New Culture Forum - May 04, 2021


Dominic Sandbrook - Labour, History, Education & Cancel Culture

Dr David Starkey: I Was Cancelled But I Wont Be Silenced For Speaking Objective Truth School Chaplain Reported To Terrorist Watchdog For LGBT Policy Sermon

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

183.0

Word count

8,030

Sentence count

140

Harmful content

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest this week is one of
00:00:27 our best-known and most successful historians. Dominic Sandbrook, who you might know from his
00:00:33 numerous appearances on television where he presents documentaries, is the author of numerous
00:00:38 history books. Perhaps best known is his huge history of Britain in the post-war period,
00:00:45 which covers politics, economics and culture. The most recent one, which came out, it's now in
00:00:53 paperback, is Who Dares Wins, which covers the period from 1979 to 1982, ends with the
00:01:01 Falklands Wars. He also writes for the Sunday Times and for the Daily Mail. Thank you very
00:01:08 much for joining us, Dominic. It's a pleasure. Thank you. I'm feeling very underdressed now
00:01:12 I see how dapper you are. They all say that. Dominic, I want to talk a bit about your books,
00:01:20 But first of all, you wrote a very interesting piece recently about the decline of Labour.
00:01:27 Yeah.
00:01:27 And I wanted to ask you, this will be going out later on this week.
00:01:34 There is the Hartlepool by-election.
00:01:37 And do you think this is a significant moment or could be for Labour?
00:01:44 I think so, because I think you would expect, you know, the government is more than a year into its term.
00:01:49 it's been managing a pandemic you would expect this to be a seat that Labour should win I mean
00:01:54 it's their own seat basically they used to have very healthy majorities in Hartlepool it's the
00:02:00 the sort of classic northern heartland seat that Labour always used to rely on and if they don't
00:02:05 win it or if they indeed I mean I think they probably will win it but I think they'll win
00:02:10 only very very narrowly if they do and you know that's an ominous result I think for Labour because
00:02:16 There's all this stuff about the sort of red wall seats, which you all know, Peter, and about the sort of inroads of the Brexit Party and before that UKIP made into Labour's vote.
00:02:25 And now Boris Johnson has made. There's always this assumption, you know, how the talk is always how will Labour win it back?
00:02:32 And there's always this sort of assumption that at some point they will win back, that these voters can be reconverted.
00:02:37 and the danger for Labour and I think you might see this in Hartlepool
00:02:41 is that actually the 2019 election was not an anomaly but was the beginning of something
00:02:47 a bit the analogy I would give would be when the Republican Party started winning the South
00:02:53 in America which had always previously been democratic and basically people you know never
00:02:57 went back and the danger for Labour I think is that they end up trapped between two they've
00:03:03 always had this tension i think peter between the sort of middle class idealists and often quite
00:03:10 small c conservative working class voters and i think that tension is becoming increasingly
00:03:15 unmanageable as voters tend to make up their minds on issues of identity and culture and so on and
00:03:20 obviously brexit was a huge part of that and i think for starmer if he doesn't you know win
00:03:26 comfortably in Hartlepool that looks pretty ominous for the 2024 election. In your books
00:03:33 obviously you've charted the post-war political scene and I mean the if you like the genesis of
00:03:40 these problems was quite a long time ago wasn't it for Labour really? Yeah I think so I mean I
00:03:46 think if you you're absolutely right that you know I've been writing about Britain since the 50s
00:03:53 really and even as early as about nine as 1968 actually let's take 1968 so in 1968 Enoch Powell
00:04:01 made his famous you know the speech that we remember as the rivers of blood speech
00:04:05 and in his diaries at the time the Labour cabinet minister Richard Crossman said
00:04:09 you know this is really a problem for us because a lot of our voters agree with him and even at that
00:04:16 point so you know very early on there was this sense of an emerging tension between the kind
00:04:22 of people who basically ran the Labour Party and the kind of people that they expected to turn out
00:04:27 every five years to vote for it and I think that has you know it's been getting worse over time
00:04:33 and the other problem of course for Labour is it's a Victorian political party that's rooted
00:04:39 I mean it's very name you know the Labour Party is kind of rooted in this world that basically
00:04:42 is gone I mean you'll know as well as I do that that sort of world of you know everybody lived
00:04:48 in back-to-backs they worked in their local factory they went to their local football club
00:04:52 on a Saturday they there was a pub at one end of the street and a kind of Methodist chapel at the
00:04:56 other I mean that world has gone and and Labour has struggled I think to adjust to a world in
00:05:02 which people see themselves much more as individual consumers than a sort of class bound in the way
00:05:09 that they were in the 1930s or something. What do you think the chances are Dominic of Labour
00:05:15 sort of even giving up the pretense of being a working class party for the reasons you said
00:05:20 and becoming a radical middle-class party?
00:05:26 Well, that might seem an obvious way to go.
00:05:28 So you look at the Greens in Germany.
00:05:31 Labour could try to evolve into a party like that
00:05:33 or a party like the Democrats in the United States.
00:05:36 The problem, though, isn't that, you know,
00:05:38 they are the second party in the first-past-the-post system.
00:05:41 So that would mean giving up on an awful lot of seats.
00:05:44 I mean, hundreds of seats, basically.
00:05:46 And, you know, what's saying leader of the opposition?
00:05:50 writes off, you know, 150 otherwise, you know, hopefully reliable seats and gambles that they
00:05:59 can win lots of, you know, leafy suburban southern English seats. I think that would be incredibly
00:06:07 reckless. I mean, the danger is that you just win neither. So I think in a way that the electoral
00:06:12 system might, the danger for Labour actually is the electoral system will trap them as a zombie
00:06:16 party they'll always finish second you know they'll never even in 2019 under Jeremy Corbyn
00:06:23 I mean they won a lot of seats um not enough but they still won you know more than 200 seats
00:06:29 so the I mean that's right isn't it they won about 200 seats I can't remember exactly how many
00:06:35 102 I think yes yeah so they the danger is you know if that if you assume that that that's
00:06:42 roughly the floor and that the ceiling could be you know 280 or something that they just end up
00:06:50 permanently uh trapped around that and that perhaps over time they are eroded um by the
00:06:59 Tories uh and that they turn into a sort of I mean you know could they make it as a kind of
00:07:05 superior version of the Lib Dems I don't know um I think the danger they have now is of course the
00:07:10 tourists are slightly stealing their clothes you know if you're if you want a party that's
00:07:16 leveling up to use boris's jargon and uh you know doling out the cash and all that sort of stuff
00:07:21 why would you choose labor when you've got one in government as it is yes yes you mentioned there
00:07:28 about that way of life going you're working class back to back pub on the corner and of course
00:07:34 football uh played a big part in that has played a big part and i you wrote a i mean i don't mean
00:07:40 being well i'm about to be ingratiating but you oh great good you wrote a beautiful piece i thought
00:07:47 in unheard recently about this super league thing that basically rose up hugely and has suddenly
00:07:54 gone as quickly um yeah but and about the effect this would have but you were writing about football
00:08:01 as being a faith in a part a cultural of such cultural importance were you surprised that there
00:08:07 There was such a reaction to that deal when it came up.
00:08:11 Were you surprised at the hostility?
00:08:14 No, not really, because I think actually what's happened,
00:08:16 it's funny, I was only talking to somebody the other day about this,
00:08:19 about how so many of these other working class institutions have died.
00:08:23 And that means that football has actually acquired even more importance
00:08:25 because it really is the only one of those things left, actually.
00:08:28 And I think a lot of people feel that it's now, you know,
00:08:33 if you live in in Bolton or Bury or you know or Wolverhampton the team I support
00:08:39 the football team is really the only local institution left that feels distinctive and
00:08:47 of which you can be proud and that binds people in the kind of area together and so I think a lot
00:08:52 of people feel that you know if that if that league had happened almost certainly the the
00:08:59 remaining teams the rest of the football league would have been kind of eviscerated because the
00:09:03 money would have followed the super league they wouldn't have got some the tv deals would have
00:09:06 collapsed and they would have you know been in real trouble as that's already happened in bury
00:09:11 actually where their team went out of business and i think a lot of people just sort of felt
00:09:15 you know we will lose something quite precious and it's not just about the game it's about
00:09:20 an institution that has deep historic roots that meant something to my parents and to my
00:09:25 grandparents and to to sort of the people who lived in this place before us and if we lose that
00:09:32 then we're left with nothing because our city centre or our town centres have been hollowed out
00:09:38 you know talent and money has all flowed to London and lots of parts of the country people
00:09:45 feel abandoned and they feel they feel sort of undervalued I think that's a huge part of it they
00:09:50 feel kind of culturally neglected and actually having that team you know if you live in I mean
00:09:55 I despise West Bromwich Albion but if you live in West Bromwich you know having a Premier League
00:10:00 team or at least a yo-yo club um it's something that you can genuinely be proud it's the one
00:10:06 thing for which your area is known and that gives it kind of meaning to a lot of people
00:10:10 and i think that's actually it is a bit of a faith in the sense it's a weekly ritual um and
00:10:16 it's replaced the rituals of old and without it i think people would feel adrift kind of rudderless
00:10:21 and abandoned yes i mean i think that you you put it very nicely in this article i've got to
00:10:25 i'm going to quote you back at yourself here but uh uh yes you said saying that football clubs
00:10:32 are just businesses is like saying the medieval church was just a landowner
00:10:36 um but the thing is is in in a way you know in a way isn't that sort of
00:10:42 the people who just see it as a business um you know they would be if you like the free
00:10:48 marketeers would they not they they would be the people who see the the you know the everything is
00:10:53 a balance sheet wouldn't they yes they would exactly i mean i don't think um uh there's always
00:11:01 this belief that sort of conservative minded people do see life purely as a balance sheet i
00:11:05 mean this is the sort of accusation that you often get from sort of left liberalish people
00:11:09 but actually the people who are most in favor of the super league were sort of economics writers
00:11:14 for the new yorker yeah who you know kind of quite woke people who who you know see nothing wrong
00:11:20 with clubs being unmoored from their traditional communities. 0.99
00:11:23 I mean, to them, the traditional communities are the problem,
00:11:25 not the sort of solution. 1.00
00:11:28 So, yes, I think there is...
00:11:31 The interesting thing is that it took football to do this, nothing else.
00:11:34 So our high streets have been kind of hollowed out.
00:11:37 Everybody shops at Amazon.
00:11:39 In other walks of life, as it were, globalisation has prevailed.
00:11:44 But football, precisely because of what you said,
00:11:47 there's kind of a religious faith element to it.
00:11:50 Because it sort of tugs at people's hearts and minds.
00:11:54 This was the one thing that millions of people were just determined to draw a line in the sand and say, no, you won't, you know, you won't come for our game.
00:12:02 And I think it's really interesting that it was football, something that's really ultimately most people know deep down is a kind of trivial thing.
00:12:13 But it mattered. And if people think it matters, it matters. And that's what's so interesting about it.
00:12:18 exactly in fact in in your book who dares wins you know the latest in your uh series about
00:12:24 british british history i wasn't it during this period that football was at its lowest ebb uh
00:12:31 yeah on the early early 80s so it sort of came back didn't it was it in the 90s i guess
00:12:37 yes it was it was um it's a really interesting story so in the 1980s you would i think reasonably
00:12:44 have assumed that football would probably die or that it would become a a a mere hobby a sort of
00:12:51 antiquated hobby in some ways um because attendances had been falling for 20 years the stadiums were
00:12:57 crumbling there were disgraces obviously the game's utterly overshadowed by hooligan violence i mean
00:13:02 every saturday you know you go through the the newspapers from the time every single saturday
00:13:07 there were reports of real trouble sort of quite vicious trouble and of course when english teams
00:13:13 went abroad they exported the hooliganism they took it with them um there's an example i give
00:13:19 in the book of mrs thatcher goes to a european council meeting in italy in 1980 and it's when
00:13:24 she's asking for our money back if you remember yeah for our budget rebate and so she's sort of
00:13:30 on the war path but it's quite early in her first term so she's finding her way and she wants to
00:13:35 make a good impression on all these european leaders and she's there precisely the same time
00:13:40 the england football team were playing in the european championships uh in rome and she had
00:13:45 she had had a reception at downing street um to see them off and she had been photographed on the
00:13:51 steps of number 10 and the step outside with um emilyne hughes and kevin keegan kissing her
00:13:56 um so they were the sort of senior players so she had slightly wrapped herself in the england
00:14:01 team's flag and they went and the hooligans behaved abysmally uh the italian police used
00:14:08 tear gas to try and clear the hooligans which then went onto the pitch so the players had to
00:14:15 come off in tears and then the game was resumed you know it was utterly it was unbelievably 0.71
00:14:20 humiliating for for English football and of course the cameras went to I think she was in Venice
00:14:26 and she gives an interview in Venice and you can see that she's you know she's humiliated it's
00:14:34 incredibly embarrassing for her to come out of this meeting and have to basically apologise for
00:14:38 her fans. And I think at that point, you know, English football or football generally was a
00:14:46 sort of, it was a disgrace. It was a disgrace on the national kind of flag. And what changed it
00:14:54 was obviously new money, globalisation, satellite television. Famously, England did quite well at
00:15:03 the 1990 world cup and paul gascoigne cried on tv and lots of people got behind you know some
00:15:08 middle class people got behind the game um so it really is a kind of you know ugly duckling story
00:15:14 you wouldn't have expected at that point football to have to have revived yes it's interesting you
00:15:18 say their middle some middle class people got um got behind the game that's how i remember in the
00:15:24 90s it suddenly became sort of almost part of the middle class uh quite self-conscious lad culture
00:15:31 do you remember that period i remember it well because i'm of that generation so you know i went
00:15:36 up to university in 1993 and uh i was absolutely that generation where the lad culture kind of
00:15:43 came in and the sort of slightly affected kind of middle class enthusiasm for football i mean
00:15:49 tony blair famously said remember jackie watching jackie milburn play for newcastle despite the fact
00:15:54 that jackie milburn had retired before he was born um and um yeah there was this sort of i mean
00:16:01 that would have been that just simply didn't happen in the 60s and 70s you know politicians
00:16:05 didn't pretend to they didn't feel the need to like football because football hadn't been
00:16:09 fashionable and then it did it absolutely did become fashionable um in the 90s um and i think
00:16:16 that's obviously once hooliganism had been dealt with you said you went to up to uh sheffield
00:16:21 you said sheffield i'm sorry it was no uh i taught at sheffield later on i was at oxford
00:16:26 You taught at Sheffield. But you started off, did you not, Dominic, as a specialist in American history?
00:16:32 I did. I did.
00:16:33 You know, you are the chronicler of post-war Britain now.
00:16:37 But I wonder, this is a fascinating time for American history, is it not?
00:16:42 I mean, I would say depressing.
00:16:44 But, you know, this is, I wonder what your thoughts on this were.
00:16:47 It seems to me that America, which has always played a big part in my life anyway,
00:16:52 has sort of actually entirely changed.
00:16:54 It's changed in its nature.
00:16:56 I mean, do you think that's the case?
00:16:59 I do think it's, I think all the problems are quite deep rooted.
00:17:03 I mean, they have historic roots and obviously, you know, the legacy of slavery is a huge part of it. 0.79
00:17:09 And obviously, things like the gun culture have always been, you know, been there for as long as America has existed because it's a frontier society.
00:17:17 But there's no doubt that since, let's say, the 1980s or the 1990s, something has changed.
00:17:24 And I think America has lost its sense of self-confidence.
00:17:28 I think it's turned inwards. 0.99
00:17:30 And obviously part of that is because of Iraq and so on.
00:17:35 But there has been a kind of hyper-polarisation of American politics.
00:17:39 There's no common ground.
00:17:42 There is a sort of tolerance of violence generally and extremism
00:17:46 and incredibly strident, aggressive kind of rhetoric and behaviour
00:17:50 that you just don't really see on this side of the atlantic and the sad thing is actually peter
00:17:57 that it's hard to see how it would ever be resolved i mean i was only talking um last week
00:18:02 to a bbc correspondent in america who's lived in america for years and he was saying you know in
00:18:06 the time that he's been there um all these problems have kind of been there in embryo
00:18:11 but they have so clearly got worse and the sense of any sort of national solidarity or common ground
00:18:19 or self-confidence in the world just seems so out of reach and I can't remember a time where America
00:18:25 you know I grew up as probably you did America was the future America was modern and it was free
00:18:32 and it was exciting and I don't think young people think that anymore I think they think
00:18:36 of America as a basket case which is incredibly sad yes I think so it was sort of one went there
00:18:42 was always you know the feeling was oh well if things got really bad there's always America you
00:18:47 know um and that has entirely uh disappeared i i would just thought one thing that's particularly
00:18:54 fascinating i'd love to hear what you think as an historian there is this move now uh which is not
00:19:00 that covered here um to entirely change the basis of american history in this 1619 project yeah which
00:19:07 started off i believe as a new york times initiative and is now being taught in schools
00:19:13 yes can you explain what that actually is about so yes so this is something i'm not um
00:19:20 a great favor of i have to say so it's a project um thoughts sort of dreamed up at the new york
00:19:26 times and they've exported in this sort of evangelizing way and it's basically to recast
00:19:31 the whole of american history to say that we didn't start in 1776 it's not all about the
00:19:36 founding fathers and breaking away from britain the starting point of american history they
00:19:41 argues when the first slaves are brought to america and they basically try to recast the
00:19:46 entirety of american history through the that you know it's all a story about slavery and race
00:19:51 and racism and um what's so interesting about it is that particularly older sort of professional
00:19:59 historians academic historians people who you know incredibly um erudite respected
00:20:06 historians basically said well this is rubbish um it's it's not it's it's too um
00:20:13 one note uh yes of course slavery and race are part of the story but they're not the whole story
00:20:20 you can't reduce the whole thing just to this sort of simplistic morality story but they've
00:20:26 been drowned out basically uh particularly by younger historians who sort of say you know shut
00:20:30 up granddad um you know you're part of the problem not the solution and this sort of it's sort of
00:20:36 it's the historical reflection of this kind of woke movement and it basically what i dislike about
00:20:42 it and it does there are parallels in britain actually sadly um is i think it reduces the
00:20:49 complexity of history to this sort of good versus evil you know black hats versus white hats um
00:20:55 villains and victims uh story where basically everything is about race and racism and and if
00:21:02 you know you want to tell a different story well you're not you know you have difficulty in finding
00:21:07 an audience yes and the fact that they're they're pushing this into schools i i really find that
00:21:13 very objectionable i mean i think schools should you know have a lot more well they shouldn't be
00:21:20 dictated to um to tell a very they shouldn't be force-fed a very politically partisan but also
00:21:28 kind of one note and slightly simplistic view of their own history and and a history that's
00:21:33 they've basically been turned into a colossal exercise in kind of self-flagellation and kind
00:21:38 of victimhood um and yes that is an it is an american story but it's also increasingly becoming
00:21:44 a british one as well um and i i it's a sort of what i dislike about it personally it's not
00:21:50 it's not that i think these things shouldn't be discussed of course they should they're part of
00:21:54 history. But I hate the premise, which is often, oh, we've been lying, people have been lying to
00:22:01 us about history, and this elite conspiracy have been covering up the truth. And now we've found
00:22:05 the truth, which is that there are goodies and baddies. I mean, I just think that's an incredibly
00:22:10 simplistic and shallow way to think about the complexity of the past.
00:22:14 I actually had conversations last year during the whole statues thing with people very much along
00:22:20 those lines actually you know where they said oh well now we know i didn't know said this person
00:22:25 i didn't know that nelson you know was a slave trade of course he's not nothing like yeah but
00:22:33 somehow and so therefore he should come down things like that yes that it's that level is it
00:22:38 not of as they say a little learning is a dangerous thing isn't it it is exactly that because almost
00:22:43 all the things that are the supposedly great revelatory discoveries they have been known
00:22:48 actually they've been known for years and people have often talked about them what happened is that
00:22:53 people didn't think they were the be-all and end-all so they weren't always center stage
00:22:57 and as you say there is a slight element of little learning so people will often say you
00:23:00 often hear now you know i wasn't taught this in schools it's a disgrace that i wasn't taught this
00:23:05 in schools but i mean there's lots of things you're not taught in schools no one's stopping
00:23:07 you from going and finding it out and you're not and maybe you're not being taught it in schools
00:23:12 because kids are only doing 40 minutes of history a week it's not because it's being deliberately
00:23:15 suppressed um the idea that there's only one story that should be told and it has to be this story of
00:23:22 in britain's case of you know evil imperialists and sort of you know saintly victims and martyrs
00:23:29 um i just think it's it's just it's actually what i really dislike about it peter quite apart from
00:23:34 the politics of it is that it's stupid i think it's just a really stupid way to think about the
00:23:39 past of course you know let's say Churchill Churchill was this incredibly interesting rich
00:23:48 character and because he was human as in he was made from cut from the same you know cloth as
00:23:54 anybody else he's flesh and blood as we are he wasn't perfect you know surprise surprise now I
00:24:00 read you know oh we've just discovered that Churchill said some some off-color things or he
00:24:05 or he made mistakes or whatever as though this is this great revelation but of course by definition
00:24:10 I mean he was a human being it doesn't diminish his greatness or it diminishes great qualities
00:24:15 to say you know he wasn't this sort of divine demigod like figure and the same with Nelson
00:24:22 and the same with all these kind of heroes of history of course they had feet of clay because
00:24:26 they're human beings I don't think it's actually terribly interesting to sort of focus in on the
00:24:31 feet of clay to the exclusion of all else i think what's interesting about them are the the you know
00:24:38 the other things they got right as much as the things they got wrong and i just worry that
00:24:43 so much of our story is being reduced to this very very um sort of as i said kind of simplistic
00:24:51 you know almost kind of sort of ladybird history but but but actually that's mean to ladybird
00:24:57 history ladybird history was often much more nuanced than some of these sort of versions that
00:25:01 you get now well i i grew up on them so i mean do you do you uh have anything do you speak at
00:25:07 schools do you have anything to do with schools do you uh you do i mean yeah i do well my actually
00:25:15 you know the funny thing is that i do speak at schools and and um i i think sometimes people get
00:25:22 the wrong idea both about teachers and about students so actually a lot of teachers are not
00:25:26 are you know completely dedicated reasonable interested open-minded people the idea that
00:25:36 they're all kind of slaves to wokishness is actually not right and that's true of students
00:25:40 too the great trouble that they're great one of the great tragedies of the way we talk about higher 0.99
00:25:45 education for example is that the only people that generally get quoted or paid attention to
00:25:50 are that tiny minority of kind of active,
00:25:54 the people who bother to care about the student union.
00:25:57 And of course, the great majority of students
00:25:58 are completely normal.
00:25:59 So often I've gone to give talks at universities
00:26:03 and sometimes I'll go and I think,
00:26:05 is this the moment, you know, when I get cancelled?
00:26:08 Is this the moment when the student's sort of obeying mob
00:26:11 sort of drives me out into the gutter or something?
00:26:15 And it never is because the majority of students
00:26:18 are just like students have always been.
00:26:19 They're open-minded, reasonable, tolerant, curious, intelligent people.
00:26:26 And, of course, there's a small minority.
00:26:29 And what's a shame is when you allow that tiny minority to dictate.
00:26:35 So, for example, at Liverpool, the University of Liverpool has cancelled Gladstone 0.96
00:26:39 because he spoke up for his family's interests in the Caribbean, his slaving interests.
00:26:45 the fact that Gladstone then went on to become you know this great progressive reformer of the
00:26:52 Victorian era I mean that's completely forgotten that's not good enough and actually the vast
00:26:56 majority I would think of students and probably of staff at the University of Liverpool would
00:27:00 never dream of cancelling Gladstone but it's so often the very noisy strident sort of over
00:27:08 enthusiastic idealistic minority who get their way because other people have got better things to do
00:27:14 than to and to fight the fight we we've we've got this actually this week most uh recently with isaac
00:27:20 newton uh who uh is just they're lapping around you know lapping at the shores of isaac newton
00:27:27 but the point is though so i was i you know i see what you mean about the numbers and
00:27:32 you know there's a very vociferous uh minority the it would appear that the punishment for possibly
00:27:39 standing up for something uh is just too great now for people they they don't want to be cast out
00:27:45 and and there's a very strong chance if you if you say for example i think we should leave
00:27:50 cecil rhodes alone or something then wow you're going to get it aren't you yeah i think you're
00:27:55 right so for example on the roads thing um i always said and said many times in my columns
00:28:02 in the daily mail probably boring the readers into into a stupor um that roads should not come down
00:28:08 i don't believe any statues should come down actually i think if you're on the side of people
00:28:12 who are toppling statues that's a pretty bad place to be uh but of course it's easy for me to say that
00:28:18 because you know i'm a daily mail colonist so that's kind of what people expect to some extent
00:28:25 but academics that i knew i mean i knew people i know people at oxford who said to me they didn't
00:28:33 think road should fall but they would never say so publicly they were afraid to um and and you
00:28:39 know people sometimes think oh this is probably exaggerated or this is all sensationalized and
00:28:43 it's not really like this but to give you an example peter i have a good friend at cambridge
00:28:49 who was told he's not british um he was told when he were he was seen reading the times
00:28:57 in the senior common room of his college and somebody said to him oh god you're reading a
00:29:03 kind of fascist newspaper um that's a big a big a big statement you know to be reading the sports
00:29:09 section in the times at lunch um and he said you know there are people who think that and there is
00:29:16 a kind of if you if you persist in these views or or that sort of thing then you then then the
00:29:23 you know you might not be driven out of the profession but people will just say
00:29:27 oh he's the conservative one and you'll be stuck with this kind of label
00:29:30 which means you might you know you might not get invited to things or people say oh
00:29:34 I mean I can remember a case at Oxford about 15 years ago when
00:29:38 they were inviting a visiting speaker from America
00:29:42 a professor to come and speak and somebody said in the meeting to agree to
00:29:47 invite him they said yeah I agree we should invite him we should invite him but
00:29:50 he's actually a bit of a centrist,
00:29:52 so I think we should have someone from the left for balance.
00:29:58 And, you know, that's obviously how it works.
00:30:01 And so what you end up with this is the culture in institutions.
00:30:04 I mean, universities are part of it,
00:30:05 but also arts institutions and so on,
00:30:07 where, frankly, I mean, I've said it in my column,
00:30:11 you know, it can be a bit of a culture of appeasement, you know.
00:30:15 People outside shout and scream, and they can be, you're right,
00:30:18 I mean they're a small minority but they can be very influential they shout and scream and the
00:30:23 university or the institution are like oh my god we can't allow a twitter storm so we'll give into
00:30:28 them and time and again you see people giving in and I just think they should have more of a
00:30:32 flipping backbone and sometimes they should say to you know students or to activists okay you've
00:30:37 had your say we don't agree with you you know the statue's going to stay up we're still going to
00:30:41 teach x y z or whatever it might be you know to just show a bit of spirit rather than sort of
00:30:47 constantly abasing yourself before this sort of self-appointed little activist group who have a
00:30:55 very kind of religious zeal actually don't they yeah with with your books i mean i don't know
00:31:02 whether you would you say you're a daily mail columnist whether you're perceived as a conservative
00:31:07 historian or or or what but i mean is there i mean what are some of the conversations that i've
00:31:13 have with people on this programme. They talk endlessly about the particular problem with
00:31:19 publishing, i.e. that publishing now is very, very left-wing. And I just wondered whether,
00:31:25 you know, you don't have problems getting your books published. Presumably that's because they
00:31:30 sell. Is that the case? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I suppose they sell, but also the books, my history
00:31:39 books aren't dictated by a political agenda i wouldn't say so so so people sometimes you're
00:31:43 right people sometimes say uh oh he writes for the daily mail therefore his books must be a sort
00:31:48 of conservative tirade um but but i mean as you know as you know if you've they're actually
00:31:55 probably much more boring than that um and uh they don't particularly they are actually very
00:32:00 sort of matter of fact in the best sense it seems to me um but the one thing that i i have picked
00:32:07 up with them, which I respond to very much, is that you tend to shed new light where things
00:32:14 have been portrayed as, for example, the 60s, hugely counter-cultural, this happening, that
00:32:19 happened. You fill in the background and say, well, actually, you know, life was going on
00:32:24 very much the same. I remember there was one particular thing that stuck out in my mind
00:32:27 in White Heat, which was that the 60s, you know, flower power, counter-revolution, the
00:32:35 biggest selling album was the soundtrack to the sound of music i believe yeah yeah that's right
00:32:43 so it goes against this kind of idea yes and i think there's a danger so what you get with
00:32:51 historians probably by and large tend to be sort of left liberal people and so they look they look
00:32:56 at history and they look for people like themselves i mean we all did that to some extent
00:33:00 and from the start I thought you know it's much more interesting to look at actually
00:33:05 as much as possible at the great majority you know what were the most popular things what were
00:33:10 people doing were they going to orgies and all that sort of you know happenings and sit-ins or
00:33:15 were they garden you know mowing the lawn and often the answer is they're mowing the lawn and
00:33:21 one thing I've tried to do throughout this that entire series is to sort of you know obviously
00:33:29 there's lots about the great and the good and there's also lots about the sort of more sort of
00:33:33 eye-catching extremes but always you know what are people doing in Northampton yeah what are
00:33:37 people doing in Worcester you know what's life actually like for ordinary people um you know
00:33:43 and actually that's probably one reason why publishers do like them is because they they
00:33:47 obviously strike a chord um among people who weren't necessarily you know the great and the
00:33:52 good they weren't on Carnaby Street in 1966 or they weren't you know doing sort of sit-ins in
00:33:58 the in the 70s or going on anti-Thatcher demonstrations in the 80s or Greenham Common
00:34:04 I mean those things are all in the books and you know I try to sort of treat them properly but
00:34:10 to me there's as much sort of drama and interest often in the life of somebody who's bought their
00:34:16 first council house in 1982 or you know a young family starting out on the sort of
00:34:22 on the road together through kind of life and work in the 70s or something going on the first
00:34:29 foreign holiday the first car all that sort of stuff I mean it's sort of finding you know
00:34:34 excitement and interest maybe excitement is quite a strong word but interest in the mundane details
00:34:41 of life in an age that actually now seems in some ways like sort of ancient history I was actually
00:34:46 going to make that very point it's astonishing when I with Who Dares Wins for example which is
00:34:51 1979 to 1982 um well i was you know just coming out of university it does feel like a totally
00:35:00 different world and indeed i think it it was a different world actually but um one thing that
00:35:06 is is in here too and i find fascinating is during this short period of three years there
00:35:12 there was particularly in after 1980 this kind of very odd sort of counter counter revolution
00:35:19 in culture uh you know we can put them all together uh you know chariots of fire the royal
00:35:26 wedding the uh falklands the new romantics it was like this sudden and also a lot of elgar around
00:35:34 and warm williams and things like that you know it's extraordinary that you know you pick all of
00:35:38 that up because you would have been what uh in your teenage years then no not yet i was i'm i'm
00:35:45 i'm a i'm a you know a pygmy in years um i was uh not even 10 i was about eight or nine yeah
00:35:52 why did you know go ahead why did you why did you decide to write this sort of history then
00:35:58 um i think i was fascinated with the day before yesterday um the sort of period that my parents
00:36:07 had grown up in um and um i suppose i started writing them as well at the moment when that
00:36:13 was dead when that period was dead so that I started writing at the point when the internet
00:36:17 had arrived when Britain was much more globalized when the days of kind of orange juice as a starter
00:36:22 um belong to history and you know the sort of British Leyland era if you like and I just sort
00:36:29 of thought you know I found it fascinating because it was I couldn't I could just remember it but not
00:36:35 quite and I just thought you know nobody else is doing this and I just think I just thought it was
00:36:41 great i just thought it was a great period and i also thought the fun that the trick would be to
00:36:47 to weave together yeah you know margaret thatcher and harold wilson with paul mccartney and david
00:36:53 bowie and you know uh the football and and tv and all that sort of stuff so yeah i mean it was it is
00:37:02 a vanished world peter i think you're right i think there's lots of things in it um you know
00:37:09 the holidays the what people ate their clothes and all that they watched what they watched on
00:37:15 what they watched on tv but you're right as well actually i at that point you make about there
00:37:20 being a um a cultural shift in the early 80s is absolutely right i think what actually happened
00:37:26 was it was a the 70s been so grim um that there was just a yearning for escapism and then of
00:37:33 course i mean people forget that you know after 1979 at first things got so much worse with the
00:37:38 massive unemployment and the rioting in the streets and so on and the government seemed to
00:37:42 have no it's to have completely lost control of the economy and all of that sort of brideshead
00:37:48 revisited you know people in cricket jumpers kind of slow rangers yeah yeah slow rangers exactly i
00:37:54 think a lot of that comes from this sort of desire people had the desire for escapism and a desire
00:37:58 for glamour and theatricality and also patriotism actually i think that's one of the biggest things
00:38:04 that this period bequeathed was it revived this sort of patriotic populism if you like it's what
00:38:11 mrs thatcher capitalized on the falklands that basically if you were 20 in 1980 all your life
00:38:19 you just heard about the flag coming down in one way or another so the end of the british empire
00:38:24 the loss of all these colonies but also just devaluation of the currency three-day week bail
00:38:29 out from the imf winter discontent you know this sort of sense of britain being a bit of a failed
00:38:34 state and people there was this yearning you know and that's why when the falklands war happened
00:38:39 even you know lots of die-hard labour voters who hated margaret thatcher said well i respect her
00:38:47 for getting the task force to the south atlantic getting the islands back she said what i mean
00:38:53 there's a quote at the end of the book from a birmingham shop steward and he says you know
00:38:56 um i've never thought of voting conservative before but i am thinking about it now because
00:39:02 of Maggie because she said what she was going to do and she did it and and I think basically the
00:39:06 previous 20 years there's been an awful lot of saying what we're going to do and not doing it
00:39:10 um and I think that's one of I mean that's probably what she'll be apart from being the
00:39:14 first woman prime minister is that sort of patriotic side yeah that I think it explains
00:39:19 her place in our national imagination I think so I mean at the the 10 years you know the 79 to 89
00:39:26 90 uh there was a transformation you felt for example if you were conservative like i was at
00:39:32 the time you felt that you were on the winning side that was it but also there was a sort of
00:39:38 sense that we weren't going to have managed decline anymore you know that was that was the
00:39:42 big thing um i mean when is the next one coming out and what period will it cover are you allowed
00:39:49 to tell us that or i am yeah no uh the next one will be not for a few years um because of something
00:39:55 and I'll just tell you in a sec.
00:39:57 And the next one will be really,
00:39:59 the hinge of the next one will be The Miner's Strike.
00:40:01 So it'll be going into the sort of middle of the 80s,
00:40:04 so you've obviously got the big bang coming in the city and so on,
00:40:06 but The Miner's Strike is the sort of big confrontation
00:40:09 that gives it, you know, its flavour.
00:40:12 And the reason it's going to be a few years
00:40:13 is because I've just spent the last year
00:40:15 starting a new series of history books for children
00:40:18 called Adventures in Time,
00:40:22 and they're sort of, you know, non-fiction narrative history,
00:40:24 but for sort of 9, 10, 11 year olds
00:40:27 because my son is 9
00:40:29 and I was trying to find something for him
00:40:32 he was doing evacuees at school
00:40:36 was his topic
00:40:36 and he said he wanted to read a book
00:40:38 about the Second World War
00:40:39 and I couldn't quite find the right thing
00:40:40 and I said to my editors at Penguin
00:40:42 you know, it's weird how no one's done this
00:40:45 how Max Hastings hasn't done
00:40:46 a kind of kid's version
00:40:48 and you know, why don't I do it?
00:40:51 So I have started doing it
00:40:53 I grew up at school on R.J. Unstead. Do you remember him?
00:40:58 Everybody, yeah. Everybody who says they like R.J. Unstead.
00:41:01 And they are like, I loved R.J. Unstead. Exactly.
00:41:05 Well, so there's one on the Second World War.
00:41:08 Are these books out now? Sorry, Dominic.
00:41:10 No, no, they're coming out.
00:41:13 The first couple are coming out in the summer.
00:41:15 And then there's two more coming out in the autumn.
00:41:17 And then hopefully some more in a year or two.
00:41:21 So they're called Adventures in Time.
00:41:22 and the first two are, perhaps not unpredictably,
00:41:26 the Second World War and the Six Wives of Henry VIII.
00:41:29 And then in the autumn, there's the First World War
00:41:31 and Alexander the Great,
00:41:32 and then some more to follow thereafter.
00:41:35 Oh, fantastic.
00:41:36 Oh, that's very, that's great to hear.
00:41:39 You know, it's wonderful.
00:41:41 And so, and then in the fullness of time,
00:41:43 there'll be the miners' strike,
00:41:45 and then you've got your whole Blair period, haven't you?
00:41:47 Can I just ask, because people often ask these sort of things
00:41:50 when they when they put comments down on how you know these are huge volumes i mean how long does
00:41:56 it take you to to write one of these um well i'm doing other things that slightly depends on yes
00:42:04 it's very hard to to answer because i'm always sort of juggling but it takes a few years you
00:42:09 know it probably takes um four years maybe i guess uh there's a lot of um i do all the research first
00:42:19 yeah and then i write it up i've been doing the research has become it's become both easier and
00:42:24 harder because of the internet so in that book who dares wins um all the thatcher stuff so all
00:42:30 her papers are online they've been digitized by the thatcher foundation it's amazing website
00:42:34 so the margaret thatcher foundation website and that's both a blessing and a curse it's a blessing
00:42:38 because you can look up everything straight and get it straight away but it's a curse because
00:42:42 all the stuff is there so there's almost no excuse not to go through it all so i probably spent about
00:42:47 18 months just sort of scrolling through endless pdfs of sort of margaret thatcher's paperwork
00:42:53 and i couldn't quite tell where my life ended and hers began as it were so probably like how
00:42:58 charles moore feels um so yeah well look i mean thank you so much for for joining us today it's
00:43:05 been fantastic really has i mean i can't recommend these books enough they don't need my recommendation
00:43:12 because many people, I mean, the critics praise them to the skies.
00:43:16 But anyway, the latest one, Who Dares Wins, in paperback.
00:43:23 Excellent stuff.
00:43:24 And we will look out as well for the Adventures in Time,
00:43:28 which I think is, you are performing a public service by doing that, actually,
00:43:34 because particularly for kids now.
00:43:37 Dominic, thank you very much.
00:43:39 Thank you. Thank you for having me. It's been a great pleasure.
00:43:40 lovely thank you so much that's it for so what you're saying is this week and we
00:43:45 shall see you next time but in the meantime please do subscribe with you
00:43:49 thanks so much