New Culture Forum - January 25, 2020


Dr David Starkey: Brexit & Our Constitutional Crisis [Smith Lecture 2019]

2.11 Simon Heffer: From The Great War to Brexit: A Traditionalist View of Britain 2.15 Zuby: How To Be a Rebel in the 2020s

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

139.49

Word count

6,894

Sentence count

270


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the 2019 Smith Lecture.
00:00:05 Full house, as indeed it should be, for David Starkey.
00:00:09 Thank you so much for coming.
00:00:12 The Smith Lecture is something we started three years ago.
00:00:17 Two years ago, sorry.
00:00:18 Our first speaker was Douglas Murray, who you might know from the book
00:00:22 The Strange Death of Europe.
00:00:24 And our second speaker last year was Nigel Farage.
00:00:27 you talked about social media and free speech, and I'm delighted and honoured actually that
00:00:33 this year we have, I think, the best-known historian in Britain, Dr. David Starkey, who's
00:00:41 going to talk to us about Brexit and the constitutional crisis. I'd like to start before, just in
00:00:50 case some of you are unfamiliar, but the new Culture Forum started in 2006. And I believed
00:00:58 and people with me believed that in that rather well-known phrase now, culture is upstream
00:01:06 of politics. And I think that particularly over the past few years, with the Brexit referendum
00:01:14 and indeed with these rather terrible three years we've been through as well,
00:01:20 we can say that this is something which is definitely gaining purchase, if you like,
00:01:25 in our intellectual life, that culture is incredibly important.
00:01:30 So like all think tanks, we produce publications, we produce books,
00:01:36 our reports have become influential, I'm pleased to say, and they have a lot of media attention.
00:01:42 They are over there, some of them, on that stall there,
00:01:46 indeed, as are beautiful mugs, which you must buy if you'd like.
00:01:51 We're into merchandising now.
00:01:55 But the point is this, really, to be serious,
00:01:57 is that I realised over the past couple of years
00:02:01 that what think tanks do is incredibly important.
00:02:08 But the problem is that we have a media now
00:02:11 that is increasingly restricted, increasingly prescribed, and very, very narrow.
00:02:19 So I think that what think tanks have to do, what we have to do,
00:02:23 is to create our own forms of media.
00:02:27 We have to create our own methods of communication to get our message out
00:02:32 in an increasingly crowded field.
00:02:37 So with that in mind, this year at the New Culture Forum,
00:02:41 We set up our own YouTube channel.
00:02:44 We started a program called So What You're Saying Is.
00:02:48 It's an interview program.
00:02:49 I don't know whether any of you have seen any of it.
00:02:52 But I don't know whether you remember,
00:02:54 but the reason we chose this title
00:02:57 is because Channel 4 News and Cathy Newman
00:03:02 did an interview with Jordan Peterson about two years ago,
00:03:06 which was a bit of a benchmark in bias, actually.
00:03:11 And it became a thing.
00:03:15 It became a bit of a landmark.
00:03:18 She kept saying all the time,
00:03:19 so what she was saying is that what she was doing
00:03:21 was constantly re-evaluating his words,
00:03:26 constantly saying, basically putting words in his mouth.
00:03:29 So we thought, this is the perfect title for a show.
00:03:34 So we started that in January,
00:03:37 and I've done 40 interviews since,
00:03:40 And we've now got 3.2 million views, I'm pleased to say.
00:03:45 And we've just started another program called Counterculture,
00:03:50 which is going to be a discussion of the various issues,
00:03:54 cultural issues that are basically shaping our thought and our society today.
00:04:00 This is terribly important.
00:04:03 I mention this because one of the first guests we had on was indeed David Starkey.
00:04:10 And he gave us an hour of his time, and as a result, very quickly got a quarter of a million views.
00:04:18 I'm very, very grateful to him for that.
00:04:22 David Starkey is one of those rare beasts.
00:04:25 He's a public intellectual who also manages to speak to an extremely wide audience,
00:04:33 whether it is on the Tudors
00:04:36 whether it's great documentaries
00:04:38 on Elizabeth I or Henry VIII
00:04:41 or whether it's on more arcane
00:04:43 constitutional matters
00:04:46 he manages to make them accessible
00:04:48 and he manages to tell our story to us
00:04:52 this is something which is
00:04:54 more valuable than it's ever been
00:04:56 because our schools have more or less given up on it
00:04:59 so I'm delighted that he's here today
00:05:03 he obviously has done much media too
00:05:07 he doesn't resile from being controversial
00:05:10 he's often on Question Time
00:05:13 The Moral Maze
00:05:14 numerous other programs
00:05:15 in fact when I was looking up
00:05:17 doing my research
00:05:18 I of course should always do my research
00:05:20 I found out that his first television appearance
00:05:24 was in 1977
00:05:25 so he's been with us a very long time
00:05:28 but he is here with us this evening
00:05:32 So when he's finished, there will be a time for questions, which we will have roving mics around the hall.
00:05:42 But without further ado, please can I ask you to welcome Dr. David Starkey to talk about Brexit.
00:06:02 Peter, ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much.
00:06:09 Can I remind you where you are?
00:06:12 You are in the Emmanuel Center, which means God is with us.
00:06:20 We hope he is on Thursday.
00:06:21 last week in anticipation of thursday i was at a very high-powered seminar
00:06:34 to contemplate what the future election result might be and it was very appropriately named and
00:06:42 certainly i required extra medication it was named high anxiety which seems to me to be
00:06:49 entirely justified and I had for perhaps some of the reasons that Peter has indicated the last
00:06:57 question was directed at me and the question was would you care to sketch what the political world
00:07:05 will look like after the election so I began by saying it would first be very helpful if somebody
00:07:12 told me what the result of the election was I would have then felt entirely competent to give
00:07:19 that sketch. As we don't have that, as we are still in the lap of God or the lap of the gods
00:07:24 or luck or whatever it is, we need to turn to something else. And as a professional historian,
00:07:33 I do not believe that historians should be prophets. There is nothing worse than pretending
00:07:39 that because you know about the past, you know about the future, even if you are as clever as
00:07:44 Neil Ferguson. It seems to me to be, perhaps especially if you're as clever as Neil Ferguson,
00:07:51 it seems to me to be an error. On the other hand, history, and you don't have to be a Marxist to
00:07:58 believe this, history does have a tendency, if not simply to repeat, to produce rather similar
00:08:05 patterns. And what I want to do this evening is to investigate what I think is the pattern,
00:08:12 the model that we're actually going through at the moment.
00:08:17 When I was an undergraduate at Cambridge,
00:08:20 as Peter has ungulantly suggested, I'm very ancient,
00:08:24 even before the 1970s,
00:08:27 when I was an undergraduate at Cambridge,
00:08:29 I detested 19th century history.
00:08:32 I was taught it by Henry Pelling,
00:08:35 which is all about the rise of labour and the trade unions
00:08:38 and was as boring as you might think that was.
00:08:41 and my other half was from some dreadful man
00:08:44 who was a specialist in non-conformity.
00:08:47 And I'm delighted to say, having been brought up as a Quaker,
00:08:50 I had been inoculated against non-conformity from childhood.
00:08:54 It was quite extraordinary.
00:08:55 In a Quaker meeting, people arise to speak as the spirit moves them.
00:09:00 And even as an 11-year-old, I realized it was quite extraordinary
00:09:04 that the spirit had always read a Guardian editorial.
00:09:11 nevertheless i have rediscovered my interest in the 19th century because it seems to me
00:09:19 that what we're undergoing now and this will this is slick it's crude but i think there is a certain
00:09:25 big pattern there what we're undergoing now as everybody tells us from every possible direction
00:09:32 are the consequences of globalization the alleged widening of well undoubtedly the widening of the
00:09:39 gap between rich and poor, the creation of a particular type of liberal elite, creative
00:09:46 destruction, models of universal governance, and so on.
00:09:54 It seems to me, if we go back to the early years of the 19th century, particularly in
00:10:00 Britain, obviously, as the cradle of the Industrial Revolution, if we go back to the 1830s and
00:10:06 1840s, we see industrialization having remarkably similar effects, as obviously it does. It is the
00:10:15 first wave of globalization. And it seems to me that it destabilizes our politics on the one hand
00:10:23 and gives new political opportunities on the other. It's also, I think, worth putting in mind
00:10:31 that the Industrial Revolution was only the second revolution
00:10:35 to have hit in that stretch of time.
00:10:38 40, 50 years before it, there had been the French Revolution.
00:10:43 And what we need to remember, and I'm sure I am, as it were,
00:10:47 teaching grandmothers to suck eggs and whatever with this audience,
00:10:51 the French Revolution is when the whole modern concept of politics begins.
00:10:57 that's to say the broad difference between the liberal reformer and the conservative
00:11:04 and with the key figure being the man edmund burke having begun of course as a supporter of
00:11:12 the previous revolution the american revolution finds with the french revolution and an extraordinary
00:11:19 it's very appropriate when a church to read burke's reflections on the french revolution
00:11:24 is to encounter, and I think for the only time in political thought, the genuine fire of prophecy.
00:11:33 To read the reflections and the best portions of the reflections.
00:11:37 It's not simply analytical, it's more than analytical, it is genuinely prophetic.
00:11:42 He writes in 1790, he anticipates the terror, he anticipates Napoleon,
00:11:48 he anticipates the entire course of the revolution in a quite extraordinary fashion.
00:11:53 But the thing that he most grasps, the thing that I think one takes away, and the thing that actually makes him the creator of conservatism, is what the effect of disinhibited reason was.
00:12:10 Remember, the French and the American revolutions share a common language of the late Enlightenment.
00:12:18 They talk doctrines of universal rights and so on.
00:12:22 But the two revolutions are absolutely fundamentally different in the reality.
00:12:28 The linguistics may be similar.
00:12:31 The actual effect is radically different.
00:12:34 The Americans, one would probably regard as being a bad thing,
00:12:37 whilst they may prate about rights,
00:12:41 are we all familiar with the magnificent inequality?
00:12:44 Are we all familiar with Johnson, Samuel Johnson's,
00:12:47 magnificent remark on the subject of the American Revolution
00:12:50 that nobody prates more loudly in favor of liberty than a Yankee slave driver.
00:12:56 So there is a wonderful, wonderful phrase.
00:13:00 So there is the preservation of black slavery, the American Constitution,
00:13:05 for all the fancy dress of senates and whatever,
00:13:09 is a very, very lightly modified version of the British Constitution of the 18th century.
00:13:15 You even have a House of Representatives, which is managed by a speaker,
00:13:20 Why is it managed by a Speaker?
00:13:22 Because the British Parliament is managed by the House of Commons, is managed by a Speaker.
00:13:27 And what is strangest of all, if you're an American, the administrative officer of the House of Representatives is the Surgeon-at-Arms.
00:13:35 And they haven't the faintest blind idea what a Surgeon-at-Arms is, but it is, of course, simply because he manages the British Parliament.
00:13:42 So you've got a revolution, and you preserve English law and so on.
00:13:47 You've got a revolution which studiously avoids following through its logic to its conclusion, which is why, I would argue, it is the only successful revolution.
00:14:00 The French Revolution, on the other hand, the French being the French, and why they are, as I said, and we've got the critic here, why I said in my first article for the critic, most of the bad ideas in the world come from France.
00:14:12 This is because they cannot stop following things through to a logical conclusion.
00:14:20 And the result, of course, quite seriously, is catastrophic.
00:14:26 The French Revolution attempts to change everything on an allegedly rational model.
00:14:33 You change time.
00:14:35 You change dates.
00:14:36 You change the calendar.
00:14:38 You change, you try and rewrite the geography of France, you replace the historic provinces with notionally equal squares just imposed upon the map.
00:14:48 You change terms of address, you change the relationship of human beings, and all in the name of reason.
00:14:56 And yet it turns out, of course, to be the most monstrous, hideous parody of unreason and of violence.
00:15:03 And this seems to me to be an absolutely fundamental point.
00:15:08 We tend to be people who believe in reason.
00:15:11 I come from a university which virtually invented the idea of empirical science, namely Cambridge.
00:15:17 But ladies and gentlemen, reason which is disinhibited, reason which is unhankered, reason which is unchained from experience is a catastrophe.
00:15:29 And this is the great model, this is the great challenge, which is offered by Edmund Burke, in which he puts against this disinhibited reason, what he calls in a magnificent and wonderful phrase, this new empire of reason and light, which turns into the most absolute tyranny.
00:15:49 he erects against that the notion that actually we don't create our world.
00:15:57 Our world creates us.
00:16:00 We as individuals don't create society.
00:16:03 Society creates us.
00:16:06 And it's that essential conception which is the origin of conservatism.
00:16:11 Now the reason that I've given you this pre-lecture is very simple.
00:16:14 It is that the man...
00:16:16 Sorry, no.
00:16:19 This is very French revolutionary, drinking out of an empty glass, right?
00:16:27 Or, dare I say, very Corbynesque.
00:16:31 We shall have much experience of it if things go the wrong way.
00:16:36 The reason I am giving this pre-lecture is because the man who learns, I think, most from Burke is Benjamin Disraeli.
00:16:46 And I think the figure who most completely shapes the politics of the 19th century, and I would argue is probably the best model for understanding and indeed working on the situation in which we find ourselves, is Disraeli.
00:17:02 And Israel takes from Burke two fundamental senses.
00:17:07 One, the historic rootedness of conservatism, and particularly the rootedness of conservatism in the nation, about which he is absolutely clear.
00:17:18 And the second, which is a deeply disturbing one, in view of the direction which conservatism has taken since Keith Joseph and Margaret Thatcher and Friedrich Hayek and whatever, that liberalism and conservatism are natural enemies.
00:17:35 Deeply confusing and awkward and difficult.
00:17:39 And arguing, of course, as he does, that the relationship again between capitalism and conservative is a very awkward and uneven and difficult one.
00:17:51 So, with that sort of introduction, what it seems to me Disraeli does, rising of course in politics as this extraordinary young man in the 1830s, the least plausible figure to be a dominant influence in Victorian England, a flamboyant, probably fundamentally homosexual converted Jew.
00:18:18 remember his first speech in the house of commons was laughed to scorn and he still had the courage
00:18:26 at the end of it to say you mock me now you will listen to me and indeed they did so this
00:18:32 extraordinary left field figure and what is he doing in the 1830s apart from scrabbling into
00:18:38 politics he is part of the that ludicrous movement of young england which tried to recreate chivalry
00:18:46 You know, there's the wonderful book on it, the Eglinton Tournament, the wonderful book that's called The Knight and the Umbrella, which gives you the general sense of the absurdity of the thing.
00:18:56 He is involved in that, the attempted recreation of chivalry in Victorian England, and he is also, of course, in another one of his novels, he is responsible for the wonderful phrase, the phrase of the two nations, the two nations of rich and poor, this Pinkett-like creation of the gap between rich and poor,
00:19:18 which is fundamentally a product of industrialization
00:19:23 in which he says the two nations have as little to do with each other
00:19:27 as though they were in different zones, that's climatic zones,
00:19:31 or different continents, that sense.
00:19:34 And Disraeli then, I think, is essentially the man who asks the question,
00:19:41 what can the social basis of conservatism be?
00:19:46 What is its nature?
00:19:47 and of course it's worth again recapping a little of the political detail what goes on
00:19:56 in the 1830s of course you've got this extremely rapid multiplication of the British economy
00:20:03 the ascendant supremacy of freedom of trade you have as I said when I was just talking about it
00:20:12 quickly to begin with a notable increase of the of a wealth divide the creation of a mercantile
00:20:20 and commercial elite which is fundamentally liberal which is wedded to notions of non-national values
00:20:28 which in other words a formulation that we become familiar with again because of the work of david
00:20:34 goodhart is archetypically anywhere the whole fundamental of capitalism and of liberalism is
00:20:42 fundamentally anywhere. Generalized rules, an absence of national frontiers, a willingness
00:20:50 to trade anything with anybody, combined, of course, with those inheritances of the universalism
00:20:56 of the 18th century, the belief in doctrines of the absolute equality of all mankind,
00:21:03 the fact that you owe a duty not simply to your national group but to the whole of humanity,
00:21:08 All of this generalizing stuff.
00:21:11 And these changes, of course, also go along with gigantic changes in industry that lead to the multiplication of laboring masses, the transformation and decline, just like now.
00:21:27 creative destruction transformation and decline of old industries and the rise of new ones
00:21:32 different areas of the country retreating from economic activity others booming and all the
00:21:38 rest of it and what it seems to me is Disraeli looks at this and begins to sketch in the 1830s
00:21:46 in a way which he is only able to fulfill as the century unfolds for me the key analysis
00:21:56 of where we are now. As I said, he recognizes that the enemy is liberalism, that liberalism
00:22:05 destroys, fragments, shatters tradition, is indifferent if not contemptuous of history.
00:22:15 It is also quite a narrow creed of quite a narrow social group. He then argues that there is a
00:22:23 natural affinity between whatever the Conservative Party was. It didn't quite exist at this point,
00:22:30 but never mind. He's a novelist. He's an inventor, an inventor of words and ideas,
00:22:37 and reality catches up with him. He sees a natural affinity between the Conservative Party,
00:22:45 by that he means a section of the political elite, of the landed aristocracy, and so on.
00:22:51 he sees a natural affinity between them and what he calls the people, the working mass.
00:23:01 Now, this is vaguely Hegelian, and in some ways it's slightly preposterous.
00:23:08 What is he actually, and Hegel is very influenced by all of this sort of stuff too.
00:23:12 Hegel, again, derives very, very heavily from Burke.
00:23:16 Hegel's basic conceptions about the state are Burke translated into bad German, and it's very bad German, utterly unreadable.
00:23:24 But setting that aside, what is it that is the glue that holds these two things together?
00:23:34 he sees it essentially as
00:23:37 the Israeli sees it essentially as
00:23:40 patriotism
00:23:42 as a general sense of passion
00:23:45 about your place of birth
00:23:48 about the country
00:23:49 about its traditions
00:23:51 which is often, dare one say it
00:23:53 a little bit belligerent
00:23:55 is often really, if you're English
00:23:57 and we are terribly good at fighting
00:23:58 especially the French
00:24:00 is exceedingly belligerent
00:24:05 and aggressive
00:24:06 and is rather fond of a dust-up
00:24:09 and I must say I thought that the goings-on
00:24:13 in Fishmonger's Hall were an absolutely magnificent
00:24:16 illustration of the general biffiness of the British
00:24:19 when they really get going. It was very deeply impressive
00:24:22 turning narwhals, fire extinguishers
00:24:26 and coat hangers into weapons was truly
00:24:29 setting aside the terror of the event it was truly magnificent and Disraeli sees this as
00:24:36 the essential point in other words what he sees is that a conservative party has to be a social
00:24:43 alliance between the top and the bottom founded upon a passionate sense of national identity
00:24:52 and nationhood. In other words, as against the liberal in the middle, which is fundamentally
00:24:59 anywhere, they are the somewheres. They are those with that rooted sense, that sense of past,
00:25:07 that sense of community, that sense of belonging. Now, it does seem to me, ladies and gentlemen,
00:25:13 that this is a fundamental observation and one of obviously direct relevance to the present.
00:25:21 But it goes on in the most interesting ways, doesn't it?
00:25:25 Because from Disraeli, there is the descent of the notion of one-nation conservatism.
00:25:33 Can we be absolutely clear?
00:25:35 Disraeli is not responsible for the term.
00:25:39 He talks about the two nations.
00:25:42 The first usage of the term one-nation conservatism is in the wildly different circumstances,
00:25:49 which I will talk about in a moment
00:25:51 but we'll get the use and we'll get the man who does it there
00:25:54 it is Baldwin in the immediate
00:25:56 Stanley Baldwin in the immediate aftermath
00:25:59 of the First World War
00:26:01 and he actually coins the phrase
00:26:03 one nation Toryism
00:26:05 deliberately looking back towards Disraeli
00:26:09 but of course at that point ladies and gentlemen
00:26:11 the political landscape had shifted
00:26:14 from two groups
00:26:15 liberal and conservative
00:26:17 into three
00:26:20 There had been the rise of the Labour Party,
00:26:22 there had been, which of course was simply the political voice,
00:26:26 to a very significant extent it still is, of the trade unions,
00:26:30 and there had been what George Dangerfield calls
00:26:33 the strange death of Liberal England after its triumph
00:26:37 on either side of the First World War,
00:26:40 its death with the aftermath of the coupon election
00:26:43 and the rise of the Labour Party at the expense of the Liberal Party.
00:26:48 And this is the very different world, this tripartite world, in which Stanley Baldwin is operating.
00:26:57 And what Baldwin is doing in that world is something very different from the Israeli in the earlier world.
00:27:08 What Baldwin is doing in that world is consciously trying to draw the revolutionary sting from the Labour Party.
00:27:16 And he does it in a completely remarkable fashion, in very close alliance with, Peter was kind enough to refer to some of my work on monarchy, what we forget in the beginning of the 20th century in the monarchy of George V was that we had a politically highly active monarchy, which is radically different from the supine monarchy of Queen Elizabeth II.
00:27:40 that the monarchy of George V is one
00:27:44 which first of all allies itself with Baldwin
00:27:47 in deliberately taking the Labour Party
00:27:50 as the equivalent of the grit in the oyster
00:27:52 and then putting as much mother of pearl over it as it could
00:27:56 and there are the wonderful scenes in which the Labour government
00:27:59 of 1924, the minority Labour government of
00:28:02 Ramsay MacDonald and you have the posters there
00:28:05 in Tufton Street where we were now
00:28:07 the government in 1924
00:28:10 is welcomed into Buckingham Palace with truly extraordinary scenes
00:28:15 in which you get the miners, in those days,
00:28:19 who were actual miners in the Labour Cabinet.
00:28:20 Can you actually believe it?
00:28:22 And the only one who wouldn't turn up at Buckingham Palace,
00:28:24 of course, is the middle-class Sidney Webb.
00:28:28 And there's a famous exchange between J.H. Thomas and King George V
00:28:32 who asks why on earth wasn't Mr. Webb there,
00:28:36 to which J.H. Thomas replies,
00:28:38 well so in that household it's Beatrix what wears the britches
00:28:41 because of course in those days you had to wear court dress with silk britches
00:28:45 and you can imagine the magnificent figure which these miners
00:28:48 all muscled up with these wonderful tight britches
00:28:52 and their wives bursting out of white court dresses
00:28:55 and this was part of the adoption
00:28:59 the fusion of labour into the heart of government
00:29:03 in this notion of one nationism
00:29:05 The honour system, remember, completely transformed in 1917, even has an order of chivalry specifically for trade unionists and Labour MPs.
00:29:16 The Companion of Honour is deliberately invented by Curzon for that purpose, on the grounds that being committed socialists, they wouldn't want vulgar trinkets like knighthoods and peerages.
00:29:28 It's how little did he know what the truth would be.
00:29:31 And now, of course, the companionship of honour is simply a kind of proxime a Kessick to the Order of Merit,
00:29:36 for not quite first-rank academics.
00:29:40 People like Roy Strong or whatever get that kind of thing.
00:29:45 So you get this very different notion of one-nation Toryism, which is social harmony,
00:29:51 which is not actually a political position.
00:29:53 It is rather setting up a notion that we now have politics rather like a cricket team in which every so often it's only fair that the other side have an innings.
00:30:03 Sune. And then, in the aftermath
00:30:05 of the Second World War, the term
00:30:07 One Nation Toryism is revived
00:30:09 in the aftermath of the catastrophic
00:30:11 defeat of the Tory party
00:30:13 in 1945,
00:30:16 and
00:30:16 with the One Nation
00:30:19 Essay Club, which
00:30:21 produces many of those
00:30:22 with extraordinary people
00:30:25 like Heath.
00:30:27 Can you imagine? Both
00:30:29 Heath and Powell were in the
00:30:31 same group, God knows what was going on there, as well as Gilmour and all the rest of it.
00:30:35 But what is really striking, ladies and gentlemen, is how completely the term, as it is passed
00:30:44 into the present, completely reverses both what Baldwin did and what One Nation Toryism
00:30:52 and what Disraeli did.
00:30:54 And if you look at the final sort of manifestations of One Nation Toryism and the people who claim
00:31:00 to belong to it, the Dominic Greaves and all the rest of this world, is supposed to be liberal
00:31:06 conservatism. It is a vile antithesis, which is why, of course, it never worked. And I would
00:31:15 suggest its peculiar combination of both economic and social liberalism is one of unique
00:31:25 unpopularity, which is why they will crash, one hopes, to
00:31:29 oblivion in the forthcoming election. So that's this
00:31:33 odd term, one nation. What I think, what I'm wanting to restore then
00:31:37 is the original Disraelian idea that one nation
00:31:41 isn't so much about being nice to the working class
00:31:45 or economic reform, though there's a little bit of that, you know,
00:31:49 Disraeli and the government in the 1870s, sanitas, sanitas,
00:31:53 omnia sanitas and all the rest of it
00:31:55 health, health, all is health
00:31:57 there's a little bit of that
00:31:58 what above all it is, it is the use of patriotism
00:32:02 it is the use of empire
00:32:04 it is the use of nationhood and nationalism
00:32:07 and a blaring assertion of these things
00:32:09 and ladies and gentlemen
00:32:10 I would suggest that Boris would be quite extraordinarily good at doing this
00:32:15 if only he would let himself go
00:32:17 so we've got then to derive from this period of the 19th century
00:32:22 this notion of the genuine meaning of one-nation conservatism, both in terms of its width of social
00:32:30 different groups within it and what the cement between those groups is. And again, it seems to
00:32:38 me we've spent far too much time worrying about the intricacies of policy and particularly social
00:32:46 policy. Yes, it's important. Yes, financial calculations are important. But isn't the
00:32:52 whole Brexit debate an absolute standing illustration of the fact that values are
00:32:58 central? And the reason that Remain lost so catastrophically was for the simple reason
00:33:04 that Cameron franchised his brain to George Osborne. And George Osborne had only been to
00:33:11 Paul's and all he could do was count and you had and you had you had this debate which was
00:33:18 fundamentally a debate about values which was then replied to simply in terms of cash so what we've
00:33:26 seen over the last two and a half years is debates two sides of the debate crossing like ships in
00:33:32 the night there they they are the perfect poles of Oscar Wilde's remark of those who know you know
00:33:37 the price of everything, the remainer, and the value of nothing. And it seems to me to illustrate
00:33:44 the point perfectly, whereas Disraeli is supremely the politician who understands value, who
00:33:52 understands the language of values and, as I said, the language of integration, of being in it
00:33:58 together, and so on. And what is, again, remarkable, it seems to me at the moment, is if you read the
00:34:05 Times today, which I take for granted everybody in the room did, you will see there's a very
00:34:10 remarkable article by Ruth Davidson pushing forward essentially this point and saying that
00:34:19 you have on the one hand an argument about nationhood in the assertion of independence
00:34:26 and self-government in, as it were, the British general, the English side of the general election,
00:34:32 And in Scotland, the wish to remain part of this nation because of union. And the two debates, she brings them together beautifully, and I think she gives a common ground between them, which again it would have seemed to have been extraordinarily easy to do, to connect the get Brexit done on the one hand with a much broader idea of a reassertion of nationhood and being in it together.
00:34:59 because what is it about if it's not that why do it why bother in other words to have a new
00:35:07 politics of somewhere and the other extraordinary aspect to disraeli that
00:35:14 is worth thinking about and this is where we get to the point of constitution
00:35:19 disraeli is the man i think who more than anybody else understands actually how parliamentary
00:35:26 government works and plays a fundamental part in both its deconstruction and its reconstruction.
00:35:34 As I'm sure we're all aware, the politics of the Tory party first begins to emerge under Sir Robert
00:35:42 Peel, with Sir Robert Peel's famous Tamworth Manifesto, which addresses the fundamental
00:35:48 question, and it seems to me to be one that we still need to debate if I'm saying that there's
00:35:53 an opposition between conservatism and liberalism. We then have to ask the question, most of us here
00:35:59 I imagine would put ourselves on the conservative side of the political spectrum, how do we relate
00:36:04 to the notion of reform? How do we relate to the notion of change? How is it to be handled?
00:36:12 Is there a particular logical way of looking at it? Is there a difference between liberal reform
00:36:18 and conservative reform. And I would argue that that's exactly what Disraeli works out
00:36:23 and what Peel fails to do. In the Tamworth Manifesto, the central section of it is Peel
00:36:29 saying, I accept the Reform Act of 1832, which created this new fundamentally urban liberal
00:36:38 electorate, which was profoundly hostile to the conservative party, and which is why Disraeli
00:36:44 only holds office seriously the very, very end of his career in the 1870s. It creates a world
00:36:51 which is deeply hostile to conservatism. Peel says, okay, I accept the Reform Act, but we can't
00:37:01 have continuous reform because otherwise, and he uses a phrase which is very reminiscent of the
00:37:07 charges which Burke made against the French Revolution, he uses a phrase that we will be
00:37:14 in a perpetual turmoil. If we have constant reform, we will be in a state of permanent turmoil and
00:37:21 distress, and there will be no foundation, which is absolutely true. But it then turned out, of
00:37:25 course, that his combination of supremely high intelligence, remember, Peel is the top in both
00:37:33 mathematics and grades in his year at Oxford. Can you imagine if we'd prime ministers like that?
00:37:38 He's a man of dazzling intelligence and with, of course, the corresponding arrogance, which I couldn't possibly comment on, that goes with dazzling brilliance.
00:37:49 and he turns out to be a natural reformer and he all things we all associate petty post and and
00:37:57 and and the police force and quite extraordinary series of transformations all culminating in the
00:38:03 repeal of the corn laws in 1846 the triumph of principled free trade and the triumph of liberal
00:38:10 opinion and disraeli splits the tory party on those grounds and can i gently point out ladies
00:38:17 and gentlemen, I've been talking all the time about how far this anticipates. This is exactly
00:38:22 the split that's taken place in the Tory party now. It is precisely the split on precisely that
00:38:30 issue. The Peelites are the equivalent of Grieve and all the rest of them. That's what they are.
00:38:37 And it's demonstrated by what happens to them. The supporters of Peel go on and they become the
00:38:45 intellectual basis of the new Liberal Party. And Disraeli is then left with the rump of the
00:38:50 Tory party having to come up with something different and create something different.
00:38:54 And he is profoundly aware that the world they move into after this split of the Tory party and
00:39:03 fragmentation of politics in the Commons is one which is profoundly unsympathetic to parliamentary
00:39:12 government. If you actually look in the middle years of the 19th century, there are a series of
00:39:18 short-lived governments. There's a tendency of a government to have to cabal a group of MPs
00:39:26 together on the floor of the House. In other words, there is something remarkably similar
00:39:30 to the situation that we found ourselves in for the last two and a half years.
00:39:36 what does Disraeli say? Disraeli says party, party, party. The only way parliamentary
00:39:47 government can work is by party. And there's no point, he says, you know, effectively there is no
00:39:54 point in adducing principle, there is no point in being like Peel and saying, you know, what I will
00:40:00 do is bend a party to my will to fulfill a matter of general principle that is not that will not
00:40:06 work that is which again is precisely what David Cameron tried to do and that you cannot do that
00:40:13 you have to rule with party and what we then see in the course of Disraeli's career is circumstances
00:40:21 time, he's a great believer in time, moving in his direction. And as I'm watching time move on
00:40:31 on my watch, also I will have to abbreviate a little of the political history of the 19th
00:40:36 century, wonderful though it is. By the time you've got to the 1860s, Disraeli realises that
00:40:42 there is a possibility of what he calls stealing the clothes of the Whigs. And what he does is he
00:40:49 broadens the franchise away from the prosperous liberal educated elite in the towns and he gives
00:40:57 it to the ordinary working man who and again this is very important is a householder he like
00:41:04 Thatcher understood what he talks about not homes or council houses he talks about dwellings he
00:41:11 understood that other sense of somewhere that sense of even if you don't own it most of them
00:41:17 didn't, but you actually have got secure rental, you're there, you are somewhere, you're in that
00:41:22 place, you belong, you are part of that community. And what Disraeli does with 1867 is to create the
00:41:31 basis of, as it were, to translate from that theory of the 1830s, the relationship between
00:41:37 the upper classes and the working classes, he turns it into a genuine electoral coalition.
00:41:45 and if what is supposed to be happening in this election
00:41:49 with the collapse of the Red Wall in the North and the Midlands happens
00:41:53 and at the same time the Tories' loss of significant
00:41:57 numbers of seats around London, we will have
00:42:00 a neo-Disraelian conservative party.
00:42:04 That's exactly what Boris will find himself in the shoes of
00:42:08 Disraeli and therefore having to deploy, I would argue, the same
00:42:13 techniques and all the rest of it, as Disraeli did. But what that triumph of quasi-democracy did,
00:42:21 and it's really important we understand this, what the triumph of in 1867 and between there
00:42:28 into the early 1870s. Disraeli cemented his position, of course, in his government in the
00:42:36 1870s by a passionate unleashing of the notion of empire. There'd obviously been a notion of
00:42:43 empire before it, but he's really the first to deploy the word consciously. Of course, the
00:42:48 creation of Victoria as Empress of India, but the general sense of, let's be frank, jingoism.
00:42:55 This is why Gladstone viewed Disraeli with the infinite contempt that he did, because Disraeli
00:43:02 understands values, I think, in a way which Gladstone doesn't. Gladstone is, of course,
00:43:09 he will trot out liberal pieties, but the things that touch people's souls seems to me to be just
00:43:16 what Disraeli was brilliant about. But alongside all that soul-touching and creation of new
00:43:21 electoral coalitions, what we have to understand, ladies and gentlemen, is that on the back of what
00:43:26 israeli did and an equal hardening in the shape of the liberal party you create modern democratic
00:43:34 party politics and it's really important that we understand what they were
00:43:40 to begin with you get the fixidity of parties you get all mps standing directly as the candidate
00:43:50 of one party or another. You get clear party manifestos, and in the House you get rigorous
00:43:58 whipping. Now, many of us tend to regard that as a bad thing, and if you want a sense of what this
00:44:05 new politics was like, can I suggest you look at the works of Gilbert and Sullivan. They're all
00:44:10 produced at this point. Iolanthe, particularly the magnificent song of Private Willis, a lot of dull
00:44:16 MPs in close proximity or thinking for themselves is what no
00:44:20 man can stand with equanimity. Every boy and every gal
00:44:24 that's born into the world alive is either a little liberal or else a little
00:44:28 conservative. This is the new world of
00:44:31 party politics.
00:44:36 They can't think for themselves, they vote just as their parties tell
00:44:40 them to. This is the new world. And ladies and gentlemen, the key
00:44:44 thing to understand about this new world is it is the only way in which a parliament can be made
00:44:50 answerable to the electorate. Every chatter about the independence of MPs and MPs as representatives
00:44:58 is saying your constituents don't matter. You can make up your mind on the key issues. And in other
00:45:08 words exactly the Dominic Grieve, the Bercow position of the last two and a half years and at
00:45:15 the same time that the cementation of political parties was taking place was also something else
00:45:21 that we heard a lot about but I think very few people actually understood, the creation of Erskine
00:45:26 May, the creation of the handbook of parliamentary procedure, Erskine May is the clerk, well he's the
00:45:32 junior clerk of the parliaments, the clerk of the parliaments is the clerk of the lords, he was the
00:45:36 junior clerk of the parliaments. He was the clerk of the commons in the 1870s and 1880s. And in this
00:45:42 period, you develop the other side that, as it were, cements government control of parliament,
00:45:48 which is the government's control of parliamentary procedure through Erskine May,
00:45:54 the precedence of government business. And ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to commit heresy for many
00:45:59 people. That is the only way a parliament can work. A parliamentary government can only work
00:46:07 with two parties. It cannot work with proportional representation. All over Europe now we are seeing
00:46:13 this phenomenon. Look at the number of elections in Spain. Look at the number of elections that
00:46:18 we're going through here. Parliamentary government depends, as Disraeli, with this brilliant
00:46:23 perception, said it depends upon party. And what, of course, the Brexit crisis, which undermined the
00:46:31 ideological basis of our traditional parties in the same way that the crisis of globalism
00:46:38 undermined the basis of their electoral coalitions, it suddenly stripped the veil of a hundred years
00:46:46 and dissolved the connection between representative democracy and direct democracy,
00:46:59 the sovereignty of the electorate, and the sovereignty of Parliament.
00:47:02 Because remember, ladies and gentlemen, there is a completely unfulfilled question.
00:47:07 What does parliamentary sovereignty mean?
00:47:09 is the actual parliament simply a bunch of people
00:47:13 who get up one morning and decide they will vote on something
00:47:16 will that bind everybody
00:47:19 and we found ourselves facing that reductio ad absurdum
00:47:23 it's impossible and it can't be justified
00:47:26 and of course you've got alongside that
00:47:28 all sorts of fantasticated nonsense
00:47:30 which has become legal doctrine
00:47:33 like the notion of separation of powers
00:47:35 which is utterly antithetical to the British Constitution.
00:47:40 There has never been a separation of powers in Britain.
00:47:43 You've all got the critic there.
00:47:45 The first article that I wrote for that
00:47:47 demonstrated where Montesquieu got this preposterous notion from.
00:47:51 It's, of course, a bad idea. It's French.
00:47:52 But where does he get it from?
00:47:54 Well, he spends two years in England, and he doesn't speak English.
00:47:58 And he moves in an entirely French-speaking circle,
00:48:01 and he gets the idea from a couple of preposterous pamphlets
00:48:05 by that strange marginal figure, Bolingbroke.
00:48:12 The idea of a separation of powers
00:48:14 never had any existence in reality in England.
00:48:18 The whole, what the great Horace Walpole did,
00:48:24 what the great Robert Walpole did,
00:48:26 Horace Walpole did lots of other things
00:48:28 that were much more amusing,
00:48:29 But what the great Robert Walpole did was to manage Parliament, was to use the power of the crown to manage Parliament.
00:48:40 That is why the British Parliament survives.
00:48:43 Most parliaments disappear because they fundamentally get in the way of good government, as we've actually seen abundantly in the last two and a half years.
00:48:52 So it's Disraeli, with this astonishing perception of the great changes of the 19th century, that creates a modern parliamentary system, that creates the necessary electoral coalition for conservatism, that supplies its necessary key ideological element, that understands the nature of the constitutional and procedural structures that underpin it.
00:49:16 And what I would invite you all to do, ladies and gentlemen, is to read Disraeli and try to persuade your MP to do the same.
00:49:24 Thank you very much.