00:35:24more Bobby's on the beat I write them off hey anybody who knows anything about
00:35:29this knows that there hasn't been such a thing as a Bobby or a beat for
00:35:34something in the region of four decades and it's it's to talk in those terms
00:35:38is to show that you don't understand what's going on yes or to accept these
00:35:42arguments that it's all about numbers and say well we will recruit more police
00:35:46officers well you can recruit you can recruit recruit a million people into
00:35:50the police force as it is now and it would make no substantial difference
00:35:53I one of the fascinating things that I discovered when I wrote my book was the
00:35:58999 service which was originally developed because of a tragedy when the
00:36:02they all could get through to the police in 1930s London so a special number was
00:36:06devised but once people had telephones in large numbers and once the police
00:36:12didn't go out on patrol and weren't accessible any other way the number of
00:36:16phone calls they got through 999 very rapidly became impossible to handle and
00:36:21for a very long time if people ring 999 and they have to be put through a series
00:36:27of trials used before they actually get anywhere and even if they think they've
00:36:30got somewhere they may well not have done simply doesn't work yes it's not
00:36:34because the extent of crime and disorder which which begins to exist and the
00:36:39desire of the public to report it which begins to exist once you've stopped
00:36:44being on preventive patrol is so huge that there's nothing you can do about
00:36:47it you would have the whole country hired for the police force you couldn't
00:36:50control it and I think the reason why it hasn't become a total crisis is that
00:36:55gradually the public learn there's no point in calling 999 most of the time
00:36:58yes and I'll say that sometimes you might know it in an absolute dire
00:37:04emergency that you you will get through and things will happen but in general
00:37:07because you can't reach the police really seriously any other way now if
00:37:11you'll try to use the other numbers try to try doing that sometime people use
00:37:16999 simply to make contact with police and they can't there's always been
00:37:23there's been an argument too as well which you tend to hear as well in more
00:37:28conservative quarters which is that their hands are tied they they do this
00:37:35very hard job and then they're let down by reading sentencing and they're let
00:37:39down by the courts I mean do you think that suppose a huge element of truth in
00:37:44that in the Police and Criminal Evidence Act of 1984 and its codes of practice
00:37:49which has to be taken together basically assumed that the police were bad and
00:37:55couldn't be trusted to do the job we pay them for and there had been a number of
00:37:58cases the Maxwell Convict case and various others which had produced a
00:38:02great deal of worry about whether the police could be trusted and the response
00:38:06to this around liberal legislators and remember 1984 was a conservative
00:38:12government and many of the liberal legislators were conservative MPs the
00:38:16response to this was to say well in that case we just put the police under tight
00:38:19control and pace and its codes of practice came into being also the
00:38:24increasingly the the rules of evidence became more and more constrained so that
00:38:29trials as one chief constable knows we said some years ago become more about
00:38:34whether we can actually introduce evidence about whether the person
00:38:37involved is guilty so the ability to convict was was much restricted because
00:38:44of it and this is because people have behaved badly and because of malpractice
00:38:49and wrongdoing which undoubtedly took place I think it was the wrong response
00:38:52myself I think you needed to have to do something about the discipline of the
00:38:57police and the training of them and the authority and rather than assume that
00:39:02they were all bad and the other point of course is that so much of this is a very
00:39:09simple point here every arrest and every trial every conviction is a failure of
00:39:15policing the police are there not to pursue crime once it's been committed
00:39:19because they can't un-burgle you they can't un-stab you they can't un-mug you
00:39:24if they can do first aid they can patch you up a bit but that's about it their
00:39:30job is to prevent you ever being burgled or mugged or stabbed and the the arrest
00:39:35is not a success of the police officers with a big arrest tally is not a
00:39:39successful police officer the police officer whose patch is free of crime
00:39:43disorder is a successful police officer but once the withdrawal of the police in
00:39:47the streets and the evisceration of the criminal justice system the removal of
00:39:52deterrence for many crimes began to take effect then really there wasn't much you
00:39:59could do and even the tough sentencing so-called and all the rest of it doesn't
00:40:06it probably isn't going to work anyway the the way in which a criminal justice
00:40:11system works is first of all by convincing people they'll be caught if
00:40:14they do something bad which foot patrolling was very good at and
00:40:18secondly that on first contact you realize it's serious so I'm not saying
00:40:22that the the the person who's who's the first offender should have the book
00:40:28thrown at him or her and be thrown into a dungeon for the rest of their life but if they are given a caution or a warning it should be made absolutely clear that this is a real caution or warning and that the second time they're in big trouble but in fact these days probably anybody who goes to prison except for homicide will have committed 30 or 40 crimes before they go there the first 10 of which they will have committed with impunity because no one will have reported them and nothing will be done about them the next 10 of which
00:40:58which may have led to to fines unpaid suspended sentences unactivated all
00:41:04kinds of warnings and then finally the criminal justice system gets really
00:41:08really tired of them waits for them to become recidivists and confirmed
00:41:12criminals and then puts them in prison where absolutely no good whatever is0.51
00:41:18done except for the brief period when they're there so now that works because
00:41:22it's a prison itself increasingly run by the inmates is not a deterrent to to
00:41:27crime as a result except for the sort of people who probably wouldn't commit
00:41:30crime anyway. If your whole system is based on a sort of dislike of
00:41:37punishment you know none of this is really going to work. But in the end we
00:41:41still have these places and we have this bizarre system where a liberal
00:41:45criminal justice system has the fullest prisons and more of them than at any time
00:41:52in our history as it isn't that strange here we are we're supposed to be
00:41:57tremendously liberal about punishment but our prisons are full and there and
00:42:01there are many many more of them than used to be and it doesn't work one of
00:42:06the ways that we've just had the conferences you know one of the ways of
00:42:09the you could always get a cheer out of the tory the tory conference maybe not
00:42:14anymore was by saying you supported capital punishment would you stand on
00:42:20people. Do you believe in it at all? Well I think it has it could be shown to be
00:42:23effective under certain circumstances but it's intolerable unless you have
00:42:28certain preconditions. So for instance if you don't have a genuinely free and
00:42:31independent press, if you don't have genuinely independent minded judges who
00:42:35prepare to stop a trial if they regard it as improper and if you don't have
00:42:40properly independent juries of mature citizens then you can't have it and in
00:42:46my view we don't have any of those things now really we have the remnants of
00:42:49free press we have some actors and judges and some who seem to be better
00:42:53sit in front of barely anything and the jury has been eviscerated with majority
00:42:58verdicts for instance mean that the whole plot of 12 angry man the famous
00:43:02Henry fondant film is impossible one person cannot one person of conscience
00:43:07and strong character cannot prevent the wrongful conviction of somebody bus
00:43:11would be standing up to them because the judge will say I will accept a majority
00:43:14verdict and he can be out voted the whole point of the jury is it has to be
00:43:18unanimous and certainly in the capital case that would have to be have to be
00:43:22the case people are prepared to excite the nature of prosecution as these days
00:43:27is often terribly emotional you get the prosecutor and he spends an awful lot
00:43:31of time detailing the horror of the murder well I don't doubt the murder is
00:43:34horrible but this often is accompanied by an almost total lack of forensic
00:43:38evidence for the to show that the person accused is guilty I fear that an
00:43:45increasing number of people and this certainly isn't just in homicide of
00:43:49being convicted for things which they would not have been convicted in a more
00:43:54effective criminal justice system which is why my book has large sections on
00:43:58jury trial for instance and how important it is and how again drained of
00:44:06meaning it is by the reforms of the past 50 years and astonishing how little
00:44:11protection. So what I don't doubt that capital punishment effectively and
00:44:16swiftly administered after a fair trial the possibility of appeal and reprieve
00:44:22can deter homicidal violence, not homicide itself but homicidal violence and the
00:44:29carrying of lethal weapons by criminals and would be effective in doing so. That
00:44:34in our current circumstances it would be responsible to reintroduce it because
00:44:39first of all it would be very very hard to be sure that people have been
00:44:44probably convicted and secondly I don't think that the the legal and political
00:44:49professions would be prepared to take responsibility of exercising in any way
00:44:52because they one of the reasons why it was abolished was because Home Secretaries
00:44:57hated the responsibility and all politicians feared that maybe that would
00:45:02be a responsibility they might one day they might one day have to have to
00:45:06undertake. So rather than do that they thought it was, they left the job of
00:45:11capital punishment to armed police officers which is basically how we how
00:45:17we now carry out capital punishment in this country. Armed police officers and
00:45:21prison suicides. We kill an awful lot of people in our criminal
00:45:25justice system but it's mostly in prison suicides and then in people shot by the
00:45:29police. It's not that we don't have a death penalty it's just we
00:45:34don't have one after due process anyway. If one wanted to start again and
00:45:41reinstate a police force of the type we had and it was until maybe as you said
00:45:47the mid last century there's no party on the horizon is there that's sort of
00:45:54going to do that. Well people don't think about it. I regard myself as a one-man
00:45:58think tank for anybody who wants to try intelligent conservatism. I can tell you
00:46:01how to do it but nobody wants to it'd be interesting by the way when I after I
00:46:07published a brief history of crime and then we wrote his abolition of liberty
00:46:11republishes the abolition of liberty which it is now still I'm proud to say
00:46:16in print I pressed it into the hands of a number of senior police officers and
00:46:21one secretary and I never even got a letter back for any of them not a thing
00:46:29I don't think they read it, whether they chucked it in a bin, I don't know whether they kept it.
00:46:34I don't think they read it or were interested.
00:46:36Politicians and police officers are actually not very interested in these subjects.
00:46:40They think that the way things are now is the way they have to be and
00:46:45therefore the way they must be and the way they're going to be and I tend to
00:46:51think that the task of almost all public debate is to examine what you have
00:46:55against what you could have and try to see how you could get something better.
00:47:00On a more general point, this is obviously a big part of it, law and order, but you've
00:47:10often said that the Tory party is the biggest obstacle to real conservatism
00:47:17in this country and I just wonder now when you look at it and the way things
00:47:22are going, do you think it will destroy itself?
00:47:27I have no idea because I can't see, one of the things I can't see is the
00:47:32economic future of this country with inequality. It looks very bad to me and
00:47:37if you combine that with the pathetic education system, equally pathetic
00:47:43criminal justice system which we've been discussing, if into that is introduced
00:47:49quite serious economic dislocation, large-scale unemployment, real poverty of
00:47:55the sort not seen for many years. I hate to think what might happen to politics, I
00:48:01don't know. Looking at the economic behavior of the government before the
00:48:09Covid panic was quite alarming and we constantly boast of what a rich country
00:48:14we are but this is not real. I mean our current account deficit with the rest of
00:48:17world is appalling, our trade performance is very bad, our level of manufacturing
00:48:22industry, our power of recuperation is appalling, our indebtedness public and
00:48:26private is astonishing. And our tax system verging on the confiscatory for an
00:48:35awful lot of people is incredibly heavy and will after the coming changes be I
00:48:39think heavier than it's been at any time in more than half a century. So all this
00:48:46going on together I think you have the ingredients of quite serious political
00:48:50trouble out of which who knows what might emerge. I don't know, I fear it but one
00:48:56thing I can say for certain Conservative Party as a present
00:49:00constituted office, no defense against these fears for me. I don't see in it or
00:49:04in the Labour Party any group of people who are examining with cold and clear
00:49:09eyes the state of the country and trying to work out how they can save it from
00:49:12very very serious and quite rapid decline. Yes, I suppose that with this
00:49:20current Tory party, there have been things happening over the past year,
00:49:25particularly it was the one that was the coming in between parents and their
00:49:30children. But all all utopian states inevitably do this, they have to because
00:49:35the thing we discussed earlier, the family being the transmission belt of
00:49:39the older conservative, common sense, religious, patriotic culture and the new
00:49:44culture coming into conflict with this. The archetype of this is the appalling
00:49:48public Morozov episode in Soviet history where a child who allegedly denounced
00:49:55his parents to the authorities and was then killed by his grandfather became a
00:49:58national martyr. As subjects of reverence the young pioneers were taught to
00:50:03revere him and there was a statue in Moscow to which they used to go one day
00:50:07year in parade in reverence to this little horror who denounced his own
00:50:11parents. That's an extreme version of it but any utopian state must come into
00:50:16conflict with parental authority. It'll do it with the schools, it will do it very
00:50:21much with sex education which as I think George Lukács when he originally
00:50:26introduced it in the Hungarian Bolshevik uprising in 1919 saw as a way of
00:50:31demoralizing society. But also the other thing we discussed how the
00:50:36universities will turn people against their parents' views and turn out a new
00:50:40generation which doesn't gain its thoughts about anything from its
00:50:45parents but from the state. We are in the grip of the equality and diversity
00:50:51utopian state. Marshmallow totalitarianism looms. Enforced by the police force which
00:50:59patrols Twitter very effectively. Thank you very much for coming and talking to us again and I know that you are writing another book at the moment aren't you?
00:51:11Yes I'm writing a book it's called A Revolution Betrayed it's about the
00:51:15destruction of the grammar schools and their replacement bias system which once
00:51:20again benefited the rich over the poor and in the name bizarrely of egalitarianism