New Culture Forum - August 11, 2020


Has The Church's Shocking Response To BLM & Covid Shown It's No Longer Fit For Purpose?

Laurence Fox: The Battle Of Our Time Is A Defence Of Britain & Its Values Michael Collins: The Demonisation of the White Working Class

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

199.28

Word count

7,440

Sentence count

267


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to counterculture I'm Peter Whittle now over the past four months in this
00:00:19 national crisis which started off with Covid of course and then has sort of gone on to be
00:00:24 a cultural onslaught which started with the Black Lives Matter protests. What have we heard from
00:00:30 the church? Well most people during this time would maybe remember two things. During Covid
00:00:37 it was that the churches were not open and during the Black Lives Matter that the Archbishop of
00:00:43 Canterbury wanted to revise the statues in Canterbury Cathedral. So is that the extent
00:00:50 of the church's response to this extraordinary situation we find ourselves in. What does it
00:00:56 actually mean? Does it mean that the church is actually relevant now? What church in fact are
00:01:00 we talking about? Are we just talking about the Church of England? Now with me to discuss this
00:01:06 today I'm very pleased that we have Ben Loughnane who is a theologian as well as a communications
00:01:12 consultant. Mark Sidwell who is the deputy editor of Smith Magazine and also author of the NCA
00:01:20 book, The Long March, which you might be aware of, and of course, Rafe Hadelman-Ku, who is
00:01:25 an historian and commentator from the New Culture Forum. Thanks for coming and talking
00:01:32 about this. Can I start by asking you, has the church made itself irrelevant, Mark, recently?
00:01:40 I am just astonished by the church's behaviour in this, and the thing that I think that terrifies
00:01:45 me the most is that I think they think that they've done rather well. They seem quite
00:01:49 pleased with themselves. And I was already a little distressed with the state of the
00:01:55 church. I knew it was very politicised. You know, I'm an Anglican myself. I go to an Anglo-Catholic
00:02:00 church. But the church hierarchy, I didn't think very much of. But I had no idea that
00:02:05 they would willingly just step aside in the middle of the greatest national crisis since
00:02:10 the Second World War and not become part of the story. Closing down the churches like
00:02:15 they did, which they didn't have to do in the way that they did. They banned clergy
00:02:19 from going in on their own to pray in the churches. They banned people from going in
00:02:24 on their own to sit in churches outside services. The government didn't make them do that. And
00:02:28 it just cut off the church as part of what could serve people in a complete spiritual
00:02:34 and moral and physical crisis. And I think that was just an appalling decision that really
00:02:39 ruled themselves out as the centre of national life in the way that the national church is supposed
00:02:43 to be you you actually i remember told us a couple of weeks ago you popped into westminster abbey
00:02:48 which is not very far from where we're filming and there was to say you were the only one in there
00:02:52 weren't you uh when i'm in london you know and i went into westminster abbey just after much later
00:02:57 in the crisis when they did eventually allow people in for private prayer and yes they were
00:03:01 all set up for queues and queues of people to come in and i was literally the only person in there
00:03:06 praying and but the same is true i also live in rural suffolk and in my little village they open
00:03:11 the church now for private prayer and i go in and i sit there and um i'm the only person there as
00:03:17 well and there's something there about the general state of the church and the state of
00:03:21 church attendance as well but it is a sign of how people do feel that it's not it's not serving them
00:03:27 perhaps do you do you know what was behind the system was it just purely about social distancing
00:03:33 gone crazy what well i think what we're seeing now really is an increasing alienation in the
00:03:40 in the church akin to what we're seeing in other institutions and it is this disconnect between
00:03:45 the leadership and the laity and the leadership really are traditional men who are out of step
00:03:50 and out of kilter and are trying their best to do what they think is right without any actual logic
00:03:55 behind their decisions and policies and they're actually acting on the spur of the moment based
00:04:00 upon knee-jerk reactions based upon small elite coteries of men and getting together to decide
00:04:05 how they're going to act without any consultation of the population who are of the faith.
00:04:11 And so what you're seeing really is this attempt by the church to be seen to be on page,
00:04:17 to be woke, to be relevant, whereas that's not actually what's being demanded by the laity.
00:04:21 And so you've really got this three-tiered structure to the church at the moment where
00:04:25 where you've got this disconnected leadership
00:04:29 who are basically privately educated members of the elite,
00:04:32 not dissimilar to David Cameron's background or public school boys.
00:04:36 Then you have this left-leaning clergy,
00:04:38 and you have the laity who are on the right.
00:04:41 And those are the people who you would think would be the flock
00:04:44 that they want to actually tend to,
00:04:45 but they're trying to appeal to a population who aren't interested,
00:04:49 and they're alienating their own population by doing so.
00:04:51 And so they're going to hemorrhage more and more numbers
00:04:54 without gaining any new recruits by following these silly policies,
00:04:57 be it COVID or be it Black Lives Matter.
00:04:59 Yeah, well, you say they're trying to appeal to the population.
00:05:02 I'm not convinced they are anymore.
00:05:03 I think you're right about these narrow elite interests.
00:05:07 I think the people they're trying to appeal to are their own class.
00:05:09 They see themselves really as sort of management consultant types
00:05:13 who are part of this managerial class, this political class.
00:05:17 They don't really see themselves as churchmen with a distinctive mission.
00:05:21 And so they're trying to talk to the other people in government
00:05:23 and important, powerful positions and say,
00:05:25 look, we know the opinions we're supposed to have.
00:05:27 We're woke, we're diverse, you know,
00:05:29 we're going to go really hard on our targets
00:05:32 on climate change and carbon emissions,
00:05:34 but they're not interested in the other stuff.
00:05:36 You know, I mean, the Brexit divide
00:05:38 is a very striking way of thinking about this, OK?
00:05:41 75% of people who identify as Anglicans voted for Brexit.
00:05:45 75.
00:05:46 75 overall.
00:05:47 And obviously that's an older demographic in general,
00:05:49 but even among the younger demographics,
00:05:50 significantly more self-identified Anglicans voted for Brexit than didn't.
00:05:55 There's like half of them, as opposed to be about a third in the normal population at that age, below 50, 40.
00:06:01 Among the bishops of the Church of England, of which there's about 100,
00:06:05 you know, across all of them, not just the big three,
00:06:07 one came out in favour of Brexit.
00:06:10 That tells you everything you need to know about how distant they are
00:06:13 from the people who actually want to go to their churches.
00:06:15 That's right, that's the disconnect, and that's what you're actually seeing right now.
00:06:18 You have the Archbishop of Canterbury himself, who has spoken out against universal credit,
00:06:22 who has spoken out against capitalism, who is pro-open borders, who has spoken out against Brexit.
00:06:28 And we know full well that that is not the belief and view of the majority of people who attend church on all of these policies.
00:06:33 Now, no one's saying that the church shouldn't have positions.
00:06:36 The church should stand for an end to exploitation, should stand for an end to injustice.
00:06:40 but that doesn't mean adopting partisan policies or adopting policies of a political party
00:06:46 or indeed of a movement like Black Lives Matter, and that's what we're seeing.
00:06:51 Ben, this was all churches that were closed, wasn't it, in Britain?
00:06:56 But I mean, there is a difference, is there not, obviously between...
00:06:59 We're talking about the Church of England, but the Catholic Church,
00:07:02 Has that been equally as sort of ingratiating to the Woke Brigade as the Anglican Church?
00:07:12 Well, in terms of coronavirus, certainly the Catholic Church was not much better, I don't think, than the Anglicans.
00:07:19 You know, churches were closed and in fact certain churches closed even before the government guidelines said that they should.
00:07:25 Yeah, some Catholic churches closed even before then.
00:07:27 So there was a failure.
00:07:28 I think people need the church more than ever during times of crisis.
00:07:32 It's sort of its function, its earthly function, is to provide comfort to people when they're most at their need.
00:07:37 And the sort of evangelistic opportunities during coronavirus were huge.
00:07:41 And the church, rather than opening their doors, shut them.
00:07:44 And rather than welcoming people in and saying, you know, you're thinking more about death and, you know, an end of life and what happens afterwards.
00:07:52 Rather than saying, we have the answers to these questions, they said, oh, don't gather.
00:07:57 Don't come near us.
00:07:59 Don't sneeze on us.
00:08:00 If you come, you know, wear a face mask and stay six feet away.
00:08:03 And it's completely the wrong message to send during times of crisis.
00:08:07 And I quite agree with your point, you know, during times of crisis, that that's what they need.
00:08:13 But where were they?
00:08:15 This is the point. When we talk about moral guidance, yes, you've actually said it.
00:08:19 You know, basically, it's a time where we are actually thinking about life and death and what might happen.
00:08:26 That is actually, that would have been their function.
00:08:29 During the Second World War, lots of, I think, erroneous,
00:08:32 but lots of comparisons were made with the Second World War
00:08:34 and the current situation.
00:08:35 The churches absolutely were open during the Blitz.
00:08:39 Well, there was an enormous religious revival.
00:08:41 Was there?
00:08:42 Yeah, yeah.
00:08:42 C.S. Lewis and Tolkien, people like that, were fascinated by it.
00:08:45 And obviously, C.S. Lewis's fame as a sort of secular preacher
00:08:50 really grew during the Second World War.
00:08:52 That was partly the American audience, but it was also true here.
00:08:54 It was huge church attendance.
00:08:56 and okay it might have been reasonable not to have services but there was something about not having
00:09:01 these physical places where you could just go by yourself and I don't think the British in general
00:09:05 are deeply you know theological people really they're not intellectually engaged in that way but
00:09:10 that's not to say that at some level they don't sense that in times of you know important moments
00:09:15 like birth and death you go to to a church for a service and when things like this are happening
00:09:20 maybe you just go and sit by yourself for a moment and just have that.
00:09:24 You know, there's a line of Robert Frost's about
00:09:27 home is where, when you go there, they have to take you in.
00:09:32 And it was a bit like that, except that they didn't.
00:09:34 You know, people would have gone, they would have wanted to.
00:09:37 Anglican churches are closing at the fastest rate that they've ever done.
00:09:40 Something like 10% of churches have closed within the last few years,
00:09:44 2,000 churches.
00:09:46 And there is an argument being made
00:09:48 that actually these churches should be allowed to close and that the that the cv should actually
00:09:53 continue with what it's doing with these online services and keeping large large places open so
00:09:58 cathedrals abbeys and the larger venues to be open and people will have to commute forever greater
00:10:03 distance in order to actually you know in order to um have a density of population within these
00:10:09 venues letting the great old parish church you know shut and closed down and be converted into
00:10:13 what a yoga center or whatever and that's unfortunately i think what the elite leadership
00:10:18 in the church are actually willing on and that's that's going to hit local communities so hard
00:10:22 because the local parish church even if you're not religious is a huge part of knowing who your
00:10:27 neighbors are interacting with them you know you might where i live i have a local church where is
00:10:33 that where south london so i have a local church and probably the only neighbors i know are the
00:10:38 people who i know from church right so i can know people that sort of three or four doors down by
00:10:44 face i see them walking in and out but i've never speak to them and i think you'll see an increase
00:10:49 in that and then if people are commuting to church as well as work i mean it's there's going to be no
00:10:54 reprieve ever you know weekends you're going to roads just be as busy as ever city centers as
00:11:00 busy as ever because people are going to be going in to go to church if they are going to church at
00:11:04 all we'll probably see a decline there anyway but we need to leave these churches open even if not
00:11:10 for services, but for people to be able to go there and pray and have a community and
00:11:15 they still have a social function.
00:11:16 I mean, there clearly is a problem. The Anglican church attendance has been, it's not just
00:11:21 a recent matter that's been going on for decades, and its attendance is cratering, not in the
00:11:27 big cathedrals. People like sort of the cathedral experience, they like pilgrimages. There are
00:11:31 points of interest. Some of the big evangelical churches, often rather outside the Anglican
00:11:38 mainstream, doing very well. It's not that there isn't the energy there, but the basic
00:11:43 attendance at church is appalling. And part of what's happened in this crisis, I suspect,
00:11:48 is that the bishops saw their opportunity and, I think, very mistakenly think that the
00:11:53 idea is, as Rafe says, is we'll probably go online, we're going to need to cut back
00:11:58 our numbers, we won't let this crisis go to waste and we'll try and use it to push our
00:12:02 agenda. But they push an agenda that isn't going to help them. You can't take the church
00:12:08 online that isn't church christianity is a very physical religion like like all religious services
00:12:13 it's about being there with other people having a community you just you just can't do that online
00:12:18 in the same way catholicism actually says that there are no sacraments online it's impossible
00:12:24 to engage in any of the sacraments online has to be cyber communion i've not yet heard of yeah
00:12:29 but certainly you know whether or not you're religious the english parish church i think
00:12:33 is a quintessential part and i think most people would regard it as such a quintessential part of
00:12:37 English life and of English society. The idea that you go to a village or a town and there
00:12:41 you have the beautiful English parish church with the flag of St George going and you wander
00:12:46 in and you take solace. You know, people are cultural Anglicans as much as they are religious
00:12:49 Anglicans. And people, you know, may not go every Sunday, but certainly for the hatch,
00:12:53 match and dispatch, you know, for baptisms, weddings and funerals, the church is there
00:12:57 because it is still the established church. And whilst it is the established church, it
00:13:01 has to, by law, provide those services to the nation. And so I think this deflection
00:13:05 of duty by the church leadership in turning their backs on these fundamental bits of Englishness
00:13:10 which actually root a community to the society that lives around it, I think is a huge mistake.
00:13:17 Well, they said something about we don't want to seem special.
00:13:21 You know, if we kept the buildings open, obviously we couldn't do services, but if we kept the
00:13:24 buildings open, let clergy go in and hold services, that would be like we were not with
00:13:30 everyone else.
00:13:32 But they aren't with everyone else.
00:13:33 They're the established church.
00:13:34 They're supposed to set themselves apart and see themselves as essential.
00:13:39 If they're not essential, as they effectively said,
00:13:41 we're not essential, we can close, then what on earth are we doing?
00:13:45 And I think you'd have to start to ask the question,
00:13:47 which is a very difficult question,
00:13:48 about whether establishment is any longer the right thing to do.
00:13:53 And also the hospitals remained open because the physical ailments,
00:13:56 people still need to see those tended to.
00:13:58 Why are spiritual ailments now seen as lesser than physical ailments?
00:14:01 Why can the church say, well, if you're, you know, you're troubled, you can't come to a church and speak to a priest, go to confession, go to communion, you know, the sort of things that people really need for their spiritual well-being.
00:14:12 But hospitals, you know, of course, the physical well-being, of course, no one would say close the hospitals.
00:14:17 So why would the church be so happy to roll over and say, well, people don't really need that?
00:14:23 I think it reveals a lack of faith in themselves.
00:14:26 Well, I'm going to ask you this point, because I think what Rafe says there, you all said, but Rafe very vividly, is that I am not, I have not strong religious belief, but I would certainly call myself a cultural Christian.
00:14:40 And when the fact is that the church is, and I know a lot of people who are religious often don't like that.
00:14:47 They think we're just sort of piggybacking on the fact.
00:14:50 But to me, they actually do give you context.
00:14:54 And, you know, I'm not so arrogant to see that, you know, our society is based on the values of this.
00:15:01 And indeed, you know, they give a sense of continuity and all of the things we need at times.
00:15:06 like this. So, in answer to take your point on really well, I mean, does this actually
00:15:11 mean, because we hear, oh, the clergy, they no longer believe in God, it's a bit of a
00:15:17 caricature, but actually, is it true?
00:15:20 I think it definitely reveals a lack of faith, if not in God, then certainly in themselves
00:15:24 and their ability to minister and be pastors to the people in their community. You know,
00:15:30 this is a real problem, I think, because it's been a recurrent theme for the past 50 years
00:15:33 at least of now bishops see and we see this with the black lives matter thing they see their
00:15:38 function as being political or social but not spiritual not religious they kind of they've got
00:15:44 they've felt this need to rebrand themselves you know almost like community leaders so that when
00:15:49 something like black lives matter happens they come out and they take the knee and they say
00:15:52 we're in solidarity with you but that's not their role you know they're not they're not Blairite
00:15:57 politicians but they seem to think they are and they don't realize the movements that they're
00:16:01 getting into bed with them, the sort of actively Marxist, anti-Christian, anti-family.
00:16:05 Yes, I wanted to talk about them just in a minute, but just to finish this point off,
00:16:08 I mean, do you think that basically the people who are in charge of the church, like Ben
00:16:16 was suggesting, actually don't really, actually don't believe in it really anymore?
00:16:20 I think they don't believe in the people that they are set over. They want a different
00:16:25 church. It's a bit like sort of wanting to elect a different people. And as I say, now
00:16:29 that they've effectively really got no one going to church in tiny numbers, they can
00:16:33 get away with it a bit. If their congregations actually came to church and saw in the way
00:16:38 that I think even my eyes have been opened by this crisis to just how alienated I am
00:16:42 from the leadership of the Church of England, they won't be able to get away with it. So
00:16:46 actually that's really the answer, is for people to just realise how bad it is. So maybe
00:16:51 at least this crisis does that. I mean, I actually increasingly think the answer might
00:16:54 be disestablishment simply because I think establishment allows you to free ride on the
00:17:01 church's existence a bit. Not just the cultural Christian thing but you know people can sort of
00:17:06 think well it's there and it's always going to be there and the state sort of takes care of it.
00:17:10 When that goes away like in America religiosity goes up because people realise that if they don't
00:17:15 care for the church and attend and keep it going it'll go away. So maybe that would increase church
00:17:22 attendance enough so that the people
00:17:24 who are so completely
00:17:26 different to the people who are actually running it
00:17:28 that it would change it around at the top again
00:17:30 On that point I think if you had this establishment you would get
00:17:32 a better class of vicar because
00:17:34 certain people who go into the church go into it for
00:17:36 the perks effectively
00:17:38 large vicarage, the
00:17:40 respect, the esteem, the church
00:17:42 knowing they'll never be out of a job and those
00:17:44 sorts of things whereas true churchmen
00:17:46 are the ones who go in taking
00:17:48 a risk, making a sacrifice
00:17:50 and I think you get a much better class of priest or vicar or religious leader of any sort
00:17:56 when it requires an enormous amount of sacrifice to do that.
00:18:00 When you have the state, the whole machinery of the state behind this sort of church
00:18:05 which effectively doesn't do religion, you know, it's largely political
00:18:10 and it is a political institution, you know, you have lords in the House of Lords
00:18:14 who are bishops, you know, that is something which first of all is, you know,
00:18:20 questionable in terms of the overlap between church and state anyway but in pluralistic times
00:18:26 when we're moving towards a multi-faith society it also presents a very dangerous precedent because
00:18:31 at what point do certain religious leaders turn around and say why aren't we represented in the
00:18:36 house of lords why don't we have institutional unelected unaccountable power to push our
00:18:42 doctrines so there there are serious questions i think going forwards about the establishment
00:18:47 Well, there are, I mean, to just make this point, there are, are there not?
00:18:50 Because this is something, you know, that basically is, you could say,
00:18:54 sort of outside the bounds of what we're talking about.
00:18:57 But it's a fascinating point, because quite a long time ago,
00:19:01 Prince Charles said, I want to be, you know, the defender of faiths.
00:19:05 And without wishing to be tasteless, the time is approaching
00:19:09 where we are going to have to sort of face this.
00:19:12 So if you disestablish the Church of England,
00:19:14 what actually would a coronation look like in the end, Rafe?
00:19:19 Well, I don't think the Church is going to be disestablished,
00:19:21 but I think what...
00:19:21 Should it be, do you think?
00:19:22 Well, if I could put on my royal commentator hat or crown here,
00:19:26 paper crown, if I can.
00:19:27 On your crown.
00:19:28 What I envisage happening, actually, in terms of the next coronation
00:19:31 is that you will have the established coronation service
00:19:35 taking place in the Abbey.
00:19:37 Now, that's not, you know, immutable.
00:19:39 I mean, things have changed there.
00:19:41 In 1953, for example,
00:19:42 a role for the moderator of the Church of Scotland
00:19:44 was introduced into the church
00:19:46 which is also an established church in Scotland
00:19:47 so what I think will happen in the next coronation
00:19:50 is you'll have a standard Christian service in the Abbey
00:19:52 following which there'll be a multi-faith service
00:19:55 in Westminster Hall
00:19:55 which was always where the coronation banquet took place
00:19:58 and has long been out of use
00:19:59 but I think that that is going to be a way for people of other faiths
00:20:03 and it's interesting actually
00:20:04 there was a book written by Professor Ian Bradley
00:20:06 it was a professor of divinity
00:20:09 called God Save the Queen
00:20:10 in which he went out to other faiths and said
00:20:13 would you like the church to be disestablished
00:20:15 and do you think that it's right for the sovereign
00:20:16 to be head of the Church of England
00:20:17 and they said yes of course
00:20:19 and this is the leading Muslims and the chief rabbi and others
00:20:21 who said we'd rather have a person of faith
00:20:23 rather than a person of no faith heading up
00:20:25 so I don't think there's any pressure
00:20:26 to disestablish the church from other religions at all
00:20:28 but I do think
00:20:29 and as you know problem in having a secondary service
00:20:32 after the coronation service
00:20:33 which must maintain its current structure
00:20:35 as it has done for well now a thousand years
00:20:37 but to incorporate other faiths
00:20:40 because we are living in a society where there are other faiths,
00:20:42 and so certainly a service to accommodate them separate too.
00:20:46 I mean, I once spoke to the Maharaja of Darangad Rahalvad
00:20:49 about this wonderful old scholar, and he said...
00:20:51 As you do.
00:20:52 As a Hindu scholar who went up to Christchurch
00:20:55 to study Jewish studies as well,
00:20:58 he said any attempt to change the coalition service
00:21:01 would be an act of vandalism akin to demoralizing Stonehenge and the pyramids,
00:21:05 which I think is great coming from a Hindu scholar.
00:21:07 So I think, certainly, you can have a broad church whilst maintaining the established church.
00:21:12 The thing is, literally, yes, I think the thing that's interesting,
00:21:16 you say that the other faiths don't, they're not wanting this,
00:21:20 they don't want the disestablishment of the church.
00:21:22 It's just, it's the same old story that you covered in your book, in a way, isn't it?
00:21:25 It's that, actually, the people that they might be doing it to help or to curry favour with don't care.
00:21:33 It's just the people inside.
00:21:34 I mean, maybe they are the ones who want to disestablish their own church.
00:21:38 Maybe this is like, you know...
00:21:39 They're very comfortable with the power I have.
00:21:41 But, I mean, the real point is that, you know,
00:21:43 Rafe was talking about diversity of religions and faiths and a broad church.
00:21:47 We no longer have a broad church in the Church of England,
00:21:49 which the whole point of the Church of England is that it's a coalition
00:21:52 with some very different versions of Christianity bubbling away under the surface
00:21:55 in a very interesting tension.
00:21:57 It's how it's worked over the centuries.
00:21:58 Part of its success in sort of resolving our religious war
00:22:02 and our religious differences from, you know, the Tudor period.
00:22:05 And now we don't have that.
00:22:07 We have all the three great bishops are evangelical,
00:22:11 are very politicised, are really of the same point of view,
00:22:15 which means the Lord's spiritual in the Lords
00:22:17 are also of that point of view, part of this political class,
00:22:21 very narrow views about Brexit,
00:22:23 very naive and catastrophic views about how to respond to climate change
00:22:28 and all the rest of it, all those fashionable views of a certain elite kind.
00:22:31 They're the only people at the top.
00:22:33 Now, there are other views around.
00:22:35 My rector, Marcus Walker, at St. Bothamie the Great,
00:22:39 is a terrific Anglo-Catholic preacher, wonderful stuff.
00:22:43 He's not going to be rising up the ranks any time soon.
00:22:46 That sort of voice, Gavin Ashenden, the former Queen's chaplain,
00:22:50 these very, very bright, educated, brilliant men with different points of view,
00:22:55 they're not being heard at the top.
00:22:56 We have a very, very narrow church,
00:22:58 precisely because, as I say, it doesn't need to refer to anyone else.
00:23:02 It doesn't feel the need anymore to accommodate different views at the time.
00:23:05 Gavin Ashenden, of course, recently converted to Catholicism.
00:23:08 So I think that's when you have this movement of the Church of England
00:23:13 away from more traditional, not even traditional,
00:23:16 just conservative, you know, what was normal 50 years ago for the Church of England.
00:23:21 When you move away from that, those people find that the ground has moved from under their feet
00:23:25 and they go, well, where do I go?
00:23:26 Because this church no longer has a place for me in it.
00:23:28 I have to say I never thought about it until this crisis.
00:23:31 I have to say it's the first time I've thought to myself
00:23:32 it might well be that the Church of England won't be a home I can stay in much longer.
00:23:35 Really?
00:23:36 The last few months.
00:23:37 That's quite a big deal to come to that conclusion.
00:23:39 Well, we've seen this for years, though, haven't we?
00:23:40 What we've seen is those churches that actually have a more small-c conservative position
00:23:46 or that stay true to their founding principles and values and the tenets of their faith,
00:23:50 those are the ones that are growing.
00:23:51 So you see the evangelical church movement, you see the orthodox church growing,
00:23:55 you see the Islamic faith growing.
00:23:57 Why?
00:23:57 because they provide the structure and the discipline and the values
00:24:01 and they stay true to the traditions of the faith
00:24:04 and that's what people seek
00:24:05 and the Anglican Church is doing just the opposite
00:24:07 and that's why you're seeing falling numbers.
00:24:09 I think, speaking of numbers,
00:24:11 I think London church attendance has actually gone up considerably
00:24:14 but it is largely from ethnic minority groups
00:24:19 like the big, as you say, evangelical churches.
00:24:22 I can think of why I live in Woolwich.
00:24:23 I don't know what the church numbers are for the local C of E church
00:24:29 but there are big audiences in what once were cinemas, for example
00:24:34 and obviously you've got Polish Catholic people in London
00:24:39 you've got African Christians and obviously Muslims
00:24:43 I just want to go on a bit from this
00:24:46 it's a bad picture therefore
00:24:48 but it seems to have been made worse by the church's reaction
00:24:52 to what's happened in the past say what six weeks two months um and i was very struck you know you
00:24:59 might you must have seen it this week i think it was sheffield cathedral are disbanding their choir
00:25:05 i think they wrote back a bit on it you can put me right i think they wrote back but basically
00:25:11 because uh they felt that this music didn't speak to their community anymore but it was
00:25:17 this all felt like code for basically diversity i mean when you hear something like that it it is
00:25:24 a point so so what are you going to do not have any more coral sacred music what i think it's
00:25:29 actually emblematic of what happens when you give in to the mob when you say okay we need to get
00:25:35 rid of things that aren't woke enough which are problematic which don't fit with the new values
00:25:39 that we now espouse you have to take every single hymn review it and if none of them fit the you
00:25:46 you know the the new values we have well you just get rid of the choir altogether because
00:25:50 because they can't sing anything what what can they sing which will align with the you know the
00:25:54 values that this mob have but i think one of the reasons that the church of england gives in is
00:25:59 because they do sense a degree of hypocrisy looking back you know it's uh iconoclasm is
00:26:05 typically something which we relate to the protestant reformation in this country 97
00:26:10 of english religious art was destroyed during the reformation and immediately afterwards in
00:26:15 the english civil war for example so they have to you know rather than owning up to that legacy
00:26:21 yes and saying you know that was that was wrong they have to say when these people do it they're
00:26:25 right as well you know when these people want to do the exact same thing and recast society in their
00:26:30 image well we can't complain we have to go along with it and when we do it it's woke and brilliant
00:26:34 and we're right and you know we can't admit that we were ever wrong do you think you know when the
00:26:40 Archbishop of Canterbury who seems to have become a bit of a hate figure actually because of his
00:26:46 reaction about saying we should look at all the statues in Canterbury Theatre, we should revise.
00:26:52 In other words he's doing a kind of religious version of what Sadiq Khan has said in London.
00:26:58 What does that actually mean in practical terms? First of all, do you know, can he do that? I mean
00:27:03 this is the point, the point has always been made now, we are the custodians aren't we of this stuff.
00:27:09 We are, you know, whatever it is, in whatever context,
00:27:12 doesn't one archbishop have the power just to actually start removing statues?
00:27:18 Well, statues or choirs,
00:27:20 and the English choral music is one of the great jewels of Western civilisation.
00:27:25 For some reason, the Anglican Church has been able to preserve
00:27:27 the beauty of its choral tradition far better than the Catholics do.
00:27:31 I mean, the best we can do is Vespas,
00:27:32 but it's a pale imitation of proper English choral music.
00:27:35 and so to do away with the great choirs of England
00:27:39 which are celebrated all over the world
00:27:40 is in my view an act of cultural vandalism
00:27:43 it's akin to knocking down a cathedral actually
00:27:45 what is a cathedral if it's not for the people and the sounds
00:27:48 and the worship that takes place within its walls
00:27:50 yeah and this crisis has caused a massive crisis for the choral tradition
00:27:55 because of the whole problem around choirs being one of the most dangerous things to do
00:27:58 so they've been banned and they can't go back
00:28:00 much as people talk about theatres and of course that's another case
00:28:03 The English choral tradition is in terrible danger right now,
00:28:07 not just about one choir, the entire thing, because it's shut down.
00:28:10 There's hardly anywhere it can be done.
00:28:11 A few brave churches that are trying to work out an online version.
00:28:14 It's very, very difficult.
00:28:16 As Rafe says, it's an extraordinary thing.
00:28:17 People all around the world want to listen to King's College Chapel on Christmas Eve
00:28:21 because it's the most magical thing.
00:28:23 Go and listen to Eve and Song in a great cathedral.
00:28:26 It's a breathtaking experience.
00:28:28 But that's all going away because they can't turn up and perform.
00:28:32 and if the church was actually interested in real crises they would be addressing that and
00:28:36 realizing that that was a serious problem but instead they're mucking around with statues
00:28:40 and they don't seem to care and they seem to think they can just that'll be old-fashioned
00:28:44 it doesn't matter we'll go online they don't seem to be aware of the real problems that have
00:28:49 suddenly arisen this year that they should be really dealing with and the church is very
00:28:52 preoccupied with the idea of oh our choir is too dangerous you know covid and whatnot and yet
00:28:57 What do you mean by that? What, in the sense that they're too white?
00:29:01 No, no, too dangerous in the sense of, you know, because of coronavirus and spreading
00:29:04 and people gathering very close to each other and singing and projecting, you know, whatever.
00:29:11 But they still support Black Lives Matter. They haven't come out and said Black Lives Matter
00:29:14 chanting in the streets, huddled together as masses, is dangerous and wrong. They don't seem
00:29:20 to care about that. They only care about, seemingly, what the choir actually is, which is worship.
00:29:25 and i think they feel very uncomfortable about the idea of worship you know worship oh no we
00:29:28 can't have that that's that's a bit too much like religion what we do now is politics and as rafe
00:29:33 you know sort of pointed out earlier you know that the english have always preserved a lot of things
00:29:39 which came from english christianity which previously would have been catholicism before
00:29:44 the reformation but a lot of that will have been preserved in the anglican church later on
00:29:49 and Catholicism in this country is largely an import it is something from
00:29:55 Europe which has returned Polish immigration and Portuguese and Spanish
00:30:01 and French and people coming over they bring their form of Catholicism with
00:30:05 them so that English Christianity isn't as present in Catholicism as you might
00:30:10 expect it to be in this country I mean it exists in dribs and drabs here and
00:30:14 there but the real tradition of English Christianity is preserved in the
00:30:19 Anglican Church, and that's why the Anglican Church needs to continue to
00:30:22 preserve it, you know, because it's all well and good saying, oh, disestablish the
00:30:26 church and get rid of it because they don't do their job anymore, but they have
00:30:29 an enormous wealth which we need to make sure isn't destroyed in the process.
00:30:34 Do you think that there is the chance, you mentioned theatres there,
00:30:38 there's a theme that's sort of been emerging the past month or so, that
00:30:42 you're hearing that on the one hand you've got what has happened because of
00:30:46 Covid and it's almost like a lot of institutions are taking the opportunity to as they put it reset
00:30:54 you know so i'm pretty sure that the arts after this for example will be drenched even more in
00:31:01 identity politics right that we it'll just be it will transform i think what we see could it be the
00:31:09 church are doing this too that they're actually looking at things saying well actually this is
00:31:13 a chance for us to you know take away things that maybe are too white and western and indeed for
00:31:21 that matter maybe we don't need core music anymore maybe the time has come for us to i don't know be
00:31:27 doing different forms well we had the archbishop of canterbury saying that um jesus shouldn't be
00:31:31 portrayed as white any longer you know despite the fact that whatever culture you go to yes
00:31:35 jesus is always portrayed as in the local as a local person and indeed of course medieval painters
00:31:41 to sort of paint Jesus in medieval clothing as well.
00:31:44 These are symbols rather than actual depictions.
00:31:46 If you go to churches in Norway,
00:31:48 you'll find depictions of Christ with one eye closed
00:31:50 because Odin, of course, was blind in one eye.
00:31:55 It's crazy, really.
00:31:57 This is a cultural thing that happens.
00:31:59 You go to a community, they have their established norms,
00:32:02 and you represent God in the established way
00:32:04 so that people can relate to it.
00:32:05 And the whole point is that people relate to it,
00:32:07 and that's been taken away entirely.
00:32:09 The new Archbishop of York has come out and said that he's in fact black, Jesus is black.
00:32:16 And there's a very telling choice in the age of Black Lives Matter,
00:32:20 whereas if you want to say anything, then it would be reasonable to say that he's Jewish, of course.
00:32:23 But that isn't the favoured group at the moment.
00:32:26 So he's being depicted, again, in ways that suit a particular elite narrative
00:32:30 and a revolutionary narrative and not the one of the traditions that we actually have.
00:32:35 I think the easiest way to understand what's happening in the Church right now
00:32:38 and in its leadership is to remember the old phrase
00:32:42 that the Church of England was the Tory party at prayer.
00:32:44 Yeah, exactly.
00:32:45 And it then became for quite a long time,
00:32:47 you know, until the last 20 years,
00:32:48 the Lib Dem party at prayer,
00:32:50 and it's now very much the Corbynista party at prayer,
00:32:53 if not Black Lives Matter at prayer.
00:32:55 That's the transformation.
00:32:56 And once you think of it in those terms,
00:32:58 I think you can understand how it's changed culturally.
00:33:01 But not in the pews, you know.
00:33:02 It's daily mail readers, telegraph readers and sun readers.
00:33:06 and with a bunch of guardian readers preaching at them.
00:33:11 As I said at the beginning, that's what we have now.
00:33:12 We have the elite are public school educated
00:33:14 and very much of the Cameroonian set and cut off from reality.
00:33:18 The clergy tend to be very left-leaning
00:33:20 and the laity, of course, are right-leaning.
00:33:22 So you have these three tiers in the church and it's not sustainable.
00:33:26 Just to finish off, Mark, you obviously have written the book
00:33:30 along the long march, how the left won the cultural war
00:33:34 and what to do about it.
00:33:36 obviously the church must feature in this book, no?
00:33:41 Yes.
00:33:41 And how is it being played out now?
00:33:43 Things have only accelerated.
00:33:44 So when I wrote the book, I was complaining as sort of examples
00:33:47 of sort of woke culture coming into things that shouldn't be bothered with,
00:33:50 such things, how the church earlier this year came out and said,
00:33:54 for one thing, that they were going to go carbon neutral by 2030,
00:33:58 which is 15 years faster than anyone thought was sensible.
00:34:01 So that was a sign of their new priorities.
00:34:04 And then Justin Welby came out and said,
00:34:05 the entire church is deeply institutionally racist.
00:34:09 This was well before the Black Lives Matter thing,
00:34:11 so just him sort of getting ahead of that, if you like.
00:34:15 So that would have been bad enough,
00:34:17 and now all of this on top of it,
00:34:19 and, you know, you said about the Sheffield Cathedral Choir
00:34:22 is apparently being shut down and completely replaced,
00:34:25 but seems to have happened in a very sort of shabby
00:34:27 and sort of secretive manner,
00:34:29 but also very near us.
00:34:31 We're in Westminster while we're recording this,
00:34:33 st margaret's which is you know the parish church of westminster that's no longer going to have
00:34:37 sunday services it was announced a few weeks ago whatever ever no not going to have a sunday this
00:34:42 was a very famous church so people would know without knowing it it's where churchill and
00:34:46 milton both got married yes when you when you yes when you come into parliament square uh right next
00:34:52 to westminster abbey there is a church there and in fact it was a high society church for a long
00:34:57 time wasn't it but why what is the reasoning for that i just can't support it like you say they're
00:35:01 using the crisis to do things that they've wanted to do for a long time and they don't like the
00:35:06 church that they have and they also can't fill it with the numbers with their approach to the
00:35:10 church they're not getting in the numbers so they're they're downsizing and kicking out the
00:35:14 bits they don't like well of course st margaret's is about 900 years old so it would originally
00:35:18 have been a catholic church if they don't feel they can support it anymore i'm sure
00:35:21 westminster cathedral about a stone's throw down the road would be happy to take it under its wing
00:35:26 and build a bustling community there.
00:35:29 And, you know, if they don't want it, you know, give it away.
00:35:32 Well, I do sense the sort of rivalry emerging,
00:35:35 not to say church wars.
00:35:37 But it is remarkable, though, I have to say,
00:35:39 with all this notion about institutional racism
00:35:41 and the gall of the Archbishop of Canterbury
00:35:44 to say that we're all racist, that the church is racist,
00:35:46 that we have this idea of, forget original sin,
00:35:49 of collective national sin.
00:35:51 And, of course, you think,
00:35:51 look, where are the religious foundations of these ideas
00:35:55 when you have, you know, the sins of the father must not be visited on the son.
00:35:59 This whole concept, you know, well, indeed, truth and reconciliation.
00:36:02 You know, look at what Archbishop Tutu did in South Africa,
00:36:05 and this idea of forgiveness as well as repentance,
00:36:09 this whole notion, basically, of moving on and forgetting,
00:36:12 forgetting what may have happened in the past,
00:36:13 whether or not there's any relevance or justice in what people are claiming.
00:36:17 This idea of basically trying to hold acts of the past
00:36:20 over contemporary society, I think, is wholly irreligious.
00:36:23 Yes.
00:36:23 well look gentlemen thanks very very much
00:36:26 for today and talking about it
00:36:28 it is extraordinary
00:36:29 on this channel we seem to be going through
00:36:32 the institutions one by one
00:36:34 but quite legitimately I think
00:36:36 because everything is at a
00:36:39 very I would say
00:36:40 sort of
00:36:41 really on a knife edge actually
00:36:44 but thank you very much Ben, Mark
00:36:46 and Rafe
00:36:47 that's it for this week on
00:36:50 Counterculture
00:36:51 see you next time
00:36:53 but in the meantime uh do remember our new save our statues campaign uh which we launched a couple
00:37:01 of weeks ago uh it's doing very well we've been so encouraged by the number of people who are
00:37:05 signing up uh so please do join them won't you saveourstatues.org.uk thank you very much see you
00:37:13 See you next time.