New Culture Forum - April 01, 2022


Konstantin Kisin on Russia, Ukraine + Western Response

Sadiq Khan's Stark Staring Mad Tfl ads + Is The West Right to Lionize Zelensky? Fathers 4 Justice Founder: New Divorce Law is Disastrous for Men. Marriage Needs Reform.

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

186.7

Word count

8,902

Sentence count

243


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my
00:00:23 guest today is Konstantin Kissin. Hello Konstantin. Good to be back. He's been on
00:00:29 before obviously I'm sure because there's a lot of crossover I think in the show
00:00:35 that you watch here and also with Trigonometry which he co-hosts with
00:00:39 Francis Foster. It's a hugely successful channel pleased to say but also of
00:00:45 of course, Constantine is a comedian, increasingly a commentator, and also a forthcoming author,
00:00:54 because his book, An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West, will be coming out in a few months' time.
00:01:00 Thanks very much for coming on. Good to be back, Peter. Thanks for having me.
00:01:04 I went through your, you know, instruction. It seems to me, tell me if I'm wrong, that the
00:01:09 comedian part of that is slightly taking a back step. Is that right?
00:01:13 Yeah, the main reason is just family life. When lockdown happened, I suddenly realized I hadn't seen my wife for a couple of years. That's how hard I was working. And she was making that very clear. And the days of me driving up and down the country to do, you know, drive for three hours to do a gig to, you know, 100 people and then drive back home or whatever it was. I just don't have the time.
00:01:36 uh with trigonometry we are doing a lot of satirical stuff now uh and so the comedic
00:01:41 instinct is still getting an outing it's just not getting an outing in a stand-up format i i
00:01:46 enjoyed it and if you remember you hosted me here with my show yes well and people enjoyed it so i
00:01:52 enjoyed my time as a comic and if i could do it from my bedroom uh i think i'd still be doing it
00:01:57 but it was just the lifestyle isn't for anyone who wants to have a family life and my wife we're
00:02:02 expecting our first child now. When's that going to happen? Early to mid-May, so, you know, it's just
00:02:08 it wasn't going to work. And yes, and also, of course, with some events that have been going on
00:02:13 recently, it's meant that I've leaned into more of the serious commentary. And, you know, I'll
00:02:18 always have many strings to my bow, I suppose. But, well, yes, I suppose you say it's a practical
00:02:25 consideration family uh i don't wish to be too earnest but is there also the sense in which
00:02:33 things are so serious it actually takes away the desire to do it in you or not no no i actually in
00:02:40 some ways as someone of russian descent with the ukrainian family ukrainian wife ukrainian mom
00:02:46 like i i almost wish i was back on on the comedy now because it's a rich time to and people want
00:02:52 answers and people want humor and people want this very dark time to be lightened up a little
00:02:57 bit i'd i'd be very happy to be doing comedy now it's just it's it's the practical side of it uh
00:03:03 there's lots of jokes to be made always particularly in dark times in my opinion yeah uh and you know
00:03:08 myself coming from uh a russian soviet background and and from a jewish background that was always
00:03:14 the way in the soviet union peter particularly for jewish people is making light of the very
00:03:19 difficult circumstances in which they were living that's always been a big part of my attitude to
00:03:23 comedy so no i'd be happily doing comedy if it wasn't for all the practical stuff right now
00:03:28 but you've been doing a hell of i mean i've seen you a lot on the media
00:03:30 for obvious reasons for the ones you've just described uh given the current situation in
00:03:36 ukraine um you did question time what was that like for you doing question time
00:03:41 uh it was interesting uh because i think for both of us who are fairly strong critics of the
00:03:46 mainstream media i i was pleasantly surprised by some things i would say uh it's clearly a program
00:03:52 that's made by very bright people uh now it's true to say that they're all anywheres in david
00:03:58 goodhart's definition they're all sort of metropolitan very open to the world and few
00:04:04 of them i would say felt to me like people who are attached to a specific place and so some of
00:04:08 the issues that you and i talk about on our shows might might not be as open-minded but i know that
00:04:13 they watch trigonometry for example to look for guests now the slot they're filling with them is
00:04:18 is a different question but nonetheless it's made by interesting bright intelligent people
00:04:25 so that was reassuring and i was pleased to to go on there and i think to make some points that
00:04:30 people maybe haven't heard before yes in particularly in a way that i think was quite
00:04:35 direct and honest and upfront about what was going on so that was good uh i enjoyed that
00:04:40 i think i think it's good so whenever i you know i'm a critic of the mainstream media and i think
00:04:45 they've done a very bad job and many many people wrote to me afterwards saying that was the first
00:04:50 time i've watched question time for 10 years or five years or seven years or whatever it was
00:04:53 and i'm one of those people i used to watch question time religiously yeah uh that i went
00:04:59 i was in the audience of question time probably 16 or 17 years ago that's how much i used to love
00:05:03 the program i i used to love the debate and the discussions that were being had and i think it
00:05:08 It's slid since.
00:05:11 So I was pleased to be there
00:05:12 and to add perhaps a bit of what I think is necessary,
00:05:15 which is straight talking, honesty,
00:05:18 and cutting through all the nonsense
00:05:20 that I think you get from politicians on that.
00:05:22 Yes, I remember doing it myself.
00:05:24 It was, what, 2018, something like that?
00:05:26 I think it was.
00:05:27 And I remember being pretty nervous about it, actually.
00:05:30 But it was the audience thing,
00:05:32 because the bias thing
00:05:34 often seems to be supplied by the audience.
00:05:37 You know, people always going about the BBC,
00:05:38 handpicking people or not being balanced but for some reason my audience down in Plymouth were not
00:05:46 bad so once you're sitting there in front of them you can see the whites of their eyes
00:05:50 and everything I suddenly sort of relaxed a little bit but I think that the main thing is
00:05:56 being that people are criticized it for being just very monolithic I mean everyone basically
00:06:01 has the same view but obviously you know not yeah I think on my program was a bit different because
00:06:07 it was about ukraine and russia and that was a much more it was a different issue to many of the
00:06:12 divides we've been talking about for years now but it's interesting you say you relaxed once you sat
00:06:16 down because i was relaxed all the way through we drove down uh i was very very calm you know i've
00:06:22 done a lot of media as you say at this point so it's it's not really anything new to me we sat
00:06:27 down on the desk very at the desk very very calm and then when the program started i remained very
00:06:34 calm up here but my body was absolutely frozen and it took me quite a while to just take some
00:06:40 deep breaths and that was that was quite a surprise but i think the magnitude of the number
00:06:45 of people who are likely to be watching i suppose hits you at that moment it does yes and of course
00:06:50 presumably you got a lot of feedback on it yeah i had you know feedback was very very positive
00:06:55 i'm very grateful for that i'm very grateful that i was as i say i was able to go and put i think
00:07:01 what was a fairly simple, but a fairly straight set of points for people that they might not have
00:07:06 heard before. And I think, you know, a lot of people in the public responded. So that's rewarding.
00:07:12 I know that you mentioned your family. And I just wonder if you, I know you have talked about this
00:07:17 before with other channels, but what is the kind of, you've got family in, you were born in Moscow,
00:07:24 but you've got family in Russia and in Ukraine, and you're West Ukrainian, isn't you? So how much
00:07:30 are you in contact with both sides oh all the time yeah i speak to people in russia in ukraine
00:07:35 i have family and my wife has family in the north of ukraine and the south of ukraine and the west
00:07:41 of ukraine it's a country to which i go or used to go regularly several times a year usually so
00:07:46 i'm very very connected with with that part of the world which i think is why i have a you know
00:07:51 perhaps a slightly different perspective to many people now yeah because i know what it's like on
00:07:55 ground it's not something i've read about or watched the video about on youtube and so you
00:08:00 say you know what it's like on the ground so there's not so much an element of surprise about
00:08:05 what's been happening well i've been predicting this since 2014 and in one way or another once
00:08:10 putin took crimea and started a civil war in the two eastern regions it was very very clear to me
00:08:16 that this wasn't going to stop particularly given that there was no reason for him to stop there
00:08:21 was no pushback from the West of any material significance. So we allowed him to sort of
00:08:26 complete this Anschluss with Crimea, and you go from there, don't you?
00:08:31 Yeah. What do you make of Zelensky? Can you explain this a bit? I mean,
00:08:39 obviously we feel we've become very familiar with him, but I thought it would be interesting,
00:08:46 given your your background how how big was he on the ukrainian cultural scene he was the biggest
00:08:53 star on the biggest oh the biggest so he people joked about it when he was first elected because
00:08:59 he hosted and he was the the lead in a comedic series in which he played the president of ukraine
00:09:07 and then he was then elected president of ukraine and it's interesting because uh i think his
00:09:12 election was not universally well received even though he got over 75 percent of the vote in uh
00:09:19 in what was at that point a completely free and fair election so the majority of the people voted
00:09:23 for him overwhelmingly but it wasn't felt that electing a comedian president was necessarily
00:09:29 you know uh giving ukraine international standing as a country that's to be taken seriously there
00:09:35 were many people who felt that this was you know it was the worst of it was the best of all the bad
00:09:40 options but it didn't it did not bode well for ukraine that i had to lend elect a comic president
00:09:46 um but uh when i speak to people now all of that sentiment has gone he's universally seen as doing
00:09:54 the right thing as defending his country as being courageous and brave um now it doesn't mean that
00:10:00 everything he's doing uh people agree down to the last little detail or that everything he was doing
00:10:07 prior to the war people agreed with at all there were many people as as there would be in any
00:10:11 country critical of him but now uh i think because it's wartime uh there's very strong unified
00:10:18 support uh behind him from many of his former critics too are you surprised at the way he's
00:10:25 handled it yes you you really would not have thought no no why well i don't think he'd had
00:10:33 a chance to show his character, really. And so I think when we look back to something like
00:10:38 Afghanistan, only a few months ago, where the moment the war starts or the Taliban start pushing
00:10:45 back because the Americans were drawn, the first thing the president does, pack all his money in
00:10:48 a car and start heading for the border. That, in my mind, was a possibility. Now, that's probably
00:10:54 very unfair on Zelensky of me to say that. But if you haven't seen him in this sort of situation
00:10:58 before how can you make that judgment so i've been very surprised at the way that he's conducted
00:11:03 himself and all power to him yes i have to say i think he's sort of given many people in the
00:11:11 west a bit of a kick up the ass mentally when you actually see someone you know being so forthright
00:11:17 and uncompromising and then it makes you realize just how lily livered our own leaders are no i
00:11:25 I'd agree. Would you think? Oh, completely. Yeah, of course. I mean, it sounds like a typical question, but I just can't help but ask it. If he, comedian, has become a highly respected leader in wartime, do you ever think, Konstantin, of becoming more political?
00:11:44 No. God, no. God, no. God, no.
00:11:48 I'm not sort of saying, oh, you must ever...
00:11:50 But I just thought he was a comedian and a hugely successful one.
00:11:54 You, comedian, started the YouTube channel.
00:11:58 But, you know, you have... It is a political thing.
00:12:01 I mean, you know, and you are asked for more.
00:12:03 I wonder whether it has ever occurred to you...
00:12:05 Actually, I quite like the idea.
00:12:07 Yeah, no, I thought about...
00:12:10 Not for a very long time, but very carefully nonetheless.
00:12:13 less and only in the sense that i think comedians particularly comedians like me who wanted to
00:12:20 explore difficult subjects through comedy um in this country in in the western world where every
00:12:26 tiny little thing that you said is going to be examined under a microscope and people are not
00:12:32 going to remember that you said something as a comedy piece they're going to take it literally
00:12:37 uh you're going to get destroyed and i get other comedians talking to me about well maybe i should
00:12:43 run for this and i always say to them are you crazy what are you doing they're going to dig up
00:12:46 that bit of material you did in 20 you know 2012 and they're going to make it look like you meant
00:12:54 it literally you were not being sarcastic you were not being ironic and they're going to destroy your
00:12:57 life so no but also peter i think let's be honest um i don't think that uh i would be able to
00:13:05 maintain my forthright approach and speak honestly about the things that I think ought to be spoken
00:13:13 honestly about if I were in politics. Politics is the art of trying to please people by not telling
00:13:18 them the truth. I don't want to be doing that. And, you know, with trigonometry, we're having
00:13:26 conversations that I think shape some of the discourse that is happening. And so if you wanted
00:13:31 to have influence i don't know that i'd have more influence as a backbench mp for wherever
00:13:37 than than i do now if if that was my ambition i actually whether that is my ambition i'm very
00:13:43 skeptical about i i'm not sure the bigger our channel becomes and the more people listen to us
00:13:48 the more keen i am to become more of a bystander who just provides yes yes neutral commentary or
00:13:54 factual commentary as opposed to getting involved because it is you you're on over 300 000 subscribers
00:14:01 now aren't you? And I think you've got a point, I think that you probably do have more influence
00:14:07 actually doing that than being a backbench MP. It's just a thought because I suppose that there
00:14:12 comes a time sometimes where you think actually you know I want to possibly rather than being as
00:14:19 you put it a kind of bystander commentator I actually want to sort of like initiate something
00:14:23 but I think this is the problem is that as we're a little bit discussing before we came on air here
00:14:29 is that you're then required to have an opinion of almost everything and we don't do it no and and
00:14:35 by the way the main most important thing is not only do we not have an opinion i would certainly
00:14:39 say for me i don't know about you there is an almost immeasurable number of things about which
00:14:45 i know nothing yeah yeah and so to have to then go into politics and suddenly have an opinion about
00:14:51 i don't know internet infrastructure in norwich it's what do i know about that there's things
00:14:57 that i think i understand and i've tried to cover them on trigonometry in my interviews in my book
00:15:03 uh in in other things that i think are a valuable perspective as someone who comes from outside of
00:15:07 the west and has perhaps an outsider's look which was always my comedy that's what it was based on
00:15:13 around as well uh and that's what i i wanted to do uh but i am you know i i of course i have ego
00:15:20 but i also have enough humility to recognize that i don't know everything and in fact i know very
00:15:24 little so the little that I know I tried to share with people everything else is
00:15:28 really for other people who have a broader perspective perhaps things is
00:15:32 that the you said they're coming from outside the West and as I said your book
00:15:36 coming out in July she's already pre orderable I would add is an immigrants
00:15:46 love letter to the West but there's this odd thing isn't there that essentially
00:15:53 you know, you're talking about coming from a country, the country of Dostoevsky, the country of Tchaikovsky, of, you know, Sostakovich.
00:16:02 It sort of is part of Western culture, isn't it? I mean, there is this schizophrenic, I've just been in Hungary,
00:16:08 they talk often about this, you know, that they would be classified as not being in the West.
00:16:12 But actually, you're talking about the same things. We, you know, we created the same things.
00:16:17 Well, I think to suggest that Hungary is not part of Western civilization is historically inaccurate.
00:16:25 The Austro-Hungarian Empire was the center of Western civilization for a long time.
00:16:30 I think the civilizational split, in my opinion, is, and Arnold Toynbee wrote about this in A Study of History,
00:16:36 is between Eastern Christian civilization, so the descendants of the Byzantine Empire, the Eastern Roman Empire,
00:16:43 and the Western Roman Empire, so the Western Christian civilization,
00:16:47 which is one of the reasons that when, you know,
00:16:49 people like to make everything about race nowadays, of course,
00:16:52 but when we talk about Australia and New Zealand and Canada,
00:16:55 but particularly Australia and New Zealand, let's say,
00:16:57 as being part of Western civilization,
00:16:59 the reason is that these are the descendants of the people
00:17:03 who were once part of the Western Roman Empire.
00:17:05 That's why we call them the West, right?
00:17:07 Even though they're geographically in a very different part of the world.
00:17:11 So I think that split is there.
00:17:12 So I think, of course, Russian writers and Russian musicians and composers and playwrights are a part of our cultural space.
00:17:25 But it's a civilization with its own values, which, frankly, we're now seeing that difference in approach.
00:17:32 You've got to remember as well, Peter, of course, what we now call Russia spent a very long time under the Mongols, under the Mongol occupation.
00:17:40 and many of the methods which were used in that time persist to this day in terms of people's
00:17:45 mindset about how they should be governed and their approaches. So there is a difference between
00:17:50 the two, I think. But that doesn't mean that we shouldn't share and we shouldn't learn. I mean,
00:17:56 some of the people that you've mentioned, the Russian writers, for example, they're a huge part
00:18:03 of our cultural sphere and we would be uh very very foolish not to learn from them and that is
00:18:10 you know people now as i'm critical of what's happening and what russia is doing people there's
00:18:15 some ironically western people have never been to russia accuse me of hating russia i love russia
00:18:21 for the precisely the reasons that you've just outlined the people the you know the people who've
00:18:26 created some of the greatest literature literature poetry music while being kept under the thumb
00:18:32 It's precisely by the sort of people that are now invading Ukraine. That's a tragedy of Russia. It's it's people who are
00:18:40 extremely bright
00:18:41 Extremely intelligent who think very deeply about the human condition about philosophy about literature of our art
00:18:47 Who've who've been under the thumb of some very nasty people who've taken control of the country for for centuries now?
00:18:55 Yes, I'm glad to hear you said I remember just picking up one thing
00:18:59 I think it was on question time and you said I feel very ashamed. Yes
00:19:04 Isn't it possible though to feel ashamed of the people running a country but not the country?
00:19:10 Of course, of course, and it's it's funny to me to be accused of not loving
00:19:17 Russia where I'm from
00:19:18 It's kind of like the trick that they tried to pull with Brexit where people voted to leave and
00:19:23 They were accused of hating Europeans as opposed to not wanting to be part of the European Union or people who talk about
00:19:29 a sensible immigration policy being accused of hating immigrants of course it is but when your
00:19:35 country invades another and is killing innocent people and under completely false pretenses then
00:19:42 i think you are right to be ashamed of what it's doing and i am ashamed of my country and what it's
00:19:47 doing right now uh ukraine is putting up uh famously uh an extraordinary fight
00:19:54 i mean this is pure speculation but are you in any way optimistic
00:20:01 uh i can't see that far into the future at this point i think it's hangs it's hanging in the
00:20:10 balance i i've commented in recent weeks that i you know my concern and i'm not saying this is
00:20:15 what will happen but it is my concern that the outcome of the conflict will likely be a russian
00:20:21 victory um just the way things were looking at that time it seems that the russian advance
00:20:29 has stalled completely now as we speak today and in fact ukraines are pushing back my worry is
00:20:35 nonetheless that um all that will happen at putin is desperate now he's desperate to win
00:20:42 that they're just going to flatten more cities and they're going to start using worse and worse
00:20:47 weapons. And essentially, they will try to win at any cost, even if that means massive civilian
00:20:54 casualties. Even if that means, you know, this idea that the Russian government is putting
00:21:00 forward is that they're rebuilding the Russian world as they flatten ancient Russian cities like
00:21:05 Chernigov. It's atrocious. And so my concern is that Ukrainians are fighting very bravely. And
00:21:14 if I were a Ukrainian on the ground in Ukraine, I would be right there with them fighting to defend
00:21:19 my country. And I hope to be wrong very much about this. I just worry that even as the conflict runs
00:21:26 on, unless the West really steps up the level of help, particularly anti-aircraft support, because
00:21:31 that's really what the Ukrainians need. They need to, as they say, close the sky to prevent Russian
00:21:36 bombing and airstrikes. If they can do that, I think they might have a very good chance of winning.
00:21:41 But if that doesn't happen, then you might just see that the conflict is extended.
00:21:46 The outcome is unchanged, but the number of casualties on both sides,
00:21:50 but obviously with the Ukrainian civilians particularly, goes up.
00:21:53 So that's my worry, and it's a very difficult conversation.
00:21:57 But as I say, I think Ukrainians, as you say, rather,
00:21:59 I think Ukrainians are putting up a brave fight,
00:22:01 and of course I hope that they're successful.
00:22:03 Well, I think they've sort of been an inspiration, actually.
00:22:07 what i find interesting i i i wonder what what your thought is on this uh constant um obviously
00:22:16 you were pretty forthright during the pandemic for example we've had the pandemic we had brexit
00:22:21 before that you were remainer were you not or i voted i i i reject the label of remainer peter
00:22:27 very harshly but i did vote remain you did okay okay i didn't mean with all the baggage i'm not
00:22:34 having a go at you i'm just trying i want to clarify the point i think you can vote leave
00:22:38 and not be a brexiteer and you can vote remain and not be a remainer oh sure sure and that's my
00:22:43 i voted remain but once the vote came in yes i thought it was essential that we respect the
00:22:49 democratic wishes of the british people right and i think what a lot of people associate with
00:22:53 the term remainer is someone who voted remain and thought that the vote of the other people
00:22:59 was irrelevant because that's what i voted for i was never one of those people and as you know
00:23:04 i was very open to hearing from people at different point of view to me that's that's why i pick you
00:23:08 up on it it's okay no fair fair point fair point um i suppose what the point is going to make really
00:23:15 is that okay let's take brexit leave it here yeah and let's take the pandemic pandemic uh you wrote
00:23:21 a great piece uh you know actually what it became a piece in substat where you now have a con don't
00:23:28 issue, which was a thread on Twitter about why people might be hesitant to take the
00:23:34 vaccine. You weren't saying that they shouldn't, you were just saying why they might be.
00:23:39 What I was wondering is, do you get impatient with people now who, on social media particularly,
00:23:48 seem to see a kind of conspiracy in the situation in Ukraine? And I've tried to understand it
00:23:55 And I think that people feel, for example, when it comes to the pandemic, that they were told lots of lies.
00:24:01 It was unreasonable. So they're actually now applying the same thing.
00:24:05 They just simply do not believe anything. Yes. I mean, what's your attitude?
00:24:09 Yeah. Well, I think we've got to delineate a couple of things within that, if you allow me to.
00:24:15 So I look, there's obviously I think mainly these conspiracy stuff that as you describe it or a feeling that we're not quite being told the truth.
00:24:23 let's let's let's call it that because conspiracy triggers people uh so we won't use that word um
00:24:29 it breaks down into two separate things part of it is the sort of populist left
00:24:33 and these are people who hate the west let's just call them what it is they always hated the west
00:24:38 they see the west as the root of all evil and so they will always side with our enemies and
00:24:43 i think we all know that the small minority of the population uh they've always existed uh in
00:24:48 times of peace, they bang on about other things. And I agree with them on a lot of the things that
00:24:54 they bang on about, incidentally, normally. But in this case, I think they've shown their true
00:24:58 colors, which I always thought would likely happen. I think on the populist right, it's a
00:25:05 different set of things. So the left hate the West. I think on the populist right, there's a
00:25:09 few things. The first one, of course, you mentioned, which is the media have been lying to us for a
00:25:13 long time, and they know that. And so their skepticism about what the mainstream media is
00:25:19 telling them is pretty natural. The other thing is that they don't like the Western elite,
00:25:26 who they see as the ones that have been lying to them this whole time. And again,
00:25:30 I have some sympathy with that. So that's another part of it. And the third one, I think,
00:25:36 is, as a result of those two things, they see Putin as someone who is challenging and attacking
00:25:46 the people that they hate, Western elites. And so for that reason, I think it's tempting to sort of
00:25:52 think that maybe, well, you know, maybe he's doing something necessary. I think that's how people
00:25:56 are thinking. Another thing, of course, is if you are disillusioned with what your media are telling
00:26:02 you, you will likely seek out other media that are giving you a different perspective.
00:26:07 So a lot of people have been imbibing Russian propaganda uncritically.
00:26:11 Now, I don't, I am not a supporter of the shutdown of Russia Today, for example, that's
00:26:16 happened recently.
00:26:17 I think that was unnecessary.
00:26:19 But I do think if you're going to watch Russia Today, which is pure Kremlin propaganda and
00:26:25 always has been one of the reasons I never did any interviews, I think.
00:26:28 Maybe I might have done one purely because, anyway.
00:26:32 I try to stay away from it as much as I can
00:26:34 because I didn't want to be involved in this.
00:26:37 But if you're going to watch Russia today,
00:26:39 you have to use your critical faculties,
00:26:41 and I think a lot of people haven't been.
00:26:43 Now, am I frustrated by that?
00:26:46 Initially, I was very frustrated by it.
00:26:48 I've made my peace with it.
00:26:50 People are allowed to think what they want to think.
00:26:52 All I can do is tell them what's going on on the ground in Russia,
00:26:56 what people in Russian media are saying,
00:26:58 that they're not hearing that what Russian leaders are saying that they're not hearing.
00:27:03 That's one of the biggest problems, Peter, at the moment is a lot of people don't speak Russian.
00:27:07 They've never been to Russia. They don't understand.
00:27:09 And so I've just been trying to put out clips about what's actually being said on Russian television,
00:27:14 the way that Russian presenters, people who are equivalent to a P.S. Morgan or an Andrew Neal,
00:27:21 Kicillov and Solovyov, for example, are saying, and these people are openly talking about how
00:27:25 Ukraine isn't the end of this. It's just the beginning. In order to secure the strategic
00:27:30 interests of the Russian Federation, we've got to keep moving further. They keep threatening the
00:27:35 West with nuclear weapons, etc. But if you only watch Russia today, of course, you're not hearing
00:27:40 that side of it. So look, in 1938, if we had Twitter and YouTube, there'd be lots of people
00:27:49 in those days saying, well, Adolf Hitler is perfectly legitimate in his view to free the
00:27:54 germans in the sudetenland uh and by the way that was partly true right hitler had more justification
00:28:02 to invade czechoslovakia than vladimir putin does to invade ukraine right but does that mean we
00:28:07 shouldn't have resisted hitler you know you know do you see what i'm saying yeah yeah yeah and and so
00:28:12 to me the the question of all these sort of different ways of looking at it is kind of
00:28:16 irrelevant because at the end of the day we're talking about a war of aggression in the heart
00:28:20 of Europe. And that is all that matters to me. There's also a lot of nonsense about why Putin
00:28:27 is doing this. People don't understand that he's been talking about this since the moment he came
00:28:31 to power, that Kiev is the sacred place on the map for him, that he's always talked about pushing
00:28:38 NATO back to its pre-1997 borders, which would mean all of Eastern Europe being under his control.
00:28:44 They don't understand that when Russia talks about a neutral Ukraine, what they mean is going back to
00:28:49 a time where russia decided who the president of ukraine was and how ukrainians lived their lives
00:28:55 uh they just they they people buy into the propaganda and critically that's fine people
00:29:00 are allowed to think what they think we live in a free country uh i'm but rather than focusing on
00:29:05 them i think peter what we should focus on is the extraordinary support this country in particular
00:29:09 is given to the ukrainians well i was going to ask you about that because you you said that you
00:29:13 pretty much you could foresee that this was going to happen something like and i just wonder whether
00:29:17 you could foresee or whether you've been surprised by the british response i have been i have been
00:29:22 very pleasantly so peter very pleasantly so when i speak to people in ukraine and it's interesting
00:29:28 seeing our media uh trying they're still stuck in that frame of mind where like boris johnson is
00:29:35 evil and i am no fan of boris johnson as i think i've made pretty clear on many occasions particularly
00:29:41 over lockdown and covid i think some of some of the things that he did in terms of the laws that
00:29:46 tried to push through, just despicable and completely un-British, in my opinion. And the
00:29:51 way that we've seen his own personal hypocrisy on that issue has been, you know, I've disagreed
00:29:57 with many other things. And I'm deeply disillusioned with Boris Johnson and have been
00:30:02 since pretty much the election, if you ask me. But at the same time, there is no question that
00:30:08 of the Western leaders, Boris Johnson has been one of the very best in terms of addressing this
00:30:12 issue in terms of providing support to ukraine and if you speak to people in ukraine that is
00:30:17 what they will tell you universally universally they say thank you please tell people in britain
00:30:23 when you speak to people you guys have been the best you've been sending support you've been
00:30:27 supporting us and it means a lot so there's no question in my mind that much of the west have
00:30:32 abrogated i think their responsibilities but britain hasn't um and you know full credit to
00:30:38 boris johnson for that it pains me to say this but but he deserves credit and so does so do many
00:30:44 other people in the british space uh in the commentary space and and so on i i think we
00:30:49 should give ourselves a pat on the back for how we've responded and when i talk to ordinary people
00:30:53 in this country they're they've been raising money i mean on trigonometry you raised about 50 grand
00:30:58 we raised 55 grand in an hour and a half peter that's how strongly people all over the world
00:31:03 field about this issue and so when british people are listening to this who who've been supporting
00:31:09 the humanitarian effort or have been watching our government providing support to ukraine
00:31:12 you should know that you should be very proud of your country in the way that it's stepped up in
00:31:16 this moment uh unlike many other western countries so uh i have no criticism to make on this
00:31:22 particular issue of of the british government at all and other british people they've been
00:31:26 extraordinary it's interesting isn't it how a huge crisis or as it doesn't really begin to cover it
00:31:31 just according to crisis something like this sort of the scales fall from people's eyes in all sorts
00:31:36 of ways so um i'm sure for example you know like with brexit uh it took the debate to actually
00:31:42 clarify what the eu was and i think that a lot of people who didn't really pay much attention
00:31:48 now know that germany was taking all that energy from you know well of course i've been banging on
00:31:54 about this for years and no one was listening yes but now we're starting to see that some of this
00:31:58 Now, I'll be honest with you. I mean, one of the things that has shocked me, one of the things I predicted very early on when the war, not the war, when Russia invaded Ukraine, was that I thought this was going to be, you know, a moment in which we would start to have a sensible policy on energy.
00:32:15 And what I mean by that is, yes, of course, pollution and resource depletion and all of these things matter. And of course, we can have a conversation about climate change. But do we throw our security out of the window?
00:32:26 yeah do we does germany destroy its entire nuclear industry to keep little greta happy i mean i
00:32:33 didn't think all of this was particularly sensible and i've been trying to make this point
00:32:37 we can focus on environmental issues that are important peter without putting ourselves at
00:32:43 risk of some much more immediate things that are a problem and you see the weakness of europe's
00:32:49 response continental europe's response eastern europeans they're they're responding very strongly
00:32:54 and Poland's been brilliant and other countries because they know this nonsense about how Putin's
00:33:00 just upset about NATO expansion. They know that's nonsense because they keep getting invaded by
00:33:05 Russia over and over and over and over in their history. They know Russian expansionist ambitions
00:33:11 have always been there and will always be there. But in Western Europe, let's be honest,
00:33:17 they've sold themselves out both in terms of their political elite to Russia and in terms of
00:33:22 energy infrastructure they buy a tremendous of energy and they don't want to inconvenience
00:33:26 themselves by having to reorientate themselves to not doing business with this evil regime
00:33:33 uh despite you know what they do um and how they have not stepped up in the right way maybe
00:33:40 um or strongly enough uh you still love the west don't you of course um so i suppose
00:33:47 I'm being frivolous, you were talking obviously about Europe there, but your book Love Letter to
00:33:53 the West, I mean I don't want to overstate this but it seems to me that there is this kind of
00:33:59 window at the moment, I think you know in a way your book is remarkably well-timed, I know it
00:34:04 wasn't intended like that, but that somehow or other we've got to get our act together, we sort
00:34:12 of have, you know, kind of a strategic wave for this crisis, sort of, but I'm talking about the
00:34:20 hinterland, all the things you've already talked about, kind of self-loathing, all of this.
00:34:27 When you were writing the book, presumably, I mean, what started you off writing that?
00:34:33 What actually was it? Was there something that happened or why did you feel the need to write it?
00:34:39 I felt the need to write it, Peter, because I'm not saying I predicted that this invasion would
00:34:46 happen on the 24th of February 2022. But my worldview is not the worldview that I think
00:34:56 liberal elites in the West have been very keen to delude themselves into, which is we live in this
00:35:03 peaceful, happy, pleasant world in which all we do is trade and get on with other people. And
00:35:09 everyone elsewhere in the world, Peter, really wants that as well. All they want is peace and
00:35:13 prosperity. And there's no one in the, in anywhere else in any other part of the world who's in any
00:35:18 way aggressive or authoritarian or expansionist. And all we just need to do is be peaceful and
00:35:23 happy and friendly and make sure that we, we, you know, really respect the rights of everybody and
00:35:28 blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. I think the reason I started writing the book is it's the question
00:35:34 I've been asking myself for a long time what happens when a civilization that believes diversity is our strength
00:35:40 encounters a civilization that believes strength is our strength and
00:35:49 It has to grow up presumably and I and it does have to grow up and it has to recognize that
00:35:55 Diversity is only a strength to the extent that is a strength
00:35:58 And all the other things that we've been focusing on are only a strength to the extent that they make us stronger
00:36:04 But if we over obsess about certain things then we detract from other things that matter
00:36:09 like making sure that we are confident in ourselves that we
00:36:14 Bring up a generation of people who who are critical of their country in a healthy way who want to make it better
00:36:20 But don't grow up in a nihilistic
00:36:23 self-loathing
00:36:25 flagellating society, which tells them that everything that we've ever done is evil, that
00:36:30 what defines us most here in the West is the evil elements of our past, the things that we were doing,
00:36:36 which, by the way, they don't tell you what happened in exactly the same way or much worse
00:36:40 in every other part of the world at the same time. So this myopia is what I've really been
00:36:45 trying to speak about for a very long time, since before I wrote the book. But, you know, I wrote a
00:36:50 preface to the book in which i basically said that if we don't get our act together
00:36:55 uh our civilization is in danger and i thought it was very powerfully written and i showed it
00:37:01 to a few friends and they said oh constance and this is beautiful but you've got to take it out
00:37:05 it's it's too melodramatic and then a few weeks ago i put it back in because i was right our
00:37:13 civilization needs to grow up it needs to remember what makes us who we are yes uh tolerance and
00:37:22 freedom and all of these things are part of our history but with that comes a responsibility to
00:37:29 protect those things we have to protect our freedoms the freedom to speak your mind freely
00:37:34 that is what makes our civilization great if you look at where are the greatest inventions in the
00:37:39 world coming from. Even though people in Russia are very smart, very, very smart, extremely well
00:37:44 educated, historically speaking, they have to go to America or to Britain to come up with big
00:37:50 technological breakthroughs. Why? Because these are the places where you are actually free to
00:37:55 pursue things, to be rewarded for the things that you do. So that's what the book is about. It's
00:38:01 reminding people the value of who we are and what we have here in the West, why people like me come
00:38:06 from other places and want to be here why this this country the united states and the west more
00:38:12 generally and our values are better than values in other places are better than those and i don't
00:38:17 think we should be ashamed ashamed to say this no no i mean ukrainians peter and this is a really
00:38:21 important point just to finish very briefly ukrainians are giving their lives at this very
00:38:26 moment for one reason and one reason only they're being punished for wanting to move in a westward
00:38:32 direction that's why they want to be as free and as prosperous as we are and they've been wanting
00:38:38 to do that from the moment the soviet union collapsed my grandfather in 1991 in ukraine
00:38:44 a russian speaker all his life you know what the first thing that happened when the soviet union
00:38:47 collapsed started learning ukrainian my aunt russian speaker all her life speaks she'll forgive
00:38:53 me for saying this terrible ukrainian to this day but she speaks it because she wants her country to
00:38:58 move in a different direction uh in the first few years after the collapse of the soviet union
00:39:02 when double glazing became a thing in ukraine for the first time you know what they called it
00:39:07 euro windows because you everything european was seen as being this opportunity to make your life
00:39:16 better this is what people want and they're now suffering and dying to protect that desire and if
00:39:21 they're going to do that i think it behooves us to do everything we can to at least if we're not
00:39:26 going to help them as much as we can at least we should remember what we have here and value it
00:39:30 and treasure it well i mean i i you know this whole thing the ncf is based on on wanting to
00:39:38 value western civilization i i couldn't sympathize more i have to say you know you say western
00:39:44 civilization could be in danger um in my my worst times i can't help thinking we've gone on a bit
00:39:52 from that and that in fact it's sort of lost its mind and sometimes it's hard
00:39:57 when people say the world's going crazy you have to say even on
00:40:01 Twitter people say oh what's happening the world is going mad you say well I'm
00:40:04 afraid the world is not going mad actually it's the West and
00:40:08 particularly the angiospheric West which is having this nervous
00:40:11 breakdown you have to remember the majority of people in the West do not
00:40:16 haven't lost their minds it's the people who are running it same old thing
00:40:20 Yes. And we talked about hatred of Western elites, which is understandable, and it's pushing a lot of ordinary people to look elsewhere, let's say. But yes, I agree with you. I think, and the media has not been helpful on this either. If you look at Brexit and the election of Donald Trump, whatever the ugliness that came with both of those, and there was elements of that, I think it's true to say, those were popular revolts against Western elites that have lost their minds.
00:40:50 and the way the media tried to paint it as something else as you know these racist movements
00:40:56 or whatever was an attempt to suppress those revolts and the problem is that of course whenever
00:41:01 you suppress people's genuine democratic expressions the revolts only get uglier and
00:41:06 that's always been my concern as well the more the more the western elites who have lost their
00:41:11 minds try to impose this uh this craziness on the rest of us the uglier the backlash is going to be
00:41:16 And that's always been my concern. I'm not concerned about a bunch of woke people with pink hair running around screaming slogans.
00:41:24 I'm concerned about the provocation that's causing elsewhere and the reaction that could come against that,
00:41:29 which is why I think it's up to sensible people like us to go.
00:41:32 We don't need to go off that deep end and we don't need to go off this deep end.
00:41:36 We need to remember who we are, what our values are and make it OK to be proud to be British again, to be proud to be American.
00:41:43 You know, one of the things that boggles me as someone who is a casual observer of American politics, I don't remember the last time I heard someone on American TV say this is un-American or on British TV say this is un-British.
00:42:00 They used to say that. They don't anymore. And I wonder why that is.
00:42:03 You know, actually the one that the saying that I just never hear now, which was just all over
00:42:11 Kids right up to all people was it's a free country. Do what you like. It's a free country. Yeah
00:42:15 And I know that sounds frivolous, but actually these things are emblematic. People don't say it. They just don't say it
00:42:22 I mean, it's maybe a conversation for another time, but I
00:42:27 am
00:42:29 horrified by the change of attitude in
00:42:31 younger generation who don't care about free speech are quite open about not
00:42:38 caring in speech. They think hate, what they consider to be hate speech or
00:42:42 offensive speech, automatically trumps free speech. And this is shown in poll
00:42:48 after poll. There was one this week, I think. And these are all the things that
00:42:52 we have to do. It's a huge thing. The rot is very deep, I would say. I agree. But I
00:42:58 I am hopeful nonetheless, Peter.
00:42:59 I am hopeful because I think, you know, we've got to remember as well that many of these young people, they've been let down by our generation, my generation, your generation and generations before.
00:43:10 They have been the way they've been educated, the way they've been taught about these issues.
00:43:14 If people our age don't care.
00:43:17 I love it.
00:43:19 I've got 20 years on you, I think.
00:43:21 Well, if people if people your age and my age don't care about freedom, don't explain to their children why freedom is valuable.
00:43:28 don't talk about what happens in countries that are not free if people of our your age and my age
00:43:34 don't tell young people about yes slavery was bad but it was happening much worse in every other
00:43:40 part of the world at the same time yeah that arab slave traders took more slaves out of africa
00:43:45 than western europeans did and the death rate was higher right if we don't explain to people that
00:43:51 of course we should aim to move forward as a society and treat people as well as we can and
00:43:57 respect the rights of minorities and allow people to live their lives as they see fit without
00:44:01 hurting other people. But at the same time, at the same time, we mustn't get into this idea that
00:44:07 we're the worst people that have ever lived. We're not. We're not the worst people that have ever
00:44:11 lived. We are some of the freest, most prosperous people in the history of the world. This is one
00:44:16 of the most welcoming, open, tolerant countries in the history of human beings. And if we don't
00:44:22 teach our children that, if they're not hearing that message in their schools, in their universities,
00:44:26 on their tv on their radio then how are they supposed to think that freedom is great yeah
00:44:31 they're 20 years old they don't know anything when i knew when i was 20 years old i didn't
00:44:35 know anything either and if you're not hearing that message the message i've just given you
00:44:39 that the western civilization is great when was the last time you saw someone articulating that
00:44:44 point on national tv doesn't happen so why are we blaming a 20 year old for that point of view now
00:44:49 i still think some of the things that they're doing you know hounding professors out of
00:44:54 universities and things like that are wrong and bad and should be opposed and i do oppose them
00:44:58 but we've got to take responsibility we've got to take responsibility so my child is about to be
00:45:05 born and i'm going to make damn sure they understand you know they're going to be going
00:45:08 back to ukraine or other countries around and seeing how people live there so they understand
00:45:14 they understand the difference they understand the difference between a free society and a less
00:45:20 free society a prosperous society and a poor society and i want them to see that with their
00:45:25 own eyes and i think if more young people in the west had that opportunity uh we'd find a lot of
00:45:30 these things evaporate you know a friend of mine works in a school for children with behavioral
00:45:34 difficulties here in the uk and she told me the story about how they went on a school trip to
00:45:40 africa for a month uh and after this girl came back and saw how people live in africa
00:45:47 All her problems disappeared overnight.
00:45:50 A lot of the problems we face in the West are problems of our own success, Peter,
00:45:53 and it's up to us to solve them.
00:45:56 Well, look, that's quite inspiring, really, Constantine,
00:45:59 and particularly what you said about your coming, your child.
00:46:03 Thank you very, very much.
00:46:05 The book, as I said, is out in July.
00:46:08 You can order it.
00:46:09 An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West.
00:46:13 Thank you very much, Constantine.
00:46:15 i'm sure we'll be seeing you on this or that with the other channel very soon um but uh thank you
00:46:21 once again uh that's it for this week on so what you're saying is we shall see you next time thank
00:46:27 you very much hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel and you believe in our
00:46:34 mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website
00:46:41 newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for
00:46:49 the future but we can't do it without your support. From as little as three pounds per month you can
00:46:54 help ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits
00:47:01 including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events including here at our
00:47:08 studios, free copies of our books and much much more including, of course, our
00:47:14 famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then please help us by
00:47:20 clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely free, just
00:47:26 remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we
00:47:32 post new videos. Thank you.
00:47:38 You