New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.02: What Has Brexit Revealed About Britain?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

36 minutes

Words per minute

190.31

Word count

6,973

Sentence count

229


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Rafe Hadle-Manku. We're hearing a lot today about how
00:00:13 politics is broken in Britain and indeed how the British nation might be broken. Is this
00:00:18 due to Brexit? Were the roots laid much earlier? Joining me today to discuss this we have four
00:00:25 experts on all matters Brexit. Dr Tim Stanley is an historian and a leader
00:00:30 writer for The Telegraph and a regular contributor to CNN. He also writes for
00:00:35 The Spectator amongst many other publications and amongst his broad
00:00:39 portfolio of TV appearances and on the radio he's appeared on The Moral Maze
00:00:45 on Radio 4 and Question Time on BBC. Madeleine Grant was a parliamentary
00:00:51 researcher, then worked for the Institute for Economic Affairs, and is now a comments
00:00:56 editor for The Telegraph, and she appears regularly on Politics Live and has also appeared
00:01:02 on Any Questions on BBC Radio 4. Tom Harwood is a journalist for the award-winning Guido
00:01:09 Fawkes website, a political and investigative journalism website. He also writes for The
00:01:14 Spectator and Conservative Home, and amongst many appearances on BBC, Sky and ITV, he is also the
00:01:22 youngest ever person to have appeared on Question Time. David Aldroyd Bolt is a historian and a
00:01:28 musician who once wrote for the Times Diary and now writes for the Telegraph and the Spectator
00:01:33 and the Catholic Herald, and indeed his cover story for the Spectator was the most viewed of
00:01:39 all time in 2017. They are all Brexiteer experts and are looking forward to discussing our
00:01:46 topic for today, which is, is Brexit broken? Tim, if I can start with you. Is Brexit broken
00:01:53 the title of our show, or has it started perhaps slightly earlier? Has Brexit actually ripped
00:01:59 the veil off of Britain and shown us underneath scars and cracks and breaks that happened
00:02:05 much earlier. Depending on your point of view, the crisis could either be Brexit itself or the
00:02:11 failure to deliver Brexit. That's the tension. So those on the left would say that Brexit itself
00:02:16 is the product of lies and a failure of leadership by the Conservatives. This is their mess and we're
00:02:21 now stuck in it. The Brexit point of view, which is my point of view, is actually the referendum
00:02:25 was a perfectly reasonable question on a perfectly reasonable idea that you might wish to leave the
00:02:31 EU. And then the real crisis comes from having asked that question, having been given an
00:02:35 answer, then refusing or failing to deliver. So that's the tension. Is the crisis Brexit
00:02:40 itself, or is the crisis how long it's taken to get it done?
00:02:44 Madeleine, is Brexit broken?
00:02:47 Well, I think that what Brexit has done is it has performed a kind of stress testing
00:02:53 on various of our institutions. And so one by one, as they've been asked to deal with
00:02:58 this big constitutional change they've been basically you know put up to they've had their
00:03:05 feet held to the fire and actually the majority have been found wanting we begin to realize just
00:03:09 how much in our system relies on people's own discretion for example the position of speaker
00:03:15 of the house of commons relies on people obeying traditions as opposed to set rules and it's and
00:03:23 And it's also, I think, been the failure of a very large part of the kind of the media
00:03:27 bubble, the political class, the kind of the intellectual chattering classes.
00:03:32 And it's removed the veil from a great deal of contempt that I'm not sure we realised
00:03:37 was simmering away.
00:03:38 I think we saw signs of that snobbery and distaste for ordinary people, but I think
00:03:43 Brexit has really exposed a nastiness at the heart of the elite.
00:03:47 And as Tom, expand on that, what do you think the revelations we've had about our elite
00:03:52 institutions and our parliamentarians have shown us about them well a lot of the rumblings behind
00:03:58 brexit from the beginning were this was this incredible tension between the people and the
00:04:03 politicians we saw it expressed during the expenses crisis it was a major theme of the av referendum
00:04:10 and of course a huge theme of the eu referendum where you had just about every expert the vast
00:04:16 majority of the political parties the politicians all the people that hold those positions of power
00:04:21 having one view and the people roundly saying shove off to them. But I think that there's
00:04:26 something quite different in what we've experienced in the last two years and the general question
00:04:31 of Brexit. This tension that we've seen in terms of Parliament not wanting to enact the
00:04:38 result of the referendum is very much a response to the 2017 election and that sort of disassociation
00:04:44 that people had. It sort of shattered that idea that I think most parliamentarians held
00:04:49 following the referendum result that it should be delivered they had a bit of a
00:04:53 grounding a bit of a shock I think that totally dissipated after Theresa May
00:04:57 failed to win that election now David looking at things from a cultural
00:05:02 perspective which is your great area of expertise it's no surprise to know that
00:05:07 Remainers dominates the cultural fields and the arts what impact do you think
00:05:11 the Remainers have had on cultural institutions since 2016 and particularly
00:05:16 what impact have they had on Brexit? Leave artists, musicians, etc.
00:05:23 The impact that the Remain camp has had on cultural institutions goes much, much farther
00:05:27 back. They've had an hegemony over cultural institutions since at least the Blair government,
00:05:34 but probably really since the 1970s. And this expresses itself in a cultural fissure through
00:05:40 the nation, between those who feel themselves to have no allegiance nationally, to be part
00:05:44 a supranational class of educated, cultivated cultural elites. And you see this through
00:05:49 their flexibility of working and living. They rarely feel that they're happy wherever they
00:05:53 are as long as they're with their people. And the contrast is with those who feel the
00:05:57 sense of what Roger Scruton has often described as an oikos, a place, and their rootedness.
00:06:02 They have no buy-in to cultural institutions in this country anymore. They are those who
00:06:06 are bidden to attend and to whom accessibility schemes are supposedly directed, but who in
00:06:11 in fact feel themselves at complete distance from it and all that has
00:06:14 happened I think since 2016 is that gulf has widened and widened and widened to
00:06:18 the point that as Maddy says there is now an utter contempt between those
00:06:22 controlling cultural institutions directing the cultural life of the
00:06:26 nation and those to whom it is supposedly directed. I can see no remedy
00:06:31 for this that does not entail a wholesale cleaning of the organist tables.
00:06:35 You have to get rid of the people running these institutions who have that
00:06:38 mindset if those institutions are ever to change because institutions take their character
00:06:42 from the leaders. And really it's a great tragedy actually of Brexit that what could
00:06:47 have been a healing exercise has in fact only solidified divisions.
00:06:52 Well you raise an interesting point as to when the road to Brexit started and of course
00:06:57 there are those who believe it started in 1997 with the election of Tony Blair and there's
00:07:02 the famous Gramsci theory. I'd like to know what you think about that, how much veracity
00:07:07 you hold to it which in a nutshell states that the plan was to have a long march through the
00:07:12 institutions Gramsci was a communist who didn't believe in the economic models of communism
00:07:18 and Peter Hitchens eloquently put this case forward on an appearance on our sister show
00:07:24 so what you're saying is and really that what we've had under Blair was a far more radical change and
00:07:30 even Corbyn has envisaged and that a silent revolution took place in our institutions
00:07:36 the buildings remain the same and people walk around thinking nothing's changed just because
00:07:40 there are no red flags on the rooftops but the people that built those buildings inhabited them
00:07:45 have vanished and have been replaced by other people but what do we think about that accident
00:07:50 conspiracy or just but they've not been replaced by marxists one one problem i have with the
00:07:54 conservative analysis the gramscian idea of cultural marxism has been a slow takeover
00:07:59 through cultural institutions particularly higher education is that the victors are not marxists
00:08:04 They are, by and large, liberals, metropolitan liberals, whose views correspond very much with the economic and social consensus post the Cold War.
00:08:13 Essentially, they take almost the Fukuyama point that history has ended.
00:08:17 The great collective endeavours, the utopian endeavours of socialism and Marxism are over now.
00:08:21 And it's all about the individual and the atomised individual aspiring to have liberty over their own life.
00:08:27 So I'm a little sceptical of that.
00:08:29 And I think it's very important.
00:08:31 there is a crisis legitimacy but it's important to remember that leaving the EU is really not
00:08:36 that controversial an idea it's a very straightforward simple idea and the people
00:08:39 only said they wanted to do it because they were asked had they not been asked this is why my point
00:08:44 at the beginning is where does the crisis come is it the asking in the referendum or is it the
00:08:48 failure to deliver is the crisis actually that the establishment thought we didn't know what to do
00:08:53 about the EU so we're going to ask people and then the people when asked said fine we want to do it
00:08:58 But it's really not that controversial a question.
00:09:00 The failure to then deliver it goes back to this 1997 point
00:09:03 about the slow decline in faith in democratic institutions.
00:09:07 Labour's problem post the end of the Cold War
00:09:09 is it abandons socialism,
00:09:10 abandons the notions of social solidarity
00:09:12 and economic redistribution.
00:09:14 It becomes a liberal party
00:09:15 and it loses touch with its working-class base,
00:09:17 which is why you see a decline in turnout and elections.
00:09:19 It's why you see rebellions
00:09:20 like the famous Blind Al-Gwent by-election,
00:09:22 why you see the rise of the BNP,
00:09:23 the rise of UKIP in working-class heartlands.
00:09:26 is because Labour has abandoned that space in politics.
00:09:30 And that's what's happening now,
00:09:31 is the left is struggling to refill it again with Corbyn,
00:09:33 but it's really not succeeding.
00:09:36 So I see all of this as really a fallout of 1989.
00:09:41 It's not just about Brexit,
00:09:42 because I think Brexit is a perfectly reasonable question.
00:09:46 It's not that controversial.
00:09:47 It's about the gulf between what politicians assume everyone wants
00:09:52 and actually what they're discovering everyone wants.
00:09:54 And it turns out that a lot of what people want is actually a return to collectivist social solidarity,
00:10:01 which has not been reflected for a very long time in the elites in this country.
00:10:05 You had Peter Oban's terrific book, The Triumph of the Political Class,
00:10:10 that showed basically how under Tony Blair and later under Cameron and Brown,
00:10:15 we saw basically the creation of spads and others who entered politics straight through university,
00:10:22 never having any experience of life outside the Westminster bubble and that that basically created
00:10:28 the separation the division between nation and politics what do we think about the influence of
00:10:35 that i think there's there is a lot of truth to that it also explains the uh the love of the eu
00:10:41 to an extent because the eu offers a further avenue for that kind of uh sort of cozy club
00:10:48 the uh the patronage it is as often the eu for a long time has acted as a kind of um retirement
00:10:54 home for politicians from national states that have either failed to be elected in those countries
00:10:59 or they've had their they've done their time in mainstream politics and it also offers um a kind
00:11:06 of melting pot where people who are have the sort of european elite have far more in common with
00:11:11 each other than they do with the average citizen of any of their countries could kind of come together
00:11:16 and set policy in such a way that continues that status quo.
00:11:22 And I can totally see why so many people would find it so attractive.
00:11:26 As someone who was a student of politics, you sort of see these grand designs.
00:11:29 You go to Brussels and you see the enormous buildings, the sort of grandeur of the whole place,
00:11:34 and it can be quite attractive, it can be sucked in.
00:11:36 I totally see why Tony Blair wanted to be President of Europe.
00:11:39 it's a it's an attractive system to believe that you can organize society
00:11:45 and structure it from the center and it's sort of that ideology that I think
00:11:49 is more pervasive than anything else in the current setup of our political
00:11:54 elites sort of that that planning from the center that they can believe they
00:11:58 can deliver society from desks in Whitehall and I think one of the biggest
00:12:03 things about the referendum vote that we haven't touched on yet is taking back
00:12:06 control isn't just to take it back and leave it with elites in Westminster, it's
00:12:11 about bringing it back to individuals and having people having more control
00:12:14 over their own lives, which has steadily slid away from them over the decades and
00:12:18 rested with people who very few have feel they have any accountability
00:12:22 whatsoever. And the fallacy that sovereignty means parliamentary
00:12:26 sovereignty alone, that was never an argument. There was national sovereignty,
00:12:29 that the sovereign had sovereignty. And most importantly individual sovereignty.
00:12:33 individual sovereignty. Could I just return to your earlier point that the idea of the
00:12:37 rise of the political class somehow began in the 1990s? It's an historical fallacy.
00:12:42 The phrase Bob's your uncle comes from the fact that Arthur Balfour was given patronage
00:12:45 in government by his uncle Robert III Marcus of Salisbury. The idea that historically people
00:12:50 have not risen through the structures of Oxford or Cambridge, then been parliamentary private
00:12:55 secretaries and then become ministers and then later cabinet ministers and prime ministers
00:12:59 is simply historical bunkum. Yes. And I suppose it's the fact that it's often
00:13:03 conducted by so-called progressives who think of themselves as generally anathema to that kind of
00:13:08 patronage in their day-to-day lives but are of course massive recipients of it. There's a hypocrisy
00:13:13 about it. You're absolutely right David it's just that the current class doing it have views we don't
00:13:18 agree with. That's our real objection here but I'm totally honest about that there's always power in
00:13:23 society and there's always a bureaucratic elite which enforces it and it always replicates what
00:13:27 it assumes is the cultural consensus. And the curious thing over the past 20 years has been
00:13:32 that conservative governments have not done what traditionally happens when governments replace one
00:13:36 of another stripe, which is to put their own people in power. Following Blair and Brown,
00:13:39 the conservatives under, well, fine, it was a coalition, but the Cameron coalition and then
00:13:44 government did not start when, for instance, Quango chairmerships came up, putting their
00:13:49 own people in place, or when the chairman of the Royal Opera House, or any cultural institution,
00:13:54 when that became vacant, didn't put their people there. This is what Blair did so effectively.
00:13:57 he created a class a bureaucratic class but also a cultural class of those who made themselves
00:14:03 indispensable and brought their people up behind them so yes there is a new class there a class
00:14:09 of cultural administrators the conservatives have simply not felt themselves culturally powerful
00:14:13 enough to replace although in fairness Blair had the political space to do so yeah when you've got
00:14:18 a socking majority and you feel like the country's behind you you sort of have the audaciousness to
00:14:22 pursue avenues like that but um in reality there's only been a conservative majority government for
00:14:27 two of the last 20 odd years more than 20 years so it's understandable why there
00:14:32 hasn't been that that sort of embedding of conservative thought institutions
00:14:39 I think it can also be difficult for conservatives because very often they're
00:14:42 made to feel pariahs when they enter these sorts of places the ivory towers
00:14:45 and the academies and so on that their views are not as popular and you get a
00:14:49 lot of shy Tories in these sorts of institutions and there's a real
00:14:54 difference between being in power obviously that gives you some confidence
00:14:58 but it doesn't have the kind of brazen confidence that the liberal elite have
00:15:02 that sense of absolute justice and morality being on their side. It is a
00:15:07 moral certainty of the liberal elite that's the difference between the
00:15:10 mindsets. A conservative believes that his beliefs are open to question and
00:15:14 often open to error. A liberal I think of the sort we're talking about really has
00:15:18 a sense of ethical rectitude that is impossible to break. And the conservative
00:15:22 faces a great emphasis upon the private sphere and the family, so they're less likely to
00:15:25 go into public organisations because they're just biased against them by instinct.
00:15:30 But certainly if Blair was the person who introduced this new meritocratic political
00:15:33 class, the Labour Party prior to that had characters who certainly were very much part
00:15:38 of the real world, and Dennis Healy on the beaches in the Second World War, with great
00:15:44 involvement in the labour movement and so forth, and they of course were expunged until
00:15:49 recently, and so they do have this disconnect where people feel much more at home in London
00:15:53 and Islington than they would be doing in Doncaster.
00:15:55 Although we shouldn't fall into this trap of saying that the Labour movement has been
00:15:58 representative of workers historically.
00:16:01 No.
00:16:01 And one of the big arguments, obviously, of Thatcherism and democratising the union movement
00:16:05 was that, I mean, so many of those unions had a considerable proportion of membership
00:16:11 that voted Conservative, and yet their leadership simply would not reflect their views, and
00:16:15 in many ways it was a similar sort of disassociation within that union movement between the people
00:16:20 who sort of are the workers being represented and their representatives who were fighting
00:16:24 for something very different.
00:16:25 Well Tom, leaving the institutions aside for a moment, what do you think Brexit has done
00:16:30 to the nation as a whole? We're now arguably more divided than any time since the Civil
00:16:35 War. Our constitution is in tatters. What do you think the effect is now on the British
00:16:39 people and where do we go from here?
00:16:41 Interestingly, I don't think it's Brexit that's done that.
00:16:44 Polls were taken immediately after the referendum where you had 85% of people thinking that the results, whether they agreed with it or not, should be implemented.
00:16:53 What we've had through failure of leadership at the top and stasis in Parliament is a steady ebbing of that consensus that did once exist.
00:17:04 and there was a sort of uh sense of of elites politicians and people that okay we might not
00:17:13 like this but we're gonna go along with it to coin a phrase um and i think more than anything else
00:17:19 as i said earlier that election result totally disassociated that um that idea that consensus
00:17:28 and it was only after that that campaigning organizations like people's votes bring up
00:17:32 It's very easy to forget because we've had so much politics crammed into such a small space of time in the last 12 months or so.
00:17:41 This was an organisation that cropped up last summer, more than two years after the referendum.
00:17:46 And suddenly the sands of politics have changed so much in that.
00:17:50 The position of the Labour Party has changed from leaving the single market in the Customs Union to just leaving the single market,
00:17:56 to perhaps having a second referendum but without Remain on the ballot paper
00:18:00 to now having a second referendum with Remain and another form of Remain on the ballot paper.
00:18:04 But that seismic shift has occurred in such a small period of time
00:18:09 and it's all been enabled by that hung parliament.
00:18:13 I'm going to say that I think Britain's always been broken
00:18:15 in the sense by which you define broken.
00:18:19 And the exception really was that 89 to about 2015 period
00:18:23 in which there appeared to be a consensus around neoliberalism.
00:18:27 The reality is that I don't think today's politics
00:18:29 could be said to be more broken than those of the early 80s,
00:18:32 the miners' strike, or those of Suez, or those of the 1830s.
00:18:37 There have always been tensions,
00:18:38 and there's always been a big debate over what defines Britishness
00:18:42 and what exactly the consensus is.
00:18:44 And very often the so-called consensus is the consensus of those power elites,
00:18:48 which at certain points enjoys a strong anchoring in society,
00:18:52 but at other times it becomes broken, that anger becomes broken,
00:18:55 and then suddenly there's a huge fight over what the new consensus should be.
00:19:00 All of which re-emphasises that Brexit, I feel like a broken clock,
00:19:03 but it shouldn't be that controversial.
00:19:05 It's just that it's come along at this moment of this crisis and democratic legitimacy.
00:19:10 Perhaps a key difference between now and previous generations,
00:19:13 I think previous generations would have looked at the result of the referendum and said,
00:19:16 right, we've got to do it.
00:19:18 What's interesting about this particular generation is there is a group of people
00:19:21 who refuse to let go, refuse to move on.
00:19:23 If you take 1945, Labour's victory,
00:19:26 the Conservatives are changed as a party within six years.
00:19:29 And they're suddenly pro-nationalisation, pro-NHS and pro-tax and spend
00:19:33 because they realise the country has changed.
00:19:35 By contrast, in 2016 to 19,
00:19:39 there's a reluctance of the establishment to change.
00:19:41 They're fighting. They refuse to let go.
00:19:43 And many of them seem to genuinely believe that unless they stop this project,
00:19:47 the Britain that they believe is the consensus Britain will be destroyed.
00:19:50 I'm always astonished by how quickly this phrase has switched from taking back control and giving me back my country
00:19:56 and all that sort of language has gone from being the leavers phrase to the Remainers phrase.
00:20:00 They're now saying, quite legitimately, where did my country go to?
00:20:03 So for them it's almost life and death struggle.
00:20:06 That's the difference is the political rhetoric, but I don't think we should pretend that this is any more divisive than the early 80s.
00:20:12 And to pick up on that, it's so interesting how so often Remainers will reference the Olympics in 2012 as if this was a harmonious society.
00:20:20 Most opinion polls in 2012 showed that most people in this country wanted to leave the EU.
00:20:24 It's just they didn't have an opportunity to express that.
00:20:27 There were riots on the streets of London.
00:20:29 The country was on fire and yet because there was this political consensus, exactly as you say, everything was assumed to be fine when it very much wasn't underneath it.
00:20:39 And how shallow to think that a good show was the bellwether for the country.
00:20:43 But also how intrinsically British, really.
00:20:46 Putting on appearances, keeping up a good face in the spirit of adversity,
00:20:50 or rather despite adversity, is the most English thing to do.
00:20:53 Well, British, but specifically English thing to do in the face of great uncertainty.
00:20:57 But I think there's a point that you were alluding to but didn't quite make.
00:21:00 There is a refusal on the part of the Remainers to learn and to understand.
00:21:05 They simply will not bring themselves to understand why this happened.
00:21:08 yes you refer to 1945 and the change to 1951 in the Tory party that's because
00:21:13 they realized they had to understand what had happened in order to come up
00:21:16 with any sort of coherent opposition or even to move on from it and I'm afraid
00:21:20 what's happened is a sort of it's a devil circle in the remain mindset of
00:21:25 well this is wrong but this is wrong to us and we are right so we're not going
00:21:30 to learn from this we're simply going to keep telling people that they are wrong
00:21:33 until they come around to our point of view it's absolutely intractable I
00:21:37 I would describe it actually as a kind of almost radicalisation that's taken place amongst
00:21:42 that particular coterie of society.
00:21:44 You know, a few years ago it would have been considered the height of eccentricity for
00:21:48 anyone to own an EU flag, much less fly it on their window.
00:21:52 Did anyone own an EU flag before 2016?
00:21:54 I mean, someone's made a fortune out of selling these things to all the people who stand outside
00:21:59 Parliament each day.
00:22:00 But I think that what's happened really is that people have been so blindsided by the
00:22:05 result they're so disgusted but mostly shocked by what happened because
00:22:11 essentially they felt that their consensus they were essentially on the
00:22:14 front foot for a long time culturally and politically and so to have the rug
00:22:18 pulled out from under your feet has sparked something of an identity crisis
00:22:21 and there's actually highly illusory not real but sort of European identity has
00:22:28 sprung up in a number of years and that's that these are the people who
00:22:31 tweet with FBP or whatever it is and wear EU flags and talk speak of themselves as you know
00:22:39 speaking with as though we live in very much a kind of fallen world now I want my country back
00:22:45 precisely the kind of decline is rhetoric that you would normally have associated with some
00:22:50 conservative man who's looking back to the 1950s with with with sadness you know that it's that
00:22:56 it's gone well there's no coincidence there that those I think who have the most buy-in to
00:23:00 the European project, are for the most part
00:23:03 the scions of the old imperial class, the governing
00:23:04 class. They're highly educated,
00:23:07 often from the families that were district governors
00:23:09 running parts of the empire. When the
00:23:10 empire went, after Suez and after
00:23:12 the commonwealth, they simply shifted
00:23:14 sideways. And they've realised now that their
00:23:16 again, cultural hegemony is coming to
00:23:18 an end. That their 200 years or
00:23:21 more of absolute domination of the
00:23:22 instruments and hierarchies of governments
00:23:24 has finished. And they do not know how
00:23:26 to respond to this. It's a form of institutional
00:23:29 post-traumatic stress disorder.
00:23:30 It is built on a sense of patrician snobbery. I saw one placard at one of these protests that was bragging about how a lady was bragging about how she'd managed to spell her placard correctly, the implication being that Brexiteers are just too thick.
00:23:49 Your Olympics reference I always thought was quite good for Brexit
00:23:53 because if you remember the media in this country constantly like to downplay and denigrate and deprecate
00:23:58 and all through the lead-up to the Olympics they were saying it's going to be a disaster,
00:24:02 turned out to be a huge triumph and I was hoping vainly that Brexit was going to be a similar thing,
00:24:06 poo-poo it and then at the eleventh hour prove it to be a great success.
00:24:10 It hasn't quite turned out that way unfortunately.
00:24:12 Yes, it might yet.
00:24:13 It might yet but really what you're talking about now is something which is affecting Boris Johnson
00:24:18 And as you know, he's now trying to realign with the Labour North, Blue Labour.
00:24:23 And certainly his economic policies are not Tory in any essence.
00:24:28 They're much more Labour than Tory in terms of his spending plans
00:24:31 in an attempt to do away with the long-term damage
00:24:34 that some would say Thatcher had implemented in the North through her policies
00:24:38 and reversed that, which the left have always capitalised on as the demon Tory party.
00:24:44 But what do you think then about this coming general election?
00:24:47 will it be an election that can offer some sort of a fix?
00:24:51 Stephen Davies and Dr. Matthew Goodwin have advanced the idea
00:24:54 that we're undergoing one of the most major political realignments,
00:24:58 which will see people dividing up, not along class lines or economic ideology,
00:25:03 but upon culture and values.
00:25:05 And so you'll have the Brexit Party and the Tory right and blue Labour on one side,
00:25:10 and you'll have Labour centrists, alleged centrists,
00:25:12 Tocco Muna being one of the former post-poster boys, and Blair as well, along with the Lib Dems.
00:25:19 Do we think that's now going to be the new divide?
00:25:21 Well, the trouble is that they currently lack a viable political home,
00:25:24 given that the Labour Party has been taken over by proper Marxists, unreconstructed Marxists,
00:25:29 and, as you pointed out, the Conservative Party is going in a more...
00:25:33 You might say more...
00:25:36 Well, it's going in the direction of blue Labour.
00:25:38 Labour I think there is a danger that it's making something of a mistake
00:25:42 because of course Margaret Thatcher managed to win over the working classes
00:25:45 in huge numbers particularly in 1983 and she did that not by offering what I
00:25:50 think are quite patronizing bribes essentially saying the way to win over
00:25:56 Workington Man as he's patronizingly referred to by some think tank you know
00:26:00 the way to win him over is just to give him more stuff but actually Workington
00:26:05 man, wants very much the same things that people have always wanted, the chance to get
00:26:11 on in life. They want potentially a hand up rather than a hand out. And I think it might
00:26:19 well pay off in this election because they are up against such a weak opposition, but
00:26:23 in general I think the Conservatives would do better to re-engage with that aspirational
00:26:28 message that scored them three landslide victories during the 1980s and 70s.
00:26:35 We all, most people would agree this election is somewhat about culture, but no one's quite
00:26:40 worked out yet how economic policy ties into culture.
00:26:43 When it comes to Brexit, there is one part of the Tory mind which is inclined to say
00:26:48 that it's all about, as we were saying, the sovereignty of the individual.
00:26:51 You leave the EU, that means you can decentralise, remove some of the bureaucracy and the regulation,
00:26:55 and we can have free trade with the rest of the world and create richer, aspirant individuals.
00:27:00 But there is another part of the Tory mind which says actually it's about a repatriation
00:27:04 of power and responsibility from Europe to the parliament.
00:27:08 And perhaps what we actually need to do
00:27:09 is sort of knit the national community back together.
00:27:12 And there's always that tension in Toryism
00:27:14 between the national and the individual.
00:27:16 And I'm not quite sure how they're going to resolve it.
00:27:20 They're trying to resolve it
00:27:21 through the personality of Boris Johnson, I think.
00:27:24 Someone who, let's face it, is a Thatcherite,
00:27:27 probably libertarian,
00:27:28 a kind of man who'd said that on one occasion
00:27:30 said he would want to give an amnesty to illegal immigrants,
00:27:33 which is something that most of the people he's currently trying to appeal to would run a million miles away from.
00:27:38 So that's his instinct.
00:27:39 On the other hand, there's something about him that embodies those patrician Tory values
00:27:44 and symbols of the past of Churchill and the nation-state.
00:27:48 So right now they're trying to get around that tension through the personality of Boris.
00:27:53 When they actually, if they win said election, they then have to have a budget and everything,
00:27:57 they have to make the choices that a government traditionally has to make,
00:27:59 that might be harder because Boris would really like to cut taxes but a lot of Tories are hearing
00:28:05 from their constituencies that the local hospital is under strain and social care is the big issue
00:28:10 coming up because of the aging population so can we really afford those tax cuts so I'm not sure
00:28:16 what the answer is to that tension. Tim you know that of course historically speaking the Tory
00:28:20 party has always embodied that dichotomy and it's only ever been electorally successful when it's
00:28:25 had a leader who was able to bridge the gulf successfully thatcher salisbury in the 19th
00:28:30 century peel for a short time disraeli most successfully of all it has always had those
00:28:35 things which are seen to be exclusive but in fact already i think congruent the sovereignty of the
00:28:40 individual and the power of parliament should work together in a burkean sense so that the
00:28:44 individual empowered feels a sense of obligation to take part in the civil nation and in the life
00:28:49 of the nation because he himself is powerful and well disposed and economically active this
00:28:55 patrician idea that by giving people something they'll feel much happier is is so erosive to
00:29:00 that sense of people taking part because they are themselves powerful and i think actually boris
00:29:04 could do something extraordinary here if he doesn't allow himself to fall into tropes of
00:29:09 essentially media class tory thinking the worst thing he could do as a tory leader is to listen
00:29:14 to what the media class criticizes in tory economic policy if he sticks with his instincts
00:29:19 which i think are low tax pro free markets pro economy but also accept that as you say with
00:29:24 social care in the NHS, people do need a leg up from time to time. I think that is his
00:29:28 route to success.
00:29:29 But I think actually that he's missed a great opportunity with the NHS to start talking
00:29:32 about how we need to reform it. By all means, let's give it more money, but we need to make
00:29:36 some wholesale changes and stop kidding ourselves that we can solve this problem by chucking
00:29:40 another 10 or 20 billion at it. Because if that's enough for a short time, give it five
00:29:45 years and it will need another 40 billion. It's just, it's simply not sustainable. But
00:29:49 instead you have the sight of these previously quite free marketeer MPs delivering these videos
00:29:55 to camera that look a bit like a sort of hostage situation where they say oh I love the NHS and
00:29:59 it's all a bit I'm not being mistreated you know. Well I think this is fear of what happened to
00:30:04 Mrs May with her social care strategy that came out in the 2017 election. They're essentially
00:30:08 avoiding the issue in order not to make it an issue and then they can deal with it when and
00:30:12 if they have a majority. And yet the issue here is also that Corbyn and Johnson are both similarly
00:30:17 deeply unpopular with the nation as a whole polling as such there's a Boris in
00:30:26 in terms of mail on Sunday poll last weekend showed a plus-two rating yeah
00:30:30 which is actually if we compare it if we compare it Blair went into the 2001
00:30:36 election with a minus five rating it's very very unusual for incumbent
00:30:40 governments to have minus 60 or something minus 60 the lowest of any
00:30:44 I mean, certainly they're both divisive, but it's sort of like comparing Marmite to mustard
00:30:48 gas.
00:30:49 Right.
00:30:50 Certainly, on the issues of trust and lying, he's basically symbolic, really, of the wider
00:30:55 issue in Parliament, of the underhand tactics that have been taking place, because it seems
00:30:59 now as being an era when people don't trust politicians at all and don't trust party
00:31:03 manifestants.
00:31:04 Have they ever?
00:31:05 This is the question.
00:31:06 And the question is, this has never been seen before to this degree, the use of basically
00:31:10 illegal tactics by John Bercow and others. And so the question is, what dangers are there
00:31:17 for the British public being exposed to the reality of what these people are willing to
00:31:23 go to? And can it be unseen? Once it's been seen, can it be unseen or can it be forgotten?
00:31:29 The great danger is that people, by withdrawing their vote, by not taking part in the democratic
00:31:33 process, denuded of its legitimacy. And this is really the only thing that could really
00:31:38 call into question the legitimacy of representative democracy here if people stopped voting i mean
00:31:43 seriously that turnout was down to 20 for instance at what point do we say this is not a legitimate
00:31:49 poll because so few people took part but actually i don't see any evidence of that going to happen
00:31:53 i think there is in fact the contrary evidence that people are so enraged by what they see as
00:31:57 a failure of their political class that they're coming out to vote in greater numbers yes and my
00:32:01 colleague jenny daily insists that in 40 or 50 years time must be regarded as a golden age of
00:32:06 political engagement because people read things and they knew things and they
00:32:09 voted yeah I think people understand that we've been discussing the crisis
00:32:14 legitimacy in the political class but the way the political class sees it is
00:32:17 there's a crisis of legitimacy in the electorate and that's incredibly
00:32:21 patronizing we would like to change the leaders they would like to change us and
00:32:27 I think people see through that I'm not sure how it resolves itself but I think
00:32:31 Boris is seen by many people as a Bill Clinton style figure he has his faults
00:32:36 I might not necessarily trust him personally
00:32:38 but because he wants to stay in power
00:32:41 and he wants to win
00:32:42 he'll do what I want
00:32:43 and that's really what populism is
00:32:45 it's about electing people who
00:32:47 the one thing they will do is what you want
00:32:50 and if he sticks with that message
00:32:52 I think he'll win
00:32:53 Finally, what do we think should happen now
00:32:56 ideally, what would you like to see happen
00:32:58 to try to at least restore
00:33:00 some of the faith and trust that we have in politics
00:33:02 and how can it happen when we have this
00:33:04 current incumbent political class in place? Well, the answer is to, to quote
00:33:09 a phrase, to drain the swamp. No, the answer is for Brexit to happen, because
00:33:13 that's the first step that needs to take place to begin to resolve the trust.
00:33:18 Luckily, we now have a fantastic speaker of the House of Commons, who I believe
00:33:23 will restore some trust that has been so tarnished in that particular. But
00:33:28 unfortunately, I think some of the broader damage there is done, because
00:33:31 what Brexit has revealed is how many of these long-standing institutions relied on conventions
00:33:38 and essentially the personal discretion. So even though we have Lindsay Hoyle in place now,
00:33:43 I would expect further questions about what we might need to do to the role to make sure that
00:33:47 that can never be allowed to happen again. People will ask similar questions about whether we need
00:33:52 some kind of written constitution because of the way that it's been so trampled upon by the great
00:33:57 and the good but I think the best way to begin to resolve the problem is to you know elect the
00:34:04 one party that is promising to abide by the referendum result and watch as the likes of
00:34:10 Dominic Grieve, Anna Soubry and the many MPs who the old patrician snobs who believe that their
00:34:17 own opinion of Brexit because they are from that Tory patrician tradition they believe that they
00:34:23 have the right to overrule the hoi polloi. To watch those people be swept away and replaced
00:34:28 by decent people who understand the need for a functioning relationship between the government
00:34:34 and the demos is so important. I would so worry though on that point of a written constitution.
00:34:40 If this were the 1780s I'd be all behind it but the problem right now is instituting a written
00:34:45 constitution with the elites who would write it. Would they ever allow a majority of the population
00:34:50 to vote for anything ever again.
00:34:51 I agree.
00:34:52 We would embed the current situation of politics.
00:34:58 There would be no substantial change
00:35:00 that could diverge from what exists today.
00:35:02 I think it would be awful
00:35:03 and we would find ourselves conducting,
00:35:07 living in a constant legal quagmire,
00:35:09 endless battles that would go on
00:35:10 and very little would ever be allowed to take place.
00:35:12 I completely agree.
00:35:13 This is one of the tragedies of Brexit, though,
00:35:14 because people have decided to trample on
00:35:16 these age-old but actually quite fragile conventions
00:35:20 for very short-term political gain.
00:35:22 There's a great irony here that, I assume, I speak for all of us,
00:35:26 that we are Conservatives, but because of Brexit
00:35:27 we find ourselves in a revolutionary situation of being asked to fix things.
00:35:31 It's not the Conservative nature to want to even try.
00:35:34 And the answer is not guillotines or the destruction of institutions.
00:35:38 It is to actually get those institutions back on track and to clean house
00:35:41 and get them working so we return to traditional authority
00:35:44 and just get back to simply being what they are supposed to be,
00:35:47 which is an institution which is part of the function of democracy
00:35:51 and which does its job and which people have faith in.
00:35:54 And transcends day-to-day politics.
00:35:56 Exactly, yes.
00:35:57 Well, that's a topic for another conversation.
00:35:59 I would just say on the written constitution, as a conservative,
00:36:02 I think it's the best way to entrench the monarchy,
00:36:04 to entrench institutions so that you can't actually change them
00:36:07 on the will of a democratic majority in government,
00:36:10 such as Tony Blair, who managed to do away
00:36:12 with the Lord Chancellorship's key authority,
00:36:15 and House of Lords became neither fission or fowl and it was a conservative viewpoint
00:36:20 to actually want to entrench these institutions and, you know, avoid Bercow choosing amendments
00:36:26 on his own and changing the course of history.
00:36:28 Actually, you were worried about that.
00:36:29 But that's for another time.
00:36:30 I'd like to thank you all for coming today, Madeleine Grant, Tim Stanley, Tom Harwood
00:36:34 and David Oldroyd both, and we shall see you next time on Counter Culture.