New Culture Forum - March 31, 2021


Rod Dreher On The Rise Of Totalitarianism In The West & Lessons From Soviet Dissidents

Is It Dangerous To Make Misogyny A Hate Crime? Why Is Sarah Everard's Murder Being Politicised? Prince Philip: An Example For Woke Prince Harry. Has Traditional Britain Died With Prince Philip?

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

171.11

Word count

6,857

Sentence count

147


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whitfall.
00:00:26 Now, my guest today recently had one of the most discussed books in religious circles, well,
00:00:33 for the past decade. It was called The Benedict Option, this is it here, and it was a bestseller.
00:00:40 Rod Dreher is senior editor at the American Conservative. He's also contributed to numerous
00:00:47 publications such as the Wall Street Journal and the New York Post. He has a new book out,
00:00:53 But Live Not by Lies, it's a manual for Christian dissidents.
00:00:59 I'm very pleased he's joining me today from America.
00:01:01 Thank you very, very much indeed for coming on, Rod.
00:01:05 Thanks for having me, Peter.
00:01:06 It's a pleasure.
00:01:07 Can I explain, first of all, this Live Not by Lies, a manual for Christian dissidents,
00:01:14 is it aimed entirely at Christians?
00:01:18 or because when I was reading it and it seemed to me that it could also be a manual for
00:01:25 conservatives for example it would you say that that is correct yeah I that is absolutely correct
00:01:31 I wrote it as a Christian for Christians and the people I interviewed in the former Soviet Union
00:01:38 and the Soviet bloc were Christian dissidents but I found much to my pleasure and delight that
00:01:45 it has a readership beyond Christians and even beyond conservatives. Barry Weiss is a very brave
00:01:53 young American journalist. She's a Jewish lesbian on the center left, and she's taken up the book
00:01:59 and is championing the book because she said the fight that we're all facing now against militant
00:02:05 wokeness is something that everyone who believes in old-fashioned liberal values of free speech,
00:02:12 freedom of assembly, and so forth, need to embrace. Also in the U.S., Brett Weinstein, a professor and
00:02:20 biologist, he and his wife, Heather Hying, also a professor, were driven out of their university
00:02:26 because they would not go along with wokeness, even though they are both atheist and of the left.
00:02:31 They've been championing the book. So we do have to form these alliances across religious boundaries,
00:02:36 even across political boundaries, to defend the sort of society that we recognize as good.
00:02:43 I think that there's a couple of instances actually in Live Not My Lies,
00:02:47 where I think you mentioned, for example, a Christian being asked by a dyed-in-the-war liberal
00:02:54 to go to church, for example, with him.
00:02:59 Yeah, I'm not sure I recall that particular story. Could you tell me a little bit more?
00:03:05 Well, it's just that basically you were making the point that, of course, we, you know, have to reach out, as it were, to liberals.
00:03:12 Oh, yeah, yeah.
00:03:13 You know, and that basically there was somebody who was, you know, pretty staunch liberal, just simply wanting to see what he could possibly get from going to the church with the Christian guy.
00:03:25 Right, right. And, you know, I was told when I was in Prague, I was interviewing a woman named Camilla Bendova.
00:03:32 She's an older woman now.
00:03:33 She and her late husband, Václav Benda, were the only Christians in Václav Havel's inner circle of dissidents.
00:03:40 And I remember asking her, because they're fairly strict Catholics, the Bendas,
00:03:47 said, how did you and your husband work along with the other dissidents?
00:03:52 Because Václav Havel's circle was famously, no pun intended, bohemian.
00:03:56 They traded partners all the time.
00:03:59 Camilla said, listen, when you're in a situation where everybody is afraid to speak out,
00:04:04 when you find someone who is brave enough to risk their livelihood and their liberty,
00:04:11 even their life, to stand up against totalitarianism, that person is your friend and ally and must be.
00:04:18 So we have to try to learn more about each other's lives and figure out what we have in common
00:04:24 and where we can stand together in common against this common enemy.
00:04:28 I think if I could just explain to people who aren't familiar, I mean, what I would say first of all, Rod, is that when we get a lot of comments coming back to us on this channel from people and they're with us and they understand the problems, we don't almost have to go into them.
00:04:45 the problems of wokeness, the fact that these orthodoxies are now in place
00:04:51 and you disregard them at your peril, all of these things.
00:04:56 But they always say to me, what do we do, right?
00:04:59 What should we do?
00:05:00 And it seems to me that, first of all, with the Benedict option,
00:05:04 and now in a way with Live Not By Liars,
00:05:08 you are sort of setting out what people might possibly do, aren't you?
00:05:13 That's right.
00:05:13 The Benedict Option was written. It's a more explicitly Christian book. It's saying, look, we live in a post-Christian civilization now.
00:05:22 And mind you, in America, we're behind Britain in terms of de-Christianization, but we're getting there very quickly.
00:05:29 So how do we live as Christians to hold on to our faith in a time when we may actually be persecuted for the faith or at least one is socially marginalized for being a practicing Christian?
00:05:43 Live Not By Lies, by contrast, is about what Christians should do, and not only Christians, but conservatives should do in a world in which they are actively persecuted.
00:05:55 And so what I did with this book is I, let me back up a bit, the origin of the book came when I got a phone call from a prominent American physician whose elderly mother lived with him.
00:06:07 she had been born she was born in czechoslovakia had been sent to prison for four years by the
00:06:14 communist authorities for being a quote vatican spy meaning that she refused to stop going to
00:06:20 prayer meetings at her catholic church the old lady eventually emigrated to america after she
00:06:25 was released from prison had her family here and lived her life she was saying to her son son the
00:06:31 things I'm seeing happen in America now remind me so much of what I saw when communism first came to
00:06:37 my country. And she's talking about this wokeness, this people losing their jobs for saying the wrong
00:06:44 thing, having the social media mob turn on them and so forth. Well, when the doctor said that to
00:06:49 me, Peter, I said, well, that's pretty scary, but it sounds kind of alarmist. I mean, my mother's
00:06:54 elderly too. She watches a lot of cable news and gets frightened. So what I did was I contacted
00:06:59 this couple i know in the uk at cambridge the bolabashes bela and gabby bolabash uh defected
00:07:06 from hungary in the 1960s he was a star mathematician he went on to teach at trinity
00:07:10 college cambridge became a don there and has recently retired i asked bela i said this is
00:07:16 what the old czech woman said is it true he said oh absolutely it's true gabby and i and our
00:07:22 retirement here in the uk we're watching the bbc daily we're reading the newspapers and we keep
00:07:27 saying this is just like our youth and again peter it was it's the same thing you know terror of being
00:07:33 canceled of being of losing everything they even said to me he said that people here progressives
00:07:40 have no uh no problem lying about you to get you to destroy you if you're the political opponent
00:07:48 i thought about that several years later when uh the the new statesman came after uh sir roger
00:07:54 scrutiny right and uh this is what they're talking about so the book i have written was
00:07:59 to go over and speak i went over to europe and uh former eastern europe and russia to speak to
00:08:05 dissidents to say what can we do to prepare ourselves to resist what is coming and that
00:08:13 that's the book do you see yourself as a dissident you know i never have i'm a middle class guy i'm
00:08:21 a conservative not a republican i'm a conservative i'm a church-going christian i have kids i live
00:08:26 a very comfortable hobbit-like life but increasingly i am becoming a dissident because
00:08:31 if you do not completely endorse the the woke agenda so to speak on race um sexual orientation
00:08:40 gender identity uh sex and so on then you are not just wrong you're evil i i've written three
00:08:47 New York Times bestsellers now. I've been a journalist for over 30 years, but there's no
00:08:52 way I could be hired now at a major American newspaper simply because of the stances I've
00:08:57 taken. And it's weird to think that as a conservative, I'm really an old-fashioned
00:09:02 liberal because I want there to be freedom of speech, diversity of opinion. I want to be
00:09:07 challenged when someone thinks I'm wrong about something. I can separate ideas from identity,
00:09:13 But this, I think, is one of the core problems of what we're dealing with now.
00:09:17 You have this generation of progressives who can't separate ideas from identity and who believe that if you object to what they're saying, then you're denigrating them as people.
00:09:28 This is insane. But this is where we are.
00:09:31 Also, you know, the point as well, you mentioned about Roger Scruton there, but just generally is that one of the things that seems to be in common with the Soviet way of doing things is to delegitimize the actual person.
00:09:43 You know, to to actually delegitimize them, you know, don't take any notice of them, X or Y, because they are this.
00:09:52 So now it's very much if you're a white heterosexual male, isn't it?
00:09:58 Yeah. And just today I was reading in the newspaper that in the city of Oakland, California, a very woke city,
00:10:05 a group of donors, private donors, have given money to the mayor to distribute to very poor
00:10:12 families who are suffering in this COVID lockdown. But white people, poor white families, are not
00:10:18 allowed to get any of this money. This is madness. You know, to the left in doing this, I guess they
00:10:25 see all white people as being oppressors. This is what social justice theory tells them. And
00:10:31 these poor people aren't really poor. They are actually of the oppressor class. I see what's
00:10:37 happening is the left is delegitimizing any opposition coming from people who are of the
00:10:45 wrong social categories. This is exactly what happened in the Soviet Union. In Live Not By
00:10:50 Lies, my book, I have a quote from Martin Latsis. He was the head of the Cheka, the predecessor of
00:10:56 the KGB in Ukraine right after the communist revolution and he sent out a communicate to his
00:11:03 agents to help them understand how to enforce the red terror he said don't look at individuals and
00:11:10 ask and try to find out what they themselves did to oppose the Soviet regime that doesn't matter
00:11:16 rather look at them and ask yourself which social class do they belong to and that will tell you
00:11:22 whether or not to oppress them. This, he said, is the essence of the red terror. Well, we have the
00:11:29 same thing. Perhaps we're not sending people to gulag jet or killing them. Maybe it's more of a
00:11:33 pink terror than a red terror. But we do see exactly this, where people are judged guilty
00:11:38 by virtue of various aspects of their identity, their race, their sexual desire, even their
00:11:49 political party they are guilty of crimes even if they did not commit them and this i think peter
00:11:55 it's crazy that the the backlash the the genuinely fascist backlash that this is going to call up i
00:12:03 mean i i guess the woke think that the that people are just going to keep taking it and taking it and
00:12:09 taking it but um you know i i live in a part of the u.s that's very conservative there are a lot
00:12:15 poor people here both black and white and uh to have the these elites who run all the american
00:12:21 institutions uh even certainly corporations and now it's even come to the military to have them
00:12:27 all denouncing wide swathes of the american population as being guilty somehow of racism
00:12:34 and bigotry solely because of the color of their skin and and factors like that it cannot help but
00:12:41 cause a tremendous backlash they the left has no idea the kind of demons that it is summoning up
00:12:47 you mentioned there rod the i mean first of all when you talk about the people getting uh welfare
00:12:54 you know and but only black people you know we're talking about racism here actually aren't we i
00:12:59 mean you know it's anti-white there's no other way of putting it uh you mentioned there the military
00:13:05 How can you just give us a broad picture of how the military in America is becoming woke if I had it has succumbed to this new orthodoxy.
00:13:15 This is something extraordinary and it's happened very quickly.
00:13:19 The military is like every other institution in American society.
00:13:23 It has been affected by this ideology that is spreading among elite networks is woke ideology.
00:13:30 woke ideology. Well, Tucker Carlson, our TV host, a conservative TV host, he recently
00:13:36 criticized the military for being concerned more with social engineering by having their officers
00:13:42 read the works of Ibram Kendi, who's now the guru of the moment about anti-racism. It's really
00:13:49 neo-racism. But by having the officers read that and by being really concerned about getting
00:13:57 pregnant women, body armor, things like that, Tucker Carlson said, wait, are we forgetting that
00:14:03 the role of any military is to win wars and protect the country, not to do social engineering?
00:14:09 Well, it was fascinating to see that the senior brass at the military at the Pentagon came down
00:14:16 on Tucker Carlson like a ton of bricks. This is extraordinary that the military should never do
00:14:22 that should never whether if they if they were coming down on far left journalists criticizing
00:14:28 them it is the role of the military like the the royal family in your country to not engage
00:14:34 politically but they did and i i think what's happening i've been getting a lot of emails from
00:14:39 uh soldiers and sailors saying yeah i feel like there's no place for me in this military now that
00:14:45 they are clearly going to start discriminating on the basis of race and sex. And I feel that
00:14:53 I have to get out. I was even told by a man I met in Virginia recently, he works at the Pentagon,
00:14:59 a soldier, and he told me that it's his privilege to serve, but he has a newborn son and he sees now
00:15:07 that he has to tell his son, I can't recommend that you go into this military because it doesn't
00:15:12 care about defending the country or rather that it does but that's not job one job one is to uh
00:15:18 is to satisfy this ideological um uh structure that's that's making america weaker yes
00:15:26 you mention in the book uh you use the term a lot in live not by lies uh the term soft
00:15:35 totalitarianism i think you've sort of already referred to it maybe by you when you talk about
00:15:41 the pink as it were pink uh orthodox but basically this is sort of if you like a more of a slow
00:15:50 creep totalitarianism would you is that how you would characterize it sure that's part of it um
00:15:57 i you know whenever we talk about totalitarianism the first images that come to mind are the gulags
00:16:03 and the secret police the kgb the midnight knock at the door george orwell 1984 because that has
00:16:10 been our experience of totalitarianism of the 20th century well what's happening now the these
00:16:16 these people who grew up under hard totalitarianism they sense that the same thing is coming
00:16:22 now but it's coming in a much softer way in a in a way that has more to do with uh
00:16:28 creating a safe space so-called safe space to turn the whole country into that and it's coming
00:16:33 for therapeutic reasons like we we mustn't say anything critical of uh because we might be we
00:16:40 might trigger someone we might they may not be able to to handle it all of this is part of its
00:16:45 softness but it i think the essence of it goes uh not to orwell but to aldous huxley and brave new
00:16:51 world you know the the two great totalitarian novels in english of the 20th century were 1984
00:16:56 and huxley's brave new world if you read brave new world the the totalitarianism the dystopia
00:17:03 they've set up there is one based on comfort in orwell the the controller's big brother uses
00:17:10 fear and pain and terror to coerce people into conformity but in the world controllers in brave
00:17:17 new world actually dose them with drugs that make them feel pleasure give them all the sex they want
00:17:23 porn entertainment uh it is a and they're happy to give up their individual rights or political
00:17:29 rights for the sake of this comfort in this constant feeling good uh there's a scene in
00:17:34 chapter 17 of brave new world in which uh mustafa man the world controller for europe confronts the
00:17:41 dissident there john the savage and he says to him john why wouldn't you want to join this society
00:17:46 uh there's comfort everywhere we have he calls it christianity without tears well the savage says
00:17:53 well i don't want that you're all too comfortable i want uh sin i want god i want love i want passion
00:17:59 He wants to be human. And Mustafa Amin says to him, it sounds like you're fighting for your right to be unhappy.
00:18:06 John says, yes, that's what I'm fighting for.
00:18:08 So all of that, Peter, is simply to say that we are dealing now with the totalitarianism that is creeping along by trying to make people,
00:18:19 trying to play on people's fears of being unhappy.
00:18:22 And I think we're seeing, in fact, I know we're seeing, especially the younger generations in this country,
00:18:27 people being completely willing to see political liberties like freedom of speech freedom of
00:18:33 religion and so forth go by the wayside as long as they are being cast aside in an effort to keep
00:18:40 people from being anxious and afraid and unsafe uh it's real madness but um you know and people
00:18:47 can't see it coming so many of my fellow americans can't see it coming because they're they're looking
00:18:52 like behind some Maginot line they're they're looking for the KGB and the gulags to come back
00:18:58 when in fact this soft totalitarianism is going through Belgium to extend the metaphor uh and and
00:19:04 taking over our institutions and managing to marginalize people and push them out of their
00:19:09 careers and silence them without ever once having to bring the power of the state against them
00:19:15 it's interesting you know that uh Marx quite famously is one one of the things that most
00:19:20 people know about Marx is that he thought that Britain would be the first country to have a
00:19:26 revolution simply because it was the first to industrialize with the working class and that
00:19:31 Russia would be way down the list because it was agrarian and feudal. Now in our time you would
00:19:38 sort of I would always say well America is the absolute last place where any of this is going to
00:19:42 happen but do you think that america is in a revolutionary state given your terms of reference
00:19:50 about haxie or a pre-revolutionary one it does appear like that from the outside you know i in
00:19:59 live not by lies i have a chapter devoted to hannah arendt yes and her book the origins of
00:20:04 totalitarianism aren't as uh your viewers no doubt know was a german jewish refugee from nazism and
00:20:11 After the war, she wrote a book in which she attempted to explain why it was that Germany and Russia both went in for totalitarianism, two different totalitarianisms, but totalitarianism all the same.
00:20:23 And she discerned that there were certain aspects of those pre-totalitarian societies that made them susceptible.
00:20:29 Arendt says by far the most important aspect of a pre-totalitarian society is mass alienation
00:20:36 and atomization, mass loneliness, because people who are disconnected from other people,
00:20:42 from institutions and ways of life, traditional ways of life, they become susceptible to anyone
00:20:47 who comes in and tells them, we'll give you meaning, we'll give you solidarity, we'll
00:20:51 give you purpose, just believe what we're telling you.
00:20:54 Well, I think that that absolutely describes contemporary America, and I think that's one reason why wokeness has moved so fast, especially among the elites who are deracinated from any form of tradition, alienated from institutions, and fearful about the future of America.
00:21:15 So they're conforming. And I don't know whether we're pre-revolutionary in America in terms of taking up arms.
00:21:21 I certainly hope not. But this thing is going a lot farther than I imagined it ever would.
00:21:27 My mother was telling me that she's more afraid now for our country than she ever has been.
00:21:33 And I reminded her, I said, look, you lived through the riots of the late 60s, early 70s and all those bombings.
00:21:38 And she said, yeah, I know. But we felt then that there was at least a strong base in the middle of the country that would keep things from going too off track.
00:21:49 Now, Peter, that has gone. And I think one reason it has gone is because of the power of the Internet and social media to dissolve any sort of local ties, local ties of authority that might keep people grounded.
00:22:06 it when i was in poland last year doing reporting for two years ago actually for doing reporting for
00:22:11 live not by lies i spoke to a teacher a brit who teaches high school in poland and he said that
00:22:19 nothing in that country is more powerful in terms of influencing the youth than social media not the
00:22:26 church not the family certainly not the state or any other institution in polish society it's all
00:22:31 globalized social media tiktok will is forming the next generations in these countries even
00:22:37 countries that had the experience of totalitarianism this i think is the core of the revolution that is
00:22:43 brewing here in america and no doubt also in western europe you in the book you make the point
00:22:53 that obviously you know this isn't just a an analysis of what's happening how do you react
00:22:58 to it so obviously live not by lies is a quote from alexander solzhenitsyn uh which you mention
00:23:06 in the book essentially what you're saying in this rod is it not that you just simply
00:23:11 just it's almost an act of revolution to defy you know in other words i will not go along with
00:23:20 your definition i will not yes sign along the dotted line i will not do this what are the kind
00:23:26 of instances because people will want to know how can they practically do this what are the
00:23:31 instances that you would suggest where can they make their point i got an email yesterday from
00:23:39 a vicar in the church of england uh somewhere i forget which diocese in which he was sending me
00:23:44 data from mailings from the bishops of the c of e saying that they're going all in on critical
00:23:51 race theory, which is going to destroy the church. It's clearly going to do that. But he wanted to
00:23:57 know now. He said that we can't stop this, but it doesn't look that we can stop this. So I want to
00:24:02 be part of forming some sort of underground resistance to it. So I was able to put him in
00:24:07 touch with other people I know in the Church of England who are starting to build this sort of
00:24:13 resistance. That's one example. I don't know what form that resistance will take, but they clearly
00:24:18 believe that we have to build an underground in resistance to the corrupted bishops of our own
00:24:23 church because we cannot live by the lies that they're expecting us to. You know, I mentioned
00:24:28 in the book the case Vaclav Havel brought up. He was the first president of a free Czechoslovakia
00:24:34 and spent time in prison as a political prisoner. He brought up a fictional case in a 1977 essay he
00:24:42 wrote called the power of the powerless and in it he talks about this fictional green grocer
00:24:47 let's say the green grocer has to live like everybody else does in the city they have to
00:24:52 put a sign up in their shop window saying workers of the world unite the marxist slogan well nobody
00:24:59 believes it but everybody does this so they'll uh they won't have any trouble well what happens if
00:25:05 the green grocer decides uh to take the sign down he said i don't believe this i'm not going to say
00:25:10 what i don't believe what happens to him the government comes they take away his business
00:25:14 from him he has to work as a janitor or something his kids can't go to the best universities
00:25:20 there is a real price to be paid but what happens when he suffers for his principles
00:25:27 in public he shows everybody else that it is possible to live in truth if you're willing to
00:25:33 suffer for it and it and if enough people are willing to do that the system will fall apart
00:25:37 said hobble. I would suggest to listeners and viewers of this podcast, think about ways you
00:25:44 are compelled to say things you don't believe, or at least stay silent to avoid getting in trouble.
00:25:51 Think about what it would take to stand up. Think about the cost to you of not standing up,
00:25:58 of being silent. I think first of all, you should start looking for jobs in which you will not be
00:26:03 pressure this way before you stand up but at some point you have to stand up you have to take your
00:26:08 kids out of these schools where this garbage is being taught you have to be willing to pay a price
00:26:14 publicly or privately for integrity this is the thing that the core of what i say in live not by
00:26:21 lies and what i heard from peter from these the people in in eastern europe and the former
00:26:26 communist countries that suffering is the key here being willing to take these risks to lose
00:26:33 money to lose status to be marginalized to be hated but if you do it for the sake of truth
00:26:40 you will triumph in the end it is difficult isn't it but in some ways you know if one's going to
00:26:47 give advice to young people about jobs now you know it happens to me sometimes you know i've got
00:26:54 godsons and and things um you're almost so find yourself saying just don't do anything where
00:27:01 you're going to be in a corporation don't do anything where you're going to so it comes down
00:27:05 to well it would have come down to the armed services but it seems like not anymore no
00:27:10 essentially in other words be your own boss that's the only thing maybe less left to you
00:27:17 absolutely that's and that is precisely the advice i'm giving to my younger son he's i have
00:27:23 two boys uh one is 21 one is 17 the 21 year old wants to go into museum work and i've tried to
00:27:30 tell him like this is such a woke profession that it's going to be very hard for you as an honest
00:27:36 person to do the work you want to do but i guess he's going to give it a try we'll have to learn
00:27:40 it on his own the 17 year old i'm telling him exactly that be a plumber or something like that
00:27:46 or own your own business uh and it's it's awful that it should come to this it should not come to
00:27:52 this but this is the this is reality this is where we are i uh in the benedict option book
00:27:58 a physician told me a prominent american physician who would not let me name him
00:28:02 said that he does not want his own children to go into medicine because he can see how quickly it
00:28:09 is becoming heavily politicized since that man told me that it has now become standard procedure
00:28:15 in american hospitals in the in american medicine to um when someone presents themselves even a minor
00:28:21 saying that i am gender dysphoric i want to be whatever the opposite sex is you have to affirm
00:28:27 it even if it is against your best medical judgment even if you have nothing against
00:28:32 transgenders at all but you think that's not going to help this person doesn't matter that's a
00:28:37 political matter you have to affirm it i can see now why this doctor would not want his children
00:28:42 doing that because you have to lie as a for the sake of keeping your medical license yes
00:28:48 the benedict option you mentioned there um i i kept on having these uh images of the name of
00:28:56 the rose you know the uh yes you know and these sort of communities where they basically sort of
00:29:01 protect obviously as in the dark ages they protected illuminated manuscripts and various
00:29:07 arts artworks um that's not obviously what you're saying especially in the option but
00:29:13 the idea is somehow that one should that there is safety in numbers is that is that surely it
00:29:19 that you should make societies and keep your you know help each other associate with each other
00:29:26 sure sure yeah that's exactly it i mean it's uh it's almost a re-ghettoization um because there's
00:29:33 safety in in the ghetto to some extent now i i have to qualify that i'm not talking about um
00:29:40 physical safety although there may be that too but i'm talking about people who want to keep
00:29:45 their culture and people who want to keep their faith um if i don't believe that we should head
00:29:51 for the hills and build high walls i don't live that way i don't recommend living that way i but
00:29:56 But I think that if we are going to keep as Christians, at least, if we're going to keep a robust faith, we need to build thicker communities of faith and discipleship so that when we go out into the world, we can be faithful Christians and represent Jesus Christ in the proper way.
00:30:14 A friend of mine, Andrew Sullivan, who is, you know, gay and a conservative, he said, he told me that what the Benedict Option is, it served an important role for gay people, this sort of thing, going into gay neighborhoods back before, you know, back in the 70s, 60s, 70s, and 80s.
00:30:36 They found a lot of spiritual and moral strength there living together where they they didn't have to fear being beaten on the street or things like that.
00:30:48 And they were they were able to be together and celebrate their own culture.
00:30:52 I don't see anything particularly wrong with that.
00:30:54 I mean, it's certainly it's certainly possible that people can withdraw into their own culture for malicious reasons, for racist reasons.
00:31:02 But I don't think that any time, I don't think it's necessarily that.
00:31:07 And when I was in Italy working on the Benedict Option book, I found this Catholic community at a seaside in an Italian, small Italian city, San Benedetto del Toronto.
00:31:18 And these are the most wonderful, happy people.
00:31:20 They're Catholic and very Catholic, but not angry about it.
00:31:23 And they live in their own houses, they go to their own Catholic churches, but they come together around this sort of clubhouse to do things together, to grow gardens, to build the community.
00:31:36 They have their own community school called the School of G.K. Chesterton.
00:31:39 And it's a wonderful way to live.
00:31:42 These are people who are not alienated from their church, from their tradition, or from each other.
00:31:48 they are enjoying their lives
00:31:50 and they want
00:31:51 but they want to
00:31:51 this intensifies their
00:31:53 commitment to each other
00:31:55 and to the Catholic Church
00:31:58 living together as they do
00:31:59 and I think it's a wonderful way to live
00:32:01 and I wish I had something like that here
00:32:02 finally
00:32:05 Rod
00:32:06 I want to ask you something
00:32:08 it might seem a bit incoherent
00:32:10 but I know what I mean
00:32:12 so if I can see if I can convey it to you
00:32:15 if you're incoherent
00:32:16 come sit by me
00:32:17 and we'll we'll have a great conversation i think the thing is is is this is i totally see everything
00:32:24 that you're saying um i have found that i would define myself as a cultural christian i know
00:32:31 that's a terrible get out possibly for people like you but i would say that i've never particularly
00:32:36 but i utterly see um particularly now that things are under attack i would line up with it i think
00:32:43 churchill said once you know he his attitude was to the church was a bit like a flying buttress
00:32:49 he supported it from the outside right that that's always how i felt however i have found
00:32:56 religion creeping in more and more to conversations i'm having with friends that never would have
00:33:01 discussed religion it's almost like we know something's happening you know now does that
00:33:08 sounds nebulous to you but i would almost say what would you say to me as someone who has never
00:33:14 really believed as you but i but at the same time completely would support christianity
00:33:18 in all its forms because it forms the basis of my society but should i therefore go the should i
00:33:27 just not piggyback on it anymore and just sign up what what what would you say to that well you
00:33:33 can't sign up if you don't really believe it's better to be faithful to your conscience if your
00:33:37 conscious tells you that this isn't true or you can't affirm it then listen to your conscience
00:33:42 i would hope that you would keep keep searching and keep an open mind and an open heart and perhaps
00:33:48 uh perhaps the the grace of god will uh will call you in i i believe that god is always there and
00:33:55 he's always knocking uh wanting us to to come to him uh to christ but that said i'm glad to have
00:34:02 you there i'm glad that people can people are like you people like you can recognize the value
00:34:08 of christianity though i'm tom holland uh in his recent book dominion very good book you know he
00:34:15 is uh he writes in there about how he though not a believer has discovered the the deep value of
00:34:21 christianity as the root of the things he does value as a liberal um but i i think that ultimately
00:34:28 uh peter people the reason you're having the kind of conversations you're having
00:34:32 is people realize that you can't simply have cultural christianity that cult is the basis
00:34:38 of culture and that if we are going to save the things that that many of us whether we're
00:34:44 believers or not believe are worth saving that ultimately it's going to have to require some
00:34:48 sort of serious religious commitment when i was interviewing these people these dissidents
00:34:54 from in the former soviet bloc all of them said that if you're going to be able to withstand the
00:35:01 kind of attacks that you're going to to get from uh from your persecutors you have to be deeply
00:35:07 rooted in if not religion then some kind of serious transcendent set of moral beliefs
00:35:14 otherwise you'll be crushed because not because you're weak but just because there's no reason
00:35:19 If materialism is all there is, then you have every reason to capitulate.
00:35:25 Well, so I also think, and this is going to be my next book, Peter, that the world is going to be re-enchanted one way or the other, because people cannot live with this flat materialism.
00:35:36 the novels of michelle welbeck that he's one of my favorite novelists even though they're very grim
00:35:42 but i think he's absolutely spot on in his diagnosis of the limelades that is crushing
00:35:48 western post-christian civilization sooner or later we're going to be re-enchanted the question
00:35:54 is where is it going to come from and i think that this is one reason i am become more outspoken
00:36:00 about my christianity i'm an ortho eastern orthodox christian now and i don't i don't want
00:36:06 to be a christian who's a sort of nationalist or using it to bash people but i do believe that um
00:36:12 that it's true and that if we stand in the public square and testify to what we believe is true
00:36:19 that other people who are feeling like you and your friends are will perhaps be drawn to it that
00:36:26 One of the men I write about in the book, Viktor Popkov, he was a Russian in the 1970s who was not raised with religion at all, but he became so overwhelmed by the malaise and the despondency of the late Soviet period that he didn't know what to do with his life.
00:36:42 he read Camus and thought, I've got to find a reason to live. That's when he discovered this
00:36:48 small group of Christians in Moscow, led by a man named Alexander Ogorodnikov, who came from a
00:36:54 prominent communist family, became a Christian in his 20s, and started a prayer group. Popkov said
00:37:00 that they knew when they gathered in Moscow, the KGB was all around them, that they were being
00:37:05 watched, and they were eventually going to all go to prison, as they did. But he said that being
00:37:10 there with that group of people who are willing to pray together and sing hymns together and just
00:37:15 be together in freedom he said that was golden those were the most meaningful times of my life
00:37:22 and i think in a similar way today we are going to find more and more people of goodwill like
00:37:28 yourself who do not espouse the the religion of christianity but who can see from the outside
00:37:35 something very good there and who want to be part of it and my friend douglas murray is a lot like
00:37:41 this too i mean he's one of the best allies christians can have much better allied than
00:37:45 many christians because he's an honest man and a brave man so um god bless these these men and
00:37:51 women who who are fellow travelers of of christians but i do hope that eventually they will
00:37:58 they and you will come to embrace the source of the things that give us joy and meaning well thank
00:38:03 you it does seem to be that there is some some sort of acknowledgement that more is needed you
00:38:13 know that that it's not just enough to say oh yeah sure i'm with you you know there is this feeling
00:38:18 because i can just tell you the people that i i know obviously you don't know them uh who would
00:38:25 never have been thinking about this at one point and i think it's testament to to what we're up
00:38:31 against which is what you talk about in your book um what the your the book by the way again
00:38:37 is live not by lies a manual for christian dissidents and it's available now on amazon or
00:38:44 well if the bookshops were open i'm sure it would be in the bookshops too um thank you very very
00:38:50 much for that well uh peter it was great to be with you and i just want to mention very briefly
00:38:55 I should have mentioned at the last question, W.H. Auden became a return to Christianity when he was living in New York just before the, just at the outbreak of the Second World War.
00:39:06 He went into a movie theater in a heavily German neighborhood of Manhattan.
00:39:10 They were watching some Nazi propaganda film at the beginning of the movie, and people stood up and screaming about kill the Poles, kill the Poles, because it was about the invasion of Poland.
00:39:20 and odd walk out and said he realized that the only force powerful enough to fight this to resist
00:39:26 this was christianity and he himself returned to his faith then that one of the greatest english
00:39:31 poets of the 20th century so if audyn can do it and he did it for precisely the reason you're
00:39:36 pointing out it's there for all of us so thank you peter so much for that thought and uh all the
00:39:43 very best to you and i hope that maybe uh we can speak again you know a year down the line or some
00:39:49 other time it'd be lovely thank you friend that's it for so what you're
00:39:54 saying is this week and we shall see you next time in the meantime please do
00:39:59 remember want you to subscribe thank you