New Culture Forum - November 01, 2021


Pause UK Immigration for 20 - 30 Years: SDP Leader William Coulston Discusses Party Policies.

EXCLUSIVE - David Starkey: Why I've Launched My Own YouTube Channel -- David Starkey Talks Cop26: Hypocritical Eco-Circus + Online Safety Bill - Widdecombe, Webb & Woberts

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

185.5

Word count

7,789

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is I'm Peter Whittle. It's been quite a while since I've
00:00:24 said this, but please do remember to subscribe. Tens of thousands of you are, I'm pleased to say.
00:00:32 It's very simple, you just go to the subscribe button on the channel and then next door to it
00:00:36 there's the notifications one. It means you get notifications of all the programs as they come up.
00:00:43 Now my guest today is the leader of a party which, if you're old enough, you would
00:00:47 remember from the 1980s. Maybe I'm being very, very unfair, but the Social Democratic Party
00:00:53 was very very much the feature of political life in the 1980s it is back um but we're about to find
00:01:00 out quite how different or how similar it is to that party um william cluston uh is the leader
00:01:08 and he has been such since 2008 he's with me now thanks very much indeed for coming and great to
00:01:14 be with you thank you yes is this something you get a lot i remember the sdp huge breakthrough it
00:01:21 seemed 1981 to 85 86 maybe yeah late 80s really um is your party the same party yes it is because
00:01:32 i know we do we're asked about it quite a lot it is because owen david owen protected its
00:01:37 independence uh refused to go into the merger with the liberals so its survival as a separate
00:01:43 social democratic party was really uh reinforced then we're now in left uh mainstream politics in
00:01:50 1990 the party was kicked to the grassroots but remember peter that a party is is a sort of
00:01:56 association isn't it and it is its members and its members kept it alive in pockets uh i often
00:02:03 say it's a bit like a bird species you know massive coverage massive impact and then it goes
00:02:08 into decline and you've got sort of pockets in east yorkshire south wales where we had counselors
00:02:12 and groups and they kept it alive and it did it actually from i mean it is actually in british
00:02:17 politics a major force because it is the biggest challenge to the two-party system that we've ever
00:02:24 had in british political history so it has we celebrated our 40th anniversary but we got very
00:02:29 small i mean membership got up to actually under 100 at one point oh really yeah yeah so these
00:02:34 things can happen but is it the same party yes same name same logo uh we've changed that a little
00:02:40 bit recently but basically yeah the same people kept it alive uh but is it the same politically
00:02:45 i mean i i think uh what is interesting uh is that it seems now to be reflecting this trend
00:02:55 which is seen in polls of people being broadly economically on the left culture on the right
00:03:00 you're quite ex explicit about this on on your website yeah what does that actually mean in
00:03:06 practice um well yeah you've linked it to the the previous to the 80s so let's go through that so
00:03:13 there are three things i would say that are exactly the same that we've kept from the 80s
00:03:17 so a commitment to electoral reform so we're still about changing that we're not happy we don't think
00:03:22 we're well governed i think it's evident that we're not well governed so that remains a commitment to
00:03:28 the social market remains which is the idea that the state and the market are not opponents they're
00:03:33 complementary parts of the same society and uh we're against vested interests i think that's
00:03:41 another thing a lot of vested interests a lot of policy that's made is made for vested interest
00:03:47 not for the whole country and that's something that we had in the 80s we have now now the thing
00:03:51 that's the two things that are different really is that we've we've sort of followed david owen
00:03:56 really in a Eurosceptic movement. I mean you know that in the 80s the SDP was very very
00:04:05 pro-EU. We've become very Eurosceptic, we argued for a no-deal situation, we campaigned to leave,
00:04:11 so very Eurosceptic. And the rest of it, the sort of cultural stuff, I think, Peter, is just a
00:04:15 reaction against rampant liberalism. So we, as a party, I think we reflect what's called post
00:04:24 liberalism you know it's i think we've economic liberalism and social liberalism combined
00:04:31 has overrun and i think we we need to to sort of pull that back so you'll see that in our policies
00:04:36 then yeah uh obviously brexit brought cultural issues before i would say the issues that were
00:04:45 absolutely there and have been there for a long long time but you know the political class seems
00:04:49 take an awfully long time to wake up to these things um what from that point of view what kind
00:04:56 of policies would reflect your attitude then to be if you could if you're culturally more center
00:05:03 right what does that amount to for example take the bbc what's your policy on the bbc well i mean
00:05:09 the official policy is to i mean i i think we have major problems everyone knows we have a major
00:05:13 problems with the bbc and some people say you know get rid of it all all together um i i think we
00:05:19 should scrap the license fee i think that's the i don't see it's an efficient tax anyway there's no
00:05:23 it doesn't make any sense uh but you need leadership at the top of the bbc that believes
00:05:27 in the country and doesn't want to knock it down all the time i think that's that's basically the
00:05:31 fundamental thing did you read you look you may not have read keir starmer's essay i had to so i
00:05:38 had to so 14 000 words a lot of it was just sort of fluff some of it we probably agree with a little
00:05:45 bit but the most disingenuous thing he said in it was that he when he accused the tories of
00:05:51 of importing an american style sort of culture war into this country and that was so disingenuous
00:05:58 given labor's obsession with id politics now that my criticism on things like the bbc and the
00:06:04 cultural stuff is that actually the largely the the Tories have been asleep or complacent and
00:06:11 they've been in government you know we're getting into sort of 12 years and on on sort of wokery
00:06:16 and woke patois and all this sort of thing a lot of Tories until quite recently said what's all
00:06:21 that about so they literally haven't been aware of what's been going on and say we have a policy
00:06:27 on our cultural section whereas if any any arts organization or gallery or public institution
00:06:33 starts editing out certain or censoring exhibits we would defund them and you've got to be much
00:06:40 harder much more committed to free speech so in terms of that you take away public money
00:06:46 in that instance what about say for example a museum or gallery national one that was basically
00:06:55 not doing what it was meant to do and take for example the british library 92 million
00:07:02 pounds worth of public um money and yet it's decolonizing everything yes would you then
00:07:09 stop the public money yeah because yes because people it's the same as the universities peter
00:07:16 people are rushing around doing all this stuff and none none of the people that are doing it
00:07:22 are feeling any consequences and until they do they they pay no price for this stuff and until
00:07:27 they pay a price until there's got to be a meeting of the of what they're doing and the consequences
00:07:32 now i don't think the government's been anywhere near as robust as it needs to be just go back to
00:07:36 starmer it just doesn't you can as a politician you can say things if they're broadly true people
00:07:41 accept it but starmer in that case was wide of the mark largely the cultural side the progressive
00:07:47 modernist side that he's from they are responsible for most of this stuff my criticism of the tories
00:07:53 that have been sort of oblivious or weak or indifferent yeah my uh feeling about tories
00:07:59 i think you sort of alluded to it though you said that they were complacent or not awake
00:08:03 um my feeling is that they have simply not understood what's been happening the extent
00:08:09 of this and indeed many of them still don't yeah i think they sort of think it's you know pc gone
00:08:15 mad almost that's that's how they see it i know many of them it's much more sinister than that
00:08:19 And it's much more, and the people that are in these institutions and putting their own people in, it's much more systematic, to use their own phrase.
00:08:28 I think the cure for this may be, Peter, because I'm an optimist, I think the cure may be that a lot of the red wall seats that they've picked up, the voters, if they're going to have a correspondence with what those voters think, they better get their act together pretty quickly.
00:08:44 because the basically what they've taken is uh labor's patriotic hinterland that's what they've
00:08:50 taken and we're accustomed in british politics to think of swings you know there's a swing to labor
00:08:56 a swing to to the tories but on on the red wall it's not a swing it's a cultural rotation the
00:09:02 type of which you say for instance you'd get in the united states in the 60s from the democrats
00:09:06 to the republics it's not coming back the red wall is not coming back to to labor so uh the
00:09:13 tories have to wake up pretty good and there's some very very good uh new tory mps that are much
00:09:18 quicker to get to the stuff so it's that that's typical in a large party there'll be a tension
00:09:22 but i agree i mean a lot of the tories the standard tory in parliament most of them are
00:09:27 economic liberals and social liberals and they'll have to work it out yeah
00:09:32 if you take an issue which straddles i would say economics and culture is immigration
00:09:40 um i was told that you had quite a radical policy for that but i i don't want to what is
00:09:46 your policy on immigration i i you know i don't want to uh you know misrepresent what it is but
00:09:51 it was i heard about a moratorium well we yeah that's something we're thinking about the the
00:09:57 the official policy on the website is just to reduce net migration to a hundred thousand which
00:10:01 is a reasonable figure uh we've got a new white paper coming out which actually sets suggests an
00:10:06 even lower number of fifty thousand now fifty thousand net was was normal yes it was normal
00:10:13 yeah until andrew nether and all the rest of in the project um i funnily enough uh peter i think
00:10:18 that the case for there's a very strong case for uh a mass immigration pause of many many years
00:10:26 and it's something we're going to talk about and and try and initiate just as an idea uh people
00:10:32 think it's it's radical no it's actually normal i mean people in the united states uh there's very
00:10:37 little immigration from 1920 to 1970 and obviously 20s and 30s coincide with the great depression
00:10:43 there's a lot of turbulence but the post-war period industrially and in terms of jobs and
00:10:48 pay and so on was the golden age very little immigration at all so i think we challenge the
00:10:53 idea that you you know mass immigration uh is is a sort of you've got to accept it why i mean you
00:10:59 know there's this 70 million people on a crowded island uh but i think that so there are cultural
00:11:05 very very strong cultural arguments for reducing immigration in terms of uh you know uh um integration
00:11:13 and social occasion those are obvious points uh we might get to know each other a little better
00:11:18 i think but strangely enough i think the really strong arguments are on the economics
00:11:23 and there I think the left-wing case for lower immigration is it just takes the palm I think
00:11:30 that's that's really what we would uh it's the prime point we'd make having it's a technical
00:11:38 thing having a massive open labor market of 450 million can only have two effects really on your
00:11:46 domestic workers it puts it applies downward pressure on wages and we've seen that uh you
00:11:51 know for the last 20 30 years and it also disincentivizes employers or government to
00:11:57 train anyone and why would you bother training anyone if you have this mass open labor market
00:12:03 so as a party we would argue for closing uh labor markets for once actually looking at your own
00:12:10 people and what do we need to do for them what do we need to do we need to train enough nurses
00:12:15 and doctors and engineers and so on we just don't do that so i think the a lot of that's already
00:12:20 happening but i think it's a very very strong case and i think you don't hear you hear every
00:12:26 time you mention immigration people always imagine it's based on culture and it is those their
00:12:31 arguments are there but actually the arguments on the economics are there as well and most working
00:12:36 people in this country can see it and it's it's one of the things that explains the uncoupling of
00:12:42 of red wall seats and red wall voters from the labor party because the labor party could never
00:12:47 make those points and won't well the extraordinary thing is there's so many of the arguments uh
00:12:53 against mass migration which are around about the time of brexit have been proved right i mean of
00:12:59 course wages have gone up and uh shortages have been exposed and you know this extraordinary just
00:13:08 you know just total ignoring of what you might call working class people uh by by the political
00:13:17 establishment you said a pause for years what are we talking about well technically i mean
00:13:23 this is where this is the problem because you can't bind the next parliament so there's a policy
00:13:26 you know you make policy theoretically for five years but what i would argue for is a long pause
00:13:31 you know 20 or 30 years of very of much lower immigration back to where we were at something
00:13:35 like 50 000 net which i think is reasonable uh and i think there would be benefits second massive
00:13:40 economic benefits from that in terms of the domestic labor situation and cultural benefits
00:13:46 too and i think that's that's you there's no good chopping and changing i think you need a little
00:13:51 bit of stability and i think culturally i mean i think david goodhart's point in his uh read
00:13:56 somewhere book i think that one of the best lines in it is where he summarized the whole situation
00:14:02 is that the the progressive left have been on immigration on mass immigration too enthusiastic
00:14:07 and on integration too indifferent i think that's got to change well you see i would say
00:14:12 my point is that it's not just simply that they think mass immigration is a very good thing
00:14:18 uh in terms of quality of life i don't think they care about that at all
00:14:23 um i i think they actually just simply want to just dilute and basically attack
00:14:30 you know the nation in a way everything that attacks the nation and they will go for yeah
00:14:36 and it's very stupid and very short-sighted because a lot of the prime thing that they're
00:14:40 forgetting is that the mutuality people have and a lot of the things the building blocks particularly
00:14:45 people on the left should understand this the building blocks the things we take for granted
00:14:49 the welfare state the national the national health service is is the foundation of that is mutual
00:14:55 solidarity within a nation state and it's a complete fantasy world to think you have the
00:15:01 solidarity that we have we can convene in a nation state beyond that we there's a line in the new
00:15:06 declaration where we say the upper limit of democracy is the nation state and that's so yeah
00:15:10 it's a major problem i think it's again i'm much more optimistic now than i was before because i
00:15:15 think a lot of the realities that we argue like as you say peter things like hdv drivers getting
00:15:22 paid better uh employers having to address training here because they can't just ship people in it's
00:15:29 this awful view of people that they're it's sort of dehumanizing idea that they're not people that
00:15:36 are rooted in a place it doesn't matter and what if we have a labor we'll just ship other people
00:15:41 in econs and just drop them in and that's i think we're finished with that and i think seriously the
00:15:46 sort of age of liberalism that we've had is closing and i think it's because a lot of the
00:15:52 realities that we talk about uh just come come hitting home you know if you if you have a lot
00:15:58 of these liberals progressives they have ideas that just don't correspond with reality it's all
00:16:03 in their own little dream but it's like the eu when it comes into contact with reality it sort of fails
00:16:10 it's a small party the sdp you obviously uh there's a lot of muffled talk at the moment
00:16:16 about parties all joining up you know because uh and we'll be talking about reform reclaim
00:16:24 a few others much smaller ones um is that something you would see as being viable for the sdp
00:16:31 our position's a little bit distinct i mean i'm not i'm not wanting to uh you know um refuse to
00:16:39 work with other small parties i will talk and we do talk with each other and we know each other
00:16:43 um but the our economics is usually the stumbling block in trying to i mean for instance if you if
00:16:49 you if you said you know do we do we agree on reform uh of the voting system yes we do are we
00:16:55 antagonistic to to work progressivism yes are we patriotic yes and so it's a lot of a lot of
00:17:02 uh common ground there and i think we should focus on that but uh on on something like you
00:17:08 know nationalization of utilities and uh nationalization of the railway system i mean
00:17:15 part of our patriotism on that is that that we should have a railway system we're proud of other
00:17:19 countries have this uh the the tories um it's not that they don't think that nation states can run
00:17:26 their railway system because actually after all the french nation state runs us the dutch nation
00:17:31 state so they they we would have on something like that peter we would have we would we would
00:17:36 nationalize the railways we would seek a royal charter and we would have royal british railways
00:17:41 from from forget scott rail from from caithness to cornwall and we'd have it as as an emblem of pride
00:17:48 and we probably build the the the rolling stock here and that's the but you know the other thing
00:17:53 is housing housing is probably the biggest issue which is affecting young people and i think the
00:17:58 only way you solve that is by the state getting back in the business of building uh social housing
00:18:03 in large numbers it's got to be combined with an immigration uh policy as well but but that again
00:18:09 you know when we argue for that i'm afraid to say corbyn is right about how social housing i mean
00:18:14 you need we need millions of new houses and the state the only way you could do it effectively
00:18:19 is for the state to put its shoulder behind that and i would argue as a social conservative that
00:18:24 is the social conservative policy because if you deny uh the chance for young people to to meet
00:18:31 get a house or a flat and raise if you're denying that you're not a social conservative you're
00:18:36 serving other uh interests so we to answer your question i'm very happy to talk and we are talking
00:18:43 uh to other parties and if we can if we together we can get a uh an electoral uh cooperation
00:18:51 system going together in the next election i'll i'll be up for that because you know but i'm not
00:18:57 but what i can't do i mean a what we can't we've survived for 40 years so you know there's no
00:19:02 there's no chance of a merger at all you wouldn't survive this long unless you're committed to it
00:19:06 but b on a on a sort of electoral program we would struggle to put one together that would
00:19:11 have any meaning if we gave all the economics away so that's but on
00:19:15 intellectual cooperation I'm keen on that I'm surprised actually when people
00:19:21 see it as a stumbling block about for example the railways I find that's a
00:19:27 very popular yeah it's happening anyway yeah I want to go back to days when we
00:19:33 were called passengers not customers yes yeah you know it annoys me that
00:19:39 something it is now somehow seen as something we should be grateful for yeah i totally agree no i
00:19:46 think they but also just the whole the the my my basic criticism a lot of conservative friends and
00:19:53 they're a great company but my basic criticism of the tory party is it's indifference it's it's
00:19:59 they think things don't matter when they do i mean they think i think it's a humiliation
00:20:04 When you come out of Newcastle Central Station, you're quite close to the old engineering shops where Stevenson built the first trains.
00:20:13 And when I see a Deutsche Bahn logo there, I just think it's slightly nationally humiliating.
00:20:19 And a sensible country wouldn't do that.
00:20:21 It's the same, Peter, on things like nuclear power.
00:20:24 A few years ago, our Conservative government was thinking about having the Chinese Communist Party effectively control part of our nuclear power.
00:20:33 i mean that's not just indifferent that's where indifference goes into negligence and stupidity
00:20:38 in my view so you've got to we've got to get some national pride back into these things
00:20:42 start doing a few things ourselves and that's why i think the sort of slightly lefty athlete
00:20:49 like sort of brexit peter shaw type brexit image is the only one that really makes sense i think
00:20:54 the world is turning in in our in our favor yes i would have thought on those sorts of issues
00:20:58 on the housing issue i mean you know when i was on the london assembly for example
00:21:03 uh housing was a massive thing uh you have to talk all the time about supply you could never
00:21:11 talk about the demand side of stuff because what that meant is you then have to start talking about
00:21:16 immigration quite well yeah you know and the population of london well it's now going down
00:21:21 because people have left but was exponentially rise and will continue to and not to be able to
00:21:27 say well one of the reasons for this of course this is huge migration obviously unprecedented
00:21:33 obviously yeah you can't know it's it but it's one of these i mean as a proponent of you've heard
00:21:38 of blue labor and philip blonde's red tory thing we're a bit like that not exactly but
00:21:42 often the solution is a combination of red and blue so on housing and immigration the solutions
00:21:47 are to be found with a blue policy which is reduce immigration significantly and a red policy which
00:21:54 get your get your state get its shoulder behind the house building take on the vested interests
00:21:59 of the the big house builds and build some houses so people can start families that is the only
00:22:04 policy that works i mean labor's policy corbyn's policy was an open door on migration and building
00:22:10 there's no point what is the point likewise the tories say they want low immigration but they
00:22:16 never do it but won't build any you know when i honestly think i again i won't be too hard on the
00:22:22 the tories but the i or despite all the anti-british rhetoric and the wokery and all the
00:22:29 all the stuff we're suffering in the moment i'm not actually sure that conservative party policy
00:22:35 on housing is more anti-social than that in aggregate because it's literally you don't
00:22:40 know the names of the people that would have been born and a lot of kids just can't have
00:22:45 can't raise families and i don't know how they can go to the electorate claiming to be conservatives
00:22:51 and and offering that and not doing the about it so i think we we can do better and we will
00:22:57 i think the point there as well as i would agree with you totally is that we have people who are
00:23:03 just free market fundamentalists quite a few around here actually who they draw a total blank
00:23:12 on any kind of what you might call today ideas of patriotism i think you more or less yeah
00:23:17 yeah totally don't they don't get it not interested it's all about the market
00:23:22 will sort it out well I'm sorry but like it won't whistle but also on just in
00:23:26 terms of I think it's because they're ready it is parallel to their social
00:23:31 liberalism because we've had 20 30 40 years of it's all about me and I think
00:23:36 that's the the point I mean we we talk a lot about the I we balance or the me us
00:23:42 balance and anyone looking at this must say we've had sufficient prioritization
00:23:47 of my rights my situation what what's in it for me it's I'm worth it it's me me
00:23:53 me all the time and we need to so you've you've got all those rights based ideas
00:23:58 and people shedding their responsibilities to others but we've
00:24:02 forgotten about duty we've forgotten and anyone looking at it seriously must get
00:24:06 back to duty so I think all of a lot of what we were saying has a very long tail
00:24:11 politically disraeli and and probably certainly post-war atli thinking and and the patriotic
00:24:18 labor thinking until about the 50s and 60s is very much what we're about and you know it has a place
00:24:24 and i think that's the solution to if you've it's simple overreach i think you know again we've we've
00:24:28 had overreach most people feel it that they want to the only way you can have meaning in life is
00:24:33 actually being committed to something other than yourself and i think that people get that
00:24:38 If we can just turn a bit to today and various events happening, recently we had the attack
00:24:48 and well the murder of Sir David Amis down in Lyon Sea. What do you make William of the
00:24:59 reaction, the political reaction to that? Well it was an appalling event and I think people
00:25:07 were shocked as they always are when these things happen but i think the
00:25:11 sadly the political reaction was predictable
00:25:14 and inadequate so after the initial shocks people start talking about
00:25:21 throwing up issues which are not directly related to what's happened so
00:25:26 they start talking about online comments or commentary
00:25:31 and so on and that's not really the cause of this
00:25:34 particular thing the cause of this thing is uh islamist ideology and frankly it would have been
00:25:41 better to if you're going to ask a question ask a question as to why we have an open border on the
00:25:49 south coast why we can have i think there's some 18 000 people have arrived unchecked undocumented
00:25:56 unvetted and that seems to be acceptable how many people you only have to look at the manchester
00:26:01 outrage that was someone that came through a migration route as a refugee so I would want a
00:26:08 little bit less throwing up of questions about what people do on Twitter and a more serious
00:26:16 approach to our border security which I think has been what I mean the set the what's happened on
00:26:20 the south coast again I think has been an outrage and people say well it's only a small proportion
00:26:26 of total migration but it's an important one because it saps people's confidence in the system
00:26:33 i think if you allow in a particularly democracy where people pay and you have this idea of
00:26:38 contribution you have you pay into a system of the welfare state and for people just to wander in
00:26:45 uh from a safe country france undocumented and the political class seems to be unable to address
00:26:52 it properly even though there's a there's a perfectly viable solution particularly now as
00:26:56 we're out of the european union which the australians have put into practice and it works
00:27:01 uh and it's not addressed so i i would say yeah desperately sad event i think the the political
00:27:07 commentary is is inadequate it is it seems to be getting more more so i think it's sort of
00:27:13 almost there's no acknowledgement now um there is amongst ordinary people yeah you know voters
00:27:21 uh but amongst the political class it's just it won't get there interesting thing was when joe
00:27:26 cox was murdered quite rightly you know there was a whole examination of what this meant
00:27:32 and the culture from which this this particular man emerged um this does not happen it's just not
00:27:39 allowed when it's uh well the the maybe i mean apart from cynicism there may be just uh one of
00:27:46 the reasons that possibly explains it is that people are just unwilling to accept what's
00:27:52 happening. I mean, people are, you know, you've got thousands of people being monitored. This
00:27:56 is a major problem in the country. And, you know, prevent doesn't seem to work. You know,
00:28:02 it does need to be working. And perhaps people would just sooner turn, turn, turn the, you know,
00:28:09 to turn another way that's that's on the other sort of huge ongoing issue that we've had uh of
00:28:16 covid do you think uh because we're hearing muffled talk about this too do you think there
00:28:24 will be a lockdown or restrictions again and if so what's your attitude i mean you're hearing this
00:28:31 yeah you can softened up well what you're what you're seeing peter is a is a dust-up between
00:28:36 the interest groups really so the people representing the nhs are arguing now and a lot
00:28:40 of the some of the people on the committees are arguing for more draconian measures but actually
00:28:45 i i may be wrong in this but i think uh my reading of the johnson government is that they're done
00:28:51 with lockdowns and i really hope that's the case i mean you know if you've if you can't take the
00:28:56 win on vaccinating uh 90 odd percent of the public uh you can't take any win i mean you know you i
00:29:04 think the broadly speaking the vaccination process is not an order of magnitude off the death rate
00:29:10 so covid is down to where a flu would be and unless you have some sort of secular change in
00:29:16 risk uh toleration which you might be i mean i hope we're not but if you are uh then then you
00:29:23 can't have lockdowns you know you've done we've done that i mean we we were we supported the
00:29:28 first lockdown it was unusual in a situation but it was hung on a particular peg to get nhs capacity
00:29:33 up and they keep changing the goalposts and after that we've been pretty implacably against lockdowns
00:29:39 because i i think for perfectly rational reasons because i don't think the government the government
00:29:44 had two committees advising them on how to smash a viral curve but they had no committee no committee
00:29:50 to advise them on the aggregate trade-off and the costs now and in the future of the
00:29:56 suppression measures they didn't even try and quantify or calculate it and i think it'll be
00:30:01 seen as a a major problem of government policy in the future when when the tail effect of the
00:30:08 death rate from the suppression measures alone will come through and i wouldn't be at all surprised
00:30:13 whether many more people have died as a result of that but that will be probably buried in the
00:30:18 future i mean do you wear a mask or would you not wear one now well i wouldn't no i mean if i was
00:30:26 asked to do in a in a very tight situation in the room I probably would
00:30:31 but I don't wear a mask on the train and you see it you know I come up and down
00:30:36 to London quite a lot and you know a couple of months ago everyone was
00:30:40 wearing masks and then it's three-hour journey Peter so you don't really want
00:30:44 to be wearing a mask if you don't have to and I think mask wearing now is about
00:30:47 30 40 percent on the on the train from you guys I'd say yeah and so that's
00:30:52 encouraging I think you know I think you only have to look at the consequences of
00:30:56 the sort of pandemic in terms of public fear to see people wearing masks in the
00:31:01 street which is a it's very sad because there's no there's no rational base to
00:31:05 do that at all but you still see it and I think so I know I think we need to get
00:31:10 back to get the offices open we're a social species we want to get back to
00:31:16 the common life don't we absolutely you still see people it's more on my way
00:31:21 here today a young guy walking along on his own no one on the huge one of these real industrial
00:31:27 masks you know I mean like you know he took he's taking very serious yes I always sort of feel
00:31:33 it's a comment on oneself when they do that you know it's almost like commenting on being
00:31:39 irresponsible or something yes you mentioned coming up and down on the train where are you
00:31:44 coming up and down from Northumberland is that where you're from yeah originally I was born in
00:31:48 Durham and uh you know went to school in North Yorkshire and then Birmingham to university and
00:31:52 I lived in London for many years yes uh Australia for a while and then went back to the northeast so
00:31:56 yeah Australia yeah what were you doing there uh well we were having I worked as a disc jockey
00:32:00 actually for a while yeah funnily enough yeah but uh no we were just waiting for our first boy to
00:32:05 be born my wife's Australian yeah so yeah we were in rural New South Wales uh most of the time did
00:32:10 a little bit of traveling and then came back yeah so you were working in a disc jockey what
00:32:13 in armadale sorry in armadale little place in new south in new south wales yeah i see uh playing
00:32:19 records yeah doing a bit of that yeah what kind of what music well well it was mainly rock and pop
00:32:26 but in the interesting thing in those days that the uh is this the 1980s it was it was sort of
00:32:31 yeah um 90 92 93 yeah but they the australian government had a a rule that you had to play a
00:32:41 certain percentage of australian really yeah see and the kiwis were involved as well yeah so in
00:32:46 getting the schedule of music we'd play uh you had to you had to you know you'd play split ends
00:32:52 crowded house you know whatever you had to play australian bands ac dc and and if you didn't play
00:32:57 20 you're in trouble it's what it's a bit like the french you know how the french yes exactly
00:33:02 these cultural things so it was interesting getting that right you could squeeze people
00:33:05 and say oh that's just about australia so i suppose zz top they were just before yeah
00:33:13 i didn't do it for a long time but it was it was good it was and it was a very fond memories and
00:33:17 of course our first born was born there and all i have three boys and they're all sort of
00:33:22 being an anglo-australian family is part of our culture and we sort of go back and forth a little
00:33:26 bit so if your wife's australian what what's her view indeed your view on what what's happening
00:33:34 in australia it you know it's extraordinary you just wouldn't think some things of certain countries
00:33:41 i i couldn't have imagined that australia would have reacted to the whole pandemic in a way it
00:33:47 seems to have done it's a strange it's a really strange thing because it's you know it's like the
00:33:51 first shall be last and the last should be first so the countries i mean new zealand and australia
00:33:56 were praised weren't they for this ultra to some extent that was that's i could follow it because
00:34:03 they had hardly any cases in their islands i mean you know australia became an autarky didn't
00:34:09 effectively uh you know and uh my wife actually had to go back and quarantine so we've had family
00:34:14 members quarantine twice in in australia um the the level of draconianism actually doesn't
00:34:21 surprise me that much the there was a there was a creeping the state's very rich they're one of the
00:34:28 countries that had uh you know economic growth without any recession for the best part of 30
00:34:34 years so the state gets quite big and it gets quite bossy uh you know so mandatory bicycle
00:34:40 helmet wearing things like that were were part of what the state was doing in australia so in a
00:34:46 sense it doesn't surprise me that much it disappoints me and i think i think let's hope
00:34:51 that they will uh you know eventually just buck up and realize it jab the jab the population and
00:34:57 open up but it does it is a warning because if you it's almost the the the the less you're affected
00:35:03 by something the more you're worried about it yes that's the strange thing about the australian
00:35:08 example where you just you just lose the ability to act normally so i'm crossing my fingers you
00:35:14 know when was the last time you were there though i was there about five years ago but but um my
00:35:18 wife goes goes back and forth a little bit more often um but yeah i mean it's got to come back
00:35:23 it but it is it's been an interesting one yeah after the uh being a disc jockey what what was
00:35:29 your work i mean well i was i was i was i did i wanted to do philosophy as a degree when i was 18
00:35:35 and and uh probably correctly i didn't do that i did town planning so i i i trained as a did
00:35:42 planning degree in birmingham i came down and worked for the city of westminster that was my
00:35:45 first job and it's actually around this patch so uh you know you're doing development control i did
00:35:50 about 350 uh cases and so a lot of around here i i've has my name on it approving or refusing
00:35:57 planning permissions uh and then i switched and did surveying uh and then got into building uh
00:36:04 some housing but mainly commercial uh uh development so i did that for the best part of
00:36:09 25 years so have you always been political during that time i i was i was my father was in the labor
00:36:14 party and he was a founder member of the sdp so he yeah he um he he that i was sort of in the blood
00:36:21 really i mean the whole of the 80s thing i was an active social democrat uh and then when it faded
00:36:26 away i i was out of politics for many years but but a friend got me back into it uh uh who's mayor
00:36:32 of hexam actually um where i close to where i lived and said you should get involved with the
00:36:35 tories and i said well not really a tory i'm more a social democrat and he says it doesn't matter
00:36:39 william he said as long as you've got regular features and clean fingernails will have you
00:36:43 so it's a difficult attitude but anyway so i was i was a i was a tory for four years uh became a
00:36:50 councillor and i was um i stood for parliament in the keep the pound election in 2001 you know the
00:36:56 the uh under william haig's leadership uh in northwest staram and and it was good experience
00:37:01 but i wasn't i was never really comfortable being in the tory party my economics are too
00:37:06 a two left wing really for for the tories i made a lot of friends and and and i learned
00:37:11 it was very useful for me actually i learned a lot about the tory party
00:37:15 being in it but i was never i think four years was was sufficient
00:37:19 you know you you mentioned earlier about being
00:37:22 having something that you care about which is outside of yourself
00:37:28 you know i think many of us in politics in politics i put it like that rather
00:37:33 grandly but uh you know i suppose we would say it's
00:37:36 politics but what what do you care about outside of
00:37:39 politics are you are you a man of faith i'm not i'm a churchgoer but i'm not a believer
00:37:44 um and my wife's a roman catholic who's elapsed as well so it's an
00:37:49 and you're still a church but you don't you i'm not a believer no i'm i'm a my sort of faith
00:37:55 system is epicurean really i'm i'm i'm i went back to university to do to read policy to read
00:38:02 philosophy later and philosophy is a a big part of my life and it is a passion and yeah so I was
00:38:10 glad I sort of did what I wanted to do at 18 in the end I always remember George Mellie the jazz
00:38:17 it's one of my favorite quotes of all George Mellie was was next to his father and his father
00:38:22 was on his deathbed and he said have you got any advice for me and his father said yes do what do
00:38:27 what you want i never did which i think within reason is is is very good advice um so yeah
00:38:34 philosophy is is a is a is a big part but would you call yourself then a cultural christian is
00:38:39 that yes oh absolutely yes totally yes no i i as i say i mean i think a congregation uh and often i
00:38:46 go on my own i mean northumberland has we have wonderful churches and i on a sunday morning i
00:38:50 generally cycle and i have a few favorites that i go and and just spend some time in but normally
00:38:56 a congregation is full of people not everyone believes not everyone can
00:39:00 believe and some people I think it was Cameron who quite cleverly said you know
00:39:04 what about your faith and he said it was a bit like the reception on come row
00:39:09 which radio station is comes and it goes no but a lot of people are like that I
00:39:12 don't think I can believe but I think we we've lost something profound I think I
00:39:17 think it wasn't all about belief it was about belonging yes and I think we need
00:39:22 to we need to find that somewhere so and interestingly a lot of young social democrats
00:39:28 particularly the young social democrats i started a lot of them are starting to go back to church
00:39:33 have an interest in roman catholicism and things you know so they they perhaps there's a yearning
00:39:37 perhaps this generation z is much more uh for social conservatives is much more promising than
00:39:44 the millennials so we'll see what happens it's interesting one hears these discussions an awful
00:39:48 lot now about religion you know the role it should play um we're recording this the end of this week
00:39:57 november 6th um you uh have your conference uh now you've got some good speakers can you tell us
00:40:07 who's coming to your conference yeah uh so we've got uh david starkey speaking he's opening up in
00:40:11 the morning uh and then we've got uh frank furady uh i'll i'll it's very interesting figure frank
00:40:18 uh interesting sociologists always worth listening to uh i'll speak after lunch then we've got claire
00:40:23 fox patrick o'flynn will be speaking uh rod little interestingly will be comparing oh right yeah well
00:40:29 he's a master he is in the yes he particularly asked so every everyone's speech will be marked
00:40:34 on his card we've got lionel shriver uh muhammad abasi is coming along he's uh director of the
00:40:39 association of british muslims and so yeah it's it's it's uh it sounds quite a cerebral gathering
00:40:46 eric kauffman as well yes it is it is uh that i think it's the streak in the sdp which i'm happy
00:40:52 with i mean some people say we're we're perhaps not as strong on the on the sort of retail end
00:40:57 of politics but i i think one what the thing that we've done rightly i think is get the foundations
00:41:03 of what we believe sorted out you know think about what you believe and that's why we did the new
00:41:08 declaration and that's why you know things like the green the new green paper the end of difference
00:41:14 is very important because you know take time think about things carefully and put out quality
00:41:20 uh stuff and that's basically what the sdp is is trying to do well that's great
00:41:26 can do you have to be a member to come um you do unless you get on my guest list
00:41:33 i'll leave that up to people to wear that one out but um well look i hope it goes well and
00:41:38 thank you very kindly and um thanks very much indeed for for coming on real pleasure thank
00:41:44 you um that's it for this week we shall see you next time and uh take care thank you bye