New Culture Forum - September 27, 2021


Migration Watch: Tory Government Is INCREASING Immigration, Which Is Already At Unprecedented Levels

WWW Ep2: Climate Extremists, Shemima Begum, Puberty Blockers & Police Free Speech Wokery British Police Have Transformed Into A Tool For Enforcing The State's Will -- Peter Hitchens

Episode Stats


Length

54 minutes

Words per minute

121.72

Word count

6,602

Sentence count

125


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now for many years immigration
00:00:25 was top of the list of the public's concerns. For a while, it seemed to drop off. Now it's back
00:00:33 there at number three, if we are to believe the polls. Of course, for millions of us, it never
00:00:40 really left the top position, including me. During the past couple of decades, Migration Watch,
00:00:48 the think tank, is the only organisation that has actually argued for properly controlled
00:00:56 immigration. It's done it from a very forensic and statistical point of view. So I'm delighted
00:01:02 that today my guest is Alp Mehmet, who is chairman of Migration Watch. Thank you very much for
00:01:08 joining us, Alp. Absolute pleasure, Peter. I've been looking forward to this moment.
00:01:13 oh um oh i'm going to start with a very broad question should people trust this government
00:01:22 on immigration they've certainly not provided any serious evidence so far that anyone should
00:01:33 trust them frankly and especially on immigration at the moment i certainly don't trust what they're
00:01:41 doing on immigration, primarily because they set out to control immigration. That's what we were
00:01:49 being told in 2019. We will control immigration along with everything else now that we're out of
00:01:57 the EU. When pressed, not only were they going to control immigration, but they were going to reduce
00:02:05 it and both the Prime Minister and indeed the Home Secretary through the campaign said we will
00:02:11 reduce immigration. That has gone out of the window. They've introduced a points-based system,
00:02:22 an Australian points-based system which is very far from being an Australian type of
00:02:30 points-based system. There are no limits for a start and that is central to the overall
00:02:38 Australian system. The Home Secretary, speaking recently, said reducing numbers, reducing
00:02:50 immigration to tens of thousands, that's old speak. We're not going to do that. What we're going to do
00:02:58 is bring in the sort of people that we need and that was it so for over 10 years we had
00:03:08 a government a conservative party saying to us we will reduce immigration we will reduce
00:03:13 immigration now they're saying no no that's old speak we're not going to do it that's why i don't
00:03:22 trust them when you look at the detail of the system that they have introduced
00:03:28 that in fact is going to lead to more immigration not less and the reason for that is
00:03:38 the points based system is supposed to allocate um award certain number of points for
00:03:47 particular areas before one qualifies for a visa to come here.
00:03:56 What they've done is actually reduced the qualification levels, they've reduced the
00:04:06 salaries that are to be earned, the earnings levels have been reduced. There is now no
00:04:15 looking locally first. There is now no looking to see what need there is for a particular job.
00:04:27 In really one fell swoop what they've done is effectively opened up
00:04:34 the jobs market to something like 600 million people around the world.
00:04:40 so can i trust them on immigration well i've seen nothing yet that would suggest to me that i should
00:04:49 be trusting them or anyone should be trusting them what's the rationale behind what they're
00:04:55 doing because frankly it flies in the face of everything that people wanted or concerned about
00:05:01 i mean essentially as i see it at the moment uh and please tell me if i'm net migration this great
00:05:09 net figure is around about 300 000 just under 300 000 a year isn't it with these new uh relaxations
00:05:20 what do you think it might be in going into the future um
00:05:26 we're in a difficult position at the moment for obvious reasons international travel
00:05:33 orbit came to a halt last year it has done since sort of March last year
00:05:40 so it's very difficult to know precisely what is going on what the government has also done
00:05:50 is actually stopped that system of surveys at the airport where people would be asked what they
00:06:00 were coming here to do and how long they would be here you may have been confronted by people
00:06:07 with clipboards asking these questions all that stopped so we don't actually know what is really
00:06:14 going on at the border they are looking at sort of official data be it um i don't know national
00:06:23 insurance cards or tax receipts or there are sort of additional data that they they can
00:06:33 examine so they have come up the most recent figure i think was a net migration at 247 000
00:06:44 however it's no good looking at what's been going on over the past 18 months or even
00:06:50 Even since we came out of the EU and even before that, the time of the referendum that you had something to do with, I seem to recall.
00:07:03 The fact is that people started to react in a certain way as a result of the referendum.
00:07:13 some people believe that a lot of people left from the EU, but there's no evidence of that,
00:07:26 frankly, and if you look at the number of people who registered to those who have registered for
00:07:37 settlement or pre-settlement this status that they were given an opportunity to acquire if they
00:07:44 wished we'd been told that there was something like 3.7 million people or thereabouts getting
00:07:51 up towards 4 million from the EU who would likely apply for settlement it turned out to be over 6
00:07:58 million for goodness sake so the truth is that we're not entirely clear as to what is going on
00:08:05 with numbers at the moment but if you look at the last 20 years then what has clearly been happening
00:08:16 and I'm sure will continue to happen in the future whatever is going on at the moment
00:08:21 around 300 000 net have been coming to this country over that period that is huge absolutely
00:08:31 huge it has um effectively doubled the number of non-uk born people in this country in in 20 years
00:08:41 from four and a half million to to nine million nine million now in doubled in 20 years yeah
00:08:49 and and those who were not born here if you add children who were born to uh those new arrivals
00:08:59 then we're now looking at an additional 7 million people to our population in 20 years,
00:09:08 the bulk of which is the result of migration, direct and indirect.
00:09:18 I mean, that is phenomenal. It's happened at such a speed.
00:09:23 And that is really what has always concerned us at Migration Watch.
00:09:28 Not immigration per se. I am an immigrant, as you know. It's not. And immigration has been a contributor. Not all immigration. Some migrants, some groups of migrants contribute quite a bit.
00:09:50 The vast majority do not. Time and again, research has shown and studies have shown that those who arrive at relatively low skill or unskilled jobs, relatively low amounts of pay, they end up in one way or another actually drawing on the system rather than contributing into it.
00:10:18 And that's really what concerns Migration Watch and what has always concerned us.
00:10:25 And before, you know, people say, well, we're scaremongers.
00:10:30 Well, over the last 20 years, time and again, we have shown, we have projected forecasts and been lambasted for it at times.
00:10:42 And in the end, we've turned out to be absolutely spot on.
00:10:46 this 300,000
00:10:49 I remember going back
00:10:52 to the early part of this century
00:10:54 I said
00:10:55 we must never let this become the new normal
00:10:58 I think both of us grew up at a time
00:11:00 where roughly it was about 50,000
00:11:02 I mean I'd say up until the mid 90s
00:11:04 roughly 50,000
00:11:06 but of course it has become the new normal
00:11:10 and there's almost no comment about it
00:11:14 apart from people like you
00:11:17 I don't mean in the population, but in the media.
00:11:20 I think it's almost barely reported on, actually.
00:11:23 But this is of historical proportions, isn't it?
00:11:27 This isn't just, oh, immigration is quite big for a while at the moment for these reasons.
00:11:33 This is a massive movement of people, isn't it?
00:11:38 It's unprecedented.
00:11:39 firstly the the rate at which our population is growing is that is a new phenomenon it really is
00:11:51 but in addition to that the scale of immigration we have never experienced anything like it
00:11:58 you say it's the new norm well um i'd like to say it's become the norm simply because the government
00:12:11 has proved itself totally incapable of doing anything about it and perhaps the reasons why
00:12:19 they've now eased off any attempts to reduce immigration is because they can't do anything
00:12:28 about it. And politically, they were continually being held up to ridicule because they said they
00:12:35 would do something and very obviously failed. I don't think it's the new norm. It shouldn't
00:12:43 become the new norm what must happen and it's still not too late really for us to reduce
00:12:52 immigration because if we don't I think that the single biggest risk is the absence and the
00:13:05 difficulty to integrate that is going to lead the underlying problems, risks, tensions that I think
00:13:21 potentially can prove very damaging to our society and it's the sort of thing that Dame Louise Casey
00:13:30 who did her own report in 2016 said you know we're sleepwalking into an integration crisis she said
00:13:38 absolutely right there's absolutely no there's no there's it's impossible surely and as you say
00:13:46 but also it's unnecessary uh to integrate if people are coming in such numbers and they can
00:13:54 go straight into a community i mean for example a good good example this would be there was a
00:14:00 discussion for a while it became very mainstream about the the use of languages on forms and
00:14:06 bureaucratic forms that even Labour I remember it was Chakauman I think said basically we should
00:14:13 actually encourage English to be used now that argument seems to have been entirely lost and has
00:14:19 gone away nothing has actually changed and there is therefore not the incentive surely or impulse
00:14:27 to integrate if you don't need to you're absolutely right I mean what is it that
00:14:35 people are integrating into and and that is a problem and then I have to just on
00:14:42 an anecdotal personal subjective basis looking at my own sort of history and
00:14:50 arrival in this country where I spoke no English. It was I actually arrived in
00:14:58 this country and I know it from my passport which had a French exit stamp
00:15:04 in it at Calais. It was the 26th of July 1956. My father had come to this country
00:15:17 1950 a Windrush generation of migrant. Actually I do rather resent that that particular phase
00:15:28 of immigration has been hijacked by a group of people who frankly only formed a very small part
00:15:35 of the overall migrant numbers people like my father and from other parts of the Commonwealth
00:15:48 at the time were by far the majority. Where was he coming from most? Cyprus, Cyprus but I arrived
00:15:56 in 1956 I spent about 18 months I suppose learning English
00:16:05 sufficiently well or well enough to get through the 11 plus and ended up in a grammar school in
00:16:12 the east end of London in September 1959 so it was I do recall all that period of
00:16:25 learning the language, of fitting into the community, of what it was that we were fitting into,
00:16:32 the way schools conducted themselves, what happened from the moment you started at school
00:16:40 in the morning until the time you left. I remember not really understanding what was being said but
00:16:48 certainly assemblies in the morning where there would be a hymn some of them well I didn't really
00:16:57 understand any of them at the time it was only later that I began to understand and have my own
00:17:03 favorites but that's how it would start and there would be morning assembly reading from the Bible
00:17:11 there'd be a little homily from the headmaster someone who just served in the in the second
00:17:19 world war as did all our other teachers there was this sort of unifying um
00:17:28 upbringing almost it was a part of it in addition to that i remember at the end of the day
00:17:37 there would be a little prayer before we left school thanking the lord for
00:17:45 what he had given us and that he would look after us until we returned the next day
00:17:55 at the end of term there would be a hymn in the morning we would have
00:18:01 morning assembly there are no morning assemblies by and large now and certainly not the sort of
00:18:13 morning assembly that they used to be in in primary school in in the 50s 60s to a certain extent
00:18:22 started to change through the 70s although my children they were in school in Kent the 70s and
00:18:33 early 80s and they still enjoyed morning assembly in the way that I had it has gone now I mean that
00:18:43 was the sort of the unifying effect of with children sort of bringing them
00:18:51 together having something a shared experience and that is what is almost
00:18:59 impossible now given the numbers from the variety of different places in the
00:19:06 Wild who arrived very quickly, what is it that they would get from singing a
00:19:15 morning hymn? Some of them would not take part anyway for religious reasons.
00:19:24 However, I do sometimes wonder if in our efforts not to offend new arrivals we
00:19:33 forget that the majority um is still those whose heritage and lineage you know it goes back
00:19:44 hundreds of years in this country well yes i mean you talk about uh not offending uh yes
00:19:53 that's almost a benign uh way of looking at it because i think it was peter hitchens who said
00:19:59 that you know back in the 60s he as a marxist he stay and he's he and his friends all supported
00:20:06 as much immigration as possible not because they cared about immigrants but they basically wanted
00:20:12 to well destroy the idea of britain and british nationality and everything and one can't help
00:20:19 feeling that when you're dealing with these people who are very the what you might call
00:20:23 the pro-migration lobby and you have argued and dealt with them all the time they are mostly open
00:20:29 borders people aren't they i mean the bb what always struck me about migration watches is that
00:20:34 when you're on the bbc or somewhere they always say they always tell you know the audience what
00:20:39 your position is i you want sort of properly controlled migration they never sort of do the
00:20:45 same with these other groups who in fact if you look at them tend to be outright open borders
00:20:51 they actually don't like any borders yeah absolutely right i mean that the internationalism
00:21:00 really was what it's all about what it was all about that we were all going to extend hands
00:21:07 across the seas we were all going to be one massive humanity and we would all kiss and hug
00:21:14 and live happily ever after at least that was the message that's what they would have you believe
00:21:26 it was actually all about control and having served in Romania in Eastern Europe
00:21:34 before the fall of the the Berlin Wall there was a nonsense then about how
00:21:43 socialism, internationalism would unify the world and it would be in the interests of the workers,
00:21:53 it would be interests in the interests of the ordinary people. It wasn't anything of the sort,
00:22:00 all the regime wanted to do was control the ordinary people and that in a way when people
00:22:07 say to me about really internationalism and accepting everyone as being the same, yeah
00:22:18 any human being is a human being and we respect and love each other insofar as we want to be
00:22:28 respected and loved. We shouldn't and we mustn't run away with the idea that
00:22:37 the feelings for nationhood, for patriotism, that they are old-fashioned and they are almost
00:22:47 destructive forces that we must read ourselves of. I think that is hugely dangerous for the world
00:22:56 frankly if that sort of idea gains currency that we are all the same and we will have one open
00:23:07 border really in this country and in every other country so that people can go from one place to
00:23:15 another at will that is so dangerous that's going to prove so harmful but you're right that is
00:23:23 precisely what some people advocate when I can I just go back a bit to the
00:23:31 previous question and you're talking about the government being so
00:23:35 incompetent so therefore hard to trust I think what strikes some people is is it
00:23:44 actually a matter of will political will in the sense that when you see what the
00:23:50 government of this country and indeed around the world has managed to do very easily with the
00:23:57 pandemic they have closed borders you know they have put this place this in place that in place
00:24:04 this restriction you know when there is a will to do something it can be done it seems which would
00:24:10 tend to suggest to me that there is no will whatsoever to control migration nor has there
00:24:16 ever been in in this in this particular era we're talking about you're absolutely right
00:24:23 this government has not shown that it has the political will unlike i mean dare i say
00:24:32 Theresa May actually genuinely wanted to control and reduce immigration she didn't succeed we know
00:24:43 she didn't but I think she certainly as Home Secretary she did have the bottle it proved
00:24:53 unsuccessful in the end at the time she was probably the only member of the cabinet frankly
00:25:00 who wanted to do that the majority of people in the camp cabinet were against her David Cameron
00:25:08 at various times supported her primarily because he came up with the idea of tens of thousands in
00:25:16 the first place but even he in the end I think he was cornered by the business community as much as
00:25:24 anything because the business business community big conglomerates actually were quite happy with
00:25:32 cheap labour and they wanted to continue with that. Boris Johnson has always been an avowed
00:25:40 softy on immigration. He's a liberal on immigration. He was keen and for all I know still is to
00:25:49 declare an amnesty to illegal migrants, those who are here without permission. I think that
00:25:58 the Home Secretary Priti Patel she is certainly keen to get a grip of the channel and a lot of
00:26:09 attention is being drawn to what's happening the bill going through with regard to the channel
00:26:14 my feeling is that the bill that is going through now will have very little impact even though it's
00:26:23 introducing some some welcome changes um the fact is that in the end those crossing the channel will
00:26:33 continue for so long as the traffickers are able to get them in yeah if they get and get them in
00:26:39 and uh receive a lot of money in return for doing so why wouldn't they continue for goodness sake
00:26:45 yes i mean my my my problem with the channel uh issue is that there's been an awful lot of
00:26:51 emphasis on this and of course it is uh it should be controlled and it is terrible what's happening
00:26:56 there but in fact it sort of draws attention away from the sheer scale of what we were just talking
00:27:02 about that of of legal migration actually you know of of net 250 300 000 to me this is the main sort
00:27:13 of issue you know what's happening down there is is bad it's got to be dealt with but what about
00:27:20 this massive issue i mean we've had the census haven't we this year uh in march um what do you
00:27:29 think uh what would you expect that the results of that to be i mean as an educated guest when
00:27:38 when we see the results which is like later this year i believe or early next year what are you
00:27:42 expecting that to show? Well let me give you an example of what we said and how we were
00:27:57 castigated for saying so in 2002 shortly after the 2001 census when we said at Migration Watch
00:28:09 that over the decade there would be immigration would add something like two million people to
00:28:23 the population. By the time of the 2011 census it turned out to be 2.1 million I think.
00:28:36 we have made some similar forecasts at other times as well for example in 2004 when we were told that
00:28:49 Eastern Europe the new enlarged EU would lead to something like between 5 and 13 thousand people a
00:29:01 coming from Eastern Europe. That's what the government was being advised and
00:29:07 that's what the government believed. We said at the time that those forecasts
00:29:13 were really pretty much worthless. We suggested something treble if not four
00:29:22 times that. In the event it turned out to be something like 78,000 people a year
00:29:30 year on average. When Romania and Bulgaria were going to join the sort of workforce available to
00:29:42 us and we're going to have the freedom to come to this country at will and work in 2014, we suggested
00:29:53 that it would end up something like 50 000 a year no no no we were told why would the romanians
00:30:01 come here i i remember having a debate with the romanian ambassador he said my people won't
00:30:07 come here there's no reason for them to come here they will go to spain or germany they don't need
00:30:12 to come here well in the event not only did a lot of romanians and bulgarians come from romania and
00:30:18 Bulgaria but many of those who were in Spain and Italy also decided that they would come here
00:30:26 and there are now well over 400,000 getting on for half a million Romanians here.
00:30:34 The fact is that we're an attractive country, that immigration if left unchecked would just
00:30:43 go on and on and on. This has implications and impact on our society and it has the sort of
00:30:56 adverse effect that I think the majority of people in this country, whatever we may hear from
00:31:05 the southeast media and the BBC, the fact is that the vast majority of people in this country
00:31:13 are concerned immigration you referred earlier to it now becoming gaining more salience and
00:31:20 more importance in the way that people
00:31:26 regarded they are concerned about it yes that is happening and it will continue
00:31:33 to develop so that it becomes the single most important issue for many people we we
00:31:40 we consistently find that something like 30 million people in this country believe that
00:31:48 immigration has been too high and needs to come down and included in that i think that 30 million
00:31:56 are people who feel very strongly about it as well very strongly and and less strongly but they
00:32:01 basically believe i mean i think you know many of the things that we discuss on this channel
00:32:07 such as issues like free speech and all of that sort of thing um i think they are also
00:32:14 strangely enough a direct consequence of mass migration in the sense that there used to be an
00:32:19 argument that if you're going to have this you're going to have to limit to an extent what people
00:32:24 can see about say about certain groups and that sort of thing or religions um and so in fact it's
00:32:29 funny that this has become acute all of these issues become acute at the end of a period of
00:32:35 huge migration um you mentioned the 2011 census that was the time which was quite historic in
00:32:42 london we're both londoners aren't we we are uh where the white british population i think was
00:32:48 for the first time in a minority of 45 percent um and probably already have been for a few years
00:32:56 then i mean what is your what what will it be this time i mean 10 years is a long time out
00:33:04 do you what would you say the proportion will be well we know from our own research and our own
00:33:12 studies that what happened and really looking at sort of figures 2019 2020
00:33:23 the proportion of white British I mean that's the category that is that shows up in in all the
00:33:36 surveys when you list when you go for your jab and you say what's your ethnic background and
00:33:42 there's a white british category there that particular category has gone from 2001 being
00:33:55 89 percent of the population nationally nationally the uk uk to 79 percent
00:34:04 20 years later.
00:34:08 That's a huge drop.
00:34:10 That's a huge drop.
00:34:11 There's a number of our major cities and towns,
00:34:17 not just London, Manchester, Birmingham, Leicester, Luton.
00:34:23 I mean, these are Cambridge, I think,
00:34:27 where the ethnic minority population is effectively the majority.
00:34:34 And that includes children born to migrants.
00:34:39 So, yeah, I mean, that is really what we have found,
00:34:45 what our research and studies over the last year or so have found.
00:34:52 And what it is that certainly concerns me as someone who really arrived,
00:35:01 accepted fitted in and made their way through through my life and became a part of British
00:35:13 society thing is is it this is the whole point you see I don't think anyone is actually against
00:35:20 immigration we're not talking about immigration as such we're talking about mass immigration
00:35:25 And those issues now are, you know, they tend to be fudged together.
00:35:31 I mean, you can't be in favour of migration, but not mass migration.
00:35:36 You're either one or the other, which, you know,
00:35:38 and you're a bigot if you're not and all of this sort of thing.
00:35:42 But, I mean, I know that Migration Watch does not, you know,
00:35:46 the last thing you tend to do is speculate.
00:35:47 But there are these things going, you know, concerns going around.
00:35:51 and you hear these things like by the middle of this century like 2060 white british will
00:35:58 actually be in a minority do you have does that have credibility for you
00:36:05 does the fact that the white british will become a minority in other words the majority will become
00:36:10 a minority uh by the end of this century certainly when precisely it will happen we don't know but
00:36:20 but one thing you can be absolutely certain of that with migration net migration continuing at
00:36:30 the rate of the last 20 years it will happen whether we like it or not it will happen now
00:36:37 there are those who say so what does it matter no it doesn't the more the merrier we're going
00:36:45 to have lots of wonderful foreigners in this country who work hard and will look after us in
00:36:52 our old age well i'm sorry but the vast majority of people don't think like that don't want it to
00:37:02 happen and are concerned that we are heading in that direction the thing is the interesting thing
00:37:08 about this you see is is that that's a perfectly reasonable position i to be concerned about that
00:37:13 And it would not be considered to be a weird question, you know, to ask in almost any other country.
00:37:20 If you said to India or Japan or any country, well, you know, in fact, you know, by the end of the century or at some point in the century, you will actually be a minority.
00:37:30 They would have something to say about it.
00:37:32 It's somehow that we are not meant to.
00:37:36 In fact, if anything, we're meant to celebrate this fact.
00:37:40 We're sort of meant to celebrate.
00:37:41 is there something bad is being overcome well you're absolutely right celebrating
00:37:49 diversity almost became the sort of the underlying mantra that we would
00:37:55 celebrate it and we would encourage it in fact and that's pretty much where
00:38:02 policy is at the moment really that we are it's continuing a pace it doesn't
00:38:09 matter we should we should welcome it we should think very carefully frankly
00:38:15 before welcoming it and you're absolutely right in any other country
00:38:20 and I've served in a few countries and I've worked diplomats were you not you
00:38:24 were you were an ambassador I was indeed a diplomat some say oh you're still too
00:38:31 much of a diplomat you you never quite say the how it should be said I would
00:38:38 argue that I probably in the eyes of some and the ears of some I say rather
00:38:44 more than they would like me to say but that's another issue yeah in any other
00:38:50 country that I've worked in with no one would no one would bat an eyelid if you
00:39:00 said well wait a minute there are far too many foreigners coming to this
00:39:04 country and they are threatening us. I'm not sure that I would say that, put it in
00:39:14 quite those terms, but nevertheless that's the sort of attitude that you
00:39:19 would get. South Africa, they're concerned about the Zimbabweans going there. I was
00:39:28 listening to from our own correspondent program this this was a few years ago now and I've tried
00:39:36 to track it down but the BBC seems to have removed it from its archives but there was a correspondent
00:39:44 talking about Johannesburg he was from Johannesburg and he really was he was saddened he was angered
00:39:56 by the fact that so many Angolans had moved into neighbourhoods that he was
00:40:04 familiar with in Johannesburg and had had changed the character of the
00:40:12 neighbourhoods and he said I don't I don't like it I don't want it. There was
00:40:18 similar program about this country and there was a an interview of someone in
00:40:26 in Wales who was bemoaning the fact that a lot of primarily English had moved
00:40:32 into the village for holiday homes and having done so had changed the character
00:40:40 of uh lithuania has brought up barriers from the barbed wire to stop belarusians from from entering
00:40:51 in poland they're complaining about the number of ukrainians so wherever you look of course people
00:41:00 are concerned whatever the state of their country is if they feel that they're being
00:41:06 they've been taken over by outsiders. I was in Nigeria 40 years ago when the Nigerians took
00:41:15 again the number of Ghanaians who were in the country illegally and said right that's it by
00:41:25 I think it was the 1st of September any Ghanaian here without permission is going to be arrested
00:41:33 and imprisoned or deported unless they can show that they've got permission to be here.
00:41:43 A million Ghanaians really were forced out. And I remember the BBC correspondent,
00:41:52 who actually became a friend, but I won't mention his name. He arrived to cover the story.
00:42:01 and firstly was detained because he had a passport that showed that he'd been to South Africa
00:42:09 and that was taboo in Nigeria in the early 80s and then he got in a cab and made his way to the
00:42:18 border to see there was sort of lots of footage of hundreds of thousands of Ghanaians making their
00:42:27 way being forced to cross the border out of Nigeria. So yes whichever country you look at
00:42:35 really sub-Saharan Africa, Asia, there is always concern where the perception is that outsiders,
00:42:47 foreigners, for that's what they are, are now increasing in in such numbers that they
00:42:55 they pose a threat to the locals or the culture or the unity of the country yeah culture that that
00:43:08 i that's probably the single most important um
00:43:14 issue really for many people. I referred earlier to the way that school day used to start in
00:43:25 in the 50s and 60s, it doesn't now. This country, we mustn't forget that it's founded on Judeo-Christian
00:43:38 belief, values, and so much of that is reflected in our laws, in our institutions, and that
00:43:54 potentially as numbers increase and increase at a very rapid rate, it's that sort of
00:44:02 of stabilizing force at the center of what this country is that is potentially threatened oh um i
00:44:13 i think that's without uh without question um oh just to to end uh you know big question maybe but
00:44:24 what should happen i mean you know we we talked about the uselessness of the current system
00:44:30 and and point systems and all of this um no party really is giving any kind of
00:44:39 real uh suggestion or policy i think the sdp the new sdp uh small party uh they think there should
00:44:47 be a what they call a pause uh on migration for for generation 20 years 25 years um that to me
00:44:56 seems to be you know the most you know plausible way actually of stopping what we don't want to
00:45:05 happen um what's your feeling about this what what is or does migration more say right there should
00:45:12 be a limit on like 40 000 people a year or or what um i think limits ceilings certainly have a place
00:45:27 and they have a role within our overall system the australians do it they decide that their economy
00:45:36 their needs say so much per year and that's reviewed as I understand it every year and they
00:45:45 decide what the limit is going to be. I think we should certainly seriously look at that.
00:45:51 stopping immigration saying right no more immigration for the next three years five
00:46:05 years actually the French are beginning to look in that direction and Michel Barnier there he was
00:46:14 telling us no no no no you've got to accept open borders and free movement and now he's saying well
00:46:20 you know perhaps he did say outside the immigration from outside the EU well we can say immigration
00:46:32 from outside the UK no because there is no there is no reason to differentiate anymore I mean
00:46:38 it's quite simple you know there was all this is a lot of people maybe um have been frustrated by
00:46:45 there was always the capacity wasn't there to limit immigration outside the eu even when we
00:46:51 were in the eu there was always that capacity but never taken up well there wasn't actually peter
00:46:57 there was never any capacity to to limit it as such there was with regard to skilled migration
00:47:06 there was a 20 700 limit per year from outside the eu i i think that's perfectly feasible to have
00:47:18 a limit on the number of people coming here to work particularly in school jobs and having a
00:47:25 limit i think would encourage us to train prepare our own people and workforce for for the jobs that
00:47:33 are needed. What there never has been as the number of people who could come to
00:47:40 this country, be it for marriage, students, and if you will say other students come
00:47:46 and go, well a lot of them don't, I mean they arrive and they're here for three
00:47:53 four five years longer some of them and they also, one particular home office
00:48:03 study the Migrant Journey study found that at one particular point 20% of those who'd claimed
00:48:16 to stay indefinitely were in fact
00:48:21 originally students. So there never was any limit on the number of people who could come here
00:48:31 to marry, to come here to study, to come here
00:48:42 to come here for almost any reason about except for particular work. Outside the EU if you didn't
00:48:51 have a work permit you couldn't come here. You had to have a work permit. You would only be issued
00:48:58 a work permit if there was a gap in in our skills and if you were going to earn a certain level of
00:49:04 money and if you had a certain qualification. Going back many years the days when I was an
00:49:11 immigration officer in fact there were no skill ceilings as such you just had to be qualified in
00:49:20 a particular area we had we had a lot of people coming over here into the rag trade for example
00:49:29 into the catering world so people would come very often frankly you would have
00:49:41 a farmer a peasant farmer from the middle of nowhere in the middle east in turkey in the
00:49:46 Balkans would turn up with a work permit to work in a sort of cordon bleu restaurant and you knew
00:49:56 that they were coming here frankly to lump things around and peel potatoes but nevertheless at the
00:50:03 time that was the constraint that you had to have certain qualifications and you had to have a work
00:50:11 permit. We could do more, frankly, to be selective about who comes here to work.
00:50:20 With those coming here to marry, well, we used to have something that the Labour Party today
00:50:30 did away with was the primary purpose rule. So that you couldn't come here if your primary
00:50:38 purpose for coming here was immigration if that was the reason why you were marrying then you were
00:50:46 to be denied entry well we did away with that i can't see that any political party at the moment
00:50:58 is going to say i don't know perhaps the sdp award and then some of the the others the offshoots of
00:51:05 of the UKIP and Brexit parties perhaps they would but I can't see the Conservatives, the Labour Party,
00:51:18 Scottish National Party, the Lib Dems, I just cannot for one second think that they will introduce
00:51:27 reintroduce something akin to the primary purpose rule, it just won't happen. Whether we should look
00:51:35 more carefully at the age of those coming here to marry. Are they coming here simply to marry or
00:51:47 because they're looking for a bolt hole, they're looking for a country to to settle in.
00:51:54 There is forced marriage which has long been an issue. We shy away from dealing with that. We pass
00:52:02 all sorts of fancy laws and legislation but ultimately we know it still goes on oh god it's
00:52:10 like fgm as well it's the same sort of thing it still goes it's been like one prosecution in 30
00:52:16 years i mean the good thing is that we don't regard that as some sort of cultural practice
00:52:24 that we should um we should tolerate and no whatever practice it is and whichever part of
00:52:32 the world it's being practiced in it's abhorrent and we should say no and to commit it is a criminal
00:52:39 offence but all these different sort of pseudo-religious originated practices yeah certainly
00:52:51 we should say no you're not going to do that if you come here and and also be very careful about
00:52:59 those who we do accept to come here to settle for all reasons really not just for marriage but
00:53:07 there are you know we keep throwing open the border to five million Chinese Hong Kongers
00:53:16 frankly we're saying oh yeah everyone that the Taliban is now
00:53:23 um dominating with you any one of you can can come here well no i'm sorry but that should not happen
00:53:34 but that you know we could go on talking about this for a long time peter absolutely it is it
00:53:41 does seem sometimes like a self-destruction on on the part of the culture sometimes you know
00:53:49 know but oh thank you very very much for for joining us and very interested to
00:53:58 hear your comments and what we've been talking about we've covered a hell of a
00:54:02 lot of points there so thank you very much up and well that's it for so what
00:54:08 you're saying is for this week and we'll be back next time so thank you very
00:54:12 Thank you very much.