New Culture Forum - May 04, 2021


Great American Race Game - New Documentary By UK Filmmaker Martin Durkin

Dr David Starkey: I Was Cancelled But I Wont Be Silenced For Speaking Objective Truth School Chaplain Reported To Terrorist Watchdog For LGBT Policy Sermon

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

172.31

Word count

6,431

Sentence count

194

Harmful content

Hate speech

61

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest this week
00:00:26 was on our show about a year and a half ago when we first started. I'm delighted to welcome him
00:00:33 back. It's the documentary maker Martin Durkin, who has been called the Michael Moore of the
00:00:39 right in the past. You might have seen some of his great long-form documentaries, such as the
00:00:45 great Climate Change Swindle, Brexit, the movie. My personal favourite was Thatcher's Death of a
00:00:53 revolutionary. He's just got a new documentary out, The Great American Race Game. Before
00:01:01 we talk, Martin, I think we should probably just take a brief look at a clip of the documentary.
00:01:06 So here we go.
00:01:08 They're racist, racist, racist, racist, racist. Everything's racist.
00:01:13 The race grievance industry would have you believe that blacks get up and think about
00:01:17 nothing else except race.
00:01:19 If I tell you this is racist, if I tell you that is racist, yeah, I'm going to get you emotional, I'm going to get you to jump, I'm going to get you to skip.
00:01:29 There is a whole big cottage industry for racism. If racism went away, a lot of people would be unemployed.
00:01:37 The mob during the Minneapolis riots following the death of George Floyd.
00:01:41 A bunch of white thugs, frankly, burning down the city's traditional black and Asian business
00:01:47 district while chanting, Black Lives Matter. 0.96
00:01:49 It was literally surreal.
00:01:51 Black Lives Matter!
00:01:52 Black Lives Matter!
00:01:53 Oh, but we black. 0.99
00:01:55 You're going to tell me how to be black, right? 1.00
00:01:57 Y'all don't care about black people. 0.98
00:01:59 I am not African.
00:02:00 I am 100% American.
00:02:04 We got the same Democrat Party who've been terrorizing black people from the beginning.
00:02:07 And now y'all got the audacity to say Black Lives Matter?
00:02:10 their bread and butter in their bottom line their raison d'etre and everything that they're trying 0.95
00:02:13 to do depends upon people being kept in these boxes.
00:02:26 Martin um can you tell us a bit about the film I have to say I watched watched it um actually before
00:02:34 you tell us about it can you tell us where one can see it that that's a crucial thing
00:02:40 uh well i'm delighted that you asked me that um you can see it on www.greatamericanracegame.com
00:02:48 right for the first time in my life i've launched a film online and so i'm praying that some people
00:02:56 will go and watch it otherwise i lose all my money so did you actually you what is your own money or
00:03:02 uh yeah no it was my very own money um this and a film about guns which i've nearly finished
00:03:06 um and uh i thought either i can try to get a a normal mainstream media broadcaster to uh
00:03:15 commission this for either they were never going to do it it just wasn't going to happen you know
00:03:19 such as the kind of blanket of woke tyranny that has gripped um and not only gripped the industry
00:03:26 but the industry creates that it's just i knew i would have to do it myself so uh i've um splurged
00:03:32 my own money rather than nervously well i mean i thought it's a remarkable uh documentary i really
00:03:38 do i would recommend everyone go and watch it it's it's fantastic it gives a narrative of history
00:03:45 and a side to history that you're simply i think most people will be unaware of but could you just
00:03:51 tell us what it is basically is it not about how the democrat party in america has managed somehow
00:03:58 to capture the votes of black voters, but from an entirely or corrupt position, you might say.
00:04:06 Yeah, it's about the cynical politics of race. 0.96
00:04:09 I started wanting to do it when, well, there were events like George Floyd.
00:04:16 And all of the, after that, I could see the kind of the radical left,
00:04:21 you know, upper middle class white activists circling like vultures around this event.
00:04:28 and all the talk around the event i thought this is just hypocrisy this is just not not real um
00:04:34 you know there was just so much lies and disingenuous stuff that i was um i thought i'd
00:04:40 like to do something about the politics of race because it i was just not convinced that it was
00:04:44 what it seemed and i mean it achieves that beautifully because i've some of the most uh
00:04:53 moving parts of it i found was when you told the story of the black experience in america
00:05:00 during a period of terrible racism but their extraordinary success in the face of this
00:05:06 what may be from 1900 to 1950 oh yeah from from the abolition of slavery until really the mid
00:05:14 part of the 20th century the progress made um by black people in america um is extraordinary
00:05:22 in the face of awful racism but nevertheless you know they were building businesses huge numbers
00:05:30 of businesses their own colleges their own universities their own churches they were
00:05:35 owning their own homes they were owning their own farms you know to a quite remarkable extent
00:05:39 and building communities that were you know resilient and self-reliant and admirable in
00:05:45 so many ways and that's the kind of story that isn't told it needs to be told not just because
00:05:50 it's of historic interest but needs to be told because it shines a light on what's going
00:05:54 on today so you have you know i think one of the documentaries that won the oscars was going on
00:05:59 about how you look at levels of black incarceration in american prisons that is clearly the result of
00:06:04 racism well actually if you go back to the 1930s most people in in american prisons were white
00:06:10 eight out of ten people were and that was in the face of racism which was clearly far worse than
00:06:15 it is today. So racism cannot explain why there are so many black people in American
00:06:22 prisons today, for example. And nor can it explain the collapse of the black family because
00:06:29 in the 1920s, 30s, 40s, 50s, the marriage rate in the black community in America was really high.
00:06:37 Divorce rates were low. Most children were not born out of wedlock. Family life was very stable,
00:06:44 communities were very stable so the question is what you know transformed those admirable
00:06:50 communities admirable as i say in the face of the most disgusting racism into these absolute
00:06:57 nightmare ghettos uh today certainly the you know where a lot of poor black americans live
00:07:03 it seems for from the film that uh i mean i'm not giving anything away about the doctor spoiler alert
00:07:09 yeah no it's just that uh obviously because it's very full of details an hour and a half long i
00:07:15 think is it yeah nearly uh but there were a number of events that happened or rather developments
00:07:20 one being welfare and one being as well the sort of hijacking by the demo the democrat
00:07:27 democrat party which actually had always been well sort of supported slavery hadn't it yeah no
00:07:33 No, anyone with the faintest knowledge of, you know, American history sort of stretching
00:07:40 back, you know, a couple of centuries, those the Democrats, they were the party of the
00:07:45 South. They were the party of slavery. They were the party of segregation. You know, the 0.75
00:07:49 Democrats, it was Democrats who formed the KKK. You know, it was described as the terror
00:07:56 wing of the Democrat Party. You know, the Republican Party was the party of Lincoln.
00:08:03 Black people set up local Republican parties, state Republican parties in the South.
00:08:08 I think until 1930 there were about 30-ish black congressmen who had been elected to
00:08:15 the US Congress.
00:08:16 All of them were Republican.
00:08:19 The Democrat Party absolutely, as someone says in the film, had blood on their hands
00:08:24 as regards the race issue.
00:08:26 It wasn't until, I mean they're kicking off with the New Deal, but not until the 60s did
00:08:31 they really managed to, you know, flip that coin.
00:08:35 And now, of course, it's weird.
00:08:37 For people with not much understanding of history,
00:08:39 they don't believe it when you say the Democrats are historically the party of racism.
00:08:43 I mean, they had election posters that had Democrat Party, the party of the white man,
00:08:48 and Republican Party is the party of the Negro. 0.53
00:08:50 I mean, this was what the Democrats pushed out. 0.94
00:08:54 I see some great illustrations, some great examples of that in the film, actually.
00:08:58 what therefore how do you view the current situation in america with the new administration
00:09:05 where this is now entirely embedded isn't it this whole attitude this particular reading
00:09:09 that it's all about systemic racism this is now this is now the reigning orthodoxy government
00:09:17 academic in the culture isn't it well the the democrats had to flip because most black people 0.60
00:09:24 in America lived in the south and that was where their stronghold was and so they had
00:09:27 kept effectively black people out of the voting booths by Jim Crow laws for decades and decades
00:09:32 but when they realised that was going to change either they captured the black vote or they 0.98
00:09:38 would be dead, they would be absolutely dead in the water and so they did that, we tell
00:09:42 the story of how they did that in particular in the 60s with welfare but the same process
00:09:50 actually as the introduction of the welfare state also alienated a lot of working class people I
00:09:55 mean the astonishing thing was the same flip happens in that decade of the decade of the
00:10:02 democrats starting to lose the working class vote of course you have it in not just in America you
00:10:07 have it in Britain as well you know the Labour Party has ceased to be the party of the industrial
00:10:11 working class and it is the party of middle class state sector people and in same thing happens in
00:10:19 America, they lose the working class vote.
00:10:22 And since the 1960s, and not enough people realize this, most white Americans vote Republican 0.60
00:10:31 and have voted Republican for decades, ever since the 1960s.
00:10:35 In every single US presidential election, most white Americans vote Republican. 0.54
00:10:40 The Democrats would not have had a single person in the White House had it not been 0.98
00:10:43 for the black vote. 0.99
00:10:45 They are absolutely dependent on it. 0.68
00:10:47 And so if 60% of black people in America woke up tomorrow morning and decided that they 0.87
00:10:53 weren't black after all, they were just Americans and were going to vote any which way, it would 0.55
00:10:57 be an absolute, what Nigerians call, an existential crisis for the Democrats. 0.77
00:11:01 They are dead in the water.
00:11:04 So they have to focus relentlessly on race. 1.00
00:11:07 They need black people to continue to think of themselves as a distinct racial group at 0.99
00:11:13 odds with the rest of society and they need to view the Democrats as the answer to their 0.98
00:11:19 problems. And they focus on that relentlessly. Without that, they're dead. And again, a not
00:11:27 dissimilar thing is happening in the UK where instead of a lot of working class voters that
00:11:32 they've lost that will go to UKIP or Tory or whatever, the immigrant vote is terribly,
00:11:38 terribly or the ethnic minority vote is terribly important to Labour. And so racism
00:11:42 becomes this thing where they must, you know,
00:11:46 effectively promote the fear of racism and spectre of racism
00:11:49 in order to drive black people to the polls,
00:11:53 to keep them, you know, this kind of besieged mentality going. 0.96
00:11:57 It is remarkably similar to here, actually, as you say.
00:12:01 I would have thought that what's happened with Labour,
00:12:04 that would probably be quite a good subject
00:12:07 for one of your documentaries, wouldn't it, as well?
00:12:10 That'd be good if I could afford another one, yes.
00:12:12 What is the position now, Martin, with, you know, the kind of work that you've done and been acclaimed for and very popular, the media landscape is not even what it was 10, 15 years ago, is it?
00:12:29 You mentioned there that this sort of thing, you wouldn't get it on terrestrial TV.
00:12:34 No, none of the main platforms, I think, would take films of a libertarian or classical liberal
00:12:43 perspective. It's got to be alternative media now. I mean, it is extraordinary. I mean,
00:12:49 it is absolutely extraordinary, the grip on the mainstream media world that woke socialism
00:12:59 has.
00:13:00 The thing is that seems to have tightened and tightened.
00:13:04 Yeah, and narrowed and narrowed and narrowed. 0.62
00:13:06 And it's part of the race story as well.
00:13:08 You know, this all started when I was saying to a mate,
00:13:14 you know, what shall I make films on?
00:13:17 I was going to make a couple of US-orientated films
00:13:19 because most of my films are UK.
00:13:21 I'm going to do things about America.
00:13:23 And he said, don't make one about race
00:13:25 and don't make one about guns.
00:13:26 So that's precisely what I did.
00:13:28 But nevertheless, you know, if you tell people you're going to make a couple of films on this,
00:13:32 they say, are you mad?
00:13:34 Are you crazy?
00:13:36 They're going to kill you.
00:13:37 You know, you'll be ruined.
00:13:39 Luckily, I'm old enough now that I don't give a damn.
00:13:41 But, you know, if I were younger, I would definitely be worried about making these sorts of films
00:13:47 because your career in the mainstream media industry, gone.
00:13:52 Well, actually, that's one of the things I was going to ask you about.
00:13:53 I mean, you know, younger people who are not necessarily signed up with the whole woke agenda.
00:14:00 You know, there isn't, well, where would they go?
00:14:04 There aren't that many places now that they could actually go, surely.
00:14:07 I mean, would, for example, you know, when you made your program about climate change,
00:14:11 would that even, would it get commissioned now?
00:14:16 I mean, I doubt it.
00:14:18 And the sort of people, I mean, luckily there were a couple of mavericks,
00:14:22 a few mavericks who were in the industry
00:14:24 back in the day
00:14:26 Sarah Rams and Hamish Makura 1.00
00:14:28 people like that
00:14:28 I mean great
00:14:29 Hamish Makura is still in the industry
00:14:31 I've got to be careful
00:14:32 and so is Sarah actually
00:14:33 but you know
00:14:35 I don't know of any of those people
00:14:37 who are bold enough
00:14:38 to stick their necks out like that anymore
00:14:41 it's terribly
00:14:42 I think younger people 1.00
00:14:43 younger people
00:14:44 you know they've got to be entrepreneurial now
00:14:46 they've got to think
00:14:47 right we're going to raise some money
00:14:48 you know
00:14:49 to try and get the money together
00:14:50 make the film
00:14:51 try and get it out there
00:14:52 I mean, that's what I'm doing. I'm putting these things out online. I hope people will
00:14:56 watch at www.greatamerican.com. Oh, we'll put it on the, after, under the sand, I'll
00:15:01 leave it to the end. Have you had much reaction to it so far?
00:15:05 No, it's just really, it's gone up. It's only just gone up.
00:15:10 I think, I mean, you have gone right to the, more than guns, I'd suggest, you've gone right
00:15:14 to the heart of everything at the moment. Do you ever sort of feel, I mean, are you
00:15:21 fearless or do you ever feel
00:15:23 oh actually why am I
00:15:25 doing this why am I going to put myself through
00:15:27 this and taking something on like
00:15:29 that well you do I do
00:15:31 I mean mainly it's because my
00:15:33 you know my wife gets
00:15:35 she's nervous because we'll you know we're not
00:15:37 invited to any dinner parties in North London anymore
00:15:39 but I mean apart from that I mean I 1.00
00:15:41 don't I mean BLM I mean are you
00:15:43 nervous about being attacked by BLM
00:15:45 as far as I can see BLM and TFA 0.99
00:15:47 all these people are a bunch of scallywags you know they need 1.00
00:15:49 be called out you know what on earth you know if blm was a genuine you know black grassroots 0.95
00:15:55 organization that really represented them then i would you know a i wouldn't attack them um and b
00:16:01 i'd be scared of them but you know as it happens i mean they've got absolutely nothing to do with
00:16:06 real black people in america you know look at what they're what they stand for they stand for 0.99
00:16:12 you know they're marxists they're anti-consumerist well anti-consumer society show me the working 0.98
00:16:19 class back people who are anti-consumerist you know they want a flat screen telly they like clothes 1.00
00:16:23 they like shoes they like a nice bmw to go around in yeah they're sensible they like they're like
00:16:29 consumer goods um the people who are anti-consumerist actually as it happens are you
00:16:35 know upper middle class white environmentalist type who consume an awful lot you know al gore
00:16:39 is anti-consumerist i mean how fat is he does he ever stop eating how many houses he got in swimming
00:16:45 ripples you know of course they are consumerist but they've got apple laptops and their ipad and
00:16:51 they go traveling it's a different source of consumption they despise working class consumption 0.98
00:16:55 that that that kick has nothing to do with ordinary ordinary black people they're into trans rights 0.57
00:17:00 go to a gym with a lot of black blokes in or go to a black church in hackney and try telling them
00:17:07 about trans rights you know there is a lot of you know reasonably you know conservative small c
00:17:14 kind of you know thinking goes on in the black community they're religious
00:17:17 a lot of them are against abortion you know climate change they're thinking 0.96
00:17:21 about climate change of course it's all cod's wallop that these are you know
00:17:25 genuine grassroots organizations that represent real people they are you know
00:17:29 absurd leftist upper middle class organizations that are con jobs and need
00:17:37 to be called out so I'm not I'm not at all far from frightened of them I think
00:17:42 was a i think brendan o'neill it might have been actually said that uh you know the whole
00:17:48 work thing was sort of a revolt of the over privileged you know i mean certainly when you
00:17:53 see for example in your program you see because you you've managed to get get hold of uh two yeah
00:18:01 one young black woman herself who's like going against the grain she starts the program yeah
00:18:07 But basically, all the people, the demonstrators you see, are white, aren't they?
00:18:12 And middle class, just like when we saw Edward Coulson's statue being, you know,
00:18:18 sung in the river, it was sort of like John Snow said, 0.85
00:18:21 I've never seen so many white people, you know, it was just... 0.97
00:18:24 If you look at the, and we look at the rushes, obviously, 0.77
00:18:27 we don't just have the news reports, we get the original report. 0.99
00:18:29 You look at these demonstrations, and they're just a sea of young white
00:18:33 university students effectively and then occasionally you see the camera person oh they spot someone
00:18:39 who's black there and they go and again and then that poor unfortunate fellow like we've got one 0.99
00:18:44 here we've got you know they turn up about five times because they're all trying to do do that i 0.82
00:18:49 mean it is it is ridiculous if if blm are organizing their own thing they'll make sure that there are
00:18:54 only sort of black faces on there so they care to sort of um orchestrated but by and large i mean
00:18:59 look at antifa i mean you know as if antifa had anything to do with working class people i mean
00:19:05 you know they are they are you know upper class white radical left poncers i mean there's just i
00:19:12 mean ah is this why the media on the whole tend to be sympathetic do you think because it's also
00:19:22 university educated poncers but when you sort of talk about they they put the camera here and there
00:19:27 and i know the level of distrust now of the media i have never known it to be at such a level i mean
00:19:37 we've i worked in television at one point i know you obviously you've been in terms of a long time
00:19:42 and can you remember it being this low i people generally don't trust what they no it's got worse
00:19:47 and worse and worse and it's got tighter and tighter and tighter and and and telly used to
00:19:52 represent and be for working-class people. I used to work at ITV. I can't remember whether
00:19:59 you were at ITV.
00:20:00 ITV's Self Bank show.
00:20:02 Oh yeah, yeah, both old LWT's. So back in the day, Cilla Black, all that kind of thing,
00:20:11 and now the grip of the kind of leftist woke intelligentsia is particularly strong in non-commercial
00:20:20 channels bbc channel 4 because you know they are they've got the sense of purpose and their purpose
00:20:27 obviously as middle class leftists is is woke authoritarianism what about this thing we've been
00:20:35 going through over the past year you know dare i say covid the pandemic um i would have thought
00:20:41 that that would be grist your mill at some point as well as as a documentary maker yeah no there
00:20:48 are a few things I'd like to make films about. I've got to get a model going. If I can make
00:20:56 these two films work and if people go to them and I can at the very least cover my costs
00:21:02 on them then I can roll out more films but certainly it's now I think the rest of what's
00:21:10 left of filmmaking in me will have to be along that kind of as I say entrepreneurial model
00:21:16 where we put things out we just bypass the gatekeepers in the bbc and so on and try to make
00:21:22 it work so so basically the way you make it work is by people paying to watch it it's as simple as
00:21:29 that they go to the site and then what do they pay sort of a three dollars ninety nine right you
00:21:34 know for a click and hope we get enough three dollars ninety nine so i'm making back you were
00:21:40 presumably making the race documentary during the past year obviously you've been doing it during
00:21:47 the past year during all of these uh restrictions we've had you're generally not sympathetic to the
00:21:54 whole thing are you is that right martin to the lockdown for example no i'm not really sympathetic
00:22:01 no i think the the uh it's it's been i think it terrifies me more than anything else the degree
00:22:08 to which and you can see the logic behind it you know the people don't want to be ill
00:22:12 and so on and so forth but you know it is played to all of those authoritarian instincts
00:22:19 that were that were strong anyway current in society and it's just sort of been a boost
00:22:25 to all of that stuff which is really worrying and to see the the you know the behavior of
00:22:32 the police and all this kind of I mean it's ironic because obviously the role of the police
00:22:38 comes up with the race question as well because they say all these racist cops and defund
00:22:48 the police and all that sort of thing which is nonsense I have met far more racist, many
00:22:55 more racist environmentalists than I have met racist cops but nevertheless these people
00:23:00 will go on about overweening policing but they describe themselves as Marxists I mean
00:23:05 they support you know social have they ever read about the Soviet Union or communist China if you
00:23:11 want overweening policing go there they're police states you know but um uh but yeah all the COVID 0.81
00:23:18 I'm sure that um we'd agree with all the worrying uh trends in COVID all this COVID business
00:23:24 how how transformative do you think it will prove to have been the past year
00:23:30 Oh, my God. I mean, I fear. Very transformative. I mean, I think I'm really all this Biden stuff
00:23:40 about, you know, let's have world taxation, a basic level of taxation over the whole world.
00:23:49 That, you know, the vaccine passports and knowing where you are and stand here, do that. I mean,
00:23:56 people are being acclimatized to a degree of subservience and obedience,
00:24:04 which I think is terrifying culturally, utterly poisonous.
00:24:10 You know, when are we going to start?
00:24:12 Why are the young kids not getting throwing bricks?
00:24:16 Why are they putting up with it?
00:24:18 I mean, their lives are being utterly ruined, 1.00
00:24:20 but they're all kowtowing and masks on and all that sort of thing. 0.72
00:24:23 I think I'm very worried. 0.63
00:24:25 I think actually that is one of the most surprising things, actually, the young people.
00:24:30 I've found this is entirely anecdotal, right?
00:24:32 It's entirely anecdotal.
00:24:34 But when it comes to people enforcing restrictions, saying when you can and cannot go into a bar or taking your order and everything,
00:24:45 I've often found that younger people seem to be far more by the book.
00:24:50 You know, there is no give and take, you know.
00:24:52 So all one often needs is some sense of mutuality, maybe some humour to get you through.
00:24:59 But there's none.
00:25:00 There's this righteousness.
00:25:02 I think there's a class thing there.
00:25:03 I think middle class, white especially, children are that righteous, play it by the book. 0.54
00:25:11 I think if you go out in Essex, no one's playing it by the book. 1.00
00:25:15 Working class, they don't give us stuff. 0.94
00:25:17 I mean, working class is doing stuff about GM food, about climate, all that sort of thing.
00:25:20 all the concerns of the you know left-wing middle class intelligentsia you know are not shared by
00:25:27 the vast majority of real people in the country is the is the encouraging thing yeah actually but
00:25:31 this is a class is the great uh invisible thing now isn't it or rather should i say the great
00:25:37 unconsidered thing uh you know in in in the woke revolution in in in the situation with covid
00:25:45 all of these situations the class element is sort of like it's just never gone into it and it seems
00:25:51 to be of a piece with Labour's more or less entirely giving up the idea of actually looking
00:25:57 after working class peoples you know representing them it's entirely gone it seems to be I mean you
00:26:04 as someone who came originally from the left you know it that must strike you particularly 0.96
00:26:09 surely oh I'm astonished at the snobbery of the left the snobbery of all these statists I mean
00:26:14 And the whole status proposition is that the state has the experts, the university educated
00:26:19 elite who are going to look after and regulate the lives of ordinary people.
00:26:24 And it is a source of intense irritation to the Democrats in America that the working
00:26:30 class don't want to be regulated and don't want high taxes.
00:26:34 Socialism does not appeal to ordinary working class people.
00:26:37 And so they condemn them as deplorables. 1.00
00:26:40 They're just these scum, these rednecks. 1.00
00:26:43 And racism actually comes in quite handy for demonising them. 0.98
00:26:47 Why do all these working class people vote for Trump, vote Republican?
00:26:51 They're racist bigots. 0.57
00:26:52 They must be racist bigots.
00:26:54 Racism again comes in handy there as a kind of slur to anyone who opposes them and they
00:27:00 use it against political opponents as well.
00:27:02 Just a cheap political slur, you're a racist.
00:27:04 So the whole term has been degraded into just a sort of political insult.
00:27:09 yeah the working classes they they are not working class are not social surprise surprise
00:27:14 and it is not and they're not green either and that's not a surprise either because they're the
00:27:18 green saying we've all got to consume less and a lot of working class people thinking do you know
00:27:22 what historically thankfully we are consuming more than we ever have in human history we're not very
00:27:27 keen on tightening our belts thank you very bloody much um no there is this kind of extraordinary
00:27:33 self-righteousness as you say and uh and it's not shared by by working past people
00:27:40 i think you've sort of already said something about this much but i i don't want to be too
00:27:44 doom laden which means i'm going to be but you know would you if young people starting out want
00:27:51 to make documentaries or would you sort of say that they've just simply got to be one man bands
00:27:59 one woman bands just forget it you know you're not going to get this anything you want to maybe
00:28:06 make onto mainstream broadcast anymore would you say that well i think that um i mean the
00:28:13 industry is collapsing anyway i mean apart this is what i mean this is my perception but i don't
00:28:17 want to sound but when you say collapsing how i mean i mean you look at i mean i think what's the
00:28:23 average viewer age for the bbc i mean it's about you know 111 or something it is shot i mean it
00:28:30 is in its 70s i think you know they are ancient um and the bbc i can't think it's going to last i 0.99
00:28:35 mean too few people watch it they're all really old and bbc don't want any old viewers so they i
00:28:39 mean you know they're just they don't know what the hell they're on about and generally terrestrial
00:28:44 tv and uh and even cable tv are in you know very great decline at the moment the platforms are
00:28:49 are coming up the ott platforms um but even there you know there's a limit on how many netflix's
00:28:55 discovery plus you're going you know you're going to want so the whole geology is changing um as it
00:29:04 as it were of the of the industry so in a way it's it's it's quite a good time you know start a
00:29:10 podcast um try to make your own um long form films are more expensive to make and and that sort of
00:29:17 thing but shorter things are much easier to make and shove onto YouTube and that revolution hasn't
00:29:24 finished I mean part of the trouble is monetizing it you know because you can make something you get
00:29:28 it out there and if you're lucky it'll get a lot of views but you know how do you get any money
00:29:33 back so so as a living it's it's hard but um but the nice thing is you know it's it's I think it's
00:29:39 a good thing that it's that it's been burst wide open what's your view of people like Netflix I
00:29:45 I mean, do you, because we've had Frank Verady actually on quite recently.
00:29:50 He was sort of talking about Netflix on the whole being a bit of a malign influence
00:29:55 when it came to this sort of slightly watered down wokery, you know,
00:30:01 but that there is an agenda, you know, there is an agenda which you sort of sense.
00:30:05 Do you feel that with Netflix?
00:30:06 I mean, or do you think it's been a good thing on the whole?
00:30:11 Well, there's a limit to what I can say about it because I'm still in the industry.
00:30:14 Right.
00:30:14 so as much as it is sorely tempting to take the gloves off there's there is only so much I can
00:30:23 sort of say about specific broadcasters because one thing they do do I have to say is they do
00:30:28 have platforms for long and beautifully made documentaries I saw one recently on Nina Simone
00:30:34 for example it's just wonderful it was just oh yeah if you want to make a doc on you know Nina
00:30:39 Simone or you know a lovely a donk that doesn't upset people and it doesn't take a libertarian
00:30:45 or classical liberal view that's fine it's specifically you know the kind of films that
00:30:53 we're talking about.
00:30:55 What about the guns one what stage are we with that actually I'm finishing about four
00:31:01 weeks I'm halfway through the edit oh right okay okay and this is just simply going to
00:31:05 be looking at what the the current argument about it's looking at the whole second amendment thing
00:31:10 and the i mean biden has come out and he's um you know raised the specter of gun control again
00:31:16 and it's looking at that and it is a very very robust um defense of the second amendment
00:31:24 and the second amendment properly read which is a defense of ordinary people to keep
00:31:29 and bear arms and it's from a big historical perspective so it's looking at the you know the
00:31:35 the situation today with with guns you know what problems they're supposed to cause and the you
00:31:42 know the reality of that and also the history it's a broad sweep of history as well the ancient
00:31:46 greeks the ancient romans the middle ages absolutism you know the whole story of because
00:31:52 as soon as you look back in history you see the whole of history the whole of human history pretty
00:31:57 much is the history of, for the most part, an armed small elite oppressing a large mass
00:32:05 of unarmed folk underneath. And it's only very rarely does that reverse itself. In ancient
00:32:12 Greece, ordinary people armed themselves. In the Roman Republic, ordinary people armed
00:32:16 themselves. The militias in England, unlike Europe in the 15th, 16th, 17th centuries,
00:32:23 and so on and so forth. So it tells the big story, but also just calls out a lot of the
00:32:26 rubbish that's talked about guns today, you know, that America, because the vision of
00:32:31 America is this blood everywhere, you know, it's just everywhere being shot to bits.
00:32:37 In fact, mass shootings form a tiny, tiny, tiny proportion of the number of people who
00:32:42 die from guns in America.
00:32:44 Nearly everyone dies because, well, the biggest chunk is people who kill themselves from guns
00:32:49 because guns are really good for killing yourself.
00:32:52 And as for the rest, it's simply not true that this is a gun problem over the whole
00:32:56 of America.
00:32:57 Internationally, you see loads of countries with loads of guns, very high levels of gun
00:33:01 ownership, like Switzerland, with incredibly low crime rates in general and crime.
00:33:07 But I think Switzerland's got about half the gun murder rate in the UK and it's got one
00:33:11 of the highest rates of gun ownership in the world.
00:33:14 Switzerland?
00:33:15 Yeah.
00:33:16 And you have the same Finland and Israel and loads of other countries.
00:33:20 And within the US, you have states with the highest rates of gun ownership, New Hampshire,
00:33:27 with the lowest rates of gun violence, and states with not very high rates of gun ownership
00:33:33 like Illinois with very high rates of gun violence.
00:33:35 It's simply not, there's not a correlation between numbers of guns and the amount of
00:33:38 gun violence.
00:33:39 And indeed, when you go within the states, there's a further breakdown that if you look 0.51
00:33:44 at Illinois, where the gun murder rate is very high, if you're white, it's not high 0.51
00:33:48 at all.
00:33:49 If you're white in loads of states in America, the gun murder rate is lower than it is in
00:33:54 the UK and France and Germany. 0.58
00:33:56 The problem is if you're black and specifically if you're black in, and not just if you're
00:34:01 black, it's the specific thing, if you're in one of those inner city ghetto areas, that 0.63
00:34:07 is where the criminal, the gun mayhem is happening. 0.78
00:34:12 And so really, again, it's going back to welfare.
00:34:14 It's a problem of the welfare state and what that has done to poor black communities in
00:34:19 america but so it's uh when you about that when when you're obviously these are american subjects
00:34:24 you're doing uh do you feel that america has fundamentally changed i mean you said that
00:34:32 obviously it's not drenched in blood you know to guns you know that's impression you know that's
00:34:36 given by the media and everything but my feeling as somebody who's gone back and forth to america
00:34:41 all my life lived out is my attitude to it's fundamentally changed now I just can't help
00:34:49 feeling that its spirit has changed would you go along with that I mean the again it's hard because
00:34:57 you often get it through the media lens and certainly if you believe the kind of mainstream
00:35:01 media in the US then I think the spirit has changed but you go further into America you
00:35:06 actually talk to real Americans and I think there's an enormous frustration there which is
00:35:10 why people were voting for Trump.
00:35:12 We're saying, you know, that's not us.
00:35:13 Actually, we're still the same America
00:35:15 in many ways that we were before.
00:35:18 But you're right, there is an enormous
00:35:20 culture war going on there.
00:35:22 And, you know, part of the reason
00:35:24 for doing the guns one was that I don't want
00:35:26 that American sense of,
00:35:29 powerful sense of individualism and freedom
00:35:32 and gutsiness to die.
00:35:35 Because my God, if it dies in America, 0.68
00:35:38 then, you know, we've got Europe over there.
00:35:41 I mean, there's America, there's us.
00:35:42 I mean, there's the Anglophone countries
00:35:43 where, you know, it's still a bit strong,
00:35:45 but it's strongest of all in America.
00:35:48 And so it would, you know, it's like we'll fight.
00:35:52 That's the kind of the big fight that's going to be fought.
00:35:55 So now, if people want to watch it again,
00:35:58 the Great American Race Game is at www.
00:36:05 www.greatamericanracegame.com.
00:36:08 and they can see it now
00:36:11 they can see it right now
00:36:12 please see it now
00:36:13 it's full of laughs
00:36:14 it's a hoot of a film
00:36:16 it's not po-faced
00:36:17 it's very fast
00:36:20 and funny in parts
00:36:22 and I'm glad you found it moving
00:36:24 oh I did
00:36:25 there's a lot of powerful
00:36:27 a lot of powerful stuff in there
00:36:28 and some great great interviewees
00:36:32 Bevelyn Beatty
00:36:33 brilliant
00:36:33 Bob Woodson
00:36:34 Glenn Lowry
00:36:35 Wilfred Riley
00:36:36 loads of really good folk in there
00:36:39 the late Walter Williams
00:36:40 the late great Walter Williams
00:36:42 I got a lucky interview before he died
00:36:44 and so please do watch it
00:36:47 yes of course
00:36:47 and we have viewers in America as well
00:36:50 so you've got even less reason not to watch it
00:36:54 Martin thank you very much
00:36:56 thank you very much for having me again
00:36:57 and also the guns when you say you're editing it
00:37:00 so that would be out
00:37:01 available to see what in a couple of months
00:37:04 a couple of months
00:37:04 A couple of months' time.
00:37:06 Thank you very much, Martin Durkitt.
00:37:08 That's it for what you're saying is this week.
00:37:12 Please do remember, won't you, to subscribe, as I always say.
00:37:16 And we shall see you next time.
00:37:18 Thank you very much.