New Culture Forum - October 20, 2021


Sir David Amess's Friend Ann Widdecombe on His Murder, MP Safety, Religion & Online Safety Bill

British Police Have Transformed Into A Tool For Enforcing The State's Will -- Peter Hitchens Future of the West: Should Traditionalists Try to Take Back Control of Institutions or Just Give Up?

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

181.21

Word count

8,001

Sentence count

238


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Widdicombe, Webb and Wobbats. My name is Emma Webb and as usual I am joined by
00:00:16 former Shadow Home Secretary and Brexit Party MEP Anne Widdicombe and Abby Wobbats, the comedian
00:00:23 who is back from her sojourn in an illness that was not COVID, one of the rarer.
00:00:32 So this week, we're obviously starting on a sombre note because of the killing of conservative MP David Amos.
00:00:43 And I think we'll probably just dive straight into that without much introduction.
00:00:48 I'm sure everybody has seen the news coverage over the last couple of days.
00:00:53 And so if we wanted to start, I think, just with Anne, because Anne knew him personally.
00:00:59 Indeed, he was a very close personal friend.
00:01:02 I've known him for years and years, ever since I entered Parliament in 1987.
00:01:07 I was a close friend of the family, godmother to one of the children.
00:01:11 So it's much more than just an MP to me.
00:01:14 It's a very close friend.
00:01:16 And it is indeed horrendous.
00:01:18 And the thing about David was he was always so full of enthusiasm.
00:01:21 He used to bubble away about Southend all the time, trying to get at city status.
00:01:27 And he was terribly enthusiastic about Parliament and its traditions.
00:01:31 And even in the age of the all-night sittings, he would be among the last to leave.
00:01:34 He just wanted to be there, wanted to be involved.
00:01:37 And I think of him going to his constituency surgery that terrible morning, going in in
00:01:43 his usual way, all full of enthusiasm, wondering who he was going to meet, wondering what problems
00:01:48 would be looking forward to getting stuck in and then that.
00:01:53 And do you feel that, you know, there are a lot of eulogies in Parliament and the silence
00:02:00 that was held, do you have any reflections on that, any particular sort of feelings about
00:02:06 some of the speeches that some MPs have given?
00:02:09 Well the speeches were wonderful and I'm sure David would have absolutely loved them,
00:02:15 flags were at half-mast at both houses of Parliament, suspended all normal business
00:02:20 to pay tributes and it was indeed about a remarkable man. So I think it was a very moving
00:02:28 occasion, I know that his wife Julia was very very touched by it.
00:02:34 And a lot of the, in the first couple of hours I guess it would have been there were some
00:02:39 interviews by um the press of constituents i imagine i assume they were constituents local
00:02:46 people who knew him and one of the things that i noticed was that if through and through almost
00:02:51 every single interview the word approachable kept coming up and as someone who has never met him
00:02:56 leon c is actually very close to where i'm from um so for me it's almost a neighboring constituency
00:03:02 i was very much aware of the fact that since i was four years old he'd been the mp of the
00:03:07 It's almost like he's furniture in Essex. And as I say, you know, the word approachable kept coming up and it just sounded to me like he was the epitome of the constituency MP, someone who was just absolutely part of his people.
00:03:21 People have been saying that it didn't matter whether you voted for him or not. He would represent everyone in his constituency, whether it was, you know, helping refugees, whether it was stuff to do with animal rights and things like that.
00:03:34 there were so many causes that were dear to his heart but he was really representing his
00:03:38 constituency in that traditional old-fashioned sort of way. I think when you use the word
00:03:42 approachable you're implying that people could approach him but in fact he used to approach
00:03:47 everybody else. I mean I always say when talking about David that you know there's no such thing
00:03:53 as a waiter who comes to take his order who can then take the order before David has spent 10
00:03:58 minutes getting all his personal history out of him and trying to get him away from an
00:04:04 event you know it was almost impossible because he always wanted to talk to
00:04:08 people at huge length and so he wasn't just approachable he was approaching as
00:04:14 well. The Speaker Lindsay Hoyle as well said that that he would come into their
00:04:20 office just to talk to the staff and that when someone left after 28 years he
00:04:25 showered him with presents and someone else was saying that when he would see
00:04:30 him travelling late night back to the constituency from London on the train
00:04:35 and that he was never somebody who just sit there and read his book, he would be
00:04:38 talking to everyone on the train. Yeah, that is very much David. My own ex-staff
00:04:44 who were all writing to me at the time when it happened, were all recalling when
00:04:48 he would come into their office, you know, never mind his own office, he
00:04:53 would come into their office and always had a joke and a funny story and they
00:04:58 were all recalling that and that was the essential David Amos. And what were your, if you don't mind
00:05:03 me asking, what were your first thoughts when you heard the news? Disbelief, just total disbelief.
00:05:07 I'm still in denial to a certain extent and it's very, very difficult to believe I was away at the
00:05:13 time. I was on a train when I heard, I heard from his wife who said it's not looking good and then
00:05:20 not very long after that, minutes rather than hours, she was the widow who said to me he's gone.
00:05:28 or he's died and I still can't believe it I came home from that weekend away and opened my front
00:05:36 door and there was his face looking up at me from every single newspaper that was on the doormat
00:05:42 and you can't say how you feel I mean everybody I've spoken to who knows him well everybody is
00:05:49 saying we just can't believe it's happened why you know the endless question why why would anybody
00:05:55 want to do that. And can I ask you also if you remember the first time that you met him,
00:06:00 if you have any recollections of your sort of first impressions of him?
00:06:04 Well I actually met him first of all in a very serious context because we were both involved
00:06:09 in the big pro-life campaigns of the late 80s and the early 90s when there were a number of
00:06:13 bills going through parliament and we were very heavily engaged in it and that's when I got to
00:06:18 know him and he was a tremendous practical joker. You know I can remember one day we'd both gone up
00:06:24 to the constituency of Ken Hargreaves which was in Lancashire and we were
00:06:29 sitting there in Ken's lounge and Ken went out to do something, the phone went
00:06:33 and David picked it up and there was a constituent on the other end and David
00:06:38 just pretended to be Ken Hargreaves. He started advising the constituent.
00:06:45 I think I'm probably you know one of many people I've seen on Twitter saying
00:06:51 they wish that they'd met him because like I said I was aware that he was a piece of furniture in
00:06:57 Essex in a neighboring constituency but I actually never had the pleasure to meet him and I know that
00:07:02 he knew Andrew Rosendale who is very much our neighboring constituency MP and they obviously
00:07:09 have in common their total love for animals and one of the first things that I did you know within
00:07:16 a couple of hours afterwards I ended up sort of scrolling through all of these photos on
00:07:22 Google Images and probably more than 50% of his photos available online with animals.
00:07:28 He's one of the very few backbenchers who's actually got a bill onto the statute book
00:07:34 and it was about tethering of ponies and donkeys and of course he was
00:07:38 photographed outside parliament on a horse and even as far as I know he's never ridden in his life
00:07:44 but he was there on this horse outside parliament and he inherited my office. Well that is to say
00:07:50 he and I conspired to make sure that he did because it was a nice big office because when I
00:07:54 got it I wish I had a Home Secretary and he was determined he was going to have this when I left
00:07:59 and we agreed that possession was nine tenths of the law so if he just moved everything in
00:08:04 before I'd moved everything out it was fine you know nobody was going to argue about it
00:08:08 and I went back in to see it after the election he was indeed there and it was I mean with me it
00:08:13 had been an office you know there was a conference table and there were filing
00:08:17 cabinets and it was an office and I went in and it was a botanical garden and we
00:08:22 had fish tanks and we had birds in cages and these enormous plants and memorabilia
00:08:29 all over the walls and didn't look like an MP's office at all. He sounds like such a character.
00:08:34 And also when he was knighted there was that brilliant photo and actually I
00:08:39 can't remember which newspaper it was I think it was the Daily Mail did a huge
00:08:42 spread of him on horseback dressed as a knight yeah in a wood yeah and there's there was another
00:08:53 photo of him as well outside of parliament holding two very uppity looking horses which I assume must
00:08:59 have been something to do with that tethering act yeah but yeah so I moving on slightly to the
00:09:06 reaction to it. Do you have any reflections on the fact that I mean the
00:09:12 conversation is obviously very quickly turned to the safety of MPs and whether
00:09:19 there should be extra restrictions for those constituency surgeries because
00:09:24 obviously Jo Cox was also murdered I think it was outside of her constituency
00:09:29 surgery and there have been other instances as well of attacks at
00:09:34 surgeries as well. So what are your thoughts on that? Do you think that's going to affect democracy
00:09:40 if they go ahead with that? When you were an MP, did you feel that your safety was at risk?
00:09:45 No, no I didn't. I once, when I was very first an MP indeed, made some very disabligent comments
00:09:53 about the IRA and death threats came in purporting to be from the IRA and I just said to my staff,
00:09:58 if the IRA were going to do anything, I'd just do it. They wouldn't bother threatening, forget it.
00:10:03 Don't worry, they'll call first.
00:10:04 Put it in the waste paper basket.
00:10:06 And I think you do have to keep a sense of proportion.
00:10:09 And the one thing David would not want, David of all people would not want,
00:10:13 is for MPs to be separated for their constituents.
00:10:16 For us to do constituency surgeries with police outside the door with screens.
00:10:22 It's crucial that MPs can mingle perfectly freely with their constituents in surgery,
00:10:28 visiting constituents in their own homes which you know we all used to do a lot
00:10:33 meeting constituents on the streets going to events you know going to public
00:10:38 fates and all the rest of it and if you can't do that then that really will be a
00:10:44 massive disservice to democracy and David would not want that those sorts of
00:10:48 restrictions imposed in his name he would not want it and what do you think
00:10:53 of both of you firstly what he would have thought but also what
00:10:58 your views are on this suggestion that there should be background checks on
00:11:03 constituents going to see their MPs to see if they've got a criminal record.
00:11:07 God forbid, God forbid quite honestly and a constituent coming to see an MP is
00:11:11 like a patient going to see a doctor. You don't go in if they've come with a
00:11:15 problem that they're expecting you to address and if you start saying you're
00:11:19 going to do criminal record checks they won't come. If they've got anything in
00:11:23 the past they won't come and that is quite wrong that is a denial of a vital
00:11:28 service. And I would simply refuse. If I were an MP, I would refuse to give any such list.
00:11:33 Those with criminal records are still eligible to vote. So it seems like an absurd suggestion.
00:11:38 And they're eligible for help. You know, would you prevent them going to hospital? If not,
00:11:42 why prevent them coming to see the MP? Would you prevent them going to see a solicitor or prevent
00:11:47 them going to see an accountant or any other professional? Why shouldn't they see an MP?
00:11:52 That is ridiculous. And David would have said, it is ridiculous.
00:11:55 Yeah, we don't want this, what's happened, to allow people, shall we say, with authoritarian intent to use incidents like this to let things slip in through the back door.
00:12:09 Because it's very easy, isn't it, to say, well, let's just, it's what happened after 9-11 where CCTV cameras were put everywhere and all of a sudden we become a surveillance state.
00:12:18 we we don't want that i agree with anne that if we start going down that path then i mean it really
00:12:23 is going to be you know sort of houses of commons and then the people and they'll get wider and
00:12:29 wider and wider gap in my time in parliament we had an incident in which fathers for justice which
00:12:34 by the way is an organization i support but i didn't support this particular action that's
00:12:40 right yeah but they were in the public gallery in the house of commons and they threw talk and
00:12:46 powder at the Prime Minister. Now it was only Tolkien powder. But of course
00:12:50 everybody said oh it could have been anthrax. So they set a screen up between
00:12:54 the Public Gallery and the Chamber and that was the first time that had
00:12:58 happened. We'd gone through all the IRA, we'd gone through all the terrorism, we'd
00:13:01 gone through everything and suddenly there it was because somebody had thrown
00:13:06 some Tolkien powder at the Prime Minister. And that in my view at the time was a
00:13:09 gross overreaction. I used to look up and see a screen and it is not
00:13:15 what I wanted to see do you think that the response I mean obviously there's a
00:13:20 lot we can talk about in relation to the way that people have responded to this
00:13:24 particularly the focus on social media rather than talking about extremism and
00:13:29 the motivations of potential motivations of the attacker but do you think that
00:13:34 the response has been proportionate or the suggestions about David's law which
00:13:39 which some people are suggesting, and Priti Patel talking about regulating online speech more, and Dominic Raab as well.
00:13:48 Oh, don't worry, Priti Patel says she's going to do something, it won't happen.
00:13:52 That's immensely reassuring if you're saying that.
00:13:54 Do you think that the focus on needing to regulate what they think is a sort of toxic atmosphere within Parliament,
00:14:03 attacks on Angela Rayner for her comments about Tory scum,
00:14:07 Do you think that that is just a, is that an inappropriate reaction to it?
00:14:10 What do you think he would have thought of that reaction?
00:14:13 Well, I mean, David hated those sorts of campaigns on social media,
00:14:17 but the fact is they've been with us forever or ever since social media came into being.
00:14:22 And they are unpleasant and they are quite wrong.
00:14:26 And occasionally I think they should actually be taken down and be censored.
00:14:32 And I do think that.
00:14:33 But I think the idea that you can somehow legislate for people's behaviour and for their attitudes is naive.
00:14:44 You can't regulate people's behaviour.
00:14:46 There was a time when people would have been saying this sort of thing,
00:14:49 but they would have been saying it in the corners of pubs to their mates and nobody else would know about it.
00:14:54 Now they fire it across social media.
00:14:56 And we're conflating speech with action, which is happening a lot in other areas.
00:15:01 with this so this is the i for i mean i find it interesting that there wasn't any discussion really
00:15:08 around other than on certain channels like talk radio on gb news where they did talk about islamist
00:15:15 extremism they were talking about the fact that it wasn't being discussed more broadly that the
00:15:19 focus had immediately turned on to social media and that dominic raab just as one example when
00:15:25 he was doing the media rounds um i think it was yesterday morning uh this is a quote from him he
00:15:30 he sort of pinned it on the as he put it widespread vilification of politicians
00:15:35 said that online hate is out of control and that is incumbent on all of us as a society because
00:15:41 this creates a climate of hatred and so it seemed that and as i say this idea of david's law which
00:15:48 is um it seems is being suggested as something that would be um limiting the expression of hate
00:15:55 online it seems that even though all of the information that we have so far about what has
00:16:00 happened is all we know from the police is that there is a man who has been arrested he's being
00:16:05 detained under the terrorism act he hasn't been charged yet and the police have stated that
00:16:10 they're investigating an islamist extremist motive that's all we have we don't have anything to do
00:16:16 with radicalization all of this talk about priti patel wanting to ban anonymity online
00:16:22 all of that kind of thing. Do you think that's disproportionate? How do you make sense of that
00:16:28 reaction? I'd be quite in favour of banning anonymity online because I've always taken the
00:16:32 view that if you've got something to say, say it. And if you have to hide when you're saying it,
00:16:38 then there is something radically wrong. So actually, I don't have a problem with that.
00:16:42 I know that probably goes against very much of the grain with you. But I have always felt if
00:16:49 you've got something to say put your name to it then if somebody wants to take any action about
00:16:54 it they can do so yeah yeah i yeah my one fear slightly is with people with whistleblowers um
00:17:01 that need to i mean you know need to sort of remain remain anonymous um so where does it go
00:17:07 you know if you sort of always have to say this is who i am then it's going to be going to make
00:17:11 it very difficult the reason why i think anonymity is important for free speech in general is because
00:17:16 you mentioned whistleblowers but also pro-democracy dissidents people who are seeking anonymous
00:17:23 advice online which I think people are entirely entitled to do but also and this was a point that
00:17:30 I believe it was made by Matt Lesh I think was at the ASI and is now at the IEA on Twitter which is
00:17:36 that it's not just it's not just pro-democracy pro-democracy dissidents in places like Hong
00:17:44 Kong or Belarus, it's also people here, gender-critical feminists, who might like to express their
00:17:50 views but don't want to be seen because they fear that for their job, even though they should be
00:17:54 allowed to say those things, they can only say them anonymously or because they have a particular
00:17:58 job and therefore they are not able to participate openly in online discussions.
00:18:06 Add all those categories up, Emma, and what sort of proportion do you think it is of social media
00:18:12 as a whole. I mean the fact is you know anonymity in those sorts of cases is one
00:18:17 thing but that is not what anonymity is usually used for and it's
00:18:22 used to spread hatred and you know and I take the line very firmly that if
00:18:28 you say something you are responsible for what you say and you should be
00:18:33 traceable. There was actually a study done on this that found that it was
00:18:38 actually the the non-anonymous accounts that were more aggressive online than the anonymous ones so
00:18:45 actually i think a lot of the time anonymous accounts are just people who are almost voyeurs
00:18:50 on social media they're there because they're keeping up with the news and so on and they want
00:18:53 to participate in discussions but they're not don't necessarily want to be seen and so but it's
00:18:57 not because they're spreading hate another example of this is and she's no longer on twitter actually
00:19:03 grooming gang survivor who was had her Twitter account taken away from her for
00:19:09 whatever reason I think probably she was Twitter mobbed and people were
00:19:13 reporting her account and but there are people like grooming gang survivors on
00:19:16 there who may wish to remain anonymous because for various reasons one of the
00:19:20 reasons I say again you are picking on the very extreme cases you are not
00:19:26 looking at the use of social media as a whole which has I mean social media can
00:19:32 be a tremendous force for good but it is all too often the exact opposite. But is
00:19:36 that a price worth paying in order to allow those people to have a voice? That does not mean that you
00:19:41 have to put Mary Smith of three railway cuttings on your email. What it means is
00:19:47 that if you do something that is wrong or say something that is wrong and
00:19:51 somebody wishes redress, that person can find out who Mary Smith of
00:19:56 three railway cuttings is. And if Mary Smith of three railway cuttings is listening in,
00:20:00 and I'm really sorry of just giving you away.
00:20:04 But I was just gonna say, but isn't it,
00:20:07 I hear both arguments,
00:20:09 but isn't it to do with the principle,
00:20:11 like Emma was saying, that it's the principle of it,
00:20:14 a bit like when people say,
00:20:17 if I've got nothing to hide,
00:20:18 why shouldn't there be surveillance on me?
00:20:21 It's that, which is, that's not the point,
00:20:23 is that it's not the fact you haven't got anything to hide,
00:20:26 it's the fact that there's people watching you
00:20:28 something else something else that has been pointed out I believe it was in an
00:20:33 article in spiked is how do you if if you do have it so that people can be
00:20:39 publicly anonymous but privately the companies they're verified companies
00:20:42 know who they are either you need some kind of if it comes from the government
00:20:46 you need some kind of idea I don't really know how that would work but the
00:20:49 the more likely suggestion would be that the companies themselves would hold that
00:20:53 information but companies like Facebook have had numerous breaches of that
00:20:57 information and if you took a case of somebody who wants to be online but for
00:21:02 maybe you know child protection reasons or maybe they've been a victim of abuse
00:21:07 or something or a grooming gang survivor and as I know of this particular case of
00:21:11 this lady who was thrown off she didn't want to give them anything to verify her
00:21:15 account because she doesn't give she I knew her and she wouldn't even tell me
00:21:19 what her name was so terrified exactly and so and so the gangs there even if it
00:21:25 the case that you would be publicly anonymous. Do you want these big tech companies to have that
00:21:32 information in the first place? I do want that information available, not publicly available,
00:21:38 but accessible. And all I would say is yes, there can be breaches of confidentiality. There have
00:21:45 been. The banks have lost people's documents and the health service has. And there are always
00:21:52 scandals about breaches of confidentiality, and that is something that needs addressing in its
00:21:57 own right. But I don't think you can say that just because it is a big company, therefore there's
00:22:04 bound to be a breach, and that's dangerous. Breaches are always dangerous, but they can occur
00:22:11 anywhere. They don't just have to occur on social media. So all I'm saying is I'm quite happy for
00:22:17 people to be publicly anonymous providing that the companies know who they are and under certain very
00:22:24 restricted conditions you know and you can you can lay down all the checks that you want for
00:22:28 restricted conditions it should be possible to find out who somebody is and of course the reality is
00:22:35 big tech probably knows who you are anyway she said she says you know throwing in a sinister
00:22:41 note the big old elephant in the room because we've actually done what the press have done which
00:22:46 which is we've been talking about the social media side of things, my question, and this
00:22:54 is something that perplexes me, is how on earth we got from what happened almost immediately
00:23:02 to talking about social media, even though...
00:23:04 Because that's where hate spreads.
00:23:05 Even though...
00:23:06 Yeah, but...
00:23:07 Because that's where hate spreads.
00:23:08 That's why.
00:23:09 That is the stepping stone.
00:23:10 Do you think it's wrong that we haven't, within the mainstream media, there hasn't
00:23:14 been a lot of conversation around the one thing that we do know from the police which is that
00:23:19 they're investigating an Islamist extremist motive. And I'll tell you exactly why there hasn't been
00:23:22 that conversation. The law is very strict in this country about prejudicing trials.
00:23:27 The fact that the police are looking into something does not mean that it is established as fact
00:23:31 and until it is you could actually end up with some very clever defence barrister saying
00:23:39 you know, my defendant cannot get a fair trial. It's quite impossible. So therefore, if the police
00:23:47 are looking at something, frankly, the most responsible thing the rest of us can do is to
00:23:51 note that and then shut up. But we don't, or we also don't know that the reason why, I mean,
00:23:55 if it is, if it is an Islamist attack, then it's very unlikely that, for example, people have
00:24:01 blamed the toxicity within parliamentary, I don't think he was sitting there watching BBC Parliament.
00:24:05 I think it's very unlikely that he was maybe maybe he was at the Labour Party conference I don't know
00:24:12 but you know the if it is an Islamist motive then the conversation around the online atmosphere is
00:24:19 going to have very little bearing on the on the motivation may have very little bearing on this
00:24:26 particular case but it has a lot of bearing on society in general and the way that we're
00:24:32 operating and the way that hate is spreading you can have that conversation I think is perfectly
00:24:37 reasonable conversation to have but what's interesting I mean the in the IRAs time there
00:24:41 was no social media but the hate for this country was was was as we all know I mean I lived through
00:24:46 the I was actually I just left Harrods when the Harrods bomb went off I'd left with my mother I
00:24:52 mean literally half I missed the Brighton bomb by 20 minutes so it's all it was all very there it
00:24:57 was there we knew about it because if people I mean from sorry this has a bit
00:25:02 try so a bit of a cliche but to me hatred starts starts in there and if and
00:25:07 if that we need a wider conversation I think about well we will probably get
00:25:12 onto this but a bit about the fact this is a Judeo-Christian country and we're
00:25:16 tolerant of faiths but we have to establish the Judeo-Christian bit first
00:25:21 otherwise what's going to happen is everyone's going to try and assert their
00:25:26 dominance in this country and and god rest to david he is one another victim of it and while
00:25:35 we're on the subject of christianity i gather that he was denied the last frights yeah he was i can't
00:25:40 believe i cried when i heard that i can't believe it so i wanted um i actually wanted to read out
00:25:45 i wanted to read out the police statement for you to respond to um because it's a it's a long one so
00:25:52 so bear with me i'll just read it out in full the police said as with any police incident it is of
00:25:58 utmost importance that we preserve the integrity of a crime scene and allow emergency services to
00:26:03 tend to those in need a cordon is put in place to secure and prevent contamination of the area
00:26:09 access to a scene is at the discretion of the investigating officers this is a fundamental
00:26:14 part of any investigation to ensure the best possible chance of securing justice for any
00:26:19 victim and their family. A cordon can also be used to restrict an area for emergency
00:26:24 services to administer potentially life-saving medical treatment in as much privacy as possible
00:26:29 and to allow officers to confirm an area is safe to enter. Do you think that giving the
00:26:36 last rites should be regarded as an emergency service? I was going to say, Dear Chief Constable,
00:26:42 If you are a dying Catholic, the priest is an emergency service.
00:26:47 Dear Chief Constable, of course it's very important to save lives, but does it you not
00:26:53 understand that if you're a Catholic, the saving of your immortal soul is also really
00:26:59 rather important?
00:27:01 And dear Chief Constable, if I should ever be so unfortunate to be in need of the last
00:27:07 rights inside a close-off zone. Will you please make sure that I get them?
00:27:13 Here, here.
00:27:15 Chief Constable of three cuttings.
00:27:18 I hope you're listening, Chief Constable.
00:27:20 Yeah, exactly.
00:27:20 I was, honestly, when I read that, I...
00:27:23 I couldn't believe it. The denial of the last rights.
00:27:25 I cried because I thought that is...
00:27:28 It sort of went to the kernel, I think, of what's wrong with this country, is that we're
00:27:34 sort of... It's, you know, computer says no.
00:27:36 yeah sorry we're not able to the rule book says not not where's the humanity where's the you know
00:27:44 the respect for this man um oh they wouldn't have understood it they wouldn't have understood what
00:27:48 they are i was i was i think it was a case that they actually just simply did not know what the
00:27:52 last rites were i think they have no clue what what and thought why is this price priest trying
00:27:56 to get it they thought what was that you know i mean it's horrendous it it it is absolutely
00:28:03 horrendous yeah there's a lot around this about culture and you know i mean everything i think
00:28:08 we so we should definitely return to it but i'm going to ask you this just because i
00:28:13 think that probably those watching will want me to ask you this don't you think that and this is
00:28:18 i've seen this various commentators have been talking about this over the last day or so
00:28:24 which is this question of it may be the case that there is a discussion to be had
00:28:29 about the social media stuff and um the the way that mps i actually think that mps should hold
00:28:36 themselves to a higher professional standard they do in the way they sling mud at each other i think
00:28:40 many of them like angela rayner don't act very professionally but that that is a separate
00:28:45 conversation to be had and yes i do take your point about prejudicing trials but do you think
00:28:50 that actually the reason why the conversation has immediately turned to this is because it's
00:28:55 something that feels like it's more within our control. Whereas the Islamist extremist problem
00:29:00 is something that keeps coming back. We've struggled to deal with it. Always talking about
00:29:04 online radicalization and things like that, that seem easier to solve than the real life problem.
00:29:11 Do you think that is the reason why we've almost skipped the Groundhog Day part that we're usually
00:29:16 the formulas that we normally recite in response to attacks? And because if in a case like Joe Cox,
00:29:21 we are quite rightly we're all talking about far-right extremism in relation to it it was
00:29:28 one of the first things that that people were discussing so my question would be and I think
00:29:34 this is probably what those watching would want to know what your views are on this do you think
00:29:39 that these are two separate conversations that the question is how did we get from one to the
00:29:43 other so quickly why did that happen I think there are a lot of conversations I mean if you actually
00:29:49 look at the headlines you know the fact that a suspect had been referred to the
00:29:55 prevent program at one point you know all this was rehearsed I don't think it
00:29:59 was ignored it was all rehearsed but then it got on to hatred in general and
00:30:03 you can't ignore the fact that MPs in Parliament were talking about hatred and
00:30:07 social media so I mean I think the conversation just did move on but I say
00:30:12 can be very very careful about prejudicing trials but is the reason why
00:30:16 it did move on in that way because MPs with the online safety bill and all of
00:30:21 these other conversations that are happening at the moment they were
00:30:24 already thinking about this they were already talking about it so it sort of
00:30:28 became part of this bigger abstract and I think that often in response to terror
00:30:32 attacks we're in danger of always very quickly jumping into the very very large
00:30:37 area of things that are tangentially related to the problem and never
00:30:40 looking at the problem in the face we're terrified I have no I have no idea why
00:30:44 we're more afraid of offending people than we are of people being murdered in
00:30:48 cold blood that's that's where we are there has and talk radio absolutely
00:30:53 credit to talk radio I've had lots of discussions about Islamism yeah and some
00:30:58 people are saying we shouldn't be calling it Islamist terrorism we you
00:31:02 know that is discriminatory or it stirs up hatred against against the Muslim
00:31:08 community but my my argument would be Islamism is a distinct thing it is an
00:31:12 intellectual tradition that and it is Islamist terrorism that is the
00:31:17 phenomenon but I find it interesting that so quickly and you know it's it's
00:31:23 the classic deflection you know that when whenever whenever something happens
00:31:28 we always end up talking about something that is something else exactly so
00:31:32 quickly and I think I wonder whether that is because we genuinely do not know
00:31:37 how to deal with the problem. I think the fear is that if you start talking about
00:31:43 Islamist terrorism you're going to be branding all Muslims in a particular
00:31:48 way. Now in case you think that's silly just reflect how the British public
00:31:53 behaves. In the First World War it used to kick Dachshunds across the street
00:31:56 because they were just... No, it's not true surely. It is absolutely true. In the Second World War...
00:32:04 Were Dachshunds terrorists at that time? Were they sort of committing a...
00:32:06 Germans, they were Germans. That's true. That's what it was about, the First World War.
00:32:11 Oh, you don't remember? No, of course you don't. I'm not quite that old. Do you recall
00:32:15 your history? And in the Second World War, Italian restaurants were burnt down.
00:32:22 You know, the British public can behave badly. And I think there's always that fear there
00:32:28 that once you start talking about Islam, you're somehow, I mean, I know you're not,
00:32:33 but the fear is that you are somehow branding all muslims but don't we have to if if your argument is
00:32:41 that that that islam is one thing and islamism is another thing isn't it important to to be able to
00:32:48 name islamism as being the motivation to actually be able to describe the thing that you're talking
00:32:53 about i'm not saying you shouldn't i'm trying to explain to you yes of course the theories
00:32:57 So there's a question here from Robin Forsyth. He asks about Salman Abadi and how Salman Abadi's older brother, the Manchester Arena bomber, has left the UK.
00:33:12 He said, when are authorities going to get a grip on what we've been discussing, why haven't they done so already?
00:33:20 Well, I don't know why they haven't done so already. I suspect the will isn't there.
00:33:25 Yeah.
00:33:25 The will isn't there.
00:33:27 I mean, it was like those grooming gangs with those girls, you know, and they didn't do anything because they were afraid that in the course of protecting women, they were going to force racial offence.
00:33:38 Yes. And so the will is not there. The will to actually get to grips with something is not there.
00:33:43 You're right. The will and also the pride in being British, which includes tolerance, but must also include recognising our cultural history.
00:33:52 because if we don't sorry keep repeating Douglas Murray saying we are going to be
00:33:56 go you know we are going to end up sort of yeah in a very dangerous place so we
00:34:01 shall return to the subject of Christianity in a bit but first I want
00:34:06 to talk about again on the topic of online censorship and so on David Davis
00:34:13 this is this really goes to the heart of how much do you trust social media
00:34:17 companies to decide what is and is not allowed to be said on their platforms
00:34:20 david davis the mp uh he did a talk a conservative party conference with uh very ironically given
00:34:28 what happened big brother watch the organization um and i'm sure everyone can figure out from the
00:34:33 name what big brother watch is all about um keeping an eye on big brother and big brother then in this
00:34:39 case google which owns youtube removed his very well evidenced very fair and measured
00:34:47 speech the video took it down from youtube and he's written a very interesting piece in the express
00:34:55 talking about how so he says here he says i have been a strong advocate for vaccines
00:35:02 and science-based policy but a core premise of science is challenging conventional wisdom and
00:35:08 being unafraid to speak your mind difference of opinion arbitrated by the facts not powerful
00:35:13 platform providers on the other side of the world and he goes on to say that it showed in the
00:35:19 clearest terms why big tech cannot be trusted to police our speech and he also talks as well
00:35:26 about how and I think this is very interesting as well is that the policy that YouTube use in
00:35:32 taking these things down they actually took down talk radio um a time a while ago um for what they
00:35:38 had been putting out on pandemic related things i think probably anti-mask anti-lockdown um and
00:35:43 he said that their policy is basically to um to remove things that contradict local health
00:35:50 authorities or the world health organization so he said uh in debating a key aspect of national
00:35:56 health policy i cannot disagree i cannot disagree with the government question mark
00:36:00 you could be forgiven for thinking that we had suddenly been transported to China so what do
00:36:06 you think? I think those are very reasonable observations from David Davis the fact is that
00:36:13 that is censorship not on the basis of harm being done or crimes being committed but simply on the
00:36:19 basis that somebody is confronting and challenging state orthodoxy and the very definition of freedom
00:36:26 is that you can challenge state orthodoxy and the very definition of fascism is that you can't
00:36:31 yeah agreed and something very strange has happened science has become you know one-sided
00:36:38 has become as if it's not challengeable exactly you know it's science is a discussion
00:36:44 exactly discussion it's it's it's weird as everything is the nature of things has been
00:36:49 changed um quite drastically over the last 18 or so months so science has changed but also
00:36:54 So this, what's happening with, you know, David Davis is discussing vaccine passports.
00:36:59 I mean, it's very, it's, yeah, it's most peculiar.
00:37:03 I'm aware that we're getting short on time.
00:37:05 So there are two more things that I want to ask you about quickly before we close.
00:37:10 The first is that, as I said, we would return to the subject of Christianity, the conversion of the Anglican bishop, Nazir Ali, to Catholicism.
00:37:18 What are your thoughts?
00:37:20 Hugely significant, this one, because unlike recent trends, because I mean,
00:37:26 Church Wing has lost bishops to Rome now for some years, but unlike the usual pattern,
00:37:35 he was not an Anglo-Catholic. That is, he was not already in sympathy with the Catholicism.
00:37:38 Like Gavin Ashenden, who recently converted to.
00:37:40 He wasn't an Anglo-Catholic. He was in fact much nearer to the evangelical wing,
00:37:45 So he really has done an enormous jump. Now, that is very significant because once that starts to happen, once members of the Church of England start to say, look, this is just so bad that, you know, we do want something where a church knows what it's teaching, teaches it unapologetically, doesn't care whether it's popular or not.
00:38:09 doesn't care whether it's modish and fashionable or not doesn't care whether
00:38:13 it's woke or not but just goes for truth once they start saying that then I think
00:38:19 you are looking as I say in my excellent column in the Daily Express tomorrow I
00:38:23 think you're looking at the eventual not the immediate but the eventual death
00:38:26 knell of the Church of England well I am one of those Anglo-Catholics looking to
00:38:32 Rome and so I obviously have my own views on what I think is wrong with the
00:38:36 anglican church but do you do you have a sort of uh diagnosis of why the the church of england has
00:38:44 and actually in the context of this they are discussing at the moment there's a brilliant
00:38:49 twitter account which you should all follow called friendless churches um and they put up their
00:38:55 brilliant charity um and they put out a tweet uh basically uh bringing to everyone's attention the
00:39:02 fact that the church is looking to change its rules to make it easier to sell off church buildings
00:39:07 so what is your diagnosis of what is wrong with the church of england i don't know what it thinks
00:39:13 i don't know i'm not as as clued up as as anne and and emerald but um i assume is it like going
00:39:21 from manu to chelsea is that that bigger that's what he's done terrible sorry sorry to lower the
00:39:26 lower the theological tone it can count on you abby somewhat yeah sorry guys going for the populist
00:39:33 um uh vote but um i will i i um yes well i mean i don't part of me sort of thinks i don't really
00:39:40 i don't really blame him but then the other part of me thinks is it better to stay on a on a on a
00:39:47 you know better on a sinking ship i mean sort of yes to check water to to stay in sort of like
00:39:54 put your mast in the sand and say i'm going to you know defend the church of england i mean i i i
00:40:00 i don't know he's been doing that for years he's been doing that for years what you're saying is
00:40:04 it's gone so well he's reached a point he can't you know he can't do it that way any longer he's
00:40:08 seen too many rainbows and sort of unicorn that's what strikes me is so interesting is that both
00:40:12 nazir ali and gavin ashenden who used to be the i think you know i believe he was the chaplain to
00:40:17 the queen and also recently converted from anglicanism to catholicism is that both of
00:40:22 them are individuals who were the ones that would fight for the Church of
00:40:27 England just to stay sound essentially and so if they are the ones who are
00:40:33 jumping ship to Catholicism that suggests to me that those who are most
00:40:38 savvy about theology and the foundations of the Church of England have decided
00:40:44 and as you say because he's from the evangelical side rather than the
00:40:47 Anglo-Catholic suggests that this is really like a the sign of the changing
00:40:52 of the seasons that the Church of England is it's not a sinking ship it's
00:40:56 sunk. No I think it's still sinking and I think it's going to sink terribly
00:41:01 terribly slowly. I don't think it's gonna happen. One bishop at a time. By Tuesday
00:41:04 afternoon you know one bishop at a time. But I think I mean you asked for the
00:41:07 reason the reason is simple enough it doesn't know what it believes. I know you
00:41:11 can get as many different opinions in the Church of England you know as there
00:41:16 are in the world you don't get bums on seats by pup-pup courses well they have skelters and
00:41:20 lovely gift shops they haven't actually you know increased their congregations by adopting a woke
00:41:27 policy they haven't increased their congregations at all well actually if you listen i am in the
00:41:33 habit of listening to strange obscure uh clerical lectures and things that some of the more um
00:41:39 curious elements of the church of england put up on youtube um and it's obvious it just seems
00:41:45 obvious to me that they are I suppose you would say theologically inept there's
00:41:50 just no meat it's no basis to it it's just a metaphor for the country quite I
00:41:56 mean Church of England is literally is what's happening they are the canary in
00:42:00 the coal mine yeah cultural canary in the coal mine so I just briefly want to
00:42:04 finish with final thoughts on a slightly lighter story perhaps it's not a lighter
00:42:10 story I don't know crazy story and is the National Church of Scotland has banned
00:42:16 the word spooky hey sorry the National Theatre of Scotland did I say church
00:42:23 National Theatre of Scotland has banned the word spooky because they say it's a
00:42:28 racial slur and they say it's a racial slur because apparently in World War two
00:42:33 US military officers used it to refer to black pilots and also in the same story
00:42:41 the National Library of Scotland also not the National Church of Scotland is
00:42:45 apparently amending the words plantation and slave in its collections in their
00:42:51 indexes and catalogues and they've changed the word in slave a slave to
00:42:55 enslaved person which just seems like it's more words for the same thing and
00:43:00 and the word plantation to forced labour plantation.
00:43:04 Oh, for heaven's sake.
00:43:06 I mean, I hardly feel like commenting. I mean the stupidity is just mind-boggling.
00:43:12 And as for spook, I don't know the etymology of spook.
00:43:15 It comes from spook in Dutch.
00:43:17 But it has been around for a very long time.
00:43:21 Yeah, and apparently spook in Dutch simply means ghost.
00:43:25 Spook? Like spies? How long?
00:43:27 Which that's actually where the word spook comes from the Dutch.
00:43:29 Yeah. So it's like, and as you rightly said earlier on, is how you're going to describe spies.
00:43:35 Yeah.
00:43:35 If you don't use the word, you know, spook.
00:43:38 We always talk about spooks when we're talking about the intelligence services.
00:43:41 If you want to see a country that we don't want to become, look at Scotland.
00:43:44 I mean, they really are the canary in the Corbyn.
00:43:47 I don't want to be like them.
00:43:50 You'll be up for racism now.
00:43:51 I will. Oh, no.
00:43:53 What a wonderful note to end on.
00:43:54 I've been cancelled.
00:43:55 Yeah, you'll be cancelled all throughout Scotland.
00:43:58 I'm so sorry, Scotland.
00:43:59 Sorry.
00:43:59 Thank you for joining us again.
00:44:02 Thank you, Anne.
00:44:03 Thank you, Abby.
00:44:04 Please like if you feel so inclined, comment, and we will see you next time.