New Culture Forum - September 13, 2021


Online Safety Bill Is A Fundamental Threat To Free Speech & Must Be Opposed.

Rod Liddle On BBC Bias & His Time As Editor Of Radio 4's Flagship Today Programme Jeremy Black on James Bond - A British Icon - Is Today's James Bond Still James Bond?

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

147.37

Word count

5,527

Sentence count

233


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittall.
00:00:28 Now on this show over the past year we've talked an awful lot about free speech and the decline
00:00:35 in free expression and indeed what we should do about it. In fact it's the question
00:00:42 that most people ask. They're on side with all the arguments but what actually do we do to preserve
00:00:49 free speech in this society. Now I'm very pleased today that my guest is the barrister Francis
00:00:55 Tor. Francis specializes in public law and employment law. He's just written a report,
00:01:02 which was commissioned by Lawrence Fox's Reclaim Party, and it's in protection of freedom of speech,
00:01:09 a legal analysis. This is the report here. And basically, it is looking at what we can do
00:01:16 legally to make sure that free speech in our country remains intact. Thank you very much for
00:01:23 coming thank you for having me pleasure to be here before we look at the actual report it is
00:01:28 extraordinary it's not that we're even talking about how we might protect something which we
00:01:34 took for granted for generations and when you uh talk in the report you you mention how you know
00:01:43 free speech is at the absolute basis of a democratic liberal society such as ours but
00:01:49 And it's right to say, is it not, that the basic idea behind your report is that free speech should be enshrined in some way in our legal system.
00:02:00 Yes, I wouldn't say.
00:02:03 So I think that there is another question, which is whether or not we should have what's called a written constitution, really a codified constitution, one constitutional document.
00:02:13 And that isn't a question that I address in the report.
00:02:17 And there are a number of proposals, six proposals that we make. They're all proposals to change the law. But I think what I would say about that is that what the last 18 months, I think, has shown in general terms is that in every country around the world is that whatever constitutional settlement you have, all of them ultimately depend on the culture behind it and human beings who are in a position to protect it.
00:02:47 protect fundamental rights.
00:02:50 And however well constructed your constitution is
00:02:53 and however nominally fair it might be,
00:02:55 and remember the Soviets had a constitution
00:02:57 that on its face gave all sorts of freedoms
00:03:00 to the people and the republics of the Soviet Union,
00:03:04 that however good that is,
00:03:06 it's always reliant on human beings.
00:03:09 So I would draw back from saying that we want,
00:03:13 that the proposal behind the report
00:03:16 was to enshrine anything other than of course legal changes of course are enshrined in law by
00:03:23 definition and say that what really is needed is a change in culture and a culture which recognizes
00:03:33 that freedom and free speech in particular the freedom of expression is at the outset I think I
00:03:40 say at the beginning and I think this is important you say democratic but it goes much further than
00:03:45 It goes further back than that, and expression is behind all constitutes, all developments, scientific, in the arts, everything really, behind human beings, and it's about the expression of ideas. Without the expression of ideas, nothing would happen. Civilisation itself is based on the expression of ideas.
00:04:07 Right. I think what struck me about it is that, well, actually, this is a quite massive area,
00:04:14 but you've been really quite concentrated in the report in two areas.
00:04:18 I mean, there's, broadly speaking, I think I'm correct in saying this, to do with hate crime.
00:04:24 But then the other side as well is, which is connected, of course,
00:04:28 is that it is in some ways a response to this online safety bill that the government is putting through.
00:04:36 Before we talk about what you're saying in here, what actually is the government, what is the essence of this bill, the online safety bill, that this opposes?
00:04:48 The essence of the bill, there's a concept called safetyism, which isn't my word.
00:04:54 It's the word of some Northern American academics describing particularly the change in culture, as I say in culture, the culture of suppression of free speech.
00:05:05 in alliance with what is perceived to be people's safety.
00:05:09 And it's interesting that originally the Online Harms Bill
00:05:13 was renamed the Online Safety Bill,
00:05:16 and that's an interesting example of how that culture of safetyism
00:05:20 has been built in.
00:05:22 And what the bill proposes is that any website
00:05:27 that has fulfilled specific criteria,
00:05:31 which would include all the social media companies,
00:05:33 or the major social media companies would have a duty of care not to any particular individual
00:05:40 but a duty to remove any material that could cause an adult of reasonable sensibilities
00:05:48 serious harm and that can be physical or more likely psychological you think about
00:05:55 great literature and you think about political ideas, it is very, very easy to see that that
00:06:05 could involve a vast weight, a vast amount of speech and novels and ideas, scientific
00:06:16 ideas and so on, quite possibly including ideas about scientific innovation or criticisms
00:06:24 of scientific ideas which the state might say are harmful and we see plenty of examples of that
00:06:32 in the suppression by social media companies already of peer-reviewed scientific ideas which
00:06:41 are contrary to what those social media companies like to promote. So it's extremely dangerous and
00:06:49 In fact, although, as you say, there were proposals in the report,
00:06:53 for me the most fundamental threat to freedom of speech
00:06:57 is perhaps that online safety bill, utterly pernicious and very dangerous.
00:07:02 What stage is that at at the moment?
00:07:04 It's at the stage, so it's about to go into its second reading,
00:07:08 which is the first time the principle of the debate
00:07:12 is put before both Houses of Parliament,
00:07:15 or each House of Parliament in turn,
00:07:17 I think in the House of Commons first, although it may possibly be in the House of Lords.
00:07:22 Then it will go into committee, which will be probably in this case not a committee of the whole House,
00:07:27 a select standing committee to reflect the balance of the House,
00:07:31 which will debate particular clauses, and then it will come back for its final third reading,
00:07:36 whether the bill is approved or not by each House of Parliament in turn.
00:07:39 What is this? How do they define harm?
00:07:44 You mentioned this word harm. My cause harm.
00:07:46 Well, you know, in sort of the layman's speech, my speech, you know, it seems to me that it's about words, whereas maybe once before it was just actions, you know, that six and stones can break my bones, you know, names can never hurt me.
00:08:02 But this is now becoming, this is sort of enshrining in law, isn't it, or integrating into law this idea that harm is what?
00:08:11 To someone's, what, mental well-being?
00:08:14 What would it be?
00:08:15 The key answer is they don't. They do not define harm, save that it is something that an adult of reasonable sensibilities could cause an adult of reasonable sensibilities serious harm.
00:08:28 It is simply not defined. And that's the most dangerous part of this.
00:08:32 Because as I set out in the report, the proposal that is made in the report is for social medias rather than be forced to censor, be forced not to censor, save where there is a defined criminal offence or civil harm.
00:08:51 And there are provisions in our recommendations that give the right of social media to companies to withdraw statements where they may.
00:09:02 There is reasonable suspicion that they may cause civil wrongs or criminal harms while they investigate.
00:09:10 But if they find that they do not, they must put them back on social media platforms.
00:09:14 Now, I fully accept that that may be difficult to implement, but it at least relies upon the certainty that in both the criminal law and the civil law of what is a civil harm, libel, for example, is an example, personal injury, potentially, although it's difficult to conceive of how it might be caused by simply words in social media companies,
00:09:42 and criminal offences which are deliberately set out in the report,
00:09:46 the very large number of criminal offences that might be committed
00:09:49 by individuals on the internet, all clear, defined things.
00:09:54 And there's always going to be some degree of uncertainty.
00:09:56 Do you fit within this criminal definition or not?
00:09:59 But the whole point of the criminal law, especially in a common law country
00:10:03 like the United Kingdom where we have, where criminal offences
00:10:09 as defined by statute, is to make them clear.
00:10:13 And then if there is a lack of clarity,
00:10:15 the courts often have case law to clarify what is meant
00:10:19 and that that case law can evolve to encompass social laws,
00:10:23 which is the benefit of the common law system.
00:10:25 But there's certainty there.
00:10:27 And there's absolutely no certainty in this bill.
00:10:30 So I think one of your suggestions in here,
00:10:34 one of your proposals,
00:10:34 is that this online safety bill should be just opposed, you know.
00:10:41 Totally.
00:10:41 You know, hook, line, sinker. Is that right?
00:10:44 Yes.
00:10:45 You know, this might seem, again, unsophisticated question,
00:10:49 but how can people who feel strongly about this,
00:10:53 how can they oppose at the moment, Francis?
00:10:56 If it's going through these stages and it's going through committees,
00:11:00 what is the best thing they can do?
00:11:02 Is it a question of just writing to MPs, your MP, to sort of point out the jeopardy here or what?
00:11:10 Well, it's certainly that. And that does matter because that is something that every constituent can do.
00:11:20 It's clearly not going to be enough in itself.
00:11:23 and what is also needed is more people in the public eye,
00:11:28 both politicians, commentators, journalists,
00:11:31 and perhaps people from scientific backgrounds,
00:11:36 from backgrounds in the arts.
00:11:37 I mean, remember Rowan Atkinson has been a famous campaigner
00:11:40 for freedom of speech.
00:11:42 We need more of that.
00:11:43 We need this to be much more in the public eye
00:11:46 because it's only if the government is forced to recognise
00:11:49 that it's supposedly a liberal conservative government,
00:11:53 both in small cases and nominally a conservative government.
00:12:00 And conservative doesn't just mean we respect tradition.
00:12:03 It means we respect the traditions that build up and are behind this United Kingdom and England in the past and Scotland in the past.
00:12:11 One, a central part of which is expressed in the Bill of Rights 1689, which expresses ancient liberties, which include the liberty to petition the king, that is to say, to make any argument before the civil authority, before the government.
00:12:30 and that's an essential expression of our freedom of expression
00:12:36 which has been recognised as it happens recently.
00:12:38 It's not just an old statute, it's been recognised in very recent case law
00:12:42 as being the background behind what is now Article 10
00:12:46 of the European Convention of Human Rights
00:12:47 and Article 9 which accompanies it, which protects the freedom of conscience.
00:12:51 I think I go into the report to say that the recognition of the protection
00:12:59 of freedom of conscience, perhaps prefigures freedom of speech
00:13:02 by 150 years or so, Thomas More famously standing for that,
00:13:08 but at the same time persecuting heretics.
00:13:10 So the idea that was still there in that era,
00:13:14 the late medieval early Renaissance era,
00:13:17 not quite the idea of freedom of speech, but it was developing.
00:13:21 And even at that stage, we had elections that were free
00:13:26 and people had the freedom to petition Parliament.
00:13:29 Parliament was originally, the House of Commons was formed
00:13:31 to enable the people to petition the king.
00:13:34 So these are ancient liberties,
00:13:36 and that's reflected in many other European,
00:13:39 especially European countries.
00:13:41 Ancient liberties.
00:13:42 So it's not really a case, is it,
00:13:44 of trying to develop some kind of version of the First Amendment, is it?
00:13:49 We had this, you say, the 1689 Bill of Rights,
00:13:53 which I think only applied to MPs, didn't it?
00:13:55 I don't think that's right, because it gives the right of petition to the crown for anyone.
00:14:03 And petition means the right to speak freely to the crown.
00:14:07 It doesn't just mean a written petition.
00:14:10 It's been defined quite rightly, far more widely than that.
00:14:14 And it was accepted at the time that it was more widely than that.
00:14:17 It's the right to go to outside parliament and protest.
00:14:20 It's the right to write to the government representatives of the crown.
00:14:25 It's the right to make expressions of opposition to the king.
00:14:31 I mean, I accept that it perhaps on one view is a little bit more limited than that.
00:14:35 But that is the ethos, that is the cultural ethos that is behind it.
00:14:40 Another crucial area here is the one of what have become known as non-crime hate incidents.
00:14:48 I know a bit about this myself, having been on the London Assembly.
00:14:51 This came up all the time, particularly the case of Harry Miller, who's been on this channel.
00:14:56 But this is where the police can record something which doesn't quite get to be a crime, but which they suspect was motivated by, in their words, hatred.
00:15:07 What is your proposal in the report about that situation?
00:15:10 The proposal there is to withdraw all guidelines that allow the police to record incidents that are not, at least there is not a reasonable suspicion that they are criminal offences.
00:15:24 So the whole concept of non-crime hate incidents, I think is how it's put, is utterly flawed and dangerous.
00:15:34 Now, of course, that is not to say that police don't, police forces don't, when there is a real reason to be concerned that somebody might have dangerous tendencies to create intelligence upon that person.
00:15:50 But the idea that they can have an entire can target somebody like Harry Miller, purely for saying things that other people found uncomfortable, but reflect, he would say, at least biological reality and also are held by a large numbers of people, opinions held by large numbers of people, albeit other people find them hurtful.
00:16:14 To say that the police can investigate him is entirely wrong. High Court found on his favour on that point. On the other more perhaps broader issue and more important issue potentially, which is before the Court of Appeal at the moment as it happens, the question is, is it lawful, and it's still not being decided by the Court of Appeal, is it lawful to be able to record incidents which are not criminal offences,
00:16:42 where there is no other operational reasons to do so.
00:16:47 And in my view, that is entirely wrong.
00:16:50 I would say unlawful too, and should be struck down by the Court of Appeal.
00:16:54 But if it isn't, then the suggestion is that the statute should intervene and change that.
00:16:59 So it would need legislative change, because this is guidance, isn't it?
00:17:04 This is not exactly, this is not sort of like a law, it is police guidance.
00:17:08 It itself is guidance. So this is why the Court of Appeal found against, because Mr Justice Knowles found that there was not any direct effect, essentially, for the police recording the non-hate crime incident.
00:17:31 However, that's not, I suggest, correct, because in fact, the result of that is that if that person wanted to work with children or vulnerable adults, the safeguarding process, which is understandable, but has been implemented in what I think is quite a dangerous way that attacks the presumption of innocence.
00:17:57 No one can understand when one is protecting children and vulnerable adults that one needs to decide on a basis that's not just a criminal conviction.
00:18:06 So I understand that. But in some cases in the past, it's been the case that even if you cannot disprove that you committed a particular offence,
00:18:17 that must stay on your record and may be taken into account by the safeguarding reviewers.
00:18:28 So it does have a direct effect, potentially, on people like Harry Miller who have that recorded against them.
00:18:35 This was a case, obviously, just in case you don't remember, where Harry Miller liked some tweets
00:18:42 that were, somebody thought, transphobic. It was as simple as that.
00:18:47 And the police turned up, didn't they, and said, we need to check your thinking.
00:18:52 I mean, quite, quite chilling, actually, and extraordinary.
00:18:58 One thing...
00:18:59 And sorry, just sorry to interrupt, but also that offends against the Thomas More principle of liberty of conscience,
00:19:06 let alone liberty of thought. We have to check your thinking. Sorry.
00:19:10 You specialise, don't you, as one in employment, and there's a lot to do with employment.
00:19:15 There is this phenomenon now of people, I think it's one very recently, actually,
00:19:21 a guy lost his job because he said something about Sharia law.
00:19:26 And I don't know what the position is in his case.
00:19:31 But first of all, is this a growing phenomenon of people actually maybe losing their job
00:19:37 because of something they've said on social media?
00:19:40 I mean, we hear it in the paper, but how widespread is this now?
00:19:44 It's very difficult to know definitively because we can see legal cases and cases that make the media such as that one.
00:19:54 The big legal case here is the case of Maya Forstadter,
00:19:58 another case where Ms Forstadter was making points about her belief in the reality of biology
00:20:07 and that it's not appropriate to define things in terms of gender
00:20:13 but in terms of sex which is immutable and she lost in the employment tribunal but won in the
00:20:19 employment appeal tribunal won her argument that she had a philosophical belief that was that was
00:20:28 worthy of protection and that is actually a protected characteristic under the 2010
00:20:32 equality act and therefore because she was in an employment dispute rather than
00:20:40 before a public body which was trying to suppress her speech,
00:20:46 it was more difficult for her directly to rely on human rights
00:20:52 because the Human Rights Act protects directly your rights as against public authorities.
00:20:58 It's more difficult in an employment relationship to rely on that.
00:21:02 The Equality Act helps to the extent that it creates this philosophical belief exception.
00:21:07 and that's good and it's very good that for starter was decided in that way my difficulty
00:21:14 with that is that i suggest that in fact rather than treating it as a a positive characteristic
00:21:23 your belief really what should be protected and protected directly is your right to freedom of
00:21:29 expression and although that gives a certain amount of freedom of expression for people who
00:21:34 can say I have this detailed philosophical belief it's not as absolute as that and it needs to be
00:21:40 clearer and I've suggested in the report that we treat that in the same way that we treat
00:21:46 discrimination against people so if you are being treated less favorably because of your expression
00:21:53 that that is a right that you can be enforced now not absolutely there will be circumstances
00:22:00 is where your employer can say, for example, it wants to restrict what you say within the
00:22:05 workplace. You might be in, for example, a place of ethnic tensions or sectarian tensions.
00:22:10 It might be Northern Ireland. You might want to stop people wearing Celtic shirts or Rangers
00:22:14 shirts because it causes literally fights. And that's understandable. But when you're
00:22:19 outside of your work or you're, for example, you're an army officer or a police officer
00:22:24 and you can't speak because there are good policy reasons for it. But otherwise, when
00:22:28 you're outside of your workplace, you should not be able to be treated less favourably
00:22:33 because of what you say.
00:22:35 So that actually would be something specific you would have to introduce?
00:22:39 Yes, it would be. It would be a change to employment law, yes. It would have to be.
00:22:43 When it comes generally to hate speech, it seems to me that, and I don't think this is
00:22:49 in the report actually, but I just would like your view on it. It seems to me that so much
00:22:55 of the problem, whether it's non-crime hate instance or indeed whether it is just a supposed
00:23:01 hate crime, comes from this original definition that this is a offensive or whatever in the eyes
00:23:11 of the victim. It's totally subjective or indeed anybody else as the wording goes. And this came
00:23:21 from the MacPherson Report, I think, back 25 years, 30 years ago. And this seems to me to be
00:23:29 the very crux of so much of this. It gives people just carte blanche, just to be offended. And also
00:23:36 for that matter, you don't even have to have seen the thing happening, whether it's online or
00:23:41 whether indeed if it's a physical act happening out on the street. I mean, would you say that
00:23:48 that is something that needs to be reformed?
00:23:51 I think it is.
00:23:53 I don't think it's in here, is it?
00:23:54 It's not, although it's sort of hinted at to an extent.
00:23:58 But I think the way I'd approach it is this.
00:24:01 What happened with Stephen Lawrence
00:24:04 and what Sir William Macpherson clearly was looking at
00:24:09 and many others, including the now Archbishop of York
00:24:12 in that committee, was a terrible situation
00:24:15 with the police force in London
00:24:16 where there was clear evidence of institutional racism, which they found.
00:24:21 The difficulty is that one of the solutions that they came up with,
00:24:27 which was that the police in investigating should treat at face value
00:24:33 what the victim says when they are investigating,
00:24:37 was understandable to the extent that it meant that they treated all alleged victims,
00:24:44 alleged victims, complainants and witnesses with respect, that is understandable.
00:24:52 But I think what the problem with it, and indeed the problem that is identified in the
00:24:58 Henriquez report, because this is something that goes wider than freedom of speech, it
00:25:01 affects the right to the presumption of innocence, which is another central cardinal value in
00:25:08 our legal system, which, albeit not perhaps put into practical effect as much as it was
00:25:14 in theory, is something with many, many hundreds of years
00:25:18 of antecedents too, and therefore is critical.
00:25:23 And what has happened is that police forces
00:25:29 have literally gone about their investigative role
00:25:35 by saying, we accept you, Nick,
00:25:39 who was a liar who's now in prison for many years
00:25:41 and was behind the destruction of people's lives.
00:25:46 He followed Britain to his death.
00:25:49 Oh, this is the...
00:25:51 Glamour and so on, all the sex offences,
00:25:55 and Edward Heath was effectively tried as a corpse,
00:25:59 and it was an astonishing period,
00:26:02 which Mr Justice Henriquez in that report recognised,
00:26:06 and how to what extent that it has really changed
00:26:10 the culture of the police, I do not know,
00:26:12 but that is very closely connected
00:26:14 to the non-crime hate incident.
00:26:18 Yes, of course, police officers
00:26:20 should always treat any witness with respect,
00:26:24 but they should not treat them as a matter of fact,
00:26:29 as a victim.
00:26:30 They're not a victim unless they are found
00:26:32 to be a victim by court.
00:26:33 Now, it may well be that they need to be effectively
00:26:36 treated as a victim from a postural point of view
00:26:39 by the police.
00:26:40 But not as a witness. Police officers are not doing their job if they assume at face value what they're being told.
00:26:49 They have a duty to investigate it, a duty to the defendant, but it's also a duty to society because it's an offence against society to convict people wrongly.
00:27:00 And it's an offence against society to remove the right to the presumption of innocence.
00:27:06 Yes. In fact, the language they use is indeed that. They talk about the victim. That's officially sanctioned language. It would be right to call them the complainant, because the victim already is setting up, isn't it, an assumption, presumption.
00:27:24 would you therefore say that
00:27:27 and I know that we've digressed
00:27:29 but would you therefore say that
00:27:30 it's basically being
00:27:33 misinterpreted in a dangerous way
00:27:35 should it therefore
00:27:36 should that subjectivity be taken out
00:27:39 of that definition
00:27:40 it's interesting
00:27:43 I started out my practice
00:27:45 as a barrister in the magistrates court
00:27:47 and I can tell you that word victim was used
00:27:49 routinely by the CPS
00:27:51 in prosecuting offences
00:27:52 and that was the then and probably for many, many years before then
00:27:57 and probably now was the ethos that they were prosecuting on behalf of victims.
00:28:04 But a prosecutor has a duty as a minister of justice to the court
00:28:08 to put the case fairly and neutrally and good prosecutors do, to be fair to the CPS.
00:28:14 And a police officer has a duty before that point to investigate scrupulously and fairly
00:28:20 and not to be putting forward, not to be pursuing and gathering evidence
00:28:25 to formulate and support a particular case.
00:28:29 And in fact, that's a fundamental duty.
00:28:31 These are all duties that go back many, many years
00:28:36 but have been put in statutory form, for example,
00:28:39 in the Police and Criminal Events Act in the early 1980s,
00:28:42 which is one of the most fundamental and important reforming pieces of legislation.
00:28:47 Introduce, for example, the recording of police interviews
00:28:51 and the right to exclude evidence, put that on a statutory footing and so on.
00:28:56 So these are not new concepts at all in the criminal justice sphere.
00:29:01 But again, it's a matter of culture because law can only do so much.
00:29:07 Culture, in the widest sense, the culture of the police forces,
00:29:11 the culture of the CPS and so on
00:29:14 is something that's more difficult to change
00:29:17 and more important, perhaps, to change.
00:29:19 Well, with some of these guidelines,
00:29:20 the College of Policing guidelines,
00:29:25 they seem to be tightening and tightening these definitions,
00:29:28 or rather, actually not tightening, I mean widening,
00:29:30 tightening, therefore, the effect on free speech.
00:29:34 But, you know, so hatred is now,
00:29:37 I think it's even become dislike.
00:29:40 The word dislike is used in these guidelines.
00:29:43 I find very funny.
00:29:44 On this cultural point, on another cultural point, Francis,
00:29:49 do you think that there is a problem that too many people,
00:29:57 particularly young people, certainly something I feel,
00:30:00 no longer really care much about free speech?
00:30:04 Yes.
00:30:04 Actually.
00:30:05 I mean, they sort of, yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:30:07 You know, you used to have these sort of conversations with people about free speech,
00:30:11 and we always knew, because the opponents used to say things like,
00:30:15 oh, well, of course I believe in free speech, but...
00:30:18 And you're like, here comes the but, you know.
00:30:20 But I think now we've moved on from that,
00:30:23 and that actually they don't believe in it at all.
00:30:26 I think that is particularly amongst the perhaps most educated,
00:30:32 with perhaps inverted commas, those who go to university
00:30:36 where the culture is very much against it.
00:30:39 And again, this culture of safetyism,
00:30:43 particularly endemic in American universities,
00:30:47 where speech has been characterized
00:30:49 as something which actually is an attack on an individual.
00:30:53 And you hear hysterical,
00:30:56 and that is the only way to describe them.
00:30:58 This is very common in American universities.
00:31:00 You see hysterical people screaming and shouting
00:31:03 that they are being physically hurt by an individual for just expressing an opinion that they don't like
00:31:10 or they assert is offensive or whatever it might be.
00:31:15 And that has been used to close down speech in American universities
00:31:19 and is increasingly being used to close down speech and debate in British universities too
00:31:26 and other European universities.
00:31:27 I think the problem actually, oddly, is much worse in the English-speaking world than elsewhere.
00:31:33 and actually it's interesting one of the because i'm a bit of an old-fashioned conservative in a
00:31:38 way and and an english sort of somebody who spent the last few years talking about the ones of the
00:31:43 english speaking world but my god has the english speaking world been a disappointment this last 18
00:31:48 months it really really has i should i should just add obviously but people you might know actually
00:31:54 but uh you've been involved in various uh challenges legal challenges government on the
00:32:00 the point of lockdown and he's basically going on over the past 18 months i mean you've been
00:32:05 very much in the forefront of that um it's interesting isn't it how you produce this
00:32:11 report but that these sort of restrictions or these things that we're having to be concerned
00:32:17 about happening roughly the same time as the physical restrictions i'm you know i'm not
00:32:22 drawing any conspiracy from that but other than the fact that the the you know the screws seem
00:32:28 to be tightening on people a bit, you know, and, you know, that disappointment you talk
00:32:34 about, I sort of, I always had this slightly maybe nostalgic view, the English particularly
00:32:40 were sort of very truculent about their rights, you know, you're not going to push me around,
00:32:45 you know, that seems to have dissipated.
00:32:49 And we always wonder what would have happened if Britain had fallen in 1940, and I think
00:32:57 The reality is that the answer can be found in the Channel Islands where British police officers sent Jews to the concentration camps.
00:33:07 And that is a terrible reality.
00:33:10 And I'm afraid to say I'm now certain that that would have happened here.
00:33:16 And the arrogance that perhaps some of us, including perhaps me, have felt in the past has been really put in its place this last 18 months.
00:33:26 where we discover that actually we don't value freedom now
00:33:31 as perhaps I thought that we did
00:33:34 and perhaps our value and our courage as a country
00:33:39 is just way below what I'd ever expected
00:33:42 and that's a very sad and disappointing reality that I've come to realise.
00:33:47 It is, but however one fights, you know, one still has to fight.
00:33:50 I mean, just finally on that point actually,
00:33:53 I was horrified quite recently that there was a poll that came out from YouGov, and it was talking about censorship, and it found that 40% of people would be happy for the government to censor books that they deemed homophobic, sexist, racist, all the usual ones.
00:34:19 I was just amazed how high that figure was I couldn't believe this wasn't just social media
00:34:27 companies they were talking about the government and I just thought wait a minute have I had the
00:34:34 wrong view I mean all this time have I been under a misapprehension to me I wouldn't have been able
00:34:40 to believe that could be so high.
00:34:43 I mean, it's a horrifying figure, isn't it?
00:34:45 And I think has been,
00:34:50 I do think there has been a concerted attack on freedom
00:34:53 over the last 18 months particularly,
00:34:55 but I think it has origins that go back well beyond that.
00:34:59 And I do think that people have just lost their sense of proportion.
00:35:04 I mean, you say I have many challenges
00:35:06 and I've expressed public views,
00:35:08 my own views on what I think
00:35:10 is the enormity, using the
00:35:12 old-fashioned sense of the word, as in
00:35:14 terrible thing, of lockdowns
00:35:17 and the destruction of
00:35:18 human rights, freedoms and
00:35:20 the ability to live as a human being
00:35:22 unprecedented as they are.
00:35:25 I think that that has
00:35:26 ground people down.
00:35:28 I think people have been ground down
00:35:30 and they've been pushed into this
00:35:32 belief that they find
00:35:34 is a necessary, accepted
00:35:36 part of being a civilised
00:35:39 and friendly and nice human being
00:35:41 which is that
00:35:41 to say that you should be allowed
00:35:44 to say things that might
00:35:47 be hurtful is itself
00:35:48 nasty and this
00:35:50 part
00:35:52 what goes with safetyism and is hugely
00:35:55 relevant to it is this thing
00:35:56 about being seen as a nice
00:35:59 person and therefore
00:36:00 I want to ban this
00:36:02 I want to stop you from going out
00:36:04 of your house so that you don't kill granny. I want to stop you from promoting this medical
00:36:12 debate or engaging in a medical debate because the public health organisations say that that's
00:36:17 going to cause harm to other people. I'm a nice person for doing that. Well, don't forget that
00:36:22 every tyrannical regime in history has always promoted itself as promoting the greater good.
00:36:29 They have never said we are promoting the greater evil. That has never been what they said and never
00:36:34 would be what they say. So people are enormously naive and enormously disappointing, frankly,
00:36:39 if they consider that what matters is promoting the nice things and giving the state the right
00:36:47 to determine what the nice things are. Well, that's a great way to end, Francis. I should
00:36:55 say, by the way, where can people see this report? Can they download it? They can download it.
00:36:59 and I'm sure that on your show
00:37:02 you can perhaps have a little link to that
00:37:05 in protection of freedom of speech
00:37:07 the point about reports like this
00:37:11 is that they give practical solutions
00:37:14 that's very very important
00:37:15 rather than just complaining
00:37:17 thank you very much indeed Francis for coming on
00:37:20 thank you
00:37:21 and very best of luck
00:37:22 I hope something comes of it
00:37:23 that's it this week
00:37:26 we shall see you next time
00:37:28 So thank you for watching.
00:37:29 Okay, bye-bye.