New Culture Forum - September 24, 2021


WWW Ep2: Climate Extremists, Shemima Begum, Puberty Blockers & Police Free Speech Wokery

Jeremy Black on James Bond - A British Icon - Is Today's James Bond Still James Bond? Migration Watch: Tory Government Is INCREASING Immigration, Which Is Already At Unprecedented Levels

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

180.16

Word count

8,828

Sentence count

269


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh
00:00:30 Hello and welcome to Widdicombe, Webb and Wobberts. My name is Emma Webb and I'm your
00:00:38 host and I'm here today with the former Shadow Home Secretary Anne Widdicombe and comedian
00:00:43 Abby Wobberts. And you can contact us throughout the show where we'll be taking your questions
00:00:49 and comments. You can send them to us via the live stream or through email at contact
00:00:55 at newcultureforum.org.uk or you can tweet us at hashtag NCFWWW. So this week we have an awful
00:01:05 lot to talk about. We have seen those pesky protesters on the M25 ruining people's lives
00:01:13 and stopping people from getting to hospital. We've also seen another mad dissent, if you can
00:01:20 believe that it's possible in the gender debate into even rougher waters. We're also going to
00:01:26 be discussing the state of art in the age of identity politics and whether policing is
00:01:32 threatening our free speech as well as updates around the case of Shumwimer Begum. So that's a
00:01:38 lot to get through. So let's start with Extinction Rebellion. Do you think that climate protesters
00:01:44 have gone too far? Well they've been going too far for rather a long time. I think it's not a
00:01:50 question of have they gone too far is have the police gone anywhere at all because I have as I
00:01:57 comment in my express column tomorrow I don't know when the police became so utterly feeble
00:02:04 and hopeless that they go up to a group of people who are obstructing a road on which emergency
00:02:11 vehicles are traveling and the latest is that some poor cell had a stroke it took her son six hours
00:02:17 to get through this demonstration and by that time she was paralyzed because you need to deal
00:02:23 with strokes very quickly and yet the police do nothing. Now the Home Secretary did kick them
00:02:30 into some sort of action on Friday but it wasn't much and my view is very straightforward. They
00:02:35 need to be arrested, they need to be charged and they need to be given a lot of hours of unpaid
00:02:42 community service so the count the counter argument has been that they are entitled to
00:02:48 protest they're expressing their free speech but what they're doing is you say they're shutting
00:02:52 down critical infrastructure which is something that extinction rebellion and this this group is
00:02:57 actually called insulate britain so they're actually sounds like a british gas advert well
00:03:01 this this this lady who suffered a stroke and is now avoid she was avoidable she wouldn't have
00:03:07 been paralyzed if she'd been able to get to hospital within 90 minutes but instead was
00:03:11 stuck on the m25 for six whole hours um and there was also another woman in her 50s who had to be
00:03:16 airlifted to hospital after a multi-vehicle crash that they were saying was because all of this
00:03:20 traffic was backed up on the m25 um ironically apparently there was a thermal engineer stuck
00:03:25 in there who was on his way to insulate all the irony so they're doing this because they think
00:03:31 that the government should insulate everyone's homes and in the process causing chaos for
00:03:34 everyone's lives but extinction rebellion for a very long time have been doing things that are
00:03:40 criminal things like digging up the lawn of trinity college cambridge and dumping it outside of a
00:03:45 bank vandalizing people's buildings and the police just seem to stand by and do nothing
00:03:50 as just as they did during the black lives matter protest it's very strange the police seem to it's
00:03:55 okay for some people to protest but but not others and i would say i would actually say
00:03:59 this isn't protest um being on public highways and stopping ambulances and cars getting through
00:04:04 So they're a terrorist organisation
00:04:07 because they are inflicting damage on our country
00:04:11 when we're already on our knees
00:04:13 after all the coronavirus restrictions.
00:04:16 So the police, unless they get tough,
00:04:19 I mean, then they were offering them a cup of tea.
00:04:21 These people were glued to the tarmac.
00:04:23 It sounded more like they were on a school trip.
00:04:26 If there's anything that we can do to help,
00:04:29 make them more comfortable.
00:04:30 But what are they doing for the people who are held up?
00:04:33 exactly what are they doing for those people all of that footage of people having to take it into
00:04:38 their own hands and then the police going and treating the people who had intervened in a
00:04:44 more heavy-handed way oh they always do yeah they'll always say you know you must leave that
00:04:49 to the police but the police don't do anything that's why people take the law but why do you
00:04:52 think this is is it politicized policing or is it definitely because they don't know what to do
00:04:56 they don't they don't know they do know what to do but they don't do it because you know they are
00:05:01 now so politically correct yeah i mean it is worth saying that there are some very brave officers who
00:05:06 do lose their lives in in the cause of protecting the public um it's worth saying that but
00:05:12 nevertheless the mass of the police force now wherever you look in whichever part of the
00:05:17 country is just dominated by political correctness instead of by common sense and the protection of
00:05:23 the public which is what they're supposed to be about i thought it's really absurd it's like sixth
00:05:28 form or sort of you know yeah sort of six form politics has taken over everything remember they
00:05:33 used to be on the fringes these people largely you know the climate sort of the climate change
00:05:39 thing has become now a central has become almost like a mainstream view because all the others and
00:05:44 i know you feel strongly about this all the other views about the fact that maybe the planet's
00:05:49 cooling solar activity has been completely excluded from the argument so this has now
00:05:54 become almost like well it must be right did you see um on good morning britain richard maidly
00:05:59 challenging one of these protesters yes reading out the definition of fascism yeah because and
00:06:05 he had a point and this is i mean a policy exchange released a report i think it was last
00:06:09 year it may have been the year before questioning whether extinction rebellion were an extremist
00:06:14 group because they have this apocalyptic world view where they think that all of their actions
00:06:19 even if they're criminal are justified because the end of the world is nigh and it's this sort of
00:06:24 and if you saw that they um it's just so outrageous uh like a sort of bourgeois apocalypticism that
00:06:31 they did a they did a whip round for one of these businesses that they had closed down as a you know
00:06:37 result of the protest and the guy who owned the business refused to take it but it was just such
00:06:42 a brilliant display of the class difference that this this very posh sounding guy trying to hand
00:06:49 their money over to this you know just working guy runs a cafe i'm surprised they even recognize
00:06:55 somebody who'd worked for a living the tabithas and tarquins are there you know let's all i mean
00:07:00 but it's it's an insult to their pride and also co2 you know i don't know if you saw yesterday
00:07:05 the um there's there's a serious worry about packaging meat because co2s need it to package
00:07:11 And CO2 has been the enemy.
00:07:13 Public enemy number one.
00:07:15 Suddenly we haven't got enough of it.
00:07:17 What's wrong with CO2?
00:07:17 Exactly, it's public enemy number one
00:07:19 and nobody can find it anywhere.
00:07:21 Hmm, I wonder.
00:07:22 I mean, it's bizarre.
00:07:23 It's like, what's wrong with carbon?
00:07:25 What's wrong with CO2?
00:07:26 I mean, isn't everything made out of carbon?
00:07:28 Am I wrong in saying that?
00:07:29 I think we are.
00:07:30 I think even we're made of carbon.
00:07:31 So, I mean, I think it's just, it is loony.
00:07:34 You know, the lunatics have taken over the asylum.
00:07:38 Just quickly to go back to the sorts of people
00:07:41 who have involved themselves in this protest.
00:07:43 I don't know if you saw the description
00:07:44 in some of the news reportings of the careers.
00:07:47 One of them's a puppeteer.
00:07:49 There's a vegan business coach.
00:07:53 You couldn't make it up.
00:07:54 An organic farmer, apparently,
00:07:55 who compares himself to Mahatma Gandhi.
00:07:57 So Chris from...
00:07:58 Sounds great.
00:07:58 ...Harrison at all.
00:07:59 I can't wait to have to do with them.
00:08:00 Chris, on the subject of what to do about these protesters,
00:08:03 Chris from Plymouth has said
00:08:05 police should use water cannons to move these protesters.
00:08:09 I think soap would be good.
00:08:12 Just to shower them with some soap, some shower gel.
00:08:15 But we got rid of the water cannons anyway, wasn't it?
00:08:18 Well, Theresa May got rid of the water cannons.
00:08:20 Boris ordered some for London to deal with just this sort of situation.
00:08:25 And Theresa May ordered him to stand them all down.
00:08:29 The thing is, though, I just think I shouldn't laugh,
00:08:31 but the problem with water cannons when people have glued themselves is
00:08:34 if you aim a water cannon at someone who's glued,
00:08:38 it's it's not going to end very well because they're just definitely i mean you know that
00:08:42 you need some some solvent to get rid of i can't believe we're having this discussion the whole
00:08:48 the whole thing is such clownery that you say water cannons and i think clown cannons firing
00:08:54 someone in a cannonball you know some kind of circus act on the m25 it's lunacy and what's this
00:09:01 got to do with i mean it's you know it's strange you know when i hear someone say um climate change
00:09:05 denier the climate's been changing for you know millions of years why are we without that phrase
00:09:12 exactly we don't hear it the other side of it it's quite extraordinary so one of the reasons
00:09:18 i'm convinced is that there is now so much money invested yeah university research departments in
00:09:25 other research areas so much money invested in climate change you know that it would actually
00:09:31 cause a lot of people um to uh suffer a lot of loss exactly if the little boy debate really got
00:09:40 underway exactly if the little boy said i don't think that emperor's got no clothes on yeah you're
00:09:45 right we've got two comments here one from mark who says how many people missed family funerals
00:09:50 flights and other important events and connor from sandbank says what about pregnant women
00:09:54 rushing to hospital to give birth i'm ashamed at our weak police there's also another comment here
00:09:59 from Sally from Margate who said
00:10:01 that if our police were as
00:10:03 tough as they are in other countries
00:10:05 many of these privileged middle class
00:10:07 protesters would likely stay at home
00:10:09 so you know
00:10:10 but what's wrong with the very basic principle
00:10:13 that we all used to subscribe to
00:10:14 which is nobody is
00:10:17 above the law, what's wrong with that
00:10:19 why are these people suddenly above
00:10:21 the law? But is there another element to this
00:10:23 as well that
00:10:24 now protesters have this
00:10:27 such a
00:10:28 such a degree of hubris that they think that their cause is more it's it's such an emergency
00:10:34 that because we live in a society now where emergency justifies almost anything um that
00:10:39 they think well it's such an emergency it doesn't matter those pregnant women you know this is just
00:10:43 collateral damage because the world is about to end and the problem is a lot of the police with
00:10:48 their rainbow their rainbow cars etc also believe that that's the problem that they're they've been
00:10:54 they're not acting in a sort of in an unbiased way by sort of treating everyone sort of you know
00:11:00 to do with the law they're they're looking at things in an ideal ideological way which oh you
00:11:06 know where that where that leads to you know while we're on the subject of policing or the lack of
00:11:13 you may have also seen this week norfolk police um there was a norfolk norfolk policeman who
00:11:21 was having a conversation with what I assumed from the video was one of his relatives an anti
00:11:26 an anti-abortion uh an anti sorry sorry Norfolk Norfolk policeman um who was explaining if you
00:11:39 I don't know if you saw the video explaining to this anti-abortion protester that uh holding his
00:11:46 banner being offensive making offensive remarks in a protest was equivalent to assault equivalent
00:11:52 to punching someone in the face i don't know but you could tell from the video that it was something
00:11:57 to do with abortion the guy on the other side was like protesting peacefully and being very
00:12:02 reasonable and what was interesting about this which also relates to the climate protesters and
00:12:08 so on is that the subjectivity of this policeman he was just stating his own opinion as if his own
00:12:13 opinion was the law and he was saying that the the guy who was protesting said well what if i am
00:12:18 offended by the blue checks on your uniform and the policeman said well that would be ridiculous
00:12:23 yeah and but you could see that for you know from what he was saying he was just saying because i
00:12:28 think that it's that that what you're saying is offensive he said that um that it could trigger
00:12:34 trauma and that we live in a society now where you know that your words could trigger trauma and that
00:12:39 is equivalent to punching someone in the face my god china must be looking at us and absolutely
00:12:44 they must be laughing their heads off you know with us navel gazing about words equal violence
00:12:50 and the russians yes and iran but it's but from a policing perspective surely this is total chaos
00:12:57 because nobody nobody really knows the policemen don't even seem to know what the law is they don't
00:13:01 and the police are selectively policing we've seen selective police judges have said in terms
00:13:07 you know nobody has the right not to be offended i mean that is that causing offense is not an
00:13:13 offense as a judgment yeah and yet the police don't seem to have absorbed that but is but this
00:13:18 is this is this a problem with the policemen themselves the policemen on the ground the
00:13:22 institution or is it a problem with the bosses in the police it's the problem that they're not
00:13:27 adequately trained to even understand what the law is the police college and the training that's
00:13:31 it's common purpose has a lot to answer for this little you know the marxist tentacles you know
00:13:37 going through the third way the third you know the the long march going little tentacle tentacles
00:13:42 going through which includes things like words equal violence and as if you hear that often enough
00:13:48 you believe it you'll believe it and that's what happens misrepresenting the law like they did when
00:13:53 they had that big slogan on the back of a bus where they said uh being offensive is an offense
00:13:58 and that was actually not the law
00:14:01 yeah exactly
00:14:02 they're sort of rewriting it in their own image
00:14:05 I mean I think I said a few months ago
00:14:07 we are in sort of Maoist
00:14:08 very strange territory here
00:14:11 it's this plague, the plague of subjectivity
00:14:13 because like with the
00:14:15 you mentioned the College of Policing
00:14:17 they are an
00:14:19 unaccountable quango that
00:14:21 came up with an entirely new category
00:14:23 of recording of non-crime
00:14:25 hate incidents which was what
00:14:27 the policeman Harry Miller had on his record
00:14:29 with the famous police phoning him up
00:14:31 and saying they were going to check his sinking
00:14:33 that they're recording these
00:14:35 non-crime head accidents. I thought you said check his sinking
00:14:37 for a minute. Harry are you
00:14:38 are you there
00:14:40 all you can hear is this bubbling down the phone
00:14:43 sorry yeah check his thinking
00:14:45 not his check whether he's sinking. Yeah so they've
00:14:47 created this entire category of reporting
00:14:49 this is not something that parliament has agreed
00:14:51 but yet it's something that can go
00:14:53 on your record and show up in an advanced DBS
00:14:55 check it just seems as if the police have forgotten what the police are
00:14:59 supposed to do. That slogan has become overused.
00:15:01 We live in a free society. That's what they have forgotten.
00:15:04 Do we? And we're sure we do anymore.
00:15:06 Well maybe not but what they have forgotten is that they are supposed to be
00:15:09 policing on the basis that we live in a free society. Yes. And that just
00:15:15 does not apply now and it's not only in policing it doesn't apply anywhere and
00:15:19 And unless your views match state orthodoxy, you know, you're going to be penalised for having one.
00:15:27 And I don't believe any citizen should have a record of any sort unless it has been imposed by a court.
00:15:34 But is this a problem not just to do with the police, but also to do with the culture around law?
00:15:41 It is in all institutions now.
00:15:42 We've been seeing for years and years this habit of over-legislating.
00:15:47 legislating for things where there is already legislation in place or the even the scottish
00:15:52 hate crime bill is a perfect example of this the idea that you can and it's very orwellian that
00:15:57 you can legislate people's hearts and minds so like with the scottish hate crime bill and now
00:16:01 with the proposals in northern ireland for a similar hate crime bill they want to um to bring
00:16:09 in legislation that will as they put it make scotland a nicer place make scotland a better
00:16:14 place but the implication of that is that they want to moderate your speech with the intention
00:16:19 to moderate your thought. They want to suppress your speech. Well the whole and it is Orwellian
00:16:24 in the deepest most basic sense because the whole point is that they want to try and make
00:16:29 people think more nicely. They're trying to affect your thoughts. I'll tell you who's to blame for this.
00:16:32 Julia Middleton who started Common Purpose, the daughter of a Marxist, then she became a Marxist
00:16:38 and this has been going on for 25 maybe more years where and these they do courses that you go on
00:16:45 and it's all this is this is what it's led to is is a total re reimagining of society
00:16:51 well she's one of the people i what i don't get is this and i really don't get this the vast
00:16:56 majority of the population are where you and i are on this they want free speech uh they believe
00:17:02 that as long as you're not you know committing any crime yeah you can hold what opinions you like
00:17:07 and providing you don't do it in a way which generates violence,
00:17:10 you can state those opinions.
00:17:12 And if you go out and you do any public opinion poll,
00:17:14 people want free speech.
00:17:17 That's right.
00:17:17 And yet the establishment, the whole of the establishment,
00:17:22 is conspiring to prevent free speech.
00:17:24 Yes.
00:17:24 And even free thought, if only it could.
00:17:27 Yeah.
00:17:27 How intentional do you think it is, though?
00:17:29 Is it just sleepwalking into it because there's this culture...
00:17:32 Or us, or the institutions.
00:17:34 The institutions.
00:17:34 Oh, no, it's deliberate.
00:17:35 So I think, I mean, in Scotland, I mean, I think it's probably quite deliberate.
00:17:40 I think that's what they're intending to do.
00:17:41 But do you think that it's a change in culture?
00:17:43 It's something in the zeitgeist?
00:17:44 It varies. I think it varies.
00:17:46 I think sometimes you're right.
00:17:47 I think it's quite deliberate.
00:17:48 It was started way back, didn't it?
00:17:49 But I also think that there is an awful lot of sleepwalking,
00:17:53 that people are just absorbing a message, this is nice and that's not.
00:17:56 You know, and we'll always have what's nice,
00:17:58 and we can't hear from what's not nice.
00:18:01 And I think people have sleptwalked into it,
00:18:03 but you know we've got a government we've got a government now what is it going to do and the
00:18:10 answer at the moment seems to be nothing well and also the government are all common purposed
00:18:14 up to the hills as well it's got it's got everywhere it's infected everything this whole
00:18:18 you know which is one of their things in common purpose i only know because my late husband
00:18:21 knew a lot about it and so he worked in government and he saw the effect of it but um one of their
00:18:27 sort of mantras is
00:18:29 act beyond your
00:18:31 authority. And
00:18:33 again, if you hear that often enough, it doesn't
00:18:35 matter who you are. I mean, look at someone like
00:18:37 Cressida Dick or Sadiq Khan
00:18:39 for that matter. This is a point that goes all the way
00:18:42 back to, you know, John Stuart Mill
00:18:43 and what the limits of the state should be. It seems
00:18:45 that every single institution
00:18:47 no longer knows what that
00:18:49 institution's purpose is. They don't see
00:18:51 themselves as part of a delicate ecosystem
00:18:53 where each part has a function.
00:18:54 they keep trying to go beyond that remit
00:18:57 like I was saying with over legislating
00:18:59 government institutions
00:19:01 no longer know what they're supposed to be doing
00:19:03 they don't know what their limits are, they don't recognise
00:19:05 the importance of their limits for protecting
00:19:07 people's freedom because they think that they
00:19:09 can just expand and expand and expand
00:19:11 more and more into people's lives and into their heads
00:19:13 Yes, and their sort of feelings
00:19:15 matter more than facts
00:19:16 the fact that I'm sort of really upset
00:19:18 Patricia from Bournemouth says
00:19:21 policemen need to be reminded
00:19:23 of the playground rhymes
00:19:24 sticks and stones may break my bones
00:19:26 but words will never hurt me
00:19:28 whatever happened to that
00:19:29 I remember that from primary school
00:19:31 that's a mantra that I still live by
00:19:33 sticks and stones may break my bones
00:19:34 but you can always find something to offend a feminist
00:19:36 that's what I quite like
00:19:38 we've just lost Patricia from Bournemouth
00:19:41 citation Peter Lloyd
00:19:41 it's logged off
00:19:43 we've also got a comment here from
00:19:47 Max from
00:19:48 Edgebaston, I hope I'm saying that correctly
00:19:51 I find the policeman's stupidity
00:19:53 to be offensive, can I ask
00:19:55 for him to be charged with assault
00:19:57 please
00:19:58 they shall be charged with dereliction of duty
00:20:03 yes, a lot of them, exactly
00:20:05 so another subject that has
00:20:07 been in the news a lot over the
00:20:09 past couple of weeks has been
00:20:11 developments in
00:20:13 the gender debate
00:20:14 so
00:20:16 yes, I'm sure this
00:20:19 will please you yesterday the court of appeal overturned the high court judgment from december
00:20:24 last year that in the kira bell case kira bell is this um lady who uh she transitioned to being
00:20:32 a boy and then transitioned de-transitioned back and feels that the medical uh establishment has
00:20:40 become politicized she did all that as a young teenager yeah and so now she is incredibly brave
00:20:45 incredibly brave woman took this to the high court the high court found in her favor that
00:20:52 hormone blockers shouldn't be puberty blockers shouldn't be given to children under the age of
00:20:58 16 because of consent issues and this was then challenged in the court of appeal the court of
00:21:04 appeal has overturned the judgment stonewall is very happy obviously um and so there but there
00:21:09 have been a number of different um you know news coming out about this in the last couple of days
00:21:17 um even you know another example of why kira bell is so brave because women who do speak out about
00:21:23 these sorts of things do get a lot of vitriol um rosie duffield who's a labor mp has actually had
00:21:32 to decide it's reported uh yesterday that she's not um going to be going to the labor party
00:21:38 conference because her safety can't be uh insured because she's received so many threats after she
00:21:44 posted a tweet saying that um only women have a cervix um and she's been quite clear she is she
00:21:51 she's fine with trans rights and all of that and um gay rights and so on but she is in favor and
00:21:59 actually so yeah terrible what i think about my feelings what i think is really important about
00:22:03 this is that rosie duffield um did if you remember she did a speech in parliament a really emotional
00:22:09 speech i was choked up by it when she was talking about how she had been a victim of domestic abuse
00:22:14 now she thinks rightly i think that women's only spaces sex based on biological sex should be
00:22:22 protected in the case of toilets and prisons and irrelevant to her case refuges for women who have
00:22:30 being victims of domestic abuse absolutely it but what what is me is going back to your your
00:22:36 cure of bell case is we've now abandoned the principle of protecting children i mean a child
00:22:43 of 10 or 12 cannot take a decision in the same way uh that a young person of 17 or 18 can i mean
00:22:50 they just can't it is impossible in terms of of development and yet we've lost now the idea that
00:22:59 A, you protect the children, B, you need parental consent
00:23:03 before a child can take any sort of decision that an adult would normally take.
00:23:08 We've lost it. We've lost it completely, and it's all about rights.
00:23:12 And actually, a child's first right is to be protected by the grown-up one.
00:23:16 That is the child's first right.
00:23:18 And they have just started rolling out experimental vaccines for children aged 12,
00:23:23 and it's going to go lower and lower and lower.
00:23:26 I mean, honestly, if this was back in the, you know, 1918 and the Titanic, all the blokes would be getting on the, women and children would be going down with the ship.
00:23:36 That's how much it's changed.
00:23:38 We're seeing the undermining of parental consent in all sorts of areas.
00:23:42 I mean, obviously there's stuff around vaccines where there was like, well, parental consent will be sought, but we might override it if the child wants it and they disagree with their parents.
00:23:53 So that's sort of not really parental consent being sought in any meaningful way.
00:23:57 But also with the new guidance in Scotland that was issued for schools that they don't, schools don't need to get parental consent or even tell the parents if their child wants to identify and socially transition by identifying, using other pronouns, being, if they're a girl, being a boy in school.
00:24:18 The parents don't even have to be consulted about this.
00:24:21 What are parents for? I mean, what are parents for?
00:24:22 they are supposed to be the guides
00:24:25 the authority, the role models
00:24:26 and the ones who are responsible
00:24:28 and if their children don't go to school
00:24:30 they are responsible
00:24:31 but if they want to take a view on what a child is taught
00:24:35 then suddenly they're completely sidelined
00:24:38 and we've undermined parental consent
00:24:40 completely, that's another thing the Marxists have done
00:24:43 thanks to Common Purpose
00:24:44 the family unit has broken down
00:24:47 so what you're seeing now is you're seeing parents
00:24:49 who are sort of, they want to be the child's friend
00:24:55 and they're sort of, you know, with the rainbow coloured hair
00:24:57 as opposed to saying, learn your times table,
00:25:01 you know, behave, get educated, you know, have a happy life.
00:25:06 It's all Rousseau's fault.
00:25:08 It's all Rousseau. God, how far are we going?
00:25:10 It's all Rousseau, damn him, and his romanticism.
00:25:14 But yes, I think there's a lot of, you know,
00:25:18 neo-marxist stuff in here but I think so there's a comment here from Gemma from Middlesbrough
00:25:24 who says that many of these kids are gay not trans they're confused teens discovering their
00:25:30 sexuality so there are issues around there from a gay rights perspective there are gay rights
00:25:37 activists who are concerned about that particular point but also it's for me it seems like from the
00:25:44 news over the last couple of days it's less about the trans side of the debate and it's become more
00:25:49 about protecting sex-based rights because you can't have women's rights unless you recognize
00:25:55 biological sex it's not possible yes um and so there are gay men being thrown under the bus
00:25:59 by these dreadful people who are saying there's no such thing as same-sex attraction i mean it
00:26:05 literally is like you know we again we we we there's a war on reality was what's happened
00:26:11 well you know and there's also a wall on the dictionary because natalie bird i don't know if
00:26:18 you've heard of uh natalie bird she's a member of the free she's a member of the free speech union
00:26:23 um she's a liberal democrat yeah she's been banned from standing for office for 10 years
00:26:29 because she wore a t-shirt that said woman adult human female which is the dictionary definition
00:26:37 banned by the the unliberical unliberal anti-democrats um and ed davey the leader
00:26:45 went on the andrew mar show and when he was questioned about why this was a problem and i
00:26:51 think andrew mar did a really good job of questioning him on it and he said the reason
00:26:55 why is because the phrase he said quote this is the dictionary definition doesn't really encapsulate
00:27:00 the debate. A trans woman
00:27:02 is a woman. A trans man
00:27:04 is a man. Which is just nonsense.
00:27:07 Again,
00:27:07 Ed, these people, what are they
00:27:10 doing? They're aiding
00:27:12 and abetting, aren't they? The lunacy.
00:27:14 I mean, you're right, Anne. It's like, where
00:27:16 are the people that are saying, no?
00:27:19 No. We're not going to be
00:27:20 doing this anymore. But it's not only that. I mean, you are
00:27:22 now not allowed to have an opinion in the Liberal
00:27:24 Party. Yeah. You're now not
00:27:26 allowed to have an opinion, on a matter of fact,
00:27:28 yes within the liberal part but how can it be that the dictionary definition is something that
00:27:33 could exclude you from running for the liberal democrats it just doesn't make any sense another
00:27:39 another um thing in the news this week brilliant article in the express about jillian phillip
00:27:45 the children's author who stood up for jk rowling on twitter she was chucked out by her publisher
00:27:52 and she has retrained as a hgv driver and she says as a woman who form a very small proportion
00:27:59 of hgv drivers um that it's a far more tolerant industry than publishing and it just seems you
00:28:07 know day after day there are so many um cases of these are just women who are standing up for
00:28:14 women's rights their right to sex same-sex spaces yeah which i think the majority of women in the
00:28:20 country would agree with you can't they do yeah it's the only way to women fought and you know
00:28:24 how do you have a biological man in a woman's refuge yes how can you yes sort of safety does
00:28:33 that give the woman there's an element of heartlessness about it as well hospital wards
00:28:36 like particularly particularly in the case of rosie duffield it's just heartless to i think
00:28:43 given her experiences of domestic abuse there's just something heartless about saying to women
00:28:49 And no, you're not allowed to have the same sex.
00:28:50 And J.K. Rowling had exactly the same experience.
00:28:53 And that's one of the things that she...
00:28:54 I mean, I tweeted support for J.K. Rowling last year.
00:28:58 My God, was that a mistake?
00:28:59 My agent dropped me because I...
00:29:02 I mean, quite subtly dropped me.
00:29:03 I just didn't return any of my goals.
00:29:05 Because I'd come out in support of J.K. Rowling.
00:29:08 And what she said, and supporting reality,
00:29:10 the reality of biological sex.
00:29:12 But if that can happen to J.K. Rowling,
00:29:15 who's our big, big...
00:29:16 Exactly.
00:29:16 you know what is it like for little Mr and Mrs ordinary precisely who suddenly find you know that
00:29:23 they've lost their job at Asda or you know Marks and Spencers and they're sorry I'm not I'm not
00:29:27 advocating you know sorry that's not product placement just the first things I could think
00:29:31 of um and uh yeah what recourse because then if they go to their you know the HR the HR people
00:29:40 are going to say well you shouldn't really have said it so there's nobody you're right there's no
00:29:44 there's no recourse
00:29:46 and people are being punished for
00:29:48 things they've tweeted at the age of 13
00:29:50 or 14
00:29:51 and they're now adults
00:29:53 probably take a slightly different line
00:29:55 or may take a slightly different line
00:29:57 but they can still actually lose their jobs
00:29:59 or be suspended or whatever it is for something
00:30:02 they said when they were
00:30:04 13 or 14
00:30:04 and it's always the classic that it's usually the people who are actually on the left
00:30:08 that are the ones that get attacked
00:30:10 and mobbed because
00:30:11 I guess it's the sort of classic
00:30:14 what was it that Orwell said
00:30:16 that communists hate socialists
00:30:18 even more than they hate capitalists
00:30:20 yes yeah exactly
00:30:21 but there's something in that
00:30:23 that they always go for
00:30:25 they're going for feminists
00:30:26 they're going for people
00:30:27 who are more traditionally on the left
00:30:28 because nobody can be pure enough
00:30:30 these people are so obsessed
00:30:32 with ideology
00:30:33 but the ideology has to be pure
00:30:35 and like Anne said
00:30:37 there's no room for disagreement
00:30:39 in the Liberal Party
00:30:42 which you're meant to say
00:30:43 The Liberal Party.
00:30:44 The Liberal Party, which is, yes, so we're, yeah.
00:30:48 Isn't it strange that when Tim Farron was obviously done away with
00:30:52 from the Lib Dems because of his views on abortion,
00:30:55 he held traditional religious views on subjects like abortion.
00:30:58 Yeah.
00:30:59 And it was incompatible with his Christian faith
00:31:01 to be a leader of the Liberal Democrats.
00:31:03 Now, those pro-abortion activists presumably will be doing so
00:31:09 from campaigning they would say from a feminist perspective so how bizarre that now we're at a
00:31:16 point where the liberal democrat the whole thing is just so fudged none of it makes any sense it's
00:31:21 all it's such a mess i call it sort of moral moral gymnastics if these people went to the
00:31:27 olympics amoral they would amoral they they would they would win on the the sort of the
00:31:32 the contortion yes exactly the woke gymnastics but how do you think that history is going to
00:31:38 judge this how do you think that because like if you were trying to imagine i'm picking this in
00:31:42 hindsight with disbelief disbelief with total disbelief i mean i think it's going to get a lot
00:31:48 worse before it gets better yeah and i had thought and i was quite wrong about this but i had thought
00:31:52 that when the covid crisis started because for the first time since the second world war we had
00:31:58 something actually real that was disrupting our way of life and we had something to actually worry
00:32:03 about something real to worry about that we wouldn't have any patience with all this yes
00:32:08 other stuff yeah and yet it's gone the other way completely and and somehow i was i was one of
00:32:14 those mugs who wagered incorrectly on that thank almost like thank goodness for coronavirus i
00:32:20 thought it was i thought it was the end of madness i was very wrong it was yes so was i
00:32:25 another thing that has been reported this week is again more guidance for schools in Scotland
00:32:33 it seems to be something that is happening a lot in Scotland for schools in Dumfries and Galloway
00:32:39 a new guide for primary school teachers and pupils aged 9 to 11 on how to use inclusive
00:32:48 pronouns and the difference between gender biological sex and interestingly in the article
00:32:54 about this it said that 200 pupils seek support to transition in scotland every year 200 that is
00:33:01 very high it's the adults who who it's child abuse but essentially i really think it's like
00:33:09 if you want to be a crazy adult go and do it in your own time go and have your own island
00:33:13 but don't inflict it on on young people because that's what's happening isn't it it's it's the
00:33:19 the way the ideology of the kind of fringe is now is now being imposed on the next generation
00:33:26 their perspective we've forgotten as i said earlier on you know a child's first right is to
00:33:30 be protected by the grown-up world yeah from from their perspective though they would say that
00:33:36 they're doing it out of compassion because if stonewall when stonewall were commenting on this
00:33:41 um this court of appeal judgment they said um that and not that i'm i'm not certainly not
00:33:50 advocating for stonewall's view here but just to put it to you um they said that the previous
00:33:56 ruling left young people in limbo without vital health care support so it's being framed as this
00:34:02 is a health care thing rather than it being viewed as an issue to do with the safeguarding of
00:34:08 children because the argument of course is that children don't know what to their what they're
00:34:12 consenting to and kira bell's argument is that these are children who are being put on a pathway
00:34:16 towards sterilization which is the consequence of taking these hormones i think it's munchausen's
00:34:22 munchausen's by proxy i guess what it is we have enough cases in the adult world of people who've
00:34:27 transitioned and who then uh transition back again yes uh because they've got it wrong now
00:34:33 if adults can get it wrong, how much more likely is it that children are going to get
00:34:38 it wrong? It's so much more likely. It's like inflicting, I'm going to sound very old fashioned
00:34:44 now, it's like inflicting a perversion on young minds rather than focusing on being
00:34:52 free, climbing trees, you know, experimenting with who they are. Adults have gone, tell
00:34:59 you what we're going to put all our neuroses onto you little jimmy or little you know and you can
00:35:05 take our decisions that's what you can take our decisions yeah you know no child should ever be
00:35:11 expected to take an adult but again this is russo again though isn't it because it's the idea that
00:35:16 the children it's like child-led learning the idea that that the children should be leading the way
00:35:22 because they know better than we do the tyranny of children it's the greater effect exactly let's
00:35:29 And also, let's choose a little, little Greta, bless her, sort of like a little, yes, she's being used for adult, what's the word, for pushing sort of crazy ideas.
00:35:43 I know, let's use a child as the poster for this.
00:35:46 Well, she wouldn't see it like that.
00:35:48 No, no, of course not.
00:35:48 She wouldn't see it like that at all.
00:35:50 She would say that she feels very strongly about this anyway.
00:35:53 Of course, because she's been so brainwashed.
00:35:56 Well, I mean, there's an awful lot of brainwashing going on.
00:35:58 But I just think in terms of the trans stuff,
00:36:02 you cannot expect children who barely know what sex is
00:36:07 to take really major decisions of that order of magnitude.
00:36:14 And the socialists, on our right in saying the left,
00:36:17 a really weird hell, they're connected with this.
00:36:20 Because was it Harriet Harman with a paedophile information,
00:36:24 whatever it's called, I was going to say agency,
00:36:26 that's the wrong word, PIE.
00:36:27 you know that she they they they pushed a lot of that you know that sort of thing of like oh well
00:36:31 you know if you know children are sort of fair game and they're not they should never be in a
00:36:37 civilized society they would have put it that way but i i think and to be fair to them i don't think
00:36:42 they would ever put it that way uh but i think that what was happening was they were pushing a
00:36:47 liberal agenda yes yes yeah it is a matter of morality rather than a matter of child protection
00:36:52 Do you think that there's an element to this of confusion,
00:36:56 that generally the British public are nice, good, decent people
00:37:00 who want to be kind,
00:37:01 and so there are some who have a kind of radical gender ideology
00:37:04 or any other sort of more radical ideology,
00:37:07 and if they present it as being the new way to be nice,
00:37:11 then people are too frightened to speak against it
00:37:14 because they don't want to be viewed as being unkind.
00:37:16 But people are speaking against it in their own homes.
00:37:18 They're speaking against it in conversations in the pub.
00:37:21 they're speaking against it they're very chary about speaking against it on social media because
00:37:26 they know what can happen yeah but people are um muttering um yeah and that's why i'm glad that we
00:37:33 now have got we've we've got a little clutch of initiatives on free speech you've got toby young
00:37:38 for example in his free speech union um and and so that there is some sort of pushback but it's
00:37:44 nothing like enough no and won't be until mr and mrs ordinary feel they can say what they think
00:37:50 Yeah. I mean, I had a conversation with a very well-known comedian the other day, a female comedian, household name, about this stuff.
00:38:01 And she said, well, I would, you know, I would say things, but I sort of worry.
00:38:05 And I said, well, don't worry. You're in a position to say things, you know.
00:38:11 Comedian can get away with more than most.
00:38:13 Well, yeah, exactly.
00:38:14 I can't believe I'm going to say this. Before I segue onto an even more controversial subject.
00:38:20 I just want to
00:38:22 mention Mark who says
00:38:24 it's becoming hell on earth
00:38:25 and to thank you Mark for your super chat
00:38:28 so
00:38:29 on to a more controversial subject
00:38:31 the English
00:38:34 touring opera
00:38:35 it was reported this week
00:38:37 have dropped 14 musicians
00:38:39 from their orchestra
00:38:41 because of a diversity drive
00:38:43 so these are white musicians from the ages of
00:38:46 I think it's 55
00:38:48 to 60 i may be getting that those numbers wrong um but they've dropped 14 musicians in this
00:38:54 diversity drive um straight after the pandemic they won't be going on the next tour um and
00:39:01 everybody is quite roundly criticizing this and condemning it as racist well it is racist yeah
00:39:08 um it is absolutely racist uh if racial equality means that we're all treated equally then those
00:39:15 musicians have been treated unequally yes uh and i mean i actually say in my uh express column
00:39:23 tomorrow uh i say that i think the eto has hit a wrong note and that is exactly what i do very
00:39:30 nice in the same in the same vein it was also reported this week that a royal holloway music
00:39:36 professor has quit over concerns about the turn that music education is taking um and his concern
00:39:44 that the faculty would stop teaching Beethoven and Wagner.
00:39:47 Why?
00:39:48 And we've seen this before.
00:39:49 Sorry, why are they stopping?
00:39:50 Oh, because it's not...
00:39:53 Colonialist.
00:39:54 Well, in this instance, because they wrote music in the time of empire.
00:39:59 And if you remember, actually, the British Library were talking about
00:40:03 removing the busts of Beethoven and Mendelssohn
00:40:06 because they were somehow centring white supremacism.
00:40:10 I'm just paraphrasing the sort of thing I imagine they would say.
00:40:14 but this has become a real thing in classical music
00:40:16 and Abby you are so the one to talk on this
00:40:18 on the subject of opera
00:40:20 but it's become a real thing in classical music
00:40:22 that is being viewed as being
00:40:24 white and white supremacist
00:40:26 and needing to be decolonised
00:40:28 yes I mean it's
00:40:29 it's crazy I don't know music to me
00:40:32 is the
00:40:33 one thing that doesn't have any
00:40:36 shouldn't have any
00:40:37 boundaries or be obsessed
00:40:40 with the colour of people's skin or what they look like
00:40:42 or what they, it's the most, it's the most universally uplifting thing in the world.
00:40:48 And what's going to happen, as with all this rubbish, is that the left is going to just
00:40:53 throw away joy for people. And that's what I really, really hate. I'd love to get these
00:40:59 people just by the scruff of the neck and say, just go and sit in a dark room, you know,
00:41:04 with, you know, with Jesse Norman, you know, or, you know, Maria Callas, or I mean, go
00:41:09 and sit in a room and just and and take that you're taking that away from people who who who
00:41:14 can enjoy it i wonder whether you can even actually have sorry i was gonna say i wonder
00:41:22 you know how soon before we start uh condemning our ancestors cavemen yeah for being unkind to
00:41:28 woolly mammoths you know just how far back do you take things and every age has its own ethos
00:41:35 it is not the ethos we have now
00:41:37 but it's a mugs game
00:41:39 to try and impose our standards
00:41:41 on people from the past
00:41:44 and yet now
00:41:45 that is becoming absolutely the norm
00:41:48 what do you think that this does
00:41:50 to art because I wonder
00:41:51 whether, I don't think that you can
00:41:53 actually have real art that is
00:41:56 explicitly political
00:41:57 I think that you destroy
00:41:59 artistic expression, the sort of like
00:42:01 humanity of it by trying
00:42:03 to instrumentalise it for some kind of political purpose.
00:42:06 Or art shouldn't have any, I mean, I don't think art
00:42:09 should have any, what's the word, sort of parameters around it.
00:42:13 That's the whole point, because as soon as you start
00:42:14 putting parameters around it, people then work
00:42:16 to those parameters.
00:42:18 But there's also this assumption in there that,
00:42:21 with the case of the English touring opera,
00:42:24 obviously the reason why they want to have more,
00:42:27 and when they say diverse, they actually just mean physically,
00:42:29 which I think is kind of brutal.
00:42:30 Which is absurd. I mean, can you play the instrument?
00:42:33 but the implication of that is that they think that when touring that audiences will only
00:42:38 associate with them or enjoy the music if they see people who look like them and it's the same
00:42:43 assumption that you get with literature it is patronizing patronizing it's assuming that those
00:42:48 people can't appreciate music it's the same as the you know the idea that you can't like shakespeare
00:42:55 if you're not a white man because you're yeah and actually another this is again this week um
00:43:01 university of exeter there is a rebellion brewing amongst the academics there because they've been
00:43:06 given guidance to um to use what they refer to as gray literature um with tweets and blogs
00:43:14 basically instead of archives because apparently the archives are biased and the quote from this
00:43:19 guidance says that archives are not neutral so again it's this assumption that you have that
00:43:25 So people can't appreciate art or relate to it
00:43:29 if they are not represented in the identity category
00:43:32 of the person creating that art.
00:43:34 But that is just nonsense.
00:43:35 And it's actually quite literally divisive.
00:43:38 Yeah.
00:43:38 Actually, all my favourite, even though I love opera
00:43:41 and I did train in it many years ago,
00:43:43 all my favourite singers are all black.
00:43:45 I mean, Ray Charles, Ruth Franklin, Chuck Berry,
00:43:50 all my favourite musicians are all black.
00:43:52 Guess what, everyone?
00:43:54 You know, I'm a white woman.
00:43:55 No one's going to take Billie Holiday away from me.
00:43:56 Is that going to be taken away from me?
00:43:58 No, it's just absurd.
00:44:00 No, music should cross all boundaries, all faiths, all genders, all colours.
00:44:04 Music and literature.
00:44:05 Yeah, music, exactly.
00:44:06 And actually that's the...
00:44:08 Music and literature.
00:44:09 The great level.
00:44:10 And art.
00:44:10 And art.
00:44:11 But that's why the humanity of it,
00:44:12 so like Shakespeare and the universals,
00:44:15 everyone can relate to it because it's real, because it's human.
00:44:18 Yeah.
00:44:18 Because we aren't our skin colours and our eye colours
00:44:21 or our height or our gender.
00:44:23 No, this is superficial.
00:44:25 this it's like what's beyond skin just just before we run to an end this has gone very quickly
00:44:32 open the doors grease the doors I'm coming through Shemima Begum has done another interview
00:44:43 another wonderfully framed PR exercise to try and come back to the United Kingdom what do you think
00:44:50 I think she should change her name to E, her first name to E,
00:44:55 and then move to Yorkshire.
00:44:56 Ebegum.
00:44:57 Ebegum.
00:44:58 Ebegum, love.
00:45:00 All right.
00:45:00 How are you, man?
00:45:01 How are you, man?
00:45:03 We're mixing our accents up.
00:45:06 I ask myself this.
00:45:07 At the time that she went out to join the jihadists,
00:45:10 they were beheading people.
00:45:12 They were crucifying people.
00:45:14 They were sacking historic sites.
00:45:16 They were behaving like a complete horde of barbarians.
00:45:19 Now, you know, she says she was only 15.
00:45:22 At 15, and considerably younger than that,
00:45:24 I knew it was wrong to run a back place
00:45:27 beheading and crucifying people.
00:45:28 Didn't she?
00:45:29 It wasn't a gap year, was it?
00:45:31 Yeah, exactly.
00:45:32 It's not just the normal going off the rails.
00:45:34 I once smuggled a bottle of Jack Daniels into school.
00:45:37 You know, it was terrible, but I never joined ISIS.
00:45:39 I never joined a terrorist organisation.
00:45:41 At 15.
00:45:42 I mean, I completely agree with you, Anne,
00:45:45 because, you know, she chose to travel
00:45:46 after all of the beheadings.
00:45:48 James Foley, Alan Henning.
00:45:50 She would have seen all of that.
00:45:51 There's no way that she would have been unaware of it,
00:45:53 regardless of what she was being fed by, you know,
00:45:55 Islamic State recruiters, whatever.
00:45:57 She would have been aware of that at 15.
00:45:59 I mean, you know, that's not...
00:46:01 And living in a country in which there's free news
00:46:03 and she could get it all.
00:46:04 But regardless, I think the whole debate around it
00:46:07 so often just gets taken off on a red herring
00:46:09 because the reason for taking citizenship away from her,
00:46:13 she still does have Bangladeshi citizenship legally.
00:46:16 No, she's not state.
00:46:17 but the reason for doing that was a national security decision if she's brought back here
00:46:22 she won't see justice because it's so difficult to get um they people will say well you need to
00:46:28 you know try her by our own laws and in our own courts but it's not possible to do that it's the
00:46:33 chances of her seeing justice here are very small yes what would happen would be she would go back
00:46:38 into the community she might be on some kind of um community service um and and ultimately would
00:46:46 probably not receive the sort of justice that you would expect from someone who has betrayed
00:46:51 their country yes yes it would be like a delayed what's it called a delayed sentence you know when
00:46:56 they sort of yeah they give you a sentence but actually then they change then they say well
00:46:59 suspended yeah suspended exactly that's the word thanks um yeah and when she was interviewed i
00:47:04 noticed she was wearing a nike was it nike baseball cap and uh looked very west i just thought yeah
00:47:10 and i just thought one of the cardassians she did it's like hi i don't know if you remember me but
00:47:15 I used to be into beheading and, you know, stoning women to death.
00:47:19 She still seems to not really grasp the seriousness of having gone to join ISIS
00:47:26 as if that was not.
00:47:28 Even in that interview, it still seemed that she doesn't really understand that that...
00:47:33 Because even if she was just a housewife,
00:47:35 she still went to take part in the state-building enterprise
00:47:38 of a terrorist proto-state that committed genocide.
00:47:42 It's no small thing.
00:47:43 Yes, exactly.
00:47:44 it's yeah so we've got a comment here from paula from mile end who says and i think this is a really
00:47:50 really interesting point um she says people forget that she actually renounced her citizenship
00:47:55 no home to come back to now i think most people would agree with paula that i think is implicit
00:48:00 in this comment which is that citizenship is not just a legal thing it's a loyalty if you if this
00:48:07 is your home you don't go and join a terrorist group that fights against your country so i think
00:48:13 many people would think well citizenship is something that is is far more than just the
00:48:18 letter it's about belonging exactly and that she by going and joining this group has renounced her
00:48:24 citizenship in the most basic sense it's called treason yeah if we had treason laws then we can
00:48:30 bring her back and try her according to them but yeah we don't we don't have treason laws anymore
00:48:34 why is that ann do we do we know what we gave them up yeah the eu oh god back to them and on that
00:48:40 Thank you for joining us.
00:48:43 Please like and subscribe if you feel that way inclined.
00:48:47 And please join us next time.
00:48:48 Thanks very much.
00:48:57 A little more laughter.
00:48:59 Wee.