New Culture Forum - March 12, 2020


Counterculture 1.08: Has Political Correctness Killed Comedy?

2.19 Charles Coulombe: A Conservative Author Examines the Culture Wars in Trad. Institutions 2.20 Darren Grimes: I fought the liberal elite and won

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

204.88

Word count

9,003

Sentence count

226


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Is political correctness killing comedy?
00:00:03 Hello and welcome. I'm Mark Sidwell and this is Counter Culture,
00:00:07 the cultural discussion show that laughs in the face of censorship.
00:00:18 Today we're discussing the state of comedy.
00:00:20 With university campuses increasingly dominated by speech codes
00:00:24 and with the BBC still dominated by a left-wing culture,
00:00:27 is talent being frozen out and how hard is it for anyone to be really funny in a culture of
00:00:34 perpetual offence. Joining me today to discuss all of this is a multi-talented panel. First of all
00:00:40 we have Rafe Hadel-Mankou of the New Culture Forum who's also a historian and commentator
00:00:45 and we have three brilliant stand-up comedians. We have Simon Evans who's known for his Radio 4
00:00:51 show Simon Evans Goes to Market and who's touring a new show around the country now.
00:00:55 We have Constantine Kissin, who's also the co-host of the free speech podcast and YouTube show Trigonometry.
00:01:02 And we have Dominic Frisby, songwriter and author best known to Brexiteers for his anthem 17 Million Fuck-Offs.
00:01:10 Thank you all for joining me so much.
00:01:12 Now, let's start with the big picture.
00:01:15 Is it true to say now that comedy is in a bit of a rut, in the mainstream at least?
00:01:20 I mean, obviously there's lots of talent around this table.
00:01:22 But is mainstream comedy not as good as it used to be at the moment?
00:01:26 I mean, Rafe, what's your feeling? Have we lost the fire somewhere?
00:01:29 Well, yes, absolutely. I mean, I would say that, I often say that if I was to go on Mastermind,
00:01:33 my subject would be British comedy in the 20th century, looking,
00:01:36 because every decade I found comedy that I found engaging and amusing,
00:01:39 and which pushed boundaries for its time.
00:01:42 But there was a transformation that occurred in the 80s,
00:01:44 and we're living through that era now of alternative comedy.
00:01:47 It's Alexei Sale, really, who started all this with the comedy store,
00:01:51 who brought in this political element to humour,
00:01:53 where, let's be honest about it,
00:01:55 a Marxist element to humour.
00:01:56 And so comedians now, if you're not on side,
00:01:59 and if you're not seen to be punching down,
00:02:02 you'll be basically unable to get any shows going,
00:02:06 despite the fact that the public at large
00:02:08 enjoy that sort of comedy.
00:02:09 And there's a huge disconnect now
00:02:11 between those who make comedy on the BBC
00:02:14 and those people who actually want to enjoy comedy
00:02:17 and go to YouTube to find other people
00:02:19 who are supplying that.
00:02:20 So, yes, there's good comedy out there, but it's not being provided on the main platforms of mainstream television.
00:02:26 Do the professionals agree? I mean, Simon, does that chime with some of your experience?
00:02:31 Well, I made a programme for Radio 4 which went out last September looking at this,
00:02:35 and I think it's slightly more nuanced perhaps than Rafe has suggested, but there's a grain of truth to it.
00:02:40 Alexis Sale, to take that as a kicking off point, certainly did initiate a revolution in stand-up comedy
00:02:45 and the Comedy Store in the 1979 or whatever it was,
00:02:48 the first few years, there was an eruption of, I guess, student politics.
00:02:53 But it wasn't like demanding,
00:02:55 it wasn't like actually advocating Marxism so much as kind of,
00:02:58 it was aware of Marxism, it was kind of steeped in it,
00:03:01 but it was self-deprecating about it,
00:03:02 and it understood that it wasn't, you know, he was mocking it,
00:03:06 and he was mocking his own pretensions and his own understanding of it,
00:03:09 and at the same time, you know, his kind of frustrations
00:03:12 as a fat little half-Jewish scouser in a tight suit, you know,
00:03:15 he was he was he knew he was an absurd figure he wasn't like jeremy corbyn kind of earnestly
00:03:19 preaching to you about the need to redistribute wealth but but there has been a kind of presumption
00:03:25 in the last 30 i think it kind of it simmered for a long time it has actually erupted with brexit
00:03:31 it's been quite interesting just to give a really bizarre analogy um i flew to aspen colorado ski
00:03:38 resort about 15 years ago to do a comedy festival there um but the on arrival in aspen which is
00:03:45 at 8 000 feet a tooth abscess which had been dormant for god knows how many years suddenly
00:03:50 erupted due to the change in atmospheric pressure and i was in agony and had to go and see a dentist
00:03:55 luckily i had travel insurance i think brexit's been a bit like that something has been dormant
00:04:00 for many years in the comedy industry in the comedy community which nobody had really examined
00:04:04 or noticed and suddenly this kind of eruption and this kind of drawing of lines and parameters and
00:04:11 whose side are you on mentality
00:04:13 exposed the degree to which an extraordinarily unbalanced
00:04:17 distribution of views had gradually taken place.
00:04:23 And so whether it's not exactly left wing or right wing,
00:04:26 that kind of somewhere everywhere kind of dynamic,
00:04:29 which people have discussed, is more to do with it.
00:04:31 But comedy was certainly exposed as really only being Remainers
00:04:35 and a handful of people who were Brexit
00:04:37 or even a little bit sceptical or willing to admit
00:04:40 they didn't quite get it.
00:04:41 you know yeah sure and that i think has created a um a sense which you quite rightly say that now
00:04:48 50 of the country don't really feel like they're getting their meat and this is creating problems
00:04:52 with the bbc who are having to justify a license fee and yet you know are not are not actually
00:04:56 serving half the public well i mean dominic as someone who's you know made brexit at the heart
00:05:01 of your comedy how do you find it well there's there's a lot of different things going on and
00:05:05 And it's, as Simon says, it's very nuanced.
00:05:08 You can't say that comedy is not as good as it was.
00:05:12 One observation I'd make is there's no one today
00:05:15 who is as big and as known in the public eye
00:05:18 as Ronnie Barker or Morecambe and Wise or Tommy Cooper
00:05:22 or one of the greats of the 70s or the early 80s.
00:05:25 But one reason for that is that there was only
00:05:28 one, two or three channels at that time.
00:05:30 So everybody's eyes focused on that thing.
00:05:33 There's so much more proliferation of media.
00:05:35 it's sort of harder to become that known mainstream person but i do think there's something very wrong
00:05:41 at the bbc and it's if you like it's every channel's dream to have a hit comedy show
00:05:51 that they can export around the world because it will make that channel's fortune and it will keep
00:05:57 that channel afloat for years and years and years every production company is trying to land the hit
00:06:01 and money is being thrown at comedy left right and center and if you look at the money that gets
00:06:06 invested and then you look at the actual output something's very wrong because there's so little
00:06:13 really really good stuff and and the really good tv series the really successful ones seem to slip
00:06:19 through by accident they slip through in spite of the system not because of the system and so for
00:06:24 example you have something like the office which um the commissioning editor of bbc radio bbc two
00:06:30 at the time um you know rejected time and time and time again and somehow i think steven merchant
00:06:36 was doing a production course and they hired an office for a week and they filmed it and they did
00:06:40 the pilot and the commissioner still didn't want to show it and then they showed it and then he got
00:06:44 a really so it kind of happened in spite of the system and it made ricky gervais and um you know
00:06:50 who by the way is in himself a great champion of free speech and all the things that that you
00:06:54 champion on this show so there's something badly wrong with the system now i can i can
00:07:00 give you some of the reasons why i think what i think is wrong with the system
00:07:04 and perhaps we'll come to that in a moment but but this the other comment that i'd make is
00:07:10 if you look at what tv comedy is very curated what goes on tv is is curated by some decision
00:07:19 maker in commissioning yeah and so what you see on telly is very different to what you see live
00:07:25 and if you look at what's going on in the live circuit
00:07:28 and some of the clubs and some of the experimental nights
00:07:31 and we have Comedy Unleashed that we've all performed at many times
00:07:34 and there's many great cabaret nights and the Free Fringe up in Edinburgh
00:07:38 there's some really great stuff going on
00:07:40 so to say that comedy is bad or worse than it was
00:07:45 in many ways it's better than it's ever been
00:07:47 you just wouldn't know it by watching telly
00:07:50 Right, do you find that too?
00:07:52 I think everybody's kind of got it exactly right here
00:07:56 because I think what Simon says is absolutely true
00:07:59 that I think in the last few years particularly,
00:08:01 it hasn't just been about Brexit or remain.
00:08:03 I think it's more even whether you're woke or not.
00:08:06 So, for example, I'm not right-wing, right,
00:08:09 but I'm treated as if I'm right-wing in the industry
00:08:11 because I'm simply not really woke and super left-wing.
00:08:15 So it's become an industry which increasingly squeezes out people
00:08:19 who are non-conformist which is a very odd thing for comedy to be because comedy is supposed to
00:08:24 be the place where people who don't conform come together and create something that's actually
00:08:28 what comedy should be about and if you think about the comedians that you respect throughout
00:08:33 the years right these are people who would have pushed back against what the predominant narrative
00:08:37 of that time was i mean bill hicks who's one of my favorites his last ever appearance on letterman
00:08:42 was actually not shown because it was considered too controversial and it was shown 20 or 30 years
00:08:47 later and letterman actually apologized to him post humorously because it wasn't actually that
00:08:52 controversial it was just controversial in that particular cultural moment so i think
00:08:56 that's right and i also agree with dominic i think uh in terms of what's happening in the comedy
00:09:02 circuit uh we may very well be in my opinion on the very precipice of a new golden age of comedy
00:09:08 the question is will you ever see that on tv in the next five years that's a different conversation
00:09:13 Because, as Dominic says, the people who seem to have their fingers on the control panel there, they're very keen to present a certain type of comedy and drive that certain type of comedy.
00:09:27 A couple of days ago, a friend of mine who's a very famous musician, he was offered to do a show on a big TV channel in this country where he would learn stand-up and raise money for charity.
00:09:39 My brother-in-law is David Hay, the boxer, and he's been asked to do that as well.
00:09:43 Right. So my friend was offered this, and he said, yeah, great, I'd love to do it, but I'd love to do it with a comedian who's a friend of mine, so let's have Andrew Doyle or Constantine.
00:09:51 And they said, no, no, these people are not approved.
00:09:54 Seriously? You're officially not approved.
00:09:56 It could be that they've just seen my comedy, I don't know.
00:09:58 But the point is that they knew who we were, but we were not approved, right?
00:10:05 So there is an agenda there.
00:10:06 And look, I'm not someone who ever complains about this stuff.
00:10:09 I don't think it helps.
00:10:10 and as someone who likes to challenge what the mainstream narrative is
00:10:14 I don't expect to be welcomed with open arms
00:10:16 I don't think that's ever going to happen
00:10:18 I think if you're going to challenge the mainstream
00:10:19 you should expect not to be necessarily liked by the mainstream
00:10:23 but I do think that that definitely happens in TV
00:10:27 which is why I think Nick Cohen wrote a piece in Standpoint
00:10:30 at the time we're recording this
00:10:32 saying that conservative comedy should be really good now
00:10:35 because there's a lot to punch against
00:10:36 but it's not good
00:10:39 Well, has he just not encountered it?
00:10:41 Well, that's my point. That's exactly my point.
00:10:43 Because if you just watch TV, other than maybe Simon or Jeff Norcott,
00:10:46 there's very few people who are not even conservative,
00:10:49 who are just not super left or super woke that ever get through.
00:10:54 So then the general public create that impression.
00:10:57 And as rightly has been said, that's a problem for the BBC in particular,
00:11:00 which I actually think is a much-needed institution if they can sort themselves out.
00:11:05 And it's a problem for the left, incidentally.
00:11:06 Exactly.
00:11:07 Because the left, I mean, the Labour Party is fast trying to render itself unelectable, having learned all the wrong lessons, apparently, from 12th of December.
00:11:16 It's now arguing itself into dust over issues that affect less than 1% of the population.
00:11:22 You know, the definitions of transphobia and so on and people being, it desperately needs to be satirised in order to wake itself up.
00:11:30 I mean, you know, it's almost like the dynamic of playground bullying, which nobody wants to see ever, you know, escalate to the point where kids are in casualty.
00:11:38 But there is a degree of enforcing social norms and letting kids know when they're wildly out of kilter, you know, which can be valuable.
00:11:45 And that satire can produce that desired effect for the left as much as it can give succour to people on the right who are just exaggerating.
00:11:52 Absolutely. And yet you will see, you know, you and I both make jokes about Jeremy Corbyn at the time of the election.
00:11:58 There was very few, if any, people making fun of that on TV.
00:12:02 No enemy to the left.
00:12:03 Right, there's no sound to have that kind at all.
00:12:05 So there is an imbalance.
00:12:06 Yeah, and there's a very interesting lesson
00:12:08 if you look at the early history of the Edinburgh Festival.
00:12:11 And the Edinburgh Festival began in 1948.
00:12:13 There was an Austrian-Jewish refugee, a chap called Rudolf Bing,
00:12:17 who wanted to put on a festival to heal the wounds of war
00:12:21 through the medium of the arts.
00:12:23 And he looked all around various places.
00:12:25 He eventually decided on Edinburgh,
00:12:26 and he raised £30,000 of subsidy
00:12:28 and he was going to put on the very cream of European and world art.
00:12:33 So he put on Sadler's Wells Ballet, the Hallé Orchestra,
00:12:37 the Vienna Philharmonic, the Old Vic Theatre Group,
00:12:41 all these great institutions of the arts.
00:12:44 And he put the festival on
00:12:45 and there was a couple of local Scottish semi-amateur theatre groups,
00:12:50 one quite left-wing Marxist group
00:12:52 and they applied to do this festival.
00:12:55 and there was another puppeteer who also applied
00:12:59 and they were told they weren't good enough
00:13:02 and they would just know we only want the very best at this new festival
00:13:06 and all these guys thought about it and they just came anyway
00:13:10 they didn't get in the official brochure
00:13:12 they came and they were known as the uninvited eight
00:13:14 and one of them put on, the puppeteer put on a show in the foyer of the cinema
00:13:18 another one found a disused restaurant
00:13:21 and there we saw the birth of the Edinburgh Fringe
00:13:25 and the following year they were so successful
00:13:27 these uninvited guests, 12 of them came
00:13:29 and the year after that 13
00:13:31 and it gradually grew and grew and grew
00:13:33 and by the mid to late 50s
00:13:35 the Fringe, it was only coined the Fringe by the mid 50s
00:13:40 the Fringe was outdoing the main festival
00:13:43 to the extent that the main festival poached all the talent from a Fringe
00:13:47 and put on this show with which they planned to kill the Fringe
00:13:50 called Beyond the Fringe.
00:13:52 The idea was it was a snub of the Fringe.
00:13:55 Beyond the Fringe became a huge hit
00:13:56 and it only made the Fringe even more popular.
00:13:59 And this went on and on and on
00:14:00 to the extent that now the Fringe dwarfs the main festival.
00:14:05 In fact, the main festival, to save itself,
00:14:07 has had to merge with the Fringe.
00:14:09 Now, the main festival is like the BBC.
00:14:12 It's got some guy who knows better than you
00:14:15 choosing what you watch.
00:14:17 Whereas the Fringe, anyone can go,
00:14:19 i decide if i'm going to go not you and i decide if my shows what what i'm capable of doing not you
00:14:25 and so on and you know it's the difference between youtube where anyone can put stuff on and you know
00:14:30 what commissioner would ever have known that cat videos would become a thing or whatever it is
00:14:34 and yet you know that's why the fringe is so exciting then the fringe began to kill itself
00:14:39 became subsidy and became uneconomic and the market reacted quite efficiently and gave birth
00:14:44 this thing called the free fringe which is like the most creative place on earth possibly and so
00:14:50 you know the market has found solutions the problem with television is that it is owned by a few
00:14:56 curators and it's very difficult if you don't tick the right boxes to get through the curators
00:15:01 you're absolutely right and i think this is where why the future for comedy is looking very bright
00:15:06 as long as it's being consumed in different ways i mean i'm a great fan of bill burr in america i
00:15:11 I think he's the best comedian out there.
00:15:12 He's the comedian's comedian.
00:15:14 And he actually doesn't like to get called into the debates about work issues
00:15:17 because he says, I don't need the approval of the work brigade
00:15:20 because his career doesn't depend on television.
00:15:22 He sells out to huge audiences and he has Netflix shows.
00:15:26 And his Netflix shows are hugely popular around the world.
00:15:28 So when he comes to London, he can sell out the Royal Albert Hall on repeated nights,
00:15:31 even though he's never had any exposure on television in this country.
00:15:35 And I think that's the model comedians here need to use, bypassing the BBC.
00:15:39 because you have to ask yourself, which of those BBC comedians that we see every week
00:15:43 would flourish if there were no BBC, or would they flounder?
00:15:46 And I don't think Nish Kumar et al. would be doing much apart from university campuses
00:15:50 if they were actually free of the BBC, and all the comedians who actually are popular
00:15:55 would avoid university campuses for the precise reason that their comedy would fall flat there.
00:16:01 So I think, yes, comedy has a great future ahead, and it's things like Netflix and YouTube
00:16:05 that are going to basically be the savers.
00:16:07 Netflix is interesting in that point of view.
00:16:09 They have put on Bill Burr and they've put on Dave Chappelle,
00:16:11 who's also defiantly anti-woke.
00:16:13 And they've also put on Hannah Gadsby with Nanette,
00:16:15 which was the single most woke sort of anti-comedy almost.
00:16:19 I mean, it was quite explicitly anti-comedy.
00:16:20 She basically spends an hour regretting that she has attempted
00:16:25 to diffuse the tension surrounding her own sexual orientation
00:16:28 through the use of comedy for her life.
00:16:31 Sounds a thrill.
00:16:31 It's not my kind of show, but she's sold out the Sydney Opera House,
00:16:34 where it was recorded.
00:16:35 Bill Burr recorded his Netflix special at the Royal Albert Hall in London,
00:16:38 despite, as you say, being an American comedian with no access to BBC.
00:16:42 So word is getting out.
00:16:43 If you're a good comedian, Bill Burr is a very talented comedian.
00:16:45 I mean, it's not easy to just go at the gates, the woke grain, and be big.
00:16:49 You've got to be funny. You've got to be great.
00:16:51 But I have to say, I just want to interrupt you, because it's interesting.
00:16:55 I think the BBC has always been curated and has always had gatekeepers.
00:16:58 And back in the day when they had the Monopoly before YouTube or whatever,
00:17:02 it still had gatekeepers but they were of a very different mindset a lot of the people who for
00:17:07 instance commissioned you know uh john cleese and the monty python or the frost report had been at
00:17:12 university with them and then they get a job in the bbc okay there's this chap uh cleese it would
00:17:17 be funny i think we should get him and his his friend you know and so you get now a lot of people
00:17:22 would regard that as you know irredeemably you know just obviously you know on the face of it
00:17:29 morally bankrupt way to run a TV
00:17:31 network, and yet it created
00:17:32 extraordinary, you know, genius
00:17:35 that will stand the test of time.
00:17:37 Whereas now, a far more egalitarian approach
00:17:39 is, you know, and actually
00:17:41 they would probably argue that
00:17:43 they are not gatekeepers in that traditional sense
00:17:45 that it is much more like a set of algorithms
00:17:47 that sort of decides who gets off.
00:17:49 There was less competition in those days, wasn't there,
00:17:51 to get on. Yeah, but they have said, I think
00:17:53 a couple of years ago, the controller of comedy
00:17:55 said, well, we wouldn't make Monty Python
00:17:57 They're a bunch of white boys from Oxbridge.
00:17:59 They won't get on now.
00:18:01 And the woman who runs the Edinburgh Fringe said that we need more woke comedy.
00:18:05 So there is an agenda there.
00:18:06 But look, the point that Simon makes about Hannah Gadsby I think is an important one
00:18:10 because none of us are saying, look, we need to shut down woke comedy.
00:18:13 No one's saying that.
00:18:14 What we're really saying is, look, we keep being told that we live in this society
00:18:18 that's obsessed with diversity and inclusion.
00:18:21 Brilliant. Let's have more diversity.
00:18:22 You know, if we have a huge political event like the Brexit referendum, let's have comedians who think it's a terrible idea.
00:18:31 Brilliant. Let's have them on TV. Let them make their jokes.
00:18:34 For some people, that's really funny.
00:18:36 But if someone makes a song about Brexit, making light of the European Union, criticizing the EU, let's have that on as well.
00:18:44 Let's have more diversity of thought.
00:18:46 But what about the counterforce that's going on at the moment, which is this sort of woke culture that says, well, you can't offend anyone.
00:18:52 You know, you were invited to SOAS and they were saying, well, you can make jokes, but you have to fill out this form and say you'll be kind to everyone.
00:19:00 You have to be respectful and kind, and they had a list of about 20 things.
00:19:03 At which point comedy becomes impossible.
00:19:05 So if that culture starts to take hold, doesn't that become a real threat?
00:19:09 Well, that's why I turned down the contract, because I think there are some people who are trying to move us in that direction.
00:19:14 And, of course, students have always been a bit crazy in that way, you know, particularly at SOAS, let's be honest.
00:19:19 But my concern is that any culture that comes from university will eventually seep out into broader society.
00:19:27 So they're students today, but 10 years from now they're going to be labor MPs, journalists, etc.
00:19:33 And that's when they start to influence our society.
00:19:36 And you can see that happening.
00:19:38 So I think, but the point I'm making is I think all of us are not calling for other types of comedy to be shut down.
00:19:44 We just want more variety of comedy to be shown on TV.
00:19:50 And for people, you know, Dominic, myself, Simon, Alistair Williams,
00:19:54 a bunch of us have had viral videos of our clips of stand-up
00:19:58 have been seen by millions of people around the world and around the country.
00:20:03 So there's demand for people to joke about Jeremy Corbyn
00:20:06 or to joke about hating Brexit or whatever.
00:20:09 But for some reason that's not being filtered through,
00:20:11 and I think we need more of that.
00:20:13 and I think you're absolutely right
00:20:15 I was on a, I don't know if you know
00:20:17 the Now Show which is like a long running
00:20:19 Friday night comedy, tomical comedy
00:20:21 and they did a Now Show Brexit
00:20:23 special which was on the Sunday before the Brexit
00:20:25 vote in 2016
00:20:27 and it was hosted by Punt and Dennis
00:20:29 who are liberal
00:20:31 Oxbridge graduates and they had their
00:20:33 usual sort of suspects on there
00:20:35 doing a liberal take on it
00:20:37 and then they had a debate
00:20:39 about in which they wanted to
00:20:41 comedians to go head to head
00:20:44 pro and against Brexit and they got me
00:20:46 in to do the pro Brexit one
00:20:48 and Ed Morris
00:20:49 I wasn't a Brexit winner, I wasn't really
00:20:52 a Remain voter either, I was like I'm not sure
00:20:54 and it's interesting but I didn't really think
00:20:56 it was going to happen. Lucy Porter
00:20:58 was, who wasn't particularly
00:21:00 you know
00:21:02 energised about it, was the Remain
00:21:04 but the interesting thing was
00:21:06 I went on and I wrote these things out and my big
00:21:08 point was, there were questions like
00:21:10 what is it you've got to get against europe and i said well you know this i think i i refute the
00:21:16 validity of the question it's not what i've got against europe it's what have i got against
00:21:19 unnecessary supranational systems of you know extraneous tiers of organization and i've got
00:21:26 my my experience of that is running one in the sixth form block when i was at school you know
00:21:30 it's a racket i know how these things work and i did this stuff and i said yeah anyway the point
00:21:35 was this was a radio for audience and they were the now show audience and they're extremely
00:21:39 but I got easily the biggest reaction on the night from the crowd
00:21:42 to the extent that I've always worried
00:21:44 that I might have actually caused Brexit
00:21:45 because the response was so enlivening
00:21:50 because this crowd were desperate to hear the other side of the coin
00:21:53 all they'd heard for about 40 minutes
00:21:55 was everyone just kind of basically
00:21:57 oh Farad is an idiot
00:21:59 and you know there's like a bunch of knuckle dragging racists and so on
00:22:02 somebody stood up and just made some really quite facetious
00:22:06 you know arguments in defence of Brexit
00:22:08 they were like oh my god it's like somebody opened a window you know there's just a bit of fresh air
00:22:13 i think that for me proved the point and yet the bbc certainly didn't seem to learn from it because
00:22:18 there's there's been no more you know jeff they've given jeff jeff norcott yes he's had plenty of
00:22:23 airtime jeff's done fantastically well from it and he's every opportunity he's been given he's
00:22:28 been taken because he's very good yeah absolutely and jeff's been very good for a very long time
00:22:33 but like if you get into an argument with somebody in the bbc and you'll go he's this other side is
00:22:39 not represented and you will go there's this program there's this program there's this program
00:22:45 they're all clearly from that remain worldview and somebody who's trying to counter that will go yes
00:22:50 but there's jeff norcott yeah but like jeff is like one guy who occasionally appears for a couple
00:22:55 of minutes we have our token person you know and almost like sooty to be honest isn't he
00:22:59 what's that Jeff Norcock
00:23:01 you think Jeremy called
00:23:03 I mean he's very funny
00:23:05 he's a great joke writer but he's not really providing any
00:23:07 and if you look at the way that he's always
00:23:09 introduced on the MASH report it's
00:23:11 the conservative voice of Britain
00:23:12 he's like a freak show let's wheel on
00:23:14 this exceptional creature that we've managed to find
00:23:17 in the wild in the jungle
00:23:18 whereas in fact we know that 50% plus one
00:23:21 of the population actually side with him
00:23:22 he's made to look as if he's the anomaly
00:23:25 and Jeff is like you know he's a white
00:23:27 sort of working class guy
00:23:28 He describes his dad as a Mondeo man.
00:23:31 He's as typical an English person as you could get, really.
00:23:34 He's a classic 80s Tory, isn't he?
00:23:36 But this is why it's so unsustainable.
00:23:37 And even he struggles on Mock the Week.
00:23:39 I've seen him, you know, have moments...
00:23:40 I mean, he's been and gone now,
00:23:41 and Mock the Week is probably on its downward trajectory now anyway.
00:23:44 But I've seen...
00:23:46 And he's talked about, you know,
00:23:48 basically you do a joke which has an underlying right-wing sentiment
00:23:51 on Mock the Week, and the air is sucked out of the room
00:23:54 because they create such a strong momentum in a certain direction
00:23:59 that you can't just turn that around.
00:24:02 It's more like you've gone...
00:24:05 It was like, what's he going with that show?
00:24:08 And Ray's point is why this whole situation is so unsustainable
00:24:11 because what you're really talking about is the fact that the majority of the country
00:24:14 are not being served by the comedy that they're being forced to watch
00:24:17 and that's why we have the conversation about the BBC license fee
00:24:20 because the comedy thing is replicated elsewhere.
00:24:24 replicated in the news side of it in other parts of entertainment i think i'd say bbc news i think
00:24:28 it's pretty well balanced personally in fact it may even have a slight right wing back so i'm not
00:24:32 saying it does but it may do i can see the argument for that i think i think their drama department
00:24:36 is is i think that's it's like anthropology i mean it's so riddled with uh over politicized
00:24:49 and i think youtube will be an excellent way to test and see how many views
00:24:53 BBC comedians get versus those who never appeared on the BBC and that would be a very good way to
00:24:58 sort of analyse it. It would but there's one there's one thing about the BBC it is the most
00:25:03 even now it is the most fantastic platform and you know I can sit here moaning about you know
00:25:09 this structurally is wrong and curation and all the rest of it but for example when I wrote my
00:25:14 book my book is sort of consistently you know two to three thousand in the bestseller list
00:25:20 and then I went on Radio 4
00:25:22 start the week and suddenly
00:25:24 it went up to 200
00:25:25 and it just goes and then stayed there for a week
00:25:28 and then went back to it's sort of natural
00:25:30 place in the sort of 2 to 3 thousand
00:25:32 so
00:25:33 return to
00:25:36 that's actually
00:25:38 pretty good for a hardback
00:25:40 but the point
00:25:42 is if like you know you get some comics
00:25:44 who they get a spot and mock the week
00:25:46 and they're very funny in it and suddenly their tour
00:25:48 sells out and it really is the most wonderful platform was top gear now top gear was the most
00:25:53 profitable correct me if i'm wrong i don't but i think it was the most profitable worldwide sales
00:25:57 it's not a comedy show per se in fact it'd be hard to say exactly what it was but i know several
00:26:02 people who worked in television all of whom acknowledged it was a work of genius the
00:26:05 production the structure the presenters were kind of clunky and glancing in his dad jeans and
00:26:11 everything were a bit kind of full of humor you you were like god it's dad jokes but it had this
00:26:16 kind of life it just had this vitality wasn't my cup of tea at all i have to say i would occasionally
00:26:22 go on walking holidays with my mates we'd end up watching it in the cottage in the evening and i
00:26:26 would be going really you know just they want to watch whether a toyota can drive through this
00:26:31 river but they but they had something that really appealed to masses of people clearly
00:26:36 no show in my lifetime has angered the left so much as that show infuriated them a couple of
00:26:43 slightly off-colour jokes, one of which, yes,
00:26:45 I can see there was one joke that was a bit racist
00:26:47 and should probably have been edited out.
00:26:50 Gradually, this momentum
00:26:51 builds. We've got to get it. And then Clarkson punches
00:26:53 a producer. Now, that was obviously a
00:26:55 massive misjudgment on his part. But if
00:26:57 the sentiment had been there, if the will had been there to save
00:26:59 him and turn him around and get him to make the abject
00:27:01 apology and go on some sort of course
00:27:03 about not crunching producers,
00:27:04 it would have been impossible to save that show.
00:27:07 Instead of which, they leapt on it.
00:27:09 It was gone almost overnight. It was
00:27:11 like what they did to Scruton you know it was like
00:27:13 this is the final straw
00:27:14 and you go where are the other straws
00:27:16 there have been two other straws in a show that is making
00:27:19 you millions worldwide
00:27:20 and so they left and now I don't know how well I don't follow
00:27:23 this stuff how well it's doing on Amazon or indeed
00:27:24 I know the follow up shows really
00:27:26 struggled but it was the determination
00:27:28 of the left that there could not be
00:27:30 a show on the BBC
00:27:33 which was essentially
00:27:34 that mindset writ large
00:27:37 and doing well and
00:27:38 you know if these blokes want to watch
00:27:40 match of the day we can't stop them because you know but that's it and that's all they get there
00:27:45 is this really i'm going to call it what it is is this evil thing and it's it's it's worse on the
00:27:52 left than it is anywhere else yeah of wanting to no platform anyone who expresses an opinion that
00:27:58 you don't like and so it happened with top gear it happened with scrutin like even like you know
00:28:04 if i get on radio four just to talk about my book there's a hundred people why is the bbc giving
00:28:08 this right-wing schriller platform and it's why is it that the people on the other side of the
00:28:14 argument never feel the need to to know platform them the the left or is that is that it's an
00:28:20 interesting thing they're wrong and they think we're evil yes they did in the 1960s in america
00:28:25 but it is extraordinary how they're talking about mccarthyism yeah but they don't seem to have drawn
00:28:29 that parallel but we are very much we're closing in on that now i think you know yeah and if you
00:28:33 I think in the 80s and 90s, it was in America the religious right.
00:28:37 That's why the comedians of that period, you know, the Carlins and the Hicksers,
00:28:41 they would push back against religion,
00:28:43 which is why you don't see anyone talking about religion, right?
00:28:46 But I think in terms of what we're talking about,
00:28:49 what you were talking about particularly,
00:28:50 there's an interesting double stand-up when it comes to offensive jokes
00:28:53 because there are a number of comedians who have been on the BBC for a very long time
00:28:57 who have been making incredibly offensive jokes.
00:28:59 You know, Frankie Boyle talking about a celebrity's disabled son
00:29:02 in a very kind of disparaging way
00:29:04 and that's all fine
00:29:05 as long as politically
00:29:07 you're in the right place
00:29:08 just like you're talking about Top Gear
00:29:10 those offensive jokes are fine
00:29:12 whereas if someone who is not left wing
00:29:14 or worse even right wing
00:29:16 were to do those same jokes
00:29:18 then instantly they're punching down
00:29:19 and they're terrible
00:29:20 so I think that interpretation
00:29:22 of people's behaviour
00:29:24 is very dependent on
00:29:26 where they're seen as being politically
00:29:28 in fact it was an interesting case
00:29:29 because he was offensive
00:29:31 up until 2010 he was punching down in 2010 suddenly 2010 that was the time you had the
00:29:38 coalition government coming in but that's also when you had russell brand and jonathan ross
00:29:42 who had to resign from the bbc over there called to andrew sacks and there was a sea change that
00:29:47 happened in comedy at that time people don't realize that comedy became more bland after
00:29:51 frankie boyle they mock the week for example he never goes back on to mock the week now he was
00:29:55 the reason people watch mock the week there's been this cleaning up this puritanical wokeness
00:29:59 has come through comedy since 2010.
00:30:02 And I don't see people commenting on that much.
00:30:04 And that's when you see things on
00:30:05 Have I Got News For You?
00:30:06 Everything changed in the last 10 years
00:30:08 and became more bland, more saccharine.
00:30:11 You can only make fun of Tories
00:30:12 or people who are privileged.
00:30:13 You can't even make fun of Meghan and Harry,
00:30:15 despite the fact that that's punching up, clearly.
00:30:17 Yeah, that was extraordinary, wasn't it?
00:30:19 They're now an oppressed minority.
00:30:21 The Meghan thing does seem to have brought it
00:30:23 into extraordinarily sharp relief,
00:30:24 even more than Brexit,
00:30:25 that you've got a bloke on Question Time
00:30:27 who's accused of abusing his privilege
00:30:31 for criticising a princess, an actual princess.
00:30:35 I mean, it's like, how much more absurd?
00:30:38 I mean, yes, he's born into an acting family
00:30:40 and he's probably had a couple of jobs
00:30:42 that he might have otherwise not have got,
00:30:44 but he's not...
00:30:45 I mean, I'd never heard of him beforehand,
00:30:47 so he hasn't had that much privilege, you know.
00:30:49 The Fox dynasty, he's on the Windsor dynasty.
00:30:51 Yeah, exactly.
00:30:52 I mean, this stuff is very powerful.
00:30:54 I mean, there have been cases out in the population, haven't there,
00:30:56 where someone just retweets on social media or on their Facebook or something,
00:31:00 a comedian's routine, and then suddenly the police are knocking at their door
00:31:04 or they're getting fired from their work.
00:31:06 The bloke at Asda who got sacked for posting a clip from a DVD they sell in Asda.
00:31:12 They actually sell from a DVD.
00:31:18 To name drop, I was having drinks with Jim Davison's son last night
00:31:22 who said that his dad was brought up as a hate crime
00:31:27 for comments he made at his own birthday party,
00:31:29 which someone recorded,
00:31:30 and he ended up having a hate incident alleged,
00:31:32 which didn't go any further.
00:31:33 But that just shows you now,
00:31:34 not even your own birthday party is free.
00:31:37 But all those guys, the comedians of the 70s,
00:31:40 were basically no-platformed by the Alexi Sale,
00:31:47 Ben Elton, that generation,
00:31:48 all those, the Jim Davidsons, and even Benny Hill,
00:31:51 and all those guys and commissioners were actually scared to commission you know they didn't want to
00:31:57 be even though you know jim davidson was excellent on the generation game and he was the only guy who
00:32:02 could who was as good as bruce forsyth was and and he and he and um you know benny hill got the
00:32:08 viewers in larry gross very sorry did larry i take that back i was thinking of the the latter
00:32:14 but you know and he's you know he's a pretty and a lot of that stuff if you judge the stuff that
00:32:19 came out in the 70s by the standards of today then of course it's unacceptable but standards
00:32:23 change with time there was a thing wasn't there where they were there was a sort of default
00:32:27 like none of these guys are okay anymore and then one by one some of them like les dawson were kind
00:32:33 of reviewed and now back in but the idea was two ronnie sort of survived if you even if you watch
00:32:38 something we all think we love the two ronnie's you watch some of the two ronnie's stuff now and
00:32:41 you're like i know funny enough i was talking about this i i checked into a travel lodge and
00:32:46 they had the tv tuned to a one of those channels where it's just like old two runners in the
00:32:51 evening and instead of being the best of the two runners you saw what an average two runners show
00:32:56 was like and you're like oh my god it's really like you know you guys i'm a bit younger than
00:33:01 you guys and and what i noticed incredible to me is actually it's it's much later shows that
00:33:07 now are completely beyond the pale so for example harry and uh uh harry hill and what was it called
00:33:13 harry and legan no no very good harry and paul oh yeah harry and paul you watch some of that stuff
00:33:21 yeah it was harry and harry enfield uh harry and paul they did they are quite edgy but that was
00:33:27 like 10 years ago yeah but it wasn't 30 years ago which okay friends yeah friends are problematic
00:33:31 trying to ban friends come fly with me right come fly with me was a great comedy written by david
00:33:37 walliams and the other chap from little britain and there they were you know dressing up in black
00:33:41 face as Shirley Bassey and as this big large black woman. It was great comedy but of course
00:33:47 they've had to apologise for something made within the last decade. That's how quickly
00:33:51 things change and how the young eat their own. But we have to celebrate the BBC too
00:33:55 because we have to remember the BBC gave us the golden age of comedy. The BBC was the
00:33:59 driving force that nurtured comedy so let's not be too harsh. What we need is another
00:34:02 Bill Cotton. He was in charge of light entertainment. He gave us everything that we had in the
00:34:06 70s and the 80s. In the 90s, David Rennick, you know, fantastic writer, One Foot in the
00:34:11 grave and there's such great comedies
00:34:12 that were put out, I mean ITV only gave us
00:34:15 Rising Damp really, that was the only comedy
00:34:16 everything else was done on the BBC so we need to celebrate
00:34:19 them and bring them back on. There's another reason that
00:34:20 so much was on the BBC, they repeated their stuff
00:34:23 and ITV never did, so there are
00:34:24 great shows that were on ITV that never got
00:34:26 repeated and have been forgotten
00:34:28 Interesting, the BBC hasn't repeated Python that much
00:34:31 they've always been a bit. They used to
00:34:32 Well there's a whole scene of trans rights
00:34:35 in there now that you would say
00:34:36 If you look at
00:34:38 like, I can talk about
00:34:41 I mean, if you want, I can tell you
00:34:42 unknown great ITV, unknown ITV sitcoms,
00:34:44 if you want, because I've sort of done a good study.
00:34:46 I'd be able to round the castle.
00:34:46 There was one called Luckyfella,
00:34:48 which starred David Jason
00:34:50 as one of two Cockney brothers
00:34:52 living in a council flat set in Broccoli.
00:34:54 Not in Peckham, in Broccoli.
00:34:56 Only David Jason was the stupid one.
00:34:58 And they drove around in a stupid three-wheeler car.
00:35:00 No.
00:35:01 Yeah, watch it.
00:35:02 Really?
00:35:03 It was just the template for Only Fools and Horses.
00:35:05 The template.
00:35:07 But it was only ever shown once.
00:35:09 and you look at the viewing figures that Fawlty Towers got
00:35:12 first series of Fawlty, there was only over 12 episodes of Fawlty Towers
00:35:14 and the first episode, the first series was repeated four times
00:35:18 and the viewing figures went 1.5 million, 3 million, 6 million, 12 million
00:35:21 so it was the repeated things
00:35:23 I think that happened with the office to some extent as well
00:35:24 yes it did
00:35:25 and that's that, when the BBC champions something and repeats it
00:35:28 and that's when it becomes
00:35:29 well they still repeat Dad's army don't they?
00:35:31 yeah
00:35:32 but you know ideologically, ideologically in principle
00:35:35 I'm a big fan of the BBC
00:35:36 I actually think it's great to have a national institution that people from both sides can come together and watch.
00:35:42 The problem we've had in recent years, as we've been talking about ad nauseum, is that it's become increasingly directed at a certain sliver of society.
00:35:49 And if it can get back to having a general plurality of thought, plurality of comedy, plurality of drama, all those things,
00:35:57 I actually think it could be a huge benefit to this country.
00:36:01 you know my grandfather when he he escaped the soviet union for actually his one of his biggest
00:36:07 crimes was listening to the bbc it was a voice of freedom to people so the bbc can be radio too
00:36:13 uh it was bbc world service but actually what i think one of the problems with with bbc and tv
00:36:19 production is it's like what happens when you start out in your 20s as a comic maybe you actually
00:36:25 started when i was 27 but you start out and there's there's always loads of you doing open
00:36:29 spots and it's just the natural way of things that not everyone can earn a living there just
00:36:33 isn't there aren't enough gigs for everyone who starts out to earn a living maybe they were in
00:36:36 the 60s or 70s or something but they just aren't now and so you just see people falling off the
00:36:41 wayside and so particularly on the club circuit where it's the quickest way to earning a living
00:36:46 you have to be you know you have you just have to be pretty good to earn a living in the clubs
00:36:52 and so what you tend to find is a lot of guys who just aren't quite hack it or they go and just do
00:36:57 edinburgh shows every year without doing the regular circuit at which point they become more
00:37:01 interesting in edinburgh because you're like oh well i can see that guy on the club circuit and
00:37:04 they go and see him in edinburgh but a lot of them just go they don't make it as a performer
00:37:08 writer performer and so they go and work in tv which is the kind of next best thing so a lot of
00:37:12 tv hierarchy is filled with people who did who didn't weren't good enough to make it
00:37:18 do you see what i mean so there's a sort of inherit second best i hope nobody
00:37:23 I was going to say you're never getting back on TV
00:37:27 I don't know whether the
00:37:28 figures would stack up but you can see
00:37:31 why somebody might want to do that
00:37:32 I mean I think
00:37:35 we sort of agreed that comedy is lively
00:37:37 out there the problem is getting it onto the BBC
00:37:39 and however much you can do now with new media
00:37:41 the BBC still has a big
00:37:43 role to play but I mean as we
00:37:44 wrap this discussion up
00:37:46 how optimistic should we be
00:37:48 is it hopeless, is it just going to fall away over time
00:37:51 is there something we should be doing
00:37:52 what's what's people's sense i think what rave said about netflix is is encouraging in that the
00:37:57 bbc will whether or not it does go to subscription or whatever the bbc will have to look at other
00:38:02 models which have found better more successful means of of delivering to a wider range of of
00:38:08 audience and if you simply just allow you know as much as the beat it's not out of the question
00:38:15 even if it remains on its current funding that it could allow a certain amount of awareness of
00:38:19 market forces you know to you know whether it be clicks and likes or whatever to to just encourage
00:38:24 it to be a little bit more it doesn't even really need it's not like you're looking for right-wing
00:38:29 comedians to be honest i wouldn't expect to see jim davison on there who has become kind of
00:38:33 pugnaciously right-wing and inappropriate and that you know and i completely understand why
00:38:39 they wouldn't put him on but just stuff that isn't actually shoving woke politics down your throat
00:38:44 all the time, you know, just stuff that is
00:38:46 funny and it's in kind of examination
00:38:49 of family life or whatever, it will
00:38:50 discover that I think. I'd love to be
00:38:52 the next Director General of the BBC
00:38:54 because what I would do
00:38:56 It's been an unusual pitch from that point of view
00:38:59 I don't think
00:39:01 I'm going to get the gig for various reasons
00:39:03 the
00:39:04 opportunity from an
00:39:07 investment point of view, the opportunity that
00:39:09 is the BBC and the worldwide
00:39:10 reputation it has and the perception it has
00:39:12 you know, I would focus
00:39:14 on making British programmes
00:39:17 for British people, but I would
00:39:19 open up the market through
00:39:20 iPlayer and through the various other means
00:39:23 you can, so that people from
00:39:25 aboard can subscribe, and there's all sorts of copyright
00:39:27 issues with BBC Worldwide and the way they sell
00:39:29 programmes, that they can't do it
00:39:30 but crikey, if you want to enough
00:39:33 and you could just make
00:39:34 so much money opening the BBC
00:39:37 up to a worldwide audience
00:39:38 making British programmes for British people
00:39:41 that you would have to charge
00:39:42 neither a license fee nor a subscription it could be free but you're gonna have to make top gear
00:39:49 again so what that's what that's why i said british programs that's what they'll have to do
00:39:54 because british people wanted a what it was made by brits for brits and the world loved it and
00:39:58 that's what we have to get back to instead of you know making stuff that people and and often it is
00:40:03 the forces of commerce it's market forces that force you to do that and and so maybe it needs
00:40:08 to be opened up to market forces so it becomes less protectionist you can tell he's a libertarian
00:40:13 can't you yeah i i think actually incredibly optimistic i am about the future of comedy like
00:40:21 i said at the beginning i think we are on the verge of a new alternative comedy and i see that
00:40:27 with comedy unleashed which dominic mentioned where he hosts often and we perform i i see that
00:40:32 there's a hunger for for a counter culture and i think that is now being formed and with the
00:40:37 internet as raith said youtube and you know netflix i think is still a form of gatekeeping
00:40:42 if you like but certainly with youtube there is an opportunity uh for people who who are funny
00:40:48 but who are not welcome in the mainstream channels to develop an audience to to become known
00:40:53 and and then to be able to perform and then you know as you say market forces in the end will
00:40:57 take over raith last thought yeah no definitely and i think certainly we've got netflix but there's
00:41:02 a proliferation of other channels that are coming out onto the internet why not have one just for
00:41:06 comedy, you know, for the UK, dealing
00:41:08 with stand-up comics, so people can go there and they know
00:41:10 that they're going to have a wide diversity of opinion.
00:41:12 It's called Dave.
00:41:14 If you want to look at how
00:41:16 you looked ten years ago, it's called Dave.
00:41:18 I would say, though, it's stand-up
00:41:20 comedy, I mean, when
00:41:21 it was funny, it was my agent,
00:41:24 sadly, who created Live, it was originally
00:41:26 Jack D at the Apollo, and then
00:41:27 Michael McIntyre's Roadshow, both with a
00:41:30 huge bank of electric lights behind them in a
00:41:32 massive stage, revolutionised how
00:41:34 we consume stand-up on telly. It's still
00:41:36 nothing like as good as going to a gig you know you really need to go out and see it live you
00:41:41 need to smell it and and and you know spill the beer and and then it really becomes alive i think
00:41:46 finding new formats through which funny people can reach an audience through television is an
00:41:51 ongoing and it does feel to me like we are due a new you know the panel game era was like 20 years
00:41:57 or so we've had of of like have i got news for you and then all it's one of is we feel like i feel
00:42:02 like now actually if you watch some of the great american podcasts which get millions of views
00:42:06 people like joe rogan will have bill burr on and they will spend three hours just chewing the fat
00:42:11 and maybe smoking a joint you know whatever and they they you know they go here there and
00:42:15 everywhere and there are no limitations at all a lot of people really like those shows that might
00:42:19 give us some kind of indication where it could go feel like we're due a new format well it's
00:42:23 interesting isn't it that the two leading podcasts in america are both done by comedians
00:42:27 Dave Rubin and Joe Rogan
00:42:29 who will have on Jordan Peterson and Douglas Murray
00:42:31 and others onto his show because stand-up comedians
00:42:33 see the potential here and of course in America
00:42:35 they're great defenders of free speech but you're bang on the nail
00:42:37 about opening up the BBC to the world
00:42:39 because we are one of the world's top-ranked
00:42:41 soft power nations, our reach
00:42:42 we punch far above our weight because of our soft power
00:42:45 the BBC is one of the ways to do that
00:42:47 and it's a crying shame that people around the world
00:42:49 or even we can't watch the BBC when we travel abroad
00:42:51 it's absolute nonsense
00:42:52 and you've got to realise that we're regarded
00:42:55 as the world's funniest nation
00:42:56 but we've only got fuel
00:42:58 fumes left in the tank right now
00:43:00 and it's 40 towers and Benny Hill that are constantly
00:43:02 and I being served of all things in America
00:43:04 they keep being cited, we need to get
00:43:06 out there and push BBC, especially in this
00:43:08 era of Brexit, promoting the best of British
00:43:10 let's use the BBC to channel that soft
00:43:12 power and give Britain a big boost
00:43:14 Well, on that optimistic note, we'll have to
00:43:16 leave it there, thank you to all of my guests
00:43:18 and thank you for listening, this has been
00:43:20 Counterculture
00:43:26 Thank you.