New Culture Forum - March 02, 2022


Inside Putin's Mind: His Goals, Motivation & World View - What The West Needs to Understand

Former Australian PM Tony Abbott: Russia & China's New World Order May Eclipse Liberal Democracy Sadiq Khan's Stark Staring Mad Tfl ads + Is The West Right to Lionize Zelensky?

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

161.24

Word count

4,823

Sentence count

157


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. This week we've been in
00:00:25 Hungary during obviously pretty historic momentous events. I'm very pleased today that we have
00:00:35 a great guest on the programme, that's Dr Attila Demko, who is an academic, he is a security expert
00:00:45 and also an author. He's author of what will be a trilogy actually, The Fury of the Tsar,
00:00:54 Vicious Circle, which is his new book, is coming out very soon on Amazon, so you can get it there.
00:01:02 I'm delighted he's joining us now. Thank you very much. Thank you for having me. I should actually
00:01:08 add that your name on the book, if you're looking it up, is actually David Auteur, right? That is
00:01:16 actually the name that he has on his writing name. Can I start by asking you
00:01:23 a little, let's go straight into the nitty-gritty. In the West anyway, in
00:01:30 Britain at the moment, everyone is talking about Putin and basically they
00:01:35 are, one has one view, one has another view, and I told you so, and this, that,
00:01:41 What kind of a man are we dealing with?
00:01:45 He's a man of history, so he wants to make history.
00:01:48 He wants to rebuild Russia as a strong power.
00:01:52 That's what I'm writing in my books.
00:01:55 Actually, these books are about how he could divide NATO.
00:02:00 There is Ukraine in it, quite a lot of Ukraine,
00:02:03 but it's about how he could defeat NATO,
00:02:05 because that's his ultimate goal,
00:02:07 to be the basically the sole strong power on the continent he knew he knows very well that the
00:02:14 the Germans and the French they are much weaker than than than Russia he already told it to
00:02:20 Monsieur Macron just a week ago that your nuclear forces are nothing compared to ours
00:02:27 so he sees that if the NATO is not here if NATO is in chaos EU is in chaos then he's he's basically
00:02:34 the strongest power on the continent so that's uh that's i think ultimately what he wants to push
00:02:39 back nato and ukraine is one step in it and then enormously big step but but most probably not the
00:02:48 final step uh what he wants to make so my books actually book one was written before the crisis
00:02:55 and this one is also written before the ukraine crisis but book three which uh which i don't know
00:03:01 how will right would be would have been about how ukraine is being totally dismantled and nato is
00:03:06 being dismantled the first part actually he did that so i will focus on nato on on book street
00:03:11 all all of it is based on on basically what i have read as a former defense official and as a nato
00:03:17 official um he's uh he's he's a man of history he wants really to rebuild russia as as one of the
00:03:25 big powers of the world right and he needs first step belarus and ukraine for that he already took
00:03:31 belarus and now he's taking ukraine but the whole story i it's this story is not written from west
00:03:38 western perspective so i really tell why the russians are angry and why he's furious so
00:03:43 not all what he's doing is without reason so he has his reasons why he is furious because russia
00:03:49 was pushed back after the 1991 fall of the Soviet Union. So the Americans were picking country by
00:03:55 country from his orbit and he was also I think in a way humiliated by the Americans mainly calling
00:04:05 him and his country calling him a dictator very early on and his country as a big fuel station
00:04:11 and he's proving to the world that Russia is not just a big fuel station it's a military power
00:04:17 it's an economic power not a very big one but still it's an important economic power because of
00:04:22 oil gas and some technologies they have military technology especially so all this comes together
00:04:29 and of course he's a man closing the age of 70. so he wants to show the world what he's made of
00:04:37 and of course his time he feels that his time is now limited so he's doing it now it's interesting
00:04:43 actually because at the very end of this book as you pointed out to me you sort of mentioned about
00:04:49 the book coming that it will actually sort of be about the invasion so in other words you
00:04:54 sort of saw this coming yes whereas in state britain for example there's been well basically
00:05:02 i think response has been one of surprise amongst many people they didn't think he would go this far
00:05:08 So actually this time in the last few weeks I thought the same that he's not
00:05:14 going to do it this time right and he can achieve his objectives peacefully
00:05:20 that's what I believe that all of this power projection is to is to make Ukraine
00:05:25 and the rest to give up so Ukraine especially to give up and be it become
00:05:30 neutral and he would continue so I thought that it's attrition because
00:05:35 Ukraine is a poor country, Ukraine is a country of many problems and Ukraine is a country
00:05:41 with a lot of ethnic Russians or pro-Russian people, at least on the eastern and southern
00:05:47 part of Ukraine.
00:05:48 So I thought that he's doing this attrition work just to make Ukraine to crack.
00:05:55 But you know, he didn't do that.
00:05:57 So it was a surprise to me.
00:05:59 It's not a surprise that he's doing everything to undermine Ukraine and to undermine NATO.
00:06:05 that's that that was his goal since 2008 actually he started this process in 2008 with the attack
00:06:11 on georgia but but you know again i'm i'm not the typical uh analyst in this typical western
00:06:17 analyst because i show the russian russian side so actually uh the main player in his book is
00:06:22 vladimir putin himself so i'm i'm showing his mind i'm showing his uh his surroundings i'm
00:06:28 showing his inner circle i'm showing how they interact with each other that he is the tsar
00:06:33 and he's really humiliating his people, but sometimes he listens. So he's a good girl.
00:06:38 He has a great mind on geopolitics. He has, of course, his vision of Russia is not something
00:06:47 we would like to see in our countries, but he has a vision for his country. So that's what I try to
00:06:53 describe in a non usual way, because the usual is that he's just evil. No, he's not evil. He's not
00:07:00 like Darth Vader. He's a he's a person of his of his of his culture. He's a person of his of his time.
00:07:08 What is his culture particularly in Putin? I mean sort of socially when you say he's a man of
00:07:15 cheat himself as a man of history how how does that manifest itself apart from invading?
00:07:22 Well you know invading is part if you look at the list of Russian invasions anywhere on the net you
00:07:27 you will find a lot of invasions,
00:07:29 including invading Hungary several times.
00:07:31 So they invaded us in the last 200 years,
00:07:33 at least four or five times.
00:07:35 So actually they invaded everyone around.
00:07:38 What is he made of?
00:07:39 First of all, he's a man of KGB.
00:07:42 In the West, we always say that he's a KGB man.
00:07:44 Actually he was quite a low level officer
00:07:47 in Eastern Germany.
00:07:48 I have a scene in the book, in book one,
00:07:50 in the first book, which I wrote two years ago,
00:07:52 when he's in Dresden and destroying the KGB
00:07:57 fights because there is a crowd outside and he goes out and threatens the crowd that he
00:08:04 will shoot at them to destroy the remaining fights before they come in.
00:08:09 Because he's paranoid, because he thinks that the crowd is organized by CIA and CIA wants
00:08:13 to take his fights.
00:08:15 It's an actual event, it happened.
00:08:18 It happened in Dresden and he did actually, he did what I described in the book, but I
00:08:23 also describe his interesting relationship to his wife, because that was also a big thing
00:08:30 at the time. And now that he divorced, we can see that he has a taste of ladies. So
00:08:37 I tried to put a personal part of his life into the book, but he's a KGB man, he's very
00:08:44 paranoid of the West. He learned not to trust anyone. And he's also a wounded man, because
00:08:52 saw the great Soviet Union to collapse in just two years. To collapse, to see your country.
00:08:59 The British Empire was the greatest empire in the world. And of course, today there is no British
00:09:05 Empire. Britain is everywhere, of course. It's a global power, but still not the empire it used to.
00:09:12 But the British Empire, you know, was 50 or 60 or 70 years to transform itself to what
00:09:22 is today.
00:09:23 The Commonwealth.
00:09:24 So it was not just like a moment.
00:09:26 But can you imagine a shock if your empire is being destroyed in just two years?
00:09:32 So it's a shock in him.
00:09:33 It's a deep hurt in him.
00:09:35 And it's a deep hurt to see that Ukrainians are resisting.
00:09:38 I'm pretty sure that now he's in his Novo Ogarevo dacha and thinks and outraged why the Ukrainians
00:09:48 are resisting him so much.
00:09:50 Because he sees Ukrainians and Belarusians as part of his wonderful Eastern Slavic great
00:09:57 country.
00:09:58 So that's who he is, he's actually in a way he's an idealist in a terrible way.
00:10:06 he has this ideal of these three nations together in a great country and talk down to everyone
00:10:15 in Europe. He sees himself like basically the ruler of this part of the world. Yes,
00:10:25 do you think, here we are on, what is it, day four? I mean, events move quickly, obviously,
00:10:33 but we're on day four after of the invasion and the narrative at least is being said in the west
00:10:41 and the western press is that basically it's going slower than he would like and that the ukrainians
00:10:50 are putting up an extraordinary fight um do you think that's true well i think there is a the
00:10:56 western narrative there is the russian narrative and there is maybe reality somewhere in the middle
00:11:03 so i think the western narrative is exaggerating uh in in that that it's it's it's slow actually
00:11:10 the southern advance is actually fast so the the breakout from crimea i traveled all these regions
00:11:16 i traveled across ukraine i i worked for the ministry of defense so we knew where he will
00:11:21 attack so we went went with a mission to to uh to see these regions so we have been to perakop
00:11:27 which is at uh at the at crimea where crimea meets ukraine proper crimea is a peninsula so
00:11:34 it has only three ways out so it was extraordinary that russians could break out from crimea like
00:11:39 this because we saw the ukrainian troops there and they were waiting for the russians to attack
00:11:45 And it's also extraordinary how they could bypass Herson and then took two bridges on
00:11:53 the Dnieper River.
00:11:54 So, I see some of the Russian moves in the south as great successes and very, very fast
00:12:01 successes.
00:12:02 So, I don't agree that it's slow.
00:12:05 And actually when you say the fuel is out and you say that it's slow, then you are
00:12:09 I saw it just before I came to give this interview on BBC.
00:12:14 On a BBC article that first part of the sentence, oh, it's slower than expected.
00:12:19 Well, the fuel of the Russian tanks are out.
00:12:21 So which one?
00:12:23 Because if they go slow, then the fuel is not out.
00:12:28 The fuel is usually out when you go faster than your logistics.
00:12:31 So actually they go faster than their logistics.
00:12:34 So I don't see that in the south.
00:12:36 They are already at Nikolaev, which is a large shipmaking, shipbuilding city.
00:12:41 We have been there too.
00:12:42 It's a strategic city for Russia, actually, because their shipmaking suffered a lot.
00:12:48 Because Ukraine was responsible for some parts of their ships.
00:12:52 So that's why Ukraine is so important for him.
00:12:55 Because part of the Soviet defense industry, a large part of it is in Ukraine, including
00:13:00 Helicopter motors, helicopter engines, ship turbines, a lot of stuff is in Ukraine.
00:13:06 So he wants maybe to get back this part of his defense in the system.
00:13:10 Mikulayev is an important time and Odessa is an important time.
00:13:14 And then Transnistria.
00:13:15 So I think this attack vector is going well and the other attack vector to Mariupol is going well, too.
00:13:21 They are already at Berdyansk, which is not that far from Mariupol.
00:13:25 And I think that now they see that there is stronger than expected resistance.
00:13:31 So they see it in Kharkiv, they saw it in Kiev.
00:13:33 But now I think he switched gears and he wants to take over the eastern
00:13:39 part of the Ukrainian army, which is near the Donbass.
00:13:42 That's the strongest army formation of the Ukrainian army.
00:13:46 So if he surrounds it, then Ukraine's military capabilities are halved.
00:13:54 so i think that he is focusing now or he will focus in the next few days if there are if there
00:13:59 is a no big breakthrough in the negotiations because he's also you know pushing the ukrainians
00:14:04 with the negotiation that if if you don't do this we will do this so maybe the ukrainians
00:14:09 budge or break i don't think so now we're looking at president zelensky but it can happen
00:14:15 so they are negotiating today in gomel in in belarus so what i see in the south it's going well
00:14:21 Harkiv, you know, they say that there was a victory. Again, Western Press, it's a victory in Harkiv.
00:14:28 I think the Russians had a recommission to Harkiv. A recommission doesn't mean that you don't want to
00:14:34 conquer the time. You just see how strong defenses are. So this recommission maybe went badly. I don't
00:14:40 know about that, but that is shown. I saw two vehicles burning on TV on, I think, Al Jazeera.
00:14:46 that's not a not a big victory but it's portrayed as a big victory investing press
00:14:51 and the third main vector is kiev actually i'm surprised that they they reached kiev so fast
00:15:00 because the ukrainians the americans were warning the ukrainians for for weeks that
00:15:05 kiev is the target is a target or the main target so either they didn't build up defenses
00:15:11 at the north at chernobyl and at other points at the border of with belarus or or the russians
00:15:18 somehow maneuver them for example it's not reported in the western press but i know from my ukrainian
00:15:24 sources that the air at the airport at hostomel there was a big battle and the the western sources
00:15:30 say that they killed the chechen commander so it's a big victory i'm sure they killed that chechen
00:15:36 general because the chechen volunteers are some of the cruelest and toughest fighters of russia
00:15:43 mr kadirov is his private uh private army it's putin's chief of mr putin's private army so what
00:15:50 i want to say that at that airport a lot of helicopters and a lot of equipment of the
00:15:55 ukrainian air force was destroyed so it's it's it's maybe very hard for the russians to keep
00:16:00 that airport but they already reached one big objective much of the ukrainian air force is out
00:16:05 it's destroyed and part of it was destroyed in a dawn raid in a dawn helicopter raid
00:16:11 by on the first day by the russian so the real picture just like as i write in my books
00:16:18 much of the russian propaganda is just like that propaganda but some of it is true
00:16:23 and you know you know we have to face it that bbc or cnn or the major news portals they are
00:16:31 influenced by what the the local what the defense ministry say it says in in in britain what uh
00:16:37 what the pentagon says in in the us so they write down many times what the pentagon or the ministry
00:16:44 of defense uh want to wants to wants them to write down so generally i feel that it's not going as
00:16:52 well for the russians as they hoped for especially the resistance of the people so maybe there is
00:16:57 less support for russia in the population even on the east than they thought and what putin hoped
00:17:04 um but it's not going terribly badly as it's shown today uh by by some of the major major
00:17:11 new sources in the west but it can go badly uh for several reasons we don't know what is going
00:17:16 inside in russia for example how big is the support for for this war because we see signs
00:17:21 that the support is not that that's wrong for the war yes i understood actually that in fact
00:17:26 it was no by no means unanimous support before they didn't prepare the russian public so when
00:17:34 i looked at uh at the reports coming out from the us and they they were right so the reports of the
00:17:40 ci and the pentagon the warnings were close to close to close to 100 right not the dates that
00:17:47 was silly to give dates that they are attacking on the 16th or whatever but the reports reports
00:17:53 were right but one thing two things were missing for me very very interestingly from the picture
00:17:59 one they didn't prepare the russian public there was no big propaganda campaign that the evil
00:18:04 ukrainians just want to destroy the separatist republic it started now but they didn't work on
00:18:12 the public for months and months and months you know if you repeat those things enough times
00:18:18 people start to believe it anyway and especially in a country like russia where tv is still a very
00:18:22 important factor and for russians they still watch tv um so that's that's that's one thing
00:18:30 the other thing there was there was not enough occupying troops so for for attacking you need
00:18:35 high level troops um elite forces and they do have elite forces but where are the occupying
00:18:41 troops to to keep a town you don't need any forces actually even civilians can can break havoc
00:18:47 somebody attacking an attacker force in a town you know because it's you know just you shoot out
00:18:52 from the window you if you kill two soldiers before you you get killed it's already something
00:18:57 big for for somebody who is a civilian but the russians have uh occupying forces the national
00:19:04 guard um they could have and it's nowhere to be seen yet or we didn't see it yet so it's the
00:19:10 Russian army which is going in. So these are the factors, you know, I would say that were unseen
00:19:18 before, but now it's very clear. Do you think as well that one of the influences on Putin
00:19:29 at the moment would be what appears to be the absolute weakness of the West? And, you know,
00:19:35 in terms just even on a cultural level you know this point is made and and every day we sort of
00:19:42 see instances of this most recently with our own head of mi6 tweeting about lgbt rights right at
00:19:49 the heart of this um how how big a part with that plane he's thinking yeah so it's it's an excellent
00:19:57 question truly because that's what i'm thinking since the beginning of this crisis i really think
00:20:04 that uh that putin thought that we are weaker than we are and much of this is because of this
00:20:10 woke craze which is in it's in the us as you say in britain in germany i mean when we debate if if
00:20:20 if a transgender man or whatever a woman can compete with a with females and that's the main
00:20:29 debate in our countries why china and russia is rising then we are in trouble it's actually we
00:20:35 have the culture war within our countries it's eating up our energies and we are not looking
00:20:41 to the world what's happening it's not only russia it's not only china africa is collapsing the sahar
00:20:46 region is collapsing and we don't talk about this because we are engaging in silly debates
00:20:52 we are engaging in almost religious debates about these questions when i see adele attack because
00:20:58 she says that she's happy to be a woman or when gk rowling is attacked for being anti-trans for me
00:21:05 it's like uh guys the word is collapsing around us is this the most important question of of a large
00:21:12 part of the british press sometimes i torture myself and i read guardian and you know half of
00:21:18 it is like this what do i feel about myself yes what is this what do you feel about yourself and
00:21:25 stuff like that the world is collapsing around us and we are blind to it and now it's a big wake-up
00:21:30 call and it and i'm happy to see the germans at least the germans woke up you know they just said
00:21:37 today that gonna spend 100 billion euros more on on military this year which means if i read it well
00:21:45 that they will more than double their military budget and it's a green left green coalition
00:21:51 who said that so maybe maybe the rest of the week but we weakened ourselves and we made ourselves
00:21:56 looking foolish in the eyes of Putin or Xi Jinping that's for sure. Do you think it really is a wake
00:22:04 up call for the West? How can one tell I mean I'm just I don't mean to be an invidious comparison
00:22:11 but I remember with the woke ideology everyone said at the beginning of Covid and the pandemic
00:22:17 this will change everything you know and you just wonder you know it didn't basically it
00:22:22 became more intense and i'm just wondering that because this is such a you know blatant and such
00:22:31 a a understandable threat that it actually might make a difference to the west well you know maybe
00:22:37 uh maybe at least i'm hoping because we need to we need to focus ourselves on the external threats
00:22:45 and we are making internal threats and divisions out of issues which it should be not the most
00:22:52 important issues in our lives. I mean can I sort of ask you as somebody who advise the government
00:22:58 and is a security expert yeah you know what is your view when you see something from like the
00:23:05 ahead of our MI6, saying that LGBTQ rights are, in fact, probably one of the most important
00:23:15 things that separate us from Putin and Russia. We should keep tweeting about this. I mean,
00:23:23 to me, it's astounding, and I am embarrassed when I read that. What's your think?
00:23:29 You know, I mean, it's a complete misreading of the situation.
00:23:33 It's not ideology, really, which separates us from Putin.
00:23:38 It's not authoritarian against democratic or anti-LGBT against LGBT.
00:23:44 No, Russia wants to be the strongest power on the European continent.
00:23:50 That's it. It's a fact.
00:23:52 And if Russia would be more democratic and pro-LGBT,
00:23:57 That wouldn't change the fact if a person like Putin is in the chair or who is making this decision, that they are a threat to us.
00:24:08 You know, they are not a threat because they are anti-LGBT, they are a threat because they are aggressive.
00:24:14 And even a democracy can be aggressive.
00:24:16 You know, if you look back what the US did in 2003 in Iraq, I mean it was an aggressive act.
00:24:23 russians always say that anyway that oh what did you do in iraq that's that's what that's what they
00:24:30 uh say so what i want to say that uh that uh uh russia for for putin of course he has this macho
00:24:38 ego and he talks about lgbt people sometimes you know not very high manner but for him this is
00:24:47 question number 1200 number one is russian power number two is russian power number three is russian
00:24:56 power and when somebody in mi6 or i think i think i think he was he knew what he's saying is untrue
00:25:03 but he needed to say that i'm pretty sure that that that these politicians many of them don't
00:25:10 believe what they say about this but they might as well because the effect is the same yeah well
00:25:15 you know, if they think this is the important question in the world, I tell you one thing.
00:25:21 My friend served at the European External Affairs Service, which is the European Corp Diplomatique,
00:25:28 as a diplomat in Africa. And you know, in that African country, they are not really LGBTQ free.
00:25:34 So the European embassy, based on the instructions from Brussels, started to push this agenda.
00:25:41 First of all, European relations nose-dived with that African country.
00:25:47 I'm not going to name it.
00:25:48 The Chinese came in, the Russians came in, they didn't ask questions about LGBTQ.
00:25:54 So is it good for us that we are pushing ourselves out from several African countries and China
00:26:00 comes in and Russia comes in?
00:26:02 Is it?
00:26:03 No, it's a question.
00:26:04 Is it clever?
00:26:05 Maybe the MI6 director can answer this.
00:26:07 But the main thing was that they didn't even help the LGBTQ community, because they started
00:26:11 to beat up LGBTQ people after these pushes, that, you know, it's self-defeating, it's
00:26:19 self-defeating.
00:26:20 Oh, absolutely.
00:26:22 Coming back to the current situation, a lot of people's fears about it obviously do relate
00:26:28 to the sheer surprise element of what could actually happen, what could be triggered elsewhere.
00:26:37 know what conflagration could come next what do you think of the I mean this is
00:26:42 speculation I do know but I mean you know where would you see the rural
00:26:47 dangers coming from from this particular act that we're talking about from the
00:26:53 war in Ukraine yeah well you know I think the main danger for us at least in
00:26:59 in the eastern and central and Eastern Europe that there is a huge refugee
00:27:03 wave. It's amazingly big already. We took in 62,000 people in four days. So for Britain,
00:27:10 you have like seven times the population. It would be hundreds of thousands. And Poland
00:27:15 is also taking a lot of people. So that's the refugee. But we don't know where it will
00:27:20 end, what it will transform into. Just now Russia announced that they are raising the
00:27:27 nuclear forces threat level to the highest so they are basically that's that's that sounds very
00:27:33 ominous that the russian nuclear force is now on standby to strike this is not a good news so
00:27:42 if the ukraine operation is not doesn't go well and russia is bogged down and because euphrine is
00:27:48 getting more and more weapons from the west they can react irrationally i still don't see that
00:27:55 Putin is a suicidal person. He is not. But you never know. The worst it is for him and
00:28:02 for his entourage, actually, the more dangerous it is. Because if he is cornered, he will
00:28:08 attack. And if he is more cornered, he will attack twice the strength and twice the aggressiveness.
00:28:16 So to play with Putin, he's the all-in type of guy. It's dangerous. So for me, that's
00:28:24 That's the biggest danger.
00:28:26 Of course, I would like to see the Russians lose, but not in a very humiliating and spectacular
00:28:32 way.
00:28:33 Because if that happens, then we are in real trouble.
00:28:37 Because then we have an extremely angry Russia facing at us.
00:28:42 And as I said, as I described in my books, they have a lot of tools to divide us, especially
00:28:49 this region because this region is full of history and change borders yes and ethnic animosities if
00:28:55 i think from britain people look at the center and eastern europeans as one block but actually
00:29:00 we have more than a thousand years of history fighting each other so imagine that hungarians
00:29:06 and romanians look at each other like the irish and the brits so we had a lot of blood bad blood
00:29:13 between each other we are still in nato but next to each other the same is true with the with the
00:29:19 with hungary and slovakia not to that extent or actually there are there is trouble between
00:29:24 poland and lithuania it's not very obvious but part of the lithuanian capital will news
00:29:30 was was a city called villano in poland before it was a polish city ethnically polish city before
00:29:34 stalin took it away it's not a big issue now between poland and lithuania but the russians
00:29:39 are working to exploit all of these fault lines in our region so um i would be afraid if if if
00:29:45 for a Russian humiliating defeat in Ukraine, because that could further
00:29:51 the Russian feeling of humiliation and revenge.