New Culture Forum - November 29, 2021


Why I Loathe The Woke: Joyless Snobs Who Despise the Working Class -- Julie Burchill

Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19 -- Matt Ridley Neil Oliver: "The Attack on Our History & Culture". The New Culture Forum's 2021 Smith Lecture

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

169.95

Word count

5,256

Sentence count

94


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. You might realise that actually we're not in our
00:00:23 usual setting because we've gone on the road for the first time and there's a reason for that
00:00:29 because the person I'm interviewing today is somebody I've admired from afar
00:00:34 for quite a long time. Judy Burshall is perhaps one of British journalism's
00:00:41 best-known columnists and writers. She's been at it now for 40 years nearly, I hope
00:00:47 she won't mind me saying. Her latest book is this Welcome to the Woke Trials How
00:00:52 Identity Killed Progressive Politics. It's already proving to be a very popular
00:00:57 on Amazon. Julie, thanks for inviting us down. Thank you so much for coming here.
00:01:03 Or should I say thanks for agreeing. Thank you. This book is, how many books have you written now?
00:01:10 My goodness, maybe 15. About 15. I've had bestseller and I've had books that 20 years after I wrote them
00:01:20 I've still got negative royalties for, so like you know all over the spectrum really.
00:01:25 but this one has been well received. I read a lovely review of this by Quentin Letts.
00:01:30 It's had one review which was brilliant. I do feel I will probably be shunned by the rest of
00:01:36 the newspapers but I can't say I'm that bothered about it. I got to number two in political science
00:01:43 and for someone who left school at 16 I'm so pleased. Yeah but this is why would they why
00:01:50 would you be shunned with this book because people for a long time in the industry thought that i
00:01:57 got away with too much it's true that when i made it when i was very young i was being paid an absurd
00:02:03 amount of money in my 20s i was a very flashy person i took loads of cocaine i showed off
00:02:11 constantly and a lot of people who and i'm very working class and a lot of people who've been to
00:02:18 university thought that they should probably have my career rather than I should have it.
00:02:24 The daughter of a cleaner and a factory worker and I think now when I had my periods when I fall
00:02:31 from grace those people who in the old days thought damn I should have a job they like it
00:02:38 but of course it don't bother me because I'm 62 and I've had the brilliant time I've had.
00:02:44 but you started you started writing at 17 isn't that right yeah that's when i was first published
00:02:49 yeah so i mean this sounds very very you know sort of like uh highfalutin maybe but
00:02:57 was it a calling then i mean very few people at 17 i know i didn't know how to breathe at 17 really
00:03:03 did how did you know how did you know why it was like a hand came down and touched me
00:03:09 I remember I was really when lots of people have careers in which they behave badly like me they
00:03:16 can blame it on their parents I had the most amazing parents really happy childhood I was a
00:03:21 really lovely little girl and then I remember reading an Oscar Wilde book and I absolutely
00:03:27 changed overnight she was absolute beast I would be 13 and I thought this is what I have to do
00:03:36 and at 13 I started to talk like a character from an Oscar on but when my mother would try
00:03:42 and kiss me goodnight I'd fend her off and I'd go father I think mother may have lesbionic tendencies
00:03:49 I was a 13 year old kid um so yeah I knew I was different and I had a call in and luckily I got
00:03:56 the job when I was 17. And that was with the newest conspiracy? Uh-huh well it was really good and
00:04:01 very big they had so many applicants for the job one was sebastian shakespeare and the other was
00:04:06 ross iddle really yeah and there were like 40 000 applicants good lord see that a lot of people
00:04:13 wouldn't know actually the new musical express was a real power in life it was huge i meet people now
00:04:18 from australia who say they used to just sit there waiting for a two-week-old copy of the
00:04:25 the reader arrive people will now you can stream and read everything online don't understand how
00:04:31 you had to work to keep up with pop then i was reading about the dj uh jay strongman and when
00:04:38 anarchy in the u came out i i think he in the uk came out he had to travel through two towns to buy
00:04:44 the record and it's like medieval times or something yes um you mentioned actually in the
00:04:52 book i was reading it that uh you were quite clear about not really wanting to go to university
00:04:58 you know the reason i'm asking is that is that now a lot of people are actually making the decision
00:05:03 you know what is this really worth it but why did you not because because of the class i was from
00:05:11 because i was considered clever i was presumed that i would go to university and become a teacher
00:05:18 or something well that was obviously the last the furthest thing from Oscar Wilde you can imagine
00:05:25 and I knew if I was corralled into further education I might have some of my my spirit
00:05:31 taken out of me my originality taken out of me and yeah it didn't appeal to me
00:05:38 um so basically after that I would become a shoplifter I already had I already had a shoplifting
00:05:44 empire and so i probably would have gone on with that but you pretty much work for most papers
00:05:50 haven't you in as used to call it fleet street yes oddly enough one of my favorite papers to
00:05:56 work for it was the guardian i had a great time there and actually produced a book of my columns
00:06:01 um just for the guardian and i left the guardian because when i asked for a rise they said i could
00:06:08 have a new sofa instead and I thought they weren't taking me seriously and then I went to the times
00:06:15 who bought me who bought me for three years like a footballer but I was at the height of my drug
00:06:20 period then so halfway through they paid me to go away then came then came a few hungry years
00:06:28 then then I sold my Banksy um so I've never been poor but you also wrote a novel which then got
00:06:37 got you in there didn't it oh my god sugar rush yeah sugar rush years were the great ones that
00:06:41 must have been around the year 2000s i think that was a fantastic time yeah i've had so much happen
00:06:48 to me but as i will admit was addled with with cocaine for 20 years i remember a lot of it you
00:06:56 were known well you you were known as the queen of the groucho club being the groucho club being
00:07:01 the media club in so i would say no i was probably that sounds so i did say that but it sounds
00:07:06 pretentious. I never had to join, I think I was their mascot. They definitely did treat me like
00:07:14 their mascot. But is that kind of, I mean it feels, the Groucho Cup media scene and journalists,
00:07:22 it feels very much in a kind of English tradition, you know going way back, is that still there?
00:07:27 Well we like to think we were like the Algonquin, which I think looking back we probably weren't.
00:07:33 I mean Toby was like shagging a princess down and look-alike in the billiards room and well
00:07:38 and other of us would be having sex in the toilets. It wasn't like the Algonquin, it was like a
00:07:44 like a teenage gang with added cocaine, that's how I think of it. Very happy time,
00:07:50 but we did get above ourselves and we did have a much higher estimation of what culture were worth
00:07:56 then. Well I don't, well actually no, I mean it sounds like I'm being ingratiating here but
00:08:01 you did start something didn't you as a group of you yeah called the modern review which was
00:08:06 really influential wasn't it can you explain what that was toby young my friend my best friend
00:08:12 was very very highly highly educated he got a double first at oxford but he was obsessed with
00:08:18 baywatch and some simpsons and i remember we were at a theme park one day and i just looked at him
00:08:26 and I said, we'll start a magazine called the Modern Review, you'll be the editor,
00:08:31 and we'll write about popular culture in a really intelligent way. Because people
00:08:37 weren't doing that. You had had people like Pauline Kael, of course, in America, who would
00:08:42 specialize in writing about films in a very popular way, and lots of American film critics.
00:08:49 But in England, people were very snobby still. So I think we did make a real breakthrough,
00:08:54 in that we had people who'd been done very well at Oxford, like Toby, Tom Schoen was
00:09:00 our film critic, but we were interested in common things.
00:09:04 But now, it seems like pretty much mainstream, doesn't it?
00:09:09 Yes, it did.
00:09:10 People write about Britney Spears in a serious newspaper and all of that.
00:09:14 I guess, now you put it that way, we were very influential. We were told by the man
00:09:20 start who began the culture at the Sunday Times and it was based exactly on Modern Review.
00:09:25 Toby says we were the victims of our own success but as our success at the most was 20,000 readers
00:09:32 I don't know how big that was but no it was an incredible time to be around and
00:09:38 oh just I got into journalism at exactly the right moment. When you say that do you what do
00:09:43 what do you think of it now Jonathan? I would not advise any young person with unconventional views
00:09:52 to try to enter this profession I think it's it reeks of nepotism um working class bright
00:09:59 working class kids like me or Caitlin Moran we could not happen again because you have to have
00:10:05 contacts you have to be able to afford to live in London and not be paid as an intern
00:10:09 so i would just not advise them to do it i'd advise them to be a shoplifter instead
00:10:15 this is the case though with so many professions isn't it i mean you know like i was in television
00:10:22 for quite a long time and it was that was the same thing it used to be have this class this
00:10:26 feel about it not anymore yeah not anymore absolutely i think it's very interesting that
00:10:32 that the rise of nepotism has gone alongside the rise of woke because in theory
00:10:38 workism should be very much against privilege but it's almost like the working class can't
00:10:43 be trusted to have nice things including easy jobs that pay well do you think julie the the
00:10:50 working class you came from in bristol uh do you think that working class is still there
00:10:57 it is it's been marginalized as the working class in brighton has been to move further out
00:11:03 but it's still there and i hate i'm a very optimistic person but i do think in the future
00:11:11 there may well be a conflict complication of of the dispossessed working class and
00:11:19 their new woke masters i think there will be a big battle in the future at some point
00:11:24 i'm i'm glad i had my phone when i had it i do say in my book young people today are so miserable
00:11:30 that if rock and roll were invented today it would be us all people out dancing to it
00:11:35 and then trying to burn the records well yes do you know those two versions of fairytales in new
00:11:42 york and they play the cleaned up one for the young people and they play the dirty one over
00:11:47 here too absolutely in welcome to the woke trials actually you're very you go into a lot of depth
00:11:57 about the fact that working class people seem to be one of the real demons for woke people.
00:12:06 Would you say that's correct?
00:12:08 Yeah, absolutely. I think wokeism, I still consider myself really left-wing.
00:12:12 I'd abolish all inheritance, I'd abolish private education, I'd nationalise everything.
00:12:18 I do think wokeism, when we voted for Brexit, the liberal ruling class realised that they can
00:12:26 no longer corral us when the red wall came down and woke is an expression of contempt for people
00:12:32 that cannot be controlled but i would much prefer to have their contempt and be corralled by them
00:12:39 yes because i think they're worthless people yeah do you think this is this thing there's a
00:12:48 trope that's taken hold now that woke is actually a power struggle and that it's about
00:12:54 maintaining upper middle class power. Yes, utterly. They can't say, I mean the
00:13:04 Fabian Society used to believe in eugenics. There's a very funny piece in
00:13:08 the book when the wonderful firefighter and trade unionist Paul Emery, who was
00:13:14 sacked for being pro-Brexit, he's at Fabian Society talking about how he is
00:13:21 pre-Brexit and he gets heckled and he calls back what you're gonna do sterilize me and there's
00:13:26 always been an attempt to keep us down in some way and woke is just the new the new way they're
00:13:32 attempting to oppress working-class sword yeah it's funny isn't it though that there seems to
00:13:40 have been a complete return around in that way yeah there's the people who think they're being
00:13:44 revolutionary the people or say that they are in fact are just simply the establishment when i
00:13:51 got sac from the telegraph i realized that i'd come absolutely full circle from the time i was
00:13:57 like 17 i'd write things and be told you can't say that and now i was when i got the boot um
00:14:04 earlier this year i was 61 and i was being told by the same class of people you can't say that
00:14:11 except this time they were younger rather than older than me but so it's like I've stayed in
00:14:16 one place and the people who tell you what you can and cannot say they've changed yeah but still the
00:14:22 same message and still a message that I will not pay any heed to yeah there's something actually
00:14:28 that I wrote down that you you put a verse in the book I just thought it was rather a nice but rather
00:14:33 sagrat you say it's a great time to be a writer this woke period we're in as an awful time to be
00:14:42 a decent human being who just wants to live a quiet life now obviously you're i'm not the second
00:14:47 you're not the second you don't worry about that uh so it's actually been quite quite good for you
00:14:52 i would have thought that actually of all journals i can think of woke would be the biggest anathema
00:14:59 to you more than almost any other children I can think of.
00:15:01 It is. I think a lot of the big gap is that we have a sense of humour and they don't.
00:15:09 I'll be very surprised if they ever, when you listen now to the state-sponsored comedians on
00:15:15 Radio 4, they literally have no jokes, they just yell Brexit and Brexit has become like
00:15:20 mother-in-law. Then you all laugh. I don't think Wotness will produce one good novel,
00:15:27 one great singer nothing i don't i think they know that they are a sterile a sterile subgroup
00:15:36 and it makes them cross that people like my our generation who did have all the fun of course the
00:15:42 cross like with them people the old people who they say own their own homes and it's a shame
00:15:47 all those old people but my generation too who just had such a great laugh i think lots of work people
00:15:53 are pissed off that they didn't live through those years but also you you mentioned here which i
00:15:57 think is right it's like a it's a bit like the revenge of the mediocre woke yes there's a
00:16:03 beautiful line in it the revenge of the war flower on the whirling dancer the delarge on the witch
00:16:13 the head the curtain twitter on the head in it something like that yeah i was very pleased with
00:16:17 that. It seems to be it's sort of anti-beauty, it's anti-excellence. Anti-sex, the age of losing
00:16:24 your virginity has gone up seven years in a generation. What is it now then? What is it? 26,
00:16:31 something like that. Really? Yeah it's really gone up. Most people taken into A&E for cocaine
00:16:37 overdoses are over the age of 60 and it's pensioners who are driving up the sexual
00:16:43 infection but also there's another point you make in the statistic in the book where you say
00:16:51 uh like 92 i think of young left wingers in berlin live at home yeah i know it's incredible
00:17:02 yeah absolutely all our generation wanted to do was get away from home and this i've got children
00:17:08 I've got friends who have woke children and you see the change in the adult, they let
00:17:19 their children bully them and they are scared to say things in front of them. Rachel who
00:17:24 was just here says she has to speak a certain way in front of her children or they'll accuse
00:17:29 her of being a bigot.
00:17:32 it's very very eastern european this uh it really really is um just before we just i
00:17:41 still have a great line in it it's as if a monstrous legion of violet elizabeth botts
00:17:47 join the stasi yes because you i think you say it's like a tantrum they're having a tantrum
00:17:53 yeah but what's lethal is that because at the huge reach of it already
00:17:58 and at the cia they now have pronouns i've never seen uh an oppressive movement move so far so
00:18:06 quickly yes well that's the astonishing thing really about it is that you're talking about
00:18:11 basically yeah one thing that's interested me i think you sort of alluded to it already
00:18:16 but is that uh like brexit all of our institutions seem to collude to try and stop it and you know
00:18:24 that shook my whole confidence in all of these institutions. But similarly, Woke has shown
00:18:30 the kind of level of snobbery. I would say this seems quite new. Would you say that it's always
00:18:39 been there? It's a new way of expressing it, because people can't look down their noses
00:18:45 at the working class and say that they smell anymore, so they'll just say that they're
00:18:51 gammons or they vote because they voted for brexit it's a new way of attempting to control
00:18:56 the working class but there are many more of us look at me many more of us than there are of them
00:19:03 and of course that's what's in the back of their minds they can't there's too many of us to make
00:19:07 them shut up as the red wall coming down proved which must have given them a lovely nice shock
00:19:13 yes um oh and they won't they won't forget that in a hurry because this is all i think a lot of
00:19:18 it is like with Brexit for example it was like how dare you yeah actually go again it was a great
00:19:24 act of insurrection and then I remember everybody being really surprised that people like Morrissey
00:19:30 and John Leighton were Brexiteers what did you think they'd be middle of the road liberals
00:19:35 people can be so silly um I should explain by the way that some of the genesis of this
00:19:42 of your new book does come out of what happened in actually seven years ago before we really
00:19:47 talked about council culture isn't that right really this is when you defended suzanne more
00:19:52 wasn't it wow that was 2013 that was when the trans thing happened for the first time
00:19:59 yeah the first chapter i think is about that can you tell us what actually what happened to you
00:20:05 suzanne wrote a um column about she wrote an essay in a book and it was about female anger
00:20:13 and she said women are angry about everything now we're expected to have the brains of an oxford don
00:20:19 then she said something like the body of a brazilian transsexual and she got the most terrible
00:20:25 mobbing for this um suzanne and i were very close in the past her three daughters are my god children
00:20:33 she had the police around people saying i know where your children go to school
00:20:36 and it made me see myself I'm very impervious to criticism my husband
00:20:44 thinks I'm a sociopath but I'm not if someone texts my friends I'll see red so
00:20:53 I I was on Facebook writing involved in an argument about Suzanne can say what
00:20:59 she likes she's a great writer and then someone from the Observer saw it and
00:21:03 said what you do is a column on this so I said well I'm going out now they said
00:21:08 we'll pay you three times the usual rate so I basically put together what I've
00:21:12 been saying on Facebook already and it was published on that Sunday and a huge
00:21:17 congregation took place was denounced in the House of Commons
00:21:21 peaceful support you were denounced in the House of Commons by a woman who got sacked for stealing
00:21:25 stationery they said Lynn Featherstone she got the boo for taking stationery I
00:21:31 i said in the book perhaps she identifies as wh smith um so yeah and so then i got pulled from
00:21:39 the observer and i do remember the editor john mulholland rang me up and said you know this
00:21:44 doesn't make a bit of difference you know of course you can still keep working for us
00:21:48 i basically didn't work for another i was still working i guess for the spectator
00:21:53 and spiked but i didn't work for a newspaper for another not till the telegraph took me on five
00:21:59 years I guess it was a long time luckily I had a Banksy so I sold it all right okay okay but
00:22:07 people like to think oh I finally shut her up for good but one journalist called me the bouncing bomb
00:22:14 the bouncing bomb he said once you think she's shut up she'll come at you from another direction
00:22:20 and that's what i am you were in in the book as well you you say for example uh you've got
00:22:31 particular villains and heroes and sus the sussexes the jucan duchess of sussex are the
00:22:38 first couple of yeah the grabdication is my words the grabdication is basically like uh
00:22:45 on the application so who's doing the grabbing so this is this was megan what i think there
00:22:52 i think they were both perfectly ordinary people until they met each other like bonnie and clyde
00:22:57 or something i think sometimes people have a personality issue which can lay dormant and
00:23:03 they both appeared separately to be having a lovely innocent time by themselves having fun
00:23:09 i think when they got together that maybe their family issues collided in a way which
00:23:14 was infelicitous and has made them into this awful awful whining self-pitying monster that they are
00:23:21 but it's the woke thing isn't it it's the kind of do as do as i say not as i do isn't it yes
00:23:28 hypocrisy is a huge part of work as with climate change there was famously a young extinction
00:23:35 rebellion person who i write about in my book who stormed out of a radio interview when the
00:23:41 person interviewing him showed him the Instagram from the past year and I believe he'd taken
00:23:46 eight trips, eight trips abroad, skiing and such on Instagram and he said people should never fly
00:23:53 unless it was absolutely necessary. So a lot of that goes on and yeah I've never seen so,
00:23:59 as as Jon Snow said about Brexit, I've never seen so many white people in one place as when you see
00:24:05 those Extinction Rebellion things. One thing that struck me actually you look at because
00:24:09 that is it in fact you alluded in the book this is pretty much up to date but
00:24:15 the thing is this is relentless isn't it it's every day there's something new I
00:24:21 think at the very end you add a few more stories a few more examples well what
00:24:25 was so funny about writing the book was that I go to bed every night and I think
00:24:30 it's all this is almost verbatim I'd go to bed really in my head reeling over
00:24:36 fact that chess was now racist and wake up to find that brum the little car from the 90s tv show was
00:24:42 now racist um it was the book should have been easy to write but it was like painting that bridge
00:24:50 when they paint it they had to go back to the beginning again um because when you sort of
00:24:54 could get any sillier and then the actor uh uh and then coming said that brunch brunch brunch was um
00:25:02 Oh, that's right. It's a stump of white supremacy.
00:25:07 Nothing surprises me now.
00:25:10 It's just remarkable, which brings us to the point, right? I quoted, I think this is a kind
00:25:19 of rough time to live in, you know, if you are not of your disposition, which is to take it on.
00:25:28 um what about the future i mean you know you you you bring up at the end you know maybe there will
00:25:36 be as you i think you put it at the 11th hour you know uh some kind of fight back but where
00:25:42 do you see that coming i have no idea christopher hitchens used to say that many movements were
00:25:50 made up by a majority of silly people led by a minority of sinister people and if the silly side
00:25:58 of woke rises quickly then in the end it will all totally become a joke if we have enough people say
00:26:06 like don butler did they're all giraffes are gay then of course the whole edifice will come down
00:26:12 but if the sinister if if they do get a total grip on the culture as it sometimes seems they will
00:26:18 then I don't know what's going to happen I think there will be there will be a some sort of class
00:26:23 war in the future luckily I'm an old lady and I won't have to put up with it much longer
00:26:28 when you know as a creative person uh you know I we've interviewed I remember Lionel Shriver you
00:26:34 know she's my favorite writer yeah and and she was talking about this stay in your lane thing
00:26:40 with novelists and all she shouldn't write about say like a black as she's a white American or she
00:26:46 shouldn't write a black character and this one this is like the death of creativity absolutely
00:26:53 um i just wrote a column for spiked in which eddie redmayne has apologized for playing a
00:26:59 trans person i wrote in my column i hope he's apologized to disabled actors for
00:27:05 getting the oscar for playing stephen hawkins too yes um daniel day lewis must give his back
00:27:11 for my left foot obviously and i almost never use our imaginations ever again because it will be
00:27:17 against the law it is it's extraordinary how this has just taken hold um you do mention some bright
00:27:24 lights towards you sort of like people like harry miller you mentioned i think he's like
00:27:29 the book is partly dedicated to harry miller we've had on the show who who basically was the guy who
00:27:35 he's one of my heroes yeah he was told i you know you should check your thinking
00:27:38 just because he tweeted things. Well I mean it's been great to talk to you about this. I've really
00:27:44 enjoyed it. And you said you're an optimistic person right? I'm a horribly optimistic person.
00:27:51 I don't know what it is but I've so often feel like I'm on drugs but I'm not. One of the reasons
00:27:57 I did leave the marital home though I am still married is because I wake up at five in the
00:28:03 morning and I begin I start to sink straight away and my husband's like I don't want to like wake
00:28:08 people up but I'm very very optimistic. I think the thing is loads and loads of
00:28:15 times people thought I was done, I was finished, they got rid of me, each time I
00:28:19 bounce back. I've got a musical in the Brighton Festival next year and I've
00:28:23 wanted to write a musical ever since I was a child but I took so many drugs I
00:28:27 didn't get around to it so I'm totally excited about that. What's it
00:28:31 about? It's called The Twitch Song Triangle and it's a sad story about a young lady that falls in
00:28:38 with a gay man and then a lesbian forced in love with her it's very brightened it's got some lovely
00:28:43 songs in it written by me and my composer robin watts and um so i'm really looking forward to that
00:28:49 because it was meant to be on three years ago then the covid came along yeah yeah yeah we won't go
00:28:55 into covid julia she was so probably uh require another hour i imagine but uh this is next year
00:29:02 is it the musical yes next spring now look when it comes to the book welcome to the woke trial
00:29:08 but this can be got where you can get it on Amazon right but amazingly I thought
00:29:15 I would be shunned by the larger stores but if you look on Waterstones or even
00:29:20 WH Smith it says they'll get it for you as well though it has to come from
00:29:24 America so he has to be ordered but you can get it on Amazon now they've got a
00:29:27 lot of stock in okay thank you thank you very much I really enjoyed myself lovely
00:29:33 and and all the very best for this thank you peter thank you um thank you for not mentioning my voice
00:29:41 thanks julie uh that's it for so what you're saying is this week so well we shall see you
00:29:46 probably in the studio again next time hello if you're enjoying the new culture forum channel
00:29:52 and you believe in our mission may i invite you to join our membership scheme
00:29:58 at the link below or on our website newcultureforum.org.uk. Our work is more important
00:30:06 now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future but we can't do it without your support.
00:30:12 From as little as three pounds per month you can help ensure that we continue on our mission.
00:30:18 As a member you'll receive a range of benefits including access to exclusive content,
00:30:24 invitations to our private events including here at our studios, free copies of our books
00:30:31 and much much more including of course our famous NCF mug. If you aren't able to become a member then
00:30:39 please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel. It's completely
00:30:45 free, just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post
00:30:53 new videos. Thank you.