New Culture Forum - February 06, 2022


Toby Young on England Having Europe's Worst Free Speech Protection + Lockdown Sceptics' Vindication.

Whoopi, Anti-Semitism & Critical Race Theory & The Left's Blind Spot: Black (& Muslim) Prejudice Former Australian PM Tony Abbott: Russia & China's New World Order May Eclipse Liberal Democracy

Episode Stats


Length

54 minutes

Words per minute

167.68

Word count

9,140

Sentence count

285


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is somebody
00:00:23 who was at the very forefront of the fight to maintain free speech. She's been on the show
00:00:29 before. I'm delighted he's back. Toby Young, of course, is a well-known columnist, best-selling
00:00:34 author. He also was the founder of Daily Skeptic one year ago. The Free Speech Union, which he
00:00:42 founded two years ago, has become one of the great forces in the battle that we face. I know that
00:00:49 sounds rather grand, but I mean it is a very big issue, Toby. But before we talk about the Free
00:00:56 speech union I wonder when it comes to all the restrictions coming off this week and the general
00:01:03 feeling in the air of people backing away from their past stance I just wonder do you feel
00:01:09 vindicated in your position I think I do broadly speaking Peter so um yet uh I set up the a website
00:01:19 called Lockdown Skeptics in the beginning of April 2020,
00:01:24 so within a week of the first lockdown being imposed.
00:01:28 And it was partly because I'd written a piece for the critic
00:01:32 saying I thought the lockdown was a mistake
00:01:35 and would inevitably cause more harm than good,
00:01:41 which was a fairly controversial and minority view at the time.
00:01:47 And I'd also written something similar for The Telegraph, and I got completely monstered, monstered on Twitter, lots of rude emails, friends kind of distancing themselves from me.
00:02:01 It wasn't like, you know, being well and truly cancelled, which I was in 2018, but it was like a sort of, you know, a sort of minor version of that.
00:02:10 And it occurred to me that there was no forum for people to express their dissent about what was happening.
00:02:18 Everyone just seemed to accept that this was the appropriate and proper response,
00:02:25 the only way to deal with a pandemic of this nature,
00:02:28 which was extraordinary because the lockdown policy had never really been tried
00:02:34 in the way it was at the beginning of 2020 anywhere else in the world in response to a pandemic ever.
00:02:40 and it had even been recommended against in a paper by the WHO in 2019 and it certainly wasn't
00:02:47 part of the pandemic preparedness strategy which was our official strategy for dealing with a viral
00:02:52 outbreak. So it was extraordinary to me that this draconian unprecedented intervention should have
00:03:01 been just accepted by everyone as you know the completely natural response but nonetheless
00:03:08 there was no opportunity for anyone to well very few opportunities for people to express their
00:03:14 dissent particularly people academics people in the medical profession and so forth so I thought
00:03:20 I'd start lockdown skeptics to create this forum and it ended up taking over my life I mean it
00:03:28 became a kind of we produced a daily update of all the stories we'd published the day before as well
00:03:34 as a summary of all the stories in the news and elsewhere about the pandemic i read it all the
00:03:39 time and and it's uh and doing it almost killed me i mean it was um i would be working on it sort
00:03:44 of 14 15 hours a day i ended up sleeping in my garden shed because i was going to bed so late
00:03:50 i would have woken up my wife if i'd gone to bed at sort of 5 a.m and i wanted to sleep in in the
00:03:53 morning and not be woken up by the kids but but it's like i was literally i would drag myself out
00:03:57 of my bed get up sit in front of my my laptop and just be there stuck to it maybe having a bowl of
00:04:04 soup for half an hour and then just kind of collapse at 4 35 a.m and they get up and do it
00:04:09 all over again but it felt you know important to do it because there were so few voices of dissent
00:04:16 at that time challenging the kind of prevailing narrative and eventually I found other people to
00:04:22 help and I relied on donations it's always just relied on donations from well-wishers and that
00:04:28 became enough to then employ a couple of people to help me do it and now I've turned it into a
00:04:33 company and it's become the daily skeptic and it has um four employees including myself um and um
00:04:39 we had our record month uh in the month of january we had two million plus um page views um which is
00:04:47 um you know it's it's more than uh the morning star the new statesman and navara media combined
00:04:53 probably doesn't compare with your figures peter but but but for a kind of you know for a for a
00:04:58 cottage industry produced out of my garden shed it's been extraordinarily successful when you are
00:05:03 sort of like really going against the tide i i wouldn't say of whole opinion but you
00:05:09 as you just described it um what's it like actually to me for that i mean do you you're
00:05:15 pretty strong-minded obviously i mean uh but does this do you feel embattled ever i mean do you
00:05:20 think what am i doing this for you know um sometimes it's um it's difficult um to be
00:05:28 you know, very much on the outside. And you have to deal with, you know, not just
00:05:35 polite counter arguments, but an enormous amount of personal abuse. But I think, you know, I mean,
00:05:43 as a journalist, particularly, you know, an iconoclastic, irreverent journalist,
00:05:49 you become accustomed to, you know, attracting a bit of hate mail. And I'd sort of gone through
00:05:58 the ringer um at the beginning of 2018 when i was well and truly cancelled and had to step down from
00:06:03 five positions um so you know i i was sort of inured to it yeah uh by then um i wouldn't say
00:06:10 i've you know got a got the height of a rhinoceros but i'm probably you know more thick-skinned than
00:06:16 average um it's tough when i think it's really tough when your family begin to notice that it's
00:06:22 happening and you're kind of kids get abuse you know um i've never been an anti-vaxxer but um
00:06:28 often people who are um lockdown skeptics get kind of smeared as covid skeptics or anti-vaxxers
00:06:35 um and my kids said that you know friends of theirs at school would say why is your dad an
00:06:40 anti-vaxxer um uh again that becomes when it sort of creeps into you know your domestic life in that
00:06:47 way it can become quite testing. But for the most part, that doesn't happen. And, you know,
00:06:53 one of the rewards of staking out these controversial dissenting positions is that
00:06:59 sometimes the rest of the world gradually comes around to your point of view. I'm not sure that's
00:07:04 entirely happened yet when it comes to the lockdowns, but it looks as though it's heading
00:07:08 in that direction. Certainly amongst the general public, amongst the kind of journalistic class
00:07:13 within the Westminster bubble, there isn't anything like as much enthusiasm for COVID restrictions as
00:07:19 there was, you know, two years ago. And people come up with a number of kind of rationalizations
00:07:23 to kind of explain why they've kind of, you know, changed their minds and sometimes quite plausible
00:07:28 explanations. But I'm beginning to think that, you know, the direction of the tide is turning.
00:07:35 Yes. I mean, I think, you know, you're reading things like perhaps we were too harsh or, you
00:07:41 that sort of thing perhaps looking back we were maybe too hard uh but um were you dismayed uh
00:07:48 or did you expect fellow journalists taken as a whole particularly broadcast media i have to say
00:07:54 uh seemed so unquestioning i mean you would think wouldn't you any reporter worth their sort you
00:08:00 know would question well first of all where these things come from and no one seemed to want to talk
00:08:05 at all about that and whether these things like lockdowns actually work at that point peter was
00:08:12 extraordinary that um there was so little intellectual curiosity about the origins of
00:08:16 the virus and anyone speculating that it might have um been leaked from you know the uh virology
00:08:26 institute in wuhan was you know for for a long time smeared as a conspiracy theorist trafficking
00:08:34 in misinformation. And that kind of smear was enough to kind of shut down debate about
00:08:39 it for more than a year. And, you know, we now know the story of how that was partly
00:08:45 orchestrated by various senior scientists and scientific gatekeepers who didn't want
00:08:50 to antagonize their Chinese allies, shall we say. But yeah, I was disappointed by my
00:08:59 my colleagues in the mainstream media for not challenging the official narrative more
00:09:05 energetically. I mean, there were pockets. Peter Hitchens in the Mail on Sunday, Alison
00:09:10 Pearson in the Daily Telegraph. There were some kind of heroic people who stood out from
00:09:20 the crowd and genuinely questioned what was happening. I was really impressed by Lord
00:09:25 consumption, who I think was, you know, risking quite a lot in staking out that territory because
00:09:30 it was so at odds with the kind of prevailing view within his kind of, you know, intellectual
00:09:35 class and his peers. And I think that was a large part of it. I think, you know, you ask yourself,
00:09:40 well, why did so many mainstream journalists toe the line effectively, just accept the official
00:09:49 narrative at face value, in many cases, just regurgitate propaganda that was being kind of
00:09:54 churned out by Downing Street with the help of the Behavioural Insights team. And I think lots
00:10:00 of people think it must be part of a conspiracy. And they point to the fact that the Bill and
00:10:05 Melinda Gates Foundation funds some journalists on The Guardian and on The Telegraph and so forth
00:10:10 and imagine that these journalists are part of this global conspiracy headed up by Klaus Schwab
00:10:20 and Bill Gates and the rest of it. I don't think that's it. I think it's, I mean, if it was that,
00:10:25 you know, that would sort of in some ways be kind of, well, it would certainly be more
00:10:29 understandable. I think it's, I don't think they needed to be bribed. They just, it was just group
00:10:36 thing. A lot of it was status signaling, I think, you know, it became very quickly established that
00:10:42 if you were a dissenter, if you didn't buy into lockdowns, and if you didn't, if you weren't
00:10:48 completely convinced that the vaccines were the solution when the vaccines were rolled out beginning
00:10:54 of last year, you were immediately tagged as a sort of deplorable, you know, you were someone
00:11:00 who wasn't properly educated, you were, there was, you had something in common with the kind of,
00:11:05 you know, animal skin wearing kind of protesters who stormed the Capitol on, you know, January the
00:11:11 6th. Yeah, it was like, it was like, it was like being a Brexiteer, but worse. I mean,
00:11:14 There was certainly an effort by Romanists to kind of smear Brexiteers as sort of beyond the pale, as these sort of knuckle dragging troglodytes, racists.
00:11:24 And, you know, but but but it seemed to be more effective at shutting down any kind of dissent from the kind of COVID orthodoxy over the past two years.
00:11:33 And it became a kind of if it was, I think, lots of lots of senior journalists, people like I don't want to name names, but but I think that it was it was a way to going along with the narrative.
00:11:44 was a way of signalling that they were a member of the kind of ruling elite.
00:11:49 I mean, one of the extraordinary things about the last two years was
00:11:52 it wasn't just that people, journalists, kind of didn't challenge the prevailing orthodoxy,
00:11:59 but they saw it as their job to enforce compliance with the kind of public health coronavirus regulations.
00:12:07 They thought that they were doing good by doing that,
00:12:09 but also it was a way of aligning themselves with the kind of responsible class,
00:12:13 with the metropolitan elite, a way of signaling that you were, you know, a member of this kind
00:12:19 of responsible, this custodian class. I mean, it was sort of, but I think, I think it was,
00:12:27 I think it was largely that it was kind of groupthink, status signaling, wanting to do
00:12:32 something in this crisis, feeling it was the right thing to do. Often there's a kind of overlap
00:12:37 between virtue signaling and status signaling. I think it's, it's that rather than, you know,
00:12:42 anything more sinister. It's just a kind of failure of kind of, what's the
00:12:49 word, sort of absence of any critical thinking.
00:12:53 Yeah. I think, I mean, one thing I would say, I would agree with that. What I found
00:12:59 interesting when the restrictions came or Plan B or whatever came off last week, I
00:13:03 have to say that just for a while in my sentimental way, you mentioned, I
00:13:09 mentioned Brexit, I did have a slight, just a glimmer of pride. I thought, my
00:13:14 god, this country is the first one to do this. Somehow, by some kind of strange
00:13:19 circuitous kind of genius, we've somehow been the first to actually become free
00:13:25 again, as it were. Just before we leave this subject, I wonder, when it comes to
00:13:30 the whole Boris thing and the party, the general force of argument has
00:13:35 been about the shocking hypocrisy you know shorthand there but my feeling is
00:13:41 the basic part the most important point is that they didn't believe themselves
00:13:47 in it I mean would you agree with that or not do you think it's just a case of
00:13:52 oh well yes this is what we have to do but well we'll get round it or do you
00:13:57 think it's actually that they never really believed it yeah it's it's hard
00:14:01 to tell, Peter. I mean, could you say the same thing about Neil Ferguson, you know, the leader
00:14:09 of the Imperial College modelling team whose apocalyptic projections in March 2020 prompted
00:14:19 Boris and his cabinet to do a U-turn and impose the first national lockdown and also, I think,
00:14:24 influenced the decision to lock down around the world and then was later caught out having an
00:14:29 an affair with a married woman even while he had just tested positive for coronavirus and you sort
00:14:37 of think to yourself well does that mean that he doesn't think these restrictions are actually
00:14:42 going to interrupt transmission and are kind of pointless and why has he been and I don't think
00:14:47 so and I don't think in the case of Downing Street either I think it's just they think the rules are
00:14:54 for the good of the general population, and that it's in the interests of the country for everyone
00:15:02 to comply with those rules, but they don't think the rules apply to them. They think, you know,
00:15:10 from a sort of utilitarian perspective, I suppose, that if I break a couple of rules here and there,
00:15:17 it won't make a big dent in the general good that the rules are doing. Is it that? I mean,
00:15:23 Maybe it's a degree of cognitive dissonance that they think that, you know, I'm I'm an intelligent, educated person, so I can make a kind of risk benefit calculation myself.
00:15:35 But but these kind of uneducated masses, they need me to tell them what to do and to order them to stay in their homes because they're incapable of making that kind of calculation themselves.
00:15:45 I mean, you know, something which was clearly wrong, as we've seen in countries where they've had less draconian restrictions and, you know, no greater COVID death toll than us, like Sweden.
00:15:55 But it's hard to know why they were so cavalier and, you know, behaved so flagrantly, hypocritically.
00:16:04 I mean, I was thinking about, you know, the party, one of the parties that Sue Gray is investigating and apparently is being investigated by the Metropolitan Police, which was the party held in Carrie's flat at which Abba's winner takes it all was supposedly played because Dominic Cummings had just departed.
00:16:23 And this is it's sort of presented as a reference to Carrie triumphant in a battle with Dom.
00:16:30 And you sort of think, my God, you know, could there have been anything more hubristic than holding a party where you play winner takes it all to celebrate your victory over Dominic Cummings?
00:16:42 And in the act of doing that, the very act of doing that, you're handing Dominic Cummings the gun that he's going to use to assassinate you.
00:16:50 I mean, it's it's pretty remarkable.
00:16:53 But, you know, of course, it's hubris, it's arrogance, it's thinking the rules don't apply to them. Maybe it's sort of an acknowledgement. People read it as an acknowledgement on their part that the rules were entirely pointless and completely ineffective, and they just wanted to be seen to be doing something for kind of Machiavellian political reasons, didn't actually think they'd make any sort of impact on interrupting transmission.
00:17:20 And maybe maybe that's partly true. I'm not close enough to it. But I mean, I've always thought that Boris was fairly sceptical about the benefits of the lockdowns.
00:17:32 And, you know, and that's part of, you know, Dominic Cummings is sort of narrative is that Dominic, that Boris was, you know, he wobbled, he dragged his heels.
00:17:41 He didn't want to do it. He didn't think it was really important. You know, I've always rather liked that about Boris.
00:17:49 And and I sort of think now, you know, for all his shortcomings, he got Brexit done or, you know, but he did his best to get Brexit done, although Brexit hasn't entirely been done.
00:18:03 And I'm not sure that any successor wouldn't kind of, you know, try and do a reverse ferret of some kind, leave a lot of loose ends untied.
00:18:14 So there's that consideration.
00:18:16 But I also think that, you know, bad though he has been and disappointing though his acquiescence to the various lockdowns was, he did at least stand up to all the kind of bedwetting hysterics and release all the restrictions on July 19th of last year, Freedom Day.
00:18:35 In spite of the apocalyptic warnings from, you know, sage, independent sage, that kind of obedient chorus in the mainstream media.
00:18:44 Nonetheless, Boris stuck to his guns on that one. Turned out absolutely fine.
00:18:50 And again, the attempt to go further than plan B restrictions in the run up to Christmas, in terms of Christmas lockdown.
00:18:56 Maybe Boris doesn't deserve all the credit for that.
00:18:59 I mean, I saw a piece in the Mail on Sunday in which Rishi Sunak had clearly briefed, you know, their chief political correspondent saying, no, no, that was all me.
00:19:05 you know, staying Boris's hand, me and Jacob and Lord Frost.
00:19:10 But nonetheless, you know, he did, he did as the kind of decision maker,
00:19:15 he decided not to go beyond plan B.
00:19:18 And that turned out to be absolutely the right decision.
00:19:20 And you sort of think now, having seen Sage and others cry wolf twice,
00:19:26 when they cry wolf a third time, Boris is going to be fairly reluctant to listen to them,
00:19:32 which you think is good.
00:19:33 But also, I think the fact that, you know, he himself broke the rules makes it much harder for him to insist everyone else obey them again.
00:19:40 I mean, you can't imagine a political leader across the West for whom it would be politically more difficult to impose another lockdown.
00:19:47 So I think for that reason, he should be kept in office. But, you know, I also think that bad though he's bad, though he's been, you know, it's hard to find another leader who's been better.
00:19:56 I mean, you know, maybe the prime minister of Sweden, Ron DeSantis in Florida.
00:20:02 But there are very few political leaders to emerge with any credit over the last two years.
00:20:07 And I do think Boris is one of the few, one of the least bad at any rate.
00:20:14 So, you know, even though he's been terrible, he's been better than almost every other Western political leader.
00:20:19 During this whole period of restriction, you know, of physical restriction, we've also had a growth, I would say, in psychological restriction coming from different angles.
00:20:33 I mean, because, and it sounds fanciful, but over the past two years, obviously, in terms of free speech, in terms of the kind of growing woke agenda, that has sort of placed, again, another restriction.
00:20:48 so people have been physically restricted but also they're they're increasingly worried about
00:20:53 what they can and cannot say this has grown and that's a rather clunky segue uh into talking about
00:21:00 the free speech union or the fsu as you refer to it um it was two years ago this month that you
00:21:07 founded it wasn't it uh sorry two two months sorry two years ago this month february that you founded
00:21:13 it um why did you do it actually to begin with why did you start it was it because of your own
00:21:19 cancelling yes in part anyway so um when i found myself um you know um uh
00:21:30 twisting on the end of the kind of pitchfork wielded by a mob um i was very conscious that
00:21:38 there was no organization to turn to for help you know to give me impartial professional legal and
00:21:46 sort of pr advice um you know when you find yourself uh in that situation um you know you
00:21:52 can see your career that you've spent you know 25 plus years building up on fire literally burning
00:22:00 to the ground um and um and you know it's it's quite panic inducing and you really want um some
00:22:07 sort of guidance as to should i throw some sand on it do i kind of do i kind of get a fire hose
00:22:14 and try and put it out where do i direct the the stream um uh and and there's nothing really no
00:22:20 organization to provide you with with that kind of advice you're getting a lot of conflicting
00:22:24 advice from all directions um uh and um and i thought when i sort of came through it that it
00:22:30 would be great um to set up an organization that did precisely that people who find themselves
00:22:35 targeted for cancellation, being put through an investigation in the workplace or at a university.
00:22:43 People who are being punished, penalized in some way for exercising their lawful right to free
00:22:47 speech, who've kind of whipped up this kind of angry, feverish kind of mob, an organization they
00:22:55 can turn to, that can provide them with some calm, reasonable, professional assistance, tell them
00:23:02 what the best what the best thing they can do is um uh and that was really the kind of wellspring
00:23:07 of the idea um but yeah in that case actually it really is genuine a union isn't it i mean it is a
00:23:14 union just as much as the firefighters union or whatever people come to you they join it don't
00:23:19 they they join it and then so how does it work actually well people who want to join yeah it's
00:23:25 it's it's a membership organization and um you can join um uh for as little as 24.95 a year and
00:23:31 you can stagger that over you know monthly payments um the standard fee is 49.95 for full membership
00:23:39 um and um in addition to you know it's like an insurance policy i suppose um if something
00:23:45 happens to you you know we can provide you with a whole suite of services um you know including
00:23:50 legal support if you know that's discretionary but if we judge that it's an important winnable
00:23:55 case we'll we'll you know we'll provide you with legal support and we have a full-time chief legal
00:23:59 counsel a legal officer who works four days a week and an incredible amount of our time is taken up
00:24:05 with um uh managing various fighting various legal cases i mean we're behaving like a medium size
00:24:11 about actually like on a daily basis we've got we've got about i'd say two dozen cases unfolding
00:24:17 simultaneously um uh and we get about 50 cries for help a week i'd say to our you know either
00:24:24 to our hotline or to our help inbox and we end up helping about half of them um and uh but we don't
00:24:30 just do casework that's about 50 of what we do we also organize events they've mainly been sort of
00:24:37 online events up until now we're beginning to organize some in-person events we also have a
00:24:41 research and a kind of briefing arm doing a bit of lobbying um so it's sort of growing um but as
00:24:47 you say, it's like a trade union. It's not legally a trade union, but it is like a trade
00:24:52 union. And one of the great benefits of trade unions, you know, back in the 19th century
00:24:59 when they were first formed, is that they would protect people who wanted to say things
00:25:04 which weren't against the law, but which were likely to get them into trouble. They're going
00:25:07 to criticize their bosses, criticize working conditions. And unions seem to have lost sight
00:25:13 for the most part of that role of protecting the speech rights of workers and that creates a kind
00:25:19 of real opportunity for us to to move in to that to that space and do that. It was quite interesting
00:25:25 I was having a quiet glass of wine in my local Wetherspoons not that long ago and you know they
00:25:32 produce a magazine in Wetherspoons and on the back of the I think it was the back there was a whole
00:25:38 article by you about the free speech union about the threat to free speech and I just thought I
00:25:43 to say to him i thought that is enviable outreach i mean here you are in all the did you get much
00:25:50 response from that it was incredible i i got a better response to that piece than anything else
00:25:55 i've ever written um uh it was extraordinary i mean i hundreds of people uh you know who just
00:26:01 read it in a weatherspoon who wouldn't normally have heard of it uh contacted me and said this
00:26:05 sounds fantastic how do i join or lots of people say i got into trouble for saying this can you
00:26:10 help we ended up helping some of them so yeah that's been an extraordinarily effective bit of
00:26:15 outreach what would you say we had harry miller on quite recently again um just after he'd had
00:26:20 his call to appeal victory on that particular on the non-crime hate incidents point um
00:26:27 when it comes to what you've been doing over the past two years
00:26:32 what's been your biggest success do you think or most significant in your mind
00:26:38 um uh we were a little bit involved in in harry miller's case so we had um we had said to harry
00:26:46 um when he was weighing up whether to appeal the high court decision to the court of appeal
00:26:52 the high court decision was great from his point of view but it could have been even better because
00:26:59 even though justice knowles condemned humberside police as the gestapo and said they shouldn't
00:27:05 have investigated Harry's thinking, you know, for retweeting a comic verse about trans people.
00:27:12 Nonetheless, the judge in the High Court said that the College of Policing's guidance,
00:27:17 which Humberside Police were following, was lawful. And so Harry challenged that in the
00:27:22 Court of Appeal. And when he was weighing up whether to do that, the risk was that he'd lose
00:27:27 and there'd be a costs order given against him and he'd be in the hole for, you know, a lot of
00:27:31 money um and um so we said look if if we'll we'll back you so you know if that happens we'll help
00:27:39 you pay those adverse costs and i think that that helped him make up his mind to challenge it in the
00:27:45 court of appeal and we would have been you know um out of pocket um in a big way had he lost but
00:27:50 thankfully he won um uh and um i mean he deserves you know um uh all the credit i mean he he's an
00:27:56 extraordinary courageous and tenacious man and has struck a huge blow for free speech by winning
00:28:03 both those cases. I mean you know NCHI's non-crime hate incidents are still there and the next step
00:28:09 lots of people and when I say lots I mean you know probably close to 200,000 people in England
00:28:16 and Wales have non-crime hate incidents recorded against their names which will show up on their
00:28:21 criminal records in some cases when prospective employers, voluntary organisations they apply to
00:28:27 work with do enhanced DBS checks on them. So they're still there. I mean, it may be that fewer
00:28:32 are now being recorded, perhaps not even any are being recorded until the College of Policing
00:28:37 revises its NCHI guidance to comply with the Court of Appeals verdict. But nonetheless,
00:28:43 these need to be expunged and one great victory earlier this week was that um uh one of the one
00:28:51 of the fair cop harry's organization helped get uh a non-crime hate incident expunged from now
00:28:59 is this the case of the lady with the book that was taken away by the police or no it's a different
00:29:05 one and um uh and uh we we we are now going to i think say to all our members um you know if you
00:29:14 want us to write to the police if you think you've got an nchi recorded against your name we will
00:29:19 write to them and ask them to expunge it and if they don't we'll threaten legal action which is
00:29:23 how fair cop succeeded in this particular case um and um and i think we'll publish an faqs on our
00:29:30 website too, just telling anyone, member or not, how to go about, here's a template letter to write,
00:29:36 because it's really, it's, you know, it's a scandal that nearly 200,000 people, you know,
00:29:43 have blighted employment prospects merely because they've exercised their lawful right to free
00:29:49 speech, oftentimes engaged, you know, robustly in a debate about, you know, trans rights or
00:29:55 something similar uh they have to go yes um is there some obviously it's very clear what you do
00:30:03 and what you offer but is there a sort of a legal thing is there anything in the legal field a law
00:30:09 or or some such which in your view in the fsu's view has to either go or change is there a specific
00:30:17 have you in other words have you got an aim to somehow or other get something scrapped or revised
00:30:21 Well, you'd be amazed, Peter. I mean, when I, you know, set up the Free Speech Union, I thought we'd be campaigning, that most of our campaigning energy would be consumed by trying to repeal existing restrictions on free speech on the statute book.
00:30:41 um uh uh i didn't imagine you know at that stage february 2020 that things could get much worse
00:30:48 but actually they then got worse by an order of magnitude partly as a result of the pandemic which
00:30:53 resulted in a huge amount of you know lawful speech being suppressed uh we saw it last week
00:30:59 with joe rogan um but in addition uh the black lives matter movement suddenly it became absolutely
00:31:05 absolutely taboo to challenge any of these kind of wild, completely un-evidenced claims being made
00:31:13 by kind of anti-racist activists. And we saw lots and lots of people who we came to the aid of who
00:31:19 got into trouble for challenging in the most reasonable evidence-based way some of these
00:31:24 claims. Nick Buckley, good example. He was one of our great successes quite early on. So he wrote a
00:31:30 blog post. I mean, I'm sure you know the story. He's been on. You've had him on the show.
00:31:34 He just criticised the Ames, as stated on their website of BLM, isn't he?
00:31:39 That's right. Yeah. He didn't appeal to anything other than what BLM said on its own website.
00:31:46 And it said things like wanting to end capitalism, dismantle the nuclear family,
00:31:50 defund the police and so forth. And he was monstered. And the charity that he had set up
00:31:55 then fired him as chief executive and really extraordinarily kind of cowardly behavior on that
00:32:02 part. And we found him, I called him, said, can we help? He said, well, maybe you can. We found him
00:32:08 an experienced charity solicitor who agreed to do the work pro bono, eventually got Nick
00:32:18 reinstated to that job and all the trustees resigned one after another. So that was a huge
00:32:24 victory and i'm delighted to see that nick has gone from strength to strength after that um but
00:32:30 to go back to my original point you know i thought we'd be campaigning to you know uh repeal those
00:32:37 laws which were but actually most of our campaigning energy has been devoted to stopping things getting
00:32:43 worse yeah i mean you know good example is the online safety bill i'm sure you've discussed it
00:32:47 many times um but um that safety by the way it was once called something what it's called the
00:32:52 online harms bill originally yes yeah yeah they've it's become more kind of uh it's been changed to
00:32:58 perhaps with the advice of the behavioral insights team to make her on too laura you know she wrote
00:33:03 all about the uh nudge theory yeah um with the uh with this uh online safety bill then um what is it
00:33:12 that you would campaign to what you think it should be scrapped or basically or just revised
00:33:20 or what well it's often a tricky judgment call um when uh thinking about these bits of legislation
00:33:28 do you just outright oppose it you know on principle and kind of make that argument in
00:33:34 the public square um knowing that it'll probably happen anyway or do you think about you know what
00:33:41 you can do pragmatically to improve it even though it's a pretty ghastly piece of legislation and
00:33:47 i tend to side i tend to go with a more pragmatic approach so um i think there's i think it's
00:33:54 politically unstoppable it's going to happen um it doesn't matter how energetically we campaign
00:33:59 against it how how much we try to mobilize opposition to it there seems to be so much
00:34:04 political momentum behind it and if you look at other you know other countries germany spain
00:34:09 New Zealand, very similar legislation has either been passed or is going through the kind of
00:34:17 parliamentary legislative sausage machine. So I don't think we can stop it, but I think we can
00:34:21 improve it significantly. And one way in which we can improve it is that the Law Commission of
00:34:28 England and Wales has proposed various reforms to communications law. So it would repeal the
00:34:35 Malicious Communications Act, which is a pretty egregious piece of legislation, and replace all
00:34:42 the communications offences with a single harms-based communications offence. And this
00:34:47 would enshrine the principle that it is the business of the state to protect people from
00:34:52 psychological harm. And that is a pernicious principle. And me and Lord Sumption had a bit
00:34:58 of a barney about that at Ditchley Park last week. He's just dead against it, which I'm sure
00:35:03 is the right position to hold. But my pragmatic view is, OK, let's accept this recommendation of
00:35:10 the Law Commission, because what they're proposing isn't as bad as the various bits of legislation
00:35:17 it would be replacing. Let's try and define psychological harm incredibly narrowly and
00:35:23 precisely. Let's include the Law Commission's proposals in the online safety bill and make
00:35:28 sure there's a read-across throughout the bill of that definition of harm. So internet companies,
00:35:35 Ofcom, cannot just pluck things out of the air and say they're harmful. They can't just respond
00:35:40 to politically motivated complainants saying, I was harmed by hearing this gender critical point
00:35:45 of view by Kathleen Stock, and it shouldn't be on the internet. It should include across the bill,
00:35:51 embedded in the bill, should be this very narrow, very precise definition of legal harm. And the
00:35:58 only things internet companies, social media companies should be obliged to remove by Ofcom
00:36:03 should be content that meets the threshold for criminal prosecution under this new harms-based
00:36:10 communications offence. Anything short of that should not be removed. And if social media
00:36:14 companies remove it, then there should be a right of appeal and they should be fined as much as they
00:36:19 are for leaving it on if they remove it, if they shouldn't remove it, if it doesn't meet that
00:36:24 criminal threshold so that it's very specific thing uh so basically this is the lobbying part
00:36:31 of what you do isn't it yes so i mean essentially how would i mean people always ask this our viewers
00:36:39 how does one do this in your case you have to build up enough influence presumably with with
00:36:46 government and with mps in order to take this on board and to change it that's what you have to do
00:36:51 That is a very long process, is it not?
00:36:54 It is a long process.
00:36:57 We have a legislative affairs director part-time.
00:37:02 And it's work.
00:37:04 When I was involved in education, I was involved in a certain amount of lobbying then,
00:37:11 when I was head of the New Schools Network.
00:37:13 So it's not completely unfamiliar territory.
00:37:15 But I also think that with many members of the Parliamentary Conservative Party,
00:37:20 You know, you're pushing it an open door. There are lots of Conservative MPs, particularly amongst the, you know, the red wall seat holders who are very pro free speech, very concerned about the erosion of free speech, you know, across various sectors.
00:37:35 So there's a lot of kind of sympathy there. There's an audience there willing to listen.
00:37:42 And I think with the online safety bill, you know, I think that I think there's certainly scope to improve it dramatically.
00:37:50 Right. But I don't think there's scope to, you know, get it scrapped altogether.
00:37:54 I mean, another thing that could be done to improve it is at the moment there is a reference to social media companies, search engine companies having a due regard.
00:38:05 They need to have a due regard for free speech.
00:38:08 But due regard is the weakest of the legal duties. And it's certainly weaker than this duty of care they'll have to their users to prevent psychological harm befalling them.
00:38:19 Adult users, not just children. And it's been designed that way.
00:38:24 So in the event of a conflict between free speech and safety, safety is going to win and they won't have to offcom when kind of adjudicate when when when scrutinizing the decisions made by search engines.
00:38:37 um they won't have to it won't be a tough judgment call because it'll be clear in the bill safety
00:38:43 psychological safety takes priority over free speech we want to get that that that due regard
00:38:49 strengthened so free speech at least has the same is given the same weight by social media companies
00:38:56 and ultimately by ofcom when judging whether they've got these calls right this uh applies
00:39:01 to England right the English legal system in the sense that obviously
00:39:07 Scotland's got a different legal system I mean the reason I was asking is that
00:39:11 some of the things coming out now from Scotland on issue of free speech just
00:39:16 make the blood run cold I mean this domestic hate speech where whereby you
00:39:23 know if you say something at home which could be called hate speech you know
00:39:26 this is somehow it's now going to be illegal it's unbelievable to me totally
00:39:31 But presumably, that's the sort of thing you would campaign against, but it's in Scotland.
00:39:36 Do you operate only in...
00:39:38 We are raising our profile in Scotland.
00:39:43 We had a conference in Scotland in November of last year.
00:39:47 And there was, you won't be surprised to learn, a lot of enthusiasm, a lot of support from
00:39:52 some pretty senior people for a much bigger presence for the Free Speech Union north of
00:40:00 border and we're going to have another conference in april and we're going to launch a campaign and
00:40:08 we're looking at what that campaign issue should be and one of the things we're looking at is
00:40:13 challenging the scottish hate crime and public order act under the european convention on human
00:40:20 rights and it remains to be seen how challengeable it is whether whether whether a challenge along
00:40:27 those lines would succeed.
00:40:30 But the really alarming thing, Peter, is not just that Scotland now probably has the least
00:40:39 free speech than any other country in Europe, fewer legal protections for free speech than
00:40:46 any other country in Europe, including Hungary, because this bill's been passed.
00:40:50 But the Law Commission of England and Wales, in another proposal, has proposed a hate crime bill almost identical to the Scottish one for England and Wales.
00:41:02 It actually goes further than the Scottish one.
00:41:04 In the original Scottish hate crime bill, the proposal was that people should be, you should be able to prosecute people for stirring up hatred, not just against the current three categories of protected people, which is on racial grounds, religious grounds or sexual orientation.
00:41:24 But they wanted to vastly increase the number of protected characteristics you can be prosecuted for stirring up hatred against.
00:41:31 And at the same time, this was originally in the Scottish bill, remove the necessity for the prosecution to show intent.
00:41:37 So if your words had the likely effect of stirring up hatred against one of these protected groups, then that would be enough to secure a prosecution, regardless of whether you intended them to have that effect or not.
00:41:49 That was that was that in the debate about the bill in Holyrood that went.
00:41:54 So that's gone. That's not in the Scottish Hate Crime and Public Order Act.
00:41:58 You still have to show intent. You will have to, to secure a prosecution for stirring up hatred in Scotland.
00:42:03 In the Law Commission of England and Wales's proposal, they have also proposed that intent shouldn't be necessary to secure a prosecution.
00:42:12 It's not necessary in the case of stirring up racial hatred at the moment.
00:42:16 But that's the exception. If you want to if you want to secure a conviction against anyone for stirring up hatred against another protected group, you have to show intent.
00:42:24 And the law commission is arguing, well, for consistency's sake, you know, just to make it all consistent. Let's not make it necessary to show intent in any case. And let's vastly increase the number of protected characteristics. I mean, it's a horrible proposal, which will have a really chilling effect on free speech.
00:42:39 But at the moment, as things stand, if this if this proposal, if this English and Welsh hate crime bill is passed in in Westminster as as proposed, it'll actually be worse than the Scottish Hate Crime and Public Order Act.
00:42:56 I mean, it's extraordinary. You know, given the fuss that was made of seeing that, you know, all the criticisms that Nicola Sturgeon attracted for passing that bill, you know, totalitarian, one party state.
00:43:08 Yeah. For the Law Commission, it's so tone deaf to think let's have the same thing in England and Wales, but let's make it even more draconian.
00:43:15 Even more draconian. And that's a battle facing us. And, you know, just as a coda to this, a very similar proposal has been made in Northern Ireland.
00:43:22 It's not quite at the same stage as the proposals for England and Wales are yet, but it's getting to the same stage.
00:43:27 We're about to publish a paper opposing this proposed Northern Irish hate crime bill.
00:43:34 I mean, it's incredible how you think kind of, again, it's sort of, you think, is there some kind of cabal, you know, orchestrating this kind of assault on free speech?
00:43:45 Because similar bills have been passed, you know, across the world.
00:43:49 There's another bill very similar going through the New Zealand Parliament at the moment in various U.S. states.
00:43:54 Similar laws have been passed, again, removing the need for people to show intent in order to prosecute someone for hate speech directed against a protected group.
00:44:03 I mean, but I think it's just group thing. I mean, they all go to the same academic conferences.
00:44:06 They read the same books. But this kind of woke virus, it just kind of it just it just kind of seems to jump from person to person without requiring kind of central coordination, partly as a result of, you know, social media.
00:44:18 With the English and Welsh proposal from the Law Commission, this is a battle you say you're going to have to fight, but at what stage are they then, Toby, in a sense, like how much time have you got?
00:44:32 Well, the Joint Parliamentary Committee, which recently published its recommendations about what should be changed about the online safety bill,
00:44:47 proposed that many of the things that the Law Commission wanted to include in an English and Welsh hate crime bill be included in the online safety bill,
00:44:56 including the enlargement of the number of protected groups
00:45:02 you can be prosecuted for stirring up hatred against
00:45:04 as well as the proposal that it shouldn't be necessary to show intent
00:45:08 in order to secure a prosecution.
00:45:10 That was the recommendation of the Joint Parliamentary Committee
00:45:14 which scrutinised the online safety bill
00:45:16 and they've said, yeah, these recommendations should be included in this bill
00:45:21 and that bill could come before Parliament
00:45:23 and that recommendation could be followed up
00:45:26 in the next few weeks, so we haven't got much time.
00:45:31 I think you might have answered my question,
00:45:33 but I was going to ask you, by way of ending,
00:45:37 where you see the greatest threat to free speech coming from now?
00:45:44 I mean, generally.
00:45:46 I mean, for me, it's quite a, you know, it's not actually even a thing,
00:45:53 but various surveys have shown recently that young people no longer actually really even care or
00:46:01 believe in the concept of free speech I know that you've written I'm sure about but certain things
00:46:06 are far more important to them so it's not even a case of oh yes of course I believe in free speech
00:46:12 but you know the old one used to get that now they really don't even believe it to me that's
00:46:18 the biggest threat we've faced out here. But would you agree with that or is there something else?
00:46:22 I think that's right. I mean, we keep winning battles at the Free Speech Union.
00:46:32 75% of the cases we take on, we win. But we're losing the war.
00:46:38 You know, I read the other day about all these multi-academy trusts involving hundreds of schools, primary and secondary schools, introducing kind of mandatory anti-racism lessons, which effectively silence anyone who doesn't kind of sign up to the kind of BLM ideological agenda.
00:47:03 I mean, extraordinary and possibly even unlawful under the Education Act 1996, which prevents, you know, prohibits political indoctrination of children.
00:47:12 You see this kind of thing happening in schools up and down the country.
00:47:16 I mean, it's worse typically in Scotland than it is in England.
00:47:19 We saw Brighton and Hove kind of proposing similar.
00:47:23 Oh, the racial lack of innocence, seven-year-olds.
00:47:26 Seven-year-olds. I mean, and you think kind of every time you win a battle, you know, you then realize that, you know, this is just the tip, what you're seeing. These victories are at the tip of the iceberg. Below the surface, you know, the war is being won by the kind of massed armies of these kind of woke fanatics. And what can we do about it?
00:47:49 Well, as you say, it's a kind of it's essentially a cultural problem.
00:47:52 And I think, you know, law is downstream from culture.
00:47:56 And and and one of the successes of the enemies of free speech is that they've successfully created the impression that they're on the right side of history.
00:48:07 You know, this is the direction of travel.
00:48:09 You know, people like you and I are antediluvian, you know, Buffton-Tufton types who haven't understood, you know, why free speech is harmful to kind of historically marginalized groups and why, if we want to bring them into the conversation, the speech of people like you and I has to be restricted.
00:48:29 you know history's on their side and that's a very powerful argument you know i think that
00:48:35 that was one of the things which did for the soviet union and the kind of communist control
00:48:42 system across eastern europe in 1989 the feeling that you know they were on the wrong side of
00:48:48 history you know that their experiment had failed it's a tremendously powerful political narrative
00:48:55 If you can persuade people, this is the direction of travel. You need to go along with it. It's a way of getting people to do. You don't really think it's inevitable. You know, you have to tell them it's inevitable to persuade them to do your bidding to make it inevitable.
00:49:06 But that's been a powerful kind of argument. And we need to challenge that. We need to persuade people that the erosion of free speech, prioritizing emotional and psychological safety and well-being over robust, the robust exchange of ideas, that's not inevitable.
00:49:27 And persuading young people of that is, you know, that's the real challenge.
00:49:30 And the Free Speech Union has been involved with the battle of ideas in setting up something called the Free Speech Champions Program,
00:49:36 trying to identify young people on campuses willing to get out there and make the argument.
00:49:41 When Eric Kaufman did some research about how little enthusiasm there was for free speech amongst students for, I think, policy exchange last year, maybe the year before.
00:49:53 One thing he discovered was that if you read students out a kind of short passage, just making the basic case for free speech, pointing out why it's important and why it should matter to them.
00:50:06 Many of them changed their minds and became quite enthusiastic about free speech.
00:50:09 And that was the sort of wellspring of the free speech champions program.
00:50:12 But it suggests that one of the reasons young people aren't more pro free speech is they just haven't heard the arguments.
00:50:18 You know, the other side has successfully suppressed any opposition to their kind of woke fanaticism, often by threatening to cancel people who do challenge it.
00:50:29 But if you can just get voices out there, if you can just make make the argument in the public square in a way that young people will listen to, maybe you can persuade them that it isn't inevitable.
00:50:40 You know, there isn't such thing as the tide of history. History is what you make it. The future is in their hands. And it's important that they should defend free speech.
00:50:49 And if you look at if you look at teenagers, this is the source of hope, I think it's mainly anecdotal at this stage.
00:50:56 But you look at 13, 14, 15 year olds, they're beginning, I think, to bridle at all these restrictions on what they can say.
00:51:07 You know, cancel culture has become almost a joke to them. If someone says something they disagree with, oh, I'm going to cancel you for that.
00:51:14 You know, and I mean, it's not surprising if any teenager has got a bit about them, given that their parents, their teachers, the BBC,
00:51:24 everybody is kind of churning out the same propaganda day after day.
00:51:30 Of course, they're going to start to push back a little bit against it.
00:51:33 And I think you're beginning to see that. And, you know, it's remarkable how often young people contact, you know, the free speech union and say, am I old enough to join?
00:51:42 I recently discovered this Canadian psychologist you may not have heard of on YouTube called Jordan Peterson.
00:51:50 And a lot of what he says makes a great deal of sense to me. I'm thinking, you know, that's very, very heartening.
00:51:57 in fact it's very interesting actually you you say that the the sort of stuff that's being put
00:52:03 out now by academies and schools which might actually even be illegal you know this sort of
00:52:08 you know i've got a family member who's actually in this very position at the moment she doesn't
00:52:12 want her kids to have to go and listen to identity politics stuff and everything and the teachers in
00:52:19 fact said well it's actually a legal requirement so i think we will look into that and see if it
00:52:24 really is um toby thank you so much for that uh it was very much a root and branch explanation
00:52:31 exactly what people can do and where how you can help them when um uh when it comes to the website
00:52:39 it's the freespeechunion.org.uk is it it's just the freespeechunion.org.org freespeechunion.org
00:52:46 and uh again to join it is uh you've got a sliding scale yeah so if if if you're if you're um the
00:52:54 standard price is about 50 quid a year um but if you're a veteran or a student or a pensioner
00:53:02 it's 25 okay there you go um congratulations on two years of it anyway thank you fantastic
00:53:09 what you're doing thank you very much thanks peter um there you go i'm sure we'll speak to
00:53:14 Toby in about a year's time, I hope, if he comes back. We shall see you next time, so thank you very much, bye.
00:53:44 from as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on
00:53:50 our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including access to
00:53:55 exclusive content, invitations to our private events including here at our
00:54:01 studios, free copies of our books and much much more including of course our
00:54:07 famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by
00:54:13 clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just
00:54:19 remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we
00:54:25 post new videos. Thank you.