New Culture Forum - September 14, 2020


The 'Decolonise Education' Movement Is Dangerous And Demoralising. It Must Be Rejected.

Andrew Doyle: "My First Little Book Of Intersectional Activism", a parody of today's woke kids books Nick Buckley MBE - Sacked For Criticising BLM Despite Helping 1000s Of Children

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

188.52

Word count

9,487

Sentence count

276


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now recently in London a primary school
00:00:20 won an award, an inclusivity award, for its work on decolonizing the curriculum. What this meant
00:00:28 was that the children for example were no longer going to be taught about the
00:00:33 seven wonders of the world but they were going to be taught about the South
00:00:37 Hall uprising of 1979. The school in question is in South Hall. We're hearing
00:00:44 a hell of a lot about this word decolonization but it still seems to be
00:00:49 lacking a definition. What actually does it mean and how is it imposed particularly
00:00:54 on the area of the most important of all being education that's straight from schools right
00:01:00 through to the academic world we're going to be discussing this today i'm very pleased we've got
00:01:05 guests from across the board of education first of all somebody who's not a stranger to our channel
00:01:11 at all katherine burble singh who is the founder and head teacher of the mikhaila free school
00:01:17 We have Alice Grant, who is a student and political activist, Rafe Hadle-Manku, of course, from the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator, and Calvin Robinson, who is a school teacher and school governor.
00:01:34 Welcome. Thank you very much for coming.
00:01:36 Catherine, I want to start with you, if I may. People, as I say, are hearing about decolonisation, decolonising the curriculum, decolonising this library, whatever.
00:01:46 what does it actually mean well I think it means it starts from the premise that
00:01:55 there that the history that we teach the children does not include many black
00:02:01 historical events or black figures and and you know once upon a time this
00:02:07 really was true and there was cause for criticism of the curriculum rightly so
00:02:14 because black people and any other ethnic people had been kind of whitewashed out of it.
00:02:20 So, for instance, the million Indian soldiers in the world wars that participated
00:02:25 or the several hundred thousand Caribbean soldiers, it was as if they never existed
00:02:31 and they were never mentioned.
00:02:33 So the textbooks never mentioned them.
00:02:36 And, you know, colonialism would have been taught in such a way to suggest
00:02:40 that Great Britain had done nothing wrong and that it was all wonderful for the colonies.
00:02:46 And obviously this just isn't true.
00:02:48 But that isn't the case anymore.
00:02:51 And so, well, I say it isn't the case.
00:02:54 The truth is that we don't actually know what's taught in our schools.
00:02:58 And I do think that that's important.
00:03:00 The curriculum is such that I don't see a problem with it with regard to it needing to be decolonized.
00:03:07 But it's true that we don't really know what children learn in history at school.
00:03:11 At primary level, at SATs, children are only assessed on their English and their maths.
00:03:16 So you have no idea what they're being taught in history.
00:03:18 And from one school to another, frankly, we have no idea what they're being taught in history at all.
00:03:23 So I always think it's a bit of a red herring, this business of talking about, well, how many black people are involved in the history.
00:03:30 Well, you know, are they being taught history?
00:03:33 Are they being taught it well enough to remember anything?
00:03:35 No. And then at key stage three, so year seven, eight and nine, again, children are not assessed nationally at all.
00:03:43 The only time children are assessed nationally on history is at GCSE.
00:03:47 But only 40 percent of children take history GCSE.
00:03:51 So that means the majority of children go through their entire school careers and we have no idea what they've learned.
00:03:58 And that in itself is worrying. But that has nothing to do with the black issue.
00:04:03 That has to do with the fact that we don't know what's going on in our schools.
00:04:07 And this is something that I've been shouting about for many years.
00:04:11 And I do think people get a bit confused as well.
00:04:15 They sort of think if children can't remember something, then it hasn't been taught.
00:04:20 And I would argue that the children are taught many things in school.
00:04:25 They don't remember them because of the way in which they've been taught them.
00:04:28 And that there's something wrong with some of the teaching methods that we use.
00:04:30 There's also something wrong with the behaviour in our schools.
00:04:34 And if children are constantly disrupted in their lessons,
00:04:36 well, it's no wonder they're not remembering anything.
00:04:38 And then they go away and they say, well, I was never taught this.
00:04:42 Well, perhaps you were, but you just don't remember.
00:04:51 Would you agree with that?
00:04:53 Well, it started off really as an attempt to do exactly as Catherine has said,
00:04:57 but it's gone far beyond that.
00:04:59 I mean, we've seen here and in America and South Africa also this effort, particularly in universities, to get rid of statues and plaques of roads and others.
00:05:08 But it's gone beyond that and beyond balancing or allegedly balancing the curriculum to actually questioning universal truths and universal values.
00:05:15 This idea of basically of knowledge relativism, that knowledge is different but equal.
00:05:21 So that basically those things that we've regarded as universal values from the Enlightenment are merely one set of values and knowledge.
00:05:29 and that there are equally valid knowledge on similar issues you'll find in Africa or Asia,
00:05:34 when we know through empiricism that's simply not the case.
00:05:36 And it's this idea, basically, that we're trying to re-racialize education and society.
00:05:43 That's really at the heart of the problem, because what you're really having put forward now
00:05:47 is this idea that blacks, for example, are a homogenized group,
00:05:51 all of whom are distressed.
00:05:54 Everyone is white.
00:05:56 And, you know, that blacks are uniquely vulnerable and fragile, that they can't actually walk through a campus without being offended by statues and so forth, or that they are incapable of learning about Kant or Shakespeare because they're not black, you know, irrespective of the fact that you have vast numbers of students coming here from all over the world, from China and elsewhere, who have no problem at all being educated in Western universities.
00:06:19 I mean, I'm reminded, you know,
00:06:20 the University College London formed this organisation
00:06:23 called Why Is Our Curriculum So White?
00:06:26 And that's the problem. Why is it white?
00:06:28 And to me, that immediately brought to mind, you know,
00:06:31 Forty Towers scene where Basil Forty takes
00:06:33 the curmudgeon of Joan Sanderson up to her hotel bedroom
00:06:36 and she's complaining about this beautiful view of a talkie scene
00:06:40 and she says, it's not good enough.
00:06:42 And he said, well, what do you expect to see from a talkie window?
00:06:45 You know, the Hanging Gardens of Babylon,
00:06:46 The Sydney Opera House, Herds of Wildebeest.
00:06:49 And what do you expect in the United Kingdom,
00:06:52 apart from having a white curriculum,
00:06:53 given that it's a European nation in a majority white country?
00:06:58 And so there's complete lunacy now.
00:07:00 There were absolutely justified reasons for starting this.
00:07:03 But now, of course, it's gone down this route.
00:07:06 And so there's not really an issue of decolonisation.
00:07:08 It's demajoritising the curriculum.
00:07:11 It's demoralising the population as a result.
00:07:14 and that's going to actually end up destabilising society as a whole.
00:07:17 So there are lots of Ds here, but it's not decolonising.
00:07:21 What do you understand by it, Alice?
00:07:23 I mean, you are about to go up to university, aren't you?
00:07:26 I mean, what's your experience been when we say,
00:07:29 oh, you know, the curriculum is being decolonised?
00:07:33 Have you had any direct experience of that yourself?
00:07:36 Well, I think Catherine mentioned a really interesting point
00:07:38 about wondering whether my generation
00:07:41 has even been taught history properly, if at all.
00:07:44 And I think that indeed history is not being taught in a way that fosters any sense of patriotism or belonging to our nation.
00:07:52 And I think that's a huge reason why we're seeing these kind of BLM far-left movements.
00:07:57 Because I think the result of this is that my whole generation doesn't feel at all belonging to this country or rooted in our values or in our culture.
00:08:06 and that's creating lots of problems among them are the fact that we've lost a sort of sense of
00:08:13 morality and a sense of what being British means. Yes you see the thing is I when people talk about
00:08:20 decolonising specifically about British history I always to me the default position over the past
00:08:28 40 50 years has been very critical I don't remember in school being taught how brilliant
00:08:35 you know the world was pink and you know and and you know this was all great if anything i
00:08:41 i remember it's actually been quite critical it's not like it was all very celebratory i mean calvin
00:08:47 if i can come to come to you to see do these things ring true to you i mean how do you think
00:08:53 history do you think history is inadequately taught and is is it taught in a very anti-british sort of
00:08:59 vein as alice was suggesting so i mean there's several issues at play here but for me is that
00:09:06 i don't see our history curriculum being broken down into white history versus black history
00:09:10 that doesn't make any sense to how we teach it we teach history based on events that have occurred
00:09:15 so the national it clearly lays out you know british history to teach and world history to
00:09:20 teach and the curriculum is very broad and very balanced like catherine said we don't know if
00:09:25 that's being taught in all schools and how it's being taught but what worries me about all of this
00:09:30 is people that are asking to decolonize the curriculum or the same people who are saying
00:09:35 we need more black history on the curriculum what they're suggesting what they're putting forward
00:09:40 is critical racism and that's all of this talk about white privilege and everything gets broken
00:09:46 down to people either being an oppressor or a victim i have real problems with this because i
00:09:52 I think we've gone full circle to the point that the far left are now preaching what the
00:09:56 far right is to preach in there, that it's essentially racial superiority, you know,
00:10:00 the perpetuating myth of white supremacy, that white people are as a national advantage
00:10:05 and everyone else, as you call BMEs, which is a bracket that doesn't make any of the
00:10:09 paper, is somehow disadvantaged just based on the color of our skin.
00:10:13 And we all have many advantages and disadvantages that change.
00:10:15 None of that's constant.
00:10:17 So I don't think we can shape the curriculum around those disadvantages.
00:10:22 And this is a point, isn't it really? It seems to, we hear in these terms increasingly white supremacy, as Calvin says there, about the oppressed and the oppressor. I mean, this is how I understand decolonisation.
00:10:36 Yeah, so the problem is that everyone is being encouraged to identify as their race, as opposed to, as Alice was saying, you know, if we're teaching British history, within British history, you might have some black figures and you might have some historical events that involves black people, but you have other events as well.
00:10:58 But I would stress that there was a legitimate grievance that,
00:11:04 I mean, I know you're saying that it was taught in a critical fashion,
00:11:08 but it's not so much, it's not just that, one, I don't think that was always the case.
00:11:15 I think it was when, at least like when I was three young.
00:11:17 Yes, yes, and that's in your school.
00:11:19 The point is that there's great variety amongst schools,
00:11:21 and we have no way, there's no audit that's taken of how history is taught
00:11:25 or whether it's taught at all.
00:11:26 We don't know what's going on in our schools, so that's key.
00:11:29 And I personally think there's a lot more important stuff that we should talk about,
00:11:33 like the fact that 20% of our children leave school that are functionally illiterate and functionally enumerate.
00:11:38 You know, if you want to help a black child have a life, it's less about teaching him black history
00:11:44 and more about teaching him how to read and write.
00:11:47 But leaving that aside, I mean, Rafe made some interesting points.
00:11:52 The point is it's gone far too far.
00:11:54 It's become ridiculous, so to the point where people are unable to walk past a statue,
00:11:58 a statue that no one ever noticed existed in the first place.
00:12:01 And it's suddenly become all about taking down this statue
00:12:04 because people are traumatized by walking past a statue, which is just absurd.
00:12:11 Well, no. I mean, from my point of view, in secondary schools,
00:12:15 most recently, because of BLM and what's been happening over the last few months,
00:12:19 particularly devastating for me is the traditional charter schools in America, the Success Academy in
00:12:26 New York, Uncommon Schools in New Jersey, and then KIPP schools that are across the country.
00:12:32 Our motto at Michaela is work hard, be kind. And we essentially copied this from KIPP. And their
00:12:38 motto is work hard, be nice. And we thought we'd change it to work hard, be kind. And they have
00:12:45 got rid of their motto because it's systemically racist to encourage children to work hard and be
00:12:50 kind and they haven't just done that they know children can wear trainers it doesn't matter
00:12:55 about their uniform uh they're not going to give them detentions for small behavior issues and of
00:13:01 course anyone who knows children in a school if you don't give detentions for the small behavior
00:13:05 issues the big behavior issues they start slamming you know their heads into a wall now how that
00:13:10 helps black children in schools, God only knows. I mean, the fact is that all children,
00:13:16 whatever their color, ought to learn the history of their country, ought to learn their times
00:13:21 tables, ought to read the best that's been said and thought. And the thing is, the problem
00:13:28 in what Rafe was saying, and this is where we need, those of us who think as we do, need
00:13:33 to be able to defend this point, because Rafe is making, he's making the point that it's
00:13:38 a European country therefore we're going to teach European writers and European
00:13:42 history and of course that means it's mainly going to be a white curriculum
00:13:45 but I think it's more than that actually I don't think it's just about us being
00:13:49 I mean I think that's true and if we were in China clearly we'd be teaching
00:13:53 Chinese history we wouldn't be teaching British history but I think it's more
00:13:56 than that the Western Canon has a value and Shakespeare has been influencing
00:14:03 writers for 400 years and Maya Angelou for instance the African American writer
00:14:08 who I have quoted twice on my wall in my office and who I love she always used to
00:14:13 say that you know she thought Shakespeare when she first read him she
00:14:16 thought he must be a black woman because he understood the plight of the black
00:14:20 woman so well you know because Shakespeare is universal and he speaks
00:14:24 of jealousy and rage and anger and joy and all of these human characteristics
00:14:30 and and and and things that make us you know gives us a soul and all of us should
00:14:37 able to access shakespeare whatever color we are and it's very odd that in 2020 we seem to think
00:14:42 that white children can identify and understand with shakespeare but the black children can't
00:14:47 and if the black child is not taught shakespeare but the white child is well the black the white
00:14:52 child is of great advantage because shakespeare has been influencing our culture and our writing
00:14:57 for so long for 400 years and the thing about you know and then we talk about you see this is where
00:15:03 what I'm saying becomes relatively controversial because then you say well are you saying white
00:15:07 writers are better than black writers and and the thing about dead white men so we're very pro
00:15:12 teaching dead white men is that everybody concentrates on the men bit and on the white
00:15:16 bit when actually the important bit is the fact that they're dead they've been dead for hundreds
00:15:23 of years and yet they have influenced writing for all of this time and so that is why we should
00:15:28 teach them and of course in 400 years you know you said well what about black authors i am a
00:15:33 black author but i would never suggest that they should be teaching my books instead of shakespeare
00:15:37 it's just absurd um so wait a minute when you're saying it the important thing is it let's clarify
00:15:42 this you mean that they're just showing how influential they are you're not obviously saying
00:15:47 it's good that they're in the past no it's also good that they're in the past i mean what what
00:15:53 What? Because they've been around forever. So their influence has been around forever.
00:15:58 So, you know, a rose would smell as sweet and, you know, all these various expressions that we use all the time that come from Shakespeare.
00:16:06 We ought to know this and we ought to be familiar with this.
00:16:09 And we hold our children back if we don't.
00:16:12 And what shocks me and terrifies me is that well-meaning teachers, they are well-meaning, in the classroom are denying black children a certain education of the Western canon because they think that black children cannot identify with white authors or with white history, whatever white history means.
00:16:34 That's what they think. And so then they think they need to decolonize it all in order for these children to be able to access it.
00:16:40 And my point is, well, all of our points is that children don't, in order to understand some history, it doesn't have to be the history of the people who look like you.
00:16:52 And in order for you to read a book, it doesn't have to be written by an author who looks like you.
00:16:57 Now, it is a problem if everything is completely whitewashed.
00:17:02 I do think that's a problem, and it was a problem.
00:17:04 I'm not sure it's such an issue now, although we'll never really know because none of this is ever assessed.
00:17:10 And so we have no idea.
00:17:11 The only thing I would say, sorry, before I come in here, Rafe,
00:17:15 is, you know, you're talking about, you know, I totally agree.
00:17:18 You know, what is it, you know, why won't black kids
00:17:21 as much as white kids, you know, appreciate classical music,
00:17:25 say, or whatever it might be.
00:17:26 Yes, exactly.
00:17:26 But the point is the decolonisation movement
00:17:29 is not just about education, even though I'd say it's the most important.
00:17:33 It's going across the board.
00:17:35 So we've had, you know, for example, in the British Library,
00:17:40 this week they're even talking about maybe revising or questioning whether statues of
00:17:46 beethoven and mendelssohn should be there because they are basically white western civilization now
00:17:54 that that is not about whether you know this is this is crazy stuff isn't it yeah but i agree with
00:18:00 much of what catherine says particularly about these universal values and universal truth and
00:18:03 knowledge and the global value of of you know philosophers from from enough and from buddha
00:18:08 to Christ, from Shakespeare
00:18:10 onwards, you know, of course these are global
00:18:12 figures, but of course my point was
00:18:14 we're in a majority white country, you wouldn't ask
00:18:16 an Indian, why is my curriculum so brown?
00:18:18 You don't expect Africans to have
00:18:20 expert knowledge on Chinese history, do you?
00:18:22 So, I mean, right, the fact is
00:18:24 nowhere in the world has more diversity
00:18:26 of courses covering
00:18:28 global subjects than Britain
00:18:30 and America and the Anglosphere, right?
00:18:32 These countries, you can cover every part of the globe
00:18:34 in far more breadth than anywhere else in the world
00:18:36 nowhere has such a diverse
00:18:38 academic background to their
00:18:40 stars in terms of the racial profiling of
00:18:42 all the university academics. I mean
00:18:44 Catherine's focusing on primary
00:18:46 and secondary schools but the decolonizing of the
00:18:48 curriculum is very much and I'm much more interested in the
00:18:50 university side where I think it's much more
00:18:52 potent. But it's also
00:18:54 extremely offensive
00:18:55 and patronizing to say that
00:18:58 black people can't actually
00:18:59 learn about these characters because they don't
00:19:02 share the same color. I mean this is absurd
00:19:04 and also as I said before it ignores the
00:19:06 fact that international students flock to America and to Britain. And if people from China and India
00:19:13 can come over here and study subjects in white universities without this feeling of oppression
00:19:17 or this inability to learn, that's another overarching issue. And that's why I have a
00:19:23 problem also with this idea of BAME, black and minority ethnics, as if they're one cohesive
00:19:28 group. You know, there's so many different gradations there, even within the subcontinent
00:19:31 between Bangladeshis and Indians. There's huge differences between the achievements of
00:19:36 different groups in the academic system and this idea that everyone is is a whole block and it's
00:19:41 also you know offensive i would say to to it's a re-rate it's a re-racializing of of society and
00:19:47 of the academic programs you know martin luther king of course famously said judge people by the
00:19:51 content of you know of themselves rather than of their skin now his name would need to be
00:19:55 decolonized today because he's named after a dead white man martin luther isn't he right but that
00:20:00 but that's a person i think who really shows how we've gone to this in this insane position right
00:20:05 now. But I agree on the point, basically, that there are universal values, but it goes beyond
00:20:11 literature and history and philosophy. Even science is now being questioned because the
00:20:16 scientific principles of today, which are global and which have lifted the world out of poverty
00:20:20 and pestilence, came from the Enlightenment. So now you have scientists calling for the
00:20:25 decolonization of science because of its inherent racism, which is perpetuated today. And it's this
00:20:31 idea that colonization and the evil effects of colonialism are not in the past that they are
00:20:36 present and ongoing today in universities which are the most woke institutions in the world and
00:20:41 yet these are apparently the hotbed of the far rights and of you know jingoistic imperialists
00:20:47 I mean it's a completely absurd world that we're now living in and I want to get off it actually
00:20:50 also I believe that we England has produced Britain has produced some of the best writers
00:20:56 and the best thinkers in the whole world, and why shouldn't we be uniting behind that
00:21:01 and teaching children and students at university to actually feel grateful to be part of such
00:21:08 an incredible heritage? And also, the truth is, decolonising of the curriculum will ultimately,
00:21:14 if we're just erasing these figures from our history and instead replacing them with
00:21:17 whatever suits the quota box, whatever ticks the box, it will ultimately, I guess, lead
00:21:23 to generations who are less educated and others who don't know as much because they're not being
00:21:28 taught the highest standard and that would obviously work very well for the left which needs
00:21:36 generations who are basically just mindless lemmings and who all vote for them and fall
00:21:40 for their victimhood narrative and and fall for their whole racism which they which ultimately
00:21:47 just causes a division so i i look at my generation and in fact i'm i guess i get i get a bit nervous
00:21:53 sometimes thinking if there was a world war would my generation stand up and fight for britain fight
00:21:58 for our values um even though so many of us have no connection to that and do not feel linked to
00:22:03 our past and that's really worrying because we need people who who feel connected to this land
00:22:08 and feel connected to our ancestors and who are able to stand up and fight for that if that if
00:22:13 that should ever happen but the thing is though isn't it that how can you fight for something
00:22:17 that you you don't you don't know about i mean that you don't love you know or that you just
00:22:22 don't know about i mean you know the extraordinary the the number of like younger people who do not
00:22:28 know about parliamentary democracy coming here or you know the magna carter we have such a huge role
00:22:34 in abolishing slavery i bet many of the blm protesters would never know that fact because
00:22:39 it's not being taught because it doesn't suit the left's narrative that we are this evil
00:22:42 colonialist nation who came in and destroyed half the world and that's the total opposite
00:22:47 of the truth in fact and yeah you're looking as though you find that controversial well i mean i
00:22:53 wouldn't go as far as saying all of that i mean look i do i don't think for the vast majority of
00:23:00 people on the left i mean i think yes it's true for some but that they're kind of sat there rubbing
00:23:06 their hands together and thinking what we need are a bunch of illiterate children who will just
00:23:12 become idiots who will shine our shoes and um it's not that but if you look at my generation
00:23:17 they don't have any spine they don't have the courage to even believe in ourselves as a nation
00:23:21 and that's why i think so many people my age actually wouldn't do not think brexit is a good
00:23:25 idea not because um they they they know they know about it but purely because they haven't been
00:23:31 empowered with the feeling that we can do this we're you know the fifth largest economy in the
00:23:35 world yeah but that i just wouldn't say that that was deliberate when i was saying these are well
00:23:40 meaning teachers they are and many of them are working so hard and giving everything to these
00:23:46 kids they've just they just don't i mean what's bizarre is that the progressives are constantly
00:23:51 one talking about making children creative and independently minded and to have their
00:23:56 be able to form their own opinions meanwhile they're kind of pushing them down a particular
00:24:02 road and wanting them to think in one particular way and um and they don't really show them the
00:24:08 two sides and they talk about diversity but there's never any diversity of thought and you
00:24:14 know when alice was talking earlier before we came on and she said she just finished her a levels i
00:24:18 couldn't believe it i thought well who is this young woman who thinks like this i've never heard
00:24:22 of a young person thinking like this on their own it's just extraordinary so and and and it is
00:24:28 extraordinary because sadly the school system i do think is failing to encourage children to think
00:24:36 for themselves and then they end up at university where they're all a bit snowflakey and upset
00:24:42 whenever the statue are upset with the slightest little thing with you know and they suddenly
00:24:46 can't uh identify with with doing something that isn't someone of their own skin color and that
00:24:52 comes back to what you were saying alice about the country you know the british values and the
00:24:58 country is the one thing that unifies us we're in a multicultural society and if we deny britain
00:25:05 and reject it because we're so critical of her past and we're unable to see how lucky we are
00:25:13 to live in a country where you can be gay and it's not just fine, you can celebrate it in a pride march
00:25:20 whereas in 22 countries it is not just illegal, you will suffer death if you're gay.
00:25:26 You know, I feel like many of these people haven't travelled, they don't know what's out there,
00:25:31 they don't know what the alternative is you know you always need to ask well what's it like in
00:25:36 comparison to what you know if it's so awful well in comparison to what i didn't know you see the
00:25:42 funny thing is about that as you can see a very good point there you might but so i feel that
00:25:46 that's the one thing that they absolutely do do and that is travel i mean the idea that they would
00:25:54 bother to go on their gap year to help people on a council estate in uneaten it just wouldn't come
00:26:00 wouldn't come into their heads that it's got to be Namibia or it's got to be somewhere else
00:26:05 because that will make them feel good. I mean, if I can bring in Calvin, who's waiting patiently
00:26:09 there by his mic. Calvin, you know, I started at the top of the programme, just in relation
00:26:15 to what we've just been talking about, I started by saying, you know, this school that's just got
00:26:19 this award in London won't or doesn't anymore, for example, teach about the seven wonders of the
00:26:27 world uh is that because that would be considered to be sort of white knowledge you know it the
00:26:34 implication was somehow other that this was the seven wonders of the world was a kind of white
00:26:39 thing and that somehow you know they should talk in the particular case of this school it was
00:26:44 about their local history um that that's what they said i mean do you think i mean rave made
00:26:51 point as well earlier that basically subjects are being relativized in this way this is a very
00:26:56 worrying thing isn't it surely i think i think you're onto something there but what i'm seeing
00:27:03 in this conversation is that it always comes back to identity as it often does when we're arguing
00:27:07 with the left and we're arguing on their territory about their issue which is id um and with identity
00:27:13 politics they're assuming that pupils are going to identify first and foremost as black or first
00:27:19 and foremost as white rather than looking at the bigger picture i don't think a lot of our kids
00:27:24 look like that think like that i don't think they assume uh that the first or core part of their
00:27:28 identity is their learning count what i see in schools like in catholic for example they teach
00:27:34 britishness that you know everyone is part of the same community school community or this nation
00:27:40 that we happen to live in and that is something that unites us and we should be proud of that and
00:27:44 and that should be the core point of our identity.
00:27:47 But with that comes, you know, taking away
00:27:50 the individualistic side of it comes a sense of service
00:27:52 and duty and responsibility to each other.
00:27:55 If we belong to something bigger than just ourselves
00:27:57 and our same color, if we belong to this sense of Britishness
00:28:01 that, you know, it's difficult to define,
00:28:03 but we will know what we're seeing.
00:28:05 I think if you shift the argument back onto that,
00:28:07 take it away from identity, which is where they want,
00:28:09 where they are possible, and say, actually, no, we're not,
00:28:13 curriculum isn't black or white uh we're not teaching about white people or black figures
00:28:16 we're teaching british history because we live in britain and we should all be proud of our
00:28:20 british values but you see calvin before sorry before when you say that you see
00:28:26 the impression one gets about the educational establishment and about schools is that if you
00:28:31 said that uh i don't know what your peers would think of that would if you said we should teach
00:28:36 togetherness in a sense of overarching britishness would they sort of say oh no no we can't possibly
00:28:42 do that because that would be automatically in an odd way exclusive automatically wrong or you know
00:28:51 or what is that what what if you say that if you want to do that what would the react have you
00:28:57 ever come up against a bad reaction to that oh all the time i every time i get an opportunity to speak
00:29:04 at an educational conference i always say we should be promoting british values because the
00:29:09 The teachers' standards say we shouldn't undermine British values, which is very passive, it's not very active.
00:29:13 I think we should actively promote them.
00:29:15 But then people say, well, what are British values?
00:29:17 We don't know what they are, but we do, because the government clearly prescribes British values as democracy,
00:29:22 the rule of law, tolerance for people of different faiths and non-inclusivity towards more people.
00:29:29 These are British values.
00:29:30 And then people say, well, they're not exclusively British.
00:29:33 How can we say that they're ours?
00:29:34 That's missing the point.
00:29:35 You know, I'm not saying that any of these things are exclusive, I'm sure there are many
00:29:40 countries around the world that celebrate their values, but I can point out to many
00:29:43 others that don't as well.
00:29:45 And that's why we should be proud of them.
00:29:46 And we have helped spread parliamentary democracy around the world.
00:29:50 We have helped highlight how civil war can be built, civil liberties and all of these
00:29:56 things.
00:29:57 So why should we celebrate the positives?
00:29:59 And this is something our academia, in particular, in our educational sector, are always bringing
00:30:03 us down and flip it back around, I think.
00:30:07 And Calvin's absolutely right in that that was superb.
00:30:09 And, of course, what the Michaela School's doing as well is absolutely stellar.
00:30:13 But unfortunately, there is definitely in the minority.
00:30:16 And, you know, as I've often said, you know, at the last election, fewer than 10% of primary
00:30:20 school teachers voted for the Conservative Party.
00:30:23 In the 90s, when I was at university, I went to graduate school at University of Toronto,
00:30:27 and there was a two-to-one bias of two liberals for every one conservative.
00:30:32 Now it's a nine-to-one bias.
00:30:34 That's a sea change that's happened in the space of 20 years or so.
00:30:37 And so whether you're looking at primary school, at secondary school, at post-secondary education,
00:30:41 there has been a huge shift.
00:30:43 There's always been a left-leaning bias in education.
00:30:45 That's always been the case.
00:30:46 But the shift that's happened over the last 20 years has been profound to the point where it's almost a ten-to-one bias again.
00:30:52 And you wouldn't want that bias on the right or the left.
00:30:56 Everything needs to have a healthy balance if you're going to have a productive society.
00:30:59 It's the yin and the yang.
00:31:01 You need to have that.
00:31:01 for any healthy society and unfortunately what I'm seeing now is a generation of children
00:31:07 who are growing up without any exposure to the very principles and values and beliefs or just
00:31:12 contrarian views that we see espoused here where we are the counterculture and ironically there's
00:31:18 the traditional conservatives who are the counterculture and you know the old adage is you
00:31:22 know give me a boy until he's seven and I will show you the man well it's now a case of give me
00:31:26 the boy until he's 21 or 18
00:31:28 and I'll show you somebody who's completely
00:31:30 brainwashed.
00:31:33 That's more or less
00:31:34 what we're seeing now in the system.
00:31:36 We have to actually speak about this in
00:31:38 plain terms because it has got to that
00:31:40 point. I may not have said that 15 years
00:31:42 or 10 years ago, but now it seems to me
00:31:44 that when you have a situation where if
00:31:46 those under 25 had been the only ones voting
00:31:48 in the election, there would have been
00:31:49 something like 80% of the
00:31:52 seats in the House of Commons would have been for Jeremy
00:31:54 Corbyn. There is a problem here
00:31:56 and the Tory party aren't addressing it with their aging population
00:31:59 and something needs to be done if we are to actually have some semblance of sanity returned.
00:32:04 Something has to happen in the teacher training colleges
00:32:06 or maybe even eradicate the teacher training colleges and come to some other form
00:32:11 whereby people are trained to be teachers in a healthier environment
00:32:16 which is actually open to diversity of opinion and diversity of thought
00:32:19 and to a wider range of views because the system as it is currently I think is broken.
00:32:23 yeah yeah no i would agree with what rafe is saying it does start in the schools uh people
00:32:30 always say how has this happened now 2020 and how are the universities like this and i always think
00:32:36 well it's pretty obvious it's because they're coming through our schools and at school what
00:32:43 the way they're taught and the fact that i mean we sing god save the queen uh i vow to thee my
00:32:48 country and Jerusalem. I don't know of any other state schools that do that. And I certainly know
00:32:54 that when teachers come and see us do it, they sort of, you can see them bristle. They don't
00:33:00 like it. They feel very uncomfortable. Now, my staff, who are amazing and extremely tolerant
00:33:07 and open-minded, I would say the patriotism is probably the hardest thing. Of all the things
00:33:13 that we do differently, and we do everything differently in comparison to other schools,
00:33:17 I'd say that the singing and the belief in Britain and the flag flying outside that is probably the
00:33:25 thing everyone struggles with the most but they come to see the benefits and there's so many
00:33:32 benefits it it binds us all we're all together when you all sing together there's this wonderful
00:33:39 feeling in the room and this sense of community and love and and you know when the football was
00:33:44 on when we the world cup i mean what do i know about football nothing but i made sure that i
00:33:48 found out lots about it we had england flags everywhere and i'd come in and i'd say did you
00:33:52 see us against columbia and it was all you know rah rah go england you know and um and that's
00:33:58 because we have a very multicultural community with children of all different colors and um
00:34:03 britain is the one thing that binds us together we have muslims and hindus and jewish kids and
00:34:08 and buddhist kids and all kinds of kids i mean jehovah witnesses and you know and then you've
00:34:13 got all these different races and colors and so on well what's the one thing we've got in common
00:34:17 britain and what calvin was saying about all of those um you know he said oh the rule of law and
00:34:23 democracy and everyone the reason why so many teachers say well what's the point of that i
00:34:27 mean who cares everybody has that but they don't this is the thing when i say they don't travel
00:34:32 and you're quite right they do but somehow they travel with with kind of i don't know i think
00:34:36 They can't see what they see.
00:34:38 Yes, sorry to interrupt, but I think the thing is, when they travel now, they travel in an odd way without the curiosity of older people.
00:34:48 They don't notice nuance.
00:34:50 They just, to them, they've sort of been taught everything sort of not British is lovely and fluffy and warm, you know, that somehow they should embrace.
00:34:57 So, you know, and you go and you try the cuisine and you don't know the place hangs gay men, for example.
00:35:02 Yeah, yeah, yes, yes.
00:35:04 No, exactly, exactly.
00:35:05 That's exactly what's going on.
00:35:06 and it's really it's really worrying and um and yeah sorry to interrupt but i just i was thinking
00:35:13 in any other part of the world you know being united under our flag and singing patriotic songs
00:35:18 would be very much celebrated and commemorated and welcomed if you look at schools in japan
00:35:24 um i know an english teacher who went there and was really impressed by their patriotism and the
00:35:29 fact that that all the children felt very much as though they belonged to this um this sense of
00:35:35 community and we don't have that here and i and i do believe it's because there has been a sort of
00:35:40 leftist infiltration at least from my experience i know my teachers um always in all subjects
00:35:45 everything was sort of taught from a lens of whether it's you know the patriarchy or or um
00:35:50 gender ideology when you were doing so that a levels definitely all my texts we had to have
00:35:55 like feminist viewpoints and stuff which is obviously so utterly boring and it's really i
00:36:00 think it's not very progressive at all because ultimately we're just going
00:36:05 backwards and everything whether it be intellectually or spiritually or
00:36:09 morally when I don't think children are being you know being being given the
00:36:15 opportunity to actually learn more and think freely and think critically about
00:36:19 what we're being taught instead everything has to be through a kind of
00:36:22 lens of racism or sexism or whatever and it's it's very very dull indeed
00:36:27 it's all actually basically power as you were saying it's about oppressed and oppressed and
00:36:32 oppressors it's a it's sort of about it's about power and essentially who has it i mean if we
00:36:38 if we are sort of actually agreed on the you know broadly about this what is to be done you
00:36:44 you know you said what you do for example uh michaela uh you are very specific you sing
00:36:51 god says the queen and you do these things um you are as you say in a minority i mean
00:36:58 calvin what how would you how do we turn this thing around if if basically this is the case
00:37:05 that like all the points we've made that's essentially we're going in the wrong direction
00:37:10 where do you start i mean where do you where do you practically start
00:37:17 i think evidence so i'm an evidence-based teacher and everything we do should be backed up by
00:37:22 research um if they're saying that kids aren't like history let's do some research into that
00:37:28 let's do some polling of teachers find out what's being taught in schools and then we can you know
00:37:33 give it back actually this is being caught and what you're talking about is nonsense let's also
00:37:37 look at what the point is that they're saying so they're saying they want to decolonize the
00:37:42 curriculum they want more black history in the curriculum what is the end goal what is the reason
00:37:48 behind them? Is it because they think that black students need to see more black people
00:37:53 in order to get self-esteem or to recognize themselves? Let's look into that too, because
00:37:59 I'm sure that's not the case either. I don't think most, like I've said earlier, I don't think most
00:38:03 of our black kids would identify as black first and foremost anyway. It's a black kid, or BME,
00:38:07 that doesn't work. And it comes back to the narrative of the oppressor versus the victim,
00:38:14 and even that is false. If we look at our schooling system, we can collate evidence that will show
00:38:18 black African kids are excelling, they're actually doing a lot better than every other ethnicity,
00:38:23 and that Caribbean kids aren't doing so well. That is something we look at. But just to say that
00:38:27 our black kids are being held back because of white superiority or white privilege is
00:38:33 impossible for me to throw evidence in their face to prove wrong.
00:38:38 Well indeed, our kids aren't being held back. All the kids, whatever colour they are,
00:38:42 doing really well at Michaela and there's a reason for that because we teach them well I remember I
00:38:47 used to do surveys with the kids at school like not at Michaela this is over many years and
00:38:52 whenever I'd asked them what was important to them in their teachers and I'd ask them whether
00:38:57 they cared about their race and whether they cared if they were male or female and various things
00:39:02 they don't care what they care about is having a good teacher in front of them that's what kids
00:39:08 want and of course they want a good teacher what do they care whether or not the teacher's white
00:39:12 black or male or female they want to be taught well and um that is something sadly i don't think
00:39:18 is always happening in our classrooms uh and that's partly because they want to so there was
00:39:25 a big campaign for instance that in music that we ought not to be teaching mozart and we should be
00:39:30 teaching stormzy now first of all we're not teaching much much much mozart in the first
00:39:34 place and that's the thing so they say oh we're teaching all this mozart and all this classical
00:39:39 music. I only wish schools were teaching loads of classical music. And then they say, we must teach
00:39:43 Stormzy. And I think, well, the children already know Stormzy. In fact, they listen to his music
00:39:47 constantly. And if you were to hear some of the lyrics of Stormzy's music, I'm not fond of them
00:39:52 listening to Stormzy. And yet, not only do you want them listening to it, you want them being
00:39:56 taught it in schools. You know, I once, when you mentioned Beethoven earlier, I was thinking about
00:40:00 once when I gave an assembly, and I talked about how difficult it was for them growing up nowadays
00:40:06 because they are surrounded by images of, you know, women's bottoms and whatever
00:40:12 and all this kind of nonsense that you would see on, you know what I mean, in the music videos.
00:40:16 And I said, the thing is, when I was growing up, there was none of that.
00:40:20 I grew up with Kylie Minogue.
00:40:21 She was the most kind of outrageous thing.
00:40:24 And it's very different for you.
00:40:26 Anyway, I went on about Beethoven and I put up a picture of him.
00:40:29 His wig was there and everything.
00:40:30 And then I played da-da-da-da because I thought, you need to know Beethoven's fifth.
00:40:34 This is really important.
00:40:35 And why?
00:40:36 Because this is cultural knowledge, you know, if you want to exist in the Western world, if you don't know this and aren't familiar with it, but you only know Stormzy, then you're missing out on life.
00:40:47 Later when I was eating lunch with them, I realized that because I'd spoken about Kylie and Beethoven, they had assumed that they were contemporaries.
00:40:55 Now, that is how little children know.
00:40:58 And I'd even had his wig on.
00:41:00 I mean, you know, but they don't know.
00:41:03 And I think too often the public and even teachers presume that children know a lot more than they actually do.
00:41:12 And when I talk about the Western canon, I'm talking about them not knowing that Paris is the capital of France, about them not knowing.
00:41:19 I remember a teacher once telling me about how he was talking about America getting involved in the war and how difficult this was.
00:41:26 And he went on and then he came to realize they didn't really understand.
00:41:29 And then he showed them a map and then they understood because America is really far away.
00:41:33 but they didn't know you know and and and when i'm telling you basic things are not being taught in
00:41:40 our schools um except then when they are met with the kind of nonsense that you're saying you know
00:41:47 look a statue is actually the reason why you're feeling so uncomfortable in your country it's not
00:41:51 because you haven't been taught to be british and it's not because you don't actually know
00:41:54 anything about your country it's because that evil statue of a of a man who once owned slaves
00:42:00 is there and that's the problem well why wouldn't they you know focus on that
00:42:04 because they don't have enough knowledge in their heads in of history to be able
00:42:10 to critically address any of this you know the biggest revolutionary Stokely
00:42:15 Carmichael Black Panther who coined the term black power he went to a
00:42:20 traditional school Bronx high school where he was he was um he was taught
00:42:25 traditionally nelson mandela a great revolutionary was taught in a traditional fashion um my thing is
00:42:33 not because people say well you're obviously trying to create robots catherine absolutely not
00:42:37 i expect some of my my kids will become dentists sure but some of them will become revolutionaries
00:42:43 and you know why and they'll be much better than the current revolutionaries my children
00:42:47 they'll be much better because they'll know stuff and they'll be able to build arguments and i don't
00:42:51 understand why anyone would want to prevent children from accessing knowledge
00:42:55 but that's precisely what's going on I think it is sort of I would say that
00:42:59 it's not just poor teaching I do feel that there is something intentional
00:43:04 behind it I mean you know I can't help feeling that there is such a self-loathing
00:43:10 and is you know disgust to one's own history that it comes out whether they
00:43:15 like it or not absolutely and there's I'm I'm holding out some hope here we've
00:43:21 just seen in the last few days with the new director general of the BBC seemingly ushering
00:43:26 in a new age into the BBC of redressing the left-leaning imbalance there. We've seen Dominic
00:43:33 Cummings wanting to overhaul the public, the civil service. So I'm hopeful that something can be done
00:43:38 about education too over the course of the next five or maybe even ten years because it really
00:43:42 does require that sort of a long-term view over five or ten years. Now I've addressed the problem
00:43:46 of teacher training colleges. There needs to be on the primary and secondary school levels.
00:43:50 a return to a core traditional curriculum of the classics
00:43:53 and history, history, history
00:43:55 that needs to be really taught and embedded
00:43:58 because you'll be amazed
00:43:59 not even at school level
00:44:00 people in their 20s and 30s and 40s
00:44:02 who lack basic knowledge of things
00:44:04 I've even watched a quiz show with leading celebrities
00:44:07 including an academic professor
00:44:09 and they placed the English Civil War in the 19th century
00:44:13 you know, these are people who are
00:44:15 these are influencers of our society
00:44:19 and people who on Twitter have large followings
00:44:21 and everyone assumes that they have a standard of education and knowledge
00:44:24 and if you have that much ignorance there by these leaders of men and women,
00:44:28 how can we expect people on lower yet younger levels to know anything better?
00:44:33 So that's the public school system, but certainly in terms of universities too,
00:44:36 the problem came with Tony Blair creating so many polytechnics,
00:44:40 making them into these universities and we know full well now of course,
00:44:43 if you look at for example the Brexit vote,
00:44:45 those young people who didn't go to university were more likely to vote for Brexit than those
00:44:50 who went to university and people are being churned out of the education system now with
00:44:55 these degrees which have little value, these Mickey Mouse courses on gender studies and
00:45:00 every other study you can think of which were created without any scientific basis whatsoever
00:45:05 this is the time now especially now when we have Covid and everyone is looking to secure their
00:45:11 funding for the government to say if you're funding these Mickey Mouse courses you aren't
00:45:15 going to get any funding close down these these women's studies close down gender studies close
00:45:20 down these these nonsensical mickey mouse courses focus on stem cells focus on the classic core
00:45:25 curriculum and syllabuses in universities let's usher in a revolution because only only a drastic
00:45:31 policy like that will have any hope of redressing the imbalance uh you're not doing gender studies
00:45:37 i hope definitely not i'm a classicist and and i was just thinking about um catherine and both
00:45:42 Catherine and Ruth and Calvin were saying which is I think ultimately the most important thing is
00:45:47 that we should be equipping our youth with a sense of empowerment and the best way to do that I
00:45:52 believe is not to tell them that they can't achieve you know whatever in life because they're
00:45:56 women or because they're an ethnic minority but that because we live in Britain which by the way
00:46:02 is the only privilege that we should be talking about that we are able to achieve whatever we can
00:46:07 because this is a great country which offers opportunity to everyone no matter where you come
00:46:11 from um no matter your origin um or what you believe so that i think is ultimately the most
00:46:17 empowering message we can give to our youth and i'm wondering why instead everything is about you
00:46:21 know belittling you and making you think of you know if you're if you're but from a poor family
00:46:26 you'll never do this or if you're a woman then you can you can expect to be hammered by the
00:46:30 patriarchy this invisible force that well it's because of what peter was saying about the white
00:46:36 guilt. It's very hard when white people, too many of them, because obviously there are some who can
00:46:45 see past this guilt, where they feel so guilty about the history of their country and their
00:46:54 people, and I say their people in inverted commas, they have to reject it. You would never imagine
00:47:04 in Colombia during the World Cup
00:47:07 that people would be sat in a bar
00:47:09 saying, so are you supporting,
00:47:11 who are you supporting, Brazil?
00:47:12 Are you supporting England?
00:47:14 I mean, it'd be mad.
00:47:15 Everyone would be supporting Colombia.
00:47:17 The idea is absurd that anyone
00:47:19 would support anything else.
00:47:21 Whereas in England, you go into a pub,
00:47:23 you don't really know who's supporting what.
00:47:25 And I mean, there's something wrong with that.
00:47:28 Now, maybe not everywhere.
00:47:29 Certainly in London, if you go into a pub,
00:47:31 you just don't know.
00:47:33 And actually, as a white person, you feel uncomfortable expecting people to back England.
00:47:42 And you're so uncomfortable that, you know, England is the only country where we have to actually write England on our flag.
00:47:49 I mean, it's mad.
00:47:52 It comes way back, doesn't it, to, he's been done to death with this quote, really, but George Orwell famously said,
00:47:59 You know, England's intellectuals are the only ones who basically are ashamed of their own nationality.
00:48:06 And I think that that, we're talking about intellectuals, but that goes right the way down to society,
00:48:12 particularly now that that class has sort of expanded.
00:48:15 So it's gone through the universities and the schools.
00:48:18 And frankly, you know, unless we shake it off somehow, I think, well, frankly, I don't know what will happen.
00:48:24 But I think that's what we're going to do.
00:48:26 Well, but the only, it is very, it's deeply embedded.
00:48:30 And white people, many white people, I think, are responsible for this because they are so guilty.
00:48:35 Now, somehow we need to explain, what I'm always trying to explain is that guilt doesn't help anyone.
00:48:40 If you want to help these poor black children, you want to help anyone,
00:48:46 if you're guilty, it prevents you from being honest and decent and sensible
00:48:52 and having the right kinds of goals for these children.
00:48:54 because ultimately everything that motivates you is about alleviating your guilt so you do things
00:49:01 just to make yourself feel better about who you are as opposed to doing what's right for those
00:49:05 children um so in a school environment you don't want to give them detentions because you feel bad
00:49:11 because you think but i don't know what it's like to be poor i don't know what it's like to be black
00:49:15 maybe he didn't do his homework because it's hard for him at home i'm a white privileged person and
00:49:20 And I don't want to hold him to the standards that would mean that he'd do his homework.
00:49:23 But if you don't get him to do his homework, that child will fall behind.
00:49:27 So your guilt is actually hurting them.
00:49:30 And somehow we need to persuade white people of this so that they can abandon that guilt.
00:49:34 Well, also just simply from what you're saying there, just not to be so damn narcissistic, actually.
00:49:40 You know, and think all the time of how they feel.
00:49:43 Well, I think that's it actually for this week.
00:49:46 Great conversation, I think you'd agree.
00:49:48 thank you very much to Calvin, to Catherine, to Alice and of course to Rafe. I hope you
00:49:56 enjoyed the show and that you watch next time so in the meantime as well do
00:50:02 remember to look at our website for our new campaign saveourstatues.org.uk
00:50:08 it's great the number of people who've signed up to it and shown their support
00:50:12 already so I hope you continue to do that won't you and also subscribe to the
00:50:17 channel. Thank you very much. See you.