00:02:41And all I wanted to, if that was the bias, the bias was to see, is there a coherent sense of belonging, harmony, attachment, love, loyalty to England and its ways, or by extension, Scotland and Wales, because I went there too.
00:02:56So that was the only bias. But other than that, it was a genuine open inquiry to see what is going on inside those institutions, i.e. mosques in Britain, that appear closed to most of the population, but are open, obviously, to most Muslims.
00:03:14So it was an attempt to understand what was going on.
00:03:19We seem to go through phases of knowing or being, you know,
00:03:24it being reported upon what is happening in mosques.
00:03:26You know, it seems to kind of go in waves, then it seems to go into the background.
00:03:31But one point you do make is that mosques now, or at least from the book,
00:03:36are mostly enthralled to the Diobandi strain.
00:03:41I wonder whether you could explain what that means, actually.
00:03:46Yes, Peter, well highlighted. And that's part of our problem in Britain at the moment in that we have a denomination, which on the one hand produced a Taliban in Afghanistan, on the other hand was set up, was established in the late 1850s, early 1860s, to oppose the British presence in India.
00:04:08and now finds itself in Britain with those heavy burdens from history being anti-British
00:04:17and yet in Britain, now controlling just over 40% of mosques in the UK
00:04:23and unable often to condemn the Taliban or even engage in the civil society political process.
00:04:30So that's the dark side and the horrendous literalism,
00:04:35The very, very morbid, orthodox, extreme form of approaching scripture, devoid of reason, devoid of understanding modernity and context, but harping back to an imagined golden age in the 7th century.1.00
00:04:51Now, that's the Dilbandi tradition in Britain, as it is in Pakistan, where blasphemy laws are a real problem, thanks to the increased presence of the Dilbandis.0.97
00:05:01And it's the same movement that produced the Taliban that is now, as British and American troops withdraw, is reasserting this control.0.97
00:05:11But there is a good story here. And the good story is in India, the same movement is supportive of a secular government.
00:05:18the same movement is supportive of a nation state. But our authorities and our Muslim communities and
00:05:24the so-called leaders haven't invested in better understanding that dichotomy and saying to
00:05:29Muslims in India and Muslims who have come from India, welcome to Britain. We need you to be the
00:05:35patriotic, pro-secular state type of delbandis we have in India. And you should not be afraid of
00:05:41flying the Union Jack outside mosques as they are flown outside mosques in India. And by the way,0.69
00:05:48Here in Britain, women and men are welcome in mosques as they are in large parts of India, including the mosques in Delhi that I've visited.
00:05:55So there's a real disconnect that we are fostering, harboring and allowing to grow the more ugly, monstrous, anti-Western, anti-British form of deurbandism across the country.
00:06:10would you say therefore that you know after from when you went out on this uh this trip with an
00:06:18open mind would you say that you are more worried therefore about the future or less
00:06:26um or should i say more optimistic more pessimistic
00:06:31I'm more worried. I'm more worried for several reasons. Firstly, I did not anticipate to see literature in mosques, especially in the mosque in Manchester that had produced the terrorist that blew himself up in the Ariana Grande concert.
00:06:52And to see that mosque still being a home for the kind of extremist literature that produced the terrorists, to see that mosque having funeral prayers for the leader of the Muslim Brotherhood had died in Egypt.
00:07:10He's not even here, but there was a funeral prayer in absentia held for him.0.69
00:07:14And to see at that mosque a Sharia court, which means, in effect, you know, something that I think, I mean, is abhorrent to modern Britain, that you can't accept the common law tradition.0.99
00:07:24You've got to have a separate legal system which grows over time.1.00
00:07:39And it was during the long sessions of writing this book, traveling between mosques, staying in northern towns, that I first saw what Winston Churchill would call that black dog, real depression about the future.0.77
00:07:55But at the same time, I'm conscious that, you know, Roger would always encourage us to be optimistic that small C conservatives who wish to conserve and preserve and protect our heritage and pass it on to a new generation cannot afford to be pessimistic.0.89
00:08:10So we've got to be optimistic and fix this problem because it is imminently fixable.0.91
00:08:15And one of the reasons I wrote the book is to awaken the nation to what is going on.
00:08:19And so, you know, collectively, those of us who are engaged in this space can, as we come
00:08:25out of the European Union and Brexit reasserts a sense of national sovereignty, we start
00:08:30to focus on who we are as one people in one country.
00:08:34Yes, one people in one country is quite interesting, because I think there's a quote actually
00:14:14there's an extreme viewing of politics and i think that what we see in the natural order of
00:14:21things throughout history is there's a balancing out that as this administration sees its way out
00:14:26we hope that the republican party regains a much more centrist center-right approach to its
00:14:33political spaces and able to win back large numbers of people who it lost and conversely
00:14:38the democrats are able to return away from the so-called progressives you know the aocs the
00:14:43Ilhan Omar's, Rashida Kleib's, and others who are doing huge amounts of damage to the American
00:14:48imagination. The good news, however, is this, that when I'm with my students, you know, in class,
00:14:54I don't, and this is a, you know, a very liberal college, and it's a very liberal city here in
00:14:58Washington, DC, I do detect a very strong sense of attachment to land, i.e. America, a very strong
00:15:05sense of defending the inheritance of the English common law systems, the jury trials,
00:15:11and a very, very strong sense of patriotism and understanding that America has a responsibility to uphold the notions of equality on all spheres throughout the world.
00:15:21The danger is that the mood music played by the far left can often eat away at American confidence.
00:15:29But I put it to you at the risk of sounding controversial.
00:15:33A lot of insulation work has been done, I think, on campuses and elsewhere in the last two years by people like Jordan Peterson and indeed Sir Roger Scruton, that they've mapped out what it is to be both modern and preserve the West for future generations.
00:15:48which gives me great hope that had it not been for these two figures in particular what Roger has done
00:15:54and indeed what Jordan Peterson has done for this generation what Alan Bloom had done for a previous generation
00:15:59Leo Strauss for a generation before that and you know Disraeli and others for a generation before that
00:16:05every generation we have these new thinkers and I think that the last point I'd make is this
00:16:09that we you know across the West and I say this as someone who's fully cognizant of the fact that
00:16:14It was the great Romans in the year 212 that gave us this idea of millions of people becoming Roman citizens if they accepted Roman values of SPQR, you know, the Senate and the people of Rome.
00:16:25Similarly, today, you know, it's been an ongoing conversation for almost 2000 years about the imminent decline of the West.
00:16:32And I think it's because we are concerned, because there are people like you and others fighting in the public domain to keep this heritage in this culture.
00:16:40We always win. Over time, we always win. There's a reason why we're not speaking German today.
00:16:44there's a reason why we're not speaking Turkish in the 1680s the Turks lost so in the end I think
00:16:50we will win we will prevail but we've got to keep this concern and this this this sense of you know0.99
00:16:54where are we headed what do we need to insulate you know a younger generation from the corruption
00:16:59of of corrosive thought this one point though I think I I wanted to address really
00:17:05Ed is that you you say in the book in fact one of the first points you make in the book is that the
00:17:12muslim population of britain is is growing hugely you know compared to any other minority
00:17:19isn't there the point to be made that if that is the case and indeed in terms of immigration too
00:17:26that actually there's no there's no need to integrate i mean that you know if if things
00:17:32are at that stage then you have almost ready-made communities you you don't need to integrate is
00:17:40isn't the whole point about integration of any population that somehow if it's got to be reasonable
00:17:46in terms of reasonable numbers in order for people to actually integrate but they just don't
00:17:53yes have to at the moment yes you you put your finger on the pulse of the problem that in large
00:18:00parts of the country that that integration is not happening and why should it you know why should
00:18:05Muslims in Dewsbury give up the comfort of one language, one community and the separatism
00:18:13that you allude to and then work harder to get to the rest of the country. I think that1.00
00:18:19we are now at about 25 to 30 political constituencies that are in that zone. And before it gets
00:18:26worse, we've got to change that attitude. We've got to put our minds to it. We've got
00:18:31to end the ghettos the better jobs the better lifestyles the the better families the better1.00
00:18:38future has got to be outside the ghettos you know there's got to be whether you call it a brain drain0.76
00:18:44or whether you call it anything else there's got to be much more movement of the population that0.88
00:18:48it can't be left alone as it is because if it is then you're right by the year 2080 2090 we will
00:18:54have you know 40 or so areas where there will be majority separatists who will have separatist
00:19:00demands legally you will have separatist cultures who will have separatist political enclaves and
00:19:06that that has has real consequences of a different kind of Britain um and I think that's what we're
00:19:13doing with sounding the alarm unless unless we wake up to that uh you know here in in America
00:19:20what despite the many challenges what you do see when you walk around as large cities is you know
00:19:26asian people married to white people married to uh to black people married to asians and there's
00:19:31a real mixing and you see that in parts of london but i think you know that's where the great hope1.00
00:19:37lies that more muslim women and men stop marrying their cousins from pakistan stop creating all the1.00
00:19:43problems that has on the health system uh you know with the result on kind of disabled children and0.98
00:19:48whatnot and just marry in britain with the rest of the population and you know we can talk about0.99
00:19:54this till the cows come home but the real issue is there's got to be political leadership on this
00:19:58which goes back to your previous point about confidence that needs to be a confident center
00:20:03in in government that articulates a vision and finally if after the vision being articulated
00:20:09if after the terrorism being you know uh seem to be out of control if after all of the invitations
00:20:16to come on and to belong to mainstream britain there is a reluctance then we've got to be in a
00:20:21a position to say if you don't like it here if this country is so abhorrent then please leave
00:20:27and that's something that has to manifest as part of our confidence that if you're in britain these
00:20:34are seven eight values that this country has inherited you know from reason individualism
00:20:38gender equality is openness its uniqueness its racial equality and so on that undercuts the
00:20:43extremism of the of the religious fanatics and if you if you don't want to sign up to those values
00:20:48sorry, this is not a country that's for you.
00:20:51You've got to go whether it's to Afghanistan, Pakistan, Sudan,
00:20:55or wherever else you think you can live that lifestyle.
00:25:16But you're right. The norm never really is a moment.
00:25:19There are several moments, but of those moments, one strikes out again and again.
00:25:25And that was, we were calling for jihad in Bosnia.
00:25:28In my organization, we were calling for violence in Egypt, in Kashmir, in China.0.90
00:25:34There was always this Chinese, not just a modern issue in China, but it was ongoing in Nigeria, in Sudan.0.73
00:25:38We were always calling for jihad in various parts of the world in order to end what we saw as oppression of Muslims.
00:25:45It never occurred to us that these were not ordinary Muslims.0.67
00:25:49they were extremists looking for political power but the point is that rhetoric of violence elsewhere0.94
00:25:56once that genie is out of the bottle it never waits for violence elsewhere at a particular
00:26:01time i saw on my college campus in new york college a young uh african christian man who
00:26:06was stabbed to death by another man identifying identifying himself as muslim and i and i saw
00:26:13the the the individual who's deceased you know on on the floor bleeding and and you know
00:26:21the connection between ideas and reality just hit that you can't just call for violence and
00:26:26separatism as an ideal it is reality and it was that moment that i walked away and i thought these
00:26:32people were terrible news just not just for my local community but for also for the future of0.88
00:26:37of the country and the world and this was before isis this was before 9 11 by by two years so it
00:26:44was just the early awakening that this is where the mood music of extremism always always leads
00:26:52to terrorism yeah um and i wonder if you could comment on something i mean you here we are we're
00:26:59talking about the need not to have enclaves the need not to have separate communities
00:27:05and also the need for us to be confident of our values obviously you'd know about the situation
00:27:14that there's been recently in fact is ongoing in Backley in Yorkshire to me this is a kind of quite
00:27:21a good microcosm of what we're talking about in a way the teacher shows cartoons to his
00:27:28pupils uh the school basically almost disowned him there's big demonstration outside the guy
00:27:36goes into hiding now um that obviously is the sort of thing that would exercise people like me a lot
00:27:42you know in terms of free speech what do you think should have happened in that situation
00:27:47if we are going to have um a good future and and not not a not a problematic future
00:27:54Well, I saw this again and again when I was writing the book. I asked this very question. What is the pronouncement for someone who either draws a cartoon, shows a cartoon or even supports the right for Muslims to be offended because of a derogatory portrayal of the Prophet Muhammad?
00:28:18And there were several imams in private who were very, very concerned about where this whole direction of travel was headed.
00:28:28But the vast majority of the individuals I spoke to about this in public and in private were supportive of the position that's advocated in Pakistan, which is if anyone blasphemes against the Prophet Muhammad, you kill them.
00:28:40and you know i met an individual in glasgow uh who was off that position and elsewhere now
00:28:49the way you should have been handled by muslims and others is to realize that's you know it's not
00:28:55to your taste it may offend you but it's bad art get over it you know you don't then go and
00:29:01have physical consequences for someone who decides to show bad art now is it aesthetically appealing
00:29:09no does it do anything for your religious awareness or appreciation of beauty no
00:29:14but it is a fundamental freedom of speech and expression on which the modern west and the
00:29:20modern world is based you destroy that you destroy who we are you remove that you eventually it comes0.92
00:29:27to no rights for muslims too muslims are only in the west in those large numbers because of that0.95
00:29:31bridge of freedom don't burn that bridge because that bridge can also be burnt both ways and as0.91
00:29:37we're playing with fire here. And I don't think many Muslims have fully appreciated how risky and1.00
00:29:42how dangerous this is. And that's why I'm a big supporter of the President of France on this,1.00
00:29:49because he's gripped it, and he's confronted it. And he said, this is a red line that the French
00:29:55Republic will not allow to be crossed. And I think we need to have a similar amount of confidence in
00:30:00our government to be able to take this fight head on. It is the fight of the future. It's a question
00:30:05of time when it raises its head again and again.
00:30:07And, you know, we've got some of the greatest people in government
00:30:10to be able to address this, whether it's Boris Johnson,
00:30:33But I think you mentioned Macron. The fact is, yes, the parties, Labour and Tory party, were conspicuous by their silence on this particular issue.
00:30:47They just simply vacated the field. And at least the French, you know, Macron, and the French have always talked about cultural issues, I would suggest.
00:30:57um but i think that this is this is in a way is it not a microcosm this is these things are little
00:31:03little crunch moments are they not yes they are it's a drip drip effect and it continues to grow
00:31:10and you know we've but by the way peter this is not new this happened with salman rushdie i know
00:31:16and then it happened with the danish cartoons and then it's happened two or three other times at a
00:31:23much lower level and now it's happening again and the truth is it's i mean i i have friends who are
00:31:28played right that can't get their plays on each because they're somehow critical of islam never
00:31:33mind the prophet muhammad and the truth is the prophet when he called to mercy he called to
00:31:37kindness that someone urinated in his mosque he didn't care that get beyond it i mean islam's
00:31:42got to be bigger than this and more confident that if you can't take criticism that you're in
00:31:47the wrong religion you know islam and by the way muslims aren't victims for for a thousand four0.89
00:31:52hundred years muslims were conquerors you know so stop this kind of fake pretense of that oh you0.99
00:31:59know we're so offended by just a simple cartoon no let people have a hundred cartoons who cares0.99
00:32:04you know we're bigger than that we're stronger than that we're deeper than that and we can take
00:32:07the criticism um and you know the bigger issue here is that no cartoon should lead to a loss of1.00
00:32:13life and no cartoon should lead to the loss of freedom and that's the risk that the the muslims0.99
00:32:21being extremist Muslims at the helm of identity are being so intolerant that they are damaging0.98
00:32:28the cultural space in which we all operate and enjoy the freedoms that we do.1.00
00:32:35Yes, I would agree with that. I think the other point really to make there is that
00:32:39people often, the cartoon thing has been at the forefront. And so people say, why are you so
00:32:47obviously being provocative but as you mentioned there Salman Rushdie it's not really even a
00:32:52matter of aesthetic standards it's you know it's whether it's a very literary novel or as you
00:32:57mentioned a play or a film you know that people now will self-censor um Ed look thank you very
00:33:04very much uh for joining us I know you've got to go off to do one of your lectures I believe or
00:33:09something, in the huge heat there of Washington. But the book, again, is Among the Mosques,
00:33:18A Journey Across Muslim Britain. And the author is Ed Hussain. Ed, thank you very, very much.
00:33:27I do hope, when are you coming, when are you going to be back in Britain next?
00:33:32I'm back for a short period at the end of August and the very beginning of September. So we hope
00:33:37our paths cross Peter well I think if that's right if I'm thinking right that's about the time we
00:33:43we was we were just about to be going into into the next lockdown at that point and so
00:33:48so our paths may not cross we may not cross well thank you very very much indeed thank you thank
00:33:55you Peter god bless thank you bye-bye that's it for uh so what you're saying is this week uh
00:34:00please do remember to subscribe won't you and uh we shall see you next time thank you very much