New Culture Forum - April 12, 2021


Prince Philip: An Example For Woke Prince Harry. Has Traditional Britain Died With Prince Philip?

Rod Dreher On The Rise Of Totalitarianism In The West & Lessons From Soviet Dissidents Dr David Starkey: I Was Cancelled But I Wont Be Silenced For Speaking Objective Truth

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

161.46

Word count

3,809

Sentence count

83


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hi there, it's Peter Whittle here from the New Culture Forum.
00:00:05 It's a bit of an ad hoc broadcast we're doing today.
00:00:09 It's Saturday, the 10th of April.
00:00:11 I'm here with Rafe Hadlemanku, of course, who you know from the channel.
00:00:16 We've got together today because we didn't really want it to go unmarked,
00:00:22 the momentous event yesterday of the death of Prince Philip.
00:00:26 This is obviously a huge event for our country.
00:00:30 and we wanted to properly consider it and look at it and the implications of it,
00:00:36 what it really means for the country and for the monarchy.
00:00:40 And I want to start actually by asking Rafe,
00:00:43 because a lot of people who know Rafe from counterculture on the channel would not necessarily know.
00:00:48 Rafe, you have been a royal commentator for, what, two decades now?
00:00:53 Yes, I've been a royal commentator for 20-odd years,
00:00:56 since the death of Diana, Princess of Wales, in 1997.
00:01:01 I've marked every single one of the major events of royal history since then
00:01:06 for various international media.
00:01:10 And it's important that we actually put the death of the Duke of Edinburgh
00:01:14 into context within that, because this is, make no mistake,
00:01:19 an extremely important event,
00:01:21 not only in terms of the royal family in British history,
00:01:24 but in terms of our culture.
00:01:25 because this was a man who lived for a hundred years and who really epitomized many of those
00:01:32 key core values that we associate with the royal family and the transformation that has occurred
00:01:40 within society one could even stay within the royal family over that period is very much worth
00:01:46 analyzing and also the impact that it has on britain as a whole too because we have to realize
00:01:53 that within monarchies it's it is events such as weddings funerals jubilees coronations that
00:02:03 actually become the markers the points for us to reflect upon where we are as a nation who we are
00:02:09 as a nation and what we believe are the key values of our nation but you see it's interesting
00:02:15 because that is actually when Walter Badgett the great you know constitutional historian
00:02:21 writing in the 19th century he talked about these universal facts as being the central one of the
00:02:30 central appeals and strengths of monarchy actually that essentially marriages births deaths it kind
00:02:38 of like gives this lineage doesn't it to all of us absolutely budget spoke about the ceremonial
00:02:45 aspect of of the monarchy and that really is one of the key elements that we have to look at
00:02:50 Because, for example, one of the downsides of being the world's oldest continuous democracy is the fact that we don't have as a nation a battle of independence, a revolution, any great tumultuous event that we can look to as being the forging event for our civilization, for our country.
00:03:12 and so being in a monarchy it is those events that is royal births weddings deaths coronations
00:03:19 jubilees that provide those rare opportunities for us to come together as a nation america has
00:03:26 july the 4th is independence day july the 14th in france for bastille day you know in canada it's
00:03:33 july the first canada day but those are events which mark the forging of a nation we haven't got
00:03:40 that so it's through the royal family the living constitution of the crown rather than a piece of
00:03:46 paper is the living embodiment of the constitution that is the monarchy and people need to understand
00:03:52 and i mean for example lots of people on twitter have been moaning about why are we focusing so
00:03:58 much on the bbc about the about prince philip during this time it's because he is part of that
00:04:04 living constitution of the crown and that is actually who we are as a people and as a nation
00:04:09 And it's one of the few times we can get together to actually cohesively reflect upon our nation, history, past, constitution.
00:04:20 You mentioned Twitter there. Thank goodness, as has been said many times, Twitter is not Britain.
00:04:27 But what has been your impression of the way that the death has been handled by the BBC?
00:04:33 because, I don't know if you might remember,
00:04:36 but when the Queen Mother died,
00:04:38 there were quite a lot of criticisms
00:04:39 that it was very slapdash,
00:04:42 that it was too informal.
00:04:44 It doesn't appear to have been that way this time, does it?
00:04:47 Well, I know that many of our viewers
00:04:49 are critics of the BBC,
00:04:51 but I have to say there's been a marked difference
00:04:54 between how they responded to the Queen Mother's death
00:04:57 and how they responded to the Duke of Edinburgh's death.
00:04:59 And yes, people will famously remember
00:05:01 how Peter Sissons, a wonderfully decent reporter
00:05:06 and broadcaster, wore a maroon tie rather than a black tie.
00:05:10 Contrast that, for example, to what we've seen today
00:05:13 in the last 24 hours with black attire everywhere.
00:05:17 But there was also this very destructive attitude
00:05:21 in 2002 when the Queen Mother died
00:05:24 that the nation was over monarchy.
00:05:26 We have to remember the 90s were so destructive
00:05:29 and there was this sort of idea that nobody would come out for this centenarian nobody was
00:05:35 interested but what happened the british public came out in their tens of thousands to show their
00:05:42 support and it was almost as if it was a last dying gift of the queen mother to her daughter
00:05:48 whose golden jubilee was just a few months later and everybody at the time had his feeling that
00:05:55 the golden jubilee would be a damp squib yeah and it was almost as if the queen mother's funeral
00:06:00 laid the groundwork for the for the golden jubilee after it's a great shame now of course
00:06:06 because of covid that the public have don't have a similar opportunity to come out in great numbers
00:06:12 to show their support for prince philip but i think the lives of the queen mother and the duke
00:06:19 of Edinburgh are so similar in terms of the values that they espoused and the importance
00:06:25 that it shows in terms of that essential British spirit of stoicism which I think is waning so
00:06:33 terribly and it would have it had not been for Covid this could actually have been a huge
00:06:38 opportunity for the public to actually reconnect with what it truly means to be British. I think
00:06:44 this thing about stoicism is particularly interesting because it's like the argument
00:06:51 about what we are culturally stoic or not has been fought out in microcosm in the royal family itself
00:06:59 so you had diana i remember there was this sort of like there used to be this kind of game people
00:07:06 played in the 90s you know like a a rather silly dinner party game or whatever so queen or diana
00:07:13 Queen or Diana, and what they really meant
00:07:15 was one was not talking about
00:07:17 emotions, etc, the other one
00:07:19 was spilling them out all over the place
00:07:21 and so in a way the royal family
00:07:23 have been a kind of playhouse for this
00:07:25 cultural battle, haven't they?
00:07:27 You're quite right, absolutely
00:07:28 and I'm not going to be the one to try to
00:07:31 compare and contrast
00:07:32 the Duke of Edinburgh and his
00:07:35 childhood upbringing and background
00:07:37 for example, with those of his
00:07:39 say his grandchildren
00:07:40 and look at how they reacted to that.
00:07:46 What I will say is that Britain transformed completely,
00:07:50 or let us say it became apparent to us all in 1997
00:07:55 with the death of Diana that Britain was a different country,
00:07:59 or as Chamberlain might have said,
00:08:00 a faraway country about which we know little,
00:08:03 which was his reference to Poland at the time,
00:08:05 because there we saw people in the crowds mourning Diana
00:08:09 in a completely illogical manner screaming shouting crying for this woman that they had
00:08:17 never met more than they probably had cried for their own grandmother or mother this national
00:08:22 history that we went through and it was almost as if everything that we thought of as being
00:08:26 british stoicism reserve sang foi the stiff upper lip none of that was present during the death of
00:08:34 diana and that was a alarming wake-up call for many of us who basically wanted to assume that
00:08:41 britain in this current form would have continued but the thing is you know you're not going to draw
00:08:48 comparisons fair enough you know i i don't mind doing it but you know obviously a while ago we
00:08:55 had the interview with bale and harry and it is all about victimhood it's all about how bad
00:09:03 The fact is, is that what we do know, and what many people will know now for the first time, is that Philip in the early days really faced huge hostility, actually, as this kind of incoming foreigner, you know, with no role as such.
00:09:21 But he basically really, really abided by that dictum of never complain, never explain.
00:09:27 All right, well, let's draw comparisons then, right? I want to give a couple of days before going into this, given how soon he had died. But yes, absolutely. But look, before that, this was a man who had the most unorthodox childhood.
00:09:43 Prince Philip would have been put into care today had he lived today and not been a member of the royal family.
00:09:50 This man's upbringing was so tragic and so devastating that one can't imagine how, say, for example, Prince William or Prince Harry would have coped had they been in his position.
00:10:03 And yet Prince Philip showed none of the signs of stress and trauma that we have seen with younger generations.
00:10:09 this was a man who was born on a kitchen table in corfu during the time when the greek monarchy
00:10:15 of which he was into which he was in the lion's succession was extremely unstable his grandfather
00:10:22 king george the first of greece had been assassinated his family were arrested and
00:10:27 exiled king george v in britain sent the royal navy out to rescue them he was taken out of greece
00:10:34 in an orange box he was then shuttled around between family members because his parents were
00:10:41 incapable of looking after him his mother was a schizophrenic put into an asylum his father had no
00:10:47 care for him whatsoever went to monte carlo to live with a mistress he was passed between uncles
00:10:55 and aunts and brothers and sisters rather his sisters got married into germany his favorite
00:11:01 sister died in a plane crash yeah his guardian died at the age of 44 from cancer all by the time
00:11:08 prince philip was 16 years of age now think of what that would put on the uh mind of a person
00:11:16 living today we're talking about oprah winfrey's special six episodes let alone the one episode
00:11:22 that she granted prince harry and yet he was stoic through it all he said well yes this happened to
00:11:28 life must go on yes but also the crucial thing is really is that one he would never have dreamt
00:11:35 of talking energy about his father and his mother and and how it affected him and and i think the
00:11:43 thing is this is a very important point to make really because is that people might like hearing
00:11:48 all of that stuff in the short term but oddly enough over a period of time i think that they
00:11:56 actually start to re-evaluate it and you know so it's the immediacy as opposed to the long-termism
00:12:03 if you like but i think what's important is to actually look at prince philip's life
00:12:09 and see how traumatic it was and how little time he had in his entire life for the indulgence
00:12:19 of self-analysis for the indulgence of all of the things that we now see portrayed in
00:12:26 contemporary society but also through prince harry and megan for example and compare and contrast
00:12:32 that also as you said look at how prince philip was accepted or not accepted i should say into
00:12:39 the royal family when he first met uh when he was first betrothed with the queen in 1947 with a
00:12:47 royal marriage he was an outsider he was german the royal household at the time the establishment
00:12:52 was very closed they regarded him as rough as uneducated as ill-suited to the role and it took
00:12:59 him a good 10 years to actually get to a point where he would be firmly established within the
00:13:06 royal family and he played a major role in ensuring that those who came after him would have an easier
00:13:12 ride of it he was a great comfort to diana for example and he made a great effort to ensure that
00:13:18 those people who were marrying into the firm had an easy time of it now he went through all of that
00:13:24 or that background of his and you compare and contrast that upbringing to prince harry's
00:13:30 upbringing you compare his entry to megan's entry and i'm sorry but there is no comparison at all
00:13:37 And you really begin to think about the thin skin of contemporary society and how it I mean, whenever I think about these things, I always think about Sweden, because Swedish children who are probably the most privileged or amongst the most privileged in the world have the highest levels of depression in the world.
00:13:56 And why is that? Because the school system constantly asks them about their feelings, about their emotions, and they obsess about these things. And I can't help think of that correlation.
00:14:07 A good brisk walk in the open air never did anyone any harm. Where do you think this leaves? I think it's obvious, you know, it's just no great insight here, that there will be a huge amount of sympathy for the Queen.
00:14:23 my feeling
00:14:26 about the Queen
00:14:29 is that in recent years
00:14:31 she's gone on to an entirely different level
00:14:33 but she
00:14:35 is now really the repository
00:14:37 the sole repository of what
00:14:39 you were describing really
00:14:40 isn't she? I mean there's no one
00:14:42 I don't think Charles is in the same way
00:14:45 perhaps Anne but
00:14:46 she's the last wartime
00:14:49 monarch we're going to have
00:14:51 isn't she? That's correct
00:14:53 I still think that there are vestiges of the imperial monarchy
00:14:56 in the Prince of Wales and in the Princess Royal.
00:14:58 I think there is so much.
00:15:00 You called them once the last black and white royals.
00:15:03 Right. Well, it's true. It is very true.
00:15:07 And so there is that change.
00:15:09 I mean, there was a 10-year gap between, for example,
00:15:11 the birth of the Prince of Wales and the Princess Royal
00:15:13 and Andrew and Edward, and there is that shift.
00:15:17 I tried to avoid in 2002 saying that the Queen Mother's death
00:15:21 was the end of an era because i regarded the queen as being her mother's daughter and you
00:15:27 had prince philip still at the time but we are at that point essentially where we're coming to the
00:15:32 point where there is an end to those fundamental concepts that we associated with the british
00:15:39 character that stoicism that reserve that concept of service and duty before and above all else
00:15:48 never complain, never explain.
00:15:52 And the Prince of Wales has explained.
00:15:54 There are others who have, but it was really the Duke of Edinburgh and the Greek.
00:15:59 And it was put very well by one commentator who said,
00:16:03 the Prince of Wales was a romantic, the Duke of Edinburgh was a pragmatist.
00:16:07 Very similar in many respects in terms of their interests,
00:16:11 but it was in terms of their attitude.
00:16:13 And I hate to say it, but we've come to a point
00:16:17 where we have seen Britain go through this cultural revolution
00:16:20 over the last 20, 30 if not more years
00:16:23 and the fact that the Duke of Edinburgh isn't better appreciated
00:16:27 and respected and indeed loved today
00:16:30 is a sign of how far that revolution has gone
00:16:33 because this was a man who was so concerned about conservation
00:16:36 but he wasn't a tree hugger, he wasn't a green
00:16:40 he wasn't an environmentalist, this was a man like Teddy Roosevelt in America
00:16:44 who shot who stalked who hunted but was so concerned about the eradication of species
00:16:51 rather than the torture done to a panda in a zoo somewhere he didn't care about those things he
00:16:59 wouldn't care about tearing up trees at windsor castle but he was very concerned about
00:17:03 forestation and deforestation this was a man who was a conservationist
00:17:08 as a conservative would be a conservative conservative this was a man who was concerned
00:17:15 about art philanthropy so many things which his his son also took on none of that holds any any
00:17:22 any sway today because the ignorant masses that i see complaining about the jug of Edinburgh
00:17:28 focus on things such as the gaffes the alleged gaffes that he's made i think i don't think i
00:17:34 don't know i don't want to call the meeting massive i think the massive people do appreciate
00:17:39 i think on twitter i meant yeah twitter let's be quite clear about that the the people who take
00:17:44 offense the kind of people who take offense are the people who will take offense and in fact that's
00:17:50 what they are doing and if you made a few comments or whatever that's exactly they'll go off on that
00:17:55 i think your point i think is absolutely right it's almost like he's too big a person to exist
00:18:03 in our rather small age i mean we live in a small very trammeled age i think now one thing about the
00:18:12 monarchy generally um there was a poll out this week um which uh looking at people wanted william
00:18:21 20 percent more wanted william to succeed the queen than charles uh be that as it may
00:18:26 uh what i found is interesting about the poll something because i've written about it myself
00:18:30 in that book i did is that around about it was about between 15 and 20 so about 17 percent of
00:18:39 people actually said no neither of them let's have a precedent what that really means though
00:18:45 is since we've been talking about monarchy and we first actually did a debate didn't we in dharma
00:18:51 when we met a long time ago since we've been doing it it's not really changed people keep saying
00:18:58 oh but it's the Queen, they're thinking of the Queen
00:19:01 no, when you
00:19:03 sort of say to people, after she has
00:19:05 gone, do you want it to continue
00:19:06 republicanism stays around
00:19:09 about that figure
00:19:10 Ipsos Mori, one of our most trusted
00:19:13 polling organisations
00:19:15 has asked this question
00:19:17 for well my 30 years
00:19:18 if not more
00:19:20 but the question hasn't changed for the last
00:19:22 20-30 years
00:19:24 and there has never been
00:19:26 a more stable question i would say in britain than support for the monarchy which has barely
00:19:33 wavered even during the 90s when the monarchy was at its lowest ebb in 92 during the annas
00:19:40 horribilis and the destruction of windsor castle and 97 with the death of diana even then there
00:19:45 wasn't a noticeable dip for this so yes it may well be that that that that's um the monarchy
00:19:51 Will endure and survive
00:19:53 I think though
00:19:55 It will be a different monarchy
00:19:56 It's a different country isn't it
00:20:00 I wonder what he would have made
00:20:01 Of all the mask stuff
00:20:02 I wonder what he would have made
00:20:04 Of you know
00:20:05 People walking
00:20:08 On the streets like on the way here
00:20:11 Coming home today
00:20:12 People walking about with masks
00:20:14 We're actually in the open air
00:20:16 Where they don't need to
00:20:17 I just often wonder what he would have thought of that
00:20:20 I mean, you know, you don't need to speculate, but I can't imagine he'd have had that much.
00:20:25 The monarchy has endured and survived in this country, whereas it's collapsed in France and Germany and Russia and elsewhere,
00:20:32 because our monarchy uniquely has been able to evolve and adapt slowly and subtly, never leading the vanguard, but always being behind and slowly changing.
00:20:43 And so the monarchy of today is not the monarchy of the 90s, which is not the monarchy of the 70s, which is not the monarchy of the 50s.
00:20:50 And that has been the solution to its success, changing necessarily, but keeping the fundamental trappings of power.
00:20:57 My only concern is that the monarchy risks disconnecting itself completely if it is to really follow the path which, unfortunately, we are seeing laid down by the younger generation.
00:21:12 and if it loses all of the lessons
00:21:14 and the great example set to it
00:21:18 by people such as the Duke of Edinburgh,
00:21:21 the Queen and the Queen Mother.
00:21:23 I think the biggest thing possibly facing any future monarch
00:21:26 is that we all know the Queen has never given an interview.
00:21:31 Philip did under serious duress.
00:21:35 The Queen has never died.
00:21:37 But that era is entirely gone.
00:21:39 That is simply impossible now, isn't it?
00:21:41 whether it's Charles or whether it's William or whoever it is.
00:21:45 Absolutely.
00:21:47 The Queen Mother gave an interview once.
00:21:49 King George V wrapped her knuckles for it
00:21:51 and she never gave another interview again
00:21:52 and she became the most loved member of the royal family.
00:21:56 Why?
00:21:56 Because she was a blank canvas onto which we could all put our views.
00:22:00 The reality was she was perhaps arguably further to the right
00:22:04 than Genghis Khan on many issues, but nobody actually knew that.
00:22:07 And I think that's one of the qualities that the Duchess of Cambridge,
00:22:11 kate has understood yes don't speak out on these issues because as soon as you speak out on an
00:22:17 issue you become political and you divide and we've seen that with megan for example as soon
00:22:23 as you speak out you become divisive and the success i would argue or the royal family depends
00:22:28 upon that and i see great strength in the duke and duchess of cambridge prince william and kate
00:22:34 in choosing causes
00:22:37 that are important
00:22:38 but aren't divisive.
00:22:41 Well, I mean,
00:22:43 it's been good to talk to you about
00:22:45 it. I mean, we both obviously care
00:22:47 hugely. We're talking from a position
00:22:49 of caring a lot about the institution
00:22:50 and also about
00:22:52 Britain. But
00:22:55 anyway, thank you
00:22:57 very much for watching. I think
00:22:59 I don't quite know what the appropriate
00:23:00 way is of ending something like this, but
00:23:03 I think our thoughts
00:23:05 obviously with the Queen
00:23:07 and next week
00:23:09 because we're recording this on Saturday
00:23:10 we're going to have the funeral
00:23:12 which of course will be in
00:23:14 much different circumstances than otherwise
00:23:17 it would be
00:23:18 but I think that by then maybe
00:23:21 some real appreciation
00:23:22 I think would have been flowing
00:23:24 the past week
00:23:26 thanks very much
00:23:27 and we'll see you back in the studio
00:23:31 next time around.
00:23:34 Okay, take care. Thank you.