New Culture Forum - August 16, 2020


We Are Witnessing An Attempt To Reset Britain To Year Zero And Eradicate Its Proud History

Michael Collins: The Demonisation of the White Working Class Douglas Murray - The Cult Of Woke & The Project To Lie About Our History

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

166.59

Word count

6,963

Sentence count

97


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittall. Now about three weeks ago we started
00:00:20 a campaign called Save Our Statues. We launched a new website called saveourstatues.org.uk and
00:00:27 And you might remember that at the time the statue issue was really at its very height, but it hasn't gone away.
00:00:37 In fact, it's bubbling away under the surface all the time with various councils around England talking about revising all their statues and public memorials.
00:00:49 We're very pleased to say that since we started that campaign, so many of you have actually got in touch and wanted to help.
00:00:58 We've had hundreds of people coming forward as supporters or joining up as members or wanting somehow to find out how they can actually be involved on the ground.
00:01:09 So that's very, very encouraging.
00:01:12 Southwaves continue to be in the news.
00:01:15 You might have seen, actually, last week, there was a new one that was unveiled on the fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square.
00:01:23 It is called The End. Here's a picture of it. It's like a kind of strange postmodern ice cream.
00:01:31 This is right in the middle of London.
00:01:33 Somewhat, I think, the very most complimentary thing you could say about it is it is somewhat pretentious.
00:01:39 at the same time a few days before that the mayor of london sadiq khan put out a press release
00:01:46 giving us more details about his so-called commission for device diversity in the public
00:01:51 realm this is going to look at all of london's historical statues memorials street names and
00:01:59 murals and to judge whether they are ones that should still be celebrated or not whether in
00:02:04 fact new ones should be commissioned or indeed old ones got rid of. These are all very important
00:02:10 issues which we're going to be discussing today. We're also going to be looking at the Europe-wide
00:02:16 situation. Is this just something affecting Britain or Western Europe or is this something
00:02:21 further afield? Now with me to discuss this I've got five guests today. We're first of all joined
00:02:30 from the czech republic by richard bingley who is general secretary of the save our statues
00:02:37 campaign we have thomas stranick who was instrumental in saving the baden powell statue
00:02:44 down in pool in dorset emma webb who is from the think tank civitas robert poll who started the
00:02:52 save our statues twitter campaign which is going great guns at the moment and the historian and
00:02:59 commentator and our resident guests from the New Culture Forum, Rafe Heidelman-Ku.
00:03:03 Thank you very, very much for joining us. I want to start actually on the Europe
00:03:08 issue, in fact. Here we are, we hear a lot about the position in America with
00:03:16 statues and memorials being attacked and also in this country, but you're in the
00:03:22 Czech Republic at the moment, Richard. What's the situation like there? Are they
00:03:28 looking on and thinking that this is something weird that's happening in britain yes
00:03:37 um the fact over here really is um that they had quite small black lives matter processed
00:03:45 but um there's no great clamor to remove any any sort of historical cultural furniture at all
00:03:52 um the big dilemma during east europe and central europe was obviously about removing
00:04:00 communist statues and those related to sort of russia or soviet union
00:04:07 there was a kind of decision 20 years ago to not remove them
00:04:12 um they were going to contextualize them and indeed in budapest of freedom square there
00:04:20 they still have statues of russian generals
00:04:26 so over here there's kind of a lot more memorial around russian generals who helped to fight the
00:04:32 cause against narcosism so what when you say we did have tattoo over here to winston churchill
00:04:39 that was vandalized was graffited but i mean why would who would be doing the vandalizing there
00:04:44 would that you said you had they've had black lives matter protests in the czech republic
00:04:49 would that have been them that's happened in hundreds of cities around the world and
00:04:56 you know that that's here it was quite a small protest um that's taken within the context of
00:05:03 every week over here you have tens of thousands of protesters coming out against the government
00:05:08 at the moment so there's quite a healthy protest culture but be under no illusion if if what if
00:05:17 what we were seeing in london was repeated over here in the czech republic the police would move
00:05:21 in do their job and prosecute people who are violent and people who are destroying our statues
00:05:29 yes yeah is this something you have quite a few connections with poland don't you right and what
00:05:35 is the situation like in poland is this is it's this sort of thing even having any purchase at
00:05:40 all there no not at all for the very simple reason that the peoples of central and eastern europe
00:05:45 have lived through a time when institutions were taken over when their symbols and history were
00:05:51 expunged and purged and the first thing that they did when communism collapsed and fell
00:05:56 was to restore their national flags restore their coats of arms restore their national honor system
00:06:02 bring back their prized sacred relics and statues and celebrate their past and their history
00:06:07 so it's actually from a point of privilege in the west that people are talking about they have the
00:06:13 luxury to talk about their oppression whereas they have no concept of what oppression is really like
00:06:18 and i happen to have been behind the iron curtain during the communist times and i've seen oppression
00:06:23 there you know i mean if people are going to be oppressed my my great grandmother was sent to
00:06:27 siberia my grandfather's brother was murdered by the russians in the cut in massacre those people
00:06:32 have been oppressed and they've seen how that oppressive regime tried very much to expunge
00:06:38 the existing culture and supplant it with a new foreign ideology and there are
00:06:43 parallels that can be drawn in terms of the way that that that that ideological
00:06:48 movement tried to get rid of all of the historical bonds that tied the people
00:06:52 to their national story and so there's a complete revulsion against that idea
00:06:56 happening in civilized societies of Central Europe and it's something which
00:07:00 we here should be alive and alert to too because although there are no sinister
00:07:05 KGB forces in this country, the effect is the same, to try to erase those vital connections
00:07:10 that tie people to its sense of identity and purpose and to a sense of national confidence.
00:07:16 I mean, that is what's really happening, isn't it, Emma? The sort of sense in which people
00:07:20 are being, the ties which bind, as we would call it, are sort of being cut, aren't they?
00:07:29 I mean, this seems to be on purpose.
00:07:30 It's interesting, actually, to see, like you mentioned, the ridiculous statue that's gone up in Trafalgar Square and some of the other statues that have been proposed, that all of them are ahistorical.
00:07:42 Yes.
00:07:42 They are, you know, round, circular blobs to talk about, you know, the unspoken history of various countries.
00:07:51 And it does seem to be like it's almost a symbol of this, the endless present that we spoke about in the last episode when we discussed this.
00:08:00 and the ground zero, the sort of totalitarian streak
00:08:04 that I think a lot of the people I've spoken to,
00:08:06 friends who are from Poland or their ancestors
00:08:10 or themselves who had experience of living under totalitarianism,
00:08:15 this is something that for them resonates deeply
00:08:17 because they know it when they see it.
00:08:19 But I think for us, we lack that kind of context.
00:08:22 And it's interesting as well to look at the divide,
00:08:27 political divide between those who are supporting it so recently the protest
00:08:31 outside of the Museum of the Home in London that where they had the socialist
00:08:36 worker placards and some recent Pew statistics as well showed it was the
00:08:44 Pew Institute yes so they they reviewed the social media activity throughout the
00:08:50 BLM protests after the death of George Floyd and they reviewed the politicians
00:08:56 activity on social media within the Anglosphere and found that firstly the UK was far more active
00:09:04 than any of the other countries in the Anglosphere and across the Anglosphere there was a clear
00:09:10 divide between those who were tweeting criticising the protests or criticising the destruction of
00:09:15 heritage and those who were in support of the protests being a very sort of clear left-right
00:09:20 divide so in some ways it's a bit chicken or egg you know are they supporting it because they're
00:09:24 left wing or is there some other reason some other motive for why they think that you know
00:09:29 the erasure of history is a good thing and why they would like to see it replaced with these
00:09:34 sorts of timeless idiotic blobs like the Horn of Trafalgar Square I've noticed also for example
00:09:40 that sort of what you might call harmless statues are going up you mentioned blobs but there's
00:09:46 actually rather a lovely one of Gene Kelly as singing in the rain it's gone up in Leicester
00:09:51 square and it's a very it's a lovely statue but that means it's sort of not going to do any harm
00:09:55 to anyone is it it's not going to sort of say any anything um thomas i i want to talk to you
00:10:01 you obviously um you know you're well decades younger than i am and i wondered what does
00:10:07 statues mean to you uh exactly why did you get involved in your particular case
00:10:13 well i i i think that um statues aren't just there to glorify people they're there to remind
00:10:21 us that they were they that they existed so they participated in making our nation what it is today
00:10:27 basically and so what happened what did you actually do it was you would it was the baden
00:10:34 power statue wasn't it can you just can you just tell us what happened what how did you
00:10:39 get involved in that what did you do
00:10:43 so i heard on the news that the local council were planning to take down the statue of robert
00:10:49 bacon powell who founded the scout movement in over a century ago and it because i'm not a scout
00:10:58 myself but i do support the scouting movement i made a petition to keep it where it was so i
00:11:05 shared that on community groups on on facebook on twitter and it it took off from there basically
00:11:13 and so how many signatures did you get in the end i think it was 40 000 over 40
00:11:20 or over 14 40 000 signatures in the end right but i mean therefore so did you think that actually
00:11:27 really did help the change the council's mind about this um in the end they decided that it
00:11:36 would be boarded up and then uh earlier last month they took away the boarding and it's now on display
00:11:43 again right i see um robert you know you're you have uh you've been doing a lot of petitions
00:11:51 how many organising petitions and do you think they are effective i mean this like appears to
00:11:58 be a case where they've been very effective well we've certainly seen them being used effectively
00:12:02 on the other side they've been using them in order to prompt council debates
00:12:10 and to publicize their efforts to get rid of the statues they've really taken off online
00:12:15 on our side it's been a lot harder really to get traction to get numbers with the
00:12:20 one exception perhaps of the Baden-Powell that you've mentioned
00:12:23 but they still do have some effect I'm sure we've we've had some success for instance
00:12:30 in Peterborough recently we chose to highlight that campaign where they
00:12:36 had a vote in their council to review all their statues and street names but we we wanted to take
00:12:43 a more kind of proactive approach to this and actually get in before there and petition the
00:12:48 councillors specifically on that point to try and at least give them some confidence that
00:12:56 there are a lot of people out there, the majority in fact, who really don't agree with this attack
00:13:02 on our history and heritage and don't want these reviews to take place. There's no large
00:13:08 groundswell of public opinion asking for these and at the moment as we said before councils
00:13:15 shouldn't really have a lot more better things to do with their time and resources
00:13:20 so i mean we think that that petition maybe had an impact on some of the councillors if
00:13:25 the motion was withdrawn in the end for lack of support but can i ask who are the sort of people
00:13:32 who put the petitions in to bring statues down i mean who who are they are they just like any old
00:13:39 body or who are they who are the people who sort of start these things to remove somebody i think
00:13:45 they are generally anybody um a lot of them have been triggered from uh there's a there's a website
00:13:52 that highlights the statues that are supposedly racist and um people these can be submitted by
00:13:59 anyone and the petition started by anyone they can also be signed by anyone there's no real
00:14:05 due diligence or or requirements for where you live for example they can be signed from anywhere
00:14:13 in the world it could just be the same people signing the same petitions over and over again
00:14:20 we've seen cases as well where they the numbers are massaged a bit where petitions may be
00:14:26 two petitions for the same cause and then there it's reported they add the numbers together and
00:14:32 say so many people signed a petition which clearly isn't true because it's probably the same people
00:14:39 signing both just being double counted. Richard what's your faith in you know petitions seem to
00:14:45 be a good thing but I mean at the same time you know that we've got to arm ice I know you've been
00:14:51 talking about this a lot with the campaign we've got to kind of arm ourselves with as much legal
00:14:56 knowledge as possible haven't we yes i mean just to pick up on rob's point the fact is that these
00:15:04 petitions are being set up by a lot of former members of the socialist workers party people
00:15:10 that have frankly not been successful even in local politics uh but but we all seem to be
00:15:15 dancing to their tune so they do have an amplified effect and in terms of sort of rob's work and our
00:15:22 work it's become almost a war of attrition around petitions because if you're not in that space
00:15:29 it looks like that they are speaking on behalf of the majority
00:15:33 but what we've got to do really is form a big big membership base um connect all the people
00:15:39 that are concerned about their local history and public realm set up local branches start running
00:15:45 for councils start launching local petitions start building new statues and take the offensive
00:15:52 back really you know because all the time at the moment as as based on the law-abiding majority
00:15:59 it's just being overwhelmed by a few hard left online activists you know it's frankly absurd
00:16:06 that we find ourselves in this situation where we have to defend our state in history and our state
00:16:13 do you think some people might be saying well why are you chaps focusing on statues
00:16:17 surely there are much bigger and important issues to deal with today but anybody who thinks that
00:16:21 that this is going to end with statues is not absolutely this is merely the most visible and
00:16:27 if there's a victory for the other side on the issue of statues then they'll be encouraged and
00:16:31 emboldened beyond belief so this is really the first front in a long battle or the most visible
00:16:36 front in a long battle because one has to actually question the motives of those people who are
00:16:41 putting out these petitions because common be honest nobody is oppressed by a statue commemorating
00:16:46 somebody from 200 years ago the idea is absurd you know if people in eastern europe can sort
00:16:52 can walk around and see statues of lenin and others without being oppressed when that when
00:16:56 those atrocities happened to their themselves or their parents or grandparents nobody in this
00:17:01 country is oppressed by a statue commemorating somebody who lived 200 years ago that's eight
00:17:07 generations you're great great great and forgive me but the attempt to equate the black experience
00:17:12 in this country with the black experience in america is absurd there was a famous adage in
00:17:17 the 1700s in law case you know as soon as a slave sets foot upon english soil he's a free man there's
00:17:22 been no traditional slavery here all the blacks living in this country arrived here of free choice
00:17:27 and that has to be emphasized and so you have to ask what is the motive then if no one's really
00:17:32 being impressed and it's a direct assault on british culture british identity and the very
00:17:37 essence of the british spirit because you have to think who are the people who are being attacked
00:17:41 it's drake it's nelson is churchill our greatest symbols of britishness they're very people who
00:17:46 epitomize the british spirit mavericks independent outward-looking adventurous swashbuckling buccaneer
00:17:52 types that's britishness and that that's anathema to everything that these people stand for
00:17:57 that's why this campaign is so important and that's why people need to support it
00:18:01 i i think beautifully put rave actually i mean you know emma do would you say that this is
00:18:08 are they the marxists they claim to be i mean frankly looking at them it seems to me that
00:18:13 they are the very very best scratch marks i mean it's very unsophisticated or is it just nihilism
00:18:20 i mean is it the same thing that we are seeing in europe with the destruction of churches which we
00:18:26 have not quite seen here on the same but i know you have certainly um notified and brought
00:18:31 attention to it's extraordinary what's happening in france isn't it yeah i don't think i don't
00:18:37 think necessarily you have to even separate out the different like the different strands of this
00:18:42 you know it's a bit of nihilism it's a bit of marxism it's just there's a whole zeitgeist
00:18:46 behind this that has been building and building and building for decades now and i think everything
00:18:50 that rafe has said is completely true i think that what's happened with the statues is that
00:18:55 we that that was basically it whetted their appetite um and now what we're seeing um is
00:19:01 there have been lots of instances where it's like the sins of the father are being visited on the
00:19:05 sons and but now it's becoming increasingly you know far removed so um with there was a
00:19:12 thing recently about um rhodes's uncle and a school um changing i think it was their name
00:19:17 because it was associated with rhodes uncle in some way even though he rhodes's uncle had died
00:19:22 when rhodes was three or something like that exactly so it was increasingly far removed and
00:19:27 And even in, you know, we've seen it with the National Trust in Scotland, in Liverpool with the appointment of particular people to kind of be like the witch finder general, looking to try and find increasingly abstract sins wherever they can find them.
00:19:46 And it's exactly what Rafe is describing, that it's not, you know, it's like we're talking about Marxism, you know, it's not that regimented.
00:19:55 it's a sort of visceral attack on something very core and central to the country and i think that's
00:20:02 why it at least resonates with what's been happening with and growing anti-christian
00:20:08 sentiment and attacks on churches in france because i think it's it's that same sort of
00:20:14 visceral sense of things that are associated with anything western being assaulted in some way
00:20:22 and there are plenty of people who have spoken out about this
00:20:26 who are people of colour, who have been attacked
00:20:29 and called horrific racist terms
00:20:31 and it's because the people who are attacking them
00:20:34 seem to be sort of identifying something in them
00:20:36 that they think is, you know, Western
00:20:38 and also somehow participating in this.
00:20:40 I think one activist was recently,
00:20:43 they had been accused of having temporary white privilege.
00:20:48 Temporary white privilege.
00:20:49 and so I think it's it's you don't have to necessarily separate out the different strands
00:20:53 of this it's a kind of long-term zeitgeist that wants to break everything down so that's where
00:21:00 the nihilism comes in but it also has this kind of ideological motivation behind it and I think
00:21:06 where it's actually probably early doors for even trying to unpick it but you know we've seen with
00:21:10 the Tate Britain as well with the you know the the mural in in their restaurant area that they
00:21:16 wanted to have removed um and it's it's like race very famous one by rex whistler yeah and it's not
00:21:24 it's you know that it's the same with uh the um national trust in scotland they identified i think
00:21:30 it was a fifth of their properties um were in some way involved in slavery or colonialization
00:21:35 when you look at the list it is increasingly abstract and and you think well you know if
00:21:40 there are pieces of art in a collection that were funded with the profits from plantations in
00:21:46 Jamaica or indirectly in some instances one of the monuments to the Jacobites who fell in the
00:21:53 rebellion is on land that was owned by someone who at some point his family profited from slavery
00:22:00 and so you have to ask well what's the material consequence of this? Do you hide away the art
00:22:07 collections do you burn them what happens to them because i think once you concede an inch on it
00:22:12 then it's always going to be asking well what next what next what next until everything in
00:22:17 the public space or even in these cases things that are held in trust or on private properties
00:22:23 will just be round spherical inoffensive yes i i tend to agree with you i think that you know when
00:22:30 it comes to things like plaques you know which explain the pros and cons i think to me that is
00:22:36 more than just the thin end of the wedge I think you're giving way too much I know it's apologizing
00:22:42 in a way I think um Thomas I mean does what we're saying resonate with you at all I mean
00:22:48 you know look you're you're nearer you know you you you're nearer to having been at school than
00:22:53 maybe we are here right but did you for example get um a sense that British history was you were
00:23:02 made to feel ashamed of it in some way growing up would you say yeah in instances i think that
00:23:10 would work for me to feel ashamed of british history and how it came to be but i think i think
00:23:19 that um for example you know there is this sort of uh sense of you only ever hear about the bad
00:23:29 things in british history and you know and good things about good dates in british history are
00:23:35 no longer really celebrated is that something you recognized was that your experience
00:23:41 um yeah in a way it's
00:23:46 i mean there were there were good parts and then we i think i think we were i was made
00:23:51 think about more of the bad parts the good parts really that the whole imperial empire thing was
00:23:59 bad because you had the slave trade yeah yes uh richard this is entirely absent isn't it
00:24:07 in say like places like the czech republic i mean the idea of kind of cultural self-loathing
00:24:15 almost entirely i think what there is over here is a healthy um reflective education system
00:24:22 that teaches critiquing it teaches um deeper understanding of social political and economic
00:24:29 issues um i mean i've worked in higher education in the uk the best part of a decade now and one
00:24:37 has to say that it you know it's dumbed down and then the way that politics and sociology is taught
00:24:43 is delivered in an infantile and one-dimensional way and so therefore it's not surprising that
00:24:51 the younger generation want to knock down monuments of things that they simply don't
00:24:55 understand, have never been asked to understand. And just sort of picking up on Emma's point,
00:25:02 she's absolutely right. But if you look at the history of slavery,
00:25:07 it actually contributed so little to the British economy in the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries.
00:25:15 We're looking at something like, at the best case scenario, a plus three percent addition
00:25:20 to the revenue of the country it was a major economic inhibitor to industrialization and
00:25:29 the rest of it now it benefited just a few families uh but but you know we all know that
00:25:37 we would dislike those individuals today but we would not destroy their the statues and the things
00:25:45 that sort of reflect how history evolved at that point you know if you don't like sugar plantations
00:25:50 and the history of it well should we all ban beer for example i mean this is just going to absurd
00:25:57 territory of course it's obvious that slavery is as you know is as old as prostitution and taxes
00:26:04 really i mean it goes back thousands of years britain was involved in a very short for a very
00:26:08 short period of time britain led the whole world against against slavery i've always thought this
00:26:14 this new thing, the Emancipation Day, should actually be a day to celebrate British achievements.
00:26:18 And the Emancipation Day, we just had it, is the day that the British Empire abolished slavery
00:26:22 and is now becoming more popular. But I think it actually should be a way to actually educate
00:26:26 people about the fact that it was Britain and the Empire that led the world, including having
00:26:30 the Royal Navy enforce the abolition of the slave trade on the Atlantic Oceans. And people need to
00:26:35 be educated about the fact that slavery continued long after in the Middle East and elsewhere in
00:26:40 the world. There were approximately 12 to 15 slaves who were transported from Africa
00:26:45 to the Americas. An equal number were actually held in slavery by other Africans. People
00:26:49 don't realize that. European and American ships were moored off the coast of Africa
00:26:54 and never actually made incursions into the country. They were actually purchasing slaves
00:26:58 from other Africans who had enslaved other warring tribes. No one seemed to talk about
00:27:03 that at all. And of course, all these millions of words and all these people marching on
00:27:09 the streets against you know against the oppressive british empire and slavery seem curiously silent
00:27:14 about the fact that there are 40 million people living in slavery today in the world that's i
00:27:19 think seven and every thousand africans today are living in in bonded labor and slavery and yet where
00:27:24 are the great protests around the the the african embassies and and high commissions about that
00:27:29 there's an eerie silence and i think that silence is a very loud a very loud thing in itself
00:27:36 Certainly when I hear about decolonising the curriculum,
00:27:40 it always makes me feel slightly surprised because I remember personally being told,
00:27:45 not being taught anything particularly wonderful about the empire. It was always really the other
00:27:49 way around or just skipped over to a large degree. But really I think this battle for history as well
00:27:56 is certainly beyond the schools and education. It's moving into other areas, it's certainly in
00:28:02 the museums it's in the plaques that you talked about where people are saying that this will be
00:28:09 kind of to provide a balanced history but of course it doesn't really look like it's going
00:28:14 to be anything of the sort it's going to be a total totally one-sided view of history the other way
00:28:20 and we see it as well spreading into other areas i think on online in particular with something
00:28:26 I've noticed on on Wikipedia there was there was an example when the statue of Baron Holland in
00:28:34 Holland Park was vandalized and I looked and within maybe two hours his entry on Wikipedia
00:28:41 had been updated with a paragraph all about this graffiti attack possibly even by the person who
00:28:47 did it we don't know any anyone could edit Wikipedia basically it's a a crowd-sourced
00:28:52 kind of history but this is it's it's very commonly used now um for some people it's really
00:28:57 their only history um sometimes it's okay you know it's a starting point that you can then
00:29:04 back up with further reading and the like but for many that's it and um it's becoming um that's
00:29:09 becoming a new battleground as well to edit those entries and actually um control how people see our
00:29:16 history yes it's interesting because this thing about decolonizing the curriculum i saw a piece in
00:29:22 this evening standard last night it was just a small report there's a school in london i can't
00:29:29 remember the name but i wouldn't say it anyway they've just won an award an inclusivity award
00:29:34 for they have decolonized their curriculum right but the point is it's not i took that to mean
00:29:40 quite literally anti-imperial history it's not actually it's basically getting rid of what you
00:29:47 might call the canon of western culture so out go white authors in come black authors i think
00:29:55 they're no longer even going to teach the seven wonders of the world for example this is presumably
00:30:00 because it's too much of a white idea i don't know but this is the point emma isn't it decolonization
00:30:06 is not quite how it sounds, is it?
00:30:09 I think actually this goes to the heart of the matter
00:30:12 and I think both of you raised a really important point
00:30:16 which is it's a question of which stories we're choosing to teach,
00:30:20 the perspective that we're choosing to look at these aspects of history through
00:30:25 because there are many stories you can teach.
00:30:27 The story of the white working class is something that
00:30:31 and their role in the Industrial Revolution is something
00:30:34 that doesn't really get very much attention
00:30:35 in the within the curriculum but when we talk about decolonizing the curriculum
00:30:40 what it usually seems to boil down to is again it's the sort of social justice theory categories
00:30:47 the lgbtq gender orientation and you know however long the list is now it's it's it's less to do
00:30:59 with the british empire and more to do with breaking down the traditional categories of
00:31:04 education the traditional categories through which we view history um and trying to find things that
00:31:11 are problematic within that um and i think it's it's interesting because it is it's a question of
00:31:17 which stories we're choosing to teach because if you look at again going back to the national trust
00:31:21 in scotland um you know i think it's great if you want to to tell those stories about you know the
00:31:27 connections between particular houses um and the transatlantic slave trade or the their you know
00:31:34 the role of the people who were living in that house at the time within Jamaica.
00:31:38 One of the houses, I think, was modelled on a house that was in the plantation somewhere.
00:31:43 You know, that's fine to teach that history.
00:31:45 I think it's a great thing.
00:31:46 You know, teach as much history as you possibly can.
00:31:49 But I think we have to be asking ourselves,
00:31:50 why is it this history that the focus seems to be on?
00:31:54 And it seems to be a kind of almost a cultural point now, a cultural default,
00:31:58 that all institutions everywhere are really, this is trendy now.
00:32:03 um and in whilst focusing on this we should be asking ourselves well if we're actually going
00:32:09 to employ some critical thinking what other stories are we missing here um because you know
00:32:15 as richard mentioned about the the contribution of slavery to the economy you know what was the
00:32:20 economy like at the time where are we actually discussing you know this because often you hear
00:32:25 um talk about you know the um the the white working class during this period of time and
00:32:32 and the role of industrialisation and oppressing them.
00:32:35 And, you know, how do all these things link together?
00:32:37 We don't have room to discuss that.
00:32:39 And I think we need to ask ourselves, why these stories?
00:32:42 And what, you know, why is it the socialist worker is so keen on it?
00:32:46 And, of course, it's the Institute of Education.
00:32:48 It's the teaching colleges that I've often said are the black heart
00:32:52 of this modernist attempt to deconstruct Britain
00:32:55 and the very nature of Britishness.
00:32:58 And so you have to ask, you know, what is a civilisation?
00:33:01 Civilizations come and go, and what is their legacy?
00:33:03 It's their monuments, it's their philosophy, it's their literature and their writings.
00:33:07 And any civilization and culture that isn't brave enough to stand up and defend those doesn't deserve to exist.
00:33:13 And yet what we're seeing here is a complete erosion of our own sense of self-confidence
00:33:17 and a complete failure to teach the young who will grow up without knowing any of this.
00:33:22 And so it's a sort of atrophying civilization that you have as a result of that.
00:33:25 And that's their goal.
00:33:26 you can win a war and a revolution without flying red flags from the rooftop simply by undermining
00:33:30 from within and that's what we're seeing now do you think actually from what you've been doing
00:33:35 robert online with uh save our statues online do you think uh do you think people kind of get that
00:33:42 do you think they know it's that or i mean have you been struck by well presumably you've been
00:33:47 struck by people's uh passion about this you know because one's always worried that people are going
00:33:53 to be apathetic that's not what we found with this new website and campaign but i mean have
00:33:59 you been struck by people's i mean you know the sheer their their emotion about this subject
00:34:05 yes um definitely and i think as well like you say they they do know it or they are largely aware
00:34:12 of um to an extent what what he's just been talking about um and the the wider um cultural
00:34:18 war that's really behind it i think very much so yes yeah but whether they're representative of
00:34:26 the wider population i don't know i mean i think the the followers we have on twitter are probably
00:34:31 on the the active end edge i suppose um and and perhaps more in tune with well some of the other
00:34:38 discussions on social media so they're they're more alert to to seeing the the the underlying
00:34:44 factors i think driving it yeah i mean richard you know we you know there's been a good a very
00:34:50 good uh response to the new campaign hasn't there it's been terrific terrific and uh not surprising
00:34:57 for me uh we've had pretty much uh an even split if we want to go into identity politics we've had
00:35:04 an even split between male and female we've had um people generally around the country
00:35:12 uh feeding into us and subscribing uh what's noticeable is the low amount of interest from
00:35:20 within the city of london and sort of the inner boroughs of london um we've we've had messages
00:35:27 of support from america that say their their history their revolution is almost gone but can
00:35:35 they help us and um really it's been a lot of young people as well you know it's been very very
00:35:41 inspiring what's noticeable about this is is that people are viscerally upset and emotionally
00:35:50 damaged i have to say on a personal level i i've never been through anything like this
00:35:56 you know where your your culture and your history is just being erased before your eyes and there
00:36:01 seems to be nothing you can do and this campaign is about bringing people together to reject that
00:36:07 narrative we are the moral majority we are the law-abiding uh communities and we are going to
00:36:15 win this one and if that means standing for council next year or in two years time or running for
00:36:19 parliament we will do it and we will do it together you mentioned there about london which you like
00:36:25 you know relatively little coming from london uh that doesn't surprise me at all um you know
00:36:32 and i mentioned at the beginning of the program about sadiq khan's particular um review which is
00:36:39 called the commission for diversity in the public realm which is actually wrong even grammatically
00:36:46 a realm is a country i believe and you can't be just in a city anyway be that as it may
00:36:52 this is going to revise
00:36:55 looking all the way through
00:36:57 all of London's monuments
00:37:00 and
00:37:01 there's a particular significance
00:37:03 here isn't it because
00:37:04 the monuments in London as well are
00:37:07 national, actually
00:37:09 internationally important
00:37:11 aren't they Raif?
00:37:13 They're international monuments
00:37:15 many of them were funded by privates
00:37:17 donations, by public
00:37:19 subscription, there are different parts
00:37:21 of London that are governed by different rules and laws in different areas, Westminster Council
00:37:26 or local councils, or if it's Crown Roads. There are a whole bunch of different policies,
00:37:31 so how on earth you would have an overriding policy on this, I can't see whatsoever. And
00:37:37 of course, a lot of it is the fact that, of course, London is the capital of the whole
00:37:41 country, and lots of things are put in there because it's a national capital rather than
00:37:45 just a fiefdom of the Labour Party or of Sadiq Khan and so I'm not sure in what his plans to do
00:37:52 and then of course if you're going to start this precedent then who's to say that in 25 years from
00:37:56 now people won't be removing the statues erected in the last five years you know it's a very dangerous
00:38:01 road to go down I'd much rather see Sadiq Khan speak out about modern slavery in Pakistan you
00:38:07 know this is a man who's constantly telling us all he's a son of a Pakistani bus driver not once
00:38:12 have I ever heard him condemn the fact that slavery in Pakistan is the worst in the entire
00:38:16 planet and he even went there on an official visit and not once did he raise the issue of
00:38:21 slavery in Pakistan and yet he's one of the key people calling for a slavery museum in this
00:38:25 country and calling for Britain to wear sackcloth for its role in the slave trade and yet he's
00:38:32 completely silent about it when it's happening today and I would have thought that the lives
00:38:35 of people today are a lot more important. I think the interesting thing about London as well is that
00:38:40 the mayor has sort of strange quite vague areas of power but he has particular authority over
00:38:48 things like Trafalgar Square you know hence I started by talking about this big ice cream
00:38:53 that's gone up you know or Parliament Square you know it it's not just a council thing it's a
00:38:58 complicated situation in London isn't it you know yeah I think well certainly like you say in London
00:39:04 in particular these are national monuments but I I would even stretch that to to those around the
00:39:09 country. I mean, who's to say who really has a stake in these? It's not just even the local
00:39:15 people. And certainly I think people are surprised that the councils have so much power. It's not
00:39:21 really what they were elected to do. They're elected to run a city or a town, but not really
00:39:27 to take these kinds of decisions. And as well, it's quite clear that the councils don't want to
00:39:34 ask the people sometimes you know if you were to put these questions to a public vote whether
00:39:40 that's locally or nationally I think it's quite clear the way it would go from every time people
00:39:45 are asked they generally say they want to keep them so yeah it seems to be a an unusual situation
00:39:52 where the councils or other institutions as well that have have a stakeholder in this have have
00:39:59 this power? Well, look, I mean, I think that we really should draw real encouragement and comfort
00:40:06 from the response to, you know, this campaign into what you've done, Rob, on Twitter. And,
00:40:12 you know, indeed, generally to the extent of feeling that you get from people around the
00:40:19 country. And I just think, you know, we've got to sort of make sure that we are equipped with
00:40:24 the right knowledge you know to to actually oppose what's going on you know I think that's
00:40:29 that's what it's about. To that end please do won't you subscribe or join saveourstatues.org.uk
00:40:40 you can become a member too and indeed if you get involved and you can tell us about your local
00:40:47 situation and indeed you know we can help you as much as we possibly can and
00:40:53 build a real network in the meantime thank you to Rafe to Emma to Richard to
00:41:01 Thomas and to Robert and we will be giving you updates on the campaign as it
00:41:06 goes along over the coming months so do join see you soon thank you bye
00:41:17 Thank you.