New Culture Forum - March 15, 2022


Sadiq Khan's Stark Staring Mad Tfl ads + Is The West Right to Lionize Zelensky?

Inside Putin's Mind: His Goals, Motivation & World View - What The West Needs to Understand Konstantin Kisin on Russia, Ukraine + Western Response

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

163.93

Word count

8,316

Sentence count

190


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to the New Culture Forums weekly discussion show NewsSpeak. I'm joined
00:00:10 this week by Mark Glendening, the head of the Cultural Affairs Unit at the Institute for
00:00:15 Economic Affairs, by Gawain Towler, the political consultant, former head of media for the Brexit
00:00:20 Party, and now involved in the referendum campaign on Net Zero, and finally by NCF's
00:00:27 director Peter Whittle. And if you haven't considered it already, we put out this content
00:00:32 every week, so you may want to consider subscribing with the button below. So let's kick off on
00:00:38 this week's news by discussing Zelensky's speech in Parliament. One thing that became
00:00:45 quite apparent soon after that speech is that people were quite divided on it. Many people
00:00:49 felt that they were, you know, it was a very inspiring speech and other people thought
00:00:52 that it was a bit strange
00:00:54 that he was being sort of idolized in this way.
00:00:57 So what are your thoughts on that?
00:00:59 Well, I mean, I thought it was quite,
00:01:00 I think it was quite moving.
00:01:03 I think the problem is,
00:01:05 I'd say Emma, I don't know what you guys think.
00:01:07 I think the problem is that when you say people
00:01:09 are worried about idolizing,
00:01:10 we've got to the stage now where,
00:01:12 and I sort of understand it,
00:01:13 where people over Brexit or indeed over the pandemic,
00:01:18 they felt that anything that the establishment
00:01:21 was at one about they should be very very suspicious of so it's made people kind of untrustworthy on
00:01:27 this subject i don't agree on that i think some things are cut and died something some things you
00:01:33 can take at face value um i didn't know very much about the ukraine before all of this uh i do think
00:01:38 he's an impressive leader i thought it was lovely the way he quoted shakespeare and churchill um and
00:01:46 And as for this sort of idealisation, I mean, well, who is sort of idealising him?
00:01:53 You know, why are people getting so uptight about this?
00:01:56 I mean, who's who on Twitter maybe or, but, you know, in the ordinary world,
00:02:01 I think most people look at him and think, well, that guy seems to be doing quite well.
00:02:05 I don't think that they are idealising.
00:02:07 I think that, again, you have this situation.
00:02:10 And I made some commentary about this right thing.
00:02:13 and it's the he's impressive come the time come the man sort of thing one doesn't know because
00:02:20 thank goodness we're not in a similar situation but one doesn't know how our own politicians
00:02:24 would react in that sort of appalling situation uh maybe they would step up maybe they would
00:02:30 um however he has been in that situation he has transparently stepped up but i think what you're
00:02:37 but it's a bit early to go into the hagiographical approach which it's not just on twitter it's in
00:02:44 the broadcast media it's in the print media it's across the board and anybody who just queries
00:02:49 just slow down a bit i mean not that long ago paul kagame was the the hero the absolute hero
00:02:57 the tory party sent plane loads of activists down to rwanda to do stuff for him he's been
00:03:03 turning out into quite a pretty grim dictator himself, Aung San Suu Kyi from Burma. Everybody's
00:03:11 favorite Nobel Prize winning peace activist. When she was in power, she cracked down on the Rohingya
00:03:16 Muslims. And there was some pretty nasty human rights abuses. The heroes we have today become
00:03:23 often problematic in the future. One of the reasons why the MOD doesn't like giving VCs in
00:03:31 combat these days is because they're terrified that the winner of that vc in 30 years time will
00:03:36 get pissed and hit a policeman so tweet something or tweet something so let's congratulate the man
00:03:42 for how he has behaved and how he is performing right now and support him and provide the military
00:03:48 and other support that he needs but stop turning him to a saint i know it's the orthodox thing that
00:03:55 soon as you become a hero you have paintings and icons with with with with uh with with shiny shiny
00:04:01 globes around your head but we we must retain a little distance and this excitement finally a
00:04:10 politician that we can all agree with has has has addled some people's brains well yeah but not just
00:04:16 that we can agree with but he's obviously not a coward i mean we're used to ours being utter
00:04:22 cowards and, you know, dissemblers, aren't we? That's exactly why I think it's not that odd
00:04:28 that people have responded in this way, because we're not used to seeing people who are, I mean,
00:04:33 even quoting Churchill and making allusions to Shakespeare, it was clever statementship,
00:04:39 you know, he's trying to do the best for his country, he's got strategic objectives in trying
00:04:44 to rally people to the Ukrainian cause. And I think people are not used to hearing that kind of
00:04:48 of um oratory from world leaders and so i don't find it particularly surprising that people are
00:04:54 you know all over yeah but i think i think there is a following on from what you were saying i think
00:04:59 there is a healthy british uh skepticism towards leadership in general which can sometimes spill
00:05:07 over into cynicism but i think overall it's been a very beneficial thing for the politics of this
00:05:14 country and you know going back to george orwell and he was writing about why the british could
00:05:18 never go down the road of following Oswald Moseley and sort of fascistic totalitarian movements.
00:05:25 It's partly because we don't eulogize leaders in the same way that other cultures and societies
00:05:33 have more of an inclination towards charisma and falling for charisma. As he said, the British
00:05:41 people are more interested in their gardens than they were in ideology. And I think there
00:05:48 has been a change in british culture and i think the whole dianarization phenomenon was a profoundly
00:05:54 unsettling for many people of my sort of generation because i saw something unhealthy in that do you
00:06:00 think that's something that has changed now as we've seen you know post-covered there's always
00:06:05 this sort of drive towards consensus politics with the house always agreeing with itself on
00:06:12 either side not having a real sort of robust debate about these sorts of things there was a
00:06:17 sort of sense when we I mean I thought that the Zelensky speech was very moving and I thought that
00:06:24 the responses in the chamber to the speech were very moving but there did definitely feel like
00:06:30 there was a kind of homogeneity to the response I don't know whether you know that that's mistaken
00:06:38 in or not i've got two thoughts on that the first is agreed it was a moving speech in a situation of
00:06:46 of pure horror that he is in um and you're right from his strategic objectives well met i mean he's
00:06:53 done a damn good job uh for his strategic objectives but those people who have just gone
00:07:01 just hold up they've had pylons for daring to question the sanctity of this man that i think
00:07:10 is concerning and that ties into what you're saying about the dynification how dare you say
00:07:14 that about our new hero and i'm not saying he's not a hero but he like every man and woman has
00:07:22 feet of clay we are all human and in that sense it is he is he's been presented to the public
00:07:30 as almost a perfect ideal of a politician.
00:07:33 And we know that's not true.
00:07:36 That doesn't take a thing away from how he's leading his country
00:07:39 in an appalling situation.
00:07:41 I think that is important to note.
00:07:43 I think this healthy scepticism is something that we should encourage
00:07:48 rather than shout down.
00:07:50 And I have seen people being shouted down for daring to question this consensus.
00:07:55 Well, where was the healthy scepticism during the pandemic then?
00:07:58 from people like you, sir.
00:08:00 Well, yeah, but I mean,
00:08:01 it was always quite a sort of minority.
00:08:04 I was never in any town.
00:08:05 But again, they were shouting down,
00:08:06 you're a denier, you're a denier.
00:08:08 I mean, yes, if you're banging your pots and pans
00:08:12 for the NHS on a Thursday night,
00:08:13 I gather in some places,
00:08:14 it was a bit like the 19th century
00:08:16 when people would be accosted in small towns
00:08:18 if people were aware
00:08:20 you weren't going to church regularly.
00:08:22 But that's, it did surprise me.
00:08:24 I mean, it did surprise me,
00:08:26 the British reaction to that.
00:08:27 I thought, I remember talking to Rod Little about it and he basically took the mick out of me.
00:08:32 I said, I thought the English were a bit more truculent about their rights and all this.
00:08:37 And he said, oh, yeah, I think late summer 1953 was about the last time.
00:08:42 So, you know, he was very, very, very specific.
00:08:45 I don't really agree with, I mean, it might not be happening with the idealisation, people like it.
00:08:50 I just think it's not really that important.
00:08:54 I think that when you're talking about the issues involved, it's a lesser one.
00:08:57 You know, I mean, I really do when you look at what's happening I for me
00:09:05 It's actually made my mood
00:09:07 Right, it's this way off and frankly, there's been a long time since that's happened
00:09:12 I mean, I sort of look at it and I think well first of all, everyone said that
00:09:18 Britain was going to have a diminished role, you know, after you absolutely not happened, right and really have helped
00:09:26 um and i just thought actually that's entirely proved you wrong that's made me feel good um but
00:09:32 also just that sort of stepping up for something which i hope has a knock-on effect with us
00:09:39 actually i i hope people look at that i'm not saying i don't know even very much about this
00:09:43 man i don't feel i need to really you know i mean you know real politic throughout the years and
00:09:49 diplomacy has meant that we've been friends with people who've been well suspicious and it's always
00:09:56 been away with humanity you know and the other side too so i'm not so worried about that i do
00:10:01 hope that that kind of absolute you know uh red-blooded standing up your country not going
00:10:08 to let it go and everything we could learn something i hope we learn it is rare to hear
00:10:13 the words glory to great britain yeah do you think it will rub off i mean that was that was something
00:10:18 wasn't it? When was the last time you heard anybody speak like that about our country in our
00:10:22 parliament and it takes a foreigner to do it? And also yes saying to be or not be okay uh you might
00:10:28 say a bit of a cliche and all the rest but I mean I thought you're looking and thinking why can't our
00:10:32 politicians actually use these kind of references you know why can't they what why are they what
00:10:38 are they so frightened? It's also interesting to see isn't it that a lot of people on the sort of
00:10:41 centre-left, who would, you know, if any kind of British politician were to talk about Britain
00:10:48 in that kind of a way, they'd be castigated as xenophobes and little Englanders. But if a
00:10:55 foreign politician talks about their own country in such a way, obviously in a time of crisis in
00:11:03 this particular instance, I know it's a sort of heightened situation, but nevertheless,
00:11:07 there would be, you know, a very negative reaction to a British politician.
00:11:14 Flag shagging is now.
00:11:17 Only six months ago, flag shagging was awful.
00:11:20 So long as it's not a British flag, you can shag a foreign flag or any other country virtually,
00:11:26 but not a British flag or probably the American flag.
00:11:30 So moving on slightly to the...
00:11:32 You could shag that, yeah.
00:11:34 So moving on from the little sort of piddly issues on to one of the bigger issues.
00:11:49 This week we saw increasing sanctions on Russia, particularly Visa and MasterCard.
00:11:56 And what is to be expected, Russia moving into the arms, the cosy, cuddly arms of the Chinese.
00:12:04 um how big of a problem do you think that is and i know you've got going you've got your own
00:12:11 sort of uh angle on that your own story about uh chinese uh chinese flirting with the west
00:12:18 it's about this way um is there something you want to share
00:12:22 only the recipe for um baby oyster porridge which i'd love to be magnificent
00:12:28 but um but now we have known for a long time have we not that uh russians and their bot farms the
00:12:37 chinese and their influence and buying schools and buying university departments and so with
00:12:41 russians and so on and so forth um if you go into any science department of any british university
00:12:47 half the phd students are not from these aisles and what's more are not from countries that are
00:12:52 friendly to these isles suddenly in the last year or so oh how can this be they're stealing our int
00:13:01 well yeah um and this this is this is not news um in many ways the i mean russia has since the
00:13:10 the sanctions were a while back um its economy unlike most western economies without if you
00:13:19 take away the money they get in through natural resources the gas and the oil is significantly
00:13:25 self-sufficient um ukraine of course is a bread basket and supplies not just egypt where we've
00:13:32 seen the prices go up through the roof but also supplies a lot of brushes and and our own uh corn
00:13:38 so it's not just oil and gas that's going through the roof it's also corn prices um because ukraine
00:13:44 is the bread basket and so the the Chinese are now just signing whatever contracts they need
00:13:53 with the Russians they get the oil what I find and this this leads on this the thing it leads
00:13:59 on to what we're discussing next but the the the drive to the net zero drive in the light of prices
00:14:11 going up seems to me to be absolutely nuts if we are looking at if we are serious and looking at
00:14:22 making everybody drive your electric cars and this that and the other is the future one where's the
00:14:26 power come from it's all very well to drive people driving electric cars but you've got to make
00:14:29 electricity from something in the first place and it's not going to be windmills but also the raw
00:14:33 materials required for those a vast proportion of those raw materials come from china russia and oh
00:14:40 Well, they used to come from Afghanistan. Who's got that now? Well, the Chinese have.
00:14:46 And so we are jumping from the fire or the frying pan of our European reliance on Russian natural resources, natural gas, to an even greater reliance on other materials that we don't possess ourselves.
00:15:03 whereas we do have under our own feet resources that will keep us ticking over
00:15:10 whilst we come up with better technologies and we need to come up with
00:15:13 better technologies let's be honest but we can do we we do have a stopgap here
00:15:18 you're talking about fracking not just fracking there are other ways to get
00:15:22 shale gas out you don't have it's not just fracking we can do better than that
00:15:25 fracking has been going on she goes the Dorset coast there's a in Kimmeridge
00:15:30 bay there's a nodding donkey that is taking oil out of shale and has been for something like 45 50
00:15:38 years nod nod nod it goes and every year it produces some and it's one of the most beautiful
00:15:44 bays you're likely to find in the south coast of england and there's an oil well in it
00:15:50 the the size of the space used for this well is less than this studio that's how big about
00:15:56 about the same size of this studio.
00:15:58 That's how large this way is.
00:15:59 And it produces and has done for decades.
00:16:02 So the idea that it's all disaster
00:16:04 if we were to tap our own resources in this way is wrong.
00:16:08 Yes, fracking has a bad name,
00:16:11 but every time the Americans particularly
00:16:13 have found a problem with fracking,
00:16:16 they've solved the problem.
00:16:17 We're not coming in at the beginning of technology.
00:16:20 We're coming in decade down the technology
00:16:22 where the ability to get at these resources
00:16:26 has far fewer dangers than even 10 years ago,
00:16:31 because at each time there's a problem, it's solved.
00:16:35 And we can become world leaders in both the technology for producing it,
00:16:38 but also in protecting ourselves and being able to sell to ourselves
00:16:44 and possibly on the open market a resource that doesn't require,
00:16:48 doesn't require us relying upon those people who are hostile to our broader intentions.
00:16:54 Do you think the reality of the situation is going to create more sort of popular momentum against this pursuit of net zero, that the reality of the situation and the rising costs is going to force people to have to reckon with the reality of this?
00:17:10 It is notable that within the last week, within the last week, we have gone from this week, we're going to put concrete tops on the tops of the wells to actually we're not.
00:17:21 Are they not going to do that?
00:17:22 nope nope they've decided yesterday they decided not to put the concrete tops on the tops of the
00:17:25 wells and let's do some more research so yes in answer to your question yes do you think that the
00:17:31 government will be likely to do away with their green levies in order to try and sadly not no i
00:17:35 don't know carrie's carrie wouldn't allow that she'd have some sort of terrible this this goes
00:17:40 is he fit in the flat above number 10 i think boris but this goes into the same problem if it's
00:17:47 problem that we mentioned with there's leslie everybody in the room says yes it doesn't matter
00:17:52 what the population think everybody in the room says yes and when it comes to the climate change
00:17:57 act i think there's one vote against it um everybody who wants to be seen to be nice and
00:18:02 cuddly and fluffy and lovely and and all the rest of it say yes and so for a movement to
00:18:10 change that and you're now starting to see there are backbenchers again a bunch of
00:18:14 Tory backbenchers proving the Tory party is a house against itself there are some who might
00:18:19 argue against this you wouldn't get a hundred percent of both houses now voting in one way
00:18:26 but I think that there is still a visceral fear of Greta amongst most people in both houses and
00:18:38 that sort of screaming how dare you from a 16 year old and in many cases their own 16 year old at
00:18:44 home at breakfast is causing them a great deal to be sensible is a very dangerous thing another
00:18:51 thing that has been sort of rattling about this week has been the sort of charge of russophobia
00:18:57 people going for things all things russian um aside from the political situation and we were
00:19:04 talking just before filming about um the card of philharmonic deciding to cancel their performances
00:19:09 of tchaikovsky what do you think about is this just pure philistinism or do you think you know
00:19:15 what is this i think there was also uh putting put in pictures of putin on urinals things like
00:19:21 that like what do you what do you think of that it's part i think it's partly actually you're
00:19:25 quite right to use the word philistinism it's partly that i remember a conversation i think
00:19:30 is just unbelievable ignorance uh and it's you know it's it's quite absurd i remember having a
00:19:37 conversation during the whole blm thing with some friends um and was a friend some yeah
00:19:44 just like acquaintances and uh they were sort of i i remember talking about people who should come
00:19:51 down and things like this and they i remember this they said i said well what would you do
00:19:55 about Wagner? I mean would you stop Wagner being played because he was a shocking anti-semite and
00:20:02 Hitler's favorite and they had never heard Wagner but they said immediately well of course he should
00:20:09 I said what you mean like off the radio and everything yeah absolutely clear about it and
00:20:14 you might say well but the thing is it they're entitled to their view and everything but to me
00:20:18 it just showed uh a kind of absurd lack of well nuance doesn't even begin to cover it i mean
00:20:25 you know what is the point of of uh you know of cancelling kakoski concerts or any of this
00:20:35 you shouldn't do it i mean it's it's not the same thing but we're living in sort of post-rational
00:20:41 times where this sort of madness which we've seen in a very domestic way with the whole you know
00:20:46 statues issue and and you know decolonizing the canon and all this kind of stuff um is is now
00:20:54 spreading uh to any political issue and so there's this tremendous desire to sort of personalize
00:21:04 everything because that's of course part of the anti-rational mindset that particularly the new
00:21:11 left are now embody and there's a frightening anti-intellectualism here which i think is
00:21:19 reminiscent of fascism i do believe that the new left is a proto-fascistic movement not only in
00:21:26 terms of its overt overt tendency towards authoritarianism but because of its complete
00:21:32 anti-intellectualism and and i think there's a danger here and i think we're seeing it with
00:21:37 this kind of madness which in another context if a conservative was to advocate something as stupid
00:21:43 as this as boneheaded as this would be castigated quite rightly as philistine idiocy but if a left
00:21:50 if again if it's the the cultural elite if it's the center left uh making these kind of mad
00:21:58 suggestions then that's sort of okay what's strange about sorry i'm a tory mps have done
00:22:03 this too haven't they they're just as bad then yeah that was that was the point that i was going
00:22:07 to make is that what's strange about this and you it is I think it's interesting that you know this
00:22:12 kind of leaking of a way of thinking into the mainstream that that this particular sort of
00:22:19 attempt to go after and like you know going after Dostoevsky and I think it was Saurabh Amari wrote
00:22:25 a piece that I think it was in the American Conservative make he made a really good point
00:22:30 I think it I think it was Saurabh Amari saying that it's almost as if they think that we've got
00:22:35 There's nothing that we could even learn about the situation by being knowledgeable about Russian culture and Russian history that actually it's in our interests to know these things that actually that leaking of that anti-intellectualism now isn't it's not left or right.
00:22:50 It's not that the normal divisions of left and right on all of these issues has become completely muddled up.
00:22:57 It's a debased culture. I mean, it's as simple as that. It's a culture that no longer knows.
00:23:01 It's lost its moorings. It no longer can see these things in perspective.
00:23:06 It doesn't understand anymore. I mean, you know, that may probably, in their view,
00:23:11 that would mark me out as some kind of elitist to say that.
00:23:14 But I mean, you know, the fact is...
00:23:16 Well, no, no. Well, the fact...
00:23:18 There's nothing wrong with that.
00:23:19 The fact of the matter is that these kind of judgments and these kind of things can only come, surely,
00:23:26 from people who have absolutely no sense whatsoever of kind of perspective or part.
00:23:32 But everything is instinctive, and that's why it's kind of animalistic.
00:23:34 I'd like to throw in, in 1940, during the Blitz, the great English-Jewish pianist Myra Hess
00:23:42 organized a concert every single day at the National Gallery.
00:23:48 even when the bombs were dropping she played she was most famous for her beethoven her schubert
00:23:54 her bronze she was english she was jewish she was a pianist in the national gallery as german
00:23:59 bombs were dropping in westminster she was playing beethoven and the king and queen went to see it
00:24:05 and the queen went to see it yeah so if if meanwhile we're not even at war and the cardiff
00:24:13 is banning tchaikovsky we've lost our collective minds on related to that um i thought that it
00:24:22 might be interesting to dip into the tfl stare anti-staring campaign um because this seems to be
00:24:29 and i'm go on the basis of um mark wrote a very interesting article on this could you not look at
00:24:34 me so directly. You're unsettling me. Can you explain for people who don't know what is the
00:24:43 anti-staring thing? I think Mark would be better to explain it. So late last year Sadiq Khan
00:24:50 launched a campaign against I don't know sexual abuse or something on the London Underground
00:24:56 and there was a whole list of things you weren't allowed to do most of which were already criminal
00:25:02 offenses, self-evidently, but it was launched a great fact we're going to be protecting the women
00:25:07 of London from, you know, people who do X, Y, and Z, some of which were quite legitimate things,
00:25:13 but they're already illegal. But one of the most hilarious aspects of it, I think there were seven
00:25:19 different aspects, dimensions to this campaign, was a campaign against staring, sexual staring,
00:25:26 undefined
00:25:28 as to what would actually constitute
00:25:31 sexual staring
00:25:33 sexually intrusive staring
00:25:35 now I don't know
00:25:37 if you would like to
00:25:38 give us an impersonation
00:25:41 as to what
00:25:43 you would consider to be sexually
00:25:45 intrusive staring where you're on
00:25:47 the London Underground and a person
00:25:49 where to be staring at you in this way
00:25:51 I'm not quite certain how you would even know
00:25:53 that there was sexual intent
00:25:55 So they have now sort of put this campaign, the staring aspect of it, into action.
00:26:08 A couple of weeks ago I was sent a photograph by a friend and she was amazed to see this incredible poster
00:26:14 which looked as if it was a bit like that Tory party poster, do you remember from the 1997 election
00:26:18 which everybody laughed about, demon eyes, with Tony Blair with mad eyes.
00:26:23 and so they have their own version with the word staring
00:26:26 and then two sort of manic eyeballs bearing into you
00:26:32 coming out of some of the letters.
00:26:35 It probably does.
00:26:36 And then it says, you know, sexually intrusive staring is an offence.
00:26:42 It's not quite clear, actually, legally.
00:26:44 What offence?
00:26:44 What, you know, this could be connected.
00:26:48 Would somebody who felt they were being stared at,
00:26:50 would they be entitled to pull the emergency cord
00:26:53 stop the train, the London Transport Police would come onto the train, take you off, were you to be sexually staring at something.
00:27:00 Presumably it would be on the basis of the person's perception.
00:27:05 Well quite, that's another sort of post-modernist.
00:27:08 Of course.
00:27:09 And if somebody is hard of sight, partially sighted, I might feel if somebody is staring at me...
00:27:17 It's an ableist campaign.
00:27:19 If somebody's staring at me, I might feel that they are being, actually, that will never happen in my case.
00:27:23 There's no definition.
00:27:24 But how much?
00:27:25 What is the duration of the stare?
00:27:27 Is it two seconds?
00:27:28 Ten seconds?
00:27:29 Half an hour?
00:27:29 Do you think this is a mixing together of the sort of radical subjectivism, as you were saying before,
00:27:39 you know, this nannying desire to kind of control people's behaviour,
00:27:45 but with this subjective element to it mixed with tfl tfl's post-covid nannying so it's a sort of
00:27:53 toxic mixture of all of these different things that have been going on in the last couple of
00:27:56 years do you think that's a really good point i hadn't thought of the covid point but i think
00:28:00 that that's all added to but is it not part of the banning adverts like the beach body ready
00:28:07 yeah adverts isn't that part of the same thing these adverts are not allowed we're going to put
00:28:11 different adverts that tell you you're not like yes i mean of course there's a huge drop of
00:28:15 identity politics because when you say radical subjectivism you're right but of course it's a
00:28:19 very selective subjectivism so that if certain groups of people were to say oh i feel i'm being
00:28:26 stared at in an aggressive or sexual manner i suspect no action would be taken tweed i don't
00:28:32 i don't want to but i don't think yes a tweed where probably no no follow-up action would be
00:28:39 taken against the person or indeed person sexually staring at you so I think there was obviously here
00:28:45 you know there's clearly a it's in it's designed to appeal to the sort of feminist lobby in the
00:28:50 same way that Sadiq Khan now has feminist and transgender symbols on traffic lights
00:28:56 LBGT whatever it is but things cost 10,000 pounds a time you know crossings
00:29:06 It's all part of the way in which identity politics is being injected into our society, imposed upon it, through public ideology, through a semi-state ideology we now experience, and taxpayers are having to pay for this.
00:29:22 yeah there's you you know you mentioned the zebra crossings uh which i quaintly call the
00:29:27 zebra crossings but even like uh there was a woman got into hot water this week a teacher
00:29:33 talking about uh the rainbow stairs in her school and all of this it by implication you're kind of
00:29:40 it's making you agree in an odd way by using the thing when when you walk across it you're being
00:29:46 kind of cajoled into kind of using even though it's just a zebra crossing i mean i think with
00:29:51 this staring thing. When I first saw that poster, it looked like staring. So I thought it was like a film poster. It says staring. I sort of thought this is typical of the left. They've always had a problem with people's, they've always had a problem with intimate human relations. They always, it's the one area that they've never been able to get into, you know, in a way they, they want to regulate it. You know, this goes right back, actually, the past century to Marxism.
00:30:20 And I thought it was part of that somehow that sort of we want to somehow or other control the way people actually
00:30:28 Respond to things. I'm not saying people don't leer at people, but you know, can't we take things and you know, can't we do things?
00:30:39 Isn't staring at somebody in an unwanted fashion a microaggressor?
00:30:42 Well, I think I mean is leering leering is not I presume I'm happy to be corrected on this, but I don't think leering
00:30:50 Or is in a criminal offence.
00:30:52 And so they're saying that this is sexual harassment, but not legally speaking, presumably.
00:30:59 And so it's moving in the direction of saying that...
00:31:01 Well, to describe as an offence is suggesting it is, even though it isn't.
00:31:03 Indefinite, yeah.
00:31:04 I mean, it's the same as when you get, you know, certain lobby groups will be misrepresenting the Equality Act, for example.
00:31:12 It's almost misrepresenting the law to suggest that looking at somebody in a certain way is some kind of criminal offence.
00:31:20 because you would assume that sexual harassment would be a criminal offence.
00:31:23 And so it's moving the goalposts into the realms of microaggressions
00:31:27 being viewed as a criminal act.
00:31:29 Can I just pick up on Peter's point?
00:31:31 I mean, it's very, very important in this context
00:31:33 and follows on from what both of you have just said about microaggressions.
00:31:38 At the heart of all this, and this is where I think, you know,
00:31:40 is the fundamental difference between liberals
00:31:43 and on the other hand the authority the new authoritarians of the new left because not all
00:31:50 the left are authoritarian on all issues of course at the heart of this is a conception of power and
00:31:57 understanding of power and the way in which the whole concept has become radically elasticated
00:32:06 to the point whereby virtually anything can be interpreted
00:32:11 as an act of oppression, of attempted dominance.
00:32:17 And this, of course, goes back to the postmodernists,
00:32:20 to the idea that all human interactions,
00:32:23 even the way we look at each other now, even the way we're talking,
00:32:26 is implicitly a craving for power over the other.
00:32:32 And this has had a huge impact upon the new left and now upon politics and law.
00:32:41 And that is why it's so dangerous, because it's taking away the understanding of power in its rational sense as being physically observable acts and material processes.
00:32:56 And once you divorce the concept of power from empirically verifiable acts and processes, then you're on a slippery slope towards the state being able to put cameras in our homes because we might be engaging in all kinds of acts of power.
00:33:16 something almost gnostic because only a select group of people are able to identify where that
00:33:22 mysterious evil spirit lies and then you end up with a situation where you you know you have
00:33:29 you certain groups who are trying to in their own way seize power in order to exercise society of
00:33:35 this evil spirit that nobody can see well it's akin to witchcraft i mean it's akin to belief in
00:33:40 Speaking of which!
00:33:43 The thing is, as well, it's connected to this whole thing of bullying.
00:33:48 You hear this word bullying all the time.
00:33:50 I know we're going to maybe talk about Burka at some point,
00:33:53 but the thing is, you know, I think it was Dawn Butler, that great intellect of our time,
00:33:58 said something like, he was bullied because he wasn't given a peerage.
00:34:08 But the thing is that basically bullying now, I always thought bullying was something school kids did to each other, but we now use this word to mean disagreeing, or even disagreeing very strongly, right? I mean, and basically pushing your point over, now that's become bullying, which to me is infantilisation.
00:34:26 Well, it's in the case that what Dawn Barton is trying to say is that the removal of a cake for Mr. Bercow, he deserves a cake.
00:34:37 All good boys deserve cake and the government wouldn't give him cake.
00:34:41 That's bullying because he will be disappointed.
00:34:44 And because he's disappointed in what he thinks are his just desserts, that becomes bullying.
00:34:49 Well, another example is Laurie Penny.
00:34:52 Yes.
00:34:52 like a towering intellect of our time.
00:34:55 She's written a book hilariously on fascism.
00:34:59 I'll leave that for the time being.
00:35:00 So she's written a book about fascism.
00:35:02 And because it's been slated, even by people who are naturally sympathetic to it,
00:35:08 she's now claiming she's been bullied, I think.
00:35:10 She says she's been traumatised emotionally.
00:35:13 And when J.K. Rowling and Julie Bindell and others steamed into it,
00:35:18 then this created people saying,
00:35:19 you adding to the trauma paul laurie is experiencing all of this the whole point
00:35:25 underlying all this for me is it's total insincerity in it people don't really feel
00:35:30 bullied they just want to be seen as victims she doesn't really feel bullied of course not
00:35:36 all the other people that we're talking about do not feel bullied or really it's just that you
00:35:41 sort of say it now because you know to be a victim uh or to you know to appear a victim
00:35:46 him this huge amount of has kudos in it now you know i mean which is terrible you know because
00:35:53 basically we stop being stop being adults and then we look at zelinski yes and he's the adult
00:35:59 in the room this is the point no but this is the absolute point sorry to that's good but this is
00:36:03 a great point because i just had when you look at what elena shriver she brilliantly said genuine
00:36:10 um what actual bad badness real bad actual badness which were things that are happening
00:36:15 and you sort of think perhaps you know this will be a salutary one a salutary wake-up call
00:36:21 i have to say i doubt it because we thought that as well with the pandemic you know all of this
00:36:28 kind of stuff would stop because suddenly you had life or death situations no it didn't in fact if
00:36:33 anything it intensified um and and that is the one maybe though you know the mere fact that he
00:36:43 is being idolized, Zelensky, might make a difference.
00:36:47 One of the things that I guess you can do to try and claw reality back and claw back
00:36:52 some objectivism is to refuse to use the wrong language that people are trying to compel
00:36:57 you to use.
00:36:58 So in a situation like, for example, the whole saga around Bercow and his behavior, obviously
00:37:07 his behavior is bad and inappropriate and it is being described as bullying but what would you
00:37:16 describe it as what word would you use instead to describe the sort of way that he was treating his
00:37:21 staff i wouldn't say but you see bullying uh he he might be a personally repulsive man right
00:37:27 far more importantly in a way i mean the staff thing is important what was more important i think
00:37:34 was when is that inquiry or whatever it was said he he was he lied and lied right that's important
00:37:41 and also the fact that one of the great offices that we have right in the center of our constitution
00:37:47 tried to thwart and despite the fact that everybody knew he was an appalling yes man yeah and was
00:37:54 hectoring and uh used abuse of power over his underlings with with with a horrible regularity
00:38:02 and this was known a large chunk of our elected betters decided to ignore this great wash of
00:38:12 personal failing that in anybody else they were thrown a huge book at because he was on their
00:38:19 side because he would subvert the constitution to subvert the vote of brexit yes and therefore
00:38:26 he was to be forgiven like the comments being made about him when he was deliberately undermining
00:38:34 our constitution deliberately thwarting the will of the people these people who today
00:38:39 whiffle on about minor issues are the ones that were lionizing it i i'm gonna i'm conscious of
00:38:48 time so i'm going to move us on to um our fun subject i guess you'd say um which witchcraft
00:38:57 another another uh angry angry little person um uh nicola sturgeon this week um has obviously
00:39:07 been in the news partly because of the gender recognition reform um bill that the scots are
00:39:12 pursue it which will make it easier really for people who are um who identify as another gender
00:39:19 to do so it removes the psychiatric and medical requirement for psychiatric and medical reports
00:39:25 um it shortens the period of reflection period of reflection required to three months and so
00:39:31 people like jk rowling have been coming out against this and criticizing it saying that
00:39:36 it puts women in danger which i think she's absolutely right there um but it's also come
00:39:40 in the same week as the International Women's Day,
00:39:46 the Vagina Museum, because there is such a thing,
00:39:50 decided to make it all about trans history.
00:39:53 And they put a tweet out saying
00:39:55 that they turned off replies on their tweets
00:39:57 because quote, some people would prefer these stories
00:40:00 to be erased and silenced whilst they were themselves
00:40:04 in the process of.
00:40:05 Where is the Vagina Museum?
00:40:06 I think it's in Camden.
00:40:07 um should anybody wish to pay a visit um but also um again on international women's day
00:40:14 um annalisa dodds the labor equality shadow minister uh said on bbc woman's hour that she
00:40:22 wasn't sure how to define what a woman is and jk rowling you know responded to this and has been
00:40:29 really critical saying that somebody should send her a dictionary and a backbone
00:40:33 um and all of this has been swilling around with the the story the funny story of the week which
00:40:41 is nicola sturgeon apologizing to witches for i think it was the witchcraft act 15 something or
00:40:48 other um 1723 did it finish so she was she was apologizing to witches for and this is a quote
00:40:54 um those who have suffered injustice driven by misogyny so presumably witch hunting would be
00:41:00 illegal under the scottish hate crime bill because it would be regarded as misogynistic
00:41:04 even for the male witches who were killed quite so what what do you think is going on here like
00:41:11 what do you what's your sort of analysis of all of the way that international women's day has
00:41:17 been twisted and i suppose in the case of sturgeon she was looking for something to hang her
00:41:26 international women's day hat on um little pointy one um and she happened across now
00:41:34 there is no doubt that i think upwards of 5 000 women in scotland were uh charged with
00:41:41 and many thousands were executed for witchcraft somewhere between 1576 and 1723 i think um this
00:41:49 is true but i mean you're really trying to find something to say aren't you if that's all you can
00:41:58 manage i today she she announced that she's interested in a no-fly zone of ukraine so
00:42:03 she doesn't have witches to defend her she won't have nuclear power nuclear trident to defend her
00:42:08 but she does want to start a third world war the woman seems to be absolutely all over the place
00:42:11 but this is the thing that you were saying about like lionel shriver talking about actual badness
00:42:16 Clearly, we still have people who are fighting against fake badness.
00:42:20 And it's not even that they have their priorities wrong.
00:42:22 They're just not seeing the wood through the trees.
00:42:24 The thing is, though, I mean, this is a bit of a wild, wild guess,
00:42:28 but I think probably quite accurate.
00:42:30 These people like Nicholas Sturgeon, right, these pygmies, literally, sorry,
00:42:35 these small political pygmies, they look at people like Zelensky
00:42:40 and they look at these events, never underestimate,
00:42:43 i think with politicians jealousy you know they want glory they want glory in fact all of those
00:42:50 things however they dress it up don't wouldn't you say they want and they will look at things
00:42:54 like this happening and they'll think you know that this you know this is going on here and i'm
00:43:00 nothing to do with it you know how can i you know and i think that that really can't be underestimated
00:43:06 But really, essentially, if you're, you know, actually, if you were Zelensky or Putin, even, you would look at this kind of thing going on and think, what is the matter with these people?
00:43:22 There's real stuff going on in the world.
00:43:23 Yes, exactly.
00:43:24 Why are you worrying about, and it might be nasty at the time, and it was, but that was literally hundreds of years ago.
00:43:29 Are we going to pardon the Vikings?
00:43:34 uh are we going to demand a policy they suffered from toxic masculinity
00:43:39 this desperate looking for things yeah to talk about when there are very real things that should
00:43:49 be spoken about now but i don't come across as an obsessive but i think there's a you know this
00:43:53 kind of stuff well it's kind of laughable on one level and it's providing us all with a sort of
00:43:59 bit of humor it is indicative of a very sinister ideology um uh identitarian neo-fascistic ideology
00:44:09 which divides our societies into goodies and baddies uh oppressors and oppressed and they
00:44:14 are constantly trying to shoehorn this madness this anti-liberalism into everything even historic
00:44:22 events that took place several hundred years ago and they are constantly using everything if the
00:44:31 people the way we look at each other historic events anything the decor of this you know this
00:44:38 establishment everything is being utilized in this very totalitarian way and so there's this
00:44:46 weird mixture that post-modernism, which you would think would lead to a kind of
00:44:54 highly individualistic, as you said, epistemological subjectivism, is actually being used strategically
00:45:02 to try to destroy all established beliefs, even that there are things called men and women and
00:45:07 and that they biologically objectively exist and on top of that then to bring in this ideology
00:45:17 which is highly authoritarian and highly elitist and so all of this stuff has to be seen in context
00:45:26 if you look at it in an isolated way you don't get it you don't get its significance
00:45:32 Before wrapping up, I just want to get your final thoughts on on this question is that the way that this is sort of the the trans arguments have been buried into International Women's Day, I think is is really interesting.
00:45:47 and obviously there are lots of women who are very concerned about this jk rowling being probably the
00:45:52 most high profile person what exactly do you think is going on with the you know the way that this is
00:45:59 is is being you know international women's day is being co-opted in this way and also at the same
00:46:05 time you have people like annalisa dodds and i think it's probably fair to say that politicians
00:46:09 like her just don't have the sort of sense of security to be able to say actually no a woman
00:46:14 is this do you have any sort of final thoughts on exactly what's going on there why it's being used
00:46:20 in this way why they're using particularly international women's day to push um trans
00:46:24 issues i mean i don't mean to to to be dismissive i i would but i i would think it's pretty much of
00:46:31 a piece i think why wouldn't they i think the majority of women don't even know it's
00:46:36 women's international women's day i don't i don't think they should know i think it's these things
00:46:42 are entirely gestural they mean nothing i mean i think that are the general argument about you know
00:46:49 the way women are being sort of essentially erased is of huge importance and ongoing
00:46:57 but i think that it's almost inevitable that these people would uh this international woman
00:47:02 saying that they would do this i agree with you it's inevitable but i think what is what is really
00:47:08 sad is that people who are in a position to call this out are too frightened to do so
00:47:17 last year the national conference of the her majesty's opposition can be boiled down to one
00:47:26 word and that's woman because the entire conference three days of their conference we have no idea
00:47:32 what anybody said about whether the only thing that i can remember from it is people were running
00:47:36 away from journalists saying what's a woman and they couldn't answer um and that that was their
00:47:42 entire three-day conference that's all they said it's the only time i think i've ever seen a
00:47:47 political party go down in the polls during their their conference because the only thing that came
00:47:52 out of it was fear of the word woman madness any final thoughts on the clownish situation of people
00:48:00 running away from the word woman well um it's indicative of the fact that the center left
00:48:08 is becoming an overtly post-modernist movement and in a way that is a good thing because i think
00:48:18 as lenin said worse is sometimes better let um all of these people um go for it wholeheartedly
00:48:26 I want them to now become overtly authoritarian on these and other issues, because I think here
00:48:34 lies an opportunity for the creation of a politically, if not economically, liberal
00:48:42 popular front which includes left-wing rationalists, traditional non-intersectional feminists,
00:48:52 libertarians, conservatives, and what have you. And I think we need now much greater clarity as
00:49:00 to where the dividing line in British and Western politics is. And anything that accentuates that,
00:49:07 that helps to develop that sense of awareness as to what's happening, which clears away the
00:49:16 a sort of conceptual fog is a good thing so i say bring it on and that's a really good constructive
00:49:22 note to end on so uh thank you mark gawain peter and thank you to you for watching and please like
00:49:29 subscribe comment below let us know what you think of the show or your thoughts on any of the subjects
00:49:33 and we will see you next time on newspeak thank you very much hello if you're enjoying the new
00:49:39 Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission, may I invite you to join our
00:49:45 membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:49:52 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the
00:49:57 future but we can't do it without your support. From as little as three pounds
00:50:02 per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member
00:50:07 you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content, invitations to our
00:50:13 private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
00:50:21 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help
00:50:28 us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free. Just remember
00:50:35 to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.