New Culture Forum - August 14, 2020


Michael Collins: The Demonisation of the White Working Class

Has The Church's Shocking Response To BLM & Covid Shown It's No Longer Fit For Purpose? We Are Witnessing An Attempt To Reset Britain To Year Zero And Eradicate Its Proud History

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

177.9

Word count

7,407

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now there is an article
00:00:27 in this month's copy of The Critic magazine, which we've talked about before, and it's called
00:00:35 The Tribe That Disappeared, and it's about the white working class. It's written by the author
00:00:42 and journalist Michael Collins, who is with me today. Michael, back in 2004, wrote a book,
00:00:50 this one here called the likes of us a biography of the white working class it was called a seminal
00:00:58 book when it came out and indeed it went on to win the george orwell prize for political writing
00:01:05 i'm delighted that michael's joining me now thanks very much michael
00:01:11 first of all the tribe that disappeared is the title of this article this month
00:01:15 and you've obviously written about this for a long time what is the basic premise of what you're
00:01:25 talking about in your article I think it's 15 years on from the book and there's been there's
00:01:33 been a number of changes because in in the book I talk about the demonize demonization of the white
00:01:39 working class I think it's got much more over in those 15 years and now it's
00:01:46 almost like the the white working class was kind of defined by the left in a way
00:01:51 it's shorthand I think for racist racist basically and now I think it's the left
00:01:56 that are saying this is a political construct this is this is a fiction
00:02:02 basically fiction yeah so the I think within that it's almost like the they're
00:02:10 kind of being erased from the present the idea of the white wooden class being
00:02:12 erased from the present because of this because it's saying it's a construct the
00:02:16 the working class is this multicultural you know diverse tribe of people and
00:02:25 also I think the past is being taken away from people that might put
00:02:30 themselves into that category as white working class because the past is kind of being fictionalised
00:02:35 and being represented as this kind of all singing or dancing multicultural past, which
00:02:43 of course isn't the case. So I think that's where it's changed. The contempt has become
00:02:50 a lot more overt and there is this idea that there is no such thing as the white working
00:02:56 class they they're part of the working class and they're if they're kind of um seen as this this
00:03:01 tribe that's all being duped by capitalism but they're not being given the status of a kind of
00:03:07 ethnic group well or or any kind of status where everyone else in that yeah melting point so called
00:03:13 is actually getting some kind of some kind of status so i think that's where we are with it
00:03:17 now 15 years on you know and when you wrote the book originally uh it was quite it was actually
00:03:24 quite you know a new well it was quite revolutionary in a way i mean people had not written
00:03:30 about the white working class um why did you actually decide to write the book in the first
00:03:35 place um i think it's because of i think it's having our generation had witnessed something
00:03:42 i think in in terms of growing up um in london and uh being part of a kind of urban
00:03:51 I suppose like an urban tribe you know that was unique to a city you know post-industrial
00:04:00 class of people that grew up within the city very insular even though you're in the capital
00:04:08 very insular very localized working locally living locally and expecting to stay within
00:04:14 those streets pretty much for their life which I think our parents and our grandparents pretty
00:04:17 much did almost and I think our generation maybe saw the last of
00:04:22 something there because we saw the change in demographic within that area
00:04:27 which which came quite you know 50s onwards particularly but much more so
00:04:32 in the 80s and 70s and also I think I think the change in the landscape you
00:04:40 know we kind of you had a London that was very much like that kind of the
00:04:47 heritage of very civic the civic the civic buildings you know the town hall the library
00:04:53 the swimming baths and then you had the places of work so that industrial kind of heritage was still
00:04:59 there we had the docks down the road and then we witnessed how the infrastructures of those
00:05:05 neighborhoods changed because um the kind of massive brutalist housing estates that we kind
00:05:11 of welcomed in in some ways because of what they brought in terms of where people could live did
00:05:16 did a bbc documentary about this about council housing um and and particularly the brutalist
00:05:22 council housing so that that changed the neighborhood as well and it's it's just almost
00:05:27 like i think we um we just witnessed these huge changes and when i wrote the book it felt partly
00:05:33 like the end of something there because there was the this diaspora where people were selling up
00:05:39 or just moving out and becoming homeowners in the sort of donut ring of um of london in those
00:05:44 suburbs which on mass which was new and also around the same time the beginnings of this idea
00:05:51 of talking of the white working class in entirely in terms of being racist ignorant reactionary
00:06:03 largely from people that had grown up in very white middle class and still lived in very
00:06:09 my middle class backgrounds and could move or could escape you know because it's like
00:06:14 it's like what david goodhart talks about the somewheres and and the nowheres you know it's
00:06:18 very it was very apparent to me that that's exactly where we were with this these a lot
00:06:23 of these people even though they moved out a lot of people you know remained there and saw all these
00:06:28 changes the the older generation i mean but it is very much i suppose people would call it cultural
00:06:34 history wouldn't they because um maybe you know memoir partly it's partly memoir it's very much
00:06:39 through your own experience isn't it because you it's based a lot of it around elephant and castle
00:06:45 in london isn't it which has seen huge sort of changes what was the reaction to the book when
00:06:51 it came out um well i think the reviews were great sometimes they were they were good uh largely um
00:07:02 the criticism was really you know this it was i had to push to get the subtitle and i think the
00:07:07 criticism was with the biography of the white working class yeah and i think that was the
00:07:10 problem i think because you weren't it's like i said earlier because you weren't talking
00:07:16 gen more generally about the working class but defining the white working class
00:07:20 in that way i think was seen as a bit controversial and also um the criticism of it were you know
00:07:28 know there was some someone called me poetic hooligan someone else said I was
00:07:32 given because I start with the Stephen Lawrence story or murder the said I was
00:07:38 given an intellectual alibi for the Lawrence killers so there's a lot of that
00:07:42 going on you know it's trying to quite obvious stuff to pull in out and the
00:07:46 strange enough the further left you went in terms of the reviews the more extreme
00:07:49 it got so I you know by the end of it I really was being compared to Oswald
00:07:53 Mosley so it was or Hitler even so it was it was that was kind of silly but
00:07:57 you actually spoke to um individual editors or columnists a lot of them got it you know whether
00:08:03 of the left or the right and also the the essay that that was the impetus of the book was in the
00:08:08 observer and there was a number of papers that wanted to run excerpts and i went with the guardian
00:08:12 you know because um uh i kind of felt it was very much that kind of um readership that needed some
00:08:22 instruction on this subject you know you're talking you know in the book but also in your
00:08:28 most recent in in this month's article about the demonization of the world class i mean
00:08:35 uh which seems to me to be without question yeah i wonder you know in the past say like four years
00:08:42 we've had brexit you know how has it shown itself there how has that demonization shown itself in
00:08:50 past period I think the brexit it was um I think that was a long time coming you
00:08:58 know it was kind of like it wasn't a huge surprise in terms of the result
00:09:04 but certainly I think a lot of people wanted the opportunity not even just to
00:09:08 do of Europe but to actually voice their opinion about a particular mindset that
00:09:14 they equated with that I thought what was very interesting was in in the book
00:09:17 i talk about in the 19th century how you had these political missionaries and religious
00:09:24 missionaries that went into these areas to sort of educate the masses and you know and they were
00:09:31 really concerned about the future of you know especially utopian socialists they were quite
00:09:36 concerned because they thought when you give health and when you give welfare and work to
00:09:42 the working class and they then have a bit of money what are they going to spend it on you
00:09:46 you know worried about vice and gambling and so they started talking in terms of you can find it
00:09:52 you find it somewhere like masterman in the condition of england where they talk about
00:09:55 the working class on the other side of the river um coming up like rats from the sewer
00:10:01 and waving their flags and there was a lot of that going on after brexit it was almost like
00:10:06 these 90 century um missionaries it's like it's like matthew arnold when he talked about the
00:10:11 populace, you know, it was suddenly this, you heard this voice from these people that
00:10:16 had come up from the wrong side of the tracks, and you saw that in a lot of the, that's when
00:10:21 I think it was really overt, this kind of contempt, because suddenly it was this emphasis
00:10:26 on people's education, their lack of O-levels, and their lack of university education, or
00:10:33 they were, oh it was false consciousness, or they weren't told the facts, it was this
00:10:39 incredibly patronizing approach and and i think what what hasn't happened what what what should
00:10:45 happen is we've had a lot you know even with people like john snow talking about how white
00:10:50 that the mark you know that's right i've never seen so many white people yeah exactly exactly
00:10:54 and even on glassdenby two years before um and so um i think what we've not had we've had a lot
00:11:01 including you know with the statues the people protecting the statues we had a lot about the
00:11:06 people that are involved in Brexit that have an opinion about these statues that don't have
00:11:11 qualifications didn't go to university I think we should start looking at the ignorance of the
00:11:16 educated I think we should start looking at those people with exams and with degrees whether the
00:11:21 Black Lives Matter marches or wherever else and let's actually look at their opinions and see
00:11:27 how informed they are these are the so-called educated and I think you'd be quite surprised
00:11:31 I've got a feeling I wouldn't be surprised actually but I know exactly the
00:11:36 point you're making it's extraordinary they've been taught they've been taught
00:11:39 enough to be able to believe certain things and that's it you know like I
00:11:46 mean we come from sort of similar areas you know my family were originally from
00:11:50 Peckham just down the road from elephant castle in London basically I remember
00:11:59 when I read your book I was really quite moved by it because it was a whole way of life which
00:12:04 it's not just sort of gone but it's sort of it's it's actually been buried I mean that that to me
00:12:12 it seems to me the crucial point that they're sort of it's actually been it so it was never
00:12:17 there you lose this beginning what was your tell us a bit about your family oh well I mean before
00:12:28 get to that i was just going to say the other thing about the book that was quite interesting
00:12:33 at the time was the if it was successful at toys because it was actually read by a lot of the
00:12:39 people that it was about judging by the feedback i got so whether they were in the north or the
00:12:44 south it was kind of like um of england or you know even scotland or elsewhere there was um
00:12:51 it was an experience that chimed with a lot of people of several generations
00:12:55 um yeah i mean i think i came from just down the road from you between the elephant and
00:13:00 old kent road and of course it really was taken away you know because that that neighborhood i
00:13:06 grew up with i saw that transition where a whole uh the infrastructure in the neighborhood where
00:13:12 there was schools tabernacles a high street everything was taken out and replaced with a
00:13:18 brutalist yes estate you know it was inspired like by le capuzio but by that point even the
00:13:25 architects had disowned a lot of that kind of those kind of estates so that so in some ways it
00:13:31 it has been eradicated but yeah i mean i i was very typical of that because um parents had been
00:13:37 there for generations maternal sorry paternal grandparents publicans in that area family dad's
00:13:44 family worked in the market my dad been a bookie eventually worked in the print mum a clerk and
00:13:50 then a cleaner when i was a kid so yeah very much like that kind of typical south london
00:13:59 background to some extent and then school as well the comp comprehensive was was
00:14:04 closer to where you were so it was the intake was from camwell brixton and walworth and that was
00:14:08 that was an interesting moment because again it was a different experience it was the 70s
00:14:12 so you were you had that kind of old school teacher that usually taught you about containerization
00:14:19 or maths you know where they were very strict and um you know would love to change you no no
00:14:24 that's not the first way maybe it was um and then the other ones were the ones that post 68
00:14:30 students moved into those areas kind of um would say things like exams mean nothing bringing bob
00:14:37 marley albums you know um had angela davis posters in their flat which they'd all tell you about they
00:14:44 they try and it was posturing really but it was their politics they would place on you and it's
00:14:49 like you know it's like i said in the book i think i said we didn't know where the top ship was so
00:14:54 you know we really didn't know care who angela angela davis was but so you had these two things
00:14:59 going on and also that area at the time and that school was quite a mixture because you had lots
00:15:05 you know quite percentage of white kids percentage of black kids and it was
00:15:08 quite that was quite unusual at the time I think and that was very specific to
00:15:13 maybe that part of London because that's an interesting point which you actually
00:15:17 make in this book too and it's in my experience too is that working-class
00:15:22 people have much more experience of genuine ethnic diversity in fact you
00:15:28 know at school into marriage this and yet the criticism often comes from
00:15:33 people who are almost entirely white i mean you know the liberal our old friends the liberal
00:15:41 you know intelligence but they're the people who have you know to talk about racism and yet they
00:15:49 have you know far less experience of kind of you know ethnic diversity and still do i i think i
00:15:58 I think with that though, what's interesting about that now, where a lot of the columnists
00:16:06 or a lot of the pundits that talk about this subject from a kind of upper middle class
00:16:11 background, I almost think they feel themselves colourless in a way.
00:16:17 But the strange thing is what gives them the pedigree is their status and their class.
00:16:22 You know, it's an old fashioned idea, but I do, and it seems very weird for these people
00:16:27 talking that always talked about representing the working class or the underdog and you you think
00:16:31 well when you peel it back there's quite a contempt for that underdog so who exactly do you represent
00:16:37 who are you actually you know yeah supporting or championing these days but yeah i don't think that
00:16:43 changes i mean i've seen it so often you've seen it in journalism in television the amount of people
00:16:47 that you know they do all that but they are they are the they they escape you know give it 10 years
00:16:53 there'll be there there'll be somewhere where it'll be a white neighborhood they're sending
00:16:58 the kids to a private school and they're buying an agar you know it's very different whereas the
00:17:03 other people there you know they're up some are landlocked some people eventually moved out i
00:17:10 i think the interesting thing about that as well with with the whole race issue is we kind of
00:17:14 covered it because we had to you know way back we weren't our parents we weren't you know that
00:17:20 our experience was different because of our mates because we had black partners or whatever
00:17:24 and so it seems really weird that now for us 40 odd years later we are being educated on this
00:17:31 subject by people that didn't have that experience you know do you see that i mean that that seems to
00:17:37 be very much in full force at the moment but the one thing that the protests that we've had recently
00:17:44 you know in the background they are not really they're not about class are they at all they're
00:17:49 they're not about they're not about uh inequality economic inequality they're about identity
00:17:57 politics aren't they and basically white working-class people are not allowed that are they
00:18:04 isn't that really what it is well it was never on the um it was never on the table was it they
00:18:10 never ever they covered everything with gender sexuality race but never ever got
00:18:15 to class I mean it's beginning to happen now the BBC are trying in terms of the
00:18:19 way they recruit but it's very heavy-handed because it's kind of what
00:18:25 you want is an equality of opportunity you just want the opportunities but
00:18:30 obviously we're on to the the equality of outcome now which again marginalizes
00:18:35 because social class doesn't entirely come into that.
00:18:40 But yeah, I think what's happened with that as well is very interesting
00:18:45 because all this stuff about the white working class being on their last
00:18:49 and as I said earlier, it's just a political fiction according to the left.
00:18:59 It's remarkable though, isn't it?
00:19:00 they can even get away with calling something a political a group that was the biggest group in
00:19:06 the country obviously after industrialization is now being called a political fiction or a construct
00:19:13 you know but still i think the other thing they don't realize is they're talking in
00:19:18 it's kind of equivalent old money because the uh you know the working class has changed certainly
00:19:24 in terms of the makeup of it and the demographic but also if you're going to define the white
00:19:29 working class that's changed as well because why what i covered in the book and what i cover in
00:19:34 the article i use the term because it's just something it's a term that was put on this group
00:19:39 of people i'm writing about but that is not talking in entirely in terms of economics because
00:19:46 you're talking about people that moved up you talk about people that moved out and there's never
00:19:49 really been a term for people that actually make it say into the lower middle class have become
00:19:56 homeowners or own their own business and don't go to university and that's the other thing that
00:20:01 i think happened with brexit suddenly they had a name and that name was ill-educated you know
00:20:05 they suddenly were defined in that way but the the the the other thing you're saying about you
00:20:11 know the whitewood because i i think they're not part of that dialogue on identity politics
00:20:16 but they are kind of pulling up a chair and watching as it completely implodes
00:20:20 as those groups subdivide and subdivide and attack each other you know which is the kind
00:20:25 a logical outcome yeah of that kind of identity politics isn't it it's interesting you see because
00:20:30 my my family work from perkin but like you just described there my parents went and got their own
00:20:35 home in institute which was suburban yeah a step up definitely um and i suppose you would call that
00:20:43 lower middle class i guess i don't know but i suppose what it is is that what we're seeing
00:20:49 over the past few months is this attack on various things that working-class people
00:20:57 hold very dear you know whether it's our statues whether it's our history and the various heroes
00:21:04 work they don't in other words their context it's the context and that is what's become
00:21:10 under sustained attack or is still being attacked isn't it yeah i i this is another thing that
00:21:16 interests me with um which i tried to allude to in the article because i'm always very interested in
00:21:22 the those people that ask that condition of england question you know that they actually
00:21:27 think this is this is the time for a kind of audit to see where we are and to see what values we share
00:21:32 and to see um uh you know what common ground there is and so that that was there's an element of that
00:21:40 with the book but certainly i mentioned in the article something like masterman's a condition
00:21:44 of england or even orwell and oral tried to define this idea of englishness or britishness
00:21:49 and i almost think that's where we are now and i i did think you know this was the whole pandemic
00:21:55 was the chance for this people to sort of settle down take a breather have some sure leave and
00:22:01 decide what what is actually going to bring people together i mean it's it's you know king mobs
00:22:08 turned it into something else it's not worked out that way no no it's getting worse i mean this this
00:22:13 is the strange thing i mean i i i i'm not entirely comfortable with using yeah i know i've written
00:22:20 a book about the white working class but it covers so much ground and it covers so many people
00:22:26 and it and it's not entirely even about race anymore it's just about a group of people that
00:22:30 probably are out there as a silent majority um who have a shared experience and a shared outlook
00:22:36 and they don't find that they don't recognize that in the media or anywhere else and they strange
00:22:41 enough the one place they have found it in the last 15 years is within social
00:22:45 media because there's voices out there they recognize and there's things they
00:22:48 want to hear you know you you talk as well and I have talked to written not
00:22:55 just in the book about the way in which working-class people have been and are
00:23:00 characterized and the way that they are depicted you know in screen and I
00:23:05 remember we've talked about people like Mike Lee you know on the one hand you've
00:23:10 got Mike Lee and Abigail's party and this kind of what is I always found
00:23:15 condescending basically it was condescending even though everyone
00:23:18 thought it was wonderful and then the other hand you've got Ken Lodge she's
00:23:21 hugely sentimentalized I think you could sell on the one hand but those figures
00:23:26 are largely now amazingly in the past aren't they they're past they're powerful
00:23:32 how does it show itself now I mean how does it how does that kind how all
00:23:37 working-class people depicted if they are indeed depicted at all culturally well
00:23:43 I think there's still an element of that I mean with someone like Loach they um I
00:23:47 always feel like he was kind of graft graft in a sort of a working-class onto
00:23:53 an agenda and the people were the victims of the worst examples of those
00:23:58 issues it's almost like they were kind of like Job or Candide or someone you
00:24:01 know the worst possible things would always happen to them I think the Mike
00:24:05 You know, ever since in Abigail's party when she puts the Beaujolais in the fridge, there's always been that mocking of working class people that somehow, as I said, they make their way up, but they don't make their way into the middle classes for education.
00:24:23 they make money or they own their own businesses they buy houses and it's always that's always
00:24:28 there there's always they got the wrong taste you know they they buy the wrong food they say
00:24:33 you know that the whole del boy thing they they pronounce words wrong you know it's um i think
00:24:39 there's still an element of that but element of that but i think the other thing that's
00:24:43 is it's much more specific in a way because you only have to see um uh you don't have to see some
00:24:49 certain journalists or columnists or even you know in television they will go into an area
00:24:55 where it is largely white now and and that is it that's enough for that that that becomes
00:25:01 they've exposed something almost like they were clowns clownsmen or something with burning crosses
00:25:07 you know and i i don't think they even bother with the fact that someone's you know buys the
00:25:13 wrong wine anymore i think it's just simply that it's shorthand for something else now
00:25:17 this happened last year i live in the west country and the um before the election i bumped into a
00:25:25 guardian journalist down there who came in um and and he said to me so who are the movers and shakers
00:25:31 down here i said i'm not going to tell you because i know what you're going to do and i said it'd be
00:25:35 like when polytimey went to the isle of y i know exactly what you're going to do um i said if you
00:25:40 really want to meet the people here and you want that diversity instead of just writing about a
00:25:45 place that's largely white i said go to morrison's go to the estates on the outskirts go to the gym
00:25:51 and then you'll see a mixture of people that some from london yeah different backgrounds different
00:25:56 histories that that's a diversity no one has been prevented from moving here you know and then a
00:26:02 couple of hours a couple of hours later i saw him and the cameraman he said you're going to hate
00:26:05 what we've done and he said we've just filmed um an elderly couple playing croquet i said of course
00:26:11 you have yeah of course you have and there it was the cover the next day and you think what a lost
00:26:15 opportunity you know it's just where would you the thing is is that this level of self-hate
00:26:24 you know it's just sometimes overwhelming isn't it i mean well you might say well then it's not
00:26:29 self-hate because they don't hate hate themselves but this desire to actually show that look at you
00:26:36 know like emily thornberry with her famous tweets she just put it there it was a white man with a
00:26:43 george cross on outside house she didn't even have to say she was obviously saying look at this
00:26:50 just terrible yeah but look at her i mean look at look no but i mean look at her i mean look
00:26:56 at the story there look at the story there you know i mean it is entirely uh that that i know
00:27:02 it's such a cliche but it is that islington dinner party set you know again i really think it'd be
00:27:09 interesting to turn this around as in terms of as i said before you talk about the ill-educated
00:27:15 working class let's look at the educated and see you know how thick some of those
00:27:19 those are and i think the same with with the thornbury's i mean she's kind of old news now
00:27:24 but i mean a lot of those people let's let's actually look at them let's let's actually
00:27:29 just look at them and their status the way we talk about people like you know
00:27:34 they make this that move to Elton or you know or buy their own house and they're
00:27:39 mocked because of their tastes and because of their outlook let's let's
00:27:43 have a look at this let's put those under the under the let's put them in
00:27:47 the spotlight and see exactly what their lives are like and what their opinions
00:27:52 really are because it comes out like that and that's just that's an old
00:27:56 example but i mean there are so many more cases post-brexit where you kind of um well that's that
00:28:01 thing about carolyn flint said about her as well yes but i mean she's just one example she's probably
00:28:06 not even the worst example you mentioned there about you know there's this whole thing about
00:28:11 being ill-educated and somehow uh you know that people are not you know uh they're not it's not
00:28:18 valid if you like their opinion is not valid because they're not educated and yet the interesting
00:28:23 thing is is that actually when you look at the situation we've had this has been in the news a
00:28:27 bit lately it's in the spectator article and it actually even got into parliament that the white
00:28:32 working class boys now are seriously the lowest group when it comes to education aren't they
00:28:39 this is actually this is goes against the whole narrative i understand going all the way out yeah
00:28:46 going all the way up to university um this is an important point isn't it that the whole concept
00:28:54 of white privilege which i don't think would have been around when when you wrote this book
00:28:59 would it not not quite uh this is really sort of now this puts an unemployed nottingham minor in
00:29:06 the same category as the queen doesn't it they're both white they're both privileged yeah i i mean
00:29:12 I mean, I'm kind of part of that in a way because I know you said cultural historian and, you know, it's been described as historian, but I didn't get exams, I didn't go to university. So it's a strange thing because I don't have anything that would make me really considered a historian.
00:29:31 I actually did have some involvement about 12 years ago, about 12 years ago working with a think tank in setting up a supplementary school to address this. Not just for white kids, but for everyone in poor urban areas.
00:29:45 And it was very interesting because when I spoke to, I went to a number of estates, almost
00:29:52 like sink estates in a way, and a lot of the kind of white parents that were left in those
00:29:59 areas said that they thought if they saw the word community, because that's kind of, we're
00:30:04 going to do it in a settlement house, they said they never thought it was for them. So
00:30:09 it's very interesting because they felt marginalised by that and just kind of had closed off.
00:30:13 Because the actual word community, they immediately turned them off.
00:30:17 Well, no, not turned them off, they just assumed the word community,
00:30:21 it meant ethnic community, you know.
00:30:23 And so you get around that, but the question I think
00:30:27 that we were asking then, and it's still relevant now,
00:30:31 is why now? Why has this happened now?
00:30:34 And is it happening in areas where these white boys make up a minority?
00:30:40 Ben Bradley's been looking at this, you know,
00:30:42 the Tory MPs have been looking at this and mentioned it in the comments, I think, because
00:30:47 partly to do with what you mentioned earlier, no one, the emphasis has been, this is not
00:30:52 the whole, this is not the whole reason, I'm sure, but the emphasis has been so much on
00:30:56 the identity politics and the ethnicity and the minority, and minority groups, that the
00:31:01 social class aspect has not been featured and the ones that have suffered from that
00:31:05 are probably, you know, white working class kids and white working class boys.
00:31:10 The other thing is with all this stuff, which not everyone wants to go to the university.
00:31:17 It's a very Blairite thing, that idea of everyone, especially the Mickey Mouse courses that they're doing.
00:31:24 Some people want apprenticeships.
00:31:27 That would probably be a better option for a lot of people, especially when you look at the state of these courses now.
00:31:38 The people who were mentioned earlier.
00:31:39 I think the, yes exactly, I think this is, you know, these whole sort of humanities, the gender studies, the media studies, all of these things, basically they've sold people down the river actually, haven't they, because all these people, it's getting to the point now where actually you, when younger people say I want to go to university or should I go to university, you're almost saying to them well actually really think about it before you do, whereas in the past, you know, definitely, oh yes, you've got to do it.
00:32:09 got to do that you've also written Michael about Black Lives Matter haven't you and about what's
00:32:16 been going on what do you think how seriously do you take the protests and things that we've seen
00:32:24 over the past two months I think the well I mean I think they're serious because of the damage and
00:32:34 chaos that's been caused and i think essentially i think the movement's essentially built on a lie
00:32:39 anyway but the um the lie would be well in terms of stats in terms of you know statistics as far
00:32:45 as police brutality and who dies you know it's out there and loads of people have commented on this
00:32:50 and but i i think if you if you take away from that i don't think as a movement i don't think
00:32:55 black black matter might go the way of the black panthers do you know i mean in 10 years time
00:32:59 if they haven't shot each other there'd be evangelicals and republicans you know that's
00:33:02 probably what's going to happen but i think the seriousness comes from the people that
00:33:07 complied with it that that's what i think is really serious i think the business big business
00:33:13 the media the church of england how quickly they complied to that you know without looking at what
00:33:20 this movement is about what which is which is out there is pretty obvious what it's about
00:33:24 and even even if you take that out the equation they didn't actually address the chaos they
00:33:29 They didn't, especially in America, you know, the murder of David Dorn, the ex-police captain, you know, they didn't address the impact on neighbourhoods, like businesses, you know, I think that was quite shocking.
00:33:44 I mean, that is what I think is worrying, is the seriousness, when you talk about seriousness, I think is how quickly people complied to it.
00:33:56 I don't mean people out there, I mean within the media.
00:33:58 the institutions the institutions i mean to the point where you'd you know you'd go on your spotify
00:34:04 playlist and the first thing you see these recommendations for black lives matter you know
00:34:08 you had those those kind of um weedy anchormen where there's sort of insipid women sat next to
00:34:14 them on coaches saying oh i'm just this poor white woman please tell me about you know how terrible
00:34:19 it is to be black in 20 you know 20 20. um that that was what i found alarming and i think a lot
00:34:24 of people do i think a lot you know talking about the education and people's knowledge
00:34:30 they mock these people they mock these people that voted brexit and everything else but they
00:34:34 are that's the other thing that's happened in the last 15 years they are a lot more savvy about this
00:34:38 stuff than you think about the media about the media about how they're primed about the responses
00:34:45 they know i mentioned this in the article they know that racism and now it's just this lucrative
00:34:50 industry where the word will just the remit changes constantly you know it's a
00:34:55 booming industry and they know that grooming gangs will be deracialized you
00:35:00 know they they're aware of all this stuff there were a lot there were which
00:35:04 15 years ago you know probably not so much but and I think that is partly to
00:35:08 do with social media like I said finding you know recognizing voices over there
00:35:12 the only thing I think with black lives matter not just black lives matter but
00:35:16 all these um you know these these these movements or these these marches which which i don't you
00:35:23 know i've i've written about in the book because the book covers almost years ago i know it's 15
00:35:28 years ago but it did cover almost 200 years and so you look within that uh the history of protest
00:35:35 you know you see trade unionism civil rights in the states you see the suffragette movement
00:35:39 people that actually put themselves on the line because their lives depended on it to bring about
00:35:43 change which has no connection with any of this stuff as far as i can see now and i think the
00:35:47 problem with it is in the seriousness of where it's serious is it's almost like we have to stop
00:35:54 their madness become an animality because you look at the streets of london before the pandemic
00:35:59 and other major cities every week there is something yeah extinction rebellion black
00:36:05 lives matter something else you think oh it must be a slow week for climate change this week because
00:36:09 suddenly it's racism and you think this is this kills protest or what protest should be about
00:36:14 because i don't believe the passion's here i don't believe the convictions there i think it's almost
00:36:18 like take buying a kick or a bounty for these people it really is but you know that is worrying
00:36:24 because that is the normality you walk around london um and you think this this is this is what
00:36:30 you you did it with the statues within a week you suddenly thought this this is our capital this is
00:36:36 it you know when did you actually leave london yourself uh well i just i i disappeared to the
00:36:44 essex coast right lovely lovely well this is great essex is really underrated yeah um and then i came
00:36:52 back to london and then i went to west country okay only because i'm poor and common not because
00:36:59 of white flag no no i mean i i think i think uh we are seeing something strange happen with london
00:37:07 at the moment i mean you come back on trips like you're here on a trip at the moment and
00:37:11 i'm born and bred london i still live and work here uh i can't help feeling there's something
00:37:16 historic happening as a result of this whole covert thing um that london essentially is
00:37:24 has changed permanently as a result this is my fear that i can't see it coming back or do you
00:37:32 think i'm being too melodramatic about this well i've been walking around you feel that it's like
00:37:39 you know i feel like as i say in that piece you feel like
00:37:44 you know you feel like a ghost walking through um a once familiar city and you look at these it's
00:37:49 that thing isn't it it's that philip larkin thing where he says you look you look up at the foreheads
00:37:53 of buildings and i find myself doing that i think i said to you earlier you know i kind of come in
00:37:57 on the train i was almost looking for a low-rise council flats from the 60s with relief you know
00:38:03 they're still there you know because it's kind of gotham city and that's that's the other thing
00:38:07 that which is interesting in terms of the book 15 years on and doing this article now is of course
00:38:13 you're talking a lot you're talking about gentrification of areas like elephant castle
00:38:18 and the old kent road which when i was growing up i mean cheapy street and the monarch people
00:38:21 no one wanted to live there you know no one could buy there if they did you know and i still got
00:38:26 relatives older relatives that are still there and they feel quite landlord because they don't
00:38:30 recognize it you know for so many reasons but um i i don't know i think what's missing as well is
00:38:37 that the thing i said earlier i don't think there's any kind of unity with with the capital i don't
00:38:42 think it feels like really itinerant it feels like i don't know i find a lot of people don't
00:38:48 seem to have that investment that maybe londoners which which is nothing to do when i'm talking
00:38:53 terms of race or i'm talking terms of a sense of connection um that tribe i talked about earlier
00:39:01 that were expecting to say on those same streets um you know for most of their lives and work
00:39:08 locally uh that kind of sense of the investment that comes with that in terms of a sense of
00:39:14 belonging or participating i don't find i don't see that there but you see i i would say that
00:39:20 it hasn't been there for a long time but there's a narrative in place because the thing is if you
00:39:26 think of being a londoner uh people were always a bit you know kind of like grumbling about london
00:39:32 but the fact is they they were so organically from it uh whereas because now that that's gone
00:39:39 you have to impose a narrative which is this wonderful city you know where isn't it i know
00:39:44 if you look at the standard newspaper it's just a constant boosterism this one you should think
00:39:50 wait a minute there's there was something actually basically temperamentally not right about that
00:39:55 london was never actually like that but it's i think it comes from the fact that it's a realization
00:40:01 that it isn't unified actually it isn't unified well i think as well there's if you talk about
00:40:09 You know, I mentioned in the article, to talk about this stuff for me is about history rather than nostalgia,
00:40:15 because we're all ambivalent about where we grew up, you know, and that kind of experience.
00:40:21 But I think with London, when you talk about this, or when you talk about even history in terms of London,
00:40:30 or a London experience, it's dismissed as you are talking about something that's mythical.
00:40:37 but I think really
00:40:39 it's the present they talk about that's mythical
00:40:41 because there's
00:40:43 so many
00:40:44 flaws and there's so many issues
00:40:47 there's good things but I think
00:40:48 address those
00:40:50 and then start on about
00:40:53 the singing and the dancing and the alfresco
00:40:55 dining
00:40:55 I couldn't agree with you more
00:40:59 Michael, thank you very much
00:41:02 that is indeed it
00:41:04 it's just flown past
00:41:06 um so michael's article is in this month uh magazine the critic which he writes for regularly
00:41:16 and the book again which you can get i'm sure on amazon uh michael collins the likes of us
00:41:22 a biography of the white working class uh it's a wonderful read okay thank you very very much
00:41:30 again thank you Michael and thank you for watching and do join us again next week thank you bye