New Culture Forum - March 26, 2021


Is It Dangerous To Make Misogyny A Hate Crime? Why Is Sarah Everard's Murder Being Politicised?

Rod Liddle: The Woke Are Erasing 500 Years Of Western Civilisation Rod Dreher On The Rise Of Totalitarianism In The West & Lessons From Soviet Dissidents

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

161.97

Word count

8,235

Sentence count

142

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now before we talk about this week's
00:00:18 subject I just want to say please do subscribe to us won't you we are now on a hundred and twelve
00:00:24 thousand subscribers and 12 million views but we want it to keep going up so
00:00:29 please do remember to subscribe just click on the subscribe button it's
00:00:33 totally free next door there is a little bell sign and that if you click on that
00:00:37 will give you notifications of our shows as they come up now this week it's a
00:00:44 very simple question I'm going to start with should misogyny be a hate crime now
00:00:50 Now, just simply for our own information, because these things get very, very complicated often,
00:00:55 let's be quite clear about what we're talking about.
00:00:58 According to the Oxford Dictionary, what misogyny is,
00:01:02 it is a hatred or dislike of or prejudice against women.
00:01:07 That's what we are actually talking about,
00:01:09 because it's been in the news over the past couple of weeks.
00:01:11 To discuss this, I'm very, very pleased to say we've got Toby Young,
00:01:16 columnist and author and general secretary of the free speech union one of the best things
00:01:21 actually to start over the past year in this area claire fox or baroness fox of buckley to you and
00:01:29 me uh was obviously a former brexit party mep and emma webb from civitas um can i start by asking
00:01:38 you um claire you were actually in the house of lords but you're not when this was debated last
00:01:44 week um did you speak i did and what did you say i said that um misogyny is a very strong
00:01:54 term to be describing the range of activities that people were talking about because it could
00:02:01 be anything from catcalling um you know leering unwanted approaches so i think it's a a very
00:02:11 dramatic hyperbolic phrase it also was suggesting that crimes and we were actually discussing it in
00:02:20 relation to domestic abuse are driven by um you know hatred of women and we have no idea
00:02:26 so the only way that you can know whether somebody is driven to hit somebody or catcall
00:02:32 or anything that is hatred is if you treat it as a thought crime so i object as a woman to
00:02:38 a whole range of interactions between men and women being seen as being driven by hate before
00:02:44 we go anywhere else the idea that it should be a crime is ridiculous and just the final thing is
00:02:51 is that in every single instance and particularly in the instance we were talking about in the house
00:02:56 of lords it was deemed to be the perception of the victim or a third party so it would never be
00:03:06 a proven crime because it could only be based on i think that you in my opinion everything you've
00:03:13 said to me is driven by misogyny so everything about it is uh problematic uh to coin a phrase
00:03:21 yes uh toby it's not quite a hate crime yet is it can you explain the situation to us it's sort
00:03:29 of halfway there isn't it? Yes well first of all the government has accepted an amendment
00:03:37 to the domestic abuse bill but it's still a bill it's not yet an act of parliament
00:03:43 and the amendment doesn't make misogyny a hate crime what it does is it instructs the police
00:03:51 forces of England and Wales to record those crimes that they think are motivated by hatred
00:04:02 of the victim's sex or gender. So that's not quite the same thing as just requiring them to record
00:04:12 those crimes they think are motivated by misogyny, because it would include crimes that the police
00:04:18 believe are motivated by misandry as well. But we know in reality that it will mean in the vast
00:04:27 majority of cases, crimes being recorded that the police believe are motivated by misogyny.
00:04:34 And as Claire has just said, they'll base that belief in large part on the perception of the
00:04:40 victim, which is a pretty nebulous basis on which to compile data. And the reason I think this is
00:04:46 alarming is because it is clearly the first step in making misogyny a hate crime first
00:04:53 those campaigning for it want the data they want evidence to show that it's a real problem and then
00:05:00 they will lobby the government to do something about it i.e make misogyny a hate crime yes it's
00:05:07 it's there is this subjectivity bit isn't there but before we get on to that uh from what i'm
00:05:13 saying to be really we're talking about we were in the territory of non-crime hate incidents aren't
00:05:19 we well we may very well be uh peter um uh there's no doubt that in addition to um recording crimes
00:05:30 they believe were motivated by hatred of the victim's sex or gender the police will also
00:05:36 be recording incidents that they believe were motivated by the victim's sex or gender, i.e.
00:05:43 non-crime hate incidents. We know from an FOI request submitted by the Telegraph that between
00:05:49 2014 and 2019, the police forces of England and Wales recorded 120,000 non-crime hate incidents,
00:05:59 which is an average of about 66 a day and to burden the police with having to record even
00:06:06 more of these when there are so many better things they could be doing seems to me to be a waste of
00:06:13 the police's time and resources at this moment. Do you think that this seems to have suddenly
00:06:19 flared up in the aftermath of the terrible killing of Sarah Everard does it not I mean do you think
00:06:26 that are we reacting you know in an impulsive way and in which case it's a terrible way in which to
00:06:33 make laws isn't it yeah i think it's an irrational response to what's happened because if you really
00:06:38 cared about women's safety then you would be wanting to ensure that the money that the police
00:06:44 invest goes on things that will actually keep women safe not on silly things like recording
00:06:49 misogyny as a hate crime and as we've seen you know i think it was it's 11 out of 43 of the
00:06:54 police forces around the country were already recording misogyny as a hate crime particularly
00:06:59 in nottingham which is the pilot that they now the government want to roll out across all police
00:07:04 forces uh from the autumn which is what has been has been suggested so i think you know this this
00:07:12 firstly this isn't the way that you should deal with trying to keep women safe i don't think this
00:07:18 is going to have any impact on women's safety all this is going to do is contribute to the world
00:07:22 view that created the moral panic in the first place, which is to make women see misogyny 0.96
00:07:28 everywhere. And it will be the framework through which not only the police, but also the general
00:07:36 public will be, you know, seeing misogyny everywhere. And it will make women feel as
00:07:40 if they are unsafe, when that isn't actually based on facts or reality in any way. Because 0.96
00:07:47 Sarah Everard murder
00:07:49 it was statistically very unlikely 0.63
00:07:51 to happen to a woman 0.61
00:07:53 and what happened
00:07:55 after that was that
00:07:57 it essentially got kidnapped
00:07:58 sorry, bad turn of phrase
00:08:01 it got hijacked
00:08:03 by people who wanted to
00:08:05 use it to push a particular agenda
00:08:07 to view society
00:08:09 as being systemically
00:08:11 misogynistic and
00:08:13 I don't think, as Claire alluded to already
00:08:15 I don't think that that actually
00:08:17 is good for women at all
00:08:19 and it's not good for the relations between men and women
00:08:21 It sort of victimises
00:08:23 women does it not in a way
00:08:25 in some ways does it 1.00
00:08:27 not also sort of infantilise them
00:08:29 Well
00:08:30 the more general point is
00:08:33 that there is a narrative that says
00:08:35 that there is
00:08:37 an inbuilt
00:08:38 majority of people who are driven
00:08:41 by a hatred of women
00:08:42 in their relations and the broad 0.92
00:08:45 definition, and this is why it's slightly complicated in terms of lawmaking, in terms
00:08:51 of crime, it's been attached onto the domestic abuse bill. Let me tell you, within that bill
00:08:58 itself, which is now about to be law actually tomorrow, I think, if tomorrow is Thursday,
00:09:04 yes, sorry, in a couple of days, it will become law, I'm pretty sure, because the government
00:09:10 have accepted it but the definitions of a domestic in the domestic abuse bill are pretty wide
00:09:16 the definitions of abuse are huge and you can be a criminal as a domestic abuser by simply
00:09:24 breaching a domestic abuse order I'm not going to go into the details of that but that does not
00:09:30 necessarily mean that you've even gone anywhere near doing anything than having a very nasty
00:09:36 fallout in a domestic setting. So now we're being told that we've got to assess that from
00:09:42 the point of view of misogyny. And so you basically see every single relationship
00:09:48 that you might have with somebody from, if you're a woman, every relationship you have with somebody
00:09:56 who's a man through the prism of they are a threat to me, you report everything as in the
00:10:03 most misanthropic, mean-spirited sense of fear. And then what's worse than that is you can
00:10:12 criminalise people based on your perception. And although Toby's absolutely right, this is about
00:10:18 counting. I think that where Toby absolutely hits the nail on the head is this is getting the
00:10:25 evidence so that you can bring in another bill to make it a hate crime. But the point about this
00:10:31 evidence is that there are not you know demonstrations on the street of thousands of
00:10:36 women demanding this particular response to sarah everard even if they might say they might want
00:10:43 something um but the police forces are being told that they are negligent in this so they are being
00:10:50 incited and i use that word particularly to go and find instances of misogynistic i mean can you
00:10:58 imagine being a police force in you know wherever in the country in glasgow and you say actually
00:11:04 we haven't had much in the way of misogynistic hate crime reported people would not think oh
00:11:10 the men of glasgow might not hate women they'd think there's something wrong with the glasgow
00:11:15 police force they aren't going out and encouraging this so in the debate that happened in the house
00:11:21 of lords it was very much the onus on the police to go out and to say to people this is misogyny
00:11:28 have you experienced it report it to us and and and not just the victims because this third party
00:11:36 matters because then you can say that you are walking down the street somebody cat calls you
00:11:42 you take no notice but you as a witness can say i have seen misogynistic hate crime and report that
00:11:49 and it will be so even the victim can say oh i didn't think it was anything much don't worry
00:11:53 about it that doesn't matter it can be therefore written down toby you this point exactly okay
00:12:00 this is a pretty you well sorry it is unique i believe in english law the the subjectivity that
00:12:07 relates to hate crime uh an ever-expanding area this in the perception of the victim they even
00:12:14 use the word victim which automatically suggests doesn't it uh guilt um it's not the complainant
00:12:21 it's it's the victim um this is extraordinary and and surely this is something that must affect
00:12:29 for example the cases you get at the free speech union i mean does it not i mean because if it's
00:12:34 up to you know i i could hear of a story that's like emma tells me or claire tells me or something
00:12:41 like this and i can go and report it even though i didn't even see it if i think it's hateful yes
00:12:48 it is a relatively new development, perception based crimes. And the Free Speech Union has just
00:12:58 published a 10 point manifesto today in the run up to the local elections, arguing that perception
00:13:05 based crime should be scrapped as a concept. I think the reason it's grown up over the past few
00:13:16 years is because of the difficulty in trying to discern whether someone in the course of committing
00:13:25 a crime has certain forbidden thoughts. So the fundamental problem with the concept of hate
00:13:33 crime, as set out by Jonathan Rauch in Kindly Inquisitors, is that if you're going to punish
00:13:40 more severely those crimes that were motivated by the perpetrator's hatred of the victim,
00:13:50 but not in every case, just if the victims happen to belong to a particular protected group,
00:13:55 is that you are essentially criminalising certain thoughts. You're saying that if you are thinking
00:14:02 certain thoughts when committing a crime, it's not just hateful thoughts, but particular hateful
00:14:10 thoughts if you're thinking those thoughts then the crime should be punished more severely so
00:14:15 it's effectively creating a category of crime which is thought crime and the one of the many
00:14:22 problems with trying to criminalize certain thoughts is that it's very difficult to determine
00:14:27 whether someone is having those thoughts or not when they're committing the crime you're not going
00:14:32 to be able to rely on the perpetrator because knowing that they're going to be punished more
00:14:37 severely if they were thinking those prohibited thoughts, they're going to deny they were
00:14:40 thinking them. And there is no machine that can be wheeled into court to determine whether or not
00:14:46 these prohibited things were being thought by the perpetrator whilst committing the crime.
00:14:50 So what can they do? It's such a difficult, subjective, nebulous concept to base the criminal
00:14:56 law on. The only thing they can do is to ask, well, what was the perception of the victim?
00:15:02 and treat that as sacrosanct? Because, of course, we've always got to believe victims,
00:15:07 which is not only very unreliable as a standard on which to base sentencing,
00:15:14 but also seems to throw out of the window the presumption of innocence.
00:15:18 Why should victims be believed? What that is effectively saying is that the testimony of the
00:15:25 victim as to the state of mind of the perpetrator has to be given more weight than the perpetrator's
00:15:33 account, which is essentially to throw out of the window the presumption of innocence.
00:15:39 I think the long term solution, the only solution to all these problems thrown up by trying to
00:15:47 create hate crimes and prosecute them is, I think, to ditch the concept, to stop trying to criminalise
00:15:54 thought. People often say in response to that argument, well, that's all very well, but mens rea
00:15:58 is important when determining guilt. And that too can affect the tariff someone gets for committing
00:16:04 a particular crime. But that's different. Intending to commit a crime and the general
00:16:08 intention is one thing, but criminalising, adding extra harsh penalties because the perpetrator was
00:16:16 thinking particular thoughts, that's something else entirely. And that's wrong, I think.
00:16:20 i i just wanted to you know because the the one of the problems we've got here is what problem
00:16:27 are we trying to solve the person whoever that person is who killed sarah everard will be
00:16:37 prosecuted for the crime of murder and kidnap does it matter what motivated them i hope that
00:16:44 they are dealt with harshly I don't care what the motive was and of course as Toby clarified one
00:16:53 thing I mean you you want to know whether it was premeditated or how it happened there are certain
00:16:58 things but but in terms of this sort of driver this idea that it makes any difference to you
00:17:04 as it was attached to the domestic abuse bill you know whether you're kind of hit because of a sort
00:17:10 of generalised hatred of women
00:17:12 or whether it's because of the particular toxic
00:17:14 relationship that you've got in with one person
00:17:16 who just, and the fights over the
00:17:18 kids and whatever. I mean
00:17:19 you've been hit, you should be prosecuted for that
00:17:22 that's fine, you know, throw away the key
00:17:24 I'm all for that
00:17:25 but this is a politicisation
00:17:27 a political and ideological
00:17:30 reading of crime
00:17:32 that I think lacks merit
00:17:34 but as it
00:17:35 and it doesn't help anyone, you know
00:17:37 I might want more lighting on the streets 0.90
00:17:39 you might want more police in in terms of women's safety although women by and large are not under
00:17:46 threat i mean we just also would like to clarify very importantly that women might be frightened
00:17:52 that they're going to be attacked but they're largely not attacked and fear as we know can
00:17:58 be debilitating and the historical argument for a lot of women who were involved in women's
00:18:04 liberation was that we were told that you know we we needed to be looked after because there was all
00:18:10 these kind of men out there with testosterone problems who were going to rape us but it's very
00:18:15 interesting to hear how quickly that argument has come back we've had talk of curfews from men
00:18:22 you know chaperones and also like the mayor uh can't said you know women are you know are not
00:18:29 safe on our street the whole implication it's been broadened straight away has it not emma
00:18:35 equivalent of as toby was saying it being perception based so you're trying to sort of
00:18:41 look into men's souls whilst convicting them of a crime it's the same thing on a societal level and
00:18:46 it has its roots i think in um the work of people like kimberly crenshaw and intersectionality
00:18:51 where they they as as claire was saying they read certain crimes against women domestic abuse
00:18:58 rape murder as being indicative of misogyny in society you can't evidence that you can't prove
00:19:05 it right or wrong it's almost like a religious belief and that's the reason why i think to
00:19:10 anybody who doesn't have that worldview you look at what happened to sarah everard you consider
00:19:14 the fact that we don't know if the person who's been arrested the police officer actually committed
00:19:19 the murder we don't know any of the details about the case we don't know we're all talking about
00:19:25 misogyny as if somehow de facto he must have been motivated by misogyny rather than some a multitude
00:19:32 of other possible motivations for doing something like that it makes absolutely no different
00:19:36 difference to the immorality of the crime that was committed against her and so I think that is
00:19:42 the societal equivalent and it's a it's a worldview that naturally tends towards this perception
00:19:48 based crime and as Toby was saying you know that that is it just completely undermines the whole
00:19:54 idea of justice you can't have a just justice system if that is at the basis of it you just
00:20:00 can't the other the other thing that I'm very worried about and this this will be important I
00:20:05 mean the the tacking on of this amendment onto the domestic abuse bill was just really just a
00:20:12 kind of opportunist move by people who wanted to just get anything passed to the point where and
00:20:18 it's kind of become a bit of a joke but where I went in my speech I made the point that we all
00:20:22 think this is the misogyny hate bill because we'd all been lobbied as a misogyny hate bill
00:20:26 and i'm opposed to a misogyny hate bill but actually when i read the amendments i suddenly
00:20:30 realized that it never mentioned the word misogyny and it didn't mention the word women
00:20:34 so it basically was an entirely politicized thing but but but it's important to say that it was
00:20:39 tagged on as an amendment to this because in the domestic abuse bill and this is important domestic
00:20:44 abuse is now a very broadened concept which includes psychological abuse all sorts of you
00:20:51 emotional abuse, all sorts of types of abuse which are not physical, quite difficult to prove
00:20:58 crimes in and of themselves. The only outcome it seems to me of introducing this idea of
00:21:03 misogynistic hate is that it will, and tagging it on now onto the domestic abuse bill, is that it
00:21:11 will criminalise speech. Because what you can be accused of misogynistic hate for being emotionally
00:21:19 abusive in a domestic context and the example that i use particularly because they didn't name it on
00:21:25 as women and they've added in this word person and it's confused as to whether that will stay
00:21:30 once it becomes an act of parliament was that if for example you are a mother who misgenders
00:21:37 their trans son or daughter who has transitioned that will be an act of hate so you can imagine
00:21:46 in the scenario or and in the domestic abuse scenario as well if you run a women's refuge and
00:21:53 you say actually we're not letting you stay here and there's any question in the mind of the victim
00:22:00 that you're doing that because you have a prejudice against someone then you can be done for the
00:22:06 equivalent of misogynistic hate crime now this will obviously freeze debate that's the point
00:22:11 i'm making and and when you look at what's happened in nottinghamshire it's you know that's
00:22:16 the problem with this what is the crime because if it can be approaching you know unwanted
00:22:22 approaching that's the one that gets me every time i mean how unwanted approaching now we all
00:22:28 know that that could mean but i mean you know unwanted approach how do you know if it's unwanted
00:22:31 unless you approach i mean i what does that mean and leering i mean what is i mean you're looking
00:22:37 at me in a particular way i mean who's leering what what i'm saying what i'm saying is is that
00:22:43 it's that's where it creeps into being hate speech rather than crime because we're talking about
00:22:50 because we're talking about sarah and this is happens in this discussion a brutal murder occurs
00:22:55 we have a conversation about a brutal murder that suddenly ends up over here now when you're saying
00:23:00 misogynistic hate crime talking about sarah everard at least you can sort of get there right
00:23:05 is a brutal crime against a woman we kind of know where we're going but the campaigners are talking
00:23:10 a much wider expanse as soon as you disagree with them they say how dare you a young woman
00:23:18 has been brutally kidnapped and murdered on clapham so i'm being insensitive because i'm
00:23:24 opposing an amendment that they've associated with a young woman but they've broadened it out
00:23:30 so that all women need this protection
00:23:32 and a lot of people could be criminalised in this way.
00:23:36 It's also, it's deeply, deeply ironic as well
00:23:38 the point about not only free speech
00:23:42 but the way that some of these campaign groups
00:23:45 have hooked their own causes onto this
00:23:47 because the primary way that you keep...
00:23:51 If you're really concerned about women's safety
00:23:53 then you will be concerned about women's sex-based rights
00:23:56 because that's the only way that you can ensure in law 0.93
00:23:58 that women do have equality 0.94
00:24:00 and are protected but a lot of these groups particularly ones like Sisters Uncut
00:24:05 have I think they've even interrupted women's rights protests in in the past because I think
00:24:13 they essentially opposed to sex-based rights and some of the people that they had listed and Zach
00:24:19 Goldsmith was very good drawing attention to this some of the people that they had listed
00:24:22 during their protest as people that they were sort of remembering memorializing were people who
00:24:28 before they had transitioned had actually kidnapped murdered and raped women so if you were really
00:24:35 concerned it's a point at which you have to step back and ask is this really about women's rights
00:24:40 or have they made this about something else it's the same with the um the what's going on at the
00:24:45 moment right this very moment in clap in clapham common uh these far left activists have quite
00:24:52 literally occupied uh it was an abandoned police station and in the statement that they released
00:24:59 they were making as they always do certain demands and one of those demands was that the police end
00:25:05 what they call femicide so they're already recategorizing the murder of women as being
00:25:11 not just murder but in some kind of separate category they're essentially instrumentalizing
00:25:18 the abuse of women and crime against women for their own political purposes so you have to stand
00:25:24 back and ask are they really intent what are their intentions really what they're saying that they
00:25:30 are because i think it's pretty clear that they're not i think you know you could actually look at
00:25:34 the same with the george floyd killing it's the same sort of thing isn't it that if you deny that
00:25:40 this was about racism or that britain is systemically racist you're actually showing
00:25:44 yourself to be the problem you know the racist as well um toby uh can i bring you in it it's
00:25:50 going back to something you said in your last uh uh answer there i do i take it that your position
00:25:57 then or the position of the free speech union is that hate crimes should be scrapped or you know
00:26:02 hate crime legislation should be scrapped well the free speech union doesn't have an official
00:26:09 position on that um and uh i would have to defer to um the trustees and um the uh director of
00:26:18 research and the deputy director of research emma webb another right she sometimes wears
00:26:23 we like to keep it in the family here so but um uh that is certainly my position peter i mean i
00:26:32 think the uh i mean when you think about it it just doesn't seem to pass the common sense test
00:26:36 Let's suppose I'm badly beaten up. If the person is motivated by a personal hatred of me, does it make sense that they should be punished less severely than if they're motivated by hatred of my being a white male?
00:26:57 um it doesn't really um surely if the person is hatred by motivated by a particular animus
00:27:05 towards me if that person has been stalking me and has singled me out then i think they
00:27:10 should be punished more severely than if they're just attacking me because they dislike some of
00:27:14 the identity categories i belong to um but the kind of rationale for hate crime the rationale
00:27:20 for punishing more severely those crimes motivated by hatred of particular identity groups
00:27:26 is that it will create a more harmonious, less divided society.
00:27:31 That if we provide greater legal protection to certain groups that have been designated victim groups,
00:27:39 that will make for a better, more peaceful, more civilised society.
00:27:45 But I can't see it working like that.
00:27:48 Surely, if you give certain groups better legal protections than other groups,
00:27:53 if you say that if you're a member of these identity groups,
00:27:56 and someone commits a crime against you, that crime will be more severely punished
00:27:59 than if you're a member of these other unprotected identity groups.
00:28:03 That's going to sow division. That's going to create disharmony.
00:28:07 It's not going to create a more civilized society.
00:28:09 It's going to create a more sectarian society.
00:28:12 So the whole rationale behind the hate crime agenda seems to me to be completely misguided.
00:28:18 And I think there is some evidence in those countries and those U.S. states
00:28:23 where hate crimes have been placed on the statute books, many more acts of hatred are committed
00:28:34 against various victim groups after those things have been criminalised than before. Now of course
00:28:40 the data is quite unreliable because sometimes reporting mechanisms aren't put in place until
00:28:45 certain crimes have been put on the statute books, but there seems to be some pretty robust
00:28:50 empirical data showing
00:28:52 that actually hate crimes
00:28:54 where they've been
00:28:55 where they've entered the
00:28:58 statute books have in fact created
00:29:00 resulted in
00:29:02 more crimes being committed
00:29:04 against victim groups than less
00:29:06 so they have the opposite of their intended effects
00:29:08 and you can quite see why that would be the case
00:29:10 I mean I think
00:29:12 that you know
00:29:14 and this is where we kind of get into
00:29:15 something of a tangle
00:29:17 for me because
00:29:19 partly if you say we talk about racism or we talk about in fact sexism or or or what have you
00:29:28 what women were fighting for was to be treated equally to men racism is where you actually say
00:29:36 i'm going to treat you and give you less equal you know we're going to treat you as a lesser person
00:29:43 than somebody because of your ethnicity because of the color of your skin and so the problem with
00:29:48 these kind of laws that actually then treat you separately and differently is it undermines that
00:29:54 aspiration for equality that's one thing but we can all recognize and i i do recognize you know
00:30:00 you can you can also know that you could get a bunch of uh of lads who might go out and beat
00:30:07 someone up because they're jewish and and they beat them up and they say you know things which
00:30:13 or anti-Jewish, so you can guess that they're probably anti-Semitic. You can go out and beat
00:30:18 up somebody because they're Asian, and they'll use racist language, and they'll actually
00:30:26 perpetrate a racist attack. I mean, when I lived in Coventry in the 80s, there were groups
00:30:33 of people who went out to beat people up because of the colour of their skin, right? It was
00:30:38 straightforward. They were skinheads. They did that. They didn't make any ban. So you
00:30:42 can say well that's a crime but the thing that that i would say about it is i don't think that
00:30:47 they should be given a harder sentence because of that but i might note it i don't think there are
00:30:52 no crimes driven by uh you know attitudes to women and and obviously rape is a particular
00:31:00 type of crime but one of the things is as i'm describing extreme examples i i don't think the
00:31:08 law needs to change because of that because i want rapists to be prosecuted i want people who go out
00:31:14 and beat people up to be prosecuted and i want to have a campaign in society that you don't believe
00:31:20 that people of a different skin color or a different sex are lesser than you right and
00:31:25 that's an argument that i would prefer to have rather than bringing the law into it that's why
00:31:30 i'm but this is why i get very nervous about language because emma's rightly described how
00:31:35 how people are talking about femicide they're actually not distinguishing when when jess
00:31:41 phillips read out all those names in the house of commons she actually added sarah everard to a lot
00:31:47 of names of women who've been killed in domestic settings even though sarah wasn't so the specificity
00:31:52 which seems quite insulting to me i mean you just lump everyone in together and assume that it's all
00:31:57 the same why is it the same everything from wolf whistling to and then you broaden out what you
00:32:04 describe as misogyny from not just being dead killed which is pretty the end result the most
00:32:12 vicious that we think of so unwanted approaches leering catcalling even you know even uh things
00:32:19 like flashing which is undoubtedly an antisocial behavior but it's still not the same as raping
00:32:25 and murdering someone and so i just feel that that's where we get into the language thing because
00:32:30 that's what worries me is
00:32:32 the thought crime element of this
00:32:34 that they just broaden everything
00:32:36 out and you're not allowed to be
00:32:38 opposed to it, being treated
00:32:40 differently under the law, not equally 1.00
00:32:42 is a real problem for women 1.00
00:32:44 but that doesn't mean that there aren't crimes 0.98
00:32:46 aimed at women and I want them to be
00:32:48 prosecuted, I just don't think this will help
00:32:50 There's a degree as well I think to which
00:32:52 it's almost cooking the books
00:32:54 and it was already alluded to
00:32:56 slightly but if you
00:32:58 have you ask the police to start recording these hate crimes and then you use the evidence of these
00:33:04 hate crimes that you've created and therefore see in absolutely everything because as you say it's
00:33:09 everything from unwanted advances to to rape and murder that you're you're sort of cooking the
00:33:15 books you're creating an environment in which women will feel as if they are being victimized
00:33:20 almost inherently and that there's nothing that can be done about that other than presumably the
00:33:24 elimination of men if they think that systemic misogyny is something that is inherently within
00:33:28 men which is why you end up with people like baroness jenny jones suggesting ridiculous things
00:33:33 like a curfew for all men um and i think that most women would see that and think well this doesn't
00:33:39 actually chime with my experience but what they're asking of women is for women to see themselves as
00:33:44 the victim so it's the absolute opposite of empowerment you're going to come in there toby
00:33:48 Yeah, I just wanted to add to what's just been said, which is that the people advocating the expansion of hate crime legislation often make the rhetorical moves which Claire just described.
00:34:09 I mean, the first rhetorical move is to say, you know, how dare you oppose what we're proposing when this woman has just been kidnapped and killed?
00:34:22 What kind of an insensitive brute are you to challenge anything we're saying?
00:34:28 If you do challenge it, if you try and enter into a debate about this, then you are disregarding.
00:34:37 You are callously disregarding what's just happened to this innocent young woman.
00:34:43 So that's one way of shutting down debate.
00:34:46 The other way, which we're probably all familiar with, is to say you don't have any standing in this debate.
00:34:53 You're a man. You don't know what it's like to be a woman walking home.
00:34:58 on your own at night through the streets of london how dare you try and speak to this issue
00:35:05 when you have no idea you don't have the lived experience which is the license you need to
00:35:12 contribute to this conversation the the upshot of ruling people out by making these rhetorical
00:35:19 moves is that no debate takes place at all and we saw that in the house of lords last week the
00:35:27 government didn't accept this amendment after it had been voted for in the House
00:35:32 of Lords after a sort of minimal amount of debate the government then just
00:35:36 accepted the agenda the amendment and my concern is that the Law Commission of
00:35:42 England and Wales have made a series of really hair-raising proposals which they
00:35:48 want to bring together in an English and Welsh hate crime bill which which which
00:35:53 which will be very similar to the Hate Crime Act, which has just passed in Scotland.
00:35:59 So they want to, for instance, hugely enlarge the number of protected categories.
00:36:05 At one point in the document, the consultation document, which is hundreds of pages long,
00:36:09 they talk about making goths and punks protected categories.
00:36:14 They want to make it much, much easier to prosecute people for stirring up hatred
00:36:20 against people in these protected categories at the moment with the exception of stirring up racial
00:36:28 hatred in order to prosecute someone for stirring up hatred you need to show intent that they
00:36:32 intended to stir up hatred they didn't just do it inadvertently well the law commission want to
00:36:38 scrap that and they want to make it as easy to prosecute someone for stirring up hatred against
00:36:43 any protected category not just stirring up racial hatred but they also want to scrap the
00:36:48 dwelling exemption whereby at the moment you can't be prosecuted for stirring up hatred against
00:36:54 someone in a protected category in the privacy of your own home. That's one of the features of
00:37:01 the Scottish Hate Crime Act. It's done away with the dwelling exemption in the Public Order Act
00:37:06 1986. Well, the Law Commission are proposing to do the same thing here. And on the face of it,
00:37:10 you look at these proposals, you think, well, thank God we have a Conservative government with
00:37:14 60 seat majority an 80 seat majority you know uh unlike scotland we won't we won't enact these
00:37:21 unbelievably draconian laws which will uh more or less wipe out free speech in in england and wales
00:37:28 but then when you see the government respond in this kind of knee-jerk way uh because this
00:37:33 amendment was put in the midst of a moral panic um you think well crikey perhaps i'm i'm placing
00:37:39 far too much confidence uh in this government and actually they'll that we'll see something very
00:37:44 like the scottish hate crime act appear as a bill um in in the third session of this parliament i
00:37:51 mean i very much hope not and the free speech union will certainly be campaigning against it
00:37:54 but i do think after what happened last week it is now a real risk
00:37:57 um i've just was in the house of lords this morning and there was in question time a question
00:38:06 about what would the government do about anonymous accounts on social media that were stirring
00:38:13 up race hatred in relation to footballers. It was a very specific question. But in the
00:38:21 course of the other questions that were put forward to the minister, this moved from a
00:38:27 very specific question to racism and sexism. Then it became racism and sexism and bullying,
00:38:35 pylons, online harassment, calling people names,
00:38:39 that it would be prosecutable if you were anonymous.
00:38:42 And the reason I mention all this is because the government minister
00:38:46 simply said, don't worry, we're dealing with all this
00:38:50 in the online harms bill, and don't worry,
00:38:54 and I've noticed this all the time in the House of Lords,
00:38:56 I've never taken any interest or notice in legislation,
00:38:59 but now I have to, so I've suddenly realised how the laws are made,
00:39:03 is that the Conservatives have accepted practically every egregious amendment
00:39:09 that came from the parties into the Domestic Abuse Bill,
00:39:13 and every time they're asked anything awkward about this kind of hate crime legislation,
00:39:18 they say, don't worry, the Law Commissioner looking at it.
00:39:22 So they've outsourced their expertise.
00:39:25 So there's no kickback at all.
00:39:28 I'd put down to speak on this question this morning.
00:39:31 I wasn't selected.
00:39:33 And therefore, 10 members of the House of Lords,
00:39:36 not one of them mentioned free speech.
00:39:37 They said free speech has to have limits,
00:39:40 and the government minister agreed with them.
00:39:43 Now, this is every single time a free speech issue
00:39:46 comes up in the House of Lords.
00:39:48 And Toby, you're absolutely right.
00:39:49 I mean, I spoke against the misogyny, hate crime,
00:39:52 part of the domestic abuse bill,
00:39:53 but I was absolutely on my own,
00:39:56 and there was no reason for me to do it
00:39:59 because the government accepted it anyway.
00:40:01 I mean, I'm having an argument.
00:40:03 And I'm, as it were, against a Labour amendment,
00:40:07 but it didn't matter because the Tories had taken it on.
00:40:10 So I think that you can't underestimate the changing climate
00:40:15 at a legislative level,
00:40:17 where basically they haven't even bothered to have the debate.
00:40:22 I think that is the most scary bit.
00:40:25 And I just wanted to stress that in all of this,
00:40:28 what we're missing is that the public think
00:40:31 that the government are doing things that will protect you know they hear the buzz they think
00:40:37 it's to do with stopping rapists or stopping racist attacks or stopping brutal murders of
00:40:44 young women but actually when you look at what's being made into law it's not that at all that
00:40:49 domestic abuse bill you'd think it was to do with the police ignoring the fact that when people come
00:40:55 and say i'm about to be killed by my ex they ignore you it's going to solve that let me tell
00:41:00 you they'll be so busy dealing with data crunching on hate crime and all the rest of it they won't
00:41:06 have time to actually deal with the real problems so it's a real smoke and mirrors situation of
00:41:12 the public thinking they're supporting one thing and the politicians absolutely spinelessly have
00:41:18 given up on any commitment to freedom at all you you mentioned there about the sort of legislative
00:41:26 atmosphere and what is going on there
00:41:28 but
00:41:29 this whole sort of what happens in the
00:41:32 legislature surely has
00:41:34 a kind of chilling effect generally on
00:41:36 society and this is the thing
00:41:38 I was very interested to see this
00:41:40 I don't know if you saw it but this week
00:41:42 probably America's greatest
00:41:45 novelist or was considered so
00:41:46 Philip Roth is
00:41:48 now under the hammer
00:41:50 shall we say because of
00:41:52 his misogyny that's what it amounts to
00:41:54 Now, no one is at the moment saying he shouldn't be, you know, his books shouldn't be published.
00:41:59 But the fact is, he is ripe for, as they put it, a re-evaluation.
00:42:04 Now, you know, this is not to do, obviously, with hate crime, but it's all of a piece, is it not, Toby?
00:42:13 It is, yes. This is the charming phenomenon of posthumous cancellation.
00:42:19 It's as though, you know, the appetite that among the witch finder generals for finding and punishing people for heresy is so insatiable that they're not going to confine themselves to the living.
00:42:37 They now have to morally inspect the dead. And if they possibly can, they'll they'll punish them, too.
00:42:46 It's almost like digging someone up and sort of hanging, drawing and quartering the corpse because they didn't suffer sufficient punishment for their heresy while they were living.
00:43:01 And as you say, Philip Roth is the latest victim of this really unpleasant phenomenon.
00:43:08 I mean, it's you sort of think when something like this happens, I always think anyway, you know.
00:43:12 the people you're trying to cancel, the people you're singling out as heretics and punishing as
00:43:20 best you can, are amongst the most brilliant of human beings. You know, they are the most
00:43:26 gifted novelists, the most talented scientists. You know, it's almost a sort of tribute
00:43:35 to their enemies that the people they single out as the most egregious sinners are as luminously
00:43:42 intelligent and imaginative
00:43:44 and as hugely
00:43:46 capaciously talented
00:43:47 as Philip Roth
00:43:49 who can they put up against
00:43:51 Philip Roth
00:43:52 who are the woke novelists
00:43:55 they want to replace him with
00:43:56 I was just going to say that
00:44:01 it's true what you say
00:44:03 though Peter because what goes
00:44:05 on in the legislation you kind of think
00:44:07 I mean it's frightening to see what laws are
00:44:09 coming through but it's then the way
00:44:11 that what i'm saying is you know probably two or three months ago the word misogyny was not
00:44:17 widely used you know it's it's quite extreme sexism maybe yes misogyny is a misogynist
00:44:24 is a misogynist the same as a sexist in your language no no misogyny is used purposefully
00:44:30 as the kind of hatred but a sexism is is not is a stronger word it's the way that kind of racism
00:44:37 became kind of white supremacy.
00:44:39 Do you know what I mean?
00:44:40 I mean, it kind of like extremifies it,
00:44:42 it catastrophizes it.
00:44:43 And the reason I'm saying that
00:44:44 is because what's now happened is
00:44:46 it is a bit like George Floyd moments,
00:44:49 as you said,
00:44:50 which is that, you know,
00:44:51 the death of one man
00:44:53 brutally watched by a soul in lockdown
00:44:55 became a way of talking about racism
00:44:58 in every single instance and everywhere.
00:45:01 But now we have a situation
00:45:02 whereby attitudes to women
00:45:05 have all become misogyny
00:45:07 and now you can say in popular culture
00:45:09 this novelist is a misogynist
00:45:12 and should be cancelled
00:45:13 and you don't argue against that
00:45:16 and Philip Roth is one of my favourite novelists
00:45:20 of all times
00:45:21 his attitude to women
00:45:23 who I don't care
00:45:26 because his literature
00:45:28 and his novels
00:45:29 are some of the most important
00:45:32 artefacts we're ever going to have
00:45:34 and everybody should read Philip Rob, by the way.
00:45:37 I don't care what he thought about anything.
00:45:39 Now more than ever.
00:45:39 But of course...
00:45:40 Now more than ever, yes.
00:45:41 Now more than ever.
00:45:42 And actually, a lot of his work will help understand now more than ever.
00:45:47 But the point I'm saying is that that word has seeped out
00:45:51 of that kind of little group of NGO campaigners
00:45:54 who lobbied and MPs who've been going on and on about misogyny, hate crime.
00:45:59 In popular culture, most people go,
00:46:00 what are you talking about?
00:46:01 I don't know what you're talking about.
00:46:02 But because of the Sarah Everard situation, I think then the way it became a moral panic, the way it was given massive, amplified by the media and the fact that we're in lockdown.
00:46:16 So this intensifies this kind of sense of kind of horror and fear and atomization.
00:46:22 Now, everybody knows about misogyny and you only have to label somebody a misogynist to think of Sarah Everard.
00:46:29 and that's what happens you know you only have to say institutionalized racism or and and white
00:46:35 privilege and you think of the brutal killing by the police or somebody in america and that's the
00:46:42 way it works in your head and that's the chilling effect but that's what they sort of want i mean
00:46:47 you sort of say oh well what philip ross was writing about or how he behaved towards the
00:46:51 women in his life there's a causal link somehow between that yeah and and the worst except it
00:46:57 It gives them a window of opportunity as well on the far left for them to, as you say, because people will say, well, misogyny, and they'll associate with Sarah Everard, and the far left know that this is the case.
00:47:09 And so then it becomes part of this general destructiveness, like you saw that all of the protesters who descended on the Churchill statue, again, and they were talking about racism, and they associate with everything to do with the police,
00:47:24 Extinction Rebellion turn up
00:47:26 Black Lives Matter turn up
00:47:27 The Revolutionary Communist Group turn up
00:47:29 The Anti-Imperialists turn up
00:47:31 And they use it as this window of opportunity
00:47:33 For the general destructors
00:47:35 Because as you say
00:47:36 They see misogyny
00:47:39 And racism
00:47:41 And all of these things
00:47:42 Intersectionality joins them all together
00:47:44 And it becomes part of this world view
00:47:47 This moral panic and this myth
00:47:48 That they're perpetuating
00:47:50 And so it is as Toby said
00:47:52 these people are viewed as having committed heresies
00:47:55 they even went for Philip Larkin
00:47:57 and they go for the people who either
00:47:59 are the most innocent
00:48:00 because then that creates the most terror
00:48:03 amongst normal people because they think well if they could go
00:48:05 for someone who really did nothing wrong
00:48:06 then they could come for me
00:48:08 and they go for as Toby said
00:48:10 the most luminous giant figures
00:48:12 to try and tear them down
00:48:15 because it's almost
00:48:16 it goes along with their bullying approach
00:48:19 to trying to
00:48:20 force change in the direction that they
00:48:22 would want it. They create this fear
00:48:24 by trying to topple these gargantuan
00:48:26 figures as if to
00:48:28 show the power that they have
00:48:30 over the cultural change
00:48:32 or the cultural revolution that they want.
00:48:34 Also, I don't think we should ever underestimate
00:48:36 sheer good old-fashioned cultural
00:48:38 envy.
00:48:40 As I think Toby mentioned,
00:48:42 absolute bringing down.
00:48:45 This is the
00:48:46 revenge of the media.
00:48:47 I want to clarify
00:48:50 the far left
00:48:52 has a fine tradition
00:48:53 the contemporary
00:48:56 identity left is a whole different
00:48:58 ballgame and I'm from
00:49:00 the tradition of the far left that
00:49:02 argued against these regressive
00:49:04 trends and we've established
00:49:06 that sadly we have a conservative
00:49:08 party government with an 80 seat majority
00:49:10 that goes along and
00:49:12 laps up this stuff
00:49:13 the intersectional identitarian
00:49:16 exactly i i just think that one of the problems that we have to identify is sadly this is across
00:49:22 the parties across left and right and uh we have a real problem in that i think that that's
00:49:28 absolutely true i think one of the um curiosities of this kind of cultural upheaval is that you have
00:49:37 the intersectional regressive left in one corner uh at the moment sweeping all before them and as
00:49:45 emma said they're incredibly good at exploiting um crises to whip up moral panics and then
00:49:54 railroad people in power and authority to do their bidding um we saw that last year with george floyd
00:50:00 we've just seen it with sarah everard um but but one of the curiosities is that um people of widely
00:50:07 different political views conservatives like me and far left radicals um like claire now find
00:50:14 themselves on the same side manning the barricades together trying to defend
00:50:19 those values that we have in common against these barbarians at our gates
00:50:26 actually we're at the gates they're in the city exactly the barbarians are in
00:50:31 the institution reasonable versus the unreasonable thank you very very much
00:50:36 for coming and talking about this is it's great thank you thank you very much
00:50:40 Toby. Thank you, Claire. Thank you. Thank you, Emma. That's it for Counterculture.
00:50:45 Do subscribe, won't you, and we shall see you next time. Thank you.