00:01:37And do you think this is a significant moment or could be for Labour?
00:01:44I think so, because I think you would expect, you know, the government is more than a year into its term.
00:01:49it's been managing a pandemic you would expect this to be a seat that Labour should win I mean
00:01:54it's their own seat basically they used to have very healthy majorities in Hartlepool it's the
00:02:00the sort of classic northern heartland seat that Labour always used to rely on and if they don't
00:02:05win it or if they indeed I mean I think they probably will win it but I think they'll win
00:02:10only very very narrowly if they do and you know that's an ominous result I think for Labour because
00:02:16There's all this stuff about the sort of red wall seats, which you all know, Peter, and about the sort of inroads of the Brexit Party and before that UKIP made into Labour's vote.
00:02:25And now Boris Johnson has made. There's always this assumption, you know, how the talk is always how will Labour win it back?
00:02:32And there's always this sort of assumption that at some point they will win back, that these voters can be reconverted.
00:02:37and the danger for Labour and I think you might see this in Hartlepool
00:02:41is that actually the 2019 election was not an anomaly but was the beginning of something
00:02:47a bit the analogy I would give would be when the Republican Party started winning the South
00:02:53in America which had always previously been democratic and basically people you know never
00:02:57went back and the danger for Labour I think is that they end up trapped between two they've
00:03:03always had this tension i think peter between the sort of middle class idealists and often quite
00:03:10small c conservative working class voters and i think that tension is becoming increasingly
00:03:15unmanageable as voters tend to make up their minds on issues of identity and culture and so on and
00:03:20obviously brexit was a huge part of that and i think for starmer if he doesn't you know win
00:03:26comfortably in Hartlepool that looks pretty ominous for the 2024 election. In your books
00:03:33obviously you've charted the post-war political scene and I mean the if you like the genesis of
00:03:40these problems was quite a long time ago wasn't it for Labour really? Yeah I think so I mean I
00:03:46think if you you're absolutely right that you know I've been writing about Britain since the 50s
00:03:53really and even as early as about nine as 1968 actually let's take 1968 so in 1968 Enoch Powell
00:04:01made his famous you know the speech that we remember as the rivers of blood speech
00:04:05and in his diaries at the time the Labour cabinet minister Richard Crossman said
00:04:09you know this is really a problem for us because a lot of our voters agree with him and even at that
00:04:16point so you know very early on there was this sense of an emerging tension between the kind
00:04:22of people who basically ran the Labour Party and the kind of people that they expected to turn out
00:04:27every five years to vote for it and I think that has you know it's been getting worse over time
00:04:33and the other problem of course for Labour is it's a Victorian political party that's rooted
00:04:39I mean it's very name you know the Labour Party is kind of rooted in this world that basically
00:04:42is gone I mean you'll know as well as I do that that sort of world of you know everybody lived
00:04:48in back-to-backs they worked in their local factory they went to their local football club
00:04:52on a Saturday they there was a pub at one end of the street and a kind of Methodist chapel at the
00:04:56other I mean that world has gone and and Labour has struggled I think to adjust to a world in
00:05:02which people see themselves much more as individual consumers than a sort of class bound in the way
00:05:09that they were in the 1930s or something. What do you think the chances are Dominic of Labour
00:05:15sort of even giving up the pretense of being a working class party for the reasons you said
00:05:20and becoming a radical middle-class party?
00:05:26Well, that might seem an obvious way to go.
00:11:39In other walks of life, as it were, globalisation has prevailed.
00:11:44But football, precisely because of what you said,
00:11:47there's kind of a religious faith element to it.
00:11:50Because it sort of tugs at people's hearts and minds.
00:11:54This was the one thing that millions of people were just determined to draw a line in the sand and say, no, you won't, you know, you won't come for our game.
00:12:02And I think it's really interesting that it was football, something that's really ultimately most people know deep down is a kind of trivial thing.
00:12:13But it mattered. And if people think it matters, it matters. And that's what's so interesting about it.
00:12:18exactly in fact in in your book who dares wins you know the latest in your uh series about
00:12:24british british history i wasn't it during this period that football was at its lowest ebb uh
00:12:31yeah on the early early 80s so it sort of came back didn't it was it in the 90s i guess
00:12:37yes it was it was um it's a really interesting story so in the 1980s you would i think reasonably
00:12:44have assumed that football would probably die or that it would become a a a mere hobby a sort of
00:12:51antiquated hobby in some ways um because attendances had been falling for 20 years the stadiums were
00:12:57crumbling there were disgraces obviously the game's utterly overshadowed by hooligan violence i mean
00:13:02every saturday you know you go through the the newspapers from the time every single saturday
00:13:07there were reports of real trouble sort of quite vicious trouble and of course when english teams
00:13:13went abroad they exported the hooliganism they took it with them um there's an example i give
00:13:19in the book of mrs thatcher goes to a european council meeting in italy in 1980 and it's when
00:13:24she's asking for our money back if you remember yeah for our budget rebate and so she's sort of
00:13:30on the war path but it's quite early in her first term so she's finding her way and she wants to
00:13:35make a good impression on all these european leaders and she's there precisely the same time
00:13:40the england football team were playing in the european championships uh in rome and she had
00:13:45she had had a reception at downing street um to see them off and she had been photographed on the
00:13:51steps of number 10 and the step outside with um emilyne hughes and kevin keegan kissing her
00:13:56um so they were the sort of senior players so she had slightly wrapped herself in the england
00:14:01team's flag and they went and the hooligans behaved abysmally uh the italian police used
00:14:08tear gas to try and clear the hooligans which then went onto the pitch so the players had to
00:14:15come off in tears and then the game was resumed you know it was utterly it was unbelievably0.71
00:14:20humiliating for for English football and of course the cameras went to I think she was in Venice
00:14:26and she gives an interview in Venice and you can see that she's you know she's humiliated it's
00:14:34incredibly embarrassing for her to come out of this meeting and have to basically apologise for
00:14:38her fans. And I think at that point, you know, English football or football generally was a
00:14:46sort of, it was a disgrace. It was a disgrace on the national kind of flag. And what changed it
00:14:54was obviously new money, globalisation, satellite television. Famously, England did quite well at
00:15:03the 1990 world cup and paul gascoigne cried on tv and lots of people got behind you know some
00:15:08middle class people got behind the game um so it really is a kind of you know ugly duckling story
00:15:14you wouldn't have expected at that point football to have to have revived yes it's interesting you
00:15:18say their middle some middle class people got um got behind the game that's how i remember in the
00:15:2490s it suddenly became sort of almost part of the middle class uh quite self-conscious lad culture
00:15:31do you remember that period i remember it well because i'm of that generation so you know i went
00:15:36up to university in 1993 and uh i was absolutely that generation where the lad culture kind of
00:15:43came in and the sort of slightly affected kind of middle class enthusiasm for football i mean
00:15:49tony blair famously said remember jackie watching jackie milburn play for newcastle despite the fact
00:15:54that jackie milburn had retired before he was born um and um yeah there was this sort of i mean
00:16:01that would have been that just simply didn't happen in the 60s and 70s you know politicians
00:16:05didn't pretend to they didn't feel the need to like football because football hadn't been
00:16:09fashionable and then it did it absolutely did become fashionable um in the 90s um and i think
00:16:16that's obviously once hooliganism had been dealt with you said you went to up to uh sheffield
00:16:21you said sheffield i'm sorry it was no uh i taught at sheffield later on i was at oxford
00:16:26You taught at Sheffield. But you started off, did you not, Dominic, as a specialist in American history?
00:16:59I do think it's, I think all the problems are quite deep rooted.
00:17:03I mean, they have historic roots and obviously, you know, the legacy of slavery is a huge part of it.0.79
00:17:09And obviously, things like the gun culture have always been, you know, been there for as long as America has existed because it's a frontier society.
00:17:17But there's no doubt that since, let's say, the 1980s or the 1990s, something has changed.
00:17:24And I think America has lost its sense of self-confidence.