New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.01: JOKER (2019) -- Right wing "Incel" Incitement or Left Wing Social Moralising?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

181.96

Word count

5,898

Sentence count

183


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello I'm Peter Whitlaw and I'd like to welcome you to the very first edition of this new weekly
00:00:13 discussion show produced by the new culture forum counterculture will over the coming weeks have a
00:00:19 panel of people talking about first of all all the new things that are happening in our culture
00:00:25 whether it is films or books or TV drama or music, right up to the big philosophical questions which
00:00:33 are preoccupying us and which in some ways now obviously are shaping our culture itself.
00:00:40 Now today we're going to be starting by looking at a film which is pretty much the biggest one
00:00:45 out there at the moment. Joker is directed by Todd Phillips. It stars Joaquin Phoenix as
00:00:52 batman's most famous opponent it's quite controversial depending on which part of the
00:00:58 political spectrum you come from but it's been hugely successful and made something like a
00:01:03 billion dollars at the international box office now i've got four people to discuss it with me
00:01:11 today they're all film fans first of all there's anishka korek from the passion for freedom
00:01:18 Festival in London. She's the co-founder of that. Mark Sidwell, who is deputy editor of Smith
00:01:23 magazine. Rafe Hadle-Manku, who's an historian and commentator. And Richard Bingley, security
00:01:30 analyst and author. So before we start getting each other's throats about this, let's just
00:01:38 quickly take a look at a clip from the film. Arthur, does it help to have someone to talk to?
00:01:48 My mother always tells me to smile and put on a happy face.
00:02:03 She told me I had a purpose.
00:02:07 To bring laughter and joy to the world.
00:02:13 Fuck! Fuck!
00:02:18 Is it just me?
00:02:22 Or is it getting crazier out there?
00:02:24 Smile, though your heart is aching
00:02:30 Smile, even though it's breaking
00:02:34 When there are clouds in the sky
00:02:40 You'll get by
00:02:42 What?
00:02:43 If you smile to your fear and sorrow
00:02:48 Smile, and maybe tomorrow
00:02:52 What's so funny?
00:03:03 Creech!
00:03:12 Gotham's lost its way.
00:03:16 What kind of coward would do something that cold-blooded?
00:03:20 Someone who hides behind a mask.
00:03:22 I used to think that my life was a tragedy, but now I realize it's a comedy.
00:03:52 If you'll just smile.
00:04:05 Let's start with you, actually.
00:04:07 This movie's taken, as I said, a billion.
00:04:10 Why?
00:04:11 Well, I think, really, it hasn't been a misfortune for it
00:04:16 to have received so much controversial criticism from the left.
00:04:19 So, basically, what we've seen is
00:04:21 A lot of people from the right have gone to see it simply because it's annoyed the left so much.
00:04:26 So you've got dedicated movie lovers who I think could quite genuinely say it is the best film
00:04:34 for an artistic display of senseless violence since Clockwork Orange.
00:04:40 Some are calling it a masterpiece.
00:04:41 I would say it's a masterpiece in terms of tone.
00:04:44 It captures that perfectly.
00:04:45 and certainly you've got one of the greatest performances
00:04:50 certainly of 2019 there
00:04:52 and so I think basically it's really achieved something
00:04:56 which we've wanted for a long time
00:04:58 which was to have a real movie back in the cinemas
00:05:00 and what Phillips has done here
00:05:02 is he's managed to sneak in a real movie
00:05:04 under the guise of a super comic hero movie
00:05:09 thereby getting through the movie system
00:05:12 that prevents that going through normally.
00:05:14 I mean that is a very good point
00:05:15 because we should make the point
00:05:16 this is not, it's about the Joker
00:05:19 you know, Batman's
00:05:20 nemesis, or not quite his nemesis
00:05:22 but at the same time it's not a
00:05:25 superhero, it's not full
00:05:27 of CGI or anything is it Mark?
00:05:28 No, no, no, it's very different to all of those
00:05:30 I think what I would say about why it's made the money
00:05:32 and something that worries me rather more
00:05:34 about the film than I think does Rafe is
00:05:36 it's a film that repeatedly refuses
00:05:39 to take sides on lots of questions within
00:05:41 the film and as to who's a hero
00:05:43 who's a villain, as to what's really
00:05:45 happened and what's happened in history, what's really going on is Joker's girlfriend or not,
00:05:50 things like that. And crucially, at the heart of it, this is a film that really doesn't want to
00:05:54 entirely say that Joker's a villain. And I have a problem with that. I find that distasteful,
00:06:00 morally insane in some ways. He's very stylish, he's very cool, and people are responding to that.
00:06:05 Part of the reason it's done so well globally is partly, you know, like the protesters in Chile
00:06:10 have started wearing Joker face paint. There are people who do see him as an exciting sort of
00:06:14 heroic figure and I think that's, you know, that's a problem.
00:06:17 Would you see Richard III as a heroic figure? Because really, what we're doing is we're
00:06:22 seeing them through their own eyes and through their own pain that's been caused through
00:06:26 it but in no way are they being idolised, I would say.
00:06:29 Well, you know, I disagree. When Richard III, you know, goes through a complete destruction
00:06:34 at the end of the play, it's a tragedy. And as Joker says in this film, this is not a
00:06:39 tragedy after all, it's a comedy. And he discovers who he is, he finds his best self and he becomes
00:06:44 incredibly cool and stylish as a psychotic murderous clown and people enjoy that that
00:06:49 moment when he dances down the steps is already an iconic moment people love it did you find it
00:06:56 cool i mean did you did you find that you were sympathetic to him i found it very painful to
00:07:03 watch and i think the reason i found it painful um is watching someone suffer so much and and
00:07:10 and the world not taking notice or actually taking pleasure in causing suffering to someone else
00:07:16 and then this dystopian society where actually i could see the mirror images of the world we
00:07:21 live in now where people are so alienated and and separated and everyone is just rushing from work
00:07:28 home and and quite a lot of people are even alienated at home so it was a painful watch
00:07:34 because of the suffering of the of the main character and you know i'm not saying whether
00:07:38 I sympathize with his illness or not but just seeing that suffering and
00:07:42 recognizing how difficult it is and then just seeing the the reflection of what's
00:07:48 happening around us now do you think I mean would you say that's why it's had
00:07:53 this resonance that it's picking I mean he says at one point in the film doesn't
00:07:57 he is it me or is it just getting crazier out there I think the whole film
00:08:02 resonates because on two fronts I mean the first thing is what Ruth said is
00:08:06 it's just a proper movie you know we're just not getting proper movies coming
00:08:10 through from Hollywood at the moment. The second thing is that it is a
00:08:15 psychological thriller whether you like it or not and it does show quite a lot
00:08:20 of graphic violent scenes I think it ducks one scene actually they actually
00:08:24 duck the issue of whether they kill the girlfriend whether it's his girlfriend
00:08:28 or not. It's an interesting issue to duck but nonetheless it was it was
00:08:34 brutal it was violent um i mean i've i've been in quite sort of difficult protest situations when
00:08:40 i was a young journalist you know sort of the g8 protest the black block type of things the the
00:08:45 actual cinematography was quite accurate to that so so i'd kind of contest your point a little bit
00:08:50 in that i think it was a criticism of violence because it was pretty accurate and and the best
00:08:55 way to criticize violence is actually show it how it is and i think that's what that film did
00:08:59 it's interesting when you look at those demos i think you made a point actually before we came
00:09:04 they are all men, aren't they?
00:09:08 I also had another point to add that I think on the point that you made about
00:09:12 we haven't had a good movie in the cinema for a very long time
00:09:16 I think what I'm missing in the cinema at the moment is that everything is so designed
00:09:20 for you to take sides and never recognise yourself in the character
00:09:24 I think the good movies where you have this point that you're wondering
00:09:28 would I be able to do this? Would I get to this point if I was really pushed?
00:09:32 And you start to doubt yourself and you're really checking your history and thinking about the future and your decision making and so on.
00:09:38 And the movie that made me think and feel so much a few years ago was an Israeli movie that I've seen in the cinema during the festival where it was about a terror attack in the center of one of the cities in Israel.
00:09:52 And the policeman was looking for his little boy. And people were trying to get into the hospital to get cured. But then the terrorist was being rescued.
00:10:01 And then there was the dilemma, would you put your child first to get cured or would you want the terrorist to be saved?
00:10:07 So in this movie there is this moment where you're also wondering, could I be pushed to this extreme with all the circumstances around me?
00:10:13 I saw it massively as a criticism of political violence, whether it's left or right.
00:10:19 You know, he kind of made the point early on in the film about when the joker was attacked, you know, sort of coming home from work by those guys that worked for the Wayne Company, the Wayne Corporation.
00:10:29 That was kind of an allusion to maybe far-rights, you know, homophobic, that type of violence.
00:10:36 But then later on, on the scenes where he's in the city centre
00:10:41 and you've got sort of the left-wing type protesters,
00:10:45 you know, it was kind of almost in alignment with what we're seeing with climate exchange,
00:10:48 that kind of scenery.
00:10:51 But again, he was showing the brute force of it.
00:10:53 I don't think he was saying the Joker character was right
00:10:56 or he was saying that one particular side was right.
00:10:58 I think he was just saying kind of a plague on all your houses.
00:11:01 If you are supporting violent politics, this is what it leads to in many ways.
00:11:06 I think that's a generous reading.
00:11:07 I mean, I agree with you.
00:11:08 He doesn't want to take sides,
00:11:10 and that's why some of the critics from the left or the right
00:11:12 have had a problem with the film.
00:11:13 They wanted to come down and be a parable,
00:11:15 and maybe that's the problem I'm having with it too.
00:11:17 But what he does to the violence that Joker commits,
00:11:19 as you point out, talking about they don't show
00:11:21 whether or not he really murdered the woman he wished was his girlfriend,
00:11:24 that he stalks.
00:11:26 All the people he actually does murder,
00:11:27 you could kind of say deserve it.
00:11:29 They at least did something to really screw up his life.
00:11:32 He doesn't kill the guy who's with the guy who gave him the gun,
00:11:36 but he does, you know, and he gets the police killed
00:11:40 who were causing him trouble and killed his mother,
00:11:42 and his mother did terrible things to him.
00:11:44 And they very deliberately do that
00:11:46 so that you could kind of sympathise with everyone he killed.
00:11:48 I wanted to see the nihilistic, pitiless violence
00:11:52 against people who don't deserve it
00:11:53 that is what Joker is all about,
00:11:55 which you get elsewhere in the Joker mythos.
00:11:57 I think they needed that in this film, but they chose not to do that.
00:12:00 I think that just makes it even more successful as a movie,
00:12:04 but it makes it very troubling, and I'm uncomfortable with that.
00:12:06 But I think that was deliberate.
00:12:08 Firstly, all those who criticise the film as being a right-wing film,
00:12:12 what you've just said is the only example of how you could see a right-wing person
00:12:16 saying this is a right-wing film because here you have an evil protagonist
00:12:20 who is essentially killing bankers, which we're supposed to sympathise with,
00:12:25 and who is trying to overthrow civil society
00:12:28 and overthrow, basically, the rich 1%.
00:12:31 But apart from that, what do you have?
00:12:33 You've got issues of mental health care cuts being made.
00:12:35 You've got the plight of this man being badly treated by society.
00:12:39 Everything in there, to me, is about one man's struggle
00:12:42 and about a failing society, failing to help that person,
00:12:46 which is very, very much a left-wing view.
00:12:48 But I would also say that you're assuming that Joker committed any violence at all.
00:12:53 because if you look really into the subtext there
00:12:56 is this not just actually showing him as a truly tragic figure
00:13:00 where all this happens in his mind
00:13:02 and you see that at the end of the film
00:13:03 where the asylum in which he's been kept for so long
00:13:06 which we see it being dirty and with madmen in the lifts
00:13:10 and really looking as if it was during our time in the 70s
00:13:13 when he had rubbish piling up
00:13:14 but then at the end it's a pristine asylum
00:13:16 when he runs with bloodied footprints
00:13:19 thereby suggesting actually that this has all happened inside the asylum
00:13:22 and he sighs his mind and actually
00:13:24 he simply is a pathetic character who in his
00:13:27 mind has created himself into this hero.
00:13:29 Although, I mean, that's very true, it's kind of
00:13:30 dreamy, isn't it? Because the therapist at the end
00:13:33 is the same woman, isn't it? But she's
00:13:34 beautifully made up, it's kind of slightly
00:13:36 stylised, but that's a cop-out, isn't it?
00:13:39 I was going to say, that is what dented
00:13:41 the movie for me. I thought it was a terrific movie
00:13:43 and then in the end, they kind of
00:13:45 the last three minutes was, oh, by the way
00:13:47 I was asleep all the time, you know, so kind of like
00:13:49 this book is like a dream
00:13:50 But that's just the very worst thing.
00:13:52 Was he really asleep?
00:13:54 By the way, from the very outset we saw that
00:13:57 when we had him being inside the taping of the programme,
00:14:02 clearly that was his fantasy, the girl was a fantasy.
00:14:05 I think all through it you had this narrative being there as a potential outcome.
00:14:09 Also on the artistic side we could maybe look into whether,
00:14:13 looking at the images and how they've been composed,
00:14:16 everything where it's dark and difficult and painful it's dark and and even you
00:14:22 know the way this the scenes are shot and how it's all composed then when he's
00:14:26 in the spotlight when he gets this the the fame everything becomes so vivid so
00:14:31 colorful so then you would also think isn't it really in his mind because this
00:14:35 is how we did when you feel depressed things everything becomes very gray and
00:14:39 and the same and equal and then when you have this idea that you're just going
00:14:44 to shine and show everyone your true self then it all turns into this kind of
00:14:48 kaleidoscope of colors and him dancing on the stairs where before he was just
00:14:53 going up slowly up. That's such a very good point sorry because I did actually
00:14:58 watch it the second time just to brush up on it and he actually twice he
00:15:04 mentioned his medication and towards the end of the film she said we're going to
00:15:07 this is going to be the last time you're going to see me and we can't renew your
00:15:11 prescriptions which meant that during that last period when he basically came
00:15:15 out of his shell and became his true self as you know for many mental health
00:15:19 sufferers suddenly they think this is the real me I've thrown off with the drugs
00:15:23 and that's when he goes on to that killing spirit the thing is that the
00:15:26 basic political divide seems to be that you can I think you can read it either
00:15:31 way in the sense that you know the demonstrators with the clown masks they
00:15:35 could easily be those you know those what are they called now you know the
00:15:38 Guy Fawkes masks, you know, those demonstrators, basically anarchists, you know, eat the rich
00:15:43 and all the rest of it. On the other hand, you know, you've got this sort of thing whereby
00:15:48 people are saying, oh, but this is going to inspire these young men. Is it called incels?
00:15:55 Do you think movies actually really do make people go out and do bad things?
00:16:03 I think it's highly unusual. You know, there's a number of academic studies around this,
00:16:07 but usually what the studies show is that there was a kind of a mental health issue in the first
00:16:13 place because simply we wouldn't be able to watch any images you know without turning into that
00:16:17 image so I don't really buy that but ultimately when you sort of look at the background of the
00:16:25 director and you look at the way that film was shot I kind of can't see any bias one way or the
00:16:30 other I just think it was quite a strong argument against political violence it was interesting when
00:16:36 you talk about brightness I from my memory of that movie the only bright
00:16:40 scene before the end was actually when he was suffocating his mother that
00:16:43 hospital room was really bright and it was the nicest room in the movie for two
00:16:48 hours but but other than that I when you look back at Todd Phillips's
00:16:53 background it's usually been kind of laddie comedy you know he did sort of
00:16:57 the hangover he's been criticized on Twitter a few times for sort of being
00:17:04 too comedic or being insensitive you know I'm not gonna say there were nice
00:17:09 politically incorrect jokes in there but certainly he delivered a couple of
00:17:14 politically incorrect jokes he didn't give you to the Nazi people though yeah
00:17:18 absolutely but but I mean at the moment we're seeing Hollywood censoring itself
00:17:22 all the time it doesn't quite make the final leap I mean there's been a kind of
00:17:26 a sense of humor bypass I think from Hollywood for the last couple of years
00:17:29 you know it's all been about trying to generate tears not not not laughter
00:17:33 Well, that's why Philip said famously that he left comedy because, as he said, woke culture killed comedy.
00:17:38 That's it.
00:17:39 Yeah, and this is definitely not a woke film in any sense.
00:17:42 As we're saying, it refuses really to take sides to the point of a fault, from my perspective,
00:17:47 but certainly it's not going to line up and tick the boxes on some woke checklist.
00:17:52 Absolutely, and I think along with the fear that the left have that this is going to incite incel activists,
00:17:56 you also had the point that there was no moral message,
00:17:59 but also there were no people of colour who were being suppressed,
00:18:04 there were no gays in there, any of the checkboxes weren't there.
00:18:07 That, I think, was another source of grievance from the left.
00:18:10 When you say that Hollywood's lost its sense of humour,
00:18:15 you could also say that Hollywood's lost its sense of being an adult.
00:18:19 Because I actually felt this was quite an adult film.
00:18:22 You made the point earlier, Anish,
00:18:24 that basically we're used to these kind of superhero films.
00:18:27 this is a superhero film but it's not at all really is it i mean we're used now to this
00:18:33 mainstream of hollywood is in fact all about marvel comics is it not i don't know it feels
00:18:38 like tube feeding it feels like tube feeding like you don't really eat real food where you can taste
00:18:45 the actual components the ingredients of the food and then decide whether you like it or not
00:18:49 or it's interesting composition it's just tube feeding you're just supposed to eat it and that's
00:18:53 It shows you what's possible to see something like this, but also it's not the only example.
00:18:59 So Logan a couple of years ago, I don't know if anyone saw that, fabulous movie, better
00:19:02 than this I think, much more clever and sophisticated, morally complicated without taking this sort
00:19:08 of very odd position towards the villain, dealing with some very dark things but also
00:19:12 hugely entertaining.
00:19:14 And it doesn't have to be that these superhero things can't be sort of fun and silly and
00:19:20 but also quite deep.
00:19:21 I mean, the Batman the Animated Series, which is kind of old now on his TV, that's amazingly
00:19:26 good.
00:19:27 That has this fabulous, really dysfunctional, emotionally abusive relationship between Joker
00:19:32 and his girlfriend.
00:19:33 It's the sort of stuff you don't get in this one.
00:19:36 So it's not the fact that it's superhero movies, and it can be done, but a lot of it
00:19:41 has become just for children and not sophisticated enough, except I suppose Pixar and things
00:19:45 like that.
00:19:46 I sort of understand it in the sense that when you have Netflix and so much opportunity
00:19:49 to watch those quieter films at home it's the big blockbusters that you want to have the surround
00:19:55 sound and the lights and everything else on the big screen and just the same way i have a similar
00:19:58 agreements with with the theater where you see so much of the stuff that you see now is just
00:20:02 musicals bringing together the top 10 hits or whatever band from the 50s and 60s and that sells
00:20:07 out it's getting a bit better now with a few more proper plays coming in but it's a similar phenomenon
00:20:13 without wishing to sound too much like mary whitehouse for for younger viewers that was
00:20:17 was someone who really didn't like smut on television or the rest of it this is a
00:20:21 certificate 15 I mean to me it was people saying oh it's a shockingly
00:20:28 violent film I've seen more violent but even so do you think 15 I mean that seems
00:20:33 like I think on the psychological level it's a bit too low not not even the
00:20:38 violence just psychology just it's R rated in the US I was surprised it was
00:20:42 15 when I saw it at the front of the film I think it's fully justified just on
00:20:46 But should nobody be hired?
00:20:48 Yeah, so you know when you've got people being stabbed in the eye and that kind of thing,
00:20:52 I'm not quite sure it was an 18, but certainly quite a lot of the sexual context in there,
00:20:59 quite a lot of, I mean there were about eight severely, severe scenes of violence.
00:21:05 But you know, let's sort of reflect, when you compare this, I mean I watch a lot of Eastern European cinema
00:21:11 and that that is brutally violent but it often sticks straight to the historical
00:21:17 script but you wouldn't argue that that's necessarily an 18 I wouldn't
00:21:22 argue that Joker was an 18 I think we've all become too soft and sensitive you
00:21:26 know in in the old days it was very clear what an 18 movie would be these
00:21:30 days if there's a little smattering of swear words and one scene of sexual
00:21:35 violence then people immediately want to put racket up to 18 and I think we've
00:21:38 become a very puritanical audience actually in the West and once you see
00:21:42 what video games they're playing at home I think do you think I mean this is
00:21:48 political okay we might think you can read it you can read it either way what
00:21:54 we hear from Hollywood now is just basically a lot of liberal messaging I
00:21:58 think you'd agree whatever your views it's just like the actor after Robert
00:22:02 De Niro is in this movie and he's you know he goes on the stage and just says
00:22:07 There's F you, President Trump, and all the rest of it.
00:22:09 We hear it all the time.
00:22:11 It's a liberal place.
00:22:13 But, I mean, do you think mainstream Hollywood films,
00:22:18 Marvel or not, are basically liberal in their general principles,
00:22:24 or are they right-wing, or is it the wrong way to read it?
00:22:28 I mean, what would you say would be a conservative film, for example, Mark?
00:22:33 Well, I mentioned Logan, the other.
00:22:37 I mean, conservative film, I don't know, what is that?
00:22:40 I mean, none of us really want to go, even me doesn't want to go
00:22:42 and listen to some sort of lecture about principles that I agree with.
00:22:45 And Logan, I think, is a film that takes human nature seriously.
00:22:49 There's a very adult, engaged film.
00:22:51 It doesn't offer cheap, you know, moralising lectures from the left.
00:22:57 That's a sort of non-woke film that I would definitely consider,
00:23:01 if not conservatively, something a conservative can watch
00:23:03 without wanting to punch the screen.
00:23:05 I have to confess that foreign
00:23:09 made movies make my day
00:23:10 because at the moment anything that comes out of
00:23:13 America is just boring, I'm sorry
00:23:15 and not to mention Netflix
00:23:18 where it's just, I remember I watched a few
00:23:20 series because it's just easy watch, you know
00:23:22 you are at home, you just have this half an hour, let's just watch
00:23:25 something, I was appalled
00:23:26 how they just shoving things
00:23:29 up into your eyes
00:23:31 and your ears that you should swallow
00:23:32 and just agree that this is, yes, this is a great
00:23:34 cultural progress and yes but there's a there's a political reality here i mean there's uh studies
00:23:41 that show last time's election you know hillary clinton got three out of four votes in hollywood
00:23:46 hills county right the same in los angeles county of the 86 million dollars given by the theater
00:23:53 industry and cinema industry to politics to the presidential candidates in 2016 uh for every five
00:24:01 dollars for when the Hillary campaign. So it's indisputable that Hollywood is
00:24:07 kind of soaked in left-leaning politics. That's not a surprise. I think that's
00:24:13 always been the case. You know, you've got strong acting unions there. Actors
00:24:17 choose to live in New York or choose to live in Los Angeles, California, right?
00:24:22 What Hollywood is struggling to realize is that in this international
00:24:27 world there are now viable alternatives you know there is not any longer sort of
00:24:33 propaganda coming out of the East you know there's a Chinese cinema scene
00:24:37 that's pretty healthy there's a Russian there's Czech there's Polish
00:24:42 are they quite political you know because you talked about before about Czech cinema
00:24:46 and are they quite no I mean they're buoyant because they're not they're
00:24:51 buoyant because they're fact driven you know they don't go into identity
00:24:55 politics they stick with what's kind of happening at a street level whether it's
00:24:59 in a police department or whether it's in an art gallery and I think Hollywood
00:25:02 can learn from this. At the moment it's kind of some self-wallowing bubble
00:25:07 that's irrelevant to most of its audience. Exactly I think it's very
00:25:11 important because there are two distinctions here there's having a
00:25:13 left-wing bias or being of a liberal persuasion and then there's trying to
00:25:16 force your opinions and your morality and have morality tales through the
00:25:20 movies that you're doing and I mean if you look at Jonathan Haidt and other
00:25:24 psychologists, it's quite clear that people who are creative tend to be more
00:25:27 liberal because they're open to new ideas. People who are more administrative
00:25:30 and business-minded tend to be more conservative and you need to have a good
00:25:33 balance of both in society. So it's no surprise that wherever you go in the
00:25:37 world, look at the Weimar Republic. Artists tend to be on the liberal side,
00:25:40 not exclusively obviously, but there's just an obvious leaning towards that
00:25:44 side. So that's expected, but if you look for example at the Joker, it won the
00:25:48 Venice Film Prize and only became controversial in America afterwards. Why
00:25:53 is that? Well it's the same reason, again I'll quote Johnson Height on this I've been reading.
00:25:57 He's the guy who wrote The Righteous Mind. The Righteous Mind and also The Coddling
00:26:00 of the American Mind. And he said that what we see now in university campuses was no platforming
00:26:04 and the work movement. It's an anglosphere phenomenon. You don't get it elsewhere,
00:26:09 primarily the UK, Canada and America. And so it's basically something in our culture specifically
00:26:17 that tries to have now in the last 15 years this issue of identity politics. And so I think that's
00:26:21 what we're seeing here that's why foreign films are so far free from that i think it's interesting
00:26:26 because just this week we're recording this on a friday this today a christmas film is
00:26:31 opening called last christmas which is just a rom-com but apparently they have managed to put
00:26:36 into it just about every woke you know trope of the moment and there's even some anti-brexit stuff
00:26:42 and there's xenophobia but it's just it's just a rom-com it just reminds me of soviet times and
00:26:48 than what we were forced to watch in Poland.
00:26:52 I think, is there a problem?
00:26:54 Do you think there is a real danger, though,
00:26:59 that if actors come out with all the stuff that they do,
00:27:02 that they are actually eventually going to kill the goose
00:27:05 that laid the golden egg?
00:27:06 Aren't they actually going to, you know, there's this saying now,
00:27:09 is it get woke, go broke?
00:27:13 Do you think that this is a real danger?
00:27:15 Is it something we should, you know, consider?
00:27:17 I mean, these industries will in the end follow the money if someone works out how to find
00:27:21 it. And Joker is a fascinating example of that. It didn't make money in the US and maybe
00:27:25 partly there's woke things going on there. I mean, it did all right in the US, but it's
00:27:28 the global box office that really showed you could make money. And, you know, these companies
00:27:33 will in the end start to realise if they see the dollar signs that they can go down that
00:27:38 road and take a less prescriptive point of view, maybe. Maybe the foreign market will
00:27:43 I mean what's interesting about all of this is actually when you look at the
00:27:48 business side of Hollywood it's still quite vibrant you know it did have a
00:27:54 couple of bad years until last year and then the last financial year has been as
00:27:59 strong as it's ever been there's a number of variables it might be that
00:28:04 the economy is in recession and people can't afford the cinema tickets you know
00:28:09 it might be that you're just simply
00:28:12 manufacturing too many sequels
00:28:14 people are sick of sequels
00:28:16 unless it's a toy story or something
00:28:18 so I think it's too early to tell
00:28:20 but one thing's clear
00:28:22 is that certainly the competition
00:28:24 will be stronger
00:28:25 they might well do this
00:28:27 and do the woke rom-com
00:28:30 but can they keep getting away with it
00:28:33 and I don't think it's sustainable
00:28:34 because it comes back to what we said at the start of the show
00:28:36 Joker was the first
00:28:39 decent movie we could just go and sit there and watch it with a pack of
00:28:43 Smarties and a Coke you know and just just switch off a bit. I just think
00:28:47 there's a danger possibly that what I meant really was that these actors
00:28:51 they like virtually pick anyone you want right they go on about deplorables and
00:28:55 they go on about jump and all that eventually people will stop saying well
00:28:59 actually you know why should I pay why should I pay my money to see you if you
00:29:03 think I'm so despicable why should I pay my money to see it? I've only got a few minutes left so I
00:29:09 just uh I want to see you know I asked you if it is a good film I said a right-wing or a left-wing
00:29:15 conservative film and you put me down on that one more so what would you suggest can you come up
00:29:20 with a recommendation of a film that's meant a lot to you that you think that our viewers would
00:29:25 be actually interested get something from you mentioned Logan I love Logan Logan okay yeah
00:29:30 Have you got one, whatever, from wherever in the world, Anishka?
00:29:34 I'm a huge fan of Israeli movies at the moment, I have to say.
00:29:38 Yes, they really go straight to the bone.
00:29:40 Anyone in particular?
00:29:43 On the subject of violence and young men,
00:29:47 last year at the Israeli Film Festival,
00:29:50 I watched a movie about, there was a poet that got fined
00:29:54 and he had to do the service with the young offenders,
00:29:57 disenfranchised offenders in Jerusalem.
00:29:59 it was painful but it was it's really worth watching I don't remember the
00:30:04 title now but it's really worth what basically you're saying is really yeah
00:30:07 pretty good Richard I have to say in the last six or seven years there's been
00:30:13 nothing I particularly enjoyed coming out of American cinema or coming out of
00:30:19 the UK particularly I mean I I've got a very scary way back in probably my
00:30:26 favourite movie that might be in any way perceived as political is The Wizard of Oz because it's
00:30:30 kind of anti-authoritarian but that wasn't picked up at the time if you ran if he ran it today
00:30:37 obviously you know it would be a massively political movie might not even get shot today I
00:30:41 guess well I'd love to say carry on Cleo because that's got the the highest budget ever done because
00:30:50 they filmed it just after Anthony Cleopatra with Liz Taylor and Richard Burton so if you want to
00:30:55 I see Sid James wearing Garish Burton's outfit.
00:30:57 Are they really these?
00:30:58 That's a very good one.
00:30:59 But personally, I would say last year when we had Gary Oldham as Churchill.
00:31:04 Terrific film.
00:31:05 Specifically now when we're seeing so much iconoclasm
00:31:07 against our heroes and the toppling of statues.
00:31:10 But there you have one man who really did, in that one year period,
00:31:14 ensure that democracy had its flame kept aglow in those crucial years
00:31:19 between Russia and America coming in
00:31:21 and how one man's resilience and determination
00:31:23 can actually bring a nation together
00:31:25 if you can motivate them and inspire them.
00:31:27 I think also that was done really with a light touch, actually, wasn't it?
00:31:32 It wasn't jingoistic or anything.
00:31:34 I just have my two-pence worth.
00:31:35 There's a movie called Seven, which was from the 1990s,
00:31:39 which has Morgan Freeman as the kind of man who knows maybe a lot,
00:31:44 is very knowledgeable, the young cop who knows nothing
00:31:47 and is very contemptuous of everything that's gone before.
00:31:50 and they have a battle and one comes off worse
00:31:54 but to me I felt that that was actually interesting
00:31:57 because it was talking about how previous knowledge
00:32:00 can actually be used to actually solve something in the present
00:32:04 so I would say that one
00:32:05 but thank you very very much for those recommendations
00:32:08 and also for the discussion
00:32:11 that's our first programme
00:32:14 but we're going to be on now regularly
00:32:16 so I do hope that you do watch again
00:32:19 it's counterculture new culture forum and thank you to my guests and see you next time