New Culture Forum - April 19, 2021


Dr David Starkey: I Was Cancelled But I Wont Be Silenced For Speaking Objective Truth

Prince Philip: An Example For Woke Prince Harry. Has Traditional Britain Died With Prince Philip? Great American Race Game - New Documentary By UK Filmmaker Martin Durkin

Episode Stats


Length

56 minutes

Words per minute

137.33

Word count

7,815

Sentence count

548

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

58

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now before I introduce my
00:00:29 I guess this week, just want to say once again,
00:00:32 please do subscribe to the channel, won't you?
00:00:35 We have 112,000 subscribers now.
00:00:38 That's brilliant.
00:00:39 We always want more.
00:00:41 And so basically, you just go to the subscribe button
00:00:44 and click on that.
00:00:45 It's free.
00:00:46 And then next door to it,
00:00:48 there's one which is like a little blue bell.
00:00:50 And if you click on that,
00:00:52 then you will get notifications of all of our programs
00:00:55 as they come up.
00:00:57 So please do subscribe, won't you?
00:00:59 Now, my guest today was last on our programme about a year ago.
00:01:05 David Starkey is one of our best-known historians
00:01:09 and the author of numerous books.
00:01:12 I'm very pleased he's with us now, David.
00:01:15 David, I think this is the first interview you've done.
00:01:17 You were interviewed by The Telegraph last year.
00:01:19 That's correct.
00:01:20 Yeah.
00:01:20 The oldest mainstream media, yes.
00:01:23 Yes.
00:01:24 I think this is the first.
00:01:25 Not to say decrepit.
00:01:26 Right.
00:01:26 um obviously you know lots happened in the past year but how is life for you at the moment oh
00:01:34 life is fine um remember people think that things like cancellation are tremendously
00:01:43 uh devastating well the actual day or two was very unpleasant uh but they somehow assume
00:01:52 that it's the equivalent of a plague cross put upon you,
00:01:56 that you become a social pariah.
00:01:59 Nothing could be further, well, at least in my case,
00:02:01 nothing could be further from the truth.
00:02:04 A single person that I just sort of called a friend said, ugh.
00:02:10 Right.
00:02:11 And he was a rather typical rich man
00:02:17 who wanted somebody amusing, you know, on holiday company and that kind of thing.
00:02:22 So that was nothing very terrible.
00:02:25 There were aspects of it that fill me with horror,
00:02:29 which not personal horror, but institutional horror.
00:02:32 The fact that learned bodies,
00:02:37 for which I've been a very distinguished member for a long period of time,
00:02:41 drop you on entirely extraneous grounds.
00:02:45 that something like the Royal Historical Society decides that a minor view on what is the right
00:02:53 language to use about blacks is more important than 50 years of scholarship. But once Cambridge
00:02:59 College does the same. This is wholly destructive of any notion of scholarship. It is wholly
00:03:08 destructive of institutions because it breaks that Burkean bond of generations of you go there as a
00:03:16 student, you become a distinguished member, you become rich, you leave more money, which further
00:03:22 endows the institution. You rupture all of that. You break it. And you break it for what?
00:03:30 Feeling good. I think, frankly, it's contemptible. It's no accident that several of the
00:03:38 individuals involved, like Dame, no, she's even grander, the Baroness Sally Morgan of
00:03:45 Fitzwilliam College, they're new labor apparatchiks. They're people of absolutely no intellectual
00:03:51 distinction, no scholarship, no originality. They are simply mental policemen. But, you
00:04:00 This is dangerous.
00:04:01 This is Cambridge.
00:04:04 Cambridge.
00:04:05 We have a vice-child.
00:04:07 I say we.
00:04:08 Wonderful.
00:04:09 I'm liberate.
00:04:10 I've got to break that habit.
00:04:11 I'm no longer.
00:04:12 I was there.
00:04:13 I'm not there anymore.
00:04:14 It's absolutely marvelous.
00:04:15 You know, rewriting one's will was a pleasure.
00:04:19 There was a moment when I thought of, it'd be quite a lot, of leaving it entirely to a cat's home on the ground that I hate cats.
00:04:28 But I was a little wiser.
00:04:31 But Cambridge, under its current vice chancellor, the very appropriately named Toop,
00:04:37 who for some reason or another was regarded as being promotional to Cambridge
00:04:41 after having been the vice chancellor of the University of British Columbia,
00:04:45 has presided over this regime which prioritizes the alleged feelings of minority groups. 0.99
00:04:55 Now, Cambridge lies at the heart of the intellectual adventure of the last 500 years. 0.89
00:05:07 Cambridge coming to prominence, it does literally 500 years ago.
00:05:11 It's a complete second string to Oxford until the Tudor period, until my own period.
00:05:17 And I find something very frightening that this institution, famously Trinity College with more Nobel Prizes than the whole of France, leads the charge in the reverse direction.
00:05:32 Up to this year, and with the odd blip here and there, I would have thought of my life and indeed of our society as one of broadening freedom.
00:05:49 There's a sudden sense of reversal.
00:05:54 I don't know whether I said it when I appeared on this program.
00:05:56 I think I probably did.
00:05:58 In other words, immediately in the aftermath of the first lockdown at the onset of COVID,
00:06:05 I think I said, did I not, you have a good memory, you may remember, a Chinese virus,
00:06:11 a Chinese society.
00:06:14 And that's what we're doing. 0.96
00:06:18 And we're reversing, it's quite extraordinary, we are reversing values.
00:06:24 and we're doing it of course
00:06:31 at the moment of the most desperate danger
00:06:33 that the only thing that we have 0.98
00:06:37 faced with a China 0.82
00:06:38 faced with India 1.00
00:06:40 a tiny little place 0.99
00:06:43 a dot
00:06:43 is that originality
00:06:47 that creativity
00:06:48 that mental adventurism
00:06:51 but made for some hundred years, some hundreds of years,
00:07:01 the cutting edge of this astonishing post-Reformation, post-Renaissance world.
00:07:09 But we're throwing it away.
00:07:13 It's quite extraordinary.
00:07:14 I mean, it's, you know, there's a famous model to the castle of Loche or Chinon under Louis XI
00:07:22 where unwanted ministers were locked up in iron cages.
00:07:26 We're going into an iron cage voluntarily.
00:07:30 We're closing the door.
00:07:32 We're turning the locks ourselves and throwing the keys away.
00:07:36 It's great being old.
00:07:38 You don't really care.
00:07:40 I mean, if lots of these nice young people choose to commit intellectual and political suicide, economic suicide, well, fine.
00:07:48 So long as one's investments last, who cares?
00:07:54 When this thing happened last year, I mean, you have said you, I think your mother once said, you know, your tongue will get you into trouble.
00:08:01 I think you said that on this show when you were on it before.
00:08:05 But were you surprised?
00:08:07 i think i was uh let's let's just investigate that um
00:08:13 it of course did finally get me into trouble but equally it was the entire making of my previous
00:08:21 career this is the point that i'm trying to get about the astonishing reversal that the
00:08:27 remember all human progress descent depends on naysaying all human progress depends on
00:08:36 And my favorite image as a child was the boy who says the emperor has no clothes.
00:08:42 It all progress is somebody being a nonconformist.
00:08:47 And I was brought up in a great nonconformist tradition of Quakerism.
00:08:52 I was brought up within a university environment that valued originality, that prized critique, that prized debate.
00:09:02 And I was, of course, extremely good at it.
00:09:04 And because alongside scholarship, I have a certain vulgar flair for language, one acquired
00:09:10 notoriety and deployed it.
00:09:13 So my mother was both absolutely right and absolutely wrong.
00:09:17 In the opening world of the 60s, you know, the genuine period of liberation, the breaking
00:09:25 down of barriers of speech, of behavior, of dress, of social class and whatever.
00:09:30 And my sort of iconoclasm was the basis of an astonishingly successful career.
00:09:39 I haven't changed. Society has.
00:09:43 So eventually, of course, the mother's curse catches up with you.
00:09:46 By the way, I should make a very important point.
00:09:49 She was equally the person who gave me the confidence that enabled me to both ride success and to ride the challenge to success.
00:09:58 You know, I haven't, as it were, retreated weeping.
00:10:03 I mean, you read of many people, whatever, who've undergone similar processes,
00:10:09 nervous breakdowns, gibbering wrecks, petitioning for forgiveness on their knees,
00:10:15 begging to be let back on Twitter.
00:10:18 Je m'en fous.
00:10:21 We should explain, actually, for people who I'm sure most people would know,
00:10:26 but we've got a lot of viewers in America, for example, as well.
00:10:30 But it was a particular phrase you used.
00:10:33 Yeah, I was dealing with the, again,
00:10:36 the fact now that just appalls me is a competition for victimhood.
00:10:44 And I was born, let me play the victim, right?
00:10:47 Shall I play the victim?
00:10:49 I was born with two club feet, with polio. 1.00
00:10:55 I turn out to be gay, acutely short-sighted. 1.00
00:11:00 Shall we continue?
00:11:02 I've got a brain. 1.00
00:11:06 Poor, outsider, bizarre religious group, perfect victim card. 0.63
00:11:17 I've always despised victimhood. 1.00
00:11:20 i belong to that generation that was product of the 45 education act of grammar school
00:11:27 that what you had to do you simply had to do best nobody was going to let you in because
00:11:34 you came from outside the elite because you haven't been to public school you would get there
00:11:40 if you were better and jolly good thing too it forces you requires you to do things we've reversed
00:11:48 again all of this and there is now this cultivation of victimhood and there's the most wonderful
00:11:55 phrase um one of the one of the uh great inventors of the idea of victimhood uh was of course
00:12:02 nationalist ireland and there was the fair are you familiar with the with the phenomenon of
00:12:07 mope no the phenomenon of mope is most oppressed people ever and the idea was because of wickedness
00:12:16 the british and the wickedness of the british empire the irish were the most oppressed people
00:12:22 ever and unfortunately now we have this intense competition to be the most oppressed people ever
00:12:28 you will find everywhere i mean the latest version of it is with some inane comment from
00:12:35 dame jenny murray or whatever you know given the dame hood for sitting in front of a microphone
00:12:40 and boring world on women for 40 years, 0.99
00:12:43 that the British Empire effectively is to be our holocaust
00:12:52 and that whereas Germany has come to terms with its history, we have not. 0.64
00:12:56 And the issue that I was addressing was, is slavery a holocaust?
00:13:05 Is it a deliberate act of genocide?
00:13:08 because that is the claim of the left.
00:13:11 You remember the famous debate.
00:13:14 It was another famous debate.
00:13:15 It wasn't a debate.
00:13:17 Panel denunciation of Churchill at Churchill College
00:13:20 directly on the other side of the road.
00:13:22 Just recently.
00:13:23 Just recently.
00:13:25 Kahinde Andrews, this extraordinary pseudo-professor of black studies,
00:13:30 again makes this claim.
00:13:33 The constant talk of white empire as Holocaust
00:13:37 I mean, he was particularly, and as genocide, he was particularly talking about, in extraordinarily unintelligible terms, about what happens with the Spanish conquest of Latin America.
00:13:51 And what I was saying was, and I said it very badly, for once, I mean, I'm normally eloquent and I'm normally clear and my grammar is good and I remember what I'm saying.
00:14:02 I said something really stupid. What I intended to say was, of course, it couldn't, of course, at least the slavery that's associated with the British Empire and the British colonies couldn't have been a Holocaust because what I intended to say, there were so many blacks in America, North America, in the United States and in Britain. 0.50
00:14:25 And instead, my tongue slipped and I said, so many damn blacks. 0.94
00:14:29 And do you know what? 0.95
00:14:30 I was even more stupid.
00:14:31 I said, actually, in Africa rather than America.
00:14:34 This is the sort of idiot thing that is liable to happen in this without some elementary procedure of editing.
00:14:42 It was stupid.
00:14:44 It was badly expressed.
00:14:46 I can remember the moment of saying it, but it was sort of, you know, six in the evening.
00:14:53 we were going over time, I was desperate for a drink.
00:14:57 I had a mental note, one really should click that.
00:14:59 And then you had a very, very inexperienced presenter
00:15:02 who didn't spot the problem. 0.64
00:15:05 And, of course, it was the height of the fever of Black Lives Matter. 0.99
00:15:09 The Black Lives Matter in Britain is the most ludicrous, 1.00
00:15:13 preposterous, imitative thing. 1.00
00:15:16 The way in which we took an utterly extraneous event
00:15:22 and it generated purely imitative behavior.
00:15:27 Here's one of the problems with Britain and America.
00:15:30 Because we do share a language,
00:15:33 you get this sort of what I would call a kind of cultural infection.
00:15:38 And I think one of the great problems 0.62
00:15:41 that has happened in race relations in this country, 0.94
00:15:44 which is of an entirely different order.
00:15:47 Slavery has never had a fully legal status in Britain.
00:15:53 We have never had a kind of neo-apartheid.
00:15:57 We have never had a colour bar formally.
00:16:00 None of those things have ever existed.
00:16:02 The history is radically different.
00:16:05 But of course, the tendency, and particularly if you're an activist, black politician,
00:16:09 is to look to what's going on in America.
00:16:12 and and and and again we pay ludicrous amounts of attention to american presidential elections i
00:16:18 mean we really do that sort of increased hasn't it in recent years very much to the point where
00:16:24 it's almost um american elections are almost covered with the same intensity as british ones
00:16:29 it's extraordinary i think that our current british political class is infatuated with
00:16:34 america maybe wants to be that maybe wants to be what they see on house and i mean again you know
00:16:40 I mean, the strength of feelings that people had about Trump, I mean, preposterous.
00:16:46 I mean, absolutely.
00:16:47 First of all, you know, the American Constitution coped with Trump without even sort of, you know, raising an eyebrow, if you like.
00:16:56 The founding fathers were perfectly aware that you could have a demagogic president.
00:17:02 What actually a demagogic president can do without the vote of Congress is very, very little.
00:17:09 He can posture. He can tweet a lot. But that's about it. But it is, I think, particularly in the area of race relations, the imitation of America has been profoundly and deeply damaging.
00:17:28 profoundly and deeply damaging 0.72
00:17:30 and of course
00:17:32 all of these things
00:17:33 damage those who adopt it
00:17:36 and
00:17:37 in a fashion
00:17:40 which I find
00:17:41 distressing
00:17:43 we are completely different
00:17:45 you were doing an advertisement
00:17:48 for the program
00:17:49 let me do a little advertisement
00:17:51 for the organ
00:17:51 that has enabled me to
00:17:55 play a very tiny part
00:17:57 in public debate over the last year, which is The Critic.
00:18:00 I've just written my regular column there,
00:18:04 and I think it comes out next week.
00:18:07 Press the button.
00:18:09 It comes out next week.
00:18:10 And this one is about the fact that we are a mongrel culture. 0.98
00:18:16 The peculiar thing about Britain, England,
00:18:19 it's really England, is we are a conquered country.
00:18:23 We are post-colonial from the very beginning 0.99
00:18:26 because we were conquered by the Normans and we have alone really a completely mongrel language 0.89
00:18:34 there's no such thing as pure English because it's a fusion of a Germanic structure and a Latin
00:18:43 and French vocabulary and it comes into being at a particular moment it's a very recent language
00:18:49 in its modern form it only goes back to about 1400. So when Shakespeare writes it it's barely
00:18:57 150 years old. It's utterly astonishing this speed of development. Now this has fundamental
00:19:03 consequences. It means we don't do what the French do. You can't have that notion of a pure culture. 1.00
00:19:11 You can't have that notion of an academy which holds you to count on grounds of linguistic purity.
00:19:17 You can't have the kind of campaigns about laïcité, about French values that they do in France.
00:19:25 And this means we have been able, I think, to have a very important reaction in the modern post-colonial world because we are post-colonial ourselves.
00:19:38 We were always multicultural. We have, by definition, a peculiar adaptability in this area.
00:19:49 I don't think there's any accident about, as I said, our success in the post-colonial world.
00:19:56 It's built into the peculiar structures of English and British history.
00:20:02 And it's even more reinforced with the way in which we became Great Britain, with the union with Scotland.
00:20:12 What everybody forgets is, because, of course, the Scots, again, the victimhood, victims of English colonialism, absolutely rubbish.
00:20:20 The agreement between England and Scotland in 1707 is an agreement of two sovereign states.
00:20:26 But what Scotland keeps in 1707 is every aspect of an independent, distinct society apart from a parliament.
00:20:38 You keep your own currency, sort of, at least your right to issue your own currency.
00:20:44 You keep a separate legal system.
00:20:46 You keep a separate church, which the monarch joins when they cross the border.
00:20:50 The monarch actually changes religion.
00:20:52 You keep a separate court.
00:20:54 You keep a separate heraldic system.
00:20:55 Extraordinary. And this, of course, is why the way that Blair's government did devolution was so catastrophic.
00:21:06 The only official, as it were, point at which Scotland and England actually came together was in Parliament.
00:21:14 So when you create a separate Scottish Parliament, you rupture the central part of that bond of union.
00:21:23 But what I'm trying to say is we were always multi-ethnic.
00:21:27 There was this very, very unsuccessful attempt in the 18th century
00:21:32 at creating a single British identity.
00:21:35 It never got anywhere.
00:21:37 The monarchy itself sponsors separate titles, identities for members of the family
00:21:43 in England, in Scotland, in Ireland, and increasingly in Wales.
00:21:48 the first international games
00:21:51 I'm no sportsman as you know
00:21:53 but the first internationals are fought
00:21:55 between England and Scotland
00:21:56 the very idea
00:21:58 in other words
00:21:59 these multiple layers of identities
00:22:03 are pioneered here
00:22:05 and this is
00:22:08 you see if you look at the contrast
00:22:09 with that in America
00:22:10 from many one
00:22:12 the emphasis on
00:22:15 a single stream
00:22:18 The increasing use, which we've seen in the last 40, 50 years, of the Supreme Court to override state rights and to impose a particular worldview on this infinitely diverse culture with, I think, catastrophic results.
00:22:37 Our history is so radically different.
00:22:39 We don't have a single system of education.
00:22:41 We very quickly abandoned any, we are one of the first countries to abandon any attempt at the creation of a single dominant religion and so on.
00:22:53 And all this makes us, I think, if we hadn't had all the things that you and I have been wringing our hands about, we are in such an advantaged position.
00:23:05 We could have been. 0.58
00:23:06 You know, I was saying, I was being a little bit flippant, I do care, of course I don't care, but it's enough to weep over, because there is just there, providing we stop following the wrong models, providing we stop, you know, that wonderful phrase, whoring after false gods.
00:23:26 you you were saying you know this this obsession with america and and indeed you know the the
00:23:33 history of uh race relations in america is quite different to here but the thing that started the
00:23:41 problem was not really related to that was it david it was actually it was about something else
00:23:46 it was about your um your your explaining about genocide and slavery but it is all part of the
00:23:54 same thing it's a competition for the most victim status right right that's what it's about um that
00:24:01 as i said and you you see this repeatedly there is the there is the attempt at claim what right let
00:24:07 me put it in very different let me put it in as simple terms as possible what is the the nature
00:24:13 of the left's attack on britain at the moment is to claim that the british empire is the equivalent
00:24:20 of the Nazis, that its wrongs are as great as the Nazis, that they require equivalent
00:24:27 atonement, that specifically the element of slavery in the British Empire is the equivalent 0.53
00:24:34 of the Jewish genocide, and that therefore we require a similar abnegation about our
00:24:43 history, a renunciation of it, to the Germans. 0.64
00:24:46 Now, all of those seem to me to be utter rubbish. Utter and complete and dangerous rubbish. Because, of course, equally what the left has done is to reject any notion of objective truth. 1.00
00:25:02 the reason that it is absurd and you know every every bbc producer talks in these terms i just
00:25:09 mentioned jenny murray there was somebody who'd been um i i remember correctly a today producer
00:25:16 again going on about oh the empire is the equivalent of genocide and whatever um and
00:25:21 it is objectively not true i think that was this week wasn't it with jenny murray she
00:25:28 She made these points.
00:25:30 Which are as disgrace and a scandal.
00:25:33 I mean, sorry, she's well-loved and all the rest of it. 0.92
00:25:38 But it's intellectually slovenly, it's a corruption of language,
00:25:42 and frankly, it's a disgrace.
00:25:45 And the reason it's a disgrace is because there is an objective test of these. 0.63
00:25:50 Six million Jews are killed deliberately, deliberately with a machine of death, right? 0.51
00:25:58 you know that is not in dispute there is no not even a thousandth part of one
00:26:06 percent of an equivalent of that and so but what the left has done is to reject
00:26:12 the notion of objective truth this is the catastrophe of what is going on at
00:26:18 the moment that everything is point of view or felt experience no it's not and
00:26:24 It again begins with the Lawrence Inquiry, where, you know, it's a racist act if somebody feels that it's a racist act.
00:26:33 We're about to do the same thing with misogyny.
00:26:35 No, it's not.
00:26:37 And particularly English law depends, always used to depend, on the objective test of evidence.
00:26:45 But we're rejecting that.
00:26:47 And so that really is, that is cultural suicide.
00:26:50 The thing is, when I keep returning to this for obviously because it's been such a huge event in your life.
00:26:58 No, it's not. So you're vastly, really, this is rubbish. You're wholly exaggerating it.
00:27:05 It was the behaviour, you know, it's a wonderful passage. Sorry, it really is important we get this right.
00:27:10 There is this wonderful passage in the book when he talks, this is the height of the French Revolution,
00:27:16 about a lot of noisy grasshoppers
00:27:19 making a tremendous
00:27:20 Twitter.
00:27:25 Whilst the great comfortable,
00:27:28 he calls them the great cows,
00:27:29 the great beef of Britain,
00:27:34 sort of contents,
00:27:35 you know, contentedly chews its cud
00:27:38 underneath the spreading British oak
00:27:40 whilst a lot of go on.
00:27:43 That's what it is.
00:27:45 And it's no accident. It affects the world of the universities and particularly the world of arts faculties and the universities and aspects of the media.
00:27:58 In other words, Peter, it's words, words, words, words.
00:28:05 And so much of this is, and this is why I say it's a sort of cultural retreat.
00:28:12 The great triumph of, and it's very much the triumph of Britain and England in particular,
00:28:18 is the triumph of the inductive experimental test of truth.
00:28:24 The whole basis of modern science and technology,
00:28:27 sort of its remote intellectual ancestor, I suppose, is Francis Bacon.
00:28:32 But the test of objective truth and objective experience. 0.57
00:28:39 And this is what separates us from the Middle Ages,
00:28:43 where you had a science, simply, there was a lot of science,
00:28:47 there was a lot of philosophy, it was just words, words, words.
00:28:51 Words about God, words about nature, whatever, and we broke out of that stranglehold with the test of objective truth.
00:29:02 We've abandoned that test, which is why there's a sudden sense of going back to the Middle Ages.
00:29:08 What I did, nobody has ever been able to produce evidence that I have ever insulted anybody of colour,
00:29:17 that I have ever used abusive language about them.
00:29:21 I have lived in multicultural London for 40 or...
00:29:26 How long now?
00:29:28 40 or longer, since 1972, just coming up to 50 years.
00:29:34 There is never... I have never been involved.
00:29:36 In other words, there is no objective test.
00:29:39 I used a wrong... I used one word out of place.
00:29:43 Oh, yes, no, no.
00:29:44 No, no, no, no.
00:29:45 But let's really pursue this.
00:29:48 This is incomprehensible, save in religious terms.
00:29:57 What we have done, religion, as a woke, has become a new religion.
00:30:03 What I did was to commit heresy.
00:30:06 Remember, heresy was a voluntary crime.
00:30:10 It was the denial of the beliefs of the church.
00:30:12 And if you denied your denial, you weren't burnt.
00:30:16 So it was completely, you know, that unspeakable death of burning alive was a completely voluntary act.
00:30:22 But it was all about words.
00:30:25 And what we've done now, we've elevated language into this absurd prominence because we've cut it off from meaning.
00:30:35 We've cut it off from outside experience.
00:30:38 Everything is now just internal to people, inside their heads.
00:30:42 It's a form of lunacy.
00:30:44 I mean, it really, really is a form of lunacy.
00:30:47 The only reason I explore it more, David, with you is the effect it has.
00:30:51 That's all.
00:30:51 Of course, I mean, it's had...
00:30:52 No, what I mean is the effect it has on your life, for example,
00:30:55 on all of our lives.
00:30:58 I mean, you know, you've had, therefore, you know,
00:31:01 a bad experience in terms of being...
00:31:04 Yes, but sorry, I'm a stoic.
00:31:07 That is to say, I believe that experiences are only bad
00:31:10 if you let them be bad.
00:31:11 They want to damage you. Of course they want to damage you.
00:31:15 They want to humiliate you. Of course they do.
00:31:17 But they can only do that if you let that happen.
00:31:21 And this is what Peterson, in an extraordinarily cack-handed and clumsy way, is trying to say.
00:31:27 I wish I made as much money as he did, but that's another matter.
00:31:31 But it is stoicism.
00:31:35 The only thing, you cannot control the world.
00:31:39 You cannot control what people say about you, think about you.
00:31:42 You can control how you react to it, which is why I'm so contemptuous of victimhood.
00:31:50 Victimhood is all about saying, because I am black or because I am disabled or because I am gay or because I am trans,
00:31:58 I require the world to make all sorts of special allowances for me.
00:32:03 What? What?
00:32:05 are you surprised
00:32:08 in the past year
00:32:10 since we spoke
00:32:11 which was just at the very beginning of COVID
00:32:14 are you surprised at
00:32:16 how
00:32:18 quickly
00:32:19 there has been in our institutions
00:32:22 a kind of capitulation
00:32:24 if you want
00:32:25 or indeed just a sort of a failure 1.00
00:32:28 I mean whether it's the British
00:32:30 Library whether it's
00:32:31 right up to Kew Gardens now
00:32:34 You know, only these institutions are scandals.
00:32:40 I mean, the British Library actually dropped publishing an essay by me
00:32:46 on Anglo-Scottish relations in the 16th century.
00:32:51 Now, that's deranged.
00:32:53 That is simply deranged.
00:32:55 And for what is theoretically the custodian institution of the central...
00:33:02 The British Library really is the equivalent of the Great Library of Alexandria.
00:33:07 Yes.
00:33:08 It is the custodian of the record of our civilisation, and it betrays it.
00:33:15 It betrays every single principle.
00:33:20 At last, I mean, there is a government.
00:33:22 The government has shown some faint stirrings.
00:33:25 Now, I think, so far I've been fairly pessimistic.
00:33:29 Let me now slightly reverse direction.
00:33:31 We've had a most interesting incident which suggests that things are going in, that there is a limit to all of this, which is, of course, the Meghan and Harry interview.
00:33:41 The Meghan and Harry interview deployed all the tropes that I've been talking about.
00:33:48 The disgraceful, unsubstantiated, carefully sprayed charge of racism.
00:33:57 Yes.
00:33:58 The question of skin colour.
00:34:02 Above all, I've been a victim of mental illness, risk of suicide.
00:34:08 All of these things.
00:34:10 And what's fascinating, particularly disgraceful reaction of the times,
00:34:15 a fundamental crisis for the monarchy, a dagger pointed at its heart,
00:34:21 it's been forgotten in 10 days.
00:34:23 And the – in Britain, it, of course, polarized opinion in very much the same way as Woke has done.
00:34:35 The young bits of the Labour Party, though you saw Keith Starmer desperately, legs being dragged ever wider.
00:34:42 You know, he'll finish up being torn apart.
00:34:44 It's going to be very, very, very entertaining to watch.
00:34:48 It'll be very painful for him and very amusing for the rest of us.
00:34:51 but being pulled apart by the wild horses
00:34:55 of trying to get the Red Wall back
00:34:57 and trying to keep Diane Abbott on the other.
00:35:00 It's exquisite watching him being pulled between the two.
00:35:03 So there were all those forces on one side.
00:35:05 And then it was that Burkean analogy that I gave you before.
00:35:10 There was a lot,
00:35:12 and the great mass of the British public shrugged its shoulders,
00:35:16 said she is an intriguing little words
00:35:19 that I would not repeat in front of a family audience
00:35:23 and shrugged its shoulders and continued.
00:35:26 So the moment you get the opportunity
00:35:29 for a genuine test of public opinion, 1.00
00:35:34 the dykes are held. 1.00
00:35:37 The problem is this, 0.99
00:35:40 that we have corporate woke.
00:35:44 We even had an attempt at royal woke.
00:35:47 There are aspects of Prince Charles and Prince William that flirt with wokery.
00:35:53 And it is whatever it touches, it destroys.
00:35:58 It is an absolute rule.
00:36:00 Whatever it touches, it destroys.
00:36:02 And of course, it's infected the human resources departments of virtually every company,
00:36:09 of every profession of, as I was saying,
00:36:14 learned societies, the Royal Historical Society 0.96
00:36:17 under the disgraceful leadership of Margot Finn 0.99
00:36:20 signs up to the most extreme version of Black Lives Matter. 0.98
00:36:24 Just what are bodies doing that? 0.99
00:36:27 We have permanent secretaries in the civil service
00:36:32 concluding official memoranda with that.
00:36:36 Oh, yeah, so that's everywhere now, yeah.
00:36:39 What? No, but it is a scandal.
00:36:42 I'm sorry, it is a genuine scandal. 0.97
00:36:46 In my view, it is every bit as bad as putting a swastika. 0.66
00:36:52 With Harry and Meghan, you're pretty much saying that this is something or nothing, that it sort of will go. 0.98
00:36:59 I think it has done.
00:37:01 I mean, the only thing that would change it, right, very interesting.
00:37:08 I mean, I know an awful lot about this from the inside, Peter.
00:37:11 I used to work with CBS, would you believe, giving you a sense of how the world has changed.
00:37:17 I was their principal contact for Royal Matters until 2017.
00:37:23 So I've worked with all of them.
00:37:26 I've worked with Susan Zerinsky, the producer of it.
00:37:30 I've worked with Gail.
00:37:32 Of the interview.
00:37:33 Yes.
00:37:34 So all of these people I know absolutely from the inside.
00:37:38 And Gail came up with the remark, because clearly acting as Megan's spokesman, they have emails to prove every point.
00:37:48 If those emails are published and they prove every point, then the monarchy is in serious trouble.
00:37:56 Until that moment, it doesn't matter.
00:37:59 I think it doesn't matter domestically.
00:38:02 The only thing I would say is that the way that the Americans have taken that interview to heart.
00:38:08 Yes, but America is split in exactly the same.
00:38:13 It's not Americans. It's the American left.
00:38:17 Remember, the America is completely split down the middle.
00:38:23 There's a piece by my friend in The Spectator by Lee Cohen, as we're all doing plugs.
00:38:29 Lee Cohen in The Spectator pointing out that the division in America
00:38:34 corresponds precisely to Democrat versus Republican.
00:38:42 And you see this everywhere.
00:38:44 I mean, the whole debate about, which we haven't really talked about,
00:38:49 the whole debate about the response to COVID replicates these lines of division.
00:38:55 The most obvious indicator of them in British politics is whether you voted remain or leave.
00:39:02 And that line, those lines, every issue was polarised.
00:39:07 But we're dealing with a society, both Britain and America, which is divided on a barometer line around 50%.
00:39:15 Yes. I suppose in the long term, though, before we leave the monarchy and go on to COVID,
00:39:24 I do want to ask you, because the things you said about COVID before really resonated.
00:39:29 It's something you wrote in The Critic, actually, as well.
00:39:31 But with the monarchy, okay, this might be a sometime thing comes and goes,
00:39:36 but do you think that, what is the outlook, do you think,
00:39:39 when the Queen's no longer there?
00:39:41 What do you think is the outlook?
00:39:43 Do you think we'll have a referendum?
00:39:46 No one can say.
00:39:47 I mean, I always say this, you know, history only works in one direction.
00:39:51 It only works backwards.
00:39:53 famous T.S. Eliot quote
00:39:57 I was a very, very fine Beckett
00:39:59 in Murder in the Cathedral
00:40:01 with all the tensions and hypocrisies as a schoolboy
00:40:04 I can still remember that gesture
00:40:08 Oh, good, good, my producer said
00:40:10 more of that
00:40:11 and it was miney, of course
00:40:14 Only in retrospection can we say that was the day
00:40:21 I think that it's relatively safe
00:40:25 I also think that what we're forgetting is
00:40:29 that my guess is that there's a bubbling reaction
00:40:33 to woke amongst the younger
00:40:36 particularly well boys
00:40:39 I still have quite a lot of involvement
00:40:45 with schools and whatever
00:40:46 and one is seeing a very marked gender divide
00:40:50 on this issue
00:40:51 Woke has been, of course, of immense benefit to women, to girls.
00:40:56 It gives them all sorts of special privileges and advantages, 0.86
00:40:59 which in the battle of the sexes, of course, they properly take advantage of.
00:41:04 And boys are getting fed up of it.
00:41:06 I think that we will probably see another generation that comes along that will,
00:41:12 I mean, let's speculate, let's be really silly,
00:41:14 will probably be violently right-wing and neo-fascistic.
00:41:17 as we've lost any notion of moderation and good sense shall we get shall we get on to covid yes
00:41:25 no i i was going to ask you you made a very good uh it seemed really plausible that the government
00:41:31 had lost its nerve on a very particular weekend yes it was the weekend of the 13th 14th 15th of
00:41:37 march all the evidence has come up to prove that i am absolutely right right um but um it's the
00:41:43 weekend I know it was my last weekend in London it was I was and it was it was it was extraordinary
00:41:50 on the Friday I was at Covent Garden it was the next to the last I think performance in the opera
00:41:56 house of Beethoven's Fidelio which of course is the opera about imprisonment so it was it was
00:42:02 entirely and you realize something it was a sellout performance and it wasn't there were empty seats
00:42:07 I went to the pub afterwards and thought oh god I'm being a fool I got out you know hastily
00:42:12 mouthing down half a pint and got into a cab and came home.
00:42:16 And that weekend, everything changes.
00:42:20 The figures of deaths multiply from some tiny number,
00:42:26 you know, like 30 to 60, but they double.
00:42:31 You get, we now know it's the weekend when Professor Lockdown,
00:42:35 when Neil Ferguson's absurd, preposterous predictions.
00:42:39 Remember, nobody has ever been more wrong about everything than Neil Ferguson.
00:42:44 He was wrong about BSE.
00:42:48 He was responsible for the disgraceful overreaction to foot and mouth.
00:42:52 I remember the countryside filled with smoking carcasses.
00:42:56 It was disgusting and disgraceful.
00:42:58 But the government panicked.
00:43:00 And, of course, the panic was exacerbated by, isn't it nice,
00:43:05 Macron has had to go into another lockdown,
00:43:07 by Macron saying that if Britain didn't follow suit, the borders would be closed.
00:43:12 And they panicked that weekend.
00:43:14 And they go from what would be a very sensible series of reactions to a grossly silly one.
00:43:20 And it's silly in every way.
00:43:22 And again, you can look at reasons.
00:43:24 We've also, again, the comments that have come out with Dominic Cummings.
00:43:30 Cummings is both very bright and full.
00:43:33 He is a historian who thinks he understands maths, which plainly he doesn't.
00:43:38 And one of the reasons that the government fell over and worshipped at the shrine of Neil Ferguson was mathematical modelling.
00:43:48 Mathematical modelling is mathematical juju.
00:43:52 Right.
00:43:52 Pure juju.
00:43:54 But the government were suckers for it because Cummings was a sucker for it.
00:43:58 And the final thing is, well, no, it's not the final thing.
00:44:02 There are many more.
00:44:03 There were two other really important things that happened.
00:44:08 One, of course, is NHS worship.
00:44:11 The Tories had tried to present, and it's a very important part of the Red Wall and whatever,
00:44:18 themselves as the party of the NHS.
00:44:20 Hence that preposterous slogan, protect the NHS.
00:44:24 The NHS is here to protect us.
00:44:27 And the criminal, I mean, in my view, it is criminal, and I'm not using the word likely, but clearing out of people into care homes to free up beds in the NHS, turning the NHS into a national COVID service.
00:44:44 But that's all water under the bridge, I'm afraid.
00:44:47 But when we look at it...
00:44:48 Oh, sorry, the final catastrophic error.
00:44:52 Here again, we've got a prime minister who once wrote a rather bad book on Churchill.
00:44:56 And Churchill, of course, has very intelligent things to say on most things.
00:45:01 Above all, scientists.
00:45:03 Churchill was fascinated by scientists.
00:45:06 He had a pet one and checkers, the professor.
00:45:11 But he said something very interesting.
00:45:14 You want your scientists on tap, but not on top.
00:45:19 And what we've done with SAGE is to put sciences on top.
00:45:23 Catastrophic.
00:45:24 You can see why.
00:45:26 They were effectively there as camouflage cover.
00:45:30 But then it gives them a veto on policy.
00:45:32 Yes.
00:45:33 The situation now, though, is that, I mean,
00:45:34 the kind of anti-lockdown argument, put it broadly,
00:45:40 sort of lost, didn't it?
00:45:41 I mean, people are kind of, you know,
00:45:43 I think Peter Hitchens sort of says, well, we sort of lost, you know.
00:45:46 Time and events has gone on to such an extent that we're sort of like,
00:45:50 this is what it is.
00:45:51 But of course, remember, it's still important to register how catastrophic it is.
00:45:59 We may have lost the argument.
00:46:00 We shouldn't have lost the argument.
00:46:02 I mean, look at what a disaster it is. 1.00
00:46:06 It is, the point that I made before, Chinese virus, Chinese society. 0.99
00:46:11 A lockdown is something that only a dictatorship can impose. 0.96
00:46:16 And that's why we did it so badly.
00:46:19 We did a really bad lockdown.
00:46:21 In China, when there's lockdown, if you stray, I imagine you're a machine gun or you're certainly manhandled back in.
00:46:28 I gather the door, a steel bolt is put on the outside of the door.
00:46:32 That is what happens.
00:46:33 We do a shambolic, incompetent version with preposterous, bumbling British policemen, 0.87
00:46:41 you know, underreacting one day and overreacting the next day.
00:46:46 But it is utterly destructive of everything that makes us what we are. 1.00
00:46:51 We've lost the moral argument with China. 1.00
00:46:53 We've lost the moral argument. 0.98
00:46:55 And, of course, the whole lockdown approach reinforces everything that I was talking about,
00:47:01 about ignoring evidence, ignoring the importance of freedom.
00:47:06 We've discarded the notion of freedom. 0.97
00:47:08 It's the only thing that distinguishes us from China. 0.97
00:47:12 It's sort of rather surprising. 0.99
00:47:14 We've thrown it away.
00:47:15 But we know why we've thrown it away.
00:47:17 We've thrown it away on two grounds.
00:47:21 Sentimentalism.
00:47:22 The dianification of society from 1997 onwards.
00:47:27 One of the things I found, right, I'm 76.
00:47:30 One of the things I found most disgusting was every death is a tragedy.
00:47:36 It's a tragedy.
00:47:37 No, it's not.
00:47:39 No, no, it's not.
00:47:40 It's an act of mutual lying.
00:47:42 It's a solving of the conscience, right?
00:47:45 So it's that gross sentimentalism.
00:47:48 That's one of the things that's gone wrong.
00:47:50 And the other is the triumph of the precautionary principle,
00:47:53 which we're seeing an awful lot of debate on
00:47:55 in its exaggerated form in Europe,
00:47:58 which of course has led to their catastrophe
00:48:00 over the whole inoculation vaccination program.
00:48:06 But it's the triumph of the notion of safety.
00:48:09 And there's a wonderful, wonderful phrase
00:48:11 of Benjamin Franklin,
00:48:13 that those who will sacrifice freedom for security
00:48:17 will shortly lose both.
00:48:19 Oh yes, yes.
00:48:20 But he anticipated.
00:48:23 This is the whole point.
00:48:25 The situation that we're in now
00:48:26 has been repeatedly anticipated
00:48:29 because it is a response to particular flaws
00:48:34 in human nature.
00:48:35 Again, the way in which all these things interconnect,
00:48:40 What I'm trying to say is all these things interconnect.
00:48:43 Oh, yes, yes.
00:48:44 They absolutely interconnect,
00:48:46 which is why a sense of genuine civilizational gloom is appropriate.
00:48:55 It is odd.
00:48:57 Civilizations die from inside.
00:49:00 They die from inside.
00:49:02 And once you lose confidence, you see, the great argument,
00:49:06 I mean, the previous great death of a civilization is the death of the classical world.
00:49:12 And, of course, Gibbon's great decline and fall of the Roman Empire.
00:49:15 It's very interesting.
00:49:16 What does it attribute it to?
00:49:18 Christianity.
00:49:20 It attributes it to a philosophy that was the direct opposite of what had made Rome great,
00:49:28 which is famously described by Nietzsche as a religion for slaves. 1.00
00:49:34 And I think it's right. 1.00
00:49:36 I really do think that is right.
00:49:39 And I'm afraid, you know, by doing what we've done, we've embraced slavery.
00:49:49 You're writing at the moment, aren't you, David?
00:49:52 I'm back safely in the Tudors.
00:49:54 Oh, really?
00:49:55 I thought you were writing a memoir.
00:49:56 Well, I'll be doing that too.
00:49:58 But I'm essentially, no, I'm safely back in the Tudors.
00:50:01 Again, you see, I have this permanent intellectual refuge.
00:50:07 You become, as you get older, and partly, I suppose, thinking of memoirs,
00:50:11 you become aware of what you were when you were young as well
00:50:14 and the relationship of that person then and this person now.
00:50:19 One of the books that most influenced me when I was a very young man
00:50:23 and was terribly pretentious and was determined to be an Oxbridge Dom,
00:50:27 terribly important learned conversations and paneled rooms and passing with port and decanters
00:50:34 and all that sort of stuff. And then I came up to London and rather discovered the leather
00:50:38 seat and forgot all about it, you know. But the, if I'm not careful, I'm going to forget
00:50:48 what I was going to say as well with the church. One of the books that most profoundly influenced
00:50:53 me, is the Microcosmographia Academica, which is this piss-take of academic politics written
00:51:00 by one of the great geniuses of Trinity College, F.M. Cornford, Francis Cornford, the great
00:51:06 classicist. And Cornford, the memoir is utterly brilliant. You know the wonderful phrase about
00:51:16 why academic politics is so vicious,
00:51:19 because the stakes are so small.
00:51:21 It's 26 brilliant pages.
00:51:26 It said Wardian prose, so it's Oscar Wilde prose.
00:51:29 Utterly, utterly, completely brilliant.
00:51:31 Phrases like, you know, those who speak at the Union
00:51:35 develop the habit of addressing their best friends
00:51:38 as though they were a room full of stupid reporters.
00:51:41 This kind of, wonderful, wonderful.
00:51:42 But there is a marvellous section in there
00:51:45 that you know you will go on you'll become an academic politician you'll become a vice chancellor
00:51:50 you will be hated and loathed and then maybe if you're fortunate you'll return to the things of
00:51:58 the mind you will go back to what you started off being serious research serious thinking and you
00:52:07 will finish up with the joys of a clean muscular intelligence and nobody will want you out of the
00:52:14 way and nobody will want to get rid of you and there is that sense of i've always loved
00:52:22 the processes of historical research of analysis of tight documentary analysis it was how i you
00:52:31 know it was how i was picked out at cambridge there was that extraordinary moment in my seminar
00:52:36 with elton who was the great historian of this and when jeffrey was going on i think this is such
00:52:42 and such and such document
00:52:43 and stuck his hand and went up
00:52:44 and said,
00:52:45 Terrible, sorry, Professor Alton,
00:52:47 but you are wrong.
00:52:50 Right.
00:52:50 The atmosphere turned.
00:52:52 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:52:53 And he was.
00:52:55 Yeah.
00:52:55 And I was able to tell him
00:52:57 why he was wrong.
00:52:59 But, you know,
00:52:59 at that point,
00:53:00 he was still big enough
00:53:02 to see that as good, not bad.
00:53:06 Later on, he became small-minded
00:53:08 and tried to defend
00:53:10 his own youthful absurdities, the Tudor revolution in government, and whatever.
00:53:15 So you see, I've had this experience of fall before.
00:53:18 I was the subject of a lecture at Cambridge given by John Morrill, rather cruelly known
00:53:25 as the Morrill Majority, given by John on Lucifer.
00:53:31 You know, you remember the bright star of the morning who turns into the devil.
00:53:34 I was Elton's favourite student, and I challenged him and was driven into outer darkness.
00:53:40 Why didn't I get that job at Cambridge?
00:53:43 So I've been here several times.
00:53:46 And providing you retain that inner confidence,
00:53:51 providing you have something that, remember, nothing is important.
00:53:56 There is that wonderful phrase which is almost certainly A.J. Balfour,
00:54:02 you know, the Bob's your uncle chap because his uncle was the Marcus of Salisbury,
00:54:06 Robert Salisbury, and nothing matters very much.
00:54:09 few things matter at all.
00:54:12 That is true.
00:54:13 Human values are our invention.
00:54:18 We make them.
00:54:20 Things matter because you make them matter.
00:54:25 There are no external forces.
00:54:28 There are human beings.
00:54:30 And all that matters is if you have that confidence
00:54:33 and you have that belief
00:54:35 and you have that sense of the recognition of
00:54:42 not the external worlds of feelings, but something else.
00:54:47 For me, a good scientist, it's what goes on in his laboratory.
00:54:51 For a good mathematician, it's his sons.
00:54:54 For a good historian, it's the document.
00:54:58 As Geoffrey Alton, at his best, always used to say,
00:55:00 there are no authorities in history, there is just evidence.
00:55:05 Well David, on that note
00:55:08 with the book
00:55:12 you're just going to write a memoir
00:55:14 or you...
00:55:15 Oh yeah
00:55:16 much of it is done
00:55:19 Oh is it?
00:55:20 Well you must come back and talk to us
00:55:22 I think I would prefer to get the two
00:55:26 what I'm doing is I'm writing
00:55:28 the reason I was having such a struggle
00:55:32 with resuming my Henry VIII biography
00:55:34 a rather good start
00:55:35 was that I couldn't work out how to get back into it.
00:55:39 Yes.
00:55:39 And I now know why.
00:55:41 What the book is going to be called,
00:55:43 it's going to be looking at something that is of crucial importance,
00:55:46 the relationship between Henry and his father.
00:55:49 Right.
00:55:49 It's going to be called Henry Tudor and Son.
00:55:51 It's rather nice, you know, like a firm of undertakers.
00:55:54 Yes.
00:55:54 Henry Tudor and Son.
00:55:56 And it's stolen, of course.
00:55:57 All things are stolen, aren't they?
00:55:59 It's stolen from dear old S.T. Bindorf,
00:56:02 who was this tedious old professor at Queen Mary College
00:56:05 when I first came to London
00:56:07 and he had a chapter of his rather bad book
00:56:10 on Tudor England called Henry Tudor and the Son.
00:56:13 It's a very good title
00:56:14 and that's how I'm tackling it.
00:56:16 And it's wonderful.
00:56:17 Do you know, and can I end on the advertisement?
00:56:19 Yes.
00:56:20 Do you know we don't actually know the date
00:56:22 on which the most important marriage
00:56:24 in English royal history takes place.
00:56:26 We don't know the date on which Henry VII
00:56:29 and Elizabeth of York actually marry.
00:56:32 I can prove that the date that's in the books
00:56:35 is a fake
00:56:36 with a single document
00:56:38 a single document
00:56:40 a single piece of evidence
00:56:42 and that's the excitement
00:56:43 it's the excitement of the chase
00:56:46 David, thank you very very much
00:56:47 real pleasure
00:56:48 thank you
00:56:49 that's it for what you're saying is
00:56:51 this week
00:56:52 we shall see you next time
00:56:53 thank you very much