New Culture Forum - May 04, 2021


Have The Police Lost Common Sense? The Politicisation Of Policing In The UK.

Dr David Starkey: I Was Cancelled But I Wont Be Silenced For Speaking Objective Truth School Chaplain Reported To Terrorist Watchdog For LGBT Policy Sermon

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

175.64

Word count

7,482

Sentence count

122

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I am Peter Whittle. Now last week the Home
00:00:18 Secretary Priti Patel declared that so-called non-crime hate incidents should no longer be
00:00:27 recorded by the police. Now this comes after a period when people's confidence
00:00:33 in the police and indeed the role of the police has been a matter of controversy
00:00:37 whether it's about hate crime or indeed whether it's about the way in which
00:00:42 various different protests have been policed over the past year. There does
00:00:48 seem to be a crisis of confidence, public confidence in the police. We're going to
00:00:53 discussing this today and i'm very very pleased that we have the guests that we have today
00:00:59 harry miller who has been on the channel before he is a former police officer won a landmark case
00:01:05 against homicide police and he is part of the campaign we are fair cop and the ncf's own
00:01:14 historian and commentator rave hadelman koo can i start with asking you actually harry uh you
00:01:20 You obviously were on our channel some time ago, and there was an incident which became very famous, actually.
00:01:27 You took the police to court. They came to you and said, we need to check your thinking.
00:01:32 This was about something which, in fact, you had just, I think you just liked on Twitter.
00:01:37 But in that context, what is the significance of what Priti Patel has announced and what is the status of it?
00:01:45 okay so in 2019 humberside police said to police officer to my place of work to check my thinking
00:01:51 as a result of tweeting things which um somebody somewhere didn't like um we battled it out with
00:01:58 humberside and ended up at the high at the high courts um in judicial review now humberside police
00:02:03 claimed right the way through that they had they had approached me and recorded me for non-crime
00:02:08 hate instance because they were following the guidance laid out by the college of policing
00:02:12 and what's interesting is that the college of policing didn't argue the college of policing
00:02:17 put no distance at all between their guidance and humberside's interpretation of the guidance
00:02:24 none whatsoever um so we found it very strange when the the courts the high court ruled that
00:02:31 the guidance itself was legal but following the guidance was illegal we said that was fundamentally
00:02:37 irrational um and as a result we we were back at the court of appeal last well in march
00:02:44 against the college of policing and uh we're now in the position where we're waiting we're
00:02:50 waiting a ruling now priti patel the home secretary is the sole shareholder and owner
00:02:57 of the college of policing because the college of policing is a private limited company set up i
00:03:02 think in around about 2012 and um it's it's a its role is nominally to be the professional body
00:03:10 for the police service of england and wales so we have this bizarre situation now where the owner
00:03:16 of the college of policing has come out before the ruling and said that she wants to get rid of
00:03:26 non-crime hate incidents and and abolish the 120 000 non-crime hate incidents that have been
00:03:33 recorded against they're not all against me but against me and i'm assuming 120 odd thousand others
00:03:39 so it it's quite it's quite odd and that she has pre-empted uh the ruling and has pre-empted it
00:03:47 in our favour. How would you describe most simply what a non-crime hate incident is?
00:03:58 Yeah a non-crime hate incident is any incident which falls short of being a crime but is
00:04:07 nevertheless perceived by somebody as being an incident inspired by hatred. Now what's worrying
00:04:15 about that is that one there doesn't need to be an incident okay when you think about of an
00:04:21 incident you naturally think of some argy-bargy or something or other in my case and in many cases
00:04:29 there was no incident all there was was me expressing a view yeah and i expressed a view
00:04:36 around reforms proposed reforms to the gender recognition act which in fact the government
00:04:42 had asked for so some of the things that i tweeted were for instance who won the 1976
00:04:50 men's decathlon at the olympics well the answer is bruce jenner but because he's now
00:04:56 caitlin jenner this was perceived as being having a go at trans people simply asking question was
00:05:04 recorded as being indicative of hate and that hate was indicative of future criminality on my part
00:05:14 so humberside police following the college of policing guidelines took the view that it was
00:05:20 it was necessary intervention in other words that unless they came and challenged my thinking
00:05:25 that it would likely escalate into some form of criminality so that's what a non-crime hate
00:05:33 incident is but again crucially it's all down to perception so if somebody simply perceives
00:05:40 that i'm motivated by hatred that's all the police need they don't need any evidence whatsoever in
00:05:47 fact the college of policing guidance says no heavy no evidence of hate is required
00:05:53 this is extraordinary isn't it rave i mean basically no evidence this is i think makes
00:05:59 it unique in english law actually there is no evidence required for this just subjective
00:06:05 perception exactly it's the latest attack the other one of course famously now is the lack of
00:06:10 mens rea one doesn't need to actually have any intent now to be convicted of many of these sorts
00:06:16 of hate crimes which is goes against every aspect of the common law tradition and harry's completely
00:06:21 right in everything he says now some people obviously are welcoming priti patel finally
00:06:25 taking a stance on such an issue but it's risible that it's taken 10 years for a conservative
00:06:31 government to actually get its house in order and at least try to address this in some capacity
00:06:36 and the problem is the college of policing which quite rightly was said is a private company and
00:06:41 the plan still seems to be as far as i'm aware that the government tends to turn this into an
00:06:46 independent statutory body which will have even more authority and power and be more difficult
00:06:51 to control and this is a body which is not enforcing legislation this is guidance which
00:06:56 is severely lobbied by pressure groups like Stonewall and others who are influencing the
00:07:01 College of Policing who are together creating this guidance which is then enforced and you
00:07:06 have this bizarre situation where the courts are supporting a lobbied guidance as if it were law
00:07:13 and that seems to me to be a major problem here. I mean it's the College of Policing that
00:07:17 would classify anybody who complained about a tweet from Harry
00:07:22 as being the victim, irrespective of where they lived in the world.
00:07:25 And Harry is the suspect, automatically criminalising individuals.
00:07:29 It's the College of Policing that really is at the heart of all of this.
00:07:32 And I would much rather see Pritchett Patel
00:07:34 tackling the College of Policing on this point.
00:07:38 Yes. It is a sort of...
00:07:40 The College of Policing, a private company.
00:07:43 But who are these people, actually, Harry?
00:07:46 you know who who technically how many what it who is it oh we know we know how many because one of
00:07:53 the great things about it being a private company is that its accounts are downloadable at companies
00:07:59 house yeah and we did that a few weeks ago and it's it's incredible the first thing that strikes
00:08:04 you is that most company accounts are about nine or ten pages long there's a little bit of preamble
00:08:09 then there's the numbers and a conclusion and that's it theirs is 100 pages long and the figures
00:08:15 are buried deep deep deep within it i'm not surprised because it turns out that they do i
00:08:21 don't know i think it's if i remember rightly about 10 million pounds worth of actual work
00:08:25 in other words invoiced work providing training setting exams etc but they've got costs of over
00:08:31 50 million they've got a wage bill of 38 million and they've got 650 employees now if you do the
00:08:41 maths that works out at accrued average the 56 000 pounds per employee now the average wage of a
00:08:49 of a constable in this country is around about 28 000 so for every one college of policing employee
00:08:55 you could have two police constables but and what do they do we've absolutely no idea what they do
00:09:02 i call them a hate factory the national hate factory because it seems to me that the only
00:09:07 thing that they do is think up new more numerous ways of generating hate they set they set courses
00:09:16 for police officers and police officers then go out and tell people how to recognize hate
00:09:23 and hate is defined bizarrely again as antagonism unfriendliness dislike ill will in other words
00:09:35 everyday human emotions have been classified by these lunatics at the college of policing
00:09:42 as being hateful as being hostility and then from that position they say that if you express
00:09:48 anything and anybody thinks that you're motivated by ill will dislike you know antagonism yeah then
00:09:55 that classes as hate and therefore there is a justification to send a police officer to your
00:10:01 door or at the very least to record you on a database of hate we say that is fundamentally
00:10:07 wrong it's evil it is undemocratic we live in a democracy and our democracy is predicated
00:10:14 on the notion of antagonism you have an idea i don't like it we have a stand-up row or a sit-down
00:10:20 row and we eventually work it out well under the college of policing guidance the antagonism
00:10:25 that is just a natural process of disagreement and is to be celebrated in a democracy
00:10:31 has been de facto criminalised.
00:10:34 There's a problem also that the idea that things are going to get any better
00:10:39 is for the birds unless the government takes steps here
00:10:41 because the College of Policing has now made it a requirement
00:10:44 as of last year for all future police to have a university degree.
00:10:48 It's a prerequisite and a requirement.
00:10:51 Now at the current time there's a hope at least
00:10:53 or a thinking that the majority of police have enough common sense
00:10:57 to know that a lot of the nonsense they hear from their executive
00:11:00 and their elites is complete nonsense.
00:11:04 Once you've got generation after generation
00:11:06 coming up through the university system,
00:11:08 being indoctrinated by the College of Policing's courses,
00:11:11 as you've seen in our universities as well,
00:11:13 you can only see this problem growing exponentially.
00:11:16 It's a huge problem arising
00:11:17 unless this government takes it into hand.
00:11:21 I think this is, yes, exactly.
00:11:22 The point you make as well about what hate means,
00:11:26 or they have widened it.
00:11:28 It's basically widening, isn't it?
00:11:30 As you say, now it's sort of dislike and everything.
00:11:33 But the point is, surely this is a problem of the legal system,
00:11:38 not specifically the police, is it not?
00:11:40 I mean, it's Parliament and it's the legal system that enshrines hate laws.
00:11:46 The police presumably just have to enforce them.
00:11:49 Well, no, that's not true, is it?
00:11:51 Because we don't really have hate laws in this country.
00:11:54 what we have at the moment is an uplift at sentencing if it can be shown that a criminal
00:12:01 action was motivated by hatred towards a particular group and i think that whilst it's it's it's
00:12:09 problematic i can see the sense in it for instance if i were to attack attack somebody who is a jew
00:12:16 and thump them in the face then that's terrible on a personal level for them if i attack them
00:12:23 because they are a jew or because they are a muslim or because they are a woman and and if 0.52
00:12:29 the purpose is not only to hurt them but to send a message throughout their entire community that
00:12:36 because of your protect because of your characteristic it could be you then i can see
00:12:41 i can see some sense in uplifting at sentence um if you're found guilty of that would you do would
00:12:50 agree with that yeah that's the solution you don't need to have hate crime laws which actually
00:12:54 identify specific groups because once you start to identify specific groups you've left out other
00:12:59 groups who will then feel as if they're being hard done by for example take the situation of
00:13:04 a jew walking down the street who's punched because he's a jew and then there's a fat kid
00:13:08 or ginger kid who's packed who's punched because he's a fat kid or ginger kid now both get severe 0.70
00:13:13 injuries identical injuries how would you think that this chap would feel knowing that this person
00:13:18 got more of a that the culprit got more of a sentence because of the fact this person was
00:13:22 jewish rather than doing that the old traditional way this goes back you know 60 years when there
00:13:27 was there were four teddy boys in notting hill who attacked any black person that they saw
00:13:33 and the judge at the time said you are free to think whatever you want you are free to say
00:13:38 whatever you want you are free to get enraged inside but once you act upon that then you will
00:13:44 have aggravating sentences put onto you and so you don't need to identify groups you can just
00:13:49 say at the time of sentencing and put that upswing in there and so there are aggravating causes here
00:13:54 whether you are fat or ginger or a jew is irrespective of that i think the problem is
00:13:59 though surely is that you know you say that you can see a logic in that situation you know that
00:14:04 but uh isn't the whole problem with this is that it's entirely on the perception of the supposed
00:14:11 victim. I mean, you know, that one surely could have, you know, what you are, what you would
00:14:17 prefer, i.e. that, you know, that there is a situation where you're punching a Jewish person 0.69
00:14:22 because they're Jewish or whatever, but it's entirely, the whole problem seems to rise,
00:14:26 it's entirely on the perception of that person. Well, I think that what we need to have is that
00:14:31 the burden of proof remains with the state, that there remains a presumption of innocence, 0.93
00:14:37 and even if you're found guilty of a crime against person a against person b who happens to be jewish
00:14:43 or muslim or what have you i think i think that you're still required to then prove that in that
00:14:50 attack there was meant to be a wider chilling effect before you're justified in an uplift of
00:14:56 sentence now it's quite a hard it's quite a high bar to reach but that's for the state to sort out
00:15:03 I don't think we can drop our standards and just simply go with perception when we start sentencing people.
00:15:11 Do you think there's a general problem with the whole notion of policing by consent, which is how we do it?
00:15:20 This is going right back to Robert Peel, isn't it?
00:15:24 Do you think we still have policing by consent?
00:15:26 Well, this is actually the fundamental issue, isn't it?
00:15:30 because the public pay the wages of the police.
00:15:34 Our police force is very different to many of the forces you see in Europe,
00:15:37 which are paramilitary forces.
00:15:39 If you go to Italy and elsewhere, if you go to the French,
00:15:42 you have two police forces.
00:15:43 One is a paramilitary force.
00:15:44 Our police force are traditionally citizens in uniform.
00:15:48 And the whole principle there is that they are enforcing laws without fear or favor.
00:15:54 It was the fifth rule of Sir Robert Peel's policing
00:15:57 was that you apply the law equally and impartially to everybody there.
00:16:01 And when they see things like this, when they see things like protests,
00:16:05 the double standards of multi-tiered policing,
00:16:09 it offends that idea of natural justice.
00:16:11 It offends that idea of fairness.
00:16:14 And we've come a long way from Dixon of Dog Green.
00:16:17 Older fewers may remember the old policeman in the 60s bicycling.
00:16:21 The local constabulary had control of deciding what to do,
00:16:24 whether you get a clip around the ear roll or whether you get a night at night behind bars
00:16:28 that's all gone now and what people are seeing is in many respects it's because of the human
00:16:33 rights act the human rights act incorporated the european convention into it and still remains part
00:16:38 of our law now which gives for example the police a lot of leeway in deciding whether or not to get
00:16:44 involved in certain protests and once you start doing that you're politicizing an institution
00:16:49 and once you politicize an institution you immediately divide the population and once
00:16:54 divide the population you dissolve those two fundamental pillars trust and legitimacy because
00:17:00 the public need to be assured that what's being done is lawful just and is necessary and in terms
00:17:07 of things like the hate crime incidents there's no concept of that whatsoever i could critique
00:17:12 the person living next to me on twitter and say look at the this messy bug is junk in his front 0.97
00:17:17 garden yeah and because he's chinese the person across the street could report me for having
00:17:22 been committed to hate crime. I may never have seen the person in my life. Now that offends 0.52
00:17:26 people. And that's why you're seeing policing at a very low level. Because as I said, at the end
00:17:30 of the day, what do we want? The British public know all of this is nonsense. The British public
00:17:34 wants policemen to catch burglars, to catch robbers, put them in jail, and if their car is
00:17:40 stolen, to get their car back, rather than not investigating. Whereas you have a 97% chance
00:17:45 of getting away with burglary if you commit it. With robbery, it's around 97% or 96%. You've got
00:17:51 a two percent chance of getting your car back or seeing someone prosecuted for stealing your car
00:17:55 and yet the college of policing has identified social media posts as a priority when you've had
00:18:01 you know close to 100 000 or 120 000 hate crime incidents at the same time that violent crime is
00:18:07 increasing and of course the public are looking at this and thinking something is rotten well
00:18:12 you mentioned there actually this uh selective policing issue which i think is really you know
00:18:18 sort of basically concentrated a lot of people's minds is something I've gone on about in London
00:18:23 Assembly. But broadly speaking, would you, Harry, agree with, is it just a, is it an incorrect
00:18:31 perception or are people right to believe that certain protests seem to be tolerated or treated
00:18:40 in a certain way as opposed to others? Well, actually, the sniff test is not whether they
00:18:47 were the sniff test is whether it looks like they were because the college of policing well not the
00:18:52 college policing guidelines the code of ethics states that policemen should not get involved
00:18:57 in politics nor give the impression of being involved in politics now i think they give the
00:19:03 impression of being involved in politics all the time now one of the problems that we have
00:19:07 is i think it's prior to 2002 a new constable would take the oath of attestation and they
00:19:14 would swear to the queen to uphold the law since 2002 they swear to uphold the law and human rights
00:19:21 what does that mean because the only human rights that a police officer should be enforcing
00:19:26 are those that have been adopted by law and so we have this bizarre situation where all you need to
00:19:33 do with a protest is call it a human rights issue and you've already got the police half on side
00:19:38 because they have they have committed they've sworn to the queen to uphold human rights
00:19:44 So there isn't an objective standard anymore.
00:19:47 There's law and human rights.
00:19:49 So, but that's what you just said,
00:19:50 that these were incorporated, actually,
00:19:53 that the Human Rights Act.
00:19:54 Under the Human Rights Act.
00:19:55 But as I said, in terms of protests,
00:19:57 police superintendents and so forth,
00:19:59 now under the Human Rights Act,
00:20:01 because of the,
00:20:01 it's not stated specifically in the legislation,
00:20:04 but through court rulings,
00:20:05 they now have this ability,
00:20:06 they can decide whether or not
00:20:09 they want to intervene in a protest.
00:20:11 And it's a personal subjective choice of theirs.
00:20:13 so if they'd like a protest then then you saw this in ed in cambridge when you had extinction
00:20:18 rebellion blocking highways the police there said well yes they have actually blocked the highway
00:20:22 this isn't a criminal act but they're not causing any it's a peaceful protest now why are they
00:20:27 making the subjective choice when you see what they're doing for example to the anti-lockdown
00:20:31 protesters or when you see when you see uh what they did in clapham with the sarah everard vigil
00:20:36 and then again with edward coolston in bristol you had the police standing by
00:20:40 as the statue was toppled a clear act of criminal damage and yet choosing not now those are decisions
00:20:45 made because of the human rights act but i would say there's the human rights there's the there
00:20:51 are human rights which are incorporated into law and there are human rights which are just tagged
00:20:57 as human rights so you see you see the police saying trans rights are human rights black lives
00:21:03 are human rights extinct the human the extinction rebellion thing is a human right matter so you
00:21:10 it's very easy to tag human rights onto a protest or an action that's not embodied in law and
00:21:18 suddenly you have a police force that feels as though it's doing its duty by supporting this
00:21:23 cause or that cause even though there is no basis for it in law that that's the problem so for me
00:21:30 i would abolish absolutely abolish that aspect of of the oath of attestation for me the litmus test
00:21:37 is this i said do we know what the queen thinks about a subject and if we don't know what her
00:21:43 majesty thinks about a subject we don't need to know what a chief constable thinks about a subject
00:21:48 okay that's that's the test and that's why every officer swears to the queen because it's to do
00:21:56 with the separation of powers and if lizzie if we don't know what lizzie thinks then we don't know
00:22:01 what we don't need to know what the police think it needs to be as bland and as neutral as that
00:22:07 that's an important point yeah sorry in which case it's sort of diverged about as far as it can
00:22:12 diverge isn't it the army and the police are servants of the crown of her majesty the queen
00:22:16 right it's the prime minister has no control they're not loyal to the prime minister or to
00:22:20 the government of the time but what's happened is not only is everything that harry said correct
00:22:25 but also you have government targets now influencing police decisions.
00:22:28 And the police, rather than protecting the individuals,
00:22:33 they're now trying to placate special interest groups
00:22:35 and meet government targets and government priorities,
00:22:38 which are often at odds with the will of the British public.
00:22:41 And so we know from all the polls that Black Lives Matter is not popular in the country. 1.00
00:22:45 We know from the polls that transgender rights and being an infringement on women's rights
00:22:50 is a hot topic, which the majority of the public are uncomfortable with.
00:22:53 and yet the police are deliberately going against the public vein
00:22:57 and that of course erodes public consent.
00:23:00 Do you actually think therefore, I mean you said the perception is all important
00:23:03 and I would agree with you, do you think, do you agree that if you take two examples
00:23:08 the Cenotaph where for example Extinction Rebellion on Remembrance Day
00:23:14 managed to get right there and stand there for about between 10 and 20 minutes
00:23:20 something like that and yet only the week after i believe it was for memory serves me uh there was
00:23:27 a woman who was an anti-lockdown protester outside parliament she was bundled unceremoniously into
00:23:33 the back of the van and the mp i think it might have been charles walker uh made a big deal about
00:23:38 in in sir charles walker in parliament now to me i'm sorry that's quite clear they're both in the
00:23:45 same as it were area yeah those were two different forms of policing would you agree with that
00:23:51 absolutely absolutely and it looks political because it is political yeah and what they say
00:23:58 is that no we were we were just simply making operational decisions well that will wash now
00:24:04 and again that will wash now and again but when consistently your operational decisions seem to
00:24:10 favor one group over another yeah then it no longer passes the sniff test it doesn't and that's
00:24:16 why pccs i think it's incumbent on pccs to haul in their chief constables and say no more matey i am
00:24:24 you are serving the public your locus of control is the law and the public not pretty patel not
00:24:31 stonewall not anybody it's the law and it's the public and unless you shape up you're getting
00:24:38 sacked the people are going to sack you this doesn't actually seem to happen though does it
00:24:42 because i mean you know people can see this is sort of very very clearly and i think a lot of
00:24:48 people you know particularly when it comes to the demonstrations they were just horrified to see
00:24:54 policemen taking the knee i mean you presumably think they were wrong to take the knee do you
00:24:59 well for the very same reason that harry explained the queen never takes an opinion and the entire
00:25:06 nation can then support the queen for that once you have a political stance you immediately divide
00:25:11 the public and the police must never be divisive the police are there for everybody to feel as if
00:25:15 they are their champion when they need them and as soon as you take a position on anything
00:25:20 you immediately alienate people and that is the most damaging thing you can do
00:25:24 and of course you know the monarchy and the police were traditionally two of the greatest
00:25:29 institutions that we had in this country the police were renowned around the world as being
00:25:33 the best in the world if you were a british bobby you know the night mess scenario was you had a
00:25:37 german policeman and a british cook and you know the ideal european union um but you know having
00:25:42 having a british policeman was you know that was was the sort of the golden ticket to policing
00:25:47 and we founded the police force around the world for example i think the thing is when you mentioned
00:25:53 edward coulson you know the when the statue went in i was personally horrified to see and i can't
00:25:58 remember his name but the quite senior guy who sort of stood by and said we decided that this
00:26:03 was the best course of action right again you sort of say an operational thing maybe but in fact
00:26:10 his whole demeanor and manner suggested sympathy with what was going on you know this this guy and
00:26:18 this was you one was appalled by this actually it's almost that they were sort of letting and
00:26:24 helping it happen you know and i think this is people can't quite work out this is the police
00:26:30 you're meant to actually be totally you know defending our public monuments you know i'm
00:26:36 a big fan of les miserables and um in les miserables i i'm i'm always rather keen on the
00:26:45 the character of javert the the police officer because he doesn't let emotion overwhelm him
00:26:51 unless until the very end when he sort of throws himself off a bridge uh but he he's dedicated to
00:26:57 upholding the law and that guy stole some bread it's against the law and i'm going to track him
00:27:04 down that's it i'm tracking it down because i'm not this is not personal this is the law this is
00:27:09 the law and quite frankly we want a few more police officers like that yeah who are dispassionate
00:27:15 we need to send them all to lay shut down the college of policing send them all to see les
00:27:19 miserable and then have them back for a seminar and tell them how policing should be that's what 0.82
00:27:24 we need to do well as it stands at the moment the the most common thing i hear when i was on the
00:27:30 assembly the same thing was oh well it's the top brass the ordinary guys on the beat if there is a
00:27:37 you know are not like this they're as demoralized as anybody i'm not sure whether that i i would go
00:27:44 along with that? I still think it's the case for a large portion but I think the segment who have
00:27:50 common sense let's put it that way is getting smaller and smaller as time goes on and I go
00:27:55 back to my earlier point that once the College of Policing has said that you have to have a
00:27:58 university degree you're drawing your talent from an entirely different pool and you're drawing your
00:28:03 talent from a group of people who have been through yet another one of these indoctrination
00:28:07 camps essentially I mean that's what we're dealing with let's be honest about it and so the final
00:28:11 end product is very different from the policemen of 20 years ago i mean i can only imagine you know
00:28:16 regan from the sweeney having a look at today's police force and seeing and seeing it as it is
00:28:21 and it's you know and as i said it's the college of policing is is the problem here and to continue
00:28:28 to have them creating the training programs creating the guidance i mean you know you might
00:28:33 as well ask gary glitter to write safeguarding for primary schools i mean that's that that's
00:28:37 basically what we're dealing with at this time you know no no i i agree it's quite interesting
00:28:42 though because i think the the whole push to recruit university graduates is because they
00:28:46 want the opposites of critical thinkers they want people who have the very opposites of common sense
00:28:51 um and i know this because after the after the um as we were prodding and poking the uh the cadaver
00:28:58 of humberside's failed defense i had coffee with the uh the chief constable of humberside and said
00:29:03 you know he's a good cop local cop rose through the ranks locally great fella in so many ways i
00:29:09 said luckily i kind of get why one over enthusiastic constable got it wrong i get that
00:29:17 what i don't understand is as this rose up through the ranks and it became a source of national and
00:29:23 international outrage why did a more senior officer not step in and apply some common sense
00:29:29 and the chief constable looked me square in the eye and he said harry you've got to understand
00:29:36 common sense is not an appropriate tool for a police officer because common sense leads to
00:29:42 unpredictable outcomes what we need is more guidance i couldn't i could not believe that
00:29:49 he said that without any sense of irony at all bearing in mind following the guidance for him
00:29:56 had resulted in his force being likened to the gestapo i said to him i said but lee that doesn't
00:30:04 make sense most normal people don't need guidance not to behave like the stasi the checker and and
00:30:11 the gestapo and here you are wanting more and eschewing common sense it makes it makes no sense 0.64
00:30:18 it makes no sense at all that's that's a fundamentally shocking thing to hear you know
00:30:22 that the police believe that they are incapable of applying common sense without guidance, you know.
00:30:26 And traditionally, local constabulary were independents, and common sense was their bread and butter.
00:30:31 That's how they went about their daily duties.
00:30:34 Well, the thing is, the whole of British law is predicated on common sense.
00:30:39 Because common law is predicated on common sense, where the state trusts us to do and say what we will,
00:30:48 up until the point that they specifically say this far and no further.
00:30:51 we're not like the napoleonic roman countries where they dictate what we can do we're free to
00:30:57 do free to say free to think right up until a specific point so the very idea that common law 0.97
00:31:03 is not appropriate when our entire nation is built upon the notion of common sense
00:31:09 is ridiculous and it's causing an absolute schism in society and it's creating a police force which
00:31:17 is becoming simply a servant
00:31:19 on who can write the law of disguidance.
00:31:22 That is not what policing is about.
00:31:24 And of course, in the common law,
00:31:25 the idea that the common law has no place for common sense
00:31:27 is ridiculous. It's the reasonable man.
00:31:29 It's the man on the bus.
00:31:32 Applying common sense
00:31:33 rules, or you can call it natural justice.
00:31:36 And when you see things like hate crime
00:31:37 incidents, you know that there's no natural justice.
00:31:40 You know that there's common sense.
00:31:41 And it beggars belief that the police
00:31:43 force don't see this,
00:31:45 or don't see how it's unjust, or don't see how damaging it is.
00:31:48 For me, I had seen the long litany of police misconduct and incompetence over the years.
00:31:55 But it was in 2018 when I saw the police doing it to themselves in the most jaw-dropping manner
00:32:01 when a police superintendent in charge of anti-corruption was delivering a talk to his crew
00:32:08 and told them, being in anti-corruption, they needed to be whiter than white.
00:32:12 and he was suspended for making a racist remark.
00:32:16 Now, anybody in their right mind knows
00:32:18 whiter than white is sort of a Daz Purcell commercial,
00:32:20 you know, with Danny, whatever his name is, you know.
00:32:23 And here was this man who actually had to go off
00:32:26 and have his career sullied for God knows how long
00:32:28 while he did an investigation. 0.99
00:32:30 And then you had this black woman 0.98
00:32:32 who had over 30 years experience in the police. 0.69
00:32:35 Her sister was concerned about a viral video
00:32:39 showing indecent images 0.92
00:32:40 and she wanted the perpetrator who created it to be arrested.
00:32:43 So she forwarded it to her sister.
00:32:45 Her sister didn't request this video.
00:32:47 Her sister didn't even open it. 0.74
00:32:49 And she was arrested and convicted and ended up with a criminal record, 0.62
00:32:53 had to do a couple of hundred hours of community service 0.89
00:32:55 for being in possession of an indecent image. 0.99
00:32:58 This is a senior black woman in the police force.
00:33:01 The problem really, surely, is in this country, as opposed to Europe,
00:33:09 there was always this idea that the police had somehow come out of you know ordinary people
00:33:14 sort of working class if you like working class uh that's why they've always had a different
00:33:19 it's been very top down uh in in europe that is something i feel is not the case anymore i mean
00:33:26 you know whether it's because of university degrees or whatever it is or whether they're
00:33:30 more middle class or whatever there is this sort of a feeling that somehow i don't for example feel
00:33:35 anymore that the police are on my side particularly I don't personally feel it I mean would you say
00:33:43 that the police are the run of the mill police are different to when you were in the force hang
00:33:52 oh absolutely because back in the day you would be trusted to go out and you know patrol your
00:34:00 beat and deal with things in a common sense manner but i would blame tony blair for a lot of this
00:34:06 because introducing sort of blair blairite managerialism into absolutely every area of
00:34:12 society it's no good anymore to simply you know come across an altercation and um sort it out
00:34:20 there and then on the street and then write in your notebooks two people were given advice that's
00:34:25 because you can't account for that it doesn't fit into a statistic so now we have the ridiculous
00:34:30 situation where in that situation given exactly the same situation the police would have to do
00:34:36 something make an arrest create generated non-crime hate incident do something to to show
00:34:43 what they had done in that time because simply trusting them to write it in their notebook
00:34:48 doesn't cut the mustard anymore no no doesn't cut the mustard anymore i was chatting to alan
00:34:52 Robinson from Thames Valley yesterday he was standing for PCC 25 years service and he said
00:34:58 he finally gave up gave up the ghost with policing when he went to attend a couple two blokes who
00:35:06 were having a bit of an altercation on the street and he said back in 1991 or whenever it was
00:35:11 whenever he'd simply done that offer them advice 20 minutes advice they would have both gone away
00:35:16 with a flea in the rear and that would have been it not allowed to do that anymore because it
00:35:21 doesn't generate a statistic so i said how much time did you spend in total dealing with that
00:35:26 incident they said well it was five hours of his time and because they had to drive somewhere
00:35:30 it was three hours of another officer's time so something that should have been sorted in 20
00:35:34 minutes took over eight hours and left somebody with a criminal record that is absolute nonsense
00:35:43 and what the college of policing are insisting is having a bunch of policing robots robocops
00:35:50 who will come in and simply unthinkingly uncritically apply guidance that's why we say
00:35:58 it's fundamentally un-british guidance as far as i'm concerned is un-british and we also can't
00:36:05 underestimate the impact that the mcpherson report into the stephen lawrence inquiry just about to
00:36:10 ask you that well in 1999 the report came out now undeniably there were racist elements within the
00:36:17 police force and within society at large. Britain is a much more different place today than it was
00:36:22 back then. And so there needed to be issues addressed. There needed to be some sort of
00:36:27 change or transformation to take place within the police force. But the way in which the police
00:36:31 have reacted in subsequent years has been so far to the extreme that it goes beyond any idea of
00:36:39 proportionality at all. And there's this idea now where as soon as you make a complaint, you are
00:36:44 automatically a victim it's this idea of victimhood that seeped into the police force as well
00:36:48 and and wanting to be seen to be open and inclusive has become such a mantra that you do
00:36:55 have these these robocops who are enforcing guidance without any idea of common sense and
00:37:00 who do want to wear the lanyard of pride or wear or take the knee to black lives matter or indeed
00:37:06 to um to go after anybody who was accused of paedophilia with operation u-tree or we saw with
00:37:11 the collapsed Westminster pedophile ring
00:37:13 where you had nonsensical accusations
00:37:15 being followed up as if they were gospel
00:37:18 when it was patently clear to anybody
00:37:20 who heard the allegations that had been made about Edward Heath
00:37:24 were obviously fake and false
00:37:26 and the product of a diseased mind to the police.
00:37:30 These were, you know, arguments which had credence.
00:37:32 These were accusations that needed to be followed up on.
00:37:35 And that's because of this blinkered, brainwashed thinking.
00:37:38 And it's actually quite scary to me
00:37:40 to think that the police of our country actually hold these views
00:37:44 or believe that their conduct in all of these cases
00:37:46 is something that they don't need to apologise for.
00:37:49 With that Stephen Lawrence example, to me that is overpowering.
00:37:56 That charged institutionalised racism,
00:37:59 which we'd never heard actually up until that point about anything,
00:38:03 it seems to me that the police's history since then
00:38:06 is just characterised by a desire to move as far away from that as possible.
00:38:12 That the damage done to general morale was extraordinary then.
00:38:17 Would you agree with that?
00:38:18 Well, it's a false reading of the Macpherson report.
00:38:24 It's a willfully false reading because what Macpherson was saying
00:38:28 is that culturally the police viewed at the time the black community
00:38:33 either as perpetrators of crime or complicit in their own victimhood and what what mcpherson said
00:38:41 was that you police officers you need to hold up a mirror to your own attitudes and that's a good
00:38:46 thing but of course what the police have done rather than holding up a mirror to their own
00:38:49 attitudes they've simply held up a mirror to our attitudes they've deflected it entirely
00:38:54 and when where mcpherson was asking them to check their thinking they've just twisted it
00:39:01 to check our thinking it's a complete and utter perversion of what McPherson meant
00:39:07 and when McPherson said police officers you need to believe reports without evidence what he meant
00:39:14 was when a black community leader says look mate we're getting a lot of problem from this gang or
00:39:19 that people or what have you we've been ignored by the police what you can't do is go well unless
00:39:24 you can provide me with the proof we're not going to take any notice of you that's what McPherson
00:39:29 and meant but we've corrupted it to this idea that anything that any perception that anybody has
00:39:36 must be believed except even that's not true because again it's all perceptions are equal
00:39:43 but some perceptions are more equal than others you know my perception isn't counted for nothing
00:39:48 it doesn't count at all when i when i write to the police and say you carrying that lanyard on
00:39:54 your uniform or flying that flag that offends me then i'm dismissed my perception is simply
00:40:00 dismissed but when i when i make a tweet uh in favor of women or in favor of keeping the gra as
00:40:08 it is then the the person perceiving me as a hater that's taken as gospel by the police so
00:40:15 this is this is where we're at and it's entirely wrong this is all because of protected characteristics
00:40:19 isn't it i mean that that's what it is well well you say protected characteristic of course the
00:40:23 the equality act 2010 names nine protected characteristics but the college of policing
00:40:29 in their wisdom have whittled that down to four protected characteristics plus one made up one
00:40:34 so we so we've got we've got gender identity as a protected characteristic or a monitored strand
00:40:41 in the college of policing guidance that has no basis in law whatsoever because the protected
00:40:46 characteristic is holding or intending to hold a gender recognition certificate so they've they've
00:40:53 they've taken it upon themselves simply to we're not bothered about them you know we'll only we'll
00:40:58 cut it down from nine to four and then add one that we've made up this is what the college of
00:41:03 policing do and that's why they need shutting down i think that there is a level of confusion
00:41:08 generally now which resulted there was a case recently just of uh it was a rainbow flag um
00:41:18 sort of billboard you know mobile mobile police billboard on the wirral yeah in the world with
00:41:25 officers around it and i think the slogan was something like being offensive is an offense or
00:41:30 something like that which is entirely wrong and they actually apologized but they the mere fact
00:41:35 that they could go out and do this was extraordinary and again peter if he was if it was a bunch of
00:41:42 you know uh pcsos had been on a community course and said okay you've got the afternoon to go and
00:41:47 put something into action and they've done that you could forgive them but there was an inspector
00:41:52 standing with them with a huge great stick by the way yes um who thought it was clearly fine
00:41:57 we don't want inspectors who think that you can parade on a 10-foot billboard and out and out lie
00:42:04 we don't want that well look uh on that note we'll have to uh end it uh thank you very very much harry
00:42:11 thank you Ralph and we see next week on counterculture but in the meantime of
00:42:19 course please remember to subscribe weren't you very simple you know you go
00:42:24 to where it says subscribe it's totally free next door there is that bell press
00:42:29 on that and you'll get notifications so I do hope you do that thank you once
00:42:33 again and see you next week. Bye.