New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.03: The BBC: "Biased Broadcasting Corporation" or National Treasure?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

191.0

Word count

5,946

Sentence count

265


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 The BBC. Is it now the biased broadcasting corporation ripe for reform, or is it still an invaluable national treasure?
00:00:09 Hello and welcome, and Happy New Year. I'm Mark Sidwell, and this is Counter Culture,
00:00:14 the cultural discussion show that takes no prisoners, even if you haven't paid your licence fee.
00:00:20 Today, we're discussing the BBC, its ideological bent and the future of its business model.
00:00:34 As the 2020s get underway, the BBC might seem as powerful as ever, but Boris Johnson's
00:00:41 new government is boycotting key current affairs shows and even threatening to decriminalise
00:00:46 the licence fee for non-payment. Currently the licence fee is compulsory for everyone who owns
00:00:52 a TV set in the UK. But with the rise of Netflix and YouTube, many critics are suggesting that the
00:00:59 licence fee has had its day and that the BBC should move to a subscriber model. Here to discuss that
00:01:05 with me today are David Cox, veteran TV producer who's worked on classic shows like Walden,
00:01:11 was head of current affairs for London Weekend Television, Rafe Hadle-Mancou of the New Culture
00:01:17 Forum, historian and broadcaster, Sophie Sandor, who's a documentary maker and writer, and James
00:01:25 Dellingpole, writer, podcaster and TV critic for The Spectator. Thank you all for joining me.
00:01:34 Let's start with the question of bias. David, you've worked a lot on current affairs.
00:01:39 is the BBC missing the mark at the moment or is Boris Johnson just trying to avoid criticism?
00:01:45 When it comes to Labour versus Conservative as we've had all these complaints about the election
00:01:50 I think that's all basically nonsense. I mean the BBC is very keen not to be seen to be biased on
00:01:56 those central issues. It tries very hard, it gets it wrong sometimes but all the complaints about
00:02:01 that I think are silly. Where the problem arises is not over the central issues it's over cultural
00:02:07 questions, and there's a good reason for that. The BBC is not supposed to be impartial. It would
00:02:12 be absurd if it was impartial. We would have to spend as much time discussing whether the earth
00:02:16 was flat or whether it was round. It can only be, it's supposed to exercise due impartiality
00:02:22 on matters of public controversy. And that means it has to decide what are the boundaries within
00:02:28 which it's going to be impartial. Otherwise, it would be absurd. Now, the trouble is, although
00:02:33 that's okay when it comes to Labour versus the Conservatives because everybody agrees that you
00:02:37 should be impartial between those two things. When it comes to cultural issues there isn't that
00:02:42 agreement. Essentially the BBC depends on working within a consensus and there isn't a consensus
00:02:49 about a lot of these things like transgender, feminism, racism and so on and the BBC therefore
00:02:56 has to demarcate its consensus and however it does that it will be criticized. The fact is that
00:03:03 it tends to demarcate it within parameters that seem natural to the metropolitan elite rather
00:03:10 than the country at large and that's mainly I think where it really does come unstuck and it
00:03:15 gets attacked understandably but the idea that that's because it's not doing something simple
00:03:20 it should be doing is wrong. It would be bound to get attacked. It gets attacked in the way it does
00:03:25 because as this sort of institution it is, a great big public sector monolith,
00:03:31 it's biased towards the values of the metropolitan elite.
00:03:35 That's its problem.
00:03:37 Of course, you raise the question of impartiality,
00:03:40 but it's not true that it's just the BBC who has to make those judgments too.
00:03:43 It's also, I suppose, its relationship with Ofcom.
00:03:45 One thing that happened at the end of last year,
00:03:48 there was a report in October where Ofcom was at pains to say
00:03:51 that impartiality didn't mean neutrality
00:03:53 and it wanted to see broadcasters having the latitude to challenge views
00:03:57 that they thought were controversial and not backed up by facts.
00:04:00 So in some ways, the broadcasters have been given a little more wiggle room to be aggressive.
00:04:04 Well, I would say that, I want to take your first point,
00:04:08 I mean, all broadcasters in this country are required to be as impartial as each other
00:04:13 when it comes to public affairs.
00:04:16 As to whether or not the rules are being changed,
00:04:21 I think there has been a very major complaint that the BBC has been too frightened to be impartial on certain issues of fact.
00:04:30 The most obvious is climate change, where the BBC has been criticised for giving equal weight to climate deniers
00:04:37 and scientists who obviously know things that these climate deniers are getting wrong.
00:04:42 I think on matters of fact, the BBC can be criticised for being too impartial,
00:04:47 and it certainly should be braver at taking a stand on matters of fact.
00:04:51 I think probably the opposite is the case when it comes to opinion.
00:04:56 It's too ready to shut out certain opinions that ought to be given weight.
00:05:03 James, you've been a strong critic of the BBC,
00:05:06 and particularly for its cultural output, which David was raising there.
00:05:09 What's your take on all of that?
00:05:11 Can I just pick David up on the climate change point?
00:05:15 For some considerable time now, the BBC has refused to give airspace to so-called climate deniers,
00:05:24 i.e. people who are sceptical about the quality of the science,
00:05:28 suggesting that we're all going to hell in a handcart because of this thing called man-made global warming.
00:05:34 I think it's a complete journalistic failure, because actually the issue is still very much open for debate.
00:05:41 And I would disagree strongly with the notion that it's scientists who know everything versus deniers who know nothing, which is what you were kind of implying.
00:05:52 Nevertheless, I think the bigger problem with the BBC is to do with things that aren't to do with current affairs.
00:05:59 The fact that you cannot watch, for example, a BBC drama now without seeing this tick box United Colours of Benetton casting, for example.
00:06:09 there was what was that what was the one about the bodyguard where the spite the sniper teams
00:06:15 had had black female snipers now you show me a black female sniper anywhere in in in london
00:06:20 i'll be very impressed um you notice these things the doctor who is now so impossibly woke that
00:06:27 it's it's gone broke basically but but this happens across the board you cannot find bbc
00:06:32 drama that doesn't play this game so i i would agree that that party politics maybe it does
00:06:38 strive to be impartial. But in terms of the culture wars, the BBC is very much on the
00:06:45 liberal left, woke, social justice warrior side of the argument.
00:06:49 I suppose the question is how much that interferes with quality. For example, there are things
00:06:54 that have been weaker, like perhaps the War of the Worlds, which I think was very broadly
00:06:57 rubbished, and then Dracula, which is pretty equally woke in many ways, but a lot of people
00:07:02 thought that it was really quite good, at least the earlier episodes.
00:07:05 Yeah, it had its moments.
00:07:07 But the first episode where it was sort of gothic was fine.
00:07:11 The second one was Agatha Christie, was less good.
00:07:13 The third one was Doctor Who, was absolute pants.
00:07:17 Another example, I suppose, would be the adaptation of Les Miserables.
00:07:21 Now, this is where the BBC is going.
00:07:22 So you had a black Inspector Javert.
00:07:27 Well, the book was written in the 1830s, or set in the 1830s, rather.
00:07:31 I don't believe that it is at all implausible that you'd have a black police inspector in 1830s France.
00:07:37 Now, you may say, well, of course, we move with the times and things change.
00:07:43 Well, in that case, why didn't they have wind farms in the background?
00:07:45 Why didn't they have TV aerials or whatever?
00:07:48 Because TV drama, classic TV drama, is ultimately about verisimilitude.
00:07:54 You're trying to recreate a period, the look of the period.
00:07:58 The BBC is failing to do that.
00:08:00 So it is sacrificing entertainment value and verisimilitude for woke.
00:08:08 Sophie, you've worked a lot on education issues.
00:08:11 How do you think the BBC deals with those?
00:08:13 Do you think they're covering the ground properly?
00:08:15 Well, first I wanted to move back to the current affairs aspect of it
00:08:19 because I think it's really important to say that the BBC is biased
00:08:21 and there have been a lot of case studies done.
00:08:24 I saw some by the IA from health warnings for free market think tanks,
00:08:29 Free market think tanks are far more likely to have health warnings and left the new think tanks.
00:08:35 Representation of lead voices before the Brexit referendum and during the 2015 general election.
00:08:44 So we know that it is biased and saying that no organisation is free of bias
00:08:50 and indeed it might not be and probably isn't desirable for an organisation to aim to be objective all of the time and unbiased.
00:08:57 The reason it's a concern with the BBC is because of its respected reputation
00:09:03 and people do not expect it to be biased as much
00:09:07 and it's providing a lot of online news content, over 75%,
00:09:12 and people are not free to unsubscribe, they're forced to pay for it.
00:09:17 So that's why bias isn't concerning to me in general, but it is with the BBC.
00:09:22 And the sheer dominance of it as well.
00:09:23 I think that, you know, there's some stats, it's three in four of us turn to the BBC regularly
00:09:28 for news, which is more than the next two put together. It's enormous how much control
00:09:33 they have over the news space in the UK.
00:09:36 Yeah, absolutely.
00:09:37 But on the education point, I mean, are they missing a trick? Are they not covering the
00:09:41 important issues?
00:09:42 Well, just yesterday the isolation booths issue came up. So left progressive educationalists
00:09:53 often use it as a method to promote their teaching methods.
00:09:58 And they're doing it a lot through BBC news websites recently
00:10:01 and using misleading pictures of, for example, isolation bits.
00:10:04 What is an isolation bit?
00:10:06 It's where someone is excluded during the day from the rest of their peers for bad behaviour.
00:10:13 And I saw lots of evidence that the BBC is using very misleading pictures,
00:10:18 conflating terms to stir up anti-traditional teaching methods and discipline among the
00:10:26 public. So that's just one example I saw yesterday, which has been going on for months.
00:10:31 Rafe, to come to you, I'd like to again to go back to this point about current affairs
00:10:35 because I'm interested, obviously there hasn't been that much sympathy for that point of
00:10:40 view, at least from David and even from James, but Boris Johnson and his new government are
00:10:45 certainly stirring it up and trying to delegitimize the BBC.
00:10:49 I mean, is that a problem?
00:10:50 Are they basically using this to try and get away with things,
00:10:53 to not stand up to scrutiny?
00:10:54 When they say, well, we're not going on these flagship programmes
00:10:57 because they're biased and we're going to go and do the soft interviews
00:11:01 on Radio 5 Live or whatever it is,
00:11:02 are they just trying to get publicity without having to face hard questions?
00:11:06 Well, I think the BBC now is the institutional sick man of Britain
00:11:10 to the degree that actually, with a potential ten years of Tory government,
00:11:15 This is a time to recreate what Thatcher did in 1986 when she got Mama Duke Hussey into the BBC as BBC chairman to clean up the shop.
00:11:24 And basically in 1997 you've had a similar coup was undertaken by the Labour government in which basically public appointments are always in the Guardian newspaper, for example, for a reason.
00:11:33 And the BBC, basically since the late 80s and 90s, adopted this very progressive woke agenda, which in the last 15 years has become a real problem.
00:11:42 And so I think that the problem with the BBC is that this constant aggressive nature of interviewing saps the will to live.
00:11:51 And shows like this are very important because there's a freeness to develop your own ideas without being interrupted.
00:11:57 You don't have 15-second soundbites and constant interruptions.
00:12:00 During election campaigns, however, I think Andrew Neil and others are quite correct.
00:12:04 You know, the BBC is impartial during election campaigns and during the referendum campaign.
00:12:09 That's when politicians need to be scrutinised.
00:12:11 and I think Boris Johnson should have appeared before Andrew Neil
00:12:13 because it's in that period you want to test the manifesto
00:12:16 and see if they're up to task.
00:12:17 But outside those periods, I think there's far too much reliance
00:12:21 on this Paxman type of interrogation
00:12:22 and a lot more healthy discussion could be had
00:12:25 if you actually try to give someone a chance to develop their ideas
00:12:28 without accusing them of basically being a borderline criminal.
00:12:32 Yes, but how do we get there if that's so?
00:12:34 I mean, it's interesting what you say about people in the past
00:12:37 having undertaken coups, whatever.
00:12:39 I mean, current Director General, Lord Hall, has said, well, I don't see a problem here.
00:12:44 You know, we're being criticised from the left, we're being criticised from the right, we think we're fine in the middle.
00:12:48 He's obviously not really in the mood to do much.
00:12:53 Johnson wants change, but what can he actually do?
00:12:55 Well, essentially, you need to, well, I think that the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation is a very good model here.
00:13:01 There, the president of the CBC is appointed by the Governor-General, the Queen's representative, on the advice of the Prime Minister.
00:13:08 And you really have to get away from this idea of the BBC Trust and the BBC Board
00:13:12 and have a night with the long knives, really, and just clear out the top there.
00:13:15 Because, you know, it's no secret that the two most read newspapers in the BBC
00:13:18 are The Guardian and The Independent.
00:13:21 And in the last 15 years, you've seen essentially the BBC engage
00:13:25 in what I would call an act of institutional suicide.
00:13:27 It's sort of self-harming by destroying its brands.
00:13:30 You know, we've mentioned Doctor Who.
00:13:33 The ratings have shown a huge decline.
00:13:35 Why? Because you've now got a female Doctor Who.
00:13:37 nobody wanted a female Doctor Who
00:13:39 they know that it's losing
00:13:40 you've seen this with Charlie's Angels
00:13:42 you've seen this with the female Ghostbusters
00:13:45 these products and icons
00:13:48 don't need to be tampered with
00:13:50 and people are rejecting them
00:13:51 and yet the BBC
00:13:52 despite seeing this declining ratings
00:13:54 continues along this path
00:13:55 and I think if it's not taken in hand
00:13:58 people are going to get turned off
00:14:00 ITN is now regarded as a much more reputable source
00:14:02 by the public than the BBC
00:14:04 and the BBC are the architects of their own downfall
00:14:07 But of course, journalism and the arts are both very left-wing professions by their nature.
00:14:15 It's hard to see, even if you change a few people at the top of the BBC, would that really make a difference?
00:14:19 No, I think the BBC is screwed beyond measure.
00:14:23 And actually, I just want it burnt to the ground and I want the earth salted.
00:14:29 There is no hope.
00:14:31 But we're not going to get that, so at least let's expose it.
00:14:34 People do love it.
00:14:35 Well, some people do.
00:14:37 Do they really? Who loves it?
00:14:39 Well, they don't trust it as much as they do,
00:14:41 but sort of half the public still trusts it,
00:14:43 but it's not exactly love, perhaps.
00:14:45 But, you know, it's seen as an institution.
00:14:46 People are slow to notice things, aren't they?
00:14:49 Because it's still got the same initials, BBC.
00:14:53 It's still got the same shaped programmes, more or less.
00:14:56 So people think, well, it must be the same thing.
00:14:57 It does many fine things.
00:14:58 The World Service is still pretty good.
00:15:00 If an organisation gets billions of pounds a year,
00:15:03 it's bound to do something good with it.
00:15:04 so it's not rather too impressive in the context.
00:15:07 But is there, does it have to be destroyed?
00:15:10 Would you agree with James there is the only answer
00:15:13 to completely get rid of it, if there's some way to do that?
00:15:15 I'm very pro-privatisation of the BBC
00:15:18 and for the subscription model to be instituted.
00:15:22 I don't think there's any good case at all for that not happening.
00:15:27 It was designed 100 years ago.
00:15:29 Yes, it's changed in the meantime,
00:15:30 but the way that the commercial landscape is now
00:15:34 the way technology has advanced, barriers to entry for production companies, producers of content online and on television are very low now.
00:15:46 Fixed costs are low economically. There's just no case for forcing people to pay for this.
00:15:52 I disagree completely with that. I'm a proud patriot, but I'm not a neocon. I'm a high Tory.
00:15:56 I believe in noblesse oblige, I believe in educating, and I believe in the BBC as an institution that should stand up for British values,
00:16:03 British culture British history all the things that Lord Reith wanted really to raise the level
00:16:09 of public discourse and exposure to those things that we espouse as being the best of British you
00:16:13 know it was the BBC that had the golden age of British television that got our civilization and
00:16:18 the ascent of man that gave us the great dramas and the great comedies which have become now icons
00:16:22 of British culture it's lost its way and that's the issue is how do we get it back on a footing
00:16:27 where you can have actually decent royal coverage for example I'm a broadcaster Sky has for a long
00:16:33 time been far superior to the BBC where you have Fern Cotton rather than an experienced person
00:16:38 interviewing dogs for the Diamond Jubilee rather than actually focusing on the history and ceremony
00:16:42 of an occasion. It's that loss of ability and it all stems down to despite this great drive for
00:16:48 diversity at the BBC they seem to have forgotten that diversity of opinion is the most important
00:16:52 thing of all and it's that lack of diversity of opinion that has created this groupthink
00:16:56 which has made them so detached from reality and so disconnected from the public at a whole
00:17:01 who are crying out to have someone actually stand up
00:17:04 for British values and British culture,
00:17:06 not necessarily for minority interests all the time,
00:17:08 but to actually celebrate the glories of being British
00:17:11 rather than being ashamed of them
00:17:12 and always told that they are somehow evil
00:17:13 for being white, working class,
00:17:15 or in any way enjoying having a flag on their window.
00:17:19 Well, Mark, I think James and Sophie
00:17:22 may be more likely to get something like their way
00:17:25 than they think,
00:17:27 because the system can't carry on as it is anyway.
00:17:30 I mean, whether you'd like it to change or not, it depends on the licence fee.
00:17:36 The licence fee depends on the public being prepared to pay at the moment £54.50 a year
00:17:42 for something that is of no interest to more and more of them.
00:17:46 And the over-75s from June have to start paying again, which is some 3 million people.
00:17:52 Yeah, but the BBC's problem isn't with the over-75s, it's with the young.
00:17:55 at the moment 16 to 24 years if you take them then fewer than half of them now watch any bbc at all
00:18:02 in a given week now those people are going to become householders when they become householders
00:18:07 when they're told oh 154 pound 50 for what they're going to ask i mean people go home now
00:18:14 they have on their remote control a red button saying netflix netflix instead of pressing the
00:18:20 bbc one button saying well what are the bbc showing showing a lot of them press the netflix
00:18:24 button and they see the netflix home page and that's all they want to see and they work from
00:18:29 there and then the idea so the idea that they therefore have to pay this fee and people who
00:18:34 don't pay this fee they're still getting sent to prison 180 000 people a year prosecuted for not
00:18:40 paying this what now seems an utterly ridiculous fee i mean as sophie said it's not a monopoly
00:18:45 anymore this made sense when the bbc was the only tv there was or the only radio as it was when it
00:18:50 was 10 shillings a week. It was 10 shillings a week for its first 20 years. And that was
00:18:55 fine. But it isn't fine. Now, the BBC is increasingly becoming just part of what's available to
00:19:00 people. Why should everybody pay for what is something that fewer and fewer people are
00:19:06 actually going to watch? Now, you can justify it in terms of the things that you're talking
00:19:10 about, where it's things of national importance that the market wouldn't supply. But most
00:19:15 of the money from the licence fee goes on entertainment. So why should people who don't
00:19:19 want that particular kind of entertainment pay for other people's entertainment especially when
00:19:23 a lot of them are single mothers who face the prospect of prosecution it just doesn't make
00:19:28 sense now this is going to become more and more apparent as these young people can't go through
00:19:34 the system now and and so much is that obvious that you even have um bbc enthusiasts now saying
00:19:41 the bbc has got to have a different kind of funding system or it's doomed the only people
00:19:46 who don't seem to see this are the BBC management themselves
00:19:48 who cling to the licence because they're so frightened
00:19:51 about what would happen if it was taken away from them.
00:19:53 But it seems to me something is going to change anyway.
00:19:57 But what is the first step?
00:19:58 Do you simply wait for that to happen?
00:20:00 Or is it perhaps about...
00:20:02 I mean, Sophie, what do you think about bringing the BBC back?
00:20:04 Because obviously it's kept expanding and expanding.
00:20:06 The internet site and all the internet news is news,
00:20:09 a lot more radio programmes now than there used to be,
00:20:13 radio channels on particular types of youth music
00:20:15 and God knows what, should it ditch the entertainment, which as David was saying is very expensive
00:20:20 and sort of come back to a narrow, more sort of wreathian agenda with that?
00:20:24 I think it should go more global, and it might bring in even more money, and it probably
00:20:29 would. It would bring more money than it does currently from the licence fee if it went
00:20:33 commercial and went global, because all of those little niche channels and programmes,
00:20:38 religion, religious, in the arts, educative
00:20:42 while domestically the market might be small
00:20:46 it could get a huge payment base all over the world
00:20:51 and so I think it should go more global
00:20:52 and it would if it was privatised and start thinking more commercially
00:20:56 and you're right, the BBC has lost its way
00:20:58 a lot of its entertainment because Radio 1 and Radio 2
00:21:01 were forced to compete with other radio stations
00:21:04 you know Big Brother, ITV's reality TV shows, the BBC is being forced to compete with all of that
00:21:11 and that's not what it was supposed to be about and I like you am a huge fan of the BBC and I
00:21:16 would probably pay a subscription fee so I don't see why you don't favour just people like you and
00:21:21 me paying for it and it being privatised and improved and more global thinking. Because it
00:21:26 should be available to all people, that's the whole point of a national service broadcaster,
00:21:29 you want people to actually have access to documentaries on subjects nobody else would
00:21:33 cover. And I think for youth particularly, I mean, the big danger for the Tory party,
00:21:38 I mean, this is why I think Boris Johnson needs to take hold of this, is the fact that
00:21:41 if the election had been held just between those who are under 25 and 18, there would
00:21:46 have been no Tory MPs at all in Parliament, right? Because you have a Department of Education,
00:21:50 secondary school system and universities that are predominantly left. I mean, eight liberals
00:21:54 for everyone Tory and Conservative in a university setting. And the BBC, the few shows that the
00:22:00 youth are watching the mash report or frankie boyle's new world order i mean these are marxist
00:22:06 programs basically david says they're not watching i mean if the youth aren't watching
00:22:09 but those are the shows that they're watching right those are the shows with the youngest
00:22:13 audience and the shows that are targeted at them all they're getting at school and on television
00:22:17 when they watch is a pure marxist agenda that's why you need to have a clearing out of all of this
00:22:21 but i think you put your finger on on the fundamental problem with the bbc i mean i i'm
00:22:25 emotionally sympathetic to your high tory argument but i don't think it's ever going to stack up
00:22:29 and the reason is that if you've got an institution which purports to be for the whole nation
00:22:34 you said yourself it's got to appeal to everyone you have an institution which spends more time
00:22:39 worrying about about appealing to different groups on a kind of a representative level
00:22:45 than it does actually just making good quality programs regardless i i i also kind of dispute
00:22:52 the notion that that that out there are black people who want to watch black black tv and
00:22:58 young people who want to watch young people tv people just want to watch good tv yeah but you
00:23:02 say it should be for everyone i mean no it should be accessible to everyone in the nation i'm not
00:23:06 saying that programs should be made for every every group within that i'm saying there should
00:23:10 be programs about you know british coal miners history about you know the brass bands in the
00:23:14 north everything that should be available for everybody because otherwise you're never going
00:23:18 to learn about that anywhere else and it's television now not books or magazines where
00:23:21 people learn about these things they're not getting this at school programs about the british
00:23:25 empire and the good things of the british empire did you know those are the things which everyone
00:23:28 should have an access to otherwise they're not going to get it anywhere else but it seems to
00:23:32 me that what you you really want is is a different set of values running the british establishment
00:23:36 because the bbc in a way the way it exists it represents the values of the british establishment
00:23:41 and in the older days in the brethian days it reflected those and now the establishment probably
00:23:45 is kind of remainery and liberal elite exactly as was always the case the upper classes and the
00:23:50 working classes are far more far closer on values and on many other things than this removed
00:23:56 meritocratic Islington type of liberal elite bubble and that's the problem they've been
00:24:00 disconnected. But can you solve the BBC without changing the entire British establishment? Mark
00:24:03 Thompson former doctor general said we need to bring more conservatives into positions of power
00:24:07 he said that you know Helen Bowden the former director of BBC News said there is a huge bias
00:24:12 here in terms of immigration migration watch we refuse to take seriously we interviewed
00:24:16 fewer UKIP candidates in 2012 and 2007,
00:24:19 despite its huge growth.
00:24:20 Peter Sissons, John Humphreys, Michael Burke,
00:24:24 I mean, they've all, Jeff Randall,
00:24:25 they've all admitted to it.
00:24:26 Even Andrew Marr, a former Marxist,
00:24:28 said that there's a deep cultural bias here
00:24:29 which needs to be addressed
00:24:30 because that is the very reason,
00:24:32 as with Brexit and the civil service,
00:24:34 all these institutions have become disconnected
00:24:36 from the public.
00:24:37 And, you know, this is a public service broadcasting
00:24:39 and the public would like to see
00:24:41 this sort of broadcasting.
00:24:43 Yeah, the top brass, of course,
00:24:44 are always promising to do something
00:24:45 about this bias but nothing ever changes it's in the nature of this huge public sector institution
00:24:51 and the people it hires who are copies of the people who are there already that it's going to
00:24:55 adopt the values that that permeate the whole of our establishment and i i can't see that changing
00:25:01 while we have the institution that we do have but i do think the institution is going to change it's
00:25:05 going to be forced to change by circumstances i think if sophie's model of people subscribing to
00:25:11 it came that would sort out the woke doctor who issue because people would if people didn't like
00:25:16 it they wouldn't subscribe to it and the bbc well if it was if it did depend on subscriptions for
00:25:21 people who are actually watching it it would then make sure it was giving them what they actually
00:25:24 wanted even if they didn't want a woke doctor well but perhaps but i mean netflix is quite woke
00:25:29 um wokeish yeah yeah it doesn't trigger doesn't trigger me in the same way that the bbc does it
00:25:36 But it's not clear that the market would completely reject those things,
00:25:41 as long as maybe it would improve the quality.
00:25:43 I think the BBC, I think you're right,
00:25:45 I think the BBC would definitely shift its entertainment output
00:25:48 in a less woke direction, because, well, Doctor Who is such a good example.
00:25:52 It's just, it's died on its feet.
00:25:54 It could never survive in a commercial environment,
00:25:57 because we wouldn't have the BBC to bankroll it,
00:26:00 we wouldn't have the viewers to support it.
00:26:01 Well, Doctor Who in general could.
00:26:03 It's a great brand and an amazing sort of...
00:26:06 They've pretty much killed the brand.
00:26:09 I mean, they've pretty much given us a sort of black female Jones Bond, haven't they?
00:26:12 They've done the equivalent thereof.
00:26:15 Well, I haven't seen the figures.
00:26:16 It was, when it first launched, it was quite good.
00:26:18 You know, it had learned from Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
00:26:21 We're talking away, but look, I totally agree.
00:26:23 The one about the statues, Blink, was great.
00:26:27 But even then, that was created by Stephen Moffat, who is now the godfather of Woke.
00:26:34 Definitely our culture has embraced this kind of identity politics, cultural Marxism thing at a very rapid and accelerating rate.
00:26:44 And I think that what may have been true 10 years ago ain't true now.
00:26:48 The BBC is over.
00:26:50 One thing I wanted to mention, one of the few good things on the BBC is Eggheads, that quiz show.
00:26:56 And I understand that the BBC is really bothered by Eggheads, the fact that it's mostly watched by older people.
00:27:02 and they're thinking of scrapping it
00:27:03 just because the audience
00:27:04 don't fit into the right profile.
00:27:05 Now, what kind of institution?
00:27:07 We shouldn't be supporting
00:27:08 an institution like that.
00:27:09 That's wrong.
00:27:10 But you deal with this.
00:27:11 I mean, the solution to me
00:27:12 is quite simple.
00:27:13 It's the Royal Charter.
00:27:14 The Royal Charter sets out
00:27:15 the mandate of the BBC.
00:27:16 That comes up for review
00:27:18 and Johnson simply has to ensure
00:27:20 that the Royal Charter
00:27:21 addresses those issues
00:27:22 and ensures that there is a commitment
00:27:23 to make certain types
00:27:25 of raw broadcasting.
00:27:26 And in terms of the funding model,
00:27:27 I think, you know,
00:27:28 why not bring advertising
00:27:29 into the BBC
00:27:30 but not to interrupt programmes?
00:27:31 Nobody wants to watch a programme that's interrupted.
00:27:33 You put adverts between programmes.
00:27:35 So at the end, people then have the choice to flick over if they want to, but you allow that.
00:27:39 Other broadcasting corporations do that.
00:27:41 I mentioned the Canadians again.
00:27:42 They have advertising within their programmes, and they receive funding in general taxation
00:27:46 because it's the idea of this hypothecated tax, as they want to do for the NHS, that's a problem.
00:27:50 People resent having to pay out directly.
00:27:53 If it came from general taxation, you wouldn't have this sort of an issue,
00:27:56 and that's why in Canada only 10% of Canadians want to see the CBC funding cut.
00:28:01 40% want it to remain as it is.
00:28:02 Another 40% want to see it raised.
00:28:04 I think having this licence fee is a problem
00:28:06 because people then feel that they're being forced to pay a tax.
00:28:10 But when is this up for review?
00:28:12 2026 is the review date,
00:28:15 but there's no reason that Parliament, as we're told, is sovereign.
00:28:18 So there's no reason they couldn't have addressed this before then.
00:28:21 Yes, although, as I was saying earlier,
00:28:23 Boris Johnson might start to look very much like a Prime Minister
00:28:25 who's just trying to hobble his main critic and enemy.
00:28:29 Well, no, Margaret Thatcher wanted to clean up the BBC in 1986,
00:28:32 and certainly Mamadou Hussey did a great deal to improve things then.
00:28:36 And this is the time. We have 10 years.
00:28:38 Tony Blair said we have 10 years to make the Tories unelectable
00:28:41 through mass immigration and all sorts of other issues.
00:28:44 Boris Johnson should say the same thing.
00:28:46 Well, we're nearly out of time,
00:28:48 so I'd just like to go round before we do and ask people,
00:28:51 if we did have a subscription model for the BBC,
00:28:55 would you subscribe?
00:28:56 and what would you subscribe for?
00:28:59 What would be the programme or programmes
00:29:01 that make you want to sign up?
00:29:03 Ralph?
00:29:03 BBC Four and Radio...
00:29:05 I don't have a television,
00:29:06 so I just watch on iPlayer
00:29:08 and Radio Four and BBC Four and Radio Three.
00:29:11 Absolutely stellar, the broadcasting there.
00:29:12 And unlike the other channels,
00:29:14 they actually do try to challenge their own liberal biases.
00:29:16 So you get documentaries on all sorts of subjects
00:29:18 you wouldn't get anywhere else.
00:29:19 Those are...
00:29:20 Worth paying for.
00:29:21 Worth paying for.
00:29:22 David?
00:29:22 Well, I think if there was a subscription out entity
00:29:26 as Sophie suggests
00:29:27 then you would also need
00:29:29 separately something that did the public
00:29:32 service programmes that Rafe is interested in
00:29:34 I think you'd have to have that split
00:29:35 and the entertainment thing I agree with Sophie
00:29:38 if the BBC is as popular as it says
00:29:40 it is, it ought to be able to make
00:29:41 more possibly than it makes out of the
00:29:43 licence fee, and if it went solely
00:29:45 for entertainment, then I think you need
00:29:47 another entity to do the public service
00:29:49 job. Interesting
00:29:51 Sophie? Yeah, I would probably
00:29:53 in fact I would definitely subscribe, I listen to
00:29:55 Radio 4 every morning and when I'm working from home, and also for the films. I'm a big
00:30:01 fan of, despite being a free marketeer and right of centre, I am a big fan of the Marxists
00:30:06 filmmakers like Ken Loach, Ben Wheatley, and they're often subsidised by the BBC, National
00:30:13 Lottery Fund films. So yes, social realism films.
00:30:16 James, would you be signing up for the Marxist films?
00:30:18 No. I watched quite a lot of BBC stuff. The only BBC drama I saw that was good last
00:30:25 year was Geary Hadji which is out on Netflix anyway this year so why would I want to submit
00:30:32 the ordeal of woke I agree with you about BBC four the documentaries are good but that's really
00:30:37 about it and I can't I don't know how you can stomach radio four it is completely unlistenable
00:30:42 across the board well even radio three is losing it I'd pay double for the cancelled woman's hour
00:30:48 I'll just say that in our times it's still pretty good yeah okay in our times right yeah that's not
00:30:55 Not really worth forking out for.
00:30:57 Yeah, I must say, I'd be...
00:30:59 Westminster era.
00:31:02 Anyway, thank you to all my guests.
00:31:05 This has been Counterculture.
00:31:06 Thank you very much for listening.