00:00:00hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now i'm delighted to welcome back
00:00:24one of our most popular guests, the historian David Starkey. He needs no introduction. David,
00:00:31thank you for coming back. A great pleasure as always. David, before anything else, it's quite
00:00:37a special day today, isn't it? Because you're about to join the battalion of YouTubers. Can
00:00:43you tell us about this? It took me quite a long time to find out what YouTube was, you know,
00:00:48such such an old dinosaur as I am but what I'm doing is I am launching later
00:00:54today a new YouTube channel which is going to be given the name David Starkey
00:00:59talks with very importantly I'm told in terms of branding three points of
00:01:04suspension afterwards so David Starkey talks and I'll be talking primarily
00:01:08about history and what I'll be trying to do is to do what I always have done which
00:01:15Which is, they're forms really, they're a curious cross between a conversation, such as we're having now, except I'm talking to myself, and old style extemporary lecturing.
00:01:26The thing that I most enjoyed in all the years that I was an academic and later on on kind of periphery of that academic world, which is now of course post-cancelation closed to me.
00:01:38The thing that I really enjoyed was lecturing and small group teaching.
00:01:43And what this is, is an attempt at saying, here we have this new medium in which you can actually reproduce the effect of your somebody, teacher, lecturer, friend, historian, sitting here and you sitting there.
00:02:00It rather reminds me, the way you describe it, of what A.G.P. Taylor used to do.
00:02:06Well, I always did. You see, I mean, anybody who ever saw me lecture, it is exactly the same. I had, dare I say, the same talent as Taylor. You could wind me up at five past ten and I would stop at three minutes to eleven.
00:02:25The standard Cambridge Hour, which was the 10-minute gap that enabled you to get from one place to another.
00:02:37I mean, it's a technique I learned long, long before I became an academic, long even really before I grew up.
00:02:45At my little grammar school, Long Extinguished, one of the first to be extinguished in the 70s,
00:02:51We have the tradition of a public speaking competition, which involved the three elements, the standard elements of reciting a piece of verse, reading unseen a piece of prose, but most importantly, what was called the stump speech.
00:17:20It seems to me that in area after area, the postmodern has triumphed.
00:17:26I mean, the most obvious area, of course, is the vast conflict
00:17:31over what is meant by gender and transgender.
00:17:34The fact that the union of university and college teachers declare that it is a matter of policy, that merely by saying you are a woman, you are a woman, whatever your chromosomes, whatever your, as it were, sexual characteristics.
00:17:57That is simply a lie. But you're institutionalizing a lie because you want to leave a lie.
00:18:05It's in other words, it is as absurd as believing literally in transubstantiation,
00:18:11that by the priest pronouncing the words, hoc es corpus, here is the body,
00:18:15that miraculously the bread and wine actually become flesh and blood.
00:18:19It is preposterous. And it's area after area that you look at, these absurd notions.
00:18:29So in other words, if you have universities that have essentially been taken over by teachers who believe this,
00:18:38by administrators who collapse before them, and by students who are prepared to use every means of coercion to enforce this,
00:18:47what is the point of somebody with an open questioning mind going there what is the point
00:18:55you've actually just said what i was about to say all the young people i know when i say young i say
00:19:00between 18 25 who i would consider to be people of real character and questioning are not going
00:19:08or have not gone that is not terrible well it is but you can no longer say yes of course you must
00:19:15I agree completely. I mean, what's happening now, of course, again, you know, let the cards be put on the table.
00:19:21There are very serious attempts now at creating new universities.
00:19:26The trouble is, where will you find the staff for these new universities?
00:19:31Unless we all just appoint ourselves, which is quite nice, but impractical.
00:19:37But, you know, figures like Neil Ferguson of that distinction are openly talking about doing this.
00:31:05And so there is that appetite. The trouble is it needs to be handled and focused properly. Otherwise, it becomes I'm thinking conservatism. It becomes sentimentalized as nostalgia. What I'm pressing for is that creative.
00:31:24Yes, yes. When it comes to the channel, how how frequent are you going to be posting?
00:31:30Today, I mean, later today, I mean, for heaven's sake, we're doing it almost as it's happening.
00:31:35We're planning to release, I think it's seven videos, of which many of them are 30, 40 minutes long.
00:31:48I'll also be doing a Q&A to begin with generally, though, as things develop, it will become a members or friend,
00:31:55The Usual Business Subscribers, Q&A, in which I will hope to engage directly.
00:32:03And some of the ones that we got, sort of from family and friends, literally, were really extraordinarily interesting.
00:32:10And I found myself talking about them, I think, rather longer than I should have done.
00:32:16But there was that, again, I think it's instructive for people to watch.
00:32:20I simply have a list of questions there, and you just respond as you go down the list.
00:32:26So there's that sense of the immediate responsiveness, the ability to recall, the ability to offer a pattern, the genuine element of the good stump speech.
00:32:39So I'm hoping people will be excited and surprised and involved.