New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.06: Debunking the Toxic Masculinity Myth

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

187.52

Word count

7,453

Sentence count

184


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I am Peter Whittle. Now you might remember a few weeks ago
00:00:12 there was a story in the press about how men should maybe stop talking about sport at work
00:00:18 because this alienated and excluded their female colleagues. These stories now come pretty thick
00:00:25 farce. Last year we had the American Psychology Institute talking about how masculinity, traditional
00:00:31 masculinity, was, quote, harmful. And a year ago, pretty much to the month, we had that now infamous
00:00:37 Gillette commercial, which really pretty much showed all men behaving badly. It seems now that
00:00:46 when we have the word masculinity in a sentence, it's always preceded by toxic. So it would appear
00:00:52 there is an attack on men if that is the case how the hell is it going to pan out in the end
00:00:58 now we're going to be talking about all these issues today with four great guests first of all
00:01:03 we have Belinda Brown who is a journalist writes for the Daily Mail and for the conservative woman
00:01:08 on issues such as feminism and men's issues Martin Daubney who is co-founder of the Men
00:01:15 and Boyd Coalition. He was also editor for a long time of Loaded magazine and more recently
00:01:22 has become well known in another area as a candidate for the Brexit party at the general
00:01:28 election. We have Dr John Barry, psychologist and also honorary lecturer at the University College
00:01:36 in London. He's also co-founder of the Men's Psychology Network. And finally we have the
00:01:43 Resident guest, New Culture Forums, commentator and historian, Rafe Hadel-Manku.
00:01:48 Thank you. Thanks very much for coming and talking about this.
00:01:51 I want to start by asking any of you, when did you first hear the term toxic masculinity?
00:01:59 Probably quite a long time ago, because I've been researching this for a long while.
00:02:04 I mean if I if I the way I would understand it is feminism has you know it's assumed that women
00:02:13 have been oppressed since the beginning of time I mean that's the whole sort of subtext of feminism
00:02:19 you know why is it that women have been unequal in the workplace and their explanation is men
00:02:25 have been oppressing us so if that's your baseline you've got to say that there's something at fault
00:02:31 with men that they've been oppressing us i mean the point is that of course that's not true at all
00:02:35 and we haven't been oppressed we're just different and we've given birth and there's a completely
00:02:40 different way of understanding the different positions of men and women in society but i
00:02:45 think the whole idea of toxic masculinity is kind of inherent within feminism that's my view
00:02:50 it's actually inherent so basically it wasn't just a case of i in your view of equality and
00:02:56 pay equality it was that basically men are are beasts that's right I mean I I well I've I studied
00:03:04 I studied social anthropology I mean right from the feminism is not just about equality I think
00:03:10 that's a bit of a myth it's got a whole you just need to read all the texts from the 60s onwards
00:03:16 it's talking about patriarchy and um the oppression of women I mean that's and and you've got to find
00:03:23 a way of explaining that. So the assumption is that men have been these sort of oppressive
00:03:30 beasts who've been trying to oppress us since the beginning of time. And that, for me, is
00:03:34 why I'm personally slightly antagonistic towards feminism, because I feel it's created this
00:03:40 really serious misunderstanding between men and women. I think it's tragic. I don't think
00:03:46 tragic is too strong a word at portraying men as being toxic. Quite honestly, I think
00:03:52 men are women's greatest allies um and um yeah so so that i mean that's that's my beef with
00:04:00 feminism when you when you hear this term you know traditional masculinity is harmful i mean
00:04:07 what's your what's your reaction to to that martin it's absolute cobblers and it's scientifically
00:04:13 unfounded let's look at the the sector of society who have willingly sacrificed their own lives
00:04:20 taken the most dangerous jobs protected nurtured created safe environments for
00:04:26 women their families it's traditional men my dad was a coal miner you know he either worked or
00:04:32 slept why is that toxic why is that patriarchal why is that controlling that generation saw that
00:04:39 as their duty and i think we've lost a great deal of the good parts of that in the wash the phrase
00:04:45 toxic masculinity first i think broke cover around about 2013 ish and at first a great many of us
00:04:52 who work in the area of men's issues sort of laughed we thought it was a joke but it was like
00:04:58 one of those canaries down the mine of the end of sense really it was it was one of those pioneer
00:05:05 phrases of the the pathologizing of being a man that could only be deemed as a negative trait
00:05:14 it was seen through the prism of of oppression and negativity and at first it was funny there
00:05:20 had been a great war on lad culture when i was at loaded magazine we were seen as the pioneers of
00:05:24 uncouth misogynistic sexist as if but it was but that in itself well in a sense yes because it was
00:05:34 nothing happens in a vacuum culturally does it because we were living through the era of we
00:05:38 must all be new men we must all wear papooses and do the housework and a great many men thought
00:05:43 it's not that or some wanted to do it but not everybody and I think the trouble with all of
00:05:48 these phrases was there's very much a feeling this infiltrated academia it infiltrated the media
00:05:54 it infiltrated politics and soon this this nonsensical fabrication became the truth worse
00:06:01 it became the backbone of policy or more to the point it became the reason to avoid helping men
00:06:09 in terms of policy applications
00:06:11 because we were taught that men can only possibly be privileged.
00:06:15 When does white male privilege kick in
00:06:17 for boys at the bottom of education, for example?
00:06:20 When does male privilege kick in
00:06:21 for the 85% of the homeless community,
00:06:23 for the 95% of the jail community?
00:06:25 It's cobblers.
00:06:26 This is a point, actually,
00:06:28 you mentioned there, white men.
00:06:31 When we're talking about the attack on masculinity,
00:06:33 if we accept, do we all accept there is one?
00:06:36 Or, I mean, do you?
00:06:37 I mean, you're looking at this from a different...
00:06:39 You're a psychologist, obviously, so you're looking at it from a different angle.
00:06:43 Well, I'm also exposed to the same media as everybody else in popular culture.
00:06:49 I think it's hard to ignore the fact that there is an attack on men and masculinity.
00:06:54 And I think toxic masculinity is just a symptom of that.
00:06:59 And Belinda's right, there are aspects of feminism that have fed into this.
00:07:03 The part of feminism I think most people will agree on, that's absolutely fine.
00:07:09 is the equality part and the equality of opportunity.
00:07:12 There is though this other aspect to it
00:07:15 that's kind of latched on about patriarchy
00:07:19 and this cast men as being the oppressors of women
00:07:24 and men are said to have some sort of innate need
00:07:28 due to the patriarchy and due to masculinity
00:07:31 to oppress women, be violent against them,
00:07:34 be homophobic and it just,
00:07:38 you'd kind of wonder where this idea grew from as martin says i mean like men have been
00:07:43 doing the dirty dangerous jobs uh they're the the the homeless they're the main population in
00:07:49 prisons and uh i know that men aren't angels or anything like that but to to say that that all
00:07:55 this that the the sacrifice that they kind of provide a role the protector role that men
00:07:59 have uh done throughout you know forever uh just leaves them with nothing except being
00:08:05 cast as toxic people. I mean, this seems to be an attack on men and undeserved.
00:08:11 Well, the big lie of the patriarchy, oppressing women, ignores the fact that, yes, whilst
00:08:17 it's true that those are the top of the totem pole are men, the vast majority of men aren't
00:08:21 at the top of the totem pole, and they're being equally as oppressed as women are, if
00:08:25 you're going to believe that this is all about power structures. It's simply a hierarchy
00:08:28 that exists, as it exists in nature and has done for thousands of years between all species.
00:08:34 The insidious element of all of this, I think, is to accept reality and accept facts
00:08:39 of what this crisis of masculinity is doing.
00:08:43 Three quarters of all the suicides in this country are by men.
00:08:48 You are more likely to die from suicide if you're the cause of death under the age of 49.
00:08:52 Suicide is the leading cause of death.
00:08:54 We're going through an epidemic here of kids dropping out of school, dropping out of university.
00:08:58 It's white working class men who are the most disadvantaged group in society
00:09:03 and there's no outreach being made towards them on in any level and so i think this idea of toxic
00:09:08 masculinity doesn't exist there's toxic feminism and it's toxic feminists who have a problem
00:09:15 with personality disorder where they can't actually distinguish between males who are
00:09:21 powerful and abusive and those who are who have powerful powerful competencies to actually elevate
00:09:26 society with their inability to distinguish between those who are the problem yeah but that's
00:09:29 the curse of identity politics right there in a nutshell if you treat an entire demographic as
00:09:35 uniform then you are not only dunderheaded you are doing a great disservice to those at the bottom
00:09:40 who are being made to be made to pay because of those at the top and that is why the men and boys
00:09:45 at the bottom just don't get any policy help there's no outreach help it's a very unfashionable
00:09:50 cause i've been trying for years over the road in westminster to get these things going that's why i
00:09:54 stood you know at the general election i would have been championing this work in westminster if
00:09:58 i could and i'm really hoping that there is optimism we have a new wave of blue-collar
00:10:03 conservatives because it's been the conservatives that seem to have cared these are traditional
00:10:07 labor heartlands that labor's completely abandoned on the altar of identity politics because they
00:10:11 don't fit the scripts but can i can i can i just uh you just talked about you know uh traditional
00:10:16 working class communities that i've come over to boris this time whatever um isn't this something
00:10:21 which is not to do with feminism in that basically men doing traditional jobs like your father did
00:10:27 like mine did actually um basically those jobs are no longer there there's jobs no longer there
00:10:33 so basically that's not feminist fault is it well that i mean a couple of things it is
00:10:38 ever so slightly feminist fault because i think that if you wait a minute what because the minds
00:10:43 were closed i think that we we could have i mean just if for the sake of argument we could have
00:10:48 actually perhaps made a lot more effort or thatcher could have actually made a lot more effort to get
00:10:53 work going for men but she knew that she had a service economy she could fill with women and
00:10:58 women you know she'd keep the feminists happy because she'd be providing women with loads of
00:11:02 work in the service economy so maybe she didn't make quite as much effort as she should have done
00:11:06 for men so I can always find a way of blaming feminists I must admit but that does seem very
00:11:11 circuitous I agree it's very circuitous but I think that there there is there is a something
00:11:18 to take into consideration if you want to understand why perhaps some issues with
00:11:23 masculinity have arisen when they have and that is that it is unarguable that feminists they
00:11:30 they really and I can give quotes I've written about it they really didn't think the father was
00:11:35 necessary in the family and if you go back at looking at policies you can see a whole series
00:11:41 of policies which worked to support the single parent family and encourage the single parent
00:11:48 family and i think we've now got about 43 of the population brought up in in single mother homes so
00:11:54 what you have is is is boys who haven't had a father in their lives and i think this is the
00:12:02 source i don't want to call it toxic masculinity but if you don't that it is the man who models
00:12:07 masculinity a mother can't teach you how to be a man and that is the source of problems with
00:12:13 masculinity the absolute lie about the american psychological association putting out this
00:12:17 terrible finding which basically is a social justice you know promotion poster saying that
00:12:22 masculinity is a social danger and is a harm when actually what they're talking about is fatherless
00:12:28 families where the man is absent so we're actually absent the masculine figure that's when you have
00:12:33 the highest incidence of delinquency antisocial behavior and criminality it's the lack of a
00:12:39 masculine figure there it's basically it's not it's actually you know masculinity is the solution
00:12:44 and actually you can make a sound and robust scientific case for precisely that if you look
00:12:51 at fatherlessness and what it precipitates in terms of criminality justice system lack of
00:12:56 educational opportunities the absence of positive masculinity a role model that keeps you on the
00:13:01 straight and narrow two parents you know helping better than one not just because of their genus
00:13:06 because two parents are just better than one in terms of academic output results teenage
00:13:12 pregnancies proponents to to expand with drugs and alcohols evidence is it is out there it's a huge
00:13:19 amount of evidence which disproves toxic masculinity at the drop of a hat yet it's been allowed to take
00:13:26 hold and you've done a great amount of work on this john when you and i've worked together
00:13:29 when you look at positive masculinity and what makes men actually fulfilled i think we're doing
00:13:35 pretty well absolutely I mean this this attack on on patriarchy I think
00:13:41 sometimes just translates into an attack on households that are led by men that
00:13:46 have got men as the main breadwinner and I think men have been quite
00:13:49 marginalized and and the results are I mean everybody's right here and you know
00:13:54 the the the research has been done the results are in a good father is
00:13:59 absolutely you know is solid gold for for the development of boys and and
00:14:04 their behavior and remove the dad, trouble can start. And of course, a bad dad is no
00:14:10 good really either. They have to sort themselves out. But a good dad is – modeling positive
00:14:17 masculinity is what creates then good men who don't go around doing the things that
00:14:24 men are being accused of. Like you've got a few offenders and then they get generalized
00:14:31 is what men are like typically and another aspect of this is too that that some of the very worst
00:14:38 and I don't want to use the word toxic especially in this case but like some of the worst offenders
00:14:43 psychopathic sex offenders or personality disorder sex offenders do have in their histories
00:14:50 some serious trauma and this this is the missing ingredient to the worst sort of behavior that we
00:14:57 see from men is um trauma especially early childhood trauma and uh and sometimes this can
00:15:04 be done at the hands of a female caregiver or supposed caregiver so this is so some of the
00:15:09 roots of the worst toxic masculinity um you know we we have to really look at some of the mothering
00:15:16 that happens too well the thing is is yeah but you go back to your first point actually it's
00:15:21 interesting if you look at like knife crime in london yeah we have endless i'm on the london
00:15:25 assembly we have endless debates about this but the one thing that people won't on the whole talk
00:15:29 about is the lack of fathers often it's interesting in the alami report into knife crime which actually
00:15:35 was a really solid piece of work it was touched upon you know the evidence of fatherlessness and
00:15:40 the propensity to to offend in the absence of a father is absolutely crystal clear and this is
00:15:47 globally you know not just in london knife crime but anywhere in the world it has a result but it
00:15:53 kind of brushed into the carpet especially by the the liberal media it just doesn't fit the
00:15:56 scripts because let's face it at the heart of patriarchy theory at the heart of toxic masculinity
00:16:02 theory is a war on the traditional nuclear conservative family this is the crucial point
00:16:08 it seems to me this is the point is that when you say about feminism you know being to blame
00:16:13 it seems to me there are two things here there's feminism and then there's also what you might call
00:16:17 the woke cultural Marxist bit, which is not the same thing, not quite the same thing.
00:16:22 Would you agree with that?
00:16:23 Absolutely.
00:16:24 Because, I mean, we've been talking, for example, particularly about, on the whole, an attack on white straight males.
00:16:31 I would recognise it as that, wouldn't you?
00:16:33 Exactly. Well, and it's an attack on the nuclear family as a whole.
00:16:36 And it's the idea now that all families are equal.
00:16:38 Well, I'm sorry, all families are not equal.
00:16:41 The evidence is quite clear.
00:16:42 Two-parent families are infinitely better than one-parent families for all sorts of reasons.
00:16:46 assuming those are two decent parents obviously you have to assume that there's a love and care
00:16:51 there in terms of the way that they're raised but certainly I think all of this comes down really
00:16:56 to the idea that think of today's young man living in East London who hasn't got a father figure
00:17:02 he's told throughout his education system that's his toxic masculinity that they're liable to rape
00:17:08 and pillage and violence and aggression and the oppression of women there's no more competitive
00:17:13 sports to engage in or any of that team building that used to happen where you challenge each other
00:17:17 everyone's got to be a winner what hope does that person have now there's no outlet for him to
00:17:21 actually develop his masculinity and that's why they're dropping out because they feel themselves
00:17:25 as failures they feel that they've got some sort of you know like a christian guilt almost
00:17:29 born into sin yeah it's interesting because you know should any of this matter you know because
00:17:34 the the response that were cry me a river you know men rule the world men captain industry
00:17:39 men are most likely to be politicians but that's not all men you know what i see i do a lot of
00:17:44 talks in schools i'm kind of on the front line with teenagers in britain and all this stuff has
00:17:49 an effect now when you when you grow up and from the age of five or six you're told that girls can
00:17:55 do anything they want which by the way is brilliant i've got a daughter and i want both of them to have
00:18:00 every opportunity but you're also told men have this intrinsic suspicious creepy propensity
00:18:07 but martin when you say you're also told this who is telling teachers and who taught them i don't
00:18:13 blame the teachers i blame who taught them and who taught them and this i think you work in
00:18:19 academia i think academia is rotten in terms of the mindset the prevailing wind of masculinity
00:18:25 where are the conservative professors where are you know the professors agree with masculinity
00:18:30 being a good thing you're a rare breed john yeah um thanks and uh yeah it's not entirely rotten but
00:18:36 I mean, social sciences do kind of lean towards the whole woke end of the spectrum, unfortunately.
00:18:43 And there's a lot of baggage that goes along with that.
00:18:46 And included in that is a lot of kind of sociological, fluffy theory about patriarchy
00:18:53 and about other social influences that may or may not exist.
00:18:57 I mean, one social influence I'd like to see some proper research on
00:19:01 is the influence of boys growing up in a culture that tells them that there's something wrong with them
00:19:06 because they're boys, there's enough research out there to tell us that we should be extremely
00:19:12 concerned about that. And we don't even know exactly what the results are going to be. I mean,
00:19:16 people who are told these negative things about them, they might just suffer from low self-esteem
00:19:22 or they might become depressed or they might reject it or they might take it on board and say,
00:19:26 okay, I'm toxic. I'll just show you exactly. I'll be the most toxic bloke you've ever seen.
00:19:31 So I think we have to be really kind of careful that we're not by doing, by kind of trying to tell boys that they shouldn't rape girls and things like this, that we're not actually causing more harm and causing more of the problems that we're trying to get rid of.
00:19:46 This all started in the 60s when you had essentially the move to create these Mickey Mouse courses of gender studies and women's studies.
00:19:54 And people looked around and they got females.
00:19:56 There were very few female faculty at the time.
00:19:58 They tended to be in departments of English.
00:20:01 So there were people from the Department of English founding women's studies and gender studies.
00:20:04 No biologists were brought along.
00:20:06 They didn't want to have any biological components.
00:20:07 Nobody with any scientific background was brought in.
00:20:10 And you began to get theories with very poor peer review.
00:20:13 and you saw that recently when two or three Boghossian
00:20:16 and two others fabricated all this information
00:20:19 and got these laughable papers published
00:20:22 and people were touting them until they were exposed
00:20:25 as being completely fraudulent
00:20:27 because there's no peer review, there's no analysis
00:20:29 and this is now constantly cited as by the BBC and others
00:20:32 oh well the evidence states
00:20:34 even though there's evidence is all bunkum.
00:20:36 So would it be fair to say that you would all agree
00:20:40 that for example the gender pay gap is fictitious?
00:20:42 Yes.
00:20:43 Well, there are differences in how men and women get paid, but often if you choose a gender studies degree, as opposed to a mathematics or computing degree, you might have a different career output.
00:20:55 So actually, it's a choice, and then later on, lifestyle choice, more like to be mothers and stay-at-home parents.
00:21:01 Yeah, women make different choices, and that results.
00:21:04 I mean, we're paid the same for the same work on the whole, but women make different choices.
00:21:09 we have different priorities we like to be we like to work nearer to home we prefer to have
00:21:15 more time with our families I mean that's all proven in evidence women would like to spend a
00:21:20 bit more time with their children and that takes a knock on our you know why why why is what we get
00:21:25 paid the most important thing I don't see why this is held up as the the main measure because some of
00:21:30 us value quality of life more and how much time we can spend with our families I think that's more
00:21:35 important than how much we get paid so yeah i think the the the pay gap thing is it's another
00:21:40 of those things just to um sort of keep feminism going and keep women getting works up with men
00:21:46 and unfairness and all the rest of it basically you know to understand the gender pay gap you
00:21:51 have to do a multivariate analysis which is too complicated to go into here but i put it most
00:21:56 succinctly by saying there isn't a gender pay gap there's a mother's pay gap yeah if you understand
00:22:01 that it's childbirth that actually is the factor and look at it that way there's a mother's pay
00:22:05 gap and it's your choice to have children or not and totally agree and a great way of addressing
00:22:11 that would be more equality for men which sounds oxymoronic but look at sweden you know where and
00:22:16 finland this week finland have introduced equal paternity pay as opposed to maternity pay so men
00:22:21 have the choice if they want to be primary carer so their wives can return to work then we see more
00:22:26 equality but still not full equality because guess what choice is stubborn biology is stubborn even
00:22:32 in sweden norway all of those where they have the most equality on the planet women still choose
00:22:37 women's jobs they still choose to be primary carers more than most and it was the feminist
00:22:41 groups in sweden that kicked back against total equality because it's it became the mother's right
00:22:46 to mother biological isn't this the point actually as well that you mentioned scandinavian countries
00:22:52 is that this is an, on the whole, this is a Western phenomenon, isn't it?
00:22:58 I mean, if you go anywhere else, you're not going to get the attack on men
00:23:01 the same way that you'll have in, say, like America, in Britain,
00:23:04 in the Anglosphere, in Western Europe, wouldn't you say?
00:23:07 Yeah.
00:23:07 Well, the academics are very quiet on this kind of thing
00:23:11 in places like Africa, aren't they?
00:23:12 Right, yes.
00:23:12 Because they're in all sorts of hot water there, and it's like,
00:23:14 oh, my God, we have to make it about white Western men
00:23:17 because we're the softest target.
00:23:19 I have to say this point, though.
00:23:21 There'll be many women watching, I don't know, possibly some of your colleagues,
00:23:24 and they will say, look, what are they going on about?
00:23:27 Women have had it like this for ages.
00:23:29 Then suddenly you get challenged and you're all getting upset about it.
00:23:34 Can you not see that view?
00:23:36 Well, I would say two wrongs don't make a right.
00:23:38 For example, we are undoubtedly about to see a flip of the gender pay gap
00:23:42 because this week it came out that for 30 straight years,
00:23:46 white working class boys have been the bottom of education again.
00:23:49 they're the least likely demographic to go to university they are therefore going to be earning
00:23:54 less in the next generation and will anybody care then so so the downtrodden men at the expense of
00:24:02 women going up surely we should all be rising together that's true equality they're replacing
00:24:06 one well-educated elite with another who happen to have different things in their trousers or their
00:24:11 skirts to me is missing the point what about the quality of helping people from the working classes
00:24:17 How many working-class people work at the BBC?
00:24:19 How many people from council estates are politicians?
00:24:21 It's not just an oversimplification to make it about gender.
00:24:25 It's actually about background and helping everybody
00:24:28 be colour-blind, be gender-blind,
00:24:30 just be helping those who need it.
00:24:32 And right now, those people are white working-class boys,
00:24:36 but the gender politicians are blinded to this.
00:24:39 It's short-circuit. It's everything they've been told for 50 years.
00:24:43 What are the kind of other psychological problems
00:24:46 that you think men face now, actually, John?
00:24:49 Well, I mean, is this kind of drip, drip, drip thing that they get
00:24:54 of kind of, you know, somehow hostility or contradiction?
00:24:59 We just don't know what the effect is.
00:25:01 No one's really that interested in researching this.
00:25:04 It's another one of those things that we tend to be blind to as a culture.
00:25:09 I'm guessing that it feeds into all sorts of problems
00:25:12 and probably quite long-term problems.
00:25:15 but we do need more research into this. We make assumptions about men and masculinity.
00:25:22 For example, the APA have decided that masculinity is purely a product of culture. It's nothing
00:25:29 to do with biology. So the testosterone that men have, increase in muscle mass or energy
00:25:34 or anything like that, brain development. And this is the APA. The APA should be leading
00:25:43 the science of psychology throughout the world, and they're not. They've just completely,
00:25:47 they've just, I don't know, they've put a big banana skin in academia and everyone's slipping
00:25:52 on it. I mean, in the UK, we have people who are falling in line with this flawed notion.
00:25:58 And the problem is you're going to have, whether men's mental health issues are created by
00:26:03 a toxic culture that we might be living in, we're going to have therapists who are not equipped
00:26:09 to help these men their idea of helping men is going to be saying well okay so you've lost your
00:26:15 job and now you're very depressed well you know that you need to get over your patriarchal
00:26:19 tendencies i mean that that's not going to help anybody that's and the whole idea of of saying
00:26:24 that uh that somebody's gender identity um is bad there's something dysfunctional about it i thought
00:26:32 we'd gone over that i thought that that was banned in in lots of countries you know with this
00:26:37 conversion therapy like it used to be a popular thing where if someone was gay they were unhappy
00:26:43 about being gay they would experience something called conversion therapy that would help them
00:26:47 in inverted commas with that and now we seem to have that for masculinity there's something
00:26:53 deeply wrong about that that's true in the prevailing view now is you have the benevolent
00:26:56 mother and the tyrannical father figure and that's always the way that you see it taught in school
00:27:00 settings now there's this implication behind that so there's so there needs to be for the good of
00:27:05 mental health of the next generation there needs to be an unapologetic celebration of traditional
00:27:10 masculinity which brought us the industrial revolution which brought us capitalism both
00:27:14 british creations too i might say and how to advance science and medicine and basically
00:27:20 progress human society to where it is it was the engineers going out it was exploring and
00:27:24 discovering new flora and fauna to give us cures that's the traditional masculinity we should be
00:27:28 focusing if there is if there is an attack on masculinity if there's an attack on men
00:27:34 uh if there's a war going on against men what would victory look like then
00:27:40 i think getting getting fathers fathers um back in families you know i know what is the victory
00:27:47 that is hoped for if men are under attack i would say the first thing um what we've been trying for
00:27:54 for years at the Men and Boys Coalition
00:27:56 is to get a cross-party action group on education.
00:28:00 Let's actually look at why these boys are behind
00:28:03 and let's listen, let's get inside.
00:28:05 Like my mother used to be a family liaison officer.
00:28:06 They all got swept away, spend time in families.
00:28:10 Now we can learn a great deal of positive stuff
00:28:13 from other cultures in the UK.
00:28:15 Chinese children, Asian children,
00:28:18 high achievers have that drive from their parents
00:28:20 which is absent in a lot of the white working class communities
00:28:24 because they had a bad education experience themselves
00:28:26 or the mines have closed
00:28:28 or the steelworks have closed
00:28:29 or the shipyards have closed.
00:28:30 What is the throughput for their masculinity?
00:28:32 What's the point?
00:28:33 The jobs aren't there.
00:28:35 So if we actually listen
00:28:36 and try and replace those industries
00:28:39 with something new.
00:28:41 We were with an organisation called Lads Need Dads
00:28:44 and they actually sort of pair up boys
00:28:47 who are going through a tough time,
00:28:49 often going off the rails,
00:28:50 they pair them with a male mentor transforming lives.
00:28:54 It's beautiful.
00:28:55 And that's the point, that a positive male role model
00:28:58 in these young men's life is a joyous thing to watch.
00:29:01 And it can be, everybody wins if these kids stay out of jail.
00:29:05 Everybody wins if they become good partners
00:29:06 and tender, loving, beautiful boys.
00:29:08 Everybody wins in society if we help these boys.
00:29:11 This is not competition.
00:29:12 But I think, you see, we would agree with that.
00:29:15 And we would want to be victorious.
00:29:17 I really, what I meant was, the people who are waging the war,
00:29:21 the people who are attacking,
00:29:22 what does victory look like to them what is their aim an inversion i think they want to see
00:29:28 yeah they want to see women in charge is that is that what you think it is i i i think that
00:29:36 they'd like to see i i think they'd like to see the family that the family fragmented i think
00:29:41 they'd like to see um sort of women in charge i think i think there's there's an aim it seems
00:29:47 to me as if there's just a really strong desire to break down the whole I mean I don't what you
00:29:54 know the whole sort of traditional family life that we've had since the beginning of time in a
00:29:59 way you know this has evolved over centuries and I think that they have a a vision of this brave
00:30:05 new society which they want to impose on the rest of the world they want to change everything because
00:30:12 this is this is empowering for them i think they've got a sort of particular vision of a
00:30:17 completely different society and that's what they're trying to bring about and the destruction
00:30:22 of of patriarchy the destruction of christianity the destruction of everything sort of traditional
00:30:28 i think that's what it's part of this is yeah but it's just there is a it's just a it's it's a
00:30:33 minor it might seem like a minor difference i think it's a very important one you're talking
00:30:37 matriarchy and and replacing men i think your point martin it's the crucial one in a way it's
00:30:43 actually good old-fashioned cultural marxism which is attempting basically to get rid of the family
00:30:48 which marx identified as being the very bedrock of capitalism isn't that what it is yeah i think
00:30:53 it is and if you replace the family with something else which might be the socialist super state
00:30:58 or you know that that i think is is the long-term dream the dependency on the family is is out
00:31:04 mode the dependency on crown is out mode let's be dependent on the state and the state politics
00:31:10 that drives this is that cultural Marxism it's the backbone of modern socialism every time this
00:31:16 comes to the electoral booze it's annihilated by the electorate yet it stubbornly persists
00:31:21 in our media in our corridors of power and in academia the public don't want it you know the
00:31:27 work that we did together John that shows that traditional values still work for men they'd like
00:31:31 to work hard they'd like to provide all these things that we're told are toxic actually brings
00:31:36 them great well-being doesn't it absolutely we did a couple of studies when the uk win the state's
00:31:42 survey of 7 000 men in total and we found that the best predictor of men's mental well-being
00:31:48 was um how much job satisfaction they experienced and whether they had relationship stability or not
00:31:54 so so basically a happy man is a guy who's he's working a job that he enjoys he's probably
00:32:00 working very hard and he's also got a stable relationship it doesn't seem toxic at all
00:32:05 we also found that the types of values that they ascribe to were all very laudable they
00:32:12 want to be dependable they value being honest I mean there was just far from being a kind
00:32:18 of toxic bunch of tearaways I mean we were just finding that these guys are really just
00:32:22 you know if anything you know I wish you know I'm aspiring to be as good as a lot of people
00:32:27 And it's bad for women, too, because it reinforces the idea of women basically being repressed and being infantilised
00:32:33 and being unable to do anything on their own and that they'll never be able to escape the shackles.
00:32:38 But there's a wider issue here, too, because Western society is now at its weakest point in 250 years.
00:32:44 And just at this point, masculinity is having a state of crisis.
00:32:48 And the traditional masculinity that brought the Western world so much success is now at its nadir.
00:32:53 just at the time when we're seeing the Western world ensnared and encircled
00:32:57 by the jackals and hyenas of China and ISIS and others
00:33:00 who are extremely alpha male type masculines, if you want.
00:33:05 And we need to project masculinity strong enough to deter them
00:33:09 as opposed to this current limp, impotent-looking sort of state that we are in now.
00:33:14 There's a backlash coming, I think, a positive backlash. I really do.
00:33:17 I think a lot of what we see in society
00:33:21 is actually to do with the absence of masculinity.
00:33:23 I mean, if you look at things like victim culture
00:33:26 or the whole idea of safe spaces
00:33:28 or the whole idea of being offended.
00:33:29 Anti-competition.
00:33:31 The whole opposition to competition.
00:33:33 What we've actually got in society at the moment
00:33:35 is a real lack of masculinity,
00:33:37 which affects women as well.
00:33:40 You know, I think that, you know,
00:33:42 we should see masculinity as a resource
00:33:44 that is available to women.
00:33:46 You know, I was thinking a practical example.
00:33:49 You know, when I was young,
00:33:50 If I remember, you know, once getting slightly harassed and my response was was to thump the chap.
00:33:56 And, you know, whereas now a young woman would would go crying somewhere, you know, so this is a masculine approach.
00:34:05 You know, now women, women have lost masculinity, unfortunately.
00:34:08 Don't we see this in a way with the Me Too thing?
00:34:10 I remember, you know, the older women say, well, why can't you just slap around something like this?
00:34:15 I mean, it's not to not to be trivial about this.
00:34:17 But it is absolutely true. For example, when we extend this into things like wolf whistling,
00:34:24 you know, wolf whistling is always in the news cycle. And there's a huge generational
00:34:28 split. Joanna Lumley said, you know, I like being wolf whistled. And there's a huge kind
00:34:33 of crossover of elderly people that, well, actually, it's quite nice. Maybe they miss
00:34:37 it. Maybe they miss getting compliments in the street. Whereas the woke generation are
00:34:42 now straight onto everyday sexism straight outright sexual harassment and sort of never
00:34:48 the twain shall meet and so do we have a position where every sort of gendered interaction is now
00:34:54 being examined and projected onto social media and this causes trepidation and uncertainty
00:34:59 and so we're seeing a great deal of men retreating into caves you know psychological caves metaphorical
00:35:06 caves real caves pornography video games social isolation and actually that's the cause that's
00:35:11 causing more problems because they're becoming removed and they feel worthless they feel despised
00:35:16 they feel hated by society because they're imbibed in this culture now nobody wins if these young
00:35:22 men are growing up feeling like that nobody it's it is actually it's very worrying when you see the
00:35:28 way in which social relations now and personal relations are sort of monitored aren't they
00:35:32 they've been it's almost like so overused but you know 1984 where people are too frightened actually
00:35:39 to interact at work or talk.
00:35:41 We'll see in that now.
00:35:42 And there's a very good reason for this.
00:35:43 Jordan Peterson says that men actually don't feel often equipped
00:35:47 to argue with women on these very points
00:35:49 because there's a point at which if two chaps have an argument,
00:35:53 they maybe go outside, have a fist fight or something.
00:35:56 You know, that's always the last resort sort of a thing.
00:35:58 Whereas you would never think of doing that with a woman in that dynamic.
00:36:01 And so suddenly you have a situation whereby if you have an argument,
00:36:05 you'll then seem to be a bully if you win.
00:36:07 But if you've lost, you're pathetic.
00:36:09 and there's no you know whereas with between men it's often shown that men can have an argument
00:36:13 they may have fisticuffs and they're friends again by the end of the day it's a very different
00:36:17 dynamic psychologically in terms of how people engage with each other and men don't feel equipped
00:36:22 to actually they don't know what the rules are for arguing with women it's interesting we've done a
00:36:26 lot of talking about banter in the past and the importance of banter in very masculine environments
00:36:31 such as the front line or coal mines you know where people's lives are dependent on each other
00:36:36 you know men test each other in a way that will be considered you know a hate crime by the language
00:36:42 we use and you know it's quite on the surface if you look at it write it on paper it looks abusive
00:36:47 but actually men do interact in different ways and a healthy way you're testing boundaries do I trust
00:36:52 this person can they take a joke they can I'll allow them more into my life it can be useful but
00:36:57 all of that interaction now has been framed as damaging and toxic and I think we're throwing
00:37:01 the baby out of the bathwater if you look at the sort of biological anthropology of all of this
00:37:06 what you actually find is that in many ways men are much more sociable than women they actually
00:37:11 have a tendency to create large groups they function in close quarters in armies and they all
00:37:16 manage to get on with each other actually men in many ways you could argue they've got stronger
00:37:21 social skills than women just in sort of their group formation and also you find that there is
00:37:26 this ability to argue and then make friends again and it's sort of it's if you look at evolutionary
00:37:32 anthropology you can also see it sort of in the animal kingdom you'll actually I mean I don't want
00:37:36 to compare but you know you'll actually find that male chimpanzees cooperate far more together and
00:37:42 groom each other much more than female chimpanzees and I think we need to start recognizing these
00:37:47 sort of real qualities of masculinity of which you know sociability and risk-taking and also
00:37:53 sensitivity if you look at there is evidence to suggest that actually if you look at you know
00:37:59 male and female babies is the male babies that are more sensitive than the girl babies i know i was
00:38:04 yes well i think that is i think i think we've got a call today here what's actually saying
00:38:12 we've been talking it's conversation now and this makeup would no longer be allowed on the bbc i
00:38:19 think no would it it wouldn't it wouldn't it wouldn't take diversity boxes and you know i
00:38:24 think that in itself is you know an absolute rot you know i have no problem with women leading i
00:38:30 have no problem with women leading the country women leading business so long as they're the
00:38:34 best person for the job meritocracy but we are now in a phase of every single thing has to tick a box
00:38:39 on a diversity sheet apart from diversity of thought where the brexiteers at the bbc for
00:38:45 example where the conservatives in academia you know diversity isn't just about how we look or
00:38:49 what's in our trousers it's about what's between our ears and we're losing sight of that thank you
00:38:53 very, very much. This is a great
00:38:55 conversation. One more point. Just wanted to say, because
00:38:57 being a bit of a geek, I went through
00:38:59 every single episode of Politics Live since
00:39:01 they launched, and
00:39:03 on no occasion was there an all-male
00:39:05 panel. There have been all-female
00:39:07 panels on around five, six, seven,
00:39:10 eight occasions, and there have been
00:39:11 panels which have been majority female
00:39:14 on many occasions.
00:39:15 The reverse has never been the case.
00:39:18 Sexist monster for even bothering to
00:39:19 check that. I'll tweet at the page
00:39:21 for anyone to check.
00:39:22 all right look thank you very very much to to all of you today um please do uh subscribe to
00:39:29 the new show won't you and and also do we love your comments you know hundreds of them come in
00:39:35 and i i think we've raised a hell of a lot of points today so i expect uh i hope a great deal
00:39:40 of engagement uh with you okay so see you next time thank you very much