New Culture Forum - February 02, 2022


Covid is a Battle Between World Views - Pro-Restrictions Lobby are Trying to Remove Johnson

Posie Parker ⧸ Kellie-Jay Keen - Why Trans Women Aren't Women Whoopi, Anti-Semitism & Critical Race Theory & The Left's Blind Spot: Black (& Muslim) Prejudice

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

166.98

Word count

7,553

Sentence count

160


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now my guest today I'm very pleased
00:00:25 say is it almost one of our almost one of our regulars peter hitchens uh the columnist and
00:00:31 author is with me now thank you very much indeed for coming peter it was about three months ago
00:00:36 we talked about the police yes um but the time before that um we were taken off because we were
00:00:44 talking about covert and all of that sort of thing yes we mustn't do that no no it quite
00:00:49 this week we've seen lots of restrictions come off and the whole feeling is of the
00:00:58 thing falling apart a bit you know in other countries in europe as well and your position
00:01:04 as you put it in that particular interview did was quite simply that you thought the response
00:01:12 to it was disproportionate and the government hadn't really proved its case for these kind of
00:01:18 measures lockdown what have you um do you feel now vindicated no because i think an awful lot
00:01:27 of people still believe that the thing was justified uh the way in which the argument
00:01:33 is presented in most cases is is the way in which it was presented throughout with what seems to me
00:01:38 to be uh a a presentation of the facts which i would in many cases dispute which which gives
00:01:47 the impression that a larger event took place than one that did. It's dangerous even to
00:01:52 say that too because to suggest that it was exaggerated is immediately to be accused of
00:01:57 claiming it didn't happen because there's no subtlety in argument anymore. You're either
00:02:02 totally signed up to the official view or if you're a critic of it you're a denier
00:02:07 and disinformation purveyor and that's where you are. So all that still persists. Any kind
00:02:15 criticism of the proportionality of the reaction isn't treated as such, it's treated as objection
00:02:23 to the whole thing. And almost immediately you're also accused of all kinds of other
00:02:28 positions you haven't taken. So people say, oh well you must be against vaccination and so forth.
00:02:33 So all that still persists. If for instance it were asserted in a couple of weeks time that
00:02:41 a new variant had arrived which required the shutdown of the country again then i'd be back
00:02:46 very much in a despised minority so vindicated not by any means no uh i suppose i was thinking of
00:02:54 i've seemed to notice journalists at least some other journalists now at least questioning things
00:03:00 that have happened over the past two years where once upon a time they wouldn't have done that i
00:03:06 the the general tone of things seems to have changed a bit i before well yeah that's great
00:03:11 isn't it i mean some months after the fire has been put out a few people turn up with tin mugs
00:03:16 and empty them on top of the embers uh they could have been more used at the time but of course
00:03:22 everybody uh well i say everybody most people fit in with the spirit of the age and the spirit of
00:03:29 the age is now to say well maybe we did go a little bit far but fundamentally when the when
00:03:34 the report is completed on this I carry on predicting this the report will say we did not
00:03:39 lock down soon enough we did not lock down hard enough the whole principle of shutting down the
00:03:43 country to contain a disease will continue to be accepted as correct. Do you do you find that
00:03:51 experience the past couple of years has altered your opinion of this country in any way?
00:03:57 A bit. Not all that much. I mean, I noticed, particularly during the Blair attempts to undermine and dismantle the liberties of the country, that there wasn't anything like as much objection to these things as I had thought instinctively that there would be.
00:04:14 And I felt instinctively, for instance, the longer and longer periods of detention without trial, which the Belay government wanted in the name of fighting terrorism, were outrageous.
00:04:24 And I thought that also the getting rid of several of the protections which we ought to have against being prosecuted twice for the same alleged crime and the total right to silence which we used to possess.
00:04:40 These things, I thought they were taken away with very little fuss.
00:04:43 So I wasn't as surprised as I would otherwise have been by the fact that when people were told, fundamentally, your liberties are gone until we decide to give them back to you, people didn't care much.
00:04:54 I was shocked by one thing.
00:04:56 I wasn't shocked by the feebleness of the opposition.
00:04:58 I knew it was feeble.
00:05:00 I wasn't shocked by the feebleness of Parliament.
00:05:01 I'm constantly astonished by the weakness and ignorance of the people who populate that chamber.
00:05:08 But I was shocked by the impossibility of making any kind of legal challenge to what
00:05:14 the government had done.
00:05:15 The courts would not even hear a case for a judicial review of the government's action.
00:05:21 Now, I just think that's ridiculous, given the judicial reviews they permitted on the
00:05:29 European issue.
00:05:30 Quite rightly, in my view, they should have done it.
00:05:33 But the courts really did surprise me by not even being prepared to consider it.
00:05:38 who knows what would have happened if they had but they didn't and that that did surprise me
00:05:45 so when it comes to public people uh the liberty aspect of things as you sort of you say people
00:05:54 didn't really seem to care very much do you put that down to the fact that uh people just simply
00:06:01 don't know about these things anymore yes and david cameron used to go on about how we should
00:06:06 to have a British Bill of Rights and we have one since 1689 and here was a man who'd actually
00:06:14 become prime minister being educated to Deaton and Oxford and didn't know we had one also didn't
00:06:19 know what the Magna Carta meant he said so yeah I don't know it may have been an elaborate joke
00:06:24 but I'm not sure I think you could now come right the way through the education system
00:06:29 without knowing these things you couldn't when I was growing up but you can now I suppose it
00:06:36 my feeling is uh it may be a sentimental one but it was a sort of feeling that the uh
00:06:42 I thought British people would have a bit more truculence about them when it came to having
00:06:49 things in force on them yeah it's been it's gone I think I'd say that's what that's what's became
00:06:55 apparent the other things I'd always noticed the the ridiculous restrictions which are placed on
00:07:00 on people who travel by air you go to the airport and from the moment you arrive the treat is if
00:07:05 you're being processed uh for incarceration uh humiliated you know you have your testicles x-rayed
00:07:11 and uh and you're made to take your clothes off and undo your trousers and all these other
00:07:16 nonsensical things which don't even make sense uh on a rational basis and people just put up with it
00:07:22 And if occasionally, if you're going through this, you let out a minor mutter of protest,
00:07:28 the chances are that the person standing next to you will say, well, it's all for your own good.
00:07:32 Would you really rather not, would you really, these things were not really here?
00:07:35 Would you like to fly on a plane where these precautions were not taken?
00:07:38 And to which one I realized, actually, I wouldn't mind at all because I don't think these things do any good.
00:07:42 But I realized as this happened that people were not merely prepared to put up with it
00:07:48 and didn't see it as outrageous, but also that they quite liked it.
00:07:52 quite liked it so presumably uh quite like wearing masks well there are a lot of people who plainly
00:08:00 do and when when the restrictions have been off or when they are taken off people continue to wear
00:08:05 them in places where they're not required to and many people wear them outside yes i've never got
00:08:11 that you know there are some things that actually cast one down a bit and and seeing people and i
00:08:17 I see especially young people walking on the street on their own with a mask.
00:08:24 No one has actually ever asked you even.
00:08:26 It's a proclamation.
00:08:28 They're saying, because remember, the official propaganda for the masks is you're doing it for others.
00:08:33 And what people are doing is saying, I'm doing this for you.
00:08:36 And they're proud of themselves.
00:08:41 What damage or what changes do you think are going to be permanent?
00:08:47 hard to tell and we're going through quite a struggle at the moment because we have a
00:08:51 government which has to some extent recovered its reason and this is why i think that johnson is now
00:08:57 under attack i'm not a friend of johnson i continue to be highly critical of him and if i'd
00:09:03 got hold of these stories about about partisan downing street during the shutdown i would have
00:09:08 publicized them and pointed out that they showed clearly that the people in charge of it didn't
00:09:12 believe in their propaganda. But nobody leaked them then. There must have been, the people
00:09:19 who knew about them knew about them then, and they didn't leak them then. They're leaking
00:09:23 them now to damage Johnson precisely at the point when actually he's out of step with
00:09:28 the rest of the United Kingdom nations and also out of step with most of Europe in being
00:09:32 more relaxed. And I think it's relaxation which is causing this. I think it's the enemies
00:09:36 relaxation who are now turning on him. Would they be, no, this is just a hunch,
00:09:43 but are those the enemies of relaxation? Are they the same sort of people as
00:09:49 would be Remainers? Well I don't know, there's probably an overlap, but being
00:09:56 someone who overlaps within himself as a friend of the Norway option, it's
00:10:02 not something which really grabs me and plainly there is a there is some
00:10:07 congruence and it's very interesting and I noticed this and Janice Turner also in
00:10:14 The Times the other day did Mark Drakeford the the Welsh First Minister
00:10:19 gave an extraordinary interview on BBC a few days ago in which he said that the
00:10:25 the people of Wales were more collective than the people of England and more
00:10:30 concerned and less concerned with individual freedom than conservatives and what janice
00:10:34 turner noted was just the considerable venom he put into into saying this i think it's quite clear
00:10:40 that there is among those who are more collective more communitarian more of the traditional
00:10:46 left which believes that you hand over your your liberties to the state in return for safety
00:10:53 there is a profound political division in this country and in wales and scotland i think the
00:11:00 it's it's it's much more on the collective side and always has been in
00:11:05 England it's more balanced but I think it's quite clear from from what mr.
00:11:09 Drake has said that we are actually engaged here in a battle between
00:11:13 collective authoritarianism and the old-fashioned liberty under the law
00:11:17 well that's I've heard you say I think it was proclaiming a different
00:11:24 worldview I think absolutely doing so but most people don't understand
00:11:30 that they have worldviews but they have them and I think an awful lot of people to go back to your
00:11:38 original question an awful lot of people who liked the European Union and our membership
00:11:43 they were the same people who like collectivism and who like a strong state a lot of people do
00:11:50 it's not this what's why the referendum was such a close division because really for the first
00:11:56 time in many years instead of dividing on party lines which are increasingly
00:12:01 meaningless the country divided on lines of real difference about what kind of
00:12:06 country and world we should live in also a different attitude to people maybe
00:12:12 maybe well if you if your attitude to people is that no I'm the best way of
00:12:17 summing it up for me has always been the great saying the secret of good
00:12:21 government is to let men alone yeah if you have that view then you're
00:12:26 going to be differing on lots of things from the person who believes that he is his brother's keeper
00:12:30 yes but isn't it also i thought about you know there's a sort of if you go through your average
00:12:38 newspaper now uh or even on the media broadcast media the word vulnerable comes up time and time
00:12:47 again as part of our culture i mean and it's almost like the emphasis now is on sort of victimhood
00:12:56 Care vulnerability not about sort of somehow strength
00:13:01 But how does one make
00:13:03 How does one make a strong state appealing you make a strong state appealing by stating that it will protect
00:13:09 Those who need protecting that it will come to the aid of the weak or the vulnerable
00:13:14 You'd like to say I had no doubt at all that in a more collective society the the old
00:13:20 individual impulses for self-defense or anything like that have gone and also we
00:13:25 live in a in a world which in some ways is a good thing that I'm not sure we can
00:13:29 sustain it with our current policies in which in which warfare and conquest are
00:13:34 now pretty much abjured so the person who we claim to admire our military
00:13:40 valour but actually we're rather nervous about exercise. We make a lot of fuss
00:13:46 about it in the past but if we actually had to provide it now we might find the
00:13:52 rather few people willing to do it because we haven't brought people up in
00:13:56 the way that they used to be believing in these things. I'm still amused by the
00:14:00 fact when I was growing up in this country after the war there were
00:14:03 actually books about the Second World War for boys and girls called Men of
00:14:08 Glory and more Men of Glory. These are written by Max Hastings his father
00:14:14 at donald hastings and then for girls there was a companion volume called women of glory
00:14:18 imagine it sounds like the soviet union doesn't it glory this is this was it seemed perfectly normal
00:14:24 at the time and these were all episodes of uh usually of martial courage sometimes of the kind
00:14:29 of martial courage where other people are rescued but often people just simply fought on long after
00:14:33 they should have stopped yeah we have a situation going on at the moment with possible invasion of
00:14:40 ukraine um and indeed the government is saying things such as that we will always defend freedom
00:14:47 and we will go to people's aid and defend freedom but um for all that bluster the majority of the
00:14:54 country seems really utterly indifferent about it well i think they possibly are but the part
00:14:59 of the reason for indifference is there's a profound ignorance of what's going on in ukraine
00:15:03 i doubt whether most of the politicians who engaged in this argument or many of the journalists
00:15:07 that you could find Odessa on a map if you gave them a blank map of the area or a number
00:15:13 of other features or people simply don't know but that's a very small part of the Ukraine
00:15:22 controversy. Do you think we are on the verge of World War III? No. No? Why? Well I don't think
00:15:31 that Vladimir Putin is a madman. If he were stark staring mad then he would invade Ukraine. In fact
00:15:36 he would probably have done so already but in the modern world the only country which can go
00:15:41 around invading other people is the united states nobody else can do it without united nations
00:15:46 sanction and and he wouldn't get away with it it would probably bring him down it would quite
00:15:51 possibly destroy russia and you could win without very much difficulty i thought of a swift war
00:15:58 even that might go wrong you can never tell how wars will go until they happen but having won it
00:16:03 what do you do next you have to hold what you've captured uh ukrainians don't want to be ruled by
00:16:08 russia they've made this perfectly plain and most intelligent russians realize this i can't
00:16:12 see what would be in it for putin to launch something as crude as an invasion do you know
00:16:18 ukraine well i've been there i spent in fact some years before all this came i went on a visit to
00:16:25 West Pole and to the Donbass to Donetsk itself and to a fascinating town called Gorlovka which
00:16:33 is actually twin with Barnsley and has a cafe Barnsley in the middle of it and to talk mainly
00:16:39 to Russians living in Ukraine about their problems with doing so because Ukrainian nationalism has
00:16:45 been actually not particularly accommodating to Russians in Ukraine especially recently in
00:16:52 in terms of language and status.
00:16:54 And I foresaw not very difficult to do trouble.
00:16:59 That was the last major time I went to Ukraine.
00:17:04 When I was living in the Soviet Union,
00:17:06 one would go down there to Crimea,
00:17:10 which was never really Ukrainian,
00:17:12 and to Kiev from time to time.
00:17:14 But my most recent sustained trip
00:17:17 was a few years before the trouble broke out.
00:17:19 And I think I can say that I saw something coming,
00:17:22 not this but something because the Ukraine is a it's been created out of a former Soviet
00:17:32 Republic.
00:17:33 Its borders are completely not ideal for a nation state and not least because they contain
00:17:38 so quite large Russian minorities they would they were not designed for an independent
00:17:42 country and the only way it could work and I think that the sensible intelligent diplomacy
00:17:49 which has been going on this is working towards this would be if Ukraine became a more federal
00:17:52 state and gave Russians particularly in the Don base and more autonomy.
00:17:57 I think the Ukraine has lost Crimea of good, I think Russia will give it back without very
00:18:02 considerable fight.
00:18:04 And I don't think that fight will happen.
00:18:06 But I think the Russian speaking East, which used to sustain the party of the regions,
00:18:14 basically kept Ukraine in balance before 2014 really does need some special
00:18:19 consideration and if people wanted peace in that area the the Minsk II
00:18:24 agreement which was intended to achieve something like that should be pursued
00:18:27 but everyone seems to let it die. Putin has said that he thinks that the West is
00:18:37 obsolete and i wonder you know when you look at the past year afghanistan and also all the things
00:18:46 that are going on internally in the west um when they do say you know we will defend freedom and
00:18:52 we have to act in the situation you sort of can't help feeling but where it do you actually still
00:18:58 have the will and the capacity to act even if you wanted to in what way is freedom an issue here i
00:19:03 I mean, Ukraine is not exactly a law-governed democracy, and technically, I mean, it has elections.
00:19:10 But journalists can run into trouble.
00:19:13 The newspapers and broadcasters can face restriction.
00:19:16 I believe that the books, Anthony Beaver's book on Stalingrad, I think, ran into trouble over there.
00:19:23 It's seriously corrupt.
00:19:26 The former president is currently facing prosecution, having lost the election.
00:19:31 this isn't really an issue of freedom versus tyranny
00:19:36 it's a much
00:19:40 much more complicated question
00:19:42 the whole zone
00:19:46 of Eastern Europe
00:19:48 which is no longer under
00:19:50 Soviet domination
00:19:51 has not universally become a
00:19:54 paradise of incorruptible
00:19:56 freedom, democracy and the rule of law
00:19:58 in the what
00:20:00 now, 30 years since Soviet rule ended, there are a lot of problems in that part of the
00:20:07 world, which really make much more sense to address those than to engage in great power
00:20:14 confrontations with Russia over who controls Ukraine.
00:20:18 Everybody who knows anything about European strategy knows that Ukraine is pivotal.
00:20:23 It has been, really, since the rise of Germany.
00:20:26 And in modern terms, speaking of Brzezinski, in his book, The Grand Chessboard, says that the control of Ukraine is crucial.
00:20:37 Now, control doesn't necessarily mean possession, but it does mean having strong influence over it.
00:20:43 If Russia felt that Ukraine had actually passed into the NATO alliance, it would be deeply alarmed.
00:20:50 so you you you actually just don't think there is going to you know there's not an intention
00:20:55 even to invade on the part of us well i i don't know i mean if i say if there is then the people
00:21:02 who have that intention are are unhinged it it couldn't conceivably do russia any good and since
00:21:08 russia controls whether it invades or not then if if if as a nation does something so unhinged
00:21:16 and self damaging then it could happen but if it does then it means that Putin
00:21:22 isn't just a sinister tyrant and a man who's failed to curb the corruption in
00:21:27 his country and certainly failed to establish or maintain a law government
00:21:31 democracy is also crazy but I don't think at the moment we have any evidence
00:21:35 of that but an invasion of Ukraine would be the evidence but it seems to me to be
00:21:39 profoundly unlikely because I see no sign that he is crazy do you have many
00:21:43 contacts with with russia now do you not really i have i haven't even been there for a couple of
00:21:49 years now and i'm it's the this the the moscow i knew is unrecognizable compared with the moscow
00:21:57 that is now so no but i keep in touch i'm still interested and i have this vague knowledge of the
00:22:04 geography and the history which enables me to to see a bit beyond the the sillinesses of what a
00:22:10 of people right this has been for many years a debate though which has been a positive disadvantage
00:22:15 to know anything about the subject the less you know the easier it is to pile in yes um i just
00:22:23 wonder we we haven't had very much coverage during the past couple of years during this pandemic of
00:22:28 certain parts of the world and what how they've done and i i have no a sense really of of how
00:22:34 russia has handled for example the past two years very badly very heavy-handedly have it so yeah but
00:22:42 it it it it went it was it was it was it was among the most repressive in its initial yeah
00:22:48 but then again it reached the stage where as i was told by by people i knew who living in moscow at
00:22:53 the time where a lot of people unless they could actually be be seen by a police officer
00:22:57 stopped paying much attention but the initial the initial shutdown was pretty draconian
00:23:02 they didn't
00:23:04 at all stand out from the rest of
00:23:07 Europe in this, they went down the path of
00:23:09 panic
00:23:09 if you come back to
00:23:13 Britain for a minute
00:23:15 you know
00:23:16 again we're waiting as you mentioned earlier
00:23:18 this report
00:23:19 the Sue Gray
00:23:21 actually you mentioned the public inquiry I believe
00:23:24 Peter, sorry, we're waiting for this moment
00:23:26 we've got to wait for the police now
00:23:28 yeah, quite
00:23:30 the dick inquiry
00:23:32 And and well and you know in question to dig and who I think you actually warned against didn't you years ago?
00:23:40 Yeah, I think there was some I heard about enough reading stuff written by my my old friend David Rose who in those days was quite keen on it
00:23:48 I thought this woman is going to be commissioner
00:23:52 I've got an old cutting somewhere predicting it so long ago that it's yellow
00:23:56 but I also said before she was appointed I said that she had there was evidence
00:24:02 that she was that she would be disastrous and I'm writing it and
00:24:05 thinking well there'd be some fuss about this yeah they hadn't actually picked
00:24:08 it yes it's five years ago and being amazed that nobody else joined in at
00:24:14 all that there was although it wasn't it her record was let's be polite patchy in
00:24:20 the extreme is it wise to is it wise to appoint this person to the most important policing job
00:24:27 in the country but no she was duly appointed as predicted so now we're having to wait aren't we
00:24:33 on this report because of well i don't know how it works honestly but it seems to me that if you've
00:24:38 got two inquiries going i suppose one is you have to work out which one which one is more important
00:24:43 And if an organ of the state, to do with law enforcement, with the capacity to take a case to the Crown Prosecution Service
00:24:55 and suggest the charges are preferred, if such an organ is involved, then presumably that takes precedence over a civil servant.
00:25:01 I don't know. It's a mystery to me.
00:25:03 I think she, to an extent, is, you know, because she's the first woman and all of that, that was the reason.
00:25:10 i remember the london assembly when i was on it for five years having to scrutinize her and the
00:25:15 police and she was deeply unimpressed a very nice lady perfectly nice yeah charming you know this
00:25:22 isn't personal yeah but totally you know at a loss i felt you know uh in in with the statue
00:25:31 thing and with the policing of the you know the pandemic restrictions but she distinguished
00:25:37 She pushed herself very early in her career with what might be very simply called left-wing
00:25:41 policing, which makes compromises with demonstrators, which is more or less neutral between offender
00:25:49 and victim, is not driven as it used to be by a strong idea of what is and what is not
00:25:58 right.
00:25:59 But it's the managing of society.
00:26:01 I call these people paramilitary social workers, and she is the epitome of paramilitary social
00:26:06 yes and they are they have the minds and attitudes of social workers but they also have big truncheons
00:26:12 yes for some strange reason baseball caps yes i know it's just a weird symbol of the new
00:26:18 police no who would have thought after all those years of the admired british bobby and his helmet
00:26:23 that we'd end up with police forces baseball caps i know that my admiration so they were in bucharest
00:26:29 yeah my admiration is almost totally gone i'm afraid um you know i don't even people admiration
00:26:34 should go. My view
00:26:36 is now quite straightforward.
00:26:38 They should be replaced.
00:26:40 We should train a new proper
00:26:42 police force, genuinely local,
00:26:45 genuinely locally controlled,
00:26:46 genuinely dedicated to
00:26:48 the enforcement of law
00:26:50 without fear or favor.
00:26:52 We should swear in proper constables
00:26:54 with a
00:26:56 proper oath. When we've
00:26:58 assembled these new police forces,
00:27:00 we should close down the other one.
00:27:02 There is no other future. If you don't
00:27:04 do that then you this is this is just a gigantic failed nationalized industry which is uh which
00:27:09 simply does not fulfill the purpose for which we hired it well when she finally you know oh yeah
00:27:17 well when we get these reports in it um we're left with the government and we're left with
00:27:24 you know people then sort of trying to hide themselves and blame and all of that i wonder
00:27:29 Another point where you've been completely consistent over the interview is in the way in which the Tory party, as it stands, is the greatest enemy of conservatism, really, in this country.
00:27:46 And I just wonder that because it is now being so reviled by its supporters
00:27:53 for having gone so far seemingly to the left,
00:27:58 whether in fact this was possibly a chance that it actually might go
00:28:03 or that something else will come.
00:28:05 If it did, the only people who would win from it
00:28:09 would be Sir Keir Starmer's Labour Party and the Scottish Nationalists.
00:28:13 And that's the problem that we now face.
00:28:15 i don't want to defend these people i have no time for them at all but and for a long time i've been
00:28:22 perfectly happy to say that honestly there's been no real choice between new labor and the conservative
00:28:26 party because they were identical in politics but this particular moment where johnson is being
00:28:32 attacked for dismantling some of the of the covid autocracy then those who are attacking him are my
00:28:39 enemy so it doesn't make Johnson my friend yeah and also there is a grave
00:28:44 danger that if people continue to us what we will get at the next election is
00:28:48 labor I think will struggle greatly to get a majority in Parliament by itself
00:28:54 but you will get the possibility of a pact between Starmer and Sturgeon right
00:29:02 yes and I think that's something which hardly anyone of any sense could
00:29:08 possibly desire but the point is they always make this this this can just make a point about this
00:29:14 people say oh well he'll never do it and uh once scotland goes he won't have a majority but the
00:29:20 point is that what the the pact will be two ways and this has often happened in english history
00:29:25 scotland could intervene on the side of radicalism as it did during the civil war and you could have
00:29:31 have the Scottish Nationalists delivering Keir Starmer a new constitution with proportional
00:29:38 representation for the next parliamentary election for instance and the abolition of
00:29:43 the second chamber in return for a promise of a referendum. The possibilities are quite
00:29:50 frightening if it happens. It won't be a minor change.
00:29:54 But don't you think that people have, it's got to come to the point where the Tories
00:30:00 at every election say uh well you know okay if you don't vote for us you're going to get him
00:30:05 right there whether it was yeah but that's so unconvincing when when when the person you're
00:30:10 going to get has been for so many years identical i mean at one point i did um i would say that in
00:30:16 the context between david cameron and gordon brown gordon brown was more conservative than
00:30:21 david cameron certainly ed balls was and certainly gordon brown was more hostile to the euro than
00:30:25 david cameron's ever been but therefore you know shouldn't it be the case that basically
00:30:32 people should be advised well actually shouldn't they say well actually okay
00:30:35 to always call their bluff and say actually we're not going sorry this time we're not voting for
00:30:41 you i mean would you advise people not to vote i've for a long time i always i urge abstention
00:30:47 abstention yeah so i think mass abstention is would be the only effective way of contributing
00:30:54 contributing to the only ethical and effective way of contributing to politics in this country.
00:30:58 But whether I can continue, and this is the thing which now troubles me, this is purely
00:31:04 a defensive thing, not an endorsement, but as at the moment, although I dislike Johnson
00:31:11 and his government and think them useless, the last thing I want to do now is anything
00:31:15 which would help Keir Starmer and Mark Drakeford and Nicola Sturgeon
00:31:21 regain the levels of shutdown and restriction which they would plainly like.
00:31:27 And of course, if they get rid of Johnson, that is quite possibly what will follow.
00:31:35 The departure of Johnson is a victory for Sturgeon, Starmer and Drakeford.
00:31:39 The feeling we get to the moment is that he's kind of coming out the other side.
00:31:43 I have no idea. I can't read it, and it's impossible. I have no means of reading Parliament at the moment at all.
00:31:51 The disposition of forces, the reason why I'm taking a position which I find quite uncomfortable at the moment of saying,
00:31:57 I'm not in favour of Johnson, I'm not defending Johnson, I'm attacking his attackers, which I am,
00:32:03 and people should be very, very wary of helping those attackers at the moment.
00:32:08 If there were to be, you know, in an imaginary world, there was to be a conservative party that was actually genuinely conservative, do you think actually that the nature of Britain has changed to the extent that actually people would still vote for something like that?
00:32:27 No. No, I think we've had, I think we live in a post-revolutionary country and have done for some
00:32:34 time. And one of the things which revolutions do is they propagate themselves among the young.
00:32:40 I think there are a few eccentrics under 30 who might conceivably have some idea of being
00:32:46 conservative. But in general, the radical ideas of the Cultural Revolution have been absorbed and
00:32:52 accepted by the vast majority of the population there is no silent majority of conservatives
00:33:00 if there ever was there hasn't been one for for many years that's very that's very interesting
00:33:06 to hear actually because you know uh i suppose you could say that uh with brexit for example was
00:33:14 was i know you weren't in very you weren't in fact the referendum itself but but um 52 48 or
00:33:22 whatever um somewheres and anywheres you know which tends to suggest that the somewheres are
00:33:28 the silent majority you know they're more likely to be and that therefore they were only they
00:33:33 amounted to 52 but on an awful lot of issues which would would move me greatly uh and those
00:33:40 people would have been indifferent or quite possibly on the left-wing side.
00:33:45 I don't think it was actually a conservative coalition. It had some conservative characteristics
00:33:50 but an awful lot of people who voted to leave the European Union were not people who were
00:33:55 of the traditional conservative right in any other way and it would be a serious
00:34:00 self-delusion to imagine that they were. So you think that basically because we're
00:34:04 as he's saying we now have you uh post-revolutionary so yeah um that in fact there just isn't the
00:34:12 appetite or the desire there isn't the knowledge or the knowledge people don't know what they've
00:34:18 lost they don't understand the nature of the regime under which they live
00:34:28 you are when when we last spoke you were writing a book about grammar school are you still
00:34:33 Plod, plod, plod. Well, it's been a little bit interrupted, actually.
00:34:37 Speaking of, you know, speaking of, you know, people not knowing,
00:34:41 I had a grammar school education, and, you know, even though I hated school,
00:34:46 that's not the point. It was a good, I can tell it was a good school.
00:34:49 You learned all this kind of stuff.
00:34:52 But you're talking about the 1960s.
00:34:54 Oh, it's amazingly long ago, isn't it? That's another thing about it.
00:34:57 but what it did
00:34:59 I had to divert because I
00:35:01 finally found what I'd been seeking
00:35:03 for a long time which is a really
00:35:05 good account of the secondary modern schools
00:35:07 and half of this argument
00:35:09 is well if you have the grammar schools
00:35:11 back you have to have the secondary modern schools back
00:35:13 which is
00:35:14 we can't have that because people think
00:35:17 secondary modern schools are some kind of
00:35:19 do the boys hall misery
00:35:21 establishments in fact
00:35:23 a lot of this argument is
00:35:25 is obscured by the fact the secondary moderns were in not in all cases but in many cases perfectly
00:35:30 good schools and their faults didn't come from them being secondary moderns they came and here's
00:35:36 a fascinating thing but you didn't know this when the secondary moderns were first set up they weren't
00:35:40 allowed to take part in any examinations for the first 15 years of their existence they were excluded
00:35:48 from from any major examination so there was no public examination to take which you would have
00:35:54 thought wet left-wing liberals would think was a good idea and in fact they did it's
00:36:00 one of the reasons why they accepted it but it meant the schools were largely purposeless
00:36:04 and shapeless and when they began later on to be allowed to take examinations a lot of
00:36:09 them did quite well at it.
00:36:12 With grammar schools that is surely one thing is not going to come back.
00:36:17 Well possibly not who knows I mean I think at the moment I think the purpose of explaining
00:36:23 what actually happened is to allow people to decide
00:36:26 what they might want to do in the future.
00:36:28 I think an awful lot of people are finding the academies a false dawn.
00:36:33 First of all, it's almost impossible to find who really runs them.
00:36:37 There doesn't seem to be any chain of proper ministerial
00:36:41 or other public responsibility over them.
00:36:44 And the word academy doesn't really mean anything, does it?
00:36:48 It can mean a badly failing school or it can mean a very successful school.
00:36:52 it doesn't actually it's not actually a transformation it's just a shift in
00:36:56 responsibility and also it seems to be a shift in scrutiny and the the private
00:37:02 schools which seem to me to have had a bonanza as a result of the closure of
00:37:08 schools because they were able to pull in the middle class and get to pay quite
00:37:11 large sums of money for for an education which ought to have been free and no no
00:37:15 longer was and have done fantastically well in watered-down examinations because
00:37:20 any well-organized school can clean up in the GCSE and A-level examinations of today.
00:37:27 They're now becoming far too expensive for most middle-class people. And I don't know,
00:37:32 it seems to be perfectly possible that those parents who want a good education for their
00:37:37 children and are not oligarchs are going to become increasingly discontented with what they're being
00:37:43 offered and to wonder again whether it's possible that selection viability might be the solution.
00:37:48 I know it's a remote possibility, but if they at least know what happened really between
00:37:54 1944 and 1965, then they might be able to come up with something.
00:37:59 There are still important countries which do this, and Germany being the most important.
00:38:04 No one can say Germany is an unsuccessful country or an ill-educated country, or indeed
00:38:09 a class-ridden country on the contrary.
00:38:12 says that but it has in most of its lander it has selective secondary schools of the kind which we
00:38:20 polished one of the the problems one of the things we get all the time from from viewers and indeed
00:38:27 from my own personal experience actually is uh almost regardless of the form of the school
00:38:33 they all now have certain things that are taught which basically a lot of people are extremely
00:38:41 uncomfortable with uh the whole identity politics agenda and all this was right through but public
00:38:46 school too what do you think of the the sort of growing discussion i hear here and there of
00:38:53 the need for homeschooling do you think that that is uh well i think um there is a great hostility
00:39:00 in british government towards homeschooling and the the recent bad man report for instance which
00:39:05 Michael Gove commissioned was a menace to it, but part of the problem with homeschooling
00:39:11 is the whole phrase has taken on a completely different meaning since the shutdown, when
00:39:16 so many people attempted some sort of education of their children at home and that's what
00:39:20 people think of as homeschooling.
00:39:22 The idea of it as it was before then has been obscured by that.
00:39:29 Also there's an awful lot of children excluded from school who might now be being classified
00:39:34 as being homeschooled.
00:39:36 It's very different from the United States,
00:39:39 where it's largely an evangelical Protestant movement,
00:39:41 but it's been enormously successful.
00:39:43 Huge numbers of most of the states permitted.
00:39:46 Huge numbers of children are homeschooled,
00:39:49 and they claim some of the best scholarships
00:39:52 at Ivy League universities.
00:39:54 The levels of success in education are very high,
00:39:56 and there are homeschool programs
00:39:58 attainable from the USA, because, of course,
00:40:00 they're designed for the American system, which, for instance,
00:40:04 doesn't have A-levels, has SATs for entry to universities, but it has not been a failure
00:40:11 and it's won a very strong legal position through very serious and diverted campaigning.
00:40:16 It's much bigger things that have been here.
00:40:20 Some people may say, well, they're much like evangelical Protestantism.
00:40:22 Well, not everybody does, but they happen to be the people who were keenest on it because
00:40:28 they felt their attitude towards life was the one being most excluded from the American
00:40:33 public schools it's a fascinating thing there i mean it was it was really getting going when i
00:40:40 was living there which is why i know a bit about it i think uh but i don't think i don't think it
00:40:47 i don't think it's in the nature of this country i don't think that you need you need the sort of
00:40:54 rebel spirit that you can find in certain levels of american society which we don't seem to have
00:40:59 to really establish a powerful homeschooling movement which does challenge the schools in
00:41:04 general. I don't see it happening here. Do you still see yourself as being Britain's obituist?
00:41:12 I do. In fact very kindly, I've often said to my publishers all my books should be put into one
00:41:19 huge black Dominic Sandbrook breeze block sized compendium. I've got one here.
00:41:27 yeah they're all enormous i want i want an enormous book with a black cover with the obituary
00:41:31 of britain uh on the cover and one of my one of my loyal readers actually went and got this done
00:41:37 and has sent me a rather fine but totally unique copy of the obituary of britain which i possess
00:41:44 yeah that's what i have i am the obituaries to britain but would you say this is being a bit
00:41:50 fanciful maybe but if it does come to pass that maybe scotland and wales go and all the rest of
00:41:56 and we're left with England that might be a different proposition it might be it would
00:42:01 certainly would certainly be a like that moment when the central heating goes off yes you suddenly
00:42:07 and you can't switch it on again you suddenly realize life is different yes I think it will
00:42:11 be would if it happens and remember Northern Ireland is quite likely to go as well it's the
00:42:16 truncation of of England back to its self would be a pretty bracing blast but
00:42:26 whether there'll be anybody equipped to take advantage of it from a
00:42:30 conservative point of view I don't know where are the institutions where are the
00:42:34 people where is the learning which would make that possible do you think of
00:42:40 yourself as english or british well actually i'm cornish oh okay so i have to be british really
00:42:48 silly me it's just one thing no no it's it's hitchens is a cornish name i mean it would be
00:42:56 so much nicer if it were those dramatic poldark type college names like trevithick or or trelawny
00:43:02 but it's hitchens uh but it is a cornish name i mean the days when we still had phone directories
00:43:08 the one part of England where you could find
00:43:10 more than two Hitchenses in the phone book was Cornwall
00:43:12 it's the Cornish version of
00:43:14 Dickens, it means Richard's son but it is
00:43:16 a Cornish name so it's nothing
00:43:18 to do with that rather unpleasant
00:43:19 sorry town in Hertfordshire
00:43:21 Right, okay, well I think that you've sidestepped
00:43:24 my question there a bit but anyway
00:43:25 Oh no, I'm not, I can't, I have to
00:43:27 be British but I mean obviously
00:43:29 Cornwall is
00:43:30 doesn't have the same sort of separate
00:43:34 existence as Scotland and Wales
00:43:35 so I'm English before I am
00:43:37 but who knows
00:43:39 well look it's been great talking to you
00:43:42 can you stay with us
00:43:43 because for our exclusive
00:43:45 members we basically
00:43:47 have just a few more questions to ask
00:43:49 you but anyway
00:43:51 thank you for this part of the interview anyway
00:43:53 and I'll be here in the other part too
00:43:55 that's all we have
00:43:57 for this week on so what you're saying
00:43:59 is we should look forward
00:44:01 to seeing you next time thank you very much
00:44:04 hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our mission may i
00:44:12 invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:44:20 our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't
00:44:26 do it without your support from as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we
00:44:32 continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:44:37 including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events
00:44:43 including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
00:44:49 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
00:44:55 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
00:45:01 it's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can
00:45:07 get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.