New Culture Forum - September 21, 2021


Jeremy Black on James Bond - A British Icon - Is Today's James Bond Still James Bond?

Online Safety Bill Is A Fundamental Threat To Free Speech & Must Be Opposed. WWW Ep2: Climate Extremists, Shemima Begum, Puberty Blockers & Police Free Speech Wokery

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

160.41

Word count

8,002

Sentence count

155


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now in 10 days time we're
00:00:23 going to see the next much-anticipated, much-delayed Bond film, No Time to Die, so I'm delighted
00:00:31 that this week my guest is a man who's written what I think is probably the definitive book
00:00:39 on Bond. It's called The World of James Bond. It is Professor Jeremy Black. Jeremy is Emeritus
00:00:47 Professor of History at the University of Exeter. He's written on military history, political history,
00:00:53 social history, and indeed I think he is the world record holder in terms of numbers of books he's
00:01:00 written, which is now over 180. He's been on the channel before, I'm pleased to say, and he's back
00:01:05 with us now. Thank you very much, Jeremy, for joining us. Excellent to see you, Peter, and
00:01:11 and delighted to be back. Oh, great. Well, first things first, with the Bond film, will you go and
00:01:19 see it? Oh, definitely. I give regular lectures on James Bond. I will always see it. And I also
00:01:26 love, I also take part in a sort of thing that goes out in America where people debate films
00:01:32 against each other. So I'll obviously, having seen it, then take part in a debate about its merits
00:01:38 vis-a-vis another earlier Bond, whichever one we do.
00:01:41 So this week, I'm doing Theatre of Blood, Vincent Price,
00:01:45 against another Vincent Price.
00:01:48 It's great fun to look at how Bond films change.
00:01:52 For me, I don't know what the new film's going to be like.
00:01:54 For me, one of the big changes compared to the early Bond films
00:01:59 is the early Bond films were less violent than the modern ones.
00:02:02 So in the modern ones, you have a larger number of people killed,
00:02:06 and you generally have less dialogue so that for example if you think of goldfinger there's a very
00:02:14 long sequence in which james bond plays golf with alrick goldfinger there's no fighting the only
00:02:23 violence is at the very end when odd job goldfinger sidekick crushes a a golf ball in his hand and
00:02:30 essentially what you're doing is creating character you're trying to get both of them to
00:02:36 say what they're like as people and they're verbally jousting with each other and that
00:02:41 kind of thing has changed and there's a number of ways of looking at it you could be critical and
00:02:46 you could say this is ridiculous it's simplified there isn't so much wit in it and all of that
00:02:52 would be true but on the other hand what you've got to remember about James Bond is James Bond
00:02:57 is a global product yeah this is the world's most successful film franchise it's an amazing
00:03:04 achievement, if you like, for Britain and an image of Britain. James Bond with Winston Churchill and
00:03:10 Her Majesty the Queen are the most famous Brits of the last century. And the point is this, that when
00:03:16 James Bond films started, the very first film was Doctor No, the very first feature-length film,
00:03:22 there'd been an earlier one-hour thing, but the very first feature-length film was Doctor No in
00:03:26 1962. At that stage, the United States was, as it still is, the world's leading film market, but
00:03:34 Britain was the number two and essentially most of the listeners most of the viewers would have
00:03:40 been people who knew English knew English relatively well now at the present moment a large
00:03:46 chunk of the market and this has been true for over 20 years are people for whom English is not
00:03:53 their first language and as a result I think you have more of an emphasis on action and the other
00:04:00 real change I think is that in the 2000s a rival franchise turned up in the shape of the Bourne
00:04:08 films the Jason Bourne films and they had a very different filmic quality very different filmic
00:04:14 character much more action orientated far fewer words spoken by either the central character or
00:04:23 anybody else and you know and they were quite successful and in a way James Bond got repurposed
00:04:30 with the Daniel Craig figure to be more of an action hero
00:04:35 and less of, as it were, an old-fashioned spy.
00:04:41 Yes, that's a very good point there about Jason Bourne.
00:04:46 I mean, I was going to ask you, actually,
00:04:48 when you say they got sort of reimagined,
00:04:50 well, not reimagined, but refashioned
00:04:52 because of all the different new influences,
00:04:56 I think one of the most important things, Jeremy,
00:04:58 I don't know whether you would agree with this, is that something which had sort of appeared to have slipped into parody was made serious again.
00:05:07 I'm thinking of Casino Royale in 2005. This is the second one.
00:05:13 And if you think of Daniel Craig in the film, the tone is quite serious. It's taking Bond seriously.
00:05:19 I mean, from my point of view, that hugely improved it. But what do you feel about that?
00:05:25 well I think the start of that film was excellent so for example the physicality of killing somebody
00:05:31 by holding them down into us in a sink you know the fight at the very beginning I think that was
00:05:37 really impressive you and you get the sense you've got the sense from the outset with Daniel Craig
00:05:42 and you still get do get the sense that he can kill you I mean Sean Connery had that sense I
00:05:48 don't think anybody had any sense that Roger Moore would kill you you know might well tell you that
00:05:53 your flies were undone, but certainly wouldn't kill you. So Daniel Craig, I think, came across
00:05:58 as a killer, and that was impressive. Where I think that particular film had a weakness
00:06:05 is it went on for a very long time, and the actual plot became quite confusing, and you
00:06:12 really had to concentrate towards the end. And the other thing is that you notice with
00:06:17 some of the modern films is when they run short of something, they have another action
00:06:21 sequence now there's nothing inherently wrong with that it's not that there is a perfect form
00:06:27 of james bond i think the good thing with craig is you can believe he's a killer the good thing
00:06:33 about him is that it actually does look at the issue which you first got in the brosnan films
00:06:40 but it does look at the issue of traitors within the service and obviously that had always been a
00:06:47 problem in real life with the service from the early known to be from the early 50s onwards
00:06:53 and it had been rather odd in the 60s and 70s and 80s that you didn't see that so the idea of a
00:06:59 traitor within um which you get with golden eye onwards and uh you know it is impressive um i think
00:07:08 some of the modern films are a bit too long i think that actually a pared down film can be much
00:07:15 tougher and can engage you have you as it were come out of the theater film theater in a sense
00:07:22 of almost shock you know you've you know that with your adrenaline having run at a very high rate
00:07:29 and that's not a bad thing um yes the obviously they've got some elements which are much harder
00:07:35 for them to do now the love interest element is very difficult to do now i mean it was very
00:07:42 important in the novels it was very important in the early films it helped to make those films
00:07:49 as it were a cultural product that reached out very broadly i mean you know famously so with
00:07:56 goldfinger for example um or even the very first full-length film which was dr no ursula andrews
00:08:03 coming out of the sea you know like a botticelli figure and being what's it honey child rider was
00:08:09 the name of the character that was in a sense an erotic an erotic attempt and there was a steptoe
00:08:17 and some episode in which that came forward but that was not the case uh with the more modern
00:08:23 ones nowadays i mean james bond is a serial monogamist yeah although actually interesting
00:08:30 i i was reading an article that you've written uh some time ago actually jeremy about this and
00:08:36 And you made the point that even though he's, I think it's in Goldeneye where there's that famous scene where Judi Dench calls him a sexist dinosaur, I believe.
00:08:46 That's right.
00:08:47 But you actually said he was quite liberated in his attitude to women.
00:08:52 The actual character, as written by Ian Fleming, liked women who were sexually aggressive and enjoyed it and all of that.
00:09:01 Is that correct?
00:09:03 Oh, that's absolutely correct. Totally correct.
00:09:05 I mean, if you go back to it and remember, the first novel comes out in 1953.
00:09:10 So you're in the early 1950s, which is a more straight, at least in public, a more straight-laced decade than what's come subsequently.
00:09:21 And what you have, which is really interesting, is women who are not defined by a wish for either matrimony or motherhood.
00:09:29 so there are women who are quite happy to have sex with bond either then you know they have as
00:09:35 it were a relationship or that's part and parcel of them trying to kill him um you know so in other
00:09:42 words they are independent agents in their own mind um and that i think is a very important
00:09:49 figure now what happens subsequently is the feminists came along and actually poured you
00:09:55 know sort of manure over james bond but in as it started you've got some really quite powerful
00:10:02 characters so although she may have a silly name pussy galore is a woman who is uh in the novel
00:10:10 she runs a lesbian motorcycle gang based in new york in the film i mean they downplay and take
00:10:17 that side out of it though they still hint at the lesbianism but the point is she's an independent
00:10:23 character she's able to run her own little air force you know she's able to do things in her
00:10:29 own right and you go that right the way through so by the 1990s you've got agents like the agent
00:10:37 played by Halle Berry or the agent played by Michelle Yeoh who are killers in their own right
00:10:44 you know they're working for friendly secret services but these secret services aren't there
00:10:49 to give you a tissue and discuss how your husband's nasty to you they're there to actually kill people
00:10:54 just as james bond is there to kill people um so there is no of this kind of reducing women to sort
00:11:02 of figures in the background who are not um who are not impressive and i think that's an important
00:11:09 element to think about um and again octopussy has a ludicrous name but you remember the actual plot
00:11:16 of the film, the short story is very different. But in the film, Octopussy is running a criminal
00:11:23 network. You know, she is an efficient and effective figure. And again, I think these
00:11:30 points need to be remembered. You know, apparently on YouTube, there's a clip,
00:11:38 there's a scene in Goldfinger with Pussy Galore, played by Anna Blackman, of course,
00:11:43 where it's sort of suggested that Bond has kind of managed to turn her against her will.
00:11:51 This now gets an 18 certificate, apparently, on YouTube.
00:11:56 I suppose it's being politically incorrect or whatever.
00:12:01 But it is a fascinating point, because this is one of the great sort of obsessions about Bond now, isn't it?
00:12:10 I mean, it's saying you can't have the women, you can't have this, you can't have that.
00:12:15 Therefore, is he, in fact, even still Bond?
00:12:18 And I wanted to ask you, actually, you know what I mean?
00:12:21 What is the actual description of Bond or a few of the descriptions of Bond in the novels?
00:12:28 How are we introduced to him?
00:12:29 I mean, you know, you can tell us what is he physically?
00:12:32 What is he?
00:12:34 The first thing to bear in mind about Bond,
00:12:37 which is different in the novels to the films is in the novels he's as it were a in the old
00:12:44 fashion sense of the world word a dark romantic hero so in other words he's troubled he kills
00:12:51 people but he's troubled about killing people he several times thinks of leaving the service
00:12:57 he has a problem uh with um breakdowns in the last novel of all he tries to kill m having been
00:13:06 turned by the soviets um you know he's a much more complex figure the novels are worth reading
00:13:13 and one of the novels the spy who loved me is actually told from the perspective of the woman
00:13:19 it's a very accomplished piece of writing i mean people tend to forget this about fleming he wasn't
00:13:24 a particularly wonderful man but he was a bloody good writer and he of course wrote not just the
00:13:30 the James Bond stories, he wrote Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, of course. He wrote a whole series of
00:13:36 travel pieces. He wrote part of the background for the man from Uncle. You know, he was a talented
00:13:44 writer in the public and popular field. And I think the way in which now people in 2021
00:13:52 are criticising somebody who was writing in the 1950s and early 60s, he died in 64,
00:13:59 is a bit silly and childish. It's rather as if in 60 years' time, let's say in 60 years' time,
00:14:07 people think in their own infinite wisdom, I'm being sarcastic there, that either we should
00:14:13 never eat meat and therefore everybody in this generation is terrible, or that people themselves
00:14:18 are the fundamental cause of climate change and therefore everybody over 60, that would include
00:14:24 me ought to be given a pill and sent off to die and they might think our generation is absurd and
00:14:31 our novels and films are absurd because they don't have those values. Now the problem with the
00:14:36 politically correct today is they do not understand that human society is constantly in a period of
00:14:44 change and process of change and you've got to be very careful before assuming that the value you
00:14:50 like today is of infinite importance which outranges everything else that you could have
00:14:56 achieved so Bond itself is actually a hero he's a hero because he is defending and Fleming very
00:15:05 much has this view he is defending good against bad now if you look at the very first novel which
00:15:12 is casino royale bond in that novel is unsure whether he should be sticking with the service
00:15:22 he's not sure whether he's doing the right thing what happens is as you may know um um he gets in
00:15:30 a way betrayed uh by the girl he's with who is being um manipulated by the fact that her i think
00:15:38 her husband um is held prisoner by the communists in poland and is being tortured to in order to
00:15:45 ensure her compliance and at the very end of the novel and she kills herself um at the very end
00:15:51 of the novel there is a line the bitch is dead very powerful line which um bond delivers now
00:15:59 one way of looking at that is to say well he's just talking about a woman and he's being very
00:16:03 harsh that's a very stupid way to look at it what he's really saying is my doubts are ended i know
00:16:10 now clearly that i am up against bad and remember if you look at the um biography that fleming gives
00:16:21 bond in his novels bond had acquired his double o status by killing people earlier he'd taken part
00:16:28 in World War II against the Axis. He then takes part in the Cold War. There is a clear sense of
00:16:37 good against bad. Now, one of the great tragedies of those people who talk about political correctness
00:16:44 today is they have no such moral compass. Many of them, as we know, hate our country. But the thing
00:16:51 that is even more serious is they have no sense whatsoever of how we compare to other countries
00:16:59 that are hostile towards us and you know Fleming creates Bond as a figure of the cold war but the
00:17:07 early novels he's up against Smirsch and in from Russia with love real um Soviet agents are named
00:17:15 you know you know Fleming knows what he's talking about now we clearly when we're looking at the
00:17:21 modern films do not have that background. So they are looking to create different kinds of modern
00:17:28 villains, whatever they are going to be busy doing. But that's not how James Bond started.
00:17:34 James Bond started as a hero figure for a country that was in the front line of the Cold War
00:17:41 and was having to defend itself. And was having to defend itself precisely because it was a Cold
00:17:47 war was having to defend itself by the secret service as much as or more than troops deployed
00:17:55 did fleming like the films if he died in 1964 he would have seen how many jeremy about
00:18:04 two or three yes he was i mean i discussed this in my books uh he had mixed views i think it's
00:18:12 fair to say. He would have preferred somebody other than Sean Connery to play the role. He was
00:18:18 interested in David Nibben playing the role. There was a lot of discussion as to whether Cary Grant
00:18:24 should play the role. Sean Connery was not him. And that's fine. But one of the things, if you're
00:18:30 an author of books, is you have to be very careful to not assume that you're going to control future
00:18:38 versions of things so let me give you an example i've got a book coming out later this year on
00:18:44 called the importance of being poirot which is about agatha christie now as you will know the
00:18:50 modern um agatha christie films the ones that have come out in the last six years have got
00:18:56 absolutely nothing to do with um agatha christie novels i mean if you look at the one for example
00:19:02 on the ABC murders, you know, or Ten Little Indians, as it's now called, or Then There Were
00:19:09 None, as the Americans call it. These are totally different to the novels. And one way to look at
00:19:15 that would be to say, this is awful. And I personally don't like it. I don't think they
00:19:21 should call them Agatha Christie's ABC murders. I think they should call them the ABC murders
00:19:27 based on an idea by agatha christie and we know agatha christie was very cross about the first
00:19:34 play um that they uh staged of one of her novels um and you know she had her views she had very
00:19:43 clear views that some of the uh stage versions and some of the film versions were better than
00:19:48 others had fleming lived longer and he died relatively young i mean he was a heavy drinker
00:19:54 a heavy smoker, at lots of rich food.
00:19:58 So, you know, he's dead by 56.
00:20:01 Had he died, had he lived longer,
00:20:03 had he lived as long as Agatha Christie did,
00:20:05 I think he would probably have been quite dyspeptic about them.
00:20:09 But that's not essentially proving that the films are wrong
00:20:13 because films are trying to do something else.
00:20:16 And, you know, you can look at the plots.
00:20:19 Sometimes the plot changes are to make the film more relevant.
00:20:23 so in goldfinger the novel it's the soviets who are trying who provide the atomic weapon in goldfinger
00:20:31 the film it's the chinese and that's because america at that stage is getting involved in
00:20:38 southeast asia that you know growing commitment to the vietnam war it's a different culture or in
00:20:46 Oh, Moonraker. In Moonraker, the novel, it's the Soviets in alliance with neo-Nazis who are trying
00:20:56 to land a rocket with an atomic warhead on London. In Moonraker, the film, it's Hugo Drax who has
00:21:06 global plots to end human life on the earth and create a new lot of superheroes. Now, you might
00:21:13 say if you were the author this is ridiculous or you might say if you're we don't know what
00:21:18 james what ian fleming would have made of moonraker because he didn't see it obviously
00:21:22 um he might have said well this is an interesting way to keep it alive to keep the idea alive
00:21:28 to look into a new technology because moonraker it's the new technology of space shuttles
00:21:34 none of which were possible obviously um for uh for fleming to write about so i'm not sure i
00:21:41 necessarily am worried about that what I'm more interested in is and I think all of us should be
00:21:46 interested in Peter everybody who's listening does a film work does it work as a coherent film
00:21:54 in which you're interested in what happens you are excited and you remain committed to the end
00:22:00 end moment and that your afterglow it's like a meal is the afterglow good now what really then
00:22:08 can make a film work even better and there are you know i mean works for me most of them not
00:22:14 absolutely every single one is do you want to see this a second time a third time a fourth time
00:22:19 and you can see that with other films so for example la confidential i know exactly what's
00:22:25 going to happen in la confidential i've seen it um but you know the second time i saw it i thought
00:22:30 this was fantastic whereas the same actor um playing the lead role in the usual suspects it
00:22:37 didn't work for me when i saw it in the second time and that's because the first time was a
00:22:42 better constructed film so partly is how does the film work for you as a first time how does it work
00:22:49 for you as a second time and one of the interesting things about the bond films is that the filmic
00:22:56 quality of settings adventure special effects um music music is very important in the bond films
00:23:04 are usually for most audiences will take them through to want to watch it more than once
00:23:10 and that is crucially important star wars has that for its audience as well and as you may know
00:23:15 the other leading contender for film franchise and it varies depending upon who's brought out
00:23:21 of film last is star wars so it's star wars and it's the james bond uh films those are the two
00:23:26 leading film franchises and they work not just through very big global audiences times one but
00:23:35 for a lot of people watching them times two or three or four yes um i think one of the things
00:23:41 one of the things you alluded to there actually i think is interesting uh james bond you know for
00:23:47 quite a few years was a product of the cold war was very much in that context as you say
00:23:54 and the villains therefore were in that context but what we have now are just villains who
00:24:00 in some ways are just sort of plucked out of thin air you know as being kind of evil
00:24:05 in other words who would in if one were going to be political who would Bond be fighting against
00:24:13 now I mean you know if it were no longer the Soviet Union would it for example could it be
00:24:19 modern day russia could it be islamic fundamentalism what you know do you see my
00:24:25 point i mean he's the the the villains now are sort of almost they're just kind of villainous
00:24:31 people you know yes and they and to my mind that doesn't work as well so you know terrible no doubt
00:24:39 for bolivia to run out of water which was the plot of one of the daniel craig ones but i can't
00:24:45 say that many or much of the audience was gripped um the blood diamonds character very unpleasant
00:24:51 in casino royal but again it doesn't really it didn't grip to the same extent one of the
00:24:58 interesting things about um some of the uh bond films though during the cold war is some of them
00:25:05 were very much against the other side but some of them had megalomaniacs in them i mean drax we've
00:25:12 already mentioned in moonraker stromberg in the um in the uh man who uh sorry in the spy who loved
00:25:21 me he wants to end all human life so he can rule from beneath the seas um or my favorite film of
00:25:29 all which is diamonds are forever where you have charles gray as blofeld this is 1971 i mean he
00:25:37 He is intent on, you know, as it were, destroying everybody
00:25:44 so that he can ransom, destroying all their military force
00:25:47 so he can hold them to ransom from his space-mounted laser.
00:25:52 And, you know, you get...
00:25:53 I mean, I think that's a very...
00:25:54 The reason I like that film is Charles Grey is a brilliant villain.
00:25:59 Sean Connery is on good form.
00:26:01 It is a funny film.
00:26:02 It is the funniest.
00:26:04 and you know i mean it's not like the first casino royale which is terribly bad and only funny in
00:26:10 this respect there is generally witty lines i mean characters like morton slumber the undertaker and
00:26:15 you know smuggling um smuggling uh diamonds in a duodenum and this kind of thing it is a funny film
00:26:23 um but in some ways the psychopaths then were more convincing than the psychopaths now they
00:26:31 were more interesting today to set a real live villain is extraordinarily difficult in a world
00:26:38 in which you're producing a global product where you are worried about all these wokes out there
00:26:46 who will say i mean if your villain you mentioned islamic fundamentalists you can imagine the fuss
00:26:53 that you would get from woke critics if that was your villain um you can imagine even though as we
00:27:00 know al-qaeda was a terrible and terrifying you know network of terrorists and if somebody had
00:27:08 been able to destroy it early it would have been a jolly good thing the fact of the matter is if
00:27:14 you'd produced an adventure film showing that or depicting that in the late 90s everybody would
00:27:19 have said oh this is awful this is encouraging hatred to you know muslims etc it's not encouraging
00:27:25 hatred to muslims at all it's encouraging hatred of terrorists but i mean i'm afraid the trouble
00:27:30 is that woke critics don't tend to go for those sort of distinctions so you've got a problem the
00:27:37 only villains these days that are allowed of course peter bad news is you and me yes the only
00:27:43 villains that are allowed i mean woke british people hate our country so much they'd have us
00:27:49 as villains or maybe you know maybe the royal family under some bunker in balmoral trying to
00:27:54 bring the world to a close but that would probably go well with them you could see the guardian saying
00:28:00 a convincing account um but the the uh and you know uh if you see a character with a cut glass
00:28:07 accent you know he is the villain it would be a he not a she of course um yes oh no absolutely
00:28:15 jeremy you mentioned the diamonds are forever being your favorite film bond film so i take
00:28:23 from that that sean connery is what your favorite screen bond he's my favorite screen bond i think
00:28:29 he's a convincing as a killer i think he has some marvelous lines and he delivered the lines
00:28:35 wonderfully in terms of the actual novels the bond who is closest to the novels is timothy
00:28:42 dalton bit introspective bit troubled um and he is the one that is closest um daniel craig
00:28:50 suggests himself as a killer i think that's good not so good he doesn't get given such good lines
00:28:57 as sean connery i think so there's less dialogue there and of course there isn't quite the uh
00:29:03 frisson relationships with women that there are in the court in the connery uh in the connery films
00:29:10 um roger moore some of the roger moore films are better than most people think live and let die
00:29:17 for example the very first one is actually a pretty convincing adventure film the sequences
00:29:24 in new york in the island in the caribbean um fictional island and in new orleans and louisiana
00:29:31 are very good but by the end they were getting very tired the roger moore films and view to a
00:29:38 kill which was the last one was really poor um brosnan i think again varied i thought golden
00:29:45 eye was a good film i thought the first half an hour of tomorrow never dies a good film
00:29:52 uh but again i think he rapidly ran out of steam um and partly it's the script partly he just
00:30:01 looked too untroubled he looked he didn't look as though he was having to break sweat to kill
00:30:08 anybody you know i mean if you look at the scenes the sea and i mean go back to the very originals
00:30:14 because sometimes the the versions that are used now particularly on television or airplanes have
00:30:21 been sanitized but the scene of the fight in the lift in uh amsterdam in uh tomorrow in diamonds
00:30:30 are forever is really tough you know they break the glass they're trying to cut throats with glass
00:30:36 this is tough stuff the fight in goldfinger no not goldfingering from russia with love
00:30:41 with robert shaw in the train that is a bloody tough fight uh attempted garroting um gets the
00:30:49 garrota by sticking a knife in their shoulder. I mean, you know, we're not talking about
00:30:54 let's shoot somebody from a distance. We're talking about blood spraying in your face
00:30:59 killing. These are convincing. I don't think you have the same air of conviction in Brosnan
00:31:06 or, you know, you cannot believe that Brosnan would throttle somebody to death. You could
00:31:12 believe that of Sean Connery or of Daniel Craig.
00:31:16 I think, yes, exactly. There's a threat there, isn't there? There's a very important, all important threat, particularly when you consider how he was written, Bond.
00:31:28 One thing that's quite interesting as well is that the various Bonds through the time have also shown us what is considered to be attractive in a man, actually.
00:31:41 And what I thought was very interesting is that there's, in Casino Royale, the second one, the first Daniel Craig,
00:31:49 there's this scene now where he walks out of the water, everyone knows it, and he's very, very, you know, masterly, very buff.
00:31:56 And it was almost like a little bit of an homage to when Ursula Anders walks out of the water.
00:32:03 But in a way, I think it's true to say, is it not, that it's not to say that Bond's been objectified, but audiences now maybe wouldn't take a kind of Roger Moore figure.
00:32:16 I mean, in the sense that it wasn't about his physicality, really, was it?
00:32:19 It was about his finesse, you know, or even Pierce Brosnan.
00:32:24 Same thing. Sort of cocktail, sophisticated, all of that.
00:32:30 But there is something much more sexual, I would say, about Daniel Craig in the way that there was with Sean Connery.
00:32:38 Yes. And the language, of course, sometimes varies enormously.
00:32:43 So if you think of Fatima Blush in Never Say Never Again, you know, the line about going down and this sort of thing, it's playing it very close to the edge.
00:32:54 do you remember she tries to get him to sign a form saying that a letter saying that he was the
00:33:01 best that she was the best person he ever had sex with and then he shoots her with a rather phallic
00:33:07 pen i don't know if you remember that scene or um if you think about the pierce brosnan scene about
00:33:14 liking it with a twist at the end you know there is there were sexual references there they've
00:33:20 largely been removed completely from the modern thing and you know nowadays there's a kind of
00:33:27 almost asexuality about it that it's almost as if the Daniel Craig Bond is so troubled at times by
00:33:36 things that have happened to him or about his angst that he really can't engage properly with
00:33:44 women or that you have with as with Judi Dench the kind of buddy film in which he and Judi Dench
00:33:49 our buddies this is a very different approach to relationships with women and um you know you might
00:33:57 argue uh that it works for audiences in fact an interesting thing is from the word go about a
00:34:03 third of the audiences were women um and the whatever feminists might have said a lot of
00:34:10 women liked going to see them um so they weren't regarded as hostile to women they weren't regarded
00:34:17 as commodifying women um they were by some critics of course but they weren't by the uh the bulk of
00:34:23 the female uh watching public but as you correctly say we are now in a very odd place i mean to put
00:34:32 it bluntly in historical terms i'm not debating the rights and wrongs of it and i don't particularly
00:34:38 interested in engaging it but a society which is so focused or has been so focused on issues such
00:34:47 as transgender is a society that is going to find any representation of traditional male sexuality
00:34:56 some people aren't going to like it well you know you cannot please all the people all the time
00:35:04 James Bond is a male action hero. If they were ever to cast a female for the role, it would be a female action hero. Action heroes tend to put themselves in positions of danger and then to use their ingenuity and force to get out of them.
00:35:22 That is not a question of sitting on the M25 because you don't like the price of butter or whatever else you might want to hold the country up for.
00:35:31 So I think one has to be aware of that there is a cultural mismatch between the enormous popularity of a film figure that stands for good, delivers good outcomes, and on the whole is very considerate to other people other than villains, and the fact that obviously in a woke universe, he is a villain.
00:35:57 yes on that point uh you you mentioned there about having a female bond uh i think it is
00:36:05 testament isn't it to bond's extraordinary powers cultural figure that there is this ongoing
00:36:13 almost a news item who is going to play the next bond uh you know what would they be in a change
00:36:21 world and all of this i mean what is your view jeremy do you think for example that we could
00:36:28 have say a black bond for example well i wouldn't be troubled if we had a black bond as long as the
00:36:35 black bond is somebody who is presented as a figure for good representing good and doing down
00:36:43 villains because that is the point of the stories it's not in order to get you to spend your time
00:36:50 thinking that the britain is a corrupt and criminal organization so this is about you know
00:36:56 a heroic figure who helps our country western values and the world as a whole in the fight
00:37:05 against evil that's what it's about it is deeply moral if you look at the fleming stories they are
00:37:12 deeply moral and in fact the villains in the fleming stories often during world war ii had
00:37:19 done dodgy things in other words they've been linked to the third reich um and if you look
00:37:25 again same thing with agatha christie agatha christie the point about agatha christie which
00:37:30 uh critic i mean i saw the richard e grant program and all the rest of it completely ignores one of
00:37:36 the central points about agatha christie she was an extremely devout religious christian there is
00:37:44 good and bad in stories like nemesis she is throwing out very strongly quotations from the
00:37:52 bible it is a very clear good versus evil and of course when you get modern film makers to totally
00:38:02 discarding that what they are doing is forgetting the moral universe in which these works were
00:38:09 written, and these works were intended to be understood. Go back. I mean, I've written a book
00:38:15 about Jane Austen, exactly the same. Jane Austen, the daughter of a clergyman, the sister of a
00:38:21 clergyman, a woman who wrote her own prayers, very devout. You cannot understand Jane Austen
00:38:28 unless you understand her as a devout Anglican. Yes, I think I absolutely see that. I take the
00:38:35 point about the good versus evil. I think the thing is with Bond, you mentioned there a bit
00:38:42 earlier, and you also mentioned Timothy Dalton, as basically being, you know, he's this dark
00:38:47 romantic hero. He's a public school boy. He's always been perceived, even though Daniel Craig's
00:38:56 probably been the least sort of, as it were, upper middle class of the lot, but he's perceived as
00:39:02 being you know a gentleman and all of this um and it's he's a product of a very particular
00:39:08 social you know milieu yes like fleming himself like fleming himself if you look if you look at
00:39:17 the descriptions of bond fleming goes into it in some detail he discusses his finances
00:39:22 essentially half of his money comes from uh his income for the secret intelligence service
00:39:29 better know that as mi6 and the other half comes from investments from dividends he has a housekeeper
00:39:35 he drives in the stories of bentley he is a member of a number of london clubs he knows how to do
00:39:42 the kind of high stakes gambling that you would get he knows how to comport himself he knows the
00:39:48 first novel he knows how to eat pate de foie gras there is he is a kind of clubland hero like the
00:39:56 adventure heroes of the interwar years who are very much gentlemen. Now, yes, James Bond, as
00:40:04 depicted in the novels, is a gentleman. And that in part is Fleming's understanding of intelligence
00:40:13 when he'd served in it. In part, it's his writing about, as any good writer should do, they should
00:40:19 coin their experience. Fleming himself not only had his intelligent links, he was a member of
00:40:26 London club so when he writes about the fictional club Blades in Moonraker he's writing about the
00:40:31 sort of club he knows about when he writes about golf he was a champion golfer you know this is
00:40:38 the sort of thing now the difficulty now is the script writers are as it were not from that social
00:40:47 background so sometimes they get it right sometimes they get it wrong but more often they're just not
00:40:55 interested and that's not a criticism they're trying to create a global character rather than
00:41:01 a character located just in the british class system and that was very important for the move
00:41:06 from david niven to sean connery david niven had been uh to a public school he'd been to stowe
00:41:12 and fleming had been to eton and david niven was classically had been a matinee idol as a younger
00:41:18 the man. Sean Connery was rougher edged in his background, in his acting style, in his accent.
00:41:26 That was regarded as somebody who was going to work better for the American market. Ironically,
00:41:35 you get exactly the same thing two years later, something I've recently talked about on one of my
00:41:40 podcasts which is Zulu because in Zulu which has an American director they cast as the aristocratic
00:41:49 British officer of all people Michael Caine but the point is that looks absurd to an English
00:41:55 audience but to an American audience Michael Caine seemed a reasonable person to have and
00:42:02 so in a way um it was entirely reasonable from their point of view to present Sean Connery as
00:42:09 somebody who the british secret intelligence service in 1962 was still fairly public school
00:42:17 you know yeah i mean it had people like john le carre had gone into the secret service you
00:42:21 know public school boys um and i in many senses what you get with sean connery is what in my view
00:42:30 you get at exactly the same moment you get with the len dayton uh uh novels with harry palmer
00:42:38 played of course for film by Michael Caine again but novels such as the Ipcris file
00:42:43 Funeral in Berlin these are in some ways also very gritty I mean just as with Sean Connery
00:42:52 there's a degree of grittiness there is an even greater degree of grittiness with Michael
00:42:58 Michael Caine as Harry Palmer now in the Ipcris file they push it further because in the Ipcris
00:43:05 filed. There is a traitor, and the traitor is within the service, and in fact, spoiler alert,
00:43:12 is Harry Palmer's superior, played by an upper-class ex-military type. So it's very
00:43:20 interesting, the social politics that one sees there. But Len Dayton is a very different man,
00:43:26 different background to Ian Fleming. Coming up to, right up to date, who, have you got anyone you
00:43:37 think would, should be the next Bond? You're obviously, you know, a film fan. You obviously
00:43:44 know, you know, about the actors and current actors around on the scene. Jeremy, who do you
00:43:50 think would make the best Bond of the current people? Well, can I just say, I wouldn't like
00:43:55 to name an individual person but i want to go into the parameters i do think they should be british
00:44:01 i do think it should be a man i'm not particularly bothered about women playing adventure heroes but
00:44:07 james bond is a male character and i think it would actually be you might as well start completely
00:44:13 anew if you're going to cast a woman and just create a new persona so i would go for a man i
00:44:19 also think it's quite important to have development through time so i think you want a character that
00:44:25 can play at least 12 years which means you should be looking now for somebody who is a relatively
00:44:32 unknown in their mid to late 20s mid to late 20s okay yes so the classic figures that are usually
00:44:41 cited would only work for about three films and then they'll start to look too old too tired
00:44:46 their bodies wouldn't look good I mean these days they're not allowed sex scenes but they
00:44:51 wouldn't look particularly convincing and could you imagine the fuss if you had a 44 year old or
00:44:56 48 year old actor picking up a 24 year old woman my god it would be the end of civilization as we
00:45:02 knew it you know um the uh but the so I think that um and actually funnily enough to you and I
00:45:11 I mean I'm you know we're not people in the first flush of youth shall we say it might look odd
00:45:16 to have a young person but given that you're trying to keep the franchise alive and relevant
00:45:23 to young people it's no bad thing to have a young person how um how old was connery when he started
00:45:30 out that is a good question and i cannot give you an exact answer the thing that you the line you
00:45:37 often hear that he was an unknown is rubbish he'd been in a number of films um but you're right in
00:45:44 saying that he wasn't particularly old and interestingly enough they looked at roger
00:45:49 more at the time but of course he was engaged in the uh the templar films you know the television
00:45:55 series so he was under contract um but in each case they were looking at younger people and the
00:46:01 problem they had one of the problems with david niven and carrie grant carrie grant had done
00:46:06 north by northwest one of the problems with both of them is they were too old
00:46:10 yes yes i can see finally um jeremy uh what do you think the future is going to be do you think
00:46:19 do you think it's going to hold out i mean you know this this particular film well it's not just
00:46:25 bond and the bond franchise it's also frankly the future of cinema going where it seems to be
00:46:32 hanging on it uh because obviously this is going to be the biggest films come along since the
00:46:37 pandemic and everything uh do you think it's got a future you know for the next 10 years
00:46:43 seems to me it has i mean first of all i hope so and speaking past you peter to your audience
00:46:48 i would say to you you can see many things on television we've all got broader screen televisions
00:46:55 than we used to but the kind of big adventure film whether it's a james bond film or whether
00:47:01 for example it's a star wars you need to see that in the cinema not just for the visual sides but
00:47:09 also for the sound experience for the experience of being plunged into darkness because your mobile
00:47:15 phone isn't or bloody well shouldn't be going on because you are actually taken into a place
00:47:21 where you can suspend reality which is one of the key things about cinema so i jolly well hope you
00:47:29 go and the fact of the matter is ultimately um this is part of our heritage and it is part of
00:47:36 a living heritage it would be an enormous pity for us as indeed the same thing in other countries
00:47:42 if you get rid of a living heritage either because you can't be bothered or because you
00:47:49 object to it we would all be poorer in every true sense of the word as a result of such a choice
00:47:56 And what I'm trying to do in my books, when I'm writing about Bond or when I'm writing about Agatha Christie, I've got another book coming out on Sherlock Holmes.
00:48:05 What I'm trying to do is to show that there is not just that these are quaint, but actually that these are major cultural works that speak to a lot about our heritage and in broader terms to moral issues facing the world itself.
00:48:22 well beautifully put Jeremy thank you um thank you very much for that uh the book is called the
00:48:31 the world of James Bond by Jeremy Black it was uh it's been completely updated so it's available
00:48:38 now in Waterstones and Amazon and uh those places this is the cover you can see coming up now
00:48:44 um thank you very much for that Jeremy and I look forward to well maybe on email uh you know
00:48:51 discussing what we think of this film when we've seen it well i think that would be great and may
00:48:57 you know you don't necessarily get me on but i mean i think it would be a good thing to have
00:49:01 people on or i'd be very happy to do it again to discuss it um but i also hope that you know
00:49:07 everybody at the present moment has been hit over the head psychologically about covid but what
00:49:13 people need to remember is our culture is still alive there is lots of books to read there is
00:49:20 lots of television to see there are many cultural forms that we should engage in whether we're
00:49:26 frightened or not frightened about covid and it's important to actually take ourselves outside our
00:49:33 own personality and outside our own fears in order to think about the collective imagination
00:49:39 absolutely 100 thank you very very much indeed jeremy thank you uh that's it for so what you're
00:49:47 saying is this week we will be back next time so i do hope you join us then bye