New Culture Forum - October 18, 2021


British Police Have Transformed Into A Tool For Enforcing The State's Will -- Peter Hitchens

Migration Watch: Tory Government Is INCREASING Immigration, Which Is Already At Unprecedented Levels Sir David Amess's Friend Ann Widdecombe on His Murder, MP Safety, Religion & Online Safety Bill

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

173.84

Word count

9,106

Sentence count

115

Harmful content

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. Now I usually do quite a long preamble as well
00:00:24 by way of introduction for my guest, but today I don't need to do that. He's been on the show
00:00:29 a number of times before, always proving very very popular. Peter Hitchens is a columnist
00:00:36 for The Mail on Sunday. He's also the author of numerous books, one of which is called Brief
00:00:42 History of Crime, came out in 2003. It was then reissued as The Abolition of Liberty, updated,
00:00:52 a year or so later. The reason I mention this is, of course, crime and policing has been very much
00:00:59 in the news. Peter, thank you very much for joining us. I mentioned that there. We've had
00:01:06 this case of Wayne Cousins, a police officer, being charged and convicted of the murder of
00:01:13 Sarah Everard. Before that, we've had the general behaviour of the police throughout the pandemic,
00:01:21 but also in response to such things as black lives matter so the media are
00:01:27 saying there is a crisis of confidence in the police you see the roots of this
00:01:34 is going back much much further don't you much further here I mean when you
00:01:41 read the book you will you actually went basically was also a brief history of
00:01:46 the police force wasn't it? Do you think that the police are unique in the way in
00:01:56 which they have developed over the past few decades or is it just part of
00:02:01 another thing? Well they were an important in my view conservative and
00:02:05 very English institution which was set up in complete distinction from
00:02:10 continental police forces and what people don't realize when they read about
00:02:14 Rod Peel's founding of the police is that Parliament had for many years
00:02:18 resisted the formation of police force in this country, particularly in London,
00:02:22 despite very high levels of crime and disorder in the metropolis because they
00:02:27 had seen continental police forces become engines of oppression. Basically what 0.60
00:02:32 they were, they were state police forces, they were armed, they were uniformed,
00:02:35 they were special bodies of armed men as Karl Marx referred to them, whose job was
00:02:41 to enforce the will of the state and they did not think that in a uniquely free country
00:02:46 such a body could be trusted to exist. Peel's genius and the genius of the early commissioners
00:02:51 of the Metropolitan Police was to overcome this by having a completely different sort
00:02:55 of police force from anything ever previously seen, unarmed, with very sub-fusk, unimpressive
00:03:02 uniforms, not given special powers but really required to derive their powers from the consent
00:03:10 to the people and to be extremely cautious in the exercise of those powers rather than
00:03:15 to rush into them and above all to be present, to be present on foot in every neighborhood
00:03:20 all the time constantly patrolling with their prime job the prevention of crime and disorder.
00:03:27 The other tasks of detection and pursuit and prosecution came a very very poor second to
00:03:34 those. The whole idea of them was to be there to deter the growth of disorder and to deter
00:03:39 the Commission of Crime, fantastically affected and as I say utterly different
00:03:44 from the from the police forces of any other country then existing and this
00:03:49 persisted because it worked with amazing success and considerable popularity
00:03:55 right up until really the middle of the 20th century and then with a series of
00:04:02 big bangs it was removed. It was removed I think most urgently because it was
00:04:09 seem to be expensive because the growth of quite high wage unskilled labour was
00:04:16 causing a recruitment problem which is a problem for many of the long-standing
00:04:21 state employers of Britain in the 1950s. But also I think there were people who
00:04:26 saw this as an opportunity to change the nature of the police because what they
00:04:30 also did was they reflected a very conservative view of what society should
00:04:34 be like. They were expected really to enforce not just a criminal care but a
00:04:38 moral code. I think it was true that certainly until the middle 1950s if the
00:04:44 police officer got divorced it would be a black mark against him. They were
00:04:48 expected to live very proper lives, unthinkable I think in those days for a
00:04:53 police officer to have a criminal conviction of any kind. Whereas now those
00:04:58 things of course totally not true and the police actually different in many
00:05:03 ways but it was so many there's no single cause for any of the great
00:05:08 changes in Britain in the 1950s and 1960s there are many many causes but
00:05:13 certainly I think it's true that the social democratic view of crime as a
00:05:18 social disease caused by poverty deprivation bad housing abuse of
00:05:22 childhood and all these others that became current at about the time the
00:05:27 police force was hugely reformed and the police force that it changed into then
00:05:31 became what I call a sort of army of paramilitary social workers who perform
00:05:36 a completely different function in a completely different way but for a long
00:05:39 time they looked the same and my for the reason why I wrote the book was partly
00:05:44 because I've written the abolition of Britain and I realized in the course of
00:05:47 writing it there was an awful lot I did not know about why and how the country
00:05:51 changed I'd come back from two stints abroad really I'd be I'd been abroad
00:05:56 effectively for rather more than five years and I kept thinking surely the
00:06:00 police used to patrol the streets in this country and I can't see them what's
00:06:03 happened to them I began to look into why and the book was a product of that
00:06:08 of that inquiry and then it as these things often do it led me down several
00:06:13 other quite broad highways into other bits of knowledge which I hadn't
00:06:16 previously known I lacked the whole the whole of life is discovering how ignorant
00:06:24 you are about everything and I discovered I was ignorant about that and
00:06:26 trying to put it right a bit and for other people as well you mentioned there
00:06:30 Peter the social democratic attitude to crime yes in a way would it be correct to say that
00:06:39 you know if if you no longer think that crime is actually a personal responsibility it changes the
00:06:47 whole way you please yes no of course there is a doesn't this isn't a hard and fast thing I use
00:06:54 the term social democratic though I sometimes would refer to myself as a social democrat when
00:06:58 comes to economic policy on things like nationalization for instance because it's
00:07:02 not it's not a communist idea about crime it's a very modern idea about
00:07:06 crime held by people who regard themselves as enlightened that those who
00:07:11 commit crime have often not done so because of the voluntary failure to abide
00:07:15 by the law or a personal wickedness but because of their conditions and if you
00:07:20 generally believe that then the whole idea of criminal justice which existed
00:07:25 in this country really up until the middle 50s is is intolerable because it
00:07:31 basically seems to some commits a crime they've done it because they wanted to
00:07:34 and a spirit of wickedness and they deserve to be punished and that's if
00:07:41 they can't be deterred then they should be punished that also governs the whole
00:07:45 nature of the prison system which you then run you don't we now claim to have
00:07:51 a system based upon rehabilitation in fact there's no evidence in the whole
00:07:54 of human history that anybody has ever been rehabilitated by a prisoner or anything else
00:07:58 but that's the that's the basis on which we do it we say the punishment consists in the in the
00:08:04 in the loss of liberty but the prison itself is not supposed to be punitive and so it's changed
00:08:09 completely the way in which in which we treat people who are convicted criminals and then we
00:08:13 have the whole system nobody is now you notice if somebody is convicted in court they're almost
00:08:19 never sentenced immediately and almost invariably remanded for what used to be
00:08:24 called social inquiry reports so the social workers step in to offer their
00:08:29 own opinion the sentence can't be given until this has been yes the whole nature
00:08:33 of the system changed about this time and my view is very strongly the new
00:08:39 system doesn't work whereas the old system did which is one major test but
00:08:43 that would this this is one of the reasons why such a wide and deep
00:08:47 subject and touches on so many different things you mentioned there about coming
00:08:55 back from being away and and seeing the police not patrolling there was I mean I
00:09:05 think in one of the presentations you've given about the police you say that in
00:09:09 fact this idea of not enough manpower has been used as a kind of reasoning
00:09:16 behind this but in fact it's not really. It's not and the figures are in my book
00:09:20 and I've also done a blog posting on the same subject called Shock New News and
00:09:27 it contains the figures which I obtained in the days when the Office for
00:09:30 National Statistics actually had a building you could go to and you could
00:09:33 pull down from a shelf government statistics on the numbers of police which
00:09:37 I did and laboriously copied out with them and that's where I got them from
00:09:41 they are official figures and what they show is that both in raw numbers and
00:09:46 per head of the population. The size of the police force is immensely bigger now
00:09:51 than it was in the middle 60s when the police were transformed from a
00:09:56 preventive foot patrolling force into a reactive force which waits for crimes to
00:10:02 happen and then rushes with lights blazing and flashing and sirens screaming
00:10:06 to the scene. It's actually much more labor-intensive to run this extremely
00:10:12 ineffective form of policing than it was to run a foot patrol system. The other
00:10:18 thing of course which people don't often realise is the police have lost a lot of
00:10:22 functions they used to have. They used to run the prosecution service which was
00:10:26 then handed over to the Crown Prosecution Service. They used to have
00:10:30 absolute responsibility for the security of commercial premises which has now
00:10:33 been transferred to private security firms and they also dealt very much with
00:10:38 parking as one of their main responsibilities and they always think
00:10:43 they've lost and they've since been given a very large number of back
00:10:47 office non-uniform staff to do a lot of the bureaucracy which they have to do
00:10:52 which they have to tackle so not merely have they got a technically a lighter
00:10:56 task to perform but they've got more people to help them with it and yet they
00:11:00 claim that they can't do foot patrols the reason they don't do foot patrols is
00:11:05 they don't believe in them and they don't want to do them not because they
00:11:08 haven't got the people to do them it's because they want to do an entirely
00:11:12 different task or what it is in terms of the public I don't know I don't believe
00:11:16 they actually serve the public anymore they serve and this is the huge
00:11:20 distinction which I now make we now have a state police force which serves the
00:11:24 state yes rather than a what was actually actually a people's police
00:11:29 force which served the people what I call the army of the respectable at the very
00:11:37 beginning this idea in in in Europe that it was very top-down whereas the police
00:11:42 kind of came from the work from the working class in a way well good they
00:11:47 did they vote the jury they were recruited from weight loss but also they
00:11:50 drew in most circumstances when they had to use the what authority they had they
00:11:54 drew that authority from the people around them from the trust and support
00:11:59 of people they could control the situation by force of personality but
00:12:02 also by the knowledge that generally people who in the street around whatever
00:12:07 they were doing supported what they were doing and that was a this is what
00:12:11 policing by consent really means that they're enforcing a law which is
00:12:14 actually believed in by the people who are living in that society at the
00:12:22 time. Now it's a fascinating thing one of them there was a period it seems to
00:12:26 come to an end now because people don't dare, there was a period when the quite
00:12:30 a lot of people tried to defend their own premises against burglars and were
00:12:35 often very severely prosecuted for it and the police seemed to take this more
00:12:39 seriously than almost any other action. I felt very strongly they were enforcing
00:12:44 a monopoly that they didn't want to see that old-fashioned law where defense of
00:12:51 your own property was pretty much sacrosanct and permitted. They didn't want that to be
00:12:55 enforced by anybody precisely because it was popular. They wanted to introduce an entirely
00:13:01 new concept of how property could be protected which did not allow the individual what American
00:13:07 law calls defense of habitation. It's one of the big divergences between the two forms of English
00:13:12 law in the United States and in Britain. In the United States, defense of habitation,
00:13:17 your freedom to defend your own home against against intruders is almost
00:13:22 absolute whereas here it barely exists at all yes that didn't used to be the
00:13:26 case point about them now being a state police force I think that's something I
00:13:34 almost instinctively feel you know when I when I see him approach it but see the
00:13:40 way they dress yes they dress they don't the old police uniform was a
00:13:43 respectful uniform, the neat tunic, the polished buttons, the concealed
00:13:51 weapon, everything about it was deferential and peaceable. Now they go
00:13:58 about with a with a whole kitchen sink load of weapons and pepper sprays and
00:14:03 clubs and handcuffs on open display which always seems to me to contain as
00:14:10 an implicit assumption that they're in danger from the people. When they do go
00:14:15 out they almost always go out to scenes of crime where the only people they
00:14:18 meet are the victims of the crime and to some extent the criminals. Their contact
00:14:24 with ordinary members of the public has almost completely ceased. Go to a police
00:14:28 station now if you dare or if you can find one and when you go into the
00:14:32 entrance if it's open, which it probably won't be, but if it is open there will
00:14:37 be armoured glass on the desk and behind the armoured glass will not be a police
00:14:42 officer but will be one of these back office staff. It's very hard to actually
00:14:47 meet a police officer as such anymore in the street. You're not going to ask them
00:14:53 the time or say hello to them. They aren't going to know who you are either as they
00:14:57 walk down your street or stand chatting outside the pub or the shop where you
00:15:03 shop. They're not there, they've gone because they serve a different master.
00:15:06 well they've gone until something like for example the pandemic came up I live
00:15:13 in Woodwich and never see peace and then suddenly it is remarkable there are
00:15:19 occasions demonstrations football matches when you suddenly rose how many of them
00:15:23 there are and you wonder where they keep them and generally you can look at an
00:15:27 English city and say well if the entire police force in this country was to be
00:15:32 abducted by aliens how long would it take for us to realize they've gone because
00:15:36 as they're not there normally if the aliens have dodged them how do you know
00:15:39 they weren't there what is it that they do certainly they don't serve us in the
00:15:45 way that they were originally hired to do that's my view what is behind this
00:15:50 urge to make them graduates as well well graduate the the I think Woodrow Wilson
00:15:57 sum this up that we he went when anybody came to university the whole idea was to
00:16:03 make him disagree with his father about everything that he would be with. If
00:16:06 anyone came to a university that Woodrow Wilson ran then he would end up
00:16:11 changing his ideas and make them different from his father. Of course the
00:16:15 great transmission belt of conservative thought of tradition of the law of the
00:16:19 tribe has always been the family and the education system increasingly and this
00:16:25 is also applies to schools in my view increasingly turns children away from
00:16:29 that law of the family and gives them a different set of loyalties and beliefs.
00:16:33 But university now absolutely and this is one of the reasons why all these
00:16:37 arguments about political greatness in university so important, university is
00:16:42 absolutely a place where people go to be to be graduated in the new ideology of
00:16:47 the country which is equality and diversity and separated from any other
00:16:52 trend or strain of thought that they previously belonged to. So a graduate can
00:16:57 be relied upon can he not or can she not to have the correct opinions and I
00:17:01 think that's got a lot to do with it the old grammar school even coming straight
00:17:06 out of grammar school going on the beat who knew who knew his neighborhood knew
00:17:09 his neighbors and basically brought up with common sense as a rule is is not
00:17:15 wanted especially certainly not wanted in that in the higher ranks of the
00:17:20 police and probably not wanted to tool that so that's no surprise do you think
00:17:24 do you agree with the this kind of common it's a bit of a cliche but this idea oh well it's not
00:17:29 the coppers you know the ordinary guys and women it is actually the top rascal of the problem
00:17:36 so at the moment that would happen to be credited dick um i don't feel that because i've having
00:17:43 when i was on the london assembly i was on the police and crime committee a lot of
00:17:48 scrutinizing and everything and it seemed to me that actually there's been a total
00:17:51 changed an attitude throughout actually but do you think it is a question of the
00:17:58 top you know people like Chris Dick or Bernard there was a transitional period
00:18:03 but I predicted an amazingly long time ago that Chris did it would become
00:18:07 Commissioner of Metropolitan Police I've still got the cutting somewhere
00:18:11 amazingly long time ago when I first read about her when she was waiting for
00:18:16 the Thames Valley police being adventurous in her room how she dealt
00:18:21 with demonstrations and things like that you could see this is someone who was
00:18:24 destined for the top this has been going on for a very long time it had been
00:18:28 going on for there was a I think a Kent police manual which I once wrote about
00:18:33 which which showed how very strongly training was tending towards the
00:18:38 equality and diversity model and that political correctness was becoming the
00:18:43 standard form of belief which was expected of the police officer and then
00:18:47 the McPherson report came along a document which hardly anybody except me
00:18:51 has read absolutely fascinating gripping document and this was the basis for what
00:18:58 then became a thoroughly politically correct inquisition of every police
00:19:02 force in the kingdom and after that I think very few people were left from the
00:19:06 old the old dispensation there was a completely as I say there was a
00:19:10 a transitional period where you had upper echelons who were very much very
00:19:15 much of the new belief and the constables of the old the old stages in
00:19:22 the CID who were not but I think that's over now I think the process is
00:19:27 complete there may still be some individuals who believe that I used to
00:19:30 get letters and emails from serving police officers saying honestly right
00:19:34 now I tend to get letters and emails from retired police officers saying I'm
00:19:38 right but from serving ones I often get a lot of hostility and particularly if
00:19:44 you're on social media it's it's one of the most tedious it's nearly as tedious
00:19:49 as arguing with marijuana advocates is arguing with police officers who support
00:19:54 the existing arrangement. Yes on social media for example there was a clip
00:19:59 recently and I can't remember the force it wasn't it was in the service they're
00:20:04 not they're not a force anymore all right of course so force forces and social
00:20:08 democratic service in the midlands but it was a it was a it was this piece
00:20:11 movement was the industry explaining to this person how words were exactly the
00:20:19 same as violent acts you were saying which is is that not the very essence of
00:20:24 a lot of
00:20:28 well creek what you want this idea that somehow words are just the same as
00:20:33 actions. I would agree to some extent that words in certain circumstances can
00:20:39 be very intimidating and I don't I don't doubt that the most untrue thing I was
00:20:45 ever taught sticks and stones may break my bones but words can never hurt me
00:20:50 because it isn't true so I am not fundamentally utterly against that but
00:20:55 what's certainly true is the police have become much more interested in policing
00:20:59 what people think and say than they have in policing what people do and since
00:21:04 English law as it formerly existed really very much concentrated on whether
00:21:08 someone had done something or not with intent sometimes important but the the
00:21:13 act the action being there's no point worrying about whether someone had an
00:21:17 intent to murder if they hadn't murdered anybody and then killed anybody but now
00:21:21 an awful lot of racially aggravated or hate crime prosecutions delve quite
00:21:32 deeply into what the person thought or said as much into what he did and so the 0.76
00:21:36 laws changed enormously but again hasn't changed in a great Bolshevik
00:21:41 revolution in which we have one law substituted for another the old police
00:21:44 force sacked on mass and replaced by something a new militia it's changed in
00:21:49 this Kierkegaardian way where everything at least to begin with looks the same
00:21:54 but it's totally different and then this is how it's all done and most people
00:21:58 don't for most of their lives have much contact with the police and so they
00:22:02 continue to believe because they see these people in blue uniforms looking
00:22:07 like police officers they continue to believe the police officers their
00:22:10 childhood and young and young years is the same is the same one as the one we
00:22:15 have now but it's utterly different and then they encounter it a crime is
00:22:20 committed against them and that all the police do is say well you can have a
00:22:23 crime number we're not coming or they're accused of something which is
00:22:27 actually thought crime I think what's this how did that happen yes it's
00:22:32 completely changed but the rather the British Revolution has been one of the
00:22:35 cleverest ever to be accomplished because it changed everything without
00:22:40 people noticing and by the time the change was complete it was too late for
00:22:44 want to do anything about it very quick amount a very short space of time to
00:22:49 really know if you you can go back to some of this the very early 60s and for
00:22:56 the the change the the this I absolutely insist on this a television dramas have
00:23:05 a huge impact on the way people think they're immensely important for
00:23:10 propaganda and the change from Dixon of Doc Green to Z cars it was actually
00:23:15 took place at the moment when the the transformation of police began as well
00:23:19 and they did Z cars instead of Dixon walking around Doc Green in his big
00:23:24 size 15s it was it was it was much rougher guys driving around Merseyside
00:23:32 in Ford Zodiacs and a completely different thing from the start and the
00:23:39 whole the whole nature of the police was changing way further back than people
00:23:43 realize the actual abolition of foot patrol as a requirement although it took
00:23:48 some time fully to take effect was agreed as a meeting in the Home Office and I
00:23:51 think 1965 I found the meeting yeah and this was where they but wasn't the case
00:24:02 that again they were using this idea or lack of manpower there was a yeah but
00:24:07 it was true and there was and there was lack of resources this is before the
00:24:11 governments had realized you could borrow money endlessly without anybody
00:24:15 caring and also when the the levels of wages in unskilled jobs had gone up
00:24:21 hugely which is for all the all the old occupation by the railways and the
00:24:26 post office and the police and the armed services said well we offer you job
00:24:29 security the pay isn't as good but if you work for the state your job is secure
00:24:34 and then suddenly they they found that the it appeared that there were secure
00:24:41 jobs available for unskilled workers outside these outside these places where
00:24:46 you didn't work as hard and the conditions were were perfectly nice and
00:24:49 the wages were very high and this is a very big characteristic of that period
00:24:53 the so-called affluent society which the sociologists were so excited about in
00:24:58 the in the late 50s and early 60s undermined a lot of the old stable
00:25:03 things and one of the things they had in mind was to be so it's true but when you see how many how
00:25:07 many people they employ now and how much they spend on them and the enormous budgets for
00:25:11 equipment of cars and electronics and helicopters and all the rest of it which they consume
00:25:16 it's ridiculous to compare it with the the comparatively tiny amounts of money we spent
00:25:21 on an effective police force before but yeah money was often the excuse I don't think Jenkins really
00:25:25 knew what he was doing directly when he when he when he made that change though I think he did
00:25:31 know when he amalgamated local police forces into much bigger, much less
00:25:36 genuinely local forces. I think he did know then that this would make the
00:25:41 police much more the tool of the state and much less the tool of the people
00:25:45 through their own neighborhoods. The smaller police forces were much more
00:25:48 responsive to public demand for what they wanted to do. They couldn't now,
00:25:52 if we still had the sort of tiny police forces they have in the United States
00:25:56 and the small ones we used to have before the 67 reforms, they couldn't get
00:26:00 away with not not with not bothering to investigate burglaries because they
00:26:05 would be too local to get a people would know the chief constable and the local
00:26:10 council would would would have contiguous borders with the local police force and
00:26:14 they would be discontented but Thames Valley police force what is it and it
00:26:19 includes Oxford and Milton Keynes for goodness sake it can't conceivably be
00:26:24 be local or responsive to local demand it's just a blob and it ultimately it's
00:26:29 under the control of the home office and that's that change was huge yes I found last year again
00:26:35 these would have been local please what do you say local not local in the sense of you're talking
00:26:39 but I found quite chilling whether it was I don't remember seeing the police at the policeman during
00:26:49 the Coulson statue thing would have been more or less saying you know actually that I let it happen
00:26:56 because we didn't want to have any further tension and sort of very being very you know
00:27:03 almost in collusion it appeared. Well this issue because the along with the merger of the police
00:27:08 forces came it's gone now but came the service of the Bramsville Police College which again created
00:27:14 an officer class of senior police officers who were very much in tune with
00:27:19 modern thinking and again began to think politically much more politically than
00:27:23 they used to. It used to be explained to me the difference between the French
00:27:28 gendarmerie and the English police was that if you had a bunch of people sitting
00:27:32 down at the road at the docks in Dover the police would come along and they
00:27:37 would arrest them for obstruction and take them away. If a bunch of French 1.00
00:27:40 people came and sat down in docks in Calais. The Gendarles would come along, ask them who
00:27:46 they were, go and ring up Paris and find out whether this is the kind of demonstration
00:27:50 they had to break up or the kind of demonstration they had to leave alone. Well now it actually
00:27:55 is identical on both sides of the channel. The police check to see what the political
00:28:02 attitude is and therefore if it's Extinction Rebellion they get a much lighter touch than
00:28:07 if it's some anti-vaccine law so it's the the law is not is not impartially
00:28:14 imposed as a law it's a politicized law imposed by a politicized police force
00:28:19 exactly because it's it's hard now not to feel that there is utterly selective
00:28:26 policing when it comes to them I think I can't it just seems to me I wish it
00:28:30 weren't true but it just seems to me to be undeniable I have no great sympathy
00:28:34 with either of the groups i just mentioned but it's clear that they're treated differently when
00:28:38 they appear on the street whether it's extinction rebellion or black lives matter you wrote recently
00:28:44 but i think i think you've written this before not that longer probably i don't have to write
00:28:49 things many times before anybody notices anything i said the whole thing should be scrapped and we
00:28:53 should start again i think it's the only the the only logical conclusion now that if you just as
00:28:58 you remember um when some nationalized industries came to an end a lot of the people who tried to
00:29:03 replace them said well we're not hiring from the people used to work for them
00:29:06 because they've got into working habits which make him completely unsuitable for
00:29:09 the new kind of services we intend to supply. And no doubt there will be some
00:29:17 people among the existing police who could be retrained to to go out in all
00:29:21 hours on foot patrol and work as preventive police officers to become
00:29:27 friendly with the public and to support the public and basically be public
00:29:31 servants again and not carry great racks of equipment around with them that
00:29:36 revert to the concealed truncheon and the the generally restrained view and I
00:29:42 think there are probably people in the police also who could if they if they
00:29:45 were asked nicely actually investigate a burglary and arrest a vandal and
00:29:52 things like that which they don't seem to like doing very much now but I so
00:29:56 among the vast numbers of people you know so the police I'm not saying there's
00:29:59 nobody who could be a policeman as I imagine the job, but I think what you
00:30:04 have to do is you have to recruit over perhaps two or three years and train a
00:30:08 new police force on the lines originally devised by Robert Peel and the first
00:30:13 commissioners to the Metropolitan Police and when they're ready then you close
00:30:18 down the old and move in the new one. Would you reopen police stations? Absolutely,
00:30:23 and I would say police stations, they would be police stations in populated and
00:30:27 busy areas not as they are now office blocks often in industrial estates on
00:30:31 the edges of town there would be headquarters of law enforcement in the
00:30:35 areas where people lived and worked and moved how they're being. I'd also put
00:30:39 police houses back in villages and very definitely have the police in rural
00:30:44 areas again instead of having to drive miles when called to some some country
00:30:49 voguing which they do now because you need the intelligence provided by people
00:30:53 living among the people they serve i would try and bring back police houses as well which i think
00:30:58 were a very very useful thing where police lived not just in villages but in towns there were
00:31:03 actually hilarious where the where police lived together and people knew where they were this had
00:31:09 an effect on the neighborhoods where they were very much so well quite near to where we are now
00:31:14 in pimlico there was a big police uh uh estate actually it was uh i don't know whether it still
00:31:19 is it might yeah but what about the general standard of the way I mean you
00:31:24 know without you to sound too much like even more I I feel that the way even
00:31:28 that you can see the change in function is you say there's all this stuff
00:31:34 hanging off but there's also a kind of stopping this often you know same thing
00:31:40 I mean if you who are you serving I mean I didn't um I remember the years ago on
00:31:47 Daily Express I did a column about the problem that the police themselves now
00:31:51 often look pretty uninspiring and I had Graham Allen who did a weekly
00:31:57 cartoon for me there I said can you can you draw this scene and he did
00:32:00 beautifully with this this man coming out of his house and going up to a group of
00:32:04 people hanging around the street really shifty looking people saying go away or
00:32:08 I'll call the police and they replied we are the police I'm baseball caps for
00:32:16 goodness sake they always seem to put on baseball caps when they're about to do
00:32:19 something pretty awful yeah but then there's the other thing this is this
00:32:22 state police thing is very much in London you noticed it sometimes in the
00:32:27 provinces outside courtrooms you see these people who have the word police
00:32:30 stenciled on their uniforms and they're holding some machine guns and they're
00:32:34 wearing baseball caps and they had the bandoliers and frying pans and were
00:32:39 dangling from them and great big whopping great kicking boots on and you think how
00:32:45 When I see this kind of police officer hanging around, for instance, Pannington Station,
00:32:50 I think against whom is this person protecting me?
00:32:53 When I see them there, I hurry through in case, I mean, here they are, heckler and cock.
00:33:00 What if that went off?
00:33:03 I just don't want it.
00:33:05 It doesn't serve me.
00:33:07 And an awful lot of these people do their main jobs, and again, I see them a lot around Kensington,
00:33:12 is guarding of embassies or guarding of politicians and they are effectively
00:33:16 centuries and my view is if these places if embassies and political buildings are
00:33:22 so under threat that they need our guards we have an army. Boris Johnson
00:33:28 recently tweeted saying we are the party the Tory party of law and order for me
00:33:37 that is an absurd claim to me I just wonder when you think they were the last
00:33:42 party of law and order they might supposedly you know stand up more for the
00:33:49 police and and for the courts and these sorts of things but but when would when
00:33:55 could they really seriously last to make that I never were it wasn't it wasn't
00:33:58 that they were the party of law and order it's that they weren't not the party of
00:34:02 law and order for a last part of their existence they didn't they didn't
00:34:05 actually undermined the design of the police forces in the 19th century which
00:34:12 they inherited was not theirs but they didn't actually undermine it until and
00:34:18 this is the problem with the party which has no dogma but is confronted by
00:34:23 another party which does a bit by bit if they won't argue with what with what the
00:34:29 Labour Party is doing and they had no real what the Labour Party was doing in the
00:34:32 For instance, were Tories calling for a national police force, which is an outrage in my view because it's
00:34:39 The freedom of the subject depends amongst other things on
00:34:44 No concentration of power such as the national police force
00:34:47 Who had raised no opposition to Roy Jenkins' mergers of police forces and destruction of local small ones
00:34:55 did nothing
00:34:58 whatever about his
00:34:59 the other reforms, they continued
00:35:01 the Jenkins reforms of the 60s, continued
00:35:04 under Heath, continued under Thatcher
00:35:05 it's not that the Tories
00:35:07 wherever the party would order, they had to
00:35:10 pretend that they were, it's that for a long
00:35:12 period they didn't actually undermine it but then
00:35:14 they joined in the undermining
00:35:15 their lack of understanding
00:35:18 of the issue is pitiful
00:35:19 every time
00:35:22 I hear a politician say we will put
00:35:24 more Bobby's on the beat I write them off hey anybody who knows anything about
00:35:29 this knows that there hasn't been such a thing as a Bobby or a beat for
00:35:34 something in the region of four decades and it's it's to talk in those terms
00:35:38 is to show that you don't understand what's going on yes or to accept these
00:35:42 arguments that it's all about numbers and say well we will recruit more police
00:35:46 officers well you can recruit you can recruit recruit a million people into
00:35:50 the police force as it is now and it would make no substantial difference
00:35:53 I one of the fascinating things that I discovered when I wrote my book was the
00:35:58 999 service which was originally developed because of a tragedy when the
00:36:02 they all could get through to the police in 1930s London so a special number was
00:36:06 devised but once people had telephones in large numbers and once the police
00:36:12 didn't go out on patrol and weren't accessible any other way the number of
00:36:16 phone calls they got through 999 very rapidly became impossible to handle and
00:36:21 for a very long time if people ring 999 and they have to be put through a series
00:36:27 of trials used before they actually get anywhere and even if they think they've
00:36:30 got somewhere they may well not have done simply doesn't work yes it's not
00:36:34 because the extent of crime and disorder which which begins to exist and the
00:36:39 desire of the public to report it which begins to exist once you've stopped
00:36:44 being on preventive patrol is so huge that there's nothing you can do about
00:36:47 it you would have the whole country hired for the police force you couldn't
00:36:50 control it and I think the reason why it hasn't become a total crisis is that
00:36:55 gradually the public learn there's no point in calling 999 most of the time
00:36:58 yes and I'll say that sometimes you might know it in an absolute dire
00:37:04 emergency that you you will get through and things will happen but in general
00:37:07 because you can't reach the police really seriously any other way now if
00:37:11 you'll try to use the other numbers try to try doing that sometime people use
00:37:16 999 simply to make contact with police and they can't there's always been
00:37:23 there's been an argument too as well which you tend to hear as well in more
00:37:28 conservative quarters which is that their hands are tied they they do this
00:37:35 very hard job and then they're let down by reading sentencing and they're let
00:37:39 down by the courts I mean do you think that suppose a huge element of truth in
00:37:44 that in the Police and Criminal Evidence Act of 1984 and its codes of practice
00:37:49 which has to be taken together basically assumed that the police were bad and
00:37:55 couldn't be trusted to do the job we pay them for and there had been a number of
00:37:58 cases the Maxwell Convict case and various others which had produced a
00:38:02 great deal of worry about whether the police could be trusted and the response
00:38:06 to this around liberal legislators and remember 1984 was a conservative
00:38:12 government and many of the liberal legislators were conservative MPs the
00:38:16 response to this was to say well in that case we just put the police under tight
00:38:19 control and pace and its codes of practice came into being also the
00:38:24 increasingly the the rules of evidence became more and more constrained so that
00:38:29 trials as one chief constable knows we said some years ago become more about
00:38:34 whether we can actually introduce evidence about whether the person
00:38:37 involved is guilty so the ability to convict was was much restricted because
00:38:44 of it and this is because people have behaved badly and because of malpractice
00:38:49 and wrongdoing which undoubtedly took place I think it was the wrong response
00:38:52 myself I think you needed to have to do something about the discipline of the
00:38:57 police and the training of them and the authority and rather than assume that
00:39:02 they were all bad and the other point of course is that so much of this is a very
00:39:09 simple point here every arrest and every trial every conviction is a failure of
00:39:15 policing the police are there not to pursue crime once it's been committed
00:39:19 because they can't un-burgle you they can't un-stab you they can't un-mug you
00:39:24 if they can do first aid they can patch you up a bit but that's about it their
00:39:30 job is to prevent you ever being burgled or mugged or stabbed and the the arrest
00:39:35 is not a success of the police officers with a big arrest tally is not a
00:39:39 successful police officer the police officer whose patch is free of crime
00:39:43 disorder is a successful police officer but once the withdrawal of the police in
00:39:47 the streets and the evisceration of the criminal justice system the removal of
00:39:52 deterrence for many crimes began to take effect then really there wasn't much you
00:39:59 could do and even the tough sentencing so-called and all the rest of it doesn't
00:40:06 it probably isn't going to work anyway the the way in which a criminal justice
00:40:11 system works is first of all by convincing people they'll be caught if
00:40:14 they do something bad which foot patrolling was very good at and
00:40:18 secondly that on first contact you realize it's serious so I'm not saying
00:40:22 that the the the person who's who's the first offender should have the book
00:40:28 thrown at him or her and be thrown into a dungeon for the rest of their life but if they are given a caution or a warning it should be made absolutely clear that this is a real caution or warning and that the second time they're in big trouble but in fact these days probably anybody who goes to prison except for homicide will have committed 30 or 40 crimes before they go there the first 10 of which they will have committed with impunity because no one will have reported them and nothing will be done about them the next 10 of which
00:40:58 which may have led to to fines unpaid suspended sentences unactivated all
00:41:04 kinds of warnings and then finally the criminal justice system gets really
00:41:08 really tired of them waits for them to become recidivists and confirmed
00:41:12 criminals and then puts them in prison where absolutely no good whatever is 0.51
00:41:18 done except for the brief period when they're there so now that works because
00:41:22 it's a prison itself increasingly run by the inmates is not a deterrent to to
00:41:27 crime as a result except for the sort of people who probably wouldn't commit
00:41:30 crime anyway. If your whole system is based on a sort of dislike of
00:41:37 punishment you know none of this is really going to work. But in the end we
00:41:41 still have these places and we have this bizarre system where a liberal
00:41:45 criminal justice system has the fullest prisons and more of them than at any time
00:41:52 in our history as it isn't that strange here we are we're supposed to be
00:41:57 tremendously liberal about punishment but our prisons are full and there and
00:42:01 there are many many more of them than used to be and it doesn't work one of
00:42:06 the ways that we've just had the conferences you know one of the ways of
00:42:09 the you could always get a cheer out of the tory the tory conference maybe not
00:42:14 anymore was by saying you supported capital punishment would you stand on
00:42:20 people. Do you believe in it at all? Well I think it has it could be shown to be
00:42:23 effective under certain circumstances but it's intolerable unless you have
00:42:28 certain preconditions. So for instance if you don't have a genuinely free and
00:42:31 independent press, if you don't have genuinely independent minded judges who
00:42:35 prepare to stop a trial if they regard it as improper and if you don't have
00:42:40 properly independent juries of mature citizens then you can't have it and in
00:42:46 my view we don't have any of those things now really we have the remnants of
00:42:49 free press we have some actors and judges and some who seem to be better
00:42:53 sit in front of barely anything and the jury has been eviscerated with majority
00:42:58 verdicts for instance mean that the whole plot of 12 angry man the famous
00:43:02 Henry fondant film is impossible one person cannot one person of conscience
00:43:07 and strong character cannot prevent the wrongful conviction of somebody bus
00:43:11 would be standing up to them because the judge will say I will accept a majority
00:43:14 verdict and he can be out voted the whole point of the jury is it has to be
00:43:18 unanimous and certainly in the capital case that would have to be have to be
00:43:22 the case people are prepared to excite the nature of prosecution as these days
00:43:27 is often terribly emotional you get the prosecutor and he spends an awful lot
00:43:31 of time detailing the horror of the murder well I don't doubt the murder is
00:43:34 horrible but this often is accompanied by an almost total lack of forensic
00:43:38 evidence for the to show that the person accused is guilty I fear that an
00:43:45 increasing number of people and this certainly isn't just in homicide of
00:43:49 being convicted for things which they would not have been convicted in a more
00:43:54 effective criminal justice system which is why my book has large sections on
00:43:58 jury trial for instance and how important it is and how again drained of
00:44:06 meaning it is by the reforms of the past 50 years and astonishing how little
00:44:11 protection. So what I don't doubt that capital punishment effectively and
00:44:16 swiftly administered after a fair trial the possibility of appeal and reprieve
00:44:22 can deter homicidal violence, not homicide itself but homicidal violence and the
00:44:29 carrying of lethal weapons by criminals and would be effective in doing so. That
00:44:34 in our current circumstances it would be responsible to reintroduce it because
00:44:39 first of all it would be very very hard to be sure that people have been
00:44:44 probably convicted and secondly I don't think that the the legal and political
00:44:49 professions would be prepared to take responsibility of exercising in any way
00:44:52 because they one of the reasons why it was abolished was because Home Secretaries
00:44:57 hated the responsibility and all politicians feared that maybe that would
00:45:02 be a responsibility they might one day they might one day have to have to
00:45:06 undertake. So rather than do that they thought it was, they left the job of
00:45:11 capital punishment to armed police officers which is basically how we how
00:45:17 we now carry out capital punishment in this country. Armed police officers and
00:45:21 prison suicides. We kill an awful lot of people in our criminal
00:45:25 justice system but it's mostly in prison suicides and then in people shot by the
00:45:29 police. It's not that we don't have a death penalty it's just we
00:45:34 don't have one after due process anyway. If one wanted to start again and
00:45:41 reinstate a police force of the type we had and it was until maybe as you said
00:45:47 the mid last century there's no party on the horizon is there that's sort of
00:45:54 going to do that. Well people don't think about it. I regard myself as a one-man
00:45:58 think tank for anybody who wants to try intelligent conservatism. I can tell you
00:46:01 how to do it but nobody wants to it'd be interesting by the way when I after I
00:46:07 published a brief history of crime and then we wrote his abolition of liberty
00:46:11 republishes the abolition of liberty which it is now still I'm proud to say
00:46:16 in print I pressed it into the hands of a number of senior police officers and
00:46:21 one secretary and I never even got a letter back for any of them not a thing
00:46:29 I don't think they read it, whether they chucked it in a bin, I don't know whether they kept it.
00:46:34 I don't think they read it or were interested.
00:46:36 Politicians and police officers are actually not very interested in these subjects.
00:46:40 They think that the way things are now is the way they have to be and
00:46:45 therefore the way they must be and the way they're going to be and I tend to
00:46:51 think that the task of almost all public debate is to examine what you have
00:46:55 against what you could have and try to see how you could get something better.
00:47:00 On a more general point, this is obviously a big part of it, law and order, but you've
00:47:10 often said that the Tory party is the biggest obstacle to real conservatism
00:47:17 in this country and I just wonder now when you look at it and the way things
00:47:22 are going, do you think it will destroy itself?
00:47:27 I have no idea because I can't see, one of the things I can't see is the
00:47:32 economic future of this country with inequality. It looks very bad to me and
00:47:37 if you combine that with the pathetic education system, equally pathetic
00:47:43 criminal justice system which we've been discussing, if into that is introduced
00:47:49 quite serious economic dislocation, large-scale unemployment, real poverty of
00:47:55 the sort not seen for many years. I hate to think what might happen to politics, I
00:48:01 don't know. Looking at the economic behavior of the government before the
00:48:09 Covid panic was quite alarming and we constantly boast of what a rich country
00:48:14 we are but this is not real. I mean our current account deficit with the rest of
00:48:17 world is appalling, our trade performance is very bad, our level of manufacturing
00:48:22 industry, our power of recuperation is appalling, our indebtedness public and
00:48:26 private is astonishing. And our tax system verging on the confiscatory for an
00:48:35 awful lot of people is incredibly heavy and will after the coming changes be I
00:48:39 think heavier than it's been at any time in more than half a century. So all this
00:48:46 going on together I think you have the ingredients of quite serious political
00:48:50 trouble out of which who knows what might emerge. I don't know, I fear it but one
00:48:56 thing I can say for certain Conservative Party as a present
00:49:00 constituted office, no defense against these fears for me. I don't see in it or
00:49:04 in the Labour Party any group of people who are examining with cold and clear
00:49:09 eyes the state of the country and trying to work out how they can save it from
00:49:12 very very serious and quite rapid decline. Yes, I suppose that with this
00:49:20 current Tory party, there have been things happening over the past year,
00:49:25 particularly it was the one that was the coming in between parents and their
00:49:30 children. But all all utopian states inevitably do this, they have to because
00:49:35 the thing we discussed earlier, the family being the transmission belt of
00:49:39 the older conservative, common sense, religious, patriotic culture and the new
00:49:44 culture coming into conflict with this. The archetype of this is the appalling
00:49:48 public Morozov episode in Soviet history where a child who allegedly denounced
00:49:55 his parents to the authorities and was then killed by his grandfather became a
00:49:58 national martyr. As subjects of reverence the young pioneers were taught to
00:50:03 revere him and there was a statue in Moscow to which they used to go one day
00:50:07 year in parade in reverence to this little horror who denounced his own
00:50:11 parents. That's an extreme version of it but any utopian state must come into
00:50:16 conflict with parental authority. It'll do it with the schools, it will do it very
00:50:21 much with sex education which as I think George Lukács when he originally
00:50:26 introduced it in the Hungarian Bolshevik uprising in 1919 saw as a way of
00:50:31 demoralizing society. But also the other thing we discussed how the
00:50:36 universities will turn people against their parents' views and turn out a new
00:50:40 generation which doesn't gain its thoughts about anything from its
00:50:45 parents but from the state. We are in the grip of the equality and diversity
00:50:51 utopian state. Marshmallow totalitarianism looms. Enforced by the police force which
00:50:59 patrols Twitter very effectively. Thank you very much for coming and talking to us again and I know that you are writing another book at the moment aren't you?
00:51:11 Yes I'm writing a book it's called A Revolution Betrayed it's about the
00:51:15 destruction of the grammar schools and their replacement bias system which once
00:51:20 again benefited the rich over the poor and in the name bizarrely of egalitarianism
00:51:25 This will be out next year?
00:51:27 I don't know exactly when it will be out. It's well on the way at the moment.
00:51:33 But like all books it's turning out to be slightly different from the one I had intended
00:51:37 because if you do anything remotely resembling proper research you find there is an awful lot you didn't previously know.
00:51:42 One of the things I really didn't know anything like enough about, I knew a bit, was the secondary modern schools
00:51:48 which to this day portrays as an utter disaster and if you want grammar
00:51:55 schools back then you want secondary ones back which of course is in a way
00:51:57 true but it's the misunderstanding of their role and position is quite
00:52:03 extraordinary well I should really as a grammar school boy certainly thank you
00:52:10 very much indeed my pleasure that's it for this time we shall see you next time
00:52:15 In the meantime, please do subscribe won't you and we look forward to seeing you next time. Thank you very much. Bye bye