00:00:00hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whitlaw now in one way or another on this
00:00:24program we talk quite a lot about tradition and traditions usually in a
00:00:29particular context which is that they are all going or that they are under
00:00:34attack but what actually is tradition and why is it important now my guest
00:00:40today has just written a book right about this whatever happened to
00:00:45tradition which comes out this week Tim Stanley is an author and historian he's
00:00:51also a columnist for The Telegraph and leader writer for The Telegraph. Thank you very much
00:00:57for joining us. It's a pleasure. Thank you. This whatever happened to tradition when you see this
00:01:02in the shop I can think a lot of our viewers will probably immediately want to buy it because the
00:01:08implication is that in fact it's going or gone but first of all what is it? Well when we say the word
00:01:15tradition we are referring to something being passed down that's the very simplest definition
00:01:20of it. It is something old that we are curating, that we hope to pass on to someone else.
00:01:27But I'd say there are lots of things that could be mistaken for tradition. But sometimes
00:01:31really we're talking in those cases about fashions, fads, customs or rituals, etc, etc.
00:01:36So if you want a sense of what a tradition is, I say it has a sort of three-part taste
00:01:41test. One, it plugs the individual into a sense of community. Second, it gives you what is called
00:01:51by Roger Scruton, social knowledge. It gives you a language to describe things. And thirdly,
00:01:56it has a remarkable effect upon time itself, so that it connects you to the past. So to take a
00:02:03tradition that does all of those things, you might say the monarchy. The monarchy is part of a wider
00:02:09community. The monarchy sits at the head of the nation, so there you are. It's plugging the
00:02:12individual into a sense of being part of something. It has social knowledge because it teaches you
00:02:18how to behave, how to speak to people. It has a language. It has ritual. It has a whole custom to
00:02:24it and an art and a culture to it. And finally, it has this effect upon time because the monarch,
00:02:30of course, their badge of honor is timelessness or the appearance of timelessness. So a monarch
00:02:36claims their authority from the fact that they are descended from other monarchs and they stretch
00:02:40back and back and back into ages long since forgotten. So tradition is at once something
00:02:44very very simple, passing things on, but the way of testing whether or not something really is a
00:02:49tradition is if it has this depth and if it has this sort of significance to it. Well actually
00:02:57it's interesting because if you take that old definition of people who came before you say
00:03:02us and the people yet to be born. The monarchy is almost the embodiment of that, isn't it?
00:03:08Because we see it actually happening. But what's interesting about, you used the example of monarchy,
00:03:13I think it seems a very, very good one, is that a lot of the tradition around it is in fact
00:03:19quite modern. Exactly, yes, yeah. And that's one of the things about tradition, the more you get
00:03:24into it, and this is where I hope the book will surprise people, and I found this when I really
00:03:28got into the subject, I thought I'd just be defending old things. But actually, when you
00:03:32look into it, you realise a lot of those old things are contemporary innovations. And the
00:03:38question which historians and thinkers have batted back and forth for a good hundred years
00:03:42or so is, does that make them artificial? It's the fact that some of these things are
00:03:45fairly new, certain ceremonies, certain forms with the monarchy. The modern monarchy, its
00:03:50look is sort of 19th century, essentially. That's when a lot of what the monarchy does
00:03:54now as established and formalized. Does that make it false or artificial? Well, I would say not,
00:03:59because it's building on what came before. Even that which is an innovation is an attempt to
00:04:04restore or stay true to the sense of what there was before. So even when you're innovating a
00:04:10tradition, you're still engaging with a tradition, adding something to it. Traditions do not stay the
00:04:15same all the time and look the same all the time. They evolve, they develop, they add things on,
00:04:20and crucially they interact with other traditions and they are changed by them. So the monarchy has
00:04:24been transformed by democracy and by the experience of democracy and paradoxically the monarchy
00:04:30actually during the 19th century with the expansion of the franchise, the monarchy went
00:04:35more on display, became grander and developed much of the air of an imperial throne during
00:04:43that period of democratization in order partly to sell itself to the new democratic polity.
00:04:49So a good, healthy tradition can always sense the way the winds are moving, adapt and appeal and remain relevant to that changing socioeconomic circumstance.
00:04:59Yes, I think some of the ceremonies that we now take for quite a bit, Trooping the Cire, oh, it's been going for years.
00:05:06Well, actually, not that long. I mean, you know, it has been, but it originated as being the monarch's real birthday, I believe.
00:05:14And the state opening of Parliament as well, with all the paraphernalia, again, a relatively new thing.
00:05:18But I would have thought that what is particularly important in the context of what we're talking about is the investiture of Prince Charles, which was sort of, just sort of, you know, I think the last one was a century before, but that, the first, that one, which was some archaic ceremony in Carnarvon Castle, there hadn't been one for about 800 years, I think, it was just resurrected.
00:05:45right right and you said at the beginning uh many people will buy this because they think
00:05:49tradition is going that's a classic example of it being restored and what i find so interesting is
00:05:53that uh especially if you look back since the since the industrial revolution at periods of
00:05:57great economic and social change that's when you see restoration you're not just in this country
00:06:02so i write a great deal in the book about meiji japan which in the late 19th century when it was
00:06:08forced to open up to the rest of the world essentially because the americans gave it um
00:06:11gave it a no option to. What is an offer it couldn't refuse? Japan did open it up but it
00:06:19tried to do it on its own terms by reviving a sense of Japanese-ness and much of which today
00:06:24is taken for granted as being innate to Japan and timeless about Japan. It's actually a 19th century
00:06:29invention or a 19th century rediscovery of that which came before. You mentioned there
00:06:37although there is this sort of fear that we're losing traditions.
00:06:41I mean, this is presumably one of the reasons that you've done this book.
00:06:44Because you say that the problem we have in the West
00:06:48is that one of our traditions is to discard tradition.
00:29:02And actually, there are points of similarity between Catholicism and Marxism.
00:29:06And it was often joked in Italy, in the post-war eras, it was often joked that the best communists were Catholics, partly because they understand organization and they do as they're told.
00:29:18They're into theory, but they're also into organization.
00:29:21And you have democratic centralism and the idea that you thrash it out internally.
00:29:25But once a party line has been adopted, you follow it. So I think it's no coincidence that Italy is both a very Catholic country and probably the most popularly communist democratic country in West Europe at the time.
00:29:37um it does sometimes seem now as i you know started off by saying that you know if if one
00:29:44really believes strongly in tradition you know we've been talking about slightly deeper themes
00:29:50but i mean oh you know the superficial tradition um that somehow or other you know it sometimes
00:29:57feels that one is actually more on the kind of subversive side of things now yes yes and i just
00:30:04wonder do you think first of all that that is you know a fair uh explanation i mean do you do you
00:30:14think that people who are believing who believe in tradition are on the back foot i mean not just
00:30:19being paranoid and also do you think that there is a way in which tradition can be made healthy
00:30:27again? Can it be revived? The great paradox of modern politics is that because the institutions
00:30:36have been captured by the liberal left, people who once would have deferred those to those
00:30:42institutions and would have respected that authority are now in rebellion against it.
00:30:47So typically conservatives like to defer. They'll defer to scientists, they'll defer to academics,
00:30:54they'll defer to politicians. But because each of those professions and institutions
00:30:59has embraced this anti-tradition vibe and have been captured by the liberal left,
00:31:05you find that the people those institutions are meant to serve are in rebellion against
00:31:10those institutions. So Brexit was the classic example. The Conservative Party didn't want to
00:31:14do Brexit. It was its membership that wanted Brexit. The Conservative Party held a referendum
00:31:18in order to settle the issue and it thought it would win and move on. That wasn't the plan,
00:31:22was to win. So it was actually the people in rebellion against the Conservative Party.
00:31:27You see it in the Anglican Church. You have a hierarchy which is overwhelmingly liberal left.
00:31:32You have people in the pews who are fighting to keep their churches open. So they find themselves
00:31:36in rebellion against. You have even medical and scientific elites who take one position and you
00:31:41find them very often being criticised by people who in the past would have deferred to them
00:31:44and want to defer to them. I want to be able to respect and take your instruction because
00:31:50because I trust it. But because something's gone wrong with the institution, I no longer trust it.
00:31:55And this is the great paradox, is that conservatism has become rebellious, not quite
00:31:59revolutionary. It's become rebellious because it's in rebellion against the very institutions
00:32:03that conservatism exists to maintain. Conservatives should love universities. They're places of higher
00:32:10learning. They're supposed to curate our culture and our heritage. And yet conservatives are the
00:32:16biggest critics of universities now so so that's the problem can that situation be reversed yes it
00:32:22can and again another irony is that it'll be done through democratic change and conservatives aren't
00:32:27supposed to like democratic change but it's things like brexit it's the people pushing back and saying
00:32:32actually i want that tradition so i'm going to vote to make it happen that's what will reverse it so
00:32:37how would that technically come about i mean absolutely no idea this is the thing that
00:32:43preoccupies people so much i mean i would say uh you know after brexit and then we had the three or
00:32:49four years after that yeah um i fundamentally changed my attitude to british institutions
00:32:55so i would have unquestionably i would be devoted to part from the monarchy which i think is still
00:33:02managed somehow to to hold it together but all of the others i thought maybe you're not what i
00:33:07always traditionally thought you were yes even the army yes even the army so but the thing is
00:33:13where will this where will people be able to go to vote to say i want to keep that tradition
00:33:18this is the problem i don't know because there there really is no conservative party
00:33:22um part of the problem is that conservatives exist to protect the status quo i mean big c
00:33:28conservatives so the conservative party will and will protect whatever it inherits and if the
00:33:33Conservative Party governs a liberal status quo, will maintain a liberal status quo. Now, in the
00:33:38last three or four years alone, they have gone slightly more right wing, slightly more pro
00:33:43tradition, because the people have forced them to do that because of Brexit. That's not their
00:33:48natural position. Boris Johnson is a big L liberal. He would not be doing this had Brexit not
00:33:53happened. So that's part of the problem. There isn't the political solution. I think the right,
00:33:58as always is split over whether it should try to retake the institutions by force. It needs a
00:34:05Potemkin moment. It needs to storm the Winter Palace and take them back. Or, as I increasingly0.55
00:34:11lean towards, but I'm not quite there yet, if we should give up and just go away and do our own
00:34:17thing. And I'm tempted to do that. I'm tempted to think, ultimately, if you want a tradition to
00:34:22flourish, live it. So if you want cricket to be as cricket always was, go and join a cricket club
00:34:27and do it if you want to someone if you want someone still to write good music write the music
00:34:31yourself or sponsor it or play it or something like that right take it into your own hands to
00:34:36do it give up on politics and i'm increasingly tempted to take that view partly because i have
00:34:42found politics so frustrating and it's so hard to make any change effective change that i'm coming
00:34:47around to the view that we just need to give up yes i don't think i'm quite there yet i hope i'm
00:34:53I mean, I think possibly one other third way is that one comes up with alternative institutions.