New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.04: What Will Britain Be Like in 2030?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

189.88

Word count

12,459

Sentence count

395


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to sorry hello I'm Peter Whittle welcome to this edition of counterculture now here
00:00:10 we are at the beginning of a new decade so on this program we're going to be looking forward
00:00:15 to seeing what we would be discussing in the year 2030 what would Britain look like at the end of
00:00:21 this decade to do this we're going to be looking at a few particular areas that is what Britain
00:00:27 look like constitutionally monarchy house of lords the very makeup if you like of the united kingdom
00:00:33 as it now is we're also going to be looking at immigration and the effect it's going to have on
00:00:37 our population then at the same time we're going to be asking questions such as where will the
00:00:42 main threats to our society be coming from how secure will we be and indeed what will the state
00:00:49 be of free speech? Will we be able to say anything that we believe in the year 2030?
00:00:57 Now to discuss this I've got four great guests with me. There's Emma Webb from Civitas,
00:01:02 Benjamin Loughnane who is a communications consultant specialising in migration,
00:01:08 Richard Bingley who is a security expert and founder of the UK NSA think tank, and the New
00:01:14 New Culture Forum's own Rafe Hadelman Koo, he's also an historian and commentator. So Rafe,
00:01:21 I want to start with you because on the quiet you're a bit of a royal commentator and you know
00:01:27 we started off with what seems to be a crisis for the monarchy in some way. Looking for 10 years
00:01:33 first, what kind of a monarchy do you think we will have? Well I rather subscribe to King Farouk
00:01:40 of Egypt's famous adage when he said that eventually there'll only be five kings left,
00:01:44 the king of spades clubs diamonds hearts and england we have a wonderful ability in this
00:01:48 country to evolve and adapt and so whilst the british monarchy looks ancient it's transformed
00:01:53 itself time and time again the monarchy of today is very different to the monarchy of the 90s which
00:01:58 again was very different to the monarchy of the 50s and that's why our monarchy has survived whereas
00:02:02 for example those in germany france and russia have failed and so whilst we're going through a
00:02:07 blip right now i wouldn't call this a full-blown crisis if if prince william had decided not to
00:02:12 fulfill his duties we'd be in a full crisis but as long as we can get through the next 20 years
00:02:17 a bit more work on the shoulders of the princess royal and prince prince edward then perhaps they
00:02:21 would have expected for the next little while until the children of of um of the duchess of
00:02:27 cambridge grow up we'll see the monarchy continuing very much as they are a streamlined monarchy we
00:02:32 won't have all of the monarchy that we see today in the form of the gloucesters and the kents and
00:02:36 the young yorks beatrice and eugenie so it'll be really a monarchy that is streamlined focusing
00:02:41 very much on the heir and the direct line of succession.
00:02:44 So is it right to say it'll be more of a presidential monarchy, in a way?
00:02:48 There's this one figurehead, as it were, you know?
00:02:50 There'll be the direct line.
00:02:51 So you'll always have the sovereign, the Prince of Wales, and the edge of the Prince
00:02:54 of Wales.
00:02:55 It'll be that Holy Trinity, if you want, the Big Three.
00:02:57 If we can go from president to, you know, a World War II analogy of the Big Three, that's
00:03:02 going to be the way the monarchy would always be seen from now on.
00:03:04 I mean, do you think this current thing with Meghan and Harry, has it sort of changed your
00:03:11 attitude to the monarchy in some way uh if anything it's made me more sort of hard in my
00:03:17 in my support of um of the queen and the sort of main line of the royal family i think um what it's
00:03:23 shown is that they're even within the royal family always being a sort of embodiment of the country
00:03:28 as a whole there is this cultural conflict between the sort of liberal individualism
00:03:34 and an almost corporatism of the Sussexes.
00:03:40 Corporatism? So what do you mean?
00:03:41 So their decision to try and transition to being financially independent
00:03:46 and their brand of the Royal Sussex brand,
00:03:50 that in comparison to their wanting to sort of self-actualise
00:03:55 and to be themselves and to be separate from the public eye
00:04:00 and to sort of separate themselves from the sense of duty
00:04:03 that is still very much epitomised by the Queen, obviously first,
00:04:08 but also in William and Kate and in Prince Charles.
00:04:11 So I think in 2030, going back to the original question,
00:04:16 that it's very likely by then that Prince Charles will be king,
00:04:20 relatively likely given the Queen's current age.
00:04:24 And I think that the immediate royal line
00:04:28 still very much embody those values of duty
00:04:32 and immersing the self in the whole
00:04:34 and the selflessness that's traditionally associated
00:04:37 with the concept of nobility
00:04:38 as opposed to what we're seeing from Meghan and Harry.
00:04:43 I mean, the thing is, when you talk about things like
00:04:44 concept of nobility and a sense of novice oblige
00:04:49 and all of these things,
00:04:50 I mean, what does that mean to most young people now?
00:04:54 I mean, do you think these things mean anything to people?
00:04:59 I mean, they're the ones who are going to be, you know, here in 2030.
00:05:01 Well, you're right about No Less of Leagues, absolutely.
00:05:03 That's, I think, what's missing here, certainly with Meghan.
00:05:06 I think she wanted to be a princess, she became a princess,
00:05:09 and then, well, she'd done it.
00:05:10 She was born a bit and moved on.
00:05:13 Is that what you think it is?
00:05:14 Well, I think, you know, when you're not raised in the sense that royalty is duty,
00:05:17 and it's not just something you get to enjoy for a while,
00:05:20 and then you get bored of it and move on,
00:05:21 but it's a lifetime commitment to a vocation which you're born into
00:05:25 and you don't have a choice about.
00:05:27 And I think there's a separation between the two.
00:05:29 there's the disney princess idea and then there's actually you know being in service to your country
00:05:35 and i think you know if you're not raised for that you're not given that sense of you know
00:05:41 obligation then you become disillusioned very quickly and it's interesting because monarchy
00:05:45 actually predates the nation state and marriages were alliances between foreign powers and if you
00:05:50 want to look at history british monarchies often today seem as being a rather you know ethnocentric
00:05:56 British institution it's always been very very multinational and you could argue that it's only
00:06:01 been with the exception of the Queen Mother Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother who's Scottish it's
00:06:05 only been since they stopped marrying other European royals and began to marry English
00:06:09 commoners that we've had problems in the royal family because they weren't raised in the tradition
00:06:13 of knowing about service and duty and that there needs to be some way of ensuring that they're sort
00:06:18 of an apprenticeship school and that's why Prince William was very good in this well actually Prince
00:06:22 william ensured that kate middleton as she then was had a long time to consider the options so
00:06:27 she had several years actually and i thought it was very interesting that you know the future
00:06:31 head of the church of england no one seemed to mind him living in sin you know with kate middleton
00:06:35 as she got to understand that the duties that she would be expected to fulfill and had a long time
00:06:40 to decide whether she wanted it whereas there was only a short courtship with um with megan and
00:06:45 harry yes uh richard you know i think it was the guardian not a well-known monarchist newspaper but
00:06:51 But The Guardian did this great article about what happens when this rain ends.
00:06:55 We're having to, on grounds of taste, be a little bit delicate here.
00:07:00 But they made the point that the country's sort of in denial about the Queen going.
00:07:06 I think the analysis is pretty much correct, if we were just assuming how things are now.
00:07:12 But we're talking about 10 years' time, and there's a lot of black swans in the planet at the moment.
00:07:17 And it's probably logical that we're facing that situation in 10 years' time.
00:07:23 I think when a lot of us think about the monarchy, we, of course, adore the Queen.
00:07:27 But we're not actually thinking about the constitutional position of, say, an unelected head of state.
00:07:32 And there's a whole range of factors coming into this now, I think, in the scenario you outlined.
00:07:39 The first thing is Brexit.
00:07:40 You know, for years, it's taken about 25 years for the country to get its democratic powers back from Brussels.
00:07:47 So the logic might go, particularly with younger people, when the Queen is not there,
00:07:51 well, what's the point of having an unelected head of state that actually doesn't sign off on legislation?
00:07:57 Why don't we have an elected head of state like most other countries?
00:08:01 You know, we are kind of facing these areas of anomalies where a couple of weeks ago we were criticising Iran,
00:08:07 but, you know, Iran has an elected head of state and we don't.
00:08:11 So it's quite difficult to sort of weigh in on the human rights debates globally
00:08:16 as we push forward in this sort of next decade.
00:08:20 I think what hasn't happened with the monarchy is it's not had a political challenge.
00:08:25 The European Union had a political challenge.
00:08:28 Nigel Farage was pretty much inspirational for millions of people.
00:08:32 Then Boris got involved and then a number of other conservative politicians
00:08:36 that had a lot of leverage.
00:08:37 that simply hasn't happened against the royal family at the moment and I think scrolling ahead
00:08:43 in 10 years time there will be significant political players they might be self-motivated
00:08:48 politicians that are looking for an elected presidency and and so I think I subscribe to
00:08:57 all the views around here I think institutionally that the royal family is safe and sound I think
00:09:04 in terms of constitution it's not if I was a betting person I would say in 10 or 15 years time
00:09:08 given that you've got this sort of parallel universe of royal oligarchs that are kind of
00:09:15 semi-detached members of the royal family sort of playing around on a global space that we've
00:09:22 actually got a little bit of risk around whether the royal family survives as providing us with a
00:09:26 head of state. It may well be that we have a ceremonial royal family pushing forward 10 or
00:09:32 15 years time that might not be a bad I'm more optimistic than you are because for the last 40
00:09:37 years ipsis mori and other polling agencies have asked the same question about support for the
00:09:40 monarchy and even during the real annas ribulis of 1992 and again at the time of diana support
00:09:45 for the monarchy never went really below 70 percent it's always been state it's been the
00:09:50 most single stable question ever asked of the great british public people are not separating
00:09:54 their support for the queen from the monarchy and i would be interested to see that polling in five
00:09:57 this time i think actually the most the most recent poll did actually support that even though
00:10:02 it was less of a support amongst millennials to boomers that this is the real issue very much in
00:10:06 favor but in 2030 those boomers will have obviously aged and there will be an entire
00:10:10 you know chunk of people that are you know slightly less in favor and i think that what
00:10:15 we're risking actually the lot of the arguments that's been ironically being made by the people
00:10:20 who are in favor of the royal family they're trying to find ways to justify the royal family
00:10:26 in the terms that usually define the public debate.
00:10:30 So talking about, for example, the financial benefits that we get from the royal family,
00:10:34 that they're an investment.
00:10:36 That's not the right way to be talking about the royal family.
00:10:38 And I think that actually once the boomers are older
00:10:40 and that the population younger demographic are the majority,
00:10:47 that actually we need to be careful in finding conservative ways
00:10:52 to justify the existence of the monarchy.
00:10:56 rather than looking at those arguments that are actually far more on the sort of like Meghan and Harry corporate sort of way of justifying.
00:11:03 And this is the single greatest threat.
00:11:05 It is a story of the long march for the institutions yet again, because nowhere are the young of today getting that story.
00:11:11 All that they receive is a story about democracy equals one man, one vote.
00:11:15 That's crude majoritarianism.
00:11:17 That leads to mob rule, particularly in a parliamentary system of government,
00:11:19 when you have an elected dictator really in the form of a prime minister with a strong majority.
00:11:23 And you need to have the check of the crown there.
00:11:25 and that's not taught and we're always basically taught as Madeleine Albright said in America we
00:11:29 don't do kings that's become the sort of attitude over in this country and it's the failure of our
00:11:34 university systems and our school systems to actually effectively teach people about the
00:11:38 long history of the crown the importance of separating those who hold power from those
00:11:43 who actually rule and reign that distinction is not made any longer and I think future generations
00:11:50 having been denied that education may well go down the republican path and so if this next
00:11:55 decade i say you know in 79 thatcher got elected 2019 we've had boris johnson he has the next 10
00:12:01 years to make johnsonianism the the 20 in the 20s what thatcherism became to the 80s not just for
00:12:07 the economy but also for culture and really try to reverse that long march that began in 97 in
00:12:12 some way and it depends on how bold he'll be with with the monarchy we've got a very interesting
00:12:17 question of most
00:12:19 people being born with the current
00:12:20 Queen and accepting that she is who she is
00:12:23 and since before
00:12:24 you were born. She's what 67
00:12:26 years now she's been on Australia
00:12:28 the vast majority of people
00:12:30 Of course we're actually going to have something which we've never had in history
00:12:33 before, a platinum jubilee
00:12:34 in a couple of years time.
00:12:36 Two years. God willing.
00:12:39 And
00:12:39 what will the reaction be when
00:12:42 Charles then is the
00:12:44 heir and we have a question
00:12:47 of coronation, will it happen? There will certainly be people pushing against this happening.
00:12:53 And even if it goes ahead, and it probably will, what sort of king will Charles be? That
00:12:59 will, I think, determine a lot of people's attitude towards the monarchy going forward.
00:13:03 I think it's important to realise that, say, 20 years ago, there was no hope of Jeremy
00:13:08 Corbyn becoming leader of the Labour Party. He was massively on the fringe, there were
00:13:12 risks of them being deselected. What that small group were able to do was build a brand
00:13:18 and they were able to build what was basically an internal insurgency within the Labour Party.
00:13:23 To some extent the same happened with Brexit. There was an alliance formed, they were viewed
00:13:28 as outsiders, it attracted the mainstream and it got 17.4 million votes in 2016. What hasn't
00:13:34 happened is the same against the monarchy. For example, people calling themselves Republicans
00:13:41 in Britain will not succeed. We do not do republicanism for very good reasons, you know,
00:13:47 to do with Ireland and the rest of it. But over in America, they do republicanism, you know,
00:13:51 even bad presidents pull up 40%. So it's about messaging, brand building. I think if they start
00:13:57 calling themselves Democrats, I think if senior politicians that look good on television get
00:14:02 behind the democratic movement, I think the royal family as the constitutional head of the UK is at
00:14:09 risk that's what i'm saying in 10 years time i think there'll be a big debate around it
00:14:13 and um it's not necessarily i can't necessarily see that the head of state will be from the royal
00:14:19 family um maybe not in 10 years but i certainly i think there's a grave risk of that not happening
00:14:24 the idea of president blair i think will ensure that it is for a long time remaining with the
00:14:28 crown it sounds like a negative kind of reason but that is a very very good thing to point out
00:14:34 What I find interesting about this, compared to, you mentioned the Annus Corribilis,
00:14:39 this was 1992 when things were going really wrong,
00:14:43 is that if you were a monarchist then, you really were a lonely person.
00:14:48 And there would have been an argument for saying, to go forward to the year 2019,
00:14:52 that we wouldn't have a monarchy, actually. That was feasible.
00:14:55 But what I find interesting here is that no one is saying
00:14:58 that there will not be the institution here in 10 years.
00:15:01 No, I think you've put your finger on one of the big issues,
00:15:03 which is the fact that under Victoria and Elizabeth you had young monarchs
00:15:07 who captured the new spirit of the new Elizabethan age of 1952.
00:15:11 And just think if King George VI had lived as long as his wife did
00:15:15 and the king didn't die until 2002
00:15:17 and Queen Elizabeth II had become queen in 2002, 50 years after she actually did.
00:15:22 How would that have changed our attitude towards the sovereign?
00:15:25 And I think it's the fact that we're going to have a series,
00:15:27 because of medicine and science and people living longer,
00:15:30 a series of old monarchs coming to the throne in the foreseeable future,
00:15:33 lacking that vitality to engage and to invigorate a new generation of youth.
00:15:40 And that idea, I think, might be, this is going perhaps beyond 2030,
00:15:44 I think our monarchy, which is currently the last one not to do abdication,
00:15:48 I think we might see a situation where monarchs in this country
00:15:50 begin to abdicate at the age of 75
00:15:51 in order to try to capture some of that youth of monarchy.
00:15:54 It also means there's a longer period as well
00:15:57 where the air is sort of exposed to the public
00:16:00 without being in the sort of closed and dignified position of being the monarch.
00:16:04 So someone like Charles has lived his entire life into old age in the public eye,
00:16:10 and it's very difficult to not trip up and not to have some kind of effect
00:16:14 on public opinion during that period of time.
00:16:16 So when they become the monarch, they're still seen as what they were before, I think.
00:16:20 I have to say that if we were sitting here in 2030 discussing all of this,
00:16:24 I would love it, dare I say, if we were talking about King William and Queen Catherine.
00:16:30 But I know that I'm probably in a minority now.
00:16:32 That's not going to happen.
00:16:33 It's going to be King Charles III, or indeed George VII, I think it might be.
00:16:39 If he chooses that name.
00:16:40 If he chooses that.
00:16:40 That would sort of be a bit absurd now that people know him so well.
00:16:44 Maybe 2050.
00:16:45 Richard, you mentioned about the effect of Brexit in the democratic sense.
00:16:53 Where does this leave, therefore, things such as the House of Lords?
00:16:55 I mean, we are hearing it's now on the agenda, is it not?
00:17:00 that what happens to the House of Lords,
00:17:02 something that we've lived with now for however long,
00:17:05 ten years' time, will we still be talking about the House of Lords?
00:17:09 Yeah, well, I think Blair's reforms were the death knells
00:17:12 of the House of Lords in terms of respectability
00:17:14 because it's one thing to accept people who are life peers
00:17:19 as being unelected.
00:17:20 It's another thing to have former politicians, failed politicians,
00:17:24 rejected by the electorate being made lords, baroness.
00:17:27 In a way, that's so much more undemocratic.
00:17:29 Well, absolutely.
00:17:30 That it delegitimises the institution.
00:17:33 The irony is that the most democratic element in the House of Lords are the hereditaries
00:17:36 because they're actually elected to their position, unlike everybody else there.
00:17:40 I mean, I did a report with Roger Scruton and Frank Field almost 10 years ago now
00:17:43 looking into reform of the House of Lords because it is now neither fish nor fowl.
00:17:47 We have the world's second largest chamber after China.
00:17:51 Ours is the only chamber apart from Iran that has clerics in it.
00:17:55 I mean, it's very hard to justify these things in this day and age.
00:17:58 And yet since 1911 we've been trying to reform this under Lloyd George
00:18:00 and we still haven't achieved it.
00:18:02 And when we did try it on Attorney Blair, it was done on the back of an envelope,
00:18:05 which also got rid of the Lord Chancellor's position in a terrible way
00:18:07 and meddling around there.
00:18:09 I mean, terrible constitutional balls up, if I can say, under Blair.
00:18:14 But I fear that there is no vested interest really in the Conservative Party
00:18:17 or the Labour Party tackling the House of Lords
00:18:19 because it suits them too much to keep it as it is.
00:18:23 I'm not sure.
00:18:24 I think there's a political reality that the House of Lords is just completely untenable,
00:18:30 particularly for a lot of younger people.
00:18:33 Do they even know what it even does?
00:18:35 I think people do.
00:18:37 You know, they're acutely aware.
00:18:38 We're all aware of what the House of Lords did or didn't do over Brexit.
00:18:40 Well, this is the point, isn't it?
00:18:41 This is the big difference.
00:18:42 I think that's a living case study of why it should be superseded by something that's elected.
00:18:48 The challenge of the House of Lords is that we have moved quite rapidly into a wokish world.
00:18:54 and an ethical world where everybody's judged by their contribution to ethics and kind of moral
00:18:59 outlook and and so britain has always been very good at that it's punched at a global weight on
00:19:04 human rights and ethics and morality and it won't be able to do that if it has an unelected house
00:19:10 of lords and an unelected kind of upper tier to its constitution as we push forward we we simply
00:19:15 will not be taken seriously uh in kind of the global media uh circles that we have to operate
00:19:21 in. I think there's a manifestly unjust case for keeping the House of Lords. The manifestly
00:19:30 unjust case for keeping the House of Lords is basically that it entrenches a two-party
00:19:33 system. You have had political parties that have been not getting as many votes on the
00:19:39 fringes that have raised the House of Lords validity over the last couple of rounds of
00:19:44 elections and it's one of these things that's easy to fix as well you know it's it's it's not
00:19:51 difficult to come up with a workable solution you know the Scots have got a parliament Welsh
00:19:56 have got a parliament maybe we have an aperteer that that's an English elected parliament maybe
00:20:00 we have one that's it's one elected senator per county it's just one of those anachronisms that
00:20:05 doesn't seem to work very well so you know so we won't have a house of lords in 10 years
00:20:10 I think we probably will.
00:20:11 We'll have a House of Lords for a long time to come.
00:20:13 I mean, firstly, in the next 10 years, Brexit will be the major issue.
00:20:17 There are simply too many issues on the plate to start tackling something as major as the House of Lords.
00:20:21 But the fact that you're going to have to deal with Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland,
00:20:25 there is hope for the House of Lords to become a sort of a regional assembly,
00:20:28 as you have in America or in Canada, for example, where the upper house deals with the regions.
00:20:32 And so as a quasi-federal, giving Scotland and Wales and England an allocation of seats there
00:20:38 in order to represent the local issues.
00:20:39 and I've advocated having non-partisan elections there
00:20:42 so that they're not tied to party politics
00:20:44 as it has done in Nebraska, for example.
00:20:47 These are independents who stand up,
00:20:48 who were born and raised in an area
00:20:50 and stand up for local interests and local people
00:20:52 and advance those without fear of any whip telling them how to vote.
00:20:55 And I think that would keep the independence of the House of Lords,
00:20:58 which is very important.
00:20:59 And I also like the idea of having a pantheon of the great,
00:21:01 to have the best businessmen, the best scientists,
00:21:03 the best sportsmen, the best people from the arts and industry
00:21:07 who can give all of their input.
00:21:08 And, of course, the greatest statesmen, you know, Lady Thatcher and others,
00:21:11 why shouldn't they be able to have a role to play in Parliament after they've left office
00:21:15 if they have valuable contributions to make?
00:21:17 Maybe call it something else.
00:21:19 Maybe it doesn't have to be the House of Lords or whatever.
00:21:21 I don't know.
00:21:22 I mean, I sort of feel, I don't know, but I think a lot of people felt this.
00:21:25 You know, I loved the tradition of it all until Brexit, actually.
00:21:31 And I found that I even got impatient of the rituals
00:21:34 because these people were blocking the very thing we'd voted for.
00:21:38 I think though that what happened over the course of the Brexit shenanigans isn't enough of an argument against the Lords to justify doing away with it.
00:21:50 I think if we're thinking in constitutional terms, the first thing that you would think there would be an appetite for going for would be the Supreme Court,
00:21:57 because that's something that's completely alien to our constitution.
00:22:00 The House of Lords really is the cronyism we don't like.
00:22:02 We don't like all of those people who were social welfare workers and suddenly become peers for seemingly having done little.
00:22:07 the question is will it be there in 10 years time and if so what format i just think there's going
00:22:13 to be a massive pressure towards democratization of that and i actually think it's a big win for
00:22:18 any but if i was boris in four years time i'd put in the manifesto some form of massive reform for
00:22:24 the house i think it's a big winner uh it's one of these big unspoken things that um when you've
00:22:29 got to re-win about 80 or 90 constituencies that you're not used to winning a lot of them in the
00:22:33 the north of england it's an easy thing to do particularly with quite a big majority i think
00:22:38 almost to do it though to democratize the entire house of lords i think we'd almost do away with
00:22:43 the point so it'll then become competitive with the house of commons they'll both claim mandates
00:22:48 and they both claim to represent the people what would the country be that these chambers
00:22:55 are governing will it still be a united kingdom do you think scotland would have gone by i don't
00:23:00 I don't think Scotland's going anywhere.
00:23:02 You don't?
00:23:02 No.
00:23:03 I mean, it depends very much on who, you know,
00:23:07 what happens politically generally
00:23:10 and with the Labour Party, for example.
00:23:12 But I think the way that we're going,
00:23:14 the Conservative Party are likely to be in for the next 10 years.
00:23:18 Again, depending on who is in the Labour Party,
00:23:21 even if Labour were to win.
00:23:22 And if, for example, Lisa Nandy...
00:23:25 Nandy?
00:23:26 That's very mine.
00:23:27 They're very well known, aren't they?
00:23:29 Lisa Nando.
00:23:30 if she's the person who becomes Labour leader
00:23:35 then I think
00:23:36 even if Labour were to get in
00:23:39 it would be very unlikely that there would be another
00:23:41 referendum for Scotland, there's just too
00:23:42 good an argument against not allowing them to have
00:23:45 another referendum, and even still
00:23:47 I don't think that the polls are even now
00:23:49 so close that it's
00:23:51 unlikely that they would
00:23:52 Do you care about that?
00:23:54 I do care, but I'm of the opinion that
00:23:57 Scottish independence becomes null and void
00:23:59 as of 11pm on January the 31st of this year
00:24:01 because once we leave the EU, Scotland is out of the EU
00:24:04 and Scotland will not be allowed back into the EU
00:24:07 with its economy the way that it is.
00:24:09 And the choice for Scotland of leaving the UK and the EU
00:24:12 is virtual suicide, I would say.
00:24:14 I totally agree with Raith.
00:24:16 I think, again, if we're looking at five or ten years' time,
00:24:19 Scotland's got a question to ask itself.
00:24:21 Does it want to remain part of an economy
00:24:24 that's the fifth biggest in the world?
00:24:25 Exactly.
00:24:25 You know, it's likely to boom after we exit the European Union.
00:24:30 It has, at the moment, an abnormally high amount of nationalist votes.
00:24:35 You know, if, for example, Nigel Farage said some of the things that Nicola Sturgeon said,
00:24:39 he'd be pretty much facing court inquiries.
00:24:42 You know, so I think people have probably had their feel of Nicola Sturgeon and nationalism.
00:24:46 And you'll probably see it settle quite a lot down, I think, over the next few years.
00:24:49 I mean, in terms of polling, I wasn't quite clear.
00:24:51 it seems to me that the polling replicates what the vote was last time tends to it's just slightly
00:24:57 narrow and the conservative party did very well i think in scotland i think actually also as you
00:25:02 were saying it depends very much on how the eu looks given the amount of time it would take for
00:25:07 another referendum potentially to happen in scotland or anything could have happened um within
00:25:13 the eurozone bearing in mind that they would have to rejoin they would have to join the um they would
00:25:19 have to join the eurozone if they were going to go back into the EU and it's possible that by then
00:25:24 we would have had another eurozone crisis and we would talk about what we were talking about
00:25:29 in 2010 we were talking about Iran and the eurozone crisis so I think that it's very possible that
00:25:36 this time in 10 years we'll be talking potentially about some kind of other crisis within the EU and
00:25:42 that's not necessarily going to be something that Scotland wants to shackle itself to.
00:25:46 Just to round this off nicely, this part of our discussion,
00:25:49 you say a crisis within the EU.
00:25:51 Will there actually be a recognisable EU in 2030?
00:25:55 I mean, a really important topic nobody is talking about,
00:25:58 apart from in Germany, is the rise of Germany.
00:26:01 You know, for about 20 years now, in Germany,
00:26:04 there's been massive debates around sort of reintroducing real politics,
00:26:08 about defining what national policy looks like
00:26:12 on a foreign and defence level.
00:26:13 I think now Britain is just about to leave the European Union, that Germany pretty much has free economic reign to develop the military and economic structures that they want.
00:26:24 At the moment, there happens to be great governance in Germany, whether we agree with Merkel or not.
00:26:28 The governmental kind of structures work.
00:26:33 But ultimately, I think after January of the universe,
00:26:36 you're going to see a massive polarisation
00:26:38 between British national defence and economic interests
00:26:44 and Germany kind of taking the European block away.
00:26:47 And to come back to the Scotland question is,
00:26:49 well, where would the Scottish people want to sit there?
00:26:51 I think it would become quite vivid to them in a couple of years' time
00:26:54 that they probably should remain part of the United Kingdom.
00:26:57 I actually don't think they want to leave the United Kingdom.
00:27:00 I think they have certain sentiments, anti-English sentiments or frustrations,
00:27:06 but I don't think it's the independence that they want.
00:27:09 I think they just want more control over the United Kingdom,
00:27:12 more of a say in the destiny of Britain as a whole.
00:27:16 And they probably have disproportionate say already, but they want more.
00:27:21 I was actually recently in Scotland and made a point of talking to as many people as possible.
00:27:26 Almost everyone I met was SNP.
00:27:27 they were all very you know pro-independence um you know even saw someone try to start a fight
00:27:35 over it because they were it was just straight after the um election result um and they were
00:27:41 obviously feeling very heated about it but i think that what comes out of the arguments i mean it's
00:27:45 very easy to sympathize with their nationalism and in a way it's a nationalism that the english
00:27:51 created um we helped to contribute to that nationalism through the sort of victorian
00:27:56 romanticism of Scotland and its identity and culture and even though it's very easy to sort
00:28:06 of sympathize with that nationalism I think that a lot of the people that I spoke to there was a
00:28:12 sense that they just felt that they were being ignored unjustly that they didn't have you know
00:28:16 that they're a very proud people and they want to be taken seriously but I don't think that
00:28:22 necessarily translates into actual political change and again it's interesting isn't it again
00:28:26 it goes down to education you mentioned William Wallace and this idea that the the Scots just like
00:28:30 people in Africa were colonized by the English and throwing off the yoke of the oppressor when
00:28:35 as everyone knows it was the Scots who were at the forefront of empire they were the great empire
00:28:39 builders and the great engineers and leading the forefront of the of the Scottish regiments going
00:28:43 out and colonizing and it's only in recent years that you've seen the S&P try to somehow draw a
00:28:48 connection between them and and this idea that the Empire was a solely English
00:28:51 initiative. Can I go back to this point about the EU? You know one of the
00:28:57 arguments or not exactly the argument but basically one of the points that was
00:29:00 endlessly made during the referendum was that once we go we are going to set off
00:29:05 this massive movement of people wanting to leave the EU. Is that rubbish or do you
00:29:12 see that happening? We haven't left yet so it's hard to say. We need to prove that it's
00:29:16 that was going to work for us.
00:29:17 Right, OK.
00:29:18 But I mean, I'm thinking again of a decade hence.
00:29:21 I think there is definitely...
00:29:22 So, again, going back to another potential Eurozone crisis,
00:29:27 in places like the Netherlands or in Germany,
00:29:29 there's definitely a sense that as net contributors,
00:29:33 if there is further integration,
00:29:34 they don't want to be subsidising the rest of the European Union.
00:29:37 That's definitely...
00:29:39 There's definitely a strong Eurosceptic movement,
00:29:41 though there's a sort of futility to it,
00:29:44 that in Italy for example or in the Netherlands the feeling that because we're in the eurozone
00:29:49 we can't pull away from it but I think if there is another eurozone crisis we might start to see
00:29:54 if given the choice between full fiscal union and leaving the eurozone or leaving the EU that you
00:30:03 might actually start to see countries pulling back for obvious reasons of national interest
00:30:09 so it's not implausible but I think probably won't necessarily happen in the next 10 years
00:30:14 How are we doing?
00:30:16 Yeah, fine.
00:30:17 Fine, because we want to go on for a lot longer.
00:30:20 Can we carry on?
00:30:21 Yeah.
00:30:21 Okay, yeah.
00:30:23 What's likely, I think, if you look at the European Union,
00:30:28 is there's lots of internal cooperation between six or seven countries,
00:30:31 you know, the Benelux countries, in terms of police rationalisation,
00:30:35 police procurement, counter-terrorism responses.
00:30:37 And then there's those kind of operations other countries
00:30:41 don't particularly want to get involved with.
00:30:44 So maybe it's some of the central European countries that have got a more national focus on defence.
00:30:49 So there's that already going on, which will trouble Germany and France.
00:30:56 There's also kind of the dynamic at the moment with Viktor Orban in Hungary,
00:31:01 and you've got President Zeeman in the Czech Republic, and then the Polish president as well.
00:31:08 Who are Eurosceptic?
00:31:09 I mean, they kind of say publicly that they support the European Union.
00:31:12 They drill as much funding out of it as they can, but then they go back home and win elections by saying they're going to tear up various EU agreements.
00:31:20 You have all these machinations, which is usual, but ultimately the test will be the big three.
00:31:27 So it's going to be what happens in the French presidential election, what happens in the German federal election, and probably what happens in the Italian elections.
00:31:34 if any of those big countries put forward or a Eurosceptic wins
00:31:39 I think the EU is dust frankly
00:31:41 and I think it will go back to being an economic alliance
00:31:45 I think we'll see a very slim down EU
00:31:46 exactly you've also had this really interesting scenario in the Gulf
00:31:49 there's the Gulf Cooperation Council of the six states
00:31:52 where Saudi Arabia and one of the Emiratis
00:31:55 is pushing forward with sort of unification in a load of areas
00:31:59 and the rest of them are not interested
00:32:01 so you've got this kind of twin dynamic going on
00:32:03 And I think coming to 10 years' time, to answer the question,
00:32:06 that the European Union will be German-led, but it will be fractured.
00:32:10 I think the key thing also to remember is it's up to us to make Brexit a success
00:32:14 because the two key aims of the EU during the post-referendum negotiations
00:32:20 was to make it so difficult and so hard for us to leave
00:32:23 that it would deter other separatist movements throughout the EU.
00:32:27 And they succeeded because there was a Brexit movement.
00:32:29 There was talk of leaving the EU in Italy and in France and in Greece and elsewhere.
00:32:33 and they suddenly turned their backs on that idea
00:32:35 when they saw how hard it was for the UK
00:32:38 and they thought, if the UK of all countries can't leave,
00:32:40 what hope do we have?
00:32:41 Mind you, they didn't have to leave.
00:32:42 And they didn't have, but they didn't have,
00:32:43 and that's just it.
00:32:44 We had, unfortunately, if Boris had got in 2016,
00:32:46 things would have been very different
00:32:48 and the EU would be in a much different position, I think.
00:32:50 And so we have to really make good
00:32:52 on having had such a bad few years.
00:32:54 The problem with that is every single newspaper
00:32:56 in the European Union, outside of the UK,
00:32:59 does not give us good coverage.
00:33:00 So we won't acknowledge, if we're booming,
00:33:01 the newspapers in France and Germany are not going to cover that
00:33:04 and not going to tell their populations
00:33:06 it could be the most successful country on the planet
00:33:09 but they're not going to hear about it in Europe
00:33:10 just travelling throughout Europe over the past few years
00:33:12 when you see the press
00:33:14 it's astounding how pro-European it is
00:33:17 in terms of Britain
00:33:18 it's like Britain's a mess, Britain's a joke
00:33:21 one thing about Britain
00:33:24 is that in 10 years time
00:33:27 we will have a much bigger population
00:33:30 will we not Ben?
00:33:31 We will. We're set to reach a population of 70 million by 2030.
00:33:36 70 million?
00:33:37 70 million.
00:33:38 By 2030?
00:33:39 By 2030.
00:33:39 So, and that is based on, is that a conservative estimate?
00:33:43 They always are conservative estimates.
00:33:45 That's, I believe, the ONS projections.
00:33:48 That would be the Office of National Statistics.
00:33:50 So it's a government...
00:33:51 Yeah, government, and that, I think, is a very conservative estimate.
00:33:55 It's likely to be 70 million by around 2027, I'd say,
00:34:00 and even higher by 2030 but we began the decade with David Cameron coming out and promising to
00:34:06 reduce immigration to the tens of thousands it was in the 2010 manifesto for the conservatives
00:34:12 it was in the 2015 manifesto and it was in the 2017 manifesto and they failed every time to
00:34:18 meet that target they didn't get close it increased every time Boris Johnson and the new
00:34:25 conservative regime, so to speak, completely scrapped the tens of thousands figure they've
00:34:30 gone for, reduce overall, whatever that means. But again, I'm very sceptical as to whether
00:34:36 that promise will be kept, because they haven't said how they're going to do it. They don't
00:34:41 even seem to intend to do it.
00:34:43 Well, I was going to ask you, there's a point with the whole immigration issue, which I
00:34:48 would say is the premier importance for the country. Is there the political will? Is there
00:34:55 the political world. People talk a lot now about disconnects, don't they, between governments
00:35:00 and people. I can't think of an issue on which there is a greater disconnect.
00:35:04 Well, I think it's not in the interest of the Conservatives necessarily at the moment
00:35:08 to be tough on immigration because there isn't any other party waiting in the wings to hold
00:35:12 them to account if they don't. Labour would, whatever the Conservatives do on immigration,
00:35:18 Labour will do worse. And of course, when you had the rising threat of UKIP to the Conservatives,
00:35:24 they started to get very tough and they started to say things that were very sort of promising
00:35:27 and to try and stave off the threat of UKIP to, well, to the seats that they wanted to
00:35:35 hold on to effectively.
00:35:37 But now we're in a situation where the Brexit party is effectively a non-entity in terms
00:35:43 of UK Parliament, in the EU Parliament, where it was a big threat, but we're leaving the
00:35:49 EU, God willing, you know, at the end of the month.
00:35:52 And so there doesn't seem to be any real threat to the Conservatives.
00:35:56 Although there is the other dynamic as well that Boris, he even said, you know, these people in the new blue wall have lent me their vote.
00:36:06 And obviously immigration is something that is of a concern to the Conservatives' new demographic.
00:36:11 And if they want to stay in for another five years after their current term,
00:36:17 then they're going to have to start listening to the concerns of that demographic
00:36:22 on things like security, immigration, extremism, and that kind of thing.
00:36:27 So even if the Labour Party don't really pose them any challenge on policy on that front,
00:36:34 I think there are sort of sounds that they are going to have to take that seriously,
00:36:39 otherwise they're going to be held accountable by their new electorate.
00:36:43 I think coming out of the European Union almost is one of the natural solutions to this issue, isn't it?
00:36:51 If you support lower immigration, the free movement basically into the UK ends on the 31st of January.
00:37:00 I think because the Conservative Party until June of 2019 was pro-EU,
00:37:07 that they have just simply not been able to solve this political issue,
00:37:11 Even though they've promised in manifestos to cut immigration, they've not been able to solve it because they were inherently pro-EU.
00:37:18 It's an irreconcilable difference.
00:37:22 So I think what you're seeing is, I think Boris will try and handle the manifesto commitment.
00:37:29 I think he's got the operating environment to do it.
00:37:32 But you're actually seeing something like 25 years of catch-up.
00:37:35 Because the Labour Party, it had policies, but it totally lost control of the UK immigration system.
00:37:42 It was just an utter, horrible mess that was handed over to the Conservative Party in 2010.
00:37:48 And I think the Conservative Party did try to grip it.
00:37:51 I think the intention was there.
00:37:53 But operationally, they could not, because we still remained in the EU.
00:37:57 So huge amounts of people were still coming in,
00:38:01 but at the same time they were still having to handle
00:38:03 the managed immigration from outside the European Union.
00:38:06 So I just think operationally it became a mess
00:38:07 under the Conservative Party.
00:38:09 But one of the standout things about immigration, of course,
00:38:15 is it follows successful economies.
00:38:18 So if we want London and Great Britain to be successful after Brexit,
00:38:24 then we should not expect low immigration applications.
00:38:27 Yeah, but you see, look, I mean, you know, a country isn't just a balance sheet, is it?
00:38:33 I mean, this is the point, you know, this is always used to justify immigration, fair enough,
00:38:41 but we're talking about unprecedented levels of migration.
00:38:45 I mean, but will, do you think that in 2030, 10 years' time,
00:38:49 that the level of migration that we have now, round about what, a quarter of them in net?
00:38:54 270,000.
00:38:54 270,000. Will that still be going on then, do you think?
00:38:57 Unless we see some quite radical changes in a number of different areas, I imagine it will.
00:39:05 Because there are areas you need to change policy in order to accommodate a reduction in immigration.
00:39:10 We've come to rely on immigration in a number of areas.
00:39:13 For example, the NHS. We don't train staff, and those we do train leave the country.
00:39:20 There's a big cultural change that needs to be made if we want to reduce the need for immigration.
00:39:25 and it's always touted as oh well we need immigration for this for that but we only
00:39:29 need it because of those policy changes we've made
00:39:31 so i think we need to look at why the key drives of immigration in this country
00:39:38 look at why they exist and try to reverse them if we want to lower immigration it's not as simple
00:39:43 as just saying close the door and that's why i say boris johnson has a chance to make the 20s
00:39:49 his version of thatcher's 80s thatcher turned the country around economically he can do the same
00:39:54 thing if he focuses on skills in the north of england prime area to actually educate the
00:39:58 population into new areas of employment because let's not you know make no bones about this by
00:40:03 2030 i think we're going to overtake france as the next most populous country and eventually
00:40:08 we're going to be larger than germany by i think 2050 or something like that in terms of population
00:40:12 that's huge you know london will be the only mega city in europe apart from those that are in asia
00:40:17 and africa and the americas so that's phenomenal let's just put it another way at no point in
00:40:23 history have so many people in this country been born abroad it's now around 13 percent in the
00:40:29 1990s it was around six percent eight percent before that it was around six percent up until
00:40:34 the 50s it was below four percent even during the roman empire it was only around four to eight
00:40:38 percent under the vikings was around eight percent under the normans around five percent all right
00:40:42 so this myth that we're told about britain was always a melting pot yes there are always people
00:40:46 here from around the world my family came in 1940 with the polish government but there was nothing
00:40:51 like this and you know all all countries need time to assimilate and this is not a slight against the
00:40:56 immigrants if you go to the costa del sol if you go to dubai you find english enclaves where they're
00:41:00 reading the the sun and watching coronation street and don't speak a word of the local language
00:41:04 it's a human instinct if there are enough of you to not to assimilate and social cohesion and
00:41:09 assimilating a society it only works if you have controlled managed immigration at a low level
00:41:14 otherwise you ask for troubles that's why america's greatest period of growth was during the period
00:41:19 from 1915 to 1975,
00:41:22 the period when it managed to get
00:41:23 all of its civil rights and social cohesion,
00:41:25 was the period when it had its lowest immigration
00:41:27 and when immigration heated
00:41:29 up using the
00:41:31 troubles of today. The thing is,
00:41:33 this narrative you mentioned about
00:41:35 we're a nation of immigrants and that London was built by
00:41:37 immigrants, etc. I mean,
00:41:39 is this going to really be challenged?
00:41:41 I mean, this is what young people now are growing
00:41:43 up with. The fact is, you're quite right,
00:41:45 it's just factual.
00:41:47 In fact, we have waves of migration
00:41:49 but certainly not enough to mean that we're actually a nation of migrants or a Mongol nation.
00:41:56 We've never had this sort of immigration before in the past.
00:41:59 This is unprecedented completely.
00:42:01 And what shows it more than anything is the direction of integration.
00:42:05 Previously, historically, when people came over here,
00:42:08 they became English or they became British or Scottish or Welsh,
00:42:12 wherever they went, they adapted to the culture and the identity of the area where they were
00:42:17 and they blended in because it was in their interest to do so.
00:42:20 But now what happens is a lot of people move over,
00:42:22 they live in small areas together.
00:42:24 You see not just ghettoisation, but also people,
00:42:28 you know, certain areas become culturally similar
00:42:31 to the people who've moved there.
00:42:33 And then the British indigenous people
00:42:35 then start to integrate with the culture
00:42:38 that has gone into that area,
00:42:40 rather than people adapting just towards British culture.
00:42:44 And actually you do hear people making the argument
00:42:45 for two-way integration that we need to sort of find some middle ground between us and the people
00:42:50 who have come here even though there are you know an enormous variety of people who have come here
00:42:55 my family also came from kenya having been in india before then and that's because the pools
00:42:59 of immigration we used to have were from the commonwealth so they had the english language
00:43:02 they had a british education system they had the queen or the king a portrait there and the church
00:43:07 of england so there was an easy transition now when you're drawing from parts of the world that
00:43:10 have no connection whatsoever to britain no history no ties of any sort assimilation is very
00:43:15 hard and needs to be managed very carefully and i see no effort being made at all to instill those
00:43:20 those values and and essences of britishness in them and this this new points-based system
00:43:25 that we hear about now are you skeptical of that or well i think it's a slogan more than it is a
00:43:30 policy focus groups very well to say australian style because people think australia good
00:43:36 immigration system okay well that yeah i'm happy with that uh but how is it going to be delivered
00:43:40 uh will there be caps will there be limits what sort of people are coming what's what are the
00:43:44 points going to be determined on and also we already have a points-based system we have done
00:43:48 since i believe gordon brown um and and that clearly hasn't been working for the past 11 or
00:43:55 12 years so really it's not about the slogan it's not about how it focus groups it's about how it's
00:44:01 implemented and the nature and the rate and the numbers uh that are consequent of of that system
00:44:09 i think one of the the hallmarks of immigration is is that it's just a complete and utter mess
00:44:15 in the way that it's been managed or mismanaged and i mean you talk about the point space system
00:44:20 yes it was introduced by gordon brown they didn't really message it very well because none of us
00:44:25 really know that it was introduced by the labour party um but the fact is that that wasn't
00:44:29 implemented you know it was it was put through as regulations within the civil service it simply was
00:44:34 was not implemented um you know in the uk we've got into the habit since thatcher of finding
00:44:39 um reasons not to implement things we've got some very good laws on the statute book
00:44:43 uh but you you but if for example uh people have so many rights of appeal you know in the
00:44:50 immigration system they simply don't have that in other countries um it's either a yes or no answer
00:44:55 and that sounds harsh
00:44:58 but if you legislate and you regulate
00:45:00 then surely then you've got to implement it
00:45:03 and I think a whole host of things
00:45:05 are going on in the UK
00:45:05 whether it's around managing security
00:45:09 whether it's around managing the NHS
00:45:10 is that politicians just get themselves elected
00:45:13 and then all they want to do is pass laws
00:45:15 they actually don't implement the laws
00:45:17 that have been put in place
00:45:18 You mentioned security in relation to migration there
00:45:20 I mean obviously there's impacts
00:45:25 one impacts upon the other but both ways so but but of course yes I mean if
00:45:32 you're having immigration coming in from various places around the world then
00:45:37 obviously we need to be thinking about some of the challenges that perhaps
00:45:41 presented back in those communities and that's a thing that the Metropolitan
00:45:44 Police and and other police services have to have to deal with I don't think
00:45:49 that factors into political planning whatsoever I think there's just simply
00:45:53 been no planning for the last i don't know what 60 years around immigration in the uk uh i i
00:46:01 personally have a lot more faith that boris johnson will firstly he will grip it because
00:46:07 he's a better and more competent leader than what's been there before him and secondly he's
00:46:11 got the operating environment we're out of the european union so therefore we've got more leverage
00:46:15 to be able to do something about this if we want to i think also boris he's he's a doer so he's not
00:46:21 the sort of person who will license
00:46:23 civil service kicking the can down the road
00:46:25 Dominic Cummings is certainly not going to have any of that
00:46:27 But he's an absolute
00:46:28 metropolitan
00:46:31 liberal on these issues
00:46:33 isn't he?
00:46:35 He's a complete
00:46:36 amnesty for illegal immigrants
00:46:38 But he's also a good politician
00:46:40 and so I think he knows exactly what he needs to do
00:46:43 in order to please
00:46:45 the electorate that voted for him
00:46:46 and I think it's quite clear that immigration
00:46:49 seems to be one of their priorities
00:46:51 It's been a priority for, I'd say, about 20 years.
00:46:54 I mean, it's been going on with this.
00:46:57 But I want to ask, next year, 2021, we will have the census, won't we?
00:47:02 In the last one, I think it was 2011,
00:47:05 this came up with a famous statistic about London,
00:47:07 for example, the first time becoming minority white British.
00:47:11 What do you think we will see in this forthcoming census?
00:47:16 Well, I think one of the most interesting things will be religion.
00:47:20 religiosity, the decline of the Anglican Church over the past 10 years.
00:47:24 So separate from immigration, of course, just the lack of relationship between the people in this country
00:47:30 and the institutions of the country which have existed for the past 500 years, so to speak.
00:47:36 Because one of the main reasons why the Anglican Church survived was because it was a tribal religion,
00:47:41 as Roger Scruton called it.
00:47:42 He said it's a tribal religion and the English don't believe a word of it.
00:47:45 and, you know, what point is there in being an Anglican if you're not English?
00:47:51 Come over, why do you maintain the church?
00:47:53 That's one thing I'd look out for.
00:47:55 Another thing would just be the demographic changes,
00:47:59 certainly in big cities, London primarily.
00:48:01 Apparently the Muslim population, for example,
00:48:03 is now over 3 million or something, isn't it?
00:48:06 Yeah, so the Pew statistics, I think were from 2017,
00:48:10 suggested that I think it was around 27 or 28 percent of the Muslim population
00:48:17 were under the age of 30, I think it was, in comparison to 15 percent in the non-Muslim population.
00:48:23 So as we age, going towards 2030, the demographic that will be in their sort of fertile years
00:48:31 and therefore have the most population growth will be, in terms of religious demographics,
00:48:39 will be within the Muslim community,
00:48:43 whereas, as Ben was saying, in the Anglican community,
00:48:46 particularly the Christian community in Britain,
00:48:48 that seems to be shrinking.
00:48:50 Do you think, when you look at the threats we face
00:48:55 in terms of terrorism and what have been in the past 10 years,
00:48:58 we're hearing a lot now, for example,
00:49:00 about the rise of right-wing extremism.
00:49:02 Is that something you recognise, Richard, as being a real threat?
00:49:07 I think undoubtedly it's crystallised as more of a threat than it was, say, 10 or 15 years ago.
00:49:15 And there's a lot of reasons for that.
00:49:17 But I think the threat from terrorism is higher than it was 20 years ago.
00:49:23 The first Islamist case that was prosecuted was prosecuted in the Midlands in 2000.
00:49:28 So we've had 20 years of Islamist terrorism in the UK.
00:49:32 And that's a constant feature.
00:49:34 I mean, we're not talking about one-off plots.
00:49:37 It's been pretty much a conveyor belt that the police services have been having to deal with.
00:49:42 And it's kind of changed the nature of policing in many ways.
00:49:46 But there's certainly something going on where people politically are angrier.
00:49:52 You know, whether it's fueled by social media, whether it's fueled because we have an unelected house of laws,
00:49:57 you know, whatever, we don't have to escape valves, I don't know.
00:50:00 But there's certainly on the far left, I would say, the risk from terrorism is far higher.
00:50:07 and it's been interesting that the police have kind of admitted
00:50:10 that they're beginning to look at that area.
00:50:11 They have admitted this.
00:50:12 It's been in newspapers over the last couple of weeks.
00:50:15 Certainly we know the threat from far-right activists
00:50:19 has gone through the roof compared to where it was 15, 20 years ago.
00:50:24 When you look at this type of terrorism,
00:50:28 there are different targets, if you want to be macabre about it.
00:50:32 The far-left might typically go for a bank or a stock exchange
00:50:37 or something like that.
00:50:38 The far right might typically go for a mosque or a synagogue.
00:50:42 With Islamist terrorism, it's more nihilist.
00:50:45 It might be a stadium or a shopping centre.
00:50:48 All these things have been through the courts.
00:50:50 A lot of them have been prevented.
00:50:52 But certainly, since we got a peace treaty in Ireland,
00:50:57 the nature of terrorism has changed massively.
00:51:00 And there's no point denying that some of this has been down to immigration.
00:51:07 Immigration has generated some wonderful things in this country,
00:51:09 but it's also generated some challenges.
00:51:12 I think, though, that surely there's no question
00:51:14 that still the vast bulk of terrorism is Islamist, isn't it?
00:51:18 I mean, it seems to me that we're sort of like talking about these other things.
00:51:23 Somehow there's this sort of sense of trying to equate...
00:51:26 I'm not saying the threat isn't there, but isn't surely...
00:51:29 I think it's what has been referred to as Rowleyism,
00:51:31 because in order to excuse talking about the Islamist extremism,
00:51:36 which has become, in some senses, politically incorrect,
00:51:39 particularly with the use of the accusation of Islamophobia,
00:51:42 when people are trying to talk about Islamist terrorism
00:51:45 rather than Islam particularly,
00:51:48 they will try to big up the threat of the far right.
00:51:52 I'm not saying that it isn't a threat,
00:51:53 but to big up the threat of the far right in order to balance it
00:51:56 so that they're allowed to talk about the Islamist extremism.
00:51:58 That's something that has been, you know, spoken about quite widely.
00:52:01 I think one of the things that we haven't spoken about, that probably in 2030 we will be, is the possibility of environmental terrorism, because that is something that has existed in the past.
00:52:11 And we've seen, you know, like Antifa in Portland, for example, in the US, that Antifa, unlike the way that they behave over here, are actually quite violent protests in the US.
00:52:24 that we may start seeing something like that from environmental movements.
00:52:29 And as you were saying about the targets,
00:52:31 you might see them targeting things like farms,
00:52:34 abatons and things like that.
00:52:35 A lot about cyber-politicians.
00:52:37 And some of the most violent terrorism in the United States
00:52:41 has been environmentalists, right?
00:52:43 The Unabomber, most famously, where there are a number of fatalities.
00:52:47 I mean
00:52:51 over here my concerns are around
00:52:53 the government not regulating
00:52:55 technology because I think technology
00:52:57 will be harnessed with terrorism
00:52:59 over the next 10 years
00:53:00 I think tragically you will see something
00:53:03 with a drone
00:53:04 because the government just simply not legislating
00:53:07 around private ownership of drones
00:53:08 I don't know why they're not doing it
00:53:10 there'll be something
00:53:12 we're already seeing sort of terrorist attacks
00:53:15 live on various
00:53:17 sort of twitter feeds and social media feeds um so the harnessing of technology and and terrorism
00:53:23 will sort of continue until we really stamp down on that and um i think at some point you know one
00:53:29 of the major governments whether it's france or america will put some punitive legislation in
00:53:33 uh they'll be they'll be wiped out because they'll be called censors and they'll be called
00:53:37 you know this is a police state but it will be the right thing to do do you think therefore that
00:53:41 like in 2030 we will be walking around cities and having less of a sense of safety I mean
00:53:49 in London now for example you know there are always those barriers up you know those anti-terrorist
00:53:55 barriers that have the feel of being temporary but then suddenly they sort of become permanent
00:53:59 pretty you know they're there all the time they look temporary but they're there all the time
00:54:03 and are we going to have more of that do you think would it be a certainly a less safe place
00:54:10 Well, actually, one of the things that's very interesting is that terrorism is successful when you see that you have to go through airport security to go to...
00:54:17 I think in China, they have to go through airport security to get on the tube in parts of China at the moment.
00:54:24 And if we see that in the United Kingdom, then, well, terrorism has been effective, is all it says.
00:54:29 We're not preventing it.
00:54:31 We can only sort of...
00:54:33 We're preventing it in terms of the actual causes at the root, which is preventing it from happening, you know, in public spaces.
00:54:39 but it's still there, it's still under the surface
00:54:42 One thing that you mentioned earlier, Emma
00:54:45 when you were saying, we were talking about
00:54:47 Islamic terrorism, right wing terrorism
00:54:51 you said that people do this so that they can talk about it
00:54:54 in other words, the implication of that is
00:54:57 that we've got to be very careful about what we say
00:54:59 this is something that comes over time and time again
00:55:02 on this programme and in our general
00:55:05 discussion about these things
00:55:08 do you think that we will be even less free to say what we think in 10 years time or do or
00:55:16 because the reason i should put it in context there are there are more of these kind of a
00:55:20 society starting up and campaigns we've got to now we've got to really challenge woke we've got
00:55:27 to really challenge threats to free speech and you think this is great encouraging but will they take
00:55:32 off i think actually that links quite closely to what we were saying before about what will it what
00:55:37 will our personal safety look like you know what as how how safe will we feel as a as a nation and
00:55:43 as a people because you can only feel so safe if you're not actually able to talk about things
00:55:48 as you find them so um if your speech is compelled and you're not allowed to say the things that you
00:55:54 think are true or if you're not allowed to actually challenge discourse that might be going in the
00:55:59 wrong direction because it's politically incorrect for you to do that because um as we saw recently
00:56:04 in the news that a university has put a sort of almost like a student police force in place
00:56:11 to target microaggressions. And if we start to feel as a culture that we're limited in
00:56:17 this way and that we're not allowed to speak freely and that we're not allowed to assert
00:56:20 things that we think are true just because there are certain ideologies that have become
00:56:24 part of the fabric of society that prevent us from talking about those things, then I
00:56:29 think actually that has a negative impact in a number of ways. And one of the ways that
00:56:32 that would have a negative impact is actually on our ability
00:56:34 to accurately assess the sorts of threats that are taking place
00:56:37 because we would be very, very much stuck on tram lines
00:56:40 that we're not allowed to leave otherwise.
00:56:42 You know, you'll be publicly assassinated.
00:56:45 There was a great example of this that you actually worked on, wasn't there,
00:56:47 which was the new definition of Islamophobia,
00:56:50 which basically, you know, the police said,
00:56:53 actually, this new definition will hamper our efforts, right,
00:56:57 in fighting against terrorism.
00:56:59 And then they took it back, didn't they?
00:57:00 They got worried and they kind of retracted what they had said.
00:57:03 But the mere fact that a definition like that can be adopted by our institutions,
00:57:07 which many of them have, is rather worrying, isn't it?
00:57:10 And actually we're seeing it now with the Labour leadership.
00:57:14 The candidates are gradually adopting the definition as a list of things
00:57:19 that have been proposed by the Muslim Council of Britain and Muslim Labour Group.
00:57:25 And I think it's very dangerous if these sorts of things get taken into our institutions
00:57:30 because then they become sort of like the holy cow that you can't you can't the sacred cow that
00:57:35 you can't question um and that becomes very dangerous for free speech but also for compelled
00:57:40 speech we've seen this with the uh trans debate and pronouns in in canada um and around the world
00:57:47 that you know it it it almost it's like it crushes the soul in a sense that um if if an individual or
00:57:55 people feel that they can't um discuss things openly and can't assert the things that they
00:58:00 think are true but i'm a lot more i'm a lot more optimistic on this front you know i remember
00:58:03 optimistic i'm much more optimistic and i think a new dawn has just broken recently with the rise
00:58:08 of jordan peterson and the failure of all these films that the female ghostbusters crashed and
00:58:13 burned the female doctor who has gone through the floor people are beginning to realize that
00:58:18 twitter is not the british public you know i remember gk chesterton for we are the people
00:58:21 of england who have not spoken yet and politicians and business are now realizing that twitter
00:58:27 was wrong on brexit wrong on trump twitter forecast corbyn getting many more seats than
00:58:31 he did twitter is always wrong celebrities do not represent the people they can't even sway
00:58:36 the votes of the people i think people are finally realizing in the in the holders of power are
00:58:41 realizing that the people are rejecting all of this and i think especially with transgenderism
00:58:46 in female sports common sense is starting to come back and my hope is that especially again
00:58:52 this is boris johnson's time to actually make an impression on the country and you know put his
00:58:56 stamp on history and it's up to him to actually lead the charge on this and bring back some
00:59:00 common sense reality in terms of no platforming and all the rest of it so i have some optimism
00:59:05 i actually completely agree with you i mean whilst i think that those things are still a risk i think
00:59:09 that they're probably something that i at least hope maybe i'm being too optimistic and will be
00:59:13 proven wrong but i think that there's something that we're leaving in the last decade even if you
00:59:17 know the um recent question time discussion about um meghan markle um and and race and and you know
00:59:24 if you look at the sorts of things just on the twitter sphere um there definitely seems to be
00:59:30 a pushback from normal people who are you know just sick of being told what to think and what
00:59:35 to say well even the panel on question time on this week at thursday when we're recording
00:59:39 had two former guests on
00:59:41 one from this show
00:59:42 one from what you're saying is
00:59:43 and a conservative MP
00:59:45 I thought three right wingers
00:59:46 on the panel
00:59:47 I think the thing is
00:59:50 my fear is that I would love to agree with you
00:59:53 but I feel a bit like with political correctness
00:59:55 everyone laughed and joked about it
00:59:57 and everyone abided by it
00:59:59 and they still do
01:00:02 I'm less optimistic I have to say
01:00:03 I think
01:00:04 if what we were talking about
01:00:07 was operating in a vacuum fine but we're operating in a technical world that can kind of pretty
01:00:13 much listen in and report and record everything that we do we simply no longer have privacy
01:00:19 since since the world's first satellites in the early 1960s are often a mirror on the world
01:00:25 the moment you can connect them to a radio and you can connect them to a phone we've essentially
01:00:29 lost privacy what that means is if I'm walking down the road and I go into a pub and I make a
01:00:36 joke, because I see something that's really funny, because sense of humour is based on
01:00:40 the element of surprise, if I make a joke, that somebody
01:00:44 somewhere can be listening in on my phone, through
01:00:48 the microphone, or even watching me, you know, if I've got the WhatsApp
01:00:52 thing running, so, you know, there's just
01:00:56 so many organisations, whether they're private or government organisations that can listen
01:01:00 into stuff, I'm absolutely not a conspiracy theorist, but I think that if
01:01:04 you are in any way involved with this technology that you simply do not have privacy and therefore
01:01:09 it's low pickings. People that are critical of the left, people that are intellectually
01:01:15 into critical analysis, it's very low pickings to deal with them at the moment. And I think
01:01:21 it's going to get a lot worse. I think you've seen political correctness, which wasn't angry.
01:01:25 You've now seen wokeism, which is polarising and very, very angry. I can't really see a
01:01:30 rollback interestingly i think if we if we reject a lot of this technology so do you remember when
01:01:35 you used to sort of drive through left-wing towns and it was a non-nuclear zone you sort of drive
01:01:39 through basalden and decide we are a non-nuclear zone so it might be you know we drive through
01:01:44 barrow and furnace and it says we are a non-internet zone or non-wifi zone and then you'll get your
01:01:49 privacy back and you'll be able to speak freely that's what i'm saying actually there have been
01:01:52 some people who have suggested and i think this is a horrendous policy recommendation trying to
01:01:58 find some way of regulating the internet i mean whether or not it's actually possible to regulate
01:02:02 the internet is another thing but the fact that there are people who are suggesting it that's you
01:02:06 know very insidious i think so even though i do agree that i think the tides are turning in terms
01:02:11 of public opinion it still remains the case that um that the particular uh elements of society that
01:02:19 um are influential in the media or in um in you know tech and um the policy sphere there is
01:02:29 definitely a sort of liberal not in the literal sense bias there um and that's something that
01:02:35 you know we may continue to see the sort of the the um rollout of of that sort of general
01:02:44 trajectory of woke um across aspects of society but i think that the majority of people are starting
01:02:50 to sort of turn against it at least that's my feeling do you have just just to finish off uh
01:02:56 do you have any particular thing you think might be the case or might not however trivial however
01:03:00 important in 10 years time i mean for example we've been talking about question time we've
01:03:05 just mentioned question time you know that probably won't be here in 10 years time for
01:03:09 for example, and we'll be looking back thinking,
01:03:11 oh, do you remember Question Time?
01:03:13 Or even do you remember the BBC?
01:03:15 Is there anything you would like to say?
01:03:18 And what do you think of, I've just given this to you like now,
01:03:22 but we'll still have cinema, I think.
01:03:24 I'll put my foot on that.
01:03:26 We'll still have cinema.
01:03:26 I think we'll have a revived cinema as well.
01:03:28 I've seen a lot of cinemas now opening.
01:03:30 Yes.
01:03:31 And they've completely changed the business model
01:03:32 because they've realised people don't want to go
01:03:34 to a big corporate style like View,
01:03:37 or actually I shouldn't name any,
01:03:38 But they don't want to go to a big corporate one with overpriced popcorn and stuff.
01:03:43 They want a local cinema, old-fashioned, the traditional style,
01:03:46 because you can watch films in that way at home.
01:03:49 Also, I think people might recall from watching things on a mobile phone,
01:03:54 like Martin Scorsese said recently.
01:03:56 And I can tell you that because of global warming,
01:03:59 the soil in champagne is becoming very acidic,
01:04:01 and Tattinger have now begun to plant vines in England.
01:04:04 So on New Year's Eve 2029,
01:04:05 I think there will be more English champagne drunk than ever before.
01:04:08 all right champagne and movies and what the founder the head of the tattinger house also
01:04:13 said that champagne was an english invention and completely pissed off all the french by doing so
01:04:18 my prediction is by 2030 the british comedy as we know it is dead yes pretty much on live support
01:04:25 isn't it now anyway yeah pretty much emma come on mine is only a small one i think the bbc license
01:04:31 fee will be dead i think if the bbc is not gone certainly the license fee will be mine was so
01:04:36 boring in comparison to everyone else's let's make a let's make a patch are we if we're still
01:04:41 going strong we'll all meet here again in like uh look thank you very much to emma to benjamin
01:04:48 to richard and to rafe uh that's the end of counterculture this week and uh we'll see you
01:04:54 next week thank you very much for watching thank you
01:05:06 Thank you.