New Culture Forum - November 22, 2021


Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19 -- Matt Ridley

The Origins of the Culture Wars: 100 Years of Identity Crisis. Plus: Is Hungary Being Demonised? Why I Loathe The Woke: Joyless Snobs Who Despise the Working Class -- Julie Burchill

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

159.88

Word count

8,070

Sentence count

154


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my guest
00:00:23 today is Matt Ridley, Viscount Ridley. He is best known perhaps to you as a columnist for
00:00:30 the Times. He's also written numerous books, best-selling books on science, economics and
00:00:37 deep political philosophy. His latest book, Extremely Timely, is Viral, The Search for the
00:00:44 origin of COVID-19 it's out this week and he's co-authored it with Alina Chen um thank you very
00:00:54 much for coming Max thank you for having me it's a pleasure um I wanted to start really before we
00:00:59 look at the book by asking you to me this is one of the biggest questions of all how did this thing
00:01:07 come about and yet what I think was characterized at the time was the sheer reluctance it seemed
00:01:14 on the part of the media to even ask the question would you agree with that yes i would i've been
00:01:20 shocked by the lack of curiosity that politicians the media the scientific establishment themselves
00:01:28 have on the whole with some very honorable exceptions shown into this question two years in
00:01:35 today is almost exactly two years since the first case that we know of which was retrospectively
00:01:41 diagnosed on the 17th of November 2019 two years in we don't know how this pandemic started it's
00:01:48 the most devastating thing to hit mankind for a very long time it's killed millions of people
00:01:54 it's disrupted the lives of hundreds of millions it's vitally important that we found out where
00:02:00 this come from came from so that we know how to prevent the next one and also to deter people who
00:02:07 are watching this episode and thinking oh i could wreak havoc if i deliberately caused one of these
00:02:13 so to to for for most of the media to say well it it probably came out of this wet market but
00:02:20 we don't have any evidence of that but you know nonetheless let's assume that um uh and and there
00:02:26 is still no evidence for that it's still possible but there's still no evidence for it and yes we
00:02:30 know the chinese aren't really being very helpful in telling us what happened there's a lot of
00:02:36 obfuscation but we shouldn't be too worried about that they're a communist regime after all they do
00:02:41 that kind of thing that shocked me um i really didn't think that was good enough i think it's
00:02:46 the most important mystery of our lifetime i think we deserve to find out the answer
00:02:49 and we should turn over every stone until we find out how this happened but why do you think
00:02:55 there was that reticence well early on um the scientists most close to virology the virologists
00:03:05 community got two articles out there one in the lancet and one in nature medicine saying we can
00:03:11 rule out any laboratory-based origin we know enough already and this was in february march 29
00:03:17 2020 they didn't know enough already to rule out that it was ridiculous to come to that conclusion
00:03:26 based on the extremely limited information at the time what they were worried about was partly some
00:03:32 very weird conspiracy theories that were starting about it being a bioweapon or a failed vaccine
00:03:37 project or something, which on the whole were crap pot and did need to be ruled out. But that's
00:03:43 not the same as saying that a laboratory accident could be ruled out. And they should never have
00:03:47 done that. The media took their cue from that and said, oh, by the way, it's been ruled out.
00:03:53 I did too. I mean, in March and April, I was saying to friends, no, no, it's been ruled out.
00:03:59 I haven't read the paper properly, but it says they can rule it out.
00:04:02 And then I did read the paper properly and I thought, hang on, these arguments don't fully stack up.
00:04:08 I don't quite understand how they're coming to that conclusion.
00:04:11 And by the way, where is the infected animal in the market?
00:04:16 Where is the record of the early cases of this disease being food handlers, as it was in the case of SARS?
00:04:24 There was no such evidence.
00:04:25 And so I began to dig further and got more and more intrigued.
00:04:28 and um here we are well yes i mean i i should uh explain i mean the the overall argument that you
00:04:36 make in the book is that we should look at the idea of it coming from a laboratory isn't it
00:04:43 that that's the thing you're not you're not saying it was deliberate are you you're saying
00:04:47 that it's a possibility that it came from a laboratory by accident very much so and and and
00:04:53 eventually the scientific
00:04:55 and journalistic establishment came around to that point of view
00:04:58 in May 2021 they said
00:04:59 there was a big statement
00:05:02 in science and then a lot of the media
00:05:03 sort of fell in behind that and said okay yes fair point
00:05:05 we can't rule it out and we need to
00:05:07 take it seriously
00:05:08 so it's
00:05:12 not a case of
00:05:13 saying we know how it happened, we're not saying
00:05:16 that, we've looked into all the evidence
00:05:18 we lean towards
00:05:19 a laboratory leak as the
00:05:21 most likely explanation when we've looked at absolutely everything we can think of and we give
00:05:26 the evidence for the market as good a run as we can in our book you know we really do try and
00:05:32 explore what happened with the pangolin stuff what happened with the wet market in uh in wuhan etc
00:05:38 you know and we have a whole chapter saying look here's the best case we can make for it being a
00:05:43 natural event and then we have another chapter saying here's the best case we can make for it
00:05:50 being a laboratory accident accident is the key word here we are not alleging that someone
00:05:56 deliberately leaked a virus in order to cause harm as part of a bioweapon experiment or something
00:06:05 like that it seems to us extremely implausible that that would be the case and it's you know
00:06:14 none of the facts that we've seen support that idea but the question is given how many experiments
00:06:22 were going on on bat born SARS like coronaviruses in Wuhan above all other cities in the world
00:06:30 that the top research on this subject was there more papers coming out of this lab than anyone
00:06:37 else in the world on this subject more samples in the database than anywhere else in the world
00:06:43 given all that is it possible that an accident happened in a laboratory and the answer to that
00:06:49 is yes of course it is because accidents happen all the time in laboratories SARS the first SARS
00:06:57 virus leaked four times actually possibly six times from laboratories in Beijing in Taiwan
00:07:04 in Singapore and in most of those cases they didn't know it had happened till afterwards
00:07:08 till someone got infected and then they retrospectively said hang on this person's got
00:07:12 SARS they were working on SARS in a lab two weeks ago oh my god they must have picked it up one of
00:07:17 these cases was in the highest possible security laboratories you know the ones where you know
00:07:22 you're wearing a pressurized suit yes kind of thing um so it's very possible that if this virus
00:07:28 was in a laboratory workers would have picked it up of course the Chinese rather liked did they not
00:07:36 the wet market idea i mean in the sense that he got them off the world yes and no um i think that
00:07:43 the the chinese authorities were torn they didn't particularly want to point the finger at the uh
00:07:49 wildlife markets because ironically xi jinping had just in 2019 persuaded the world health
00:07:57 organization to recognize traditional chinese medicine as a valid form of medicine right now
00:08:03 some parts of traditional Chinese medicine are okay, but most of it is quack pseudoscience of
00:08:08 the worst kind. It's, you know, if you eat pangolin scales, you will live forever or be
00:08:14 more fertile or something like that. Well, pangolin scales are exactly the same material
00:08:18 as fingernails. So why not eat your fingernails if that's what you want to do?
00:08:22 I'll live forever then.
00:08:23 exactly um so so there was i think a real uh an equal reluctance to point the finger at the
00:08:33 wildlife markets and they were quite quick in may 2020 to say well not quick very but they did
00:08:40 eventually say by the way none of the animals we tested in the market have tested positive
00:08:45 that wasn't the case with SARS we meet we very quickly found infected animals in the market
00:08:51 um uh so instead of the wet market theory or the lab league theory they did a whole bunch of
00:09:00 research which they presented to the world health organization which pathetically signed off on it
00:09:05 saying here's what we think happened we think it came into china on frozen food from abroad
00:09:12 sounds ridiculous to a layman like me well if that you just you know think that through someone
00:09:20 somewhere in Southeast Asia is farming some animals that come into contact with a bat the
00:09:25 animals get infected they're slaughtered they're frozen they're packed they're sent to Wuhan
00:09:29 right why does no one on the farm get infected why does no one in the packing plant get infected
00:09:35 why does no one along the train get infected why does no one in any other city get infected to
00:09:39 where this produce is being sent why does it happen in Wuhan a city which doesn't have a
00:09:44 particularly thriving wildlife trade Guangdong the southern province is where most of the wildlife
00:09:49 trade happens um etc so it and oh and by the way when you erect a theory don't you do it because
00:09:56 you have some evidence where is your evidence of a piece of frozen food that was effect oh and then
00:10:02 once it happened once in wuhan how does it disappear how does it never happen again how
00:10:07 can't how come we can't find it on any frozen food after the event so it it was the most ridiculous
00:10:13 theory you could think of and yet the world health organization their experts who went to to wuhan in
00:10:19 early 2021 signed off on a document that said that is a more plausible explanation than that
00:10:26 there was a laboratory leak in the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which was doing work on bat SARS
00:10:31 related viruses that it collected from elsewhere in China. Why would they do that? The World Health
00:10:39 Organization became very beholden to China over the last few years. Dr. Ted Ross, the Director
00:10:48 general was elected with Chinese support and China basically went around Africa saying if you support
00:10:53 this guy we'll give you more subsidies and they when the outbreak happened they
00:11:04 believed the Chinese statements and repeated them that this was not transmitting human to human
00:11:12 for several weeks in January after the Taiwanese were picking up the phone and saying
00:11:17 there is evidence that people are catching it from people in hospitals and in homes in wuhan
00:11:24 what are you going to do about it the world health organization put out public statements saying
00:11:29 there is no evidence of human to human transmission in other words every case so far
00:11:34 we're talking middle of january here every case so far will have been caught from an animal
00:11:38 well that was they'd known for a month that that was not the case but the chinese were
00:11:45 authorities were reluctant to admit it and the World Health Organization went along with it
00:11:50 and Dr Tedros went to Beijing and he met Xi Jinping and he said words cannot express my
00:11:58 admiration for the transparency that you've shown this was at a time when the two whistleblowers in
00:12:06 the hospital where these cases had first started cropping up who'd gone on social media and said
00:12:11 hang on we've got a nasty new infectious pneumonia here it could be a SARS-like thing
00:12:16 when they had been reprimanded in the most vicious way and lots of other people had been censored
00:12:24 for saying anything about this and yet the transparency of the Chinese regime was being
00:12:29 praised. So I simply don't understand how the World Health Organization got itself into this
00:12:35 position its excuse is that it doesn't have any power to force a member country to let it in
00:12:41 and its only way to get in was to uh dance to their tune yeah um uh i don't think that's good
00:12:48 enough frankly and i i think if the world health organization did not exist then we would have
00:12:54 started an international investigation into this much sooner and much more effectively yes
00:12:59 Before we actually look at how the book pans out, I just wonder, because I'm sure most people, including myself, don't really know, what kind of a place is Wuhan, actually?
00:13:09 I mean, what is this place? I mean, is it a fishing village? It's not, is it?
00:13:14 Wuhan is a huge city. It's a city of 11 million people on the Yangtze River in central China.
00:13:21 It's about as sort of central in China as you can get.
00:13:24 it's a national city
00:13:27 it's got particularly strong links with France
00:13:29 historically funnily enough
00:13:30 and actually the Wuhan Institute of Virology Laboratory
00:13:33 was partly built by the French
00:13:34 and it's a big
00:13:37 modern industrial
00:13:39 city
00:13:40 it's
00:13:43 you know
00:13:44 it's not a
00:13:46 the area around
00:13:49 Wuhan has been heavily
00:13:51 sampled for bat viruses
00:13:53 interestingly because there's a lot of virology research in based in wuhan and uh they found
00:14:02 that they there are no sars-like coronaviruses in the bats around there at least very very few
00:14:08 they've never found them and curiously when they did a study before the pandemic in the area where
00:14:14 they could find sars-like viruses there's a lot of interest in where sars came from in china
00:14:18 in southern Yunnan and they found that very occasionally ordinary people do have antibodies
00:14:24 to SARS in these areas you know which implies that maybe people do sometimes come into contact
00:14:31 with bats and pick it up as a control as a comparison they chose the city of Wuhan
00:14:37 because this lab is here not because they thought that the viruses were there and they showed that
00:14:43 there's nobody in Wuhan that has antibodies to these kinds of viruses. So this is not a place
00:14:48 where these outbreaks happen. That's the key point, which a lot of people miss. A lot of people think
00:14:53 that, oh, they built the Wuhan Institute of Virology in Wuhan because that's where viruses
00:14:58 are found. It's not true. These viruses are found much further south. I mean, the closest relative
00:15:03 of SARS-CoV-2 came from a mine shaft in southern Yunnan near the Laos border and was collected by
00:15:12 the Wuhan Institute of Virology. That is 1,885 kilometers from Wuhan by road, okay, on Google
00:15:20 Maps. So, you know, worked it out. And that is the distance from London to Rome. So it wasn't like
00:15:28 the Wuhan scientists were just popping out next door and picking up viruses. They were going on
00:15:33 very long journeys to get these viruses, bringing them back a very long way to Wuhan and not to
00:15:40 anywhere else that's the point so that's what makes the city stand out it is the center of
00:15:45 research on these kinds of viruses otherwise it's just a normal Chinese city and what struck me
00:15:52 about about the book is it is almost sort of like a thriller in a way I mean it is very much there's
00:16:00 a lot of sleuthing in it but I think it's the central part of it I wonder if you could just
00:16:06 tell us how
00:16:07 that came about. In particular
00:16:10 there is this character called the
00:16:12 Seeker.
00:16:13 Who and what is the Seeker
00:16:16 and what part does he play in your story?
00:16:18 Well, you say
00:16:20 it's like a thriller and
00:16:22 we were very careful
00:16:23 not to
00:16:25 lurch into breathless prose.
00:16:28 You know, he was panting as he walked
00:16:30 up the hill.
00:16:32 But
00:16:32 we just wanted to tell, we want to stick
00:16:36 to the facts whenever we could um but it turned out as we were writing it that it became more and
00:16:42 more like a a detective story in the sense that we had to explain how somebody had found out this
00:16:50 piece of information and how that fitted in and how it led to somebody else finding something else
00:16:55 out and so on the seeker is a brilliant young indian man living in the city of bhubanashwa
00:17:02 um we do reveal his name in the book he he agreed to that um but he hadn't done that before but
00:17:09 although he has appeared on on films before um he's just a highly intelligent young man
00:17:14 who as he put it to us i just know how to make search engines work for me
00:17:20 okay so what he did was he uh when he read my co-author's original paper on this that sort of
00:17:29 started to get people intrigued about why this virus was so well adapted to infecting human
00:17:35 beings from the start which is an unusual feature shouldn't have been like that
00:17:39 he got intrigued by this and he started digging and he managed to get a login details for some
00:17:49 Chinese websites not illegally he just managed to get someone to share something and he started
00:17:55 researching obscure Chinese websites and before long he'd found a bunch of theses a bunch a bunch
00:18:03 of scientific documents put together by scientists giving huge details about cases they were working
00:18:11 on. The first of these turned out to be very important because it was a medical thesis in
00:18:16 Kunming the capital of Yunnan talking about the treatment of six people for viral pneumonia
00:18:23 in 2012 three of whom died and this was a really serious case of a really scary outbreak that
00:18:31 alarmed people all over China but had never really been there'd been one brief mention of it
00:18:37 before in the literature but the details were not there till the seeker found this thesis
00:18:42 and what was clear from the thesis is that they thought this was a SARS-like virus
00:18:46 because the men had been working in an abandoned mine shaft shoveling bat guano that's what they'd
00:18:52 been doing and the immediate result of that thesis was that the wuhan institute of virology
00:18:58 scientists went to the mine shaft and started sampling the bats and within a year they'd found
00:19:04 a virus a sars-like virus which they published a bit a little bit about but in a very obscure way
00:19:14 and then said no more about it and then six years later the pandemic begins and the wuhan
00:19:20 Institute of Virology says oh by the way the closest relative 96.2% the same that we know of
00:19:29 is something that was found in you now and before no reference to their name they changed the name
00:19:36 of the virus no link to their previous papers it wasn't till the seekers theses came out that we
00:19:44 were able to say oh hang on you're talking about a virus you collected yes six years ago um in the
00:19:53 wake of a human outbreak and by the way the human samples were also sent from the lungs of these
00:20:00 miners were also sent to wuhan not to anywhere else um why didn't you tell us that and don't
00:20:08 you think that's relevant and what other samples did you collect from that mine shaft and then
00:20:14 eventually another sleuth like the seeker called Francisco Ribera in Madrid said hang on I think
00:20:22 I found in another obscure data sets that you actually collected eight other viruses from that
00:20:29 mineshaft did you well a few months later they admitted that they had so these guys these open
00:20:37 source analysts. They called themselves internet sleuths. There's several others. There's
00:20:46 Rossana Segreto, Yuri Dakin, Mona Rahalka, Gilles Demeneuve. These are the people who've
00:20:57 found out the most about Wormontal. They've done better than the mainstream journalists.
00:21:03 They've done better than the mainstream scientists. They've done better than the
00:21:06 intelligence agents i mean we've talked to a number of intelligence agents who've been helpful
00:21:10 but not nearly as helpful as these guys who are just amateurs who know how to search the internet
00:21:15 and find information that's there and that's the that's what makes this such an extraordinary story
00:21:22 if this was happening in america or europe we wouldn't need to rely on people like this we'd
00:21:27 go to this lab and ask the scientists can you please show us your database but we can't do that
00:21:33 it's quite it's quite fascinating how it how it sort of unravels um Alina Chan your co-author
00:21:43 um I read a piece recently and I think it was in the times where she was saying that she was
00:21:50 you know slightly in fear um you know of of her life is that something you feel too I mean is
00:22:00 this sort of, you know, is this a dangerous book to write, even though you're saying what you're
00:22:05 saying? Yes, it is. I mean, there is no question that Alina and I have, to some extent, increased
00:22:12 the risk we're running by writing this book. It is very clear that the wolf warrior diplomacy
00:22:19 that the Chinese state operates is one that involves cyber attacks, denigration,
00:22:30 criticism of people who say unwelcome things about what's going on in China and saying that
00:22:39 a laboratory leak might have been responsible for this outbreak is something that will not be
00:22:43 welcome in China. So to some extent, but we don't know to how much extent, we have to
00:22:52 be concerned about what the reaction will be. Alina is a working scientist. She's a postdoctoral
00:23:02 student at the Broad Institute, which is a Harvard MIT researcher, the leading molecular
00:23:09 biology institute in the world basically she's an extraordinary brilliant young woman she's
00:23:14 Canadian and she just got interested in this topic and said I'm sorry it's not good enough
00:23:23 to say we don't know and when we may never know we need to find this out and she's been absolutely
00:23:29 relentless since she became a very useful source for me as I got more intrigued in this subject
00:23:34 and eventually I proposed that we write a book together. We were told by a lawyer,
00:23:41 you won't be going to China again. I hope that's okay with both of you. Well, I'd like to go to
00:23:47 China again. I think it's a wonderful country. I think they're wonderful people. I think they're
00:23:50 under a non-wonderful regime at the moment. But we don't want to exaggerate the degree to which
00:24:03 were in danger we're not making a big scene about it but yes we can't deny
00:24:08 that the one does run risks and given that the mainstream media want of a
00:24:14 better word were very very should we say well they certainly weren't curious
00:24:20 about it to begin with how have they received this book on the whole well it's
00:24:27 quite interesting. There's still a lot of journalists and commentators out there who
00:24:34 bought the idea that a laboratory leak was a conspiracy theory, which was the phrase that was
00:24:42 used again and again in the early part of the epidemic, who haven't moved on. They haven't
00:24:48 re-examined the evidence, they haven't looked at what has come to light since, and they haven't
00:24:55 followed the whole story and so some of them are reacting to our book by saying
00:25:00 well this is ridiculous these people are trying to inject life into a conspiracy theory
00:25:08 surprisingly to a surprising degree that's the reaction we've had from quite a lot of people
00:25:14 and i think there's a big disconnect here between such sort of establishment commentators if you like
00:25:19 and the general public and a lot of scientists.
00:25:26 I mean, we are constantly being contacted by scientists who say,
00:25:29 keep going, thank God you're doing this, you're on the right track,
00:25:32 but by the way, I daren't say so because I might not get a grant again.
00:25:36 Well, how did it come to that?
00:25:40 One of the reviews in The Guardian, talking about implausibility,
00:25:47 they came up with something about the fact that the virus could have come about because of changed
00:25:56 climate conditions and the loss of natural habitat for various creatures meaning therefore
00:26:03 this would give rise to virus I mean that seems to me to be almost wanton you know extraordinary
00:26:10 Do you remember that? Yes we don't discuss that issue in in the book but I did look into this
00:26:17 because I'm interested in this. There was a paper published by some very prominent virologists
00:26:23 saying that deforestation is the cause of pandemics. There's no doubt about that this
00:26:29 is what's happening and this is bound to be one of the parts of this story. Well do you know what
00:26:35 southern china where this virus came from is the area in the world that is reforesting faster than
00:26:43 anywhere on the planet practically i mean it's certainly it's seeing an enormous increase in
00:26:48 green vegetation going on at the moment these these rather in uh infertile unfertile uh hillsides
00:26:56 uh in remote areas where people were scratching out a living on with terrorist agriculture
00:27:01 are clothed in new forest yeah the forest cover is dramatically increased in that part of the world
00:27:08 so you cannot blame deforestation for this anyway even if there had been deforestation
00:27:14 you know it's just a sort of misunderstanding of ecology to think that you cut down a forest
00:27:21 so the bats move to where they come into contact with people think about this for a minute back in
00:27:26 old days people were not in cities they were in villages they were out there catching animals for
00:27:32 food they were out there um you know digging guano out of bat caves to use as fertilizer in
00:27:38 their fields they were far more likely to come into contact with bats in those conditions than
00:27:43 they are now they live in cities so the ecological explanation for pandemics which is very very
00:27:50 fashionable among a certain kind of environmental activist simply don't make much sense yeah and
00:27:56 that's true by the way of of other pandemics you know ebola and so on there's no evidence to link
00:28:01 it to deforestation or changes in habitat or anything like that eventually a scientist produced
00:28:08 a paper this year saying actually reforestation might have caused this pandemic there's more
00:28:17 forest so there's more bats because there's more insects so people are more likely to come into
00:28:21 contact with a bat well i mean you know honestly you know um i'm a scientist i believe you should
00:28:32 produce evidence for a theory not speculation um i have to ask you a little bit uh on the point
00:28:39 you you are very well known for your articles on the environment and particularly environmentalism
00:28:45 um and uh sort of coming it as it seems that the pandemic is or should we say either becoming
00:28:52 ingrained or towards its end uh suddenly now we are in the middle of this extraordinary
00:28:59 um i would say neurosis actually uh about climate change um you what were your observations about
00:29:07 what we've just had up in scotland cop 26 and do you think any evidence and hard fact came
00:29:15 out of that? Well, you say I'm well known for that, but I don't actually think that's particularly
00:29:22 true. I have written four books about genomics in one form or another, and none about climate
00:29:28 change. I have written many, many articles about things like genetically modified crops,
00:29:35 about innovation, which is one of my passionate topics, etc. But commentators say I'm best known
00:29:44 for my comments on climate change I don't think I am I over the years I have covered climate change
00:29:50 for about 35 years since I was science editor of The Economist when it first blew up as an issue
00:29:55 in the late 1980s and I've moved from being quite alarmed by it to being much less alarmed and I
00:30:03 think we're hugely exaggerating or at least the environmental activists are hugely exaggerating
00:30:08 the problem and coming up with bad solutions um so actually and and in the last couple of years
00:30:14 i've really not said anything about the topic which is very little um uh and i was out of the
00:30:21 country when the glasgow um took place um uh and was rather relieved i mean it just it seems to me
00:30:30 that the whole thing has has become unmoored from planet earth in a way and is is very distracted
00:30:37 very distinct from what the main requirements of ordinary people are.
00:30:44 The way to approach this issue is to think that human beings do need energy.
00:30:49 If you don't get available, reliable and affordable energy to people,
00:30:53 they can't live decent lives.
00:30:57 And there's still a billion people without access to reliable energy.
00:31:01 And a lot of them are depending on forests and going out and cutting down trees
00:31:04 and coming into contact with wildlife as a result.
00:31:06 So the more we can do to get people into a situation where they've got plenty of energy available, the better.
00:31:15 To do that in a way that doesn't increase the carbon dioxide in the air is something that we should be trying to do as well.
00:31:25 But there's no way we can achieve that with renewable energy on a massive scale.
00:31:32 It's too expensive, takes up too much land, involves too many resources, is too unreliable.
00:31:39 So it's got to be nuclear power if that's what you want to do.
00:31:41 And I think that's just the simple answer to this question.
00:31:46 We should press ahead with nuclear wherever we can.
00:31:49 But we've also got to bring down the price of nuclear because we've driven it up with a lot of things.
00:31:55 So that's my view on that.
00:31:56 But as I say, effectively for the last year and a half, I've been thinking about viruses, not climate change.
00:32:02 Yes, yes, yes, of course.
00:32:04 You did actually come up with a great name.
00:32:09 Instead of Insulate Britain, I saw you wrote Insult Britain recently.
00:32:15 There are people who are going around and gluing their faces to the ground and all of that.
00:32:22 Well, the elitism of a lot of these environmental pressure groups bothers me, actually.
00:32:31 This isn't a grassroots, ground-up organisation.
00:32:37 This is the middle class trying to do a bit of virtue signalling and having a bit of fun at it.
00:32:42 And I don't see why they should stop ordinary people getting to work.
00:32:45 Absolutely.
00:32:48 With that in mind, you said you were first writing about this.
00:32:53 when you were at The Economist 30 years ago.
00:33:00 Do you think that there is some kind of religious type zeal? I mean, because throughout that time,
00:33:09 there have been so many sort of warnings, we have 100 days left, or we have maybe a year
00:33:16 left or whatever it is from prince charles all the way down and i mean you know you've written
00:33:23 throughout that whole period it does seem to be the case that there is a kind of
00:33:28 sort of like a strange sort of armageddon type mentality you know sort of like deliver us from
00:33:34 this it's a kind of religious it's not just with climate change i mean i was young in the 1970s
00:33:43 there were a lot of environmental concerns then they related to the population explosion which
00:33:48 was going to be unstoppable the famine which was going to be inevitable the pollution which
00:33:52 was going to shorten our lifespan the the rainforests were disappearing the desert was
00:33:57 expanding the oil was running out you know there were all these scares about the environment
00:34:01 and they made me very pessimistic as a young person about the future of the world i don't
00:34:08 remember growing up saying anything optimistic to me at all about the future in those days so i
00:34:13 was shocked when suddenly in the 1980s i thought well hang on the living standards are improving
00:34:18 economic growth is happening i thought that wasn't supposed to happen yes i thought we were doomed
00:34:23 and then i noticed that these doom stories just kept being churned out by the media generation
00:34:29 after generation so i went back and looked at how long this had been going on and i traced it way
00:34:35 back i mean right back to the early 19th century i mean you know in the 1830s you've got macaulay
00:34:41 saying will everyone please shut up about how terrible this industrial revolution is because
00:34:46 actually it's probably raising people's living standards um and you know he says why is it that
00:34:51 with nothing but improvement behind us we're to expect nothing but deterioration before us
00:34:56 every generation says things have got better but they're about to start getting worse
00:35:01 we are at the turning point we the narcissistic us generation are the one who are about to go
00:35:08 from things getting better to things getting worse and i'm sorry after 200 years of that i take it
00:35:13 with a pinch of salt i think there's every reason to think that i indeed the intergovernmental panel
00:35:19 on climate change says this that our grandchildren will be richer than we are particularly in
00:35:25 developing countries if we allow innovation to flourish and yes there will be problems relating
00:35:32 to climate change and other things i'm a passionate environmentalist i'm a naturalist i've been
00:35:39 interested in environmentalism all my life i worked on environmental you won an award didn't
00:35:44 you for yeah i did for uh you know on my own property in the thumberland for the environmental
00:35:51 conservation but i worked on environmental uh conservation projects wildlife conservation
00:35:57 projects in the 1980s in India and Pakistan so it's it's you know it's in my blood but when I
00:36:04 look around the world and I look at what's threatening the wildlife that I love to watch
00:36:09 as a bird watcher it's much more invasive species than it is climate change that's the problem you
00:36:17 know you get invasive species and invasive diseases come in and damage habitats and ecosystems
00:36:25 systems and uh or you know wherever you go in the world where it's the Galapagos or Hawaii or
00:36:31 you know Iceland I've been to lots of places and always the most urgent environmental issue is an
00:36:38 invasive species one it's true here you know the gray squirrel is getting rid of the red squirrel
00:36:42 yes the signal crayfish is getting rid of the uh native crayfish and so on um so I just you know
00:36:50 I'm not saying climate change doesn't matter I've always said it it's it is an issue but I think
00:36:55 we've got it out of proportion with other environmental issues i mean over fishing of
00:36:59 the oceans is another one and so on you've you've written about innovation in business haven't you
00:37:04 and you know and basically so i take it from that you're saying look wait a minute you know we will
00:37:09 actually innovate as time goes on yes um my book which only came out last year is called how
00:37:16 innovation works and in in that i i simply take lots of examples of innovation from vaccines to
00:37:23 vaping you know to nuclear power to fertilizer to the airplane and I tell
00:37:31 their stories and I then try and see whether common themes emerge from those
00:37:35 stories and if so how they tell us how we should set up the world to to
00:37:41 encourage innovation because there is no doubt that innovation is the main
00:37:45 source of the incredible improvements in human living standards that we've seen
00:37:50 I mean, in my lifetime, the percentage of the world population that lives in extreme poverty, $1.90 a day is the current agreed level.
00:37:59 Is that what it is now?
00:38:00 In today's money.
00:38:02 Actually, I think it's in 2009 money.
00:38:04 Right.
00:38:05 But anyway, correct it for inflation.
00:38:08 The percentage of the world that lives at that level was over 50% when I was born.
00:38:13 It's now well less than 10%.
00:38:15 Now, that's amazing.
00:38:17 No one has ever lived through a diminution of poverty, child mortality, and other forms of misery as great as that.
00:38:27 No other human being has ever had that experience than we have in our generation.
00:38:32 And yet we're extremely pessimistic about the future.
00:38:35 I think the only reason to be pessimistic is if we somehow prevent innovation happening.
00:38:40 The problem is, you see, we seem not to be just, you know, depressed about it.
00:38:47 We're actually sort of going in on ourselves and disowning our past.
00:38:51 I mean, you know, you had Greta Thunberg talking about the Industrial Revolution.
00:38:55 Britain was particularly bad, you know, we've got a particular price to pay.
00:38:59 I think even the Prime Minister, I think, this past week has said something along the lines about the Industrial Revolution being, you know, a bit of a problem.
00:39:08 It's just like we're sort of going back now
00:39:10 and sort of like atoning.
00:39:12 Well, there's a terrible nostalgia
00:39:15 for a pre-industrial age.
00:39:18 You watch a Jane Austen adaptation
00:39:21 and you think, oh, how lovely.
00:39:22 They're all, you know, dancing under candles
00:39:25 in a country village.
00:39:30 There's no smoke.
00:39:31 There's no oil.
00:39:33 There's no cars running up the streets.
00:39:36 You know, doesn't it sound lovely?
00:39:37 hang on a minute examine the child mortality examine the the lifespan of these people
00:39:46 examine the price of light do you know how long you had to work in 1800 on the average wage in
00:39:54 the UK or the US to be able to earn one hour of light from a candle no six hours six hours of work
00:40:03 for one hour of light the average person could not afford a candle so when you see those Jane
00:40:08 Austen adaptations remember artificial light was a luxury of the rich in those days most things
00:40:14 were a luxury of the rich you know I have a passage in my book The Rational Optimist about
00:40:19 this you know where I describe an idyllic scene in a in a country village in 1800 and I say well
00:40:24 hang on a minute you know you know the father's cough is going to kill him within a year the
00:40:30 children have lice infested clothes the mother has never been to a town you know they've none
00:40:37 of them ever seen a play you know etc etc and i begin to sort of dismantle this romantic myth so
00:40:45 that we are we are haunted by this um uh rose-tinted nostalgia for the past uh you know
00:40:55 somebody once said you know anyone who thinks life was better in the in the 18th century just
00:41:00 mention one word to them dentistry dentistry i can think of antibiotics actually um the book is
00:41:09 now out viral um we have talked a bit about uh uh alina chan but she she's at just just to make
00:41:17 clear again she's not actually a journalist is she she's a no she's a she's a working scientist
00:41:21 a working scientist she's she's a um you know a very successful professional scientist working on
00:41:28 gene therapy and other molecular biology applications at the as I say the world's
00:41:35 leading institute she's got a fantastic career ahead of her doing that she sometimes stops and
00:41:42 says how have I got diverted yes into doing this crazy thing but she became such a reliable and
00:41:52 careful observer and contributor to the debate about the origins of covid largely on twitter
00:42:00 which was the one social media forum that didn't censor any discussion of a laboratory leak facebook
00:42:06 censored it if you said i think this piece of evidence points towards a laboratory leak being
00:42:12 the source of the virus you weren't allowed it was just wiped out twitter allowed it so these
00:42:18 sleuths these open source analysts um and some scientists including Alina had a conversation
00:42:26 saying have you seen this bit of evidence have you seen that bit of evidence which gradually grew
00:42:29 uh to the point where the um establishment could no longer ignore it um so she's got a fantastic
00:42:37 future as a scientist um uh it's been a remarkable experience for me i've never co-written a book
00:42:44 before we didn't meet until after the book was finished we met last week for the first time
00:42:50 which was very moving actually yes of course that's the way people of course we'd spend a huge
00:42:55 amount of time not only communicating in emails but also face to face on on uh on screen um uh
00:43:04 and uh she wouldn't let me get away with uh any mistakes or speculations or something you know
00:43:10 some of my drafts she'd say well hang on i'm not sure we've quite established that yes and i'm
00:43:15 saying well i think we have and she would say no we haven't you know and she's often she was always
00:43:18 right you know good point yeah no the facts don't quite go that far and we're not going to put
00:43:24 speculation in the book we're going to you know stick well as far as possible you know we have to
00:43:28 do some kind of speculation but not not significantly we're trying to stick to what
00:43:34 we know and what it's telling us the thing is what writing a book like this uh the story is
00:43:40 changing as you're writing it presumably yes i mean you know how long did this it was about a
00:43:45 year to write was it or more yeah we we we uh we pressed the button on doing it less than a year
00:43:51 ago um i did the first draft in three months which was something of a record she rewrote it in
00:43:58 three months we then rewrote each other's rewrites for a couple of months and right up till the
00:44:05 middle of September we were taking we were taking news into it you know but you know there's a good
00:44:11 example of a story that broke after the book was finished which is of relevance which was that some
00:44:17 French and Laotian scientists working in Laos found a virus that's even more closely related
00:44:25 to that one from a mine shaft. Very, very slightly, it's 96.8% instead of 96.2%, the same
00:44:32 as SARS-CoV-2. And you think, oh, okay, so maybe this virus came from Laos, not China, right? And
00:44:41 then just a couple of weeks ago, some documents dropped from a freedom of information request by
00:44:48 some of these other sleuths, which revealed that the EcoHealth Alliance, which is this American
00:44:54 group that collaborates with the Wuhan Institute of Virology were collecting viruses in Laos
00:45:00 among other countries in the period over the last five or so years and that instead of analysing
00:45:10 those viruses in Laos or in America they were sending them to their favourite partner in this
00:45:19 work the wuhan institute of virology so again even with these viruses from laos the only people
00:45:27 we know who took samples from bats and took them to a place called wuhan were the wuhan institute
00:45:34 of virology scientists we don't have any evidence for wildlife trade between those two sites but we
00:45:42 We do have evidence for scientists taking bat samples between these two sites.
00:45:48 So, you know, even that story, which was immediately greeted as being good news
00:45:56 for the wildlife trade theory, doesn't really help that theory at all
00:46:02 because we now know this connection.
00:46:06 We still don't know, of course, if they took this virus from those.
00:46:10 we do know that the virus that infects people has a particular genetic signature in it called a
00:46:18 furin cleavage site that none of the other viruses including this lous one has and no other SARS-like
00:46:25 virus has ever been found with this thing in it and that's a bit mysterious as to how it got there
00:46:31 this is the thing that makes it particularly easy for humans it's particularly infectious yeah it
00:46:36 makes it infectious and without it there would be no pandemic we know that because we've done
00:46:39 experiments have been done to take it out and the virus becomes less infectious so where did it get
00:46:45 that from well again some information came to light very recently that among the several labs
00:46:53 around the world that that did experiments putting fearing cleavage sites into virus genomes
00:46:59 deliberately to make them easier to grow in laboratories among those labs was the Wuhan
00:47:05 Institute of Virology and the specific proposal of doing so with novel SARS-like coronaviruses
00:47:13 was made in an application to the Pentagon by the EcoHealth Alliance in 2018 saying this is what
00:47:22 we'd like to do if you give us the money. They didn't give them the money so that's their excuse
00:47:26 well then they may not have done the experiment but it would have been helpful a year and a half
00:47:32 ago to come forward with this information and say by the way we did actually ask to do this
00:47:37 experiment so maybe our partners in china did it anyway so that's a relevant piece of information
00:47:43 and yet we had to find that out through a leak i'm sorry that the lack of transparency from
00:47:49 establishment science here has really shocked me as someone who is a passionate supporter of science
00:47:55 has been all his career. Is this the first book, do you know, to your knowledge, about the origins
00:48:03 of the virus? No, Shari Markson, who's an Australian journalist, produced a book a few
00:48:09 weeks ago called What Really Happened in Wuhan, which is also a very good book. Not quite as good
00:48:15 as ours. No, of course. That's why she's not on the show. I'm joking. I'm sure it's a perfectly
00:48:21 good book um but it's she goes into the politics of it slightly more than we do um and she speculates
00:48:29 a little more than we do i would say but uh and and there are other books out there and people
00:48:34 are saying oh come on why are you writing a book you know i mean this is too important for a book
00:48:39 well we felt that there's no other form of words that's long enough to go into all the arguments
00:48:48 for and against each hypothesis than a book it's all very well writing blog posts and tweets and
00:48:54 things like that but at some point you've got to sit down and put all the evidence in one place
00:48:59 stir it around put it in order and see what what you end up yeah and you know i partly wrote this
00:49:04 book helped write this book with alina because i wanted to satisfy myself yes as to what the
00:49:13 evidence suggests and for the future of course yeah i mean i very much hope that within a few
00:49:22 months or a few years we do know the answer for sure and we can look back and say well we didn't
00:49:28 need that book because we've now found out but i think even if that does happen the story of how we
00:49:33 found out and how we tried to find out is itself a very interesting story and the story of these
00:49:38 people these unsung heroes like the seeker and francisco ribera and charles small here in the uk
00:49:45 and people like that is is it is a is an important story that needs telling it's it's a slightly it's
00:49:51 almost a democratic thing yes yes actually ordinary people can can contribute to this story absolutely
00:49:59 absolutely viral the search for the origin of covet 19 by alina chan and matt ridley this is
00:50:07 again it's just out um i think extremely important book matt thank you very much for coming and
00:50:14 explaining about it it's an extraordinary story thank you very very much yeah i've thoroughly
00:50:20 enjoyed it and um thank you uh that's it for so what you're saying is uh this week
00:50:26 We shall see you next time.
00:50:28 Thank you.