New Culture Forum - December 13, 2021


What's Happened to Australia? Why Has Australia Reacted So Severely to Covid?

Neil Oliver: "The Attack on Our History & Culture". The New Culture Forum's 2021 Smith Lecture Harry Miller on His Landmark Appeal Court Victory over Police Recording Trans Tweet as Hate Incident

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

165.02

Word count

8,671

Sentence count

193


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying, I'm Peter Whittle. Now throughout this pandemic many
00:00:25 of us have been extremely well bewildered and disturbed by some of the images coming out of
00:00:30 Australia and how Australia seemingly seems to have dealt with the pandemic. So I'm very pleased
00:00:37 that today we have with us someone who knows Australia very well, she's indeed Australian,
00:00:43 Helen Dale who now lives in England is an award-winning novelist, journalist and indeed lawyer.
00:00:51 um thank you very much for coming hello peter how are you i'm very pleased to be here
00:00:57 it's great to have um before actually we go and talk about Australia actually and i just want to
00:01:02 we're recording this on a friday this week they brought in these new restrictions this plan b
00:01:09 thing will you be going along with plan b in a sense that it's not really difficult for me
00:01:16 to go along with Plan B because I'm one of these people that's able to work from home
00:01:21 and they haven't extended it to hospitality.
00:01:25 So you don't have the mask wearing or any of those kind of issues.
00:01:31 So it's kind of, it's one of those, it's a theoretical question for me.
00:01:36 So whenever I've commented on COVID regulations of whatever sort,
00:01:41 I've always had to be conscious of the fact that I am one of those people
00:01:45 who throughout COVID has had a relatively easy life.
00:01:48 The only impost on me has been not being able to travel.
00:01:53 The last time I went overseas was in January, February 2020,
00:01:58 and my partner and I were actually in South Africa.
00:02:01 Right, really.
00:02:01 So we haven't travelled this year, and that has been annoying.
00:02:05 We booked a trip to Israel.
00:02:06 We thought we would get a nice sunny holiday in Israel,
00:02:09 and Israel shut the borders,
00:02:11 and we had to cancel the trip that we were going to go to Israel.
00:02:14 so but where where sort of are you on the broad spectrum of opinion about all of this i mean
00:02:21 you know do you are you anti-vaxing passports for example or you know i mean how where do you sit
00:02:30 on the line as it were when a lot of the restrictions first started coming in to the
00:02:38 lockdowns and particularly the lockdowns that's the thing i found particularly alarming
00:02:43 precisely because many people like me with my advantages and yeah being a professional member
00:02:53 of the upper middle classes who could work from home that kind of thing I was acutely aware that
00:02:58 I lived in this nice house in the countryside with a big garden and I saw people like me
00:03:04 criticizing I wrote the one I really remember is criticizing Londoners in tiny flats
00:03:11 for going to the park and lying in the sun oh yeah so what i found really alarming about
00:03:18 the pandemic restrictions originally was the blindness of people who can have an easy life
00:03:24 during lockdown to to those people who can't have an easy life so that was the first thing
00:03:31 And then the second thing is the opposition that I had to the rules that were developed around the management of the pandemic were not based on scientific arguments.
00:03:47 And I think the lockdown sceptics of various sorts made a mistake when they tried to turn the debate into science against science.
00:03:55 So you had the government scientists and you had the group of heterodox scientists say, but they all were scientists and in some cases they would agree.
00:04:04 I didn't enter into that apart from very occasionally getting really cross with journalists not being able to be numerate about things.
00:04:12 So we get basic mathematical and statistical things wrong.
00:04:15 I used to be a corporate solicitor and one area of the profession that does mean lawyers have a reputation for working with words, which is fair enough.
00:04:25 But one branch of the profession where you do actually have to be very numerate and good at doing calculations in your head and that kind of thing is corporate finance and corporate law.
00:04:34 That's where I used to work.
00:04:36 And so I got very cross about that at times.
00:04:39 And I did start to get news outlets writing to me saying, can you write a piece on epidemiology?
00:04:44 And I would finish up having to say, I can comment on the maths because that's what I can do.
00:04:50 But I can't comment on the biology or the genetics because I stopped doing biology at O level.
00:04:55 I didn't even do an A-level in it. I did an A-level in maths, so it's kind of consistent
00:05:01 with someone who's good at maths. So my opposition to it was the problem with the lack of parliamentary
00:05:08 scrutiny and the attacks on civil liberties. And I spoke a number of times to a number of
00:05:14 media outlets along those lines, but I would not venture into the science aspect of it
00:05:20 because I'm a what's known as an ethical pluralist.
00:05:24 So I don't think it's possible to rank all values on a single scale.
00:05:29 I think there are opposed sets of values that are equally valuable.
00:05:34 And the approach that you will take to ordering civil society will be based on how on which sets of values you think are most important to you.
00:05:43 And to me, as you would expect from someone who is a lawyer who has worked for a parliamentarian in Australia with a strong commitment to civil liberties himself, Senator Lionhelm, before he was elected to parliament, one of the things he was known for, for example, was being a conscientious objector to the Vietnam War.
00:06:00 So I was coming out of that tradition. And so when I articulated criticism, it was based on civil liberties, not on science.
00:06:07 I think it is possible both for someone who's very pro-science to reject a civil liberties argument because their value structure is different.
00:06:16 And I also think that goes in the other direction.
00:06:18 It's possible for someone who's got a strong commitment to civil liberties to reject a scientific argument on the basis that they think civil liberties are more important.
00:06:25 and i don't think you can rank those two things on a common scale it's not something that's
00:06:31 amenable to trade-offs it's interesting though that actually i see your point but what's
00:06:36 interesting at least in britain uh i know you've you felt this is that the sort of people who
00:06:41 would usually be very keen to talk about civil liberties uh like liberty itself you know are
00:06:49 noticeable by their absence they've almost said nothing about this the the people who seem to be
00:06:55 most worried about civil liberties are people broadly speaking on the conservative side of
00:07:01 things, you know, broadly speaking. But in fact, the people who generally talk about human rights
00:07:06 and civil liberties have been noticeable by their absence. I think part of that is to do
00:07:12 with the fact that a lot of contemporary human rights organisations, they do human rights,
00:07:20 they don't do civil liberties those things are not the same and the reason they're not the same
00:07:25 is it comes from back to the point about moral ranking when i talked about being an ethical
00:07:30 pluralist i am drawing on ideas developed by isaiah berlin and isaiah berlin was the one who
00:07:38 pointed out that there are different forms of liberty and the tories who have been in favor of
00:07:45 civil liberties assembly and speech and so on and so forth are making arguments in favour of negative
00:07:53 liberties, which are the traditional removal of restraint style of liberties. Whereas the human
00:08:00 rights organisations have been, I believe, compromised by a belief in positive liberties.
00:08:06 So you get a right to health care or a right to self, you get self-expression rights, like to go
00:08:15 on a pride march or so on and so forth so it's not just the negative right that homosexuality
00:08:20 for example should be decriminalized it's a positive right to express it in public as well
00:08:24 yeah and i actually think in many respects human rights and civil liberties because so much
00:08:31 of the human rights space has been colonized by positive rights that really are you can have this
00:08:39 You can have that. You should have these things that you finish up with them being an Isaiah Berlin, actually, when he wrote his original famous essay, Two Concepts of Liberty, he said that these two are going to come into conflict.
00:08:51 If you have too many of the positive rights, they're going to come into conflict because in order for people to say have a human right to health care, you finish up starting to instruct people to live in a particular way.
00:09:03 and we're familiar with this historically because of the anti-smoking and anti-obesity and sugar
00:09:09 tax and that kind of thing and that just looks silly and trivial and so on and so forth but you
00:09:13 can it's quite possible to ramp that up significantly so you finish up with things
00:09:20 like lockdowns and then at the at the extreme compulsory medical procedures which is well
00:09:26 what we're possibly facing yeah compulsory vaccination which is what you've started to
00:09:29 in European countries and certainly in China, the more authoritarian countries.
00:09:34 Authoritarian countries. Right. Now, I've never been to Australia.
00:09:38 I should add, by the way, as you mentioned, you live here, don't you? You moved here in...
00:09:43 Well, I've been back and forth between Australia and the UK since I was four.
00:09:46 Right. So I'm a dual national. My father was Scottish, my mother was Irish.
00:09:51 I was born in Australia but I have always had lifelong connections in both directions I went
00:10:01 to university in Australia my classics degree there but I also went to university here I did
00:10:05 my law degree in Oxford so I am as deeply rooted in both cases as it is possible to be right well
00:10:15 therefore your perspective will be particularly important to us I look out having never been to
00:10:21 Australia, but I have an image of it, of being rugged individualism and also no
00:10:27 nonsense. These are possible cliches that have gone with the same ways they met
00:10:33 in average, I don't know. But it has been so surprising of all countries to see
00:10:40 the kind of things that seem to have been happening with civil liberties and
00:10:44 and the police or whatever in Australia.
00:10:47 Now, does it surprise you at all?
00:10:52 I mean, am I wrong to feel this?
00:10:54 Or do you see that actually this is exactly
00:10:57 the way Australia would deal with this?
00:11:00 It's possible to be surprised by some aspects
00:11:03 of the Australian response, but not by very many of them.
00:11:09 Australia is a very distinctive polity.
00:11:13 It has a very unusual approach to politics
00:11:17 and a very unusual approach to civil society
00:11:20 and to governance.
00:11:22 That doesn't mean that it's so weird
00:11:23 that it's more like China than Britain.
00:11:26 It is obviously more like Britain
00:11:27 and it's not just the English language,
00:11:29 but it is a very unusual country.
00:11:31 And to be fair, many Australians,
00:11:34 even when they first go overseas,
00:11:36 don't realize how different their country is
00:11:39 until they've spent quite a bit of time overseas.
00:11:43 I mean, I started to experience it as a teenager.
00:11:45 I realised actually,
00:11:47 now other countries are very different from Australia.
00:11:48 They do things very, very differently.
00:11:50 They value different things.
00:11:52 I wrote a long piece at the end of 2020
00:11:56 for Standpoint magazine,
00:11:58 which was both praising some Australian qualities,
00:12:03 but also an attempt to provide a warning to people.
00:12:07 And so I was saying to those Americans
00:12:09 who want to copy Australia's gun laws,
00:12:11 or to those British people
00:12:12 who want to copy Australia's immigration policy,
00:12:16 or to many countries all over the world
00:12:17 that want to copy the Australian healthcare system.
00:12:20 All of these things are good things.
00:12:22 They have, you know, the country is extremely well governed
00:12:27 and it's also a shock to the system
00:12:30 if you've come out of a particular political tradition
00:12:33 that says, for example,
00:12:34 oh, you can't centrally plan an immigration policy.
00:12:37 Well, Australia can and does and has done since 1991, and it's the most successful immigration policy in the world.
00:12:43 So you can take your Hayek and his knowledge problem and you can stick it where the sun don't shine, to use an Australian expression.
00:12:48 Yes, Australians are no nonsense. They will be like that.
00:12:51 So it's a very unideological approach to governance, but it's not that third wayism of Tony Blair.
00:12:58 It is just this brutal kind of pragmatism.
00:13:01 The poet A.D. Hope described it as the people who live in Australia are the people who will inhabit the dying earth.
00:13:06 you know they are the last people who will be alive basically everyone else will have died but
00:13:10 the australians will still be there because they're survivors along with share of course
00:13:14 okay that's good i'll pay that one so these are good things you can have that idea in your head
00:13:23 if you're joe biden and you're horrified about school shooters if you're pretty patel and you're
00:13:26 horrified about migrants uh coming across in the channel in small boats uh if you're horrified about
00:13:32 both the nhs and the american health care system you could you could look at the aussie thing and
00:13:36 say these are good things to have but there's a price to pay if you want those good things
00:13:42 you may have to and this is the warning i tried to sound in my standpoint piece which is available
00:13:48 for free you can just go on their website and search my name and you'll find the article yeah
00:13:52 it's called emulate australia question mark and you may have to give up things that you find
00:14:01 in your own culture in order to do the things that Australia does
00:14:06 that you find very precious.
00:14:10 And I have tried to warn people to get this across to people
00:14:15 without criticising Australia's remarkable achievements,
00:14:19 but also to point out to them that it is a very distinctive country
00:14:24 with a very distinctive culture.
00:14:27 And there are some things you would have to do.
00:14:30 for example the the american electoral system would have to be completely replaced
00:14:38 and rebuilt from the ground up probably with australian advisors in order to reproduce
00:14:45 some of the qualities that the likes of barrett across the spectrum everyone from you had barrick
00:14:50 obama praising the health care system you had donald trump praising the immigration system you've
00:14:55 You've got Joe Biden praising the gun laws.
00:14:59 So, for example, in Australia, voting is compulsory.
00:15:05 Civic education is compulsory.
00:15:08 It uses compulsory preferential, what the Americans call instant runoff,
00:15:13 and what here is called the alternative vote.
00:15:15 But it's compulsory alternative vote.
00:15:16 You have to number all the boxes.
00:15:18 And everyone is compelled to the polls.
00:15:21 If you don't go to the polls, you are fined.
00:15:23 so it drags the australian political system to the center and i don't mean center in the terms
00:15:31 of boring centrist i mean center in that you cannot produce a situation where for example
00:15:37 working class voters who are hostile to immigration as we saw in the brexit vote here
00:15:43 are just systematically ignored because if you do that in australia will rip the base out from
00:15:47 underneath of one of the major political parties.
00:15:50 So in many respects, the Aussie system has roots in compulsory voting.
00:15:56 Not only is it compulsory voting, redistribution,
00:16:00 all the fights in America over redistricting,
00:16:02 and you finish up with electoral systems that are sort of roughly shaped
00:16:06 like a spiral or a banana to try and get all the Democrats in one seat
00:16:11 and all the Republicans in another.
00:16:12 And there's trade-offs between the two.
00:16:14 Both parties are equally guilty of this.
00:16:16 They're all impartially decided in Australia, basically by algorithm.
00:16:23 And before every election, you finish up with the same number of people and any kind of electoral apportionment is structured in such a way that it is impossible to favour one side or another.
00:16:34 It's impossible to have a gerrymander at the federal level.
00:16:37 It used to be possible at the state level.
00:16:39 I experienced this growing up in Queensland, but it is no longer.
00:16:43 you tell an american by the way all the horse trading over congressional districts give it up
00:16:51 you have to give it up all your voting laws that you have about you know whether it's voter id or
00:16:58 getting people out to vote or so on and so forth you have to give them all up you have to have
00:17:02 compulsory registration you know the electoral commission comes around to australian high schools
00:17:05 and registers all the students when they're 16 and 17 so that as soon as they turn 18
00:17:12 they're flagged as a voter so it involves thinking about politics and that's just one tiny area
00:17:21 there are many many other areas as well and you notice it's based on compulsion
00:17:26 Australia doesn't have a pensions crisis nearly every other western developed country does it
00:17:34 has a system known as superannuation it has had its 1991 compulsory saving when you work
00:17:42 right but you see the compulsion again it's this australians work out a good way to do something
00:17:48 and they think oh everybody should have that but people are too stupid
00:17:52 to necessarily choose that's all choose for them so it's a form of forced choosing
00:17:57 this is profoundly profoundly different from any other political tradition and if you look
00:18:06 at the australian constitutional debates which i acknowledge many australians are not familiar with
00:18:11 the 19th century constitutional debates but lawyers typically are I mean I was taught them
00:18:17 you know you learn about them you study constitutional law in Australia because
00:18:21 it has a written entrenched constitutional document like the Americans do with no human
00:18:25 rights in it and there you go the only state in Australia with entrenched human rights in a form
00:18:32 that would make sense to either an American or to someone from the European Union with the ECHR
00:18:37 is Victoria and that has been the state with the worst human rights abuses or the worst civil
00:18:43 liberties abuses I'll correct myself there because human rights and civil liberties are in certain
00:18:48 respects contraindicated and I think that it is probably only possible to guarantee
00:18:56 civil liberties I'm not sure you can guarantee human rights and I'm put in mind of some comments
00:19:03 made by my jurisprudence tutor at Oxford is Professor John Gardner. And he said, universal
00:19:09 health care is a good thing to have. Don't pretend that it's not. But also, is it a right?
00:19:16 Are you elevating to the status of rights, things that are simply good things to have?
00:19:22 And that has been why you've had your human rights organisations basically looking everywhere
00:19:27 and looking under their armpit and not doing anything in the face of, say, lockdowns. That's
00:19:32 the most obvious thing i think is is it that's fascinating this compulsion culture uh it sort of
00:19:40 sort of goes hand in hand with conformity maybe does it i you know uh in a way i'm just wondering
00:19:46 because when you see for example and i know it's different to when you go to different territories
00:19:51 in australia but when you see the way that the police have behaved for example um and it seems
00:19:57 to have public backing on the whole does it not i mean despite the demonstration is that an
00:20:03 expression of what you're what you're talking about australian policing is distinctively
00:20:08 authoritarian uh the police in australia are closer to the gendarmerie in france than they
00:20:16 are to the bobby on the beat here uh i think that is an obvious thing to say and i've attempted to
00:20:22 explain this previously to other media outlets, and I shall try here. There has been a long history
00:20:29 in Australia of very authoritarian policing, going back before Federation. Federation was when all
00:20:35 the states joined together to become the one country in 1901. But before that, there was the
00:20:40 state of, colony of Queensland, the colony of New South Wales, colony of South Australia, and so on.
00:20:46 And colony of Van Diemen's land, which then became Tasmania, that kind of thing. There has been a
00:20:52 long history of very authoritarian policing and there were even things that you tend to associate
00:20:58 with South America now like really quite nasty conflicts between civil society and the police
00:21:05 and something that almost approached what we would consider to be a military coup if you look
00:21:10 at what happened to Governor Bly yes Bly as in mutiny on the bounty I'm not going to go into all
00:21:16 the history here but it's well worth just sit on go to Wikipedia or something like that and look up
00:21:21 what happened to Governor Bly and you will see the very famous picture of the New South Wales
00:21:25 Corps because Governor Bly hid under his bed in the governor's mansion being hauled out from under
00:21:30 his bed by members of the New South Wales Corps in an incident known as the Rum Rebellion where
00:21:35 rum had become a currency in the colony so this very authoritarian policing has deep roots
00:21:42 and the funny line that is being used misattributed to Clive James he didn't actually say it
00:21:50 But it is generally acknowledged that Peter Ustinov said a version of it, but I have heard it ever since I was a little girl from my dad, is always remember that Australians are not only the descendants of convicts, they're also the descendants of their jailers.
00:22:06 So this long history of very authoritarian policing and sometimes too, I experienced this as a girl growing up in Queensland, a very corrupt policing.
00:22:17 Lots and lots of brown paper bags.
00:22:19 lots and lots of money changing hands and association and corruption in the context of
00:22:27 prostitution and gambling one of the reasons why australia was one of the first countries in the
00:22:33 world to go down the path of decriminalization with prostitution was precisely to take it out
00:22:38 of the hands of the police because the police were as bent as bobby pins and you can get you
00:22:43 can once again read it on the internet but it goes back to the 70s and 80s you can read the
00:22:47 report of the Wood Royal Commission into the New South Wales police force, which was famously and
00:22:53 notoriously described as a joke as the best police force that money could buy because of this
00:22:59 cultural tradition. Now, it is generally acknowledged that the most authoritarian
00:23:07 police force in Australia now is Victoria Police. And it took over from the Queensland police who
00:23:14 were cleaned up, less authoritarian now. And that is why the worst stuff you've seen in terms of
00:23:22 reporting over here, including the incident with the rubber bullets, has occurred in Victoria.
00:23:28 In the context of the COVID pandemic, Victoria has also had the worst outcomes of any Australian
00:23:37 state and and the longest lockdowns it's so extreme that victoria at one point had something
00:23:45 like 230 odd days of continuous lockdown while queensland had had three days in total so there
00:23:52 are huge variations between the individual states because that's another thing i don't know whether
00:23:57 you have any american viewers like like people so americans will get this better than british
00:24:04 people who are unitary state australia is a federal system and there is considerable divergence
00:24:08 between the states so you could have a state in australia south australia was like this for
00:24:14 example that was kind of like florida and nothing was locked down and it was very liberal and so on
00:24:19 and so forth and then you could have a state like victoria where the capital city melbourne
00:24:23 actually had the longest period of continuous lockdown in the developed world and those states
00:24:29 abut each other victoria and south australia share a border so it gives you an idea within one
00:24:35 country you can get this incredible divergence but just for if you're an american imagine if
00:24:40 florida and california were next to each other rather than separated by a continent exactly or
00:24:47 or new york indeed the big cities are much more it's also the northern territory as well that's
00:24:53 pretty harsh isn't it when it comes to it hasn't now the thing is where these confinement comes on
00:25:00 the thing in in the northern territory is it's territory not a state so constitutionally it has
00:25:05 less power over its own affairs than the states do and this is worked out this arrangement is worked
00:25:11 out in the constitution so the northern territory in the australian capital territory are the two
00:25:15 territories the main thing in terms of representation is they only get two senators each whereas the
00:25:20 other states get 12 each in the parliament in the federal parliament is that down to population
00:25:26 it's a mainly population but there are a few other little indicia as well which i won't go into
00:25:32 because they'll just bore you but so the northern territory the main claim to fame of the northern
00:25:37 territory is that it has the largest as a proportion of the state's population number
00:25:46 of aboriginal people who are the indigenous people of australia and they are very very distinctive
00:25:53 aborigines are really really distinctive even though in the context of forager civilizations
00:25:58 all over the world aborigines are really really unusual it's generally acknowledged that they've
00:26:03 been in australia for about 40 000 years give or take um the culture is very unusual it's not
00:26:11 unified they speak many different languages they're not like the maori in new zealand
00:26:15 And when the British went to New Zealand, they discovered the Māori.
00:26:19 One of the reasons why the Māori provided such an effective resistance during the Māori Wars is they all spoke the same language.
00:26:26 It was all mutually intelligible and they were very, very organised.
00:26:29 Aborigines, there are hundreds of languages, all these small tribal groups in a very harsh environment.
00:26:35 and so what the northern territory has done and i'm not going to excuse it here because i
00:26:43 think that there has been overreach and the young woman who was interviewed on unheard
00:26:50 who was basically locked up because she told a lie so she was effectively imprisoned without a trial
00:26:57 that's egregious she was the expression that's used in australia is that she was verbaled by
00:27:02 police here so painted into a corner and and finished up being locked up in howard springs
00:27:06 that's egregious you can't excuse that but the panic in the northern territory is born of the
00:27:13 terrible fear that if coronavirus gets into the remote aboriginal communities it will have a
00:27:18 catastrophic effect and i probably need to explain a little bit of genetics here many educated
00:27:24 americans and british people are familiar with the colombian exchange which the shorthand is
00:27:31 we gave the native americans both north and south america smallpox and they gave us syphilis
00:27:39 this was not a good experience for people on either side but while syphilis makes you very
00:27:43 sick smallpox kills you and so it had an awful effect on those populations however colds and
00:27:50 flu coronavirus and influenza were already endemic in those populations when european
00:27:56 colonists went to Australia not only did the Aborigines have no experience of smallpox
00:28:03 there was no colds or flu there either and often you get people ask why didn't the Aborigines
00:28:12 resist so effectively the Maori nearly beat Whitey you know in New Zealand and a big part of the
00:28:19 reason it's not the only part I mean the the fact that they didn't speak mutually intelligible
00:28:23 languages is part of this as well but a big part of it is because all the battles against the
00:28:29 aborigines weren't won by the colonists they were won by general coronavirus and general influenza
00:28:35 and that memory is very strong in the aboriginal communities it was then repeated in 1918 and 1919
00:28:46 the aboriginal people their populations had just started to recover from settlement basically
00:28:53 what happens when half of you get wiped out and then they were flattened again by Spanish flu
00:29:00 and that is seared into the country's memory it was a disaster and whilst there was a lot of
00:29:07 racism in Australia in 1918 as there was in lots of other countries nobody on any side of politics
00:29:14 or out of any particular background wanted to see the Aboriginal people die out so Australians
00:29:22 were horrified at what Spanish flu did to the Aboriginal populations so that panicked and very
00:29:29 authoritarian response in the Northern Territory is a combination of the country's political history
00:29:35 and policing history that is an element of that that is true as I was describing earlier but it's
00:29:40 also terrible panicked fear that once again the colonial the original colonial power will screw
00:29:49 it up when it comes to the indigenous population and lead finish up with vast numbers of them dying
00:29:55 because even though modern aborigines are the descendants of people who survived colds and flu
00:30:01 they've only got 230 years of that they don't have thousands upon thousands perhaps even tens
00:30:10 of thousands of years like europeans and east asians do who are the majority of the rest of
00:30:15 the Aussie population in terms of building up genetic resistance and biological resistance
00:30:21 to colds and flu. So if you understand all of that I mean extremely vivid portrayal of the
00:30:31 of the background then I suppose it means you are quite understanding as to why Australia
00:30:38 has reacted to the way it has. I understand it but I see why it's alarming. Does that make sense?
00:30:45 I completely understand. I mean, and I see why that video, the interview with the young woman who's originally from Victoria and moved to another part of the country to get away from Victoria's long lockdown.
00:30:55 And she was in Melbourne, which is where they were very bad. I completely understand why someone would do that.
00:31:01 And her alarm and distress. I mean, I saw as a as a young woman and as a teenager, the behaviour of the Queensland police and they astonishingly authoritarian behaviour.
00:31:14 I've had the experience of being arrested on an illegal pride march.
00:31:19 It was not fun.
00:31:20 I'll just leave it there.
00:31:21 Okay.
00:31:23 What happened to you?
00:31:24 Well, basically, everybody was arrested and we were all strip searched.
00:31:28 Right.
00:31:28 Yeah.
00:31:29 This is in the days of Joe Bjorka-Peterson when he was the premier.
00:31:33 He was a shocker for this.
00:31:34 Very, very authoritarian government.
00:31:37 Queensland, you know, the chant that people, when I was a girl, would be Queensland police state demand the right to demonstrate.
00:31:48 Queensland police state demand the right to demonstrate.
00:31:51 Because at one point there was legislation that if you gathered in more than a group of three, the police could come and break you up.
00:31:58 and there was this awful awful joke that went around at about that time that if you got three
00:32:05 victorians together they'd talk about the football if you got three south australians together they
00:32:12 would form a modern family because they had a gay premier at the time this is what i mean about state
00:32:15 differences if you got three tasmanians together they were all related um if you got three west
00:32:22 australians together you'd have an international business corporation because of all the iron ore
00:32:26 and the jokes about yeah and there were jokes about the other states but the ones for the
00:32:30 northern territory in queensland were vicious if you get three queenslanders together they'll get
00:32:34 arrested and if you get three northern territorians together they'll blame it on the bloody dingo
00:32:38 and i think even here people will get the dingo joke yeah yeah that these are the it's a shorthand
00:32:46 way of describing the differences between the states um so i understand where the northern
00:32:53 territory government is coming from but i still find it alarming and it is a shock to foreigners
00:33:00 who've had this idea in their head including for part of the pandemic where basically hardly anyone
00:33:06 in australia died and even by comparison with the rest of the world probably australia has had the
00:33:11 most successful pandemic response even victoria the worst performing australian state is substantially
00:33:18 better than nearly everybody else in in the world and other states where like one person's died all
00:33:23 that kind of thing and so people can look at this country and go gee it's well run isn't it nice
00:33:31 isn't it clean people go there and think oh it's so clean it's so nice and everything works and so
00:33:36 on and so forth but there is that the price you pay for getting all the trains to run on time
00:33:42 yeah is this very orderly form-filling compliant i'm not so much compliant as conformist
00:33:51 there is an australian expression that has got there are several of them that have gone global
00:33:57 i've i've talked yeah i finished up talking on one outlet about dead cats you know plan b is to
00:34:05 distract from boris's flat and from parties in number 10 that's right amongst the great and the
00:34:11 good and so they've introduced plan b and the australian joke is plan b is the dead cat you
00:34:18 throw on the table it's to stop people talking about the embarrassing thing to the government
00:34:23 so that they can say because everyone's running around like a mad thing going look there's a dead
00:34:29 cat on the table now that's from australian politics now that's one hell of a dead cat
00:34:34 it's a huge dead cat yes it's a main coon it takes up the whole table it's massive
00:34:38 now the other expression that started in australia but has now become global i think
00:34:44 even americans will have heard of this is the tall poppy syndrome yeah now this is an immense
00:34:50 part of australian culture and the japanese translation of it is i actually think more vivid
00:34:58 the nail that sticks up gets hammered down flat is the way it will be translated into japanese
00:35:05 because japan has elements of this as well but it's expressed in the context of east asian
00:35:11 Confucian Buddhist Shinto culture rather than a broadly liberal democratic Christian Jewish
00:35:20 kind of little bit of Muslim culture in Australia and the tall poppy syndrome explained is
00:35:29 the country it's not socialist nobody has any issue with you making lots of money in Australia
00:35:36 having a very good life if you're very clever or entrepreneurial or very talented knock yourself
00:35:42 out make a fortune Australia has no issue with that so it's not socialist kind of envy politics
00:35:50 of envy it's not like that the tall poppy syndrome is if you have a special talent or trait or skill
00:35:58 you can make a lot of money out of it and get a lot of respect but you can't demand respect
00:36:05 and you can't demand that you be treated better or be given more chances or more deference
00:36:13 on the basis of your talent or skill now this will make more sense to british people and i'm sorry i
00:36:20 don't have a good example for americans you'll have to look it up but you may if you're british
00:36:25 and we're playing an you're playing an ashes series against australia at the moment remember
00:36:29 the sandpaper incident with ball tampering by members of the australian cricket team including
00:36:35 the then captain at the time steve smith one of the one of probably the best batsmen in the world
00:36:40 still he's just fantastically gifted um nobody in australia had any issue with steve smith being
00:36:46 fantastic making lots of money getting huge kudos for being uh gifted at his sport and for being
00:36:54 captain of the cricket team which is just like massive if you're canadian like it's like being
00:36:59 captain of the maple leafs it's just huge um but as soon as he arrogated to himself the right to
00:37:09 behave in a way that was not an expression of his talent but rather i am the skipper of the team
00:37:19 therefore i will bend the rules it created an enormous outburst and outrage and anger in
00:37:29 australia because that is and that is the tall poppy syndrome coming into effect yeah i think i
00:37:34 mean here you see uh it's slightly i think the meaning was always slightly different it might
00:37:39 have changed but it was because stats used to use it you know as well is essentially that if you
00:37:45 looked like you had particular initiative and not necessarily just talent actually but you wanted
00:37:52 to get on then there was resentment amongst other people who do you think you are it didn't require
00:37:58 you to do anything like to do that tampering with the ball and everything it was actually much more
00:38:04 if you were kind of like i'm going to make something of myself and you to then somehow
00:38:09 people would start to get jealous you know like the socialism is the politics of envy kind of
00:38:15 Australia doesn't really have that politics of envy.
00:38:17 What it has is the tall poppy syndrome.
00:38:20 Remember the, in the Brexit context of the Brexit debate,
00:38:25 this happened a little bit in the United States with Trump as well,
00:38:28 where a lot of people who were quite well-educated,
00:38:32 who'd been to good universities and so on and so forth,
00:38:34 were saying extraordinary things like these people vote,
00:38:38 these people shouldn't vote, these people are too stupid to vote,
00:38:41 that kind of thing.
00:38:42 anybody with any sort of career in public life in australia who said that in the response
00:38:54 to an electoral result of any sort and remember australia uses referendums because that's the
00:38:59 only way you can change the constitution that would be the end that would be out of public life
00:39:04 right you cannot that is and that is also the operation of the tall poppy syndrome you can't
00:39:11 arrogate to yourself because you're very clever, or you went to Oxford or Cambridge or whatever,
00:39:15 the ability to say, I'm smarter than you, therefore, I get to tell you what to do.
00:39:22 This is so bad. It's probably a little less than it was, but only a little bit because I've got
00:39:29 friends with teenage children who describe this phenomenon. If you are very clever at an Australian
00:39:35 in school and you then on the basis of your cleverness attempt to tell other people what to do
00:39:42 if you are a boy 100 out of 100 you will get the snot flogged out of you in the playground yeah
00:39:51 if you are a girl and you know that girls are less violent you're likely to still have standard
00:39:57 probably a good one in two chance of somebody going
00:40:00 around your face don't you dare sit down so that's the way the tall poppy syndrome operates
00:40:09 in australia and it is and that is quite close to what you're you when you're quoting from thatcher
00:40:15 is quite close to the how very dare you get above yourself but if you're very clever and you go on
00:40:20 and you make lots of money nobody's got a problem with that i made stacks of money out of my first
00:40:24 book and i got some envy from other writers who didn't have a bestseller but it wasn't particularly
00:40:29 nasty envy the controversy over my first novel was all over your sort of cultural appropriation
00:40:35 and that kind of thing it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't how very dare you write a bestseller
00:40:39 you know nobody cared about that this is the hand that signed the paper yeah and yeah
00:40:46 just briefly can you explain to people who don't know but it was a real
00:40:50 literary cause celeb wasn't it well yes what i did is i it's a proper there's a i wrote a feature
00:40:57 because there was a 20th anniversary edition that came out a few years ago that you can still get
00:41:02 off of amazon or at waterstones or blackwells whatever you've got no problem getting it there
00:41:05 and i wrote an essay and the long story short is and i have no problem with appending the word
00:41:12 lobby to their name i irritated a lot of jewish people so i had a big public fight with the jewish
00:41:18 lobby right and i was accused of everything one of which part of which was racism but some of it
00:41:24 cultural appropriation and all of these things that you associate with wokery now but it happened
00:41:30 in 1995 the net effect of that big controversy over my first book was to make it into an enormous
00:41:38 bestseller this is a difference now when this happens people's books it often happens before
00:41:44 the book is published and so the person doesn't make any money and they just have a dreadful
00:41:48 controversy and they get nothing out of it it was really unpleasant and why uh why was it cultural
00:41:55 appropriation what you what what was the the main beef then two things one i used a pen name and
00:42:03 pretended to be from an ethnic group of which i'm not and two i told somebody else's story the
00:42:08 standard cultural appropriation argument uh honestly read the essay which is about 2 000
00:42:15 words long buy the book but you can get the essay i wrote it for the australian which is paywalled
00:42:20 so it was republished by arrangement with the newspaper in quillette so if you just search my
00:42:25 name you will find it in quillette and you will just be able to read it and read the full story
00:42:29 there and you but you went on to win australia's biggest literary prize i won them yeah that book
00:42:35 won the miles franklin award which is the australian equivalent of the booker prize or the
00:42:39 the pulitzer prize yeah um what you prefer being a lawyer or writing you're not practicing that
00:42:48 much at the moment are you i've got one consultancy job on the go at the moment uh but all the other
00:42:54 work i'm doing is is writing i've tended to split between consult legal consulting and writing i
00:43:00 gave up full-time practice in sort of mid mid 2016 and I like writing on the back of my legal
00:43:11 knowledge so that's the kind of writing I really like doing I am a what they call Americans have
00:43:18 slightly different systems here I'm what they call a senior writer at law and liberty which is a
00:43:23 legally focused magazine and it's published by liberty fund which is a very distinguished American
00:43:29 legal and economically focused non-profit and I write for them once a month and it's nearly
00:43:36 always a law article that I do for them. Law and Liberty. Law and Liberty is the magazine and it's
00:43:42 owned by Liberty Fund which has been non-profit. Because before this you told me you had one
00:43:47 coming out this week which I read which was about it was a review was it not of Ayaan Hershey Ali's
00:43:53 book in particular relation to the Australian immigration system which yes which she thinks
00:43:59 is a good one well it's a little bit more complicated than that whilst there are places
00:44:03 in and i say this in my piece and law and liberty is not paywalled so if people want to go to the
00:44:08 website and just click on my name the that article of mine will probably still be on the front page
00:44:12 somewhere and you can just go through my whole author archive going back over several years now
00:44:17 what while she occasionally quotes australian prime ministers i think she quotes uh john howard
00:44:24 there at one point and paul keating at one point and various other little bits of information
00:44:30 because her focus is on europe and to a lesser extent the us which is fair enough they're much
00:44:35 bigger markets australia has a small population what she finishes up doing without being really
00:44:43 obvious about it is advocating the australian immigration system to other countries so when
00:44:49 When she, at the end of Prey, Hirsi Ali goes through and sets out, this is how you fix this, all the problems I've identified in the book.
00:44:58 And you read the rest of the book for the issues with your correlation between Muslim immigrants from countries that tolerate polygamy and high crime rates.
00:45:07 That's probably the biggest, strongest point that she makes with the best documentation.
00:45:12 And I go through this in my piece, but the book is well worth the read.
00:45:15 And once she's made her statistical case, she then goes on and makes policy recommendations.
00:45:22 And all the policy recommendations that she makes, only once does she quote one of the Aussie prime ministers.
00:45:29 But all the policy recommendations that she makes are ones that are absolutely standard in Australia and have been since 1991 when the points based immigration system was introduced.
00:45:39 Oh, I see. It's funny because the Australian-style point system, everyone used to talk about it all the time here during Brexit, you know, without really knowing what it was, you know.
00:45:53 In fact, a lot of people said, actually, the Australian-style point system wouldn't really work very well for Britain, actually.
00:45:59 But it was always put up as being, this is exactly what we should have.
00:46:03 I don't think people really know what we've got now. I think some people think we have got that.
00:46:08 No, well, you're starting to do it, but the problem you've got here, and now we're getting back to the very odd Australian history that combines both authoritarianism and exceptional competence in terms of governance.
00:46:24 And there's an expression that economic historians use to describe this, and I'm thinking of people like Mark Koyama, who used to be at Oxford and is now at the Hoover Institution.
00:46:33 and uh koyama talks about high state capacity which is am i allowed to swear on here of course
00:46:43 you are okay the best way to define high state capacity is it is a government a state
00:46:52 that independently of anything the private sector does can get shit done yeah and get it done to a
00:47:01 high standard, which is why for many years you had The Economist, for example, talking about,
00:47:08 oh, it's not possible to have a centrally planned immigration system. And this became so egregious
00:47:13 that eventually, I think it was Keating, it might have been somebody else, but I'm pretty sure it
00:47:17 was Paul Keating, actually wrote a letter to The Economist and said, can you stop saying this? We've
00:47:22 had it since 1991 and we have the best immigration system in the world. And both those comments are
00:47:27 true um but yeah points-based immigration came up constantly in british focus groups i'm aware
00:47:34 of this from friends of the tory party and not just tory friends my labor friends they say the
00:47:39 same thing as well and it's one of those things it is a good thing it clearly works all of the
00:47:46 issues with immigration that happen in other polities including in the european union just
00:47:51 don't arise in australia don't really arise in new zealand either which has copied the system and
00:47:56 don't particularly arise in Canada either because it also has a very similar system and you could
00:48:03 the Canadian one if anything is a bit more obvious when for example the Syrian civil war was really
00:48:09 bad Canada was praised all around the world for taking 12,000 Syrian refugees which was more than
00:48:15 any other country and then you looked at the fine print must be unaccompanied females married with
00:48:23 kids really it's fascinating which by which ties into hersey alley's point about the problem of
00:48:30 young males from countries where polygamy is normal and they are unattached so it was literally
00:48:37 canada and australia does this all the time as well it's just the canadian one was widely reported
00:48:42 because it was such a big number and you just knew if because australia too has a points-based
00:48:47 immigration system it you just looked at it and you went ah yeah canada and australia cherry
00:48:54 picking taking the one the desirable ones off the top and leaving the dross yeah you know this is
00:49:00 just this is deeply deeply australian and canadian and kiwi this is just something that the three
00:49:05 countries do um and one thing before we wrap up can you can you actually go to australia
00:49:13 I can now because I'm an Australian citizen, I'm a dual national and I'm fully vaccinated, but it's an entirely legitimate question to ask because there was a long period of time when Australian citizens, regardless of their vaccination status, could not actually go back to Australia.
00:49:32 And it became a matter of enormous public controversy because one of the things that's part of the Australian immigration system, and this is an ancient thing that Australia has copied from something that existed in pagan Rome, is the status of a citizen is very strongly elevated over the status of non-citizens or permanent residents or anybody else who might be living in Australia.
00:49:58 and the fact that everybody was being barred from going back to Australia including citizens
00:50:04 really caused a lot of stink it made a lot of people across the political spectrum left right
00:50:10 up down doesn't matter made them very very angry and the expression that was used continually by
00:50:16 people in debates about this was Australian citizenship Australian citizenship means
00:50:23 something it is supposed to mean something our system is set up so that it means something
00:50:28 this is inconsistent with the Australian conception of citizenship and you would even start to get and
00:50:35 this is just about the worst thing you can be accused of in Australia you started to get
00:50:39 comments about this is un-Australian and if people start running that this is un-Australian line
00:50:44 you just know okay this is ugly this is going to be really bad and there's going to be a nasty
00:50:49 public debate about that. Well I have to say we'd rather nice in Britain if we did a lot a little
00:50:55 bit more importance to our own British citizenship I think as well already it seems to be very
00:51:01 disposable now but Helen thank you very very much. Thank you very much for having me Peter.
00:51:07 It's a pleasure and again I hope you know maybe next year you know where we get over,
00:51:11 thanks very much Helen. Not a problem. That's it for this time we shall see you
00:51:16 next week and thank you very much for watching. So what you're saying is thank you. Bye.
00:51:23 Hello if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission may I
00:51:30 invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk
00:51:39 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we
00:51:45 can't do it without your support. From as little as £3 per month, you can help
00:51:50 ensure that we continue on our mission. As a member, you'll receive a range of
00:51:55 benefits including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private
00:52:01 events including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much
00:52:07 more including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a
00:52:14 member, then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our
00:52:19 channel. It's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so
00:52:25 that you can get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.