New Culture Forum - September 12, 2020


Andrew Doyle: "My First Little Book Of Intersectional Activism", a parody of today's woke kids books

Douglas Murray - The Cult Of Woke & The Project To Lie About Our History The 'Decolonise Education' Movement Is Dangerous And Demoralising. It Must Be Rejected.

Episode Stats


Length

56 minutes

Words per minute

199.92

Word count

11,257

Sentence count

283


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now if you've been into your
00:00:26 local Waterson's recently and wandered into the children's section, you would have seen that
00:00:31 there's been a sort of mini explosion of woke books for kids with titles such as anti-racist
00:00:36 baby and feminist baby. Well, not to be outdone, the Twitter sensation Titania McGrath has come up
00:00:44 with this new book, my first little book of intersectional activism. And in fact, it's
00:00:54 just come out now and basically unfortunately Titania can't be with us
00:01:00 today but a great friend and fellow author Andrew Doyle has come and said
00:01:07 thank you very much for having me that's a very very tortured way of saying of
00:01:12 course you are the creator yes this wonderful character yes it's a it's it's
00:01:18 not a surprise you stumbled over the title because that would intersectional
00:01:20 quite a sort of convoluted yes yes exactly um thanks for pointing that out no i wasn't trying
00:01:26 to shame you i was making the point that these people use this jargon and yeah you know it
00:01:32 doesn't really mean much um why is there being do you think and do the you know these books i mean
00:01:40 these these there's a few more aren't there you you mentioned a title isn't it something about
00:01:45 the the little girl the little girl who gave zero fucks yeah there was that one there was a few
00:01:48 Tewa Hirsch's book about Baroness Hale as well, who was the Supreme Court judge.
00:01:53 So there's all these very sort of politicised, more sort of very ideologically driven kids' books.
00:01:58 There's loads.
00:01:59 There's one, The Good Night Stories for Rebel Girls,
00:02:02 which is a sort of catalogue of all the feminist icons of history.
00:02:05 That was a big seller.
00:02:07 So, yeah, it's very much the thing now.
00:02:09 Yeah, but, you know, why?
00:02:11 What are they doing?
00:02:12 What's happening?
00:02:13 They're quite hilariously attempting to indoctrinate the next generation into their mindset.
00:02:17 I mean, it's so overt.
00:02:20 I mean, there's no point in talking about conspiracy theories or anything like that.
00:02:23 I mean, they're doing exactly what they say on the tin.
00:02:26 You know, the book Anti-Racist Baby, which I'm sure you've read
00:02:28 because it's only about three pages long, will tell you exactly what it's doing.
00:02:32 You know, it's pushing an ideology onto children that simply will never understand it.
00:02:37 There's that book Who Are You?, which is a kid's guide to gender identity,
00:02:41 which is aimed at sort of three years plus that sort of level.
00:02:43 And it's talking about things like, you know, genderqueer, genderfluidity, two-spirit, gender identity, and all this kind of thing in there.
00:02:49 And it's obviously, more than anything, is probably for woke parents.
00:02:54 Well, this is the point.
00:02:55 You know, because the kids haven't got a clue.
00:02:56 You know, when Anti-Racist Baby was published, Kendi, who is the author, wrote a tweet asking for people to send pictures of their babies with the book.
00:03:06 And you have all these babies reading this book that they don't understand.
00:03:09 with there was one with a Black Lives Matter t-shirt on and you think this baby's about one
00:03:13 years old this isn't a um these children haven't chosen this stuff for themselves and to me that's
00:03:18 funny you know more than anything I mean it's sinister and creepy as hell yeah but it's also
00:03:22 just laugh out loud funny yes you know the idea of you know it's no it's the same as any kind of
00:03:28 fundamentalist indoctrination I'm not talking about people who are brought up in a religious
00:03:31 uh household you know I mean I was brought I went to a convert school I was brought up Catholic
00:03:35 but there was never a point at which
00:03:37 anyone was going to say
00:03:39 if you have doubts about this or want to discuss issues
00:03:41 we're not going to do that
00:03:42 of course the intolerance in this very rigid
00:03:45 notion of
00:03:47 identity politics and social justice
00:03:49 that it is a fundamentalist religion
00:03:51 and that's why
00:03:53 the indoctrination of children troubles me but also
00:03:55 makes me laugh because it's so silly
00:03:57 do you really think that if you give
00:03:59 a copy of Anti-Racist Baby to a book
00:04:01 it's going to grow up to believe in critical
00:04:03 race theory
00:04:04 because once it develops its critical faculties
00:04:07 it will realise what a load of bunkum it is
00:04:09 the thing is as well though
00:04:10 it does make you wonder about the outlook
00:04:13 and mentality of the parents
00:04:15 who would buy these books
00:04:17 well they're lost causes aren't they
00:04:18 I suppose on the one hand
00:04:21 it looks good on your coffee table
00:04:22 because your middle class friends come around
00:04:24 and they see that you're educating your child
00:04:26 in the right way of thinking
00:04:27 maybe that's the purpose
00:04:28 but on the other hand
00:04:31 there's a lot of people who just believe in this stuff
00:04:33 they've just bought the snake oil and they just they part of involving
00:04:39 yourself in that world is that you don't question things anymore yes you just
00:04:43 have a kind of fealty to a higher ideal that you only half understand so that's
00:04:49 that's the sad thing about it it is a case really of de-radicalization now
00:04:53 actually I think people need to be de-radicalized out of this way of
00:04:57 thinking was not even a way of thinking because it doesn't involve thinking so
00:05:01 So I'd say it's, and particularly the trouble with the way in which this has infiltrated schools and schooling,
00:05:07 you know, I'm not just talking about the universities, I mean, they're gone, you know,
00:05:10 but schools, and particularly in the UK now, I mean, I'm constantly contacted by teachers
00:05:15 who were telling me about how they've been told to read White Fragility by Robin DiAngelo
00:05:19 or they've been told to teach children about white privilege and you have curricula are being updated,
00:05:24 pastoral policies are being updated, teacher training courses are being updated to include
00:05:28 these obviously very niche and uh academic theories which they're invited to teach to
00:05:36 children as though they are uncontested truths which more than anything is just bad educational
00:05:40 practice because they're they're shoddy niche academic theories that are actually fraudulent
00:05:45 so and you know i wouldn't care if you if you went into a school talked to a bunch of kids about
00:05:50 white fragility by robin d'angelo and explained uh you know this this is her theory what do you
00:05:56 think of that but also this is why it's so obviously flawed and ridiculous what do you
00:06:00 think of that as well and let's have a discussion about it that would be okay but going in and
00:06:03 saying to a bunch of kids you are racist if you are white and you are complicit in white supremacy
00:06:09 if you are white um that's just firstly wrong uh and secondly uh quite flagrant political
00:06:16 indoctrination is probably against the law according to the 1996 education act so but this
00:06:21 is happening across schools throughout the uk i'm not hearing much from the education secretary
00:06:25 about any of this people are talking about it so there's a big move it's not just about the woke
00:06:29 children's books it's something that's much broader uh than that you said actually universities
00:06:34 they're gone well i think the humanities have gone yeah humanities yeah and this is something
00:06:38 roger scutin i think said it was like he said uh that's they're beyond hell now it comes a point
00:06:44 i'd like i'd like to be an optimist but there comes a point where some something is a lost
00:06:49 cause there just there just is you know and i i don't know how they can be rescued now because
00:06:56 the rot is so deep uh you know it's like a house if the rot becomes so deep you just have to
00:07:01 demolish the house there's no point in in in building it again you'd have to build it from
00:07:05 scratch and that's probably what we'll have to do i mean you'll it'll probably have to be new
00:07:09 private humanities universities and you know things like ralston college yes uh emerging uh
00:07:17 to to educate people properly you know um and in fact universities are particularly bad and i'm
00:07:23 always in contact with academics who uh i had a discussion with an academic last week actually
00:07:28 about this and uh he was quite open about the fact that he couldn't express his misgivings
00:07:32 about a lot of this ideological nonsense because he's got a career to worry about look i i know
00:07:38 i'm sure like you do many people get in touch or whatever with us uh same thing yeah same thing it's
00:07:44 They are sort of surrounded, they're behind enemy walls, you know, even for just being, if you like, Tory voters.
00:07:51 I mean, you know, just a simple thing like that, you know.
00:07:54 Yeah, well, exactly. It's completely anti-educational.
00:07:58 It's the opposite, really, of what a university should be.
00:08:02 It's genuinely tragic. I don't know how you...
00:08:05 This is why I say it's probably best just to give up on...
00:08:09 And I say maybe not just humanities.
00:08:11 I mean, now they're trying to decolonize science and mathematics.
00:08:14 And so it is spreading to those other areas as well.
00:08:18 I don't know. Maybe I should be a bit more positive.
00:08:21 Yeah, yeah. And basically start new institutions.
00:08:25 I think so. I think that's probably the only way.
00:08:27 I mean, I'm not going to do it.
00:08:28 It's a lot of effort and takes a lot of money, which I don't have.
00:08:30 But I think if rich people who care about education have the resources,
00:08:35 they probably should do that.
00:08:36 in the meantime um you know to help little kids along my first book of intersectional activism
00:08:43 what what is what i loved about this actually was that it's sort of a how-to book isn't it
00:08:48 it's a kind of awareness raising you know don't take any notice of your parents all of this yeah
00:08:54 they are going to be wrong yeah um but at the same time you've got the throughout you've got these
00:08:58 woke heroes um you know little potted biographies of why they're such good people sam smith megan
00:09:05 Markle makes it in, doesn't she? Yes, yeah. But my two favourite were the ones that I thought were a
00:09:09 bit counterintuitive. You've got in here Mary Whitehouse and Joseph Stalin. Why would they be
00:09:18 woke heroes? Yeah, I mean, I like the idea that you're reading and you have Hillary Clinton and
00:09:23 Brie Larson and Alyssa Milano and then you hit Joseph Stalin or, you know, that to me makes me
00:09:29 me laugh anyway but but also because this sort of contorted excuses that
00:09:35 elements of the left find to excuse Stalinism or communism or quite
00:09:40 flippantly say that you know I'm a communist yeah as though that that isn't
00:09:44 loaded with this incredible history of murderous this baggage of murder and
00:09:48 and and and genocide as though it's just not sort of there I mean that to me is
00:09:53 funny even when they say I'm literally a communist or even literally a communist
00:09:56 exactly as opposed to metaphorically a communist but yeah so that to me is a
00:10:01 funny thing that happens and I mean who was the other one you mentioned Joseph
00:10:06 Stalin and Mary Whitehouse I mean you know she was a I should just in case
00:10:11 anyone's you know because she was a huge figure wasn't she back in the 70s 60s
00:10:16 and 70s and she would she would have been considered to be a heroine of kind
00:10:22 of disgusted tunbridge wells wouldn't she sure so mary whitehouse uh was a very sort of prim prissy
00:10:29 uh christian lady who um you know used to have twin set and pearls and that kind of thing and
00:10:34 said set set up this cleanup tv campaign uh in the 1960s i believe it was and and that sort of
00:10:40 carried through to the 1980s where you actually had the um video nasties campaign where she
00:10:45 successfully uh petitioned the bbfc to ban uh videos and certainly particularly horror films
00:10:51 such as Driller Killer and that sort of thing and The Evil Dead which is a film that I actually like
00:10:57 and so she was very she was of the belief I mean she would write to the BBC about absolutely
00:11:04 everything I mean I remember once she wrote about Some Mothers Do Avum you know the Frank Spencer
00:11:08 character because whenever Michael Crawford played a sort of nervous moment he had this habit of
00:11:14 rubbing his wrist along his leg he didn't know why he did it but he did it apparently because
00:11:18 there's nerves here and it's a natural thing that people do she she interpreted this as having a
00:11:22 masturbatory quality and so she contacted the bbc and asked that that be banned as well so anything
00:11:27 you know and the reason why she's in the book is um i want to make the point that the modern day
00:11:35 social justice movement has is identical in its view of the potential impact of the arts and
00:11:43 culture on the masses as mary white house it is it is precisely the same idea which is that um
00:11:49 problematic that's the word they use that's their favorite word problematic ideas representations
00:11:54 depictions in art or cinema or tv can have a corrupting effect on the masses that's the idea
00:12:01 that they do believe which is why they will say you well you can't depict an act of rape on screen
00:12:06 or you can't depict uh misogyny you can't or you have the advertising standards authority in this
00:12:11 country saying that you can't show uh gendered stereotypes uh you know they censored the um
00:12:16 the volkswagen e-golf uh advert because there was a woman with a pram and really i didn't really
00:12:21 yeah well they they said that isn't allowed uh because it implies that women can be mothers
00:12:25 right um and obviously that's problematic shock i know it's disgusting and then um
00:12:30 so this stuff is but that's the same theory that mary whitehouse had now the difference is
00:12:35 20 30 years ago people on the left were mocking mary whitehouse routinely there was even a comedy
00:12:40 TV show called the Mary Whitehouse
00:12:42 Experience, right, so
00:12:43 she was a figure of fun, no one took her
00:12:46 seriously, her ideas have won
00:12:48 out on the left, not even
00:12:50 on the right, this is coming from the left
00:12:52 that is hilarious to me, so I love the
00:12:54 idea, and they never own this
00:12:56 they'll never just say, actually Mary Whitehouse was right
00:12:58 we have to protect the masses from
00:13:00 the evil influences of
00:13:02 things they see on screens, they won't say
00:13:04 that, so I thought Titania should just say
00:13:06 yeah, she's a hero, Mary Whitehouse is brilliant
00:13:08 and that to me
00:13:10 makes the point. Also, there are people, I mean, you know, Meghan Markle, you know, I think in
00:13:17 some ways it's sort of like, I can understand why she'd be in there more, but again, it's this kind
00:13:23 of, what comes across is this sort of moral, this incredible moral superiority. You mentioned
00:13:30 the religious aspect of this. I mean, the whole thing with woke is literally that, you know,
00:13:35 basically I am completely pure now. That's it. That's hilarious, though, because no one is.
00:13:41 And that's why any kind of moral grandstanding is funny, because it implies a sense of personal
00:13:46 purity and that you can, you know, I can do nothing wrong and therefore I'm in a position
00:13:49 to judge everyone else. That's funny to me because obviously it's not true.
00:13:54 Meghan Markle's a very good example of this. I mean, she's just, she loves to pontificate
00:13:58 about the morality of the little people, you know, and, you know, she goes on and on about
00:14:04 how they must lower their carbon footprint while taking private jets to elton john's house for a
00:14:08 party you know that that is just already self-satirizing and funny you know often she
00:14:12 speaks through her her conduit uh the ginger head royal you know so sometimes that happens
00:14:18 um so this is a funny situation i think um you know this this uh wild misinterpretation that
00:14:25 people disliked megan uh on a racial basis it's quite clear i mean we know that's not true because
00:14:30 when the the royal wedding was happening the country was all behind them they loved it they
00:14:35 absolutely adored it yeah no it's because she's hectoring everyone about how evil they all are
00:14:39 and how wonderful she is yes which is an unpleasant personality trait um so that's
00:14:43 you know especially coming from a multi-millionaire who's married a prince yes yes exactly that's a
00:14:47 definition of lack of privilege isn't it yeah um with titania which has been this enormous
00:14:54 uh success and i mean it's it was a show too wasn't it was it at the end yeah it did a show
00:14:59 out the Edinburgh Fringe which was meant to be touring this March but obviously because of the
00:15:03 lockdown that didn't happen yeah we moved the whole all of the dates are now this coming March
00:15:07 so we moved it back a whole year yeah and as far as I'm aware that's still going ahead yeah but
00:15:11 what how is she doing at the moment she's not suspended but I mean you know you've you've had
00:15:17 a few of these run-ins haven't you with on Twitter yeah it's so weird to me it's it's I mean she
00:15:23 going on there well okay so she look obviously she was invented on Twitter and through Twitter
00:15:28 That makes complete sense, because if you want to satirise the social justice movement, you do it on their own turf.
00:15:33 And Twitter is where they perform their activisms, you know?
00:15:36 That's what they do.
00:15:36 They go out there and pontificate to everyone through social media, and obviously it's complete nonsense.
00:15:42 So that's what she does.
00:15:44 The problem with that is, of course, because Twitter and Facebook and YouTube and Google and all the rest of them
00:15:47 are run by these very ideologically driven tech giants in Silicon Valley who are very much on board with the woke movement.
00:15:54 and added to that have a very sensorial mindset you know they don't believe in free speech
00:16:01 they don't believe in unfettered speech they think it needs to be regulated and they think
00:16:05 that they are the people who should be regulating it because by implication they know best so which
00:16:11 is the same to me as the bbfc back in the day banning films you know they were able to watch
00:16:16 them and understand that they wouldn't be good for everyone else but the other people they
00:16:19 couldn't see it you know it's the same kind of idea and you know given that the
00:16:24 the social media companies hire people to moderate their content I mean
00:16:29 thousands of people to sit there and moderate content and make arbitrary
00:16:32 decisions about what is acceptable and what is not and they all have these very
00:16:36 nebulous terms of service which are the rules so people get violated and banned
00:16:40 people violate the terms of service and are banned from Twitter but they'll just
00:16:44 get an automatic email saying you've violated our terms of service if you
00:16:48 reply saying what what have i done that you just get another automated response back there's no
00:16:53 way to sort of this it's a very shady operation so they never tell you why you've been banned what
00:16:57 they do is they just say you you've committed a crime we're punishing you for it but we're not
00:17:01 going to tell you what the crime is that sounds quite reminiscent of a certain novel by franz
00:17:06 kafka um it's it's the same thing you know uh and then you're left thinking well i don't know what
00:17:11 i mean a lot of the things that titania's been banned for um i mean it's always been reinstated
00:17:16 ultimately but they're for nothing like the tweets are not in any way offensive at all i mean when
00:17:22 she was uh suspended recently it was on the same afternoon i think the same hour window as about
00:17:29 10 or 11 other satirical accounts all at the same time so if you're telling me uh that someone at
00:17:35 twitter had decided that all of those accounts violated these terms of service which don't mean
00:17:39 anything anyway and they all did it within that one hour window i don't think that's true is it
00:17:43 So this would have been, yeah, this would have been, so have the others come back?
00:17:48 No, one of them has, the Babylon Bee, which is an American Christian satirical site,
00:17:52 as in it's run by Christians and they're conservatives as well.
00:17:57 So that's why they're going to be, so I've speculated about this,
00:18:00 that it's probably because the election's coming up
00:18:02 and they don't want people to mock Joe Biden and the Democrats.
00:18:06 But, you know, as I pointed out in an article this week,
00:18:08 I don't think they need our help to mock themselves.
00:18:12 You know, they do it themselves. They do it pretty well. So this weird fear of satire, of comedy, I've never understood it.
00:18:20 I've never understood it. And it's not just confined to social media. It's out there generally amongst audiences.
00:18:25 There's a new development that, you know, certain types of jokes will spread hate or normalise hate.
00:18:31 It's a complete comedic illiteracy. It's a complete misunderstanding of what a joke is.
00:18:35 If you're taking a joke at face value, if you think that a stand-up comedian is literally saying what they think, then you have absolutely no understanding of the medium.
00:18:45 It would be like me opining on football and the offside rule, which I don't understand.
00:18:50 If I start going and say, I want to commentate on this and say, no, you need to move that man with the ball to that bit.
00:18:56 And, you know, you would say to me, well, you don't know what the fuck you're talking about.
00:19:00 So you're not in a position to have an opinion on this, right?
00:19:03 So, same thing. People who don't understand comedy, who don't read very much, who don't understand the idea of artistic representation, and they think that if you represent something through comedy, through art, through drama, it's an automatic endorsement of the thing that you represent.
00:19:21 I mean, these kind of, well, it's Philistinism, isn't it?
00:19:23 it is but it's not even having a view or putting a perspective it's enough actually to even be
00:19:31 talking about a subject actually just just talking about a subject that's enough to do it but
00:19:36 in a way don't you think that that's a huge victory for the people who basically
00:19:42 wanted us wanted to embed this idea that words are the same as actions yeah you know that words
00:19:48 This is such a big complicated thing isn't it? This is the major development in recent
00:19:53 years which is the idea that speech is violence. It isn't, it's speech. And the idea that
00:19:59 that has taken hold I find very disturbing. We know where it comes from. It comes from
00:20:06 this post-modern idea, this Foucauldian idea of this emphasis on how language creates reality,
00:20:14 which is not specifically Foucauldian because it's just to do with this post-structuralist
00:20:17 notion of reality that there is no truth really beyond the language with which it is expressed
00:20:23 basically. So it's got an old sort of pedigree and now it's just become a kind of mainstream idea
00:20:30 that that's why otherwise why would this movement be so obsessed with policing speech and really by
00:20:39 extension policing thought? Why is it that dictionaries online now are changing definitions
00:20:45 in accordance with their ideological values not which is their traditional role to record common
00:20:50 usage right why does merriam-webster uh the oldest american dictionary now now say that racism
00:20:56 doesn't mean what we thought it meant we we all used to think it meant um prejudice and hatred
00:21:01 against people based on race well that's what everyone thinks it means everyone thinks it means
00:21:05 but because a few niche uh know nothing academics think it's an equation which is a prejudice plus
00:21:10 power now a major dictionary has decided to change the definition in accordance
00:21:15 with that value now no one's using the word in that way what they're trying to
00:21:18 do is a form of social engineering they think if they change the definition and
00:21:22 then everyone will start using it in the way that they prefer now that's very
00:21:24 scary and sinister we were talking just before we we started recording actually
00:21:30 about words and and about the importance of them and you you were saying and I
00:21:35 see something I feel very much myself that you were concerned more and more
00:21:39 about libraries you know and what's happening in libraries I mean obviously we also had this huge
00:21:44 case well these reports this week anyway of what's happening in the British Library yes which is but
00:21:51 but you're talking as well about what what exactly what's your concern with libraries well there's a
00:21:56 really weird thing going on um over the past few months I've noticed I'll get a really well I get
00:22:01 a lot of vicious attacks on Twitter and I started to notice that more and more I'd click through
00:22:06 look at the bio and they're librarians. And I thought this is quite funny, this is quite
00:22:10 a funny thing, like these really angry librarians have suddenly emerged. I mean that sounds like
00:22:14 the plot of a sitcom. And occasionally they'd be boasting about how they're taking off books
00:22:22 by white authors off the shelves or they're sort of getting rid of, they're decolonising the
00:22:27 bookshelves at their local libraries and they're educating people about the things they should be
00:22:32 reading which is not a librarian's job uh and and it's it was just interesting that this was
00:22:38 i thought i was going mad right because it seemed a bit weird um to the extent i mean some of the
00:22:43 abuse was so bad from librarians i had to start blocking librarians uh i actually think my twitter
00:22:47 experience would be better if i could just filter out librarians couldn't you just get back to them
00:22:50 say silence please right wonderful yeah but you always think afterwards what would be the best
00:22:55 retort um so there's this weird thing and then of course you read about the british library which is
00:23:00 the library of libraries right the major copyright library in this country which has a copy of every
00:23:05 book and the head of that liz jolly i think her name is is uh is deciding to uh she has to
00:23:10 decolonize the library and and and um uh revalue its collections and sort of reconsider its
00:23:15 collections why it's not your job no exactly you know just put the books back on the shelves where
00:23:19 they belong the point is the problem is with you know with all these institutions is that this is
00:23:24 sort of becoming clearer and clearer is that they have political objectives and they sort of quite
00:23:29 They see the organisation as actually having to have political objectives quite sort of openly.
00:23:35 But as a result, they actually run the things really poorly.
00:23:39 Well, you're not a good librarian if you think that you should filter out, decolonise, decide what your readers are reading.
00:23:47 It reminds me of that Victoria Wood episode about the library, where there's a woman who runs the library like Hitler.
00:23:53 And she goes through Jackie Collins' books with a felt-tipped pen to cross out the rude words.
00:23:58 or she draws she crayons bras on the women in the breastfeeding manuals you know so that that that
00:24:02 sort of figure is now actually happening and and and whereas victoria wood was making fun of the
00:24:07 idea of that the concept now it's a reality and uh you know i i just think it's mad because it's
00:24:13 i don't want to smear all librarians i must be clear about this i'm sure there are some lovely
00:24:17 librarians with much to offer the world i you know i know a couple um of some of my best friends are
00:24:23 librarians but um i do find there is an odd trend yes in particular maybe people of that mindset
00:24:31 are just attracted to that job um i mean certainly things to do with words people who staff dictionaries
00:24:37 people who staff libraries people who go into um uh media um there's an overwhelming predominance
00:24:44 of this kind of idea so do they go into these industries because they want to influence the
00:24:50 way that people think or is it is there something about that job that just appeals to someone who
00:24:57 isn't very good at critical thinking or thinking for themselves i don't know i'd be fascinated
00:25:02 to know the answer to that yes i suppose along the lines maybe a bit like with teachers again
00:25:07 one doesn't want to malign all teachers but there's this idea you know those who can do those
00:25:11 who can't teach yeah and i i don't know whether this is there is something in that um well i think
00:25:17 just to say i think teaching is one of the most valuable things anyone can do i think it's utterly
00:25:20 crucial and i i think with teaching just because i've been so overwhelmed by the number of teachers
00:25:26 who've got in touch with me about this stuff it does make me think actually that it's a minority
00:25:30 of teachers who are pushing this really and yeah i do think that and i think i know what it's like
00:25:35 though i mean i used to be a teacher myself and you'd sit there in the teacher training days and
00:25:39 someone would be giving you a talk about something ludicrous and everyone's just thinking i just want
00:25:43 want to go to lunch or I just want to get like the inset days aren't really that useful on the
00:25:48 whole um it's just a an excuse to pay someone a lot of money to you know to to to do it to be seen
00:25:54 to be doing something you know um so firstly you know everyone wants a quiet life but also if you
00:25:59 want to get promoted you know if you want that head of sixth form job or whatever um which
00:26:03 everyone's got their eye on or head of house or whatever you're probably not going to get it if
00:26:06 you're the sort of person who puts your hand up in an inset and says sorry I think what you're
00:26:10 saying is nonsense so that's really the problem you know when all the yeah and I'm being serious
00:26:16 about this now teachers are being told to read White Fragility a book that any intelligent
00:26:21 person will discredit once they've read it I've read it twice for some stupid reason
00:26:24 well I read it once before I wrote the last Titania book and I read it again because I
00:26:29 wanted to write a chapter about it in this book and you know I'll give you an example a friend
00:26:35 of mine who's starting a new job in September he's been sent a reading list and it includes
00:26:38 white fragility and and things like this he had to sit in on a zoom assembly with the school where
00:26:44 where the kids were berated for their white privilege for their heterosexual privilege
00:26:48 which is an assumption anyway uh for their um berated by who andrew by one of the teachers
00:26:53 who was giving the assembly and these kids would have been how old roughly uh well it's secondary
00:26:56 so yeah 11 to 18. also being told that they were because it's a boys school they're all male so
00:27:01 they have male privilege what's very funny to me though the teacher didn't mention class privilege
00:27:06 at any point this is a private school where people are playing extortionate fees so that their
00:27:10 children can attend and of course that is the real problem with that school that's the real source of
00:27:14 privilege in that school you know i mean if that school doesn't turn you away if you're black it
00:27:19 does turn you away if you don't have 30 grand a year so it's just funny to me that identity
00:27:24 politics is it supersedes those issues of class inequality to such ridiculous extents and and my
00:27:30 teacher friend was saying to me it's a new job right uh he's on probation he's not in a position
00:27:35 to stand up and say i i think this is all bollocks because that will that means his card is marked
00:27:42 promotions out the window he might even not have his contract renewed so i think that's the real
00:27:47 issue it's not that teachers have suddenly read robin d'angelo and thought oh this is a good idea
00:27:52 in fact i put it to you that i don't think anyone with half a brain could read it and think this is
00:27:55 a good idea um so and teachers generally are intelligent people this is something that really
00:28:01 characterises as a whole movement, the woke and the social justice, and that is the total absence
00:28:07 of, as you just pointed out, issues of class. It's mad. This is why I don't consider the woke
00:28:14 movement a left-wing movement. It's a bourgeois movement. It's just not. What do you think of
00:28:20 this view? I've seen a few pieces about it, that a lot of the protests we've had, the ones going on
00:28:28 even in America at the moment, they are essentially a kind of elite protest, you know, that these
00:28:36 people make a great song and dance, actually I've seen them doing it, about the fact they
00:28:41 have college degrees and that they are actually almost rebelling against, so who would they
00:28:47 be protesting? Does it all go back to things like Brexit or Trump? Are they really angry
00:28:54 that essentially they have not been listened to on these occasions.
00:28:58 Could it be that? Is that too fanciful?
00:29:01 Well, I think the people who are largely behind a lot of these protests, though,
00:29:05 have been in positions of power and have been listened to.
00:29:09 I don't think they are disenfranchised in that way.
00:29:11 I think of things like you see working-class communities being trashed and burned
00:29:16 and working-class shop owners, often people of colour,
00:29:19 having their livelihoods destroyed by white liberals.
00:29:24 in masks, rich white college kids.
00:29:27 That's weird.
00:29:29 That's a really weird idea, isn't it?
00:29:31 It is weird, and also I would have thought
00:29:34 something that could be easily satirised...
00:29:38 It's funny.
00:29:38 It's funny, but I just want to come back to this point.
00:29:41 We were talking a bit earlier about satire
00:29:45 and the state of satire,
00:29:46 which is obviously thriving on, say, Twitter and social media.
00:29:50 but I just noticed recently that for example Spitting Image is going to be
00:29:55 returning to television yeah and I just sort of thought will they take on things
00:30:00 like the social justice movement you know well will they satirize that I would
00:30:06 have thought that could fill up for example a whole series surely oh of course
00:30:10 it could I mean many series yeah I mean it's but will they do you think I've got
00:30:14 I mean, I've no idea, actually.
00:30:16 You know, I believe the new series is written by the people who wrote the old series.
00:30:22 And if that's the case, they might well do, because they come from that.
00:30:27 I mean, it's funny, isn't it?
00:30:28 So all the old school lefties of the 80s, they're not on board with this identity politics at all.
00:30:34 So maybe they will.
00:30:36 It would be harder for it to get through the commissioners and the executives and that kind of thing.
00:30:41 This is the problem that we have with the media at the moment and the BBC and Channel 4 and all the rest of it.
00:30:48 It's not an issue of left and right, actually.
00:30:52 It's that the identity politics is systemic at the BBC.
00:30:58 That's the problem.
00:30:59 So, you know, when the incoming Director General talks about how he wants to make it more diversity of opinion, he wants left and right.
00:31:09 He particularly did mention comedy didn't he? Yes he did. I mean what do you make of that?
00:31:13 How could he, how could, what could he possibly do? What could the BBC do to change the situation?
00:31:20 Well you know there aren't many right-wing stand-up comedians, in fact there are not that many political comedians, full stop.
00:31:26 The real issue is about wokeness, is about identity politics and social justice, which is it's so absolutely palpably the case
00:31:33 that in order to advance very far at the BBC you have to be on board with that.
00:31:37 you know that's just that's everyone knows that um and anyone who denies that is is lying frankly
00:31:43 so and that is so systemic at the bbc it's so embedded i don't know how you would even begin
00:31:49 to dismantle that i think you know and and largely it's because uh people who work there are so
00:31:53 obviously more privileged you know you're twice as likely to be privately educated if you work at
00:31:57 the bbc as any other as your average britain so um how do you dismantle that well i think what you
00:32:03 do is you have to effectively employ commissioners and executives who are not put off by political
00:32:11 opinions they don't agree with, that have this liberal idea that we should be hearing
00:32:16 different voices and different ideas about the world. And particularly in comedy, that
00:32:21 is a problem. I mean, I know comedians. Lots of comedians get in touch with me and say
00:32:25 that they really like what I'm doing, but they never share my stuff. I've even had people
00:32:31 say that they wish they could have a go at this stuff as well but they don't and that's because
00:32:35 people have to you know they need to pay the mortgage and the rent and all the rest of it so
00:32:39 so i get it um so it it will be hard um it isn't just as simple as getting uh people on to have a
00:32:47 pop at the labor party or whatever like it's not no it's not it's i know i totally get that i mean
00:32:52 i really do because when you when you talk about identity politics what it really is is like uh
00:32:57 somebody put on twitter recently a very uh it was a very good point they put on a
00:33:00 a clip of morcom and wise and tom jones and said oh look this nasty right-wing uh male dominated
00:33:07 comedy or something they were making a point uh you know satirically yeah um but you see that's
00:33:13 the point there was nothing right wing about morcom and wise for example um but they were just
00:33:20 if you like i mean i suppose the bbc would look at them and say well no because they're not diverse
00:33:24 enough ethnically maybe something like that because right so but that's yes
00:33:28 that's the problem isn't it with this I mean what was very interesting is when
00:33:31 this announcement was made by by the incoming director-general the the
00:33:37 principal objection on Twitter which is where I gauge everything from appeared
00:33:40 to be either as Owen Jones said well there's no funny right-wing comedians
00:33:45 which just exposes that he's not familiar with the comedy scene at all
00:33:48 which is fine you know he's not somebody goes to comedy clearly so that's fine
00:33:52 which is why he is wrong about that
00:33:54 but the main thing was
00:33:56 oh well what do they want
00:33:58 they want like Bernard Manning
00:33:59 we're just going to put Bernard Manning back on TV
00:34:02 and it's
00:34:03 it shows an incredible
00:34:06 failure of imagination
00:34:07 that your only reference point for right wing comedy is from the 70s and 80s
00:34:11 the kind of comedians
00:34:12 incidentally who no longer exist
00:34:14 where are you going to get these people
00:34:15 they don't exist
00:34:16 so firstly you have to overcome this idea
00:34:19 that we live in an inherently racist society
00:34:21 The problem is that the BBC is pushing that systemic racism idea, and it's a faith-based position that they hold.
00:34:28 So you'd have to get beyond that. You'd have to recognise that that is not true. That's the first thing.
00:34:33 There is racism in society. That does not mean that society is systemically racist.
00:34:37 That's an important distinction that needs to be made.
00:34:39 The vast majority of people despise racism. That's the point.
00:34:43 And I've never met a racist comedian, and I've met most of them.
00:34:47 So that's the first thing I have to acknowledge.
00:34:48 And then what you'd have to do is be willing to have someone who will express that point comedically
00:34:55 or poke fun at this stuff that is obviously funny and not be accused of being racist for doing so.
00:35:02 That's, you know, that's the other thing.
00:35:04 So I've been actually quite amazed at the sort of infantile reaction to this statement.
00:35:11 The only thing I saw recently, I'm not talking about the big, like, David Chappelle and people like this in America,
00:35:17 But I saw a Tracey Orman sketch where she's taking a class of people who are trying to, you know, get over their wokeness.
00:35:25 I saw that sketch. And it went viral.
00:35:26 Yes, it went viral. But there was nothing actually right-wing about it.
00:35:30 I mean, it's not right-wing. It was very funny, actually.
00:35:32 No, but it's interpreted as being right-wing.
00:35:34 Because people... That's why people think that Titania McGrath is a right-wing character, or that the whole concept is a right-wing.
00:35:40 Or that you're right-wing, but you're not, are you?
00:35:41 Exactly. So that there's a right-wing... Well, I mean, this is the problem.
00:35:44 What does it even mean anymore?
00:35:46 You know, I mean, I come from a left-wing background so far as, you know, I believe in the welfare state.
00:35:53 I believe in a degree of wealth redistribution.
00:35:55 You know, these, through proportionate taxation, these are traditionally left-wing ideas.
00:36:00 I suppose I have conservative elements culturally.
00:36:04 I suppose you could say I have a certain cultural conservatism in line with, say, George Orwell,
00:36:08 who wrote that essay, The Lion and the Unicorn, about this very thing.
00:36:12 I think that education should be conservative insofar as I think we should learn about the past.
00:36:15 there should be canonical texts you know so all of this stuff I mean what does it even mean and
00:36:20 if I mock social justice and if I mock um the woke movement that's automatically interpreted
00:36:26 as being right-wing well the mistake there is firstly you're assuming that the woke movement
00:36:29 is left-wing which it is not that's the first thing because it has no it like we said it doesn't
00:36:34 care about class inequality if you don't care about class inequality and economic inequality
00:36:39 you're not left-wing you're just not so so and most of these people don't care about that stuff
00:36:44 So they care about identity issues.
00:36:47 What would you what would you what kind of how then could you categorize?
00:36:51 OK, they care about identity issues.
00:36:54 I would call them cultural totalitarians, actually.
00:36:57 This is the problem that we don't know what to call.
00:36:58 Yeah. Yeah.
00:36:59 And and, you know, even the word woke now, people say, yeah, but you're just making that word up.
00:37:04 It's not a word that anyone uses to describe themselves, apart from all the people who use the word to describe themselves.
00:37:09 This is the weird thing.
00:37:10 I mean, like two years ago, Nika Burns, who's the head of the Edinburgh Comedy Awards, used
00:37:15 to be the Foster's Awards, gave a speech which opened the festival saying she was looking
00:37:20 forward to the new woke world of comedy, where up and coming comics would determine the parameters
00:37:26 of what was acceptable to joke about, which is sort of the opposite of what comedy should
00:37:30 be and is a bit sinister coming from someone who's quite high up and instrumental in the
00:37:35 comedy industry so there's that but she used she just self-described as woke and
00:37:39 she said this is what you know I remember I was getting in an argument on
00:37:43 Twitter with someone saying well no one no one who's before social justice uses
00:37:47 the word woke to describe themselves so I just screenshot it and posted loads of
00:37:51 Guardian articles where they do exactly that so it's it's not true this sort of
00:37:57 revisionist idea that that woke isn't used in this way it is it's interesting
00:38:01 People, no one ever really used to describe themselves as being politically correct, did they?
00:38:07 Right, so there's another one.
00:38:08 And also, this is not the same thing as political correctness, so that's another thing.
00:38:13 Really, I mean, because a lot of people say woke is almost like political correctness on steroids, isn't it?
00:38:18 It's a development out of it, I think, like a perverted offspring, the kind you keep in the attic, you know?
00:38:24 I think it's, if you go back to political correctness, it's sort of informed by a well-intentioned idea.
00:38:31 that maybe don't go up to gay people and call them dirty faggots and stuff like that.
00:38:35 I mean, you know, be polite, right?
00:38:38 That's quite a nice idea.
00:38:40 And I think we're kidding ourselves if we don't agree that we've got a social contract, haven't we?
00:38:44 We know what's acceptable and what's not acceptable.
00:38:48 And I'm not talking about arresting people who choose to transgress those boundaries.
00:38:52 But what I'm saying is we know what polite society means.
00:38:55 We know what being polite means.
00:38:56 That's a good thing.
00:38:58 So there's that.
00:38:59 that's not the same as the intersectional woke social justice movement whatever you want to call
00:39:04 it which believes in imposing a rigid set of what opinions are acceptable what opinions are not
00:39:10 instituting hate speech laws cracking down on what people can say that's a massive a massive
00:39:18 authoritarian leap beyond what political correctness was I think so so do we call it
00:39:23 wokeness do we call it political correctness intersectional I mean sometimes I call it
00:39:29 left identitarianism, but that's complicated because people don't really know what
00:39:33 identitarianism is and as I say, it's not really left-wing. But the problem is that a lot of the
00:39:37 things that they describe themselves as, they're not. So for instance, they're not really for
00:39:41 social justice, but they call themselves social justice activists. They call themselves liberals,
00:39:45 but everything about them is illiberal. They push this notion of anti-racism, which is a racist
00:39:52 ideology. So it's very difficult to navigate this stuff because the language they use is almost
00:39:58 the opposite of what it actually means that's really it's really difficult so
00:40:02 what do we call them I wish if you can come up with you know some people call
00:40:05 it critical social justice which is critical social justice that's what
00:40:09 Robin DiAngelo called it so that's one but again then you find yourself in this
00:40:14 position where you you have to explain these terms I mean I'm writing a book
00:40:17 about this stuff at the moment and and and the big problem having is what the
00:40:21 hell do you call it because if you just talk about social justice people will
00:40:26 say to you what does that mean you're not for social justice that doesn't
00:40:29 make sense it's the same with black lives matter yes if you if you criticize
00:40:32 the black lives matter movement people say what you don't think black lives
00:40:34 matter yeah everyone thinks that black lives matter that's a given that debate
00:40:38 was one decades ago right let's why don't we talk about what they actually
00:40:40 think yes and whether we're on board with all of that sort of stuff so it's
00:40:44 difficult you say you're writing this book is this kind of this is not a
00:40:48 a satirical world no no this is a non-fiction and it will be basically what a an exploration of the
00:40:55 whole yes i'm i'm talking about the religion of social justice and its impact on society and and
00:41:00 and that that to me is i think the you know i i i went on the big questions a couple years ago to
00:41:08 talk about how wokeness is a religion and that seems to be um the best way the best analogy i
00:41:15 think for it it's a it's a flawed analogy in many respects but but i think it's a useful one because
00:41:21 i think people will understand what you mean by that as in as in you know here you have a group
00:41:25 of people who set themselves up as the elites or the high priests who decide what it is you should
00:41:30 think they have their own jargon and esoteric language that they can communicate with each other
00:41:36 but they don't want you to be able to understand it that's why if you get into an argument with
00:41:39 a woke academic they'll throw lots of jargon at you in the hope of of scaring you away you know
00:41:43 It's the equivalent to the priests in the Middle Ages not wanting the Bible to be translated into the vernacular
00:41:48 and burning anyone at the stake who did, because they should be able to interpret the Holy Scripture, not you.
00:41:55 It has its own foundational texts, such as Foucault and Derrida and Lyotard, say.
00:42:02 So it has all of those elements of religion.
00:42:05 It excommunicates people who are heretics.
00:42:08 it seeks heretics out and and we have cancel culture instead of burning at the
00:42:13 stake but of course there's those two things clearly are related and I think
00:42:18 if they could burn people at the stake they probably would so they have all
00:42:21 these elements of religion and a total lack of forgiveness right now this is
00:42:25 where it clearly parts company with Christianity whether at the heart of
00:42:29 Christianity is forgiveness and redemption and that it does not exist
00:42:32 And that's why the closer analogy would be to a fundamentalist religion.
00:42:38 Maybe ISIS might be a good comparison, you know, because they like to trash statues as well, don't they?
00:42:44 So, although, you know, that would be extreme because no one in the social justice movement is beheading people yet.
00:42:51 But so I think that's a good, useful way to describe what's going on.
00:42:58 But that's what I'm writing about.
00:43:01 And I'm writing about it because I want to basically do something about it.
00:43:06 I think we should reinstate liberal values and the primacy of liberal values in society.
00:43:12 You know, when I was growing up, we were taught not to judge people for their sexuality, their race, their skin colour, their gender, that beautiful ideal of colour blindness.
00:43:23 We need to bring that back, you know.
00:43:25 So whenever teachers are contacting me about this anti-racism stuff, anti-racism doesn't
00:43:30 mean being opposed to racism.
00:43:32 It means subscribing to the ideas of white fragility, white privilege, or Robin DiAngelo,
00:43:36 that kind of thing, which is very damaging and creates more racism in society.
00:43:41 So I say to these teachers, just show them the Martin Luther King speech, the I Have
00:43:43 a Dream speech.
00:43:44 Leave it at that.
00:43:45 Tell them not to judge people by skin colour.
00:43:47 And yes, colour blindness is the right way.
00:43:49 Colour blindness should be the ideal, and that doesn't mean, as people like to pretend
00:43:53 it means that you don't see race. It means you don't care. It means you don't judge anyone
00:43:57 and you don't treat people differently because of race. The current intersectional crop want
00:44:02 us to judge people on their race, treat them differently on their race.
00:44:05 Roma D'Angelo says explicitly that if you treat black people the same as white people,
00:44:09 you're being racist. In other words, unless you're being racist, you're being racist.
00:44:14 So that's an impossible bind, isn't it?
00:44:16 It's pure doublespeak.
00:44:19 double-speak. Well she says that the colour blindness advanced by Martin Luther King is
00:44:23 a form of covert white supremacy. Well this is the point, is that what they will do with,
00:44:28 you mentioned Martin Luther King there, you know, they will, basically they will bring
00:44:32 him down, won't they? Well they've already accused him, some have accused him of being
00:44:35 racist or at least suffering from internalised racism. I mean the arrogance of that is astonishing.
00:44:42 Some others, another tactic that you'll get is people say well you haven't read all of
00:44:46 of Martin Luther King's corpus and actually look at these selected quotes that I can throw at you
00:44:50 which show that he's more on our side. Look, I don't actually care, right? I don't care what
00:44:54 else he said. What I'm saying is the ideal of colourblindness as encapsulated and beautifully
00:44:59 and eloquently expressed in that particular speech, right? That's what I'm talking about,
00:45:03 that ideal. I don't care who said it actually. It's the fact that he was able to express that
00:45:08 idea so beautifully and so perfectly. That's what we should be striving towards. Their idea that if
00:45:14 look at other elements of his life that somehow undermines the concept of that speech it simply
00:45:19 does not i mean did they really think at the end of the speech he just said ah lol only kidding no
00:45:24 actually when he says judge people by the content of their character not the color of their skin
00:45:28 that's what he means and that's the ideal we should be we should be aspiring towards
00:45:35 and we have to be when people like robin d'angelo come into your corporation for 12 grand an hour
00:45:41 to berate you for being racist even if you're not racist and tell you that if you say you don't
00:45:45 uh believe that people should be judged differently on on racial grounds you were therefore a racist
00:45:50 people have to have the courage to stand up and say you're wrong you're an idiot and you're a
00:45:54 racist and and so therefore that's how we'll get past this people don't do that because they fear
00:45:59 for their jobs that we're in this climate where they fear for as i've said their promotion prospects
00:46:04 and that kind of thing but you know the truth is uh society is not improved by uh an emphasis on
00:46:12 race and sexuality and gender that is disproportionate and inviting people to see those things
00:46:18 first and foremost and see us as human beings second or to see people as groups and demographics
00:46:23 and as individuals second um that isn't helpful i mean robin d'angelo have you read white
00:46:28 fragility no i haven't i don't think like you're very lucky um it's um it's like a form of torture
00:46:34 as a book it could be used as a device um i think if you what's very clear about the book
00:46:40 is i mean she continued well firstly she's a racist let's just say it and by the way that's
00:46:46 not me because i don't like people throwing that word around promiscuously she admits it
00:46:50 so she talks about how she once was invited to a party a street party or something and
00:46:55 she turns up and there's two parties going on and one is predominantly black and one is
00:46:59 predominantly white and she says she was filled with anxiety that it might be the black party
00:47:03 she's been invited to um now that's what a racist would think yeah so her interpretation is she then
00:47:10 says well that made me think that as a white woman i should reflect on my on my racism and i think
00:47:16 yeah that's a good idea because you're racist right um but her theory is in fact a form of
00:47:22 projection her theory is because i'm a racist white woman all other white people must be racist
00:47:27 and you see what that does that kind of um exempts you from fault yes because it's not your fault
00:47:33 because it's there's something inherent we go back to the religion idea that it's a kind of
00:47:37 original sin they use the phrase whiteness that's what i mean but whiteness is an original sin
00:47:41 it's something that is inbuilt within white people so all white people are racist um i can't help but
00:47:46 think that actually this idea is just being advanced by white racists yes and we probably
00:47:50 shouldn't get on board with that you know i think the thing is is that uh this woman and this book
00:47:57 and the whole concept of white fragility,
00:48:00 it's had an enormous sort of currency.
00:48:05 It's really funny, by the way.
00:48:07 Yeah, but what does it actually mean?
00:48:09 What does it mean?
00:48:10 It's got a massive, you know, open door.
00:48:14 I mean, everyone, you know, is taking it on board.
00:48:17 It's on these Lister reading lists that you mentioned earlier.
00:48:20 It's in schools.
00:48:21 Yes, in schools.
00:48:22 So, in other words, there's also a hell of a lot of people
00:48:25 who want to be told this.
00:48:27 No, there aren't. That's the thing. I don't think there are. I think the people who are pushing it are a minority. They're this indoctrinated minority who are not thinking. They're just in power, that's all. They're just in positions of power and people don't want to challenge them or, like I say, they're intimidated by the language.
00:48:44 the theory of white fragility
00:48:47 is that all white people are racist
00:48:49 and if a white person claims not to be racist
00:48:51 they are demonstrating white fragility
00:48:52 which is a form of racism
00:48:53 which means that you can't lose
00:48:55 so she's setting the rules of the game
00:48:57 so that she cannot lose
00:48:59 but what I'm saying is
00:49:00 the game is a fraud
00:49:01 so just reject the game
00:49:04 don't refuse to play it
00:49:06 unfortunately I read all this stuff
00:49:09 because I feel I have to have an understanding of it
00:49:11 before I mock it
00:49:12 and I think that's fair enough
00:49:14 it's exhausting
00:49:15 I mean I'm going away
00:49:16 on holiday now
00:49:17 for a few days
00:49:17 and I've only got
00:49:18 books like that
00:49:19 in my bag
00:49:19 you know I'm going to have to
00:49:20 there's a new one called
00:49:21 Is Free Speech Racist
00:49:23 I'm reading that one now
00:49:24 so I'm going to
00:49:25 you know I'm going to have
00:49:26 to sit there on a beach
00:49:26 and read that fucking thing
00:49:28 you know
00:49:29 and I know what it's going to be like
00:49:31 and I don't like to be prejudiced
00:49:32 when I go into reading it
00:49:32 but I do actually go in
00:49:33 with an open mind
00:49:34 like even in Robin DiAngelo's book
00:49:36 there are moments
00:49:36 where she makes points
00:49:37 that I think
00:49:38 yeah I'm on board with that
00:49:38 that's fine
00:49:39 and then she'll just undermine it
00:49:40 by saying everyone's a racist
00:49:41 ah screaming you know
00:49:42 and so
00:49:42 and that's that's the thing so i i have to read this stuff and it is it is like it's painful
00:49:48 partly because they're so badly written these are bad writers and academic writing largely is
00:49:53 comprised of bad writers you know if you can't express your ideas with clarity you're not good
00:49:57 at writing you know i'm sorry if you have to use words like discursive and phalogocentric and
00:50:03 words that are obviously only going to be i mean they're not even really uh useful terms what they
00:50:09 are is they're kind of codes they're signals to other people within the cult
00:50:13 that they're on board I mean my supervisor I had a supervisor called I
00:50:16 two supervisors at Oxford for my doctorate and one of them was a brilliant
00:50:20 guy called Robin Robbins who by the way wrote the definitive edition of John
00:50:24 Dunn's poetry so if you ever need that there's a two-volume thing for long which he spent 20
00:50:29 years working on so that's why it's so good but anyway he was a proper
00:50:31 scholarship you know back in the day but he used to say to me um firstly he said
00:50:35 don't go into academia that was his first piece of advice he said you'll end
00:50:38 running around the quad when you're 80 screaming why have I wasted my life and I took that on board
00:50:43 and got out but the other thing he used to say is that publishers people at the OUP or Cambridge
00:50:50 University Press or wherever you are they tend to take these books because they don't understand
00:50:55 them so you just stuff these books for the jargon and the publishers will publish them because they
00:51:00 don't know what they feel like if they if they come back and say well I don't really understand
00:51:03 this they might look stupid yes um empress new clothes yeah i mean i always find that kind of
00:51:10 writing judith butler's style of writing judith butler's queer theorist from the 90s i remember
00:51:14 reading gender trouble when i was at university and and then i i remember i got in a conversation
00:51:19 about this book with a friend of mine and i explained what it was about about gender
00:51:23 performativity was what she calls it um i explained it and i realized i just basically
00:51:28 explained the whole book in in like a minute and and then i realized the blurb on the back of the
00:51:32 book actually tells you all you need to know you don't need to read the book because what she does
00:51:36 is she finds very convoluted ways to say a very simple thing over many pages um i mean she won
00:51:41 the award for worst right worst academic writing in the world because honestly you can have a whole
00:51:45 sentences that go on with multiple clauses for three quarters of a page saying absolutely nothing
00:51:51 well you know when it comes to sort of the the cult of work and identity politics even something
00:51:56 which is understandable you know makes no sense for example lived lived experience um right what
00:52:05 is unlived experience i'm going to start pushing this idea of unlived unlived experience yes exactly
00:52:10 i've tried to think would it be in a one's inner life maybe or once fantasy world or something like
00:52:16 that lived experience is this what we used to call anecdotal evidence and we used to disregard it
00:52:21 yeah because everyone everyone who's who's schooled in critical thinking understands
00:52:25 that the way you experience something doesn't mean you can extrapolate that and and apply it to the
00:52:30 whole of society and assume that this so you know therefore someone um who experiences an unpleasant
00:52:35 act of homophobia right and then decides because this has happened to me our society is systemically
00:52:41 homophobic that would be the equivalent and i've seen that happen you know i i've gotten an argument
00:52:46 recently on twitter because again twitter uh because i i wrote an article saying we need to
00:52:49 ditch identity politics in the lgbt we actually let's get rid of lgbt and all its variant
00:52:54 initialisms let's get rid of all of that because it's just divisive and it doesn't serve any
00:52:58 purpose anymore other than for corporations to whack a flag on a product and sell it that's all
00:53:02 it is really now so let's get rid of that and uh and one person came back saying yes but i was i
00:53:06 was attacked i i was suffered from a homophobic attack and everything well okay that's horrible
00:53:11 and in a liberal society we deal with that and the police deal with that and it's illegal by the way
00:53:15 um so the your conclusion that because something bad happened because i'm gay means that uh society
00:53:23 hates gay people is not correct it's simply not accurate so um so we need to get back to the idea
00:53:30 that if someone invokes lived experience as evidence we say well that's not evidence you
00:53:35 know i think i think children need to be schooled in this stuff really yeah so so just the basics of
00:53:39 critical thinking it would be so simple if children just knew you throw an insult you've lost the
00:53:44 argument it's an ad hominem attack you mischaracterize what your opponent thinks that's a
00:53:48 a straw man you've lost the argument you know if you just taught them these basic ideas if you if
00:53:53 you appeal to your own experience as as as evidence that's not evidence you know all these
00:53:58 basics unfortunately what you have is um people are prominent people in the media and politics
00:54:03 who think who don't know these these basic rudimentary things i mean that's that's weird
00:54:08 to me so the solution is education basically it's probably one of the reasons why titania's book
00:54:14 will do very well actually as well they don't need they just don't know what they're talking
00:54:18 about these people they don't um and this is very instructive this book um i love that you keep
00:54:25 plugging it yes it means that i don't have i want to keep saying intersectional because i was cut to
00:54:30 the quick no no but i wasn't criticizing my whole point as you know the joke of the title is that a
00:54:35 child would never be able to grapple with this terminology i mean titania says in the opening
00:54:38 chapter i don't i don't believe in speaking down to children children have innate wisdom you know
00:54:43 as she says, with Greta Thunberg, you know, Titania's first words were, seize the means
00:54:48 of production as a baby, you know, so she doesn't believe that you talk down to children.
00:54:53 So that's just...
00:54:54 It's very, very funny, very, really.
00:54:56 And you thank so much, you know, for coming and talking about it.
00:54:59 Has that gone already?
00:55:00 Yes, no, it's great.
00:55:02 My first little book of intersectional activism, it's available now in all good bookshops in
00:55:07 the children's section?
00:55:09 well it probably won't be
00:55:12 and maybe it will end up there
00:55:14 I saw in a did you see in America
00:55:16 recently a thing called the Bronco bookstore
00:55:18 they tweeted out their display
00:55:20 of books that are committed to diversity
00:55:23 and inclusion and there was
00:55:24 Ibram Kendi and Robin
00:55:26 D'Angelo and there was Woke by Titania
00:55:28 McGrath as well and
00:55:29 they didn't realise
00:55:32 and then at first I thought
00:55:34 well maybe they're in on the joke
00:55:36 but then they got a lot of tweets saying you realise that's satire
00:55:39 not only did they remove it from their display
00:55:41 they removed it from sale on their website as well
00:55:43 so they weren't happy about that
00:55:44 what a compliment though
00:55:45 what a compliment to you
00:55:47 thanks very much
00:55:49 and look
00:55:49 you're getting off on holiday
00:55:51 try not to read too much
00:55:55 do relax
00:55:56 I will do my best
00:55:58 I've got one of my Stella Benson books as well
00:56:00 so I can read something that's actually good
00:56:02 and then I'll read all the rubbish as well
00:56:04 you just have to vary it
00:56:06 thanks very much
00:56:08 Thank you.
00:56:09 Thank you.
00:56:10 That's it for what you're saying this week.
00:56:13 Great talk, I think you'll agree.
00:56:15 We shall see you next week.
00:56:16 Thanks very much.
00:56:17 Bye-bye.