New Culture Forum - March 01, 2022


Former Australian PM Tony Abbott: Russia & China's New World Order May Eclipse Liberal Democracy

Toby Young on England Having Europe's Worst Free Speech Protection + Lockdown Sceptics' Vindication. Inside Putin's Mind: His Goals, Motivation & World View - What The West Needs to Understand

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

127.67

Word count

1,939

Sentence count

51


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. We are in Budapest this week because we have been at a conference organised by the Danube Institute about the current state of geopolitics.
00:00:12 Now the keynote speech this morning was given by, I guess to say, I'm delighted to say, is the former Prime Minister of Australia, the Honourable Tony Abbott.
00:00:24 Thank you very much for joining us Tony.
00:00:26 Thanks for having me Peter.
00:00:27 It's great. I'd like to refer to one thing you said in your speech today, it
00:00:33 struck a chord, if you could just maybe talk a bit more about it. You said, you
00:00:40 quoted a line which was, history is a good teacher but a bad master. Are we
00:00:48 living in a time where history is our master at the moment? It's interesting
00:00:54 how many people will use history for their own purposes but in so doing they tend to
00:01:02 take a pretty one-sided view of history. Now if you look at someone like Vladimir Putin
00:01:10 he is using history against the people of the Ukraine talking about Kiev and Rus, talking
00:01:18 about the hundreds of years in which the Ukraine was part of greater Russia but nevertheless
00:01:27 for a long time the Ukrainian people have had a very strong sense of national identity.
00:01:35 We shouldn't forget the Holdemore, Stalin's man-made famine against the farmers of the
00:01:43 Ukraine, one of the great bread baskets of the world.
00:01:47 We shouldn't forget the fact that there was really 10 years of guerrilla fighting against
00:01:52 the Soviets after 1945 in the Ukraine.
00:01:58 So we need to have, as far as we humanly can, a fulsome view of history rather partial view
00:02:08 of history because properly understood there is no perfection, there is no
00:02:17 monopoly of wisdom, there is no monopoly of insight. All peoples and all
00:02:22 countries have done good things and bad things. Nevertheless when you do look at
00:02:27 the history of the world over the last couple of centuries I think we can say
00:02:33 that America has been a relatively benign superpower. Before that Britain was a relatively
00:02:40 benign superpower and under the American-led world order of the last few decades we have
00:02:53 had the best times in human history and that's why the very dramatic challenge that we are
00:03:00 now seeing to that world order from Russia from China is pretty concerning and my fear
00:03:10 is that what we're seeing in Eastern Europe is not just a struggle between two countries,
00:03:15 what we're seeing in East Asia is not just an issue between China and what they say is a rebel
00:03:22 province but it could be a pivotal point in history leading to a period of eclipse
00:03:28 of liberal values and an eclipse of the democracies and that's why it's so important
00:03:33 that we are alert to this and do whatever we can to try to stop it from happening.
00:03:39 You made a statement there which I would agree with but which would seem to many people to be
00:03:45 controversial now which is that America was a benign superpower and Britain was basically a
00:03:50 a benign superpower. Why do you think those two countries seem now to be intent on portraying
00:03:57 themselves in an entirely different way? This is a very good question and the cultural self-loathing
00:04:04 which is now all too often evident in Anglo-American universities seeping into so many other parts of
00:04:13 English speaking societies is both unjustified because there has never been less racism.
00:04:25 Minorities have never had a fairer go than now. So it's unjustified in fact and it's
00:04:35 dreadfully destructive in practice. I imagine that if Martin Luther King stood up today and
00:04:43 said judge me on the content of my character not the color of my skin in
00:04:48 lots of English-speaking universities he'd been he'd be held down because we
00:04:54 are now supposed to judge people precisely by the color of their skin
00:04:58 white people bad black people good well the truth is all of us whatever our
00:05:05 ethnicity or skin color can do good and bad things and the challenge for all of
00:05:11 us, black, white, whatever, is to try to be our best selves and that requires being given a fair go
00:05:21 and there's not a lot of tolerance around today and there should be. You mentioned as well on
00:05:28 that subject in your address today that despite there being less racism etc that the elites in
00:05:38 what you might call the Anglosphere are obsessed with these things but at the same time they don't
00:05:46 criticize other cultures for the various mishaps. Where has that obsession come from? Well again it
00:05:53 comes I think from this cultural self-loathing which is completely unjustified, I'm not saying
00:06:01 there haven't been blemishes on the record, I'm not saying there aren't still imperfections but
00:06:06 But one of the things that's often bandied around in criticism of Anglo-American societies
00:06:15 is supposed Islamophobia.
00:06:18 Now, the people who are so quick to detect Islamophobia in Britain and America are almost
00:06:25 completely silent about what's happening in Xinjiang province and what looks very much
00:06:30 like the genocide of the Uyghurs.
00:06:33 Now, you know, I'm not saying that Uyghurs should be put up on a pedestal any more than anyone else should be put up on a pedestal.
00:06:40 But human beings, regardless of their ethnicity or their religion or their gender or their race, should all be given a fair go.
00:06:51 And that certainly doesn't appear to be happening at the hands of the Beijing government in Western China.
00:06:57 Do you think therefore that you know Russia is obviously looks at the west and says well you
00:07:04 know it's pretty impotent, it's pretty weak, do you think we are weak and impotent? Well we're not
00:07:12 as weak and as impotent as the Russians or sorry as Putin and the Beijing government
00:07:22 often suspects but I do sometimes think we're weaker and less potent than we should be
00:07:30 and I'm not saying that we should be triumphalist I'm not saying that the anglosphere should attempt
00:07:39 to impose upon others our particular way of doing things but I think we should be proud of what
00:07:48 we've done which is on balance a very good story and I think we should be unapologetic in putting
00:07:57 forward a point of point of view. Yes just briefly if we could it's coming out what England is coming
00:08:05 out of Covid anyway you can say the world maybe has seen the worst of it in geopolitical sense or
00:08:12 even just in a cultural sense what do you think what do you think are going to be the main effects
00:08:17 of what we've been through? Obviously you can't spend the trillions
00:08:25 in dealing with COVID that have been spent and not significantly weaken yourselves economically.
00:08:36 Sooner or later because there's no such thing as a money tree all of this debt is going to have to
00:08:41 be repaid and the countries and the peoples that became incredibly dependent upon effectively
00:08:52 money printing over the last couple of years and before that as well since the GFC are going to
00:08:59 have to learn that in the end you can only spend what you raise in taxes. So I think there's going
00:09:08 to be a difficult economic overhang and I fear that some of the ways of thinking that
00:09:16 we've got into will be hard to shake. The other anxiety I've got is that we've seen
00:09:24 unprecedented restrictions on freedom, unprecedented growth in government and that will take a
00:09:33 a while to roll back and I hope that we can swiftly recover our robust independence of
00:09:41 mind and action and get right away from this situation where we all too readily accept
00:09:48 the judgment of unaccountable unelected experts and we have elected and accountable politicians
00:09:55 all too often hiding behind unelected and unaccountable experts and simply accepting
00:10:03 whatever advice they give us. Now what is the point of having an elected government if its job
00:10:09 is simply to implement the views of so-called experts, particularly given when it comes to value
00:10:17 judgments experts often have no particular insights and in any event the experts are often
00:10:25 as divided as the rest of us. There's a view that all epidemiologists supported lockdowns well
00:10:37 that's not correct absolutely false just as there's a view that all scientists
00:10:43 believe in the so-called climate science. Well sure there may be a lot of people in the science
00:10:57 world who for all sorts of reasons subscribe to the establishmentarian view but there are
00:11:06 certainly plenty of climate scientists like Richard Linson and Judith Currie who would
00:11:12 respectfully dissent from what is thought to be the consensus in inverted
00:11:19 commas just as there were plenty of epidemiologists like Gupta of Oxford and
00:11:26 Ian Edes of Stanford who would have dissented from the Nile Ferguson Imperial
00:11:33 College view. Many would do that idea. Mr. Albert we're talking about reaction to
00:11:41 Covid there and what we have to change and come out of but a lot of people have
00:11:48 been very surprised by our reaction to it and in particular in Britain one hears a
00:11:54 lot about Australia and people think well I really am surprised at Australia.
00:12:00 Are you surprised at the Australian reaction? Look I was surprised that larrikin
00:12:08 egalitarian Australians proved so ready to submit to the dictates of government
00:12:19 but someone made a very interesting point I think it might have been Clive
00:12:22 James not in the context of the pandemic but the point I think it was Clive made
00:12:29 was not so much that Australians are descended from convicts but were
00:12:34 actually descended from prison guards maybe that explains why we were so docile in the face of
00:12:42 all these instructions we got from government yeah you obviously were born in and educated in
00:12:49 Britain when you look at Britain now from the outside what do you see I mean we seem to live
00:12:57 in perpetual crisis? Look I think one of the problems that Britain has had for a long time now
00:13:10 is defeatism and declinism amongst the British establishment. I'd forgotten just how entrenched
00:13:18 this was until I read Andrew Roberts' bio of Churchill. The British establishment was riddled
00:13:28 with defeatism and declinism in the 1930s and of course we saw plenty of that in the aftermath of
00:13:36 the Second World War. Thatcher was a magnificent antidote to so much of that in a very different
00:13:44 why i think tony blair was an antidote to much of that and at his best boris johnson is an antidote
00:13:51 to that as well the great thing about boris johnson is that he is such a vibrant optimistic
00:13:59 individual at his best and that's what we want we want our leaders to be at their best and is he
00:14:07 At his best do you think? Well I probably shouldn't get involved in offering
00:14:13 commentary on day-to-day British politics but let me just just make this point
00:14:20 I absolutely understand that the general public get very irritable when they think there's one
00:14:28 rule for them and a different rule for people in government but you know Dan Andrews the Premier of
00:14:35 Victoria the author of the world's longest lockdown he was fined twice twice for breaking
00:14:44 his own lockdown rules right no one says he should resign right well there's a moral in
00:14:50 there somewhere I shall try and figure it out thank you very much indeed Mr Albert thank you
00:14:56 very much thanks better thank you that's it for a very brief but fascinating so what you're saying
00:15:01 is and we shall see you next time. Thank you.