New Culture Forum - November 01, 2020


How Significant Is The 2020 US Election & What Might A Trump Or Biden Victory Mean?

Is Government Reaction To Covid A Threat To Civil Liberties? A Price Worth Paying Or Too High? Navigating the New Political Divide - Matt Goodwin

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

180.45

Word count

7,112

Sentence count

243


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to counterculture. I am Peter Whittle. Now as we're speaking in a couple of
00:00:19 days time, in fact that's really just a matter of hours isn't it, we will know the result of the
00:00:24 2020 presidential election in the US. Now it's a bit of a cliche that every election is always the
00:00:33 most important you'll ever vote in but this time depending on who you talk to we're either going
00:00:39 to be having the salvation of western civilization or its further destruction. Now with me to discuss
00:00:47 the election and indeed the aftermath I've got a great team of guests today. First of all Tim
00:00:53 Stanley is the columnist and leader writer for the Daily Telegraph. He's also an author of a
00:00:59 number of books about American politics and culture. Sarah Elliott is head of Republicans
00:01:07 Overseas UK. Oliver Wiseman is the US editor of The Critic magazine joining us from Washington
00:01:15 and Rafe Hadle-Mancou of the New Culture Forum, historian and commentator.
00:01:22 Thank you very, very much for coming.
00:01:24 I want to start with this point that I mentioned in the introduction.
00:01:28 A few years ago, President Trump made a speech that I thought was one of his best,
00:01:33 where he said that the basic question of our time is, does the West have the will to survive?
00:01:39 so you are hearing this argument basically about all that stands between
00:01:45 us and the decline of our very civilization is Donald Trump do you have
00:01:49 any chuck with that view Tim both sides think it they're both apocalyptic
00:01:54 Trump's people say if Biden wins that's the end because not only does Trump win
00:01:58 but Kamala Harris wins and also black lives matter and the radical left Bernie
00:02:02 Sanders socialized medicine all this sort of thing but equally Biden's people
00:02:06 say, if Trump wins, then that is a damning indictment of America, and it will lose its
00:02:10 status in the world, and it will lose its moral leadership. It's really interesting
00:02:14 how both sides have ratcheted it out. You could blame that on Donald Trump, of course.
00:02:18 You could say that those speeches he gave back in 2016, they set the tone, they set
00:02:22 the stakes for the next four years. You could say that this was all coming down the track
00:02:28 a long time before Trump, and Trump was actually the person who articulated what a lot of people
00:02:32 were feeling. So both sides think it's very bad. I don't know how that'll play out, though,
00:02:37 because, of course, in the middle, there must be a significant number of independent and moderate
00:02:42 voters who don't see things in those terms. And I personally don't see things in those terms. I
00:02:46 think Western civilisation is far more capable of weathering its problems than most people give it
00:02:51 credit. And also, I don't think Donald Trump's been as apocalyptically bad a president as some
00:02:57 people seem to think and I don't think Joe Biden is as corrupt or incompetent as some people think
00:03:03 so for many people watching this election who don't feel they have a stake in that particular
00:03:07 kind of culture war it's a bit odd to see people throwing biblical amounts of mud at each other
00:03:12 do you think it's biblical Sarah? Biblical at times it does seem a bit apocalyptic especially
00:03:22 when we had 75 cities burnings after George Floyd's death and, you know, you have Republicans
00:03:30 are being shouted out of restaurants or Black Lives Matter protesters are forcing people to do
00:03:36 the fist in the public and pushing them out of restaurants. I mean, this is this is the United
00:03:41 States of America, freedom of speech, freedom of expression. And then you have this Hunter Biden
00:03:47 laptop that's appeared from the repair shop that the big tech is suppressing online and on Twitter
00:03:55 and the New York Post can't get the story out and George Stephanopoulos wouldn't even ask Joe
00:04:02 Biden about it in a town hall. You kind of wonder what world you're living in. And so I completely
00:04:09 agree with Tim that the right definitely feels that this is on the edge of fascism for the United
00:04:16 States, in a sense, but the left does as well because they have two very different and contrasting
00:04:22 visions for America. Oliver, you know, are we sounding sort of well out of sync here? I mean,
00:04:30 in the sense that you're on the ground there. We're talking about sort of, you know, very basic
00:04:36 choices that people are facing with a slightly apocalyptic air, as Sarah said. Is this something
00:04:44 that you recognize uh broadly speaking yes i mean i'm in washington dc and actually the the infamous
00:04:51 clip of the forced fists in the air was only a couple of blocks away from from my apartment so
00:04:56 so you do sort of wonder when you're out for dinner what you're going to be uh forced to do
00:05:01 uh to stay safe that evening but um slightly more seriously i think to tim tim's point about
00:05:08 um what this means for the for the voter that doesn't see it as an existential battle
00:05:13 I think that's really the key question and I think that part of the reason Trump may come
00:05:18 up unstuck on election day is because he's the candidate that seems the more online seems the
00:05:25 more obsessed with the culture war um seems the more um kind of tiring and and so on and Biden
00:05:33 whilst the left very much wants to have that fight Biden is not that type and I think that's
00:05:43 kind of his central political appeal at the moment is that he is the I don't want to have to think
00:05:47 about this everyday candidate which is quite I think quite a powerful message in a very tired
00:05:53 and sort of innovated country yes would you agree with that I mean there is a sense that Biden
00:06:01 just represents kind of what does status quo ante or what?
00:06:06 Yes, and it's for those moderate voters for whom I think there is an element of Trump fatigue
00:06:11 that's in play here, and Biden really offers an opportunity to go back to a more settled world,
00:06:17 a world of multilateral engagement, the world of Obama essentially,
00:06:22 despite the fact, of course, that given his age, if anything, there could be more unforeseen
00:06:28 turmoil ahead if he does actually become nothing more than an interim president and paving the way
00:06:34 for the vice president and a more progressive left takeover of the White House which could you
00:06:40 know intensify the cultural walls beyond belief but certainly I think the moderates aren't aren't
00:06:46 cleaving towards Trump in the way that they would have had it not been for coronavirus because the
00:06:50 economy was good if you know look back towards February right in February you had Boris Johnson
00:06:55 with a stonking majority here and you had Donald Trump in America and it looked as if
00:07:00 they were both secure for years to come and the economy was going great. You had a huge
00:07:05 amount of wage growth in the lowest elements of the American society. You had unemployment
00:07:10 at its lowest level for decades, particularly amongst blacks and ethnic minorities. On all
00:07:16 levels, it seemed as if people who were moderate could have a reason for voting for Trump and
00:07:21 And yet, because of coronavirus and because of his personality in handling coronavirus, it seems as if that's been jettisoned.
00:07:28 Isn't there this thing that one here's time and again, I saw a piece by Kate Andrews recently in Spedhead,
00:07:34 where she basically sort of almost conceded that Trump had done a lot of good things, but that she just couldn't bear him sort of thing.
00:07:40 And that's the key thing. I mean, your point about, if you take the metrics of how America was doing at the beginning of this year,
00:07:46 you'd line up all those metrics and say Trump is on for a landslide, but he still polled poorly.
00:07:51 He still had a high disapproval rate.
00:07:53 And really, since about the first week of his time in office, since the inauguration, he's been under 50 percent, 45 percent.
00:08:01 He's over 50 percent right now. He's at 52.
00:08:03 Is that Rasmussen?
00:08:04 Yes, yes.
00:08:05 And that's the thing is that that poll, some people feel, is a little skewed.
00:08:08 But either way, there is this extraordinary disconnect between the individual things upon which the voters say Trump's not that bad, particularly the economy, and then how they rate him overall.
00:08:18 And so if you have any sympathy for Trump's philosophy, it's very frustrating because some people have been waiting all their lives for a candidate like Trump, have been waiting for Trumpism, for populism, for someone who said borders matter, for someone who said the nation state's important, all these sorts of things, cut taxes, deregulate, all that sort of thing.
00:08:41 You've been waiting your whole life for someone who's a serious, philosophical conservative.
00:08:45 And then the guy who it is, is Donald Trump.
00:08:48 And he just spends four years insulting everyone, saying things which I think are racist,
00:08:52 but other people say are being interpreted as racist.
00:08:54 And he just blows this golden opportunity.
00:08:58 But, Sarah, would you say to the idea that Trump is a sort of street fighter and we need a street fighter?
00:09:06 Yeah, exactly.
00:09:07 I mean, for the first time, not only did conservatives have actual conservatism in the White House,
00:09:13 where he marshaled all the conservative think tanks and heads that have been waiting since the Reagan years
00:09:20 to come back to the White House to implement this agenda,
00:09:23 which, by the way, when I was in Washington, D.C. and got my start in politics there,
00:09:27 it was George W. Bush's second term, and he was a complete disappointment to conservatives
00:09:32 because he didn't hire the movement.
00:09:35 He didn't include the movement in policy. He wouldn't rule out tax increases. He barely touched social issues very finely. He was the compassionate conservative, which scares a fiscal conservative, you know, when you use that word compassionate.
00:09:50 And so here we have this guy who's like bringing in Kellyanne Conway and Leonard Leo and Larry Kudlow from the Reagan years.
00:10:00 And you're kind of like, wow, this is exciting if you're a movement conservative.
00:10:05 And then, you know, he does kind of, you know, his personal life's not conservative.
00:10:12 His mouth goes off.
00:10:14 It's all a bit frustrating and juggling.
00:10:17 but you're getting three Supreme Court justices on the Supreme Court
00:10:21 who are originalists and constructionalists, and they're blocking.
00:10:24 You filled Ruth Bader Ginsburg's seat.
00:10:27 He's worth it, and he's worth putting up with the rancor
00:10:33 because actually he made conservatism offensive.
00:10:36 This whole idea of putting together a garden of statues of American heroes
00:10:40 at the same time as they're being tackled in America is just brilliant,
00:10:45 You know, because the left just, and you can't look at Donald Trump in a vacuum.
00:10:51 You have to look at him compared to his opponent.
00:10:54 And, you know, here they are, the opponent is destroying American history, even Abraham Lincoln, who freed the slaves.
00:11:02 And Donald Trump is like, no, I'm not going to put up with that.
00:11:05 We're going to memorialize these people.
00:11:07 And I'm going to give my Fourth of July speech in front of Mount Rushmore.
00:11:10 And I'm going to be the next American legend.
00:11:14 I'm going to be COVID and be the comeback kid.
00:11:17 I'm going to be the legendary story they're going to talk about
00:11:20 just like George Washington's cherry tree.
00:11:22 You can't talk about American history without talking about me
00:11:26 because I'm going to bring America back.
00:11:28 And that's what he's doing.
00:11:29 And you know what?
00:11:30 When you look at the other side who's hiding in a basement with a mask
00:11:33 and is 78 years old and not even doing rallies
00:11:37 and not even proud to be American, really, that's kind of appealing.
00:11:41 I think so.
00:11:41 I was absolutely right on that point.
00:11:43 But it goes further still because he kept saying, I, I, I.
00:11:47 Trump isn't a conservative, right?
00:11:49 He's had a great conservative record, but he's a Trumpian, first and foremost.
00:11:53 In the same way that Johnson is not a conservative, really, he's a Johnsonian.
00:11:57 And these are people who essentially want to have power and will be flags in the wind
00:12:01 so long as it secures them their mandate and their legacy in history.
00:12:04 And so I just like the person in terms of his personality.
00:12:09 I just like the man's personal politics
00:12:11 and his personal backstory in terms of his morality and so forth.
00:12:15 But he is the necessary evil because he is actually the vehicle
00:12:18 that is enabling us to achieve what we need to achieve.
00:12:21 I only wish Johnson had a bit more of that chutzpah
00:12:22 to actually do something equivalent to that wonderful July the 4th speech,
00:12:26 which was the speech that we were dying to hear over here
00:12:29 over the last few months in terms of standing up for American values
00:12:33 and for America's history and completely rebutting the 1619th project
00:12:37 you know that america was founded upon slavery and that's 1776 is a complete myth if only we
00:12:43 had somebody here to galvanize people who are desperately crying out for that we saw a glimmer
00:12:47 of that in the first few days and weeks when johnson took over when he brought in this breath
00:12:51 of can-doism about brexit and that's completely evaporated trump still has that and it's that
00:12:57 enthusiasm that is actually one of the few ways i can see him actually securing a victory here
00:13:03 in terms of the ability that he has to motivate his his core forces to come out because there's
00:13:08 a lot less enthusiasm for biden amongst amongst democrat voters than there is for trump and it's
00:13:12 that ability because he is a showman this is a guy who slam dunks people at the wwf wrestling
00:13:17 federation yes you know onto the mat so he's got that ability and he brought clinton's um victims
00:13:24 there's sexual victims uh to the debate the last time he took he brought last at the the final
00:13:31 debate he brought hunter biden's associate who's now turned on him and has claiming that all the
00:13:36 emails and conversations are legitimately hunter biden and the big guy is joe biden um it's he does
00:13:43 know how to play the media and you know you can i think you can blame trump for you know being in
00:13:50 our faces every single day but i think a lot of onus goes on the media as well and if the media
00:13:55 didn't cover him as they do it wouldn't be as much of a problem and the media is hoping that
00:14:00 it is a problem for people but I agree to Tim Stanley's point this you know there are a lot
00:14:06 of people who do not see the culture wars in America and they don't see it and and I have
00:14:12 family like American voters who don't see the right and the left really going at it on values
00:14:20 and they would love a Mitt Romney and what matters for them is probably the coronavirus I mean yeah
00:14:25 that's what this election is Dr Anthony Fauci that's what this election is really all about
00:14:29 and it's been that way since February and I think it's why he's been losing since February
00:14:33 and the irony being that Trump is thought of by his opponents as a big authoritarian
00:14:37 but actually when this great genuinely civilizational challenge came along
00:14:41 he turned out to be more libertarian than his critics because he doesn't actually want to shut down society
00:14:46 and now it's taken all this time, all the cultural stuff to slightly recede into the background
00:14:52 for that issue to come to the fore and Americans have a genuine choice on this matter
00:14:57 which in britain we don't and the choice is joe biden has essentially said shut down the economy
00:15:03 until we find a cure donald trump has essentially said no we've got to learn to live with it and
00:15:08 actually in a way that translates uh the the existential culture war stuff into real a real
00:15:13 public policy practical debate which is do you think when lemur hits the fan that you shut
00:15:20 everything down and let big brother take over or do you in that very old-fashioned conservative
00:15:24 libertarian way say no we need to balance being secure against freedom i think it's very right
00:15:31 we've also seen these images um ollie we've seen images here of you know reasonably big trump
00:15:37 rallies and apparently totally empty uh speeches with biden or or with obama i think in supporting
00:15:46 him uh obviously just put up for as it were for the cameras um what's your what's your view at
00:15:52 the moment ollie on on the relative status of the candidates i mean i think that actually if i
00:15:59 remember uh tim uh said at one point that he was sort of didn't think that trump stood a chance but
00:16:06 that you now weren't so sure is that right yeah yeah do you would you go along with that ollie
00:16:11 um well i mean rallies i was at a front rally in florida last week and you know the energy and um
00:16:20 and kind of excitement at those events is undeniable but talking to people there
00:16:27 I was reminded of sort of 80s Labour politicians who after they lost in
00:16:33 1983 would say they couldn't understand because you know we had bigger crowds
00:16:37 and you know what is that famous line of like no one I know voted Republican
00:16:42 how could they have won so you know I think there's I think that the energy
00:16:48 gap between the Trump campaign and the Biden campaign is is real um but I I suspect that's
00:16:55 not my my suspicion is that the polls are broadly correct and that Biden is ahead in the race um
00:17:01 and that energy is not necessarily what people are looking for um if I could just go back by
00:17:06 the way to the to the history wars kind of stuff I think it's an important point um I agree Trump
00:17:12 being sort of full-throated in his defense of American values in a way that conservatives are
00:17:17 right to be pleased with. I would just say, I think it's worth tempering that a little bit
00:17:22 because, you know, I think the way to describe the culture wars in America at the moment is
00:17:29 basically in terms of massive left-wing overreach. They've decided that, you know,
00:17:34 no American president pretty much full stop isn't an irredeemable racist. And it's not clear to me
00:17:44 that Trump is Trump's presence as the voice for American
00:17:48 values, you know, is actually making the case for for those
00:17:54 values. I think that many more moderate, many more conventional
00:17:58 Republicans would be just as comfortable sticking up for for
00:18:02 those things, probably in a more persuasive, less divisive way.
00:18:06 So I just want to get that in there on the cultural stuff.
00:18:09 Yeah. And on that point about left wing overreach, I could just
00:18:12 say because I've found this so interesting this election. Pete Buttigieg said it first back in
00:18:15 August. Joe Biden said it a couple of weeks ago. They both said America is an idea. I find this
00:18:22 really fascinating because it goes right back to the heart of what defines nationhood. America is
00:18:25 an idea and it's not lived up to that idea. And so history is a slow progress towards getting
00:18:32 things better. That is a classic post-enlightenment liberal view of what a nation state is. It's a
00:18:38 political project that has got to match the ideals of its founders. Trump represents the
00:18:44 view that a country is where you live. It's that simple. It's your home. And you support it and
00:18:50 you fight for it because it's your home. And I just find the tension between those two things
00:18:55 has really, for me, become crystallized in this election. And it's such an interesting choice.
00:18:59 But they do represent two very different visions of America. And both, I have to stress,
00:19:02 sorry, you said that you implied that Biden didn't perhaps love his country. I disagree with that.
00:19:08 I think there are two completely legitimate different takes on what America is.
00:19:12 There's that idea of America, and there's America as a reality and a place.
00:19:16 And I think we're really seeing a generational conflict between those two.
00:19:20 But isn't this the whole problem, in a way, I see this as part of the culture war, to go back to that.
00:19:26 Britain, quite often, is, oh, it's just a sort of construct, or it's an idea.
00:19:31 You hear this all the time.
00:19:33 Most people would not dream of saying that about India.
00:19:36 they wouldn't dream about saying it about Japan
00:19:38 or any of these, it seems to be something
00:19:40 in the Anglosphere which is essentially
00:19:42 undermining the idea of
00:19:44 well I would say place
00:19:46 Japan is not an idea
00:19:48 it's a piece
00:19:49 and a geography
00:19:52 that's how Shintoism works, it's all about
00:19:54 geography and where you're buried
00:19:56 you can't be anywhere
00:19:57 wasn't it Margaret Thatcher who said
00:19:59 America is a philosophy
00:20:01 and Britain is history
00:20:05 or something like that
00:20:06 I wouldn't say that conservatives would disagree about the idea or the philosophy.
00:20:13 I think it's a matter of whether we can live with one another who have different ideas.
00:20:19 If we have different philosophies and different religions,
00:20:22 and the left is consistently in America showing that they don't want to live with people
00:20:26 who have conflicting values and ideas,
00:20:29 and who just want to be left alone to homeschool their kids or go to church or mosque or synagogue.
00:20:33 or just run their own business.
00:20:37 But just to jump in there, this is the irony,
00:20:39 is that that left-wing commitment to the idea of America
00:20:42 that keeps shifting.
00:20:43 So the definition, generation by generation,
00:20:46 the definition of what it is,
00:20:47 so if you take something like civil rights and race
00:20:49 back in the 1960s, it was everyone's equal.
00:20:53 It's meritocracy.
00:20:53 It's Hubert Humphrey saying,
00:20:54 if this ever leads to affirmative action, I will oppose it.
00:20:57 Then you flip forward a couple of decades more
00:20:59 and it's everyone's racist.
00:21:00 And there's a hierarchy of different identities.
00:21:02 So that's the frustrating thing. But that's an inevitable outcome of the very idea of your nation being an idea, because reason defeats reason, as De Maistre said.
00:21:11 You can't just commit to an idea because ideas can change. And they do. And they have.
00:21:16 And that's why the Constitution is so important.
00:21:18 Yes. And that's America's anchor as a nation.
00:21:21 It restrains.
00:21:21 It's its constitution. Absolutely.
00:21:23 And this is why when Joe Biden can't say if he's going to pack the Supreme Court or expand it or bring statehood to D.C. or Puerto Rico, which would then bring more liberal senators to the U.S. Senate, I mean, they are having a fit because they can't win over the American people in a legitimate electoral college election.
00:21:43 And so this is why there's an effort in America right now to overthrow the electoral college.
00:21:51 And it's because they are too radical.
00:21:54 The reason that there is the old dinosaur Joe Biden as their candidate right now is that they are the radical establishment, so to speak,
00:22:03 because I think the establishment has become the AOCs and the Ilhan Omars and a bit of the Bernie Sanders.
00:22:10 because let's face it, Bernie was on his way to winning until South Carolina with Joe,
00:22:14 is because the actual more moderate Democratic candidates of Tulsi Gabbard and Andrew Yang,
00:22:20 who are in the primary, they cannot be controlled. They cannot be leveraged. Joe Biden's voting has
00:22:27 consistently gone left throughout his career. And they know that he'll be a rubber stamp for
00:22:33 their left wing policies. And many of my friends who, again, who don't like the culture war,
00:22:38 who don't see things that way and they don't like donald trump they want to vote for joe
00:22:42 biden but they see kamala harris and they go no yeah yeah it's interesting actually because
00:22:49 one of the points i'm you know going way back like when i was a kid doing american politics
00:22:54 you know in at college is that there was this idea it was receiverism that essentially in all
00:23:01 essentials the democrats and the republicans weren't really that different it was a matter
00:23:05 of emphasis yeah that unlike here because we were in the middle of a huge
00:23:09 capitalism versus socialism thing in the same that was all settled that seems to
00:23:14 me to have entirely gone absolutely it has I mean you had just you know even in
00:23:18 the late 19 in the 80s you had you know Tip O'Neill would have no problem
00:23:23 crossing of having a fierce debate in Congress and then going for a drink with
00:23:26 his opponents you know Jonathan Haidt writes about this a lot actually and he
00:23:30 says one of the problems in America in Washington is that there's no longer any
00:23:35 socializing or intermingling. Everybody is existing in their own little bubbles
00:23:38 and they don't go to the same school, they shouldn't go to the same schools any
00:23:41 longer and because of that you've lost that ability to humanize and
00:23:45 personalize your opponents. There's absolutely no mixing at all. I think
00:23:49 that is a very real problem. But just to go back to the earlier point
00:23:53 you were saying about why is this an Anglosphere issue all the time, this idea
00:23:56 of home and place, is because Britain and America aren't ethnic constructs, right?
00:24:01 but that was always the difference between Japan.
00:24:03 Britain was a concept to unite Scotland and England together,
00:24:06 and then you got the idea that whether you were living in Auckland,
00:24:09 New Zealand, or in Sydney, or in Vancouver, or in Glasgow, Manchester,
00:24:13 you were all equally British under the crown, you were subjects of the crown.
00:24:16 America as well was this great ethnic melting pot.
00:24:19 Very unique concepts Britain and America had compared to what you had in Europe.
00:24:22 And the problem with the current situation is that this founding idea,
00:24:27 The city on the hill that America is, is that, as Tim referred to the Enlightenment idea,
00:24:33 is that the far left don't believe in the Enlightenment any longer.
00:24:36 There's this idea of relativism, about all science and all logic and reason,
00:24:41 and the Enlightenment doesn't exist, and so consequently the ideals upon which America was founded
00:24:46 are no longer accepted or recognised as being valid.
00:24:49 In fact, if anything, they regard this as being intrinsically problematic.
00:24:53 This is a huge question, maybe.
00:24:57 so just maybe we should be brief but the things that i imagine that i sense that we all love about
00:25:03 america i mean you've lived there tim haven't you i think on and off yes yes i i lived there for
00:25:08 five years you obviously from america and you love america we kind of love it you know i feel
00:25:13 in a culture oliver's in america oh no you you're there obviously i'm sorry i lived in canada but
00:25:18 there you go but it seems to me i just sometimes wonder whether it is entirely changed i don't
00:25:26 just mean in the sense of Democrats
00:25:28 and Republicans but
00:25:30 the various things that we've always liked about it
00:25:32 just seem to be disappearing
00:25:33 and this is just purely
00:25:35 a perception on my part
00:25:38 people used to go to America
00:25:39 for certain things and that was a kind of
00:25:42 optimism, all of this
00:25:44 sense of dreaming
00:25:45 it just doesn't seem to have
00:25:47 that
00:25:48 even though we have a president who is
00:25:52 about dreaming and about
00:25:53 but the actual mainstream culture
00:25:55 doesn't seem to have that anymore. I'm going to say I've been going there for about 20 years
00:26:00 studying it and I've been going to certain places over the 20 years so I've got to know them very
00:26:06 well and for me the abiding impression is one of palpable physical decline. The country looks
00:26:14 poorer than it did 20 years ago. The infrastructure's not been updated. It's a country which
00:26:20 has pockets of extraordinary innovation and wealth like Silicon Valley but there are large
00:26:25 sways of it which is how trump won last time there are large sways of it which really genuinely
00:26:30 not only not only are but really look and feel left behind um and trump managed to speak to that
00:26:38 but of course he he played upon a grievance he didn't play upon the old american idea of pack
00:26:42 up your troubles in the old kit bag i know it's an english idea but he didn't he didn't pack he
00:26:46 didn't play upon the pioneer spirit which is the ronald reagan approach to capitalism and freedom
00:26:50 He played really upon grievance politics. And so he hasn't corrected that decline because, in a way, he sort of stoked the emotions that were the consequence of it.
00:27:01 Olly, do you sense decline? I mean, is this something that is in the air for you? Physical decline?
00:27:08 I would agree with what I think that it's not also it's not just a question of political
00:27:16 sclerosis and division it's also a sort of deeper question of you know America used to
00:27:24 pride itself on sort of embracing the new and you know technologically speaking and
00:27:30 being a very sort of practical republic rather than whereas Europe was busy sort of rowing
00:27:34 with itself about about history or whatever um and now you have the opposite and and and you have
00:27:41 you know you have the american left for example looking at various european countries with envy
00:27:47 because they have a healthcare system they would like or whatever i mean without going into the
00:27:51 merits of that debate it's just a sort of rather uninspiring way of thinking about the possibilities
00:27:56 of america to think like which of these european countries would i most like to be like my country
00:28:02 to be to be like um so no i i agree thank you as well well the other thing that's declined on the
00:28:08 cultural side side is the old-fashioned bourgeois values of capitalism uh this is going to make me
00:28:13 sound like a maiden aunt um but really american culture is it's kind of disgusting i mean really
00:28:19 it's it's it's just unpleasant it's i don't just mean it's it's over sexed or anything like that
00:28:23 i mean it's foul-mouthed it's mean-spirited it's abusive i'm talking about american tv and
00:28:29 American movies. Now, I think now, but not always. No, if you went back, no, again, if you went back
00:28:35 to the 1990s or the last embers of the 1980s, which of course things like Stranger Things are
00:28:40 sort of played upon because they have this sense of nostalgia for the last era of family values,
00:28:45 if you had an image in your mind of what an American family was, it was mum, dad, apple pie,
00:28:50 white picket fence, kids. It was incredibly wholesome and it was a very old-fashioned 19th
00:28:55 century Protestant idea of capitalist decency and dignity culturally that's gone I'm just really
00:29:02 struck by how trashy how really in the trash not just a creative culture but news is news in America
00:29:09 is appalling the music's awful I mean I completely agree I mean I'm very glad that I live over here
00:29:15 right now at this time of the election because I I think um it's it's just it's it's so unpleasant
00:29:21 to be around because if you don't wear a mask or if you wear a mask it's a sign of your politics
00:29:26 everyone is getting in your face you can't put a lawn sign out there's nothing to talk about
00:29:31 i talk to my family in america because they vote democrat like as if there's no u.s election going
00:29:37 on at all it's very bizarre because it consumes my almost every waking moment at the time and and
00:29:43 I just, what you find is, and I think this is, this cultural just cesspool is, you know,
00:29:53 it had been going on for 50 years with people's loss of their religion or shared morality, really.
00:30:00 And this idea of everybody believes in the Ten Commandments or God or everyone had the same sense of what was right and wrong.
00:30:10 On left and right.
00:30:11 On left and right until the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s.
00:30:16 And then each decade, it's just, I feel like it's gone, gone down.
00:30:19 And so my conservative friends are now putting their kids in Christian schools and religious ed schools where they would normally have been in a state school, right?
00:30:28 And so that separates the gap.
00:30:30 And so then you don't end up knowing anybody who's on the opposite side because now you're raising your children in a bubble so that your values then get passed on because the culture is so poisonous.
00:30:41 And Trump is a product of this trash culture.
00:30:44 He's the trash president of a trash culture.
00:30:45 And the irony is that middle-class conservatives and religious people are voting for him to protest trash culture.
00:30:52 They're voting for a dumpster fire to protest a dumpster fire.
00:30:55 Yeah, I'm that person.
00:30:57 I have to say, I wouldn't disagree with a lot of what you're saying, but I just don't think this is just an American thing.
00:31:05 I mean, I think that much of, I'm afraid, much of British culture is actually quite trashy now.
00:31:10 And I think what it is is that we're just in an era of cultural exhaustion.
00:31:15 You know, when you go back to the mid-century, last century,
00:31:19 you know, popular American culture was just, you know,
00:31:23 a jewel in the cultural crowd.
00:31:25 A jewel in the cultural crowd.
00:31:27 But that's sort of gone.
00:31:28 But it's not like we're doing very much better here in Europe.
00:31:33 Can I just ask as well, you know, to become Mystic Meg for a while?
00:31:38 We're going to know very soon.
00:31:39 But what do you think, Ray, supposing Trump wins again on Tuesday,
00:31:47 what do you think is going to happen?
00:31:50 Well, I'm more concerned about what won't happen.
00:31:53 I mean, we're going to get more of the same if Trump is in power.
00:31:56 The infrastructure issue that you raised before is a very, very relevant one
00:32:00 because I think that's one of the great problems of the last four years
00:32:04 that he didn't address a lot of those things, things like infrastructure.
00:32:06 So I'd only hope that that would become part of the next four years.
00:32:10 But I'm more concerned about a democratic victory because of what that would entail.
00:32:14 Would it entail stacking the Supreme Court to basically enlarge it beyond the nine?
00:32:20 Would it entail making Puerto Rico and D.C. states and therefore enlarging the Electoral College?
00:32:26 Would it be an end to the filibuster?
00:32:28 All of these things that would make Republicans unelectable for a generation or more, if that comes into play.
00:32:34 That's why I think this is a really decisive and important election
00:32:36 and why Trump needs to win, because the alternative, if it doesn't happen.
00:32:40 And also, again, the culture wars.
00:32:42 If you think of the Democratic Party today,
00:32:45 it is unrecognizable compared to how it was even four years ago under Hillary Clinton.
00:32:49 This is not the Democratic Party of Obama or of Hillary Clinton's time.
00:32:53 This is a brand new thing.
00:32:53 It only has the thin veneer of rice paper of Joe Biden shielding the reality.
00:32:59 And that's why I think the victory for Trump is so important, albeit one that I think is increasingly unlikely.
00:33:07 So, in other words, it's not unlike the Labour Party with momentum.
00:33:11 It's become a bit like that, the Democratic Party, hasn't it, in America?
00:33:15 In terms of the culture wars, I'd say it's worse.
00:33:18 Yeah.
00:33:20 What about the idea that I've heard from friends who are living in America, or in fact have just left America,
00:33:27 that they fear extraordinary civil unrest and convulsion.
00:33:32 Supposing, there is this idea too, isn't there as well,
00:33:36 of just simply delegitimising election results,
00:33:39 just simply not accepting them.
00:33:41 I mean, so do you think that there will, if Trump wins again,
00:33:45 do you think people are just going to be,
00:33:46 these people we've been seeing in the streets,
00:33:49 will they just simply lose it and start burning things down?
00:33:54 That's really interesting because I've had this conversation
00:33:56 with many of my friends i i'm actually really concerned for the country again on a cultural
00:34:02 perspective because those who could not handle the death of ruth bader ginsburg or that trump
00:34:07 won the first time and were screaming in the street i mean what kind of nervous breakdown are
00:34:11 they going to have this time um will there be suicides will someone just go wackadoodle and
00:34:16 commit mass murder will there be arson you think antifa is bad now or black lives matter is bad now
00:34:22 I'll wait till, you know, they lose, if they lose.
00:34:27 And I'm not saying there aren't factions on the right that will come out and, you know, say that Trump's really their victor and Biden cheated and da-da-da-da-da.
00:34:37 I think when you have so many people doing postal voting, the chances for cheating and voter fraud increase.
00:34:45 And also in such a close election, my hope is that it is a very decisive election quickly.
00:34:52 so that neither side can really do this.
00:34:55 But I suspect there will be court challenges.
00:34:58 Pennsylvania has just now allowed, and it's been supported by the Supreme Court,
00:35:02 to extend accepting absentee ballots until Friday,
00:35:05 but they need to be postmarked by Tuesday, Election Day.
00:35:09 So Pennsylvania is a key state for the president to win,
00:35:13 and we may not know about that until Saturday.
00:35:17 And I do know that retail, I mean, think how much they were disrupted
00:35:21 and looted and rioted over the summer they are now putting up they have a whole security plans
00:35:29 in place for after the election and i have friends who are leaving new york city um during during the
00:35:35 weeks following so yeah i it's a it's a grave concern and we've never had this no no um ollie
00:35:43 it's right isn't it that both parties have been getting their various attorneys in line to to
00:35:49 start the kind of process of challenging the result isn't that right yeah i mean the way i
00:35:55 see the the post-election kind of potential nightmare is this is a two-part thing part one
00:36:04 is um actually quite conventional and nothing which is both parties hire top lawyers and duke
00:36:11 it out in the courts to decide who wins the election we had that in 2000 and and you know
00:36:15 a grown-up republic should be able to handle that and then there's the kind of stressful bit in my
00:36:21 view which is the layer of possible um and kind of refusal to accept the result which uh as as
00:36:28 as you guys are saying is is a sort of point of bipartisan agreement there are there are people
00:36:33 on the left and people on the right that will you know there'll be a legitimacy problem um in their
00:36:39 eyes and I should add the president doesn't help things by by saying some quite
00:36:46 irresponsible stuff about what he'll do with in terms of the results and whether
00:36:49 he'll leave and that sort of thing so so yeah and I think it's it's there's
00:36:55 reason to be somewhat worried about what happens in the in a sort of close
00:36:59 result. Do you think, Tim, are we being a little bit too full of dread about that? Or do you think
00:37:10 there is a chance of... Yeah, I think we possibly are. Partly because a lot of voters have probably
00:37:15 decided to give Biden a landslide precisely to avoid this scenario. That's one theory going
00:37:20 around why he's so far ahead in the polls. Some of those polls really are very troubling for Biden.
00:37:24 and if we end up with a blue wave then really this could all be over in a couple of days it'll
00:37:30 take some time to be absolutely clear about because we're lying upon mail ballots this time
00:37:34 not just people voting on the day and it's suspected that Trump will get a big boost on
00:37:37 the day because his voters are more inclined to go out and vote rather than vote by mail but if
00:37:42 Biden does do very well then a lot of this nightmare does go away and let's not forget a
00:37:47 lot of the problems are stoked by Trump himself and by his own rhetoric on legitimacy and whether
00:37:52 not elections are fair and if there's fraud going on it's not as if it's just the left doing these
00:37:56 things and also don't forget that america has been through much much worse before i'm not i know
00:38:02 that's a very that's a bizarre standard to set don't worry because there was once a war in the
00:38:06 1860s and no one wants to be that bad again but the point is that the thing about america is it's
00:38:11 constantly being written off and then it bounces back and it usually bounces back through a
00:38:16 combination of economic uh reinvention it's very good adaptation to technology it's very good of
00:38:22 absorbing people from out from other countries and those people sort of buy into its belief systems
00:38:26 and contribute to it but also it has had a series of religious awakenings a cultural counter revolutions
00:38:32 and it's it's always possible that america could go through that again i i really wouldn't write
00:38:37 this off i i don't see this thing descending into civil war i'm more concerned as i said before by
00:38:42 a long-term sense of atrophy
00:38:45 and the inability to get
00:38:48 anything done
00:38:50 I think as you rightly point out there
00:38:54 the 1970s did actually then become the 1980s
00:38:57 didn't it? Exactly, yes
00:38:58 so maybe that will happen
00:39:00 but look, thank you very very much
00:39:02 we will know all too soon
00:39:04 either way
00:39:05 thank you very much Oliver
00:39:08 thanks so much Tim, Sarah and Rafe
00:39:11 and thank you for watching we will see you next time there might be a new
00:39:17 president but anyway in the meantime please do subscribe and we'll see you
00:39:22 soon thank you