00:24:00and are protected but a lot of these groups particularly ones like Sisters Uncut
00:24:05have I think they've even interrupted women's rights protests in in the past because I think
00:24:13they essentially opposed to sex-based rights and some of the people that they had listed and Zach
00:24:19Goldsmith was very good drawing attention to this some of the people that they had listed
00:24:22during their protest as people that they were sort of remembering memorializing were people who
00:24:28before they had transitioned had actually kidnapped murdered and raped women so if you were really
00:24:35concerned it's a point at which you have to step back and ask is this really about women's rights
00:24:40or have they made this about something else it's the same with the um the what's going on at the
00:24:45moment right this very moment in clap in clapham common uh these far left activists have quite
00:24:52literally occupied uh it was an abandoned police station and in the statement that they released
00:24:59they were making as they always do certain demands and one of those demands was that the police end
00:25:05what they call femicide so they're already recategorizing the murder of women as being
00:25:11not just murder but in some kind of separate category they're essentially instrumentalizing
00:25:18the abuse of women and crime against women for their own political purposes so you have to stand
00:25:24back and ask are they really intent what are their intentions really what they're saying that they
00:25:30are because i think it's pretty clear that they're not i think you know you could actually look at
00:25:34the same with the george floyd killing it's the same sort of thing isn't it that if you deny that
00:25:40this was about racism or that britain is systemically racist you're actually showing
00:25:44yourself to be the problem you know the racist as well um toby uh can i bring you in it it's
00:25:50going back to something you said in your last uh uh answer there i do i take it that your position
00:25:57then or the position of the free speech union is that hate crimes should be scrapped or you know
00:26:02hate crime legislation should be scrapped well the free speech union doesn't have an official
00:26:09position on that um and uh i would have to defer to um the trustees and um the uh director of
00:26:18research and the deputy director of research emma webb another right she sometimes wears
00:26:23we like to keep it in the family here so but um uh that is certainly my position peter i mean i
00:26:32think the uh i mean when you think about it it just doesn't seem to pass the common sense test
00:26:36Let's suppose I'm badly beaten up. If the person is motivated by a personal hatred of me, does it make sense that they should be punished less severely than if they're motivated by hatred of my being a white male?
00:26:57um it doesn't really um surely if the person is hatred by motivated by a particular animus
00:27:05towards me if that person has been stalking me and has singled me out then i think they
00:27:10should be punished more severely than if they're just attacking me because they dislike some of
00:27:14the identity categories i belong to um but the kind of rationale for hate crime the rationale
00:27:20for punishing more severely those crimes motivated by hatred of particular identity groups
00:27:26is that it will create a more harmonious, less divided society.
00:27:31That if we provide greater legal protection to certain groups that have been designated victim groups,
00:27:39that will make for a better, more peaceful, more civilised society.
00:32:58have you ask the police to start recording these hate crimes and then you use the evidence of these
00:33:04hate crimes that you've created and therefore see in absolutely everything because as you say it's
00:33:09everything from unwanted advances to to rape and murder that you're you're sort of cooking the
00:33:15books you're creating an environment in which women will feel as if they are being victimized
00:33:20almost inherently and that there's nothing that can be done about that other than presumably the
00:33:24elimination of men if they think that systemic misogyny is something that is inherently within
00:33:28men which is why you end up with people like baroness jenny jones suggesting ridiculous things
00:33:33like a curfew for all men um and i think that most women would see that and think well this doesn't
00:33:39actually chime with my experience but what they're asking of women is for women to see themselves as
00:33:44the victim so it's the absolute opposite of empowerment you're going to come in there toby
00:33:48Yeah, I just wanted to add to what's just been said, which is that the people advocating the expansion of hate crime legislation often make the rhetorical moves which Claire just described.
00:34:09I mean, the first rhetorical move is to say, you know, how dare you oppose what we're proposing when this woman has just been kidnapped and killed?
00:34:22What kind of an insensitive brute are you to challenge anything we're saying?
00:34:28If you do challenge it, if you try and enter into a debate about this, then you are disregarding.
00:34:37You are callously disregarding what's just happened to this innocent young woman.
00:34:43So that's one way of shutting down debate.
00:34:46The other way, which we're probably all familiar with, is to say you don't have any standing in this debate.
00:34:53You're a man. You don't know what it's like to be a woman walking home.
00:34:58on your own at night through the streets of london how dare you try and speak to this issue
00:35:05when you have no idea you don't have the lived experience which is the license you need to
00:35:12contribute to this conversation the the upshot of ruling people out by making these rhetorical
00:35:19moves is that no debate takes place at all and we saw that in the house of lords last week the
00:35:27government didn't accept this amendment after it had been voted for in the House
00:35:32of Lords after a sort of minimal amount of debate the government then just
00:35:36accepted the agenda the amendment and my concern is that the Law Commission of
00:35:42England and Wales have made a series of really hair-raising proposals which they
00:35:48want to bring together in an English and Welsh hate crime bill which which which
00:35:53which will be very similar to the Hate Crime Act, which has just passed in Scotland.
00:35:59So they want to, for instance, hugely enlarge the number of protected categories.
00:36:05At one point in the document, the consultation document, which is hundreds of pages long,
00:36:09they talk about making goths and punks protected categories.
00:36:14They want to make it much, much easier to prosecute people for stirring up hatred
00:36:20against people in these protected categories at the moment with the exception of stirring up racial
00:36:28hatred in order to prosecute someone for stirring up hatred you need to show intent that they
00:36:32intended to stir up hatred they didn't just do it inadvertently well the law commission want to
00:36:38scrap that and they want to make it as easy to prosecute someone for stirring up hatred against
00:36:43any protected category not just stirring up racial hatred but they also want to scrap the
00:36:48dwelling exemption whereby at the moment you can't be prosecuted for stirring up hatred against
00:36:54someone in a protected category in the privacy of your own home. That's one of the features of
00:37:01the Scottish Hate Crime Act. It's done away with the dwelling exemption in the Public Order Act
00:37:061986. Well, the Law Commission are proposing to do the same thing here. And on the face of it,
00:37:10you look at these proposals, you think, well, thank God we have a Conservative government with
00:37:1460 seat majority an 80 seat majority you know uh unlike scotland we won't we won't enact these
00:37:21unbelievably draconian laws which will uh more or less wipe out free speech in in england and wales
00:37:28but then when you see the government respond in this kind of knee-jerk way uh because this
00:37:33amendment was put in the midst of a moral panic um you think well crikey perhaps i'm i'm placing
00:37:39far too much confidence uh in this government and actually they'll that we'll see something very
00:37:44like the scottish hate crime act appear as a bill um in in the third session of this parliament i
00:37:51mean i very much hope not and the free speech union will certainly be campaigning against it
00:37:54but i do think after what happened last week it is now a real risk
00:37:57um i've just was in the house of lords this morning and there was in question time a question
00:38:06about what would the government do about anonymous accounts on social media that were stirring
00:38:13up race hatred in relation to footballers. It was a very specific question. But in the
00:38:21course of the other questions that were put forward to the minister, this moved from a
00:38:27very specific question to racism and sexism. Then it became racism and sexism and bullying,
00:38:35pylons, online harassment, calling people names,
00:38:39that it would be prosecutable if you were anonymous.
00:38:42And the reason I mention all this is because the government minister
00:38:46simply said, don't worry, we're dealing with all this
00:38:50in the online harms bill, and don't worry,
00:38:54and I've noticed this all the time in the House of Lords,
00:38:56I've never taken any interest or notice in legislation,
00:38:59but now I have to, so I've suddenly realised how the laws are made,
00:39:03is that the Conservatives have accepted practically every egregious amendment
00:39:09that came from the parties into the Domestic Abuse Bill,
00:39:13and every time they're asked anything awkward about this kind of hate crime legislation,
00:39:18they say, don't worry, the Law Commissioner looking at it.
00:41:54Now, no one is at the moment saying he shouldn't be, you know, his books shouldn't be published.
00:41:59But the fact is, he is ripe for, as they put it, a re-evaluation.
00:42:04Now, you know, this is not to do, obviously, with hate crime, but it's all of a piece, is it not, Toby?
00:42:13It is, yes. This is the charming phenomenon of posthumous cancellation.
00:42:19It's as though, you know, the appetite that among the witch finder generals for finding and punishing people for heresy is so insatiable that they're not going to confine themselves to the living.
00:42:37They now have to morally inspect the dead. And if they possibly can, they'll they'll punish them, too.
00:42:46It's almost like digging someone up and sort of hanging, drawing and quartering the corpse because they didn't suffer sufficient punishment for their heresy while they were living.
00:43:01And as you say, Philip Roth is the latest victim of this really unpleasant phenomenon.
00:43:08I mean, it's you sort of think when something like this happens, I always think anyway, you know.
00:43:12the people you're trying to cancel, the people you're singling out as heretics and punishing as
00:43:20best you can, are amongst the most brilliant of human beings. You know, they are the most
00:43:26gifted novelists, the most talented scientists. You know, it's almost a sort of tribute
00:43:35to their enemies that the people they single out as the most egregious sinners are as luminously
00:46:02But because of the Sarah Everard situation, I think then the way it became a moral panic, the way it was given massive, amplified by the media and the fact that we're in lockdown.
00:46:16So this intensifies this kind of sense of kind of horror and fear and atomization.
00:46:22Now, everybody knows about misogyny and you only have to label somebody a misogynist to think of Sarah Everard.
00:46:29and that's what happens you know you only have to say institutionalized racism or and and white
00:46:35privilege and you think of the brutal killing by the police or somebody in america and that's the
00:46:42way it works in your head and that's the chilling effect but that's what they sort of want i mean
00:46:47you sort of say oh well what philip ross was writing about or how he behaved towards the
00:46:51women in his life there's a causal link somehow between that yeah and and the worst except it
00:46:57It gives them a window of opportunity as well on the far left for them to, as you say, because people will say, well, misogyny, and they'll associate with Sarah Everard, and the far left know that this is the case.
00:47:09And so then it becomes part of this general destructiveness, like you saw that all of the protesters who descended on the Churchill statue, again, and they were talking about racism, and they associate with everything to do with the police,