New Culture Forum - November 19, 2021


The Origins of the Culture Wars: 100 Years of Identity Crisis. Plus: Is Hungary Being Demonised?

Nick Buckley: How I Fought Back Against Cancel Culture and Won Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19 -- Matt Ridley

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

159.86

Word count

6,692

Sentence count

105


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my guest
00:00:23 this week is someone who's been on the show before, Professor Frank Verady, Emeritus Professor of
00:00:30 Sociology at the University of Kent, the author of numerous books, the most recent of which is
00:00:36 this, A Hundred Years of Identity Crisis, Culture War Over Socialization. It's just come out,
00:00:46 But also I want to talk to him particularly about Hungary, where he's originally from,
00:00:53 and Poland and this ongoing demonization that seems to be happening with regard to these countries.
00:01:01 Thank you very much for joining us.
00:01:03 Lovely to be here.
00:01:04 Very good to see you again.
00:01:06 We're talking now, and the reason I want to start with this,
00:01:09 this because we've just had the anniversary October 23rd of the Hungarian uprising against
00:01:17 the Soviets or Hungarian revolution. You would have been around nine years old. What is your
00:01:26 memory of that in 1956? Well, I remember a number of things. What I remember most is
00:01:33 the few days leading up to it where all of a sudden all these illegal newsletters appeared
00:01:41 and my father would send me down to pick them up for him so he could read it and I just remember
00:01:46 seeing people in stalinist hungary who were usually very scared and reluctant to open their mouths
00:01:54 and who would walk around you know with their eyes averted or looking at their shoes all of
00:01:59 sudden transforming themselves into very loud noisy you know aggressive individuals criticizing the
00:02:08 government and I remember that transformation occurred very very fast and something that I
00:02:14 always feel really good about because it shows you how ordinary people can find their voice very
00:02:19 suddenly in certain circumstances but I remember the first day very very clearly because what
00:02:26 happened was my sister was very active for the student and they were very active in the original
00:02:33 sort of momentum behind the revolution and there was a big demonstration organized and the
00:02:39 demonstrators ended up in front of the Hungarian radio which was just about 100 meters diagonally
00:02:46 across from where I lived and so my sister took me out that night to kind of watch the proceedings
00:02:54 to yell and shout and all of a sudden we heard a burst of machine gun fire and what happened was
00:03:01 that the secret police who was in the building got scared about the noise and about the sort of the
00:03:08 aggressive nature of the demonstrators in the sense that they were demanding to be let in
00:03:14 and make a statement and the minute they started shooting my sister just grabbed me
00:03:20 and ran back home you know and that was at that point that's when it really broke out the armed
00:03:25 conflict broke out at that point in time and i also remember my father who became the one of the
00:03:33 the heads of the council the workers council in the fifth district of budapest and he made me used
00:03:39 to carry this council stamp these official sort of ink pads because he was scared that
00:03:51 it might be found so I used to go around in my school bag and walk around with it for him because
00:03:56 nobody would search a nine-year-old kid you know so I love incredible memories and it stayed with
00:04:03 me to this day because the two weeks during which the revolution succeeded were so joyous
00:04:10 and so intense that for me watching it almost like in front of my eyes it kind of imprinted
00:04:18 itself upon my imagination to this day and I almost remember every single hour of the first
00:04:24 two or three days all the way until the moment when it was crushed when the tanks came back
00:04:29 the soviet tanks came back and the fighting you know the fighters were defeated i remember that
00:04:35 very very clearly it was a a really transformative moment for me and and i think a lot of people that
00:04:40 were involved in that you have to remember people don't realize but if it hadn't been for that
00:04:46 revolution i don't think that you know the the unraveling of the russian empire would have taken
00:04:55 place so fast i don't think that regime change would have happened i think that after 56
00:05:01 people recognized in the communist party in the communist regime that you just couldn't
00:05:06 simply rule in the old way you had to make concessions and that's why hungary became the
00:05:11 most liberal in inverted commas of these states not really liberal but you know they allowed
00:05:16 people to have a certain amount of of freedom and i think that it was precisely because it was
00:05:23 clear that people just wouldn't put up with this regime of oppression indefinitely, that gradually
00:05:31 the Soviet leadership, the East European leadership, began to know that they were
00:05:36 really, really isolated and that they were living on borrowed time. When you say you remember
00:05:43 those first days before it was crushed, what is it you remember? I imagine, and I've never been
00:05:53 in the situation of course that it's just the sheer intensity and joy i don't know but what
00:05:58 was it you remember as a nine-year-old as a nine-year-old i remember some bad things for
00:06:04 example i remember on day two walking around my father on this boulevard and there were these
00:06:10 street cars that were they were off the track and i looked in then there were a couple of dead bodies
00:06:15 and i still remember my father putting his hands on over my eyes to make sure that i didn't see
00:06:20 see it and I remember those kinds of incidents but I also remember this one day I remember very
00:06:26 very clearly because I went to the playground where I used to play with my friends and in the
00:06:32 playground there were two tanks that were blown up by people that we knew they were barely older
00:06:38 than us they were like 16 17 year old kids who threw some Molotov cocktails into the Russian
00:06:43 tanks and blew them up and I remember watching you know sort of watching you know some of the kids
00:06:50 playing in the tank and then what happened was something that I don't quite understand
00:06:54 to this day what happened was that there was a few kids that I knew whose parents and family
00:07:02 were implicated in the regime who were different than we were we just never talked to them
00:07:07 never trusted them but there was one boy who was my friend who I didn't you know I didn't
00:07:11 know very much about his family but he came up to me and he said to me you know Frank
00:07:16 I'm really worried.
00:07:17 I said, why are you worried?
00:07:18 I'm worried because, you know, my dad is in the ABO, which was the secret police, and
00:07:24 I'm really worried that they're going to come and get him and, you know, sort of jail him
00:07:27 or beat him up or even execute him.
00:07:31 And I was shocked to hear that.
00:07:33 But contrary to what I thought I would do, which is to go and tell other people about
00:07:38 the family, I kind of said, well, look, I know the guy, you know, he's a friend of mine.
00:07:43 really rather that he wasn't you know put in a difficult situation so I just kept it to myself
00:07:50 and that's just remember the uh the inner tension you know I was very conflicted about what I should
00:07:55 do but in the end I said on the balance of things I'm not going to tell on him you know and that was
00:08:01 one that that day is so much in my memory you know all those conflicting emotions that kind of kicked
00:08:06 in what is the what is the popular memory now in in Hungary of that year would you say well it's
00:08:18 really funny I should say that because I remember going back first of all in 1969 with my girlfriend
00:08:24 I was hitchhiking around Europe I was a young university student and the first time I've been
00:08:30 back I was there for two days only and I kept trying to find out what people you know people
00:08:35 I knew and every time I saw somebody I knew I wanted to talk about 56 but didn't want to know
00:08:41 you know people were just really scared to talk about it because of all the repression that occurred
00:08:46 and one of the things that occurred gradually is that a lot of people just didn't want to talk
00:08:50 about it for decades and decades and decades and even after regime change when you had a new
00:08:57 regime being installed. The memory of the revolution was almost too raw or alternatively
00:09:05 people were too complicit in its crushing to want to discuss it. So the memory of the revolution
00:09:12 was really very much left on the side for a very long time until the Fidesz government
00:09:19 sort of was elected and even though the Fidesz government has been very prominent
00:09:25 in talking about it and celebrating it and promoting it and you know kind of
00:09:30 organizing cultural events around it the memory is still a little bit ambivalent so just to give
00:09:38 you an example about six seven months ago six seven months before the lockdown I went to Hungary to
00:09:45 give a lecture to a group of history teachers and afterwards they all came up to me and they said
00:09:51 you know Frank was it really so bad in the 50s that we needed a revolution in other words in
00:09:57 their mind they just they just completely could not conceptualize how horrible that period was
00:10:04 and they couldn't really understand the rationale for the revolution why that
00:10:08 occurred why that it broke out so I think it tells us that historical memory and the legacy
00:10:15 of the achievement of the Hungarian people is not something you can take for granted
00:10:20 anymore in Hungary than you could do in England with the with the historical legacy of Britain
00:10:25 it's always being contested people forget they develop very selective memories but I think that
00:10:31 by and large the memory I think that for a lot of people 56 has still served as a it's probably the
00:10:39 single most important source of cultural inspiration in their lives well I suppose
00:10:45 what a little bit like the Battle of Britain in this country you know in terms of folkloric memory
00:10:54 that still balks hugely. It is and I think you raised a very important parallel in a number of
00:11:01 respects. It's interesting to note that you know when I first read about the Battle of Britain
00:11:07 it was unambiguously celebrated in the most positive way but given the impulse to rewrite
00:11:12 history now you find a lot of people are saying well actually the blitz spirit wasn't really
00:11:19 you know what it was meant to be there was a lot of you know black marketing going on you know bad
00:11:24 things were going on people weren't as brave as the books tell us you know and anyway look at what
00:11:32 what the British air force did in Hamburg you know sort of so there's a kind of equivalence
00:11:36 drawn between what the Germans did to Britain and vice versa so there's a there's a kind of sad
00:11:41 attempt to de-legitimate the importance of that experience and similarly on a much smaller
00:11:49 scale there are attempts to say well actually you know some people actually argue some leftists in
00:11:56 in Hungary that if it hadn't been for a revolution then regime change would have happened faster
00:12:01 that somehow it was on or it was unnecessary or it actually slowed things down completely
00:12:07 rewriting history in a way that violates the fundamental facts of the of the time.
00:12:15 So really in many ways it's still kind of looked at ambiguously is what you're saying?
00:12:23 By some, I mean not by the government and not by the majority of the people because
00:12:28 the majority of people support the government and even significant section of the opposition.
00:12:34 I think what's happening now is that there's an attempt by different political forces to interpret the revolution in different ways, to give a different kind of meaning to it.
00:12:43 So there are debates about whether it was a working class revolution, about class issues, whether it was a revolution for national independence, whether it was an anti-communist one.
00:12:55 there's all kinds of different interpretations and the reality is that you know every revolution
00:13:02 is complex and people have different motives but the key motive behind the events of 56
00:13:08 was the affirmation of national independence of national sovereignty and that's that to me is
00:13:15 really cannot be contested in in terms of historical facts what is your when did you
00:13:21 come to Britain? Well, basically what happened was that we fled Hungary in November 56. We spent two
00:13:28 months in Austria and we ended up in Canada, in French Canada, where I went to school. I grew up
00:13:34 there and when I was 21, finished university, I decided to do my PhD in London. And the plan was
00:13:43 that this was in 69, that I would spend two, three years in England and then go back. And then
00:13:49 one morning i woke up and i realized i spent all my adult life in this country
00:13:55 but do you have what is your connection now with hungary i mean has it grown stronger as you've
00:14:01 gotten older or what well for a long time i felt uneasy about getting involved in hungary i don't
00:14:09 know why it was and although i kept an eye on what's going on in hungary i very rarely went back
00:14:16 and I think that what happened was that the the first event that really set me thinking was I
00:14:23 think in in 206 there was a at that point there was a socialist government so in in Hungary and
00:14:32 this government was extremely sort of corrupt in in the way that it handled financial affairs
00:14:40 it essentially was complicit in privatizing the state property of the old regime and just giving
00:14:47 it to you know their mates to their leads and what happened was there was the the prime minister
00:14:55 the socialist prime minister was a big favorite of the european union leadership
00:15:00 made a speech where he said look we've been lying to the population about the fact that
00:15:06 things are going to be better we were lying about the population about hiding all the economic
00:15:11 problems that we've created and that speech was somehow leaked out and when it was leaked out
00:15:19 and people heard but you know that the prime minister was saying that uh they were lying
00:15:24 you know mass demonstrations broke out which which which then got you know really badly
00:15:30 brutally sort of handled by the police and what happened was that the media here in England,
00:15:37 I remember this very very clearly, was denouncing the demonstrators like football hooligans and
00:15:44 right-wing thugs and you know neo-fascists and everywhere I was looking at all the European press,
00:15:49 the Western European press, and they were being all denigrated and almost criminalized even though
00:15:55 this was just a genuine you know sort of protest movement by people who feel that they've been
00:16:02 cheated and let down and I think it was at that time that you know sort of I remember writing an
00:16:08 article and making the point that you know sort of what the EE was saying is that they don't mind
00:16:15 liars you know like Gurchani the prime minister as long as there are liars yes you know sort of
00:16:21 and that kind of double standard from for which the brussels bureaucracy is very famous
00:16:26 was something i really picked up at that particular point in time and i think from
00:16:30 that point onwards i became more and more interested and in the last five or six years
00:16:35 i started going back quite regularly so i spent a lot of time there now
00:16:39 and i you know one of the things i tried to do is to act as a almost like a mediator between
00:16:47 hungary and the west where i try to explain to western and a western audience what hungary is
00:16:52 doing what's important about what hungary is doing and i try to explain to hungarians you know what's
00:16:58 going on in the west because they find it very difficult to understand the hostility that's often
00:17:03 targeted against them they also find it very difficult to understand you know sort of how this
00:17:09 crazy identity politics which is quite incomprehensible to them is just you know in
00:17:14 ascendancy all over the West. So I tried to sort of act as a bit of an intellectual kind of bridge
00:17:22 between these two societies. Well we'll talk about that in a minute, the identity politics.
00:17:28 You've actually talked about that on this channel before, I mean Netflix and all of this kind of
00:17:35 it's happening but I mean the fact is is you say you know you you want to try to explain to a hostile
00:17:45 environment here uh you've got your work cut out haven't you because there really is and I would
00:17:50 say a growing demonization you wrote about this recently Hungary and Poland in particular that
00:17:57 there is this uh belief that amongst journalists and colonists here that people are you know that
00:18:05 these countries are incipient dictatorships right and this is just not the case is it no i mean i
00:18:11 think there's a almost like a parallel universe that's been created which anybody that goes to
00:18:16 hungary doesn't recognize so for example the eu frequently denounces hungary for being authoritarian
00:18:25 and they talk about the putinization of hungary that somehow it's going to become this
00:18:30 naked dictatorship and when i tell you know sort of a western audience all you got to do is compare
00:18:36 how the hungarian government handles a protest demonstration and how the government of macron
00:18:43 in france handles it you get a different reality because in you know when the the gilets john
00:18:49 demonstrate in france they get killed you know almost 12 people got killed in recent years and
00:18:55 and the police violence that's used against them is quite considerable when when when you have a
00:19:01 hundred thousand protesters in budapest yelling and shouting at the government and and just
00:19:08 basically kind of sitting down and you know you know sort of uh really demonstrating in a very
00:19:13 kind of uh militant way the police watch them and the police just make sure that you know order is
00:19:20 there's no violence, no nothing. And yet, you know, Hungary is authoritarian, whereas France is super democratic and is, you know, super liberal, so it's a kind of double standard. I can give you a lot of examples. I think the most grotesque example that really riles me up is when they say that the Hungarian government is anti-Semitic. And the interesting thing is that Budapest has got this, you know, the second largest Jewish community in the whole of Europe. It's got a flourishing Jewish culture.
00:19:50 and very often when my English friends come to Budapest and I show them around
00:19:54 they make the point that they don't they see all these all these posters
00:19:58 advertising you know Yiddish klezmer music or advertising Jewish cultural
00:20:03 activities and there is not a single graffiti on any of these posters and they
00:20:08 make the point imagine if similar posters were put up in East London or in
00:20:12 Bradford yes they would be defaced you know almost immediately so you know and
00:20:19 And the other example I use is that, you know, there is about eight or nine Jewish restaurants
00:20:22 in Budapest.
00:20:23 Not a single one of them has got any police protection or there's no need for guards.
00:20:28 You go to Brussels or Paris, it's unthinkable that you would have a Jewish restaurant without
00:20:33 there being two policemen, you know, standing outside to kind of protect it.
00:20:38 So there's a kind of weird, you know, sort of double standard, a kind of fantasy sort
00:20:45 of uh hungary that's been constructed almost in a disney fight kind of a way and yet you know
00:20:52 it's very powerful i know personally i know personally that ever since i've been actively
00:20:57 talking about hungary ever since i wrote a book a few years ago called the culture wars in european
00:21:05 union the case of hungary ever since i did that a lot of media outlets that would publish my stuff
00:21:12 or would interview me I just you know cut me out completely yeah you took my
00:21:18 here in Britain also in a few other countries and and it's almost as if I
00:21:23 become a persona non grata you know almost overnight just because I have I
00:21:28 have good things to say about what's happening in Hungary I mean I'm not a an
00:21:33 apologist you know and I've never said that the Hungarian government is or a
00:21:38 bunch of angels and they don't make any mistakes all I make I'm really kind of
00:21:42 of pointing out is there is a really sort of horrible propaganda campaign that's been organized
00:21:50 that's very systemic and totally contradicts the reality of what's happening in
00:21:57 Hungarian and for that matter Polish society. There's also a very particular problem
00:22:05 with the EU at the moment is now while the people remainers, particularly in pro-EU people like
00:22:11 David Aronovich, I think you mentioned in your comment, they have particularly got it in, haven't
00:22:16 they, for Hungary or Poland, excuse me, simply because it's about parliamentary sovereignty,
00:22:22 isn't it? I mean that they're going against the idea of supranational sovereignty. Exactly,
00:22:28 so all the important ideals that motivated pro-Brexit supporters are now institutionalized
00:22:37 in hungary that is the official doctrine of of national independence and parliamentary sovereignty
00:22:44 not being part of this globalist you know sort of uh cultural outlook i mean all those things
00:22:51 are there and in their eyes you know sort of uh the hungarian government and hungarian society
00:22:58 is committing every single cultural crime that they have ever imagined on all the important
00:23:04 questions they have a they have a world view that's almost almost polar opposite but not only
00:23:12 that but unlike other governments the hungarian government actually and aggressively you know sort
00:23:18 of idealizes those kind of traditional values yes which they love which they really really hate and
00:23:25 and it's probably the only government because although there is also the polish government is
00:23:31 is also not like, the Polish prime minister and the Polish government are not nearly as committed
00:23:39 to the promotion of that culture and the long-term sort of projection of a different way of living
00:23:48 and being as a human being that the Hungarian government does, because whatever you think
00:23:53 about them, the prime minister in particular is a man of ideals and principles, not a pragmatic,
00:24:00 not simply a kind of pragmatic politician.
00:24:03 And I think that kind of marks him out.
00:24:05 There's very few people around now who actually live by their principles
00:24:10 rather than simply by the dictates of the next election.
00:24:15 This is a point, really, isn't it?
00:24:18 Even though they might talk about sovereignty and parliamentary sovereignty in these things,
00:24:22 essentially it is a distaste, isn't it, for what Prime Minister Orban or the government stands for,
00:24:29 what it sees as important. Are you a supporter of Orban? Are you a fan of the Prime Minister?
00:24:39 Well, I think that in the world that we live in, you have to make choices. And I think that
00:24:45 if I've got to make a choice between the sovereignty, a political culture that is
00:24:51 promoted by Orban's government, I'm wholeheartedly behind that. And I'm wholeheartedly behind
00:24:58 his attempt to protect hungary and affirm its independence hungary has very rarely enjoyed
00:25:05 national independence and and and i think that the historical legacy is very much preying on
00:25:10 on the mind of him and his colleagues so i think that's something i really support i think i think
00:25:15 the hungarian government has done some wonderful things as well um i think that their family policy
00:25:21 is really good in the way that they are providing a lot of support for for women and families in the
00:25:28 sense of providing daycare making it easier to bring kind of children up and i think some of
00:25:34 their economic policies have really worked quite well they're they are old-fashioned conservative
00:25:41 not liberal kind of economic policies where they they have gone out of their waste to provide
00:25:46 a social net particularly for the rural poor and just in general sort of helping people get on the
00:25:55 mortgage ladder. They've done a tremendous amount of work to provide people with the resources to
00:26:01 buy their first home. So a lot of those things I think are extraordinarily creatively done.
00:26:07 Obviously, like other governments, they make mistakes, they screw things up. That comes
00:26:13 the territory. So I wouldn't say that I'm an uncritical supporter, but I do think that
00:26:21 they have really marked out for themselves a very strong foundation to develop a more
00:26:28 independent and genuinely conservative, not kind of rhetorically kind of conservative
00:26:36 political sort of outlook. And also just valuing a pride in the nation-state
00:26:44 and the fact that it's a Christian nation-state. What I hear quite a bit here is people sort of
00:26:52 say well you know if things get really bad here there's always it used to be there's always America
00:26:59 or it's not America anymore. Increasingly people say well actually there's you know there's Hungary,
00:27:05 there is Central Europe, Eastern Europe, where people still value these things.
00:27:10 We are at the beginning of an election campaign, would you say, in Hungary?
00:27:16 Is it sort of like, has it really kicked off?
00:27:18 Yeah, it's a non-stop election at the moment.
00:27:21 The election is going to be held in April.
00:27:23 April, yeah.
00:27:24 And it's going to be a very close election,
00:27:26 because all the opposition parties from the far right to the left have united
00:27:31 in a very unprincipled way.
00:27:34 so basically they formed an electoral bloc and they're putting forward one candidate
00:27:39 to run against orban so it's going to be a fairly close election in the sense that you know it's
00:27:45 going to be you know sort of totally polarized you either vote for one or the other kind of situation
00:27:51 myself i think that the uh government is you know is likely to to win the election
00:27:56 mainly because it's got a very solid base of support uh and that's that's all base of support
00:28:03 is not going to disintegrate anytime soon whereas the opposition you know sort of
00:28:10 although they've been able to get you know everybody together from you know all across
00:28:14 the political divide there's a lack of solidity uh in in in there yes yeah but it's it's gonna
00:28:21 be it's gonna be very very exciting in the sense that uh in the in in the previous election it was
00:28:27 very clear that Orbán would win and also the one before that. So it is, despite what one hears,
00:28:35 it is a genuinely democratic political campaigning that is taking place.
00:28:41 Who is the candidate that has drawn, all these parts have drawn? You said there's one candidate.
00:28:47 Yeah, he's a man who's lived most of his recent life in Canada and America,
00:28:55 came back to hungary and and i think a couple of years ago he managed to get elected as a mayor
00:29:02 of a small city in hungary and he did that primarily by uniting the whole opposition he
00:29:08 got he got again the on the left to the far right is basically one candidate yeah and to everybody's
00:29:14 surprise he did he defeated the fidesz mayor who was who had become relatively unpopular so that's
00:29:21 how he became propelled on a national stage he hasn't got a real party and that's one of the
00:29:28 interesting things because if should the opposition win and he gets becomes prime minister he hasn't
00:29:34 got a parliamentary majority or parliamentary support so i would probably i would think that
00:29:41 he wouldn't last very long he'd be replaced by an opposition leader with a more solid party support
00:29:48 but the reason why they're running him rather than anybody else, the reason why the opposition
00:29:52 has united behind him is because he claims to be conservative, he claims to be religious,
00:29:59 you know he's got seven kids, so you know the opposition reckons that a left-wing candidate
00:30:06 is unlikely to beat Orban, so they're trying to find somebody who's like you know sort of their
00:30:12 equivalent, you know, more Orbán than Orbán in many ways, even though his politics is really the
00:30:21 politics of the European Union. If you can imagine Tony Blair and David Cameron had a child,
00:30:28 you know, so that would be him. What a thought! Excuse me. You mentioned
00:30:35 that the kind of identity politics that take up so many hours of our time here you know would
00:30:45 still strike most people in Hungary as being um strange yeah um by way of rather clumsy segue
00:30:54 your book a hundred years of identity crisis which looks actually doesn't it at the very
00:30:59 genesis of what we're talking about now with identity politics would people looking in Hungary
00:31:07 reading your book would they sort of nod along and say oh yes that's true that's true
00:31:13 or or or is this something which is you know are you talking about western Europe here
00:31:17 well well the thing is is that although these kinds of ideals are particularly strong in
00:31:26 the Anglo-American sphere and particularly in the urban centers and particularly amongst the
00:31:31 university educated professional classes that's where their heartland is not in you know sort of
00:31:38 not in Bradford or not in Sunderland nevertheless because of the power behind it which is essentially
00:31:46 fueled by American self-power it does spread everywhere so you know Germans laugh about it
00:31:52 and all of a sudden they're kind of deciding what kind of pronouns to use and similarly if you look
00:31:58 at east europe i i remember very very clearly about three and a half years ago i gave a speech
00:32:03 in hungary about gender politics about the whole obsession with gender identity in the west
00:32:10 and i remember at the time some people said to me afterwards that's very very interesting frank
00:32:15 it's not relevant to us because that will never take off in in budapest and i said yeah i said
00:32:20 i'll bet you my 50 pounds against your one pound they're very very soon you know you'd be going
00:32:26 to be coming up against it and sure as sure as as my 50 pounds and their one pound it's really
00:32:33 beginning to surface in budapest where you have you know sort of the almost like the aping of
00:32:40 cultural habits first amongst university people but then gradually within that cultural you know
00:32:47 sort of milieu kind of seeping in and so you now have a situation where you know sort of
00:32:53 many of the opposition politicians have embraced the EU LGBTQ you know sort of identity
00:33:02 sort of orientation and although they're not going to be that noisy about it because they know it's
00:33:07 not going to be a vote winner nevertheless you know that it's only a matter of time
00:33:13 before it spreads from that core, that core of academics and cultural professionals to the rest
00:33:21 of society, or at least in the urban environment. So, I think that those Hungarians imagine that
00:33:29 they're immunized from this or complacent. I mean, thankfully, at the moment, you know,
00:33:35 sort of good sense prevails in many sectors of society. And it does feel like, you know,
00:33:40 like this is home you know the sense of real real old-fashioned old-school you know sort of
00:33:48 attitudes that are being demonstrated but that's that is not going to stay the way it is for any
00:33:54 length of time unless it's challenged they wouldn't uh the trans thing hasn't got a big purchase
00:34:00 there at the moment i mean here in london you know we've got uh in camden we've got these new
00:34:07 uh road crossings that are in trans colors and you know it's just relentless all the time i mean
00:34:15 if someone would someone wouldn't presumably put down a trans crossing in downtown budapest would
00:34:21 they possibly the new mayor of budapest who's my but look the way that it works is that if you're
00:34:28 a kid if you're like an 18 year old kid and you were in budapest and you want to be a little bit
00:34:34 edgy and you want to demonstrate you're a bit of a rebel and you want to give your parents
00:34:39 and and and the adults a hard time you're going to pick up on all this stuff that you see online
00:34:45 and you're going to put on the lgbtq hat one of those hats you know or you're going to uh sort of
00:34:50 do something that an act of defiance that's expressed through the uh transgenderist ideology
00:34:57 because that's that's the way these things go now you know i can live with that i can live with you
00:35:03 you know, sort of rebellious kids doing that, as long as there are sensible and intelligent
00:35:08 grown-ups who are able to manage this and deal with this and affirm, you know, sort
00:35:15 of the value that at the end of the day, whether we like it or not, you know, there is two
00:35:21 sexes, you know, there are men and there are women, and we mustn't violate scientific
00:35:28 facts in the interest of you know celebrating these rainbow colors so i do think that you know
00:35:36 i i am worried because i know how these things can spread very very fast i mean i i spent most
00:35:42 of my adult life in a university environment and i can see how the most see how the most grotesque
00:35:50 ideas can take hold very very fast and then spread like wildfire as long as people acquiesce to it
00:35:57 and look the other way and don't take a stand against it would you even go would you go would
00:36:03 you pursue an academic career now if you were say like in your early 20s to be honest this is an
00:36:12 interesting question because the university system has changed so much i would but the reason why i
00:36:20 would is because i don't want to leave all those kids under the influence of one body of opinion
00:36:28 i think there are a lot of people i know are really good people who think the way that you and
00:36:32 i think who tell me that they would never go anywhere near university because of the kind of
00:36:38 culture that prevails there and i tell them that that's an easy way out that to some extent as an
00:36:44 educator as an intellectual you got a duty to do whatever you can to stand up against
00:36:50 this to provide an alternative poll I mean look what happened in Sussex University when
00:36:55 they got rid of Kathleen Stock to me the really horrible thing about it was more than anything
00:37:00 wasn't what they did to Kathleen it was the fact that not a single academic signed a letter
00:37:06 of support in her own university I mean her own philosophy department was just conspicuously
00:37:12 silent can you imagine your colleagues turning their backs on you your colleagues even if they
00:37:18 disagree with you just ignoring the fundamental precepts of academic freedom so when you have
00:37:26 that kind of climate of opinion we need more people in there I don't need to create new
00:37:33 universities which I'm all for or alternatively we need to be there and provide a counterpoint
00:37:39 to the dominant ideological sort of mood on these campuses, so I would even though
00:37:46 I know I wouldn't you know I wouldn't have the kind of easy time that I had in my own academic
00:37:50 career, it would be a struggle to be there and I would need you know a few friends to
00:37:57 give me stiff drinks and watch my back. Well I think what is quite encouraging is
00:38:03 Kathleen Stock has just joined up with this new university, I think the University of Austin,
00:38:10 that's right, yeah, yeah, which is not sort of actually operating quite yet, that's right, yeah,
00:38:16 but it's a step in the right direction. This book does, as I say, lay the roots of a lot
00:38:24 of what we're talking about a long time ago, doesn't it, in particular in the whole point of
00:38:31 socialization do you mean of children yeah i think the culture war always begins in the nursery
00:38:37 in the nursery yeah we don't realize that but it's uh ever since uh the late 19th century
00:38:44 it's been through the attempt to influence children that the culture war has kicked in
00:38:50 and after i wrote this book uh what look what happened in virginia where you had the attempt by
00:38:57 the teaching profession to bring in transgenderist ideals in the classroom, to bring in critical
00:39:05 race theory.
00:39:06 And when the parents basically said, I don't want my kid to learn all this stuff, they
00:39:12 were denounced as domestic terrorists, right?
00:39:15 So a huge row broke out.
00:39:18 And that to me is like, you know, what the culture war is really all about.
00:39:21 By the time he gets to the university, you know, sort of one side or the other has one.
00:39:26 too late to turn the clock back because if young people are educated into a view of the world that
00:39:33 is against the the legacy of western civilization that is suspicious of britain's past that is all
00:39:40 too ready to make fun of it and everything that is british by the time they get to university
00:39:45 it's really too late to do very much about that so what i've done is i kind of showed the genesis
00:39:51 the genealogy of the culture war, which began a long time ago.
00:39:56 A hundred years? A century?
00:39:57 Yeah, and more than a century. And it's only now crystallized into becoming the dominant
00:40:05 sort of kind of battlefield. Because, you know, at the moment, we're not arguing that much about
00:40:11 taxation policies or about social spending, spending a lot of arguments about identity
00:40:16 related issues. And that took a long, long, long time to come in. And in the book, I trace the
00:40:23 origins. And the reason why I do it is not because I want people to learn about history, but I want
00:40:28 people to understand what is special, what is distinct about the way in which the values that
00:40:35 have made Britain Britain and made human civilization what it is, how those values
00:40:43 are have such a precarious status at the moment and if you understand that i think a lot more
00:40:49 people would be willing to mobilize against it and spread the word you've actually i mean identifying
00:40:58 the very roots of this um there are still a lot of people around who think this is kind of
00:41:06 just like modish fashion, isn't that right? And it's absolutely not as we're seeing in America,
00:41:12 as you said. A Hundred Years of Identity Crisis by Professor Frank Verady. The book is out now,
00:41:20 is it? It is indeed. Thank you very much for talking to us about that, but also about Hungary
00:41:28 and about the past in Hungary. Yeah, it was a pleasure to reminisce. No, it's wonderful,
00:41:34 I've got to know at least Budapest myself a bit lately and I love it and looking forward to going
00:41:42 back again thank you very much Larry thank you that's it for this time on so what you're saying
00:41:48 is we shall see you next time thank you very much bye