New Culture Forum - September 06, 2020


Douglas Murray - The Cult Of Woke & The Project To Lie About Our History

We Are Witnessing An Attempt To Reset Britain To Year Zero And Eradicate Its Proud History Andrew Doyle: "My First Little Book Of Intersectional Activism", a parody of today's woke kids books

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

155.32

Word count

7,047

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted to say that my
00:00:27 guest today is one of our most requested. Douglas Murray the best-selling author and columnist
00:00:33 was first on the show last year. He came on to talk about his latest book which was The Madness
00:00:39 of Crowds, Gender, Race and Identity. Before that he'd written another international bestseller
00:00:46 called The Strange Death of Europe. Now The Madness of Crowds is out in an updated paperback. It's
00:00:53 just come out this week so i'm delighted that he's come to talk about it again thank you very
00:00:59 much it's a huge pleasure to be back nice to see you again peter your timing is is is pretty spot
00:01:04 on isn't it uh yes i mean in some ways i'd say regrettably yeah um i had thought slightly at
00:01:14 the beginning of this year particularly with covid i thought well maybe all this identity
00:01:18 politics stuff would go away the paperback was coming out I was
00:01:22 reflecting on what I would say in this updated edition and then I just there
00:01:28 was no shortage of material there was no shortage of things to say to write about
00:01:32 to reflect on yes it's it's it feels to me now as if I tried to sound an early
00:01:41 warning siren and you know sometimes people said to me what it seems it's
00:01:47 very prophetic and there's this problem with being regarded as being in any way
00:01:54 prophetic which is that you immediately people think it's flattering yeah but
00:01:59 actually it's not because a really good prophet would have stopped something
00:02:04 happening you know being hard on yourself well sure I mean I'm
00:02:09 overstating what you can achieve with a book mainly but you know if you actually
00:02:13 say to people you've got this catastrophe coming down the road stop it
00:02:18 now and they run harder and faster and nastier then you do think slightly you
00:02:24 know it could could we have warned people better yeah of course one thing
00:02:33 interests me is with with the book obviously we're talking about the
00:02:38 incredible emergence of wokeness identity politics the way they're
00:02:43 dominating that was the theme yeah why are they dominating but you presumably
00:02:49 had a lot of people contacting you afterwards because we hear the big
00:02:56 cancellation stories don't we yeah but did people get in touch with you and say
00:03:01 you know this is a situation I'm in yes yes I had a lot of that emails letters
00:03:07 and when we could still do public events you know the most moving one is people
00:03:15 in person coming up to you after events and telling their stories I one of the
00:03:21 ones I found most moving in a way was the number of people didn't happen a lot
00:03:25 but it happened a fair amount parents of children who'd been going through the
00:03:31 trans thing just bewildered bereft parents just saying thank you for helping
00:03:39 me try to see what's happening in this because people in that position have
00:03:45 been totally ignored I mean when every professional says either your child is
00:03:53 in the wrong body or you'll have a dead child accept it when people are being
00:03:58 threatened with the suicide of their children by medical professionals and no one cares you know
00:04:06 that that really struck me um but yes you know i i got some of that the other one i suppose i heard
00:04:16 most rather inevitably you won't be surprised to hear this is people in you know good what we
00:04:23 would have thought of as good reliable jobs who just can't say anything and
00:04:30 and of course for anyone in the position I'm in and I think you're in where thank
00:04:36 goodness we can say what we think we can see what we feel and what we notice
00:04:41 with our eyes that that adds gives you an added responsibility I think you said
00:04:48 this is actually you do have a duty i think i think i don't i don't want to misquote you if
00:04:53 you don't have an employer or you don't you've almost got a duty to make some sort of stand
00:04:59 i think that i mean it doesn't have to be i'm not saying that people should take a political stand
00:05:04 or argue a particular set of policies i just think if you are in a position to say what you
00:05:09 see and to argue out your position in a way it matters less what that is than that you can do it
00:05:15 You know, if somebody was in a position where there was some terrible injustice of any kind,
00:05:22 and they felt they couldn't identify it, we'd know that something was systemically wrong.
00:05:29 And yet we have this situation where on issue after issue and job after job,
00:05:34 people feel they not only don't have the right to speak, but don't speak.
00:05:40 and of course that means that those of us who are not in hock to you know
00:05:47 vulnerable to an employer of course that means that we have a certain extra duty
00:05:53 I think yeah but my hope is always that everybody can do it with the trans
00:06:01 trans issue that you mentioned there I think there were quite a few people
00:06:07 commentators who thought that this was the tipping point that the absurdity of much of it and in fact
00:06:12 the damage of so much of it would somehow make people pull back but i don't get the feeling
00:06:20 that's happened aren't you suspicious of tipping points in general i mean by now aren't you i mean
00:06:26 how many years on how many subjects have we heard people say i think this might be the tipping point
00:06:32 I think it's wishful thinking
00:06:34 I remember it always used to happen
00:06:36 with the terrorism thing because I think this
00:06:38 one will be the tipping point
00:06:39 and then things happened which
00:06:42 you would have thought wouldn't just be a tipping point
00:06:43 it would be a complete tipping over point
00:06:45 and everything went on as normal
00:06:47 I think you might have commented on
00:06:50 that with the Manchester bombing
00:06:51 yes
00:06:52 this surely your daughters
00:06:55 are being killed
00:06:56 just the other day
00:06:58 Harry Cole was
00:07:01 on Sky News with a lunatic of the left I don't know who she is she's a new lunatic to me and
00:07:09 she was talking about the sentencing said you know I think well we need to find out why the
00:07:14 sentencing was so uh you know long and obviously she was actually had no plans to read the judgment
00:07:19 did she she spends her evenings pouring over judicial you know and and she said well I need
00:07:25 we need to see why the uh the sentence was so so particularly long and Harry Cole said
00:07:29 maybe because he killed 22 young people at a pop concert you know I was delighted he made the point
00:07:38 because so many other people seem to have forgotten it but yes I mean this is so the
00:07:42 whole tipping point thing on issue after issue I I wish I wish that we had tipping points perhaps
00:07:48 we can see them in the rearview mirror but when you're going through them I think it's very hard
00:07:54 to see what the tipping point is not least because it might be something which is relatively small
00:07:58 scale i mean maybe the tipping point on the trans one is i said in the madness of crowds in the
00:08:03 first edition i said there are legal cases that are going to start and when that really gets going
00:08:08 this will stop and now some of that has started right you know a young person in the uk has got
00:08:14 legal aid funding to take action against the tavistock clinic i do think a bit of that will
00:08:21 will speed us up to realizing we were going in a very dangerous direction there also do you think
00:08:27 that the jk rowling thing has helped at all i mean it's related obviously yes she wasn't
00:08:33 cancelled for what she said which was i basically a woman you know people who menstruate i think
00:08:39 wasn't it yeah yeah yeah you mean you mean a woman yeah and um she wasn't there was another
00:08:43 of course around the same time another company did they said you know people with vaginas that's
00:08:50 and you know jk rowling and others are right to say we didn't used to be known as people with
00:08:56 vaginas or people who menstruate there's a word for it women by the way the jk running one was
00:09:02 interesting because it's worth reflecting when somebody doesn't get as it were successfully
00:09:06 cancelled um uh is it because she's very rich well that's possible powerful you know money does bring
00:09:15 certain power um she she's probably quite hard to complete the real thing with cancel culture is
00:09:23 people going for your source of income so that you are totally bereft and effectively made homeless
00:09:29 and that's what they want so it's hard to turf jk rowling out of every one of her houses by now
00:09:34 i imagine but but but i don't want to diminish what she did it's an exceptionally important
00:09:39 thing that people like her particularly women like i'm particularly women of the left make
00:09:45 their voices heard and uh this again argue the truth as they see it uh and yes this has a huge
00:09:53 impact and also let's face it i mean you know i'm sure there are some people it's easier to portray
00:09:58 as bigots and some people it's hard it's quite hard to say that harry potter woman is you know
00:10:03 basically goebbels i mean they try obviously but it's it's a tough one yes well she was actually
00:10:10 always very sort of woke very much on that oh yeah kevin myers yes the distinguished irish writer
00:10:19 uh wrote the spectator the other week reminding people at jk rowling when when the twitter mob
00:10:23 came for him several years ago she uh she led it yeah she whipped her people up yes so you know
00:10:30 but anyhow hopefully people who've done that then realized that was a horrible thing to have done
00:10:37 and it's come for them and so you know try to step back from that kind of
00:10:42 behavior you mentioned people coming up to you afterwards and getting in touch
00:10:47 with you with their personal experiences I remember when you came on the show
00:10:52 last time Douglas you and in the book well you're talking about how we go
00:10:56 forwards and one of the ways to go forward is to try not to live so
00:11:02 politically yeah to to be loving yeah I found it really quite a moving conclusion
00:11:08 that would you say is become more difficult now I mean or how do people do
00:11:16 it now because a lot of people I feel now and I've certainly the reaction that
00:11:21 I get from people who write into showing is of utter despair despair you know
00:11:26 they feel their context is being essentially taken away from them yes yes
00:11:33 so what do they do um I do think this issue of trying to depoliticize our
00:11:40 lives is more urgent than ever what I tried to suggest that that in that
00:11:49 passage in the matters of crowds was to say young people in particular have been
00:11:54 misled they've been misled into thinking that purpose and meaning in life can
00:11:59 primarily or best be found in political activism and there's lots of reasons why
00:12:05 I suggest that isn't the case just one of which is you'll never win you know
00:12:11 you'll never win totally you'll win the odd round but as you know politics
00:12:20 political activity is a constant tug of war in which you very rarely in fact
00:12:29 never win outright so it's it's it's it's it's it's dangerous from that point
00:12:37 of view it's dangerous also because you will imbue it with too much meaning you
00:12:42 know if you think that everything in life is about politics and the people
00:12:47 disagree with you are unmentionables you know they are they will be people who
00:12:54 are deliberately trying not to do that which is good and you'll find it very
00:13:00 hard to find you'll find it very hard in the end to live in the same country as
00:13:04 them even and and so that that's that's one of the reasons but the other is is
00:13:12 just that central fact that I mean so many writers have touched on this over
00:13:16 the years i always think of that uh figure in is it in bleak house or hard times mrs jellyby
00:13:25 who dickens shows you know she's she spends all of her time raising funds for a far off land in
00:13:32 africa that she's never been to and she has all of these children of her own who she completely
00:13:38 ignores in fact when we first meet the jellybies the youngest jellyby has his head stuck in the
00:13:44 railings and mrs jellyby doesn't have time to remove her son's head from the railings
00:13:51 because she's got to save this and we all know this type it's why dickens in his great genius
00:13:56 was able to create the character because we recognize the type there's a lot of that today
00:14:03 there's a lot of suggestion that that's what we should do i mean look at the whole greta fernberg
00:14:08 you know children's crusade as we might call it what is that but an urge to involve yourself in
00:14:16 a very great task i think that's pg pj walk said yes what is it he says pj rock said everyone
00:14:26 everyone wants to save the world no one wants to help mom do the dishes exactly no one wants
00:14:30 help mom do the dishes exactly and uh we also now have this thing which we should identify
00:14:38 which is not just the wanting to save the world, but the cult that is now operating.
00:14:45 When people are told that they should disassociate from family members who do not agree with them,
00:14:52 you're not dealing with politics, you're dealing with a cult.
00:14:56 Something that tells you to give up a portion of your worldly goods,
00:15:01 remove yourself from the environment of your family and loved ones,
00:15:06 if they are not sufficiently of the correct view this is a cult anyone who's ever lost a relative
00:15:12 or met somebody who's lost a relative to a cult knows this is a cult-like behavior
00:15:17 and this is what's happening and so that's one of the other dangers of this imbuing of
00:15:22 of this attempt to find meaning in politics is that you will also go into that utmost place
00:15:28 where you're not even involved in politics anymore you're involved in cults
00:15:31 you said a very interesting point there about how it's hard to live with people who are going to
00:15:40 consider you sort of wicked if you like or even the same country yeah and that is not far-fetched
00:15:49 actually i mean uh you sort of sometimes you you know i said don't we all do this and we look and
00:15:55 well wait a minute you know is this the dominant attitude now i mean this came up during brexit
00:16:02 of course with people who who voted brexit you know they were essentially bad people they were
00:16:09 stupid wicked people that's a very dangerous situation do you think that's alleviated by the
00:16:14 way um no i think it's just transferred right i think you see it with covid actually whatever
00:16:22 your view on covenants i think it's this kind of strange moral righteousness you know that is what
00:16:27 i am and as you were saying about sort of like um cults there is this sort of sense of i'm i'm going
00:16:35 to purify myself this is me purified you know i'm totally pure now i i is woke yes yes and of course
00:16:43 really i mean one way to change this is to identify this behavior and identify what it really means
00:16:48 historically what does it mean when somebody wishes to go around parading themselves as a
00:16:55 person of virtue almost certain it means they're guilty of every vice you can think of and then
00:17:00 some you haven't thought of yet it's a very reliable rule isn't it people who go around you
00:17:08 know lecturing people over sexual morality as my late friend Christopher Hitchens used to say
00:17:13 make a small note in a book make a jotting and before long you'll find them
00:17:19 you know spread eagled on the floor of a public lavatory and yeah and maxing out
00:17:26 the credit card paying for transsexual and that's that that's that's pretty
00:17:30 reliable that rule and it's happened once again in recent days in America
00:17:33 with a certain man of the cloth oh yeah yeah so so we know that type I mean we've
00:17:42 known it for so long you know Chaucer wrote about this type that for some
00:17:47 reason we haven't identified them in the current age but I mean we have we have
00:17:52 whole classes of these people who I mean the most obvious is the ones who jet
00:17:56 around the world in private jets telling us not to fly on cheap budget holidays
00:18:02 these people are Chaucerian figures and the climate the most extreme climate
00:18:11 activists and clearly now the most extreme woke activists they are all this hypocritical new
00:18:17 priestly class and i don't mind other than the fact that people are unwilling to identify them
00:18:22 as such if they came along with you know dog collars and purple robes we'd identify them
00:18:28 straight away but because they're sort of you know dressed undercover we don't but we should
00:18:34 we should call them out i mentioned at the very top there about the updating of your book as an
00:18:41 afterward and it is extraordinary actually the period since your book came out first and you
00:18:49 know i think in some ways probably dougs you could have written an afterward to the afterward yeah
00:18:54 because it's sort of events are going on and on are you surprised first of all are you surprised
00:19:00 at the extraordinary intensity of the cultural onslaught that there's been from Black Lives
00:19:07 Matter onwards and I also want to really ask you do you think that it's actually to do with Black
00:19:16 Lives Matter or in fact are we seeing the extraordinary weakness of all of our institutions
00:19:22 because they are the ones that have capitulated whether it's the Archbishop of Canterbury right
00:19:27 to the premier league right yeah all of them but i i mean what is your when this happened straight
00:19:35 after lockdown really were you taken aback you know with the statues being um i was struck by
00:19:45 how far they went so fast yes i mean we're sitting in london talking about this and of course we've
00:19:52 had you know butter cold compared to what's been going on in America there
00:20:00 was a very worrying moment in this country wasn't there where when the
00:20:03 statue of Colston was torn down in Bristol and I particularly objected that
00:20:08 I was on a radio show with the maniac from The Guardian and this this man said
00:20:15 well were you in favor of the pulling were you against the pulling down the
00:20:18 statue of course you know Douglas I said yes of course I was he said oh so you're
00:20:22 in favor of slavery are you and I said to him you know how much easier do you
00:20:26 want to make this debate for your side and that you think that's what it is you
00:20:31 know you think that those of us who mind seeing mobs pulling down things in
00:20:36 cities are desiring to bring back slavery I mean you need to lie down
00:20:41 after you speak to somebody that dim you know yeah and and there he was
00:20:47 was seriously arguing this and of course really what it was that struck me and worried me as I'm
00:20:52 sure it did you was we know those of us who know and care about history we know what this means
00:21:01 because we've seen it before now we saw a glimmer in this country but anyone who has read the
00:21:09 history of the French Revolution don't even need to have read Burke's reflections on the French
00:21:13 revolution we know how this goes anyone who's read about any revolution knows
00:21:21 this is how it goes and in this country thank goodness eventually the police
00:21:30 reasserted their authority eventually our conservative government managed to
00:21:39 defend our history just about just about in america the police have stepped back considerably
00:21:52 for reasons which are very obvious and city after city in america is burning
00:21:58 and now in america you cannot unite around the history because of a project that has
00:22:07 been underway i think for two generations that has taught people a lie about their history and
00:22:13 we should get on to this because this is a really well you can talk about it now i mean yeah this
00:22:18 is a really dangerous moment oh it is and again it's the sheer speed of things but when you talk
00:22:25 about this project that's been going on for two uh two decades two generations two generations
00:22:31 There is also, initiated by the New York Times, an actual project, which is called the 1619 Project, which is an attack on the American Revolution.
00:22:41 The 1619 Project aims to change the founding date of America and turn it to the time that slaves were first brought into the, well, it wasn't even the Republic yet.
00:22:52 I'm so pleased you raised that one because it is the epitome of the problem the teaching of
00:23:03 young Americans that their country is not just a country that is not particularly virtuous but
00:23:09 their country is the worst unfortunately and I say this with all due respect to my American friends
00:23:16 unfortunately this is only possible because of mass ignorance in America now
00:23:22 it turns out that the ignorance is not from the people that we might have
00:23:26 assumed would be ignorant people it is from the elites it is from people whose
00:23:31 parents remortgaged their houses to send their children to college to learn this
00:23:36 stuff and we have this in Britain we have this in Britain we have the idea
00:23:46 that we are the country that has been bad in history and the problem is is that
00:23:53 when you push back against this there's a tendency of people say well you would
00:23:56 say that wouldn't you because you're British and you can say in response yes
00:24:02 that's true I I do defend the things in my country that are good but I also
00:24:08 believe that on any fair analysis this is also possible and this this fair
00:24:15 analysis is now something that is not happening in either America or Britain
00:24:19 and we have to address it I wrote recently on this whole issue take any
00:24:27 country in the world it's thought that over the period of round the 17th
00:24:33 century up to one and a half European one and a half million Europeans were
00:24:38 seized by the Barbary pirates one of the reasons why by the people in Britain
00:24:43 sang and sing royal britannia and britain's never shall be slaves was because of the familiarity in
00:24:50 the public mind from defoe and others who make it clear the familiarity with the concept that
00:24:56 you could be enslaved and that wasn't enslaved by the americans it wasn't enslaved by the horrible
00:25:05 other british it was enslaved by the barbary pirates among others by the moors as they were
00:25:11 called then now if we're going to do this grand historical sweep that regard history as this vast
00:25:20 savannah which the grievance mongers can hunt through and find things in good let's do it
00:25:29 i want to get turkey first they've got it coming they really do the ottoman empire was one of the
00:25:37 longest widest empires in human history we have to make the turks pay half a million anatolian
00:25:45 greeks chased out massacred and chased out only a hundred years ago we don't have to go back two and
00:25:51 a half centuries as you do in britain to our terrible terrible past we can go back far less
00:25:56 time to turkey where are they going to pay the reparations where can greece send the bill should
00:26:02 it send it to Ankara? What about all the other people? What about the Armenians? The first great
00:26:08 terrible genocide of the 20th century. Where can the remaining Armenians get their reparations from?
00:26:14 We can do this on every country on earth. I'm completely up for it if people want to decide
00:26:23 that all of us who are Europeans and Britons, who are descendants of the people who feared being
00:26:29 abducted at sea or on land by the Barbary pirates should go now to Algeria and take their money.
00:26:35 Fine. Let's have a go. You think we'd get peace? You think we'd get justice? You think we'd lay
00:26:43 any ghosts to rest? We'd dig the whole damn thing up again and then some. And that's what they're
00:26:50 doing to our country. And that's what they're doing to America. It's fundamentally unfair.
00:26:57 it's fundamentally unjust it's fundamentally dishonest in some ways what's been happening
00:27:04 what you're describing there but what's been happening over the part over the summer
00:27:08 in america and here to a lesser extent but in america i see really as being
00:27:16 described in both of your books you see not just the man's a crowd but i see you talk about with
00:27:22 In The Strange Death of Europe, I should explain to people,
00:27:25 you talk about the massive collapse of confidence in Europe.
00:27:29 Yes, yes.
00:27:30 But when you wrote it, Doug, would you have thought
00:27:33 that this would have applied to America too at that time?
00:27:37 I thought it was less advanced in America than it's turned out to be.
00:27:40 It's moved much further, much faster in America.
00:27:44 I thought that America had the sense that we had in Britain
00:27:50 and that we probably both still have,
00:27:52 that we had done things wrong in the past,
00:27:57 but that by and large we were a force for good in the world.
00:28:01 And the Americans I've known throughout my life,
00:28:03 and I've always admired America,
00:28:05 I've always had my criticisms of it,
00:28:06 like everybody does, of everywhere.
00:28:08 I mean, show me a perfect country.
00:28:12 But I always thought that Americans had this sense,
00:28:15 that of course, you know,
00:28:18 of course the founding fathers had not been perfect,
00:28:21 but my word were they people you know um yes there had been slavery but there had also been
00:28:29 a very bloody civil war fought in a country that tore itself apart to stop the evil of slavery
00:28:39 i thought they still had the narrative of goodness about themselves but they have been taught as i
00:28:46 I say for a couple of generations the narrative of nothing being more evil and I suppose if you
00:28:52 if you tie that in with a country which by its geographical location apart from anything else
00:28:57 is a country where a lot of people don't go abroad all that much and see the rest of the world
00:29:03 you know this is always used against Americans it's not necessarily I've never quite got no it's
00:29:09 Not necessarily a, you know, it's a huge country, it's a continent and, but, you know, as we all know, if you do go abroad and see a lot of different cultures, you do notice, without needing to over, you know, think it, you do notice some of the things that are good in your own culture, which you're happy you've got, you know.
00:29:32 i remember once um coming out of north korea with some friends getting across the chinese
00:29:39 border and a friend of mine is saying to me welcome to the freedom of china
00:29:43 it's one of the great dry lines i've ever heard but it did feel like that we were oh we can breathe
00:29:52 out now um um but so it is the case that if you travel around you you can see and you see among
00:30:00 other things gosh the things i've taken for granted i shouldn't have done you know that's
00:30:06 why traditionally people have been encouraged to travel is to is among other things to learn about
00:30:11 the world but also to get in a better perspective what's good about the place you're from which
00:30:16 otherwise you might take for granted in this country we have now though this same this same
00:30:22 perverse teaching as americans have got that that we in britain were not a force for good in the
00:30:27 the world and I I I have a problem with this not because of some sentimental
00:30:35 thing or not some sentimental thing alone but because it's such a clearly
00:30:39 unfair analysis of us and you know that if I can think of an occasion when that
00:30:49 was epitomized recently the one I minded most I'm sure you felt the same was
00:30:55 after the black lives matter protests once again once again people from that
00:31:00 protest graffitied the senator and those young men and women from the household
00:31:07 cavalry went it turned out there from the Household Calvary went on this morning
00:31:13 off in their civvies and cleaned the graffiti off and this one is young you
00:31:22 You know, activists of Black Lives Matter with their friends videoed this and derided those young men and women for doing it.
00:31:32 One of them said, oh, you're so keen that you won't even leave the Black Lives Matter on your precious monuments.
00:31:42 On your monuments, yes.
00:31:44 Your precious monuments.
00:31:45 And I thought several things from that.
00:31:47 One was your.
00:31:50 war. Wow, you're treading on a landmine there. These are either our monuments, our monuments,
00:31:59 or they belong only to some people. And if they only belong to some people, we're going down the
00:32:03 worst imaginable path. And it's those people that would lead us there. But the second thing to say
00:32:10 about that is what this country needs to say is yes yes they're precious
00:32:18 monuments yes they're precious and we make no apology for that because our
00:32:24 forebears yours mine gave their lives and are commemorated silently at that
00:32:31 place so no you don't get to deride us you don't get to laugh at it you don't
00:32:38 get to graffiti it no your cause is not more important than that you can have
00:32:45 your holy places fine we have ours this is serious but how serious I mean we
00:32:58 talked about the speed of events when particularly you look at America as you
00:33:04 said uh their holy places are seemingly endlessly systematically under attack to the point where it
00:33:14 actually was not inconceivable that they would go off to mount rushmore oh yeah yeah yeah in fact
00:33:19 the new york times sort of egged it on if i remember cnn said that the president was speaking
00:33:24 in front of the statues of slave owners on land stolen from native americans
00:33:29 unbelievable you would think anyway but what do we talk I mean are we talking about are we actually
00:33:40 talking about the decline not just of countries but actually the fall of a civilization it could
00:33:49 be it could be that's what I suggest in strange death of Europe and you know there's four centuries
00:33:58 that it takes the Roman Empire to properly collapse and the time you can
00:34:03 identify the start there are lots of very bad signs around and I have a
00:34:17 suggestion of how this can be avoided I've quite a lot of suggestions for how
00:34:23 it can be avoided because can I make one suggestion to begin with which is this
00:34:28 why don't we try to work out who are the honest critics who wish us well and who
00:34:32 are not you know when people say you can be a better country if you do X do they
00:34:41 really want us to be a better country or do they want us to end there's I've
00:34:47 dwelt rather too much perhaps on mad people but can I throw one more in there's
00:34:55 There's an academic at Cambridge, I won't name, at a certain college named after somebody
00:35:00 far greater than she could imagine, who is a race baiter, a racist, I would say.
00:35:08 She says the most disgusting things about white people on a regular basis, and it's
00:35:12 an amazing thing that an institution like Cambridge should still have such a person
00:35:16 in their employ.
00:35:18 However, I would say when she says things about modern Britain, she doesn't really wish
00:35:24 us to become better she wishes us not to be seems to me I don't wish to attribute
00:35:32 motives to people that aren't there but that's how it appears to me and I think
00:35:38 there are an awful lot of people who have an awful lot of voice and an awful
00:35:43 lot of noise they make in the public square who are of that opinion they
00:35:47 think that this country of ours never had anything good going for it that we
00:35:51 don't have anything good about ourselves now, that we've just done the worst, the most racist
00:35:55 thing imaginable in deciding to be sovereign, and it would be better if we weren't here.
00:36:02 I submit we do not listen to these people. They don't wish us well. They don't wish us well.
00:36:11 And we know, we all learn in our lives who we should listen to. In our lives we learn,
00:36:17 should i listen to this person when they say this about me or not and we have to as we form our
00:36:24 characters work out who gives us good advice because they want us to be good and who gives
00:36:30 us bad advice because they want us to fail we all encounter this in our lives but we also encounter
00:36:38 it in civilizational terms in national terms we have got an awful lot of people who pose as people
00:36:46 wishing us well, wishing to simply improve us, who clearly wish us ill. And I think they're very
00:36:52 hard, they're very easy, sorry, they're very easy to spot. They are the ones who misrepresent our
00:36:58 past. They are the ones who say that we are things that we're not. They are the ones that pretend
00:37:02 there's nothing good about us. And so when we are made to pretend that those people are sincere
00:37:10 and good people and we should listen to them we hasten the decline that you fear
00:37:18 rightly we bring it on because we invite our enemies into the sanctuary and and
00:37:31 that is by the way those people can be of any any background you know Portland
00:37:37 Oregon where most were the most extreme madness is now happening nightly on the streets where
00:37:43 people in search of nazis who call themselves antifa anti-fascists find there's not enough
00:37:50 nazis in portland oregon and so just bashing old women's heads you know they find in the street
00:37:55 haul people out of their cars and smash their heads until they've hospitalized them you know
00:37:59 these are these fine fine new anti-fascists that city of portland is something like 92 percent white
00:38:05 you know most of the people uh the uh the people who you see in the police mug shots when the
00:38:11 police do bother to arrest anyone for uh harming people in portland oregon most of those people
00:38:16 are white they have been you know so this isn't a racial point these people are these critics
00:38:21 these malevolent critics the people who do not wish us well can be of any background i felt that
00:38:27 rather about the people who pulled down the course and stuff yes they were mostly white yes but also
00:38:33 it was the the way in which they did this stamping on the statue yes which first of all felt alien
00:38:41 to me but also there was this was not a reason this was pure unadulterated hatred yes and i
00:38:48 i'm sure it wasn't just about statue no i i agree with you i thought it was
00:38:56 a generation who among other things had learned odd bits of recent history i mean
00:39:03 you know the whole taking the knee thing when dominic raab mentioned it as coming from game
00:39:06 of thrones everyone laughed at it no that's that's one of the ways it's come in definitely
00:39:13 and when before people in britain saw iraqis hitting the statue of saddam hussein with their
00:39:21 shoes would we have seen people in bristol jumping up and down on a statue and hitting it with their
00:39:29 shoes you know i mean we do live in this global culture where we learn bad as well as good habits
00:39:37 in very strange ways um but i agree i mean i thought the whole the whole site in bristol
00:39:42 was a very alien alienating uh scene um and you know where to even start with where those people
00:39:53 have ended up I mean no one's gonna no one is gonna be able to reach the
00:40:01 heights of the morality that these people expect and there's a sadness in
00:40:06 that because it means that their own lives will be very unhappy because they
00:40:10 will intuit at some point that they themselves cannot live up to the
00:40:14 standards they believe exist you know because one of the most important things
00:40:19 about a real rounded understanding of history is the fact that everybody in
00:40:22 history did things that we think are mad and we will be doing them too and we
00:40:28 might realize that in our own lifetimes and so part of the purpose of thinking
00:40:35 is to think what we're doing that's bad now and stop doing it fast but if you
00:40:41 think that your job is to judge everyone in history as being lesser than you now
00:40:48 one extraordinary mindset that is to have found yourself in i mean there's no one to live up to
00:40:55 is there other than yourself this is this is perhaps the great thing is that is that it leaves
00:41:00 nobody it leaves nobody to admire other than yourself which is a sort of childlike actually
00:41:09 oh yeah well i mean it's why the child leads the child's crusade yes i mean they found a person
00:41:16 who they can revere. It is all the end of religion coming back in another way, isn't it?
00:41:27 Well, actually, that is what you say in the book as well. This is the strong religious element.
00:41:32 Religion's gone, and this is the secular religion, if you like.
00:41:36 Yeah, the way to show that you're good, the way you pay your tithes to Black Lives Matter,
00:41:41 you wear the lapel things that show you're in the right club
00:41:46 and so the mob will pass you by
00:41:48 you stick the right sign outside your shop front
00:41:51 you chant the right things
00:41:53 you put your blackout thing on Facebook on the right day
00:41:57 you tweet the right thing
00:41:58 you've got to tweet that day
00:41:59 when you're told you're not to tweet that day
00:42:01 you don't tweet that day
00:42:02 that isn't really living though, is it?
00:42:05 i think one of the flash points in the situation might well come in november i mean to bring us
00:42:14 back down to to to political day-to-day politics with the election uh you've got a you've got a
00:42:21 big following in america uh i'm glad to hear it sorry nice to hear well you have i suppose so i
00:42:28 mean yeah it's nice to hear i like i like having american readers yes and you've been the white
00:42:33 house will you you know at this will you do you think you'll go to the States
00:42:47 during between now and I'd like to yes I'd like to I'm very interested in it
00:42:54 I'm very worried about it and it's obviously a hugely important time you
00:43:02 You know, it matters, among other things, because I do think that the thing that we have always worried about,
00:43:11 those of us who think about foreign policy issues have always worried about,
00:43:14 is what happens after the era of American hegemony.
00:43:18 And if this is, if America is breaking apart, if it is in the territory of civil war,
00:43:26 where half the country thinks there's nothing good about the country, its founding, or anything else,
00:43:31 then we're in civil war territory and if that's the case then eventually we're talking about the
00:43:37 end not just of the american era but of the anglo-american era and then we're talking about
00:43:43 the rise of the chinese era and um yeah people will love that they'll love that i can't wait
00:43:51 for see why i could could wait but i'd rather not see how the woke warriors get on when china
00:43:56 introduces a security law like hong kong yes apparently extinction rebellion are going to
00:44:01 sort of have one of their demonstrations in beijing oh gosh if they have any need for funding
00:44:09 to send them there i will i will chip in it's been a real pleasure to talk to you again of course
00:44:16 um and um i should say again doug's book the madness of crowd gender race and identity is
00:44:25 just out in paperback so do get it it's you know if you want to understand what's happening more
00:44:31 it is a book to get uh thank you very much for coming on maybe come back will you um
00:44:40 you know after the election or something in if you go to the states or something maybe if you can
00:44:44 i'd love to do that i'd love to do that that um irrespective of what happens in november none of
00:44:50 this is going to be going away thank you very much Douglas once again thank you and the book is
00:44:57 The Madness of Crowds by Douglas Murray it's out in paperback now and it explains an awful
00:45:04 lot about what's going on at the moment so see you next week on so what you're saying is thank you
00:45:20 You