried

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

192.91

Word count

10,732

Sentence count

350

Harmful content

Hate speech

31

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now to call my guest
00:00:27 this week a political YouTuber
00:00:29 is rather
00:00:31 an understatement.
00:00:33 Carl Benjamin, who was known for
00:00:35 quite a long time as Sargon of
00:00:37 Arkad, is a
00:00:39 phenomenon on social media with
00:00:41 hundreds of thousands of followers
00:00:43 as well as his own
00:00:45 YouTube channel. He also is host
00:00:47 of LotusEaters.com
00:00:49 and he's with me
00:00:51 now. Thank you so much, Carl, for coming.
00:00:53 Absolutely.
00:00:54 I must get something kind of cleared up.
00:00:58 Lotus Eaters and also Sargon, these are steeped in classical illusion, are they not?
00:01:05 They are. Deliberately so.
00:01:07 I'm a big fan of ancient history, is the simplest way to put it.
00:01:12 I find it deeply romantic and alien.
00:01:16 It's so very different, the way we live our lives now.
00:01:20 And we don't understand it.
00:01:22 And so the modern view of the ancient world is clouded with our own presuppositions and our own assumptions about language and beliefs and relations between people that we are transposing onto them.
00:01:38 And it's very difficult to try and separate yourself from that and get into the heads of those people.
00:01:44 I mean, one of the classic questions I will forever have is how did Hannibal persuade 100,000 men and 40 elephants to go across the Alps in winter to invade Rome?
00:01:58 I mean invading Rome is a suicidal prospect at the best of times and they knew that at the time it sounded ludicrous but somehow he got a city to move across in the tremendous difficulty the unbelievable prospect of death laying before them with the expectation that they would win and I'm just that there has to have been something much deeper going on in the way that they viewed the world because I as a modern 21st century man was like well I'm never going to do that that's lunacy.
00:02:24 But what can we get from, I mean, what do you get from it?
00:02:29 I mean, I know you just, it's fascinating and it's sort of expansive, isn't it, and outward, and that's what is attractive to that.
00:02:37 But, you know, because I think probably a lot of younger people don't, you know, they don't know much about this history.
00:02:44 And I noticed with Lotus Eaters, you actually do do a lot of podcasts purely about ancient history, don't you?
00:02:51 Absolutely. We try to also cover those topics that aren't in the mainstream, because if
00:02:55 you go to Hollywood and ask them, well, what about history? You hear about the Roman Empire
00:02:59 and Caesar and the fall of the Republic, and that's pretty much it. Or you might get the
00:03:04 Battle of Agincourt, if you're lucky, or you might get Napoleon. And it's like, okay,
00:03:07 that's interesting, but very narrow. And history is actually much broader. And one of the things
00:03:12 that we learn from history is the range of human experience is far greater than anything
00:03:18 we have now. In fact, one of the things that I think Britain can pride itself on is actually
00:03:24 civilizing ourselves and a large part of the world to the point where we don't have to go
00:03:29 through these kind of trials. Because as much as I might be romanticizing them in my own modern way,
00:03:37 there was a huge amount of suffering, a huge amount of endurance and just grit and determination
00:03:43 to carry almost any of it through. I mean, one example is the Persian invasion of Greece.
00:03:48 Xerxes built a bridge across the Bosphorus,
00:03:51 across what was called the Hellespont.
00:03:53 And just the description of how the bridge was built,
00:03:55 it was boats lashed together,
00:03:57 that was then covered in earth,
00:03:58 covered in reeds,
00:03:59 and then covered in more earth,
00:04:01 in order so that he could march thousands of cavalry across.
00:04:04 And that's an unbelievable endeavour.
00:04:06 That's unbelievable.
00:04:07 And if someone were to task me with that,
00:04:10 I wouldn't know where to start.
00:04:12 Was this something that you liked as a kid?
00:04:16 You know, not particularly.
00:04:17 It was actually in my early 20s that I got into it,
00:04:21 after I'd left university.
00:04:23 And looking back now, I wish I'd been interested in it when I was young.
00:04:27 I mean, I would have done a history degree at university and things like this.
00:04:29 But I didn't know what I wanted to do.
00:04:33 And I just kind of stumbled upon this, and I found a deep love for it.
00:04:38 Well, when we were talking earlier, before you came on,
00:04:40 we were talking a little bit about ancient English history.
00:04:44 And I mean, this is a very hazy, for someone who talks a lot about English, it's a very hazy air of the name.
00:04:52 But I mean, particularly you were talking about Alfred.
00:04:56 I find this fascinating. What is it exactly?
00:04:59 One thing I really like about Alfred the Great is that he was a scholar before he was anything else.
00:05:05 And he is a fascinating character and he very much had events thrust upon him.
00:05:11 Wessex being the last of the English kingdoms to fall,
00:05:14 the Vikings had taken the rest.
00:05:16 And one thing that comes out of that is actually surprising.
00:05:20 There's a compilation of poems and essays,
00:05:23 and I suppose we'd call them poems,
00:05:25 from English history called The Essex Book.
00:05:28 And I posted a copy of this fairly recently, actually,
00:05:30 and I just read through all of them,
00:05:32 even the ones that are overtly religious.
00:05:34 I'm a child of the 90s, so I'm an atheist,
00:05:38 and I've been raised in a materialist culture.
00:05:43 And so it's difficult for me to be able to believe in God or anything like that.
00:05:47 And I don't think I ever will.
00:05:48 But I don't feel I have a loss there either.
00:05:51 I don't have a part of me that misses that.
00:05:54 But I do find myself romanticizing our traditions and history here.
00:06:01 Because I think there is actually a great deal of good there.
00:06:03 And there's a remarkable amount of consistency.
00:06:05 Alfred doesn't sound like he's writing from 1,300 years ago.
00:06:09 He actually sounds surprisingly modern.
00:06:12 And one thing that I find fascinating is how he is taking responsibility
00:06:17 for what's happening to England at the time.
00:06:20 He blames the Viking invasions on the English becoming loose with their morals
00:06:25 and failing to follow the correct path as laid out by God and Jesus.
00:06:30 And so what Alfred does personally is translates the Bible into English at the time,
00:06:36 old English obviously now, but English at the time,
00:06:38 and then sends these copies of the Bible around the country.
00:06:41 Now, that was something that started the Protestant revolutions, was it not,
00:06:45 in the printing press.
00:06:46 This was a revolutionary idea.
00:06:48 And Alfred did it a thousand years before it happened on the continent
00:06:51 because he just thought it was the right thing to do.
00:06:53 The average Englishman needed to know about what was happening
00:06:57 and what the right thing to do should be, as laid down by God, because, of course, they're deeply Christian.
00:07:03 But one of the things that I found really interesting is the theme that runs through it
00:07:08 is that there has been something that has been lost during the Viking invasions.
00:07:13 Because he begins one of his pieces of writing by just saying,
00:07:16 England used to be a happy place, and then the Vikings arrived.
00:07:21 And I found that fascinating because, of course, you get the echoes of it throughout the medieval era 0.84
00:07:25 with the term Merry Old England.
00:07:27 which continued on until the Victorians, because it was a romantic ideal.
00:07:31 And it, I think, gained its best popular culture representation in Tolkien and the Shire,
00:07:37 who, of course, was a massive scholar, one of the premier scholars of Anglo-Saxon history,
00:07:42 and clearly had modelled the hobbits on the small people of the Shires.
00:07:47 And there's a kind of dual romanticism that comes out of English history after the Norman Conquest.
00:07:52 So, of course, the Normans becoming English kings, tremendous conquerors.
00:07:58 If there's one major European success story in the Middle Ages, it's the Normans. 0.79
00:08:03 And the massive success stories in the East from the Mongols and various other steppe nomads. 0.76
00:08:07 But in the West, it's the Normans.
00:08:09 And it's fortunate for the English that they had such energetic kings and capable kings,
00:08:17 because what this allowed England to do is be an expansionist power.
00:08:21 and it's that comes on the heels of the terrible struggles that the english suffered under the
00:08:31 viking invasion and if there's if there's one poem i would recommend it's called the wanderer
00:08:35 it's only about the wanderer this is the poem that tolkien based um lord of the rings on and
00:08:42 it's about a lone anglo-saxon man who has lost his friends and family and is now uh sailing across
00:08:47 the rhyme covered seas
00:08:49 lost and alone
00:08:50 and has nowhere to go
00:08:51 and it's the most sorrowful
00:08:52 thing I've ever read
00:08:53 in my life
00:08:53 what were the qualities
00:08:57 of merry England
00:08:59 then Carl
00:09:00 I mean
00:09:00 I sort of
00:09:02 I think of
00:09:03 full staff
00:09:03 and all of that
00:09:04 which of course
00:09:04 is way later
00:09:05 but it's the same
00:09:07 it's the same idea
00:09:07 what is it then
00:09:08 what are those qualities
00:09:09 it's about
00:09:10 a kind of
00:09:11 right ordering
00:09:12 of the world
00:09:12 there is an appropriate
00:09:14 way for the world
00:09:15 to be ordered
00:09:15 and
00:09:16 you know that involves a person at the top it's hierarchical you know there is a there is a place
00:09:21 for hierarchy in this but there's also a strain of equality to it as well and the the idea of
00:09:27 equality the rule of law so that the law that flows from the king the king himself should be
00:09:33 subjected to is actually quite an unusual thing when it first crops up but it's present in the
00:09:38 sort of oldest robin hood myths where there's one myth where the king sneaks into robin hood's camp
00:09:43 and Robin Hood is dealing out justice, essentially.
00:09:48 So the Merry Men, they eat,
00:09:49 they then engage in an archery competition.
00:09:52 And if you miss by three fingers or something,
00:09:54 you get a smack around the head.
00:09:56 And, you know, the first, you know,
00:09:57 Will Scarlet misses, Little John misses,
00:10:00 and so Robin Hood smacks them.
00:10:01 Then Robin misses, and so someone needs to smack him.
00:10:04 And the king in his secret, you know, in his disguise,
00:10:08 he's the one who smacks Robin Hood.
00:10:10 And then the king misses,
00:10:11 and then so Robin Hood smacks him.
00:10:12 And it's very interesting how that, and that's like a 12th century poem, you know, this is very old, this is before Magna Carta. This is a very old concept that actually, no, the rules should apply to everyone regardless of your station.
00:10:24 And that's a very deep moral principle that seems to have been and originated in England from this kind of view that the world should be ordained in a certain way that's fair to everyone.
00:10:36 And one of the, I think, the most nourishing parts about it is that it's about letting people just live their lives.
00:10:46 You know, this is why the hobbits in the Shire seem so homely.
00:10:50 You know, they're not being interfered with by some central government.
00:10:53 No, they're expected to just go and live their lives, be good people, have their relationships, you know, enjoy themselves, work hard, obviously, you know, you've got lots to, you know, enjoy, but, you know, sing and dance and make merry and be happy.
00:11:06 And that was what it seemed that it was all about.
00:11:12 Where could one find that now?
00:11:14 I mean, you know, I've made this point on this show in other times, and I remember what little really mocking me for it.
00:11:21 You know, this idea of fairness and one rule for all seems to have been flouted, if that's the right word.
00:11:29 It's probably not enough recently.
00:11:33 I said, well, where is this sort of English truculence about this? 1.00
00:11:38 It's kind of, it's gone.
00:11:41 Do you see any through line in the England of today with this past?
00:11:49 It's, I think, very deeply baked into our lizard brains. Because these things are unconscious. And so there are sort of habits of language that we still have that have this intonation that underpins it.
00:12:11 But it's something that I think has been deliberately attacked during the 20th century because of the conquest of science over mythology, over religion, over romance.
00:12:24 And that's failed, that project.
00:12:28 There were many projects.
00:12:29 There were specifically, there was a project that's called Logical Positivism.
00:12:35 There was a philosophical project that was designed to have a value-free form of language.
00:12:39 and that failed because it's simply not possible all language seems to originate from an individual
00:12:45 perspective and then it's hard to devalue that you know say that that person has no interest and
00:12:50 can't value anything and so this this project failed and so but what this what this ended up
00:12:54 doing i think is opening the door to the sort of corporate speak that we have now this kind of
00:12:59 sanitized politically correct uh the the sort of language that hr uses you know um and it's awful
00:13:07 and it's dehumanizing it's the kind of language robots would design and we don't need to use it
00:13:13 we can actually use value judgments when we're describing a circumstance and i think we're
00:13:18 actually right to do so because what we're doing when we allow them to get away with this kind of
00:13:23 thinning of language is to present a neutral playing field as if good and evil are the same
00:13:30 they're just two sides of the same coin who cares no there's a real effect when you allow them to
00:13:36 present wrong as right and right as wrong and in a in a more sensible world uh say i mean just just
00:13:44 a hundred years ago uh the the very words we would use to describe certain circumstances now
00:13:50 would never have been used and we would be using much more loaded terms such as deceit betrayal
00:13:55 yeah you know yeah cruelty you know wantonness we would be using words that have judgments in them
00:14:00 and rightfully so i mean like just look the fact that the grooming gangs are still operating around
00:14:07 this country is i just can't imagine just go back a hundred i mean this is the same as alfred 0.60
00:14:13 looking at the vikings raping and pillaging it's it's no different it's like they're raping children
00:14:18 yeah and specifically english children and if you speak to the victims of these grooming gangs
00:14:22 these victims will say yeah they're doing it because they think we're failed christians
00:14:25 because we're english and we're not christian and so they don't respect us and so they don't
00:14:30 think that you know they know that we've got no family and friends who're going to come for us
00:14:33 because normally when if i mean normally in a in a small english village if a man were to steal
00:14:39 away a child a small girl and a raper you get a dozen men and go and go and deal with it but that
00:14:44 doesn't happen now you mentioned there about you know using strong words like deceitful
00:14:51 there has been a flight from judgment hasn't there absolutely the worst thing you can say
00:14:57 now to someone, which is sort of connected
00:15:00 to what you're saying about grooming gangs
00:15:01 too, actually, in a wider sense,
00:15:04 is that you're judgmental,
00:15:05 or as the Americans call it, judgy.
00:15:08 Yeah.
00:15:08 It seems to me that we have been
00:15:12 conditioned.
00:15:13 We've been gifted with judgment. That's what makes us
00:15:15 human beings, isn't it?
00:15:17 Well, I mean, this...
00:15:20 So, I think the
00:15:21 problem
00:15:22 is that we've been conditioned to essentially see
00:15:25 ourselves as isolated individuals
00:15:27 devoid of significant relationships and one of the one of the main things i think i think in say
00:15:34 sort of a hundred years time they'll look back and say what the government could say that you
00:15:37 don't own your children uh and that's mad that's an absolutely mad statement because i can't see
00:15:44 how the government can have a claim to my children they're mine i own those children and that's good
00:15:49 for them because i love them you know i want the best for them i don't think the government cares
00:15:52 about them at all any more than they are numbers on a spreadsheet to the government and so the the
00:15:57 but the the the importance and the primacy of these relationships are from where we draw our
00:16:02 judgments it's how i feel you've behaved to me or i've behaved to you and you can and and when you
00:16:08 if it's someone that you love and they say well you've betrayed me here you've disappointed me
00:16:12 you've hurt me then that that's an emotional obligation and a pull on me and there's nothing
00:16:17 you know we're way outside of the bounds of talking about science and reason now now we're
00:16:20 talking about how we feel about things and that's not wrong for us to be able to articulate this
00:16:25 and in a way that is powerful you know this is what gets civilizations moving this is what this
00:16:30 is what binds a hundred thousand men to hannibal as he crosses the alps you know they have a
00:16:35 relationship with him they're not just signing a contract and be like well you're paying me 50
00:16:39 you know denarii a month or something so i've got to do it they're not doing that they're doing it
00:16:44 because they feel they have deep moral obligations and this is why like when when caesar's army turns
00:16:48 on him or alexander's army like we don't want to go any further into the boss for us you can read
00:16:52 alexander's speech it's been recorded you can read it it's deeply emotional and he's saying
00:16:56 i went through this with you i suffered every hardship that you suffered you know and they say
00:17:01 well you know you owe us you know we want to see our families back in greece you know you owe us
00:17:06 and then alexander turns back so they there's there's deep moral importance in the relationship
00:17:13 that we have with each other and these can be large numbers of people that have relationships
00:17:17 in fact nations you know there's deep moral importance in the national connections that we
00:17:22 have. And one of these things that's under attack at the moment is the concept of banter between the
00:17:26 British nations, between the English, Scots and Welsh and Irish. That's a terrible thing, right?
00:17:30 Because people don't seem to understand that these relationships are ancient. These relationships
00:17:37 predate the arrival of Polynesians in the Polynesian Islands. These relationships go back
00:17:44 over a thousand years. England was a United Nations in something like 950 and the Scots in like 860,
00:17:50 something like this and they've been neighbors ever since and so if i and to the welsh of course
00:17:56 as well and so if if i make a joke about a scotsman that scotsman can now go to the police
00:18:01 and say oh this this person said something racially aggravating to me it's like okay
00:18:05 now you've broken that bond because there's always a reply the scot can always he knows he's got a
00:18:11 reply to an englishman that he can just shoot back with and i'm like oh okay fair enough and
00:18:15 And there's something that's created when you engage in this kind of banter.
00:18:19 There's a kind of confirmation there.
00:18:21 Because if I want to make a joke about a Scot, I need a Scot to be there.
00:18:25 There's no point in making a joke about the empty space where a Scot used to be.
00:18:28 And so I now, the way I view the world is that there should be a Scot there.
00:18:33 And so that's confirmating.
00:18:34 That's saying that you belong, you know.
00:18:36 And I belong when you're making your joke back at me.
00:18:39 And that's validating, you know.
00:18:41 And it gives you a reassuring way of understanding that, look, we understand each other.
00:18:48 We have a shared language.
00:18:50 Because, you know, the Scot can't make that same joke against someone from Vietnam or something like that. 0.96
00:18:55 They've got no relationship there.
00:18:56 They don't know anything about each other.
00:18:57 They've got no shared culture.
00:18:59 They've got no shared expectations.
00:19:00 So they're alien to one another.
00:19:02 They're unsure.
00:19:03 They don't know what to do.
00:19:04 But it's sort of, it's been deconstructed, but also sort of almost denied, isn't it?
00:19:11 of like this was not really ever the case that that's what i feel about a lot of the historical
00:19:17 uh retrospective re-evaluation of our whole history whether it's about migration to oh
00:19:24 britain's a country with migrants for example this is just factually wrong i mean this is just
00:19:29 factually wrong um would you say you are a proud englishman absolutely as opposed to a
00:19:38 proud Britishman?
00:19:41 Well, I think when you say Britishman
00:19:43 sounds weird, doesn't it? Yes, it does. 1.00
00:19:45 It doesn't sound right. I faltered rather there
00:19:47 because I don't know what to actually mean.
00:19:48 Well, that's because that's not really a thing.
00:19:51 British isn't an ethnic group. It's
00:19:52 a civic identity. I think it's a
00:19:55 valuable one, you know, and I think it's good that
00:19:57 we can have that open
00:19:59 to everyone. But
00:20:00 English is an ethnic identity, and 0.99
00:20:03 I think it is wrong to try and take people's
00:20:05 ethnic identities away from them.
00:20:06 is deeply disempowering. 1.00
00:20:08 One of the things you're doing
00:20:09 is severing the relations.
00:20:11 If I'm not an Englishman,
00:20:11 then a Scot can't make a joke about me.
00:20:13 And if he's not a Scotsman,
00:20:14 I can't make a joke about him.
00:20:15 And I'm not confirmed in the reassurance
00:20:17 that we know where we stand.
00:20:19 And so now I'm isolated.
00:20:21 I don't know him.
00:20:22 I don't know his thoughts on me.
00:20:24 And I don't know how I should behave
00:20:26 in certain circumstances
00:20:27 and how I should respond to jokes
00:20:29 or maybe I should take them as insults.
00:20:31 Maybe I should be in a fight now.
00:20:33 Now maybe we should take up arms against you.
00:20:35 Who knows?
00:20:35 banter is a way of making sure that everyone knows their place and this is not just like
00:20:42 casually being undermined or coming to the end of its natural lifestyle cycle this is we we are
00:20:49 suffering a direct siege on our culture from an enemy who is open about the fact that they want
00:20:56 to abolish what we have i mean the the most explicit example of this in my opinion is the
00:21:04 decolonization movement in Oxford. How can you decolonize an English university? You of course
00:21:11 can't. What this really is, is a de-Anglicization program of England. And so what this leads us to 0.95
00:21:18 is a moral question that I don't think that the wider public are ready to answer. And that is,
00:21:25 do the English as an ethnic group have a moral claim to England? And the left will say no.
00:21:33 They will say no.
00:21:34 They will say that the English don't exist.
00:21:36 And if they do exist, they're evil and we should abolish them.
00:21:39 And I don't think that we should allow ourselves to be abolished.
00:21:42 The thing is that that's the modern left.
00:21:45 Yes.
00:21:45 But, like, if you think, you know, we always press the levelers into action in these situations.
00:21:51 We do, yeah.
00:21:52 But even going right to Tony Benn, I would have thought a very strong sense of Jerusalem,
00:22:00 a very strong sense of English.
00:22:02 they used to be
00:22:04 they absolutely used to be
00:22:06 and Jeremy Corbyn
00:22:07 I think would have
00:22:07 actually been
00:22:08 the sort of
00:22:09 tail end of that
00:22:10 and it's a shame
00:22:13 that the modern left
00:22:13 and just to be clear
00:22:15 the forces that are
00:22:16 besieging our culture 1.00
00:22:17 are entirely foreign 1.00
00:22:18 and they 1.00
00:22:19 again are self-conscious
00:22:20 they begin
00:22:22 I think
00:22:23 you could probably
00:22:24 I mean
00:22:25 they're a form of communism
00:22:27 and they've worked out
00:22:28 at the end of the
00:22:29 19th century
00:22:30 the communists realized
00:22:32 that the proletariat are not a revolutionary force. And that was greatly disappointing to them
00:22:36 because, of course, Marx had said, well, look, the capitalist system will make the situation so
00:22:41 unbearable, the proletariat will rise up and abolish it. And they'll bring about a socialistic
00:22:45 dictatorship that will wither away into a communist utopia. None of that happened.
00:22:51 And it turned out that, in fact, rather than being a revolutionary force, the proletariats are
00:22:54 actually the most far-right reactionary force going, because why wouldn't they be? It's their
00:23:00 relationships that they're defending it's their knowledge and connections with their friends and
00:23:04 family and the place that they live in that they're defending of course they're not revolutionary
00:23:07 they live a nice life they like their lives they like the people around they're not going to rise
00:23:12 up and they would only rise up against the tyrannical authority like a socialist regime
00:23:16 but it's very clear that this has gone through i mean it went through it sort of branched out into
00:23:23 Leninism, fascism, and then whatever you want to call the Frankfurt School, which then went to
00:23:30 America and then ended up merging with a bunch of the postmodern French intellectuals like Foucault,
00:23:35 Derrida, de Beauvoir. And this gestated in American universities and emerged as something
00:23:42 called critical legal scholarship. And out of critical legal scholarship came something called
00:23:47 critical race theory and essentially to to summarize it very briefly critical race theory
00:23:54 seems to want and i'm not an expert and i'm still studying it but it seems to want parallel legal
00:24:00 systems for different ethnic groups which i think is an unacceptable prospect i think there should
00:24:04 be one rule the rule of law for all people in a given country and i probably think that because
00:24:10 i'm an englishman but i'm not going to move from that position i demand it i demand it how would
00:24:16 you actually characterize yourself now actually politically i mean i know that this is you know
00:24:20 boring question number 64 probably but i mean you know is there a shorthand for how for what
00:24:28 you would call yourself uh well okay so what what's interesting is i wasn't really talking
00:24:33 about politics before i was really talking about social life and how i see myself socially in
00:24:38 relation to other social groups and in relation to individuals in those groups and none of that
00:24:43 required government intervention you know whenever i i meet a scottish friend of mine we have lots of
00:24:48 good banter and i don't need the government to sign off on any of this um but how how do i think
00:24:53 the world should be structured when it comes to politics um i actually very much agree with
00:24:58 frankly the classical liberal ideal i'm a constitutionalist my sacred document is the
00:25:03 magna carta i went to the uh the magna carta in salisbury cathedral uh when i was on my ukip tour
00:25:08 in fact and i found it amazing that it's not guarded it's not guarded so you just walk in
00:25:13 that i could have just picked it up and if i was someone who was a hater of english culture i could
00:25:18 go in there and burn it it's an 800 year old document it's irreplaceable there are the four
00:25:23 in existence and that's another miracle as well isn't it you know imagine having four copies of
00:25:27 a document that's 800 years old four 800 year old like that we should have these under lock and key
00:25:31 they shouldn't just be you know i mean the lady the lady who was there just showing people around
00:25:36 was just i mean if if something terrible had happened she was you know she's a very knowledgeable
00:25:42 idea but she wasn't going to be able to stop them uh and so i was quite i came away from that
00:25:46 thinking well i'm glad i've seen it it's in latin so i couldn't read it uh i'm glad i've seen it but
00:25:50 like i'm concerned now because i know that there are these forces that will topple statues that
00:25:56 will try and destroy and desecrate our cultural heritage um but when but when it comes to like
00:26:02 how how politically how do i see myself i still see myself as a classical liberal i think that
00:26:06 we should have constitutional protections i think that this should be for everyone each individual
00:26:11 should have constitutional protections.
00:26:13 I think there should be limits on government.
00:26:16 I think there should be a delineation
00:26:17 between the public and the private.
00:26:20 And I think there are places
00:26:20 that the government shouldn't be.
00:26:22 I mean, the reason I ask that
00:26:24 is because obviously
00:26:24 when one talks about traditions
00:26:26 and such like,
00:26:28 the general assumption is
00:26:30 that that is a conservative position.
00:26:32 It doesn't have to be.
00:26:34 But I think that that is,
00:26:35 I would say it's a general assumption.
00:26:39 Well, on that point, actually,
00:26:40 can I make a point?
00:26:41 because it's very interesting you say that
00:26:43 because I'm sure you'll have noticed
00:26:45 very radically left-wing people
00:26:47 who absolutely fetishize
00:26:49 the native cultures of other places
00:26:52 and they will go all around the world
00:26:53 and say, well, look,
00:26:54 this man with a bone through his nose,
00:26:56 look at his beautiful tribal traditions, 1.00
00:26:58 these not his heritage, 1.00
00:26:59 and that sounds like
00:27:01 an incredibly conservative position.
00:27:03 It's like, okay, well,
00:27:04 but I accept it.
00:27:05 That's fine.
00:27:06 I agree.
00:27:06 You know, I mean,
00:27:07 as long as he's not burning his wife alive
00:27:09 or something, you know,
00:27:09 when he wants or whatever,
00:27:11 you know because i am obviously believing human rights so uh you know that's fine you know as
00:27:15 long as it's not doing any particular damage but why can't we apply that same standard to our own
00:27:20 culture because actually we've got that here you know i mean and foreigners absolutely apply that
00:27:26 same standard they like you can read what foreigners write about england in particular
00:27:29 and it sounds like a fairy tale country that you'd made up in a in a lord of the rings novel it just
00:27:34 sounds made up but when you realize this is actually a real place it kind of just makes me
00:27:39 want to be the Englishman that foreigners think we are you know it makes me think okay well I 0.96
00:27:43 should probably live up to this you know this is a good standard and that the word standard I think
00:27:48 is an important one that we don't think about because the reason England is frankly better
00:27:54 than other countries is because of these standards and it goes right the way back to Alfred Alfred
00:27:59 didn't say god why have you done this to us Alfred didn't be like oh it's those Vikings no Alfred's
00:28:04 like we did this we did this we are the ones who strayed from the path and we got what we
00:28:09 deserved and so we have to change we'll we'll improve ourselves we will take responsibility
00:28:13 we will improve our standards and all of english civilization has been about maintenance of high
00:28:18 standards and all i see now is an attack on these standards your standards are very exclusive and
00:28:23 the whole point is exclusivity like the this this movement for total inclusivity well why would you
00:28:29 want that who wants anything that's open to everyone no one wants anything that's open to
00:28:33 make the world. All of value comes from exclusivity. And the more exclusive it is, the more valuable
00:28:39 it is. And so the higher your standards, the more difficult it is, the better the people that you
00:28:44 get achieving their standards and therefore getting the position. This is what we would
00:28:47 otherwise describe as a meritocracy. And again, all of these words, I'm sure you've heard them
00:28:51 deeply under attack from the left. We have to defend them. They know what they're doing. They
00:28:55 know that if they can destroy these standards, then they can essentially erase our culture
00:28:59 because these are the pillars of the culture.
00:29:02 This is what holds up the sky as far as we're concerned.
00:29:05 And we have to patrol this.
00:29:07 We have to be on guard.
00:29:08 Say, no, we're not prepared to drop these standards.
00:29:11 And the assumption from the left as well
00:29:13 is deeply, deeply racist, in my opinion,
00:29:15 that foreigners can't abide by these standards.
00:29:18 No, I think they can.
00:29:18 I absolutely think they can.
00:29:20 And what's more is I think they should.
00:29:22 Even more, it would be good for them
00:29:24 to take from our example and follow these standards
00:29:27 because it's not like this was easy.
00:29:29 you know it's not easy to uphold these standards but it is good it is it is an upward momentum it
00:29:35 makes you a better person it makes the world around you better and it stops you being envious 0.98
00:29:39 and gross and violent and destructive look what black lives matter is just an end a movement built 0.98
00:29:46 on envy to destroy what other people have and what's worse is they're not even they're not even 0.99
00:29:51 harming the billionaires they're harming the small businessman who's like yeah i'm gonna i'm gonna
00:29:55 get up early today i'm gonna make sure that i get that shipment in and it's on the shelves and we'll
00:29:59 get people and I'll make some money and I'll have made the world a better place in my own
00:30:02 small way.
00:30:03 You know, that's what's under attack right now.
00:30:05 You said we've got to be on our guard.
00:30:08 Yes.
00:30:08 About that.
00:30:09 In your work, you know, you're on air a huge amount of the time, aren't you?
00:30:16 Oh, yeah.
00:30:17 You know, a couple of hours every day, I suppose.
00:30:19 Okay.
00:30:20 All right.
00:30:21 Well, throughout that time and also just what is your perception?
00:30:25 how many people are on their guard or do you think that it's well thankfully a lot um because the
00:30:33 the the problem with well i mean it is a problem obviously but the characteristic of left-wing
00:30:41 ideology and activism is that it is totalizing it is in all ways in all aspects of life something
00:30:48 that is always itself on patrol for its own boundaries so if you were to say something
00:30:54 that's not controversial in any other respect but if you're in a if you're in a group that's
00:31:00 doing sewing and knitting and stuff and this is a real example actually a real example of knitting
00:31:05 and the question of the definition of woman comes up you you say well there's a there's a lady over
00:31:10 there someone could say to you how do you know that's a lady because i can see her you know she
00:31:16 obviously presents herself to be a lady and i can see the biology that's underneath her clothes
00:31:20 from the shape of her body and so i know that's a lady they say yeah but how do you know that
00:31:23 doesn't identify as a man and you haven't even asked their pronouns and so suddenly this knitting
00:31:28 circle on a totally trivial point has become highly politicized and a nexus of this culture
00:31:34 so that there is nowhere that is outside of this and so we have to be on patrol for it all the time
00:31:39 as well i find i don't know if you you have this this uh because when when one does things on
00:31:46 youtube or it's politically active like you were you know standing for election 2019 wasn't it
00:31:51 the european election it was the the european election we should never have had yes uh you
00:31:58 know when you're doing those things it can be a very a great outlet but i would say that what
00:32:04 suddenly happened to me is that covid aside i find myself waking up in the morning thinking
00:32:11 well okay what thing that i've always loved is about to be cancelled shout on from a big height
00:32:18 what thing that i always took for granted is no longer and you know i will be thought the
00:32:25 worst of it uh for taking it for granted bit by bit by bit all the time do you have that experience
00:32:32 every day every day i mean every the first thing i do every day is get up and make sure that the
00:32:37 online presence that i have is still there because the sword of damocles may have dropped overnight
00:32:41 while i was asleep and uh they may have just because we have we have very little power uh
00:32:47 over these decisions and they can be made totally arbitrarily and you've got no recourse and honestly
00:32:55 it's a wonder that youtube is people people always complain about youtube's moderation and uh and i
00:33:01 have plenty of complaints about it but they are still the most permissive platform that we have
00:33:06 they are much better than facebook's actually improving in this way because i think mark
00:33:13 zuckerberg i've watched enough of his interviews to to realize that he he sees that what he's doing
00:33:19 is very impactful and he understands that hang on uh if you want to be a platform for everyone
00:33:24 unfortunately that means everyone uh not just the progressives in california um but we we are the the
00:33:33 twitter has effectively become mordor at this point and so what the twitter mob is is the eye
00:33:38 of sauron looking around for the ring and the ring is whoever is being counter progressive at
00:33:47 the time and so anyone who can get the attention of the twitter mob to rile up a big anger then
00:33:53 the eye of saron comes down and whoever that person is and destroys them and so the the trick
00:33:57 is to try and avoid that well just getting back to that point obviously i i totally understand
00:34:03 get the thing about youtube um but in your own life and what what is what do you find when when
00:34:10 you wake up in the way you have to check that you're still on but you know oh there are certain
00:34:15 magazines i used to kind of read i no longer do there's certain obviously the papers things like
00:34:20 that but even in you know you mentioned missing yeah it is the politicization is it not of
00:34:27 everything all of society um the so there's there's a there was a an american historian
00:34:37 called robert conquest uh and you're probably familiar with his three laws of politics i can't
00:34:42 remember which law it was now but one of them is i think it's the second law where it's any
00:34:45 institution that's not explicitly right-wing will eventually become left-wing and that is
00:34:50 something that you can predict in advance. And so unless it is an explicit right-wing
00:34:56 organization, essentially just expect every organization or institution that you like
00:35:00 and you're aware of to fall to leftism, because they will agree to the premises of left-wing
00:35:06 ideology. And it's because, and I'm sad to say this, but it is true that critical race theory
00:35:13 and intersectionality are a product of classical liberalism, as bastardized by Marxists. And
00:35:19 they're explicit about this. There's a book that I recommend to everyone. It's insanely boring.
00:35:24 It's a collection of academic texts from critical legal scholars who became critical race theorists
00:35:29 called Critical Race Theory, The Key Writings That Formed the Movement. And in there, I can't
00:35:34 remember which essay it was offhand, but they expressly say that what we'll do is we'll simply
00:35:39 stretch the definitions of words in order to encapsulate their opposites, in order to ruin
00:35:44 the foundations of the people that we're arguing against so they will have to agree with our
00:35:50 premises and this is how we end up with words that are just totally bastardized like there's
00:35:54 from a from the progressive perspective if racism is institutional oppression why would you ever
00:36:01 call someone a racist you're not an institution you're a person unless you're an elected politician
00:36:07 or something or a functionary in a in a bureaucracy or something there's no point calling anyone a 0.58
00:36:12 racist because i'm just sat here on the bench you know and i have an opinion oh that you're a racist
00:36:16 you don't how could i be from your study but from our perspective of course we believe that racism
00:36:21 is a process we believe it's something that someone believes and and does to someone else
00:36:25 and of course then we could be racist of course you know and of course you know we oppose that
00:36:29 idea because why would you be it's it's totally unfair but um but yeah so it's it's it's a 0.99
00:36:35 deliberate attempt from within our own ideology by marxists in order to bring about communism 0.91
00:36:40 frankly 0.96
00:36:41 that's my next question actually
00:36:44 this is the point
00:36:47 isn't it really
00:36:47 a lot of people say oh cultural
00:36:50 Marxism this isn't really a thing
00:36:52 I don't even know whether you would meant cultural Marxism
00:36:55 I don't use the term cultural
00:36:57 Marxism because it's too loaded
00:36:58 but it is
00:37:00 Marxist and they are trying to affect the culture
00:37:03 so essentially
00:37:05 going about the whole
00:37:07 thing in a different way but with the end
00:37:09 of being exactly the same yes they just the liquidation of standards the liquidation of
00:37:14 barriers uh because again you guys remember the communist ideal is that nobody owns anything and
00:37:21 sits around as if they're in the garden of eden picking fruit off the trees and presumably
00:37:26 philosophizing and looking at the stars and thinking and it's like okay but this is nonsense
00:37:30 you know this this doesn't that you know you don't produce a good civilization like that there's a
00:37:36 reason that mankind struggled to get out of that position because you know as idyllic as it might
00:37:41 sound it's only idyllic until you break your leg until you get sick until your child is ill and
00:37:47 dies and then you realize oh god actually maybe all of the things that we struggled to develop
00:37:51 to prevent all these things were actually a good thing in the first place and really i think this
00:37:55 is based on a difference between english philosophy and continental philosophy in the
00:37:59 enlightenment i mean in the english view is the hobbesian view you know man's life is nasty
00:38:04 brutish in short and he's not very nice this is why we need civilization to civilize us and the
00:38:09 french view is very much rousseau's view which is man should never have put down the stakes that
00:38:14 marked out the first plot of land because that has society corrupts him is the view of the french
00:38:20 and the sort of continental philosophers and again the marxists take this up completely
00:38:24 and assume that people are just naturally good it's like i don't agree that they are i think it
00:38:29 takes a great deal i actually very much agree with aristotle on this you have to be habituated
00:38:33 into good behavior, into good morals.
00:38:36 And you don't just pick them up on your own.
00:38:37 You're not going to just invent them.
00:38:38 They have to be something you work on
00:38:40 and are conscious of.
00:38:42 And, you know, I think the ancient Greeks knew that.
00:38:44 I think the English knew that.
00:38:45 And I think the French and the Germans 0.99
00:38:47 are lying to themselves. 0.99
00:38:48 Do you think that you have to be consciously
00:38:52 socialized into that belief?
00:38:55 Do you think that that has to come from a Christian belief?
00:39:00 No, no.
00:39:01 I mean, this, like, Aristotle predates Christianity.
00:39:03 And honestly, I've recently been reawoken to the accuracy of Aristotle's understanding of what a human life requires.
00:39:13 And I've been working on it very hard, and I've lost a huge amount of weight.
00:39:16 I feel amazing.
00:39:17 I feel like I'm a much better husband and father.
00:39:20 Because it's just his view of virtue.
00:39:23 It doesn't require any supernatural beliefs at all.
00:39:25 It's completely separate.
00:39:26 So what did you have to jettison then?
00:39:27 If you say it's about his idea of virtue.
00:39:29 So what did you say I've got to change?
00:39:31 What I had to change is my view of materialism, because essentially, I think that we, the idea that we're purely materialistic is essentially the consequence of these logical positivists that I mentioned earlier.
00:39:46 and i think that that view has fallen out of favor both in the academy and in kind of like in like
00:39:53 online circles i'll say because there's quite a few christians online who are like actually
00:39:57 gaining some ground because they're like hey i've got a sort of metaphysical view of the world here
00:40:02 and it's it's doing me some good and aristotle's presenting a metaphysical view of the world
00:40:06 and it's thankfully a secular one and i'm happy to adopt it because it's right that um so the
00:40:12 the thing i liked about aristotle is the way he conceives of the four kinds of man so you've got
00:40:17 the vicious man who is an evil man and enjoys being evil no one wants to be that man then you
00:40:22 have the incontinent man who is evil but doesn't really want to be and then you have the continent
00:40:27 man who is good but doesn't really want to be and you have the virtuous man who's good and wants to
00:40:32 be and it's it's actually in relation to diet that i actually think this is a really useful
00:40:37 framing because my wife is in the same position as i am but she doesn't adopt this kind of thinking
00:40:42 so she's on the diet that she hates and she she has to grin and grit her teeth and just go through
00:40:48 i'll just have my bowl of salad and uh but i i uh i chose a different diet to her i'm on the keto
00:40:54 diet and so basically you're not allowed uh sugar or carbs and that's sounds terrifying right it
00:40:59 sounds terrifying but then i realized that actually i can still have quite a lot of the foods i like
00:41:03 Like, you know, I can sell bacon and cheese and, you know, you're getting sugar-free chocolate.
00:41:08 And so it's not so bad.
00:41:09 But then you start to like the results.
00:41:11 And then you realize, oh, no, I actually find the sugar and the carbs kind of disgusting.
00:41:16 You know, you end up developing a kind of disgust response to them.
00:41:19 And so you love not having the bad things.
00:41:21 You love having good things.
00:41:22 And so in the realm of the diet, in Aristotle's view, you're kind of a virtuous diet, you know, engaging the virtuous diet.
00:41:29 And it really seems to work.
00:41:31 Oh, my God, it's warmer here.
00:41:32 yes no yeah no no it's the heat we are in a very very hot day yeah um but yeah and so that that
00:41:39 again no god required no god required but the idea that there's something about yourself that
00:41:44 is actually a bit sacred and there's a kind of way of entering into a state of affairs and again
00:41:49 a diet is actually a really good way of looking at this because when you break your diet you know
00:41:55 that you've done something wrong because you set yourself a task you're going to get to a sort of
00:41:59 end state and to do that you have to be in a particular condition a state of affairs a state
00:42:03 of affairs where you haven't eaten this you haven't done that you've done some exercise
00:42:07 you've got boundaries you've got an order that you've created and while you're doing the right
00:42:12 thing the order exists and you know it exists but then when you get that donut and you eat that
00:42:16 donut you've broken it and you know you've broken you've defiled it yeah and that's the so there is
00:42:22 something there that is the kind of that is slightly sacred you know it's not related to
00:42:26 god or anything to your own opinion of yourself but there is something that you've created and
00:42:31 it's and i think that this is important this is this is the sort of essence of what our
00:42:35 relationships are it's like marriage particularly right so if if you cheat on your wife then you
00:42:41 knew that you had an agreement with your wife that you would you you've created a state of affairs
00:42:45 when you get married this is exclusive it's me and you and that's been for all time and then
00:42:50 when you break that that can never be repaired i can never there will always be the knowledge of
00:42:54 that betrayal that's in the in even if you can work past it it'll never be the same as it was
00:43:00 and so the question really is one of prudence like look you have to accept you know that that's
00:43:04 the case you know you have this kind of sacred thing that's been created are you prepared to
00:43:10 break it and that's yeah that's something that you have to think about colt when i we were talking
00:43:17 about you know basically how one lives one's life privately if you like
00:43:22 personally and also how one's beliefs inform you did stand as I said for
00:43:30 election so that was actually taking it a step further actually in and hoping to
00:43:35 to represent what you know people in you know with what you believe what as an
00:43:42 experience was it like for you did you enjoy it loved it you loved it loved every second of it
00:43:48 there was a strange uh confusion within ukip at the time and i'm not an expert on the inner workings
00:43:55 of the party politics or anything like that and i don't want anyone to think i'm speaking ill of
00:43:59 anyone there because i very much liked everyone that i met but i i was obviously coming into
00:44:04 something that had a deep series of relationships entwined in it and people had personal grudges
00:44:09 and things like this and and all this sort of stuff and so i i tried to avoid all that and i i
00:44:14 was just like right okay what can i do so i've always um i guess my dad has always told me look 0.72
00:44:20 do something work do something move you know don't don't just sit on your ass get something done and
00:44:26 one of the problems i found was that nobody was really campaigning with ukip and when this came 0.70
00:44:30 along i was i was i just said to my team we only had like two of us uh me and two other chaps i was
00:44:36 i was like do you guys fancy doing something and they're like yeah okay we'll do like the southwest
00:44:41 tour and and so it was just this amazing like energetic thing that we got to do whereas
00:44:48 everyone else seems kind of like like blinking in the light and like oh god we've got an election
00:44:52 and i i mean i knew we were never going to win you know because i mean nigel farage was running
00:44:56 parallel to us you know against us and he was mr brexit there's no way we're going to win but we
00:45:01 we could we could do some interesting things maybe change some minds and and cause a bit of a stir
00:45:06 which i think we successfully did did you enjoy the whole speaking aspect of it it was wonderful
00:45:10 yeah so the the it was it was a great adventure because we didn't know what we're going to find
00:45:15 and so in some small towns we had uh not just small towns and some cities like in plymouth we
00:45:20 had 500 people turn up to see us in the middle of the day uh just in plymouth and so that that was
00:45:26 huge you know it was a lovely day it was like monday afternoon or something like that and so
00:45:29 getting 500 people out on a monday afternoon seemed like a big deal to me but then in some
00:45:33 places like totness uh you we we we we were we were met with a very large and angry crowd of
00:45:42 insufferable middle-class left-wing prats and they had their like oh refuse fascism
00:45:52 what are you talking about you know we're we're here for brexit we want to leave the fascists if
00:45:57 that's okay with you you know we're and i and i remember having some fantastic conversations
00:46:03 i had a conversation with one woman and she went off angry at me and then this
00:46:07 chap who was literally stood next to her said well i just think you wouldn't platform a woman
00:46:14 not engaging their brains they're engaged in virtue signaling and trying to you know
00:46:19 desperately make it look like oh i'm so good and left wing and it's like yeah
00:46:23 is there good in the left wing though?
00:46:25 I'm struggling to see it.
00:46:27 Would you do it again?
00:46:28 I don't necessarily mean for UKIP,
00:46:30 but I mean at all.
00:46:32 Would you stand for elected office?
00:46:34 I think I would probably save my wife
00:46:36 the headache of it.
00:46:38 Well, yeah, because if it was just me,
00:46:40 if I was a single man, yes, definitely,
00:46:42 because it was great fun.
00:46:43 And I enjoy going and talking to all of these people
00:46:46 and doing all of this stuff,
00:46:48 and it was exciting.
00:46:50 It was really exciting,
00:46:51 and really gratifying as well.
00:46:53 And you get to speak to a huge range of people that you just don't expect are out there.
00:46:58 And it was really fun.
00:47:00 And I guess there's something in me that enjoys being a showman as well.
00:47:04 When you're going back and forth with the left wing activists who are never very well educated in their own subject.
00:47:13 And when it came to the very end of the tour, I think it was in Exeter, the left wingers, they have their chants.
00:47:21 They've got this cult like chants that they have.
00:47:23 And one of the chant leaders was just saying, don't talk to him.
00:47:26 He's a professional. You won't win.
00:47:27 It's like, OK, I'll take that as a compliment.
00:47:30 Thank you very much.
00:47:31 You know, I was very proud of that.
00:47:34 But I mean, you know, I knew we won't win everything.
00:47:37 So we we just had a good time with it.
00:47:38 And I got Milo Yiannopoulos across the very controversial man,
00:47:41 but he's a good friend of mine and he came over
00:47:43 and he did a brilliant job with the crowd.
00:47:45 So again, he's an actual showman.
00:47:47 So it was it was just a tremendous fun thing.
00:47:49 But I think we're in a different political environment now where I think that the tensions are too high.
00:47:58 I think the left have extended themselves so far that they're afraid of losing because they do know that they're vulnerable in certain areas.
00:48:06 And they will absolutely come down as hard as they can on anyone that they feel is threatening their hegemony.
00:48:13 and so I think at the moment what we have to do is kind of retire and encourage them to overextend
00:48:21 encourage them to fail on their own terms because they absolutely will every left-wing project ends
00:48:26 in tears and bloodshed and so we we actually we have a kind of not a leave of absence because
00:48:36 that's not the right term but there's a there's a kind of bit of breathing room at the moment
00:48:40 because the left are electorally terribly weak.
00:48:42 And in America, people are becoming aware
00:48:44 that the parents are rising up against critical race theory
00:48:47 in their schools.
00:48:48 They're going to start doubtless replacing school boards
00:48:51 and things like this in at least Republican areas.
00:48:53 For some reason, the Democrat areas are totally fine
00:48:55 with just pure racism being taught.
00:48:59 But in Britain, we have people voting conservative,
00:49:03 not that we have a conservative government,
00:49:04 but we have people voting conservative.
00:49:06 And so the culture is not going in the left's favour.
00:49:10 And in fact, recently, I think it was Nezrin Malik wrote an article in The Guardian lamenting, saying, well, why are we losing the culture war?
00:49:16 Why are the right winning the culture war?
00:49:18 They don't know.
00:49:18 They don't know what it is that makes people, that animates them, that gets them to do the things they do.
00:49:23 They don't understand because they've spent their entire lives and for generations now theorizing abstractly in academia rather than being among people and living lives.
00:49:33 Yeah, you influence a lot of people.
00:49:38 there's no no question about that um what's the next sort of logical stage really car in that
00:49:46 because you you have this enormous uh presence you know you're one of the british pioneers there's
00:49:52 no question about that um where does it sort of go in your mind where would you go i think um
00:50:00 And one of the purposes behind lotusseaters.com is that it's an intellectual project.
00:50:08 Because one of the things that conservatives are terrible at is theory.
00:50:13 Where are they?
00:50:13 Where are the conservative theorists?
00:50:15 I mean, doubtless, you can name dozens and dozens and dozens of left-wing theorists.
00:50:20 But the conservatives have got this great dearth.
00:50:22 I mean, when Roger Scruton died, everyone was like, okay, well, that's conservatism over.
00:50:25 Why is he the only one?
00:50:26 You know, why is there only one conservative theorist?
00:50:29 you know, examining what the conservative view of the world is. And since there seems to be this
00:50:35 vast gap in the market, I suppose I'll probably end up trying to write a book and saying, well,
00:50:40 look, I think that there's actually, this is what I can see. And I think that this is what it might
00:50:45 be valuable to people. And hopefully this will influence conservative politicians to actually
00:50:50 be conservative. Because I think that would be the ideal thing. Because it doesn't take much
00:50:54 to be able to say well hang on a second like i mean why why why is mass immigration bad you know
00:51:00 why is that the case i mean for example the left will say ah but but these these people are here
00:51:04 to and and i've met immigrants well the last haircut i got was from a guy from turkey it's
00:51:09 like why are we accepting immigrants from turkey why do they come here and he was like i'm here i'm
00:51:13 here to live out my dream it's like this isn't some frontier country that's unexplored that
00:51:17 there's not the american west you know this is a very ancient country that's currently struggling
00:51:22 under the burden of millions of new arrivals we don't know what to do we don't know how to 1.00
00:51:26 integrate them and they're forming what are effectively colonies on our soil we need to 1.00
00:51:29 talk about this we need to be able to say well no look we don't hate you or anything but you've got
00:51:33 to understand you've got to become familiar and normal and you've got to act in the sort of way
00:51:37 that the english act you know you've got to understand we're happy to incorporate you but
00:51:40 you've got to we've got to be able to articulate that that's necessary to happen but we've also
00:51:45 got to examine the reason why we're allowing these people in now the labor government under
00:51:48 to Tony Blair would say, oh, it's good for the economy. I don't care about the economy at all.
00:51:53 You just shut down the country for a year. Don't tell me about the economy. You don't care about
00:51:56 the economy. Right. And then what's worse, though, is, OK, well, it's good for the economy. You're
00:52:00 going to have, like, ethnic foods everywhere. Oh, wonderful. So essentially what we're saying,
00:52:04 and these people will be able to, you know, make their lives better. It's like, OK,
00:52:07 but these are material reasons. These are mercenary reasons. They're here to make money
00:52:11 for us and for themselves. So I don't know if that's wise. I don't know if that's really
00:52:16 what we're talking about because especially if you take this kind of relational view of the world
00:52:19 and you know okay so england's a very old place with these very old relationships well a lot of
00:52:25 them have been sundered i mean where are the cockneys now because when i was growing up i
00:52:29 knew that parts of london were the cockney parts of london i believe they've all fled to essex now
00:52:33 so they're currently living in exile away from what i guess we can call their homeland 0.83
00:52:37 so are we never going to talk about that they're just going like sorry cockneys
00:52:41 sorry Sadiq Khan's London is here now you don't get a say in any of this it's
00:52:46 like it just seems cruel to me and I don't think we'd accept it for any other
00:52:49 group outside of oh no no it'd be possibly said earlier celebrated I mean
00:52:53 yeah the thing is as well is when you're arguing with people about say like
00:52:58 you mean they will suddenly move the goal but so if you're talking about
00:53:01 economics yeah they will well as you know it's usually when you're talking
00:53:04 about cultural thing no and they'll suddenly start yes but what about this
00:53:08 no no no steady wait a minute one thing at a time you know economics fine the cultural effect is this
00:53:16 that and the other which is never talked about really it really despite what we had a great guy
00:53:20 on called michael collins he wrote a book called the likes of us all about the white working class
00:53:25 in london he's one of our our documentaries excellent but that is the exception that proves 0.64
00:53:31 your rule i think um well look we've been sitting here drenched in sweat but it's a shame about the
00:53:39 weather but it's such a pleasure actually well thank you i mean i i do hope um that you know
00:53:45 you will come back again uh i really do to our humble place and um you know and all the very best
00:53:53 with lotus it's lotus eaters.com yes right um i think it's a fascinating project you've got going
00:54:00 now i mean all these little history capsules too and everything but it's also just i i really think
00:54:06 we need to engage in a kind of laboratory of ideas what what is it that we're doing who are we
00:54:11 where do we want to go what do we want you know and and so we're very open to and we've got lots
00:54:16 of very well qualified people everyone there has got much better qualifications than i do
00:54:21 uh which which was remarkable i didn't realize i'd have people with master's degrees applying
00:54:25 for jobs and things like this um phd students and things like that but uh no it's it's very
00:54:29 interesting like and you do written work on it too yeah yeah we yeah well your written work uh
00:54:35 articles videos um direct videos or scripted videos you know we do lots of you know stuff
00:54:40 and the book you mentioned uh that is something in your mind is it at the moment or is is that
00:54:45 is that you actually thinking you know next year i might put fire yeah well i'm i'm developing
00:54:52 what i think is essentially a kind of metaphysics of the english and i think it needs to be done
00:54:58 i don't see anyone else doing it and i there there are lots of things i have to read in advance of
00:55:03 doing this uh because i've got a bunch of books on my shelves because a hundred years ago you would
00:55:07 get um english professors writing books about englishness and they're very thick books and i
00:55:14 need to be able to find the time to put it aside but at the moment i'm doing the critical race
00:55:18 theory stuff so i just haven't had the time but um in a couple of years i expect all right a couple
00:55:22 Yes, we're looking forward to that.
00:55:25 Thank you.
00:55:26 Thank you very much.
00:55:27 My pleasure.
00:55:28 Benjamin.
00:55:29 That's it for this week.
00:55:31 Please don't forget to subscribe.
00:55:34 And we shall see you next time.
00:55:36 Thank you very much.
00:55:37 Bye.