New Culture Forum - February 05, 2022


Whoopi, Anti-Semitism & Critical Race Theory & The Left's Blind Spot: Black (& Muslim) Prejudice

Covid is a Battle Between World Views - Pro-Restrictions Lobby are Trying to Remove Johnson Toby Young on England Having Europe's Worst Free Speech Protection + Lockdown Sceptics' Vindication.

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

192.24

Word count

8,242

Sentence count

160


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to the New Culture Forums brand new in-house show with me Emma Webb the
00:00:11 director of NCF Peter Whittle and Mark Sidwell the author of The Long March this week we're
00:00:16 going to be talking about all of the big stories in the news including our first story which is
00:00:21 this anti-semitism scandal that has unfolded around Whoopi Goldberg I believe that we have
00:00:27 the clip of that so let's take a look at that first the holocaust isn't about race no no it's
00:00:36 not about race no it's about man's inhumanity to man but these are two white groups of people
00:00:44 it's extraordinary isn't it and i think in a moment like this you really see how far we've
00:00:48 come i mean there's obviously this is this is america which is different uh racial debate and
00:00:52 and anti-semitism debate to the one that you get in the uk just to see a major a major figure on
00:00:56 news in the American public scene, just openly talking in that way about about the Holocaust
00:01:03 and about the Jewish people as if that wasn't a racial issue, that everything has to be framed
00:01:07 in this particular way around the race debate in America just seems like something that even
00:01:13 five, ten years ago wouldn't have been that way. Yeah, isn't this all down to critical race theory
00:01:18 actually? You see things totally in terms of black and white, quite literally. I mean, I think,
00:01:24 I think, you know, her remarks, she went on then to say, scenes such as, like, this was just a fight between two bunch of white people or something.
00:01:33 Now, you know, isn't it the case that a white celebrity would have been cancelled for about a tenth of what she said, straight away destroyed?
00:01:42 Not just a white celebrity, but this was a point that, I don't know if you saw Ben Shapiro's tweet pointing out that if she had at any point in her career suggested that she had any sympathy with any kind of conservative cause, that this would have been the end of her career as well.
00:01:57 So he was making a point about the fact that we've got these double standards towards the anti-racist, supposedly anti-racist people on the left.
00:02:06 I mean, we should say, I think she has been taken off the show, but perhaps...
00:02:09 Only for two weeks, though.
00:02:10 this is two weeks to be re-educated or rather to reflect on her remarks and all this i mean you
00:02:16 you could say i mean the whole point about free speech surely is and we've said this ourselves
00:02:22 you have to take the good with the bad so you know i guess in theoretically she should be allowed to
00:02:27 say what she likes but at the same time uh you know good ideas should come up and defeat those
00:02:34 sort of bad ideas but really it was the level of ignorance that i found astounding well the way she
00:02:41 she doubled down as well didn't she because she did she did a chat show afterwards sort of semi
00:02:44 defending herself which and the lack of self-awareness as well she didn't seem to to you
00:02:50 would think i mean anybody watching that would have cringed themselves into oblivion just how
00:02:54 absolutely horrifying it was um and you know i don't know if you saw that in in spite brendan
00:03:01 o'neill wrote this really interesting article about marcus rashford and marcus rashford and
00:03:06 another uh popular footballer i don't know very much about football had their photograph taken
00:03:11 recently in dubai with the rapper wiley and wiley has also been exposed for making anti-semitic
00:03:19 comments are quite wild ones suggesting the jews are snakes and cowards um he believes that they're
00:03:26 satanic in some way. And they had their photograph taken with him. And the point that Brendan
00:03:31 O'Neill was making was that if these were, you know, individuals who, you know, were
00:03:37 not of the sort of stripes that they are, that they would have been completely, you
00:03:42 know, that it would have been all over the news.
00:03:44 I mean, it's not just the inconsistency that troubles me, though. I mean, it's always
00:03:48 a bad thing. But I think just the way that anti-Semitism or at least remarks that are
00:03:53 critical of Jews in slightly conspiratorial ways have become more mainstream or acceptable in a
00:03:58 way that would have been unthinkable when I was growing up and at school, even at a time when
00:04:03 things like Holocaust education seem to have grown and be taken more seriously. It seems behind that
00:04:07 sort of superficial thing there's a real sea change. Going back to what you were saying about
00:04:12 Whoopi Goldberg saying that this is you know between white people, it's almost as if
00:04:18 in within this critical race theory structure that the Jews are almost viewed as being almost
00:04:26 hyper-white, hyper-privileged, never mind the actual history of the Jewish people.
00:04:30 Isn't that the biggest irony of all? The people who suffered the Holocaust are somehow not accorded,
00:04:37 you know, they're accorded privilege, they're not accorded this victim status, you know,
00:04:43 in this hierarchy it's extraordinary but again this is this is it was a point that was made by
00:04:47 brendan o'neill is that because of the and perhaps it's because people are blinded by critical race
00:04:52 theory that we don't talk about um anti-semitism in the black community we don't talk about
00:04:58 anti-semitism in the muslim community because people are afraid of being called racist or
00:05:02 islamophobic if they well i mean if they challenge it yeah i'm only to to hold this one but i mean
00:05:07 What I find, you know, we sort of see articles about what is happening in the UK?
00:05:14 Why, you know, why is there this growth in anti-Semitism and everything?
00:05:18 No one addresses who is doing this, right?
00:05:21 Well, there was the recent incident with the bus and the BBC was getting some flack for not covering it properly
00:05:28 or suggesting that maybe that they were sort of spurring them on.
00:05:31 Was this the attack on two Jewish men?
00:05:34 yes no no yes uh but the one on the bus on oxford street was i think the bbc suggested that somehow
00:05:41 they had been provoked into doing this as though that would make it okay um but the fact is it's
00:05:46 no you know i think it's a terrible slander because i think this country's always been remarkably
00:05:53 you know good on in terms of antisemitism i as you say growing up i you know apart from the kind
00:05:58 of you know admittedly there was always casual racism growing up there's no question but i mean
00:06:03 there's never been a massive sort of sense of that in this country not like in Europe not like in
00:06:09 France or Germany and yet somehow you read these articles now saying oh this is on the rise what's
00:06:13 happening to us you see well actually is it us what what do you mean by us even the fact I had
00:06:18 to ask which incident you were referring to because I remember back when I was a university
00:06:24 and I was studying and I studied for a time at Leo Beck which is a sort of rabbinical training
00:06:28 college and they had so much security because they're obviously there has always been a threat
00:06:35 but i don't remember a time when you would be in a conversation like this having to ask oh which
00:06:42 violent attack in the news against jewish people are you referring to i think you know going back
00:06:48 to whoopie gold but it'll be interesting to see actually what happens you know i mean will she
00:06:54 be bad because a lot of this is down to also to commercial value you know i mean it's you know
00:07:01 is she really worth everything to the view which is the program she co-hosts things like that
00:07:07 um and uh which is a terrible consideration but that's the kind of thing they'll be thinking of
00:07:12 um but i just thought it was the level of kind of boneheaded ignorance you know of actual history
00:07:19 the absolute illiteracy historically i just thought it was astounding it's interesting that
00:07:25 we often hear about misinformation holocaust denial and that kind of thing nobody really
00:07:30 ever talks about how as you were saying critical race theory but some of these ideologies are
00:07:36 bending and distorting the way that we the prison through which we view history and in the process
00:07:43 you you just do end up with the sorts of views that whoopi goldberg is expressing here the idea
00:07:49 that that the jewish people were just another white group in europe and as you say it's just
00:07:53 complete historical ignorance you see it's not just ignorance it's it's sort of learned foolishness
00:07:58 it's a new way of seeing the new prism that's very recently come along and people have picked
00:08:03 it up because they know the fashionable language and the new ideological frames and and it's that
00:08:08 it's imposed it's not just oh i just don't know anything about this is i've learned something
00:08:12 about it which in fact is a sort of horrendous distortion well the saying isn't it a little
00:08:17 learning is a dangerous thing, you know. Shall we move on from that to the story of a lady who had
00:08:25 a book of trans essays confiscated from her by Gwent police, so this lady was going around town
00:08:33 sticking up these stickers, I've got some quotes here of what was on those stickers, they said
00:08:38 things like no child is born in the wrong body, humans never change sex, respect women's spaces,
00:08:44 There's a woman equals adult human female, no men in women's prisons, cervix.
00:08:51 It's a woman's thing. And the police arrested this lady.
00:08:55 They received some complaints about the stickers and apparently raided her home and took a book of essays,
00:09:02 an academic book of essays on trans issues edited by two academics.
00:09:07 And they confiscated this from her. They took her to a police station.
00:09:10 She was released on bail at 3.30 in the morning. Her phone had been seized. She was disabled in a mobility scooter and made her own way home, apparently.
00:09:19 So I guess this leads us to ask the question, which is a point that Harry Miller, who I'm sure everybody is aware of, made.
00:09:27 And he said that this suggests that the police are out of control. Do you think the police are out of control?
00:09:33 Well, you know, the problem is also they're stuck within a regulatory framework where they feel like they don't know what else to do.
00:09:39 So what's really happening is activists are complaining. Now, okay, this is an activist herself making provocative comments in public, but then particular activists are seeing that and complaining to the police, knowing that the police kind of have to act under the equality frameworks that they're set up within.
00:09:53 And then the police are following that and going through all this process. So the question is, is it the police or is it just something about what they're now caught in that then they feel like they have to behave in this way that seems completely baffling to us?
00:10:05 I mean, it does remind me of Harry Miller, because, of course, the problem with what happened to him was that the police were bringing him up after he made some provocative tweet and saying, well, we need to check your thinking.
00:10:14 Again, this catch taking away of a book suggests that they're trying to sort of get inside the thought process behind the stickers or whatever, which just seems an extraordinary overextension.
00:10:24 It suggests that the police now believe that they have the power to decide what is legitimate to have on your bookshelf, even if that even if that literature is not illegal.
00:10:31 And again, going back to the Harry Miller case, the whole point about non-crime hate incidents is that these things are not crimes.
00:10:37 And so, again, this is the police interfering with something that is evidently nothing to do with criminal behaviour.
00:10:43 But what happened with Harry Miller recently, you know, is a great victory over the recording of non-crime hate incidents.
00:10:48 It was a real problem. And that's an example of where you really do need legal recourse to sort out the general problem.
00:10:53 These specific cases happen because of much more general situations or structures within the legal framework that the police are following.
00:11:00 And we can get lost in the individual cases and forget that we need to look at the Equality Act or something around the policing guidelines where these problems are actually set up.
00:11:09 Well, that was Harry Miller's case, largely, which was that the College of Policing Guidelines,
00:11:16 he managed to get the decision that they were, in fact, unlawful, you know, in recording these
00:11:24 non-crime incidents, and indeed that they shouldn't be reported, you know, and, you know,
00:11:30 kept on your records for God knows how long, so that employers could see them.
00:11:34 There was actually another case, was there not, of a woman, and the police came up,
00:11:38 this is the past couple of weeks and sort of said we want to know the context in which you've said
00:11:43 this the thought process is behind it but i don't know whether it's it's something like this i think
00:11:49 can be actually done out of stupidity too i mean i think that there's nothing worse than a bit of
00:11:56 indoctrination and a bit of thickness combined and you get these kind of actions do you not think
00:12:02 do you think to a degree this is also the police's ignorance of the law so like when we saw that the
00:12:07 video of the police officer explained to someone outside of an abortion clinic that
00:12:11 them expressing their views were essentially equivalent to assault, that the police are
00:12:17 actually no longer clear on what they are supposed to be policing, what is legitimate
00:12:23 to be policing, in the same way that the government don't seem to be entirely clear on what is
00:12:27 legitimate government activity, that now we've ended up with the boundaries being so blurred
00:12:33 that actually the police are not even, not only are they ignorant of the law, but they're
00:12:36 not actually sure what policing is for anymore yeah I mean I think the question that incidents
00:12:41 like this make me think about is what do you do about it how do you fight back against a problem
00:12:45 like this one of the problems is this is a form of asymmetric warfare conservatives people on the
00:12:49 right don't really like making complaints like they don't do the equivalent of the left-wing
00:12:53 protesters of complaining to the police and pushing that thing so you're not going to be able to fight
00:12:57 it in the same way but what you can do perhaps is work out what the legal issues are clarify them
00:13:03 make sure that the police are properly trained and get the law reformed when it needs to be.
00:13:07 Those seem to be like sort of good places to tackle this problem in a way that the right has some sort of ability to do.
00:13:12 Yes. I think that you can't, unfortunately, you can't underestimate, as you say, the legal framework.
00:13:18 I say one of the big problems with all of this is that subjectivity has now come into the law in a big way.
00:13:24 It was never subjective. Now it is sort of almost about what the victim perceives, what the victim feels.
00:13:30 even the use of the word victim you know i mean it you should actually use the word complainant
00:13:37 if you're going to be completely correct if you use the word victim you've more or less decided
00:13:41 it haven't you already you know what the situation is well and and it's sort of the hierarchy of
00:13:47 of people's ability to be offended or who do you have to be most careful of you know these are
00:13:52 difficult issues but it's part of part of what's pushing the the police response is a concern that
00:13:57 people who are in the trans community are much more sensitive or suffering
00:14:01 with mental health issues and but these are these are sort of issues of truth
00:14:05 and fact that need to be properly established and investigated not just
00:14:08 sort of taken on trust. How do you you know if the issue is subjectivism in the
00:14:14 law and I mean we've seen it in the Scottish hate crime bill there are other
00:14:18 proposals in in Northern Ireland elsewhere in the Law Commission this
00:14:22 the sort of pervasive subjectivism is obviously a problem for law enforcement you can't have a fair
00:14:31 and just legal system when there is so much based on the subjective perception of particular people
00:14:36 who are offended how do you how do you combat that is there a way that you can combat that
00:14:42 given how deeply entrenched that already is within legislation well no you have to change
00:14:46 the definition don't you you have to get rid of that subjective it's not enough to say it's
00:14:51 the victim in the victim's view it's just not it's just i could sort of i could decide that what you
00:14:58 just said to me there is offensive right and i could go off and they would probably put it down
00:15:02 as a stat and all of that it would stay there for a while that's that's what's got to change it's
00:15:07 got to be somehow we've got to we have got to re-establish the objective criteria i think so
00:15:13 and certain activist groups have worked out how to use these gaps in the law these sort of weaknesses
00:15:18 in a way that it's framed and turn them into a way to get what they want even when they're actually
00:15:22 very very small minorities of people uh and and how do you fight against that well you've got to
00:15:27 change the the the loopholes that they're they're making use of and there's another aspect to this
00:15:32 as well which i think connects in a way back to the whoopi goldberg discussion about around double
00:15:37 standards and um inconsistencies in the thinking of particular parts of the left which is that
00:15:44 from the perspective of the lady who was doing this as well as from the perspective of you know
00:15:49 a number of women who have taken the same approach to transgender issues they get referred to as
00:15:54 gender critical feminists people like jk rowling you know the these are feminist issues these are
00:16:00 not as as this lady said herself she's not you know trying to attack trans people she's trying
00:16:06 to protect women she's trying to protect sex-based rights these women are concerned about women's
00:16:11 issues and women's safety and it's not i mean a couple of weeks ago i think it was um it was
00:16:17 reported that in california a 26 year old trans uh sex offender had been sentenced to so male to
00:16:26 female sex offender um had been sentenced to two years in a juvenile institution um which just
00:16:36 seems absolutely mad this is somebody who had assaulted a 10 year old girl being sentenced to
00:16:41 two years in a juvenile institution you know there are people have legitimate concerns around
00:16:45 women's safety and so I guess the question here is also you know what you know what has happened
00:16:52 to feminism third wave feminism but what has happened to that entire segment of the left that
00:17:00 they are no longer able to see that these women are not doing anything other than the old school
00:17:07 you know fighting for women's rights you know we were talking earlier about subjectivism but I
00:17:11 think part of what the problem is here is is the big problem with identity politics which is you
00:17:15 know the loss of individualism what you see here is two different identity groups sort of fighting
00:17:20 for power and this happens to be you know women and feminists versus the trans community and
00:17:25 that sort of fight because the power now lies in victimhood and groups of victims whereas you know
00:17:33 The older way of seeing things is thinking about people as actual individuals, not as a sort of cluster of ranked victim statuses.
00:17:41 And unless we can get back to some form of individualism in law and in how we treat people, I think we're always going to have problems.
00:17:47 And it's just we see this very clearly in this particular sort of dual.
00:17:51 Do you think individualism is the solution?
00:17:53 I think, yes, it is on a kind of philosophical level.
00:17:56 That's not too diminishing.
00:17:57 But I think that what, you know, what is clear from these stories is that the whole structure is riddled with this stuff.
00:18:06 Because the institutions, you wrote a book about it, you know, I mean, the institutions are riddled with it.
00:18:12 So, you know, what is a court doing making that kind of decision about that person in America?
00:18:17 How does that happen?
00:18:19 You could say it's the influence of feminism or third-wave feminism or whatever, or wokery or whatever.
00:18:24 But somehow, these people are actually making the decisions, or the police, same thing.
00:18:30 And this is the frightening thing, because I don't know about you, but sometimes, and people feel this,
00:18:36 is that we're sort of sitting here watching this all go on.
00:18:40 And this is a sense of powerlessness people have.
00:18:43 How come this kind of crazy stuff is happening?
00:18:47 How many more times can we complain about it?
00:18:49 What's going to happen? This is the thing.
00:18:51 Well, this is the thing. But of course, this is unfortunately what my book is about in many ways is the fact that, you know, the culture war is, I think, in many ways lost.
00:18:58 And that's a very hard thing to hear because then you have to accept, oh, that's that's right.
00:19:03 We have actually lost. We are sitting in a landscape where the victors are the other side and this new world of identity politics.
00:19:10 And you're trying to work on how to resist or how to exist within a sort of occupied landscape.
00:19:15 It isn't a battle that's still being fought. It's really been been won by the other side.
00:19:19 And that's the conditions we now have to adapt to and work out how to survive and fight back.
00:19:25 But it's a long road.
00:19:26 How much do you think this has to do with we're talking about subjectivism, but the death of reason that, you know, the court in California that we've become so unmoored from reason, partly because, you know, a lot of these authors who people like Robin DiAngelo, it's an explicit attack on reason, on the enlightenment, on the things that more us to objectivity.
00:19:49 And once you lose that, you don't, you know, the playing field is completely different.
00:19:54 You can't engage in the ways that we are familiar with.
00:19:57 And so it's very difficult to tackle these sorts of things because they've become completely slippery.
00:20:04 There's nothing to tackle them with because there are no tools available.
00:20:06 Yeah, I mean, I think you sort of get caught in a paradigm.
00:20:09 It's not entirely a lack of reason, although they are often suspicious of reason.
00:20:13 That's sort of enlightenment as being sort of coded white and with the power structures and so on.
00:20:18 but they're stuck within a way of thinking about the world and what the causes of oppression are and the
00:20:23 inequalities in the world and therefore that that leads them down through a process of reason to the only thing
00:20:29 we must do is tear the whole thing down and you know the whole society is just
00:20:33 riddled with with dysfunction and
00:20:35 discrimination and white supremacy and so that's the the path they're stuck on it's very hard to argue with that because it's
00:20:41 it's like seeing the Sun going
00:20:43 around the earth or not all the earth going around the sun you know just
00:20:46 you're stuck within one paradigm and how do you how do you talk to the other
00:20:49 side the thing is social is all right I tend to the view that you know this is
00:20:56 it's nihilistic because there's no kind of alternative offers you know to tear
00:21:03 down the tear down the basic sense of who we are men and women tear down this
00:21:07 instead of that. Destroy, basically. But what do we put in this place? So, you know, you
00:21:14 then have to say, well, is it in fact a form of communism that they want? Is it a form
00:21:19 of, because cultural Marxism, that term, which is a bit controversial, I think, but it's
00:21:24 used, isn't it, often as a way of describing what's happening?
00:21:27 I think it is a form of cultural communism, if you like, because we all sort of got inoculated
00:21:33 in the Blair years, the left got inoculated against the idea of equality of economic
00:21:37 outcomes. People kind of understood that that didn't really work. It led you down a sort
00:21:42 of pathway to poverty and misery. But seeking equality of cultural outcomes, of social outcomes
00:21:47 for identity groups is now what is in power and people are trying to do that. But it's
00:21:52 the same problem. If you try and do that, you're going to build this oppressive bureaucracy
00:21:56 of control that is very unjust and isn't good for anyone.
00:22:00 this leads nicely on to the next subject and especially because you mentioned the equality act
00:22:05 because in this case this is probably a violation of the equality act i imagine
00:22:09 um this story is a is a is a real zinger this is this is real clown world stuff
00:22:14 um in a nightclub in east london um a company called uh pussy palace but spelt with an x so
00:22:22 pooksy pooksy palace um held an event that was apparently um themed around quote celebrating you
00:22:30 and your relationship with the universe and the facebook event said the facebook event said that
00:22:37 it was a space that this is a quote again prioritizes women with an ex womxson and fems
00:22:45 of color and other queer intersex and trans people of color now the reason why this story was in the
00:22:51 news is because they were charging different rates according to people's uh intersectional
00:22:59 intersectional credentials and so um they interesting they use they use the phrase
00:23:04 bipoc which is the american phrase black indigenous people of color uh even though
00:23:09 obviously indigenous here does not mean the same as indigenous in the united states
00:23:13 um so they were charging bipoc only queer women trans and non-binary 16 pounds 80 to enter the
00:23:23 same price for bipoc only queer cisgender men allies which are defined as white trans and
00:23:31 queer slash straight bipoc women were charged 22 pounds 42 it's very specific it's almost as if
00:23:37 they've got some kind of sliding scale here but they were charging straight cis gendered i think
00:23:42 white men although it doesn't say so here um 112 pounds to enter well that's more or less the same
00:23:50 as saying don't calm isn't it well so the the idea the idea came from um it was a vegan cafe in
00:23:57 australia which uh quite appropriately is now closed down um which was charging 18 percent
00:24:03 more to uh men for guests who were coming to get coffee because it was supposed to reflect the
00:24:08 gender pay gap and there was also a pharmacy in manhattan who were also charging men more
00:24:13 a pharmacy so presumably charging men more to get their medication um to reflect the gender pay gap
00:24:20 so what that suggests is that the reason why they're doing this scaling of the prices is
00:24:25 because they believe that the people who are in that lower category which i think is quite offensive
00:24:29 will be earning less um so the question is is this a violation of the equality act if you think the
00:24:37 equality act is a good or a bad thing. But also, this is exactly as you were just describing the,
00:24:44 you know, the structure of the hierarchy. And you know, I think, you know, it sort of inverts
00:24:49 that old saying of Gandhi's of basically, first we laugh at them, and then they win, right? This is
00:24:54 this is something that seems very silly. But I think it is a cultural trend that this is right
00:24:59 at the cutting edge of the culture, right? This is this sort of sexually permissive, young, cool
00:25:04 culture and clubbing isn't you know for my generation these these are young kids come back
00:25:08 in 20 years these things could well have moved into much more powerful places in the culture
00:25:13 and you see these things at the edge of it they turn up later so even though this in itself i
00:25:17 mean it's just a sort of silly fun story but it may be a sign of of things to come well isn't it
00:25:22 basically it's war it's the triumph of equity exactly equality that basically equality of
00:25:29 outcome. Regardless, you've got to have equality balance. This is actually a very pure example of
00:25:35 it. We can't fix the other supposed gender pay gap, if you believe there is one, so what we'll
00:25:42 do is enforce it at the other end by charging more for it. I think in this case it wasn't so
00:25:46 much about the pay gap as just probably people that they thought were relatively poorer, but
00:25:51 they were just trying to sort of favour the ones that they were saying the evening is for, so
00:25:54 therefore the the others were getting left out. Although they are slightly hoist by their own
00:25:58 own petard and perhaps by the law because I think what they've done is say well we are going to
00:26:02 enforce this because obviously that would involve telling you who you identify as so in fact you
00:26:06 could just turn up and say well I'm in the cheap group. I think they did actually say that that
00:26:10 people could identify as whatever group they they fancied. Can you tell me what cis actually
00:26:15 means literally? Cis is essentially a way of of un-normalizing being
00:26:25 uh the gender the gender that you were bought the gender that you were born into the sex that you
00:26:31 are your natal sex so they they they want that to not be normalized no i know what it all means but
00:26:37 why the word cis where does that come from i think it does have some old derivation like i
00:26:43 think they used to use it like was it cis alpine gall or trans alpine gall it does have some
00:26:48 obscurity but it's not not really part of normal language no but no but the thing is is that what
00:26:53 kind of I mean what kind of guy is going to turn up of that anyway and what's a self-respecting
00:26:57 the straight guy's going to turn up of that anyway well presumably someone who's got a point to make
00:27:01 well sort of an ally you say like an ally well that is one of the categories if you're going to
00:27:06 this club and you're not an ally then I think it's pretty questionable it's not actually it's not
00:27:14 actually the night nightclub that did this to be fair on the nightclub it was this this um
00:27:19 organization I suppose it is that put this on called Pussy Palace Pussy Palace
00:27:23 well I think you should know pretty much what you're getting by the way in which
00:27:27 they've spelt women and all of that you should have an idea what I think I'm not
00:27:33 you know belittling that point because I think you're absolutely right people
00:27:37 laughed at this thing okay you think of the things that people laughed at now
00:27:41 which are absolutely normal everyday stuff because you know it's been just
00:27:46 it you know brought in and it's now become ingrained so you know this idea of equality
00:27:51 equity by all means is just obviously the way we are if you if you think that if you imagine you
00:27:58 know going back to the 2010s if you had fallen into a coma in the in 2010 and you woke up now
00:28:04 the the in vast difference even things like you know the spelling of woman with an x
00:28:11 its talk of equity instead of equality as this kind of like sleight of hand that has occurred
00:28:17 so much has changed and it's been so um uh difficult to detect while it was happening
00:28:24 but when you look back over the last 10 years we've come such a a long long way that these
00:28:29 these are not small things um the idea that that a company would think that they could get away
00:28:35 with this kind of overt discrimination on the basis of your sexuality your uh your color your
00:28:43 your gender or you know sex no it's the power thing it's purely power you can't it's like uh
00:28:50 they say that uh white uh you white people um are racist black people can't be racist because white
00:28:58 people hold the power so therefore it's it's it's always going to be unequal it's exactly the same
00:29:04 with this kind of thing really is that essentially men in this art men hold power so basically it is
00:29:10 quite okay for them to be discriminated against in this way you know i mean this is so this is a
00:29:16 insidious you talk about 10 years ago i mean uh you know why in the press for example why does the
00:29:24 media talk about equity why is it taking it on board so quickly why does it now just write in
00:29:30 terms of equity it doesn't it is the new moral fashion and i think we could do you know culture
00:29:36 wars are long wars people need to think on that sort of level of how you fight these things over
00:29:40 very long periods of time and there was a vast movement and some very big organizations that
00:29:45 created the the fight back against the idea of equality of economic outcome and really took that
00:29:50 away and made it about economic opportunities instead that hasn't happened yet with this and
00:29:54 we really need people who are thinking about that very hard building the institutions that fight
00:29:59 back or in 20, 30 years time. And why have you just given them a new term there, equinomic,
00:30:04 equitable economics. Don't say it too loudly, they might start using it. But I think, I mean,
00:30:10 I don't think it's a small thing that, you know, the way that these ideas have seeped so deeply
00:30:21 into every aspect of our society has been so imperceptible and um by such such incremental
00:30:30 little steps that i think when you when you do look back on i mean even a couple of years ago
00:30:34 and if you go through you know in the morning go through the the newspaper stories some of them are
00:30:40 so utterly bonkers that it's it's it's difficult to you know believe that we've ended up in in
00:30:49 such a mad situation but they're not written in a kind of isn't this bonkers type way actually no
00:30:55 that's exactly what is so bonkers about it is that it's the language itself has changed that now we
00:31:00 when we talk about equality people are speaking in the language of equity it's no longer equality
00:31:04 it's the opposite um and it's the it's the it's orwellian you speak in many ways actually speaking
00:31:10 of which all 1984 got a trigger warning on it did you see this is one of the stories
00:31:17 I mean that's beyond these cliches no longer really work do they I mean but you know one
00:31:28 would say it's beyond parody beyond satire 1984's had a warning that some of the material in it might
00:31:35 be what not exactly harmful but offensive what is the what is the warning on it or what there
00:31:41 is a kind of warning isn't there now I mean they just they put some kind of trigger warning on it
00:31:45 they've put trigger warnings on all sorts of things obviously people I mean people have tried
00:31:49 been trying to cancel Orwell anyway it's not the first story of its kind but you know this is this
00:31:54 is exactly what I mean is that you read these stories and you think you know Whoopi Goldberg
00:31:59 is is coming out on American television and essentially it's a kind of holocaust denial
00:32:05 we have books being confiscated by the police we have people being told to check their thinking
00:32:12 um we have all while having trigger warnings put on his work with no sense of self-awareness
00:32:17 whatsoever um and we have people spelling woman with a with an x and and charging white straight
00:32:23 men more to enter clubs by hundreds of pounds than their you know um ethnic minority trans gay
00:32:32 counterparts um it is so far removed from where we were a decade ago that i i think that many people
00:32:39 will be wondering where we'll be in a decade's time if this kind of thing continues without it
00:32:45 being laughed at I guess maybe maybe laughing at it is the only way to I don't I mean that might
00:32:50 help to sort of you know get you through but it doesn't necessarily change it as I say I think
00:32:55 you know the trends go in a certain direction unless people also thinking has that have that
00:32:59 sort of long-term thinking about how you counteract it and how you change the culture I think the
00:33:04 problem is yeah is that uh okay you yes you say you can laugh at it you know crazy old world etc
00:33:10 um i find it very hard to do that actually now i can't laugh i mean even though i'm at the other
00:33:16 end of life as opposed to very young uh and you should be able to say oh well you know the world
00:33:22 get on with it sort of thing and i just can't because it offends my sense of reason i find it
00:33:28 offends my own intelligence actually but i think one of the worrying things you know you say what
00:33:34 be like in 10 years time um and discussing this recently with toby young you know from the free
00:33:39 speech union uh is that young people according to surveys young people really don't care for
00:33:47 example very much about free speech yeah this is why it's going to be much worse in 20 years time
00:33:53 there's a sort of cohort effect the generations that are coming through in the universities and
00:33:57 just in general aren't really worried about these issues at all and of course they're brought up on
00:34:02 them in ways that we weren't um so you know the natural course of events is definitely going to go
00:34:08 towards you know a much less open and free culture in that sense on that note the elephant in the
00:34:14 room is the political aspect of this because obviously we've pretty much everything that's
00:34:19 been in the news has been party gate party gate party gate for weeks and weeks and it probably
00:34:23 will be for weeks and weeks to come um obviously there are political implications of the things
00:34:30 that we've been discussing but also the politics matters to the you know where these things end up.
00:34:36 What do you think is going to happen with the Conservative Party? Do you think that Boris has
00:34:41 got away by the skin of his teeth or do you think that it's just a stay of execution and that
00:34:45 ultimately he's done for and if so what what are the implications of that for the Conservative Party?
00:34:50 It seems to me he sort of limps on like a sort of wounded animal and covered in cake
00:34:54 sort of with everyone laughing at him and unable to do anything very interesting and
00:35:01 perhaps not really wanting to anyway, which is, you know, the worst of all possible worlds.
00:35:05 And if someone like David Frost were running the show or even Dominic Cummings, dare I say,
00:35:11 who actually had visions of, you know, alternative vision of what you might do in government,
00:35:14 something interesting might happen. But as it is, I mean, he'll throw the odd bit of red meat
00:35:19 for two seconds if he thinks you'll get him a good headline. He's not going to pursue things
00:35:22 over the sort of the time and with the long time horizons that really have the ambition to make a
00:35:27 difference and you won't have the authority or the power to do it. Well in fact they did throw
00:35:32 a few bits of red meat and the odd thing about today's politics is that they're sort of
00:35:39 quite consciously do it and describe that this is what they're doing. I mean there's there's no
00:35:44 you know there's no sort of like attempt at analysis analysis is not needed it's just like
00:35:49 we're throwing them some red meat about the bbc and i think it was immigration that level um
00:35:55 do they have that much contempt for us that they just think this we're going to say oh that's okay
00:36:01 then you know um and if it's that easy to do why didn't you do it before you know that's the other
00:36:07 thing but i think um with boris um my perception is is and actually that's another thing sorry
00:36:14 boris we keep calling him boy it's too affectionate uh you know this is stuck this branding i find
00:36:20 myself saying boy it's all right you know it's too we never said margaret no one ever said margaret
00:36:25 it was always mrs thatcher or thatcher but i i think that we were more adult then that's because
00:36:31 we took her seriously but it's now i think johnson might open him up to jokes it might be but boris
00:36:37 he's like this fun figure but the thing is I get the feeling he'll kind of he's
00:36:44 already limping out the other side I could be wrong because I don't watch 24
00:36:48 hour rolling news but so therefore my perception is probably he'll survive this
00:36:53 the Tory party though is another question altogether I mean it's just not even
00:36:58 remotely conservative well that that's another aspect of it is that or the
00:37:03 discussion has been who would replace him and the only good candidate seems to
00:37:08 be Steve Baker but that seems extremely unlikely most people don't even know who
00:37:11 he is I'm sorry but outside of this this sphere they don't know who he is that's
00:37:17 a big that's very important that people know who you are I mean and I don't even
00:37:22 know who Liz Truss is no if you look at the surveys they know who Rishi is yeah
00:37:25 that's it yeah they don't know who they are what do you think long-term the
00:37:30 implications would be if the result of this was just a crashing electoral defeat and you know
00:37:36 they do terribly in the may elections the conservative party starts plummeting into
00:37:41 terminal decline as a result do you think that that's what's going to happen from partygate
00:37:45 because i mean another question would be whether or not partygate is a is a kind of media concocted
00:37:50 scandal and that the public are paying so much attention to it because the media have made it
00:37:55 into this enormous thing, and that otherwise,
00:37:57 perhaps the public wouldn't care so much.
00:37:59 Do you think this is gonna have a knock-on effect on there?
00:38:03 Because they seem to be recovering slightly in the polls.
00:38:05 Party affiliation is extraordinarily robust.
00:38:07 That's one of the reasons why the most effective thing
00:38:09 you can do is really sort of take over a party structure
00:38:11 for a different way of thinking, which, of course,
00:38:13 Margaret Thatcher did and Tony Blair did in different ways.
00:38:17 But who is there and who's got an actual vision
00:38:20 to take over the Conservative Party
00:38:21 and actually make something interesting of it?
00:38:23 I mean, you know, Cummings was trying and he'd argue that Frost and Baker have a vision somewhere.
00:38:28 And if they got some power or behind the right candidate, perhaps they could do it.
00:38:32 But I don't see anyone.
00:38:34 I think, you know, possibly Peter Hitchens is kind of on the right track.
00:38:38 You know, he's been saying for ages, the only thing that's going to save any kind of conservatism in this country is if the Conservative Party goes.
00:38:45 Right. So he would say abstain. Don't don't.
00:38:48 for if they have a big defeat then maybe there'll be a space open for a proper conservative party
00:38:54 maybe you know maybe it might it will take that i don't think election results really
00:38:59 count for much i think it'll be the next next election do you think that those who are predicting
00:39:06 that people will vote sort of protest vote for either the lib dems or reform in the red wall do
00:39:12 you think that that's something that you know might result from this in by elections maybe i
00:39:16 think in a general election you have to wait and see you know people don't disappoint me look i
00:39:20 mean however when much one agrees or disagrees with reform or reclaim just look at the result
00:39:26 the results that have been you know the past few elections it's just minimal you know it's minimal
00:39:33 yeah but uh the brexit party ukip did have quite a lot of power on on shifting conservative policy
00:39:39 so the ability if you can find a sort of protest party that can do that then that's another way
00:39:44 to shift the party from slightly from outside i couldn't agree um that would probably involve
00:39:48 something like farage i don't know who else has the the muscle to do it that's the only the only
00:39:52 way uh uk up so it's in uk uk and then the brexit party uh enormously effective actually at doing
00:39:59 what they were meant to do which was being an elected pressure group in a way they were an
00:40:03 elected but no one really cared what they thought about economic policy or that it was about the
00:40:08 referendum is about the eu if you had some group like that on the issues that we've been talking
00:40:13 about today then that could really start to the Tories need to be made frightened that's the
00:40:20 thing they frightened only of their losing their seats and if they see something coming up on 15
00:40:27 percent or 20 percent then they might start actually you know which is what Cameron did
00:40:31 with Brexit how plausible do you think that is though well well UKIP happened I guess I mean
00:40:37 the thing is you're talking about what it was founded in 93 so that's the idea of how long
00:40:45 it's a long time long time long time to wait i mean you know you might have lost all interest
00:40:48 in politics i'll be dead culture wars are long wars and it's you know you've got to hold on to
00:40:58 that fact it's that's the only way uh to go about it actually that's one thing i want to ask mark
00:41:02 before because i think we were about to end on i was about to end on the note of you saying you
00:41:06 were going to die. You read that book two years ago, right, but you actually wrote it, without us
00:41:14 knowing, right before a massive cultural onslaught. I mean, has it changed? Would you write it
00:41:20 differently now? Well, the bit that's most out of date is the bit at the end where I'm optimistic
00:41:24 about what Boris might do to reform things. Although I think some of those things could still be done,
00:41:30 but just obviously not by Boris. You know, if someone wants a blueprint for what to do with
00:41:34 with their rival pressure partner. Okay. On that note, buy the blueprint.
00:41:39 Thank you for joining us and we will see you next time. Thanks.
00:41:44 Hello, if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission,
00:41:49 may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:41:56 newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:42:03 the future but we can't do it without your support from as little as three pounds per month you can
00:42:09 help ensure that we continue on our mission as a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:42:15 including access to exclusive content invitations to our private events including here at our
00:42:23 studios free copies of our books and much much more including of course our famous ncf mug
00:42:31 If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by clicking this
00:42:36 button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just remember to
00:42:42 also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new
00:42:48 videos. Thank you.