New Culture Forum - August 23, 2021


Rod Liddle On BBC Bias & His Time As Editor Of Radio 4's Flagship Today Programme

A Journey Across Muslim Britain - Why Prof. Ed Husain Is Worried Online Safety Bill Is A Fundamental Threat To Free Speech & Must Be Opposed.

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

149.2

Word count

5,660

Sentence count

99


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Rod let me take you back to when you were a young journalist and you joined the BBC when you were
00:00:11 in your 20s I think is that right? Yeah that's right. What impression did you have of the BBC
00:00:18 in those days and did you feel proud joining that organisation? What were your expectations of the
00:00:24 bbc i felt very proud joining the bbc and excited to do so especially on a program such as a day
00:00:31 program which where i've been working which was in the labor party uh was regarded with awe
00:00:37 and i arrived there and it was very friendly um i was one of three people at that point
00:00:47 out of 46 who went to a state school and there had been there were five people there when I
00:00:55 when I joined who were at Eton and I just thought it would be interesting wouldn't it if I turned
00:01:01 up to this job and there were five people who'd gone to my comp in Middlesbrough so that it would
00:01:05 be a coincidence but they were very nice people haphazard dishevelled very old school and a very
00:01:16 agreeable place to work for a time of course you were coming from the left so they knew you'd come
00:01:21 from the labor party did you did it feel as if you were amongst friends in that sense did it feel
00:01:26 politically very uh agreeable to you no they were several several yards to the left of where i was
00:01:33 most of them uh i mean in a kind of not in and not when it came to financial issues but but in
00:01:39 in almost every social issue they were exactly as they are today um very agreeably bien pensant
00:01:49 and liberal on pretty much everything there were a couple of exceptions there was a rather gruff
00:01:56 and uh a pleasing man called francis halewood who uh was to the right of a soup spoon but uh
00:02:04 but other than that it was there was a unanimity of opinion did it surprise you at all going into
00:02:11 the bbc was it what you expected i tell you why it surprised me um and it was an interesting time
00:02:18 this was the late 80s um and i think that the the the cultures change in countries over time
00:02:28 um and i think that we were in the process then of the culture changing completely
00:02:34 both within the bbc within the judiciary within the church of england within all of our
00:02:44 institutions that's when the change was really taking place because if you go back to
00:02:48 the 70s the bbc would have been considered a conservative institution
00:02:54 um and certainly all the popular performers at the time all the people everybody liked you know
00:03:01 from uh jimmy tarbuck and the two ronnie's and morcom and wise and lulu uh were all conservatives
00:03:08 and the tilt of the agenda tended to be conservative it was criticized for such i
00:03:14 remember being outraged by the bbc and its attitude to punk rock well i was a punk rocker
00:03:19 the age of 15 16. um and it completely changed completely changed uh over the course of beginning
00:03:27 in the early 80s um it became i think margaret thatcher uh kind of helped the change along they
00:03:37 couldn't abide her no they couldn't they didn't get her they didn't get any more than they get
00:03:42 today why people are patriotic um why they like normal ordinary family life and faith and all that
00:03:51 kind of stuff they didn't get thatcher's appeal to the mass majority of the population they just
00:03:57 didn't get it i well remember that and there was a real animus against against thatcher yeah i mean
00:04:04 i think that showed in the journalism i don't know if you'd agree well without question i mean
00:04:10 when it came to the argument as to whose side you are margaret thatcher or the ira there was no
00:04:16 debate within the bbc we we think we have the right to put shin fein on air whenever we like
00:04:21 and you're censoring us her arguments simply didn't hold water they were querulous as well
00:04:26 and i guess this is also where it began because it did begin in those early 80s
00:04:30 um the falkland war uh where the bbc started getting very skeptical uh about the falkland
00:04:37 the BBC should be a bit sceptical
00:04:39 don't doubt that
00:04:41 but by the time we got into the 90s
00:04:44 the BBC was
00:04:47 moving further and further away
00:04:50 from the values
00:04:51 aspirations
00:04:52 and tastes
00:04:54 of the people who pay for its existence
00:04:57 do you put any
00:04:59 do you put any
00:05:00 credibility behind the idea of the
00:05:03 the so-called long march through the institutions
00:05:06 do you believe that is what has happened yes it's exactly what has happened uh good old gramsky he
00:05:12 was right uh it wasn't actually gramsky it was someone quoting gramsky i think but i forget
00:05:16 it was rudy deutsch it was rudy deutsch wasn't it that's right yes yeah yeah yeah
00:05:21 yes it's remarkable and it's happened it's happened not quite how it was envisaged
00:05:29 in that what has happened is that a very small coterie of people
00:05:34 has, over the course of 30 years,
00:05:38 continually invited into its environs
00:05:42 people who think exactly the same as itself
00:05:44 and that there are some opinions which are simply contraband
00:05:48 and you would not be allowed to express them
00:05:50 and therefore you don't get the job.
00:05:51 So it's been done in a kind of authoritarian way.
00:05:55 A lot of these jobs, of course,
00:05:56 are not the sort of jobs which are open for interview they are you are appointed if you look
00:06:02 at all of our uh quangos and major institutions uh you will find the same names cropping up over
00:06:11 and over again to the point where you can play a i would advise you if you're bored at christmas
00:06:17 to play this game which is six degrees of shami chakrabarti
00:06:21 that whatever position
00:06:23 in whatever quango or charity
00:06:25 you find, you could get to
00:06:27 Sharmi Chakrabarty in about two or three moves.
00:06:30 You know? And Sharmi
00:06:31 herself was on about four boards
00:06:33 and National Film Board
00:06:35 or something, you know?
00:06:37 What does she do about films?
00:06:39 Why?
00:06:41 Why? Why is Lord Hall
00:06:43 boss of the National Opera
00:06:44 and boss of the National Gallery?
00:06:47 How does this happen?
00:06:49 I'd like to do that.
00:06:51 I mean, so I met you actually on the Today programme back in the 80s, the first time.
00:06:57 We went to a gay wedding together.
00:06:59 We did, yes.
00:07:00 We went to a gay wedding together.
00:07:01 And I wondered, I mean, to me at that time, you seemed to be pretty much identikit lefty,
00:07:07 to me you seemed, because I was always someone who thought of myself as a conservative with a small c.
00:07:14 yeah and um so i saw you then as somebody who was just one of them but over time in the bbc
00:07:24 did you not see me laughing my head off at the gay wedding yeah i did i mean i remember the thing
00:07:29 i remember i i have a an absolutely distinct memory of the floral arch and the yes i mean it was it
00:07:36 was so camp you know it was it was baden-pale on stilts the whole thing it was brilliant
00:07:40 however uh that's by the by but the but the but um so you seem to me to fit in at that point but
00:07:49 you were i mean horrible expression but you were on a journey weren't you yourself a sort of
00:07:56 political journey yeah i mean how did that tell me it's difficult in truth even when i was a trot
00:08:04 you know back when i was 15 16 um i've always been left-wing on green issues and financial issues
00:08:14 but i've always had grave doubts on social issues even back when i was young
00:08:20 but because i was part of the labor party you know and part of the bbc these didn't seem to
00:08:27 be things which you could advance opinions about uh i can remember advancing opinions about
00:08:33 the legitimacy of abortion
00:08:36 and the horror,
00:08:40 that absolute horror
00:08:42 that was occasioned.
00:08:46 But it may be,
00:08:47 it may be
00:08:49 that the BBC itself
00:08:52 hastened me on that journey
00:08:54 because it just seems so grotesquely unfair,
00:08:58 so grotesquely biased.
00:09:00 and it's not as people sometimes say a left-wing bias it's it just isn't I didn't
00:09:07 you couldn't argue for example that the BBC gave Jeremy Corbyn an easy time
00:09:12 and indeed on financial issues I suppose it's logical say affluent middle-class people they
00:09:19 don't seem to be screaming for tax rises all the time you know
00:09:24 just on those social issues but I say just because au contraire Karl Marx this is not
00:09:33 false consciousness these things matter to people faith matters to people patriotism matters to
00:09:39 people they had no time whatsoever for that and it it made me angry and the the first signs of
00:09:47 anger i think what would have been the first i think clause 28 there was no debate about clause
00:09:57 28. i think clause 28 was right you know um now even the people who signed up to clause 28
00:10:08 such as michael portillo saying how ghastly of me i forgive me i think it was probably right
00:10:15 um because because i don't think we need our children taught
00:10:21 about the myriad sexual adventures which they will undoubtedly experience after the age of 16
00:10:31 leave them alone so it's not it's not it's not a moral moralistic position but you're saying that
00:10:37 it's a partly moralistic position because i also think at the same time that the best way
00:10:41 to raise a family to bring children into the world is with the biologically
00:10:48 genetically determined parents a man and a woman this isn't this isn't the church speaking this is
00:10:57 what science tells us that every single study that's ever been done tells us that this is the
00:11:02 best way and it seems to me wrong therefore to start inculcating into kids at a very early age
00:11:08 that now you can do something different to that go on you know you want to which of course we've
00:11:15 had an even greater fecundity over the last 15 to 20 years with the advent of those excellent
00:11:22 transgender people and within the BBC it has always seemed to me that there is an automatic
00:11:32 approval of
00:11:34 and
00:11:36 putting the weight behind
00:11:38 any campaign
00:11:40 which is transgressive
00:11:43 on these
00:11:44 social issues
00:11:45 this is what infuriated
00:11:48 and it still does
00:11:50 there will be an article
00:11:52 there will be a piece on the news
00:11:54 about
00:11:54 anti-abortion protests
00:11:58 in America
00:11:58 and it will come solely from
00:12:02 one perspective it will not even debate the issue as to whether they're right or not you won't even
00:12:07 hear the issue it's simply these people are victimizing women and they've got to be stopped
00:12:13 could this happen here we go to jennifer harridan from the organization you know women are cross
00:12:20 about everything and jennifer comes on and she says this could happen here uh and it's just
00:12:26 relentless and they never see the other side you just don't get the other side at all and yet all
00:12:35 this is within the context of the bbc's much trumpeted ethos of impartiality i mean how can
00:12:43 an organization which says um because it doesn't believe it's political robin it doesn't believe
00:12:50 it's political it simply thinks it's civilized and that civility uh extends to uh obviously the
00:13:01 europe issue where it simply thinks that we're little england as xenophobes rather than can make
00:13:08 a a decent case for why we might be better off outside the european union and it and it's also
00:13:17 a kind of vacant banal um identification with the underdog in every single case
00:13:25 uh and so that's what you get in foreign foreign coverage without question you know uh the bbc was
00:13:33 opposed to robert mcgarvey it was not remotely fair to robert mcgarvey good thing you might
00:13:39 argue but by the same context it's not remotely fair to israel not by any stretch of the imagination
00:13:45 and yet bbc journalists live and die by the idea of impartiality how is it they don't see
00:13:53 i mean well this is what richard tate do you remember the tate report i do um and he didn't
00:13:59 address the issue of bias enough but he did say that people have got to know they've got to try
00:14:05 to recognize their bias but but they don't see it as a bias they see it as decency it is this
00:14:12 liberal worldview it's incredibly arrogant that that it is decent and everybody else anyone who
00:14:19 disagrees with it is indecent beyond the pale they just they they do not see it as political
00:14:25 and it's unanimous you know i went to a a really enjoyable party for an old colleague
00:14:32 at the bbc uh and there were a hundred people there i was the only one who had voted for brexit
00:14:39 The only one. And it's the same on every issue. And they don't see it as political at all.
00:14:51 The Brexit issue, of course, is a particularly interesting one because Brexit, as we both know,
00:14:59 I mean, any working journalist in Britain over the past 30 years knows that actually that is the fault line,
00:15:05 which has run down right through the centre of British politics.
00:15:09 So it was an issue where an organisation,
00:15:12 which is the biggest journalistic organisation in the country
00:15:15 and the most important cultural organisation in the country,
00:15:20 should have been striving to do its level best
00:15:22 to make sure that on that issue,
00:15:25 both sides of the argument were properly represented,
00:15:27 but they weren't.
00:15:28 How does that happen?
00:15:30 Well, two things.
00:15:32 I think leading up to 2016,
00:15:35 in the short period leading up to 2016 they did their job I don't think they were bad
00:15:42 I think there was sufficient pressure coming on them to let them know that they had to be
00:15:49 seen to be neutral however in the years from 1992 to 2014 the opposite is the case there was
00:16:00 continued systematic bias against people who would call themselves euro realists
00:16:07 and at the time the opinion polls opinion polls were pretty clear most people until about
00:16:14 2010 wanted to stay in the eu but they didn't want the eu to get any bigger
00:16:20 and there was a good you know 30 who wanted to leave the bbc never reflected those views it
00:16:27 never reflected the views of the people who didn't want the EU to get bigger either and it
00:16:32 continually discriminated against people and there were studies you know Lord Pearson of Rannoch
00:16:38 did one such study and brought it to me and told me about it the amount of air time given to
00:16:46 Eurosceptic voices and I agreed with him and I took it to Anne Sloman and she said
00:16:52 you've got to understand, Rob, that these people are mad.
00:16:55 That was the view.
00:16:57 And everyone thought it.
00:17:00 It was a very funny time, I must tell you this.
00:17:03 We've got a different issue.
00:17:05 There was an American election coming up.
00:17:06 What would it be? 2000?
00:17:09 2000, I think.
00:17:10 And Mark Danizer, who was then head of news, I think,
00:17:15 invited us all into his office, all the editors of the programmes,
00:17:20 to give us a good, stern lecture.
00:17:22 about how we should avoid bias to either side
00:17:26 in this forthcoming US election.
00:17:28 And behind him on the wall, as we were sitting looking at him,
00:17:33 were posters for the Democratic Party
00:17:36 and campaigns which he had worked for the Democratic Party in.
00:17:43 This is beyond surreal, you know.
00:17:48 And on Europe, there was another report,
00:17:50 I forget what the name of the report was,
00:17:51 came out in 2000 you've written about it yeah that's right um uh which said yeah they were
00:17:55 biased they keep being told they're biased they keep saying we're not no not really of course
00:18:00 that's just pathetic the uh the bias against the republicans reached a new peak under trump
00:18:07 didn't it i mean what did you think of the way the bbc reported just the whole thing made me
00:18:13 actually vomit it wasn't just trump had i been in america in 2008 was it eight i think it was eight
00:18:22 i would probably have voted for barack obama you know um
00:18:29 but the way they greeted his victory the ejaculate flying around the studios you know
00:18:39 People dancing with joy.
00:18:43 It's just absurd.
00:18:47 I mean, they weren't alone.
00:18:48 You know, Obama got the Nobel Prize within about six weeks.
00:18:53 We're going to give him the Nobel Prize because he's black.
00:18:57 There's no other reason.
00:18:58 He hadn't done anything.
00:19:01 And then you compare it to Trump, where they were openly hostile all the way through,
00:19:07 all the way through his presidency.
00:19:08 and by god their their delight when joe biden won uh you could see it yes well you struck also by
00:19:17 the way that certain stories in the culmination of that campaign were set on like the the story
00:19:22 about the hunter biden story the hunter biden story was in fairness the hunter biden story was
00:19:28 sat on by the entire liberal establishment and far less worrying than the bbc sitting on it
00:19:34 because I don't know how much traction it would have got over here.
00:19:36 But, you know, Google, Facebook, Twitter, all sitting on it
00:19:46 and banning anyone from commenting on it.
00:19:50 That raises an interesting point.
00:19:52 To what extent do you see the BBC as, it were,
00:19:57 part of a big media liberal cartel?
00:20:01 I mean, do you think that the BBC shows any independence of mind or thought
00:20:08 when it comes to this sort of issue like the BLM issue or like the Trump issue?
00:20:12 Has the BBC acquitted itself any better than any of the rest of them?
00:20:17 No, no, the BBC is exactly the same as the rest of them.
00:20:22 you know liberal arts grads by and large who share a single world view which they don't think
00:20:31 is political but which is okaron within cnn you know the new york the worst newspaper in the world
00:20:39 the new york times an appalling appalling newspaper and also the big tech social media
00:20:48 companies they are all of the same opinion and it's getting dangerous because they are censoring
00:20:54 stuff um and this is bad you know they shouldn't be doing that uh some of the censoring which has
00:21:01 been done by the big tech companies is truly chilling and i think we saw with the defeat of
00:21:07 trump who i would never have voted for uh with the defeat of donald trump that this is the first time
00:21:12 election has actually been gerrymandered and won by a liberal elite in charge of
00:21:22 communications organizations it was a it was interesting wasn't it the alacrity with which
00:21:29 the bbc after the election was held dismissed any idea that there had been voting irregularities i
00:21:38 I think they probably weren't voting irregularities, or not many.
00:21:41 No.
00:21:42 But, no, they had no interest whatsoever in doing that story.
00:21:46 None at all.
00:21:48 And BLM?
00:21:49 It's pretty shocking, and we've got to get to grips with it,
00:21:53 because this isn't on the BBC.
00:21:56 It's more on the other institutions supported by the BBC,
00:22:00 because this could happen here, you know?
00:22:02 um on blm the b the bbc was entirely uncritical of blm and i think the bbc stance on blm helped
00:22:13 to persuade organizations led by fabulously stupid people such as the football association
00:22:23 um that they should too should be totally uncritical of blm and so they all went along
00:22:30 with it and so we have every single time a football game is played and players take a knee
00:22:36 the crowd boos every single time they do not get it you know these people do not get how repellent
00:22:46 we find BLM tell me um how widespread do you think disaffection is with the BBC now I mean
00:22:56 you know we're talking as people who have both worked for the organization and been long-standing
00:23:01 critics of it publicly so you know we are like-minded to a certain extent about that
00:23:06 but do you think that the do you think this sense of distrust of the bbc has filtered down into
00:23:14 um the minds of you know the average person do you think it is doing it is doing it's a long
00:23:23 process um but you're beginning to see it more and more and the obvious way you're beginning to
00:23:28 see it is the growth of independent commercial stations which do not take the the view of the
00:23:36 bbc so you know gbtv for example is going to be popular um there's also talk radio which is is
00:23:46 the fastest growing radio station in europe and shooting up like that uh i don't think you'd get
00:23:53 that if there was a general satisfaction with with the way the bbc presented itself and some people
00:23:59 are refusing to pay their license and some people are refusing to pay their license fee yeah how
00:24:03 serious a threat to the bbc do you think all that is it's difficult it changes by the months i think
00:24:14 if you went back 14 months to february 2020 i think there was a genuine um assault on the bbc
00:24:25 partly from within the public not wanting to pay its license fee you just had the debark of
00:24:32 last night of the proms and you had an incoming government which was uh explicitly hostile
00:24:41 to the BBC with Dominic Cummings and people like that and the resignation of Tony Hall
00:24:48 and the resignation of Sarah Sands the editor of the Today programme you could see
00:24:53 a kind of end in sight. Covid comes along and I think the BBC for the first four months of Covid
00:25:00 didn't do a bad job. I think people suddenly remembered ah sometimes it can bring the country
00:25:06 together and i think it did do that a little bit blm comes along however and shatters that
00:25:14 myth that perhaps it's got the interest of the people at heart so i think we're probably now
00:25:20 after the uh the panorama uh imbroglio and um martin bashir who i never thought was much cop
00:25:29 if i'm honest um but there we are um i think we're pretty much back at where we were in february 2020
00:25:35 I mean, you mentioned the COVID coverage.
00:25:40 And like you, I thought that at the start of that, in fact, the BBC rediscovered what public service broadcasting is.
00:25:47 Yeah, that's right.
00:25:48 That's not a phrase you hear so often these days.
00:25:51 But there is, I don't know if you'd agree with me, but do you think there is a, do you think that the ideal of public service broadcasting,
00:26:01 The ideal of having an impartial, news-gathering, journalistic organisation is a worthwhile one and a good one?
00:26:09 Yes, I'm a social democrat. Of course I do. I think it's a great thing to have.
00:26:14 But its problem is that it's hamstrung by this notion that it has to be neutral.
00:26:20 And under the cloak of that neutrality, it is not neutral.
00:26:23 um and and so what you need to do is to encourage bbc staff to tell us what their political opinions
00:26:33 are and then we can see how well balanced it is and what way do they vote um because what you need
00:26:43 is a thousand flowers blooming what you need is what i tried to do on the today program by
00:26:49 hiring a reactionary old
00:26:51 tosser like you Robin if I may say
00:26:53 so and indeed
00:26:54 Patrick Mercer and
00:26:56 indeed Michael Gove at one point
00:26:58 there has to
00:27:03 be a multiplicity of opinion
00:27:05 yes and
00:27:06 that was such a refreshing thing for me
00:27:09 actually when I joined your team
00:27:11 on today
00:27:11 because it was
00:27:15 the first time I think that
00:27:16 I'd worked on a programme at the BBC
00:27:19 where there was an openness to a journalistic inquiry
00:27:26 which wasn't running on the liberal tram lines.
00:27:29 No, that's right.
00:27:30 That was the point of it, really.
00:27:31 Absolutely vital.
00:27:33 Absolutely vital.
00:27:33 And if you're a journalist, you have to be interested in all that.
00:27:40 You have to try to see the other side
00:27:42 and try to see the very left-wing side of issues as well.
00:27:46 Indeed.
00:27:47 I've never been able to do that.
00:27:49 I mean you handled in your time as an editor
00:27:57 a lot of BBC
00:27:58 very good BBC reporters
00:28:01 this question of impartiality
00:28:05 I wonder if it comes down to this
00:28:07 I mean how
00:28:08 can you expect people
00:28:11 who are national
00:28:13 journalists at a national level
00:28:14 people who know the trade
00:28:17 inside out and have done their time most of them have strong opinions don't they about things they
00:28:23 have strong personal opinions yes and they know their stuff they know their stuff is it realistic
00:28:29 to expect um people to be impartial no no it's a it's a delusion it's an utter delusion it's
00:28:35 always been a delusion the tony hall quote i think was that we expect that when people come
00:28:43 into the bbc they will hang their opinions up on a coat rack i don't think there's a
00:28:50 coat rack big enough for emily mateless you know i you know where's she gonna store all her stuff
00:28:56 um she'd have to hire somewhere no of course it's a delusion it's a delusion and but it's
00:29:03 a comfortable delusion because it enables them to say no no we leave our opinions at the door
00:29:09 but you don't you don't in story selection in the way it's reported in the tone of delivery
00:29:16 not remotely and in the diversity of opinion amongst the diversity well that's the crucial
00:29:22 thing there needs to be diversity of opinion among the staff that means to a certain degree
00:29:27 also a diversity of class background amongst the staff which there certainly is not uh but also
00:29:33 so um you know just just people with different views i know one lad who works for one of the
00:29:41 bbc's top journalistic programs who is in perpetual fear because he's right of center
00:29:49 you know i'm sure you like me have had this experience though i've written stuff you know
00:29:56 often very critical of the bbc and then i'll get an email from someone you know who's senior at
00:30:03 the BBC still an on-air personality knows their stuff saying right on you know you've got that
00:30:09 right yeah there's a lot of people aren't there in the BBC itself at quite senior positions who
00:30:14 actually would not reject what you're saying as nonsense but would actually privately agree with
00:30:20 you I think they would there will always be resistance though to the stating of political
00:30:24 views you know I wouldn't have a problem if Emily make this for example you see obvious example of
00:30:32 of someone who's who's clearly politically on on the liberal left um uh despite the public
00:30:40 school education of her children obviously um i wouldn't mind if she promulgated those views
00:30:47 regularly i i wouldn't care because it would mean that news night would then have to get in someone
00:30:53 to present the program who put a different perspective in order to provide that balance
00:30:59 you know
00:31:01 so look at the future now
00:31:04 we've got
00:31:04 we're just in the
00:31:07 we're just
00:31:08 in the aftermath of the Martin Bashir
00:31:11 scandal and the dust is still
00:31:13 settling to a certain extent on that
00:31:15 do you think
00:31:17 there is going to be
00:31:19 change at the BBC
00:31:20 and if so
00:31:23 how do you think it can be enforced
00:31:25 I think we are
00:31:26 I'm more optimistic
00:31:31 than most people on this
00:31:32 I think there's a good
00:31:35 new director general in charge
00:31:37 who I think gets it
00:31:39 I think he gets it
00:31:40 and all that prevaricating over
00:31:43 last night at the prongs
00:31:46 sorted like that
00:31:48 all that lying that Tony Hall did
00:31:51 which was lying
00:31:52 it was lying
00:31:53 I'm blaming the poor conductress
00:31:57 so he gets it
00:32:00 I think in tandem with that
00:32:04 there are two other things
00:32:06 first is the growth of independent channels
00:32:09 which will put a different point of view
00:32:11 which makes it clearer to the public
00:32:13 that the BBC is one view
00:32:15 and thirdly we've got a government
00:32:18 which has had enough
00:32:19 now it's not turned its guns on the BBC just yet
00:32:23 But you're seeing with Liz Truss and the defenestration, thank the Lord of Stonewall, and in the judicial decision about the Tavistock Clinic, you're seeing a bit of a change.
00:32:39 you're seeing a change in tone and so i think those things together may impress upon the bbc
00:32:46 the need to face reality and which is to ensure that it represents the values of all of its
00:32:56 audience rather than just those who live in kensel green it's a matter of self it's a matter
00:33:02 of self-preservation to a certain extent isn't it absolutely it is yeah because otherwise it
00:33:06 won't have a license for it where would you stand on so if i was to ask you then you know bbc keep
00:33:14 it and reform it or scrap it all together what do you think i'd prefer to see it reformed
00:33:21 whether it can be reformed is another issue i think the next two years are crucial if tim
00:33:26 can affect real change then i think it might be worth having a bbc which which is a public
00:33:32 service broadcaster um but it's a tall order and i don't fancy his job one bit um yes the the the
00:33:42 idea of uh reform at the bbc um if that is to have any if that is to be made a reality it's going to
00:33:54 meet a change of personnel isn't it yeah well you see i think they should have made andrew neil paul
00:33:59 dacre or trevor phillips uh chairman you know and i said i think what they've got to do is look at
00:34:06 the board the board of the bbc is one of the first places you should go to if you ever want to play
00:34:11 six degrees of shami chakrabarti they are all i mean there are people out there i have no idea
00:34:17 what their interest in broadcasting is but they all have the same view get rid you need a board
00:34:25 which which will react with fury when they see uh biased coverage not one which merely
00:34:35 sort of is emollient one thing that stands in the way of reform i think is is that politicians
00:34:42 by and large are frightened of the bbc less so than they were you think yeah far less so than they
00:34:48 were and I think the BBC understands that as well and I think it understands its vulnerability now
00:34:56 more than it did but increasingly this government looks as if it is prepared to take on stuff which
00:35:07 will find a voice with kind of what you might call populism. One of the things that disarms
00:35:13 the critics of the BBC to a certain extent is that I think most of us, probably 90% of
00:35:20 the population, will have at least one warm memory of the BBC, yes?
00:35:27 So the point is that we've all enjoyed programmes that the BBC have produced and we can all
00:35:32 look at things and say this is a programme which probably no one else would have produced
00:35:39 or produced as well as the BBC has done.
00:35:42 so the thing is that there is a core of value there isn't there is a real value there i can
00:35:48 remember listening to the i think it was the the last it was the last presidential election in the
00:35:54 united states and they sent jim nocte to do a piece in uh i think in the rust belt uh and it
00:36:01 was superb journalism you know it and it's what jim does best of all uh on the hoof journalism
00:36:07 and i thought i don't think anyone else would either have the money because of course money
00:36:12 is a big issue uh or maybe the inclination to do journalism with that level of of intelligence
00:36:20 and reportage um and yeah i you see i think the bbc is for those reasons valuable but i find myself
00:36:27 in a dwindling minority amongst friends you know even people who two or three years ago would have
00:36:33 said to me well we need to keep the bbc and now say no scrap it get rid of it get rid of the
00:36:37 license fee a final question yeah i mean you have been a very virulent at times public critic of the
00:36:45 bbc um has the bbc ever engaged with you um in these terms about reform and what needs to be
00:36:54 done i only ask because i'm in the sort of similar position although less uh prominent than you but
00:37:01 but they've never actually engaged with me.
00:37:05 And I see myself as a reasonable critic of the BBC,
00:37:09 not someone who wishes to destroy the organisation,
00:37:11 but wishes it to reform.
00:37:13 But I think there's a reluctance in the BBC
00:37:16 to actually engage with critics.
00:37:18 Robin, they think we're mad.
00:37:20 They do. They think we're mad.
00:37:22 They think we're wrong and we're mad.
00:37:24 And they are in that bubble
00:37:25 where everyone thinks the same as them.
00:37:28 And then they will go onto their Twitter feeds
00:37:29 where they are followed by people who think the same as them and they think this is the country
00:37:34 and it's not the country it's kensel green you know it really is they think we're mad and wrong
00:37:41 and that they have the public with them and they don't rod little thank you