New Culture Forum - December 06, 2021


Neil Oliver: "The Attack on Our History & Culture". The New Culture Forum's 2021 Smith Lecture

Why I Loathe The Woke: Joyless Snobs Who Despise the Working Class -- Julie Burchill What's Happened to Australia? Why Has Australia Reacted So Severely to Covid?

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 20 minutes

Words per minute

164.32

Word count

13,172

Sentence count

456


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for joining us tonight. Welcome to the New Culture
00:00:06 Forum Smith Lecture for 2021. We had our first one in 2017. It was Douglas Murray talking about
00:00:18 the strange death of Europe. That was followed by Nigel Farage talking about the threat to free
00:00:25 speech from social media, and then David Starkey, who was talking about the
00:00:30 constitutional crisis brought on by Brexit. I'm delighted that tonight we
00:00:35 have the archaeologist, historian, and broadcaster Neil Oliver. I'll come to him
00:00:41 in a in a while. Just a few things. We started the New Culture Forum in 2006
00:00:48 because basically we felt the cultural issues were the main ones of our time.
00:00:55 I think we've been more than proved right by that. Indeed it's meant that we
00:01:01 are now the foremost think tank working in this area. I don't know how many of
00:01:08 you watch our YouTube channel but we started this two years ago at very small
00:01:16 beginnings. We now have something like 15 and a half million views under our
00:01:20 belt and 131,000 subscribers. I do believe it's really contributed to the
00:01:27 political debate particularly around these issues. We recently started a
00:01:36 membership scheme and you will see a little kind of reminder on your seat so
00:01:41 if you haven't joined up again please do have a look and see great benefits which
00:01:46 accrue to becoming a member, whether you are, if you like, a basic member, going right up to what
00:01:54 we call a gold member. But that will allow all sorts of advantages such as free entry to events
00:02:02 like this and indeed free publications. As I said, I'm delighted that we have Neil Oliver with us
00:02:12 tonight. He's obviously very well known I'm sure to you for his broadcast series
00:02:18 such as Coast, The Vikings, History of Ancient Britain. He's written numerous
00:02:26 books and when it comes to council culture and wokery he's had more than a
00:02:33 brush with that when he was president of the Scottish National Trust for three
00:02:38 years until 2020. The order of things tonight will be that he will speak and then there
00:02:46 will be a period of about half an hour for questions from the audience. I'm sure there
00:02:51 will be many. But without further ado, the attack on our history and culture, Neil Oliver.
00:03:02 Thank you.
00:03:08 Well, hello and welcome.
00:03:24 That's a very humbling welcome to receive.
00:03:29 Listening to Peter name-check, the previous occupants of this space that I'm in now,
00:03:35 Douglas Murray, Nigel Farage, David Starkey only intensifies the feeling that I've had for the last
00:03:43 few years of how on earth, how on earth do I keep finding myself in these situations but
00:03:51 why me oh God. But without further ado I'll start. I've over the years you know of course
00:04:04 you can, as you can imagine, I have been called upon to speak in various circumstances and I used
00:04:09 to, I used to wing it. But the times are changing increasingly and things end up online and being
00:04:16 filmed and, and I feel increasingly that I need to be a bit more precise. So I've got, I've now
00:04:22 got into the habit of writing, writing things down, which I never used to do. But if you'll
00:04:27 bear with me, if you'll bear with me, I'll, I'll work from notes. But I want to start, I mean,
00:04:31 I'm here to talk about the attack on our history, and I'm not an academic, which I will repeat
00:04:38 over and over again. I just love history, and I came to love history mostly because
00:04:43 of stories, and so I will start with a story, which I think takes a few minutes to tell
00:04:50 it, but I think it illustrates something about our history, I think, and it's always said,
00:04:55 it's amongst a raft of stories that I think they say something to me about the power of
00:05:00 history. In January 1852, the iron-hulled, ocean-going paddle steamer HMS Birkenhead
00:05:07 left Portsmouth with soldiers bound for South Africa. She journeyed first to Cove of Cork
00:05:13 in Southern Ireland, where she collected soldiers and horses. As far as fighting men went, these
00:05:19 were as green as could be. They'd signed up just weeks before, in the main, to escape
00:05:24 the horror of Angorta Moor, the Great Hunger, which has gone down in the history books as
00:05:29 Irish potato famine. They had nothing in their way of training. They had uniforms.
00:05:35 They may have been attracted by the idea of adventurous lives in far-off places,
00:05:39 but in the main, the likelihood is that they signed up and got aboard Birkenhead because
00:05:43 of the promise of three square meals a day. Birkenhead headed south into war. They were
00:05:48 going to Africa, to South Africa, to fight there in the endless sequence of wars that were there
00:05:55 in that part of the 19th century. The largest single group were the 66 men of the 74th Regiment
00:06:03 that would be the Highland Light Infantry in later years. They were commanded by a six-foot
00:06:06 three-inch Scotsman, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Seaton, a great, you know, a fantastic figure of
00:06:15 a chap. Think Connery or something of that ilk. It's hard to know how many people were aboard,
00:06:22 how many men were aboard the ship, but it's probably well over 600 went up the gangplanks.
00:06:27 There were also, and this is crucial, women and children. It was not unusual at that time for
00:06:31 officers in particular to take their whole families on campaign with them. Seton made good use of the
00:06:38 time. The men were brought out on deck, fairly limited space, but nonetheless he put them through
00:06:43 their paces. He taught them all he could in the days and weeks where it was to be a soldier in
00:06:50 Victoria's army. There were divisions, naturally, between the different groups. They were all small
00:06:55 cohorts and he tried to establish something amounting to an esprit de corps.
00:07:01 By the 25th of February 1852, fully loaded with everything they needed, food and water and
00:07:07 provisions, they began the final leg of their journey to Port Elizabeth. She was making eight
00:07:12 or nine knots, steam-powered paddle steamer, very efficient for the time, by the standards of the
00:07:19 day. And to make the fastest route possible to her destination, she was coasting. She
00:07:24 was just three miles out from the coast, which put her into slightly unpredictable waters
00:07:31 because they were shallower. They were closer in than there was the potential of hazards.
00:07:37 But as far as possible, they were taking their line from the available charts.
00:07:42 There were lookouts fore and aft. There were officers on the bridge, sailors on watch.
00:07:46 Just before 2 o'clock
00:07:48 On the morning of the 26th
00:07:50 That's the day in question
00:07:51 The 26th of February 1852
00:07:52 A sailor's voice broke the silence of the night
00:07:55 He was the ledsman
00:07:57 He was swinging a led
00:07:59 On the end of a rope
00:08:00 And checking the depth
00:08:01 And he shouted 12 fathoms
00:08:03 All is well
00:08:04 So there was nothing to worry about
00:08:05 Another sailor shouted four bells
00:08:10 Which is to say they were halfway through the night
00:08:12 And everything looked as it should be
00:08:15 and the Birkenhead at that moment ran full steam onto a hitherto unknown reef of rock.
00:08:21 They were in an area known as Danger Point,
00:08:23 but there were rocks on the charts that whatever it was that Birkenhead hit
00:08:28 had previously never been known about.
00:08:30 It was just sheer bad luck.
00:08:33 She'd hit so hard with her paddle wheel still turning full pelt
00:08:37 that it drove them further onto the reef of rock.
00:08:40 And a great rent was torn in the hull
00:08:43 And sea poured into the space
00:08:45 Below decks
00:08:46 And many of the men, uncounted numbers of the men
00:08:49 Drowned where they were in their bunks
00:08:51 Just sleeping
00:08:52 So they never even had the chance to do anything
00:08:55 The captain of the Birkenhead
00:08:57 Was Captain Salmond
00:08:58 He was thrown out of bed
00:09:00 Made his way, he was an old navy hand
00:09:02 He got up on deck as fast as he could
00:09:04 And started assessing the damage
00:09:05 He was shouting orders left and right
00:09:07 He knew what to do in the circumstances
00:09:08 And very quickly orders were dispatched to get the women and children up onto the deck
00:09:13 And that was achieved, all of the women and children were assembled
00:09:16 Distress rockets had been fired out of force of habit
00:09:21 But there was no one for miles around, there was no help coming
00:09:24 Lieutenant Colonel Seaton was quickly there too, in his nightclothes
00:09:29 But with his sword belted on, it was the only precaution he'd taken to come on deck
00:09:34 and then the wounded, the walking wounded started to emerge. Some of them terribly hurt but there
00:09:40 was no help for them. There were men appearing half-dressed, naked. There was nothing they could
00:09:44 do. They just had to muster on the deck as best they could. Salmon's crewmen needed help with the
00:09:50 pumps because obviously the ship was sinking and Seton, the soldier, rounded up 60 of his men and
00:09:56 put them at the captain's disposal and then he called. Of course what they did was to lower the
00:10:02 lifeboats. The soldiers and the sailors joined together for this crucial task, but they found
00:10:07 to their horror that of the eight lifeboats that were aboard Birkenhead, only two could
00:10:13 be released. The rest of them were painted or rusted into their positions. They had never
00:10:17 been called upon, never been needed, never properly maintained. In the end, three boats
00:10:22 were lowered, two eight-oared cutters and a gig. What they knew right away was that most
00:10:28 people were going into the water and the water off the coast of South Africa then as now was
00:10:33 known to be thick with sharks, including the white pointers that we know as great whites.
00:10:39 Seton never actually used the words women and children first, but he made it clear who would
00:10:45 be taken up the first places in the available boats. And so the officers' families, the women,
00:10:51 the wives and the children of varying ages were put aboard the available boats. And, you know,
00:10:57 It was causing great distress.
00:10:58 You know, wives and children were calling out for husbands and fathers,
00:11:01 but there was nothing else for it.
00:11:03 But nothing else that this had ever been done before,
00:11:05 because previously, it's extraordinary that it happened,
00:11:09 because previously the call was something like,
00:11:11 save yourselves if you can, every man for himself.
00:11:15 But this was going to be different,
00:11:16 and the young soldiers and the young officers of the 74th and other regiments,
00:11:21 that night, in the dark and the chaos of that night,
00:11:25 They set a new standard.
00:11:30 Seton selected a young ensign of the 74th, 19-year-old Alexander Cumming Russell, Ensign Russell.
00:11:37 And he was put into the main cutter with women and children.
00:11:42 Once that was in the water, Seton put himself at the end of the gangplank with his sword drawn in case any of the soldiers broke ranks.
00:11:51 But nobody moved.
00:11:52 Everybody stayed in line.
00:11:53 They stayed where their officers had told them to be
00:11:55 And they stood there, you imagine in the dark
00:11:58 They're looking up at the Southern Cross
00:12:00 And the other stars in the sky
00:12:01 As the women and children are rode away into the darkness
00:12:04 And then what they did
00:12:05 What was done, what was always the case
00:12:07 Was that the army followed what's known as
00:12:10 Funeral Order, which is youngest first
00:12:12 So the youngest of the
00:12:14 Recruits were put into the available
00:12:16 Spaces in the cutters
00:12:18 Salmon then made a disastrous decision
00:12:22 He thought that he could get Birkenhead off the rocks by throwing her into reverse and using the wheels, the paddle wheels, to pull her back into deep water.
00:12:30 But when he did it, it tore another rip into the hull of Birkenhead.
00:12:36 Water poured into the engine room. It extinguished the boilers.
00:12:39 There was now no power. They were into deeper water.
00:12:44 The next thing that was done was the horses.
00:12:48 They had cavalry there as well, and the horses were blindfolded, put into the water in the hopes that they would swim to shore,
00:12:54 but they were instantly taken by sharks so that the men still aboard could see what was going to happen as they went into the water.
00:13:01 It's like the USS Indianapolis, you know, the scene in Jaws, you know, where he describes what happened to the people that went into the water.
00:13:10 Birkenhead broke her back. Finally, she snapped on the reef.
00:13:14 But the men still stayed where they had been put.
00:13:16 And you have to remember that these were the greenest recruits imaginable.
00:13:20 I mean, they were barely soldiers.
00:13:21 They had done no active service.
00:13:23 They had just been recruited, and there they were,
00:13:25 but they were taking orders from their officers.
00:13:28 The ship's funnel snapped and fell down, causing chaos, killing many.
00:13:33 They set about trying to free more of the lifeboats, but they couldn't.
00:13:36 Captain Salmond had climbed up into the rigging,
00:13:38 either to get clear and try and stay out of the water for as long as possible,
00:13:42 or to find a better place from which he could address the soldiers.
00:13:46 and he told them to get into the water and make for the boats make for the cutter but he said
00:13:52 save yourselves if you can swim just jump overboard and get to the boats but Seton realizing what that
00:13:59 would mean if all the men started swimming towards these already filled boats said you will swamp the
00:14:04 cutter you will kill the women and children I beg of you not to do this and I beg of you to stay
00:14:10 where you are and no one broke ranks not one of the soldiers not one of the officers
00:14:14 the officers took up the call and they shouted out to these men hold the line hold the line
00:14:21 hold the line and so they did and then so the Birkenhead slipped below the slip below the
00:14:27 surface completely the men were in the water the wives and children had to watch as their you know
00:14:31 as their husbands went into the water one man's voice rose above the tumult of the ships dying
00:14:36 God bless you all, he said, God bless you all. Captain Wright of the 91st Regiment, he survived
00:14:42 to fight another day and he reported, and I quote, the order and regularity that prevailed on board
00:14:48 from the moment the ship struck till she totally disappeared, far exceeded anything that I thought
00:14:53 could be affected by the best discipline. And it's the more to be wondered that, seeing that most of
00:14:58 the soldiers were but a short time in the service. Every man did as he was directed and there was not
00:15:03 a cry or a murmur among them until the vessel made her final plunge.
00:15:07 All received their orders and had them carried out as if the men were embarking
00:15:11 instead of going to the bottom of the sea.
00:15:14 There was only one difference, that I never saw an embarkation conducted
00:15:17 with so little noise or confusion.
00:15:21 The ship went down quickly.
00:15:24 Soon there was hardly anything but the very tops of the superstructure available.
00:15:28 And the sharks came in.
00:15:29 They circled for a while, but then they gained confidence and they moved in.
00:15:34 And it's this crushing irony that these young boys that had stepped aboard Birkenhead,
00:15:41 stepped away from their old lives in hopes of being fed, became food for sharks.
00:15:47 But nobody moved.
00:15:48 Nobody made a move on the boats.
00:15:49 But the women, the wives in the boats, they were driven beyond endurance,
00:15:53 and they started demanding that the cutters be taken back towards the struggling men.
00:15:57 And so they did, the young ensigns moved the boats back in
00:16:01 And they were calling out to their husbands
00:16:03 But nobody would approach the boats
00:16:05 And then Ensign Russell, who's 19
00:16:08 He jumped, the family that was in his boat
00:16:11 Saw their husband and father
00:16:13 Ensign Russell jumped into the water
00:16:15 Helped the man take his place in the boat
00:16:17 Struck out for shore and then was taken by a shark
00:16:20 While others watched
00:16:21 and then in all 430 men aboard the Birkenhead died Captain Salmond was killed by one of the
00:16:30 ship's masts falling on him Lieutenant Colonel Seton was around surrounded by his men but he was
00:16:37 they were taken they were all taken by sharks however the point of Birkenhead is that every
00:16:42 single woman and child was saved and some hours later another ship in the vicinity the Lioness
00:16:50 came across the lifeboats and the women and the children told them what had happened and they
00:16:55 proceeded and they pulled a few people out of the water but in all respects the the crew the
00:17:00 soldiers and the sailors were all gone and because of the circumstances of middle of the 19th century
00:17:05 the news of what happened to Birkenhead didn't reach Britain until April but it became legend
00:17:12 the king of Prussia Frederick Wilhelm later who became the German emperor he was told of what
00:17:19 had happened on Birkenhead and had an account of it posted in every barracks of his army telling
00:17:24 the men that this was the standard, the almost unattainable standard that he expected from his
00:17:30 men. And Seton and his men had changed naval protocol forever. The cry of women and children
00:17:37 first is properly described as the Birkenhead drill. And this is their memorial. This is their
00:17:43 memorial and their greatest monument. And half a century later, Kipling, Rudyard Kipling,
00:17:48 immortalised it in a poem called Soldier and Sailor 2, which he dedicated to the Royal
00:17:53 Marines. To take your chance in the thick of a rush with firing all about is nothing
00:17:57 so bad when you've covered a hand and leave and the liking to shout, but to stand and
00:18:02 be still to the Birkenhead drill is a damn tough bullet to chew. Now, most people have
00:18:08 never heard, I would imagine, of the Birkenhead, and they won't know that Women and Children
00:18:12 First is the Birkenhead drill. And it's impossible to say how accurate the accounts that we
00:18:18 have of what happened that night actually are what actually played out on the 26th of February 1852
00:18:25 but but still but history as much as anything else or certainly to me it's the stories that
00:18:31 we tell ourselves about what we think happened or or it might even in some cases be what we hope
00:18:38 happened in the past history is partly narrative and ultimately if it's the matter at all it becomes
00:18:45 personal narrative. Roger Kipling also wrote, I keep six honest serving men. They taught
00:18:52 me all I knew. Their names are what and why and when and how and where and who. And these
00:18:58 are the questions. These are the questions that we should ask all of the time of our
00:19:03 leaders and of everyone else in relation to what is happening around us and what's being
00:19:09 inflicted upon us. What, why, when, how, where and who. In relation to history I think the question
00:19:16 of why is the hardest to answer. Why something happened because we weren't there and we cannot
00:19:23 know why events unfolded, why events unfolded in the way that we did and I think we have to
00:19:30 content ourselves in the main with answering the other five questions so that why remains elusive
00:19:36 to the last. Historians hope to find the truth of the past, but truth is as elusive as why.
00:19:44 What is true is that some of the stories that we tell ourselves, the kind of stories that I count
00:19:51 as history, they take the trouble to remember and to retell, at least in part, who we think we are
00:19:59 as people and as a civilisation. If not who we are, then who we might be if we try hard enough
00:20:07 to put the needs of others above our own. And there are many stories that work that way and
00:20:13 that break my heart. And they told generations of British people and people around the world.
00:20:20 They told people who the British were or, which is just as important, who they thought they were
00:20:26 and what they thought their ancestors had done.
00:20:30 The Battle of Britain, the Birkenhead Drill,
00:20:32 the Blitz, the Thin Red Line,
00:20:34 the Charge of the Light Brigade,
00:20:36 and on and on and on, on and on and on it goes.
00:20:38 These are the kind of things that get remembered
00:20:39 for hundreds and then for thousands of years.
00:20:42 In Scotland, which is my homeland,
00:20:44 much is made of Calgacus,
00:20:47 the warrior swordsman who, according to Tacitus at least,
00:20:50 rallied the Caledonians.
00:20:51 He brought together all the clans,
00:20:54 all the tribes of Scotland.
00:20:56 According to Tacitus, he brought them together for a climactic battle against Agricola's Romans at a place called Mons Graupius, which is to say the Grampian Hills.
00:21:06 And this happened sometime in AD 83.
00:21:10 And real or imagined, let's allow for the artistic license, according to Tacitus.
00:21:17 But the words that he either heard or put into the mouth of Calgacus are quite something.
00:21:22 Whenever I consider the origin of this war and the necessities of our position
00:21:27 I have a sure confidence that this day and this union of ours
00:21:31 Will be the beginning of freedom to the whole of Britain
00:21:33 To all of us slavery is a thing unknown
00:21:37 There are no lands beyond us
00:21:40 We are the last of the free
00:21:41 And even the sea is not safe
00:21:44 Menaced as we are by a Roman fleet
00:21:46 To us who dwell on the uttermost confines of the earth and of freedom
00:21:51 This remote sanctuary of Britain's glory
00:21:54 Has up to this time been a defence
00:21:57 Now, however, the furthest limits of Britain are thrown open
00:22:00 But there are no tribes beyond us
00:22:02 Nothing indeed but the waves and the rocks
00:22:05 Let us then, a fresh and unconquered people
00:22:08 Never likely to abuse our freedom
00:22:10 Show forthwith at the very first onset
00:22:12 What heroes Caledonians has in reserve
00:22:15 How can you read that without the tears
00:22:17 Swaking in your eyes?
00:22:19 It's so good
00:22:20 It's so good. And how familiar is it in terms of inspiring the rhetoric that some of us
00:22:27 continue to tell ourselves about what Britain is, or at least what Britain has meant.
00:22:33 We've been hearing this for thousands of years then. We've been telling each other,
00:22:37 those of us that care so much about it that it brings a lump to the throat, that Britain
00:22:42 is a special place. And it's a place where no one should accept enslavement. And it's
00:22:49 a place that values freedom from totalitarianism above all else. So history then, some of history
00:22:56 can be used, can be exploited to stir the blood, to persuade people in times of doubt or in times
00:23:03 of fear that they have an obligation to meet standards set by others who went before and by
00:23:09 so doing to inspire generations as yet unborn. Stories from history at least suggest what might
00:23:15 be possible, what might be achieved if we seek to live up to an ideal, an ideal that may or may not
00:23:22 have been realised, ever made real by the ancestors. I think, and I say this from the heart, that it's
00:23:28 hard to express how important it is to give people the confidence to try and do that which might
00:23:34 otherwise seem impossible. And there we have it, the C word that matters so much now, and it's
00:23:41 confidence, confidence without which people lack either the will or the wherewithal to keep going.
00:23:51 Subjects of my talk, the attack on our history and culture, both are certainly under attack by
00:23:56 those preaching the nihilistic narrative born of, among other contagions, post-modernism,
00:24:02 an ideology that seeks to persuade us to disregard and to forget all that we have previously valued
00:24:07 and understood about our nation and ourselves it's a blatant attempt to erase the past to forget
00:24:12 the past and to find only shame in the memory of our predecessors the removal of statues is obviously
00:24:19 a highly visible aspect of this bid to establish a year zero no one's safe not even Thomas Jefferson
00:24:27 I watched I watched online I saw footage of an eight foot tall statue of Thomas Jefferson being
00:24:33 removed from New York City Hall, a statue that had been gifted to the people of New York in 1834
00:24:40 and there and here and elsewhere statues are toppling subject to an agenda that makes no sense
00:24:50 to me. As has been rehearsed elsewhere and by others smarter than me, the past, our past is
00:24:58 being viewed now and by many who should know better from the narrow perspective of the present
00:25:03 through that highly subjective prism judged in relation to 21st century morality any and everyone
00:25:10 from the past might be so judged and found wanting this is a metastasizing cancer that will kill us
00:25:17 all in spirit if not in the flesh unless we deal with it our defense against the worst of the attack
00:25:24 our cultural immune system if you might say could and should be confidence in who we are who our
00:25:31 ancestors were and what they achieved. But our confidence, collective and individual, is being
00:25:37 undone. Its power as an immune system in the face of an uncertain future is being suppressed.
00:25:44 Without the confidence drawn from knowing who we are and what we are about, we will be prone to all
00:25:48 the opportunist infections spread by those who would make us ashamed of our past and our culture
00:25:55 and the civilization that has been its product we know this is wrong and disastrously so
00:26:01 we know that children raised in shame children who are made to feel shame about themselves about
00:26:08 their parents about their background about those from whom they come go on doomed to disastrous
00:26:14 outcomes we've known this for thousands of years in deuteronomy 23 16 the fathers shall not be put
00:26:21 to death for the children neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers every
00:26:26 man shall be put to death for his own sin i'm often introduced as a historian god help me but
00:26:34 the truth is i'm not um and not in the way that matters to real historians let me tell you because
00:26:39 they write to me to say so tv likes to badge it likes to badge people it's called an aston
00:26:49 anything they put under your name, you know, to make it clear to the viewers who or what you are.
00:26:54 And in the days when the legacy channels used to give me the time of day from time to time,
00:26:59 I was always cast in the role of talking about old places and old things. And it just made life
00:27:06 easier for everyone if they called me a historian. I did go to uni. I went to Glasgow University in
00:27:13 the mid-80s. I've got a degree in archaeology way back in the 1980s, though, and I've never
00:27:21 really given university a thought since. And having seen the way academia has gone, more
00:27:27 so in America, I suppose, at the moment, but certainly the same contagious infection is
00:27:33 also here. Academia is tainted and corrupted in many ways by bad faith. It has marched
00:27:39 unchallenged through the rest of our institutions. Increasingly, I wasn't ever cut out to be
00:27:46 an academic. I didn't have the ability, truth to tell, but in any event, when I look back
00:27:52 at it, I'm glad that I just turned my back on the ivory towers after I graduated with
00:27:58 my degree and went away and got a job, because that's worked out well for me, better for
00:28:02 me. I often tell myself that the most useful education I ever got was because I tried to
00:28:08 make a go of it as an archaeologist, but I was excavating a bit of Roman road on Lurg
00:28:14 Moor. There's a name to conjure with, Lurg Moor, above Greenock, above the Clyde in,
00:28:21 I think it was a November or a December, and it was brutal, just me and another guy, and
00:28:25 it was just snow and whatever. And I was about, I don't know, early 20s, and I thought, I'm
00:28:30 going to be 40 one day, and I'm never going to be able to afford a house, and I'm going
00:28:38 to be arthritic before I'm out of my 30s and I walked away from archaeology and I got
00:28:43 the chance to retrain as a cub reporter. I got the chance to be what they called in
00:28:48 the old days an indenture. Do you know why an indenture is called an indenture? It was
00:28:54 a contract that people used to sign in the good old days and two copies of it were written
00:28:59 out on the same sheet of paper, two duplicate copies and then it was torn in half quite
00:29:05 laboriously so that there was a toothed edge and it meant that you signed one and your boss
00:29:12 signed the other and if you ever had a dispute relating to your contract the two could be brought
00:29:17 together and because of the teeth they fitted together and you could see oh it is the same
00:29:22 contract that was an indentured contract which fascinated me so I was given I was given an
00:29:28 indenture. And I got a proper old-fashioned cub reporters education. I did the day job
00:29:35 most of the time, but twice I was sent away to college to study Scots law for journalists
00:29:41 and newspaper practice. I went to night school to do shorthand and typing. And shorthand
00:29:46 and typing, without a doubt, more than my degree, more than learning to drive, shorthand
00:29:52 and typing changed my life for the better. I say to my kids, it's the best thing you
00:29:57 could learn shorthand and typing. It absolutely, you know, set me on a path which I'm so glad
00:30:03 about. And my first editor, get to the point, I worked for the Dumfrieshire Newspapers Group,
00:30:10 which was this little privately owned entity based in Annan and Lockerbie and Dumfries.
00:30:15 The Annandale Herald was the local paper when Pan Am 103 came down. I was working in the
00:30:21 Annandale Herald in the aftermath of Pan Am 103. I attended the Lockerbie inquiry
00:30:26 and heard some of the unbelievable testimony but my editor was a very eccentric man called Bill
00:30:34 Laidlaw who told us every day that every word we wrote about cattle sales and the local sheriff
00:30:42 court he said they read this in the Kremlin every day he was convinced that Russia was watching us
00:30:48 but on my and they are and he told me on my first day in the office in the newsroom he said
00:30:53 your job is to represent the reasonable man or woman he said the reasonable man or woman is
00:31:01 is reasonably educated reasonably interested in what's going on about them they want to stay up
00:31:06 to date they want to be informed and they want they want newspaper reporters to ask reasonable
00:31:12 questions the sort of questions that they would ask if they had access to those people and so
00:31:18 So he said, I mean, he preached it as though it was a quasi-holy obligation and responsibility.
00:31:27 He said, you have to represent the reasonable people.
00:31:31 And that is how I see myself and how I have seen myself ever since.
00:31:35 I'm not a historian.
00:31:36 I'm not an academic of any sort.
00:31:38 I have no wishes so to be.
00:31:40 I've worked as an archaeologist.
00:31:41 I've worked as a newspaper reporter.
00:31:43 I was the editor of the third website in Britain
00:31:47 BT.com
00:31:48 There was Tesco
00:31:50 There was the Royal Bank of Scotland
00:31:52 And the third website in Britain in the mid-90s was BT.com
00:31:54 And I was part of the team that built it
00:31:57 And I edited some of the content
00:31:58 But always I try and remind myself
00:32:01 That the most important thing to be
00:32:04 Certainly now is to be a reasonable man
00:32:06 And ask reasonable questions of people in power
00:32:09 I said this earlier to some of the people I was talking to
00:32:14 several of whom I genuinely with my hand and my heart think are better equipped
00:32:18 to stand up here and talk than I am
00:32:19 but I said a couple of times to people that I feel
00:32:24 as if I've walked through an invisible door, a door I didn't know existed
00:32:27 into a parallel universe where everything looks the same
00:32:31 but all of my relationships with more
00:32:36 and more people have become fundamentally different. Friends and acquaintances that
00:32:41 I've known for years, another one this week actually publicly distanced themselves from me,
00:32:47 is someone that I've known for a long, long time. But mercifully into that void or into that vacuum
00:32:55 have been pulled incredibly important relationships, new friendships with people
00:33:01 Whose paths mine would not have crossed
00:33:05 And I genuinely think it's been a great blessing
00:33:08 To have gone through this kind of sorting process
00:33:11 It's almost been like doing some kind of
00:33:13 Clearing out of, I don't know
00:33:16 I don't want to say clutter about living, breathing human beings
00:33:19 But everything's been altered
00:33:23 And I've now, in a very short space of time
00:33:26 Established relationships with new and
00:33:28 genuinely fascinating and inspiring
00:33:31 people and I wouldn't have met them previously
00:33:33 but the past
00:33:34 in short the past 20 months have been incredibly
00:33:36 disorientating
00:33:37 I feel as if the planks of everything I knew
00:33:40 before, I'm 54
00:33:42 and I feel as if up until I was about 52
00:33:44 I was walking about on an identifiable
00:33:47 surface and then
00:33:48 all at once those floorboards
00:33:51 have just dropped out from underneath me
00:33:52 and I continue to be
00:33:54 in a sort of free fall
00:33:56 and I'm not sure where I'm going to end up
00:33:58 and bizarrely part of that process I found myself casting the role of commentator
00:34:05 commentating on all manner of things current affairs and the rest and it's honestly it's
00:34:13 not a role I ever wanted it's certainly not a role I ever sought actively but here I am and here we
00:34:19 are and all the time now my wife we look at each other across the breakfast table after the
00:34:26 after the kids have walked off to school and you know she'll say something like how on earth did
00:34:31 this happen to you to us and and you know how indeed and we you know I shrug I shrug what can
00:34:39 you say we just look at each other uncomprehending about this sequence of events that it's not just
00:34:44 us obviously it's everyone in the world in the last 20 months has been turned upside down
00:34:48 so the long and short of what I've said so far is I tell myself for the sake of my own sanity as
00:34:55 much as anything else that I must try and continue to be the reasonable man that Bill Laidlaw told
00:35:01 me I was obliged to be on behalf of the readers of the Annandale Herald and the Annandale Observer
00:35:06 and the Dumfries Courier. All I want to do now is what I was paid to do then, which is to ask what
00:35:14 I consider to be reasonable questions of the people in authority and to have those questions
00:35:18 answered and honestly and this is being made increasingly difficult in this current climate
00:35:25 in which more and more we're encouraged to feel ashamed of ourselves in part not only but also
00:35:33 having the temerity the unmitigated gall to challenge even to ask questions of the powerful
00:35:39 and I've made clear from the outset that I'm not a historian but I'm here tonight to talk about the
00:35:44 ongoing attack on our national history, on our nation's story and culture.
00:35:50 And what I am as well, I hope, as a reasonable man, is a lover of history and a lover of stories
00:35:55 in general. And I started with the story of Birkenhead, and it's just one of the stories
00:35:59 from history that stirs my blood. And I've loved history ever since I was a pupil at primary school.
00:36:05 I'm state educated. I went to a primary school in Dumfries and then Dumfries Academy.
00:36:09 me. I had a fantastic history teacher in my secondary school called Ivor Waddle. There's
00:36:16 a name to conjure with. I look back now, I remember thinking about him as being an older
00:36:21 guy, but when I look back now, I think he must have been about 26. But I came to him
00:36:28 by the time I was in his classroom, I had acquired, I don't know, a nascent love of
00:36:35 history, I suppose, because I had learned that my grandfathers, my mum's dad, my dad's dad,
00:36:41 had both fought in and survived the First World War. And that my family, that my dad's dad and
00:36:48 my mum's dad were connected to world-changing events, the like of which had never been conceived
00:36:52 of before, that struck a deep chord with me. And on the rare occasion, and it might only have been
00:36:59 once actually, when I sat on grandpa's knee, that was my dad's dad, my mum's dad was wounded in
00:37:04 Gallipoli. He was shot by friendly fire aged 16 and invalidated out. He was back home in Renfrew
00:37:09 by the time he was 16. He'd lied about his age to join the Royal Marines. But when I sat on my
00:37:15 dad's dad's knee, and I can remember distinctly putting my finger behind one of his ears and
00:37:20 there was a raw, there was an edge under the skin. It was like touching the serrated edge of a bread
00:37:26 knife. I could feel it under the skin and I didn't ask grandpa but I asked my dad. I was about five
00:37:33 and my dad said it was shrapnel from a shell that had exploded you know near enough to hurt
00:37:39 grandpa but obviously not to kill him and the surgeons left it in. I don't know they just
00:37:44 they just didn't take it out and he was deaf as a post in that ear because the metal had gone
00:37:49 straight through and it was still there across his ear canal. He also had a wound here on his right
00:37:54 forearm. It was a circular puckered scar that he called his clock. It looked a little bit like a
00:38:02 circular face with the lines of where the numbers would be. And whatever had gone in there, it might
00:38:08 have been a bullet, it might have been shrapnel, I don't know, nobody ever said. Something had cut
00:38:12 the tendons on his hand and these two fingers were permanently trapped against his palm as if he was
00:38:18 holding something there but he simply couldn't move them. And so for a five-year-old boy this
00:38:22 made Grandpa especially fascinating, because not only did he have a fragment of a bomb
00:38:26 in his head, his hand was the same as my Mark 1 Action Man.
00:38:32 He was shaped like that to go into the trigger guard of the wee Lee Enfield rifle that he
00:38:35 came with.
00:38:37 So I absorbed this about history, and it's always been there for me, because when it
00:38:45 came to looking at the Great War, for example, at school, it wasn't for me something that
00:38:50 happened to strangers long ago. It was family business. I thought, oh yeah, that's the thing
00:38:54 that hurt grandpa and hurt my mum's dad was dead long before I was born. Now the Great War has been
00:38:59 described as a set of iron railings separating the world of before from everything that came after.
00:39:05 And it's a perfect description because through the railings we could still see the horse-drawn
00:39:11 world of women in crinoline dresses and men in straw boaters, but there was no touching it. There
00:39:16 was no going back. We could see it, but we could never get there because the First World
00:39:20 War was a line drawn and forever. And at this time of year, I mean, honestly, I've said
00:39:27 this before recently, I'm absolutely preoccupied with what the, I think the Great War, I believe
00:39:36 that we're still suffering the wounds of the Great War and the Second War that followed
00:39:39 it. I think that we think that we're beyond it because the last of the veterans is dead
00:39:43 is completely wrong.
00:39:46 I think so much of what's going on in Europe and in the world
00:39:49 is like a fire in a coal mine that we think has been extinguished
00:39:54 but it's still smouldering under the surface.
00:39:57 It's still there.
00:40:00 And I think about the promises we make
00:40:04 or we're supposed to be making every armistice day
00:40:06 to remember the sacrifices of the ancestors.
00:40:09 And I find it particularly opposite
00:40:12 to think about the poetry of Humbert Wolfe, Requiem for a Soldier, and I quote,
00:40:17 Down some cold field in a world outspoken, the young men are walking together, slim and tall,
00:40:23 and though they laugh to one another, silence is not broken, there is no sound, however clear they
00:40:28 call. They're speaking together of what they loved in vain here, but the ear is too thin to
00:40:33 carry the things they say. They were young and golden, but they came on pain here, and their
00:40:38 youth is age now their gold is grey yet their hearts are not changed and they cry to one another
00:40:44 what have they done with the lives we laid aside are they young with our youth gold with our gold
00:40:50 my brother do they smile in the face of death because we died down some cold field in a world
00:40:56 uncharted the young seek each other with questioning eyes they question each other the young the
00:41:02 golden-hearted of the world that they were robbed of in their quiet paradise. I think about those
00:41:10 lives laid aside more and more with every passing year. And given that we promised the dead that we
00:41:15 will defend the freedoms they died for, I think about them with renewed poignancy now, right now.
00:41:21 What have we, I ask myself, done with the lives they laid aside? And more recently, I have wondered
00:41:28 if we are being robbed again of our world, of our quiet paradise?
00:41:33 Are we defending the lives and the freedom that they bled and died for?
00:41:39 Are we defending the world they were robbed of?
00:41:41 A world of proud history, of culture, of civilisation?
00:41:45 Or are we standing mutely by while it's taken apart piece by piece
00:41:48 by ideologues that want to see it gone for good and replaced by something else?
00:41:53 Something else that remains out of sight for now, uncertain and unknown.
00:41:58 Sometimes I wonder if too many of us have grown accustomed to so much that we've forgotten what
00:42:04 enough feels like and with this mindset nothing is ever enough. Now there are more than 36,000
00:42:11 memorials to the Great War at least. There's a great census of them done about 15 years ago now
00:42:18 and they add up to the greatest public art movement in British history and almost without
00:42:24 exception they were commissioned and paid for not by government or by local authorities but by the
00:42:29 people who had lost sons and husbands and fathers. They had been denied graves because the dead were
00:42:39 left behind, British army policy was to leave the dead where they fell and in those far-off days
00:42:44 France was out of reach, Belgium was out of reach, Passchendaele, they weren't going there
00:42:49 and so because the dead had been left behind millions of people had nowhere to go and the
00:42:56 dead matter and graves matter and the living need places where the dead can be honoured and remembered
00:43:01 first to our ancestors who lie in barrows or under nameless cairns on heathery hills
00:43:07 or where the seal swim crashes the island narrows or in jacobean tomb where scrolls and skulls carry
00:43:14 off death with an elegant inscription, the Latin phrasing that beguiles and dulls the bitter regret
00:43:21 at the loved body's corruption. Or those who merely share the prayer that is muttered for many
00:43:26 sunk together in war's eruption. To all clay-bound or chalk-bound, stiff or scattered, we leave the
00:43:32 values of their periods, the things that seemed to them the things that mattered. That's W. H. Ord
00:43:38 and Louis McNeice in letters from Iceland. And I think about those words too, the values of their
00:43:44 periods the things that seemed to them the things that mattered the things that matter to them like
00:43:50 freedom worth dying for ought to matter to us so in those towns and villages all across the land
00:43:56 funds were raised and artists were consulted and commissioned and it was testament all of it to the
00:44:03 scale of what had happened to so many and they looked down you know if you know if the if the
00:44:09 war dead, if the British and imperial dead of the First World War were to mark four abreast down
00:44:15 Whitehall past the cenotaph, it would take them two and a half days to get past. And they look
00:44:23 down from their plinths, those sentinels made of bronze and stone, and they've stayed in place for
00:44:29 a hundred years while the world has moved beneath and around them. And as I've already mentioned,
00:44:34 will become as many others around the world a nation that pulls down statues and I've wondered
00:44:39 how long it will be before they come for the war memorials those watchmen from an older world from
00:44:45 the foreign country of the past where as LP Hartley said they did things differently. It seems to me
00:44:51 that what we're seeing what's been happening for years now is the rise of a mass movement of sorts
00:44:57 I think the attack on our history and culture is part of that rise. Eric Hoffer was a stevedore
00:45:03 on the docks in San Francisco in the 40s but he was a genius and he was a great philosopher and he
00:45:10 thought about the world and he wrote books to try and explain how he thought the world worked and
00:45:14 what people were all about and probably the greatest certainly the one I've read most is
00:45:19 his first it's called the true believer about the nature of mass movements and I quote at its
00:45:25 inception a mass movement seems to champion the present against the past it sees in the established
00:45:32 institutions and privileges an encroachment of a senile vile past on a virginal present
00:45:38 but to pry loose the stranglehold of the past there is a need for utmost unity and unlimited
00:45:44 self-sacrifice this means that the people called upon to attack the past in order to liberate the
00:45:50 present must be willing to give up enthusiastically any chance of ever tasting or inheriting the
00:45:56 present. Hence the inevitable shift in emphasis once the movement starts rolling. The present,
00:46:03 the original objective, is shoved off stage and its place taken by posterity, the future. More
00:46:09 still, the present is driven back as if it were an unclean thing and lumped with the detested past.
00:46:16 To lose one's life is but to lose the present and clearly to lose a defiled and worthless present
00:46:22 is not to lose too much. I think we're now in the grip of a mass movement determined among other
00:46:29 things to discredit the past and the present so that once again as has been attempted before in
00:46:34 many places all focus and hopes must become about reaching or building utopia that perfect place
00:46:43 of the imagination in the future that place that does not and never can exist or at least that has
00:46:48 never been made to exist so far under the hands of men and women. Now I've already mentioned the
00:46:53 C word confidence and how much it matters to the maintenance of a civilization. Kenneth Clark
00:47:00 not the politician art historian was the presenter of a television series in the 1970s one of those
00:47:06 masterworks that the BBC made then it was called civilization and he wrote a book fantastic easy
00:47:12 to read book of the same name and to accompany the series and he wrote about how more than anything
00:47:17 else meaningful civilisation requires confidence, which is to say confidence in the society
00:47:22 in which we live, belief in everything around us, belief in the philosophy of the society,
00:47:27 belief in the laws, and confidence in our own mental powers as functioning individuals.
00:47:34 He described how all civilisations in the past, good or ill, have had that, a weight
00:47:40 of energy, and people think civilisation is this, you know, grand buildings and fine
00:47:46 art and good conversation
00:47:48 and elegant sensibilities
00:47:50 but these are just the products of
00:47:52 civilisation, they're not what makes
00:47:54 civilisation, civilisation
00:47:55 and you can have all of that
00:47:58 in a society
00:47:59 in Rome, in Greece
00:48:02 you can have all of that and yet society
00:48:04 can still fail
00:48:05 and our history and our culture
00:48:08 are under attack and there can be no
00:48:10 doubt about that, we're being bullied into accepting
00:48:12 that our history is a place of shame
00:48:14 worthy only of forgetting
00:48:15 that here was the cradle and crucible of the industrial revolution that changed the world for
00:48:22 the better and lifted millions or billions of people out of poverty is now apparently something
00:48:26 we should be ashamed of. Industrial revolution was founded on tapping coal and then oil and so
00:48:32 instead of being eternally proud of all that was made possible by that white heat or to mourn only
00:48:37 that we set the world on course for climate catastrophe, that we came to understand that
00:48:42 chattel slavery was an immortal wrong and so got rid of it means nothing. That we exploited slavery
00:48:48 as had every civilisation before us from Babylon onwards may never be forgiven. In spite of the
00:48:54 wisdom of Deuteronomy we the children of a civilisation tainted by slavery are forever
00:48:58 damned by the sins of our fathers. Even to be born with white skin is original sin now, a sin for
00:49:04 which there's no redemption and no forgiveness. We're under attack, our history and our culture
00:49:09 but what we're noting is that we're doing all of this to ourselves it's not an attack by
00:49:16 barbarians at the gates but corrosion from within we've lost confidence in ourselves
00:49:22 we've lost all of our confidence the modern greek poet cp kavathy wrote waiting for the barbarians
00:49:29 about city dwellers who have heard an enemy is massing somewhere beyond the walls
00:49:33 what are we waiting for assembled in the forum the barbarians are due here today why isn't anything
00:49:40 going on in the senate why are the senators sitting there without legislating because the
00:49:45 barbarians are coming today what's the point of senators making laws now once the barbarians are
00:49:51 here they'll do the legislating why did the emperor get up so early and why is he sitting enthroned
00:49:56 at the city's main gate in state wearing the crown and so it goes on there's this litany of
00:50:01 hopelessness you know where people are bored and they're exhausted and nothing that they've got
00:50:05 used to nothing none of the things that they've always done seem worth doing anymore and then
00:50:10 word comes that the barbarians have gone buggered off they've not come to the city and hearing this
00:50:15 the citizens are dismayed now what's going to happen to us without barbarians those people
00:50:19 were a kind of solution it seems to me that it's too many of us are citizens like those
00:50:28 Cavafy imagined. We've known
00:50:30 nothing but unprecedented peace for more than 70
00:50:32 years. During that time
00:50:34 we've been hypnotised by our good luck into
00:50:36 thinking civilisations like ours are in the
00:50:38 natural order of things, that a place like Britain
00:50:40 just happens. Of course
00:50:42 history tells us, or certainly should, that quite the opposite
00:50:44 is true. Look at the
00:50:46 civilisations of the past, or look around
00:50:48 at the rest of the world and see what the natural
00:50:50 order gets you. There are maybe
00:50:52 30 or 40 countries on the face of the earth
00:50:54 where you've got even half a chance of living a life
00:50:56 such as has been possible here.
00:50:58 A life of tolerance of faith, tolerance of difference, tolerance of sexuality,
00:51:03 a life of peace and equality before the law, of education for all.
00:51:07 The rest of the world is run by gangsters and thugs.
00:51:10 The rest of the world is a mess.
00:51:12 And that we have allowed ourselves to grow so complacent
00:51:15 that we've allowed ourselves to take for granted this marvel handy
00:51:18 gifted to us by our ancestors is horrifying to me.
00:51:22 Run the old place down if you wish or listen to others doing it for you,
00:51:25 of whom the mainstream media is full now,
00:51:27 and ask yourself, compare to where and compare to what?
00:51:32 Our history is under attack by bad actors,
00:51:34 those that would see an end to what we have had.
00:51:37 It's not just history that's the target.
00:51:39 Even the family is threatened now.
00:51:41 In Scotland, my homeland, as I've mentioned,
00:51:44 the government of the SNP seems constantly preoccupied
00:51:46 with finding ways to come between parents and children.
00:51:50 Most infamous of their efforts was the named persons bill
00:51:53 that would have inserted a state-sponsored figure,
00:51:55 a stranger into the life of every child, someone empowered to talk to the child alone, to gather
00:52:01 information without need of parental consent. Mercifully the bill was struck down by the highest
00:52:06 court in the land but it's never gone away and it's out there, it's out there, it could come back
00:52:10 at any time. More recently the same government ruled that a child as young as four could choose
00:52:16 at school to identify as the opposite sex, even to answer to a different name and wear different
00:52:21 clothes and all of that without the parents ever knowing no need to tell mum and dad this can be
00:52:27 our little secret i've already referenced eric hofer and the true believer and hofer also
00:52:33 described how almost all mass movements have in their early stages at least a hostile attitude
00:52:38 towards the family and this is done by undermining the authority of parents by making divorce easy
00:52:44 and by taking over responsibility for feeding educating and entertaining the children hofer
00:52:51 even points out that Christianity showed a certain early hostility toward the family with Jesus
00:52:56 himself saying for I am come to set a man at variance against his father and the daughter
00:53:01 against her mother he that loveth father or mother more than me is not worthy of me and he that
00:53:06 loveth son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me all of the warning signs of all of that I've
00:53:13 been saying are here in the present it all boils down for me to exhaustion to taking the present
00:53:19 for granted, to treating that present with contempt and to loss of confidence in all
00:53:24 that we have had. We are under attack, but the attack comes from within and the solution
00:53:29 must come from within as well. It will begin with recognition that here in Britain has
00:53:35 been for some little while at least one of the best places in the world in which to live
00:53:40 and to raise a family. For too long, too many of us, we who are the grown-ups and who should
00:53:45 be taking on the responsibility of maintaining the old place, have been acting like children,
00:53:52 spoiled and ungrateful children. It's time for us to grow up and to show that we deserve
00:53:56 our inheritance. I've said it before and I'll say it again that the time is now to realise
00:54:01 and to understand that we here in these islands are as lucky and blessed, if not luckier and
00:54:07 more blessed, than anyone else on earth. And I'll leave it there. Thanks very much.
00:54:15 I have to say I'm very humbled, but I'm very moved, so thank you very much.
00:54:43 Thank you. What a wonderful speech, Neil.
00:54:47 I'll get back.
00:54:47 Okay.
00:54:48 You talk about the mass movement.
00:54:51 Is it possibly a very vocal minority movement?
00:54:55 And the mass of us aren't struggling at the point of this?
00:54:58 Yeah, well, I think to some extent that's also, I think, maybe a characteristic of mass movements.
00:55:04 I think there's hope in your question.
00:55:09 in that I think, yes, I think it is a vocal minority,
00:55:12 but a vocal minority can have a great effect.
00:55:17 And I think that is demonstrable.
00:55:19 You know, they carry, maybe even unwillingly
00:55:22 and uncomprehendingly, or sleepwalking,
00:55:26 or whatever you want to say,
00:55:27 they carry a lot of people with them
00:55:28 who just don't want to put their heads up.
00:55:32 But likewise, I think the solution, you know,
00:55:35 can be made real by a tiny vocal minority of people.
00:55:38 if that minority of people would just bother to get vocal.
00:55:42 I think mass movements are led by something small and vocal.
00:55:47 And according to Eric Hoffer, it's such a wonderful book.
00:55:53 He makes such a lot of very straightforward sense.
00:55:55 He says that mass movements appeal to people who want to shrug off like an old skin their own personality
00:56:05 because they've come to, for their own reasons,
00:56:08 they've come to detest the present and themselves
00:56:12 and that a mass movement can seem to offer the possibility
00:56:16 to shrug off that skin and to jump into and be absorbed
00:56:19 by a collective that knows better
00:56:22 and that will make all the decisions for you.
00:56:25 You know, Hitler said that it was easier
00:56:29 to convert communists to Nazism
00:56:34 and the leaders of the communist movements
00:56:36 in Nazi Germany at the time said it was much easier
00:56:37 to switch Nazis into being communists
00:56:40 than it was to get anybody from within the
00:56:42 middling field motivated
00:56:44 in either way
00:56:45 because all mass movements are alike
00:56:48 and to some extent
00:56:49 some people just want to shrug off their old personality
00:56:52 and take on
00:56:54 something new
00:56:55 I was talking to some, we were talking before
00:56:58 before we came in here
00:56:59 there's a tendency for a lot of people
00:57:01 if their own small, if their own normal life
00:57:04 becomes too much for them and they can't you know they can't bother to straighten out their own
00:57:07 business it's very tempting to go and change the world you know it's just easier but I want my
00:57:16 privilege here I just want to ask my own question really uh before gentleman here comes in um you
00:57:22 know you you have been doing monologues on GB news which have struck such a chord and I just
00:57:30 wondered have you been surprised by the response? Oh completely you know that the the the genesis of
00:57:38 that I've made this that that has become something that I kind of now have to do I've made a rod for
00:57:46 my back in a way because because I knew that or I suspected that that any audience seeing me
00:57:52 suddenly appear you know the guy off coast suddenly cast or recast in that role that I had to take on
00:57:59 I thought I should explain myself, and so I embarked upon a seven or eight minute explanation
00:58:05 of how on earth people were looking at the coast guy, talking about current affairs and
00:58:11 pontificating about everything under the sun.
00:58:14 And so having done one, the producer said, why don't you just start every show by just
00:58:19 laying out a few thoughts about what you think about the week?
00:58:21 And well, the rest is what has begun to happen
00:58:27 And no one is anywhere near as surprised as me
00:58:30 At how much attention these seven, eight, nine minute
00:58:35 Prasages gain on
00:58:38 Someone within GB News actually said
00:58:42 GB News is a media platform
00:58:46 With a television channel attached to it
00:58:48 And I think that's very, that's, I've never forgotten that from the day she said it, because the number of viewers that see me on a Saturday night, I think are, you know, could be this, it's small, but then it has this ability to go out into the platform, and you know, sometimes I get a million views on Twitter or half a million views on YouTube, and I am stunned by it.
00:59:13 But as I said tonight, I think it's only because I am, to the best of my abilities, trying to be the reasonable person.
00:59:22 And I think because I'm saying the things I'm saying, and they're not spectacularly clever or original or anything like that.
00:59:29 I'm just saying things that, as it turns out, I think millions of people want to hear said.
00:59:35 Simple, reasonable things about the state.
00:59:38 I mean, I'm not, you know, it's not philosophy.
00:59:40 I'm not saying anything that millions of people aren't thinking, but I get great comfort from that.
00:59:47 As I've said in a couple of the monologues, I love knowing that I'm, because if people write to me all the time,
00:59:53 I get these amazing letters that come to the guy with the hair off the telly, or he lives somewhere near Stirling Castle,
00:59:59 or sometimes it's just a wee sketch of me, and the postman manages to deliver them.
01:00:04 And while the envelopes are funny, the contents of the letters are often heartbreaking,
01:00:07 And it's from people over and over again saying, I thought it was just me.
01:00:12 I thought I was mad. I thought I was the only person that wasn't getting it.
01:00:16 But when I hear you speak, it gives me the confidence to think, no, I think that as well.
01:00:21 And so, you know, that was supposed to be the core of what I was saying tonight about just being, just representing the reasonable people.
01:00:29 And there are millions of reasonable people and they're not getting a voice.
01:00:33 The gentleman here has been waiting patiently.
01:00:34 I would just like to move one step forward with the question the other gentleman said
01:00:45 with the things that are going on, predominantly so the whole Brexit going on,
01:00:52 Yeah, I do, but I also think it's easy for somebody like me to say that because obviously I've got, you know, I've got a microphone right now and every Saturday night I get one and then it goes out on Twitter and all the rest of it.
01:01:20 It is difficult. If you don't have that, then how does a person working on the tills at Tesco or working as a carer in a care home and just trying to secure an income to support a family and get through the day, what are they realistically supposed to do to raise their voices?
01:01:43 So it's a heart
01:01:46 I think the answer to your question is yes
01:01:47 But I think it's very difficult
01:01:49 For that silent majority to find a voice
01:01:52 But I do, in some of the letters
01:01:53 A lot of the letters, I'm cheered and encouraged
01:01:56 By how many say that they're gathering together
01:01:58 In small groups
01:01:59 It's funny, it's like hearing about little sects
01:02:02 Forming in
01:02:04 Judea
01:02:06 2,000 years ago
01:02:07 People are coming together in 10s
01:02:09 And 20s and sometimes hundreds
01:02:11 out in the open in parks.
01:02:14 They describe it to me
01:02:15 or they gather wherever they can gather
01:02:18 and they don't do anything particularly.
01:02:21 They just take comfort in having conversations
01:02:24 within that larger group in ones and twos
01:02:26 and they reassure themselves that they're still not mad,
01:02:30 that there are other people within their communities
01:02:33 that think the same way.
01:02:34 And I think that kind of step is important.
01:02:37 I think it's that regaining of confidence
01:02:39 for the people of the vast majority that's to be there simply in knowing that they are not mad and
01:02:46 they are not alone and then you know and then inevitably if and when the opportunity presents
01:02:51 itself to do something about it via the ballot box then you know people must have the have the
01:02:58 confidence to know that yeah there's millions of people that think like them and they're not
01:03:02 cranks and they're not insane by seeking to conserve and to maintain you know that which
01:03:08 they have loved? There's a lady here, actually. Yeah, there's someone itch behind you. Thanks,
01:03:19 Thanks Ronald. Thank you.
01:03:49 of political correctness, destroying our church, taking away Christianity from our siluting
01:03:58 act, taking away pride in who you are. I have put it through my veins, posted my love of
01:04:09 the United Kingdom but also through the West. Now I think this has been done intentionally
01:04:15 and I think that there are a class of people within this country, or the West actually,
01:04:24 that are embarrassed to say that they love the people of this country and this country.
01:04:32 I never went to a university, I'm just the ordinary, well-class person,
01:04:38 that I've always lived on the tent for all my life.
01:04:43 But I want to fight for our children, and I want to fight for this country.
01:04:48 So I can't do anything but feel and talk about.
01:04:51 For God's sake, people stand up.
01:04:53 And please the media, stick up this country and stop the press down.
01:05:00 We're great.
01:05:01 Thank you.
01:05:08 I do think it's been deliberate. I do think it's been going on for, I honestly don't know
01:05:18 how long, generations maybe. But again, I think it's not a majority. It's a, well, not
01:05:24 maybe vocal, but a motivated minority. And I think there has been what you just described
01:05:30 as a march through institutions. I think that has, I don't know how, I don't know if it's
01:05:34 how coordinated it's actually been, but I think it has undeniably, it has undeniably happened.
01:05:40 And like you, I mean, I could hear your voice cracking as you were speaking, because, you know,
01:05:46 you grew up in the Thames, I grew up in mostly in the southwest of Scotland with a dad that was
01:05:50 obsessed with, you know, going up into the highlands and, you know, the landscape. And I grew
01:05:57 absolutely imbued with love of landscape for me really it started with and love of and love of
01:06:04 history and i've tried to express it you know i've written you know a couple years ago i wrote the
01:06:09 story of the british isles in a hundred places and i was simply writing about places of all the
01:06:14 thousands of places that i've had the opportunity to visit and which i love there were a hundred
01:06:19 that were just like when i shut my eyes in the dark it was like they were the the lights that
01:06:23 stayed on behind my eyelids and I just
01:06:25 had to string them together like beads on a
01:06:27 string and it all came from love
01:06:29 and I do
01:06:31 I absolutely love Britain and I'm not
01:06:33 and I've never been ashamed to say it and it's not
01:06:35 in a triumphalist way
01:06:37 it's not in a saying better
01:06:38 I do sometimes say I think you know best place
01:06:41 in the world but it's just that I
01:06:43 think that Britain is fantastic
01:06:45 yeah absolutely
01:06:48 and I think and people shouldn't
01:06:51 be afraid to say that absolutely
01:06:53 We have to get some other people in, sorry. Also this gentleman came down from Stirling today and he's going to go back tonight, so we did offer him a hotel, we offered him a hotel, so we had two, there's a gentleman here and there was one very long arm at the back there, so this one here, gentleman here, thank you.
01:07:23 very much in the presentation today. It seems to me that education is a clue or a key to
01:07:31 so many things. And we here probably have very little control over the education of
01:07:37 our children, about teenagers, and even about getting to go to higher education universities
01:07:43 and then teach our children. Which is a problem. We've got a big barrier and it seems, I wonder
01:07:50 How are we able to come back? How are we able to come back? Not just recent history of 100 years, but thousands of years of history which have built our nation. I mean, I'll give you a document to sign a declaration of growth, which you all know very well. Who's ever heard it? I think it's got great history in it and great history in it. How are you concerned about this?
01:08:12 I think there would need to be a motivated government that was prepared to root out and winnow out
01:08:26 the characters and the groups that have been pushing that nihilistic negative agenda and
01:08:33 replacing them, at least in part, with people who are prepared to offer up the other side of the
01:08:39 story you know it's a one it's a one it's a monoculture at the moment within the institutions
01:08:45 and within within education i mean i'm sure there are still i mean i only really have ever experienced
01:08:50 the state schools there are we have lovely teachers at my kids primary school and and there
01:08:58 are you know there are good teachers that i've encountered i've encountered in the in the high
01:09:02 school still in high school right has been there since the 12th century can you believe it been
01:09:07 in different locations but you know to talk about a heritage going back and it's always been available
01:09:13 to the to the ordinary folk of Stirling but from the 1100s it's remarkable to me um but I think
01:09:18 there just has to be a rebalancing there is a monoculture at the moment it's pushing one line
01:09:22 pushing one agenda but there are good teachers there and maybe they maybe they feel oppressed
01:09:28 or suppressed and not able to educate in the way that they in the way that they want to but it's
01:09:33 what you identify a thing. I don't know. I share your belief that that is what has happened,
01:09:39 that we've ended up with an education system that is pushing an ideology that I, for one,
01:09:44 don't approve of and don't agree with. But you just need other voices. You need other people
01:09:52 to say other things. You don't just want to replace one monoculture with another monoculture
01:09:56 that just says one thing. You need to have it all. I'm part of GB News, as you know,
01:10:03 Honestly, I mean, hand on heart. I mean, I hear other people on screen saying things within the context of GB News that make me shout at the screen.
01:10:11 Like, no! But, and then I caution myself by thinking, well, that's probably, that's probably the way that ought to be, rather than it just being another, you know, one-way street.
01:10:22 So, I think it's a rebalancing that's required rather than a wholesale replacement of one thing with another thing.
01:10:28 But the problem is absolutely there
01:10:33 And why there isn't space for just people
01:10:35 Openheartedly expressing love
01:10:39 For the thousands of years of history
01:10:43 I started off my book story of the British Charles in a Hundred Places
01:10:46 With human footprints at Haysborough and Norfolk
01:10:49 That are a million years old
01:10:50 And when they were revealed, they weren't fossils, they weren't solid
01:10:54 They were soft prints in sediment
01:10:56 that had been sealed beneath other sediment for a million years.
01:11:00 Homo anteces, a pioneer man and woman
01:11:03 who'd come into the peninsula of northwestern Europe
01:11:05 a million years ago, ice ages ago.
01:11:08 And that's here.
01:11:09 And that, the depth of history in our little archipelago,
01:11:13 breaks my heart.
01:11:14 I mean, I just feel as if we're holding such a treasure.
01:11:20 We have such a treasure here.
01:11:21 And it's history that tells us the nature of that treasure.
01:11:27 And some of the stories are terrible.
01:11:30 And there's black stuff that went on and dark stuff and ugly stuff that went on and cruel things that happened.
01:11:36 But in that way that when you fall in love with somebody properly, you know, the shades, the light and dark of that person's personality is what makes them the person that you absolutely fall in love with.
01:11:47 It's because they're not perfect.
01:11:49 if you get, you know, if you have the opportunity to get to know somebody properly, you'll know that
01:11:54 that's true. And it's like that, I feel that this temptation or this determination that there has
01:12:00 been to undo and to erase and to expunge the history of, and to take characters out, that
01:12:06 they tell us things about ourselves. You know, we got here because of footsteps that were taken
01:12:12 and mistakes that were made. I wear a suit of armour made only of my mistakes. You know,
01:12:16 So, you know, we need to see these people, we need to see these characters, hear these stories, learn from it, and, you know, and appreciate that it's all part of that texture.
01:12:25 You said that thing about the mainstream media.
01:12:28 I think the mainstream media is greatly, greatly at fault and has been for, God, I don't know how long.
01:12:34 I can't look at newspapers now, and I don't.
01:12:37 And I consume whatever current affairs elsewhere.
01:12:42 You can't, CP Cavafy, you know, you cannot hope to bribe.
01:12:46 twist, thank God, the British journalist, but seeing what that man will do, un-bribe,
01:12:50 there's no occasion to. It's not a new thing that the mainstream media has a tendency to
01:12:59 follow a line to push an agenda. They've always done that and they always will. But yes, absolutely,
01:13:07 that's a long rambling answer, but something has to be done to level out. There's one big heavy
01:13:13 bottom on one side of the seesaw at the moment and there needs to be another couple of bottoms
01:13:18 at the other end to i think uh we have sorry we've actually got the the the gentleman down here we're
01:13:25 going to have to call it tonight i'm afraid after that yes you sir yeah i guess building on uh
01:13:31 they may confront the corrosion, as you will, of many of our institutions that also extends into
01:13:42 parliament and politics. So, as you said earlier, we've got a chance to vote to express a few more
01:13:48 changes in power. So, it strikes me that most mainstream political parties are competing for
01:13:56 I would absolutely I am I've always been I've always been politically homeless
01:14:06 I've never been a member of a political party I've always been deeply cynical
01:14:10 about politics politically agnostic however you want to express it I've had
01:14:14 no truck with any of them I you know and don't get me started on the SNP
01:14:19 I can't believe I invoked that spirit
01:14:31 I agree, I absolutely share your desperation in the face of that
01:14:36 But in the 30 seconds every other day where I feel slightly optimistic
01:14:41 I do entertain the possibility that the political landscape
01:14:48 is shifting
01:14:50 and that there are
01:14:52 other voices and that if some of those
01:14:54 voices rather than being lone reeds
01:14:56 in the wilderness
01:14:57 could set aside some things and come
01:15:00 together because there is
01:15:02 a greater battle to be won
01:15:03 the
01:15:05 government and the opposition at the moment
01:15:08 as far as I'm concerned are just
01:15:10 dead flesh
01:15:11 I would just
01:15:15 slough off all of it
01:15:16 and start again
01:15:17 And I hope, I would like to think
01:15:20 There are voices, there are voices
01:15:32 There are voices out there and they say things
01:15:34 Some things that chime with my thoughts
01:15:36 And as I say, when I'm feeling optimistic
01:15:40 And I think given the gravity of the situation in which we find ourselves
01:15:45 if some of those smaller entities could speak to one another meaningfully
01:15:49 and come together so as to offer the voters a realistic alternative
01:15:55 to the stultifying, stagnant boredom of the two-party state
01:16:01 that we've got at the moment.
01:16:06 There's a happy note to end on.
01:16:08 Well, look, I just want to thank you, Neil, so wholeheartedly for that.
01:16:21 I think I found it quite moving, actually, and so vivid.
01:16:27 Thank you so much on behalf of us all.
01:16:30 I'd also just like to, just a couple of things.
01:16:34 First of all, thank you for making the effort to come out tonight.
01:16:38 I think you talked about how we should associate
01:16:41 and how we should get together.
01:16:43 This is one such occasion, I think,
01:16:46 and all the better for it.
01:16:49 Neil mentioned in his talk about Kenneth Clarke's civilization,
01:16:53 which I think had quite an effect on most of us.
01:16:59 Next year, the New Culture Forum is going
01:17:03 to be producing a six-part series called The West.
01:17:08 The whole point of it is to talk about the glories and the wonders of the West and our
01:17:19 achievements. One thing's for sure, you can make sure the BBC are not going to make it.
01:17:26 But these days, we have good old YouTube, but it will be up to our usual standard.
01:17:32 It's going to be presented by Mark Sidwell, and there will be an awful lot of, we hope,
01:17:36 very distinguished people in it, so that's something to look forward to.
01:17:39 I also, before I sign off with Neil, would like to thank the New Culture Forum team
01:17:47 who put together events like this and indeed do the whole channel.
01:17:52 Rafe Hadle-Mancou, you might know from the TV, also Lynn Evans,
01:18:00 Ollie Hurtson, our cameraman at the back, our producer there, Clive Watson,
01:18:05 and Rollo Pignon, who helps out on a regular basis.
01:18:10 These are the people who put us together, really,
01:18:13 and put us on screen, and all that.
01:18:16 And so I'd very much like to thank you for all that you do.
01:18:31 So I'm sure that Neil, before he gets on his train,
01:18:34 Oh, actually, we've got to have some dinner.
01:18:36 But I'm sure that he might answer some questions
01:18:38 if you quickly get a hold of him when we finish.
01:18:41 Thank you once again.
01:18:42 Thank you very much.
01:19:01 Hello.
01:19:02 if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission may I invite you
01:19:08 to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work
01:19:17 is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it
01:19:23 without your support. From as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we
01:19:28 continue on our mission. As a member you'll receive a range of benefits
01:19:33 including access to exclusive content, invitations to our private events
01:19:39 including here at our studios, free copies of our books and much much more
01:19:45 including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member
01:19:51 then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
01:19:56 It's completely free, just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can
01:20:02 get notifications when we post new videos. Thank you.