New Culture Forum - December 23, 2021


Harry Miller on His Landmark Appeal Court Victory over Police Recording Trans Tweet as Hate Incident

What's Happened to Australia? Why Has Australia Reacted So Severely to Covid? Youthquake: Why Africa's Demographics Should Matter to the World

Episode Stats


Length

27 minutes

Words per minute

169.45

Word count

4,705

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hi, welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my guest
00:00:06 today is someone who's been on the show before, I think you'll be very familiar with his case.
00:00:11 Harry Miller, former policeman, was the gentleman who was approached by the police and asked to
00:00:18 check his thinking after he'd simply liked a few tweets. Well, here we are quite some
00:00:24 considerable time after that and we've just had a court of appeal ruling that was this week
00:00:32 delighted that harry's come in to talk to us about it thanks very much indeed harry thanks for having
00:00:38 me on the show pete it's always a pleasure what actually happened in the court of appeal what
00:00:43 was decided what was ruled okay so if you just take you back a little bit initially um i was
00:00:49 approached by Humberside Police because of some gender-critical tweets that I put
00:00:56 into this Twittersphere including I was assigned mammal at birth, I identify
00:01:02 as fish, don't miss pieces me, then I said a naughty little word and I asked
00:01:08 is transgender Remembrance Day a thing then like an actual one and I also
00:01:14 retweeted a piece of feminist doggerel which began your hormones are
00:01:22 synthetic your vagina goes nowhere so that so the police the police decided
00:01:27 that this was so egregious of me that without what they called necessary
00:01:33 intervention that I would follow the five-step approach to genocide and I'm
00:01:40 not I'm not making that up they said that by tweeting what I tweeted I was on step one on a
00:01:47 five-step journey which ended in genocide through through through assault you know through grievous
00:01:53 bodily harm through murder and eventually my tweets would lead to the socio-economic conditions
00:01:59 which led to Auschwitz now we what I said was that this is patently nonsense absolute rubbish
00:02:07 it can't possibly be the case anyway i then discovered the origin of of this which was the
00:02:13 the the hate crime guidance issued by the college of policing in 2014 which bound all chief constables
00:02:21 to follow up on non-crime hate incidents with the same degree of commitment as if they were
00:02:29 investigating a crime now what happened here is this we challenged humberside and said this is
00:02:37 irrational there's no possible way that left unfettered and unchallenged um i would spark
00:02:43 the next genocide it's just not it's just not feasible um he went to the we went to the high
00:02:48 court and mr justice julian knowles agreed and said that harry miller with the tweets that he
00:02:54 made wasn't even in the foothills of criminality and there was no chance whatsoever that anything
00:03:00 that harry miller had said could possibly escalate to criminality and therefore the judge ruled at
00:03:06 first instance in favor of me and liken homicide police to the charge to the to the stasi the
00:03:12 checker and the gestapo yeah but bizarrely at the same time he said whilst following the guidelines
00:03:19 as homicide did was illegal the guidelines themselves were legal now we thought that was
00:03:25 simply irrational illogical and could lead to an absolute disaster which had done in humbersides
00:03:32 case so we went back we appealed the decision and that went to the Court of Appeal it was heard
00:03:39 last March and we finally got the ruling yesterday and three senior judges including the I think the
00:03:46 third or fourth most powerful judge in the land they agreed unanimously that the mere recording
00:03:52 of a non-crime hate incident constituted an unacceptable interference in democracy
00:03:59 and served as an illegal chilling effect on free speech so in effect we won so that's how we ended
00:04:05 up at the at the court of appeal but the thing is that this is extraordinary victory isn't it
00:04:12 i mean i'm not you know in the sense that you know they are saying that actually what the
00:04:17 college of policing guidelines say is wrong and therefore you know they can't presumably be
00:04:23 applied anymore well that's the thing i mean the the college of policing god bless them um tweeted
00:04:27 yesterday i put out a statement yesterday um almost almost categorizing it as a victory
00:04:33 you know their their statement is quite bizarre it reminds me of chemical uh sorry comical alley
00:04:39 yes in baghdad pretending that the american troops weren't passing by in tanks behind him
00:04:45 that's that's precisely what it reminded me of and um because they seem to think that with a
00:04:50 little bit of a tweak here and there then their precious hate crime guidance uh and their non-crime
00:04:55 hate incidents will be able to be continued but that's simply not the case and the reason it's
00:05:00 not the case is this the non-crime hate incident is predicated on perception if someone perceives
00:05:07 it if you as as the the victim or any other person perceives something that i've said as being
00:05:15 rooted in hate against one of the five monitored strands then the police have no power whatsoever
00:05:22 to filter that claim out because the second you apply a rational or a reasonable or a common sense
00:05:29 filter to it it's no longer perception based you've added something else into the mix now
00:05:34 so far but thus far baked into the police guidance is this it talks about secondary victimization
00:05:42 and it warns the police they must not engage in secondary victimization now secondary victimization
00:05:47 is where the police go are you sure that's motivated by hate are you sure are you sure
00:05:53 that's bigotry is that not a little bit unreasonable the second a police officer does that they are
00:05:58 guilty of hate that is secondary victimization so the entire idea that you can just tweak the
00:06:05 guidelines and basically end up with the same thing is patent nonsense you can't you have to
00:06:14 you have to add rationality and reasonableness we used to call that you know evidence things
00:06:21 like evidence you've got to you've got to root the claim in some form of reality okay so that
00:06:27 is the check and the balance but the second you do that of course perception-based recording
00:06:32 no longer exists yeah so it's clearly clearly a massive massive victory i mean this morning when
00:06:38 I saw um how the college of policing had reacted I did I did send them a um a Kubler-Ross five
00:06:45 stages of grief uh theme and said look look guys you're in you're in step one denial but uh given
00:06:52 time you'll get over it so we'll we'll see if that one lands this has been a how long is the
00:07:00 whole the whole stretch of this been then actually it will be three years on the 23rd of January
00:07:05 right next year so i mean what is your what is your feeling at the moment i mean are you sort of
00:07:13 feeling elated or are you feeling anticlimactic or how do you feel i i'm certainly not anticlimactic
00:07:20 but not also not elated i think overall my emotion is one of i'm slightly tired
00:07:25 uh uh i'm pleased i'm quietly i'm quietly satisfied um but i'm certainly not i'm certainly
00:07:36 not elated what i am i'm i'm pleased for for the other 120 to 200 000 people who've managed to
00:07:44 ratchet up a non-crime hate incident against their name which will be sitting on databases
00:07:49 in police forces across the country now that now what needs to happen now is that they need to be
00:07:56 ripped up they need to be expunged entirely because this is how sinister it is as we've
00:08:02 talked about this before on the basis of no evidence whatsoever on the basis of a malicious
00:08:07 complaint or a political complaint all you have to do is cite i believe that person was motivated
00:08:15 by hatred and then you have a non-crime hate incident which names you as the suspect in the
00:08:20 offense of hate and that has been that is disclosable on an enhanced DBS for up to six years
00:08:28 that is that is quite frankly terrifying yeah I mean if that's not obviously wrong then there's
00:08:35 something wrong with you that really there has to be something wrong with you if you think that is
00:08:40 acceptable then your your natural home is the other side of the Berlin Wall pre-1989 you know
00:08:48 we don't want that sort of people that sort of person governing us or having any influence on
00:08:54 our lives whatsoever so yeah I feel I feel quietly happy I think I mean the thing is this has been
00:09:02 going on so long and when I was on your show the first time I talked about how at one point I was
00:09:07 so desperate i nearly sort of slung myself off the humber bridge um but you can't live with that
00:09:14 degree of emotion you can't keep it up for three years you can't live on on adrenaline so one way
00:09:20 or another i think i've learned to calm my emotions down and remain focused and positive
00:09:29 and really not not think too much about outcome think more about process and am i doing the right
00:09:35 thing and do the right people think I'm doing the right thing and are my motives correct and then
00:09:41 just pretty much thinking well what will be will be I'm not going to worry a huge amount about it
00:09:46 so when the result came in of course of course I was pleased I had a you know there's a little bit
00:09:52 of a tear in my glass eye type thing but I wasn't overly emotional and I wasn't overly emotional
00:09:58 about it yesterday it's like well great we've done that it's a major victory my concern now is how we
00:10:05 roll this out beyond police forces into hr departments because quite frankly it's people
00:10:12 who are in work who have real terror not of the police but of their hr managers who swallowed the
00:10:18 same pill they've been on the same course they signed up to stonewall they believe in in the
00:10:24 gingerbread theory of human nature um and they've got they've got the very real capacity to sack you
00:10:32 you know to put you in a position where you can't pay your mortgage or you know buy presents for
00:10:37 christmas these people terrify me but i think i think if it's the case that hr departments have
00:10:44 been looking at the police for inspiration and going where they lead well now that the police
00:10:49 have been given pause for thought and told that you are operating illegally with a bit of luck
00:10:54 my hope is that hr departments will will follow suit i mean how hopeful are you with that
00:11:02 well i mean i'm very hopeful because i think i think we lead by example i i gave an interview
00:11:08 yesterday i said what should our response be now and i said well our response should be this we
00:11:12 should go out and say what was unacceptable last week just go out and say it and i said don't go
00:11:18 out and target an individual don't harass somebody don't send them a malicious communication in the
00:11:24 name of free speech that's never what we were about but go out and say what last week you thought
00:11:30 was unsayable for me that's that's straight up i say trans women don't have penises you cannot
00:11:36 commit rape without a penis trans women are men um now a week ago saying that would have got me
00:11:46 yet another non-crime hate incident not any longer not any longer so whatever it is whatever
00:11:51 it is you want to say say it say it providing you're on the right side of the law say it because
00:11:59 if we don't use it we'll lose it peter so i think we have to do that i mean i i got into a lot of
00:12:06 trouble a year or so ago when in as a direct response to a police virtue signaling meme which
00:12:14 said we stand against hate in all its forms all its forms including misgendering people
00:12:21 you know pronoun policing all that stuff i responded with a hashtag um hate is a human
00:12:27 emotion like love and jealousy and it's got nothing to do with the police hashtag say yes to hate
00:12:33 and you should have seen the uproar the uproar that there was over that but i believe it i don't
00:12:38 regret it for a second hate is not in the purview of the police no well speaking of the police i
00:12:46 mean you know you said where do we go from from here we've had you've had this victory but how
00:12:53 do we get the police back to doing what the police should do for want of a better way of putting it
00:12:59 how do we get the police out of this kind of activity you're a former policeman you know
00:13:06 when i was on the assembly i was on the police and crime committee i came across it all the time
00:13:12 it seemed to me that the police had been sort of entirely captured really by a kind of woke
00:13:17 ideology and people say oh it's not the guys down on the beat as it were it's the i'm not so sure
00:13:23 about that anymore harry well i think it's right the way through the ranks but i think the vast
00:13:30 the vast majority of serving police officers who spend their diet their time investigating
00:13:35 in burglaries sorting out domestic violence going to accidents you know uh dealing with the very
00:13:40 worst of humanity and there's a lot of it in this country um they're entirely on our side but of
00:13:46 course to say so publicly they would find themselves at the wrong end of the disciplinary
00:13:51 and we know that because stonewall have written the guidelines uh you i've put in so many fois
00:13:57 for information about internal police policies and you look and typically it will it will start
00:14:03 off with um how terrible racism is racism this racism that homosexual you know homophobia terrible
00:14:09 terrible terrible and then before you know it it slipped into pronouns and gender and all the rest
00:14:15 of it so so this is policy by stealth yes and it's absolutely sent a chilling effect through
00:14:21 the rank and file of police officers so i i think it is fair to say that the majority of police
00:14:28 officers are on our side they're regular good human beings with with loads and loads of common
00:14:33 sense now one of the things that the college of policing have done is now they're now insisting
00:14:40 that only graduates are police officers now why would that why could that possibly be well i'll
00:14:47 tell you why it is it's because if you're a graduate you've learned how not to think you've
00:14:52 learned how to tick learning outcomes tick boxes and and play the game and the police want police
00:15:00 officers who know how to play the game who don't critically think who don't think for themselves
00:15:05 who simply do as they're told and follow process now when i spoke to the chief constable of
00:15:11 humberside that's what i was going to ask you this was quite something wasn't it when i spoke to the
00:15:15 chief constable of humberside and following my victory against him i said look look lovely that's
00:15:20 a good guy he's a really good guy's leave freeman the cops on cops on the street love him he's great
00:15:26 until he gets into things like politics and then he loses his mind as they all do so i said
00:15:32 i understand why pc gull an over-enthusiastic young copper came and and got it wrong and did
00:15:39 i need to check your thinking and all that nonsense i said but when the world's when the
00:15:43 world's press were focused on humberside why did somebody not apply some common sense and he said
00:15:49 to me he said harry you should know that common sense is not an appropriate tool for a police
00:15:54 officer because it leads to unpredictable outcomes and what we need is guidance i'm like
00:15:59 how can you possibly say that lee how can you possibly say that that common sense is not an
00:16:05 appropriate tool for a police officer now in britain in the united kingdom we operate under
00:16:11 common law we operate with the the state assumes that we are free we are three free to think say
00:16:19 and do right up until the point that the law specifically says now in other words our behavior
00:16:25 is predicated on an assumption of common sense yeah okay so if the police are of the people
00:16:32 then the the one quality you would expect from a police officer is that same common sense but what
00:16:39 the police have done under the guidance of the college of policing is adopt a much more european
00:16:44 napoleonic roman model yeah whereby the state gives us permission to do to say and to act and
00:16:52 that's a very very different model so for so for me i think the way the college of policing and
00:16:58 chief constables in turn have been acting is nothing short of of treasonous it's a betrayal
00:17:04 of everything that we as people who live in britain stand for and part of that came in
00:17:11 with the when the police act 2003 brought changed the oath of attestation so we went from um we went
00:17:19 from a police officer swearing to the queen to uphold the law and keep the queen's peace to
00:17:24 uphold the law keep the queen's peace and uphold human rights yes now why why suddenly bring in
00:17:30 human rights in addition to law surely surely a human right that has not been adopted into law
00:17:39 is a is a politically contentious issue otherwise it would have been adopted into law so this then
00:17:46 leaves the police in a position where they are genuinely genuinely confused because all it takes
00:17:51 is for amnesty or stonewall or black lives matter or whoever to say this is a human right yeah and
00:18:00 suddenly the police think well i swear to uphold human rights they're saying this is a human right
00:18:05 i've got to uphold it so what we need to do is get that out get that oath of oath of attestation
00:18:11 back to uh simply up keeping the queen's peace and um obeying the law upholding the law get rid
00:18:19 of this human rights nonsense it's not it's not the responsibility of the police also i think
00:18:24 actually you made a point i remember on last time you were on where where you said that in fact any
00:18:29 political statement by policemen of any sort is entirely in breach of what of their oath of
00:18:35 allegiance to the queen because they're meant to be neutral because they're doing it in her
00:18:39 the sovereign's name yeah exactly exactly so i i think i said that if you don't know what the
00:18:45 queen thinks about the subject we don't need to know what a police officer thinks about a subject
00:18:49 because the queen has been you know she's been um she's been great at political neutrality you
00:18:55 simply don't know it's been a lot more difficult in recent years with social media and capturing
00:19:00 things you know all that kind of stuff but in principle she is politically utterly vanilla
00:19:06 absolutely vanilla there's no way is she going to raise an lgbtq flag above above buckingham palace
00:19:12 she's not because she recognizes that it is a political symbol and and the police they take
00:19:19 the oath to the queen because they are expressing that same political neutrality and of course
00:19:25 it's baked into the code of ethics i think section section six where it says not only
00:19:30 should a police abstain from politics they should abstain from the appearance of being political
00:19:35 the appearance of it and the person the person who who is able to say what is what does or does
00:19:42 not constitute the appearance of politics is the ordinary person well not not the expert not the
00:19:48 academic no the ordinary the ordinary person the person as you say the the man or woman on the
00:19:54 clapham omnibus so like here and that's me yeah if you've got to abstain from even the appearance
00:20:01 of politics that one's been shot out the water hasn't it by the coppers taking the knee for
00:20:06 example that's that's the appearance of political yeah but they get that they're able to do it
00:20:12 because they know i also swore to uphold human rights and i i think this is a human rights issue
00:20:19 therefore i will take the knee so that's what i'm saying if you've got a human right that has not
00:20:24 been codified into law and it's gone through the democratic process and therefore we all agree or
00:20:30 a majority of us agree that this is this is correct we agree as a nation to abide by this
00:20:36 that's called the law and the police need to be upholding the law not contested human rights ever
00:20:43 ever ever if it's not in the law the police need to have nothing to do with it whatsoever whether
00:20:49 that's black lives matter whether that's um yeah pronouns whether that's a reform to the gr
00:20:55 to the gra whether it's marching with pride all of these things are political and you can't get
00:21:02 away with saying well it's a human right well i'm sorry but you are not the human rights police you
00:21:08 you should be the law police and the upholding the queen's peace police not the political police
00:21:15 and for me this victory yesterday when i came out and spoke to the press i said we've had stasi by
00:21:22 stealth and that's exactly what we've had and i think what i've done is just push that back
00:21:28 not just a little bit but quite a lot quite a lot actually quite a lot actually so for me next it's
00:21:35 getting that to that section of the 2003 police act repealed so we get back to policing without
00:21:41 properly policing without fear and favor and properly policing without political influence
00:21:46 i think we also need to be purging every police force of the insidious influence of of stonewall
00:21:52 and or any other pressure group uh that that has a political manifesto with stonewall they they
00:21:59 they have been sort of it seems to be like sliding down the other side of their peak if you like yeah
00:22:04 but not with the police though isn't that right well well it's difficult to tell them i mean a
00:22:08 number of police forces have openly now left uh the their champions diversity champions program
00:22:14 but interestingly stonewall wall have have locked down um their list of who is one of their champions
00:22:20 because people are leaving left right and centre but there are still a number of police forces who
00:22:25 are fully committed uh to the the stonewall agenda not least of which is the city of london police
00:22:31 merseyside police north yorkshire police who held a who held an intersectionality conference for
00:22:37 goodness sake in the summer where they were actively promoting uh critical race theory i
00:22:42 mean how political can you get that is not something that the police should be involved
00:22:47 with leicestershire police whilst they've got a fantastic pcc leicestershire police are taking
00:22:52 to the streets during pride marches carrying trans riot shields riot shields literally painted
00:22:59 in trans colors saying policing with pride you couldn't get more political than that it's wrong
00:23:05 and when you think back to the battle of orgrieve what what what riot shields signified in the battle
00:23:10 of orgrieve they are terrifying to the working classes yeah yeah terrifying and and and it they
00:23:17 they have become riot shields are synonymous with politics and policing due to that that that
00:23:21 particular battle and it's entirely wrong when the police take a riot shield paint it with the
00:23:28 political colors and then step back and say we're doing it in the name of human rights it's not
00:23:31 political well it's political uh you said you would you campaign you'd want to get rid of this
00:23:38 particular part of the law you know that you mentioned in the act but also um what about
00:23:44 the subjectivity aspect that's gone into the law now isn't that that's a hard one but what we're
00:23:51 talking about as you just mentioned there is this subjectivity this perception thing which now is in
00:23:57 the law um so not to require evidence there's no requirement of evidence uh that in a way is
00:24:05 the root of a lot of this isn't it we've got to get that out of the law again yeah it's it's a
00:24:12 post-modernism gone awry isn't it yeah i mean i i i'm all for taking someone's perception of
00:24:19 something as part of the equation you know how you feel about something has got some value but
00:24:26 it doesn't tell the whole story because your perception quite frankly might be entirely wrong
00:24:30 so whilst it is correct that we listen to your perception that cannot that cannot be the
00:24:37 dictating factor when it comes to law or policy or policing it simply can't it's one more factor
00:24:43 to think about the entire language around non-crime hate incidents is predicated on the
00:24:50 immediate assumption that you because you felt offended are a victim and me because i offended
00:24:56 you i'm a suspect that sort of language it simply has to go it cannot possibly stand and it's not
00:25:03 the job of the police to believe anybody it's the job of the police to listen to people's stories
00:25:09 and then go out and find evidence to support that story belief should play no part in whatsoever none
00:25:16 well look harry i mean many congratulations again you know for it and uh i think it's a long hard
00:25:25 slog but i mean you've you know you've given us a great uh model how to do it i think very
00:25:33 courageous of you um thank you um and uh we shall see you again i think i know we will actually
00:25:41 because i think this isn't going to end is it we're going to have many other things yeah yeah
00:25:47 you know activism is not for everybody peter because i think um i think um who was it yesterday
00:25:53 they call me bloody i've got the healthy degree of bloody mindedness um and somebody else said
00:25:58 that i'm an immovable object well not everybody is are they but those of us who are bloody minded
00:26:03 enough and immovable enough and um like that fear gene i think it's uh incumbent upon us to
00:26:10 make a stand for everybody else yeah and i think the thing is as well with the sort of
00:26:15 issues that we talk about a lot on this channel this is a very very nice piece of good news to
00:26:20 to which we end in the year.
00:26:21 Yeah, yeah, to America.
00:26:23 Thank you.
00:26:25 That's it this time.
00:26:26 And we shall see you next time, I hope.
00:26:29 Okay, take care.
00:26:30 Thank you.
00:26:31 Hello.
00:26:32 If you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel
00:26:34 and you believe in our mission,
00:26:37 may I invite you to join our membership scheme
00:26:40 at the link below or on our website,
00:26:44 newcultureforum.org.uk.
00:26:46 Our work is more important now than ever,
00:26:49 and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without your support. From as little
00:26:55 as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member
00:27:01 you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content, invitations to our
00:27:08 private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
00:27:15 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then
00:27:22 please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely
00:27:28 free, just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new
00:27:36 videos. Thank you.